1
Computing as Strategic Tool for Computing as Strategic Tool for
Glocal Human Rights Movement?Glocal Human Rights Movement?
Positioning Socio-Cultural-Ethical Positioning Socio-Cultural-Ethical
Aspects of Cyberpower in their ContextAspects of Cyberpower in their Context
On-Kwok Lai
School of Policy Studies, Kwansei Gakuin University, Japan
2
Globalization–driven Social Dualism
• widespread poverty in affluent societies / localities, rural-
urban divided
• deregulatory policy initiatives favour commodification /
privatization of social services social dualism
Economic, Social & Cultural Rights Challenged!Economic, Social & Cultural Rights Challenged!
China: Economic Miracle: >8% GDP Growth since 1978
per capita income of city dwellers in China increased by 8%, compared to rural residents of 2.5% (2000-06)
Working in cities accounted 70% of the total annual increase
3
44
Global Crisis – Local Global Crisis – Local Solutions?Solutions?
• World ‘War’ for Economic Development? World ‘War’ for Economic Development?
• Trading - Mobility Regime reduces Trading - Mobility Regime reduces People’s Eco-Humanity SensitivityPeople’s Eco-Humanity Sensitivity
• Decoupling Production-Consumption Eco-Decoupling Production-Consumption Eco-Nexus Nexus andand ESC Rights ESC Rights
• Development Divides: Sourcing / Development Divides: Sourcing / Utilization / Mis-Match Utilization / Mis-Match betweenbetween Rich-Poor, Rich-Poor, Developed-DevelopingDeveloped-Developing
• Under-developing/investment Under-developing/investment forfor Future Future
5
Against Human ESC Rights?Against Human ESC Rights?Globalization Globalization reinforces reinforces Polarization? Polarization?
Productivity Increase ESC Rights Challenged! Job Mobility Employment Insecurity? Winners and Losers in Globalization? Promoting (Anti-)Globalization? Which Versions of Globalization? Globalization with Benevolence? What ESC Rights, esp. Left for the Least
Advantaged Groups?
6
Humanity under Siege in a Globalizing World?
Regional/Global Divisions of Labors –cum- Competitiveness Discourse
Informational Society Time+Space Compression
Hyper-Flexible Production Regime: Borrowed Time+Space Compression –/ Job–Life Course?
De-Skilling Derived Job / Life-Chance: Redundancy, Early Retirement, Downsizing
Anti-Globalization Protests & Processes?
7
Human (ESC) Rights Human (ESC) Rights in a Globalizingin a Globalizing World World
• Globalization: problematic & contradictory life chance / ESC Rights of people?
• Globalization: a benign and automatic force better
economic benefits for everyone, even the poorest group can be better off.
• Political Extreme Left: unbridled capitalism does produce effects of exploitation of the weak and socio-ecological degradation
Political Extreme Right: the malignant forces of globalization engender xenophobia, the demising local people’s jobs, culture, language and hence identity
8
NGOs Questing for Social, Alternative Development!
9
NGOs’ Anti-Globalization NGOs’ Anti-Globalization Communicative Actions & ProcessCommunicative Actions & Process
Fair Trade for All? (G22 Agenda) 1st May, Seattle & Other Protests Global Peace Movement (15. Feb. 2003)
‘Anti-G‘ information and ideas in/beyond cyberspace, bypassing the mass media, turn into global real time social actions
1010
Differential LOGICSDifferential LOGICS ofof GlobalizationGlobalization• Global Civil Society: Mobile Communicative Actions Global Civil Society: Mobile Communicative Actions
by NGOs – articulating their human, bio-eco ethical by NGOs – articulating their human, bio-eco ethical demands through non-institutional politics of protest demands through non-institutional politics of protest movements movements
• WTO though sticks to its multi-lateral summit WTO though sticks to its multi-lateral summit (protected by strong police force), yet it has to deal (protected by strong police force), yet it has to deal with with human (eco-social-cultural) rights & animal human (eco-social-cultural) rights & animal rights!rights!
