City Hal l East 200 N . Main Street Room 800 Los Angeles, CA 900 12

CARMEN A. TRUTANICH City Attorney

REPORT RE:

(213) 978-8100 Tel (213) 978-831 2 Fax

CTrutanich@lacity.org www. lacity.org/atty

REPORT NO. R 1 3 - 0 0 ~ 1 FEB 1 Y 2013

OUTSIDE COUNSEL EXPENDITURES FISCAL YEAR 2013

The Honorable Budget & Finance Committee of the City of Los Angeles

Room 1010, City Hall 200 North Spring Street Los Angeles, California 90012

Honorable Members:

Attached please find the Citywide Outside Counsel Expenditures Report for Fiscal Year 2013 as of September, 2012 (First Quarter). Pursuant to City Council approval of July 27, 2011, this report now captures expenditures on a quarterly, rather than bi-monthly, basis. As directed by Council, the City Attorney met with the CAO to discuss appropriate revisions to this expenditures report. As a result of that meeting, General Funded contract expenditures are now separated from Special funded ones and the recap is organized by client department rather than paying department. There is also the addition of a "Status of General Fund Appropriations" which shows any previous draws from the Unappropriated Balance outside counsel line item for the year and the remaining balance in that line item. As before, information is included for all City departments regardless of funding source and expenditure data is provided on a per contract basis and includes appropriation amounts and individual contract balances. We will continue to work with the various departments on a regular basis to ensure that cost savings measures are applied and that the information we report is accurate.

The Honorable Budget & 1 _,.a nee Committee of the City of Los Angeles

Page 2 of 2

I hope this information is useful to you. I look forward to working with you as we continue to refine and enhance the City's management of outside counsel and its tracking and reporting of outside counsel data. If you have any questions, please contact Assistant City Attorney Anne Haley at 213-978-7009.

Chief Deputy City Attorney

Attachments

cc: Miguel Santana, City Administrative Office Gerry Miller, Chief Legislative Analyst

STATUS OF UNAPPROPRIATED BALANCE OUTSIDE COUNSEL INCLUDING WORKERS' COMPLINE ITEM

FISCAL YEAR 2012/2013 As of September 30, 2012

UNAPPROPRIATED BALANCE, OUTSIDE COUNSEL- ADOPTED BUDGET FY2011/12

APPROPRIATIONS/TRANSFERS TO FUND 100, DEPT 12, ACCOUN19301 *

APPROPRIATIONS/TRANSFERS TO FUND 100, DEPT 12, ACCOUNT 9302*

BALANCE AS OF 9/30/12

*Transfers were actually made in the 2nd quarter of the fiscal year.

3,000,000

(2,944,000)

(56,000)

COMPARATIVE RECAP OF EXPENDITURES BY CLIENT DEPARTMENT -·SCAL YEAR 2012/13 VS. FISCAL YEAR 201 1 ,. '2

• Citywide/Other

• Comm

a Finance

• Information Technology Agency*

• Police

• Public Works

Sub-total

Pension Funds

• Fire & Police Pensions

• L.A. c m

• Water & Power Retirement Plan*

Sub-total 80,889 111,196 111,196

Proprietary Departments

• Los Angeles World Airports

• Port of Los eles

• Water & Power

Sub-total

Quasi-Government Agencies

• Commu

Sub-total 362,975

Workers Compensation

48

3,028

• Various 49,711

Sub-total 52,787

Conflict Panel

• Ethics

• EERC/CAAO 204,480

• Fire 1 788

• Harbor

• Police 119,531

• Recreation & Parks

• Water & Power 5 322

GRAND

*No response received from the departments.

**In FY2010/11, CRA transferred $3,050,000 to the City Attorney for outside counsel expenditures. These expenditures were paid

30,307

57,323

891

by the City Attorney using these funds. In July 2012, the City returned all unspent funds back to the CRA after the State appointed

a new Designated Local Agency (DLA).

-23%

37%

5%

-100%

77%

9%

COUNCIL-CONTROLLED DEPARTMENTS

NUMBER I LAW FIRM MATTER! CASE NAME BRIEF DESCRIPTION CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF I BALANCE FY2013

9/30/12 FY2013

9/30/12

11 8698 I CHRISTIE, PARKER & HALE Intellectual Property Legal assistance in intellectual

100,000 3,887 9,8oo I 90,200 property matte rs

DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH LLP IBC381773- Nicole Fahmie, et al. v. Class action concerning the use of City sidewalks and access to public

113455 I (formerly Eisenberg, Raizman, COLA; Saundra Carter v. COLA/ transportation from City sidewa lks by I I 1 ,486,ooo 1 96,6961 766,1941 719,806

Thurston & Wong LLP) ADA the disabled .

Legal ass istance in the evaluation

I KATIEN MUCHIN ROSENMAN, I P3 Matter land implementation of public-private

1 ' -'161 partnerships re lating to City-owned I - I zoo,ooo 1 - I 191,5571 8,443 LLP*

parki ng structures and parking meters

Re lated to the City Counci l's adoptio

KRONICK MOSKOVITZ I Fiscal Emergency of the reso lution and ordinance

115552 1-·---· •••••• & GIRARD I declaring a fiscal emergency and I I 6,566 1 - I 1,5661 5,000 authorizing reductions in work hours for city employees.

