braidwood, unit 1, fourteenth refueling outage …washington, d.c. 20555-0001 braidwood station,...
TRANSCRIPT
Exelon,Exelon Generation Company, LLC www.exeloncorp.com
Braidwood Station Nuclear351o0 South Rt 53, Suite 84Braceville, I L 60407
July 16, 2009BW090068
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionAttn: Document Control DeskWashington, D.C. 20555-0001
Braidwood Station, Unit 1Facility Operating License No. NPF 72NRC Docket No. STN 50-456
Subject: Braidwood Station, Unit 1 Fourteenth Refueling Outage Steam GeneratorInservice Inspection Summary Report
In accordance with Technical Specification 5.6.9, "Steam Generator (SG) Tube Inspection Report,"Exelon Generation Company, LLC is reporting the results of the SG inspections, which werecompleted during the Braidwood Station, Unit 1 fourteenth refueling outage (Al R14). The attachedreport is also being submitted in accordance with the requirements of the American Society ofMechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 2001 Edition through 2003Addenda, Section XI, "Rules for Inservice Inspection of Nuclear Power Plant Components," ArticleIWA-6000, "Records and Reports," and Paragraph 11-890.2.3, "Reporting" of ASME Section V"Nondestructive Examination," Article 8 - Appendix II, "Eddy Current Examination ofNonferromagnetic Heat Exchanger Tubing," 2001 Edition through 2003 Addenda.
If there are any questions regarding this submittal, please contact Mr. David Gullott, RegulatoryAssurance Manager, at (815) 417-2800.
Res etfully
B kanHansonSite Vice PresidentBraidwood Station
Attachment: Exelon Braidwood Station Unit 1 Fourteenth Refueling Outage Steam GeneratorInservice Inspection Summary Report
cc: Regional Administrator - NRC Region IllNRC Senior Resident Inspector - Braidwood StationIllinois Emergency Management Agency - Division of Nuclear Safety
Exelon NuclearBRAIDWOOD STATION UNIT 135100 South Rte. 53, Suite 84
Braceville, IL 60407
COMMERCIAL OPERATION: July 29, 1988
STEAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT INSPECTION REPORT
FOURTEENTH REFUELING OUTAGE (Al R14)
April 2009
Exelon Nuclear4300 Winfield Road
Warrenville, IL 60555
Document Completion Date: July 1, 2009
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 INTRODUCTION
2.0 SUMMARY
3.0 CERTIFICATIONS
3.1 Procedures/Examinations/Equipment
3.2 Personnel
4.0 EXAMINATION TECHNIQUES AND EXAMINATION SCOPE
4.1 Examination Techniques
4.2 Steam Generator Inspection Scope
4.3 Recording of Examination Data
4.4 Witness and Verification of Examination
5.0 EXAMINATION RESULTS
5.1 Eddy Current Inspection
5.2 Other Inspection Results
6.0 RESULTS OF CONDITION MONITORING
6.1 Fan Bar Wear
6.2 Lattice Grid Wear
6.3 Foreign Object Wear
7.0 REPAIR SUMMARY
8.0 DOCUMENTATION
9.0 FIGURES/TABLES/ATTACHMENTS
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Braidwood Station Unit 1 operates with four Babcock & Wilcox Replacement SteamGenerators (SGs) in the four loop pressurized water reactor system. The SGs eachcontain 6633 thermally treated Inconel-690 U-tubes that have a nominal diameter of0.6875 inches and a nominal thickness of 0.040 inches. The tubes are supported bystainless steel lattice grid structures and fan bars. The tubes are hydraulically expandedinto the full depth of the tubesheet. Main Feedwater enters the SGs above the tubebundle through a feedring and J-tubes. The SG configuration is shown in Figures A.1and A.2. The replacement SGs were installed at the end of Cycle 7, in Fall 1998.
In compliance with Braidwood Station Technical Specification (TS) 3.4.19, SteamGenerator (SG) Tube Integrity," TS 5.5.9, "Steam Generator (SG) Program," andAmerican Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel (B&PV)Code Section Xl 2001 Edition through 2003 Addenda, IWB 2500-1, ExaminationCategory B-Q, Item B16.20, SG eddy current examinations were performed during theBraidwood Station Unit 1 fourteenth refueling outage (Al R1 4). The inspections wereperformed consistent with the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) "PWR SteamGenerator Examination Guidelines," Revision 7, and Nuclear Energy Institute NEI 97-06,"Steam Generator Program Guidelines," Revision 2. The inspections were conductedfrom April 1, 2009 through April 15, 2009 by the Westinghouse Electric Company(Westinghouse). The Al R1 4 refueling outage was completed on April 19, 2009. Thefollowing inspections were performed during this outage (TS 5.6.9.a).
* 100% full length bobbin coil eddy current in all four SGs* 100% hot leg dents and dings > 2.0 volts +Point TM
* Diagnostic +PointTM eddy current based on bobbin coil eddy current resultsa 100% Visual Inspection of Previously Installed Tube Plugse 100% Visual Inspection of Newly Installed Tube Plugs
The Braidwood Unit 1 SGs are currently in their first 144 Effective Full Power Month(EFPM) inspection interval following SG replacement, per TS 5.5.9.d.2. The BraidwoodUnit 1 SGs have operated 103.5 EFPM within the 144 EFPM inspection period atrefueling outage 14. Refueling outage 14 was neither the inspection period mid-pointoutage nor the inspection end-point outage. The mid-point inspection outage wasconducted during refueling outage 12 (69.9 EFPM within the inspection period) and theend-point inspection outage is expected to be conducted during refueling outage 17.
2.0 SUMMARY
The guidance in Revision 7 of the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines(i.e., EPRI Guidelines and applicable interim guidance) was used during the inspection.A degradation assessment was performed prior to the inspection to ensure the properEPRI Guidelines Appendix H, "Performance Demonstration for Eddy CurrentExamination," qualified inspection techniques were used to detect any existing andpotential modes of degradation. Each technique was evaluated to ensure that thedetection and sizing capabilities are applicable to the Braidwood Station Unit 1 site-specific condition in accordance with the EPRI Guidelines. All data analysts werequalified to Appendix G, "Qualification of Nondestructive Examination Personnel for
1
Analysis of NDE Data," of the EPRI Guidelines (i.e., Qualified Data Analyst (QDA)). Alldata analyst and acquisition personnel satisfactorily completed site-specific training andtesting prior to beginning examinations. An independent QDA process control reviewwas employed to randomly sample the data to ensure that the analysis resolutionprocess was properly performed and that the field calls were properly reported. Ananalysis feedback process was implemented that required the data analysts to reviewtheir missed calls and overcalls on a daily basis.
The modes of tube degradation found during Al R14 were fan bar wear, lattice grid wearand foreign object wear. Pursuant to EPRI Guideline Section 3.7, "Classification ofSample Plan Results," the results of the inspection were classified as inspectioncategory C-1 for the 1A, 1C and 1 D SGs and category C-2 for the 1 B SG. No additionalscope expansion was required since 100% full-length bobbin eddy current inspectionwas already being performed in all four SGs.
As a result of the eddy current inspection of the SGs, a total of 5 tubes were removedfrom service by mechanical tube plugging. The 5 tubes were removed from service dueto either having wear associated with secondary side foreign objects or were required tobe removed to bound secondary side foreign objects that could not be retrieved.
There were no scanning limitations during the eddy current examinations. Table 2.1,"Equivalent Tube Plugging Level," provides the total tube plugging history and equivalentplugging levels to-date for the Braidwood Station, Unit 1 SGs. Table 2.2, 'TubesPlugged During Al R14," provides the total number of tubes plugged during the currentoutage by degradation mode.
Table 2.1Equivalent Tube Plugging Level (TS 5.6.9.f and 5.6.9.h)
SG A 9G B §G C __SG D& TotalTubes Plugged at Factory 1 2 0 0 3Tubes Plugged in A1RO8 1 0 0 0 1Tubes Plugged in AIR10 8 10 3 0 21Tubes Plugged in ARll 0 2 2 1 5Tubes Plugged in Al R12 11 17 0 0 28Tubes Plugged in AIR13 6 8 7 0 21Tubes Plualied in AlR14 0 1 4 0 5
Total Tubes Plugged 27 40 16 1 84Total Tubes Plugged (%) 0.41% 0.60% 0.24% 0.02% 0.32%
Note: Steam Generator Inspections Were Not Performed During Al R09.
2
Table 2.2Tubes Plugged During A1R14 (TS 5.6.9.b and TS 5.6.9.e)
Mode of Degradation SG A SO B SG C SG D TotalFan Bar Wear 0 0 0 0 0
Lattice Grid Wear 0 0 0 0 0Foreign Object Wear 0 1 1 0 2Preventively Plugged 0 0 3 0 3
Total Tubes Plugged in 0 1 4 0 5A1R14
3.0 CERTIFICATIONS
3.1 Procedures/Examinations/Equipment
3.1.1 The examination and evaluation procedures used during the SG eddycurrent inspection were approved by personnel qualified to ECT Level III inaccordance with the 1984 Edition of the American Society forNondestructive Testing (ASNT) Recommended Practice SNT-TC-1 A,"Personnel Qualification and Certification in Nondestructive Testing," andthe 1991 and 1995 Editions of the American National Standards Institute(ANSI)/ASNT CP-1 89, "ASNT Standard for Qualification and Certification ofNondestructive Testing Personnel." Exelon Generation Company, LLC(i.e.,, Exelon) Procedure ER-AP-335-039, "Multifrequency Eddy CurrentData Acquisition of Steam Generator Tubing," Revision 6 and ExelonProcedure ER-AP-335-040, "Evaluation of Eddy Current Data for SteamGenerator Tubing," Revision 5, were used for data acquisition and analysis.
3.1.2 The examinations, equipment and personnel were in compliance with therequirements of Exelon and Westinghouse Quality Assurance Programsfor Inservice Inspection; Braidwood Station TS 5.5.9; 2001 Editionthrough 2003 Addenda of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel CodeSections XI, "Rules for Inservice Inspection of Nuclear power PlantComponents," and Section V, "Nondestructive Examination"; EPRI PWRSG Examination Guidelines, Revision 7; and NEI 97-06, "SteamGenerator Program Guidelines," Revision 2.
3.1.3 Certification packages for examiners, data analysts, and equipment areavailable at Braidwood Station. Tables A.1 and A.2 of Attachment A listall personnel who performed, supervised, or evaluated the data duringthis SG inservice inspection.
3.1.4 CoreStar International Corporation OMNI-200 TM Remote Data AcquisitionUnits (RDAUs) with Westinghouse ANSER computer software was usedto acquire the eddy current data. Analysis was performed withWestinghouse ANSER 8.4.3 Rev 354 computer software. Secondaryanalysis was performed with CoreStar EddyVision TM32, Release 6.3computer software.
3
3.1.5 The bobbin coil examinations of the SGs were performed withWestinghouse 0.560 inch diameter probes. For low row U-Bend tubing, a0.540 inch diameter probe was utilized to achieve the complete full tubeexamination in tubes where there was difficulty using the 0.560 inchdiameter probe.
3.1.6 The rotating coil examinations were performed with Zetec 0.560 inchdiameter three coil +PointTM probes for straight section tubing. The coilswithin this probes were a 0.115 inch diameter pancake coil, a shielded0.080 inch diameter pancake coil and a standard +PointTM coil. Fordiagnostic evaluation of indications within the U-Bend tubing, a 0.520 inchdiameter probe was used with a single standard +PointTM coil.
3.2 Personnel
3.2.1 The personnel who performed the SG eddy current inspections werequalified to Level I and Level II certification in accordance with the 1984Edition of the ASNT Recommended Practice SNT-TC-1A, "PersonnelQualification and Certification in Nondestructive Testing" or the 1995Edition of ANSI/ASNT CP-1 89, "ASNT Standard for Qualification andCertification of Nondestructive Testing Personnel." The Level I personnelperformed the inspections under the direct supervision of Level II or LevelIII personnel. A list of the certified eddy current personnel who performeddata acquisition for the examination is contained in Table A.1 ofAttachment A.
3.2.2 The personnel who performed the SG eddy current data analysis werequalified to a minimum of Level II, with special analysis training (i.e., LevelIIA) in accordance with the 1984 Edition of the ASNT RecommendedPractice SNT-TC-1A, "Personnel Qualification and Certification inNondestructive Testing" or the 1995 Edition of ANSI/ASNT CP-189, "ASNTStandard for Qualification and Certification of Nondestructive TestingPersonnel." A list of the certified eddy current personnel who performeddata analysis for the examination is contained in Table A.2 of AttachmentA.
3.2.3 All SG eddy current data analysts were qualified in accordance with EPRIAppendix G for Qualified Data Analysts (QDAs). In addition, all dataanalysts were trained and tested in accordance with a site specificperformance demonstration program in both the bobbin coil and +PointTMinspection data analysis. Resolution analysts were also trained andtested specifically for the performance of data resolution. All analystswere required to achieve a minimum score of 80% probability of detectionwith a 90% confidence level on the practical examination, and a minimumscore of 80% on the written examination prior to analyzing data.
3.2.4 All SG eddy current data acquisition personnel were trained and tested inaccordance with a site specific performance demonstration program. Thedata acquisition operators were required to achieve a written test score of80% or greater prior to acquiring data.
4
3.2.5 The SG eddy current analysis was subject to two independent analyses.Primary and secondary analysis was performed by an automated datascreening analysis system as described in the EPRI Guidelines, Revision7. The analysis systems were operated in the manual interactive mode.Each system successfully passed the EPRI Automated AnalysisPerformance Demonstration Database (AAPDD). Each system also wasrequired to successfully pass the site specific performance demonstrationpractical examination prior to analyzing field data. Discrepanciesbetween the two parties required Level III concurrence between bothparties for final resolution.
3.2.6 Two independent SG eddy current Level III QDAs who were not part ofthe resolution team were employed to serve as a process controlreviewers, in accordance with EPRI Guidelines. The Independent LevelIII QDAs randomly sampled the data to ensure the resolution process wasproperly performed and that the field calls were properly reported. TheIndependent Level III QDAs also provided data acquisition oversight toensure that the data collection process was in compliance withappropriate procedures, that all essential variables were set inaccordance with the applicable Examination Technique SpecificationSheet (ETSS) and to provide a data quality check of acquired data. TheIndependent Level III QDAs reported directly to the Exelon Level III QDA.
3.2.7 Personnel qualified as data analysts performed real time data qualityverifications.
4.0 EXAMINATION TECHNIQUES AND EXAMINATION SCOPE
All SG eddy current examination techniques used were qualified in accordance withAppendix H of the EPRI Guidelines. Each examination technique was evaluated to beapplicable to the tubing and conditions of the Braidwood Station Unit 1 SGs.
