comms 318 - final - dec 10
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
1/137
Contents
Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................ 1
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 4
Background ..................................................................................................................................... 6
Qualitative Section ........................................................................................................................ 17
Quantitative - Survey Research and Analysis ............................................................................... 24
Strategic Recommendations.......................................................................................................... 39
Conclusion and Recommendations ............................................................................................... 43
Appendix A ....................................................................................Error! Bookmark not defined.
Appendix B ................................................................................................................................... 45
Appendix C ................................................................................................................................... 76
Appendix D ................................................................................................................................... 95
Appendix E ................................................................................................................................. 103
http://c/Users/Shamo'/Downloads/Comms%20318%20-%20Final%20Project%20-%20Dec%202012.docx%23_Toc342847513http://c/Users/Shamo'/Downloads/Comms%20318%20-%20Final%20Project%20-%20Dec%202012.docx%23_Toc342847513http://c/Users/Shamo'/Downloads/Comms%20318%20-%20Final%20Project%20-%20Dec%202012.docx%23_Toc342847513 -
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
2/137
1
Executive Summary
Research Purpose
BYU Radio hired the Bradley Lab to conduct research to gain understanding of who
listens to BYU Radio, why they listen and how they listen. BYU Radio also wanted to know if
its content and relationship with listeners is effectively maximizing its potential as a missionary
tool for the LDS church. Currently, BYU Radio does not have any demographic information
concerning who its listener base is or why they listen. Programming decisions are based on
assumptions of what executives think their presumed audience will enjoy.
The core problem in our research lies in the discovery of three questions. Who is the
average BYU Radio listener, are listeners satisfied with current content, and is BYU Radio
successfully being implemented as a missionary tool?
Research Questions Answered
The Demographics ofBYU Radios Average Listener
Our qualitative research suggests that BYU Radio listeners are typically more than 50
years old with families, and have a household income of over $100,000 a year. In our
quantitative research though, we discovered the possibility of a younger audience base with over
80 percent of respondents with an annual household income of less than $100,000. This lower
age and income may be a result of the channel through which the quantitative research was
conducted. In both sets of data though, listeners were predominantly LDS, Caucasian and from
Utah.
Listener Satisfaction
When asked the question if listeners are satisfied with BYU Radios programming, only
51 percent responded that they were satisfied or very satisfied. Music, the programming genre
with the highest listenership also has the highest percentage of dissatisfaction. We also found
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
3/137
2
that the most popular programs were ones that BYU Radio rebroadcasted. Original programming
in comparison ranked in the bottom half in listener satisfaction levels.
BYU Radios Effectiveness as a Missionary Tool for theLDS Church
When asked the question if BYU Radio is an effective missionary tool, 48 percentof
listeners responded that they either agreed or strongly agreed. When asked the question if BYU
Radios current programming is likely to attract non-LDS listeners, only 31.8 percent of listeners
either agreed or strongly agreed. These numbers summarize the thoughts ofall five of the
individuals we interviewed in our qualitative data as well. Our net promoter score, which
measures the likelihood of customers referring friends to a service, is 24, on a scale of 100.
Research Methods Employed
Our research methods consisted of both qualitative and quantitative research allowing for
greater depth and understanding of BYU Radio listeners.
Qualitative ResearchPhone Interviews
Our qualitative research took the form of in-depth phone interviews with listeners whose
names were generated from a list provided by BYU Radio. We contacted these individuals and
gauged their interest in being interviewed with the incentive of a $25 Visa gift card. We then
conducted the interviews, with each one lasting between 10-30 minutes. The interviews were
recorded and coded according to a variety of themes.
Quantitative ResearchOnline Qualtrics Survey
Our class developed an online survey through Qualtrics software consisting of 29
questions designed to identify demographic information, what listeners preferred to listen to,
how listeners listen, and if listeners feel that BYU Radio is maximizing its potential as a
missionary tool. The survey was promoted primarily online. Because of this, we feel that survey
results could be skewed toward a younger audience. Only 83 listeners completed the survey,
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
4/137
3
meaning that results cannot be generalized for a population. The information obtained from the
survey results though is extremely valuable.
Important Discoveries of Research Results
In summary, three conclusions can be extracted from our research based on what we now
know. First, the average BYU Radio listener is LDS, Caucasian, from Utah and has children.
Second, only 51 percent of BYU Radio listeners were satisfied with current programming. Third,
BYU Radio is not likely to attract non-LDS listeners with its current programming.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
5/137
4
Introduction
BYU Radios Issue
BYU Radio is one of 140 other stations broadcast on Sirius XM satellite radio. BYU
Radio is a station focused on talking about the good in the world. Programs vary from original
content including talk shows such as Matt Townsend and Thinking Aloud to rebroadcast
programs such as Music and the Spoken Word and other religious devotionals and forums.
Research Questions
Due to the confidentiality of Sirius XMs contract with BYU Radio, little is known about
BYU Radios demographic and its breadth. Therefore, the three main concerns Don Shelline,
manager of BYU Radio, hired the Bradley Lab to identify through background research are the
1) demographic of the listeners of BYU Radio, 2) the satisfaction with the current content among
its listenership and 3) whether or not BYU is being implemented as an effective missionary tool.
Methodology
To generate a better understanding of BYU Radios audience we began our research by
conducting in-depth interviews over the phone to a list of BYU Radios listeners. We compiled
the results and conducted a thematic content analysis on the five phone calls we recorded,
ranking the most frequently mentioned topics regarding BYU Radio. The top four themes
mentioned by the listeners include access, music, time of day and talk.
Using the results from the qualitative research we compiled a quantitative survey asking
in-depth questions about the satisfaction with BYU Radios programming, the association with
non-LDS affiliates, recommendations and listenership demographics. The questions for the
survey were specifically formulated from the inferences and knowledge gained from the
qualitative in-depth interviews.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
6/137
5
Through IBMs SPSS, a data-analysis software, we found many patterns and correlations
associated with listenership and satisfaction. Due to the low number of responses, it was difficult
to deem some responses as statistically significant; however, through these patterns and positive
correlations, we were able to identify a few findings that we believe can be a positive asset for
the future of BYU Radio.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
7/137
6
Background
History
BYU Radio was formerly as Bonneville International LDS Radio, but was given to BYU
in 2002 (BYU Radio). Initially BYU Radio had three internet streams (in English, Portuguese
and Spanish), but the two international channels were discontinued this past year. BYU Radio
used to be a strictly Internet-streamed radio, but is now more commonly viewed as satellite radio
as it airs on both satellite radio and on satellite television services. The newly-acquired state-of-
the art equipment and facility has enabled BYU Radio to address and discuss numerous topics.
BYU Radios mission is to enrich lives by touching the minds, hearts, and souls of all its
viewers and listeners worldwide (BYU Radio). However, this wide-range of topics has not
created an apparent need for the station to specify and target specific audiences, which has
potentially decreased their pool of subscribers. While there are several full-time employees,
BYU Radio has access to numerous students for part-time hire. This demonstrates one of BYU
Radios functionsto employ a number of different students from various disciplines in order to
prepare them for future professional endeavors.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
8/137
7
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
State-of-the-aft facility
and resources
No prior reputation base
from past campaigns
Financial freedom of
BYU Radio
Cost of Sirius XM
Access to numerousfull-time and student
employees
Overly-broad in subjectmatter
Monopoly of Sirius XMon satellite radio
Local free radio stationswith similar
programming (KSL,KNRS, KCPW, etc.)
No real limitations onsubject matter
No knowledge oflistener base
18.5 million subscribersto Sirius XM
Ever-declining economy
Broadcast acrosssatellite, internet and
apps
Repetition in airedprogramming
Internet radioprovidessame services but for
freeEclectic range of
programsNo attainable
listenership data
Past Promotions
Due to tight restrictions from Sirius XM, BYU Radio has not been able to view a pattern
of its listeners because of Sirius closed guards dealing with its ratings. Therefore, little
knowledge is known about BYU Radios audience and supporters. BYU Radio is a non-
commercial, non-profit station. It is only made possible by BYU.
BYU Radios station, launched in 2002, began as a local, developing station. However, in
less than ten years, Sirius XM announced BYU Radio as one of five stations (Accompanied by
Howard University, Eventus/National Latino Broadcasting, WorldBand Media, KTV Radio) to
be broadcasted on its channel after a search to incorporate diverse entertainment content on
Sirius XM (Israelsen-Hartley, 2011). This promotion given to BYU Radio over 40 competing
stations, enabled BYU Radio to broadcast 5,000 hours annually to an audience of 20 million
people (Harper, 2011).
