crm vs cem

12
Article 1 CEM vs CRM-What is the Fuss all About? Richard Snow, NACC Advisory Board Member and VP and Research Director for Contact Centers Ventana Research [email protected] In a world where three letter acronyms proliferate, is the emerge nce of CEM just another marketing ploy invented by vendors keen to sell products in highly competitive markets or is it something businesses should sit up and take note of. CRM – customer relationship management – has been around for several years now and is associated with anything from creating a customer database to driving marketing and sales initiatives to full blown CRM application suites from vendors such as Oracle and SAP that promise to take care of managing every aspect of “managing customer relationships.” CEM – customer experience management – appears on the surface to be very similar in that it promises to improve the customer experience at every touch point and thereby keep customers more loyal. Therein lies the issue, both are striving to achieve the same end result – more loyal customers – so many would say they are one and the same thing. The very phrase customer relationship management suggests that organizations should spend their dollars managing relationships. But how do you “manage a relationship?” Or even more fundamentally “can an organization and a customer have a relationship?” Relationships tend to be one-on-one and rely on a continuous dialogue between the individuals, something which is very hard for organizations to have. So at the heart of CRM was the concept of “markets of one” where organizations attempt to personalize every interaction with a customer, a great idea but something very hard to achieve in today’s mass market place that is more and more influenced by trading on the Web. Three things get in the way of achieving this ideal: 1. customers interact with many different business units within an organization and more often than not these don’t share processes 2. in the same way different business units, including the contact center, have different systems managing customer data, and our re search shows that less than half of organizations make any attempt to synchronizes these different sources 3. customers interact through many different channels of communication and again there isn’t very much consistency across different channels, with the Web often being the channel most out-of-line. This is where CEM comes into play. Ventana Research defines CEM as the set of activities and processes required to ensure consistency between all interactions with a customer, to the maximum benefit of the customer and the organization. It relies on organizations creating and maintaining a single source of the truth for customer data that is kept up- to-date and consistent across all systems, especially those used to support different channels of communication. It relies on companies creating a single, 360-degree view of customers that reflects all interactions and business transactions, across the entire lifetime of the customer. It requires organizations to review their processes across the entire organization and ensure these are consistent across different business units, in turn making sure, for example, that if a customer responds to a market campaign, this is reflected in any sales transactions, which in turn are carried through into invoicing, which are also reflected in calls to the contact center and field service visits; and most importantly making each interaction consistent with the 360-degree view. All of which means companies need to take a hard look at what and how customer information is provided to employees interacting with a customer and how each interaction can be supported in different ways depending on the particular customer. So CEM is more pragmatic than CRM, with lower ideals that don’t presume any relationship

Upload: nehal10

Post on 10-Apr-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 1/12

Page 2: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 2/12

Page 3: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 3/12

Page 4: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 4/12

Page 5: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 5/12

Page 6: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 6/12

Page 7: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 7/12

to its automated prompting and prodding, but it doesn't give much insight when customers donot respond in the predicted way. CRM is thus unable to determine whether failures are theresult of faulty assumptions, incorrect information or poor execution. It is also unable to tellhow these "failed" interactions affect the customer relationship; it treats all failures as neutral,when in fact the fabric of the relationship may have been weakened or undermined by a

poorly executed service encounter.

CEM's strengths lie in precisely the areas where CRM is weak. By focusing on theexperiences of customers and how those experiences affect behavior, CEM examines both thequality of the company's execution and the efficacy of the result. It aligns customer needswith the company's ability to fulfill those needs, leading to business relationships that aremutually beneficial and that both parties - company and customer - are motivated to improve.

So what does CEM look like? At its most basic, a Customer Experience Management systemcaptures information about individual service events and feeds it back to the organization.The information can be gathered from customers who provide their impressions of recentservice experiences, as well as from objective observers who record specific details aboutservice execution (such as mystery shoppers and call monitoring agents). More sophisticatedsystems integrate data from both sources so that company standards and execution can becontinually calibrated with customer expectations and impressions. Unlike traditional marketresearch reporting, which is delivered weeks after the data are collected, CEM systems feed

back information within days or hours of the service event, allowing employees andmanagers to make small, effective adjustments on an on-going basis.

Capturing and integrating data about service execution and customer impressions isimportant, but it is only the first step. These data need to looped back to training andcoaching content so that knowledge and performance deficiencies among employees aredirectly and continually addressed. Furthermore, CEM programs may extend the linkage toemployee and manager incentives. Thus, front-line employees and supervisors continuallyreceive feedback, training and rewards linked to their day-to-day interactions with customers.

