document resume ed 093 375 dewees, daniel

34
DOCUMENT RESUME ED 093 375 IR 000 871 AUTHOR DeWees, Daniel TITLE A Developmental Proposal to Try Out a Limited System of Manpower Information Dissemination to Provide Better Linkages Between Some Neighborhood Agencies and a Range of Available Manpower Programs. Final Report. INSTITUTION Settlement Houses Employment Development, Inc., New York, N.Y. SPONS AGENCY Manpower Administration (DOL), Washington, D.C. Office of Research and Development. REPORT NO DLMA-21-36-73-14-9 PUB DATE 21 Nov 73 NOTE 38p. EDRS PRICE MF-$0.75 HC-$1.85 PLUS POSTAGE DESCRIPTORS Educational Opportunities; Employment Opportunities; *Employment Programs; *Information Dissemination; *Job Placement; Job Training; Manpower Needs; Manpower Utilization; Occupational Guidance; Program Evaluation; *Vocational Counseling; Vocational Training Centers IDENTIFIERS New York City Manpower Information Bulletins; NYCMIB ABSTRACT Some neighborhood based manpower agencies in the impacted areas do not possess the inhouse capability of informing their constituents of available manpower programs. The Manpower Administration funded a project to gather and disseminate manpower training information to some 60-70 neighborhood based agencies on standardized forms. Checks would be made on the utility of this information and the impact on the neighborhood agencies' practices. A directory of Manpower Services was also to be developed. Of the 98 agencies approached, 87 (89%) participated--over twenty more than anticipated. Thirty-six different training programs contributed information and provided over 5,500 training slots. Over 1,200 referrals were reported using the NYCMIB system. A steady increase of referrals was reported. For the first sixteen weeks, 252 referrals were made; over the last eighteen weeks, 924 referrals were made. A survey of a sample of participating agencies indicated that 63% of referrals resulted in placements. The utility of the project seems to be demonstrated. It is felt that a local agency should continue its operation. (Author)

Upload: others

Post on 15-Mar-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

DOCUMENT RESUME

ED 093 375 IR 000 871

AUTHOR DeWees, DanielTITLE A Developmental Proposal to Try Out a Limited System

of Manpower Information Dissemination to ProvideBetter Linkages Between Some Neighborhood Agenciesand a Range of Available Manpower Programs. FinalReport.

INSTITUTION Settlement Houses Employment Development, Inc., NewYork, N.Y.

SPONS AGENCY Manpower Administration (DOL), Washington, D.C.Office of Research and Development.

REPORT NO DLMA-21-36-73-14-9PUB DATE 21 Nov 73NOTE 38p.

EDRS PRICE MF-$0.75 HC-$1.85 PLUS POSTAGEDESCRIPTORS Educational Opportunities; Employment Opportunities;

*Employment Programs; *Information Dissemination;*Job Placement; Job Training; Manpower Needs;Manpower Utilization; Occupational Guidance; ProgramEvaluation; *Vocational Counseling; VocationalTraining Centers

IDENTIFIERS New York City Manpower Information Bulletins;NYCMIB

ABSTRACTSome neighborhood based manpower agencies in the

impacted areas do not possess the inhouse capability of informingtheir constituents of available manpower programs. The ManpowerAdministration funded a project to gather and disseminate manpowertraining information to some 60-70 neighborhood based agencies onstandardized forms. Checks would be made on the utility of thisinformation and the impact on the neighborhood agencies' practices. Adirectory of Manpower Services was also to be developed. Of the 98agencies approached, 87 (89%) participated--over twenty more thananticipated. Thirty-six different training programs contributedinformation and provided over 5,500 training slots. Over 1,200referrals were reported using the NYCMIB system. A steady increase ofreferrals was reported. For the first sixteen weeks, 252 referralswere made; over the last eighteen weeks, 924 referrals were made. Asurvey of a sample of participating agencies indicated that 63% ofreferrals resulted in placements. The utility of the project seems tobe demonstrated. It is felt that a local agency should continue itsoperation. (Author)

FINAL REPORT

A DEVMOPMLNTAL PROPOSAL TO TRY OUT A LIMITED SYSTEMOF MANPOWER INFORMATION DISSEMINATION TO PROVIDE BETTERLINKAGES BETWEIN SOME NEIGHBORHOOD AGENCIES AND A RANGE

OF AVAILABLE MANPOWER PROGRAMS

asI COP'tokott.

Submitted to:

Mr. Howard Rosen, DirectorOffice of Research and Development

Manpower AdministrationU. S. Department of Labor

1111 20th Street, N.W.Washington, D. C.

Submitted_tu

Mr. Daniel DeWee8, Project DirectorSettlement Houses Employment Development, Inc.

101 East 15th StreetNew York, New York 10003

S GEPARTMENTOF HEALTHF DUCA TION A VtELCAR ENATIONAL INSTITUTE OF

EDUCATION, A', TI. EP. REPRO

I AAr'* %", RI CI FROMORIGIN

t.' . 09 OP,NIONSzf ".F F SSAA11.', PFPAE

f ",A1 iNAL 'N5,1TuT1- 01

This report was prepared for the Manpower Administration,U.S. Department of Labor, under research and development con-tract (grant) No. 21-36-73-14. Since contractors (grantees)conducting research and development projer:ts under Governmentsponsorship are encouraged to express their own judgementfreely, this report does not necessarily represent the offi-cial opinion or policy of the Department of Labor. The con-tractor (grantee) is solely responsible for the contentsof this report.

