constantine, divine emperor of the christian golden … · 2015. 8. 8. · 28. ptolemy iii...
TRANSCRIPT
CONSTANTINE, DIVINE EMPEROROF THE CHRISTIAN GOLDEN AGE
S
Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden Age offers a radical reassess-ment of Constantine as an emperor, a pagan, and a Christian. The bookexamines in detail a wide variety of evidence, including literature, secular andreligious architectural monuments, coins, sculpture, and other works of art.Setting the emperor in the context of the kings and emperors who precededhim, Jonathan Bardill shows how Constantine’s propagandists exploited thetraditional themes and imagery of rulership to portray him as elected by thesupreme solar God to save his people and inaugurate a brilliant Golden Age.The author argues that the cultivation of this image made it possible for Con-stantine to reconcile the long-standing tradition of imperial divinity with hismonotheistic faith by assimilating himself to Christ.
Jonathan Bardill has held fellowships at Oxford University, Dumbarton Oaks,Newcastle University, and Koc University’s Research Center for AnatolianCivilizations, Istanbul. He has contributed articles to numerous archaeolog-ical and historical journals, including the American Journal of Archaeology, theJournal of Roman Archaeology, and Dumbarton Oaks Papers, as well as severaledited volumes, including Social and Political Life in Late Antiquity and TheOxford Handbook of Byzantine Studies. He is the author of the reference workBrickstamps of Constantinople.
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
CONSTANTINE,DIVINE EMPEROR OF THECHRISTIAN GOLDEN AGE
S
Jonathan Bardill
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
cambridge university pressCambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town,
Singapore, Sao Paulo, Delhi, Tokyo, Mexico City
Cambridge University Press32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, ny 10013-2473, usa
www.cambridge.orgInformation on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521764230
C© Jonathan Bardill 2012
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exceptionand to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,no reproduction of any part may take place without the written
permission of Cambridge University Press.
First published 2012
Printed in the United States of America
A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication data
Bardill, Jonathan.Constantine, divine emperor of the Christian golden age / Jonathan Bardill.
p. cm.Includes bibliographical references and index.
isbn 978-0-521-76423-0 (hardback)1. Constantine I, Emperor of Rome, d. 337. 2. Byzantine Empire – History – To 527.
3. Emperors – Rome – Biography. 4. Rome – History – Constantine I, the Great, 306–337.5. Rome – Kings and rulers – Religious aspects – History. 6. Kings and rulers in literature.
7. Kings and rulers in art. 8. Rome – Antiquities. 9. Christianity – Rome – History.10. Christianity and politics – Rome – History. I. Title.
dg315.b334 2011937′.08092 – dc22
[B] 2010046932
isbn 978-0-521-76423-0 Hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls forexternal or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publication and does not guarantee
that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Publication of this book has been aided by a generous grant from the Vehbi Koc Foundation.
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
For my parents again
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
CONTENTS
S
Illustrations page ixAcknowledgements xixAbbreviations xxiChronology xxvMap of the Roman Empire under the Tetrarchs and Constantine xxviiiThe Families of the Tetrarchs and Constantine xxx
introduction 1
1 a change of image 11
2 emperors and divine protectors 28
3 the saving ruler and the logos-nomos 126
4 the hippodrome procession 151
5 the symbol from the sun, the standard, andthe sarcophagus 159
6 the roman colossus 203
7 constantine and christianity 218
8 sol and christianity 326
9 constantine as christ 338
Epilogue 397Bibliography 401Index 425
vii
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ILLUSTRATIONS
S
1a–d. The First Tetrarchy. (a) Diocletian asAugustus. Obverse of gold coin mintedin Nicomedia. A.D. 295. (b) Maximianas Augustus. Obverse of gold coinminted in Nicomedia. A.D. 294. (c)Galerius as Caesar. Obverse of gold coinminted in Antioch. A.D. 294–295. (d)Constantius Chlorus as Caesar. Obverseof gold medallion minted in Trier. A.D.297. page 12
2. Constantine as Caesar. Obverse of goldcoin minted in Rome. A.D. 307. 13
3. Constantine as Caesar. Obverse of goldcoin minted in Trier. A.D. 306–307. 13
4. Constantine as Augustus. Obverse ofgold solidus minted in Trier. A.D.319–320. 13
5. Constantine wearing plain diadem, hishead turned to heaven. Obverse of goldcoin minted in Ticinum. A.D. 326. 14
6. Constantine wearing diadem decoratedwith small jewels and leaves, his headturned to heaven. Obverse of goldmedallion of 11/2 solidi minted in Siscia.A.D. 326–327. 14
7. Constantine wearing heavily jewelleddiadem, his eyes turned up to heaven.Obverse of gold coin minted inThessaloniki. A.D. 335. 15
8. Alexander wearing the diadem and thehorns of Zeus Ammon. Silver
tetradrachm issued by Lysimachos.306–281 B.C. 16
9. Victory standing on a sceptre andbreaking a diadem. Reverse of silverdenarius minted by Marcus JuniusBrutus. 43–42 B.C. 17
10. Alexander the Great. Marble portraithead from Kyme. Hellenistic,third–second century B.C. 20
11. Commodus. Marble portrait head witheyes raised towards heaven. End secondcentury A.D. 21
12. Bronze head of the statue of a Tetrarchfrom Adana, Turkey. Height: 37.8 cm. 21
13. Constantine. Marble portrait head witheyes raised heavenwards. Ca. A.D.324–337. 22
14. Philosopher Carneades. Marble portraithead. Late third century A.D. 23
15. Constantine’s porphyry column as in2010. Built ca. A.D. 324–330. 29
16. Constantine’s porphyry column. Builtca. A.D. 324–330. 30
17. Reconstruction of the imperial statueand the porphyry column inConstantine’s Forum at Constantinople.Ca. A.D. 324–330. 31
18. Reconstruction of the imperial statueon the porphyry column inConstantine’s Forum at Constantinople.Ca. A.D. 324–330. 32
ix
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
x ILLUSTRATIONS
19. Detail of a reconstruction of theimperial statue on the porphyry columnin Constantine’s Forum atConstantinople. Ca. A.D. 324–330. 33
20. Sol wearing crown of vertical rays.Reverse of silver denarius minted inRome by C. Coelius Caldus. 51 B.C. 34
21. Sol, wearing a chiton, rides in four-horsechariot and radiates angled rays of light.Reverse of silver denarius minted inRome by M. Aburius Geminus. 132B.C. 34
22. Drawing of the base of Constantine’sporphyry column by Melchior Lorck.A.D. 1561. 35
