business ethics project~world com
TRANSCRIPT
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 1
WorldCom: Can You Hear the Lawsuits Now?
Team 8
ANISA VRENOZIKATERINA BETAORTENCA HOXHA MARVIL POTKA
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 2
Outline• Timeline
• A short introduction of the case s tudy
• Key topics in bus iness e thics
• Key players & the ir work pos ition
• Critica l e thica l is sues & e thica l dilemmas
• Analys is of the main s takeholders
• Red flags
• Impact of the fraud
• Review of the solutions
• Pros & Cons of the solutions
• Fina l Comment
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 4
Background Information
1983 : LDDS, Mississippi, Bernie Ebbers– Long-Distance telephone company
Main StrategiesAcquire small companies in the
fieldProvide the service for cheaper cost per minute
for the customers
In two years, Ebbers became the CEO of the company
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 5
1989 : LDDS became public with the acquisition of Advantage Companies
1995 LDDS changed his name into WorldCom
1997 : Ebbers acquired the largest players in the industry, MCI
The list of the acquisitions by 2002 accounts for more than 60 companies!
Ebbers “Telecom Cowboy”
Background Information
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 6
• March 11: WorldCom receives a request for information from the U.S. SEC relating to accounting procedures and loans to officers.
• April3: WorldCom says it is cutting 3,700 jobs in the U.S.
• April 30: WorldCom CEO was requested by SEC information for his personal loans. – Ebbers resigned and Vice Chairman John Sidgmore
assigned as CEO
The Beginning of the End 2002
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 7
• June 25: WorldCom fires its CFO, Scott Sullivan after uncovering improper accounting – The company cut 17,000 jobs, more than 20
percent of its workforce.– WorldCom admits inflating incomes by $3.8 billion
by using improper accounting of expenses.– Stock falls to 20 cents/share.
The Beginning of the End 2002
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 8
• June 26: SEC files civil charges of fraud against the company
• July 21: WorldCom declared bankruptcy • July 29: NASDAQ stock market delisted WorldCom
Inc.’s securities.• August 8:WorldCom announces another $3.3 billion
in improper accounting discovered, bringing the amount to a total of $7.15 billion in income inflation.
The Beginning of the End 2002
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 11
Transparency → One of the eight principles of Codex
(Not truthful, inaccurate records,
fraudulent actions)
Embezzlement → theft and misuse of the money of the
company
Corruption → Conscious about illegal actions used
to make personal profits.
Corporate Governance → Totally destroyed. No more control over
the operations of the firm
Key Topics in Business Ethics
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 12
Key players & their work position
Bernard Ebbers → Former founder, chairman and CEO of
WorldCom (1985 – April 29, 2002)
John Sidgmore → WorldCom’s vice chairman in charge of
WorldCom’s Internet division, UNNet; New CEO of WorldCom (May
2002 – September 11, 2002)
Scott Sullivan → Chief Financial Officer
David Myers → Senior Vice President and Controller
Cynthia Cooper → Vice president of internal audit
Gene Morse → Internal auditor, Cooper’s subordinates, an
information technology expert
Glyn Smith → Internal auditor, Cooper’s subordinates
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 13
Key players & their work position
John Stupka → Head of WorldCom’s wireless division
Buford Yates → Director of general accounting
Jerry Jilly → Senior manager in information technology department
Tom Bosley → Subordinates of David Myers
Ron Beaumont → Chief Operating Officer
Betty Vinson → Accounting department manager (former director of
corporate reporting)
Troy Normand → Former accounting department manager
SEC → Government Regulator
Arthur Andersen → External Auditor
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 15
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 16
Unethical Accounting ProceduresWhistleblower-Cynthia Cooper
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 19
Ethical Dilemma
→Accept →Do NOT accept
• Violate GAAP • Be in accordance with GAAP
• Conspire with other employees • Be not part of the conspiracy
• File false financial statements • Refuse to manipulate the financial statements
If not discovered: Gain support from Ebbers &maybe some huge benefits
If discovered:Put himself in risk of jail sentence & an end to his career
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 20
Ethical Dilemma
Investigate every single transaction Leave the fraudulent situation alone to continue to happen
Act in contrary of the orders of her boss Be part of the fraudulent actions
Respect all the accounting rules and regulations Violate the basic accounting rules and regulations
Gain respect and admiration but by threating her career Maybe some support and bonuses for her collaboration
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 24
Stakeholders
SuppliersSuppliers continuous complaints and later charges forced WorldCom to declare bankruptcy since the company was not able to fulfill its obligations anymore
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 25
StakeholdersSEC• Requested information relating to accounting procedures and
loans to officers. SEC filed civil charges of fraud against the company SEC revealed the fact that WorldCom had a debt of 5.75
billion dollars SEC proposed the implementation of Sarbanes-Oxley Act
which focused on: - Creating and strengthening corporate controls
- Requiring enriched financial disclosures
- Creating new standards for corporate accountability
- Creating new penalties for acts of unlawful activity
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 29
The Impact of the Fraud
BOD
Investment Banks
SEC
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 30
The Impact of the Fraud
Executives and Accounting Staff
6 individuals convicted of fraud / conspiracy / false filings
Ebbers – CEO 25 years in prison
Sullivan – CFO 5 years in prison
Myers – Controller 1 year in prison
Yates – Director of Accounting 1 year in prison
Vinson – Accounting Dept Manager 5 months in prison
Normand –Accounting Dept Manager 3 years probation
Finally, in April, 2003 WorldCom no longer existed. A year later, in April
2004 The company changed its name to MIC
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 31
Five lessons to be learned from WorldCom
Beware of companies that
have a corporate culture that is
similar to a cult
Beware of the companies that depend on the
government for their operations
Beware of companies that depend on
mergers& acquisition for financial growth
Beware of companies that have close
relation between top management and
BOD
Beware of companies where actions result in mgmt defending
them selves in court
Free Powerpoint TemplatesPage 32
Alternatives to prevent the scandal