central council of indian medicine new...

189ec minutes 1

CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE

NEW DELHI

MINUTES OF 189th MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE HELD ON

19.03.2014 (FN) AT NEW DELHI

PRESENT

1. Dr. Rashidullah Khan, President I/C Chairman

2. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member

3. Dr. Bhirgupati Pandey Member 4. Dr. V.G. Udayakumar Member

5. Dr. Mohd. Shafique Member

6. Dr. Shuhabuddin Member

7. Dr. B. Muthukumar Member Dr. Shamshad Bano, Asstt. Registrar (Unani), CCIM

Agenda Item No. 1. Confirmation of minutes of the 188th meeting of

Executive Committee and its Adjourned meeting held on 04.03.2014 & 07.03.2014 at New Delhi.

It was noted that 188th meeting of Executive Committee and its Adjourned meeting

was held on 04.03.2014 & 07.03.2014 at New Delhi. The minutes of the same will

be placed before the Committee at the time of consideration of the same.

Executive Committee confirmed the minutes.

Agenda Item No. 2. The Establishment of New Medical College, opening

of New or higher Course of Study or Training and

Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College

(Amendment) Regulations, 2013 - Notification

regarding.

It was noted that the Govt. of India has forwarded a copy of Draft Regulation

namely; “The Establishment of New Medical College, Opening of New or Higher

Course of Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical

College (Amendment) Regulations, 2013” approved by Hon’ble Minster of Health

and Family Welfare and duly vetted and translated in Hindi by Legislative

Department of Ministry of Law & Justice and further requested to get it notified in

the Gazette of India and to send 100 copies of the same for taking further action

to lay on the table of both the Houses of the Parliament in the coming session.

Accordingly the Executive Committee at its 188th meeting considered the matter

and deferred the same to the next meeting.

Executive Committee referred the matter to Regulation Amendment

Committee.

189ec minutes 2

Legal

Agenda Item No. 3. Ratification of the decision of President

I/C in respect of payment to Senior

Advocates appearing on behalf of CCIM.

It was noted that given below are the details of payments done by CCIM to

Senior/Additional Advocates with the sanction of President I/c, CCIM for

pursuing the cases before the Supreme Court of India, High Court of Delhi

and Nanital.

With regard to appointment of Senior/Additional Advocates, suggestions

were made by Legal Axis to President I/c, CCIM & President I/C CCIM

accordingly approved the appointment of Senior/Additional Advocates and

sanctioned their bills.

The details are as under:-

S.No. Name of Senior Advocate

Case No./ H.C Amount

1. Kirti Uppal

6867/2013, Raghu Nandan Sharma v/s UOI & Ors., Delhi H.C., 28.01.2014 @ Rs. 55,000 per appearance

Rs. 55,000/-

2. Kirti Uppal

6867/2013, Raghu Nandan Sharma v/s UOI & Ors., Delhi H.C. 21.01.2014 @ Rs. 55,000 per appearance

Rs. 55,000/-

3. Sudhir Nandra Jog 3904/2013, P.R Sharma V/s CCIM, CAT, New Delhi.13.11.2013

Rs. 44,000/-

4. Sudhir Nandra Jog 3862/2013, Kiran V/s CCIM, CAT, New Delhi. 13.11.2013

Rs. 44,000/-

5. Tasneem Aziz Ahmadi

1754/2013, Ved Prakash Tyagi v/s Govt. of Uttrakhand & Ors. Nainital H.C. Drafting/ Settling application, Supplementary Affidavit and reply to notice of Motion @ Rs. 11,000

Rs. 33,000/-


1754/2013 , Ved Prakash Tyagi v/s Govt. of Uttrakhand & Ors. Nainital H.C. 26.12.2013, 28.12.2013, 03.01.2014 @ rs 33,000 per appearance.

Rs. 99,000/-

7. Kirti Uppal 6867/2013, Raghu Nandan Sharma v/s UOI & Ors., Delhi H.C. 16.12.2013

Rs. 55,000/-

8.

Kirti Uppal 6867/2013, Raghu Nandan Sharma v/s UOI & Ors., Delhi H.C. 19.11.2013

Rs. 55,000/-

9. Paras Kohal SLP No. 5230/2014, CCIM V/s Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors. Supreme Court, Appearance on

21.02.2014

Rs. 3,30,000/-

10. Chirag M. Shroff (Advocate on Record)

SLP No. 5230/2014, CCIM V/s Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors. Supreme Court of India, verification of SLP.

Rs. 48,500/-


SPA No. 15/2014 CCIM V/s Ved Prakash Tyagi, Nainital H.C dated 03.02.2014, 10.02.2014.

Rs. 1,76,000/-


SPA No. 15/2014, CCIM V/s Ved Prakash Tyagi, Nainital H.C dated 03.02.2014, 10.02.2014.

Rs. 17,600/-

189ec minutes 3

Executive Committee ratified the same.

REGISTRATION

Agenda Item No. 4. Request for permanent Registration at the

Medical Council Travancore- Cochin Kerala.

It was noted that a letter has been received from Dr. Carina Miorin, Trivandrum

regarding request for permanent Registration at the Medical Council Travancore-

Cochin Kerala. The contents of letter are as under:- “I am a German national and have graduated from the University of Kerala in 2012

after studying BAMS at Shree Narayana Institute of Ayurvedic Studies and

Research. I am trying to get my registration at the Medical Council of Travancore- Cochin after the completion of my internship in December 2013. Unfortunately

there is no provision provided for foreign nationals who graduated in BAMS for

registration.

The Medical Council Registrar has mentioned that the IMC has issued a direction to

Medical Councils to provide permanent registration to foreign MBBS medical graduates.

We request you to provide a similar direction to the Medical Council Travancore-

Cochin so that foreign nationals could get registration in the Council so that I could

get my registration done at Travancore-Cochin Medical Council.”

Executive Committee decided to get information from MCI about the

procedure followed for Foreign students and then put up in EC.

TECHNICAL

Agenda Item No. 5. Suggestions on teacher’s eligibility issue

based on 186th Meeting of EC by Screening

Committee.

It was noted that a letter is signed by Dr. B.P. Pandey & Dr. Udaykumar, EC

Member is received in the office. The contents are as under:-

“In the Agenda Item No.6 of 186th EC held on 04.02.2014, it is decided that all

issues will be categorized by the Screening Committee on the basis of the decision

of the additional Agenda Item No.6 of 184th meeting of the EC except point no. 20.

Thereafter, the recommendation of Screening Committee will be placed before EC.

The matter again considered and Committee suggests that these teachers are put

in false/controversial list shall be asked to submit an affidavit stating that they are

accepting the decision of the Screening Committee and make then eligible/not

eligible. Those teachers are cleared by the Screening Committee based on the

policy accepted by the 184th EC shall be made eligible/not eligible and send letters

accordingly”.

Executive Committee agreed to the same.

Agenda Item No. 6. Chance limitation in BAMS Examinations

Regarding.

189ec minutes 4

It was noted that a letter is signed by Dr. B.P. Pandey & Dr. Udaykumar, EC

Member is received in the office. The contents are as under:-

“Accordingly to the Rules and Regulations of CCIM that is following by the Kerala

University of Health Science under BAMS course, those students who are admitted

in the affiliated institutions by the University are still facing the threat of

termination system. But the same rule is not in practice for the batches admitted

under the University from 2012 academic year onwards and also not applicable for

the students under Calicut University.

But, by making this termination system specific for two batches admitted in the

academic years of 2010 and 2011, they are the only batches who come under this

special rule as the genuinely deserved a consideration in the view of the fact that

one or two years before”..

Executive Committee decided to inform all the Universities in view of GOI

letter received in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 7. Submission of Part I and Part II of visitation

reports separately by College and Visitation

Team -Regarding.

It was noted that the office of CCIM, received the visitation report in respect of

Govt. Nizamia Tibbia College, Hyderabad separately by College and Visitation Team.

Part I of the report was sent by College on 22.01.2014, whereas Part II was

submitted by the Visitation Team and was received in the office on 28.01.2014.

-In this regard it was noted that the visitation of the college was carried out on

20-21.01.2014. Part I of the visitation report is neither verified by the visitors and

nor by the principal of the college. Part II of the report is also not properly verified -

-by the visitors as most of the pages are not signed by them. In view of the same,

the said visitation report could not be assessed.

The matter was placed before President I/c, CCIM and he directed to place the

matter before Executive Committee.

Executive Committee decided to get re-visitation of the college done.

Further, explanation may be called from the visitors and the reply of

visitors is to be placed before EC for settling their TA Claim of the said

visitation.

Administration & Establishment:

Agenda Item No. 8. Extension for the tenure of Ayurved Experts.

It was noted that as per decision of Executive Committee, Dr. Ratna, Ayurved

Expert has been appointed on 13.12.2013 and her tenure was expired on

12.03.2014

The President I/c, CCIM extended the tenure of Dr. Ratna, Ayurved Expert for

further 11 months owing to her satisfactory services.

189ec minutes 5


Agenda Item No. 9. To provide the High Tea, Working Lunch

(Deluxe Thali) and Evening Tea for 19th to

21st March, 2014 – regarding.

It was noted that a Sub-Committee constituted of for the purpose of obtaining and finalizing the quotations for the arrangement of catering services i.e. tea, lunch,

high tea, tent and waiters etc. to be provided during the meeting /election to be

held on 19th -21st March, 2014, collected three quotations from the following agencies:-

S.No. Name of Agencies

1. The sky Caterers & Decorators,28, New Khan Market, Lodhi Road, New

Delhi

2. Rai Sahin Tent House, 112, Meher Chand Market, Lodhi Raod, New Delhi

3. Balaji Caterers , E-144, B.K Dutta Colony, New Delhi-03

The comparative rates quoted by the agencies are as under:-

Item Balaji Caterers The sky Caterers &

Decorators

Rai Sahin Tent House

Rate Rate Rate

Working lunch in Deluxe Thali (Cat-B)

Rs.225/- Rs.300/- Rs.230/-

Working Lunch in Special Thali(Cat-A)

Rs.200/- Rs.250/- Rs.260/-

Morning High Tea (Cat-D) Rs.85/- Rs.180/- Rs.125/-

Evening High Tea(Cat-C) Rs.80/- Rs.150/- Rs.110/-

Tea with Biscuits Rs.14/- Rs.25/- Rs.22/-

Coffee with biscuits Rs.18/- Rs.30/- Rs.25/-

Tea Rs.10/- Rs.20/- Rs.18/-

Coffee Rs.14/- Rs.25/- Rs.22/-

Mineral Water bottle 200ml/Glass As per MRP. - -

Charges of Waiters Rs.400/- Per waiter +

Rs.200/- after 8 hrs.