23. Drawing of head of Constantinewearing crown with vertical rays. Detailof Figure 22. 36
24. Constantine’s statue upon the porphyrycolumn beside the enthroned Tyche(Fortune) of Constantinople. PeutingerMap. Twelfth-century copy of fourth-or fifth-century original. 37
25. Colossal bronze head, left hand, andglobe from a statue of Constantine orConstantius II. 38
26. Colossal bronze head, from a statue ofConstantine or Constantius II. 39
27. Colossal bronze head, from a statue ofConstantine or Constantius II. 40
28. Ptolemy III Euergetes wearing radiatecrown. Gold coin of Ptolemy IVPhilopator minted in Alexandria.Ca. 222–205 B.C. 41
29. Silver denarius minted in Rome forSepullius Macer. Obverse shows head ofCaesar with star behind. Reverse showsVenus with Victory in right hand, andwith a sceptre resting on a star in theleft. 44 B.C. 43
30. Octavian adorning Caesar’s statue witha star. Reverse of silver denarius mintedin Rome by L. Lentulus. 12 B.C. 44
31. Statue of Apollo Actius holding acithara and sacrificing on a high podiumdecorated with ships’ prows. Reverse of
silver denarius minted in Rome by C.Antistius Vetus. 16 B.C. 45
32. Portrait head of Augustus fromPergamum. 27 B.C.–A.D. 14. 45
33. Silver denarius of Augustus minted inSpain. Obverse shows head of Augustuswearing oak wreath. Reverse showscomet with inscription referring to thedivine Julius Caesar. Ca. 17 B.C. 47
34. Divus Augustus wearing radiate crown.Obverse of copper alloy as minted inRome under Tiberius. Ca. A.D. 15. 48
35. Radiate statue of Octavian on a columndecorated with ships’ prows. Reverse ofsilver denarius minted in Rome underVespasian. A.D. 79. 48
36. The divine Augustus enthronedwearing radiate crown. Obverse ofcopper alloy sestertius minted in Romeunder Tiberius. A.D. 21/22. 48
37. Copper alloy as minted in Rome.Obverse shows head of Nero. Reverseshows Nero wearing flowing robes ofApollo and playing the cithara. A.D. 62. 49
38. Nero wearing radiate crown. Obverseof copper alloy dupondius minted inRome. A.D. 64. 50
39. Nero wearing toga and crown of angledrays holds patera in right hand and longsceptre in left. To the right stands theempress (probably Poppaea), veiled anddraped, holding patera in right hand andcornucopia in left. Reverse of aureus ofNero minted in Rome. A.D. 64–65. 51
40. Amethyst intaglio probably showing theColossus of Nero in Rome. Romanimperial period. 52
41a. Titus wearing radiate crown. Obverse ofcopper alloy dupondius minted in Rome.A.D. 80–81. 53
41b. Trajan wearing radiate crown. Obversecopper alloy dupondius minted in Rome.A.D. 104–111. 53
41c. Hadrian wearing radiate crown.Obverse of copper alloy dupondiusminted in Rome. A.D. 118. 53
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ILLUSTRATIONS xi
42. Caracalla wearing radiate crown.Obverse of silver antoninianus(double denarius) minted in Rome.A.D. 215. 54
43. Aureus minted in Rome. Obverse showsbust of Septimius Severus. Reverseshows Severus wearing the crown andcloak of Sol, riding in Sol’s chariot.A.D. 197. 55
44. Septimius Severus, wearing radiatecrown, and Julia Domna with acrescent. Reverse of aureus of Caracallaminted in Rome. A.D. 202. 55
45. Diocletianic copper alloy radiate.Obverse shows bust of Diocletian withradiate crown. Reverse shows theemperor receiving a Victory-toppedglobe from Jupiter. Mint of Alexandria.Ca. A.D. 296–297. 56
46. Copper alloy nummus minted inLondon. A.D. 312. Obverse showsConstantine wearing radiate crown overhelmet. Reverse shows Sol radiate withchlamys, whip, and globe. 57
47. Gold medallion showing Constantinewearing a radiate crown. Minted inAntioch in A.D. 326. 57
48. Aureus minted in Antioch. A.D.218–219. Obverse shows bust ofElagabalus. Reverse shows triumphalcar carrying the conical black stone ofEl-Gabal and an eagle shaded byparasols. 60
49. Sol wielding Zeus’ thunderbolt.Reverse of aureus of Elagabalus mintedin Antioch. A.D. 218–219. 60
50. Copper alloy radiate minted in Rome.Obverse shows Aurelian wearing radiatecrown. Reverse shows Sol with his footon the back of a captive. A.D. 274. 61
51. Fides handing two standards to Sol.Reverse of copper alloy radiate mintedin Siscia. A.D. 274. 62
52. Aurelian (left) receiving the globe fromJupiter. Reverse of copper alloy radiateminted in Serdica. A.D. 271–272. 63
53. Aurelian (left) holding sceptre or spearand receiving globe from Sol holdingwhip. Reverse of copper alloy radiateminted in Cyzicus. A.D. 273–274. 63
54. Diocletian and Maximian as Augusti inconsular dress. Aureus minted in Rome.A.D. 287. 64
55. Two of the porphyry Tetrarchs in theVatican Museums. 68
56. Two of the porphyry Tetrarchs in theVatican Museums. 69
57. Porphyry sculptures of the Tetrarchs.South side of San Marco, Venice. 70
58. Two of the porphyry Tetrarchs on thesouth side of San Marco, Venice. 71
59. Heads of two of the porphyry Tetrarchson the south side of San Marco,Venice. 72
60. Heads of two of the porphyry Tetrarchson the south side of San Marco, Venice. 73
61. Arch of Galerius, Thessaloniki,southern pier (Pier B) from the east. Ca.A.D. 299–303. 74
62. Arch of Galerius, Thessaloniki,northern pier (Pier A) from the east.Ca. A.D. 299–303. 75
63. Detail of the frieze showing theTetrarchs enthroned. Arch of Galerius,Thessaloniki, Pier B, north side. Ca.A.D. 299–303. 76
64. The Rostra and Five-ColumnMonument in the Roman Forum inRome. Reconstruction drawing. 77
65. Line drawing of frescoes depicting theeagle of Jupiter above the four Tetrarchs.Apse of room dedicated to the cult ofthe emperors. Temple of Ammon,Luxor, Egypt. Ca. A.D. 308/9. 78
66. Gold medallion of Maximian minted inTicinum. Obverse shows MaximianAugustus wearing the lion-skinheaddress of Hercules. Reverse showsthe seated Diocletian being crowned byJupiter (left) and the seated Maximianbeing crowned by Hercules (right).A.D. 286–305. 79
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xii ILLUSTRATIONS
67. The Basilica of Maxentius (right) andthe temple of Romulus (left) in theRoman Forum. 85
68. Aureus minted in Ostia. Ca. A.D.308/9–October 312. Obverse showsfrontal bust of Maxentius. Reverseshows Mars handing a Victory-toppedglobe to Maxentius. 86
69. Copper alloy nummus minted inLondon. Ca. A.D. 310. Obverse showsbust of Constantine with laurel wreath.Reverse shows Sol, naked except for achlamys, with globe in left hand andright arm raised with open hand. 87
70. Aureus minted in Ticinum. A.D.312–313. Obverse shows bust ofConstantine with laurel wreath.Reverse shows Victory crowning Sol asthey both ride in a four-horse chariot. 89
71. Constantius Chlorus as Caesar wearingthe lion-skin headdress of Hercules.Obverse of gold medallion (5 aurei)minted in Trier. A.D. 297. 90
