developing an agile organization increasing delivery and ... · bank rt. slovakia 1991 —tatra...
TRANSCRIPT
Global Back Office & Operational Efficiency Summit
Frankfurt, 17th November
Gert HebenstreitCFO & COO
Developing an Agile Organization Increasing Delivery and Process Performance
Countries
Hungary
1987 — Raiffeisen Bank Rt.
Slovakia
1991 — Tatra banka, a.s.
Czech Republic
1993 — Raiffeisenbank a.s.
Bulgaria
1994 —Raiffeisenbank (Bulgaria) E.A.D
Albania
2004 — Raiffeisen Bank Sh.a.
Ukraine
2005 — JSPP Aval
Poland
1991 — Raiffeisen Bank Polska S. A.2012 — Polbank EFG S.A
Kosovo2002 — Raiffeisen Bank Kosovo J. S.C.
Belarus
2003 — Priorbank, JSC
Russia1996 — AO «Raiffeisenbank»
Romania
1998 — Raiffeisen Bank S. A.
Serbia and Montenegro 2001 —Raiffeisenbank a.d.
Bosnia and Herzegowina2000 — Raiffeisen Bank d.d. Bosnai Hercegovina
Croatia
1995 —Raiffeisen-bank Austria d.d.
RBI is an important player in 15 of Central and Eastern Europe
Austria
2005 — RBI listed
2
Raiffeisenbank International Footprint
01.COMPANY BACKGROUND
Clients
HighlightsBusiness units Employees
~ 14 mio ~ 2 850 ~ 54 000
Austria
3
A leading universal bank in Central and Eastern Europe
01.COMPANY BACKGROUND
4
Raiffeisenbank Russia - Key Facts
01.COMPANY BACKGROUND
Key Data:
Branches: 179
Customers: 1.6 Million
Employees: 7600 FTE
Cities: 44
Russia
Austria
Ukraine
Belarus
Poland
Romania
10.000km
600km
5.600km
6m Results
NPAT: 200 MEUR
CIR: 35.8 %
ROE: >31.0 %
ROA: 1st
Operational and Delivery
Excellence
5
Achieving Operational and Delivery Excellence
OVERVIEW OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE
Key areas of attention
Lean BPMSRob-
otics
Agile
Org.Scrum Other
Toolset
6
Achieving Operational and Delivery Excellence – Toolset
OVERVIEW OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
Lean Management
ONYX
(security
check)
SME
Application Cash Mgt
review
ONYX
(security
check)
Fraud
prevention
check
SSC
Merchant
registration
POS
install
FO
Sales
request
FO
Sales
request
FO
Sales
SSC
request
SME
Application Call center
Consult +
lead to SSC
SSC
Checklist & Match check
+
Merchant registration
POS
install
FO
Sales
SSC
request
TO BE
AS IS
(for standart customer)
4. Changes and SLA and IT
configuration to reduce
process waiting times
6. Create an antifraud checklist based on scoring model and
move Match check to SSC. ‘Grey’ decision zone will trigger
Antifraud check
7. Reduce tariff and fee variations for SME clients and move
them to single platform
1. Standard process for client enrollment
through website, call-center and Elbrus
2. Merge client application and offer
acceptance into one document
1 2 3 3 34 5
1
2
3 4
5
Process
Waiting time
Process Time
to Yes77h
Examples of key changes
22h 80h 24h
8
Acquiring E2E origination for SME - Results snapshot
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
Other Bank Raiffeisenbank
9
Lean Cash SettelmentLayout and money flow generate additional work in the process
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
30 min observation
Printer
Printer
Vacuum Machines
Principal Teller
Senior Teller
Teller Teller Teller Teller
Teller Teller
With average human speed 5 km/h it is equal to 4 kilometers 10
Current layout generates a lot of motion waste in the process
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
10
Current layout generates a lot of motion waste in the process
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
Process redesign conception:
Built an “assembly line” and establish team
responsibility instead of individual
accountability
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
11
The wish to explore and improve
02. LEAN MANAGEMENT
Improve efficiency by 20+%
Results
Implement Process Transparency and
Measurement
Improve employee satisfaction
Enhance customer value proposition
Improve customer satisfaction
11
The wish to explore and improve
Lean BPMSRob-
otics
Agile
Org.Scrum Other
Toolset
12
Achieving Operational and Delivery Excellence
Data collection Dashboard design Manage process
variation
Process review
meetings
WH
Y D
O W
E
NE
ED
IT
?
Agreement on
regular data extract
in defined format
Set of data
collected
WH
AT
IS
TH
E
OU
TP
UT
?
Standard charts
Charts organized in
dashboards
Describe and
display variation:
data for Period of
Time, Over Time
Launch process
management
discussions between
process leader and
P&L owner –
business review
Agenda, schedule
meeting
Business review
meetings
Establish real
process
performance review
culture - Live
process reviews
Agenda, schedule
meeting
To create strong and transparency process leadership and improve key processes we need to review, control and manage
them. The Process review is a platform for process performance discussion between process leader and main process
stakeholders.
COUNTRY Level 1 Level 2 - E2E process DATE
PLANNED ACTIVITIES ISSUE LOG ESCALATION OVERALL KPI's
Detail KPI's - go to dashboard
PERFORMANCE REVIEW MEETINGE2E PROCESS LEADER
SUBPROCESSES PROCESS KPI's
TIME TO YES [TTY]
UNIT/COST
Customer complaints
TASK COMPLETED
TIME TO CASH [TTC]
Loan application and data entry
Verification and underwriting
DocumentationContract signing
Disbursment
13
Manage process performance as part of BPMS
03. BPMS
Who is the P&L owner
and the Process leader?