Rs.650/- per waiter

Rs.700/- Per waiter

Tent 3 days Rs.50,000/- Rs.93,000/- Rs.80,000/-

Terms & Conditions 1)50% of the total Amount to be given 2) Govt taxes

applicable

-

-

After going through the above comparative statement, the rates quoted by M/s

Balaji Caterers, New Delhi were found the lowest amongst all.

Keeping in view the lowest rates quoted by M/s Balaji Caterers, the work order for

providing the catering services has been given to the said agency after obtaining

approval of the President I/c, CCIM.


189ec minutes 6

Agenda Item No. 10. To provide the bags to the Hon’ble Members

of CCIM on the occasion of Special General

Body Meeting to be held on 19th March, 2014-

reg.

It was noted that a Sub-Committee constituted for the purpose of obtaining and

finalizing the quotations for the arrangement of Bags to be distributed to the Hon’ble Members of the CCIM on the occasion of the Special General Body Meeting

to be held on 19th March, 2014, collected three quotations from the following

agencies:-

S.No. Name of Agencies

1. M/s Astha Bag Company, 5416,New Market, Sadar Bazar, New Delhi-

110006

2. M/s Nagpal Bag Factory Shidi Pura, New Rohtak Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi-110005

3. M/s Shree Sita Laxmi International 18, Balvinder Apartment, A-6 Mayur

Bagh Society, Paschim Vihar, New Delhi-110063

The comparative rates quoted by the agencies are as under:-

Item M/s Astha Bag Company M/s Nagpal

Bag Factory

M/s Shree Sita Laxmi

International Rate Rate Rate

Delegate Bag/Bags/ Conference Bags

Rs.485/-+12.5% VAT Extra

Rs.460/-+12.5% VAT Extra

- Rs.425/-+12.5% VAT Extra

Terms & Conditions 1) Delivery at door step. 2) Rates are without printing. 3) 40% payment

advance with work order.

-

1) Delivery at office 2) Rates are without printing.

After going through the above comparative statement, the rates quoted by M/s

M/s Shree Sita Laxmi International, New Delhi were found the lowest amongst all.

Keeping in view the lowest rates quoted M/s Shree Sita Laxmi International, the

work order for the supply of Bags has accordingly been given to the said agency

after obtaining approval of the President I/c, CCIM.


MISCELLANEOUS

Agenda Item No. 11. Enhancement of remuneration- regarding.

It was noted that two representations dated 05.03.2013 received from Mr. Satish

Chander and Mr. Gilbert, Retd. Assistant (on contract basis) stating that they have joined the Council on 16th September,2010 and 03rd October,2010 respectively

189ec minutes 7

and after three months, their contracts were renewed for another six months on

consolidated salary i.e Rs.15,000/- per months each.

In this connection, it was noted that after completion of six months remuneration

was enhanced by Rs.5,000/- each with the approval of Executive Committee in

March/April,2010. Since then their remuneration has not been enhanced for the last three years.

Therefore, they have requested to enhance their remuneration.

Considering the satisfactory services, EC agreed to enhance the

remuneration of Rs.5000/- per month.

Agenda Item No. 12. Fake Registration Certificates issued by State

Council of Ayurvedic & Unani Systems of

Medicine, – Patna ( Bihar) to various persons.

It was noted that an application dated 27.07.2013 alongwith all documents has

been received from Dr. Ramrao Dhondiba Chavan, Beed (Maharashtra) for

obtaining Enrolment Certificate.

Further, it was noted that the name of applicant was not found/included in the

Central Register of Indian Medicine therefore, the matter was referred to State

Council of Ayurvedic & Unani Systems of Medicine, Patna ( Bihar) for verification

about the genuineness of the registration of Dr. Ramrao Dhondiba Chavan. In this

connection, the genuineness vide their letter dated 30.01.2014 has clarified that

Registration Number 1026 the name of Dr. Ramrao Dhondiba Chavan Beed (MS) is

not mentioned, therefore, Bihar State Council has requested to take legal action

against Dr. Ramrao Dhondiba Chavan who has submitted fake documents to the

CCIM for obtaining Enrolment Certificate.

It is also submitted that the copy of State Register/List of ISM practitioners

registered with Bihar State Council from April 2011 to March 2012 was also been

received. The Copy of the same was also sent to State Council of Ayurvedic & Unani

Systems of Medicine – Patna – Bihar/ for verification of its genuinity and

authenticity. In response of this Council letter, the Registrar of above said Council

confirmed that the State Register/ISM practitioners registered with Bihar said State

Council lists are fake/bogus and also informed that legal action be initiated by this

Council vide their letter dated 05.03.2013.

Executive Committee constituted a sub-committee consisting of Dr.

Shuhabuddin , Dr. V.G. Udayakumar, Dr. B. Muthukumar (EC Members), Dr.

Jagjit Singh, Dr. Vishwajeet Phokat and Dr. Ariz Qadri to look into the

matter.

Agenda Item No. 13. Unauthorised agencies/persons are involved

in running a racket to cheat innocent

applicants and misusing and affixing the seal

189ec minutes 8

of CCIM/Ayush on application form for

obtaining Enrolment Certificate.

It was noted that the applications have been received from the following 12

applicants for obtaining Enrolment Certificate from CCIM and their details are as

under-

Sl.

No.

Name of applicant Dairy No. Date

1 Dr. Preeti M Mhatre 2038 10.06.2013

2 Dr. Patil Manohar Bhaurao 2606 25.06.2013

3 Dr. Majid Banemiya Sayyed 2643 25.06.2013

4 Dr. Kavita Arun Katkade 2666 25.06.2013

5 Dr. Arun Kishan Katkade 2685 26.06.2013

6 Dr. Masud Raza A Gani 2779 28.06.2013

7 Dr. Vinod K Thakare 2858 02.07.2013

8 Dr. Kamble Manisha Sanjay 3080 15.07.2013

9 Dr. Kamble Sanjay Muralidhar 3081 15.07.2013

10 Dr. Syed Saadat Ali 9169 22.01.2013

11 Dr. Kanjaria Chirag T 9307 24.02.2014

12 Dr. Akshay Shah 10164 07.03.2013

In this connection, it was noted that all the applicants have not submitted the

requisite fee for obtaining Enrolment Certificate alongwith their applications & the

forms are not as per CCIM’s format. On perusal of the applications received, it has

been observed that out of the above 12 applications, names of 5 applicants are not

included in the Central Register of Indian Medicine.

It appears that some unauthorized agencies/persons are involved in running a

racket to cheat innocent applicants and misusing and affixing the seal of their own.

If agreed to please, the Council may adopt some measures to prevent such

malpractice to avoid further harassment and cheating.

Executive Committee decided that sub-committee constituted at Agenda

No. 13 will also look into this matter.

Agenda Item No.14. Matter regarding applications received for

LDCs post through open advertisement and an

online requisition from District Employment

Exchange, Delhi Govt. and to fill the post of

LDCs

189ec minutes 9

It was noted that two (02) posts of LDCs (01- reserved for OBC and 01-General)

were fallen vacant in CCIM for which an advertisement was published in the

newspapers i.e. Hindustan Times(English), Navbharat Times (Hindi) all over India

and Employment News/Rozgar Samachar dated 25.12.2011 and 07-13.1.2012

respectively in which the last date of receiving of application was mentioned 31st

January, 2012 and the prescribed fees was Rs.50/-.

As per rule, an online requisition dated 22.12.2011 was also filled up by CCIM and

sent to District Employment Exchange, Delhi Govt. to sponsor the name of

candidates for the post of Lower Division Clerk.

In response to the above, following Number of applications were received through

open advertisement .

S.No. Heading Number of applications

1. Total applications (with fee) within stipulated date

6974 (approximately) Fees deposited

In response of CCIM ID No.2011001693 dated 22.12.2011, a sponsored list of 8305

candidates dated 02.1.2012 has been received through email from In-Charge, Data

Centre, Date of Employment.

S.No. Heading Number of applications

1. List sent by Directorate of Employment, Delhi Govt. through e-mail

8305

Total number of applications received - 14,379 approx.

It was noted that the number of application received were too large therefore, it

was not possible to scrutinize all the applications, therefore, the whole matter was

placed before the 178th meeting of Executive Committee held on 09.5.2013.

The Executive Committee decided to sought the legal opinion in respect of

cancellation of previous advt. and calling new applications from applicant with 60%

marks in Graduation beside other requirement as per approved Recruitment Rules.

The legal opinion was obtained from Legal Consultant of office and thereafter the

matter was placed before the then President and thereafter before the President

I/C, CCIM. The President I/C constituted a Sub-Committee consisting of three

members i.e. Dr. Bhrigupati Pandey, Member, Executive Committee, Dr. Uday

Kumar, Member, Executive Committee and Sh. Wasiq Imam, Admn. Officer,

RRI(CCRUM) .

The meeting of Sub-Committee was held on 14.3.2014 at 3.00 p.m. to examine the

applications of LDCs. The opinion of Sub-Committee is as under:-

“As regards to the large number of applications received for 02 posts of LDCs (01-

reserved for OBC and 01-General) advertised in the Newspapers on 25.12.2011 and

07-13.1.2012, the Sub-Committee is of the opinion that due to large number of

189ec minutes 10

applications, these could not be sort out as the CCIM has limited manpower for this

job and it is not possible to prepare datas of these applications.

Keeping in view, the recommendations of Legal Consultant, Official Secretary, the

Sub-Committee is also in favor to defer all the applications and also recommend to

re-advertise the vacancies in Local Newspaper i.e. Hindustan Time (English) and

Navbharat Times (Hindi). Employment Exchange may also be approached to

submit limited applications.