BlaLIOGRAPHIC DATASHEET

1.q, s,o;DLA 21-36-73-14 - 9

2. 3. 114, 1.:f 1,1'. A. ; .;..:. N...

4.tr " t ".r ' to Developmental Propoaal to try out a limited

system of Manpower Information dissemination to provide betterlinkages between soma neighborhood agencies and a range of.available Manpower Programs

5 It; 1,..ri I) ;;;

November 21, 1973

7 1tilit,r)Mr. Daniel DeWees

8, I .1 th,f1.1J),: 1);,..11.5 .,,l,,I, i. /'9,. P; rts.,;;11%.6. l):4.011.,.111011 VIL.I .111%1 AddttSettlement Houses ihployment Developmentanc.

101 East 15th Street New York, New York 10003

10, l'r,;[; ; t I L..1"t,./;: I.:,;; \'1.

1 1. ( ,,,(,.., , .r,r.,n, Ni,

DL 217-56-75-14 -92. Si,,,r,.. rm.. Orl.txiii..it ;on N w,..tild N,Idr..;,.U.S. Department of LaborManpower AdministrationOffice of Research and Development1111 20th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20210

13. li'l Ot V4 1.1 tt N. Pt ri,!( ,,,.i Rd

Final

14.

15. S,::ppIcrnL nt.iry tivte,

16. A''''c' Some neighborhood based manpower agencies in the impacted areas do notpossess the inhouse capability of informing their constiuents of available manpowerprograms.The Manpower Administration funded a project to gather and disseminate man-power training information to some 60-70 neighborhood based agencies on standardizedforms. Checks would be made on the utility of this information and the impact on theneighborhood agencies' practices.A directory of Manpower Services was also to be de-veloped. Of the ninety-eight agencies approached, eighty-seven(89%) participated-over twenty more than anticipated. Thirty six different training program contributed in1formation and provided over 5,500 training slots. Over 1,200 referrals were reported us-.ing the NYCMIB Gystem.A steady i-crease of referrals were reported. For the first six-teen weeks, 252 referrals were made; over the last eighteen weeks, 924 referrals weremade. A survey of a sample of participating agencies indicated that 63% of referralsresulted in placements. The utility of the project seems to be demonstrated. It is feltthat a local a:enc should continue its operation.17. Key \k vrds and Doc urrect

Education (includesManpower, ManpowerGuidance, Psychological

17b. 1';^.1fiers Open-Ended

New York City Manpower

17c. cosATI Fizid/Gro,,,

Antlysis. 17o. DesetIptor,

traininii), Employment, Information Systems, Job Description,Placement, Tests, VocationalRequirements, Manpower Utilization,

Guidance

Terms

Information Bulletins' Service

I

It Ava'

i'-; vme

;'rt 'tate ntS Distribution is unlimited.

Available from National Technical InformationService, Springfield, Va. 22151.

19. Sicurity Class (1-hkRepots)

um- ;,,. I. t

21. No. of P.,ttes28

2 ,r,suritl C:Ass (I hi!,l'at.,;(

UN( 1.ASS11,11 p

22. Price

A

Pi T:".115 J. 1,72,THIS FORM MAY BE REPRODUrED 'JSCO.AVLC '4932.P7Z.

Table of Contents

I. Project's Objectives and Findings

II. Acknowledgement of Sponsorship

page

1

3

III. Results 5

IV. Problems 11.

V. Learnings 13

VI. Conclusions 13

VII. Appendix 14.

101 COPI010911

List of illustrations

1 dumber of Referrals Reported

2. Telephone Log

List of Tables

la. Training Slots Distributed by NYCNIB'11/22/72 - 9/11/73

lb. Referrals Reported Under Training Categories 11/22/72 - 9/11/73

2. Field Visits

3. Solicited Opinions of Pmject'sUtility

ii

List of Abbreviations and Symbols

1. DOT . Definitions of Titles

2. DOE - Department of Employment

3. DOL . Department of Labor

4. - - insuffient information

5. JOBS - Job Opportunities in Business

6. MCDA - Manpower Career and Development Agency

7. n - no

8. .4.- number of ongoing slots

9. NYCMI;s - Now York City Manpower Information Bulletins

10. OIC - Opportunities Industrialization Centers

11. RTP - Recruitment and Training Program

12. R&D - Research and Development

13. sev. - several

11+. SHED . Settlement Houses Imployment Development, Inc.

15. y . yes

iii

I. Project's Objectives and Findings

A. Objectives

Some neighborhood based manpower agencies located in the impactedareas of inner cities do not possess the inhonee capability of in-forming their constituents of available manpower programs. SettlementHouses Employment Development Inc. proposed to the Manpower Adminis-tration to gather and disseminate manpower training information to some60-70 neighborhood based agencies on standardized forms; and thatchecks would be made on the utility of this information and the impacton the neighborhood agencies' practices.