Finally, a comprehensive CEM program also incorporates key metrics related to customer behavior and profitability, such as retention rates, average purchase amounts, store sales,complaint and resolution rates, etc. The strength of a CEM system is in its ability tocontinually align company performance with customer needs and behaviors, enablingcompanies to make small, day-to-day adjustments as well as enterprise-wide changes.

Peter Gurney is the Managing Director of Kinesis . Peter Gurney can be reached by calling206-285-2900.

Page 8: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 8/12

Article 4Customer Experience Management

By

Prakash Chandra DashSenior Lecturer

Bhubaneswar Institute of Management and Information TechnologyBhubaneswar

If you do build a great experience, customers tell each other about that. Word of mouthis very powerful.

- Jeff Bezos –

Abstract

The customer experience is central to the corporate goals. Delivering a relevant, personalised, and consistent customer experience can, for instance, improve customer satisfaction, across every customer touch-point. Accelerating the delivery of new brands,messages, and promotions to customers enhances market agility. In addition to these,delivering a consistent customer experience across world markets and languages isessential for building a strong global brand.

However, the truth remains that an optimal customer experience is easier to describethan to deliver. This paper discusses the importance of superior customer experience,opportunities to explore and developing a customer experience strategy to win over thecustomer.

Introduction

When a customer is participating in KBC-2, through Airtel, he can vouch for hisexperience from being a customer of Airtel. Watching world cup grand final with HritikRoshan, gives a better experience of the world cup. So customer experience is the talkof the day. Customer experience can be drawn through expertise and providing bettervalue to the customer. So customer value plays a critical role in shaping the customerexperience. In this regard, significant steps have been taken by companies in their

endeavor to enhance customer value. This has resulted in tumultuous events wheremarket leaders have suddenly found themselves virtually out of business or strugglingfor survival. Today new value creators have been reeling the roost in various sectors. Forexample, the entertainment industry has seen single screen theatres that did roaringbusiness once are now on the brink of shutting down, owing to the enhanced customervalue being offered by multiplexes dotting India's urban landscape. So better customervalue leads to better customer experience. The customer value includes product value,service value, personnel value and image value. The gap between perceived value andreal value can be minimized through the better customer value.

Experience matters

To define more clearly, managing customer experience at every opportunities to buildbrand equity of the service,which leads to sustainable profitability for the organization iscustomer experience management (CEM).however we must keep in mind that CEM is not

Page 9: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 9/12

customer relationship management(CRM).The latter in practice is an information drivenapproach to customer analysis and process automation. CEM focuses on delightingcustomers at every opportunity and during all interactions,which is online real time andtough. CEM focuses on the value proposition from customer's point of view and includesall interactions at various touch points.

Many customers are actually looking for a pleasant experience with the organization atevery touch point at every moment of truth(interaction).Whether a customer is a user of a mobile phone ,hotel service,banking,airline or travel service ,all that , he or she looksfor ,is a memorable experience .Since every interaction is unique and important,thecustomer looks for personalized attention and service in each one of them. Even if oneexperience wasn't upto his expectation,it puts him or her down and affects the image of organization. Hence ,CEM isn't about providing 90 percent and above good service,experience to customers, and feeling good about it .But, it is about ensuring a six sigmakind of service to customers, to build a good service image among customers and scorehigh on customers experience .

CRM vs. CEM

What When How monitored Who uses theinformation

Relevance to futureperform

CustomerExperienceManagement(CEM)

Captures anddistributes what acustomer thinksabout a company

At points of customerinteraction "touchpoints"

Surveys, targetedstudies,observationalstudies, "vice of customer"research

Business or function alleaders, in order tocreate fulfillableexpectation andbetter experience withproducts and services

Leading locatesplaces to addoffering in the gapsbetweenexpectations & experience

CustomerRelationshipManagement(CRM)

Captures anddistributes what acompany knowsabout a customer

After there is arecord of acustomerinteraction

Point-of-salesdata, moarketresearch, websiteclick-through,automatedtracking of sales

Customer-facinggroups such as sales,marketing, fieldservices and customerservice, in order todrive more efficientand effectiveexecution

Logging Drivescross selling bybundling productsin demand withones that aren't

The Importance of Superior Customer Experience

In product marketing, typically 30% of an organisation's resources and spent onproviding a good customer experience and 70% goes into marketing the sameinnovatively. The entire focus is on marketing, to dominate the customers' mind space.However, in services marketing, 70% of a company's resources need to go into creatinga great customer experience and the balance should be spent on "marketing thesuperior experience delivered "among prospects. Once the companies focus is oncreating good customer experience, it automatically generates strong referrals, and word

of mouth complements the 30% spent on marketing the service. Several studies haveshown that repeat purchases have mostly been based on quality of service delivered,commitments honored, product/service quality, continuous innovations and theexperience with the product/service. The focus is less, and less on price. Customersvalue and remember the quality of their interactions with the service providers .The ruleis: higher the quality, higher the positive word of mouth and loyalty from thecustomers .In a survey by CRM Guru, positive and memorable experiences withorganizations were found to be the key reason for profit growth.32% of happy customerssaid they recommended their service provider to a friend or colleague, and 19% saidthey purchased more products and services from same service provider. The bad newsis, negative experiences lead to customer defections and reduced spending on theservice .In the same survey, it was found that while 77% attached importance to

superior product or service by customers to be loyal with the organization,78% attachedimportance to high quality interactions with people and systems to be loyal. only 31%linked importance to lowest price or cost of ownership of the service, clearly outlining