Th is lawsuit arises out of Americans

118838 I MEYERS NAVE 1usDC CV10-5782- Mark Willits et allwith Disabilities Act allegations

COLA/ ADA rega rd ing the City's sidewalks and I I 1.01 o,ooo I 68,0661 68,0661 941,934

curbs.

USDC CVOG-04691 - M. h I H t- j Thi' l'ws"lt "''" oot of oh•lleoge'

120019 I MEYERS NAVE CV09-6731 _Matt Dow~~ ~:11 _~~32 to LAMC Section 42.15, w~ich is the

I 625,600 1 96,7231 96,7231 L · · 1 1 c ·t 1 C ft r 1 freedom of expression ordmance for 1 528,877

e a v 1 Y ons 1 u lana the Venice Boardwalk and LA City

Council Rule of Decorum 12.

Constitutional cha llenge to the multiple use restriction included as

NEW I MEYERS NAVE . . part of LAMC Section 12.70 which

I I 1o,ooo 1 I I 10,000 !Alameda Books/ ConstllutJonaf Law I prohibits more than one Adult - -Entertainment Business within the same bu ild ing.

120558 IREMCHO , JOHANSEN & PURCELL, Fiscal Advice Council Redistricting Litigation I I 295,000 I - I - I 295,000 LLP

lT 0 T A L

*Katten Muchin contract was paid by the CAO. All other contracts were paid by theCity Attorney.

Page 1 of 15

NUMBER LAW FIRM

115159 IMEYERS NAVE

NUMBER LAW FIRM

106214 COLANTUONO & LEVIN, P.C.

MATTER/ CASE NAME

None

cfone Wireless; BC 1 04694 J2 Global Communications LLC; BC406473 Nextel Boost of California LLC dba Boost Mobi le/Telephone Users Tax (Finance)

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

Provide legal counse l and counsel on issues regarding the New Market Tax Credits oroaram.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

declaratory relief case in wh ich the plaintiffs seek a declaration that the City's purported "increase" in the Utility Users Tax paid by wireless

lephone customers is illegal under Proposition 218.

NOTES: *Cotantuono/TUT expenditures were paid by the Office of the City Attorney.

**Contingency fee basis; no appropriation set aside for contracts; payments are offset against revenue co/lee ted

NUMBER I LAW FIRM I MATTER/ CASE NAME I BRIEF DESCRIPTION

IBC336783 - Brenda Lee v. Pla intiff firefig hter alleges

1' -35 I ALBRIGHT, YEE & SCHMIT LLP !discrimination and retaliation due to I COLA/Employment (LAFD)

her race and sexual orientation .

is similar to Haro & Cleveland matters. Achan was dropped out of

109849 1 LIEBERT CASSIDY & WH ITMORE 1cV04-4334 Achan/Ackley et al. v. ' COLAIFLSA (LAFD)

I the case and the court took the next plaintiff in sequence (Ack ley); case I number has not changed.

Dual function firefighter/paramedics

109883 I LIEBERT CASSIDY & WHITMORE ICV02-9587 - Haro v. COLA/ FLSA ' (LAFD)

I cla im entitlement to premium overtime when assigned to I paramedic duty.

Page 2 of 15

261 ,420

BALANCE

9/30/12 9/30/12

2,220,500 138,979 1,308,264 912,236

CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF FY2013

9/30/12 FY2013

9(30/12

I 573,5oo 1 161,349 1 161,349 1 412,151

I 1,326,750 I - I 1,283,556 1 43,194

I 390,971 1 14,1551 349,1781 41,793

Case involves claims by an LAFD fi refighter that he was not eligible for

11 8837 LIEBERT, CASSIDY & WHITMORE Ramsey v COLNFLSA (LAFD} the FLSA's partial overtime

388,000 13,862 77,797 310,203 exemption for firefighters while he was assigned to a rescue ambulance.

T 0 T A L - ·' 189,366 -·---~- ,~~~- _.__j_~_._:_ __ ""~ _. ~ .< ' •:· loJ,: --- - --- ---- --- ------ '------

*NOTE: The above outside counsel expenditures were paid by the Office of the City Attorney.

CONT. NUMBER

MATIERJ CASE NAME APPROPRIATIONS EXPENDITURES

I CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF I BALANCE

FY2013 9/30/12

FY2013 9/30/12

LAW FIRM BRIEF DESCRIPTION

C0-1 09391 I BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP Various Legal assistance on various matters 753,243 751 ,9631 1,279

ROBINSON & PEARMAN LLP Various Legal assistance on various matters 93,507 $ 93,507

T 0 TAL

CONT. I CUM. AS OF I NUMBER I LAW FIRM MATTER/ CASE NAME BRIEF DESCRIPTION CUM. AS OF . BALANCE

FY2013 9/30/12

FY2013 9/30/12

103124 !MILLER & VAN EATON, PLLC rarious/Cab/e Television Legal assistance on cable TV

2,083,009 1,851,090 I 231 ,920 Agreements agreements

T 0 TAL I - .. c

CONT. I I I APPROPRIATIONS EXPENDITURES

N :ER LAW FIRM MATTER/ CASE NAME BRIEF DESCRIPTION CUM . AS OF CUM. AS OF I BALANCE

FY2013 9/30/12

FY2013 9/30/12

Brent case alleges retaliation and violations of the Peace Officers' Bill

BC434486 - Marvin Brent v. COLA; of Rights against the LAPD. City 119634 !ALBRIGHT, YEE & SCHMIT LLP IBC466319 - Carr v. Atty's Office received ten new claims I I 9so.ooo 1 2oo.ooo 1 2oo.ooo 1 750 ,000

COLA/Employment (LAPD} referred to as the "Carr" litigation which involves quota related allegations involving LAPD.