• Bio-Diversity: Ethics of Bio-production (Bio vs. GM)Bio-Diversity: Ethics of Bio-production (Bio vs. GM)
• ICT: a crucial factor to empower the (presumably) powerless ICT: a crucial factor to empower the (presumably) powerless NGOs; global civil society has learned quick, adopting wire and NGOs; global civil society has learned quick, adopting wire and wireless communication set up to champion their project, in wireless communication set up to champion their project, in cyber and mass mediacyber and mass media
11
Anti- Pro-Development Advocacies:
New Humanity?New Humanity?Deep-to-Shallow EcologyDeep-to-Shallow Ecology
glo(bal-lo)cal communicative actions – using of all wired and wireless media of communications in both cyber / in real communications – enable people’s participation in bio-eco-ethical debates and communication
Local – Global Dialectics of DevelopmentLocal – Global Dialectics of Development
1212
Post-Asian Crisis – Digital Post-Asian Crisis – Digital CapitalismCapitalism ‘e’-Strategy‘e’-Strategy • Post-financial crisis: pro-growth development model for Post-financial crisis: pro-growth development model for
e-commerce, e-government, e-technopolis… e-commerce, e-government, e-technopolis…
• E-Singapore E-Singapore
• ‘‘e-‘ project: e-Japane-‘ project: e-Japan
• South Korea tops cable connection South Korea tops cable connection
• China is catching up its mobile communications China is catching up its mobile communications
networking, networking,
• Taiwan is becoming a silicon islandTaiwan is becoming a silicon island
13
14
Status of Diffusion of Mobile Phones - Japan
15
Trend of Household Ownership of ICT Devices
16
Total Internet User Population &Internet Diffusion Rate
1717
Globalized SpaceGlobalized Space
Internet, the World Wide Web and the other electronic technologies Internet, the World Wide Web and the other electronic technologies
that are shrinking the world offers considerable potential as a source of that are shrinking the world offers considerable potential as a source of
democracy... by facilitating the continued proliferation of networks that democracy... by facilitating the continued proliferation of networks that
know no boundaries, these technologies have introduced a horizontal know no boundaries, these technologies have introduced a horizontal
dimension to the politics of dimension to the politics of Globalized SpaceGlobalized Space. They enable like-minded . They enable like-minded
people in distant places to converge, share perspectives, protest people in distant places to converge, share perspectives, protest
abuses, provide information and mobilize resources – dynamics that abuses, provide information and mobilize resources – dynamics that
seem bound to constrain vertical structures that sustain governments, seem bound to constrain vertical structures that sustain governments,
corporation and any other hierarchical organizations corporation and any other hierarchical organizations (Rosenau 1998: 46). (Rosenau 1998: 46).
18
TRANSNATIONAL ACTIVISMGlobal-Local
• ‘Globalized Space’ thesis James N. Rosenau (1997, 1998)
• ICT affects: the shaping of individual’s identity and actions that transcend territorial borders anchoring upon ecological issues
(Katz & Aakhus Eds., 2002; Woolgar Ed., 2002)
• Transnational Advocacy Networks Margarett E. Keck & Kathryn Sikkink (1998, 1999), Lai (2004)
19
HUMAN SUSTAINABILITYHUMAN SUSTAINABILITYCYBER-ACTIVISMCYBER-ACTIVISM
Participatory politics at global/local scale is possible with all forms of communications: one-to-one, one-to-many, many-to-one and many-to-many.
Internet (cable, wireless and satellite) multi-
modal of communications, representing both micro as well as mass media functioning.
2020
CommunicativeCommunicative Actions, LogicsActions, Logics
&& Green PraxisGreen Praxis ofof CyberCyber--RainbowRainbow
WarriorsWarriors in/out in/out ofof Everyday LifeEveryday Life ::
ee--MobilizationMobilization forfor Transnational Ecological Transnational Ecological
Activism (TEA) Activism (TEA) in/beyondin/beyond CyberspaceCyberspace
Human ESC Rights’ CommunicationHuman ESC Rights’ Communication
2121
Eco-Cyber-Activism-Advocacy?!!Eco-Cyber-Activism-Advocacy?!! Association of Progressive CommunicationsAssociation of Progressive Communications Amnesty InternationalAmnesty International Human Rights WatchHuman Rights Watch Opendemocracy.netOpendemocracy.net South Korean Jinbo.net South Korean Jinbo.net Friends of the Earth InternationalFriends of the Earth International
Greenpeace InternationalGreenpeace International PETA.orgPETA.org
22
Redefining New Humanity?New Human Rights Movement
Questioning Economic Development? Against outsiders on indigenous Development? Questioning CSR of TNCs? Against neo-liberal / Trading Regime? Indigenous Rights? Profits vs. ESC Rights? Local Community & Ecology vs. Global TNCs
2323
Advocacies & Appeals Advocacies & Appeals forfor ESC RightsESC Rights
• Choreographed - Visualized Reality Choreographed - Visualized Reality
• Sensational Advocacies & AppealsSensational Advocacies & Appeals
• Dramatized Clear Role for Victims - Predators Dramatized Clear Role for Victims - Predators
• Binary Code(s) for Winner / Loser Binary Code(s) for Winner / Loser
• Ethical & Moral Appeal – Support for VictimsEthical & Moral Appeal – Support for Victims
• ““Normal-Natural” (Fundamentalist) AppealsNormal-Natural” (Fundamentalist) Appeals
• Appeal for Personal / Individual ActionsAppeal for Personal / Individual Actions
24
COMMUNICATIVE Ethics PRAXIS @TRANSNATIONAL ACTIVISM
Communicative Praxis: Creation of new political
activism of NGOs in global civil society, with the praxis of
broad access avenues of civic participation at national,
regional, international levels.