14
Establish process leadership
03. BPMS
15
Who is the process leader and who is P&L owner
03. BPMS
“End-to-End” Process leader
P&L Owner (by product, segment, etc)
Two important roles that should not be combined
but leveraged
Volumes RevenuesCostsCosts Risk Profit
Work-in-Process Finished GoodsRaw materials
16
Process leader is different from P&L owner
03. BPMS
May'2015
PI Lending Origination Process Dashboard
VO
LU
ME
S
Personal Loans Credit Cards
NE
W P
OR
TF
OL
IO
QU
AL
ITY
Highlights
DIS
BU
RS
EM
EN
T
/US
AG
E R
AT
E
RE
TU
RN
RA
TE
TIM
E T
O
CA
SH
AP
PR
OV
AL
RA
TE
TIM
E T
O
YE
S
ER
RO
R R
AT
E
CH
AN
NE
LS
FU
LL
LO
AD
ED
CO
ST
S
UN
IT C
OS
T
2.00%
90%80%90%80%
90%80%90%80%
7100.0%
of the applicationsare approved
of the loans are disbursed within 2 days
45.3%
10,551
11776
581,492,900 RUB
of the decisions are made within 1day
3,973
39.5%of the applicationsare approved
13
3
116.0%budget fulfillment
3,445,856,000 RUB
347,926 RUBaverage loan
97,938 RUB average loan55.8%
budget fulfillment
9863
93.5%of the approvedloans are disbursed
54.1% used out of issued
2798
9
b
0.8%
2-42.3%19.57%
7
5.5% -5.3% -
1.5%
of the decisions are made within 1day
of the loans are disbursed within 2 days
0.8% -
1.3% -
97.1% 96.1%
90.5%
190% 100% 90% 100
48%95%
20% 27%16% 23%
18,054,576,198 RUB outstanding balance
0% 10%
0.80%
93,778,474,367 RUB outstanding balance
0% 5% 0 5
o
0.41%30@3MOB
247.4%0.97%90@6MOB
31.6% 2.90%30@3MOB
82.4%
100.7%4.28%
60@6MOB
1. Budget fulfillment in CC has been decreasedsignificantly in May in comparison with April .2. Return rate in CC has negative dynamic since July' 14 - main reasons: changes in legislation in July and outdated client info in APS for existing clients.3. New process KPI has been added - Return rate combined UW and SC returns3. SLA fulfillment has negative dynamic for CC due to RR for branches and DSAs
1195
24.0% of the applications processed with rework
-0.1%
40
-12.7%
36.1% of the applications processedwith rework
-5.9% 7
94.4%of target 2965 RUB
110.6%
7
0.
of target 3292 RUB-5.1% -
3640
45 40 45
23,279 10065
10549 21758
4972
92.5% 100.0%100.0%100.0%
Channels Call Center
SCHUW
SERVICE LEVEL PL
CapstonePL
99.0%
CRE
98.8%
FPS
99.0%99.0%
Capstone CC
System UP Time
73.0% 100.0%100.0%
Channels SCHUW
SERVICE LEVEL CC
0% 30% 0% 40%
N/A
35%
3464
-11.1%104.7%of target 3308 RUB
131.9%of target 6197 RUB
1.9%
8176
20%16%
852
17.1% of the applications processed with errors
4972
1.6%
20%16%
20.1% of the applications processedwith errors
157 782
-2.0%
0% 30% 0% 30%
SLAs
KPIs
Monthly reporting
Daily control
Link to incentive system
17
Manage process performance – Process review Meeting
03. BPMS
Error Rate
18
Manage process performance – Procurement
03. BPMS
19
You always need a vision how the future can look like
03. BPMS
Lean BPMSRob-
otics
Agile
Org.Scrum Other
Toolset
20
Achieving Operational and Delivery Excellence
21
Reference Model
04. AGILE ORGANIZATION
22
Applying Agile brings four key benefits to the organization
04. AGILE ORGANIZATION
Speed up
delivery
Iterative rapid
change cycle
Cross
Functional
working
Full
accountability
Key Benefits
Reduced time to
market
Increase product
flexibility
Improve team
motivation
Improve
response time
to ops. issues
Plan Analyze Design Build Validate
Everything is an experiment
there is the willingness to fail
and learn
Everything depends on
everyone across silos
Highly collaborative and
transparent
Mix business and technical
knowledge in one team.
Easier to track and trace issues
Tim
e B
ox
ing
SME daily
banking
Accounts, deposits,
cards
TBD
PI Daily banking
CA & SA, Payments, SO
& utility, FX, sms,
Payroll, Captive
TBD
Cards
DC & CC (except
underwriting)
TBD
Lending
CC underwriting, E2E
Unsecured & Mortgage
TBD
Savings,
insurance &
investments
TD, UIF, OPI, insurance
TBD
23
Retail Products tribes & tribe leads – initial proposals
04. AGILE ORGANIZATION
Currently six squads and one tribe are proposed to be subject for pilot in 2 phases
SO & auto-paymentsMortgage lending
Cards
Future Lending tribe Future PI Daily banking tribe
PHASE 1 (09/2016) PHASE 2 (11/2016)
Tribe LeaderCards
Until 08/2017 (Full)
Internet (.ru)Future tribe to be defined
SMSFuture tribe to be defined
BARSFuture tribe to be defined
Payroll origination & maintenanceFuture PI Daily banking tribe
24
Pilot
04. AGILE ORGANIZATION
25
Thank you for your attention