BYU Radio broadcasts a variety of shows such as religious firesides, devotionals,
symposiums, religious music, BYU sports, family messages, cooking shows, etc. BYU Radios
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
9/137
8
purpose for broadcast is to spread good to both Latter-day Saints and non-Latter-day Saints alike.
With the exception of Deseret News, there is little information regarding other third party
sources promoting BYU Radio.
Social Media is the current communications force BYU Radio is engaging in to maintain
and foster an interactive relationship with its current viewers. BYU Radio posts constant feeds
both on its Twitter and Facebook page. BYU Radios presence on Facebook began on August 1,
2002. The page is currently owned and updated by Christopher Hoffmann.
BYU Radios self-description on its homepage is BYU Radio produces and airs good
entertainment that is enjoyed by people from all over the world. The type of entertainment
provided includes sporting events, interviews with some of the most influential people, live
musical performances, and many other radio programs.
The purpose of BYU Radios presence on Facebook is to create a place where current
viewers can interact with each other and the station. As of October 9, 2012, there were 5,197
likes and 433 people talking about BYU Radio. The conversations regarding BYU Radios
Facebook page fluctuates depending upon the newsfeed. Several weeks later, on September 25,
2012 there were 620 people talking about BYU Radio, almost two hundred more individuals
talking about BYU Radio than in October. Depending on what is posted in the newsfeed, a
different level of interaction among its viewers is fostered.
In order to satisfy BYU Radios purpose, encouraging interaction, much of the posts
include activities and thought-provoking insights for its viewers to enjoy. These posts include
exercises such as animal searches within an abstract picture, thought-provoking questions to
engage debates, inspirational quotes from Pinterest, as well as reminders for upcoming football
games or apps to download, such as the BYU Radio App.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
10/137
9
Solely in the month of September, up until the 25th, there were 1,764 comments and likes,
accompanied by 257 pictures posted on the Facebook page. The number of pictures is
consistently growing because a majority of the posts published on the homepage incorporate a
picture accompanied with a caption. One downfall to this heavy strive for consumer interaction,
the content being published is generally unrelated to BYU Radio.
In the month of September, BYU Radios Twitter account reported tweeting a total of
805 tweets, acquiring 353 followers and following 252 other Twitter accounts. A few weeks
later, BYU Radios Twitter account tweeted 816 times, followed one less account than in
September (251) and accumulated 23 more followers (376 followers). The content of BYU
Radios tweets deal primarily with sports. These tweets include random updates of football and
soccer games, reports of athletes injuries and celebrations of team wins.
Programming
BYU Radio broadcasts a variety of shows including religious firesides and devotionals,
symposiums, religious music, BYU sports, family messages, cooking shows, etc. This
programming could be categorized
into genres of miscellaneous talk,
religion, music, lifestyle and sports.
With these genres decided on we
categorized each program offered by
BYU Radio into one of these
categories. We then used the weekly
schedule given to us by BYU Radio to add up the number of hours devoted to each genre. With
the total number of hours in a given week for each genre we could divide them by the total
24%
1%
31%13%
31%
Percentage of Time-- Full
week
Lifestyle
Sports
Religion
Music
Misc. Talk
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
11/137
10
25%
1%
17%
16%
41%
Percentage of Time-- Weekday
Lifestyle
Sports
Religion
Music
Misc. Talk
number of hours to get a percentage of time devoted to each. The genres of talk and religion
dominate the programming over the space of a week, but this may be deceiving as religion is
played for all 24 hours on Sunday. To account for this additional caused by Sunday
programming we calculated the numbers again, but only adding the time during weekdays for the
genres and then dividing by the number of hours from Monday through Friday. This changed the
top genres with Lifestyle and Talk being the two biggest parts of programming during weekdays.
Although only slightly represented, Sports is also a large portion of programming but the
scheduling varies because of the nature of sports schedules.
Breakdown of Programming by Genre
LifestyleThese shows talk about everyday life events from cooking to traveling. They are
designed to help others better themselves and their families. Shows include Eyres on the Road
Parenting in the Modern World, Living Essentials, Real Families Real Answers, and The Food
Nanny.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
12/137
11
SportsProgramming of this sort includes all types of BYU Sports games. The programming
varies with the season and times and broadcast schedules vary as well. The constant in the sports
is weekly talk show True Blue, which discusses BYU sports from the previous week and gives a
look at the week ahead.
ReligionReligion we classified as all programming dedicated in large part to The Church of
Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints and its doctrine. Programming includes genealogical and
scriptural subjects along with historical stories from past members. These are shows such as
Ancestors, History of the Saints, Music and the Spoken Word, Road to Zion, and Scripture
Roundtable.
MusicThese are shows dedicated entirely to music and musicians. Shows include Highway 89
and The Tantara Hour hosted by Ron Simpson.
Miscellaneous TalkThese are talk shows that can change from topic to topic each day.
Therefore they cannot be classified as any other specific programming, but in a given day they
may be religious in nature and on another they may be more lifestyle in nature. These shows
include The Morning Show, Insights and The Matt Townsend Show.
ResourcesIn the fall of 2010, BYU Broadcasting completed work on its new state-of-the-art facility.
The 100,000 square foot facility is now the new home for all of BYU Radio. BYU Radios new
facility has two on-air rooms (one for BYU Radio and one for Classical 89). Attached to these
rooms are small producer news rooms. BYU Radio also has two small post audio rooms, a
recording studio, 260-seat theater and access to all three television studios. Both the recording
studio and theater have the ability to go live on air at a moments notice (Scherer, 2011). The
following statement is found on BYU Broadcastings home page regarding resources:
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
13/137
12
The activities and educational resources of Brigham Young University serve as the
primary source of content for television and radio productions; however, BYUB also
partners with independent producers from around the world to create and distribute
values-based programming to appeal to its ever-expanding audiences. Ultimately, each
program supported by BYU Broadcasting seeks to enrich lives by touching the minds,
hearts, and souls of all its viewers and listeners worldwide. (BYU Radio)
BYU Radio is available on Dish Network (channel 980), Sirius XM Radio (channel 143),
Internet, cable systems and satellite. Sirius XM distributes to more than 22 million listeners and
can broadcast to more than 800 different devices. In conjunction with automobiles, Sirius also
works with various marketing partnerships and hardware manufacturers to ensure its broadcast
can be heard all over the world (Sirius). Sirius has more than 180 satellite radio channels and has
become the largest radio company in the United States. Last year Sirius XM brought in over $3
billion dollars in sales surpassing Clear Channel Media, the previous market leader in the radio
industry.
Personnel
At BYU Radio, personnel is compiled of individuals who work for a larger organization
within BYU Broadcasting. The following is a screen shot of the top-tier management for BYU
Broadcasting:
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
14/137
13
History of Issue
According to a press release issued by Sirius in August of 2012, Sirius XM radios are
now installed in more than 50 million vehicles. This year, 70 percent of all vehicles sold in the
United States will come installed with Sirius XM Radio. Sirius XM Radio was launched 10 years
ago and is the worlds largest radiobroadcaster measured by revenue (Sirius, 2012). Sirius XM
Radio is the only company that has FCC licenses to the requisite spectrum and is the only
company that provides satellite transmissions to car radios in the US (Seeking Alpha, 2010).
BYU Radio was founded as a web stream in August of 2002. Originally the station had
been known as Bonneville International LDS Radio Network. Bonneville International
transferred ownership of the station to BYU, which has continued to add programming. In the
fall of 2011, BYU Radio was added to Sirius XM Satellite Radio (Hartley, 2011).
In a study conducted by the Council for Research Excellence, satellite-radio subscribers
listen to satellite-radio the most at home. The study does not take in to account satellite-radio that
has been streamed via the Internet (Palenchar, 2010).
Location Percent
Home 29.5%
Work 23.1%
Car 21.4%
Source: Palenchar
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
15/137
14
Below is a breakdown of how much Sirius XM Radio costs per month:
Plan Number of
Channels
Base Monthly
Price
Base Price
For 1 Year
Base+Internet
Per Month
Base+Internet
For 1 Year
Sirius Premier 140+ $17.99 $215.88 $21.49 $257.88
Sirius Select 130+ $14.49 $173.88 $17.99 $215.88
Sirius XM Internet 130+ $14.49 $173.88 - -
Source: siriusxm.com
After researching sites such as bestbuy.com, most Sirius XM receivers cost somewhere
between $60-100.
According to information released by Sirius to Bryan Katrek, the lead anchor for the
PGA Tour Network (Katrek, 2012), the typical Sirius listener fits a very particular profile.