Claims of sexual orientation

115056 I BURKE WILLIAMS SORENSEN 1BC150151 - Grobeson v. COLNDiscrimination (LAPD}

' discrimination , harrassment, and related retaliation during employment I I 849,ooo 1 32,289 I 421,1821 427,818

as an LAPD sergeant.

108296 1 LIEBERT CASSIDY & WH ITMORE 1c V04-8592- Alaniz v. COLN FLSA

' (LAPD} 1 ~~~~;~ff:_~~~.i~:-~~- ~ave worked I I 883,750 I 2,960 I 793,7231 90,027

108297 LIEBERT, CASS IDY & WHITMORE CV03-2109 - Nolan v. COLA!FLSA Class action brought under the FLSA (LAPD) for alleged unpaid overtime at LAPD.

Class action fi led against the City

U.S.D.C. Central District of alleging wage and hour violations by

California, Case No . CV07-the LAPD. Plaintiffs allege violations

113155 LIEBERT, CASS IDY & WH ITMORE 06782GHK(0Px)- Mala v. COLA/

of California state Labor Code and ldustrial Wage Order provisions

FLSA (LAPD) relating to mandatory employee break periods.

Action wh ich seeks a writ of mad ate to enjoin the LAPD from conducting discovery in pending FLSA litigation

117390 LIEBERT, CASSIDY & WH ITMORE LASC Case No. BS 118964 Petersen on the theroy it violates the Peace Law Firm/FLSA (LAPO) Officers Bil l of Rights. The City

brought & won it's anti-SLAPP motion & there's an atty's fees motion current

State court action to compel

LASC Case No. BC 118647 LAPPL arbitration of the issue of whether

117391 LI EBERT, CASSIDY & WH ITMORE donning & doffing of the LAPD v. COLAIFLSA (LAPD)

uniform is compensable under the FLSA.

Putative class action wh ich LAPD detective claims the City un lawfu lly

118926 LI EBERT, CASSIDY & WH ITMORE Burns v COLAIFLSA (LAPO) deducts pension contributions from employees' IOD pay in violation of City Admin/Labor Code.

T 0 T A L

NOTES: *The above outside counsel expenditures were paid by the Office of the City Attorney. **Negative appropriation amounts represent reduction in encumbrances.

Page 4 of 15

1,391,500 13,898 1,110,644 280,856

295 ,000 9,706 182,666 112,334

I

102,500 1,409 57,213 45,287

31,000 4,709 22,042 8,958 I

'

13,048 - - 13,048 I

I

I - 'lli~'~f ·4\F%,«: '~'''' 264,971 ' ~tL; ' j#ili'.J;;l; ~·" ' 'F , :.;~"r' ;J';i:"": :~'·

LAW FIRM I MATTER/ CASE NAME I BRIEF DESCRIPTION I I CUM. AS OF I I CUM. AS OF I BALANCE

FY2013 t=V'Jn1'J 9/30/12

Breach of contract lawsuit filed by a

111296 !AKERMAN SENTERFITT LLP IBC208414- Dillingham Ray-Wilson number of subcontractors and I general contractor Dillingham/Ray I I 134,459 1 I 134,459

Wilson ("DRW').

Breach of contract lawsuit filed by a

119107 I BEST BEST & KRIEGER I BC208414 - Dillingham Ray-Wilson number of subcontractors and I general contractor Dillingham/Ray I I 3,169,641 I 227.580 1 3,024,224 I 145,417

Wilson ("DRW") .

Federal court challenge to the legal

110169 !BEVERIDGE & DIAMOND I CV06-5094 - COLA v. Kern County/General Litigation

I of Prop E which instituted a ban on the land application of biosolids in I I 2,782,053 I I 2,666,606 1 115,447

portions of Kern County.

Federal court challenge to the legal

110281 !BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN LLP I CV06-5094 - COLA v. Kern I of Prop E wh ich instituted a ban on

I - I 1,286,217 1 I 1,249,637 1 36,580 County/General Litigation the land application of biosolids in

portions of Kern County.

Lawsuit involving a contaminated

118748 I GALLAGHER & GALLAGHER 1 CV11-00245 - Los Angeles Unified Schoold District v. COLA

I property owned by the City, which was adjacent to a site LAUSD I I 20o,ooo I 3,869 I 70,0061 129,994

intended to build a school on.

Class action alleging that the City, through the Bureau of Sanitation , has

111751 !LIEBERT, CASSIDY & WHITMORE IBC356014- Gravina v. COLA/ FLSA !failed to provide sanitation truck I I 22o,ooo I - I 156,135 1 63,865 drivers with the meal breaks requi red by the California Labor Code.