Ethical Communications!Ethical Communications! e-platforms for exchanges of information, in-house action-
strategies, and recruitment of volunteers for e-mobilization
25
Communicative Praxis Action + Identity @ Time+Space
• cyberspace (for novices as well as veteran activists) is a learning-by-doing, action-oriented media at both individual and collective levels.
just a few clicks, sending support and appeal letters or animated e-cards to the targets
Global Citizen (Guardian for Humanity)
26
Glocal Communicative ActivismBoomeranging!!!Bio-Eco-Human Ethical Diplomacy!!
Transnational Advocacies Networks (TAN) for people empowerment - the global civil society: Boomerang Strategies: Local Global Local
ICT (mobile communicative actions in a progressive mode) in enabling Global Communicative Activism
ICT - the leverage for the resource-poor and/or under-privileged groups in articulating their justifiable demand for a fair / equitable life chance.
2727
Outsiders -as- InsidersOutsiders -as- InsidersComputer-Comunnicative Ethics?Computer-Comunnicative Ethics?
ICT enhanced cyber-cum-social mobilization ICT enhanced cyber-cum-social mobilization extends the territorial (ir)relevance of human extends the territorial (ir)relevance of human ESC rights issues ESC rights issues
enables “outsiders”, non-reference-persons, enables “outsiders”, non-reference-persons, to have influence in and beyond the locally to have influence in and beyond the locally and regionally specific, territorially defined, and regionally specific, territorially defined, human ESC rights struggles human ESC rights struggles
2828
Local-Global Eco-Humanity LinksLocal-Global Eco-Humanity Links
Selectivity & Reversibility for Selectivity & Reversibility for
Local Action – Global Outcome / Global Action – Local Action – Global Outcome / Global Action – Local ConsequenceLocal Consequence
Selectivity of Ethical Dialectics (Thesis – Anti-Selectivity of Ethical Dialectics (Thesis – Anti-thesis – Synthesisthesis – Synthesis
Individual Behavior Individual Behavior Collective Reciprocity Collective Reciprocity Global Action Global Action Sustainability? Sustainability?
(Non-)Common Sense Approaches: (Non-)Common Sense Approaches: – ESC Rights Compatible Consumption Consumerism ESC Rights Compatible Consumption Consumerism
Ethics of New Modernity in the Informational Age?Ethics of New Modernity in the Informational Age?
29
Individual makes Difference Individual makes Difference in thein the Global Humanity PoliticsGlobal Humanity Politics ––
multiple linkages of TAN in and beyond the cyberspace stretch geographical localities…
Global - Humanity Citizenship?Global - Humanity Citizenship?
extending to numerous individuals who used to be passive observers (of the mass media) and call upon their participation in a less militant, yet supportive, role for the protest movements
30
Rediscovering Rediscovering Biodiversity - HumanityBiodiversity - Humanity?? Expanding Asian Cyber-Space: Expanding Asian Cyber-Space:
Embryo for Cyber-Activism?Embryo for Cyber-Activism?
Geo-Politics Anchorage of Social Agencies?
Asian state’s e-government projects
Burgeoning ICT Market in Asia
Wired + Wireless Access for Communication Expansion???
31
BARRIERS AGAINST GLOBAL ESC Rights-(CYBER-)ACTIVISM
• Censorship + Control the Internet
• Cyber-Imperialism
• Geo-Comparative (Dis-)Advantage of (i)NGOs
• Digital Divides & Regional/Local Differences
• Differential State-Society Conflicts
32
Age-Specific Digital Divide:
Mobile Phone Users by Age (2005) - Japan
33
3434
Hyper-Modernization forHyper-Modernization forNew Modernity – Eco-HumanityNew Modernity – Eco-Humanity
Re-organization or disorganization of Re-organization or disorganization of Socio-Economic Life through ICT?Socio-Economic Life through ICT?