4.1 Examination Techniques (TS 5.6.9.c)
4.1.1 The bobbin coil examinations were performed with a 0.560 inch diameterprobe as described in Section 3.1.5 of this report. For low row U-Bendregions where there was difficulty using the 0.560 inch diameter probe, a0.540 inch diameter probe was utilized to achieve the full tube inspection.Nominal probe inspection speed was 40 inches per second for tubes inrow 10 and higher and 24 inches per second for low row tubes. Sufficientsampling rates were used to maintain a minimum digitizing rate of 33samples per inch. The bobbin probes were operated in both thedifferential and absolute modes at frequencies of 650 kHz, 320 kHz, 160kHz, and 35 kHz. The following suppression mixes were used toenhance the inspection: 650/160 kHz differential mix, 320/160 kHzabsolute mix, 650/320 kHz differential mix and a 650/320/160 kHzdifferential mix.
5
4.1.2 Inspections of non-quantifiable bobbin coil indications and hot legdents/dings greater than or equal to 2.0 volts as detected by the bobbincoil examination, were performed utilizing +PointTM probes as describedin Section 3.1.6. Maximum axial probe inspection speed was 0.6 inchesper second for straight tubing, 0.35 inches per second for U-bend regionof the tubing and 0.15 inches per second at dents and dings. Samplerates and rotation speeds were used to maintain a minimum digitizing rateof 30 samples per inch (i.e., 25 samples per inch for the axial directionand 30 samples per inch for the circumferential direction). The rotatingprobes for straight section tubing and dents/ding inspections wereoperated in the absolute test mode at frequencies of 300 kHz, 200 kHz,100 kHz and 20 kHz. The rotating probes for U-bend section inspectionswere operated in the absolute test mode at frequencies of 400 kHz, 300kHz, 100 kHz and 20 kHz. In addition to the four base frequencies, threeprocess channels were used to display axial indications in the positivetrace.
4.1.3 The eddy current calibration standards used for the bobbin coil and+PointTM inspections met the requirements of the EPRI Guidelines,Revision 7, and Sections V and XI of the ASME Code, 2001 Editionthrough 2003 Addenda.
4.1.4 The SG eddy current examination techniques used during this inspectionwere equivalent to the EPRI Guidelines Appendix H techniques listed inTable 4.1. Each ETSS was evaluated and determined to be applicable tosite conditions.
6
Table 4.1
JbUU4.3Rev. 11
i-an bar/Lattice urna/-oreign uDject vvear ana i-reeSoan Flaws
96910.1 . +Point TM Foreign Object Wear/Free Span Flaws (Wear LikeRev. 10 Flaws)21998.1 +Point TM Foreign Object Wear (Volumetric Like Flaws)Rev. 4
96703.1 +PointTM Dents/Dings - Primary Water Stress CorrosionRev. 17 Cracking (Axial PWSCC)21409.1 +PointTM Outer Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking (AxialRev. 5 ODSCC)
21410.1 +PointTM Outer Diameter Stress Corrosion CrackingRev. 6 (Circumferential ODSCC)
20511.1 +PointTM Inside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking (AxialRev. 8 PWSCC)
20510.1 +PointTM Inside Diameter Stress Corrosion CrackingRev. 7 (Circumferential PWSCC)
96010.1 Bobbin Manufacturing Burnish MarksRev. 7
22401.1 +PointTM Dents/Dings - Outer Diameter Stress CorrosionRev. 4 Cracking (Axial ODSCC)
96008.1 Bobbin Tube Support Plate / Sludge Pile - Outer DiameterRev. 14 Stress Corrosion Cracking (Axial ODSCC)
PWSCC - Primary Water Stress Corrosion CrackingODSCC - Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking
4.2 Steam Generator Inspection Scope (TS 5.6.9.a)
4.2.1 100% of the tubes in all SGs were inspected full-length with a bobbinprobe as described in Section 4.1.1.
4.2.2 Diagnostic examinations were performed on all non-quantifiableindications, locations of foreign object wear, and hot leg dents/dingsgreater than or equal to 2.0 volts that were detected by the bobbin coilexamination. Diagnostic examinations were also conducted in the vicinityof potential foreign objects to determine the extent of tubes potentiallyaffected by the objects. These special examinations were performed withthe three coil +PointTM probe described in Section 4.1.2 above. SeeSection 5.1 and Attachment B.3 for further detail.
4.2.3 See Attachment B for tubesheet maps detailing the inspection scope foreach SG.
7
4.3 Recording of Examination Data
Results of the SG eddy current data analysis were recorded on optical disks.The data was then loaded into a Westinghouse Eddy CLrrent Data ManagementSystem, "STMax" version, 1.23.01. The system was used to track the completionof the examinations and was used to generate the final SG eddy current reportsummaries.
4.4 Witness and Verification of Examination
SG eddy current inspections were witnessed and/or verified by the AuthorizedNuclear Inservice Inspector, Mr. L. Malabanan of the Hartford Steam BoilerInspection and Insurance Company of Hartford Connecticut, Chicago Branch,2443 Warrenville Road, Suite 500, Lisle, Illinois 60532-9871.
5.0 EXAMINATION RESULTS
5.1 Eddy Current Inspection (TS 5.6.9.b and TS 5.6.9.d)
Full-length bobbin coil examination of all inservice tubes was performed in allSGs.
5.1.1 Fan Bar Wear - A total of 34 indications of tube wear at the Fan Barintersections were identified during Al R14. The largest indication of FanBar wear was 16% Through Wall (TW) as measured by the eddy currenttechnique. The EPRI Appendix H bobbin coil technique 96004.3 Revision11 was utilized in this inspection for depth sizing of all Fan Bar wear.Refer to Attachment B.4 for detailed locations and sizing for all Fan Barwear.
5.1.2 Lattice Grid Wear - A total of eight indications of tube wear at the LatticeGrid intersections were identified during Al R14. The largest indication ofLattice Grid wear was 11% TW as measured by the eddy currenttechnique. The EPRI Appendix H bobbin coil technique 96004.3 Revision11 was utilized in this inspection for depth sizing of all Lattice Grid wear.Refer to Attachment B.5 for detailed locations and sizing for all LatticeGrid wear.
5.1.3 Foreign Obiect Wear - A total of six indications of secondary side foreignobject wear were identified during Al R14. The EPRI Appendix H+PointTM technique 21988.1 Revision 4 was utilized in this inspection fordepth sizing of all foreign object wear.
Of the six indications, four were associated with relatively small amountsof tube wear (16% TW, 15% TW, 15% TW and 21%TW) as measured bythe eddy current technique. These indications were identified during aprevious SG inspection (Al R12) and were allowed to remain in servicesince they were below the TS plugging criteria of greater than or equal to40% TW, and secondary side visual inspection confirmed that the objects
8
that caused the tube wear were no longer present. Re-inspection ofthese indications during Al R1 3 and Al R1 4 confirmed that the associatedwear had not changed since first identified during Al R12. Thereforethese indications were allowed to remain in service.
Two tubes contained secondary side foreign object wear that was newlyidentified during Al R14.
In the 1C SG, Tube Row 30 Col 63 had a 9% TW foreign object wearindication, as measured by eddy current technique 21988.1 Revision 4,which was 0.13" above the hot leg top of tubesheet intersection. Thewear was associated with a piece metallic gasket material that wasunable to be retrieved. The gasket was approximately 1.0" in length by0.188" thick by 0.050" wide. The object was identified during secondaryside foreign object search and retrieval, but could not successfully beretrieved. The inservice tubes surrounding the object were inspected with+PointTM. Tube Row 30 Col 63 was the only tube in the vicinity of theobject that showed any signs of tube wear. Tube Row 30 Col 63containing the 9% TW indication, along with three additional tubessurrounding the gasket material were preventatively stabilized andplugged.
In the 1 B SG, Tube Row 89 Col 30 had a 73% foreign object wearindication as measured by eddy current technique 21988.1 Revision 4,which was 0.26" above the hot leg tubesheet. Secondary side videoinspection of the region as performed during Al R1 4 did not identify anyforeign object(s) in the vicinity of the wear indication. The inservice tubessurrounding the area of wear were inspected with +PointTM. Tube Row89 Col 30 was the only tube in the vicinity that showed any signs of tubewear. Structural and leakage integrity of the tube, as required by TS5.5.9.b, was demonstrated through In-Situ pressure testing as describedin Section 5.2.4. Tube Row 89 Col 30 containing the 73% TW indicationwas stabilized and plugged after completion of In-Situ pressure testing.
The 73% TW wear indication in Tube Row 89 Col 30 is believed to beassociated with a piece of metallic gasket material that was originallyidentified and unable to be retrieved during the Spring 2003 refuelingoutage (AlR10). During Al1R10 the tubes surrounding the object wereplugged and stabilized. It is believed that the gasket migrated from itsoriginal location, contacted Tube Row 89 Col 30, and based oninspections performed during Al R14, is no longer in the region. Basedon the Al R1 4 inspections confirming that the gasket is no longer in a highflow region of the SG, it is possible the gasket broke into smaller piecesthat were removed by the Blowdown System or during sludge lancingoperations. It has been conservatively assumed that the gasket migratedto a lower flow region of the SG, where it has been shown throughanalysis not to be capable of causing substantial tube wear prior to thenext scheduled SG inspection.
Review of previous outage bobbin eddy current data indicates that anindication of secondary side foreign object wear was present in Tube Row
9
89 Col 30 during the two previous SG eddy current inspections in Spring2006 (Al R1 2) and Fall 2007 (Al R1 3). The bobbin eddy current signalpresent during Al R12 was smaller and not distinguishable fromsecondary side deposits, therefore it was determined not to be above theTechnical Specification (TS) 5.5.9.c.1, plugging criteria of greater than orequal to 40% TW. The bobbin eddy current signal present during Al R1 3was essentially the same as that identified during Al R14, which wassized by +Point TM during Al R14 as 73% TW. As such, it was determinedthat an indication larger than the TS 5.5.9.c.1 plugging criteria was left inservice during the A1 R1i3 inspection. This was identified during theA1 R14 inspection. Refer to Braidwood Licensee Event Report (LER)2009-001-00, "Steam Generator Tube Exceeding Plugging CriteriaRemained In Service During Previous Cycle," for additional detail.
Refer to Attachment B.3 for detailed locations and sizing for all ForeignObject wear indications.
5.1.4 Attachment B contains tube lists with axial elevations of all imperfectionsthat contain measurable through wall depth that were found during theAl R14 eddy current inspection.
5.2 Other Inspection Results
5.2.1 Hot Leg Dent / Ding Inspection: During refueling outage AlR14, 100% ofthe hot leg dents / dings greater than or equal to 2.0 volts were inspectedwith +PointTM. A total of two tubes contained dings that met theinspection criteria and were inspected. No degradation was identified asa result of these inspections.
5.2.2 Visual Inspection of Installed Tube Plugs - All previously installed tubeplugs were visually inspected for signs of degradation and leakage. Inaddition, all plugs installed during this outage were also visually inspectedand the installation parameters were reviewed for acceptable installation.No anomalies were found.
5.2.3 Tube-to-Tube Proximity - The condition of tubes being in close proximitywas monitored as part of the 100% full-length bobbin coil inspection of allSGs during Al R1 4. The inspection results, including historical datarelated to tube-to-tube proximity is provided in the Table 5.2.3 below. Notube degradation was identified associated with tube-to-tube proximity.This condition will continue to be monitored during future scheduled SGinspections.
10
Table 5.2.3Tube-to-Tube Proximity Summary
Number of TubesPr e- R ....... AR8A A1131 AR12 A.Rl3 Al R14
Service .(Spring (spring (Fall (Spring (Fall ,.(Sp~ring
SIns~pe~ction.20.00).2003) 2004) 2006) 2Q07) 2009)Note 1 Note 2
Total 508 85 132 39 188 196 204Note 1: During Al R10 the 1A SG received 100% full-length eddy current
inspection and the 1 B, 1C and 1 D SGs received 54% full-lengthinspection.
Note 2: Only the 1 B SG received 100% full-length inspection through thearea of interest during Al R1 1.
5.2.4 In-Situ Pressure Testing - In the 1 B SG, Tube Row 89 Col 30 contained a73% foreign object wear indication as measured by +PointTM technique21988.1 Revision 4. The wear indication was 0.26" above the hot legtubesheet. Structural and leakage integrity of the tube, as required by TS5.5.9.b, was demonstrated through successful In-Situ pressure testingduring A1 R14.
Westinghouse performed local In-Situ pressure testing of the wear regionper the requirements of EPRI In-Situ Pressure Testing GuidelinesRevision 3. Leakage tests were performed at multiples of differentialpressures associated with normal operating and main steam line break.No leakage was identified during these tests. Proof testing was performedat various pressures up to differential pressures associated with threetimes the normal operating differential pressure (3XNOdP) conditions.The In-Situ pressure tests were performed at approximately 1700 psig,2100 psig, 2600 psig, 3100 psig, 3600 psig, 4100 psig, 4600, psig and4900 psig. Each test pressure was held for a minimum of 5 minutes. Noleakage was identified during these tests. Based on the results of theleak and proof In-Situ pressure testing, the accident and leakageperformance criteria as required by TS 5.5.9.b, were demonstrated for the73% TW indication. The tube was stabilized and plugged followingcompletion of In-Situ pressure testing.
6.0 RESULTS OF CONDITION MONITORING (TS 5.6.9.g)
A condition monitoring assessment was performed for each inservice degradationmechanism found during the Al R14 inspection. The condition monitoring assessmentwas performed in accordance with TS 5.5.9.a and NEI 97-06 using the EPRI SteamGenerator Integrity Assessment Guidelines, Revision 2. For each identified degradationmechanism, the as-found condition was compared to the appropriate performancecriteria for tube structural integrity, accident induced leakage and operational leakage asdefined in TS 5.5.9.b. For each damage mechanism a tube structural limit wasdetermined to ensure that SG tube integrity would be maintained over the full range ofnormal operating conditions and design basis accidents. This includes retaining a safety
11
factor of 3.0 against burst under normal steady state full power operation primary tosecondary pressure differential and a safety factor of 1.4 against burst under the limitingdesign basis accident pressure differential.
For Braidwood Station Unit 1, the limiting case is 3 times operating differential pressure,which is significantly higher than 1.4 times the most limiting accident condition (steamline break). The structural limit of 60% TW used was based upon 360-degree uniformwall thinning for infinite length assuming ASME Code minimum material properties. Thestructural limits provided are conservative in that the limits assume 360 degree uniformwall thinning for the entire length of the tube and use conservative lower reactor coolanttemperatures. Satisfying the structural limit ensures that the SG tube integrityperformance criteria for structural integrity, accident induced leakage and operationalleakage will be maintained.