Three types of bulletins would be developed:1. Gathering current manpower training openings from program

agencies, publishing these on a standardized form and mailing themat regular (usually two week) intervals;

2. Distributing periodic analyses of current manpower problemsand issues of interest to manpower staff which are prepared by NewYork City's Manpower Planning Council;

3. Developing and distributing local program descriptions as aDirectory of Manpower and Related Services.

B. Findings

1. There was a good response to the project by neighborhoodbased agencies.Of the ninety-eight agencies approached, eighty-seven (89%) participated - over twenty more than anticipated.

2. There was n' problem gathering training program informa-tion. Thirty six (.1) different training programs contributed informa-tion and provided over 5,500 training slots,

3. Over 1,200 referrals were reported made as a direct resultof the NYCMIB system.(2)

4. Thera was a steady increase in the use of the NYCMIBsystem. For the first Sixteen weeks, 252 referral were made; overthe last eighteen weeks, 924 referrals were made.(3)

5. A survey of a sample of participating agencies indicatedthat b3% of referrals resulted in placenents.(4)

Footnotes:

(1) See appendix A "Program Agencies Providing Training Slots toNYCMIB."

(2) See Table Ia, page 7.(3) See Illustration #11page 4:"#of referrals plotted against program

time period."Also see Illustration #2, page 10:"NYCMIB staff ac-tivity to obtain referrals. e

(4) "Special Sampling Report" to Manpower Administration by SHED,September, 1973.

1.

6. The survey indicated that the percentage of placements ofreferrals was almost equally as high for training slots which leadto high, medium and low paying jobs as categorized by DOL DOT Cedes.(5)

7. Findings from the project telephone log include the following(6)a. Requests for information about specific programs suggests a

bell curve. Inquiries were reluctant at start, peaked duringthe middle and slackened as manpower personnel became adeptat using the binder.

b. Requests for information in the use of the binder(6) is asomewhat sharper curve suggesting again, inquiries taperingoff as manpower personnel became mo:e knowledgeable in a-vailable manpower services.

c. Telephone training sessions in the use of the Bulletinsremained high over a six month period as new agencies wereintroduced and personnel changes occured at the referralagencies. An attenuation at the end of the project reflectsgreater knowledge on the part of referral agency personnel.

d. Persi'tent requests for referral data was a consistent fea-ture of the project.

e. Other specific (7) requests from referral agencies for tech-nical manpower information decreased as the project pro-ceeded - while referrals reported to NYCM18 increased.

8. Table 3 (see Table 3, page 9) is a compilation of data securedthrough SHED's survey of twelve agencies to determine the utility ofthe program.

a. Five indicated that =MID had provided new training slots.b. Three indicated that the formats and practices of NYCMIB

had aided their agencies in refining the manpower practicesof their agencies.

c. Three agencies indicated that their professional staff ef-ficiency had been increased through the concentration ofmanpower information in the Bulletins.

d. Four agencies indicated that the Bulletins insured cur-rency of information.

e. Three agencies recognized the duplication of most of thetraining information but indicated the concentration increasestheir productivity.

Footnotes:

(5) Under Table Ia,(page 7) Column 5 (College Adapter), 8 (DriverTraining), 16 (Recruitment and Training Program-formerly JointApprentice Program) and 23 (Warehouse Shipping and Receiving) areinstructive. In each of these categories there are more referralsthan openings. In the case of Programs under 16, these are low DOTCodes leading to good salaries; program under 5, although an educa-tional program, this is associated with higher earnings. Programunder Column 8 and 23 is a program dominated by minority males whocan meet entry level requirements.

(6) Illustration #2, page 10.(7) Specific requests included items including locations of agencies,

criteria for applicant acceptance in programs, general entranceprocedures for training agencies, locations of specific trainingprograms not listed in the Bulletins.

2.

IX. Acknowledgement of Sponsorship

This report of a demonstration project was prepared under a grantfrom the Manpower Administration, U.S,. Department of Labor, under theauthority of the Manpower Development'and Training Act. Organizationsundertaking such projects under the Government sponsorship are encouragedto express their own judgement freely. Therefore, points of view or o-pinions stated in this document do not necessarily represent the officialposition or policy of the Department of Labor.

3.

Illustration 1

NIMER OFREFERRALSREPORTED

550......., 1111

11111111111111111500

450 1=NM4.0

350

......300

1111250 ,f.-,,,..

.,,..... -4.-

, i

}

----....-

).

" Ai-

200

1 5C) 1. -

1111

. .. .

7

......

....

.-.

_77' - ''"r..

,., ,

0__ :1.0...c.-.............,--r..t. L -, .

.,Z._

5 5 32 43 65 1.13 277 271 271 97 161176

C\J N Cll tcl l'cN M t41 tc) 01 t41 141 IC) t-rNCs- N N N (... iN- t- C N N N C,--

.. . . . . . . . .-

. . .4-10 0 0(I) 00 $4

0-40 0 t30 . A . P-I *4 -.

Z''' .:4 0 0

4

III. Results

1. Thirty-three referral agencies located in the five boroughs ofNew York City, grouped under a selection criteria,(8) responded toSHED's first mailing of an invitational questionnaire (9) to partici-pate in the project.

At subsequent periods, sixty-five additional referral agencieswere invited to participate in the project.

Of this total recruitment of sixty-five agencies, eleven referralagencies withdrew; (10) twenty-nine additional referral agencies re-quested participation but were not accepted due to the anticipatedrefunding problem.