Facilitating Differential Cultural Facilitating Differential Cultural Formation and the Change of Formation and the Change of Everyday Social Practice in Various Everyday Social Practice in Various Domains Domains
3535
Dynamics of CyberspaceDynamics of Cyberspace Multiple Differentiated EngagementsMultiple Differentiated Engagements
IndividualisticIndividualistic,, Profit-Seeking Profit-Seeking,, Self-Promotion Self-Promotion andand Greedy Encounters Greedy Encounters
Enlightened Individual driven e-Mobilization Enlightened Individual driven e-Mobilization for nano-scale objects to yotta (10for nano-scale objects to yotta (102424)-scale )-scale Global SustainabilityGlobal Sustainability
Wired and Wireless CommunicationWired and Wireless Communication to to develop develop SizeSize, , Power Base Power Base andand Influence Influence ofof Critical Mass Critical Mass forfor Alternative Politicking Alternative Politicking
3636
Cosmopolitan Participatory Democracy Cosmopolitan Participatory Democracy versus / for Individual Existence?versus / for Individual Existence?
Creation of new political institutions and a Creation of new political institutions and a diversity of NGOs in global civil society diversity of NGOs in global civil society Global Governance for one’s Survival?Global Governance for one’s Survival?
New democratic – participatory (critical New democratic – participatory (critical engaging) principle and praxis of broad engaging) principle and praxis of broad access to avenues of civic participation at access to avenues of civic participation at national, regional and international levels national, regional and international levels
37
ee-MOBILIZATION-MOBILIZATION GGlobal/Locallobal/Local Sustainability Sustainability
Transnational Advocacy Networks & Activism – a powerful challenge / reminder for supra-national bodies to abide the basic condition / morality for development
But the question is how to do it, by market force, the supra-national state or civic forces?
3838
Positioning HumanityPositioning Humanity in Hyper-Modernizationin Hyper-Modernization
•High Economic Growth – Social Change High Economic Growth – Social Change •Economic Liberalization - GlobalizationEconomic Liberalization - Globalization
• ICT Sophistication – Mobile CommunicationICT Sophistication – Mobile Communication
Communicative Actions in Mobile ICT RegimeCommunicative Actions in Mobile ICT RegimeCyberspace – e-MobilizationCyberspace – e-Mobilization Articulating One’s Presence & Ethics in Blogs, Articulating One’s Presence & Ethics in Blogs,
SMS, MMS, SNS onto e-platform of YouTube, SMS, MMS, SNS onto e-platform of YouTube, MySpace, MSNMySpace, MSN
39
Eco-HEco-HumanumanRRightsights Ethics & Norms: Ethics & Norms: Ideas / Ideals Ideas / Ideals ofof New Humanity New Humanity
Questions revolve around / against Corporate and/or State Agencies for Sustainable Development/Progressiveness: towards next (Eco-)Modernity?
ICT’s Articulation of Animal - Human Existential, and International (humanity and bio-ethics) Norms and Justice, for a more Open and Participatory Regime of Global Governance
Science (Knowledge) or Religion (Belief)?
4040
HumanityHumanity:: Objects Objects asas Subjectivity? Subjectivity?Human Value Human Value versusversus (ICT) (ICT) KnowledgeKnowledge
Cultural, ideological and value base of Cultural, ideological and value base of scientific knowledge questioned?scientific knowledge questioned?
Disorganized-Uncoupled Disorganized-Uncoupled Communications on Scientific, Humanity Communications on Scientific, Humanity and (Eco-System) Sustainability Risksand (Eco-System) Sustainability Risks
Emerging or Ending of Paradigmatic Emerging or Ending of Paradigmatic Shift?Shift?
Whose Value? What Scientific Whose Value? What Scientific Knowledge? Individual, Church, Knowledge? Individual, Church, Community, NGOs, Market or the State Community, NGOs, Market or the State as Proxy of Final Appeal and Judgment?as Proxy of Final Appeal and Judgment?
4141
New Ethical-Communicative New Ethical-Communicative PraxisPraxis@ New Humanity-Modernity?@ New Humanity-Modernity? New Communicative PraxisNew Communicative Praxis:: Promotion of Promotion of Communicative Independence - Communicative Independence - guard guard against the expert- imperialist controls. against the expert- imperialist controls.
Cyber-Activism towards Socio-Eco E-quity & Cyber-Activism towards Socio-Eco E-quity & Justice: Justice: call for normative call for normative ddevelopment evelopment agenda for agenda for the humanization of the the humanization of the informational society and global informational society and global sustainability: equity, participation and sustainability: equity, participation and social justice in the system of global/local social justice in the system of global/local governancegovernance
42
New Humanity & SustainabilityNew Praxis?
• Pooling of ‘Global-Flexibility’ Risks? • Diversified Regime of Development? • From Dependency to Self-Sufficiency?• New Socio-Eco Contract for Sustainability!• Beyond Market Approaches: CSR? Local
Capacity Building, Self-Help Cooperatives, Benevolent Regime for Development