Generally the typical Sirius listener is a wealthy male with a college degree.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
16/137
15
Industry
A major factor in the satellite radio industry is the status of the current economy.
Although the United States has technically been out of a recession since 2009, the economy is
still very weak. The number of Americans that have a job or are looking for one fell to 63.5
percent of available workers, the lowest percentage since 1981. Of those people, 8.3 percent are
currently unemployed(Reuters, 2012). A large number of Americans are unemployed,
underemployed, and lacking expendable income. As the economy continues in this recession,
retention of listeners will decrease as they will not renew their satellite radio services after the
free trial because they can get free radio through conventional means. These services include free
streaming apps like Pandora and iHeartRadio along with FM and AM radio.
Past Measurements
Ten years ago, Satellite Radio aspired to possess 1 percent of all listeners. Today, according
to Arbitrons Radio Today (2011), 93 percent of the population listens to broadcast 14.3 hours a
week. According to Bridge Ratings, 9 percent of the population listens to Satellite Radio 8.3
hours per week (Johnson, 2011).
FCC created satellite radio broadcasting in 1992. XM and Sirius bid the two highest bids and
consequently received the license to produce satellite radio stations. XM officially launched its
station in 2001 and Sirius launched in 2002. Over the past ten years, each station has mounted to
several million subscribers (Daugherty, 2007).
Sirius Satellite Radio and XM Satellite Radio joined forces in 2007. Combined, Sirius
XM Radio, the station was set to rank as the second-largest U.S. radio organization, providing
more than 300 programs to 18.5 million subscribers. The combination of the two stations brought
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
17/137
16
about controversy among the FCC, who previously designated two stations to control the field of
satellite radio to generate competition (Kawamoto, 2008).
Sirius XM reports the viewership and revenue for its station annually. These numbers are
tolled from subscribers (prepaid, discounted pricing plans, regular pricing plan, etc.). With the
presence of Sirius XM in automobiles, subscribers are also counted with the sale of vehicles.
Sirius XM also counted subscribers from the Internet and other data sources. However, the
predominant source of subscribers comes from paid fees.
Sirius XM reports the viewership and investor growth annually. Coming from Sirius
XMs quarterly and final reports as seen from their Annual Reports under Investor Relations
(http://investor.siriusxm.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=698545):
http://investor.siriusxm.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=698545http://investor.siriusxm.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=698545http://investor.siriusxm.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=698545http://investor.siriusxm.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=698545 -
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
18/137
17
Qualitative Section
Describe Qualitative Methodology
The collected data was gathered through qualitative research, or in-depth interviews.
Qualitative research is a flexible, time-efficient way to gather information from a respondent.
Unlike quantitative research, qualitative is a dialogue between the interviewer/focus group leader
and the participants. It is a better method when trying to understand how to improve a product or
service, taking away the risk of limited and potentially misinterpreted responses gathered from a
survey or poll. As a result, this structure of research enabled our team to form a better survey,
with more accurate questions giving us better results.
Participants for the interviews were located all over the country; therefore, conducting
focus groups was not a viable way to gather the qualitative research. Consequently, we decided
in-depth interviews on the telephone were the best alternative to focus groups.
As a class, we divided a list of 65 BYU Radio listeners into four parts. Each team was
responsible for contacting a portion of the list. We sent an email to 14 listeners informing them
of an opportunity to receive a $25 gift card in return for participating in an in-depth interview
over the phone. Each of the four groups in the class was responsible for contacting and
interviewing five of the listeners. Messages via Facebook were also sent out to ask for volunteers
to participate in this study. As a team we gathered four participants from the list and one from
Facebook.
Once a BYU Radio listener agreed to participate, a time was set to conduct the
interview over the phone. Based upon scheduling, members of the team volunteered to conduct
the interview. Before every interview, the student prefaced that the conversation would be
recorded with a tape recorder so the information received from the interview could be
transcribed. All of the transcripts are attached at the end of the report.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
19/137
18
As a team, we established a blueprint for the interview. This included both a set of
questions to ask and information to tell the participant sometime throughout the course of the
interview. We also asked personalized follow-up questions which resulted in an opportunity to
elaborate on a concern or suggestion. The goal of the interview was to be as transparent as
possible. We wanted honest suggestions of ways to improve the fan-base for BYU Radio. The
questions dealt primarily with radio content and demographic information.
After the interview, each participant received a $25 Visa gift card in the mail as an
incentive for his or her feedback. The interviews were then transcribed from the tape recorders
onto the computer. We collected the interviews and conducted a thematic content analysis, the
process of underlying the reoccurring themes or most often talked about subjects regarding BYU
Radio. As a result, we identified nine overall themes based upon the content and suggestions
given. We then color-coded the themes to identify the most dominant themes from the five
transcripts. For example, dialogue regarding talk shows was labeled yellow. We counted the
number of times a respondent mentioned either positive or negative feedback about talk shows
and totaled it on the transcripts.
Analysis of Qualitative Data
From our analysis we have determined that our main interviews focused on ways in
which BYU Radio listeners access BYU Radio and the choice of music selection by most
listeners. After careful analysis we determined that BYU Radio listeners were also interested in
religion, various programs, and customer service.
We discovered that of the five listeners we interviewed, most access BYU Radio through
Sirius XM satellite radio while driving in their vehicle. BYU Radios current publics tend to
listen sporadically throughout the week with a few of them who listen to set programs while
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
20/137
19
driving to and from various activities. The listeners that we interviewed all felt that although
BYU offers a variety of programs, most listen to religious programs or repeat devotionals, CES
Firesides, or other religious oriented programming. Many of our listeners liked listening to the
mix of radio that was being produced before the switch was made to more talk radio. Now most
of BYU Radios clients would like to listen to more music with a good balance of talk in
between.
From our interviews, we have concluded that most of our interviewees tune in because of
their affiliation with the LDS faith or BYU. Most of our interviewees said that if they were not
LDS they would not listen to BYU Radio. We have also concluded that while BYU Radio is
accessible through various outlets it is still hard for a few of its customers to interact and work
with personnel from BYU Radio to either request songs or give commentary. Two of our
interviewees said that although BYU Radio personnel is very helpful, at times they seem to be
spread a little too thin. Some of our interviewees also suggested updates to the website such as
contact information and program descriptions. Although BYU Radio offers a variety of different
sports programs many of its listeners go elsewhere to listen to sports. In short, BYU Radios
current listener base appreciates the content and programming of its station, yet there is still
room for improvement if BYU Radio hopes to expand its reach to those not of the LDS Faith
across the country.
Primary Themes
There are a number of different topics that were discussed throughout the in-depth
interviews that developed into prominent common themes between the different listeners. These
top themes were access, music, time of day, talk and religion.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
21/137
20
Access (29)
This was the dominant theme that was brought up in all of the in-depth interviews. Most
of the commentary in regard to this subject was informative and described how and where
subscribers listened to BYU Radio. Most listeners that were interviewed had a subscription to
Sirius XM and they listened it to it while they were in their car driving.
However, the younger demographic tended to access the programming online or via the
BYU Radio app. One listener even suggested that BYU Radio should make it be available in
MP3 format instead of streaming. This way it can be downloaded and listened to, and played in a
church class, or other places and times. If it is streaming, you always have to have Internet access
and that is not always convenient. There seemed to be two distinct ways to access BYU Radio
(online vs. Sirius) and each seemed to attract and cater to two very different demographics.
Music (27)
While music is only a portion of what is broadcast on BYU Radio, many listeners
explained that they did not listen for the music, but that they listened for various talk shows. If
music was playing on the channel when they tuned in, they might listen to it, but again, it was
not their primary purpose.
As a younger listener, one interviewee commented, students are more interested in
music that I dont think they would play on BYU Radio. Like what type of music would they
play, church music?
Time of Day (26)
This was another prevalent theme that was discussed in the interviews and the results
varied. Some people listened to it while they were driving home from work, running errands, as
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
22/137
21
an alarm clock in the morning, etc. Most listeners that were interviewed accessed the channel on
a relatively consistent basis (every day or a couple times a week).
One listener mentioned that it was occasionally frustrating for him because he listens at
similar times every day and programs are often repeated during the same time slots, so he ends
up listening to the something hes already heard before. Some of it I wish they wouldnt repeat
very much. Like some of the choir broadcasts Im like, we just heard that 4 weeks ago.
Talk(18)
Of the two interviewees that mentioned talk radio, one loved it while the other viewed it
as secondary to mainstream national talk radio shows. The interviewee in favor of talk radio,
Vaylene Tucker, particularly enjoyed Matt Townsends show. Vaylene said, Its like education
because I learn about how to treat my teenagers. I learn about parenting. Today they were talking
about personal image and my teenage daughter is really into that. It pertains to me. A lot of the
things pertain to what Im experiencing.
