convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/b/solar/newtalk.pdfr.d. simitev...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
R.D. Simitev
School of Mathematics & Statistics
F.H. Busse Institute of Physics
Convection-driven spherical dynamos:
bistability and
attempts to model the Solar cycle
![Page 2: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Convective spherical shell dynamos
Basic state & scaling
Length scale:
Time scale:
Temp. scale:
Magn. flux density:
Model equations & parameters
Boundary Conditions
Boussinesq approximation
Si m
ite v & B
uss e, J F
M ,2 0
04
![Page 3: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Numerical Methods
Toroidal-poloidal representation
Spectral decomposition in spherical harmonics and Chebyshev polynomials
Scalar equations
Pseudo-spectral method. Time-stepping: Crank-Nicolson & Adams-Bashforth
Resolution: radial=41, latitudinal=193, azimuthal=96.
Linear problem: Galerkin spectral method for the linearised equations leadingto an eigenvalue problem for the critical parameters.
3D non-linear problem:
Tilg
ner, IJNM
F, 1999
![Page 4: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Part 1.
Bistability and hysteresis of non-linear dynamos
References:
● Simitev, R., Busse F.H., Bistability and hysteresis of dipolar dynamos generated by turbulent convection in rotating spherical shells, EPL, 85, 19001,2009
● Simitev, R., Busse F.H., Bistable attractors in a model of convection-driven spherical dynamos, Physica Scripta (submitted 1 Dec 2011).
![Page 5: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Two types of dipolar dynamosgenerated by chaotic convection
Energy densities
● Fully chaotic (large-scale turbulent) regime. ● Two chaotic attractors for the same parameter values.
● Essential qualitative difference: contribution of the mean poloidal dipolar energy
black.......mean poloidalgreen......fluctuating poloidalred..........mean toroidalblue.........fluctuating toroidal
(ab) (de)Rm 133.6 196.5
Mdip/Mtot 0.803 0.527
![Page 6: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Regions and transition
Two types of dipolar dynamosRatio of fluctuating to mean poloidal magn energy
Mean Dipolar (MD)
Fluctuating Dipolar (FD)
● MD and FD dynamos correspond to rather different chaotic attractors in a fully chaotioc system
● The transition between them is not gradual but is an abrupt jump as a critical parameter value is surpassed.
● The nature of the transition is complicated.
MD FDMdip/Mtot (0.62,1) (0.41,56)
![Page 7: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Bistability and hysteresis in the MD <~> FD transition
Bistability and hysteresis in the ratio of fluctuating poloidal to mean poloidal magn energy
(a)
(b)
(c)
in all cases:
The coexistence is not an isolated phenomenon but can be traced with variation of the parameters.
PMD= 2.2 PFD = 0.5σMD = 0.07 σFD = 1
Mean Dipolar (MD)Fluctuating Dipolar (FD)
![Page 8: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Bistability and hysteresis as a function of the rotation parameter
The coexistence is not an isolated phenomenon but can be traced with variation of the parameters.
PMD= 2.2 PFD = 0.5σMD = 0.07 σFD = 1
Mean Dipolar (MD)
Fluctuating Dipolar (FD)
black.......mean poloidalgreen......fluctuating poloidalred..........mean toroidalblue.........fluctuating toroidal
(a) ratio of fluctuating poloidal to mean poloidal magn energy
(b) ratio of kin energy components of FD to MD dynamos:
![Page 9: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Comparison of coexisting dynamos – magnetic features
● Mean Dipolar (MD) dynamos are non-oscillatory.
● Fluctuating Dipolar (FD) dynamos are oscillatory.
![Page 10: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Comparison of coexisting dynamos – convective features
( )
● The stronger magnetic field of MD dynamos counteracts differential rotation
![Page 11: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
The hysteresis is a purely magnetic effect
Magnetic field is artificially suppressed, i.e. non-magnetic convection
● After magnetic field is suppressed both MD and FD dynamos equilibrate to statistically
identical convective states (period of relaxation oscillations, clockwise)
![Page 12: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Basins of attraction – Random initial conditions
● From small random initial seed the Fluctuating Dipolar state is approached.
● This, however means only that a the existence of a third attractor is unlikely.
black.......mean poloidalgreen......fluctuating poloidalred..........mean toroidalblue.........fluctuating toroidal
![Page 13: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Basins of attraction – Controlled initial conditions
Mean Dipolar (MD)Fluctuating Dipolar (FD)
● Initial conditions – taken as a linear combination of MD and FD dynamos
with a continuation parameter :
![Page 14: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Part 2. Minimal models of the solar cycle
● Simitev, R., Busse F.H., Solar cycle properties described by simple convection-driven dynamos, Physica Scripta (accepted 13 Jan 2012).