Of the total eighty-seven participating referral agenciesltwentyreturned the invitational questionnaire.

Of the total twenty-nine referral agencies requesting participa-tion, twenty-eight returned the invitational questionnaire.2. 201 Training Information Bulletins (11) using a format designed

by Manpower Specialists from New York City agencies were distributedfrom November 22, 1972 through November 11, 1973.3. Three instruction sheets (12) to update information content were

distributed at eight week intervals.4. By the sixth month of the project, 250 copies (,1:' each training

information bulletin sheet containing training slot information wasmailed on an approximate two week basis to the eighty-seven referralagencies.5. Using data as of September 11, 1973, thirty-six program agencies(13)

provided approximately 5,647 (14) training slots for distribution.

Footnotes:

(8) Criteria for selection included:(1) the "needs" concept, (2) theprofessional capacity of manpower agency personnel, (3) the agencyservice to "problem populations" e.g. ex-addicts, (4) the referralagencies' energetic response to SHED's invitation to participants.The total number or referral agencies served was 25% greater thanthe original condition of the grant. In addition, w:th multiplemailings, the total sheets distributed increased by 250%. Projectcosts reflect these changes in the original mailing estimates.

(9) Appendix B. "Interview questionnaire...Distributed to ReferralAgencies by SHED."

(10) Appendix C. "Method of Selecting Referral Agencies and reasonsfor withdrawal." from Special Report on Manpower InformationBulletin to Manpower Administration"- 7/73.

(11) Appendix D sample. "NICMIB Training Information Sheet"(12) Appendix E. "Typical Instruction sheet for updating NYCMIB Train-

ing Information Bulletins' binder."(13) See Appendix B. List of program agencies providing UYCMIB project

with training slot openings.(14) This total count excludes some totals in training categories noted

as sev.(several) and +. In the letter case of the coded 4-, thisnumber including general information sheets for JOBS, NeighborhoodYouth Corps, etc. would increase the totals significantly.

5.

6. Other training slot information was circulated as general informa-tion when the available slots were ongoing. (15) Table Is summarizesthe total slot distribution by training category as of September 11, 1973.

See Table Ia, page 7.

7. 1,079 referrals from referral agencies were reported as of September 11, 1973. Table Ia summarizes referrals submitted to NYCMIB by train-ing category.

See Table Ib, page 7

8. Forty six field visits were conducted to referral agencies inorder to check the condition of the binder. Using an interview formquestionnaire (16), visits to thirty-one agencies yielded the followingtable.

See Table 2, page 8.

9. Of the thirty-one agencies visited, twenty-seven were using thebinders actively and an updated binder was observed. Four agencies werenot using the binder. Twenty-two agencies requested that NYCM1B seek moretraining slots, particularly from private industry and slots relevant tomales 16-20.

10. A NYCMIB Manpower Services Directory (17) has been distributed tothirty-seven referral agencies and to ten program agencies.

Divided under fourteen manpower service categories, the Directorylists 801 places to obtain services as supplied by 450 agencies.

Footnotes:

(15) Program example of continuing slots is the Neighborhood YouthCorps, the New York City Board of Education programs. An exampleof program slots deemed not proper for NYCMIB distribution is theJob Opportunities in Business (JOBS)

(16) Appendix F. "Field Visit Interview Form"(17) Appendix G. "NYCMIB Manpower Services Directory"

6.

,ts 0

0 c+ 0

N ei

N E.

ro

P cwt

0 SI)

crl

k0 P. -Q 0 t.)*

1

1

AGED H

BUILDING CONS. 11t23

TRADES N

CLERICAL 939

ki,

CIVIL SERVICE 90

COLLEGE ADAPTER \il

COMPUTER TRAINING 52 al

-1/43 li

40 DRAFTING

SEV DRIVER TRAM ING C

4 20 DRY CLEANING

kOi

20 ELECTRONICS h--. 0

ENGLISH AS SECOND 560 F-' F"

35 FOOD SERVICES f --,

NJ

444 GEN. EDUCATION DIPL. Z.-,;

0 HANDICAPPED

75 INDUSTRIAL ELECT.

50 JOINT APP. PRCGRAN

1

20 MACHINIST

MAJOR APPLIANCE SEA REPAIR if 1.......;..4

1N.Y. STATE EIVLOYMIT 1--i-3' i4a,,,,......_.arzuzz.......

1

j INURSITG

' 0

Lil

N 0

5 i PRINTING j

4 4 st! IREPAIR SERVICE 1,r',

.

0

O 1,1

}-1

(11

' )---3

tn H cc'

N 0 c+- M p H

H %.0 -

N c t.

0'

wtzj

WARMOUSING ,SHIPPING

r. 55 RECEITTiG

JOB CORPS 4:-

Table 2

Field Visit Reports

riNAMEOF N N

AGENCYPi

tnE-4Hei)

>nvi'

HQ`Ei0 --1

4

pi

PA

p

NAMEOFAGENCY

P1 0

NM

0E-I

17)H

2fr-i

fl 0LoIN

a .0 6Nrir0

ma #8 N* 1 Y* COURT EMPLOY. Y

Y

)

0

-*

-RMC # 10,Y 2 Y

CENTRALLAB. COUN.