The Sub-Committee is also recommend to fix a criteria to short out applications on

basis of experience/qualification etc. at the time of selection to the post of LDC”.

Further, it was noted that after promotion of Sh. Rajpal Singh from the post of LDC

to UDC, one more post of LDC has also fallen vacant w.e.f. 24.1.2013. The said

post falls on OBC category.

Now, at present, total number of vacancy of LDCs are 03 (three) which are lying

vacant w.e.f. 25.3.3010, 29.6.2011 and 24.1.2013 respectively.

Executive Committee deferred the matter.

Addl. Agenda Item No.1. Visitation report of Baba Hira Das ji

Ayurved Medical College, Muktsar,

Punjab under section 13A.

It was noted that the visitation report of Baba Hira Das ji Ayurved Medical College, Muktsar, Punjab under section 13A has been received from Dr. Gajendra Bharali on

04.03.2014. The date on the report has been mentioned as 30-31.12.2013.

However, it is noted that the date has been written over the whitener on the first

and last page of visitation report and signed by only the said visitor. With the visitation report a letter of said visitor has been attached in which he has stated

that he went to muktsar on 30th dec. 2013 alongwith DR. D.P. Das and Dr. G. P.

Reddy for the visitation of the said college as per direction vide letter no. 26-75/2013-14 dated 23.12.2013. It is also mentioned that there was no infrastructure

available for the proposed college, only two new buildings were undergoing

construction so the question does not arise for filling up the visitation performa.

Further, it was noted that the visitation of the said college had been postponed and

the same was rescheduled on 17-18.01.2014 and regarding this visitors has already informed well in advance telephonically before 30.12.2013 followed by letter of

postponement of visit dated 30.12.2013 was sent by email.

It was also noted that the visitation report dated 17-18.01.2014 signed by two

visitors namely Dr. D.P. Das and Dr. Rama Reddy, of the said college has already

been received on 31.01.2014 and placed before screening committee and then

before meeting of EC held on 04.03.2014. EC decided to not to recommend for issuing LOI and accordingly recommendation has already been sent to GOI on

11.03.2014.

Executive Committee decided to ask a clarification from all three members

and reply may be placed before EC.

189ec minutes 11

Addl. Agenda Item No.2. Recommendation of Shri Krishna Govt.

Ayurvedic College & Hospital, Umri Road, Kurukshetra, Haryana incompliance of the

direction given by the Hon’ble High Court of

Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh, in view of

Judgment dated 15.10.2012 passed in CWP No. 20743 of 2011 for the session 2011-12.

It was noted that Shri Krishna Govt. Ayurvedic College & Hospital, Umri Road, Kurukshetra, Haryana was visited on 17.02.2014 in compliance of the direction

given by the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh, in view of

Judgment dated 15.10.2012 passed in CWP No. 20743 of 2011 to assess the available infrastructure for teaching and practical facility for BAMS course for the

session 2011-12. The visitation report was placed before screening committee on

06.03.2014 and screening committee decided to recommend for the session 2011-

12. Accordingly the same has been sent to GOI with approval of President I/c, CCIM.


Addl. Agenda Item No.3. Recommendation in compliance of the court

order dated 09.12.2013 in WP(C) No. 9563 of

2012 titled Late Kedari Redekar Ayurvedic

Mahavidyalaya, Dist. Kolhapur, Maharashtra and another V/s UOI & Ors before the Hon’ble

court of judicature at Bombay - Reg.

It was noted that Late Kedari Redekar Ayurvedic Mahavidyalaya, Dist. Kolhapur,

Maharashtra was visited on 29-30.01.2014 in compliance of the court order dated 09.12.2013 in WP(C) No. 9563 of 2012 to assess the available infrastructure for

teaching and practical facility for BAMS course for the session 2012-13. The

visitation report was placed before screening committee on 13.03.2014 and after

going through the contents of the case screening committee decided as under:-

“The committee carefully examined the visitation report for the year 2014-15 and

found the following facts.

1. The college is having 53 teachers including 11 Professor, 17 Reader and 25

Lecturer against the requirement of 33.

2. The additional faculty for running PG course is sufficient.

3. IPD and OPD attendance are sufficient.

4. The college is having 7 OPD against the requirement of 8.

In view of the above the college is found eligible to be recommended for the year

2012-13.”

Accordingly the observation of screening committee has been sent to GOI with the approval of President I/c, CCIM.


Addl. Agenda Item No.4. Furnishing recommendation/report in compliance of the Court’s order dated

13.09.2013 of Hon’ble Court of Karnataka

Bench at Dharwad in WP No. 66672 of 2012

189ec minutes 12

filed by Sri Sidaramappa Danigond Memorial

Trust’s against the UOI & Ors., - Reg.

It was noted that the visitation report dated 20-21.12.2013 in compliance of Court’s

order dated 13.09.2013 of Hon’ble Court of Karnataka Bench at Dharwad in WP No. 66672 of 2012 of SDM Ayurvedic College & Hospital, Terdal, Dist. Bagalkot,

Karnataka was placed before Screening Committee. After going through the contents

of the case the screening committee decided as under:-

“The committee examines the matter in detail and compared with visitation report of

2014-15 and found that the functionality of the teaching hospital is genuine. Hence, the college is eligible to be recommended for the year 2012-2013.”

Accordingly the observation of screening committee has been sent to GOI with the

approval of President I/c, CCIM.


Addl. Agenda Item No.5. Recommendation of Screening Committee in

respect of Ayurved Colleges under section 13A for

starting the PG diploma course.

It was noted that Screening Committee (Ayurved) was held in the office of CCIM to

do scrutiny in respect of the proposals for starting new PG diploma course under

Section 13 A. The recommendations of Screening Committee (Ayurved) are as under.

Screening committee held on 12.03.2014 and members of committee were Dr. B.P. Pandey & Dr.

V.G. Udaykumar

S.No. Name Of College Proposal Remarks of screening committee

1. R.A. Podar Ayurved

Medical College Dr. Annie Besant Road,

Worli,

Mumbai-400018 Maharashtra

To start the PG Diploma

Course in 04 subjects (1) Prasuti tantra &

Strirog-3 seats

(2) Rasayan Vajikaran-5 seats

(3) Kshar karma- 5 seats

(4) Netra Vigyan-3 seats

Recommended for starting the PG

Diploma Course in 04 subjects (1) Prasuti tantra & Strirog-3 seats

(2) Rasayan Vajikaran-5 seats

(3) Kshar karma- 5 seats (4) Netra Vigyan-3 seats (Conditionally

recommended)

2. Dean, Faculty of Ayurveda

Institute of Medical

Sciences Banaras Hindu

University

Dist. Varanasi- 221005 Uttar Pradesh

To start the PG Diploma Course in 02 subjects.

(1) Sangyaharan-2 seats

(2) Balrog with 02 seats .

Recommended for starting the PG Diploma Course in 02 subjects.

(1) Sangyaharan-2 seats

(2) Balrog with 02 seats.

3. Institute for Post

Graduate Teaching & Research in Ayurveda

Office to the Director

Sushruta Bhavan Gujrat Ayurved

University


Course in 06 subjects. (1) Prasuti tantra &

Strirog- 5 seats

(2) Ayurvedic Cosmetology & Skin

Disease-2 seats


Diploma Course in 06 subjects. (1) Prasuti tantra & Strirog- 5 seats

(2) Ayurvedic Cosmetology & Skin

Disease-2 seats (3) Kshar Karma-2 seats

(4) Netra Vigyan-5 seats

189ec minutes 13

G.G. Hospital

Road Jamnagar 361008

Gujarat

(3) Kshar Karma-2 seats

(4) Netra Vigyan-5 seats (5) Rasashastra &

Bhaisajyakalpna-5

seats

(6) Balrog-5 seats

(5) Rasashastra & Bhaisajyakalpna-5

seats (6) Balrog-5 seats

4. Shri Vivekanand

Nursing Home Trust’s

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

Shri Shivaji Nagar, A/P- Rahuri Factory,

Tal. Rahuri,

Dist. Ahmednagar-413706

Maharashtra


Course in 06 subjects.

(1) Prasuti tantra &

Strirog-5 seats (2) Ayurvedic

Cosmetology & Skin

Disease--5 seats (3) Kshar Karma-5 seats

(4) Netra rog Vigyan-2

seats (5) Ayurvedic

pharmaceutics-2 seats

(6) Rognidan Vidhi-2

seats


Diploma Course in 06 subjects.

(1) Prasuti tantra & Strirog-5 seats

(2) Ayurvedic Cosmetology & Skin Disease--5 seats

(3) Kshar Karma-5 seats

(4) Netra rog Vigyan-2 seats (5) Ayurvedic pharmaceutics-2 seats

(6) Rognidan Vidhi-2 seats

Executive Committee accepted the recommendations of Screening

Committee and decided to send the recommendation to Govt. of India as

the Govt. is pressing hard to furnish the same at the earliest. However,

these recommendations of 13 A proposals will be subject to ratification of

the General Body of CCIM.

Addl. Agenda Item No.6. Recommendation of Screening Committee in

respect of Ayurved Colleges visited under

Section 13A.

It was noted that Screening Committee (Ayurved) was held in the office of CCIM to

do scrutiny of the visitation reports in respect of visitation carried out under Section

13 A. The recommendations of Screening Committee (Ayurved) are as under:-

Screening committee held on 12.03.2014 to 15.03.2014 and members of committee were Dr. B.P. Pandey &

Dr. V.G. Udaykumar

S.No. Name Of College Proposal Remarks of screening committee

1. Shri Anand Niketan

Dharmshala Avom

Dharmik Trust, Shri

Dhanwantri Ayurvedic

Medical College &

Research Centre

At NH – 02, Vill. Semari,

Tehsil Chhatta , Dist.

Mathura,

Uttar Pradesh

To increase UG intake

capacity from 50 to 60

seats

Recommended for increase intake capacity in

UG course from 50 to 60 seats

2. Govindbhai Jorabhai Patel

Ayurveda College and

Research Centre

B/h G.I.D.C, New

Vallabh Vidyanagar,

To increase intake capacity

in UG course from 50 to

60 seats.

