8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

1/9

Documentation of Hadith

Rebuttals to Islamic

Awareness.htm

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

2/9

Al-Sahifah Al-Sahihah

Hammam bin Munabbih (d. 110/719)

A Yemenite follower

Disciple Abu Hurayrah (d. 58/677) trustworthy.

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

3/9

"Abu Hurrayrah told us in the course of

what he related from the Prophet",

138 Hadith 98 Bukhari and Muslim

136 Ahmad ibn Hanbal

Witness: the preservation of hadith andthat earlier works were faithfully rendered

in later documents

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

4/9

Marston Speight

Sahifa 1500 variant readings

of the same ahadith

found in the:

MusnadAhmad

Sahih al-Bukhari

Sahih Muslim

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

5/9

Outcome of the Comparison

... the texts in Hammam and those recorded in IbnHanbal, Bukhari and Muslim with the same isnad showalmost complete identity, except for a few omissions andinterpolations which do not affect the sense of the

reports. On the other hand, the same ahadith as told byother transmitters in the three collections studied show arich variety of wording, again without changing themeaning of the reports

... I have found practically no sign of careless ordeceptive practices in the variant texts common to theSahifa of Hammam bin Munabbih.

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

6/9

Razzaq-Abd al`annaf ofsThe Mu

ani`

anS-al

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

7/9

Harald Motzki

While studying the MusannafofAbd al-Razzaq,I came to the conclusion that the theory

championed by Goldziher, Schacht, and in theirfootsteps, many others - myself included - whichin general, reject hadith literature as ahistorically reliable sources for the first century

AH, deprives the historical study of early Islam ofan important and a useful type of source.

Journal of Near Eastern Studies

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

8/9

Terms of theCollections

Types of theCollections

ProvinceName

FiqhMeccaAbd al-Malik ibn Abd al-Azizibn Juraij (d. 150H)

MaghaziMuhammad ibn Ishaq (d. 151H)

MaghaziMa`mar ibn Rshid (96-153H)

FiqhMesopotamiaSa`d ibn Aruba (d.157/774)

FiqhSyriaAl-Awza`i (d.159/775)

FiqhMadinahMuhammad ibn Abd al-Rahman(d.159/775)

FiqhKufahZaida ibn Qudama (d.16o/776)

FiqhKufahSufyan al-Thawri (d.161/777)

FiqhBasrahHammad ibn Salama (d.165/781)

Sufyan ibn `Uyaynah (107-198)

MuwattaFiqhMadinahMalik ibn Anas (d.179/795)

8/6/2019 CUHS1 Hadith Documentation Same

9/9

adith collectionshSome important

from second century of hijrah The Muwatta' of Malik bin Anas: Malik bin

Anas (d. 179/795) was the founder of Malikischool of jurisprudence. The Muwatta' of Malikwas compiled in mid-second century AH. It is nota corpus of hadith in a true sense but acollection of practices of people of Madinah.

Musannaf of Ibn Jurayj (d. 150 AH)

Musannaf of Ma`mar bin Rashid (d. 153 AH) For Detail : My Islam Web (Why Sahih Bukhari is

Sahih)