chauhan response to kanhaiya and bhusan
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
1/31
1
In the Supreme Court of India
Criminal Original Jurisdiction -------------------------
!"#$ &'$#$#() *+",- )(. /0 (1 0234
!"#$%$%&' )'*#+ ,+$%-.# /0 &1 $2# 3&'4$%$)$%&' &1 5'*%67
*&56,#+ #)$'"'7$ ,#$#89$#()-
#) $:' ;9$$'" (1<
=>?@A@ B>@CD>EF
"#$ %&'()*+$ ,-&./)*$
012*).) ,31*4 35 6789&$:)' ;)>>=?@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@A)494937)*$
89 =@ 5A@GA GH #AI@>F
B979+4*( 35 C3.) D55&9*+
E-*@ 94+ 0)F*)4&*(
:3*4- GAF
D8M3F&4)
E-*31N-O
G&* ,317F9< 35 6789&
J=$ P31+) DM)71) 67+49414937&< D*)&$:)&* G&>J
"@ S>CLT>E 7@AQLF
D8M3F&4)
E-*31N-O
G&* ,317F9< 35 6789&
J=$ P31+) DM)71) 67+49414937&< D*)&$
:)&* G&>J
Q@ (? 7L>P?>
D8M3F&4)
E-*31N-O
G&* ,317F9< 35 6789&
J=$ P31+) DM)71) 67+49414937&< D*)&$
:)&* G&< G-&'&7$
:)' ;) >>J ?@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@ P)+2378)74+@
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
2/31
2
In the Supreme Court of India
Criminal Original Jurisdiction
"'&,S 6"#'1 1(" $:' "'7&. UF N#="9; 7. +:95:9) #) (&&(7#$#()
TO,
THE HON‘BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA AND HIS
COMPANION JUDGES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA:
P)+2378)74$ R9H*&. 097N- ,-&1-&7 ST,-&1-&7UV 4-*31N- -9+
&8M3F&4)+$ W&*&.M9* ;&-9(& &78 DX&( A&
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
3/31
3
&78$ 95 53178 N19=b SZYAV@ D78 43 2*3M98) N*&M94( 43 4-9+
A6%$ B+@ a&9+'&< 37 2)7&@ E-) A)494937)* &
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
4/31
4
J@ B*@ W1.&* 9+ +3.)37) T'-3 -&+ F
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
5/31
5
666 *9N-4+ &*) 7)94-)* &++9N7&/#$#+4 &1 K)*%-%6. +#8%#C >)4$ :# -.#6+.@ *#1%'#* 6'* '#8#+ #T-##*#*9D
5:%* @ E-1+$ &7 9789M981&< F&7 F3.2
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
6/31
6
3*N&79`&4937 8)89F&4)8 43 4-) F&1+) 35 *)Q 0, JoJ> S&
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
7/31
7
-6+#1). $& 4## $26$ $2# >#>:#+ &1 $2# B):.%-= C2& 6BB+&6-2#4 $2# 3&)+$ %'
-64#4 &1 $2%4 V%'*= %4 6-$%'? :&'6 1%*# 6'* '&$ 1&+ B#+4&'6. ?6%' &+ B+%86$#
B+&1%$ &+ B&.%$%-6. >&$%86$%&' &+ &$2#+ &:.%W)# -&'4%*#+6$%&'9U I9"9 J)B$6 89
LS5= D6P =ojJ 0, ="o@ E-) ,31*4 51*4-)* &8.379+-)8 4-&4$ ;%$ %4 '&$
#8#+@ *#16).$ &' $2# B6+$ &1 $2# I$6$# &+ 6 B):.%- 6)$2&+%$@ $26$ %4
K)4$%-%6:.#9 )4$ $6V# -6+# $& 4## $26$ %$ * '&$ &8#+4$#B $2#
.%>%$4 &1 %$4 K)*%-%6. 1)'-$%&' 6'* $+#4B644 %'$& 6+#64 C2%-2 6+# +#4#+8#* $&
$2# XT#-)$%8# 6'* $2# A#?%4.6$)+# :@ $2# 3&'4$%$)$%&'9D 68@ D
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
8/31
8
E-) 9..)89&4) F&1+) 35 59Jm=b 35 +)793* &8M3F&4)+ &223974)8 &+ F31*4
F3..9++937)*+ /( 4-9+ F31*4$ *)23*4 8&4)8 =o@>J@J>=b 35 4-)
:&4937&< C1.&7 P9N-4+ ,3..9++937 &+ ')J@J=>b c+9Fd F3781F4)8 /( 6789& E38&( 7)'+ F-&77)
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
9/31
9
/&FH97N@ Further, this Court can judicial notice of events or records being
established out of court, (§ 57, The Indian Evidence Act, 1872) and is not
bound by the trial courts nitty-gritty however, no judicial notice could be
taken of a press vying with each other to be more sensational.