To start new PG in 7

Recommended for increase intake capacity in

UG course from 50 to 60 seats and starting

new PG in 6 subject namely

1. Ayurved Samhita-5 seats

2. Rognidan-5 seats

189ec minutes 14

Taluka; Dist. Anand-

388121

Gujarat

subject

1. Swasthavritta

2. Kayachikitsa

3. Ayurved Samhita

4. Panchkarma

5. Dravyaguna

6. Rasashastra &

Bhaishjakalpana

7. Rognidan

5 seats in each subject

3. Kayachiktisa-5 seats

4. Swasthavritta-3 seats ( instead of 5)

5. Dravyaguna-3 seats ( instead of 5)

6. Rasashastra-3 seats ( instead of 5)

Not recommended for PG in Panchkarma

due to deficit faculty

3. Faculty of Ayurveda

Institute of Medical

Sciences Banaras Hindu

University

Dist. Varanasi- 221005

Uttar Pradesh

1. To increase intake

capacity in UG course

from 50 to 78 seats

2. Increase capacity in

PG from 25 to 40 seats

in following subjects

1. Panchakarma -01 seat

2. Chaya Evum Vikiran

Vigyan -01 seat

3. Swasthavritta – 1 to 2

seats

4. Prasuti tantra &

Striroga from - 3 to 4

seats

5. Shalya tantra (Kshar

evum) - 3 to 4 seats

6. Sangyaharan- 1 to 2

seats

7. Kaumarbhritya- 2 to 3

seats

8. Shalakya tantra (Netra

Roga) - 1 to 2 seats

9. Rognidan- 1 to 2 seats

10. Dravyaguna- 2 to 3

seats

11. Rasashastra- 2 to 3

seats

12. Kriya Sharir- 1 to 2

seats

13. Ayurved Samhita &

Siddhanta- 2 to 3

seats

14. Rachana Sharir- 1 to 2

seats

Recommended for 60 UG seats instead of 78

seats due to over all deficit in faculty to

increase intake capacity above 60. But it is

also noted that new proposal is not required.

Also recommended increase intake capacity

in P.G. seats in following subjects with seats

noted against each.

1. Prasuti tantra & Striroga from 3 to 4 seats

2. Shalya tantra (Kshar evum) - 3 to 4 seats

3. Sangyaharan - 1 to 2 seats

4. Kaumarbhritya- 2 to 3 seats

5. Shalakya tantra (Netra Roga) - 1 to 2

seats

6. Rognidan - 1 to 2 seats

7. Dravyaguna- 2 to 3 seats

8. Rasashastra- 2 to 3 seats

9. Kriya Sharir - 1 to 2 seats

10. Ayurved Samhita & Siddhanta - 2 to 3

seats

11. 11. Rachana Sharir - 1 to 2 seats and

12. Conditionally Recommended for 13. 12. Chaya avum vikiran - 1 seats 13.

Swasthavritta - 1 seats as the college Shall

fulfil the requirement of additional faculty by

the time of LOP.

Not recommended for PG in

14. Panchakarma due to deficit in higher

faculty.

Executive Committee accepted the recommendations of Screening

Committee and in respect of No.3 (BHU proposal) decided that the

proposal of increase seats in PG be considered only in existing PG subjects

and accordingly recommendation may be sent to GOI as the Govt. is

pressing hard to furnish the same at the earliest. However, these

recommendations of 13 A proposals will be subject to ratification of the

General Body of CCIM.

189ec minutes 15

Addl. Agenda Item No.7. Recommendation of Screening

Committee in respect of Ayurved Colleges visited under13C.

It was noted that the screening committee constituted by Dr. B.P. Pandey and Dr.

V.G. Udayakumar, EC Members, CCIM held from 12.03.2014 to 15.03.2014 and

scrutinized the Visitation report of Ayurved colleges under section 13C and the

decision of scrutiny committee is as under:-

Sl.No. Name of College Remark of Screening Committee

1. Government Ayurvedic College, Jalukbari, Distt-Kamrup (Metro), Guwahati- 781014,

Assam

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 02 subjects namely 1. Samhita & Siddhanta -06 seats.

2. Kayachikitsa -03 and

2. Govt. Ayurved College

AT Tulsi Nagar, Bolangir -767001, Orissa

Not recommended due to deficit in higher faculty.

1. The higher faculty in 9 department only against the requirement in 11department.

3. Faculty of Ayurveda Institute of Medical Sciences

Banaras Hindu University Dist. Varanasi- 221005

Uttar Pradesh

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 13 subjects namely 1. Ayurved Samhita & Siddhanta -02 seats,

2. Rachna Sharir - 01 seats, 3. Kriya Sharir -01 seats,

4. Dravyaguna – 02 seats, 5. Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana – 02 seats

6. Rognidan -01 seats,

7. Prasuti Tantra -03 seats,

8. Kayachikitsa -04 seats, 9. Manovigyan Evum Manas Roga – 01 seats

10. Shalya Tantra -03 seats, 11. Sangyaharan -01 seats

12. Shalakya Tantra – 01 seats, 13. Kaumarbhritya -02 seats,

And not recommended for Swasthavritta due to deficit of higher faculty in the department.

4. R.A. Podar Ayurved Medical College Dr. Annie Besant Road, Worli,

Mumbai-400018, Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 13 subjects namely 1. Samhita -03seats,

2. Rachana Sharir -03 seats, 3. Kriya Sharir -02 seats,


6. Rognidan -02 seats, 7. Swasthavritta -02 seats,

8. Prasuti Tantra -05 seats, 9. Kayachikitsa -08 seats,

10. Shalya Tantra -04 seats,

11. Shalakya Tantra – 03 (instead of 04) seats 12. Panchakarma -06 seats

And not recommended for Agadtantra due to deficit of higher faculty in the department.

5. Institute for Post Graduate Teaching &

Research in Ayurveda

Office to the Director Sushruta Bhavan Gujrat Ayurved University

G.G. Hospital Road Jamnagar 361008

Gujarat

Recommended for PG in 10 subjects namely

1. Ayurved Samhita & Siddhanta -06 seats,


4. Rognidan -03 seats, 5. Prasuti Tantra -05 seats,

6. Kaumarbhritya – 04 seats 7. Kayachikitsa -03 seats,

8. Shalya Tantra -05 seats, 9. Shalakya Tantra – 05 seats,

10. Panchakarma – 05 seats.

2. As per the PG regulation 2012, the PG education centre shall satisfy the entire minimum requirements of UG training

including faculties for training in basic sciences of Ayurveda and other supporting subjects as specified by the council. In

IPGTR Jamnagar no faculty available in department of Rachana Sharir, Kriya Sharir, Swasthavritta & Agadtantra.

The regulation also says that minimum one higher faculty

and one lower faulty is needed for starting PG course. There

is no additional faculty in Rognidan, Prasuti Tantra and Kayachikitsa. Being a stand alone PG institute these

shortcoming shall be addressed. There is no separate

189ec minutes 16

regulation for stand alone PG institute.

6. Dr. D.Y. Patil Vidya Pratishthan Society’s Padmashree Dr. D.Y. Patil College of Ayurved

& Research Centre, Pimpri, Pune 411018, Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 75 seats and PG in 05 subjects namely 1. Samhita -04 seats.

2. Rahana Sharir -04 seats, 3. Prasuti Tantra -04 seats,

4. Kayachikitsa -04 and 5. Shalya Tantra -04 seats

7. Shri Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Dhanwantri Marg, Hanuman Nagar

Nagpur 440009 Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 70 seats and PG in 05 subjects namely 1. Rachana Sharir -04 seats,

2. Kriya Sharir -03 seats 3. Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -06 seats

4. Dravyaguna -03 seats 5. Shalakya Tantra -03 seats

Not recommended for PG in Panchakarma, Shalya Tantra, Kayachikitsa, Kaumarbhritya, Agadtantra and Swasthavritta due

to deficit in additional faculty.

8. Rishikul Govt P.G. Ayurvedic College & Hospital

Haridwar- 249401, Uttarakhand

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 07 subjects namely 1. Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -07

2. Dravyaguna -04 3. Shalya Tantra – 05

4. Shalakya Tantra -04 5. Prasuti Tantra -04

6. Kayachikitsa -04 7. Panchakarma -04 (instead of 5)

Due to deficit in faculty

9. Govt. (Auto) Ayurved College, Nipaniya the

Huzur, Dist-Rewa 484001, Madhya Pradesh

Recommended for UG 40 seats and PG in 01 subject namely

1. Samhita -05 seats

10. Pt. Khushilal Sharma Govt. (Autonomous)

Ayurved College & Institute, Behind Manit, Nehru Nagar, Kolar Byepass Road, Science

Hills, Bhopal-462003 Madhya Pradesh

Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG in 01 subject namely

1. Swasthavritta -04 seats

11. Shri Narayan Prasad Awathy Government Ayurved College, G.E. Road, Raipur- 492001

Chhatisgarh

Recommended for UG 55 seats and PG in 05 subjects namely 1. Samhira-03

2. Rachana Sharir -03 3. Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -03

4. Shalya -03 5. Kayachikitsa -05

12. Pt. Shivnath Shastri Auto Govt. Ayurved

College & Hospital, Shikarpura, Near Water Tank,

Burhanpur 450331, Madhya Pradesh

Not recommended due to following reasons:

1. The totals number of teachers is 08 against the requirement of 27.

2. The total of number of higher faculty is 02 in 02 departments against the requirement of 12 in 11 departments.

3. The bed occupancy is 10.95% against the requirement of 40%.

4. Average attendance of patients in OPD per day is 41 against the requirement of 120.

13. Government Autonomous Ayurved College, Gwarighat, Jabalpur- 482001, Madhya

Pradesh

Not recommended due to following reasons: 1. The bed occupancy is 29.13% against the requirement of

40%. 2. Average attendance of patients in OPD per day is 42 against

the requirement of 120. 3. The totals number of teachers is 26 against the requirement

of 27. 4. The total of number of higher faculty is 10 in 09 department

against the requirement of 12 in 11 department.

14. SDM Trust’s Ayurvedic Medical College,

Padma Ayurvedic Hospital & Research Centre, Terdal-587315, Tq. Jamkhandi, Dist.