In the case of the 73% TW foreign object wear indication in the 1 B SG, Tube Row 89 Col30, SG tube integrity was demonstrated though performance of In-Situ pressure testingas described in Section 5.2.4.
The as-found condition of each degradation mechanism found during Al R14 was shownto meet the appropriate limiting structural integrity performance parameter with aprobability of 0.95 at 50% confidence, including consideration of relevant uncertainties.
No tube pulls were performed during Al R1 4.
Sections 6.1 through 6.3 provide a summary of the condition monitoring assessment foreach degradation mechanism.
6.1 Fan Bar Wear
The largest Fan Bar wear indication found during the Al R1 4 inspection was 16%TW as measured by the EPRI Appendix H qualified technique 96004.3, Revision11. Considering technique and analyst uncertainties, the largest AVB wearindication found is corrected to 24.3% TW with a 0.95 probability at 50%confidence. This is well below the conservative Fan Bar wear structural limit of60% TW using low Reactor Coolant Temperature Average (Tavg).
6.2 Lattice Grid Wear
The largest Lattice Grid wear indication found during the Al R1 4 inspection was11% TW as measured by the EPRI Appendix H qualified technique 96004.3,Revision 11. Considering technique and analyst uncertainties, the largestantivibration bar wear indication found is corrected to 19.5% TW with a 0.95probability at 50% confidence. This is well below the conservative Lattice Gridwear using structural limit of 60% TW using low Tavg.
6.3 Foreign Object Wear
The largest Foreign Object wear indication found during the Al R1 4 inspectionwas 73% TW as measured by the EPRI Appendix H qualified technique 21998.1,Revision 4. Considering technique and analyst uncertainties, the largest ForeignObject wear indication found is corrected to 91.7% TW with a 0.95 probability at
12
50% confidence. Since this indication was above the conservative ForeignObject wear structural limit of 60% TW using low Tavg, SG tube integrity wasdemonstrated though performance of In-Situ pressure testing of this indication asdiscussed in Section 5.2.4. No leakage was observed during the In-Situpressure testing, therefore all performance criteria as defined in TS 5.5.9.b weremet for this indication during A1 R14.
The next largest Foreign Object wear indication found during the Al R14inspection was 21% TW as measured by the EPRI Appendix H qualifiedtechnique 21998.1, Revision 4. Considering technique and analyst uncertainties,the largest Foreign Object wear indication found is corrected to 38.8% TW with a0.95 probability at 50% confidence. This is well below the conservative ForeignObject wear structural limit of 60% TW using low Tavg.
7.0 REPAIR SUMMARY (TS 5.6.9.1)
Repairs were conducted in accordance with ASME Section XI, 2001 Edition through2003 Addenda. All tube plugging was performed by Westinghouse using an Alloy 690mechanical tube plugging process in accordance with ASME Section XI IWA-4713,"Heat Exchanger Tube Plugging by Expansion." All repairs were performed inaccordance with Westinghouse approved procedures. Table 7.0 summarizes the repairsperformed during Al R14. No tube sleeving was performed.
Table 7.0Summary ofAlRl4 TubePlu ing
REPAIRS SG 1A. S iG It~ SG 1 SG 1D~ TOTAL2PERFORMED7
Tubes 0 1 4 0 5PluggedTubes 0 1 4 0 5
Stabilized
8.0 DOCUMENTATION
All original data is stored on optical disks that have been provided to Exelon and aremaintained at Braidwood Station. The final data sheets and pertinent tube sheet plots arecontained in the Westinghouse Outage Report for Braidwood Unit 1, Fourteenth RefuelingOutage, and are also maintained at Braidwood Station.
NOTE: The ASME Section Xl NIS-1 Form, "Owner's Report for Inservice Inspections," andNIS-2 Form, "Owner's Report for Repair / Replacement Activities," for steam generatorinspection activities performed during the Braidwood Unit 1 Fourteenth Refueling Outageare contained in a separate transmittal, i.e., the "Braidwood Station Unit 1 InserviceInspection Summary Report."
13
9.0 FIGURES/TABLES/ATTACHMENTS
Attachment A Contents
Table A.1 Data Acquisition Personnel Certification List
Table A.2 Data Analysis Personnel Certification List
Figure A.1 Babcock & Wilcox Replacement Steam Generator Braidwood Unit1 Configuration
Figure A.2 Babcock & Wilcox Replacement Steam Generator Braidwood Unit1 Tubesheet Configuration
Attachment B Contents
Attachment B.1 As-tested Bobbin Inspection Maps
Attachment B.2 As-tested +PointTM Special Interest Inspection Maps
Attachment B.3 Tubes Damaged by Secondary Side Foreign Objects
Attachment B.4 Tubes Containing Fan Bar Wear
Attachment B.5 Tubes Containing Lattice Grid Wear
Attachment B.6 Tubes Repaired During A1 R14
14
Attachment A
Personnel Certifications
TABLE A.1A1R14
Data Acquisition Personnel Certifications
No. Name Company Level ODA(YIN)
1 Estel, J. Westinghouse II No2 Conner, M. Westinghouse II No3 Mantic, S. Westinghouse I No4 Dillard, W. Westinghouse II No5 Douglas, B. Westinghouse III No6 Evering, D. Westinghouse II No7 Greenawalt, L. Westinghouse I No8 Groh, T. Westinghouse II No9 Miller, G. Westinghouse II No
10 Palmer, T. Westinghouse II No11 Ripple, G. Westinghouse II No12 Scott, A. Westinghouse II No13 Smith, D. Westinghouse II No14 Yernerall, R. Westinghouse I-L No15 Agosti, S. Master-Lee IIA No16 Debreto, T. Master-Lee IIA No17 Shaffer, E. Master-Lee IIA No18 Lopez, P. System One I No19 Markowsky, M. System One I-T No
TABLE A.2A1R14
Data Analysis Personnel Certifications
No. Name Company Level ODA(YIN)
1 Beehner, S. Westinghouse Ill Yes2 *Black, C. NDE Technology Ill Yes3 *Brown, M. NDE Technology IlI Yes4 Calender, D. Young IIA Yes5 Case, J. NDE Technology III Yes6 Causby,G. NDE Technology III Yes7 Chevalier, W. Young IIA Yes8 Collins, J. Young IIA Yes9 Drumm, R. NDE Technology III Yes10 Gomez, A. Young IIA Yes11 Grant, B. NDE Technology Ill Yes12 Haynes, W. NDE Technology III Yes13 Herold, M. Infineddy IIA Yes14 Hover, L. Young III Yes15 Ingenthron, J. Infineddy IIA Yes16 Ives, D. Young IIA Yes17 Kajari, I. Master-Lee IIA Yes18 Kirshberger, G. Young III Yes19 Lewis, C. NDE Technology IIA Yes20 Lohner, E. NDE Technology III Yes21 Lynn, V. Master-Lee III Yes22 Merriman, R. MoreTech III Yes23 Owens, S. Young IIA Yes24 Popovich, R. Westinghouse III Yes25 Siegel, R. NDE Technology III Yes26 Skirpan, J. Westinghouse III Yes27 Stocklin, P. Young IIA Yes28 Stokke, T. NDE Technology III Yes29 Thompson, K. NDE Technology IIA Yes30 Thulien, T. MoreTech III Yes31 Tommarello, D. Master-Lee IIA Yes32 Welch, L. Young III Yes33 Wheeler, C. NDE Technology III Yes
* Independent Qualified Data Analyst
FIGURE A.1Babcock & Wilcox Replacement Steam Generator
Braidwood Unit 1 Configuration
I
FIGURE A.2Babcock & Wilcox Replacement Steam Generator
Braidwood Unit 1 Tubesheet Configuration
. ...... ......
.................%..'o..%. .'.....%. o%..%.=.
.%%..... ..........................
................................-..........%..... ....... ...................... 0
.".....:....... :":...'........::........'..........
. . . ...... ..........°= . = . ...•* ...... ....... °. .no o o = ° =
.... o =..o.. ... °.......=..........•....=. ° = °. . ° .........
..........-..-...%=';.. .%.%..% ....-. %.%%%.-... .- %..... o ...
.. •.*. °%.;............. ..%* %.=..... %........ .. o= .. . . .S ...................................... ,'"'% "% "......
_ .:...:.....:...: ... ......:......~...::ii:.:• :.:::.:!.........:....:..::. *j-...%%*.%.jj..j=%%;.%%%o%% .;...*.% .j............
% ,.',%......JJ..... J ... %o*.%,';=..".
;%...%°...............-
:.:.:%-.:-..:-.:..-.- - ,
.. .. . . .. . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . ... .. .. *. .. .. .. .. .I .. 3 . . . . .. . . . . . . .
.... ~ I .. . . . .. . .. ... .. . .. .. . .. .... . . .. . . .. . . .. ..
Attachment B
Inspection Scope / ResultsA11R14
Attachment B.1
As-tested Bobbin Inspection MapsA1R14
SG - A Bobbin as Tested from the Hot Leg
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720E 6043 Tested fromTEC through TEH
1 563 Tested from F01 thýough TEH
a 27 Plugged Tube
40 135 130 .125 .20 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60
IE EEEE E E Eý E E EE E E__ EE E EFF
55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
. F_ F E115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
- F E .I E E E E E E FEFE EFE IEE,_ _ .E •EE D * E•.E F•:ýE EE E E E E E E E! E F __
I- EEE EE H F FEEF 'FE - E t -E-E E EF--E E E ! •E 'ErE :ERE; HE Er E ErEr E EE E:E E E E:EEEE:EjE _E E ,E :E E• •E E ,E E
ý ýE; EýE : E• :•E tEýE• :EýEý ;EýE 'EýEE ; E ýE = E _E ý.E :EýIE•E EýE:ýEE EEF E E EE E E EE E F:III---F ý E-OQE~ -H F TE "E .E[E E [E [ EE : LE F FEH E H E F-HF F E EýFF E _
-Ej E EE E EEE E E E E E E'E E E E EE E , E E - EEEEIE F 'EE E EE E -EE E E E-E E E:EE_
,E E [! [E E !E
SG - A Bobbin as Tested from the Cold Leg
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 77209 533 Tested from 09H through TEC
1 30 Tested from F01 virough TEC
a 27 Plugged Tube
1A&A 1• 1"f0 1,!; 1911 11-, 1110 101!; 1010 gR g0. A!; 60 7!; 70 65; 60 55; 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
S
4 .). 00~00o oo o o 00 0 .-010 00 1-
0 0
0000 00
0 .07a7 "I *00o . . . . . . . .-~ - ___ >::j.:::oO... o . . .:: ,:0 :_ _00 • •00
0..0
I-- X. .1o 0
00
.... ...: . .. o 0 .0°. .: :t. 00'" '7 .. 0 .... 0
0°•_____• • 7 7,.r : 4.0 ____ "'__ '_"0"••"o
00.. : . • . .
000-
0. .00 .• K .0 .. .... . o0. . 0 .. .. .. .
00
00. . I I 0....-..
0.:.:. . . .0
OCT...... .'. ,0 • ... .. ... . ... . .- -.. .. 0OC T . .: : :0: . .. • .: ..,
()~~ . .0 : .
...I: *~i . . .. . . ,*. 00 0 o-0 . . . " .. . . . .T . . . . . . ° . . .
. . : .: .D.O. . . . . . . .
.:: . .•: .- - -' ' . . ..0 . .. . : . ... . . . oO. --oI : --. --: : ---Oo- -.... .. ..................' .i ......Co
999.._ _ _ _ i i _ _ ___
... .. .. . . ....o °
0" . .. .....°°.o)0 I. .•.: • ... ..'' ' ' .: .-: .: .. 0'. o
.. . . . . . 0 0•
o °) • • • • I • • • " . ° . . . . , . .(0 .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. .. ... ..... ... ... ." ... . . . : ..1 ..o . ?. . . . .... .. . . . . .• .. .. .' ' .. . . .... .. .11 .... . : -0
0. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .°, .'° ."°'.. ., . . .
-0 .. . .. .. . . . . .oo ' ' "o:"' " :" • : • ;o ".' . ... . . . " . . .. .. I . • . ... . . ... .. . 0o " " .: : : : .: : . . . . ..... ," ..