The one interviewee opposed to talk radio, Jerry Hall, was mainly voicing his concern
that BYU Radio is now a variety show, because he used to listen to BYUs classical music
channel frequently.
Religion (15)
This was another primary theme in the interviews because every interviewee responded
that they associated BYU Radio with the LDS faith. When they were asked if they thought
people from other faiths would listen to it, most interviewees made the comment that other
listeners would make a similar association that they did.
For the most part, listeners appreciated that BYU was related to the Mormon faith. I like
that because I like how they embrace their purpose. However, one listener noted, I just think
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
23/137
22
they could be like a little looser about it. Im totally fine with the LDS focus, just would think it
would be cooler if they were a little bolder maybe in some stuff, and talked about some stuff they
might avoid because they dont evenwant to reach a potential controversy.
Secondary Themes
After recognizing our primary themes, we were able to identify four secondary themes
that support the primary, and give more insight into how interviewers feel. The four secondary
themes that we identified were lifestyle, customer service, price and sports.
Lifestyle(14)
Lifestyle programs appear to be more popular, especially as a secondary theme or priority
for listeners. The Wheatley Institution was a particular strong point for two of our interviewees.
Vaylena Tucker said, Im really interested in educational shows that teach me
something. I love the Wheatley series because it keeps me up on current events and helps me
understand whats going on in the world.
Respondents seemed inclined to enjoy lifestyle shows, especially the Wheatley Institute
and the food shows. Lifestyle though remains secondary to other bigger topics that came up.
Customer Service6
Some interviewees were unsatisfied with the quality of their signal. They were convinced
that other Sirius XM channels came in clearly, while BYU Radio had continuous problems.
One customer, George Larsen, responded, I try to tell them about it by email and theyre
like it could just be your receiver. And Im like, no, its not my receiver, its your connection that
dropped off, not me.
Overall however, this issue was only brought up by two of our five respondents that we
interviewed. The other three customers we interviewed were happy with the quality of their
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
24/137
23
equipment and signal from BYU Radio. Some customers went out of their way to express
appreciation for the overall quality of program that BYU Radio puts together.
Price (4)
The price of a subscription to BYU Radio did not seem to be a legitimate factor for
listeners, most likely because they already had a subscription and as a result were current
listeners. However, one interviewee commented, I like the fact that its on the Internet and I can
also get it for free. I really like that a lot.
SportsSecondary 4
When the topic ofsports was mentioned, the overall consensus was that it wasnt a
priority for the average BYU Radio listener. Two respondents, one being Jerry Hall, gave an
almost identical response, No, Im not interested in sports radio. If I am going to watch sports,
Ill watch TV.
The other respondent, JohnCharles, also commented that he would specifically watch the
BYU team on BYU TV. These types of responses came from individuals that identified
themselves as both sports fans and non-sports fans.
One individual, Austin Peterson, mentioned that he liked the idea of BYU Radio playing
all different types of BYU sporting events, but didnt admit to actually listening to any of them.
Our conclusion is that sports were not a priority for the customers we listened to.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
25/137
24
Quantitative - Survey Research and Analysis
Methodology
After we conducted in-depth interviews with current listeners of BYU Radio we built a
survey around the results we found. Our class was divided into four different groups and was
tasked to create questions that would give us a better look at what current listening habits of
BYU Radio listeners and suggestions for improvement regarding programming.
After careful deliberation, we narrowed our survey down to 29 questions. We used
Qualtrics, a survey software company, to build and host our survey. The survey began by stating
our purpose for the questionnaire and informing willing participants they would be entered in a
drawing for prizes such as gift baskets and $25 iTunes gift cards donated from BYU Radio.
The survey consisted of demographic questions such as age, gender and residence.
Demographic questions were included in the survey in order to get a better idea of who was
listening to BYU Radio. The survey also asked questions pertaining to programming preferences,
customer service/communication and ifBYU Radios association with the LDS faith is being
used as a missionary tool.
The survey was promoted through BYU Radio programming, BYU Radios website,
social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter and the BYUTV blog. Participants could click
on a link found on the various channels that would take them directly to the survey.
Below is an example of a link found on Facebook:
Take this BYU Radio survey for your chance to win a $25 iTunes gift card or BYUtv gift-set!!
And help us improve the quality of our Radio Programming. Please click here:
https://byu.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_6nRLUgWdOtFiLVr
https://byu.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_6nRLUgWdOtFiLVrhttps://byu.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_6nRLUgWdOtFiLVrhttps://byu.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_6nRLUgWdOtFiLVrhttps://byu.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_6nRLUgWdOtFiLVrhttps://byu.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_6nRLUgWdOtFiLVr -
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
26/137
25
Sample Selection, Sample Size, and Margin of Error
Our results derive from 83 participants who completed 100 percent of the survey. Of
these 83 participants, 54 percent were male and 46 percent were female. Although we had 83
people complete the survey, the sample size is too small to calculate a 95 percent confidence
interval. Also, due to the lack of participants, it was impossible to calculate a margin of error.
Nevertheless, our team was still able to find significant data from the results of the survey.
Missionary Tool
One of the major topics we wanted to learn more about through the survey was how
effective BYU Radio was as a missionary tool. We found a majority of the respondents are of the
LDS faith or have family or friends who are affiliated with BYU. Only four respondents were
not affiliated with BYU in any way. This demographic shows the trend of an almost exclusive
listenership of members of the church. We also measured the net promoter score for BYU Radio,
which measures the likelihood of a listener referring BYU Radio to others. The net promoter
score for BYU Radio is 24 out of 100. A healthy net promoter score lies above 50 percent. This
shows that listeners are not promoting the station to others.
When specifically asked whether a respondent disagreed or agreed with the statement
BYU Radios current programming is likely to attract non-LDS listeners, there is an even
distribution of respondents both agreeing and disagreeing. The majority of respondents neither
agreed nor disagreed with the statement, and only a handful of respondents strongly disagreed
or agreed with the statement (see graph on next page). This tells us that the programming is
currently not serving its purpose as effectively preaching the gospel to those of other faiths.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
27/137
26
To what extent do you agree with the following statement: BYU Radios current
programming is likely to attract non-LDS listeners.
When the respondents were asked if BYU Radio could be an effective missionary tool for
the LDS church, the distribution wasnt as even as the question asking respondents opinions
regarding BYU Radios attraction to non-LDS listeners. Most of the respondents answered
indifferently, they neither agreed nor disagreed with the statement. Combined with those who
said it was ineffective it made a majority of 52 percent. Only 48 percent believed it was an
effective missionary tool (see graph below).
Do you feel that BYU Radio is utilized as an effective missionary tool for the LDS church?
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
28/137
27
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Listens for Devotionals/Inspirational
Messages
What extent they believe
BYU Radio is accomplishing
its purpose as a missionary
tool
As a follow-up question at the end of the survey the respondents were asked to contribute
any feedback to better improve BYU Radio. Many of the recommendations insisted on
incorporating more LDS content into the programming. The respondents want to center the
programming around the LDS Church rather than BYU campus. By centering around church
news, many respondents hope this will create a more global and international approach to the
programming therefore improving the likelihood of BYU Radio being utilized as a missionary
tool.
We conducted crosstabs and ran a T-test measuring the correlation between what
programming the respondents listened to and whether or not they believed BYU Radio is utilized
as a missionary tool. All the graphs featured below prove to be significant figures. The
respondents who tuned in for music and devotionals or inspirational messages were more likely
to believe that BYU Radio could be utilized as a missionary tool (see graphs below).
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
29/137
28
02468
101214
1618
Listens for Music
What extent they believe
BYU Radio is accomplishing
its purpose as a missionary
tool
0
2
46
8
10
12
14
16
Doesn't listen for Music
What extent they believe
BYU Radio is
accomplishing its purpose
as a missionary tool
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
30/137
29
The program preferences have a correlation with the respondents opinions regarding the
effectiveness as a missionary tool. To better illustrate the significance of the program
preferences, the crosstab between respondents who listen for talk shows compared with
respondents who do not listen for talk shows is featured below. Respondents who listen for talk
shows are much more likely to believe BYU Radio is effectively utilized as a missionary tool
(see graph below). This shows that listeners believe the content is what makes a useful
missionary tool. If programming were more tied to the context of the gospel as listeners
suggested the trends suggest more listeners would see it as a missionary tool.
