doc.: ieee 802.11-11/1341r0 submission september 2011 andrew myles, ciscoslide 1 jtc1 sc september...
TRANSCRIPT
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 1
JTC1 SC September 2011 - Closing Report
22 Sept 2011
Name Company Phone email
Andrew Myles Cisco +61 284461010 [email protected]
Bruce Kraemer Marvell [email protected]
Authors:
Meeting document: 11-11-1273
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
JTC1 SC agenda items
• Status of WAPI in SC6
• Status of 802.1X/AE and 802.16 security replacements
• Status of N-UHT (802.11ac replacement)
• Plan for 8802 standards
• Plan for next SC6 meeting Feb 2012 in Guangzhou
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 2
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 met in San Diego in June 2011 and will meet in Guangzhou, China in Feb 2012
• SC6 has a F2F meeting every 9 months or so
• The last meeting was held on 20-24 June 2011 in San Diego– All WGs met in San Diego
— WG1: Physical and data link layers— WG7: Network and transport layers (also known as Future Network)— WG8: Directory— WG9: ASN.1 and registration
• The next meeting is in Guangzhou, China in February 2012– Now confirmed for week of 20 Feb 2012
– Only two WGs are planning to meet— WG1: Physical and data link layers— WG7: Network and transport layers
– The IEEE 802 will need to send a delegation again!— Please start planning to attend!
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 3
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
The 802.11 WG has liaised various Sponsor Ballot drafts to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6
• Bruce Kraemer will send the red highlighted documents after Okinawa
• The WG told SC6 it will liaise 802.11ac as soon as it passes a LB
• 802.11-2012 will be submitted to SC6 when approved by the SASB – early 2012
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 4
Task Group
AfterSD
After Hawaii
After Dallas
AfterLA
AfterSing.
After Palm Sp
After SanFran
After Okinawa
July 10 Sept 10 Nov 10 Jan 11 Mar 11 May 11 July 11 Sept 11
TGae - - - - - - - D5.0
TGaa - - - - - - - D6.0
TGac - - - - - - - -
TGmb - - D6.0 - D8.0 - - D10.0
TGs - - D8.0 - D10.0 - Ratified -
TGu D11.0 - D13.0 - - Ratified - -
TGv D13.0 D15.0 - - - Ratified - -
TGz D12.0 D13.0 - - - Ratified - -
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
There have been attempts to make progress on WAPI NP at a series of CRM teleconferences
• In San Diego, the US NB proposed that progress could be made on resolving the WAPI NP comments by teleconference
• IEEE objective is to expunge false commentary on 802.11 security
• SC6 subsequently agreed to hold comment resolution meetings (The CRMs were held – 10 Aug, 31 Aug, 15 Sept held so far, 21 Nov scheduled (probably last!)
– US, UK, Switzerland, China, Korea and IEEE 802 have been represented
– Convenor: Mr Seung Ok Lim (Korea) – also new WG1 Chair
• After the first two teleconference made little progress, it was decided to use e-mail as well– Hundreds of e-mails resulted
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 5
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
The Chair would like to thanks various individuals for representing IEEE 802 at the CRMs
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 6
• Bruce Kraemer
• Dan Harkins
• Dorothy Stanley
• Jodi Haaz
• Brian Weis
10 August
• Bruce Kraemer
• Dan Harkins
• Dorothy Stanley
• Jodi Haaz
• Brian Weis
31 August
• Bruce Kraemer
• Dan Harkins
• Dorothy Stanley
• Jodi Haaz
15 September
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
There will be one final CRM on 21 November ...
• The CRM convenor stated that there will only be one more CRM– It will be held on 21 November
– E-mail discussion is encouraged in the meantime
• The various parties are far apart ...– Latest e-mails are not very encouraging
– China NB & Swiss NB technical experts do not seem to understand the implementation of functional entities defined by 802.11i
– Swiss NB rep is continuing to asserting that all of 802.11i is insecure because it includes WEP and TKIP
– US NB, UK NB and IEEE 802 reps appear to be aligned
– SC6 Chair has stated, “Unless the allegations around 'serious security loopholes' in the NP are deleted and the NP form is revised, it's chair's position not to accept the DoC”
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 7
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
Other topics in SC6
• China NB has proposed– An 802.1X/AE replacement
– An 802.16 security replacement
– An 802.11ac replacement
• Withdrawal of a number of standards including the 8802 series – responsibility delegated to IEEE 802 to report back with definitive list in February 2012
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 8
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/1341r0
Submission
September 2011
The discussion in San Francisco decided to send 802 standards to ISO/IEC under certain conditions
Summary from San Francisco 802 plenary meeting
• There was consensus that it was important for 802 to send standards to ISO/IEC for “registration”
• Need to guarantee that these will not be edited without the explicit agreement of the 802 owner
• An implementation plan will be further explored during the November plenary
Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 9