q.; °°9 9 1 99 9 9 ;9 ; ;t 9; , ° 9 9 -*;9 * 9; 9 * * , * ; 9 99 , *
9° "~~~~ ~ ~~~~9" 9 * 9999 9 9" 9 "99". L 9 ..9 9-9" .9999" 9999 ,'99 )9999" 9999"^99999;9,•9g 9 ;;; 9. 9 9 9 9 S9 9 ,9 9
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
59999 9999 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 ;9 9 9 99 9 9999 99 9 9 -9 99 999999 999 9 9999 99 9999999999 9999
9~f 9 9.1.0 -IIi 91 1 99S9 999999 9 99•9_99 9 9 9 1-1"99999999_ 9 99 99 9 999999 9 9 99 9999 9999 9999 99 99 9 9 9
9499 9 9 9 1 , 1 1 1 9 9 99 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 t9 99 99 99 ý9 91 99 99; 19 9 9 '9~ 9 9 g~ 9 9 9 ~9- 9 9 9 9 99 9
140 135 130 *125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90' 85 80 75 70 65~ 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electic Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:54:15
SG - B Bobbin as Tested from the Hot Leg
Braidwood AlR14 CCE 7720E 6032 Tested from TEC through TEH
a 39 Plugged Tube
40 135 130- 125 .20 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 -70 65 160 55I,;, EJ ýEEEE50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
.EjE EFE IEEE :E .E E FE EE - E E Eý E EE _EI_ E-E' !E E E
F E E E E !E E -E EE E F F F EFE FEE E-E E-F E E E•~ FEEL !Y-E E FEE E E E~ F FE;E E E; : r EE, ..EF • E F FE ;ýE :E; E E EE E •• t
EE :E'E FEL E E E F E ; EEF E E FE
FL FE E E E-E [F E ":E. H FE FE E EE E -[EE E- E ELE EL E E E E E E E E F E
F FE E E_ E E E EE E F F E E E OFE F EF .... tE E FEE E E E E I E E:EE- Ei EEE EPEE E E E IFE EFFE : EEE FE FE EEE E EEE- E-EE-EE-E-E FEEE- E- E E EE£ I E EE •EE EE
______ _ FE E:E;E FEELLEEEE FEL : 'EF Q LE ' F- EE -EE, E EEE~ ' E •E E E EEEEE EF E FEi FEE F E F E E EFE E E EEQ E .E
-E .'E E N ý,,r- E E i. E. rE .E E ! E ýE ,E -EýE[ E ýE 'Et :[ . Q .E- E ,. E R- { E .,[E ý E ,E. E ,EE E
E:E~ ~~~ "E.E E E .r..;E E E'E. E. E EE ýE Eý:ý Ef Eý • E E ; ý E E- E:
E,E E E :E E :E E E E E E •E E E EFE FE E F E E FFE E E E... !F. E E E ... F.. E.F E:EEE E E E'EE EE E FE EE,•FE•EEE EE F FEE EFEF EE EEEE FE EF F E FE FE-E
I.FEEF E : E - EE E F. EELFE E E E F
E.E:t E- ,El -F . :E E -.F E E E EE.E [ýEE FE E E 1 .F1E E E - E.F E E E E FEE EEE E E - E E E. ' [E E- E E E ýEEF E. E E F LE. E
F-EE FE F E F E E FE FE E F F F EEE E EEEE :E
FEEE!F F E E FE FE EýE NE --E EH [E- E :_ F F : F E E-E -EFF __
F EE FELE LEFE FE E E, :EE. E E E.EF HE-E. E- . EE • FE
F E EFEý EEE E'EE FE E;E E Fw FE EE F F EýE E EFEE E E E EE[ : E:[ FL" E E 'E. E '.F 'E• E• H E E E E E E E E t F EEtE FE E E E E EE F E E E E .E E E EE
•_ '!E F • EI EE E -E :E E E F . EE E LEE -EýE - ..-F- ..F-F E- EE -E: E"Eý EEF E FL EE L E
F E ;F E•E Eý EE E EEEý -E'E E-FEE E E .F;EEF -FE"FEE E EE E`•E .E.,'E EE FE E E E :E LE F EL F FE FE F F FE FE
" E E F E" FE E:• " F EE"E E E E EE .EF : F F E FE'
_F EE :E E E E EFE I E E -E .E I E _ E E E EE E E E E .EF FEEE EýFE F F F FE EE FE F E E E E
E FI• •E E E I EE:• •I• • :E E E C .. .E E.. F E FE -F • . L E L L L-f -L-.EF EHEE F EF E:E EE FE EF EEEE E ,EF EELEE. [FEE .FE E -E-I- E EEF F :E -EE EE E EE -EE E E L
-i- F- EýE[E~.;4Jf . E F EýE ýE'E FF LE E; .EEE ýFE.E :EJ . E EEEE FE
E L FE: FEFF F E F F F E T
EE E EE E E EE E E E :E : E' EE E E E E E FE : EE F -E F- E E -F E E " E 'E
-__ ____ FEE EFEF. .E FEF.!. EE EE FE EF : ýEE :E EEF FE EEF C E {E! F E EE EL F F E 'EE- FF E F[ OE.. iE EE L !E!-E'E ' EE
E E
E q E 11 E Q E E I" E E E E.. • '" " • ••E E
E EF EEE E" FEE EEE E E E "E EE E E E EE E E E E • E EE E - EE E :E E - E E E E _ _E E E EE E E- E E E .E E .. E E F F F E E E E
E-I E E E .EE, E.E. .. E.E . . F . E. E , EE .. E E E E .E :E E . EE =-E ,EFE. E E . .E. . .E E E.. F.E E- E O E " ýE
EE E EE E.E EEE E EE, EýE' -E E"E E t E ,. E- E EE F E EFE .;E; F EL F EýEý F E F EF E_-__ ___•__ E E EE L : ELE E E E -E -FF-, -- F .. F F FEEL: E E EEEEtE E•TEE:E'E EEE I .E .. E .E F E IEE- F. E-EE .I .. E : E E E E E E E•EE F.EE F..L
F..E E.F.U ... -.• E F EF E FEE ELE EE EFEF. F EE I E..E ;.FE F .:F EFEF :F FEF- E .E EE EFE -E, ;E .E .F HE E E. F
E EE E• E F E E;E EFE ;EE E Fe e : FF -E EF FE F E FE - F E E .E E EE FI
F F F E E :E .E E E
E E E E -
F EE E E E :E
FFF EFF, FLEE EE FEE L E E FEEL E L F E•E F F FE E• E E E E, •E -F E E"E E FE: F- E E ;E E E:" E E EFEFI EF[ E F EE EE EEFEFE E:E E FEE EEF E•EEE E •EE NEE E rE EE EE.E[ ET- - E .E EFE ...EF _ýEE I EE ELEEHE 1EEE EEýE :EFEF EEE FEFE E.E F EF: EFEFEE E H"F: EE -E___
FE F,":EE -'-E F E -E. F E E EEEP
EEEE E E'EE E E E E E E E E "E E E -E E E E 1: E E E E E E :EE E F E E E EE- FE E EE EE__ _EE "
- --- E E E F E F . .E E I E E F. - F EI~ .F.F F F. F . F • ! . .C : E E F F:L FEL E E FEEE 'E::F E E I E L E EE FE E F E E QE-E"E E • -E-E E I F E E E E E E- * FE E E
-'E E F F..E E E" EE E E E
.. .V E E - E F E E E -E : E FE E F..E - E F E EE F - E- E -.E -E ,..E IE ± E _E F-.E F E
__ _ _ F EF F F E E:E E !E:E:FE"EF F EE.. F E E.E EFEFFEE E E • EE- EFE :EFE : E E F.E_ E• •I E E EE F F F F [F[ :E E F:E F FEE FEEL
E E EE- FE k L ' L L £ L l= I I ' E E E.E FE : E E• • E• E E : E F[ F E 'EE
E" • E-e: ;•:; ;e : , - -'e• I - ' ' c • , • • , e e ..F -.EE
E EEE F.
I ' E F
; ;. EE F E 'E
FE E E E E E E I E E E E F:e E- L El F F E E E E E EE
[FEE E E E E EE E E -E E E E -E E F E
.L r : k. . . _._ • .: v . .: • F- 1• F F:.. • L:E .E.I - .E EL F L F I E. E :EF .EF : E E. E .E F.F. F, [
L. E' .EF FE! ELEE .. - - FE F :E EE E -FEF F EH - EEE E.
F E.F EEF E L E,
:F ELE EE E 'E EEEF EE LE E ; E FF E l-EC:-FEE E :E E• F FE E" ELEE FE E E E E CE E F FEE : EE
E E, EE E E I F F F1.FE E E E E EE E E E E E E E E E :E E E E "E EL E E E 'IE E E 1 EEE E EE
F .FE EEFEE E E E E E E EF FE - EE FE E E E FE .-E .•EF E E..E IE E• E E :E!E 'HEH !EýE E E Eo. ,E_ E ..E .E ..E E Q E . I E E E• • E E.... E.E .E.E E .. E. E.E ..- EFE:
F E F E EL FE .. F : :E E E E EE E E E E EF E FEE E E-E. - FE [E E E E F E ::' E FE E
FE E EFE E :E E E E E E E E E E F
EEE E FELL [ E E EFE FE E E 'E E - EE E E E E•:E E L EEEL E F EI
L -U _L_- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _._ _EE .- I E E .E E -E E .E I E E .
E E-F EEE EEE EE E7EE EEFE EE : E F F E : E E E E E EFe E E' E FE
FE E E EFEF - FEF E E IFE E E E E F EE
EE .E - FEE
Z EE I E E I E E E E
E- E EFE.F-F!T-F-E HTET E E!L EL E ! E - E E ! E E E ! 1. F E , E TEE- -[E 4 ELEFF
F FEET F E
-- :E E
E 'E ' F -FE E E E E Eý ý E E4EiEE E E;-E; FEEE EL•EE E EE [F FEýE- PýEý ;F F F F F F F EEE E E;EEE -IE-E E _ :E E F FE
E- E
E E I E E E I E E
:E E EE
EEE_ ___: E E E E E E ! : EE EEEE E . - L•EE E•EEE E E• E EE.
EEE EZF E F F F E
:H ET E
• t • E4E .1.• _ _ _ _.. -. .. .[ 1 E ..
-1.• E EE E E EE I • _ E E ý , E E E E , E E E i E E EE E: E
E !E S• .•EEI ý.E E ý- F EE.E~ E E-, ,E .EE:E E E ., eSE H E Ee E-Iz EE e EE E .E _E
-ý-ý E E ý E E ýE 'E ' E E 'E - E . •ý- E E :E • E:EI E "E :E "E ii E E E E I. E E Eý : E[ E ' 'I :
E E E I:E E E E E E EE E E E E"EE E :E Ei "IEEE. _ E E • • E E -E :E E
.. E EEE-E E E E.EE..E.E'EEEE,.. .. .E.............
.E EE E E.EE.EH• E ý E -I E - E ý E H - E I-EE - E E - ! E_ • E: _t. ý ..- EE ! H E.! - -! :E E. I _'. E t E E! E ! - ! E- E E E :
E` E EE=E E "E
;'E! EE EE E E E E.E,
J.•. .,• EýC 1'I ,E, i
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 .100 95 85 80 75 65 60 55 50 •45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electnc Company LLC - ST Max 04/111/2009 14:55:35
SG - B Bobbin as Tested from the Cold Leg
Braidwood AlR14 CCE 77209 241 Tested from 09H through TEC
1 320 Tested from FOI rouh lEC
4 1 Tested from 04H through TEC
0 39 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60o 0000~0 o. 0 0
0 * T. .~to010 S 1 060
55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
-.... 00
.1 * 0 0
0. 0.. .. .. .. .. .. . ...000 0.............................. .00_
* . . . . ... .. . .... .. ...... 00 0.. . .. .. . . ...... .. .a. .ý.... ..
00. .*0 * . . . . . . . ... .00
....00 .. . . . . . . . 00 0.0S00
_0
0 0 0(
-00.-
00.... ...... . . . ...10 . .. . . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . 0
0. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
0. . . . . . . . . . ..0 0 0 *0 .1 .... 10. . . . . . . . . ..0 . 0 . .00
000____0 0
. . . . . . .. . . . . 0 .. . . . .00 . . . . .
-a0
0 . . .
0 0 . . . . . .. . . . .
-0- -10 )I4 / t . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . . . a . . . .. . 0
00~99 . 1 . . . ./ . ._ .99 .99 99. .999 . .. . . . . . . . . ..0
.0.9 9 9 9 4.00I
115•
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25.
20
15
5
99140 135 130 125 120
I - ii I. ý I ". .- - '.. 1 ý I , ..I. v 9 9 9 ti 9 9 ý;9;9 9 91 9 - 1 9 ; 9 9 9 9 9,9 91 9 9 9 99?Pý - 1 9 ?9999 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 Sli91 1 i I . 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 le
599
15 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/1112009 14:55:33
SG - C Bobbin as Tested from the Hot Leg
Braidwood AlR14 CCE 7720E 6061 Tested from TEC through TEH
1 560 Tested from F01 throu'h TEH-
0 12 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55
IF: F EL 4E EE FEEEEEE E FýE EE I
50 45 40 35 30 25 15 5
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45.
40
35
30
25
20
15
L FEIEt L EL L .L L EEL L 4 + _
F EE E EEE E E E:E E E E F E E Eý EEE-Eý E ý E,
1Eý EE EEE IE HE! FEEE E4E E IEE'ý EE EEEE ; EE E ~E EE~ E FFEE EE [ E E E E E E" E EFE EE E E E E QE EEI E E E FE
FEE FE E EFE EE EEE E4 EE E E EEE E F H E E E E E FE a EEE E E [1 E E E E E E :1E EE E E [1E- R E E EE !-[1 EE-1HE
.E • E E E ý E , [1,E E E E E E E E E E[E1E E ý E E E E EE E FE EE E I E E_EE_ E E .EE4EEEEEEE E E E EE EEE EE
E E E•
EE
.E EEE E E EEE E E EE E EE EF E' E L EEE EE E EE E EH E E-EFE tEEEE E E I EEE E EE E FE E E , E E E E EE HEFE E E E FEE EE
FFEE EE:E LEF;r EE, ~rErrErETEr -E -EE EE E EEE E FEF EE FZEr EEE-EEEE E•E •" F-E,.. F__EE EEEE E E EE E E• E E E EýE E EEE E F1EkE EE E E E EEEE Eý EE EE E EIE E EE_EE F EE EE QE .1 F E EE EF E!E E !EEEEE E H E FE E F FE EEE F EE E
_EýEJEýEF E E ; E FEFE 1 E- E E FE EE4EFE E E-EE F1 E E E EEE E EE E E j E E E :EEE
EEE EEE E EE EE EýEEE E E EEE EE EEE EE E E E EEFEEEEEE E E F .E!E E E E E-E EE E E.IE E E FE EE
EE I E E_ E E _EE_ E_ E E EFE E E EE E E EEE F E E___EEEEE E E E E E'E E E E E E FEE EEE E E E E E E E E E E EEE E
EE E-Er E E E ýEE E EEErEr F EE E :E EE E E' :EE
FE EF E E E E E E -FE E E EE EF E E.EE E EE E EE rE -E£E E E EEE E FE FE EEE EFE EFE FEEL E E EE E EE I E F E E E E E EE E E E E E5 EI E EE, E
,EýEý EE E FE Fi E FEFEEEF E F F E .EF .F4 EýE FEFF E'EE' -EE £ E F F FE F F FE F E E
FEFE EýEF•I•E •E FE EFEF . E E FE-EF EE E rEr-F EE F E r'FE EFEE EE- E E, FEEF E FE- F F E, E EE• - EEE _ __
F EE E E-IE- :E E E E EE E E E E E EE E E E EjEjEjE EýEj E E E EE. E E E E E E E E E EE F:E IE E E E E 'EEE EEE i 4 EEEE E E E F E F E E E E EtE EFEEj 'F E L
E.E__. E E E EEI.E EEF EFEFEEEEE E E E E E EE E E, E5EE E FE FF-F EL F- i r. F FL • EEE EEE E E. EE EE E FE E E4 E 4E E- F [ E FItLE [1.I E ...E4
EE F E EF EEF E 'E E EE E E EE E-E . EE Eý FEI L . -EEE E F -F F FE FE -E 'EEr !HEE lFE -
•-EE•E :E•E EFE I:E E. E •E•- .: - tEE EE F EEEEEEE•E1 EEEEEFEEEE FE[F F EE EFE E'EEI F EFE EEFE EFEEE FEEEIEEIEE...• • F ! E .•E4 E..[1.t' E -E-E E E E;EFEE E .Ef E E - E E F E E .E E E ;E E -E E E EF E EE , E E-• E -E
[E•E.EIEE [. FEEFI F.EF FE EE EE- F E-FE F 1 E F 1•[ EE '[ 1EEE EE E F FE E F1 E F :E E F E- E !1F EFE[EEE EFEE EEE E F E EE E E F E E F E FE E . U
FE FEFE . !EEE!EEFF F E FEE FE E F! EEE EýE F FE EF E FE EEEE FEý E__E :EF. EME -E .E" E E F .E E.EFEý ; E E LE E EE .EE EE EE FEE -EE 4 -E FEE E .E.-.- E EFE .E E EE F;E E EEE F E. E E- F .EL FE E
-E! EEE EI E EEEE5E 4 ! E .5E EE F E : E E t E F E E E E EF E E EFEE FE E F E E'EE FE FE . E EEE FEEFFE E F EE E EE E EL E fE E FE E FF FEFE EFE. EFE EFEL E.EE E. EE E.- EE E -F•• -F E EE E EE . E FE E E; EE E E E E E E E FE
__E EE __ý - EýFE FEFE.EEL E H EFEE E EF F-Fý FEFE FEE F E__ F •E E :E E] FEEFr. t 'E FE E EE F EFE F: F EE E FE F E E EEL FE FE FE FEE F• E FEE FE FEE FE FEt t *FEEEE.••.IEE' EEE [ [ E["E "[1E•'[" [" E FFEE "EE____ L E- 4E FE -F FEFHF F FE : E IE :ý F :-F E FE I EE E -
L FEFE EFEI EEEEE EEE I E EEEE E EEEE.FE EE EE E F .E E FLEE Eý E _ EE E FE FE EE E -E E
FE EFF Er . EFEF EE F F E E E E E E E E E E EE E E FE EE E E E E E F E EE- 1 - 4-E EL~ -F-.F. FEFF4EqE EF t FEFE __E EEF E EF FF F F F FE E EFEE 'EE EF
.. 1.E-E E,.EI .: •Eý E ... H .E , .EýEý E ..-Eý E H - IEEE,- E E• •. :E.EEE ;ErE .. ErEH 5ER.[ ... ý E,E,iEýE ý:E,.ý Eý E EE, E-EE• '-1E, IE-E.. :E'• 'E E .• E-E-1 :EE
FE[ [EE L F ý E E•ý E E. E. . .. FE E' E EFEiE E ýEE F E'.ýEE .. ... . . . .. ....F E E'E p4- F . , 'EE jEE-: F :E EFE~ E E.E. FEEF FE -EEE EFE EE EFEF FE FE E E ~ F EFEE F:E EEE E FE[1 EE [1'E EE EE E! EEE EE 'E E E E E FE"E
44ýE ýEE.F E -FF F F~EE EF- EEFF F -F---E E-E F. F EE tE' FE ___EE EwE E E EEI EE E E E E E EF E F E. E-E! '-F-
3F F FEE LE-.-E- 44EL -E!E: E,.E- E E.EELE•E•• • E-E.EL F E.E ,.E I- E- -FE-- E-- -E F rI E .E!L H. NI t E!
