delineation and remediation of wabamun derailment site · ¾local derailment study (delineation...

53
Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site M. Jillian Mitton, P.Eng Brian Pimblett, P.Eng

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site

M. Jillian Mitton, P.Eng

Brian Pimblett, P.Eng

Page 2: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Outline

Initial Remediation Plan

Short Term Monitoring Plan

Soil Excavation

Delineation Plan

VER Design and Installation

VER Performance and Monitoring

Page 3: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Derailment Area - Initial Remediation

712,500 litres of Bucker C and 88,000 litres of Imperial Pole oil were releasedInitial response activities included recovering fluids, cutting and removing cars, repairing track starting August 3, 2005August 5th PTO observed seep from spring near lakeDamaged water well where Bunker C flowed, discovered on August 16th

Page 4: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Stage Excavation Areas

Area I – CN right of way (Bunker C)Area II – Private Property (Bunker C)Area III – PTO (CN Land)Area VI – Beach AreasArea V - Background

Page 5: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Conceptual Spill Model

Page 6: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Derailment Topography

Page 7: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk
Page 8: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk
Page 9: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Excavation

Page 10: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk
Page 11: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

The Fuels and Fingerprinting

Comparison of Bunker C and PTO

Bunker C histogram

PTO histogram

Similar chemical constituents, different fate and transport characteristics, natural sources in the area (coal and peat)

Page 12: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Fuel Characterization Property Bunker C PTO

Density (kg/m3 @ 15 ºC)

986.4 939.6

API Gravity (15.6 ºC)

11.9 19.0

Viscosity (cSt @ 20 º C)

6756 5.411

Description Aliphatic, olefinic, naphtenic and

aromatic hydrocarbon

Aliphatic and aromatic

hydrocarbons (diesel like fuel)

Page 13: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Pre-Excavation Activities

Health and SafetyUtility Clearance and ManagementLegal SurveyRemoval of Vegetation and Infrastructure

Page 14: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil ExcavationBunker C oil recovery using vacuum trucks from rail cars, pools of oil within ditches and bell holes.Removal and offsite disposal of impacted soil was stage due to restricted assessAll impacted soil disposed of at Hazco Tower Road Class II Industrial land fill5059 tonnes of PTO impacted soil (11,000 litres of PTO)17,472 tonnes of Bucker C impacted soil (231,000 litres of Bunker C)

Page 15: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Excavation

Page 16: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Excavation

Page 17: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Excavation

Page 18: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Excavation

Page 19: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Excavation

Page 20: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Confirmatory Soil SamplingThe plan required soil sampling every 5 linear metres for every 3 m depthCollected over 500 soil samplesSoil samples were analyzed for BTEX, PHC fractions F1-F4, and PAHsGIS and Information Management were essential for Sampling PlansWinter sampling program conducted for further validationGuidelines were the CCME Soil Quality Guidelines for Residential Land Use

Page 21: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Soil Confirmatory Sampling

Page 22: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Damaged Water Well

Page 23: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Damaged Water Well

Vacuum Truck Removal

Steam Removal

Well Abandonment

Installation of 3 deep Observation Wells

Page 24: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Water Well Remediation

Well Excavation

Casing Removal

Page 25: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Water Well Remediation

Steam Injection and Vacuum Extraction

Page 26: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Water Well Remediation

Well Decommissioning

with Mud Rotary Rig

Page 27: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Initial ContaminantIn addition to topography, underground culverts (wooden), natural spring and wood stave pipe promoted PTO migration

Page 28: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Initial Containment/RecoveryAbsorbent pads and booms initially used

Shallow sump and vacuum truck

Additional Bell Holes and Vacuum Trucks

Temporary Dual Phase Vacuum System, storage tank, oil/water separator, clay/carbon filtration, clean water storage.

Permanent Concrete Vault

Page 29: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Sump

Page 30: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Short Term Monitoring Plan

Page 31: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Short Term Monitoring Plan

Page 32: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Short Term Monitoring Plan and ResultsDeveloped Sampling Categories

Category 1 - Immediate derailment areaCategory 2 - East of derailment Category 3 - Greater Wabamun Lake area

Regional Groundwater StudyLocal Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing CompletedRisk Management Screening of all Water Wells in potential high risk areaLong-Term Plan focused monitoring in the derailment area comprehensive quarterly sampling and limited monthly monitoring for first year

1 -800 Hotline

Page 33: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Drilling Equipment

Drilling equipment selected based on:

• availability

• access restrictions

• depth

• drilling method

Page 34: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Delineation Program

Page 35: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Remaining PTO Subsurface Impact

Page 36: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Pilot Test

Page 37: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Pilot Test Results

Page 38: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Recovery System

20 Recovery Well Network and PTO Recovery SumpBiological Percolating System (BPS)Water Treatment System (clay and carbon)Push PipeLake Discharge BasinElectrical

Page 39: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Permanent PTO Remedial System

Page 40: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Recovery System Installation

Push Pipe

Well networks

Page 41: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Sump

Page 42: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Biological Percolating Filter (Primary Treatment)

Page 43: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Recovery and Water Treatment

Page 44: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Discharge System

Page 45: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Performance

VER recovery system has operated for a total of 5,550 hours. Groundwater recovery rates range from 3 L/min to 13 L/min. Total volume of groundwater recovered and treated during the period is 2,038,000 L.Total volume of PTO recovered in the dissolved phase (i.e., groundwater) is estimated to be 7,950 L. Removal efficiencies are generally greater than 95% BTEX, PHC and PAHs48-h Daphnia magna (LC50) toxicity testing indicate greater than (>) 100 percent (%) survival for the test criteriaCurrent apparent PTO thicknesses in recovery wells range from 0.010 to 0.050 m.

Page 46: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

PTO Recovery

PTO Recovered From PTO (litres)PTO Released During Derailment 88,000Excavated Soil 10,675PTO losses due to Volatilization UnknownPTO commingled with Bunker C UnknownContaminated Fluids from Tanks 28,260Pilot VER System 1,500Full Scale VER System (holding tank) 600Removed from Groundwater Phase 5578Removed from Air Phase 268Total Recovered 46,881Amount Remaining <6,000

Page 47: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Delineation and Remediation ResultsWork completed in this presentation contributed to 5 monitoring/delineation and remediation plans required under an environmental protection orderAll plans were successful prepared and submitted on time under challenging working conditionsAll plans submitted to date have been accepted by the agencies and successfully implemented.

Page 48: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Landscaping

Page 49: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Landscaping

Page 50: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Current Views

Page 51: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Current Views

Page 52: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Current Views

Page 53: Delineation and Remediation of Wabamun Derailment Site · ¾Local Derailment Study (Delineation Plan and Water Well Survey) ¾Extensive Groundwater Quality Testing Completed ¾Risk

Website Links

Alberta Environment - Wabamun Lakehttp://www3.gov.ab.ca/env/water/WabamunLake.html

CN - Wabamun, ABhttp://www.cn.ca/about/community/wabamun/en_wabamun.shtml

Lake Wabamun Residents Committeehttp://www.wabamunresidents.com/index.php