● Simitev, R., Busse F.H., How far can minimal models explain the solar cycle?, Astrophys. J. (submitted 13 Jan 2012).
![Page 15: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Dependence on the shell thickness
0.35
0.5
0.6
Motivation: Goudard & Dormy, (EPL 2010)no
-slip
bou
ndar
y co
nditi
ons
Black – mean poloidal, Red – mean toroidal, Green – fluct poloidal, Blue – fluct toroidalSolid – magnetic energy components; Empty – knietic energy components
black.......mean poloidalgreen......fluctuating poloidalred..........mean toroidalblue.........fluctuating toroidal
![Page 16: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Transition to fluctuating dynamos in thin shells
Crucial assumption:
●Stress free at outer boundary●No-slip at inner boundary
black.......mean poloidalgreen......fluctuating poloidalred..........mean toroidalblue.........fluctuating toroidal
![Page 17: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Regular dipolar oscillations in thin shells
No-slip at inner boundary, stress free at outer boundary
![Page 18: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Butterfly diagram
No-slip at inner boundary, stress free at outer boundary
Hathaway, D.H., et al, 2003, Astrophys. J., 589, 665-670
● Not realistic – propagation if structures is in the opposite direction
![Page 19: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Thin-shell dynamos in the parameter space
Decay
MD
FD
quadrupolar
coexisting
![Page 20: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Bistability of dynamo solutionsN
o-sl
ip a
t in
ner
boun
dary
, st
ress
fre
e at
out
er b
ound
ary
![Page 21: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
m=1 azimuthal structure
The m=1 structure
● resembles the phenomenon of Active Longitudes
(Usoskin et al, Adv Space Res, 2007).
● suggests that the solar field might not be azimuthally symmetric as often assumed.
![Page 22: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
m=1 azimuthal structure – butterfly diagrams
● Still unrealistic - no drift towards equatorial region
![Page 23: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Radial profiles of the differential rotation
Internal Rotation of the Sun as found by helioseismology, NSF's National Solar Observatory No-slip at inner boundary,
stress free at outer boundary
/R
● Unrealistic drift is due to the increasing profile of the differential rotation (Yoshimura, ApJ, 1975)
![Page 24: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
A modified boundary condition
● Along with solar observations, a recent analytical analysis of a simplified model problem (Busse, Solar Physics 2007) indicates that a suitable way to reproduce the decrease of differential rotation with radius near the surface is to employ the following boundary condition
Beta is a fitting parameter.
![Page 25: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Radial profiles of the differential rotation
Internal Rotation of the Sun as found by helioseismology, NSF's National Solar Observatory
No-slip at inner boundary, stress free at outer boundary
● Profile is still unrealistic but decreasing near the surface.
![Page 26: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Regularly oscillating dipoles with
After systematic variation of parameter valuescases with regular oscillations have been found.
Fairly regular dipolar oscillations
Black – mean poloidal, Red – mean toroidal, Green – fluct poloidal, Blue – fluct toroidal
![Page 27: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Sunspot drift in dipoles with
Diff rot decreases near surface
Active longitudes – m=1 structure
![Page 28: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Sunspot drift in dipoles with
Maxima of Bphi propagate from higher latitudestowards the equator
![Page 29: Convection-driven spherical dynamos: bistability and ...rs/res/B/Solar/NewTalk.pdfR.D. Simitev School of Mathematics & Statistics F.H. Busse Institute of Physics Convection-driven](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022041215/5e03b0022c57a0621224f034/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Conclusion
● Two types of dipolar dynamos can be distinguished:
*) Mean dipolar dynamos (MD)
*) Fluctuating dipolar dynamos (FD)
● MD and FD dynamos have rather different properties.
● FD dynamos are normally oscillatory. In some cases this may lead to reversals.
● The transition between MD and FD dynamos is hysteretic.
● Most geodynamo simulations have typical parameters values P in [0.5, 2], Pm in [0.5, 10] and R < 10 Rc which are within the observed hysteresis region.
Thank you!
Part A
● Bistability seems to occur in a certain region as a function of all parameters.
● Many published dynamo simulations are within the region of bistability – special care is needed.
Part B
● The large scale Solar dynamo might be dominated by a non-axisymmetric m=1 component of the magnetic field.
● Periodically reversing FD dynamos in thin shells with an equator-ward drift of magnetic structures may be a good minimal model of the solar cycle.