.E.. E E E FE FE L E EE IEEF E EEE EE EE E F F F F F EE E EE E FE E E E E E EIE EEEE EfE EFEF E FE E.EE EýE EI •Fý,ý FE E L E i E E E E EEE. E -E E E•-EE E E "EE- E EE F F E E -F EL .E EEEE. , E4 F FE FE E E' E E:E E ' E-E -E-E :E EE. E 'EE
S F• EL E E F E E F E E E F,FýE EFEý F!E FE!E E EFE! :E!E E- E,- ýEFE E -E! EFýE!E , E ,F E EFE F E,-E FEFF . -EE,1: EýF E Q ,4 -- E- ý4 E4-4 -E-ý-Q E:4- E F~- E ý !E4 E 4 - EFFEýE
FEýE EFE FEFE!ýý;ýE EE ý Eý E E'E FFEý EFE E .EFEE EFFýýEE E E ýEE4 F .; E - E : EEý ý Eý E F EEFF EEFF EFFE. FFF•E F E- .F E EF E L E E EEE
-F-- --E F FE -F--E F FL -:.---.. ' •--- .-F--F F -. E E-•••:L -F-r-. .FI I:FLEtFIF - F--- :.l LFEL FF •~ "F t-~ Fr L F F:• . .• . ,n.EE
E!EE E F. FEE E EEE FE- ' E F E ýEE E -FEE E E EFE !EE E EFEE E E-F F :E EE :E E :E E "E E FE EE- F EE-E-E FE[E F F-E!ETE :HEE !EýE
EE"E! EEýE E-
-F--F 'E JEEE FEE FEE; FEFF LEFE FEE EFE- ýEFE E FE F'EIE'E F'F LE' E : Eý EýE;E1 F ;EL E L E F .EE F-Fý FEE FEEEE E E E F LELE' E LEFE E EFEEE EFE EE _ F E FE E_ E' E" F E E "EEI -E E __E" FEEFE E E E E F " EE E F4 E 5E E E E E
EFEE :E, E E F-F- -F-- EEL EE E ,EE F E E EL F EL FE EE E EEE:E'EEEEE 'E E F-f E F E EEH ýEE • •.. E•, E ýEE :-ý :EEH ý Z E ýEý :EH • L .L••• .EE HE, :-E-EEE HE E[• E.E-E, - iE-E :[E-E E E_ E.;E E:E- EE- ýEýEý ýEýE;E' ;E.- EE :E_ ý -E .E. ýEý E- E :EýE.I [1EýE• ý ;-E E E E :EE E' E F.E E 1
"j]" EE" EFEF E E E FE E E F F E FE E E E 1 E E .E E EE E F -.E -EE F FE• F. E FE
F *E EEEE F EE FE EFEýIEFEF FE E E 'EE F EE EE EF::EF FET'E E !EEE FE 'ý EF -E17 - FE FE EE FSE FE F EE E FE, 'FE EF F'IýEE FEE FEEFE.: 4 F F F-- EL :EI EE ,:EE.E :Ej------- -E-------[-E E :F E L E E E 4 - E I E E E ""
L:E LE FEEF FE EL F E E Q [E E E F E E E EE E E E [E
EF E ý wFE E EE EýEF !ETF EýFL -FEE LEýE E EEL -- F-i-F--F- FEFF F E FEF!E F :EE , F--EE E E-E F: ýEFE FEE
Eý ý ý-E E'ý ý ýý ;E;[{ Eý E•EýE. ýEýE•I ýE E E;E ~~E ; E rE r - ~ E [r~ E E:1 E .1 E;• •:E• E E • • E~ E E . • E E E E •E E
-4 p-- LE•E- E4' EU ,.E• E F [F" '" E -EE~ F-F- FEE FE,.i . ~uL . LE -F -F • E F. E.--• F ELF FrE FE. . FL•- • FEEL ,LL... •.- F[F -4 -hE FL E 4L F- F[,
FE F EE E EE E E E E E E EE F E E :E E 'EE F E E E E E E E E L E E E 'E E :E E EE EF F F FEFF EFE E ý E FF L E 'E.E EEE EEE EEEE F E E EEI F E E E E E F! E E E EE E• F• EIE :E E E EEHEFEIE
EE 'E, E, .E EE i E F -- EFE !H4 E E FLE • E -E 'E EL E'E E,.EI- E . E . E E1 ,- .E "EE,£ ' E .. 1 : ,. .-ErE ' E E E :Er"'E• ý ,-E'E :E`.E,.* E'E E :E E• :,E E E' -: . -E Et E i..1 :E..E E
E E E~4 E EEE-E E EEý[E EE IE -E'E ' E : EE E[ E ; E F: E E E E F EL E E FF: EtE'Ep E EEEE E Et E -t E.E E E E :E-E :E E JE E ,E F. -- E -E E E____' 4-F iI-i-i v f
E •.• ', E'E E'E'I •. .. . E. r E. E rE E, E 'Eý E-, E-E.E.E , . E 7EE EI .E E. E.E j.E.'E :-'E E. E-E E. :E'E 'E-[, EEý L.. _ _ , E E ý.E E.E 'E
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
55.1.:Ii•:
135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10140 5
Westinghouse Electic Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:30:25
SG - C Bobbin as Tested from the Cold Leg
Braidwood AIR14 CCE 77209.482 Tested from 09H through TEC
1 78 Tested from F01 throug h TEC
a 12 Plugged Tube
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
.65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
251
20
15
10
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75.-70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 50" 00'O'0'0 S00' 0,,
00100 00000
*TO LO
0_ ._ ._ _ . . . . . . . .0 ._ .
0 . . - i . . . . . . . . . . . . .
___~.100 00 0~~i 1 1 :~ _
0 . . . . 7 .~ ._._0_1_
~i~e~HH..<:'...... . . ..... ......... . . . . . .
- .~V : 7 . ... . .... .. ~ . . .: V Ik i .7 : .: ._
-01 . . .H
_o~ 7 7 .7
0 .... 70
0 . . .1 0I00.
999 999 .1 .999~~~~ ~~ 999 99 -~ 9 999 999 99 9 9 99 9 9 9 99 - - f 9 -9 9 999 999 999 999 999 999 -
§j 9 9
9 0~ 9. . .9 9 .4 .~ 00 .99
.~9 . .99 . . . .-- s- .- 9 9 9 9'90 ..9 99. 9
9 99: 0 9 9 ~ 19 9 ~ 1 ~ 9 9 ~ ~ 919 9~ o ~ 1 9 9 9 19~999~~9 99
099 99 9 9 00 99~~ ~ I 1 ~ 9 9
9 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ T 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 .9 9 9 19 99 9 99:0 9 199 9 99999999 9
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Wesfinghouse Elecndc Company LLC - ST Max 04111/2009 14:30:23
SG - D Bobbin as Tested from the Hot Leg
Braidwood AIR14 CCE 7720E 6069 Tested from TEC through TEH
S555 Tes ed f-om FOI t u&T
0 8 Tested from F10 - TEH
a 1 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 : 20 115 : 10 105 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55
FS .EIEE E EýEE E EýE E E E
50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
EEýEL~~E EFE F'"ý
___.,.. .. ...___ .,"E E , , ,,. LE. .. . .. .rc-,.c--L,. r -c -- -,"'. " ___ _ __'EE -i : i i
_ - E E FE 'E E E EE E E EL EE E EL E E F E •FE! E E E F E E E -E'EEEE E.-EE EEEEIF FE.I EEE E E FEF EE I ~L L LF FE E L F LE FL L[ .. : r EE. EEI EEIEEE FE E LE *F EEE !EEF LEE E EF E EE F __
JSLE E E. E EEE L E ý EE • E•I ES _E_
SE E • F_ LE E FLEE FEFE EFEE.I FELE EFE FLEE FEEL E FEE.
__ LEL EE LE-EE L E FEEL Fýý F FLE E EF ýEFE FELL Eý.-EL iE~ ___
FE E EE F LE F FE FLýEE E _____ FLEE E.El L: Cl EFEEE FE E:E E E E E E F F F
SE EE FL E EEL LEEE : EE. EE. .E LE.EE .EEE.FE FE :E ;, F .E.L ____
E' E.: . : : E E I ; I EýE:IE Eý E E E L Eý ý E" :EýEý ýE.L E "E IE EE: "E. -Eý|L LE;ý E _I .ý ' EýEI • . . _ _ _I .: E E :E E :Eý-
EEE E E E F[ FI.E..