Page 5 of 15

PENSION FUNDS

LAW FIRM I MATTER/ CASE NAME I BRIEF DESCRIPTION I CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF I BALANCE FY2013

9/30/12 FY201 3

9/30/12

113703 ICE MILLER LLP Various Legal advice on tax law matters - 253 ,373 8,582 97,014 156,359

Fiduciary counsel on pension &

117635 I NOSSAMAN, GUTHER, KNOX & ELLIOTI

I Various I retirement matters; legal review on alternatives investments and real I -I 2oo,ooo I 6,388 1 36,859 1 163,141

11 8532 I OLSON HAGEL & FISHBURN LLP I Various 100,000 26,780 73, 220

11 8287 I REED SMITH LLP Various

NUMBER I LAW FIRM I MATTER/ CASE NAME I BRIEF DESCRIPTION CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF I BALANCE FY2013

9/30/12 FY2013

9/30/12

113707 liCE MILLER, LLP 1 Various I Legal advice on tax law matters 400,000 52,089 279,077 1 120,923

Legal advice on fiduciary law I - I 186,391 1 - I 134,381 1 52,010

109666 I MORRISON & FOERSTER, LLP 1 Various I matters

Fiduciary counsel on pension & retirement matters; legal review on

I - I 3oo,ooo I 37,718 1 295,208 1 4,792 alternatives investments and real

·. 636 I NOSSAMAN, GUTHER, KNOX & EL Various estate

Fiduciary counsel on pension & retirement matters; legal review on

30,000 15o,ooo I - I 28,221 I 121,779

I OLSON HAGEL & FISBURN LLP

alternatives investments and rea l

11 7771 Various estate

Fiduciary counsel on pension & retirement matters; legal review on

5o.ooo I 1so.ooo I - I 67,148 1 82,852

I Various

alternatives investments and real

117094 I REED SMITH estate

Fiduciary counsel on pens ion & retirement matters; legal review on

I - I 75,ooo 1 - I 62,5881 12,413 alternatives investments and real

119632 I STEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP I Various I estate

Page 6 of 15

PROPRIETARY DEPARTMENTS

'f'' ' 't'~: . nlilr ~·;~·;;;'~', -~, - ~ n~~:~: .,f\'4 ''" ·' , •.• ·'~'i..l-!-i!U'l'' 'ot,·;•'r: ·• lh!r: ·~~ ~ : :At., :··t·'""'' '~"" }•'.l;;t·~i~'i'"1 t•' :o? 'lf" ~-n:::\ '; .''':1'., ·I' 1:1, "~:,t• w·.•· mf ·~· ;.: rK~"<l.J~i!·-; :f?)]''f i r~ t~":;i Pil>t;. 'J<f--"'i ~ >: ?""'; --· • l;< " """" " " ,,,.,, ~-ell ~ft~;-, dH ''Pi/"; -~~ :~i'' .,.,, • ,"'" ,, <•i

CONT. APPROPRIATIONS EXPENDITURES

NUMBER LAW FIRM MATTERf CASE NAME BRIEF DESCRIPTION CUM, AS OF CUM, AS OF BALANCE

FY2013 9/30/12

FY2013 9/30/12

Provide legal representation for LAWA and City Attorney in litigation

DA-4497 AND ERSON KREIGER LLP Federal Regu larory and transactional matters involving - I ,000,000 34,557 215, 573 784 ,427 federa l regu latory work and related matters.

Provide legal services to assist

DA-4238 ATKINSON, ANDELSON, LOYA,

Construction Litigation LAWA and CA's office with public - 350,000 164,034 185,966

RUUD & ROMO contracting, construction litigation -issues & other related legal services.

-COTCHETI, PITRE & MCCARTHY

Legal services concerning municipal derivative and bond insurance and Contingency

DA-4657 LLP AND RENNE SLOAN Municipal Lit igation antitrust violation issues, litigation, 9% of Recovery

- - -HOLTZMAN SAKAl LLP

and proceed ings affecting the LAWA.

DEMETRIOU, DEL GUERCIO, Assist LAWA and CA's office with

DA-4266 SPRINGER & FRANCIS, LLP

Rea l Property lega l services regarding real property 100,000 500,000 - 399,997 100,003 and related matters.

Assist GAO and LAWA with advisory

DA-4678 FOLEY & LARDNER, LLP Terminal Media Manager counsel services in connection with

500,000 500,000 22,934 22,934 477,066 deve lopment of a terminal media manager business model.

Provide advisory and litigation DA-4159 KAYE SCHOLER Federal Regulatory counsel for federal regulatory and - 4,200,000 4,112 3,632,675 567,325

re lated matters for LAWA.

KRONICK, MOSKOVITZ, Provide legal services related to

r 717 Groundwater Contamination Antelope Valley groundwater 250,000 250,000 - - 250,000 TIEDEMANN & GIRARD

adjudication matters.

Legal counsel services in connection with the financing or refinancing of current and future capita l

DA-450 1 KUTAK ROCK Municipal Financing improvement projects and other - 150,000 2,000 15,267 134,733 related financial issues affecting airports owned and operated by LAW A.

LANDAU, GOTTFRIED & BERGER, Provide legal services concerning

DA-429 1 LLP

Bankruptcy bankruptcy issues, litigation, and - 200,000 - 136,905 63,095 proceedings affecting LAWA.