Bagalkot, Karnataka

Recommended for UG 50 seats

15. Bharat Ayurved Medical College, Hospital &

Research Centre, 10 K.M., Roorkee Road, NH-58, P.O. Barla,

Muzaffarnagar-251001, Uttar Pradesh


16. Santhigiri Ayurveda Medical College, Olassey, P.O. Kodumba (Via), Taluk & District

Palakkad- 678551, Kerala


17. Shri Vivekanand Nursing Home Trust’s Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Shri Shivaji Nagar,

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 06 subjects (i) Rasashastra -04 seats

189ec minutes 17

A/P- Rahuri Factory, Tal. Rahuri, Dist.

Ahmednagar-413706, Maharashtra

(ii) Rognidan -04 seats

(iii) Prasuti Tantra -06 seats (iv) Kayachikitsa -06 seats

(v) Shalya Tantra -03 seats (vi) Shalakya Tantra -04 seats

18. SNVV Samasthe’s SGV Ayurved Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre, Tal:

Bailhongal, Dist. Belgaum-591102, Karnataka

Recommended for UG 40 seats.

19. Bal Bhagwan Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’s

Dhanwantari Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Degloor Road, Udgir-413517, Dist.

Latur, Maharashtr


20. Karnataka Liberal Education University,

Shri B.M. Kankanawadi Ayurveda Mahavidyalaya

Shahapur, Belgaum- 590003, Karnataka

Recommended for UG 75 seats and for PG in 08 subjects

namely:- 1. Dravyaguna – 5 seats

2. Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -11 seats

3. Agadtantra -06 seats 4. Kaumarbhritya – 06 seats

5. Kayachikitsa – 03 seats 6. Shalya Tantra – 03 seats

7. Sangyaharan – 02 seats 8. Panchakarma – 06 seats

21. Rajiv Gandhi Education Society’s Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital, Taluka Ron, Dist.

Gadag-582209, Karanatka

Recommended for UG 40 seats and for PG in 03 subjects namely:-

1. Dravyaguna – 6 seats 2. Kayachikitsa – 06 seats

3. Shalya Tantra – 06 seats

22. Vasant Dada Patil Ayurved Medical College &

Institute of Yoga, South Shivaji Nagar, Opposite Income Tax Office, Miraj road, Tal.

Miraj, Sangli 416416, Maharashtra


23. Bapuji Ayurvedic Medical College and Hospital

Bapuji Campus, T.R. Nagara, Challakere-577522

Dist. Chitradurga, Karnataka


24. Poona District Education Association’s, College of Ayurved & Research Centre, Tal.

Haveli, Dist. Pune – 411044, Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 11 subjects namely 1. Samhita Siddhanta -02seats,

2. Rachna Sharir -06 seats, 3. Kriya Sharir -06 seats,

4. Dravyaguna – 02 seats, 5. Rognidan -06 seats,

6. Agad tantra-06 seats, 7. Swasthavritta -06 seats,

8. Prasuti Tantra -02 seats, 9. Kayachikitsa -06 seats,

10. Shalya Tantra -02 seats, 11. Panchkarma -06 seats

25. Taranath Govt. Ayurvedic Medical College, Ananthpura Road, Bellary-583101, Karnataka

Recommended for UG 40 seats and PG in 1 subject namely Rasashastra & Bhaishjakalpana 7 seats

26. Government Ayurveda College, P.O Pariyaram Medical College, Kannur-670503, Kerala

Recommended for UG 40 seats and PG in 2 subjects namely 1. Kriya Sharir-5 seats

2. Rognidan-5 seats

27. Rajkiya Ayodhya Shivkumar Ayurved College

& Hospital, Dist. Begusrai-851218, Bihar

Not recommended due to following reasons

1. There are only 3 higher faculties in 03 departments against the requirement of 12 higher faculties in 11 departments.

2. Non functionality of the hospital

28. Govt. Ayurvedic College, Raje Raghuji Nagar,

Umrer Road, Sakkardara Chowk, Nagpur-440024, Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG in 9 subjects namely

1. Rachna Sharir-4 seats 2. Kriya Sharir-4 seats

3. Rasashastra & Bhaishjakalpana-2 seats 4. Swasthavritta-1 seats

5. Rognidan-1 seats 6. Agad tantra-3 seats

7. Shalya tantra-3 seats 8. Shalakya tantra-1 seats

9. Kayachikitsa-2 seats

29. Government Ayurved College, Wazirabad, Tal.

&, Dist. Nanded 431601, Maharashtra


1. Samhita Siddhanta-2 seats 2. Rachna Sharir-3 seats

3. Kriya Sharir-4 seats 4. Dravyaguna-2 seats

189ec minutes 18

5. Rasashastra & Bhaishjakalpana-2 seats

6. Rognidan-2 seats 7. Swasthavritta-2 seats

8. Prasuti tantra & Stri roga-2 seats 9. Shalya tantra-4 seats

10. Shalakya tantra-5 seats 11. Kaumarbhritya-3 seats

12. Kayachikitsa-4 seats 13.

30. Mahatma Gandhi Ayurved College, Hospital & Research Centre, Salod Hirapur, Dist.

Wardha, Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG in 2 subjects namely 1. Samhita Siddhanta-4 seats

2. Dravyaguna-4 seats Not recommended for PG in Rachna Sharir due to deficit higher

faculty

31. Sri Sai Ram Ayurveda Medical College &

Research Centre, Taluk Kanchipuram, Chennai – 600044,

Tamil Nadu


32. Dayanand Ayurvedic College, Mahatma Hans Raj Marg, G.T. Road, Opp. Burlton Park, Dist.

Jalandhar-144008, Punjab


33. S.R.M. Govt. Ayurvedic College Bansmandi,

Bareilly-243005 Uttar Pradesh


34. Govt. Auto Ayurved College & Hospital, Amkho Lashkar, Gwalior -474009

Madhya Pradesh

Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG in 01 subject namely 1. Kriya Sharir -4 seats

35. Shri Balahanuman Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

At & Post Lodra, Ta.Mansa, Dist. Gandhinagar-382835

Gujarat

Not recommended.

1. Eight departments are not having single teachers. 2. There are total 06 teachers against the requirement of 27

3. The bed occupancy 22.73% against the requirement of 40%. 4. Non functionality of the hospital.

36. Kannada Balag Society’s

Rural Ayurveda Medical College, Auto Nagar, Main Double Road, Tq & Dt. Belgaum-590016,

Karnataka


37. Taluka Shikshan Prasarak Sahakara Mandali

Ayurvedic Medical College and Hospital Sindgi-586128, Dist. Bijapur, Karnataka

Not recommended due to deficit of higher faculty.

3. There are only 13 higher faculties in 08 departments against

the requirement of 12 higher faculties in 11 departments.

38. Govindbhai Jorabhai Patel

Ayurveda College and Research Centre B/h G.I.D.C, New Vallabh Vidyanagar, Taluka;

Dist. Anand-388121, Gujarat


39. Ashtang Ayurveda College, Pune 411030,

Maharashtra

Not recommended due to following reason:-

1. The higher facilities are only in 10 departments against the requirement in 11 departments.

40. Shri Shirdi Sai Baba Ayurvedic College &

Hospital, Mundiyagarh Kishangarh-Renwal , Jaipur- 303603, Rajasthan


41. Smt. Urmila Devi Ayurvedic College Kharkan,

Dist. Hoshiarpur 146001

Punjab


42. Karnataka Ayurveda Medical College Ashok

Nagar, Mangalore D.K.,

Karnataka


43. Shree Narayan Institute of Ayurvedic Studies

& Research, P.O Puthur 691507, Kottarakkara (Via)

Dist. Kollam Kerala


44. Shri Gurudeo Ayurved College,

At/Po. Gurukunj Ashram, Tq. Tiosa, Dist. Amravati-444902

Maharashtra


45. Rajiv Gandhi Ayurvedic College & Hospital

E-8, Trilanga Colony Shahpura,

Bhopal-462039

Madhya Pradesh


46. Lt. Sunil Ramsinh Chunawale Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya


189ec minutes 19

Deendayal Nagar, Tq. Chikhli – 443201,

Dist. Buldana Maharashtra

47. Late Kedari Redekar Ayurvedic Mahavidyalaya,

P-2, MIDC Area, Shendri Mal, Tal. Gadhinglaj,

Dist. Kolhapur – 416502 Maharashtra

Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG in 3 subjects namely 1. Rognidan-4 seats

2. Rasashastra & Bhaishjakalpana-5 seats 3. Shalya tantra-5 seats

48. Vimla Devi Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital

At Wandhari, Post-Tadali Tal & Dist-Chandarpur, Maharashtra


49. Parul Institute of Ayurved, P.O Limda, Tal. Waghodia

Distt. Vadodara- 391760

Gujarat


50. A.V. Samiti’s Ayurveda Mahavidyalaya

Vidya Nagar, Bagalkot Road, Dist. & Tal Bijapur-586101

Karnataka


1. Rasashastra & Bhaishjakalpana-5 seats

51. Aroor Laxminarayana Rao Memorial

Ayurvedic Medical College Koppa- 577126, Dist. Chikmagalur

Karnataka


1. Dravyaguna-6 seats 2. Rasashastra & Bhaishjakalpana-5 seats

3. Kayachikitsa-5 seat

52. Shri Anand Niketan Dharmshala Avom

Dharmik Trust, Shri Dhanwantri Ayurvedic Medical College & Research Centre

At NH – 02, Vill. Semari, Tehsil Chhatta , Dist. Mathura,

Uttar Pradesh


Executive Committee agreed to the recommendation of Screening Committee and decided to send the recommendation to GOI.

Addl. Agenda Item No.8. Clarification received from Dr. Shaik Shahul

Hameed, Chennai regarding his T.A. claim for the two separate journeys of Jaipur to

conduct visitation of two Unani colleges.

It was noted that an email/letter has been received from Dr. Shaik Shahul Hameed,

Chennai furnishing clarification of his two T.A. claims for the two separate journeys

of Jaipur to conduct visitation of two Unani colleges. In his letter, it has been stated

that just during the visitation of first Unani college on 17.1.2014, he was intimated

over phone that the Minister of Health, Govt. of Tamil Nadu is going to visit the

Govt. Unani Medical College, Chennai on 20.1.2014 and being the Principal and

Head of the Institution, he was supposed to be at Chennai all of sudden. That’s

why, he had to leave Jaipur just after completing the visitation of the first Unani

college and after attending to the urgent and sudden visit of the Hon’ble Minister of

Health, he again participated in the visitation of the second Unani college at Jaipur.