__ FEFL FIN F F F FS LESE FIEEL EEL FLE EES FEE S EFE LSES:E FESES F FS E E
.- E FE. .E EI E E E.I T . .E * .:EE E E L LE • E ELE : E E :E E E E EE EL F L FL E.E; L FE FE FELL E E FE EEE : F FL E FE L E E F
EE ESE-E FLE F E F E F E E E E E E FE E F S EE FEEEL F EEI EEEL F 4E E E E ES EE, ET E E5 F SE
EL FL E ýE LEýE ;ELL FL EFELL FEEL FEEL FLEýE FýEELFLEE FE;EL ýEFFE: FL E ýE E ýEL FL E ýE ELEý F F 1 EL EFFE FELL EL F FLEE EE
_ ELL SEEL E!ESI"SFEL 'SF"ELFLE FEESLE! F ELL L EE. :SE EE F ELL F EEL FEL 'E!ESSEFLE'E ELF 'F E E E E E ____E
E :E E ' ' EýE; E E: ý .I 'E E E E E' ' E.. E.E.I . EýE :ýE . ýE E 'E ; :E. E EEE
E E E E 'E E ,F E. F E E E F E FE E,.E . E E LEEl" E LE E EE E E I E .E -E E E. EI E E.E. E E 'E E E: t E E .UES• :SH 'E E I : SESEi E
FEE E 'E E E ELL .EFE E LE E E EL E E £ E EEl E EL F.L F.EE EEL FL F F F F EE L F ELL EE -E E:E F F E L F
EE• : .E E EEE ] EE :
- 7 F~~ E E. • E•. .~ EE FLEE E LE EL 5 f r -- -IE-LE FELL FLEEEEL FELL FELL FI E E E E EF FLELEEL FLEE S L E FLEE EL F EL FLE FLEE F EE EELEE.. -- L E-E" ' SF F L:S E F E ` -___ E, l_ _ LSE-EES E E E. _ 'E E IS S E _ . E I. _ :E E I.E .ES ..S 5Eýý. ýS S -E E! SES EtE 'S S : E :!ESE :ES E I ES E EFE SE E E ES - S E E SESEE
E'E ELE EL EL L E FE EEEEL E E E ELFLEE EELFE E FLEE LEIE E EE
E.ESLE! F E E L E E:EE. , t E- E L * ES E [ E- E EE EFE [ :E [ EE FLEE E. E E : EEE LEE E FE L FEE FEE EE
E E F E E EE 'E E E * E E FE L FL E E E FLEE E EEEE_.E"
F L FEEEEL E E E E E E E E EELL E E EE
E E -E E E E E E E E E EE E E E :EL E E E E LEE EE E F FL EEF L E E .EFE L LL FL. E .E ,-FEE .L F L LE,- E E .EEL,.-
LF EFE FEýEL F EEE E E" ELEE E " E E E E ELE -E E E E. -_ S E , E S ElE5 EE E ESE, EFEE. IE F E , F S E S ESE
. L.E.EE L FEE EEL FEL ELE EE L LFEL ELL :'ýE;E ELE E • E; : LE E FLE E EE F Eý E EEL EL E FL F EE FEL F E; E L E L F L
:EE
-F -ELE L F-- LEE FLEE E EL E EL FEL ELL• • EEE • - •E E I ,
F s FLEEEI.E E F E E E E E EEE AE E EEEE E.E
E,' S I SE !E EF SE E -F--FS F -EE E SS E. F-EI",EE EEEE ,EE ES ESFE E F L -EE 'EF FELL LEE FEEL EE F F F E EL F ELL E F-E.F
-E' F 'E' E . FEE EFIF .- FT F LE EE Eý;E E LL E LEF:;;'ýý ELE EII EIE FEýELEE EIEL FL EE ELFIELF E F. LE LE F Eý E E . IFE E FE E EE' E-E-__
F FE E E.E F E E E- F FL EE :-EE EL F F E EE EE E
SESE ErE FE IE .E LýES E EI S E HSE SE[ L [ : EF, ES L ES [. : E-E:. [ EL ! L E • ' S L E EF.•: E.• , -I 'r""S"EEE E SE5 E E,:P • E 'E •iF .ES E5ESES'SE E
ý.Eý.EJ. ELEE E U E EEEF EE E E E E E E Eý ELEEE - E.E-I :E LEEEEE L.. EL E E E E E E E E E E E E EEEE E E E -E -E -E-E -- • E EL LE LEEE FEE E EL E E EE
-F-F -Eý F-F- IES
EE FEE F FLEE E FE• E• • E - E
L. E I EE.E
"ý: EE " E E E ' •E E ' E E E E E Eý ý E•:E ' E E • E E E E [ ý E SEE_ E : E E E: E E E- EI :E* E I E "E E E I"E E !E E t."E E : E E • E E E E: : EE
F._ S -E E F. F E E EE F E E E E m_ E E :S E:':SE ES -:E E, . t F SE:.E E , EE E E E , E ' ELL E EL E E E,E_ E . E ESE_ _ S_ E -E E , E E E E E LE"E E • SE EE . E E.-E E, E .E -F . E E
"-E;..E .Eý ;E..E .E E E LEE-.E.. E..E- E..E E E t E ; E- - Eý E ;E;EE .ý_ý .LE ýý ý E E :EE Eý E ..EýE :E E EE E E:E E I E 'E -
EE :E E E E E E E E E E FEE EE E .. _ E E,[.',EE E EEEE E E, • EE E t E !E ! oESE ESES S F E ESI! E EoE ES E E :EoE E E E E F
EE F -. ES• E N SEEEEE E E. E_ E ._ H E E ,. E .. E. EL t. .. c •.EEE; ; E.- .E,.EE•I E. E EýE :EE;RE,;;.E ý E,.E,.;:..E EE, EV E :EE r.EE ý E E E E
:r~ • r r r'•E E EE E E E. t E. E E E E- E. i ES'E: E S
"ESE S Si, k E :ESE SE , "- - .- ý- ES S S E E S
ýE .E - E . E ;E ý -_E- E "E• ;EýE E Eý ý ý ' E E:ý E EEE :E EEE EE. E E EE E EEE•E : :EEE. E•E- :E E - E :E .E E E EEEE- FEEI EEEE EEEE E. E E -
:E.E E E E E E. E t • .. t L- :.E E E.. E,. ' . .• .. E E'E'E'E.. E•E E... _ • E o. L E E- :E E :E E, :E . • .E E-
.E -E E E E E[ [ E E F E LE :E"E" ý E [ [ L L E'E - Eý E •I [ E E E:I. . # ; . Lý LE E E" Eý' EE E EE EE EEE EE EEE1
E:;. .EEE EE S E.SE. ýESEEE SE'EEEE:E- EEE E E•E.I E : ESE• E-ES E SE 1 -E! E= = E.E E -E- .E.L L L - ES "E E -S S E... FESE' :E EEE, -E Eý-F S S E E ..ES .E E E E E
E..E.. .E•E .E• Eý• E'E..I .. E.EEEE...E..IEE E E.E..E E' E E
ET E :E E E E :E E E E E E E E E -~ E E E E E : E E. .E-E E E I.E E• • E E• E E E E-E E E EE E ' E .E L
[ E ;.E E: SESE EE I , EE : E.ý E E ES .~ .• _ .'E _E I : L L L k L L L L L L E E !E S S , E E" E E E E,.E E E-
SE •. _.E E!E :EE H EI -E:EE EE: E E E :EE S S LESE,ý E E E E LE :E E :E E E Q LEV E; E ES ýEE EE E E: E SEI E E :E E- -E E E EE S S S
L LE [ý ý E E- E :[ E ;EýE.[ L L E qEý L E L EýEý - IEý •EýEý 'E El •E [•E E I L; E E [ ýý E Eý• jE; E E' E E
E , E E E E.;E E E E - :j;: E E EE E ýEE IE E E E E- E• . • _ r c • r _•:• ~ E E • • E E • _ ,E E•SS ESE
:E"E-
E".- -E E - E- .Eý E E E E E: . : E E E tE -. ' E c E E 'E E'-E 'EE. I" E L L L:. E' E 'E E' :E "E' E E, 1: E L E t E' 'cE EE- EE E'EE - E ' E'E'E'• EE' E'
.1:J.E
•
E1E. 0_ 1
115
110l
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
.55
50
45
-40
35
30
25
20
15
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
55
140) 135 .130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 , 70 65 60" 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15
WesSnghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/1112009 14:32:15
SG - D Bobbin as Tested from the Cold LegBraidwood A1R14 CCE 7720
9 563 Tested from 09H through TEC
a 1 Plugged Tube
140 135 125 120 115 110 105 100 95. 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35- 30 25 20 15 101 000000o 010 I0
~ 0 000 . .ý.O.Oý .K" A
5
ý00115
110
105
100
95
90
.85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
20
15
10
5.
-,ý0 000
000 .0
.0
1 . . .0
00. . 0
0 . . .
. . . .. .... . . . . . . . . .00 ~~~. . . . . ... . . . .... .. . . ... . .. . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . 0
__0 ??0 _
0.
0 . . . . 0
00~~~~. - --- n
0 _ _
00.- .... 00
0'0_ _ 0 . . . .
0c)~~~.. .. .. .. ..... . . . . .......:, *.-*. .. .. .. .. .. .... 0. . . . . .. . . .
0
o .00..0
0. .I0 . . 1
0 . .1
99C 9 9O9.9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 99 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 99 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9~9 9 9 9- C- -40- 0-- - ~ ~ ~ ~ 9 ¾ 9 ~ ~ ~ 9 - q- c 9 ~ ~ ~ ~ 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
599 I 9q6SVqVYt169!;qqq;9 9 9 99 p999 9999 zo99v 9F99 9 9
9 9 999 9 9919! 39 9 9 99140, 135 130 125 120 115
. 2 9 9 1 9 9 9 99 99999 !9
9 9-991r 9110.-105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 5V 45 40 135 30 25-20 15-10 5
Westmgihoýs Ele~fin Comlpany [[C - ST Ma.x 0411112009 14:32:12
Attachment B.2
As-tested +PointTM Special Interest Inspection MapsA1R14
SG - A Hot Leg +PT Special Interest Testing
Braidwood AIR14 CCE 77201 16 Tested at TSH -2/+4" for
Bounding of PreviouslyPlugged for PLP Wear -
Appendix 12.8 SG-A HL Rev 1
D 2 Tested for DNT/DNG >= 2 Voltsin Hot Leg
F 1 Tested for DFI
T 3 Tested for Foreign ObjectWear from Prior Inspection -DA Table 4.3.2
0 27 Plugged Tube
S1 Tested for DS1
140 135 130 125 120 115
115
i10
.10 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 .45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
f o... '00001. .•o • oI o • . I ., . . , . jo. . •5
1~ ~ ~ ~~~ý _ L0~ .. W:1I
105
100
95
000T 0
1- .1. .00
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
0-.T .:-..- .--. '.' o 0o 1 1 1 . . . . . . . o° 0o,. T..:.1-. .::1 *.1. ..11 •: :• • •: :• • •: :• • • : : : .:., . :•. : : : °o~ ~~ .. . ". . . . " '. ' ." " . . . ." "- -. '. " ".. . . .'. . .... 00.'. ". . . ." " 1
o. o ............ .... .... .. . ... .... .... .... .... ..
0.0
0..0
00 . . . 001""" - " -" " " 0-"I " T' " " " - " " ' T ' " "- - - , - - : - " °
0-. . . . . I . . . . . .0
. . . . .. . . . . .... 00
00~~~~~~~~ . .0 ..... 0)
-0c). . . 0
0 . . . . . . 0.
00* 0.0
0 . .. 0.000 I I4 I I 4 I , 0
o .-0 . - -. . - - . . . .-.-.. * ,..*-. ,. . ..*; .-. - ., - ..:.-.- - . . .-.- -.-.. . .-.- . -. . . - Oo . ..0 .o°°:':::~~ ~~ .': ".' .': ".: .''': .': " .: .': .::°° .:: .': ".' .': ".::: : ": ''•!i~ ::::i~ iii i~ i~ i~i!ii~ ii! !iili:! iii:i~ ~i~ : ::i ii:i~i iii iii iii ii!!ii i!! iiil!:ii: 0°... .•lI •I• • .•I • • • •• .I .i. . ..I .• ....• .... .... ..° •..- I... ...• ...• .....• ..•.
.o' - .. _ . .. . . ' ." . . . . .' ,. . .: . . . . . . .' , . . . . . . . . ' " , , . . " . , . o . . ' ° o . • ° .. .-. -. .-. -
... . . . ~. . . . . .. . .. . .. . . :. .:.: : : : ., . : : :.,:o::: : : : : : : : : ::. ° ° . .. . . I. " .. 0 0
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5514o 0 o13 1 015 0 0 1o5 1o o oo11 o05 1 0 00090 8 05 08 0 0 o0 75 7 0 65 00 55 50 45 460* 35360o * 25 0 15 1 0 I
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company [[C - ST Max 04/1112009 14:5428
SG - A Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
.---- .---- .------------- +----+---- ---- +----+ --- +- ----.. . . .-- +- ----+- +- +-÷... -. ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+---- +- - -+----+ .---. +----+----+.----+-- -+---- -------4-+. + ----.+ --...--+ - +- -+ ...... +.
8 11 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI8 11 3.01 181 ONG P1 TSH 10.37 F01 TEH .560 ZBALL 107 HI8 11 NDF 2 TSH 10.37 TSH 01H .560 NPSNM 133 HI
2007/10/01 8 11 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 8 CI2007/10/01 8 11 2.45 179 ONG P1 TSH 10.17 09C TEH .540 SBALL 105 HI
1.2007/10/01 8 11 NDF 2 TSH 10.17 TSH 01H .560 ZPSNM 135 HI
99 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI99 58 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 99 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 73 HI
101 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI101 58 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 101 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI
98 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL i5 HI98 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 98 59 NOD .TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI
100 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI100 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 100 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI
102 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI102 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 102 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI
97 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI97 60 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 97 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
99 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI99 60 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 99 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
96 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI96 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 96 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 73 HI
98 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI98 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 98 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 73 HI
97 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL. 5 HI97 62 NOD TSH- TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007110/01 97 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
99 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI
99 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI2007/10/01 99 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
98 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI98 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 98 63 NOD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 69 HI
100 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
100 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI2007110/01 100 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
102 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3HI102 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 102 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
99 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
1 99 64 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI2007/10/01 99 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
101 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI101 64 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 101 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
...---- +---+---+---+---+----+---- .+ -+ --....-- +- +.......--. ------- +---- -- +-- ----
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI---- .----.---- --- +----- - - --- ÷--+----+" ------ +----+-- -.--- -+..----÷
ST Max
SG - A Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
-------- +--- .------- ---- + -+--- -+------+-----+--- +--- +----------+- -+------------- +
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+------------------+----- +-----+------+-----+--- +----+-- - +--- +-- -+------+------------+
50 77 2.42 182 DNT P1 05H .73 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI50 77 NDF 2 05H .73 05H 05H .560 NPSNM 133 HI
2007/10/01 50 77 2.47 176 DNT P1 05H .82 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 49 HI2007/10/01 50 77 NDF 2 05H .82 05H 05H .560 ZPSNM 135 HI
96 107 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 117 HI96 107 .16 88 VOL P4 TSH .11 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI96 107 .16 280 PCT 16 2 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 96 107 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI2007/10/01 96 107 .13 107 VOL P4 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI2007/10/01 96 107 .15 281 PCT 15 2 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI
98 107 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 117 HI98 107 .14 78 VOL P4 TSH .09 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI98 107 .14 83 PCT 15 2 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 98 107 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI2007/10/01 98 107 .13 85 VOL P4 TSH .10 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI2007/10/01 98 107 .15 80 PCT 15 2 TSH .10 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI
75 108 .13 0 PCT 4 P2 07H . -1.69 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 117 HI75 108 .14 76 VOL P4 07H 71.82 07H 07H .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 75 108 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
97 108 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 125 HI97 108 15' 272 PCT 15 2 TSH .17 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI97 108 .15 83 VOL P4 TSH .19 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 97 108 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI2007/10/01 97 108 .12 95 VOL P4 TSH .16 TSH TSH .560, ZPSNM 133 HI2007/10/01 97 108 .13. 269 PCT 14 2 TSH .16 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI1
2 109 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 18 CI2 109 .15 156 DFS 1 07H 33.52 F01 TEH .560 ZBALL 95 HI2 109 NDF 2 07H. 33.52 07H 08H .560 NPSNM 131 HI
1 2007/10/01 2 109 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 10 CI1 2007/10/01 2 109. NDD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 115 HI
----- +----+----- - ------. +--------------+--------- ----------- +-+-- + --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+.......+----+----.----+.. ---+----.----+----+----+. -+..------ +----+----+ -...... +- +-+ ---
Tubes: 23 Records: 842 ST Max
SG - A Cold Leg +PT Special Interest TestsBraidwood AIR14 CCE 7720
0 23 Tested at TSH -2/+4" forFOSAR Findings - Appendix12.8 SG A CL Rev 0
1 29 Tested at TSH -2/+4" forBounding of PreviouslyPlugged for PLP Wear -
Appendix 12.8 SG A CL Rev 1
S 2 Tested for DS
m 27 Plugged Tube
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
2n
15
10
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 .80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5I o o° . . . . .. . - - .0 .I00
___00c000 0'0. -~O - -- ~ - ---- -ITI" 0 . ". .. ' 0
. . . .. . 00o° .'." .. .. ... 0 0.... . •__ • T - ' 0070 00
__ _0
.017. . . . . . .001'0
00~ .I . -0; ::I:::iti: °ý00 00 _
-~-00
±0•. .. . ...'..." . °. °° ° . i..° . . °o
0.." . ..''.V. • K . ..'.. 0
00 0 0 0 000 000
0 : : : : .:.: . : : . )--" - - - , " -. . . .
0 ..: t' : .: : : :t - ' .: .: .. . .... . .. .. . ..0 ...• ." ... .'. .". . . .C1 .'' t . ". .. . . .t : .: ' ...' ..•0 • . ," ." .. . . . " . " . • . .•• ... ..' " ."" . .. .: ': . "" . '. . '. ' ..- . ..-- . . .
O T -. 00 0 . . . .. . . ..0,o~'°' .t ... '.'.. ., ... . ••.. . ." " :'. . . . " : t 'C . ., ....: !C .T 'T ' ,
0 .° ° ° o .• . . .. 0.. .
