compare and contrast
TRANSCRIPT
COMPARE: POINTING OUT SIMILARITIESCONTRAST: POINTING OUT
DIFFERENCES
Compare and Contrast
BLOCK STYLE
Discuss all details of item #1
Discuss all details of item #2
How similar? How different?
BLOCK STYLE
I. To Kill a Mockingbird A. Setting B. Defendant/ charged with C. Lawyer D. VerdictII. A Time to Kill A. Setting B. Defendant/ charged with C. Lawyer D. Verdict
To Kill a Mockingbird & A Time to Kill
POINT BY POINTI. Setting A. TKAM B. ATTKII. Defendants A. TKAM B. ATTKIII. Lawyers A. TKAM B. ATTKIV. Verdict A. TKAM B. ATTK
TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD
CONTRAST the NOVEL and the MOVIEWhich format is BEST suited?I. BLOCKII.POINT BY POINT
LOOK AT YOUR VENN DIAGRAMDo you have a balanced number similarities and differences?
Are there more similarities?Are there more differences?Analyze which are more important…the similarities or differences?
PICK A FORMAT
LOOK AT YOUR 3-COLUMNDo you have a balanced number of similarities and differences?
Are there more similarities?Are there more differences?Analyze which are more important.
PICK A FORMAT
TKAM/ATTKBalanced informationUse a point by point format for organizing
your details.THESIS STATEMENT-While these books have different settings
and different trials, both To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee and A Time to Kill by John Grisham involve cases where rape and racism are important elements.
TKAM: the novel/the movieThe main difference is plot; scenes are
omitted in the movie. You could list a few of these, but then what? List some scenes that are in both? Nah….
This wouldn’t involve much analysis!Could you discuss narration?Could you discuss visuals? Were you trying
to picture scenes in your mind as you read?
Block style might work best!What would your thesis statement be? In my opinion the book/movie is better than
the movie/book because …Be sure you do more than just list scenes
from the book that don’t make it into the movie.
You must discuss/elaborate!
To Kill a Mockingbird – 1960A Time to Kill - 1989
Compare – pointing out similaritiesContrast – pointing out differences
Compare and Contrast