With this justification and clarification, Dr. Shaik Shahul Hameed has requested to

admit the said two T.A. bills.

Executive Committee accepted the clarification and directed office to clear

the T.A. Bill of the member.

Addl. Agenda Item No.9. Proposal of Dr. G. Parusha Ram Reddy,

Member, CCIM.

189ec minutes 20

It was noted that a letter has been received from Dr. G. Parusha Ram Reddy,

Member, CCIM regarding changes of subjects and marks in different professionals

in latest UG Regulation (Ayurved). The letter/ proposal may kindly be seen at

ANNEXURE – 1.

Executive Committee deferred the matter to Regulation amendment

committee.

Addl. Agenda Item No.10. Inclusion of resolution presented by

Dr. Vishwajeet Singh in EC meeting.

It was noted that an email is received in the office of CCIM by Dr. Vishwajeet Singh,

Member, CCIM. The content is as under:-

” 1. Online link for the public to upload the information and complaints about the

standards of Ayurvedic College.

2. Legal definition of Ayurvedic drugs in India as there is no legal definition of

Ayurvedic drugs as per AYUSH department, Govt. of India.

3. Recommendation to Central and State Governments to include BAMS degree in Employment departments as many states are not having this degree to get

registered as unemployed although MBBS, MD, BDS, MDS, B.Vsc etc are

included. 4. Recommendation to the Central Government and other concerned agencies

BAMS eligible for admission to MPH/MHA/MBA (Health/Hospital

Management)/direct Ph.D as for MBBS. 5. Nationally accepted Legislative framework for the practice of MD (Rog

vigyan)/MS Ayu. Surgery) etc.

6. Legislative guidelines for all the Central/State departments to accept the

medical certificate sign by the BAMS Graduates (Section 17-c IMCC Act) 7. Regulations of Indian Government meant for identification and differentiation

of Ayurvedic drugs from Allopathic drugs and vice-versa.

8. Recommendation to Central and State Governments for giving rights under different acts to graduates of Ayurveda for purpose of Gynecology and

Obstetrics to the extent of their teaching and training in this subject.

9. Constitution of IMCC Act 1970 Amendment Committee as various Sections of

this Act are in immediate need to be amended as per the need in today scenario and need of ISM community of India.

10.CCIM Members may be empowered to visit colleges in their state on receipt of

complaint by Student’s /teachers/practitioners and submit a confidential report to President/Secretary CCIM. This report shall be presented before EC for

necessary action.”

Executive Committee referred the matter to General Body.

Agenda Item No.11. Letter received from Dr. Chandrakant Kolte

Regarding Bill of Bridge Course meeting at Pune.

189ec minutes 21

It was noted that a letter relieved from Dr. Chandrakant Kolte dated 02.03.2014

regarding Bills of expenditure done by him at the time of Meeting of Bridge Course

(PG syllabus) held on 23-24.12.2013 at Pune. The content of letter is as under:-

“the meeting of Bridge Course syllabus of PG was held on 23-24.12.2013 at BJ

Medical College Pune and I was convener of the meeting and hold responsibility of

the meeting was given to me. I have done all the expenditure of the meeting. So I

request you to kindly clear my bills and make the payments.

The details of bills submitted by Dr. Chandrakant Kolte are as under:

Sl. Number of Bills / Date of Bills Expenditure done

Amount of Bills

1. 62 / 24.12.2013 Canteen of BJ Medical College (Breakfast, Tea, Coffee & snacks)

6550/-

2. 45812/23.12.2013 Xerox copies of syllabus

450/-

3. 34331/05.01.2014 42 Lunch Packs on 23.12.2013

5880/-

4. 9330/24.12.2013 Lunch packs on 24.12.2013

4220/-

5. 314/ 24.12.2013 Rutuja Tours & Travels

1992/-

6. 4839/25.12.2013 Shantai Hotel Dinner

25000/-

Total Amount 44072/-

Executive Committee decided to clear the bills of expenditure done by the member during Bridge Course meeting.

Addl. Agenda Item No.12. Reporting of decision of GOI in respect of

various colleges.

It was noted Govt. of Indian has forwarded that decision in respect of following colleges:-

Sl. No.

Name of college Subject Ref. no. & date GOI decision

1. Lt. Sunil Ramsinh Chunawale Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Deendayal Nagar, Tq. Chikhli, Dist. Buldana Maharashtra

Grant of permission to the Lt. Sunil Ramsinh Chunawale Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Tq. Chikhli –Dist. Buldana Maharashtra for UG course with 40 seats under section 13A/C of the IMCC Act, 1970 for the

R.17011/151/2011-EP (IM-1) dated 04.03.2014

In supersession to the Departments order no., R.17011/151/2011- EP(IM-1) dated 08.09.2011. it has been decided by the Central Government to Grant permission to the Lt. Sunil Ramsinh Chunawale Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Chikhli Maharashtra for BAMS UG course with 40 seats under section of the IMCC Act, 1970 for the academic session 2011-12 incompliance to the order

189ec minutes 22

academic session 2011-12 incompliance to the order dated 22.11.2013 in WP No. 5054 of 2011 of Hon’ble High Court of Bombay, Nagpur Bench at Nagpur - Reg

dated 22.11.2013 in WP No. 5054 of 2011 of Hon’ble High Court of Bombay, Nagpur Bench at Nagpur - Reg

2. Shetkari Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’s Mahesh Ayurved College, Ashti, Teh. Ashti, Dist. Beed 414203 Maharashtra

Grant of permission to the Shetkari Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’s Mahesh Ayurved College, Ashti, Teh. Ashti, Dist. Beed , Maharashtra

R.12011/37/2006-EP (IM-1) dated 30.10.2013

It has been decided by the Central Government not to Grant permission to Shetkari Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’s Mahesh Ayurved College, Ashti, Teh. Ashti, Dist. Beed Maharashtra for taking admission to BAMS course at 50 seats in the acedamic year 2013-14 under section 13A of the IMCC, Act, 1970.

3. Parassinikkadavu Ayurveda Medical College, P.O Parassinikkadavu, Dist. Kannur-

Kerala

Kept in abeyance the order of the withdrawal of Letter of Intent dated 20.12.2013 against 13A application dated 23.04.2012 of the Parassinikkadavu Ayurveda Medical College, Parassinikkadavu, Dist. Kannur, Kerala to increase the admission capacity from 50 to 60 seats in existing BAMS course – Incompliance of the order dated 04.12.2013 & 03.01.2014 in WP (C) No. 29480 of 2013 (H) passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala at Ernakulum –Reg.

R.14011/46/2012-EP (IM-1) dated 06.03.2014

With reference to the department’s order of even No. dated 20.12.2013 for withdrawing the Letter of Intent against the application dated 23.04.2013 under section 13A of IMCC Act, 1970 to increase the intake capacity in the said college from 50 to 60 seats in existing BAMS course due to Non submission of bank guarantee as per the IMCC Act, and the relevant regulation. The department has received a letter from the college forwarding their with the order Hon’ble High Court of Kerala at Ernakulum dated 04.12.2013 and 03.01.2014 respectively passed in WP (C) No. 29480/2013 (H) came to know that vide order dated 04.12.2013 the Hon’ble High Court was pleased to stay the further proceeding in pursuant to letter dated 29.10. 2013 and 20.11.2013 issued by the department. Since the department has no knowledge/ intimation about the interim order dated 04.12.2013 prior to receipt the letter of the college, the order dated 20.12.2013 was issued, withdrawing the letter of intent dated 30.04.2013 to college and rejecting their application dated 23.04.2012. now as the department has come to know about the stay order dated 04.12.2013 and 03.01.2014

189ec minutes 23

passed in WP (C) No. 29480/2013 (H), the department order dated 20.12.2013 is hereby kept in abeyance till further order of the Hon’ble Court.

4. Bhanwar Lal Nahata Samriti Sansthan, Mandsaur Institute of Ayurved education & Research, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh

Grant of permission to the Bhanwar Lal Nahata Samriti Sansthan, Mandsaur Institute of Ayurved education & Research, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh for UG course with 50 seats under section 13A of the IMCC Act, 1970 for the academic session 2011-12 incompliance to the order dated 18.12.2013 of Hon’ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore in WP No. 9345/2011 alongwith WP No. 7444/2011- Reg

R.12011/10/2009- EP (IM-1) dated 04.03.2014

In supersession to the Departments order no., R.12011/12/2009- EP dated 25.10.2011. it has been decided by the Central Government to Grant permission to the Bhanwar Lal Nahata Samriti Sansthan, Mandsaur Institute of Ayurved education & Research, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh for UG course with 50 seats under section 13A of the IMCC Act, 1970 for the academic session 2011-12 incompliance to the order dated 18.12.2013 of Hon’ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore in WP No. 9345/2011 alongwith WP No. 7444/2011- Reg.

5. Shri Dhanwantry

Ayurvedcl College

& Dabur

Dhanwantry

Hospital

Chandigarh.

Grant of permission to

Shri Dhanwantry

Ayurvedcl College

& Dabur

Dhanwantry

Hospital

Chandigarh,

Punjab for BAMS

(UG) course with

50 seats under

section 13C/A of

the IMCC Act,

1970 for the

academic session

2010-11

incompliance to

courts order dated

17.07.2013 of

Hon;ble High

Court of Punjab &

Haryana at

Chandigarh in

LPA No.2156/2012

(O&M) field

against order

R.17011/14/2009- EP (IM-1) dated 07.04.2014 (relieved on 14.03.2014)

In supersession to the Departments order no., R.17011/14/2009- EP dated 20.10.2010. it has been decided by the Central Government to Grant

permission to the Shri

Dhanwantry Ayurved College &

Dabur Dhanwantry Hospital

Plot No.-M-688, Sector 46-B

Chandigarh, Punjab for BAMS

(UG) course with 50 seats under

section 13C/A of the IMCC Act,

1970 for the academic session

2010-11 incompliance to courts

order dated 17.07.2013 of

Hon;ble High Court of Punjab &

Haryana at Chandigarh in LPA

No.2156/2012 (O&M) field

against order dated 07.09.2012 in

CWP No. 17592/2010.- Reg.