72. Constantius on horseback approachesthe fortified city of London, in front ofwhich kneels a personification ofBritannia. Reverse of electrotype copyof gold medallion (10 aurei) minted inTrier. A.D. 297. 90
73. Sculptured frieze showing a Caesarmaking a libation. The radiate head ofSol and the headless body of Romareclining appear to the right of thescene. Decennalia base of theFive-Column Monument in theRoman Forum. 91
74. Sculptured frieze showing Maxentius’troops drowning in the River Tiber.Detail from the south facade of the Archof Constantine, Rome. Ca. A.D. 315. 92
75. Gold medallion minted in Ticinum inA.D. 313. Obverse shows bust ofConstantine overlapping a bust of Solwearing a radiate crown. Reverse showsConstantine on horseback raising hisright hand as Victory walks ahead. 93
76. Arch of Constantine, Rome. Southfacade. Ca. A.D. 315. 94
77. Arch of Constantine, Rome. Northfacade. Ca. A.D. 315. 95
78. Sculptured frieze showing Constantineand his troops at the siege of Verona.Detail from the south facade of the Archof Constantine, Rome. Ca. A.D. 315. 96
79. Sculptured frieze showing Constantine(headless) standing on the rostra in theRoman Forum. Detail from the northfacade of the Arch of Constantine,Rome. Ca. A.D. 315. 96
80. Sculptured frieze showing Constantine(headless) enthroned distributingmoney. Detail from the north facade ofthe Arch of Constantine, Rome. Ca.A.D. 315. 97
81. Head of Constantine with nimbus.Roundel showing a boar hunt on thenorth face of the Arch of Constantine.Hadrianic, reworked ca. A.D. 315. 98
82. Frontal portrait of Constantine withnimbus. Obverse of gold solidus mintedin Ticinum. A.D. 316. 99
83. Sol wearing chlamys and radiate crown,with right arm raised. West side of theeast passage of the Arch of Constantine.Ca. A.D. 315. 100
84. Constantine, with right arm raised inimitation of Sol, is crowned by Victory.East side of the east passage of the Archof Constantine. Ca. A.D. 315. 100
85. Column-base relief from the Arch ofConstantine showing soldiers carryingpoles topped by small statues of thegods. The god held by the soldier onthe right is Sol. Ca. A.D. 315. 101
86. Sol ascending from the ocean in afour-horse chariot. Roundel, east sideof Arch of Constantine. Ca. A.D. 315. 102
87. Luna descending in two-horsechariot. Roundel, west side of Arch ofConstantine. Ca. A.D. 315. 103
88. A personification of the emperor’seternity (Aeternitas Augusti) holds a bust
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ILLUSTRATIONS xii i
of Sol in her right hand and a bust ofLuna in her left. Silver denarius mintedin Rome under Hadrian. A.D. 118. 104
89. Roundel showing Sol ascending fromthe ocean in a four-horse chariot abovefrieze of Constantine’s entry intoRome. East side of Arch ofConstantine. Ca. A.D. 315. 105
90. Nero’s colossal radiate statue viewedfrom the south through the Arch ofConstantine. 105
91. Sol Invictus presenting the globe toConstantine. Reverse of gold coinminted in Arles. A.D. 317. 106
92. Sol Invictus crowning Constantine.Reverse of gold coin minted inSirmium. A.D. 321. 106
93. Frieze on the west side of the centralpassage of the Arch of Constantine. Theemperor on horseback crushesbarbarians. Trajanic, reworked ca.A.D. 315. 130
94. Frieze on the east side of the centralpassage of the Arch of Constantine. Theemperor, standing with Roma to hisright, is crowned by Victory. Trajanic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 131
95. Rare copper alloy nummus minted inConstantinople. Obverse shows head ofConstantine. Reverse shows serpentpierced by a standard topped by thechi-rho monogram. A.D. 327. 143
96. Remains of the Serpent Column inthe hippodrome in Istanbul. After479 B.C. 145
97. Reconstruction drawing of thehippodrome in Constantinople duringConstantine’s reign, showing southernturning-post (left), masonry obelisk(centre), starting gates (distance), andkathisma (right). 153
98. Reconstructed plan of the hippodromein Constantinople showing survivingremains. 155
99. The masonry obelisk in thehippodrome in Istanbul. 156
100. Nielloed and gilded silver dish showingan emperor, possibly Constantius II, onhorseback. Discovered in a necropolis inKerch. Mid-fourth century A.D. 162
101. Funerary plaque of Beratius Nicatorasnow in the Vatican Museums. Thirdcentury A.D. 163
102. Staurogram used as part of mint mark.Reverse of gold solidus minted inAntioch, A.D. 336–337. 164
103. Bronze steelyard weight filled with lead,in the form of the emperorConstantine. Height: 12.5 cm. 165
104. Late antique intaglios (red jasper andgreen jasper) with anchor symbols anddolphins. Third–fourth century A.D. 166
105. Carved ivory panel from casket made inRome showing nimbate Christ on thecross. Ca. A.D. 420–430. 167
106. Reverse of copper alloy nummus mintedin Aquileia in A.D. 334–335. 169
107. The Great Cameo. Agate cameoshowing Constantine, Fausta, andCrispus in a chariot drawn by twocentaurs. Ca. A.D. 315. 171
108. Sol radiating light in four directions.Reverse of copper alloy nummus mintedin Thessaloniki. A.D. 319. 172
109. Eight-pointed star in wreath.Reverse of bronze coin minted inhonour of Helena in ThessalonicaA.D. 318–319. 172
110a–f. Copper alloy nummi showing aprofile bust of Constantine wearing ahelmet decorated with a variety ofdesigns. a–d: Minted in London, ca.A.D. 319–320; e–f: Minted in Siscia, ca.A.D. 318–320. 173
111. Bronze statuette of St. Peter carryingstaurogram. Fourth–fifth century A.D. 176
112. Gold medallion minted in Sisciadiscovered in Borca, a suburb ofBelgrade. Obverse shows Constantinewith diadem looking towards heaven.Reverse shows Constantine in militarydress holding a standard bearing a
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xiv ILLUSTRATIONS
chi-rho symbol on its banner in hisright hand. A.D. 326. 176
113. Constantius II, being crowned byVictory, holds a standard bearing thechi-rho monogram on its banner andlooks towards the powerful sign.Reverse of bronze medallion minted inSiscia. A.D. 350. 177
114. Bust of Constantine carrying standard orsceptre over left shoulder, and wearinghelmet with chi-rho monogram increst. Obverse of silver medallionminted at Ticinum in A.D. 315. 178
115. Valentinian II (A.D. 375–392) carrying asceptre or standard over his rightshoulder. Obverse of copper alloymedallion. 178
116. Silver coin of Seleucus I Nicator mintedin Ecbatana. The reverse shows Zeusholding an eagle, a horse grazing at hisfeet, and monograms and an anchor inthe field. After 306 B.C. 180
117. The pharaoh Akhenaten, his wifeNefertiti, and their three daughtersreceive ankhs from hands at the ends ofthe rays of the sun’s disc. Limestonestele, 1351–1334 B.C. 181
118. The pharaoh Tutankhamun in a chariottrampling his enemies, with solar discand ankhs overhead. Painted woodenchest, ca. 1333–1323 B.C. 182