-- -

Page 7 of 15

Provide legal representation of I

LIEBERT, CASSIDY & WHITMORE, LAWA in a lawsuit alleging donning

DA-4381 LLP

Labor Litigation and doffing violations under the Fair - 225,000 - 9,873 215 ,1 27 Labor Standards Act (FSLA) against

I the Airport Police Division (APD).

Assist the City Attorney with legal I

DA-4745 MORRIS, POLICH & PURDY LLP Groundwater Contamination services with respect to groundwater 450,000 450,000 - 450,000 contamination and related matte rs.

Legal counsel services in connection with the financing or refinanci ng of current and future capital

DA-4502 NIXON, PEABODY LLP Municipal Financing improvement projects and other - 150,000 - 150,000 related financial issues affecting airports owned and operated by LAWA.

1- .

Assist with legal services related to

PARKER, MILLIKEN, CLARK, Undergound Storage Tanks LAWA receipt of a Notice of Violation

DA-47 18 O'HARA AND SAMUELIAN Compliance

from th e State Water Resources 250 ,000 250,000 - - 250,000 Control Board re: underground storage units compl iance.

Legal counsel services in connection with the financing or refinancing of

POLSINELLI SHUGHART current and futu re capita l

DA-4503 (PREVIOUSLY QUATEMAN LLP)

Municipal Financing improvement projects and other 11 8,131 118,131 2,561 29,638 88,494 related financial issues affecting airports owned and operated by LAW A.

Legal counsel services in connection with the financing or refinancing of

QUATEMAN LLP (ASSIGNED TO current and future capital

DA-4503 POLSINELLI)

Mun icipal Financing improvement projects and other - 150,000 - 31,869 118,1 31 related financial issues affecting airports owned and operated by LAW A.

Assist LAWA and City Attorney with

DA-4503 SOHAGI LAW GROUP PLC Land Use I Environmental respect to environmental and land

500,000 1,275,000 95,758 861 ,255 413,745 use litigation, and proceedings affecting Dept. of Airpo rts.

Provide lega l services concerning

DA-4297 JOHN WERLICH ISKCON Litigation litigation arising out of the City's

95,000 277,250 - 180,678 96,572 ordinances that regulate solicitation of funds at LAWA.

2 263 131 ' . , f·: . ,.

161 922 '· ., .. I',.,,

otc"!. :no:. ;j; -.,! ;7~~,;~;=t~~·~::"it',r~"~" - : ..

f.JO.RTOF LOS ,ANGE~~.-r#iii;, ·-·~) ::· .i

vv ..... LAW FIRM MATTER/ CASE NAME

NUMBER

10-2879 POLSINELLI SHUGHART Bond Counsel

10-2880 KUTAK ROCK Bond Counsel

10-2877 NIXON PEABODY Bond Counsel

2519 KAYE SCHOLER Environmental

1" "1042 MEYERS NAVE RIBACK SILVER &

Environmental WILSON

-12-3043 SOHAG I LAW GROUP Environmental

2441 CASTELLON & FUNDERBURK Environmental

, •. ~~ ., ro:tr ,.m-...-,:·+:~;~ct~nry·-~···~11

WATER 8/ PdWER;, '1:'/"' ~ $:/-':"! ... I,•t ··:· ... i'-: ·. ., .. •; ~,;;;~ .. . :·rp;;jftli~~~ - ··;, ·'·.p·

~ ......

CONT. NUMBER

LAW FIRM MATTER/ CASE NAME

47581 CHR ISTIE PARKER HALE, LLP I Intellectual property

1-

47082-2

47762-8

47 107-3

47043-2

DOWNEY BRAND, LLP

DYKEMA GOSSET, LLP

FREDERICK MERKIN

JACKSON DEMARCO TIDUS PECKENPAUGH

CEQA

General Counsel

General Counsel

Air Quality Matters

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

Legal services in the area of municipa l bonds.

Legal services in the area of municipal bonds.

Lega l services in the area of municipal bonds.

Advise and representation related to the San Pedro Bay Ports Clean Air Action Plan .

California Environmenta l Quality Act litigation and disputes.

California Envi ronmental Quality Act litigation and disputes.

California Environmental Quality Act litigation and disputes.

. ;~;;l~~r::'J~ BRJEF DESCRIPTION

Assist in providing legal representation for the City in intellectual property and re lated matters.

Provide legal representation for City in CEQA, NEPA, and related matters .

Provide legal advice and

representation in complex business litigation and related matters

Provide legal re presentation for City in advisory, litigation, and related matters .

Provide legal representation to City on air quality matters related to CA Health and Safety Code Section 42316.

Page 9 of 15

FY201 3 CUM. AS OF

9/30/12

- 60,000

- 145, 000

- 130,000

288,000 8,041 ,679

- 330,000

- 330,000

- 1,230,000

288 000 ';'

··!: ·~;1r

APPROPRIATIONS

9130112 FY2013

CUM. AS OF

50,000

450,000

400,000

600,000 600,000

1,450,000

BALANCE FY2013

CUM. AS OF 9/30/12

- 2,862 57 ,138

- - 145,000

16,254 40,853 89,147

53,522 7,706,858 334,821

17 ,961 17,961 312,040

23,420 30,908 299,092

218 901,852 328,148

111 374 . ··'·.· ' il! ,:,. ·, ..