S.E. QUNS. NMSC Y 2 Y FORTUNE SOC. Y 1 -NY URB. LEAGUE Y 2 Y BRIDGE PLAZA Y 1 -CORONA EASTIntauRsTmsc Y 1 Y ENCOUNTERELD. EMPLOY.& QUID. SERV. Y 1 - MODEL CITIES YMDT RIKERS ISL. Y 1 EDUCA. ALLIANCE Y 6 YHUDSON GUILD Y 1 Y HEALTH SER. AG.

JOBS FOITTOTTITT7YY 2 Y

BETH ISRAEL Y 1 -

STATE UNIV.or NY (BMW) Y .1 -

ADDICTION SER.AGENCY Y 1 -

'

RMC #9 N 1 YNARC. ADDIC.CONT. COMM. Y 1

RMC #7 N 1 Y HARLEM SPAN Y 1NYC DEPT. OFVET. AFFAIRS N

CODE *

N = NOY = YES- = INSUFFICIENT INFORMATION

ADDICT RESOURCE& TREAT.HANHATTADPROBATION Y 1 YRIC d 4 Y 1 YOS/30RITEFOUNDATION Y 1 -

HUNTS PT.MULTI-SER. CNTR. Y 1 _

COT,ONY SOUTHBROOKLYN Y 1 -Tu \ MILTOirMADISON Y 1 YBRONX RIVERNEIGH. HOUSE Y 1 YJAMES WEL.JO"NSON Y 1 Y

8.

Table 3

Solioited Opinions of Proects Utility

RESPONSES OFAGENCIES FROMNYCMIB SOLICITATIONOF PROJECTS UTILITY

I.

II.

IV.

V.

VI.

VII.

VIII.

Ix.

x.

XI.

E-4

ddN

GE+

:7300

[SIE-- D1

C 1tr)

--1 1-1I--1

Cet nc.4

1

E-t

00 0

PROVIDED LTFORMATION ON NEWTRAININII OPENINGS

BULLETLI GUIDKMES DETERMINEDCRITERIA FOR APPLICANTS TOPROGRAM III

III

ill

III

PROVIDED CRITERIA FOR REFININGINTERNAL Z.:ANPOWER PRACTICES III

.

ALLOWED AN INCREASE IN AGENCYPERSONNEL CASELOAD TERUORGANIZED STRUCTURE OF BULLETIN

X

IMPORTANT ACCESS TO MANPOWERINFORMATION PROVIDED BYBULLETIN SERVICE 1111

------

X

CURRENCY OF TRAINING OPENINGSAND CLOSINGS BY BULLETINSERVICE III X

SUBSTITUTED FOR ABSENTPLACE.= COUNSELORS:APPLICANTS WERE ALLOWED TO USEBULLETIN BINDER TO SEEK SLOTS III

REFERRAL AGENCIES CAN SOLICITTRAINING SLOT INFORMATIONAFgER BULLETINS EXPERIENCE IIINYC; 13 SHOULD EVALUATE QUALITYOF PROGRAMS

X....-w-

PROGRAM OF FEEDBACK FROMTRAMINGAGENCaSNEEDED III X

DESPITE DUPLICATION, BULLETINSINCREASE EZrICIENCY

9.

Illustvlation 2

ik

En_

-0 ,

0i, 1

..,(..,

o

0;r_ Askr

Al A

o iolam=.

1111111111111111

1

c

0

FfB, 1

1

, \ /

41)

6,

'I s.A , ..

//

,

1

, -

5

8

17

16

15.

11+

13

12

10

9_

8

7

6

5

if

3

2

1

0Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May June July Aug. Sep. Oct.

N=116a: Solid line: 1/ of calls from referral agencies re: specific programs

N=26b; Short dash lines0 of calls from referral agencies on use of binder

N=42c: Long dash:Training sessions in use of NYCMI.3 Training Information Bulletin

!1=186

d. Line with circles: Calls from NYCMIB staff to referral agencies requesting

referrals10.

IV. Problems

The problems of executing the grant canO)e organized into four majorgroups.

A. SHED

1. The first person chosen as assistant project director did notpossess a range of knowledge suitable for the project. The direct respon-sibility for the project impleme,tation shifted to the project director.The program suffered through insufficient responses from referral agenciesin returning their interview questionnaires(18) and a delay in initiatingwork for the Manpower Services Directory.(19)

2. The production time of the Manpower Services Directory was mis-calculated since the instrument had to be constantly checked and broughtup to date.

3. The misinterpretations of the initial measures led referralagencies to believe that =CB was mandated to follow up applicants atthe training site.

B. Referral Agencies

1. The major problem was the incessant prodding of NYCMIB referralagencies for information regarding'their referralsa11ulitratien4 2, page10, details the inquiries made for the referral information.

2. Once the referral agency began receiving the training bulletin,it was impossible to obtain the interview questionnaires that had notbeen promptly submitted in the early stages.

3. Some referral agencies insisted that NYCMIB should not distri-bute claims made by training agencies for future jobs based on trainingwhen, from their experience, such claims were false. =NIB discussedthe feasibility of seeking guidance from the funding agency in respectto these charges. Referral agencies never submitted any formal documentsthat could serve as a basis for this procedure. In effect, we had main-tained that we were not empowered to monitor; rather we were seeking interagency cooperation within very strict confines of the grant condition.