Satisfaction with Programming
We also asked respondents to rate their satisfaction with various aspects relating to BYU
Radio such as customer service, accessibility and convenience. For example, 60 percent of BYU
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Strongly
disagree
Disagree Neither Agree
nor Disagree
Agree Strongly Agree
What extent they believe BYU Radio is
accomplishing its purpose as a
missionary tool
Doesn't listen for Talk Shows Listens for Talk Shows
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
31/137
30
Radios listeners found BYU convenient, and 56 percent found it accessible. When asked about
satisfaction among BYU Radios programming, only 51 of the respondents were either satisfied
or very satisfied. Though there were fewer respondents identifying themselves as dissatisfied
listeners of BYU Radios programming, many remained neutral. A neutral respondent in a sense
can be identified as a negative respondent because there is no relationship binding them to the
programs. The graph below dictates the satisfaction level listeners have regarding the various
aspects relating to BYU Radio (see graphs below).
Then we asked listeners specifically about satisfaction among the specific programs BYU
Radio offers. Although the various programs have different levels of listeners, every program
had at least three people who listened to the program at least once. The most frequently listened
to program was Music and the Spoken Word.
Generally speaking, most of the responses indicate a satisfaction with the programming
themes of BYU Radio: News, Talk Shows, General Conference, Devotionals/inspirational
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
32/137
31
content, sports. Dealing strictly with the content of the programs, the most dissatisfaction
occurred among the original programs compared to the broadcasted programs.
The highest dissatisfaction among a particular genre of BYU Radios programming dealt
with the music content. Ironically, 59 percent of BYU Radios listeners tune into BYU Radio to
listen to music; however, it generates the highest dissatisfaction at 13 percent. Many of the
recommendations regarding the programming included suggestions to improve the music
broadcast. There is a demand for music among listenership, but there is also an opportunity for
BYU Radio to improve the music programming to better satisfy those listeners.
As mentioned before, much of the recommendations from listeners involve improving the
talk show content as well as the news section of BYU Radio. These two themes were also a point
of target in the commentary when respondents were asked in a follow-up question asking for
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
33/137
32
feedback regarding the programming. Comments included such things as, I used to Love BYU
Radio, but all the talk shows are boring and uninspirational, News: how about real news, not
recaps from other news sources, or Seems very bland and not very current.
Who is BYU Radios Average Listener
Although we were able to see statistical significance in our results, our sample size was
small, meaning we have a low confidence level for how widespread these results would be in a
larger sample size. However, we were still able to identify some important trends in the
characteristics of listeners. Based on the results of the administered survey, we determined that
the average subscriber was LDS, Caucasian and the majority (over 80 percent) of BYU Radio
listeners had an annual household income of less than $100,000. However, since the results for
other demographic factors, like gender and age, were relatively evenly distributed for each
subcategory (apart from the tail-end age groups), no other category was a dominant factor in
identifying listenership.
Ethnicity and ReligionOur research indicated a lack of ethnic diversity in listenership.
The overwhelmingly predominant ethnicity of BYU Radio listeners was Caucasian at nearly 70
percent of all respondents. The second highest ethnicity was Asian which is under 10 percent.
Additionally, almost 90 percent of the survey respondents were LDS. Most of the respondents of
the survey were from Utah, so these results are reflective of the Utah demographic (see graphs
on next page).
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
34/137
33
Income -- In regards to income levels, the most common income of listeners was in the
category of under $50,000 with the second most common category being $50,000-99,999. This
was surprising, because after conducting our initial background research, we expected most BYU
Radio listeners to be in the higher income brackets, as subscribers of Sirius/XM tend to be. The
numbers may also be a result of advertising the survey on social media sites, which attracts a
younger audience. This younger audience is more likely to listen through online streaming and
does not typically subscribe to Sirius/XM Radio. BYU Radio needs to tap more into a Sirius/XM
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
35/137
34
listenership because they represent the national audience you are looking for. For this reason,
those in the upper income brackets are an important target audience that needs to be addressed by
BYU Radio.
Gender -- Based on our results, we discovered that although male listeners outweighed
female listeners 57percent to 43 percent, there really is no statistical significance to men listening
at a greater value than women, so this is not a factor in listenership.
However, we did learn that men, more than women, tend to listen on the weekends and
during the 6 pm to midnight time slot, whereas women tend to listen more often in the mornings
between 6 am and noon. This could be a result of the programming on at these hours. Evenings
have more sports programming which is appealing to males.
We learned that there was no significant difference between male and female listening
habits relating to the different programs, except for when it came to sports. In the sports
category, over 60 percent of the male listeners listen to sports broadcast, but less than 20 percent
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
36/137
35
of women tune into sports programming. So although the males could be explained by sports,
why females tend to listen in the morning could not be answered by our research.
Age -- The age groups that we analyzed were divided into seven different categories.
Aside from the tail-end groups of the sample size (under 20, and 70-79), most of the other groups
are evenly important for listeners for BYU Radio.
Based on the results from our survey, the age group that most commonly listens to sports
programming is the age group of 20-39, while in comparison, the age group that commonly
listens to Talk Radio are those in the age group of 40-59.
In terms of how the audience accesses BYU Radio, over 65 percent of listeners listen to
BYU Radio via the live stream online, with the remainder of listeners tuning in via Sirius XM.
Interestingly, all 65 percent of respondents that accessed the live stream online were in the age
category of 20-39. (See graph on next page)
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
37/137
36
Does BYU Radio Communicate Well with its Audience?
In reviewing the high satisfaction levels in questions related to customer service,
promotional efforts and social media, we were able to conclude that communications with BYU
Radios audience is already incredibly successful.
In regard to customer service, many of our participants appreciated the way in which
BYU Radio ran its operations. About 41 percent were satisfied with BYU Radios customer
service with a small margin being unsatisfied. Many participants appreciated the quick response
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
38/137
37
from BYU Radio personnel but felt the accessibility of BYU Radio could improve. After
analyzing our survey we realized that BYU Radio has lacked past promotional value. We feel
that more promotions will increase listener participation and ultimately broaden the listener base.
Many of our participants felt that BYU Radios social media sites could improve in some
way or another. Of those that took the survey, 86 percent suggested that BYU Radio increase its
use of visual aids. Second to visual aids, promotions and the ability to request songs straight
from the social media site were the next highest request from listeners. From the survey we
discovered that most individuals wanted to see an improvement on-line with social media. We
also found most of the respondents that took our survey have not used social media and would be
open to trying it out if introduced to it (see graph below). Effective use of social media could be
key in increasing following.
Conclusion
The results varied from our predictions. Unfortunately, the responsiveness to our survey was
not as large as we initially anticipated. With only 83 survey participants, it is difficult to make any
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
39/137
38
concrete, significant statements. However, there are beneficial suggestions and data BYU Radio can
consider to improve its station.
The general demographic is Caucasian of an LDS faith with an income less than $100,000.
There were more male participants than female. The two most popular age group respondents
included 20-29 and 50-59 year-olds.
As a whole, a majority of the participants do not consider BYU Radio an effective missionary
tool. The programming is mildly appreciated, but listeners suggest real news regarding the LDS
church and its international affairs. Most of the indifference and negativity revolve around news and
talk shows. As mentioned above, customer satisfaction levels with social media, customer relations
and promotions in relation to BYU Radio were all favorable or neutral.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
40/137
39
Strategic RecommendationsSWOT Analysis
After conducting our background and primary research, we developed a new SWOT
analysis to better display strengths of BYU Radio, weaknesses and areas for growth.
Situation Analysis:
BYU Radio was formerly known as Bonneville International LDS Radio, but was given
to BYU in 2002 (BYU Radio). Due to BYU Radios similar nature in messaging to LDS Radio,
BYU Radio has been able to sustain the same relatively loyal listener-base that was formerly
listening to LDS Radio. In the turnover from LDS Radio to BYU Radio, BYU Radio sought to
differentiate itself from its former patron and provided a wide variety of programming for its
audience. BYU Radio used to be a strictly Internet-streamed radio, but is now more commonly
viewed as satellite radio as it airs on both satellite radio and on satellite television services. The
newly-acquired state-of-the art equipment and facility has enabled BYU Radio to address and
discuss numerous topics. BYU Radio broadcasts a wide-range of programming subjects;
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
-Already existingcustomer base
-No significant pastpromotional efforts
-Social media expansionand use as missionarytool
-LDS Stereotype
-Customer Service -Doesnt relate tonon-LDS listeners
-Expand listener base tonon-LDS listeners
-Cost of Sirius XM
-Accessible froma number ofdifferent sources
-Lack of popularityfor originalprogramming
-Develop originalprogramming
-Pandora/Spotify/podcasts(create your radio profile)
-Religious content(namerecognition)
-Dissatisfaction withprogramming ingeneral
-Devote more time topopular programming
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
41/137
40
including sports, talk radio, music, and religious discussion. BYU Radios current threats include
being stereotyped as an exclusively Latter-day Saint station. More importantly, listeners are
currently dissatisfied with programming.