-~i~~~·:j~:·:~~~.~J:"~;5··.mw:~_~;~~:~{t·~~::t:l EXPENDITURES

FY2013

175,961

CUM. AS OF 9130112

15,462

343,878

762,285

BALANCE

34,538

450,000

56,122

600 ,000

687,715

Provide legal representation in 47039-2 KUTAK ROCK, LLP Disclosure Counsel disclosure counsel and related - 465,000 50,840 117,018 347,982

matters.

Provide legal representation for City 47075-2 MEYERS NAVE CEQA in CEQA, NEPA, and related 500,000 950,000 139,010 40 1,796 548,204

matters.

Provide legal representation for the

47 106-3 MORRIS POLICH & PURDY, LLP Groun dwater Contamination City in respect to groundwater

750,000 750,000 - - 750,000 ocntamination issues in San Fernando Basin and related matters.

Provide legal representation with

47103-3 ORRICK, HERRINGTON,

Bond Counsel respect to Department's revenues,

2,700,000 2,700,000 - - 2,700,000 SUTCLIFFE, LLP financing and borrowing activites . tax

issues. and related matters.

Provide legal representation with

47887-0 ORRICK. HERRINGTON,

Bond Counsel respect to Department's revenues, - 1,575,000 94,941 1,489,230 85,770

SUTCLIFFE, LLP financing and borrowing activites, tax issues, and related matters.

PARKER, MILLIKEN, CLARK, Provide legal representation to

47829-9 General Counsel groundwater contamination issues in - 667,143 1,350 587,38 1 79,762 O'HARA & SAMUELIAN

San Fernando Basin

Provide legal representation to City

47087-2 SOMACH SIMMONS & DUNN Air Qual ity Matters on ai r quality matters related to CA

800,000 1,400,000 283,620 283,620 1,116,380 Health and Safety Code Section 42316.

47885-0 VAN NESS, FELDMAN, P.C. Energy Federal Energy Regulatory Issues 130,000 1,130,000 92,349 868,680 261,320 5 480,000 : 838 072 .:i":: , i , 1 ~ ;jj i!: I , ;!i .,. ,.;>·· < ..

Page 10 of 15

CONTR. NUMBER

110450

108308

.08308

108309

LAW FIRM

CAMILO A BECERRA A LAW CORP

LDSTEIN GURVITZ MARLOWE/GURVITZ MARLOWE & MILLER

LAW OFCS OF ARA AGHISHIAN

LAW OFFICES OF DON A. BAGGETT

NOTE: Contracts are on flat-fee basis.

p

CONTR. NUMBER

LAW FIRM

Personnel I GOLDSTEIN GURVITZ MARLOW & MIL (WC)

Personnel I GOLDSTEIN GURVITZ MARLOW & MIL (WC)

Personnel I GOLDSTEIN GURVITZ MARLOW & MIL (WC)

Personnel I KEGEL TOBI N & TRUCE (WC)

WORKERS COMPENSATION

CASE NAME/SUBJECT MATTER

us/Workers Compensation

Various/Workers Compensation

Various/Workers Compensation

Various/Workers Compensation

CASE NAME/SUBJECT MATTER

Various/Workers Compensation (Civifian)

us/Workers Compensation (Fire)

Various/Workers Compensation (Police)

Various/Workers Compensation (Pofice)

Page11of 15

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

Lega l counsel for litigated workers compensation cases involving sworn employees (police & fire ) and civi lian conflict cases

Legal counse l for litigated workers compensation cases involving sworn employees (police & fire) and civilian conflict cases

Legal counse l for litigated wo rkers compensation cases involving sworn employees (police & fire) and civi lian conflict cases

Legal counsel for litigated wo rkers compensation cases involving sworn employees (police & fi re) and civi lian conflict cases

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

Legal counse l for lit igated workers compensation cases involving sworn employees (police & fi re) and civi lian confl ict cases

Lega l counsel for lit igated workers compensation cases involving sworn employees (police & fi re) and civi lian conflict cases

Legal counsel for litigated workers compensation cases involving sworn emp loyees (police & fire) and civil ian conflict cases

Legal counse l for litigated workers compensation cases involving sworn employees (pol ice & fire) and civil ian conflict cases

AS OF 9/30/12

AS OF 9{30/12

2,885

Personnel Legal counsel for litigated workers compensation I

(WC) LAW OFFICES OF MICHAEL MANSFIELD Various/Workers Compensation (Po lice) cases involving sworn employees (police & fire) 1,500 428,253

and civilian conflict cases .

Legal counse l for lit igated workers compensation I

Personnel I

(WC) PEARSON STOER WARSHAW & PENNY Various/Workers Compensation (Civilian) cases involving swam employees (police & fire) 1,630 91 ' 187:

and civi lian conflict cases

' ' T 0 T A 14,704 ,.