119. Porphyry sarcophagi displayed outsidethe Istanbul Archaeological Museums.Inventory nos. 3154 (left), 3155(centre), and 3157. 183
120. Cupids harvesting grapes. Fragment ofthe flank of a highly decoratedporphyry sarcophagus. 184
121. Highly decorated porphyry sarcophagusfrom the mausoleum on the ViaNomentana in Rome. 185
122. Cupids harvesting grapes. Detail ofFigure 121. 185
123. Porphyry sarcophagus. 188124. Porphyry sarcophagus in the atrium of
Hagia Eirene, Istanbul. 189
125. Detail of the holes on the north side ofthe lid of the porphyry sarcophagus inHagia Eirene. Reconstructed designsuperimposed. 190
126. Detail of the holes on the south side ofthe flank of the porphyry sarcophagusin Hagia Eirene. Reconstructed designsuperimposed. 191
127. The combined ankh and chi-rho designcarved on the eastern gable end of thelid of the porphyry sarcophagus inHagia Eirene. 192
128. Scenes from the trial of Christ withcentral cruciform standard topped by achi-rho monogram within a wreath.Sarcophagus found near catacomb ofDomitilla. Mid-fourth century A.D. 193
129. Two groups of six Apostles approacha central cruciform standard topped bya chi-rho monogram within a wreath.Sarcophagus from cemetery of SanSebestiano. Left and right sections arecasts; central section is original. End offourth or beginning of fifth century A.D. 193
130. Fragments of the colossal statue ofConstantine from the Basilica ofMaxentius. Musei Capitolini, Rome. 204
131. Reconstruction of the colossal statue ofConstantine integrated into areconstruction of the Basilica ofMaxentius, Rome. 205
132. Reconstruction of the Basilica ofMaxentius as remodelled byConstantine, showing the colossal statuein the northwest apse. 206
133. The Basilica of Maxentius. Exteriorview showing the northwest apse (farright) and northeast apse (left of centre). 207
134. Head of the colossal statue ofConstantine from the Basilica ofMaxentius. 208
135. Head of the colossal statue ofConstantine from the Basilica ofMaxentius. 209
136. Closed right hand of the colossal statueof Constantine. 210
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ILLUSTRATIONS xv
137. Closed right hand of the colossal statueof Constantine. View of hole in top offist. 210
138. Right bicep, elbow, and forearm ofcolossal statue of Constantine. 211
139. Statue, probably of Constantius II, inthe narthex of St. John Lateran, Rome. 211
140. Closed right hand found at the Capitolin 1744, probably from the colossalstatue of Constantine. 213
141. Closed right hand found at the Capitolin 1744, probably from the colossalstatue of Constantine. View of hole inbottom of fist. 213
142. Copper alloy medallion showingConstantine in the costume of Jupiterreceiving a phoenix-topped globe fromone of his Caesars. Mint of Rome.A.D. 326. 214
143. Augustus in the Jupiter costume,enthroned beside Roma. Detail of theGemma Augustea. Ca. A.D. 10. 215
144. Six-armed monogram with a dot at thetop serving as part of the mint mark ona copper alloy coin of ConstantineJunior as Caesar, minted in Ticinum.A.D. 319–320. 222
145a–c. Reverses of copper alloy nummiminted in Arles. Two soldiers stand oneither side of a single standard. Thesymbols on the banner (serving asparts of the mint mark) vary. Dates:December 333–September337. 223
146. Inscription on the Arch of Constantine,Rome. Ca. A.D. 315. 223
147. Sculptured frieze showing Roma(second from left) striding forwards onthe bridgehead alongside Constantine(lost) as Maxentius’ troops drown in theTiber. Detail from the south facade ofthe Arch of Constantine, Rome. Ca.A.D. 315. 225
148. Diagram of the Arch of Constantine toshow the positions and dates of thevarious sculptured elements. 229
149. Head of Constantine. Attic panelof profectio. Arch of Constantine,Rome. Aurelian, reworked ca. A.D. 315 230
150. Head of Constantius Chlorus. Roundelshowing a sacrifice to Apollo. Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 231
151. Constantine on horseback during a boarhunt. Roundel, north facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 232
152. Constantine after a successful lion hunt.Roundel, north facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 233
153. Constantine addresses his troops. Atticpanel, south facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Aurelian, reworkedca. A.D. 315. 234
154. Constantine distributes money. Atticpanel, north facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Aurelian, reworkedca. A.D. 315. 235
155. Constantine sacrificing to Diana.Roundel, south facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 236
156. Constantine sacrificing to Silvanus.Roundel, south facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 236
157. Constantius Chlorus sacrificing toApollo. Roundel, north facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 237
158. Constantius Chlorus sacrificing toHercules. Roundel, north facade, Archof Constantine, Rome. Hadrianic,reworked ca. A.D. 315. 237
159. Constantine sacrificing a bull, pig, andsheep. Attic panel, south facade, Arch ofConstantine, Rome. Aurelian, reworkedca. A.D. 315. 238
160. Reconstruction of the interior of theimperial audience hall (basilica) atTrier. 239
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xvi ILLUSTRATIONS
161. Reconstruction of the interior of theBasilica Ulpia in Trajan’s Forum, Rome. 239
162. Basilica of St. John in the Lateran. Planand 3-D reconstruction. 240
163. Basilica of Sts. Marcellinus and Peterwith the Mausoleum of Helena. Planand 3-D reconstruction. 241
164. Basilica of the Apostles (now SanSebastiano). Plan and cut-away 3-Dreconstruction. 242
165. Basilica of St. Laurence. Plan and 3-Dreconstruction. 244
166. Basilica of St. Agnes and mausoleum ofConstantina. Plan and 3-Dreconstruction. 245
167. Basilica of St. Peter. Plan and 3-Dreconstruction. 246
168. Chapel in the Sessorian palace.Cut-away 3-D reconstruction and plan. 249
169. Map to show the locations ofConstantine’s Christian foundations inand around Rome. 250
170. Copper alloy medallion showing on theobverse a bust of the Tyche ofConstantinople, and on the reverseVictory standing on the prow of awarship with the legend VICTORIAAVGVSTI. Minted at Rome inA.D. 330. 253
171. Map of Constantinople in theConstantinian period. 254
172. Anastasis Rotunda and basilica of theHoly Sepulchre, Jerusalem. Cut-away3-D reconstruction and plan. 256
173. Anastasis Rotunda and apse of thebasilica of the Holy Sepulchre,Jerusalem. Cut-away 3-Dreconstruction. 257
174. Gold solidus minted in Sirmium.Obverse shows Helena as Augusta.Reverse shows a personification ofSecuritas. Ca. A.D. 324–325. 259
175. Church of the Nativity, Bethlehem.Plan and 3-D reconstruction. 260
176. Church at Mamre. Plan. 261177. Silver medallion minted in
Constantinople in 330. Obverse shows