BYU Radios ability and resources to expand, coupled with the fact that Americans are
spending an increased amount of time with media, provides a good opportunity for BYU Radio.
However, competing radio stations and online streaming channels pose a viable threat to the
audience expansion of BYU Radio. In order to be successful with its current audience and future
audiences, BYU Radio needs to utilize its resources as a missionary tool.
Core Problem/Opportunity
If BYU Radio does not accept its purpose as a missionary tool while satisfying current
listeners, then future development for building and attracting relationships with new listeners
will be hindered.
Recommendations
From our research, we have generated four strategic recommendations that we encourage
BYU Radio to consider and implement moving forward.
1) Improve social media content as a missionary tool-- One recommendation we felt
would greatly improve the quality of BYU Radio is to improve the social media content for its
listeners. To keep in line with the desire for BYU Radio to be a stronger missionary tool for the
LDS church, we recommend that BYU Radio shift its messaging to focus more heavily on LDS
related material. Having more LDS related content on BYU Radios social media will generate a
stronger brand image for the organization as a whole. 31.8 percent of listeners either agree or
strongly agree that BYU Radio does not attract non-LDS listeners. Consequently, BYU Radio
should take advantage of the opportunity to promote missionary content. In conjunction with
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
42/137
41
LDS themed material on BYU Radios social media sites, we also suggest an increase in two-
way communication between BYU Radio and its listeners. We suggest that BYU Radio monitor
its social media sites to actively engage its listeners because 54 percent of current listenersare
not aware that BYU Radio has a Facebook page or Twitter account. If BYU Radio can increase
its social media presence and actively engage its listeners, it will in turn be able to take
advantage of search engine optimization and increase its brand recognition in hopes of attracting
a larger audience.
2) Reach a broader base through featuring non-LDS speakers -- We recommend that in
an attempt to reach a broader listener base, BYU Radio bring in non-LDS speakers to talk about
various faith promoting materials. We feel that this recommendation will help increase traffic of
BYU Radio and promote better relationships with other religions and have a wider reach in the
United States. This recommendation is meant to bring in a larger audience base for BYU Radio.
One of BYU Radios main goals was to increase its listener base outside of Utah and attract
listeners from all religions. Most religions are seeking opportunities to share their message with
others. This shows a measure of good will with the LDS faith and may increase listenership if
listeners are aware that BYU Radio offers a large variety of other faith based programs.
3) Develop original programming in consideration of listener preferences -- According
to our research, only 51 percent of the surveyed listeners are satisfied with the current
programming of BYU Radio. We recommend that BYU Radio spend some time reevaluating
their current programming to match what their current listeners would like to listen to. The most
listened to program on BYU Radio is Music and the Spoken Word. Along with Music and the
Spoken Word many listeners tune-in to BYU Radio for devotionals, General Conference talks
and sporting events; it is pertinent to mention that none of these programs are part of BYU
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
43/137
42
Radios original programming. Listeners wanted to hear more of the real issues facing the LDS
Church. Another suggestion was to have more news updates. We also found that most listeners
wanted to hear more music broadcast and less talk show type programs.
4) Devote more time to popular programs -- Our last suggestion for BYU Radio is to devote
more programming time to shows or topics of which the majority of your listeners enjoy
listening to. As mentioned above, many listeners wanted to hear more hard news and an
increase in LDS Church discussion. The most important thing to realize is that BYU Radios
current listener base is about 89 percent LDS. Tailoring content to the LDS population is critical.
We feel that if BYU Radio can implement our previous suggestions and tailor its programming
to the needs of its listeners, brand image will increase, the potential of BYU Radio as a
missionary tool will grow, and ultimately BYU Radio will increase its listener base throughout
the country.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
44/137
43
Conclusion and Recommendations
Summary
From the research we have conducted we have determined that BYU Radios current
listener is LDS, Caucasian and has children. From our survey we determined that 14 percent
more males listened to BYU Radio than female. We also found that only 51 percent of BYU
Radios current listener base is satisfied with its programming. Music and the Spoken Word is
the most popular program that BYU Radio offers. BYU Radios original programming is
currently not well received and should be reevaluated. When listeners were asked if they thought
BYU Radio was an effective missionary tool, 48 percentanswered that they either agreed or
strongly agreed. However, only 31.8 percent of respondents either agreed or strongly agreed that
BYU Radio was likely to attract non-LDS listeners. We feel strongly that BYU Radio could
implement different tactics to increase non-LDS traffic and broaden its listener base.
Strengths and Limitations of Research
While conducting this research over the last semester we experienced both positive and
negative experiences from our methodology. A few strengths include the opportunity to conduct
in-depth interviews with people throughout the nation. We were able to understand why these
individuals listened to BYU Radio, how they listened and possible improvements that BYU
Radio could make to its overall organization. Another strength was the use of the statistical
program SPSS, developed by IBM. With this program we were able to analyze the data received
from our survey which we conducted through Qualtrics to draw conclusions about certain types
of programming, accessibility, and whether or not BYU Radio is meeting the needs of both the
LDS Church and its current listener base.
Although our findings are valuable, there are limitations to both the scope of those who
we targeted and the ability to generalize our information for a population. Due to BYU Radios
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
45/137
44
lack of audience understanding and limited awareness of those who currently listen to BYU
Radio, we had to shift our methods from focus groups to in-depth interviews. Although in-depth
phone interviews are resourceful, it still lacked the valuable face-to-face communication that
focus groups can bring. Another problem we faced was the lack of participants in our survey.
The ideal sample size is just under 400 people. We only had 83 people participate in our survey,
and as a result it is impossible to generalize results from such a small sample size. Various
channels were used to launch BYU Radios survey, including a variety of web-based channels,
including social media sites. The survey was also promoted via live broadcasts on BYU Radio.
