discovery and access: standards and the information chain a jisc seminar co-sponsored by the...
TRANSCRIPT
Discovery and Access: Standards and the Information Chain
A JISC seminar co-sponsored by the Association of Learned and Professional Society Publishers (ALPSP), the Publishers Association, and CrossRef
Bonhill House, London; 7 December 2006Moderator: Mark Bide, Rightscom
Objectives
1. Explore how publishers, libraries, and other participants in the information chain are using standards to enable discovery and access
2. Identify any action needed to move things forward – fill gaps, identify and resolve issues
Programme
10:00 – 11:40: Key Standards and the Information Chain Welcome and Introduction [Mark Bide] Vision for academic information environments [Catherine Grout, JISC] A library perspective [Chris Awre, University of Hull] A publisher Perspective [Cliff Morgan, John Wiley]
12:00 – 13:00: New Developments ONIX for Licensing Terms [Brian Green, BIC/EDItEUR] OpenURLs [James Culling, Scholarly Information Strategies] Versions of Journal articles [Frances Shipsey, LSE]
13:00 – 14:00 Lunch
Programme
14:00 – 15:15 Innovative Applications Improving usage statistics [Peter Shepherd, COUNTER]
Innovative uses of RSS [Tony Hammond, Nature & Paul Evans, Emerald] OAI [John Robertson, University of Strathclyde] eBooks [Hugh Look, Rightscom]
15:40 – 16:30: The Future - What needs to happen? An open discussion, led by the panel:
Ed Pentz, Cross Ref Ramon Schrama, Swets Information ServicesHazel Woodward, Cranfield UniversityRobert Bley, Ex Libris
16:30 Close
An introduction:PALS “Metadata Sharing” issues:the metadata interface between publishers and libraries: some thoughts from the chairMark Bide, Rightscom
December 2006
Publishers sharing data with libraries
Acquisition
Cataloguing
Resource Mgmt
Price &availability
Commercial(Invoice etc)
Product information
Productdescription
ResourceIdentification
ResourceLocation
ProductIdentification
Resourcedescription
Library dataacquisition
Publisher data supply*
Licenceterms
*Note this data may flow through intermediaries
Usage
All typesof resources
Digitalresources
Disclosure
Libraries sharing data with publishers
Acquisition
Commercial(Order etc)
Library datasupply*
Publisher data acquisition
*Note this data may flow through intermediaries
All typesof resources
Digitalresources
Fulfilment
Access MngmtAccess &
authorization
Price &availability
Product information
Productdescription
ResourceLocation
Resourcedescription
Licenceterms
Usage
Cataloguing
Resource Mgmt
Disclosure
Search
Standards that (some) publishers use
Commercial(Order etc)
Price &availability
Product information
Productdescription
ProductIdentification
Books Journals
ISBN ISSN +volume/date [SICI]
ONIX for Books ONIX – SPS
ONIX for Books
ONIX for Books
ICEDIS StandardsEDI (inc EDItX)
ONIX – SPS
ONIX – SPS
Institutionalidentifier
Productdescription
RSS, OAIDisclosure
Standards that (some) publishers use
Access & authorization
ResourceLocation
Resourcedescription
Licenceterms
Usage
ResourceIdentification
Books Journals
ISBN/DOI DOI
COUNTER? COUNTER
ISBN/DOI/URL
ONIX-PL
ONIX SRN [article or issue]
DOI/URL
ONIX-PL
ICEDIS proposal?Open URL
???
ONIX for Books
Institutionalidentifier
Standards that (some) libraries use
Acquisition
Cataloguing
ISBN, ISSN + volume/date [SICI]
Commercial(Order etc)
Price &availability
Product information
ProductIdentification
ONIX for Books, ONIX – SPS
ONIX for Books, ONIX – SPS
EDI (inc EDItX), ICEDIS Standards
Productdescription MARC
ResourceLocation
Resourcedescription
ResourceIdentification
ISBN/ISSN/DOI
DOI/URL
MARC
Resource MgmtResource
description
Licenceterms
ODRL/MPEG-21??
DLF ERMI
Standards that (some) libraries use
Search
Access Mngmt
Disclosure Productdescription
RSS, OAI
Access & authorization
ATHENS, Shibboleth (SAML)OpenURL (appropriate copy)
Productdescription
ResourceLocation
Resourcedescription
Z39.50 (Bath Profile), SRW/U, OpenSearch
Some complicating factors
Content hosting/access management intermediaries Require information from publisher fulfilment systems
Appropriate copy OpenURL ONIX-SOH [“populating resolution servers”]
Different standards used by publishers and libraries eg ONIX/MARC
Preservation A topic on which data sharing issues seem to have been
little explored
Where some gaps may be(courtesy Ted Koppel, Ex Libris) Publisher to Library
usage statistics (already beginning through the nascent SUSHI project) downtime (and uptime) alerts for automated processing by ERM, Link Resolvers, etc. suspected breach communications to Library interaction with library financial systems on pay-per-use titles non-e-journal and non-e-book identification and electronic delivery (for instance,
patents, technical reports, digital objects) license expression delivery and receipt (format already being discussed, but not
functional exchange rules or mode of exchange) Library to Publisher
IP address change automated notification to publisher Customer incident reporting to publisher when resource misbehaves License expression delivery/receipt with library-based changes (versioning)
In general standard format for sharing acquisitions data between libraries (EDI is not adequate) globally unique identifiers for libraries down to the branch or sub-library level (the SAN
is excellent, but limited to North America) globally unique identifiers for collections/databases/aggregations, etc.
An introduction:PALS “Metadata Sharing” issues:the metadata interface between publishers and libraries: some thoughts from the chairThanks a lot