" . • . . ' . ." t .. . . o0o . .' : .: . .:-. ..: ' .... . ...I. . .:J : T . . : t : : ". '. ' ' ' T ' T ' ' '•. " f.0
-- -- - - -I" -- "" --.. . . . . ..' . " " "o 0: ..... .... ... .. . ::: .. . ..o
.. . ." .: . t. . ." ..: . ." " ..: 6
•~ .'.' .. .'' ' ' . . . . .. . .0oo-( :: : : : .~~oo ': : : :,:• . . . . " ' :':': °o:: :, ' .° . ,0 °°0 . ° °0•°o° ooooo00,oo oooo OO, 000 00.-0oi~o+oo ,oooo
115
110
105
100
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04011/2009 14:54:25
5
SG - A Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:49
---- + --- + ---- +- - - --------- + -- -+ - - - - - - -....... + . . .- -- + ---- + ---- + - -+ -- -- - ----
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+----.----.-------.--------+----..-----...---.-- - -- -- +.----.+ --- +--------.- + ----
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
114114114
116116116
113113113
115115115
112112112
114114114
116116116
111111111
113113113
555555
555555
565656
565656
575757
575757
575757
2.62
2.52
0
0
CONNDDCON
P4
P4
F02
F02
15.89
15.46
55.96 TECTSC
55.62 TEC
55.34 TECTSC
55.26 TEC
TEHTSCTEH
TEHTSCTEH
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
2.72 .0 CONNOD
2.77 0 CON
NODNOD
.65 77 MBM
P4 F03 11.23
P4 F03 11.96
6 01H 18.70
5858,
58
585858
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
115 58115 58115 58
117 58117 58117 58
116 59116 59116 59
118 71118 71118 71
111 76111 76111 76
109 86109 86109 86
111 86111 86111 86
113 86113.* 86113 86
108 87108 87108 87
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC. TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560. SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLO1C 01C .560 NPSNMTEC TEH.. .560 SBALL
07C 07C .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH. .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560. SBALL
TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
13 H38 C75 H
13 H38 C75 H
15 H38 C71 H
13 H38 C71 H
13 H38 C77 H
13 HI38 Cl77 HI
.I.ý13 HI38 CI77 HI
9 H38 C73 H
9 H38 C73 H
9 H38' C73 H
9 H38 C71 H
17 H38 C71 H
9 H38 C45 H
38 CI59 HI39 HI
38 CI115 HI
33 HI
38 CI115 HI
33 HI38 C1
59 HI33 HI
38 Cl109 HI
35 HI
.15 0 PCT
.25 88 VOLNOD
NDF.17 147 DSS
NOD
6 P2 01CP4 01C
2 07CP1 07C
.9187
- .42-. 42
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
.- - - - + ---- + - --- + .............---- .- ----------- + - -+ - -+ - --.. .- -- - -+ - --- + - --- + - +- - -+ - +- -+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT , PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.........+----+----. ----+.. ---.----. ---- +----+----.----+. . ..--- +-- . -- + - --- +----+-.. +. - .... +-....-- +
1 ST Max
SG - A Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:49
+.....----. ---- +----.+ +--- +-- -+-- -+- +-------+... ...... ...------.--.- +-.----+- +-+.....+-....+-+
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.----. ----.----.---- +-- -+---------+--------+ ---- --+ ----. ---+--- -- ------ +
110 87 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 Cl110 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 109 HI
2007/10/01 110 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
112 87 NOD TSC TSC* .560 NPSNM 38 Cl112 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 109 HI
2007/10/01 112 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
107 88 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI107 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 113 HI
2007/10/01 107 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI109 88 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI
109 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 113 HII 2007/10/01 109 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
108 89 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI108 89 2.48 60 MBM 6 07H 23.95 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 115 HI
2007/10/01 108 89 2.45 60 MBM 6 07H 24.87 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 33 HII
110 89 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 Cl110. 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 115 HI
2007/10/01 110 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 33 HI
109 90 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI109 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 109 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HII I
111 90 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI111 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 113 HI
2007/10/01 111 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HII
110 91 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 Cl110 91 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL . 113 HI
2007/10/01 110 91 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
43 132 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI43 .132 NOD. TEC TEH .560 TBALL 85 HI
2007/10/01 43 132 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
45 132 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI45 132 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 85 HI
1 2007/10/01 45 132 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI47 132 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 C
47 132 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 85 HI2007/10/01 47 132 NOD TEC TEH ,560 ZBALL 3 HIII
40 133 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI40 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HI
2007/10/01 40 133 NDD TEC TEH 1.560 ZBALL 3 HI
42 133 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI42 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HI
2007/10/01 42 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HII44 133 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI44 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HI
1 2007/10/01 44 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
46 133 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI46 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL. 89 HI
2007110101 46 133 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
48 133 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI48 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HI
2007/10/01 48 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
50 133 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI50 133 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HI
----- +-- ---- +----+-- +------------+---------+--------------+------- +----+--- -+-------------+-------+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGTENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+------------+---- + -- +-----+---- ----- +--------+------+-----+- ------ +-- ---- +----+-------------+-------+
2 ST Max
SG - A Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:49
- - - -. -- - ÷- - - - - ---- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---+ --- - . . ÷ . - - - - - . ------- -- -- --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI........---- +----. ----... ---.---------.-------------...-- + -+- ------- -- +.--.. - + -- ÷ .... -- ÷
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
50 133
393939
414141
434343
474747
494949
515151
383838
404040
484848
134134134
134134134
134134134
134134134
134134134
134134134
135135135
135135135
135135135
NOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 3 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 C1TEC TEH .560 ZBALL .91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560. ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC. TSC .560 NPSNM 38 ClTEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 C1TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM -38 CITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM *38 CI.TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 1 HI
ITSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HITEC TEH .560 SBALL. 23 HI
* * ITSC TSC .560 NPSNM- 38 CITEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HITEC TEH .560 SBALL 23 HI
* ITSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HITEC TEH .560 SBALL 21 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HITEC TEH .560 SBALL 21 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HITEC TEH .560 SBALL 21 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CITEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HITEC TEH .560 SBALL 23 HI
TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 38 CI
50 13550 13550 135
525252,
393939
414141
434343
494949
.515151,
404040
135135135
136136136
136136136
136136136
136136136
136136136
137137137
NDDNODNDD
NDDNDD
.65 62 MBM
NODNODNOD
6 06C 34.58
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NOD42 137+- - -------- +- - -- ------- +---+- -- +- --- + -- -+ --- +- - ----- +-- -- - - - ---
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+-------. .--------------..--. . m..------- - - -" - +----+- --- +- +-- --- - ---
3 ST Max
SG - A Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:49
÷- --- -- - - ---------- ---- - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - -- - ---
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+- - - - - +- - - --- - ----- --- - - - - - -- -- - +- --------- + -- -- - - ---
1 42 137 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 89 HII 2007/10/01 42 137 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 23 HI
÷---- .----+----+--------+----+----+--------+--- - ----- -+.. ÷ ------- +---.. --- - -÷ ... .- ÷
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI- -- - -------- + - - - ---- +------+.. .------ ...----- --..- - - --.---'-- - ---------- ------- - ---
Tubes: 54 Records: 1624 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg +PT Special Interest Tests
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 77200 132 Tested at TSH -2/+4" for
FOSAR Findings - Appendix12.8 SG B HL Rev 0
1 25 Tested at TSH -2/+4" forBounding of Confirmed DTICall - Appendix 12.8 SG B HLRev 1
2 42 Tested at TSH -2/+4:' forBound ng of PreviousiyPlugged for PLP WearAppendix 12.8 SG B HL Rev 2
T 1. Tested for DTI
a 39 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
000%0°° 00 0. oO•O:~~ ~~ 0 o00,0,0... 00.10.0''.
0 ..Ao0 1 "030 130 .0 1 1 1 " 1 9 " 8 00 70 5 5 4 4 3 3 2 2 1 le 5
• 0 0 0 0 . . .. . 0 . .. . . . -.0 10I00.....00 0 •. •K ... . . 00 .o_
....... 0 0 00................o
00 - 0. ei2& 7 _
0 o ' ' . . .. .^ ,_ .. . I. t . ; . . .I .
01 1
. .. .. U - • . .. . .. .' =T.... . 1 ?-_ _o... ..... ••..............I..o. "•""• . z..-.....................o°. _
o. .. . . . . -. . . .o ~.. . . .. . . ...... ....... }... .. ° ........ I"" °•..•.•.ooo.. . . . .. . . ............... l............ "" •o0 .... 0z'o
0.0S~0S- 0
0-
. . .. " ". . .' ." ". . .'." ". . .' ." ". ' . ." "- . .' ." ". '. . ." ". . -'. " ".'. . .' . .O o O? : : : : : .. :.. .: : • • . ... . . . : . . .: : . . . .: : . .-:.:• • # °o. '. " ".'.. .. '. " ". '. . '. " ". '. . " . .' ." " .' . .'." " .' . .'." " .' ."" . '. .' ." . . . ". .
0..................... ................
0O......... ...........................-....- I.......................}.0?~
0.. .........-.... ..-....- ... .. .. .-. ... .. .I : -:' .' :' • .. OoO . ..... . . ........... .. . .:: .O o .. ... .:: : : . . ,. . , ... • -• ,0"o i! --- ..i ..! .! ...! .~ .i .~t ...t .. . o.
..... ........ .... .......... , . . . ... . ..... . .. . ... . ...0
... . . .... . .. .. . ... ... . ..... ... .. .. .. ...... .... .... .... .. ... ....0
0o... .•...............................•..... .. ° . .....,.a...........................,................. ......- . ......•.... ... .. ,. ... .. o
0 .T - -~ ~ . ..... .. ... . .... . .... - .
0 ., .. 0
.;~~ ~; . o0o~; "" . .. " ... OoO. .o.' .OoO;.. .OoO2 O
0 0 0
0. .O 000 .0
0. .. .. . .000 .00 0
t 130OT: ~ ~ ~ ~ . ... ... .. 0
0 0
0.0
(0.* .1
0 00
0 ... .. ..,. . ....( 000
o~0 Oo a o o 0 0 CQ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 0411112009 14:55:47
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
---- '--------+...---. -------------------- -- -. --- ---... +---- -------.-. ----- ----
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.-.-.- .- .- .---------- -- --------------------- ---- -- "- ----- - - -- - -- ---- - -- - -
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
636363
62626262
646464
61616161
63636363
60606060
62626262
59595959
61616161
676767
585858
606060
666666
686868
595959
616161
1616.16
17171717
171717
18181818
18181818
19191919
19191919
20202020
20202020
202020
212121
212121
212121
212121
222222
222222
NODNDDNOD
NDDNDDNODNOD
NDONODNOD
NODNODNODNOD
NODNODNODNDD
NODNODNODNOD
NODNODNODNOD
NDDNODNODNOD
NDDNDDNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNDDNDD
NODNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
11 HI125 HI
9 HI
5 HI28 Cl
125 HI9 HI
5 HI125 HI
9 HI
5 HI28 CI
125 HI11 H
5 H28 C
125 H11 HI
HI7 HI
28 Cl125. HI
11 H
7 H28 C
125 H11 H
7 H28 C
125 H11 HI
7 HI28 C
125 H11 H
7 H125 H
11 HI
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HITSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HITSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125. HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HITSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HITSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125. HITEC- TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HITSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HITEC TEH .560, ZBALL 9 HI
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HITSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HITEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
+-- + -- - -- +- -- + -- + -------------------- --- - - - - - - +- --- +- - - +- -- -
I INSPDATE ROW COL. VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI--- - + .----+-------+ ---- .---- +----+----. ----. .--- - -+-- +.- ------ ----------- ---- - -----.-
ST Max.
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
+.....----+----.----.. ..--- + ....---- ---- + --------- +- -- +-÷- ÷ •---+--- + -...... + -------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI........ ---- +----.----.+... ---. ---... -+..--- +---- ---- +--+- -- --.. .+.--..+----+- + -......--
65 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI65 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 65 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
67 22' NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI67 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 67 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI
60 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI60 23 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10101 60 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI
62 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI62 23 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 62 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI
64 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI64 23 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 64 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI
66 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI66 23 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM, 125 H1
1 2007/10/01 66 23 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI
61 24 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI61 24 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 61 24 NOD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 11 HI
63 24 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI- 63 24 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 63 24 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI
65 24 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI65 24 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 65 24 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 11 HI
88 27 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI88 27 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 88 27 NOD TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
87 28 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI87 28 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 87 28 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
1 89 28 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI89 28 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
I 2007110101 89 28 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
84 29 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI84 29 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007110/01 84 29 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
86 29 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI86 29 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 86 29 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HIII
88 29 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI88 29 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007110101 88 29 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
83 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI83 30 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007110/01 83 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
85 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI85 30 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 85 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
87 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI1 87 30 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI1 2007/10/01 87 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
.....------------.. ----------- ----.... +----.. ... ...--- +----.-.. .--- +--- 7 --......-- ..-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+........----+----.----.+ .--- +----.--- +-+-------+----+--- -- -+----+..----+- ---+-----+--- ------
2 ýST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
.....---- .----+----..---. ----.---------------- --- ----÷-÷------..----.+ - - +---....... ÷.
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN.LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL Ll....--------------- +. .----.----.--------.------ -++--- ---.----. +- - + -÷ ......-- +
89 30 1.84 116 DTI P6 TSH .25 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI89 30 1.29. 63 SVI P4 TSH .25 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI89 30 1.67 62 PCT 73 P1 TSH .26 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119. HI89 30 1.53 58 PID P4 TSH .25 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
1 2007/10/01 89 30 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
84 31 NOD TEC *TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI84 31 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 84 31 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
86 31 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI86 31 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 86 31 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
88, 31 NOD TEC: TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI88 31 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 88 31 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
90 31 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI90 31 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 90 .31 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
92 31 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI92 31 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 92 31 1.11 67 MBM 6 O1H 24.24 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI2007/10/01 92 31 1.09 66 MBM 6 01H 29.72 TEC TEH, .560 ZBALL 15 HI
83 32 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI83 32 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 83 32 NOD. TEC TEH' .560 ZBALL 15 HII.
85 32 NOD TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI85 32 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 85 32 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HII . I
87 32 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI87 32 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 87 32 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI89 32 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI
89 32 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI2007/10/01 89 32 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
91 32 NOD TEC. TEH .560. ZBALL 21 HI91 32 NOD TSH TSH ..560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 91 32 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
93 32 NOD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL. 21 HI93 32 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 93 32 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HIII
84 33 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 Hi84 33 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
1 2007/10/01 84 33 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HII I
86 33 NOD TEC TEH .560. TBALL 37 HI86 33 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 86 33 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
88 33 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI88 .33 NOD TSH TSH .. 560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 88 33 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HII
90 33 NOD TEC. TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI90 33 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 90 33 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HII
85 34 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI85 34 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 85 34 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI....----. +------+------+------------------+------+----..----+----------- +-- -+--------+--- +-------+----- ......