Online promotion excludes BYU Radio listeners who access BYU Radio entirely through Sirius
XM. This results in a younger, less affluent listener who accesses BYU Radios content through
affordable online streaming.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
46/137
45
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Never 0.00 0%
2.00 Less than Once a Month 27.00 26.73%3.00 Once a Month 14.00 13.86%4.00 2-3 Times a Month 18.00 17.82%5.00 Once a Week 15.00 14.85%6.00 2-3 Times a Week 17.00 16.83%7.00 Daily 10.00 9.9%
Total 101.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
47/137
46
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 BYU sporting event coverage 36.00 36.73%
2.00 Live BYU Football 43.00 43.88%3.00 Live BYU Basketball 29.00 29.59%4.00 LDS General Conference 40.00 40.82%5.00 Talk Shows 31.00 31.63%6.00 Music 53.00 54.08%7.00 Devotionals/Inspirational Messages 49.00 50%8.00 News 16.00 16.33%9.00 Education/Information 27.00 27.55%10.00 Other 2.00 2.04%
Total 326.00 100%
Othertest
links others send me
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
48/137
47
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Less than an hour 25.00 25.51%
2.00 1-2 hours 43.00 43.88%3.00 3-4 hours 26.00 26.53%4.00 5-6 hours 4.00 4.08%5.00 More than 6 hours 0.00 0%
Total 98.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
49/137
48
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Mornings between 6 am and 12 pm 40.00 41.24%
2.00 Afternoons between 12 pm and 6 pm 53.00 54.64%3.00 Evenings between 6 pm and 12 am 50.00 51.55%4.00 Overnight between 12 am and 6 am 3.00 3.09%5.00 Saturdays (please specify time) 19.00 19.59%6.00 Sundays (please specify time) 20.00 20.62%
Total 185.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
50/137
49
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Sirius XM Satellite Radio 26.00 27.37%
2.00 Mobile Phone App 26.00 27.37%3.00 Podcast 9.00 9.47%4.00 On-line Streaming 62.00 65.26%5.00 Satellite/Cable Provider 10.00 10.53%6.00 Other 4.00 4.21%
Total 137.00 100%
Othertest
Radioon the radio
radio in the car or house
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
51/137
50
# Answer Bar Responses %
1.00 Very Uninterested 11.00 15.71%2.00 Uninterested 14.00 20%3.00 Nuetral 17.00 24.29%4.00 Interested 15.00 21.43%5.00 Very Interested 13.00 18.57%
Total 70.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
52/137
51
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Alone 72.00 75.79%
2.00 Friends 12.00 12.63%3.00 Family 42.00 44.21%4.00 Co-workers 3.00 3.16%5.00 Other (please specify) 2.00 2.11%
Total 131.00 100%
Other (please specify)Family, if conference
truck driver
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
53/137
52
# Question Never Rarely Sometimes Often All of the Time Responses Mean2.00 Home 7.00 12.00 22.00 26.00 27.00 94.00 3.57
1.00 Car 48.00 8.00 19.00 9.00 10.00 94.00 2.204.00 Work 60.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 7.00 94.00 1.893.00 School 76.00 5.00 5.00 7.00 1.00 94.00 1.435.00 Other (please specify) 84.00 2.00 6.00 1.00 - 93.00 1.18
Other (please specify)Computer Shop
NoWorking out
Computer ShopBYU Broadcasting from DirectTV
Noalome
Others homes while watching gamesWhen I can get WIFI
No
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
54/137
53
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Every day 51.00 54.26%
2.00 2 - 3 times a week 13.00 13.83%3.00 A few times week 13.00 13.83%4.00 Once a week 6.00 6.38%5.00 2-3 times a month 2.00 2.13%6.00 Once a month 3.00 3.19%7.00 Every other month 1.00 1.06%8.00 2 - 3 times a year 2.00 2.13%9.00 Never 2.00 2.13%10.00 Other 1.00 1.06%
Total 94.00 100%
OtherSometimes
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
55/137
54
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Podcasts 29.00 31.18%
2.00 Internet streaming 56.00 60.22%3.00 Smart phone apps 24.00 25.81%4.00 FM radio 71.00 76.34%5.00 AM radio 24.00 25.81%6.00 HD radio 4.00 4.3%7.00 SiriusXM radio 22.00 23.66%8.00 None 1.00 1.08%9.00 Other (please specify) 2.00 2.15%
Total 233.00 100%
Other (please specify)TuneIn Radio app for IOS
Pandora
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
56/137
55
# QuestionVery
Dissatisfied
DissatisfiedNeither
Satisfied or
Dissatisfied
SatisfiedVery
Satisfied
No
Opinion
ResponsesMean
1.00BYU sporting events
coverage1.00 5.00 8.00 27.00 28.00 23.00 92.00 4.58
2.00 General Conference 3.00 1.00 9.00 17.00 46.00 16.00 92.00 4.633.00 Talk Shows 4.00 3.00 19.00 15.00 27.00 24.00 92.00 4.414.00 Music 4.00 8.00 11.00 20.00 35.00 14.00 92.00 4.26
5.00Devotionals/Inspirational
Messages4.00 4.00 7.00 22.00 36.00 19.00 92.00 4.51
6.00 News 5.00 1.00 21.00 13.00 20.00 31.00 91.00 4.48
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
57/137
56
Text EntryNot sure
I used to LOVE BYU radio, but all the talk shows are boring & uninspirational.Breaks up too often
Radio shows are MUCH better live. Pre-recorded or audio feed from another source tend to be dry and boringThe sports casters are very opinionated and don't give great commentary about sports.
Not sureSeem very bland and not very current
NOThe music is lame and the devotionals are too frequent.
Music doesn't fit in with the other programming, and it's often cheesy.You took Sounds of Sunday off the air.Just not enough relevant mix of music.
News; how about real news, not recaps from other news sources.I can't stand listening to anything to do with conference or "faith promoting" crap. If you are going to delve into
real issues, than get real.Uh ?
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
58/137
57
# Answer Bar Responses %14.00 General Conference 59.00 66.29%27.00 Music & the Spoken Word 53.00 59.55%
5.00 CES Firesides 34.00 38.2%3.00 BYU Forums 26.00 29.21%2.00 Bronco Mendenhalls Coachs Show 24.00 26.97%41.00 True Blue 22.00 24.72%6.00 Conversations 21.00 23.6%37.00 Thinking Aloud 20.00 22.47%7.00 Education Week 19.00 21.35%18.00 History of the Saints 18.00 20.22%31.00 Scripture Roundtables 18.00 20.22%1.00 Ancestors 18.00 20.22%17.00 History of Hymns 17.00 19.1%
25.00 Matt Townsend Afternoon Show 17.00 19.1%4.00 BYU Weekly 17.00 19.1%36.00 The Tantara Hour 16.00 17.98%16.00 Highway 89 16.00 17.98%21.00 Legacy 15.00 16.85%29.00 Real Families Real Answers 13.00 14.61%33.00 Sunday School Scriptures 13.00 14.61%44.00 Why I believe 12.00 13.48%40.00 Traveling With Eric Dowdle 12.00 13.48%20.00 Inspiring Lives 12.00 13.48%22.00 Living Essentials 11.00 12.36%
10.00 Eyres on the Road with Richard & Linda Eyre 11.00 12.36%12.00 Food Nanny 11.00 12.36%24.00 Marcus Smith Morning Show 11.00 12.36%32.00 Sperry Symposium 11.00 12.36%9.00 Everything Creative 10.00 11.24%42.00 Turning Point 10.00 11.24%15.00 Generations Project 10.00 11.24%26.00 Mormon Identities 9.00 10.11%11.00 Faith in Action 9.00 10.11%38.00 Thisll Take A While 8.00 8.99%30.00 Road to Zion 8.00 8.99%8.00 Enduring it Well 7.00 7.87%45.00 Other (please specify) 7.00 7.87%28.00 Notes From The Kennedy Center 7.00 7.87%19.00 Insights 7.00 7.87%43.00 Wheatley Forum 6.00 6.74%35.00 The Julie Hanks Show 5.00 5.62%23.00 Making Your Own Road 4.00 4.49%13.00 Fresh Take 4.00 4.49%34.00 Talk Worthy with Kim Stilson 4.00 4.49%39.00 Through the Garage Door 3.00 3.37%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
59/137
58
Total 665.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
60/137
59
# QuestionVery
DissatisfiedDissatisfiedNeutralSatisfied
Very
SatisfiedNo
OpinionResponsesMean
1.00 Programming 6.00 2.00 20.00 32.00 19.00 9.00 88.00 3.942.00 Convenience 2.00 4.00 15.00 30.00 30.00 7.00 88.00 4.173.00 Accessibility 3.00 6.00 16.00 26.00 30.00 7.00 88.00 4.08
4.00CustomerService
3.00 1.00 16.00 17.00 19.00 32.00 88.00 4.64
5.00 Promotions 3.00 1.00 20.00 18.00 13.00 33.00 88.00 4.55
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
61/137
60
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
62/137
61
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Current BYU Student 15.00 17.44%
2.00 Alumni/Alumna 39.00 45.35%3.00 Have family who attends/attended 42.00 48.84%4.00 LDS Church member 76.00 88.37%5.00 I live in a BYU community 15.00 17.44%6.00 I am in no way affiliated with BYU 4.00 4.65%7.00 I have a friend who attends/attended 34.00 39.53%
Total 225.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
63/137
62
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Strongly Disagree 3.00 4%
2.00 Disagree 2.00 2.67%3.00 Neither Agree nor Disagree 34.00 45.33%4.00 Agree 26.00 34.67%5.00 Strongly Agree 10.00 13.33%
Total 75.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
64/137
63
# Answer Bar Responses %
1.00 Strongly disagree 3.00 3.53%2.00 Disagree 22.00 25.88%3.00 Neither Agree nor Disagree 33.00 38.82%4.00 Agree 21.00 24.71%5.00 Strongly Agree 6.00 7.06%
Total 85.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
65/137
64
# Answer Bar Responses %
1.00 Strongly disagree 0.00 0%2.00 Disagree 5.00 6.02%3.00 Neither Agree nor Disagree 23.00 27.71%4.00 Agree 39.00 46.99%5.00 Strongly Agree 16.00 19.28%
Total 83.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
66/137
65
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Twitter (@byuradio) 18.00 21.69%
2.00 Facebook (facebook.com/byuradio) 28.00 33.73%3.00 No 45.00 54.22%
Total 91.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
67/137
66
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Promotions 5.00 71.43%