Constantine as Maximus TriumphatorAugustus wearing a jewelled diadem.Reverse shows the Tyche ofConstantinople holding a horn ofplenty, wearing a turreted crown, andseated on a throne. A ship’s prow isvisible below her feet. 263
178. Ivory diptych showing the Tychai ofRome (left) and Constantinople withturreted crown. Sixth century A.D. 265
179. Gold aureus of Licinius minted inNicomedia. Obverse shows frontalportrait of Licinius. Reverse showsJupiter enthroned. A.D. 321. 283
180. Radiant charioteer in a ceiling mosaicin the Tomb of the Julii (MausoleumM) beneath St. Peter’s basilica, Rome.Mid-third to early-fourth century A.D. 329
181. Christ as a bearded, long-hairedphilosopher preaching the Sermon onthe Mount and performing miracles(Cure of the Paralytic, Cure of theLeper). Sarcophagus, ca. 290–310. 346
182. Youthful Christ performing miracles.Detail from sarcophagus of MarcusClaudianus, 330–335. Centre: Miracleof Loaves and Fishes. Right: Raising ofLazarus and Cure of the Woman withIssue of Blood. 347
183. Christ teaching, seated among HisApostles. Fresco in the catacomb on theVia Anapo, Rome. Ca. A.D. 325. 348
184. Christ enthroned surrounded by theApostles. Fresco in cubiculum 74 of theCatacomb of Domitilla, Rome.Watercolour by Carlo Tabanelli overphotograph by Pompeo and RenatoSansaini, 1897–1903. Ca. A.D. 350–375. 349
185. Magi presenting their gifts to the babyJesus. Sarcophagus ca. 325–350. Fromthe Vatican Necropolis. 350
186. Constantine ascending in chariotreaching out to a divine hand emergingfrom the clouds. Reverse of gold solidusminted in Constantinople in 337. 350
187. The Ascension of Christ. Ivory diptych,ca. 400. 351
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ILLUSTRATIONS xvii
188. Christ, beardless and with nimbus,hands the law to Peter, the first bishopof Rome. Apse mosaic from themausoleum of Constantina (SantaCostanza). Ca. A.D. 360–390. 352
189. Christ, bearded and with nimbus, sitson the globe of the cosmos. Apsemosaic from the mausoleum ofConstantina (Santa Costanza). Ca. A.D.360–390. 352
190. Reverse of silver denarius of Octavianminted in Italy, showing a naked statueof Octavian with his foot on the sphereof the cosmos. 36–31 B.C. 353
191. Beardless Christ seated above Caelus.Detail of plaster cast of sarcophagus ofJunius Bassus, A.D. 359. 353
192. Christ in military dress, carrying a cross,and standing upon a lion and a serpent.Mosaic in the Archiepiscopal Chapel,Ravenna. Sixth century A.D. 355
193. Reconstruction drawing of the churchof the Holy Sepulchre, Jerusalem,showing the basilica and AnastasisRotunda. 357
194. Copper alloy nummus in honour ofHelena Augusta. Reverse shows Paxholding an olive branch and sceptreMinted in Trier, June 337–April 340. 366
195. Copper alloy nummus in honour ofTheodora Augusta. Reverse showsPietas nursing a child. Minted in Trier,June 337–April 340. 366
196. Porphyry sarcophagus formerly in themausoleum of Helena, Via Labicana,Rome. 367
197. Comparative plans of the Pantheon anda number of late antique rotundas. 371
198. Frieze showing the Tetrarchs enthronedin the centre of a gathering of gods and
personifications. Arch of Galerius,Thessaloniki, Pier B, north side. Ca.A.D. 299–303. 374
199. Christ on the cross flanked by sixApostles on either side. Carnelianintaglio, British Museum. Third–fourthcentury. 374
200. Cross topped by wreath beingapproached from either side by sixApostles. Sarcophagus. Museedepartmental Arles antiques. Ca.A.D. 380. 375
201. Copper alloy nummus minted inLondon ca. 307–310. Obverse showsbust of the divus Constantius. Reverseshows lighted altar flanked byeagles. 377
202. Gold solidus minted in Constantinoplein 337. Obverse shows a veiled bust ofConstantine. Reverse shows theemperor ascending in a chariot reachingout to a divine hand emerging from theclouds. 378
203. Reverse of a 30-solidi gold medallion inhonour of the Caesar Constantius.Constantine is crowned by a handemerging from a cloud. A.D. 333. 378
204. Hercules, riding a chariot, is receivedinto heaven by Athena. Funerarymonument of the Secundinii from thevillage of Igel near Trier in Germany.Ca. A.D. 200–250. Photograph withdrawn outline overlaid. 379
205. Schematic diagrams showing threedifferent scenarios for the developmentof the Holy Apostles complex and itsinternal arrangements: 1. Rotundaprecedes church; 2. Church precedesrotunda; 3. Rotunda and church builtsimultaneously. 383
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
S
This book has been long in gestation. It started in asmall way whilst I held a British Academy Postdoc-toral Research Fellowship at the Institute of Archae-ology and Linacre College in Oxford from 1994 to1997. Those readers interested in the curiously den-dritic ways in which scholarship develops may wishto know that it was the references to Constantine inPalatine Anthology 1.10 (the poem inscribed in AniciaJuliana’s sixth-century church of St. Polyeuktos) thatcaused me to look more closely at the first Christianemperor and the statue on his porphyry column.The work was a stimulating distraction from mymain research topics at the time – Constantinopoli-tan stamped bricks and the church of St. Polyeuktos.
I found the time to explore Constantine andkingship philosophy in greater depth whilst I was aResearch Fellow in the AHRB Centre for Byzan-tine Cultural History at the University of Newcas-tle upon Tyne from 2001 to 2003. The article that Iproduced during that time developed to become thisbook during a year of research undertaken with per-sonal resources in 2005–2006. In the following aca-demic year, 2006–2007, I was able to make significantadvances whilst holding a memorable Senior Fellow-ship at Koc University’s Research Center for Ana-tolian Civilizations in Beyoglu, Istanbul. I broughtthe book to completion by subsequently undertak-ing much further independent research and writingin precious spare time up to April 2011.
I am particularly grateful to Averil Cameron andJas Elsner for their detailed and thought-provokingcomments on my early article in 2004 – comments
that stimulated me to expand that text into this book.Cyril Mango generously took the time to read theentire typescript at a much later stage in compositionin 2007 and made helpful and encouraging remarks.Mary Whitby always took an interest and was happyto enter into discussion of knotty linguistic mat-ters. I would also like to thank Halil Arca, AssistantDirector of the Ayasofya Museum, and his colleagueSabriye Parlak for permission to study the sarcophagiin Hagia Eirene. In the very beginning there weremany long lunches in Oxford with Dimitris Plant-zos, who deserves thanks for patiently listening tomy vague plans to write, among other things, aboutConstantine’s Golden Age.