' . ' ' L

·'

Page12 of15

CONFLICT PANEL

; ""' .. ,,·-~~t··~,. ·<--if!~· ''1,'-r.<J""f.: ,:1.>-i..• : •~.: . 'i 'p .. ··. ,__.,;•;w~~ fj\-"1':'~ :· V'·':H{· ; >."''!;P~Ij!' · ')~){<nT ~'_-;; •: .-• '"' iif:)•-•t: "1'~~~.,-:,-~:;.r.,., .-'.~'"5 : ) - l~ •;·;,;,.y.r:,'' 1ii.,il:''!(l1( ·,W~i-!1~'~, ·_tt-,~ ".ti'i ' ''~ i<W\'{"i: ;·<li'<Jifi' '}"!.;;,: , ; ~:--;~· , :r; '•'i''l1>

. "'!imW/;:~; .~'·."··:··: ., . .... ·.n. 'H"

. . . '"' :; ,, , • ' .c '>ij(,: ·~·r~;;;., ir '0''i' APPROPRIATIONS EXPENDITURES

CONTR. CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF

NUMBER LAW FIRM CASE NAME/MATTER BRIEF DESCRIPTION FY20 13 9/30/12 FY2013 9/30/12 BALANCE

Citywide

BC463 183 Michae l Fernandez v. Racial discrimination and retaliation C-1202 11 ALBRIGHT, YEE & SCHMIT City/Police Employment Litigation complaint. - 30,000 - - 30,000

ATKINSON, ANDELSON, LOY A, CV12-4235 LA City Attorneys Assoc. Furlough - Constitut iona l rights C-120828 RUUD & ROMO v. City/Labor vio lations 35,000 35,000 - - 35,000

CV11-07774 CV12-00551 U.S. Dept of Justice; HUD Audit, Mei Ling v. City; ILCSC Noncompliance claims re lative to

C-121 063 BYRNE & NIXON v. City/Complex Business Litigation Federal Disabi lity requ irements 450,000 450,000 - - 450,000

Sub-total 485,000 l·~>!i~:j,; ; ··~·:1" - ·::~~:Ht: ki;tJ.I;!i!!htfllitil ;P, J:: ·•:t,, .,;~.: ' :r":n,:;

EERCICAO ATKINSON, ANDELSON, LOYA, Unfair Employee Relations Practice I

C-119830 RUUD & ROMO N/A UERP 1850/Labor Grievance - 25,000 500 11 ,780 13,220 I

BC476943; ! BS135294 Retiree Health I

C-120550 MEYERS NAVE Benefits/Labor Lega l advice an d reprsentation - 430,000 203,980 203,980 226, 020 i

Sub-tota l - ;! .•. 204,480 ·~: ~· ~~ I i'l ' >IV:k';h~::;t. ~~ 111' ' 'l'. '.

Harbor

' I LEWIS, BRISBOIS, BISGAARD & CV04-9495. John P. Pring le/General Comp lex insurance re lating to I

C-118936 SM ITH , LLP and Business Litigation coverage and cost recovery - 6,584 - 6,584 - I

CV02-7986 City of LA v. San Pedro i LEWIS, BRISBOIS, BISGAARD & Boat Works/General and Business Complex insurance relating to

C-119007 SM ITH, LLP Litigation coverage and cost recovery - 90,000 - 73,243 16,757 :

Sub-total - . 'ii•iiiH• '"1i1 . ;ifi-.' - . ' ' ,i,i d:'• ·.·r;, . ''!!:, •17' '•!:,, ii•

Fire

GONl.A.LEZ SAGG IO & HARLAN, BC449758 Lesl ie D. W ilkerson v.

C-118958 LLP City/Employment Litigation LAFD - racia l hostile environment - 25,000 1,788 17,824 7,176

Sub-total - l :~'liJi,, •' . ,.h·, 1,788 : ~~' 'lil l!H i!!: ,~:;!; :) i!; !f:·~l~. ii!i,l' 'i''

Police BC465451 Linda Gotham & Lynn

BALLARD ROSENBERG GOLPER & Whitey v . City/Police Employment Sexual harassment and retaliation C-120298 SAVITT Litigation complaint - 35,000 14,962 23,463 11 ,537

CVD9-01835, CV09-01592 Rukhsana Chaudry v.

C-116291 FERGUSON, PRAET & SHERMAN City/Complex Police Litigation Deprivation of Civil Rights. - 200.000 - 196,388 3,612

Page 13 of 15

BC448773 Nata lie Wrongful death and deprivation of C-119006 FERGUSON, PRAET & SHERMAN Hard ison/Complex Police Litigation Civil Rights. 45,000 85,000 14,531 54 ,53 1 30,469

CV1 1-02897 Mateos Santiago & Estate v. CityiComp lex Police Wrongful death and deprivation of

C-119896 FERGUSON, PRAET & SHERMAN Litigation Civil Rights. - 25,000 5,920 14,220 10,780

BC445382 Mariana Bern ice Cabrera Wrongful death and deprivation of C-1 19391 GUTIERREZ PRECIADO & HOUSE v. City/Police Tort Litigation Civil Rights . - 20,000 - 5,028 14,972

CV09-4120 Guillermo A larconiPolice Falsified evidence and wrongfu l C-119492 GUTIERREZ PRECIADO & HOUSE Tort Litigation conviction complaint. - 2,800 - 2,430 370

CV09-1 592 Rukhsana Chaudry v.

C-11 9636 HAIGHT BROWN & BONESTEEL City/Complex Police Litigation Deprivation of Civi l Rights. 50,000 100,000 37,268 87,268 12,732 CV438920 Kathleen Washington v. Wrongfu l death and deprivation of

C-119005 HURRELL, CANTRALL, LLP City/Complex Police Litigation Civi l Rights. - 100, 000 - 100,000 -CV10-00617 Richard Boone v.

c-·1 .93 HURRELL, CANTRALL, LLP City/Police Tort Litigation Deprivation of Civil Rights. - 60, 000 320 36,407 23,593 CV12-01 670 Anthony Garrett v.