Sting Operation is Inadmissible
U. B+@ a&9+'&< F374)78+ 4-&4 & 21*23*4)8 T0497N L2)*&4937U )f)F14)8
/( 6789& E38&( 9+ .&4)*9&< )731N- 43 9789F4 4-) P)+2378)74+ 53* & T+13
.341U F374).24@ A)494937)* '\. &]3[. k1*4-)*$ 4-) 0497N L2)*&4937$
2*355)*)8 97 )M98)7F) -)*) 9+ 734 /( &
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
10/31
10
U.3. k1*4-)*$ *)+4*9F49M) 35 4-) A6% F3.2&++ M9+^_^M9+ P)+2378)74+
71./)*)8 # 43 Q 9+ 4-) &FF1+&4937 &N&97+4 4-).$ '-9F- 9+ 35 & +)*931+
N)7*)^^&++&1
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
11/31
11
4. A)494937)* F374)78+ 734 4-&4 B*@ W1.&* -&+ 734 /))7 N9M)7 &
53*1. 53* *)8*)++$ -9+ /&9< -)&*97N )4F@ /14 4-&4 4-)*) ')*) )f4*&7)31+
9.2)89.)74+ F*)&4)8 /( 3.9++937 &78 F3..9++937 35 A&49&)*6. U6446' 89 LS5 $ D6P J>=> 0, S0122V J# S=V@ E-) A)494937)*
+31N-4 *)51N) '94- 4-) 012*).) ,31*4$ 53* & F&7898&4) '-3 -&8 89*)F4
&FF)++ 43 ;)
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
12/31
12
,^C "K_R@C@V@GAKI 7TKM@>E #AWKCV@Q>V@GA $K>? J@ERVKC
8GWKPA?KAV>E 9QKAM@KC "GEKC >AI VLK@P 9MMGRAV>Y@E@VX
\@ E-) 2)494937)* *)]1)+4 & F37+49414937 35 & Z02)F9&< 67M)+49N&4937
E)&.Z SZ06EZV 43 Z97M)+49N&4) 4-) 97F98)74+ 35 &44&FH+ 37 =Q@>J@J>=b
&78 =\@>J@J>=b /( +3.)
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
13/31
13
53*.&4937 -)*) F-92+ &'&( 4-) 974)N*&< &+2)F4 35 4-) N3M)*797N
+4*1F41*)$ &78 9+ &7 178)+9*&/
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
14/31
14
FV@GA "REK !>PP>AVC J@C?@CC>E GH VL@C +>CK
a. ;)+294) 8955)*)74 *1
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
15/31
15
+F)7&*93 -)*) '&**&74+ *).&78 3* *)4= D6P =oQ\ 0,
\## S-3
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
16/31
16
")'K6:= D6P =ob\ 0, =b"# SZk178&.)74&< P9N-4+ &*) 4-3+) *9N-4+ '-9F-
4-) 04&4) )753*F)+ &N&97+4 94+)J@J>=b 35 4-) :&4937&< C1.&7 P9N-4+
,3..9++937 &+ ')J@J=>b
F3781F4)8 /( 4-) 6789& E38&( 7)'+ F-&77)
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
17/31
17
X31*7&
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
18/31
18
,31*4$ & ,31*4 35 F3.2)4)74 X1*9+89F4937 M)+4)8 '94- 4-9+ -3.) '3*H$ 9@)
517F493797N 35 4-) 4*9&< F31*4+@
b.3. D*49F
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
19/31
19
5*3. +)*M9F)$ 4*&7+5)*$ 2*3.34937$ *)49*).)74$ 97F
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
20/31
20
&78 94 ZF&7734 /) F9*F1.+F*9/)8 /( &7( *1
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
21/31
21
73*.&
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
22/31
22
M94&>JV " 0,, QJ"$ C)*) 4-) ,31*4
'&+ M)*( +)7+949M) &/314 4-) +F32) 35 &*49F
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
23/31
23
5'*%6$ D6P =oj> 0, =\joO I6'K##8 3&V# F1?9 3&9 89 H26+6$ 3&V%'? 3&6.
A$*9$ D6P =oj# 0, J#oO %@ 326'*+6 Q)>6+ 89 L'%&' &1 5'*%6= D6P =oo\ 0,
==JQ@ ,37+49414937 &22
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
24/31
24
=o\= 3* 178)* 94+ T97-)*)74 23')*+@U D78 4-9+ ,31*4e+ 23')* 43 2179+-
53* F374).24 9+ 8)).)8 43 /) & F37+49414937&< 37)i734 +1/X)F4 43
89.9714937 /( &7( b ST,31*4g+ X1*9+89F4937 &78 23')* 43 4&H) &F4937 53* F374).24 35
+1/3*897&4) F31*4+ '31
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
25/31
25
O%+4$= 5*3. 4-) 2=b &54)* & 8)4&9
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
26/31
26
4-&4 -) -&8 *)2)&4)8
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
27/31
27
Q@ R&N1) &78 F37F
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
28/31
28
N
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
29/31
29
R9Q9,'6'* 84 R#?%4$+6+=G#.2% U%?2 3&)+$ $ SJ>>oV j 0,, =>b$ =oj@ E-1+
/&+)8 37 & /&+)8 37 +497N 32)*&4937$ 94+ *) I%'?2= I):[G%8%4%&'6. X'?%'##+= "):.%-
U#6.$2 89 R6V#42 I%'?2= 59,9I9 I#-+#$6+@= A&-6. J&8#+'>#'$ SJ>>JV \ 0%P
\\=@ E-9+ ,31*4 97 5' R# "939 I#'$ &:+6'-#+ 89
F6$%.6. J2&4#$ D6P =o=" ,&< bo S0GV 3297)8 4-&4$
A*3F))897N+ 53* F374).24 +-31
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
30/31
30
, #CCRKC >PK ;GGV
33. E-) A)494937)*g+ 34-)* N*9)M&7F)+ 97FAV]6LRCL>A]:GD]M>A]
XGR]YKMG?K]VLK]MKAVPK]HGP]TRYE@M]@AVKPKCV]E@V@Q>V@GAg>PV@MEKCLGDgU2UU/4aa.M?C
E-9+ &8.379+-.)74 9+ F
-
8/19/2019 Chauhan response to Kanhaiya and Bhusan
31/31
31
4-) 178)*+9N7)8 83 734 &8M3F&4) 53*)F