C. Etpaligkesaa

Delays in obtaining training slot information was due to thebureaucratic procedures of agency personnel authorized to decide ifthe agency wanted to participate.

D. Manpower Administration

The project vas completed without a single field visit nor anywritten response to the reports dispatched to the funding agency. Evennow, it is unclear what this means. Evaluating ourselves is not an

Footnotes:

(18) See appendix B.

(19) See appendix G.

11.

easy task. Numerous staff discussions to discipline the referral agenciesfor not providing information, positive or negative, on their referrals,invariably ended with no action taken. Toward the end of the projectNYON/B had to decide whether an elaborate search for referrals was asimportant as the completion of the NYCMIB Vanpower Services Directory.(20)

Footnote:

(20) See appendix 0.

12.

V. Learnings

The learnings relate to the grant conditions and are reported animprovements to problems leading to the grant request.

1. Complaints that training slot information is not as dispersedas it should be has been somewhat altered through the distribution ofthese slots as new slots.

2. Manpower Information presented in a single format is useful asan aid in undermanned neighborhood agencies.

3. The problems of assessing the relation of unfilled trainingslots and the referral mechanisms of referral agencies is an area re-quiring sharp study.

VI. Conclusion

As a Research and Development project, the NYCMIB understandsthe problem of why such a grant should not be renewed by the ManpowerAdministration. In large part we feel that the utility of the projectrests on a realization by the local funding authority that the R&Daspect has been demonstrated. The project should, if worthwhile, bocontinued through local Department of Labor funds or funded by a CityAgency.

13.

List of Appendix

Inge

A. List of Program Agencies15

B. Interview with Agencies (Referral) 16

C. Agencies Dropped From Participation 7/9/72 20

D. Sample: NYC Manpower Information Bulletin Sheet 21

E. Typical Instruction sheet for updating NYCMIB Training Information 22

Bulletins' binder

F. Field Visit Interview Form 28

O. Manpower Service Directory - attached to report

14.

Appendix "A"

List of Program Agencies

1-11 Manpower Career Development AgenciesAt the time of this projects inception MODA funded elevenregional offices - Regional. Manpower Center (RMC). Eachcenter provides some training programs. MODA is now knownas New York City Department of Employment (DOE)

Other Program Agencies Funded Thru NYCDOE

12 College Adapter13 Renter14 District 6515 Airco16 New York State Employment Service17-21 Opportunities Industrialization Centers (OIC)

OIC has five regional centers which supplied training slotsto NYCMIB

22 New York City Board of Education23 State University of New York (Brooklyn Campus)24-26 Recruitment and Training Program (RTP)

RTP has four regional sites for pre-apprenticeship programs.New York City School of Locksmithing, Inc.

27 United States Marine Corp28 New York School of Printing29 Young Men's and Young Women's Hebrew Association30 Federation Employment and Guidance Service31 Brooklyn Bureau of Community Service

32 National Puerto Rican Forum

33 Service Education for the Rehabilitat6on of Drug Addiction34 New York City Youth Services' Agency35 University of the Streets36 Training Resources for Youth37 New York City Neighborhood Youth Corps

38 Young Men's Christian Association Upward Bound Program

15

AGENCY

NAn 0? ZTERVIEVEE

PHONE 0

Appendix "B"

nr:F.Tr..1:11 11.7.711 AGEIZC17.5(R73 414./Ajj)

DA'T'E

POSXTION

1. Vow many people come to your agency each year seeking job.'training or vocational education information?

less than 500_,_,500 - 1,000 1,000 2,000 2,000 +

What percentage are:

16 21 21..35 35..50 50+

b. Male Female

c. High School Drop-outs High School Graduates

Id.. Veterans Handicapped or disabled

Ex-offenders Ex-addicts Experienced workers '

e. Welfare Recipients Spanish speaking

2. Does your agency conduct its own training

If so,What type of training programs or resources do you have atyour agency and how many people per year are served?

SININ114111

3. To what outside training prograris do you refer applicants?How many per year?

4

Neighborhood Manpower Service Centers Joint Apprenticeship Program

CAC Centers Wilding Trades' OCT Public Service Careers Program

0ob Corps Work incentive Program Community Centers

NYSES

Other Cipe ~=01.......1.14

16.

4. From Which agencies or resouzces do you receive training orvocational education information? In what form is it received?

SOURCE FORM

1111=1.1/0*. 11.M.

...0.

Is this information adequate to meet your agency'scommitment to applicants? Yes No

If no, what types of information do you need?

...

..M.....m..0,=1111.111.

b. Do you think the information you receive is wellcoordinated? Yes No

Vhat method of information dissemination is best suited toyour agency?

11.. , 11,

41 ......rwro.......orSI

c. Will the proposed information from this SHED project serve your

needs? Yes No

Do you have any specific suggestions on altering what SHED has

proposed?

11.1 .

I111I,

.0.11110.

5. How many staff members do you have in your Manpower program?

What positions do they hold?

Vocational Counselors

Job Developer

Trainers

intake workers

Research

Other (specify)

Full Time Part Time

4.me 11.4110

easioA*alrato

01. illmoi.omm.110

111...111.1111.1.