For generous grants towards the cost of theillustrations and of the extensive notes and bibli-ography, many thanks are due to the Vehbi KocVakfı and the Kress Foundation. I would liketo thank all of the institutions and individuals whohave provided or helped me obtain the images inthis book. Among them I must single out for spe-cial mention: Richard Abdy of the British Museum,who not only set me straight on certain numismaticmatters but also gave his assistance with obtainingimages of coins; the British Museum itself for pro-viding a marvellous online image database; FranzAlto Bauer for kindly helping me obtain articles andillustrations in works out of my reach; Sylvia Dieb-ner and Daria Lanzuolo for advice and for locatingimages at the German Archaeological Institute inRome; William Storage for allowing me to makefull use of his excellent photographs of the Arch
xix
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xx ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
of Constantine after cleaning; and particularly Tay-fun Oner, who exceeded my expectations by pro-viding not only fresh plans of the monuments ofthe period but also excellent 3-D reconstructions.Brigitte Pitarakis kindly liaised with the Vehbi KocVakfı.
For seeing this book into print, I would liketo thank Beatrice Rehl and Amanda J. Smith atCambridge University Press in New York, and PeggyM. Rote at Aptara, Inc.
Finally, I thank my parents, Janet and PhilipBardill, for their patient encouragement. Without
their constant support it would not have been possi-ble to bring this project to completion.
A number of the topics discussed in the text werepresented in lectures at the Byzantium in the Northconference on Constantinople at Newcastle Univer-sity on 16 November 2002; at Late Antique Archae-ology 2003: The Social and Political Archaeology of LateAntiquity in the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford, on22 March 2003; at Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitatin Munich on 23 May 2006; and at Constantine and theLate Roman World in the Yorkshire Museum, York,on 19 July 2006.
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ABBREVIATIONS
S
Reference Works
AE L’Annee epigraphique: revue despublications epigraphiques relatives al’antiquite romaine 1888–. Paris.
ANRW Aufstieg und Niedergang der romischenWelt. 1972–. Berlin–New York.
BMC H. Mattingly and others, Coins of theRoman Empire in the British Museum.6 vols. (London 1962–1976)
CAH2 Cambridge Ancient History, 2nd ed.14 vols. (in 19). (Cambridge 1971–2005)
CIL T. Mommsen and others, eds., CorpusInscriptionum Latinarum. 17+ vols.(Berlin 1862–)
DACL F. Cabrol and H. Leclercq, eds.,Dictionnare d’archeologie chretienne et deliturgie. 15 vols. (in 30). (Paris1924–1953)
FHG C. Muller and T. Muller, eds. FragmentaHistoricorum Graecorum. 5 vols. (Paris1848–1928)
ICVR G. B. de Rossi, ed., InscriptionesChristianae Urbis Romae (Rome1857–1861)
IGR R. Cagnat, Inscriptiones Graecae ad ResRomanas Pertinentes. 4 vols. (vol. 2 neverpublished). (Paris 1906–1927; reprintedChicago 1975)
ILCV I E. Diehl, Inscriptiones Latinae ChristianaeVeteres I (Berlin 1925)
ILS H. Dessau, ed., Inscriptiones LatinaeSelectae. 3 vols. (Berlin 1892–1914)
LIMC Lexicon Iconographicum MythologiaeClassicae. 9 vols. (as 17).(Zurich–Munich 1981–1999)
LTUR E. M. Steinby, ed., LexiconTopographicum Urbis Romae. 6 vols.(Rome 1993–2000)
OLD P. G. W. Glare, ed., Oxford LatinDictionary. Combined edition,reprinted and corrected (Oxford 1996)
PG J.-P. Migne, ed., Patrologiae CursusCompletus. Series Græca. 161 vols. (Paris1857–1866)
P. Lond. F. S. Kenyon and H. I. Bell, eds., GreekPapyri in the British Museum. (London1893–1907)
P. Oxy. Grenfell, G. P., Hunt, A. S., and others,eds., The Oxyrhynchus Papyri. 68+ vols.(London 1898–)
PLRE A. H. M. Jones, J. R. Martindale, and J.Morris, eds., The Prosopography of theLater Roman Empire. 3 vols. in 4.(Cambridge 1971–1992)
Repertorium Repertorium der Christlich-antikenSarkophage.
I F. W. Deichmann, Rom und Ostia.(Wiesbaden 1967)
II J. Dresken-Weiland, Italien mit einemNachtrag Rom und Ostia, Dalmatien,Museen der Welt. (Mainz 1998)
xxi
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xxii ABBREVIATIONS
III B. Christern-Briesenick, Frankreich,Algerien, Tunisien. (Mainz 2003)
RIC The Roman Imperial Coinage (London)I C. H. V. Sutherland, 31 BC to AD 69 –
Augustus to Vitellius. Revised edition.(1984)
II H. Mattingly and E. A. Sydenham,Vespasian to Hadrian. (1926)
III H. Mattingly and E. A. Sydenham,Antoninus Pius to Commodus (1930)
IV.1 H. Mattingly and E. A. Sydenham,Pertinax to Geta (1936)
IV.2 H. Mattingly, E. A. Sydenham, andC. H. V. Sutherland, Macrinus toPupienus (1938)
IV.3 H. Mattingly, E. A. Sydenham, andC. H. V. Sutherland. Gordian III toUranius Antoninus (1949)
V.1 P. H. Webb, Valerian to Florian (1927)V.2 P. H. Webb, Probus to Amandus (1933)VI C. H. V. Sutherland, From Diocletian’s
Reform (AD 294) to the death ofMaximinus (AD 313) (1967)
VII P. M. Bruun, Constantine and Licinius,AD 313–337 (1966)
VIII J. P. C. Kent, The Family of ConstantineI, AD 337–364 (1981)
IX J. W. E. Pearce, Valentinian I toTheodosius I (1951)
X J. P. C. Kent, The Divided Empire and theFall of the Western Parts AD 395–491(1994)
RPC A. Burnett, M. Amandry, P. P.Ripolles, Roman Provincial Coinage. 2vols. + supplement. (London 1992–)
SIG W. Dittenberger, Sylloge InscriptionumGraecarum. 3rd ed. 4 vols. (Leipzig1915–1924). Reprinted 1960.