189ec minutes 24

dated 07.09.2012

in CWP No.

17592/2010.

Executive Committee agreed to the recommendation of Screening Committee and decided to send the recommendation to GOI.

Addl. Agenda Item No.13. Recommendation of Screening

Committee in respect of Bagamar Seva

Samiti’s Bhagwan Mahaveer

Jain Ayurvedic Medical College &

Hospital Gajendergad, Dist. Gadag,

Karnataka visited under Section 13A for

reconsideration.

It was noted that the matter related to recommendation of Bagamar Seva Samiti’s

Bhagwan Mahaveer Jain Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital Gajendergad, Dist.

Gadag Karnataka under Section 13 A was discussed in 188th Meeting of EC under

Agenda Item No.14 and EC is decided to recommend for increasing 50 to 60 UG

seats and to start new PG in(i) Ayurved Siddhanta (ii) Sharir Rachna (iii) Sharir

Kriya (iv) Kaumarbhritya with 5 seats each. But not recommended for PG courses in

(i) Rognidan (ii) Prasuti Tantra as this college not fulfilling the minimum space

requirement.

Further, it was noted that while sending the recommendation it was noticed by the

office staff that college cannot be not recommended for PG in Kaumarbhritya as

state Government NOC was only for 04 PG subjects and not for PG in

Kaumarbhritya and Prasuti Tantra. Therefore, with the approval of President I/c,

CCIM the matter was reconsidered by screening committee on 14.03.2014 and

remarks of screening committee are as under:-

“not recommended for starting new PG course in Kaumarbhritya as the college not

submitted NOC from state govt. for PG in Kaumarbhritya & Prasuti Tantra”

Executive Committee agreed to the same.

Addl. Agenda Item No.14. Matter in respect of eligibility of

teachers- regarding.

It was noted that a meeting of screening committee was held from 18th to 22nd

Feb 2014 in pursuance of letter issued by Central Council of Indian Medicine vide

letter No. 26-80/2014(teacher eligibility) dated 14.02.2014, 18.02.2014 and

20.02.2014 with the approval of President I/C, CCIM. Following members were

present in the meeting of screening committee:-

S. No. Date of screening committee Name of members of screening committee

1 18.02.2014 Dr. B.P.Pandey

Dr. V.G. Udaykumar

189ec minutes 25

Dr. Ragini Patil

2 19.02.2014 Dr. B.P.Pandey Dr. Ragini Patil

3 20.02.2014 Dr. Ragini Patil Dr.S.K. Bannigol

Dr.K.G.Vishwanathan

4 21-22.02.2014 Dr K.G.Vishwanathan

Dr. S.K.Bannigol, Dr. Sarangpani

Decision of Screening Committee are as under:-

Sl.

No.

Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of screening committee

SCREENED BY Dr. B.P.Pandey, Dr. V.G. Udaykumar, Dr. Ragini Patil on 18.02.2014

1. Dr. T.S.Gopalkrishna Reader Swasthvritta Considered eligible after deducting the period of long gap from 1992 to 2011,

as teacher was in service under state Govt.

2. Dr. M. Sudheer Kumar Professor Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 2007 to 2009

3. Dr. Kulamani Sarangi Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible after deducting the period of controversy (4years) as

teacher was on suspension

4. Dr. Phaim Mohd. Shafi Qureshi

Lecturer Shalya Tantra Considered eligible Lecturer in shalya tantra dept. from 01.01.2010 onwards

after deducting the experience of 2 years

5. Dr. Anita Gunwantrao Holey

Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience

6. Dr.Murli Dhar Das Reader Shalya Tantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of controversary (4years) of

teaching experience

7. Dr. Prabhugouda Patil Lecturer Sharir Kriya Considered eligible

8. Dr.Arun Kumar Sharma Professor Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the

period of 2 years, as teacher is non PG joining before 1989

9. Dr. Asha Gupta Professor Ras Shastra Considered eligible

10. Dr. Kishore Daulatrao

Tarar

Reader Samhita Considered eligible

11. Dr. Rakesh Kumar Singh Reader Shalakya

Tantra

Considered eligible after deducting the

period of one year experience

12. Dr. Seema Saxena Reader Kriya Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience

13. Dr. Bhavana Vinod Shah Professor Kaumarbritya Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience

14. Dr. Anitha Panda Reader Ras Shastra Considered eligible after deducting the

previous experience from 20.10.2004 to

30.05.2007 of Santhigiri Ayurved College Pallakad Kerala

15. Dr. P.K. Beena Rose Professor Prasuti Tantra Considered eligible

16. Dr. Snehalata Jakkula Reader Kaumarbritya Considered eligible and teaching experience countable from 03.07.2006

onwards

17. Dr.Lilabati Mishra Reader Panchkarma Considered eligible after deducting the period of two year experience

18. Dr. Arun Kumar Singh Reader Kaumarbritya Considered eligible

19. Dr. Saily Sreedhary

Parameswaran

Lecturer Swasthavritta Considered eligible and teaching

experience will be counted from the daye of result of PG (2013)

20. Dr. Kalyani Pranita Prakash

Reader Kyachitiksa Considered eligible

21. Dr. Prasant Anant Surup Reader Shalakya

Tantra


period of two year experience

22. Dr. Manoj K.S. --- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher

and the concerned college for

189ec minutes 26

Sl.

No.


clarification

23. Dr. Kavita Vyas -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

24. Dr. Sharavati Goroba

Kamble

-- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher

and the concerned college for clarification

25. Dr. Neeta Narendra Harale -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

26. Dr. Renuka Chegaraddi -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


27. Dr.Pravin Laxman Naik -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


28. Dr. Amit Prakash Nawkar -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

29. Dr. Sharmila Sen Das -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


30. Dr.Minakshi Gopalrao Borude

-- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

31. Dr. Sudhir Manohar Zuvekar


clarification

SCREENED BY Dr. B.P.Pandey, Dr. Ragini Patil on 19.02.2014 32. Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the


33. Dr. P.S. Vinohba Professor Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience

34. Dr.Neeta Raj Holkar Reader Sharir Rachna Considered eligible after deducting the

period of three year experience

35. Dr. Sheshadri B.V.

Venkatarao B.V.

Professor Panchkarma Considered eligible

36. Dr. Mahadev Laxman

Bhosle

Professor Shalakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the

period of three year experience

37. Dr. Yashpal Singh Lecturer Panchkarma Considered eligible after deducting the


38. Dr. Basavraj Dundappa

Hundekar

Professor Samhita

Siddhant

Considered eligible

39. Dr. Sunil Bandopant Patil Professor Rasashastra Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience

40. Dr. Kavita Gorla Lecturer Prasutu tantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Controversy and experience

will be counted w.e.f. 01.01.2011 onwards

41. Dr. Venkatshiva Chadalawada

Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience

42. Dr Manish Lodha Reader Kriya Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience

43. Dr. Chitralekha K.S. Reader Kayachikitsa Considered eligible after deducting the

period of two years experience

44. Dr. Bhimrao Ganpat Patil Professor Prasuti tantra Considered eligible after deducting the


45. Dr. Sanjay Ramchandra

Mali

Professor Kriya Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the


46. Dr. Shambhunath Baijnath

Raj

Professor Kaumarbhritya Considered eligible after deducting the


47. Dr. Ujwala Kantilal Shah Professor Rognidan



48. Dr. Cheriyachen P. Professor Panchakarma Considered eligible after deducting the


49. Dr. Krishnaji Vithoba Phadtare

Professor Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of three years experience

50. Dr. Ashok Virupaxappa Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the

189ec minutes 27

Sl.

No.


Nandi period of one year experience

51. Dr. Shobha Shivram Mhasawade

Reader Shalakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience

52. Dr. Kantha Reddy Toomu Professor Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience

53. Dr. T.C. Jayaraj Professor Rognidan

Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience

54. Dr. Archana Jagadish Desai


clarification

55. Dr. Poormina V. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


56. Dr. Narashmulu M. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


57. Dr. Rajendra Ojha -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher

and the concerned college for

clarification and supportive documents

as name of first college is not clearly mentioned in the teaching staff list

58. Dr. Stella Thekkekara George

Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

Submitting PG certificate

59. Dr. Anil Singhai -- -- Ask to verify previous experience which was not mentioned in 2010, from

teaching staff list of Rani Dhullayia Ayurved college. If the experience date

match with previous data the teacher may be considered as Eligible Reader in

Kayachikitsa

60. Dr. Govardhana Reddy

Ravula

-- -- Ask to verify previous record from the

year 2002 to 2006 of the concerned college

SCREENED BY Dr. Ragini Patil , Dr.S.K. Bannigol, Dr.K.G.Vishwanathan on 20.02.2014 61. Dr. Pradhumnha

Madhukarrao Pasarkar

Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible

62. Dr. Laxmi Soujanya D. Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible after deducting the experience of Hingulambika Ayurvedic

College, Gulberga, as reqested by teacher at the time of hearing

63. Dr. Reddy V.L.Prasannakumar V.

Satyanarayana

Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience of Sri Sairam Ayurvedic

College , Chennai as per statement

given by teacher at the time of hearing

64. Dr. Premananda Kar Lecturer Panchakarma Considered eligible

65. Dr. Mangesh Parkash

Deshpandey

Reader Sharir Rachna Considered eligible after deducting the

experience of KMCT Ayurved College, Kozhikkode Kerala.

66. Dr. Santosh Kumar Mishra Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible

67. Dr. Milind Ganesh Mokashi Professor Samhita Siddhant

Considered eligible

68. Dr. Niranjan Shukla Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible

69. Dr. Namrata Harichandan Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the

experience of SVM Ayurved College ILKAL.

70. Dr. Vrushali Tole Reader Shalakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience

71. Dr. Vasant Patil Reader Panchakarma Considered eligible

72. Dr. Chandu Nair

Govindapillai Sarawathy

Amma

Professor Swasthavitta Considered eligible

73. Dr Sudha Rani . R. Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible

74. Dr. Deepa Atul Lecturer Samhita Considered eligible

189ec minutes 28

Sl.