18.

IIMI*1

6. You understand that the SHED system is an R & D program, andthat it will require a commitment of your staf's time.

a.. Can you commit your staff to utilizing the .-,ystem?

b. Can they attend a series of orientation sessions to learnto use the system, and periodic meetingS to improve thesystem? Yes No

c. Will the staff have time to report on a regular basis on theresultd of the system? Yes No

7nterviewerlsPatinv

Agency is:

likely

unlikely

19.

P

Appendix "C"

AGENCIES DROPPED FROM PARTICIPATION 7, 7

Agencies Method of Selectionfor Procrram

1. Action for Progress Selected by NYCMIBin First Round

Agency requested

Same

Same

2. City Hospitalat Elmhurst

3. Childrens HealthService

4. Irving PlaceMini-School

5. Dept. of Social SameServices (Empl. Div.)

6. Willoughby Settle-ment House

7. Training Resourcesfor Youth

8. Stanley M. IssacsSettlement House

9. Federation Employ-ment & GuidanceService

By NYCMIB

Same

Same

Agency requested

10. New York Urban League Same

114A Monserrat Assoc- Sameiatesv Inc.

20.

Reason for Withdrawal

Program no longer makesvocational referrals

Population too mature(45+) recovering fromstrokes, amputations

Mothers at Day Care Centersneed jobs; not interestedin training

Dearth of jobs for girlsseeking employment/training af4rJ2 noon

Have checked with counselors;much information duplicated."Program not working for us"

Not enough youth opportunities

Not much use due to theyoung population (14-21)

Not enough slots;for Age16-17

No referrals made due tomaturity of applicants (55+)

Programs not applicable

Not using 'Linder

Sample:

I. Training Agency

Ii. Type of Program:

Apponulx "o"

NYC MANPOWER INFORMATION BULLETINS Sheet101 EAST 15th STREET NYC 10003 677.0300 EXT, 24, 25Leonora McLaughlin - Assistant Project Director

TRAININ6 INFORMAFION

VI. Entry_ Requirements

pescriation & Location of Training

1. What .`find

2. Length of Training

3. Time/Hours

4. Location

15. ...Upend

6. Who does placement7_a. Good

7. Chances for placementb. Faitafter training c. Poor

IV. Consideration given to:

1. Veterams...----- 2. Unemployed

3. Youth 4. Ex-Addict

5. Ex-Offenders 6. Meth Maint

2. Handicapped 8. Other

V. Slot Information

is 0 2. Cycle Begins

6%Chances for training

Minimum Income1. Aga 2. for entry

3. Is Certification Required?

4. Geographical Limitations

5. Citizenship 6. Alien Card

7. English Fluency

8. Minimum EducationLimitations on source of H.S. Equivalency (GED)

9. and H.S. Diploma

10. Test Given

Where to report11. for test

12. Physical Requirements

13. Type of Physical ExamWhere to Report

14. for Physical Exam

VII. Referral Information

1. Who to Contact

2. Telephone 4

3. Where to Report

4. Travel Directions

VIII. N.Y.C.M.I.B.

1. # Follow -up Date:

2. Mailing Date

21.

Appendix "E"

NYC MANPOWER INFORMATION BULLETINS101 EAST 15th STREET NYC 10003 677.0300 EXT. 24, 25

(Typical Instruction sheet for updating NYCNIBTraining Information Bulletins' binder)

TO: NYCMIB Agencies

August 22, 1973.

We here at New York City Manpower information Bulletinsare aware that pressing agency tasks may prevent your insertingthe training sheets under their proper tabs and removingtraining sheets when the training period is ended.

We are listing the sheets that should be in your bodt as ofthis mailing. The sheets are listed as they should appearunder the tabs beginning with the first tab.

Of course it is possible that some sheets were mispaced,never arrived, etc.

We are indicating the closing dates of each program in caseyou are missing programs that are still open. Please let usknow if you need any of these sheets.

Sincerely,

oht /IVA/

Dan DeWeesProject Director

Pagel.

AGED

will notify

Type 0J:: Procram

Program #

Trainina Aaency

Closina Date

Clerical

154

Federation Employment & Guidence

August 1, 1974

Service

BUILDING CON-

Carpentry

116

Service Education for the Rehabi-

Open entry

STRUCTION

Utz:U.0n of Drug Addiction

TRADES

Electrician

127

Electricians Union Local #3

Locksmith

144

NY School of Locksmithing, Inc.

Bricklayer

168

NY Executive Committee of Bricklayers,

Masons, and Plasterers

Ornamental Iron Workers

169

Local #580

Pointer, Caulker &

170

P4nters4 CIeaners & Caulkers Masonry

Cleaner

JAC Local #66

CIVIL SERVICE

Mail. Clerk/Carrier

95

Regional Manpower Centers #'s 1, 2,3,

TRAINING

4,5,7,8,9,10,11

Federal Office Assistant

120

NYC Department of Employment

GS2, GS3

Region #3

CLERICAL

Steno

7Manpower & Career Development Agency

Regional Manpower System #2

Basic Office Practice

11

'In

ftIf

II

Basic Office Practice

44

Regional Manpower Center #5

Basic Office Practice

59

Regional Manpower Center #10

Basic Office Practice

69

Manpower & Career Development Agency

Regional Manpower System #11

Open entry

ftft

ftrr

ftIf

rrft

Page 2

Tab

Tyne of Proc7nam

Procram #

Traininc Acme)/

Cie-inc Date

CLERICAL

(cent.)

