can domestic courts learn about good practice interpreting from international courts? from the...

39
Can domestic courts learn about good practice interpreting from international courts? From the Australian War Crimes Prosecutions to the International Criminal Court Ludmila Stern, University of New South Wales (Australia)

Upload: tyler-knight

Post on 17-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Can domestic courts learn about good practice interpreting from international courts?

From the Australian War Crimes Prosecutions to the International Criminal Court

Ludmila Stern,University of New South Wales (Australia)

BACKGROUND

BACKGROUND

• Courts and cases:

BACKGROUND

• Courts and cases:– Cases heard in domestic courts

• Demjaniuk (1989)

• Australian War Crimes Prosecutions (1986-1993)

BACKGROUND

• Courts and cases:– Cases heard in domestic courts– International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY),

International Criminal Court (ICC)

BACKGROUND

• Courts and cases• Expectations and evidence of quality

BACKGROUND

• Courts and cases• Expectations and evidence of quality• Working languages and interpreting modes

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

• Selection process and criteria

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

• Selection process and criteria• Professional qualifications & background

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

• Selection process and criteria• Professional qualifications & background• Pre-employment interpreter training

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

• Selection process and criteria• Professional qualifications & background• Pre-employment interpreter training• Pre-employment testing by the court

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

• Selection process and criteria• Professional qualifications & background• Pre-employment interpreter training• Pre-employment testing by the court• Prior training or experience in court interpreting

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Approaches to ensuring interpreting competence

• Selection process and criteria• Professional qualifications & background• Pre-employment interpreter training• Pre-employment testing by the court• Prior training or experience in court interpreting• In-house training

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description• Courtroom physical setting and conditions

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description• Courtroom physical setting and conditions• Employment:

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description• Courtroom physical setting and conditions• Employment:

– ongoing v casual

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description• Courtroom physical setting and conditions• Employment:

– ongoing v casual– remuneration

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description• Courtroom physical setting and conditions• Employment:

– ongoing v casual– remuneration– working hours

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Organisational structure• Interpreters’ role description• Courtroom physical setting and conditions• Employment:

– ongoing v casual– remuneration– working hours– relief

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court:

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court:– preparation

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court:– preparation– briefing

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court:– preparation– briefing– document provision

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court:– preparation– briefing– document provision– terminology unit

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court• Team work

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court• Team work• Quality control - monitoring & safety nets

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

Infrastructure, employment conditions and support

• Support provided by the court• Team work• Quality control - monitoring & safety nets• Interpreters’ Code of Ethics

INTERPRETER USERS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

INTERPRETER USERS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

• Cross-cultural awareness and competence

INTERPRETER USERS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

• Cross-cultural awareness and competence• Skills of interpreter-mediated communication

INTERPRETER USERS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

• Cross-cultural awareness and competence• Skills of interpreter-mediated communication• Interviewing techniques

INTERPRETER USERS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

• Cross-cultural awareness and competence• Skills of interpreter-mediated communication• Interviewing techniques• Role of judges in monitoring courtroom communication

INTERPRETER USERS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR EFFECTIVE INTERPRETER-MEDIATED COMMUNICATION

• Cross-cultural awareness and competence• Skills of interpreter-mediated communication• Interviewing techniques• Role of judges in monitoring courtroom communication• Interpreter users’ education