TLL Thesaurus Linguae Latinae. 10+ vols.(Leipzig 1800–)
Series
ACL Ante-Nicene Christian LibraryCCSL Corpus Christianorum Series LatinaCFHB Corpus Fontium Historiae Byzantinae
CSEL Corpus Scriptorum EcclesiasticorumLatinorum
CSHB Corpus Scriptorum Historiae ByzantinaeCUF Collection des universites de FranceFC Fathers of the ChurchGCS Die griechischen christlichen
Schriftsteller der ersten JahrhunderteJACE Jahrbuch fur Antike und Christentum
ErganzungsbandLCL Loeb Classical LibraryMGHAA Monumenta Germaniae Historica
Auctorum AntiquissimorumPC Penguin ClassicsSC Sources chretiennesSLNPF Select Library of Nicene and
Post-Nicene Fathers of the ChristianChurch
TCL Translations of Christian Literature Series1. Greek Texts
TTH Translated Texts for Historians
Journals
AAAH Acta ad Archaeologiam et ArtiumHistoriam Pertinentia
AB Analecta BollandianaAC L’Antiquite classiqueAIPhO Annuaire de l’Institut de Philologie et
d’Histoire Orientales et SlavesAJA American Journal of ArchaeologyAJPh American Journal of PhilologyAnTard Antiquite tardiveArtBull Art BulletinBABesch Bulletin Antieke BeschavingBCH Bulletin de correspondance helleniqueBJ Bonner JahrbucherBMGS Byzantine and Modern Greek StudiesBoreas Boreas: Munstersche Beitrage zur
ArchaologieByzZ Byzantinische ZeitschriftCJ The Classical JournalClAnt Classical AntiquityCPh Classical PhilologyCQ Classical QuarterlyCRAI Comptes rendus de l’Academie des
Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
ABBREVIATIONS xxii i
DOP Dumbarton Oaks PapersEMC Echos du Monde Classique, Classical ViewsG&R Greece and RomeGRBS Greek, Roman and Byzantine StudiesHSCP Harvard Studies in Classical PhilologyHThR Harvard Theological ReviewIstMitt Istanbuler MitteilungenJARCE Journal of the American Research Center in
EgyptJbAC Jahrbuch fur Antike und ChristentumJBL Journal of Biblical LiteratureJDAI Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archaologischen
InstitutsJEA Journal of Egyptian ArchaeologyJECS Journal of Early Christian StudiesJEH Journal of Ecclesiastical HistoryJHS Journal of Hellenic StudiesJLA Journal of Late AntiquityJNES Journal of Near Eastern StudiesJRA Journal of Roman ArchaeologyJRS Journal of Roman StudiesJSAH Journal of the Society of Architectural
HistoriansJSAN Journal of the Society for Ancient
NumismaticsJSNT Journal for the Study of the New TestamentJThS Journal of Theological StudiesJWI Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld
InstitutesLNV Litterae Numismaticae VindobonensesMAAR Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome
MediterrAnt Mediterraneo AnticoMDAI(R) Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archaologischen
Instituts, Romische AbteilungMEFRA Melanges de l’Ecole francaise de Rome:
AntiquiteNC Numismatic ChronicleNZ Numismatische ZeitschriftOJA Oxford Journal of ArchaeologyPAPhS Proceedings of the American Philosophical
SocietyPBSR Papers of the British School at RomeP&P Past and PresentRAC Rivista di archeologia cristianaRBen Revue BenedictineREA Revue des etudes anciennesRHPhR Revue d’histoire et de philosophie religieusesRHR Revue de l’histoire des religionsSBN Studi bizantini e neoelleniciSCI Scripta Classica IsraelicaSTh Studia TheologicaStudPat Studia PatristicaTAPhS Transactions of the American Philosophical
SocietyT&MByz Travaux et memoiresTPAPhA Transactions and Proceedings of the
American Philological AssociationVChr Vigiliae ChristianaeYClS Yale Classical StudiesZAC Zeitschrift fur Antikes ChristentumZKG Zeitschrift fur KirchengeschichteZPE Zeitschrift fur Papyrologie und Epigraphik
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
CHRONOLOGY
S
273 Constantine born to ConstantiusChlorus and Helena at Naissus (27February).
284 Diocles (later Diocletian) proclaimedemperor near Nicomedia (20November).
285 Maximian appointed Caesar (earlysummer), so forming the Dyarchy.
286 Maximian elevated to juniorco-Augustus with Diocletian (1 April).
289 (approx.) Constantius separates fromHelena and marries Theodora.Panegyric X is delivered (21 April).
291 Panegyric XI celebrates Maximian’sbirthday (21 July?).
293 Constantius and Galerius appointedCaesars to Maximian and Diocletianrespectively (1 March), so forming theFirst Tetrarchy. Constantius drivesCarausius from the coast of Gaul.Carausius murdered and replaced byAllectus.
296 Constantius liberates Britain fromAllectus. Narses invades Armenia(autumn).
297 Panegyric VIII to Constantius isdelivered (1 March). Galerius capturesthe harem of Narses at Oskha inArmenia (autumn).
297–298 Galerius captures Ctesiphon (winter)accompanied by Constantine.
298 Panegyric IX by Eumenius is delivered.
301–302 Constantine travels through Palestine toEgypt with Diocletian.
303 Diocletian posts the First PersecutionEdict in Nicomedia (24 February).
Diocletian, Maximian, Galerius, andConstantius meet in northern Italy anddiscuss the imperial succession(autumn).
Galerius required on lower Danubefrontier.
In Rome, Diocletian and Maximiancelebrate their vicennalia and the victoryover Narses (20 November).
In the temple of Jupiter on theCapitoline, Maximian swears an oath toretire with Diocletian.
305 Diocletian and Maximian retire;Galerius and Constantius are appointedAugusti in East and West; MaximinusDaza and Severus are proclaimed theirrespective Caesars (1 May), so formingthe Second Tetrarchy.
Active persecution ceases in the Westunder Constantius.
Constantine joins his father in Gaul.They cross to Britain and win a victoryover the Picts (summer or autumn).
306 Constantius dies in York andConstantine succeeds (25 July).
Constantine restores property andfreedom to Christians in Britain, Gaul,and Spain.
xxv
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xxvi CHRONOLOGY
Galerius proclaims Severus the newAugustus and Constantine Severus’Caesar.
Maxentius claims imperial status inRome (28 October) and summons hisfather, Maximian, from retirement in hissupport. He extends toleration toChristians in his realms (winter).
307 Severus defeated by Maxentius atRavenna and later murdered.
Constantine marries his second wife,Fausta (daughter of Maximian andEutropia) and is raised to the rank ofAugustus by Maximian. Galerius doesnot recognize the appointment.
Panegyric VII celebrates the marriage(December).
308 Maximian attempts to take Rome fromMaxentius but fails (April).
Diocletian, Maximian, and Galeriusmeet at Carnuntum (11 November) anddeclare Licinius successor to Severus,Constantine Caesar to Licinius, andMaxentius as usurper. Maximian stepsdown again.
310 Maximian attempts to regain power butis captured by Constantine and forced tocommit suicide at Marseille ( July).
Panegyric VI describes Constantine’svision of Apollo.
Galerius acknowledges Constantineand Maximinus Daza as Augusti, sobringing the Tetrarchic system to anend.
311 Galerius posts edict of toleration toChristians in Danubian provinces andGreece (late April) but dies a monthlater in Serdica, having entrusted hiswife and bastard son to Licinius. Histerritories are divided between Liciniusand Maximinus.
Panegyric V celebrates Constantine’squinquennalia (25 July).
Constantine and Licinius attempt tocurb Maximinus’ persecuting tendenciesin the East.
311 or 312 Diocletian dies at Spalato (Split;3 December).
312 Constantine crosses the Alps (spring orsummer), becomes master of northernItaly, defeats Maxentius at the MilvianBridge (28 October), and enters Romethe next day.
Maximinus’ edict of toleration in theEast (end of year).
313 Constantine and Licinius meet in Milanand forge an alliance through themarriage of Constantine’s oldesthalf-sister, Constantia, to Licinius. Theyagree on a policy of religious freedom(February).
Maximinus attacks Licinius atHadrianopolis (Adrianople; April) but isdefeated and flees eastwards. Liciniuskills surviving members of otherTetrarchic families.