Basic Office Practice

Various

62

89

Manpower & Development Agency

Open entry

Regional Manpower System #7

University of the Streets

Open entry

Steno/Speedwriting

134

IfRegional Manpower Center #11

Clerical Education

137

Opportunities Industrialization

Feb. '74

Basic Office Practice

Bookkeeping

138

139

Center

tiO.I.C.

tf

0.I.C.

Basic Office Practice

140

O.I.C.

Mar. '74

Secretarial

145

Dec. '73

Basic Office Practice

146

O.I.C.

Jan. '74

Clerical

151

Service Education for the Rehabi-April '74

litation of Drug Addiction

Basic Office Practice

153

Manpower & Career Development Agency Feb. '74

Regional Manpower Center #8

Secretarial Science

155

The SUNY Educational Opportunity Cen. May '74

Clerical Education

165

Opportunities Industrialization Cen. March '74

COLLEGE ADAp-

Education

96

College Adapter

Feb. '74

TER PROGRAM

College Adapter

156

The SUNY Educational Opportunity

May *74

Centre, NYC

COMPUTER

Computer Operation

141

Opportunities Industrialization

Open entry

TRAINING

Center

PROGRAM

Page 3

Tab

Type or Proeram

Procran

Training Acencv

Closing Date

COMPUTER

TRAINING

PROGRAM (cont.)

Computer Programming

Console Operator

Keypunch Operator

142

157

158

Opportunities Industrialization

Center

The SUNY Opportunity Centre; NYC

The SUNY Opportunity Centre, NYC

Open entry

Feb. '74

Open entry

DRAFTING

Mechnical, Architectural

159

May '74

Drafting

DRIVER TRAINING

Bus Driving

17

Rentar Educational Corporation

Open entry

Straight Truck

18

11

it

Ittt

Tractor Trailer

19

tttt

DRY CLEANING

Dry Cleaning

160

The SUNY Educational Opportunity

Dec. '73

....-

Centre

ELECTRONICS

Basic Electronics

161

nH

May. '74

Technician

ENGLISH AS A

Education

10

Manpower & Career Development Agency

Open entry

SECOND LANGUAGE

Education

28

Regional Manpower Centre 4S

nn

Education

57

n11

System 410

/III

Education (Title III)

62

Itif

Center III

n.11

Education

68

(same'as above)

System #11

nn

Education (Title III)

85

Regional Manpower Center III

11II

Education

152

Manpower & Career Development Agency

March '74

Regional Manpower Center #8

FCCD SERVICE15

Food Preparation

79

Opportunities Industrialization

Open entry

Center

Page 4

Tab

1\-ry, of r-ccram

Proaram #

Trinina Ancncy

Cloninc Date

FOOD SERVICES

(cont.)

GENERAL ED-

UCATION DIPLOMA

Baking

Basic Education

(Title III)

Basic Education wEp

112

63

64

Baking in.dustry Labor l':anagcment

Apprenticeship Council of NY

Regional Manpower Center III

.

Regional Manpower III

Open entry

se

Mini-School

83

Regional Manpower System #7

GED

133

Opportunities Industrialization

Center

GED

143

O.I.C.

March "74

GED

147

O.I.C.

December '73

Basic Education

166

0.I.C.

February '74

HANDICAPPED

Sewing

24

Brooklyn Bureau of Community

Open entry

Service

INDUSTRIAL

Mechanical Trades

135.

Opportunities Industrialization

March '74

ELECTRICITY

Center

Industrial Electricity 167

O.X.C.

I?

MAJOR APPLIANCE

REPAIR

Machine Repair

117

Service Education for the Rehabi-

litation of Drug Addiction

Open entry

MARINE CORPS

.

Various Occupations

136

U.S. Marine Corps Reserve

re

RESERVE TRAINING

PROGRAM

NY STATE EMPLOY-

Multi Occupational

90

NYC Board of Ed. & selected

Open entry

MENT SERVICE

Project IX

private schools

On the job training

93

Various private employers

Page 5

Tab

TVpe of Program

Program #

Training Aaencv

Closing Date

NEIGHBORHOOD

YOUTH CORPS

Out-of-school & in-

school

104

Youth Services Agency

Open entry

NURSING

Nurse's Aide

23

YM & YWHA

if

"

PRINTING

Offset Duplicating

162

The SUNY Urban Center, Bklyn.

December '73

REPAIR SERVICE

Radio/TV Repair

27

Regional Manpower Center #5

Open entry

Air Conditioning, Oil

45

(same)

IfIt

t

Burner Servicing, &

Refrigeration

Photo Copying Machine

148

O.I.C.

February '74

Repair

Typewriter Repair

149

0.1.C.

VI

Automatic Packaging

163

The SUNY Urban Center, Bklyn.

May '74

Line Mechanic

Business Machine Repair 164

(same)

February '74

WAREHOUSING,

Factory

150

Development & Training Center

November '74

SHIPPING & RCCEIV-

for the District Trades (Dis.65)

ING

.1