No.


Anserwadekar Siddhant

75. Dr. Prasanth S. Acharya Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience of Ramakrishna Ayurved

College Banglore as he was working as honorary teacher and his teaching

experience will be considered from 01.10.2006 onwards

76. Dr. Akthar Hussain -- Considered ineligible as non PG joining after 1989

77. Dr. Chaihtanya R. Menon -- -- Directed to write a letter to the teacher and concerned college for submission of

PG degree and after submission of PG degree the teacher may be treated

eligible teacher in concerned subject after the approval of President CCIM.

78. Dr. Krishna Kumar T.S. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


79. Dr. Shakuntala Mahapati -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

80. Dr. Indira Shivnand

Hiremath



81. Dr. Satwashila Thorat -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

82. Dr. Seema Punjabrao

Gangale



83. Dr. Seema Singh -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


84. Dr. Rama Krishna T. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

85. Dr. Jayalaxmi

Shankargouda Menasagi



86. Dr.Ashwini Venkatesh Junjarwad


clarification

87. Dr Chandra Shekher Pandey

-- -- Directed to take a legal opinion in the matter

88. Dr. Ashok Kumar Tripathi -- -- Directed to take a legal opinion in the matter

SCREENED BY Dr K.G.Vishwanathan, Dr. S.K.Bannigol, Dr. Sarangpani on 21.02.2014 89. Dr. Dhanraj Bhagwan

Gayakwaid

Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible

90. Dr. Anita Santoshrao Wanjari

Reader Rasshastra Considered eligible

91. Dr. Padmavati Venkatesh Kulkarni

Reader Panchakarma Considered eligible

92. Dr. Dharmendra Kumar Mishra

Professor Swasthavritta Considered eligible

93. Dr. Itnal Shobha Ramappa Lecturer Kayachikitsa Considered eligible

94. Dr. Awade Swateja Ajit Reader Prasuti Tantra Considered eligible

95. Dr. Prasanna K.G. Lecturer Kayachikitsa Considered eligible and teaching

experience will be counted from 01.01.2012 onwards

96. Dr.Chandrashekhar Alladi Lecturer Samhita Siddhant

Considered eligible after deducting the previous experience of six years and

teaching experience will be counted from 01.06.2008 onwards

97. Dr. Anil Kallappa Bagalkoti Lecturer Swasthavritta Considered eligible and teaching experience will be counted from date of

completion of PG

98. Dr. Subbaraju Nagaraju Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the

189ec minutes 29

Sl.

No.


M. Reddi previous experience from 06 01 1997 to

10.10.2000 and teaching experience will be counted from 16.10.2000 onwards

99. Dr. Satyendra Chaturvedi Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible

100. Dr.Tanuja Pawar Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible and teaching

experience will be counted from 10.02.2009 onwards

101. Dr. Hemant Laxman Shinde

Reader Rachna Sharir Considered eligible

102. Dr. Pramod Anand Tiwari Reader Rachna Sharir Considered eligible

103. Dr.Shrikant Gaddi Halli Shetty

Professor Samhita Siddhant

Considered eligible

104. Dr. Virendra Singh Yadav Lecturer Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the previous experience from 01.10.1998 to

19.02.2007 and teaching experience will be counted from 05.05.2008 onwards

105. Dr. P Laxmaiah -- -- Ineligible due to overage

106. Dr. Satish Chandra

Madanlal Jaiswal



107. Dr. Ujwal Krishna Deshpande


clarification

108. Dr. Rajeshwari Sangagouda Biradar


clarification

109. Dr. Rohini Revansidha

Keskar


and the concerned college for clarification and Directed to verify the

records available with CCIM

110. Dr Atul Nirgude -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


111. Dr.P.Nageshwara Babu -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

112. Dr.Ishwarappa Prahillad Ugar


clarification

113. Dr.Rajnesh Kumar Mishra -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


114. Dr. Tushar Jagannath Jogi -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for

clarification

115. Dr. Subash Maruti Kolhe -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG

Joining after 01.07.1989

116. Dr. Nisha K.V. -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG


117. Dr. Devrajan Shankarnarayan

-- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989

118. Dr. Pradeep Sreedharan As per the certificate with ref No B3/3040/2012 Dated 25.08.2012 issued by the Principal of Govt. Ayurvedic College, Tripunithura That

Dr. Pradeep S is a final year PG in Panchakarma under M.G.University and will complete MD exam on 03.09.2012. Oral and practical exams

of the same is scheduled on 04.09.2012 and 05.09.2012. Date of birth of the teacher is 29/05/1964 i.e. above 45. So

screening committee ask to refer the matter to the Executive committee as teacher is PG.

SCREENED BY Dr K.G.Vishwanathan, Dr. S.K.Bannigol, Dr. Sarangpani on 22.02.2014 119. Dr. Bhagirathi Sahoo Lecturer Kaumarbhritya Considered eligible after deducting the

period of four years experience

120. Dr. Bhagavati Mohan Professor Prasutitantra Considered eligible after deducting the

189ec minutes 30

Sl.

No.


Mahantappa experience from 01.04.2000 to

31.02.2009.

121. Dr. Sunil Kumar Bansal Professor Kayachikitsa Considered eligible

122. Dr.Sunita Goyal Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 28.09.1998 to

14.06.2003.

123. Dr. Usha Ravindra

Deshmukh

Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible

124. Dr.Jonthan Rout Lecturer Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the

experience from 01.05.2006 to 10.01.2012(period of suspension).

125. Dr. Bihu Ranjan Nanda Reader Shlakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the

experience from 15.04.2006 to 14.02.2009(period of suspension).

126. Dr. Sapan Kumar Das Lecturer Shlakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 15.04.2006 to

14.02.2009(period of suspension).

127. Dr. Satya Naryan Patnaik Professor Kayachikitsa Considered eligible after deducting the

experience from 2006 to 2009(period of suspension).

128. Dr. Kailash Chandra Tripathi

Reader Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 15.04.2006 to


129. Dr.Subhendu Kumar Nanda

Reader Prasuti Tantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 15.04.2006 to


130. Dr. Jogesh Chandra Rath Professor Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the

experience from 2006 to 2009(period of suspension).

131. Dr. Niranjan Prasad Tripathi

Lecturer Samhita Siddhant

Considered eligible after deducting the experience three years.

132. Dr. Mruthyunjaya Nanjundaiah Hiremeth

Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible after completion of PG, 2007(date of result)

133. Dr. Baban Singh Reader Swasthvritta Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 03.10.2003 to

21.12.2009.

134. Dr.Dilip Prabhakar Gadgil Professor Samhita Siddhant

Considered eligible after deducting the experience of Tilak Maharashtra

vidyapeeth Pune .

135. Dr. Madanlal Dewashwar Reader Kayachikitsa Considered eligible

136. Dr. Praveen Kumar Shayamsunder Madikonda

Lecturer Panchakarma Considered eligible and teaching experience will be counted from

09.11.2011 onwards.

137. Dr. Amol Suresh Doshi Reader Prasuti tantra Considered eligible

138. Dr. Kembhavi Akash Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible

139. Dr. Dayanand S Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience two years.

140. Dr. N.R.Shankarnarayana -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989

141. Dr. Shankar Pandurang Chougule


142. Dr.Yellambhatla Janardhana

-- -- Considered ineligible due to due to overage

143. Dr. Krupakar Reddy -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG


144. Dr.Vilas Rajaram Mane -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG


145. Dr. Dwarkanath Shripad

Kodolikar

-- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG


146. Dr. Ravindranath

Basappashetty Gundal



147. Dr. Suresh Venkappa

Amberkar



148. Dr.Maheshwar Siddayya

Karpurmath



149. Dr.Girijashankar Banshnarayan Singh


150. Dr.Prakash Pandurang -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher

189ec minutes 31

Sl.

No.


Gosavi and the concerned college for

clarification

151. Dr. T. Venugopal -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG

Joining after 01.07.1989 as experience shown from 01.01.1988 is found false

after verification with concerned college.

152. Dr. Vivekanand Shridhar

More



153. Dr. Nisha P. -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG


154. Dr. Mahajan Anita -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher


155. Dr. Krishan Kumar

Sharma

--

Directed to put up the matter before EC

Executive Committee agreed to the recommendation of Screening

Committee except S. No. 118 and 115 which will be discussed in next EC.

LEGAL

Addl. Agenda Item No.15. Ratification of the amount paid in respect of

translation of Hindi documents into English by

Govt. approved translator for filing in

Supreme Court.

It was noted that as a rule for filing petition in Supreme Court the documents are

required to be translated from Hindi to English by Govt. approved translator. The

SLP was in process to be filed before Supreme Court for vacation of stay on

forwarding recommendations to GOI, granted by Nainital High Court in W.P. No.

1754/2013. The President I/C, CCIM considering the emergency in matter directed

Legal Axis to get the work done on urgent basis as the SLP was ready for filing in

Supreme Court on 14.02.2014. Accordingly Legal Axis got the translation work

done besides typing documents from English to English. Thereafter the bill of

amount of Rs.44,000/- was received from Legal Axis and President, I/c accorded

his sanction for the said amount for the Payment of Legal Axis. The Details are as

under:-

S.No. Name of Law

Firm

Case No. Amount

1. Legal Axis SLP No. 5230/2014,

CCIM V/s Ved Prakash

Tyagi & Ors. Supreme

Court of India.

Rs. 44,000/-

(Rs.150 X 210Pages=

Rs.31,500/-)

(Rs. 25X 500Pages=Rs.

12,500/-)


189ec minutes 32

Addl. Agenda Item No.16. Denial of Admission to ISM Courses by some

Universities during one month extension of cutoff date by GOI- regarding.

The matter was discussed in EC that GOI has extended the cutoff date of admission

to ISM Courses from 31.10.2013 to 30.11.2013 as a one time measure for admission in 2013-14 session and the same has been circulated to all the

Universities. However, EC objected that some Universities are not considering the

students admitted after 31.10.2013 upto 31.11.2013.

Executive Committee decided that a strong letter is to be written to all

Universities to the effect to comply the order of GOI in respect of cutoff date for 2013-14 session.

The meeting concluded with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

central council of indian medicine new...

Documents