contamination of µcmm stylus tips: on-machine inspection · •mitutoyo cmm euro-c-a121210...

1
Abstract: Contamination adhered to the surface of a μCMM stylus tip significantly impairs the dimensional accuracy of a μCMM system. Regular cleaning of the stylus is essential to minimising the dimensional error but little data exists for determining appropriate cleaning intervals. This study investigates the build-up of contamination on the μCMM stylus tip during probing procedures. Experiments were conducted on surfaces with controlled contamination for 18 different conditions to study the impact of surface morphology and contact pressure. Contamination rate was observed to vary significantly, suggesting a probabilistic mechanism for contamination adhesion. As such, predictive methods may not offer a reliable threshold for determining cleaning intervals. To that end, a technique for on-machine imaging has been proposed to work in-line with the μCMM and inspect surface contamination as it builds. Debris of less than 300 nm in size was detectable. Contamination of μCMM stylus tips: on-machine inspection Manufacturing Metrology Team Advanced Manufacturing Research Group european society for precision engineering & nanotechnology Xiaobing Feng, Cyril Lacorne, Gustavo Q Fernandes, Simon Lawes, Peter Kinnell Sample preparation The samples involved in the study were precision surface references (Rubert & Co, Microsurf) representing surfaces made with various machining processes and calibrated surface roughness. To reproduce consistence amount of contamination, each sample has undergone the following steps: 1. cleaned with isopropanol in an ultrasonic bath for 5 minutes; 2. immersed in used cutting fluid for 5 minutes; 3. left to dry in the air for 5 minutes, 4. cleaned again with isopropanol in an ultrasonic bath for 5 minutes. Experiment setup Equipment: Mitutoyo CMM Euro-C-A121210 Renishaw probe head PH10M Renishaw modules TP200SF/LF Renishaw styli, ruby sphere Experiments: Set 1: low contact pressure Set 2: high contact pressure Contamination detection: Hitachi H-2600N ESEM Contamination rate Progression of contamination Contamination was observed to build up over multiple contacts of the same location, plateauing after 3-5 contacts Statistic influence of machining process & surface roughness Large variance between & within experimental conditions. Stochastic nature in debris adhesion. Variance in build-up rate more strongly affected than average rate. Higher contact pressure correlated with higher contamination rate. Sometimes 5% of stylus tip was contaminated after only 50 contacts. Table 1. List of variables involved in the study. (a) (b) Fig 2. SEM images of ground finish (a) after step 2, (b) after step 4 and milled finish (c) after step 2, (d) after step 4. Fig 3. Probing setup in (a) experiment set 1 with parallel orientation and (b) set 2 with perpendicular orientation Fig 6. Images of a 0.3 mm diameter stylus tip obtained using (a) proposed solution at 20X, (b) SEM and (c) confocal microscope at 50X. Fig 4. Stylus tip of 0.3 mm diameter (a) before probing, (b) after 3rd probing round, (c) after 8th probing round and (d) after 1st probing round on a new location. Variables Values Machining process grinding, EDM, milling Surface roughness/μm 0.4, 0.8, 1.6, 3.2 Stylus tip diameter/mm 0.3, 1.0 Contact pressure level low, high Fig1. EDM samples with calibrated surface roughness values. (a) (b) (c) (d) (a) (b) (a) (b) (c) (d) (a) (b) (c) Fig 5. Stylus contamination after probing various samples: each data point representing contamination after 50 contacts On-machine stylus inspection Principle: Epi-illumination microscope Focus stacking algorithm Capability: Imaging of full hemisphere On-machine inspection Resolution on par with SEM and confocal with same field of view Cost effective

Upload: others

Post on 11-Mar-2021

34 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Contamination of µCMM stylus tips: on-machine inspection · •Mitutoyo CMM Euro-C-A121210 •Renishaw probe head PH10M •Renishaw modules TP200SF/LF •Renishaw styli, ruby sphere

Abstract: Contamination adhered to the surface of a µCMM stylus tip significantly impairs the dimensional accuracy of a

µCMM system. Regular cleaning of the stylus is essential to minimising the dimensional error but little data exists fordetermining appropriate cleaning intervals. This study investigates the build-up of contamination on the µCMM stylus tip duringprobing procedures. Experiments were conducted on surfaces with controlled contamination for 18 different conditions to studythe impact of surface morphology and contact pressure. Contamination rate was observed to vary significantly, suggesting aprobabilistic mechanism for contamination adhesion. As such, predictive methods may not offer a reliable threshold fordetermining cleaning intervals. To that end, a technique for on-machine imaging has been proposed to work in-line with theµCMM and inspect surface contamination as it builds. Debris of less than 300 nm in size was detectable.

Contamination of µCMM stylus tips: on-machine inspection

Manufacturing Metrology Team

Advanced Manufacturing Research Group

european society for precision engineering & nanotechnology

Xiaobing Feng, Cyril Lacorne, Gustavo Q Fernandes, Simon Lawes, Peter Kinnell

Sample preparation

The samples involved in the study wereprecision surface references (Rubert &Co, Microsurf) representing surfacesmade with various machining processesand calibrated surface roughness.To reproduce consistence amount ofcontamination, each sample hasundergone the following steps:

1. cleaned with isopropanol in an ultrasonic bath for 5 minutes;

2. immersed in used cutting fluid for 5 minutes;

3. left to dry in the air for 5 minutes,4. cleaned again with isopropanol in

an ultrasonic bath for 5 minutes.

Experiment setup

Equipment:

• Mitutoyo CMM Euro-C-A121210• Renishaw probe head PH10M• Renishaw modules TP200SF/LF• Renishaw styli, ruby sphere

Experiments:

• Set 1: low contact pressure• Set 2: high contact pressure

Contamination detection:

• Hitachi H-2600N ESEM

Contamination rate

Progression of contamination

Contamination was observed to build upover multiple contacts of the samelocation, plateauing after 3-5 contacts

Statistic influence of machiningprocess & surface roughness

• Large variance between & withinexperimental conditions.

• Stochastic nature in debris adhesion.• Variance in build-up rate more

strongly affected than average rate.• Higher contact pressure correlated

with higher contamination rate.• Sometimes 5% of stylus tip was

contaminated after only 50 contacts.

Table 1. List of variables involved in the study.

(a)

(b)

Fig 2. SEM images of ground finish (a) afterstep 2, (b) after step 4 and milled finish (c)after step 2, (d) after step 4.

Fig 3. Probing setup in (a) experiment set 1 withparallel orientation and (b) set 2 withperpendicular orientation

Fig 6. Images of a 0.3 mm diameter stylus tipobtained using (a) proposed solution at 20X, (b)SEM and (c) confocal microscope at 50X.

Fig 4. Stylus tip of 0.3 mm diameter (a)before probing, (b) after 3rd probing round,(c) after 8th probing round and (d) after 1stprobing round on a new location.

Variables ValuesMachining process grinding, EDM, millingSurface roughness/µm 0.4, 0.8, 1.6, 3.2Stylus tip diameter/mm

0.3, 1.0

Contact pressure level low, high

Fig1. EDM samples with calibrated surfaceroughness values.

(a) (b)

(c) (d)

(a) (b)

(a) (b) (c) (d)

(a) (b) (c)

Fig 5. Stylus contamination after probingvarious samples: each data point representingcontamination after 50 contacts

On-machine stylus inspection

Principle:

Epi-illumination microscopeFocus stacking algorithm

Capability:

• Imaging of full hemisphere• On-machine inspection• Resolution on par with SEM and

confocal with same field of view• Cost effective