2.00 Transcripts 2.00 28.57%3.00 BYU Radio Schedule 4.00 57.14%4.00 Pictures/Videos 6.00 85.71%5.00 BYU Events 4.00 57.14%6.00 Interactions with BYU Radio personalities 2.00 28.57%7.00 Ability to request songs/programs 5.00 71.43%8.00 Information on guests and interviews 4.00 57.14%9.00 Other 1.00 14.29%
Total 33.00 100%
Othertest
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
68/137
67
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
69/137
68
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Male 47.00 56.63%
2.00 Female 36.00 43.37%Total 83.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
70/137
69
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Under 20 3.00 3.61%
2.00 20-29 23.00 27.71%3.00 30-39 17.00 20.48%4.00 40-49 12.00 14.46%5.00 50-59 21.00 25.3%6.00 60-69 5.00 6.02%7.00 70-79 2.00 2.41%8.00 80+ 0.00 0%
Total 83.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
71/137
70
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Under $50,000 36.00 42.86%
2.00 $50,000 - $99,999 25.00 29.76%3.00 $100,000-$149,999 10.00 11.9%4.00 $150,000 - $199,999 6.00 7.14%5.00 Over $200,000 0.00 0%6.00 I decline to answer 6.00 7.14%
Total 83.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
72/137
71
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Less than high school diploma 0.00 0%
2.00 High School diploma/ GED equivalent 3.00 3.61%3.00 Some college 20.00 24.1%4.00 Associates Degree 10.00 12.05%5.00 Bachelors Degree 31.00 37.35%6.00 Masters Degree 15.00 18.07%7.00 Doctoral Degree 0.00 0%8.00 Professional Degree (MD, JD) 4.00 4.82%
Total 83.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
73/137
72
# Answer Bar Responses %45.00 Utah 34.00 40.96%
5.00 California 8.00 9.64%13.00 Idaho 5.00 6.02%53.00 Other 4.00 4.82%38.00 Oregon 3.00 3.61%33.00 New York 3.00 3.61%48.00 Washington 3.00 3.61%21.00 Maryland 3.00 3.61%3.00 Arizona 3.00 3.61%47.00 Virginia 2.00 2.41%34.00 North Carolina 2.00 2.41%26.00 Missouri 2.00 2.41%
10.00 Florida 2.00 2.41%37.00 Oklahoma 1.00 1.2%24.00 Minnesota 1.00 1.2%41.00 South Carolina 1.00 1.2%44.00 Texas 1.00 1.2%12.00 Hawaii 1.00 1.2%6.00 Colorado 1.00 1.2%15.00 Indiana 1.00 1.2%29.00 Nevada 1.00 1.2%39.00 Pennsylvania 1.00 1.2%
Total 83.00 100%
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
74/137
73
# Answer Bar Responses %1.00 Caucasian 70.00 84.34%
2.00 African-American 1.00 1.2%3.00 Asian 5.00 6.02%4.00 Hispanic 3.00 3.61%5.00 Native American 1.00 1.2%6.00 Other 3.00 3.61%
Total 83.00 100%
Othermix of different ones native american and caucasiuon
Europe
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
75/137
74
Text EntryI used to LOVE the old format, especially the music; return it to the previous way. These talk shows are
horrible!more info on programs
Church news at the top of the hour would be nice to hear.BYU should have current events or news talk program and/ or an entertaining talk show from the LDS
perspective.Get on Sirius a la carte programming
sometimes the challel is a bit fuzzy and hard to hear.Thanks for offering it; I especially like listening to instrumental music online, including sacred music pieces
(background music at home). I now also use Pandora for this.test
I would like to hear more general authorities talks, and less repetition in programmingTry mormonthink.com for dealing with real issues facing the LDS Church.
Good work so far, just keep improving.
Nono real suggestions / i love the way you do sports games
in the past i have had some difficulty getting into the programing i wanted if it was something that had beenbroadcast earlier that day or week. Maybe i just assumed i could. i havent been on in awhile so i am not sure it
the menus are anu different nowI don't listen to much of the live programing on BYU radio but find many good things at byub.org and enjoy
BYU tv and the programs immensely. Thank you for all aspects of what you do.More tabernacle Choir and other arrangements on church music
n/akeep it up
Get the "word out" better about what content BYU Radio has.
I want to learn on new technology that we have today.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
76/137
75
Maybe have a program more directly related to campus life or introducing listeneers to accomplishments ofcurrent students in different majors? What are research projects of the day? What are some interesting results of
that research? Why would I want to study certtain subjects--and do it at BYU? What is distinctive aboutMormons? What myths about mormons can you (gently) dispel about Mormons for me? Could I submit
questions and maybe be directly involved in their answers?No.none
NoneMany times I get snippets of talks and am unable to listen to an entire program. It has been frustrating for me totry to find out who the guests were on shows. It would be great if you could have a weekly guide that showedwho lecturers are, guests on talk shows and the subject matter so I have a point of reference to look into the
subject further. I LOVE!!!! your station, it's a blessing for me to be able to participate mentally and expand myuniverse daily. I finally got my husband to start listening on days other than Sunday and he now loves it too!
NoNo.
What's happened to the Generations Project? (used to be on 6 am EST)Play LDS music on Sunday Mornings. Sounds of Sunday
No.Love you guys!
Another non-coach sports related show (recruting, interviews, etc.)None yet--Just started listening
More music, less talk showsnone
I'd like to hear more lectures on current events and would like to hear more church lectures and firesides. I alsoliked the Mike Townsend show in the morning.
not at this time
noneMas programacin que incluya espaol.
More live shows. Bring in Bruce Seely and Mark Wait.Only recently have I been listening to BYU Radio, and I have liked what has been broadcast.
Overall, I enjoy cultural exchanges between the radio personnel and the guests. The sports programming coulduse lots of improvements, but overall I enjoy listening.
More music, less talkI'm sure you have this but maybe you could address nation wide or global news...I feel that might make us lookmore current and aware of what's happening around us as opposed to just what's happening on campus! I hope
this makes sense.Keep it up!
offer multiple streamsReplace Matt Townsend hour with current national and world events, get rid of Spoken word- you can getenough inspirational content on lds.org, have a more regularly scheduled family history hour, print a nice
cardstock programming guide to mail to listeners to check daily schedules,Anything you can do to promote "This'll Take a While" is going to be good. That show deserves a much bigger
audience than it probably has.Contine on these manner to speaking about Good to all of the World
Hey, i realized after I started this survey that it is not for Classical 89. I am on there a whole lot more and Ifollow twitter links for anything catching my attention on twitter.
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
77/137
76
Appendix C
Crosstabs
In what ways are you affiliated with BYU? (Check all that apply)-LDS
Church member * To what extent do you agree with the following
statement: BYU Radios current programming is likely... CrosstabulationCount
To what extent do you agree with
the following statement: BYU
Radios current programming is
likely...
Strongly
disagree
Disagree
In what ways are you affiliated
with BYU? (Check all thatapply)-LDS Church member
No 0 5
Yes 3 17
Total 3 22
In what ways are you affiliated with BYU? (Check all that apply)-LDS Church member *
To what extent do you agree with the following statement: BYU Radios current
programming is likely... Crosstabulation
Count
To what extent do you agree with the
following statement: BYU Radios current
programming is likely...
Neither Agree nor
Disagree
Agree
In what ways are you affiliated with
BYU? (Check all that apply)-LDS
Church member
No 2 1
Yes 31 20
Total 33 21
In what ways are you affiliated with BYU? (Check all that apply)-LDS Church member *
To what extent do you agree with the following statement: BYU Radios currentprogramming is likely... Crosstabulation
Count
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
78/137
77
To what extent do
you agree with the
following statement:
BYU Radios
current programmingis likely...
Total
Strongly Agree
In what ways are you affiliated with
BYU? (Check all that apply)-LDS
Church member
No 2 10
Yes 4 75
Total 6 85
T-Test
Group Statistics
Why do you listen to
BYU Radio? (Check all
that apply)-LDS
General Conference
N Mean Std.
Deviation
To what extent do you
agree with the
following statement:
BYU Radios current
programming is likely...
Listens for Conference 36 3.31 .980
Doesn't listen for
Conference
49 2.88 .927
Group Statistics
Why do you listen to BYU Radio?
(Check all that apply)-LDS General
Conference
Std. Error Mean
To what extent do you agree with
the following statement: BYU
Radios current programming is
likely...
Listens for Conference .163
Doesn't listen for Conference
.132
Independent Samples Test
-
7/27/2019 Comms 318 - Final - Dec 10
79/137
78
Levene's Test for Equality of
Variances
t-test for
Equality
of
Means
F Sig. t
To what extent do you
agree with the
following statement:
BYU Radios current
programming is likely...
Equal variances
assumed
1.104 .296 2.052
Equal variances not
assumed
2.035
Independent Samples Testt-test for Equality of Means
df Sig. (2-tailed) Mean
Difference
To what extent do you
agree with the following
statement: BYU Radios
current programming is
likely...
Equal variances assumed 83 .043 .428
Equal variances not
assumed
73.098 .045 .428