Page 10: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 10/12

the importance of managing the customer experience better .Lastly,the survey alsooutlined how business performance improves with the improvement in customerexperience. Higher the customer experience score, higher the business performancegrowth and vice versa. In India leading companies like Taj Hotels, Airtel,Hutch,JetAirways,Kingfishers Airlines,ICICI Bank have all succeeded due to their focus onmanaging the customer experience well with their services and products consistently.Though, they haven't reached the six sigma levels in delivering defect free customerexperience.

Opportunities and challenges

However, along with this tremendous growth comes the challenge to the service industryto live upto the growing demands of customers, who are continuously benchmarking oneexperience with another and expecting improved services in every area. Their alsobecoming list tolerant to delays and failures in service, and expect every service providerto deliver world class experience in every interaction. This growing demand for serviceexcellence also gives an opportunity to every service provider to emerge as leaders intheir chosen field .To date, few companies have optimised this entire create-to-publishcustomer experience process. The lack of an enterprise-wide strategic approachundermines the very objectives that executives are seeking to achieve, resulting in someimportant issues or shortcomings. The first of these being decreased customersatisfaction. Inaccurate, out-of-date, or incomplete customer information preventspeople from understanding companies and their products, and can drive customersaway. The second issue is sluggish market execution. Labour-intensive manualprocesses require months-long lead times to roll out brand changes, new products, andnew campaigns, delaying launches and weakening competitive advantage. The next inthe line is brand dilution. Without the capability for centralised control, brands andmessages become distorted as they are altered for the requirements of different touch-points and diverse global markets. At the same time, another penalty is incurred,because customer experience inefficiencies increase the cost of each customerinteraction. This can damage the bottom line.

Developing a Customer Experience Strategy

To develop a customer experience strategy, we must first find out what the customersreally want from the service during their interactions with the service provider? It iscalled "customer specifications for service" on the service expected. But in ourenthusiasm ,"we should not over specify''.Most customers look for a pleasant experience(quick service with minimum hassles or procedures) with the service providers and not a"wow" experience every time. Understanding this thin difference is critical in order toavoid over specifying and incurring high cost to provide "unnecessary"experience tocustomers.

One of the telecom service providers has provided in their showrooms several mobilerelated services including one of customers taking their photographs instantly anddownloading in their mobile phones and printing them. Though there are alwayscustomers waiting for their turn at the showrooms to meet the customer relationshipexecutives, rarely do any of them use the service, since all that they are looking for at amobile showroom is quick connection or quick resolution to their problems. They have notime to spend on all these "over specified" services. Though these over specified servicesimprove the ambience of the showroom, they don't service the real purpose thecustomers are looking for, from these facilities.

It is a good idea to map the customer expectations with service provider at all the touchpoints through one-on-one interviews. These interviews will enable companies tounderstand "what is really important from the customers' point of view" and what to

Page 11: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 11/12

Page 12: crm vs cem

8/8/2019 crm vs cem

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/crm-vs-cem 12/12

all geographies, and throughout all stages of the customer lifecycle, from attractingcustomers through fulfilment to retention

Reference

Books

• CRM at the Speed of Light. Joseph Pine & James Gilmore• Mariton, John. Smart Things to Know about Brands and Branding .Mumbai, Indian

Books Distributors Limited, 2000.

Electronic Resources

• The Economic Times Knowledge Series .Times Multimedia,2001(CD-ROM)• "ET in The Classroom", Times Multimedia ,2003(CD-ROM)

Internet Resources

• www.economictimes .com• www.marketingprofs.com• www.businessstandard.com• www.netmba.com• www.hbr.edu

Prakash Chandra DashSenior Lecturer

Bhubaneswar Institute of Management and Information TechnologyBhubaneswar

Source: E-mail October 21, 2008

Articles No. 1-99 / Articles No. 100-199 / Articles No. 200-299 / Articles No. 300-399Articles No. 400-499 / Articles No. 500-599 / Articles No. 600-699 / Articles No. 700-799

Back to Articles 800 Onward / Faculty Column Main Page