Maximinus issues edict endingpersecution and restoring confiscatedproperty in his territories (May).
Licinius sends to governors of boththe Balkans and provinces newly takenfrom Maximinus (Asia Minor, Syria,Palestine, and Egypt) a letter extendingto Christians the same benefits alreadyenjoyed by those in the West (13 June).
Maximinus, besieged in Tarsus,commits suicide ( July).
Constantine perhaps visits Britain.Panegyric XII delivered in
Constantine’s honour (autumn).314 Council of Arles convened to discuss
the Donatist controversy.315 Constantine’s decennalia celebrated in
Rome (18/21 July–27 September).Arch of Constantine dedicated by the
Senate and people of Rome.316 Constantine defeats Licinius at Cibalae
(autumn).317 Peace negotiated at Serdica between
Constantine and Licinius.Licinianus (son of Licinius), Crispus
(Constantine’s son by Minervina), andConstantine Junior (Constantine’s firstson by Fausta) named Caesars (1 March).
319 Constantine bans private acts ofdivination.
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
CHRONOLOGY xxvii
321 Panegyric IV delivered by Nazarius onthe quinquennalia of the Caesars (1 March).
323 Constantine encroaches on Licinius’territory.
324 Constantine defeats Licinius at the RiverHebrus (3 July) and Chrysopolis (18September) and adds Asia Minor, Syria,Palestine, and Egypt to his domains.
Constantinople founded on site ofByzantium.
Constantius (Constantine’s second sonby Fausta) named Caesar, and Helenaand Fausta made Augustae (8 November).
325 Licinius executed at Thessalonica(spring).
Council of Nicaea convened todiscuss the Arian controversy( June–July). Bishops invited to banquetto celebrate beginning of Constantine’svicennalia (25 July).
325 or 326 Macarius, bishop of Jerusalem, receivesletter from the emperor instructing himto build a basilica at the site of the HolySepulchre.
326 Trial and condemnation of Crispus;suspicious death of Fausta.
Constantine enters Rome (15 July) tocelebrate the twentieth anniversary ofhis accession ten days later.
327 Helena embarks on pilgrimage to HolyLand (spring) and is joined by Eutropia,Constantine’s mother-in-law.
Council of Nicomedia readmits Ariusto the church.
328 Constantine constructs a bridge over theDanube.
Helena dies, probably in Nicomedia,and is buried on the Via Labicana inRome.
330 Constantinople dedicated: radiate statueof Constantine placed on top ofporphyry column (11 May); circusprocession of Constantine’s statue(12 May).
332 Constantine wins a victory over theGoths (winter).
333 Constans (Constantine’s third son byFausta) proclaimed Caesar (25December).
334 Constantine wins a victory over theSarmatians.
Council at Caesarea investigatesaccusations against Athanasius.
335 Council at Tyre ( July–September) findsAthanasius guilty.
Dalmatius (nephew of Constantine)named Caesar (18 September).
Church of Holy Sepulchre dedicatedin Jerusalem, and Eusebius recites theextant oration on the church of theHoly Sepulchre (September).
Council of Tyre summoned toConstantinople and presents newaccusations against Athanasius.
Eusebius recites a second oration onthe church of the Holy Sepulchre inConstantinople (November).
336 Constantine adopts the title DacicusMaximus.
Arius dies (24 July).Constantine’s thirtieth anniversary
celebration (tricennalia) atConstantinople, at which Eusebiusrecites his In Praise of Constantine (25July).
337 Constantine baptized and dies atNicomedia (22 May). He is buried in ashrine of the Apostles in Constantinople(late May or early June).
Constans agrees to the constructionof a temple in honour of the imperialfamily at Hispellum.
Massacre of the sons and grandsons ofTheodora, including the CaesarDalmatius (early June).
Constantine’s sons (Constantine,Constantius, Constans) proclaimedAugusti (9 September).
339 Eusebius of Caesarea dies (May).359 Patriarch Macedonius moves
Constantine’s body to the church of St.Acacius.
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
Map of the Roman Empire under the Tetrarchs and Constantine
xxvii i
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
xxix
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information
A
fran
ius
=
(
1) E
utro
pia
(2)
=
(
2)
Max
imia
n* (
1) =
unk
now
n
Dio
clet
ian
=
Pris
ca
R
omul
a
Han
niba
lianu
s
(
r. [2
85–]
286–
305,
(r. 2
84–3
05)
30
6–30
8, 3
10)
Val
eria
=
(2)
Gal
eriu
s (1
)
=
unkn
own
da
ught
er(r
. [29
3–]3
05–3
11)
Hel
ena
=
(1)
Con
stan
tius
I Chl
orus
(2)
=
The
odor
a (?
)
T
heod
ora
(?)
(r. [
293–
]305
–306
)
(
adop
ted
by M
axim
ian)
Can
didi
anus
(
adop
ted
by V
aler
ia)
Min
ervi
na
=
(1)
Con
stan
tine
I (2
)
=
Fla
via
Max
ima
Max
entiu
s*
=
Val
eria
Max
imill
a M
axim
inus
Daz
a
(r. 3
06 [3
06–3
07] 3
07–3
37)
F
aust
a*
(r.
<30
6–31
2>)
(
r. [3
05–]
310–
313)
Val
eriu
s R
omul
us
F
l. D
alm
atiu
s†
Gal
la =
(1)
Jul
ius
Con
stan
tius
(2)
= B
asili
na
H
anni
balia
nus
C
onst
antia
=
Lic
iniu
s*
Eut
ropi
a =
Viri
us
A
nast
asia
= B
assi
anus
*
(di
ed y
oung
)
(r. 3
08–3
24)
Nep
otia
nus†
?
Lic
inia
nus
Lici
nius
*
Juliu
s N
epot
ianu
s
s
on†
Fl.
Dal
mat
ius†
(r. [
335–
337]
)
Cris
pus*
=
H
elen
a
C
onst
antin
e II
C
onst
ans
C
onst
antin
a =
(1)
Han
niba
lianu
s†
(r.
[317
–326
])
(r.
[317
–]33
7–34
0)
(
r. [3
33–]
337–
350)
(
Kin
g of
Kin
gs r.
[335
–337
])
= (
2) G
allu
s C
aesa
r
(r
. [35
1–35
4])
ch
ild
Hel
ena
=
Julia
n
(bo
rn 3
22)
(
r. [3
55–]
360–
363)
Con
stan
tius
II (
1)
=
D
augh
ter
(
r. [3
24–]
337–
361)
(
2) =
Eus
ebia
(
3) =
Fau
stin
a
Ke
y R
eign
ed a
s A
ugus
tus:
(r.
284–
305)
R
eign
ed a
s C
aesa
r: r.
[293
]
R
eign
not
rec
ogni
zed:
r. <
306–
312>
*
Con
stan
tine
invo
lve
d in
the
deat
h
† A
ssas
sina
ted
in 3
37
The
Fam
ilies
ofth
eTe
trar
chs
and
Con
stan
tine
xxx
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-76423-0 - Constantine, Divine Emperor of the Christian Golden AgeJonathan BardillFrontmatterMore information