C-120730 HURRELL, CANTRALL, LLP City/Complex Police Litigation Deprivation of Civil Rights. 40,000 40,000 4, 881 4,881 35, 119 CV10-2806 Nick Ross v. City/Police

C-11 8415 L/0 OF THOMAS FEELEY, P C Tort Litigation Unlawful assault and battery. . 75 ,000 . 51,756 23,244 CV09-9374 Bruce E. Lisker v.

C-119008 L/0 OF THOMAS FEELEY, P.C. City/Police Tort Litigation Deprivation of Civil Rights. . 10,000 . 4,500 5.500 BC475954 Jorge Luis Damages to se ized property returned

C-1 20300 L/0 OF THOMAS FEELEY, P. C. Barcena/Police Tort Litigation via Court order " 25 ,000 . 2,280 22,720 LEWIS, BRISBOIS , BISGAARD & CV05-1 977 Hall, Harold C. v. City Falsified evidence and wrongful

C-108921 SMITH, LLP /Complex Police Litigation convict ion comp laint. . 218,100 . 203,456 14,644

CV04-9391 Chrisman , Kelly v. City Pending appellate decision -C-1 09453 LOZANO SMITH /Police Employment Litigation improper termination comp laint. - 25,000 238 8, 71 4 16,286

BC429535 Gregory Hoskins v. Racial discrimination and retaliation C-119156 LOZANO SMITH City/Police Employment Litigation complaint. - 10,175 . 6,896 3,279

CV11-1 326 Leonard Avila v. C- . 97 LOZANO SMITH City/Police Employment Litigation FLSA case . 100,000 . 100,000 -r---

CV10-5072 Paul Blumberg v. Falsified evidence and wrongful C-11 8589 MEYERS NAVE City/Police Tort Litigation conviction complaint. - 20,000 . 2,875 17,125

CV10-7213 G.L.G ., minor, v. Starr Vio lation of constitutional rights C-118905 MEYERS NAVE Jordan/Complex Police Litigation relating to sexual molestation case. - 80,000 3,283 43,283 36,71 7

BC473661 Daniel Landrum v. C-1 20834 STONE BUSAILAH, LLP City/Police Tort Litigation Excessive force claims 25,000 25,000 7,703 7.703 17,298

BC454283 Stella Carrera v. N. C-120835 STONE BUSAILAH , LLP McCullough/Police Tort Litigation Excessive force claims 100,000 100,000 26,170 26 ,170 73,830

CV11-03141 Regionald Doucet, Jr. v. Wrongfu l death and deprivation of i

C-120836 STONE BUSAILAH, LLP City/Police Tort Litigation Civil Rights. 4,300 4,300 4,255 4,255 45!

BC31 1284 Chavez, Robert v. City Hostile work environment and C-115475 THE ZAPPIA LAW FIRM !Police Employment Litigation reta liation complaint. . 275,000 . 275,000 -

Sub-total 264,300 Iii ·>;:;. : 11! ,;:'. ·iHH'"~ ~· 119,531 iti::~l':!fli> : ..• !;: l .;a'\t!-ii1'1 ~:""1"';i''i'·,;n• . T 0 TAL /4ll,JUU PH:n~ti.' ·: ~:·i: : .. ,,r .,,,,, J<::b,f\:lll •1 ·, ,;• .· .. ki!:: ... ,,, ,<. ~ - ~ ~ ;-~{~~; , ·~;;~ .. · _ :;~-- (~!;!lj'!:;

Page 14 of 15

+~- -~"If· ., ... ., . .,w· ·· :r:~''7'": '· ~ ·~·· · · :r".~~\"+1~-~:J~J~!~~-~'"; l :tr·-:r ·-t~~?"~ 7"'··~;--::-~~--,·y:~!."t-t> ri'f:'--~"':.~~·:·.~"1wr:rm;;:l~~~, .. , · ~:~-~~me·~~f.,.or:~-;~~rm~:~·:;;-::·!~~mr:;;::~:~~n~i!~1l!:-~· n·~ ... ~·--, .... .... ;~"· ·~:···

, .. ,. • ., .• ,, <~; '' ; ' ~~ •• JI< .. 'j' • . , ... F.-• or;-• .-'1 '" ·'!' . .,~ · :;•- ,., -; .. "01'"""' lf'!l f.o!'•· • ~ .r: • ' " ' '

APPROPRIATIONS EXPENDITURES

CONTR. CUM. AS OF CUM. AS OF

NUMBER LAW FIRM CASE NAME/MATTER BRIEF DESCRIPTION FY2013 9/30/12 FY2013 9/30/12 BALANCE

47569-7 FUENTES & MCNALLY Miranda V. DW P/City of LA Federal civil rights violation - 475,000 4,909 437,187 37,813

49058-2 HINSHAW & CULBERTSON Various On-site personnel investigations - 150,000 413 413 149,587

T 0 TA L - ji' ', ,,. 5 322 •n: .. ,. ; •f; ,,

Page 15 of 15