I INSPDATE ROW COL + VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOON INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI....---- +---. +----+---+----+----+---- -------- + ---- -------.----..+ -...- -+-+ - + -+......
3 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest' +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
...---- +- --------- +-----+---4 -+----+--- +--+--+- --- +-------+.-.+. .+ -- 4 .... -- 4
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI...----.. +----.-------•--+--+......+ --.----.----.---- + ........--- +---. +-.--- ... + .... + ----- +-....+.......+- +
87 34 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI87 34 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 87 34 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
89 34 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 23 HI89 34 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 89 34 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI
94 43 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI94 43 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 94 43 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
96 43 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI96 43 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 96 43 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
I HI198 43 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI
98 43 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI2007/10/01 98. 43 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
93 44 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL .5 HI93 44 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 93 44 NOD TEC TEH .560. ZBALL 15 HI
95 44 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL .5 HI95 44 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM. 121 HI
2007/10/01 95 44 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
97 44 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI97 44 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 97 44 .55 74 MBM 6 02C 21.25 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
99 44 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI99 44 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 99 44 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI
92 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI92 45 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 92 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
94 45 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI94 45 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 94 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
96 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI96 45 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
1 2007/10/01 96 45 NOD .TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
98 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI98 45 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 98 45 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
I 100 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI100 45 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 100 45 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
37 46 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI37 46 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 37 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 29 HI
39 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI39 46 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 39 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 29 HI
1 93 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HI93 46 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 93 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
95 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HI95 46 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
+ -..... + .-+-- - - ---- --- - --- +- -+-- - -+- --- + -- -- + -- -+ - -+-- -- "
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE . CAL LI+. .----. ---- +----..+.. -- -+-------------------- ---- --....- +--+ ----.+ -.. +--+-----.--
. 4 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
+---- + ++----+ .... 4-+ .... -.... + .... +- + --- 4---- +--+ .... +- ÷- +-- .... -- ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI---- +-- -+-- -+........---+----+----+---. +----+------ -+--- +-- -+...-----+-.....+-------. .-- +
2007/10/01 95 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
97 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HI97 46 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 97 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
99 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI99 46 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 99 46 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
36 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI36 47 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 36 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI
38 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI38 47 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 38 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI
40 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI40 47 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 40 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI94 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI
94 47 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI2007/10/01 94 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
96 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI96 47 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 96 47 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
98 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI98 47 :22 78 VOL P4 TSH .02 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI98 47 .16 86 PCT 21 P1 TSH .03 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 98 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HII 2007110101 98 47 .25 78 PCT 22 P1 TSH -. 01 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 98 47 .10 94 VOL 0 P4 TSH .01 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
35 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 33 HI35 48 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 35 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI
1 37 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 33 HI.1 37 48 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10101 37 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI
39 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 33 HI39 48 NOD TSH TSH .560" NPSNM 121 HI
I 2007/10/01 39 48 NOD TEC TEH* .560 ZBALL 31 HII I
41 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 33 HI41 48 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 41 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI
99 48 NDD TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI99 48 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 99 48 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
32 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI32 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 32 49 NOD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 33 HI
34 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55• HI34 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 34 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HII . I
36 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI36 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 36 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
38 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI38 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
---- .-------- ..----------- +----+----------- ---------------.. -------. ------- ---
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER' CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI---- +-----------+-----------.----.----+.. -------..--- ---- +--•.- -.-........-- ÷
5 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
÷---- --+...------- .---- +....----..-------.. .-------.---. .---- +----÷ .... +-. - +---.....--÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+- ---- -- --..------.----.----+----.............----+---+---.---+ .... ÷....÷ ... .----+----- - -
1 2007/10/01 38 49 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
40 49 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI40 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 40 49 NDD TEC TEN .560 ZBALL 33 HI
98 49 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HI98 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 98 49 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
100 49 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HI100 49 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 100 49 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19. HI
31 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI31 50 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
I 2007/10/01 31 50 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL .33 HI
33 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI33 50 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 33 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
35 50 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI35 50 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 35 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
37 50 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI37 50 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 37 50 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
39 50 NDO TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI39 50 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 H[
2007/10/01 39 50 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
97 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HJ
97 50 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI.1 2007/10/01 97 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
99 50 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 29 HI99 50 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 99 50 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
30 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 H30 51 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 30 51 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
32 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI32 51 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 32 51 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI2007/10/01 32 51 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
34 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI34 51 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 34 51 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI1 2007/10/01 34 51 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
36 51 NOD -TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HN36 51 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 36 51 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI2007/10/01 36 51 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
38 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI38 51 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 38 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
98 51 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI98 51 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 98 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
100 51 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI100 51 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
+---------------------------------+----+----+---+----+----+----+----+----+---+---+----+---------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI----------------- ---------------------------------- ----- -------- -------------
6 .. ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection. Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
-- - - -+-+----+-+ ---- ------- + --- -- - -- - - - -- - - - - - - - - - 7- - - -- - - -...- ------ - -- -- - -
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+---- .----+.----+--- 4--------.----+'-- ---+--- ------- ---- +- 4.---.---+ - - +- "...--÷
1 2007/10/01 100 51 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
31 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI31 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 31 52 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI2007/10/01 31 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
33 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI33 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 33 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI2007/10/01 33 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
35 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI35 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 35 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI2007/10/01 35 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127. HI
I37 52 NOD' TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI37 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 37 52. NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
99 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI99 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 . NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 99 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
I. . I101 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI101 52 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 101 52 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
I 32 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL. 55 HI32 53 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 32 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
34 53. NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL. 55 HI34 53 NOD TSH TSH .560. NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 34 53 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI~I36 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI36 53 NOD TSH TSH. .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 36 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 33 HI
100 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL' 47 HI
I - 100 53 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HII 2007/10/01 100 53 NDO TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
I .' I'1 102 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
102 53 NOD TSH TSH. .560 NPSNM 125 HI1 2007/10/01 102 53 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL ,37 HI
I I'104 53 NOD TEC .TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI104 53 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 104 53 .55 66 .MBM 6 01H 5.58 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI2007/10/01 104 53 .91 61 MBM 6 02H 16.41 TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
101 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI101 54 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 101. 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
103 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
.103 54 -NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI2007/10/01 103 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
105 54 NDD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 . C105 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI105 54 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 105 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
110 81 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI110 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI110 81 NOD TSH TSH .560' NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 110 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI--- -+----+----+ ------- +--------+----+----+----- +-.....---.--4---+----+- + - +-4. --- 4.
I 'INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-....---- .----.----. ---------- +-----'----+-.---+ .---- ... -....+-- . - -- + ----.----+ -.- +-+ - "- - "
7 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
+ ...... +...+------+----+---+--- +- -- +----+---+-.... +-- -- -+ --- +----+-- + -. +. --
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI....... ..---- . .---- +----. .---+----+--- +----------+-- -+ ------ +----+----+--- ... +- + ---
103 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI103 82 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10101 103 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
105 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI105 82 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 105 .82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
107 82 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI107 82 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI107 82 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 107 82 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
109 82 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI109 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI109 82 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 109 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI111 82 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI
111 82 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 111 82 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
102 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI102 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 102 83 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
I I104 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI104 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 104 83 NOD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 57 HI
106 83 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI106 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 106 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
108 83 NOD TEC TEH .. 560 TBALL 77 HI108 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM. 121 HI
2007/10/01 108 83 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HII.
110 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI110 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
I 2007/10/01 110 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
112 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI
112 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI2007/10/01 112 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
101 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI101 84 NOD TSH TSH .560. NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 101 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
103 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI103 84 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 103 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
105 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI105 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 105 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
107 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI
107 84 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI2007/10/01 107 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
109 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI
109 84 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI2007/10/01 109 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
111 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI111 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 111 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
+.....----.----...+---+--- +----+----+--- +---.---+.... +....... - - --- +--- +- + ----- +--------+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+.---- .+---'- ----. ---.--+- +..----+------------+-•- ------------- +----- -.... +----+---
8 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 , CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
....-------- +----.+.-- ---- - --- +....+----÷ -- --- +----+- - -- "--.. .. +.------ .... +- - - --- ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHNLOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+ --------- +---....-.......+...--------+- ----- ----- +----+ .... ...... ...... +----- - +......--÷
113 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI113 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 113 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HII
102 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI102 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 102 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
104 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL. 77 HI
104 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 104 85 NDD. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
106 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI
106 .85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 106 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
108 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI108 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 .108 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
110 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI110 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 110 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
112 85 NOD TEC -TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI112 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 112 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
114 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI114 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 114 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
85 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI
85 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121. HI
2007/10/01 85 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 85. 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
87 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI87 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 87 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
103 86 NDDO TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI103 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 Hi
I 2007/10/01 103 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
105 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 .TBALL 79 HI105 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 105 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
107 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI
107 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 107 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
109 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI109 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 109 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
I . I.11 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI111 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 111 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
113 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI113 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 113 86 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
115 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI115 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 115 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
117 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI117 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
........--------.---- + ....------- +----+----+----+----.. +--- --........ +...----+---- + - + ...... + ...... +--+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-- ------------- ---------------------- +----- -------------- -+ -.-------- -------
9 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braldwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
+..----.+----+ ---- ÷--- +---------------------- -- --÷-----÷.. ..... ÷ "" ' -- - -.--... -.... ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+ . . . . .-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---÷ .. .- - - -- - --+ - - -+.- - -+.- - . . . .- - --" - - --+-+ -" -- . . . . . . " "
1 2007/10/01 117 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HII I
84 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI84 87 NOD TSH TSH. .560 NPSNM 121 HI.
2007/10/01 84 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI2007/10/01 84 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
I86 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI86 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 86 87 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
88 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI88 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10401 88 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
106 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI106 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
1,2007/10/01 106 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
108 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI.108 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
1 2007/10/01 108 87 . NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HII110 87 .24 163 FS 1 03H 13.50 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI
2110 87 .19 158 DFS 1 03H 13.87 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI
110 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HII 2007/10/01 110 87 .69 78 MBM 6 03H 13.41 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HII I
112 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI1 112 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 112 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
114 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI114 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 114 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
116 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI116 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 116 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
83 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI83 88 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 83 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
85 88 NOD TEC TEH 560. TBALL 77 HI85 88 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 85 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL. 65 HI
87 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI87 88 NOD TSH TSH .. 560 NPSNM 119 HI
I 2007/10/01 87 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
89 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI89 88 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 89 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
107 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI107 88 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 107 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65' HI
109 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI109 88 NOD TSH TSH .560 .NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 109 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
111 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI111 88 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 111 88 NOD TEC .TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HII I
113 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI113 88 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
I 2007/10/01 113 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI.----.----- +. - ----- ----+----+----+----+------ ------ +---- -- +- +----+---------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI----------------------------------- ----- - ----------- ----------- -L ------
10 .. STI'Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
.----.---- +----.+.---.----.----..---- -------- --- +--------+----+- + - -• -- -- ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+--------------+ ----+--.--+----+ ----+-----+-----+-----+------+ ---+ --- + ---- ------+ - ----------
115 88 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI115 88 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10101 115 88 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HII
84 89 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI84 89. NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 84 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
86 89 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI86 89 NOD TSH *TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007110/01 86 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
88 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI88 89 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 88 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
108 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI108 89 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 108 89 .53 65 MBM 6 F08 12.28. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
110 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI110 89 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 110.: 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HII
112 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI112 89 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HL
1 2007/10/01 112 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HII
114 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI114 89 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 114 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI~II 116 89 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI
116. 89 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI2007/10/01 116 89 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
I85 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI85 90 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 85 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
87 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI87 90 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 . 87 90 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
109 90 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI109 90 NOD TSH . TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 109 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
111 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI111 90 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
1 2007/10/01 111 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
113 90 NDD TEC TEH .560. TBALL 79 HI113 90 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 113 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI115 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI
115 90 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI2007/10/01 115 90 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
1 136 NOD F01 TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI1 136 NOD F0l TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI
I1 136 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 H12007/10/01 1 136 NDD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007/10/01 1 136 NOD Fl TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
2 137 NOD F01 TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI2 137 NOD FO TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI2 137 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 2 137 NDDO Fl1 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI+....----+----.----. ---.-------- ------------ + .. ---... . .+-- --.--......... --.----.... .+. .-
I. INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1I INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-------- +----- ---. --- +.---- +- ------- +---+-------.+- --- +--- -+-......---- +- -----
I1 STM
11 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braldwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:28
+- ---------- - - - - -- --------------------- + --- - - - - -........ - .+ ---- + .. - - . .--- + - -- - -- --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1. INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+- --- ---- +----+--- ----------+...-------------..-- -------------------- ------- --------+- ----
1 2007/10/01 2 137 NDD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
1 138 NDD FOl TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI1 138 NOD FO1 TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI1 138 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 1 138 NDD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007/10/01 1 138 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
3 138 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI3 138 NOD FOl TEH .560 TBALL 111 HI3 138 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 3 138 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI
2007/10/01 3 138 NDD Fl0 TEH .540 SBALL 125 HI
2 139 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI2 139 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 111 HI2 139 NOD TSH TSH. .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 2 139 NOD Fl1 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007/10/01 2 139 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
4 139 NOD FO0 TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI
4 139 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 111 HI4 139 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 4 139 NOD Fl1 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007110101 4 139 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 125 HI
1 140 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 C11 140 NOD FO0 TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI1 140 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 1 140 NOD FlO TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007/10/01 1 140 NOD Fl TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
3 140 NDD FO0 TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI3 140 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 111 HI3 140 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 3 140 NOD Fl0 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI
2007/10/01 3 140 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
5 140 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26. CI
5 140 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 111 HI5 140 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
1 2007/10/01 5 140 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI1 2007/10/01 5 140 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
1 2 141 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI2 141 NOD FO1 TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI2 141 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 Hl
2007/10101 2 141 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007/10/01 2 141 NOD FIO TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
4 141 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI
4 141 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 111 HI4 141 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007110101 4 141 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI1 2007/10/01 4 141 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
1 142 NOD' 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI
1 1 142 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI1 142 NOD TSH TSH .560. NPSNM 119 HI
.1 2007/10/01 1 142 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 "C
2007/10/01 1 142 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
3 142 NOD 09H TEC .540 . SBALL 26 C13 142 NOD F01 TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI3 142 NDD TSH .TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
2007/10/01 3 142 NOD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 CI2007/10/01 3 142 NOD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI
2 143 NOD 09H TEC .540 SBALL 26 CI
2 143 NOD FO1 TEH .560 TBALL 109 HI2 143 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI
- ---- +----------------------------+-...+- -- ---- +--- ----- ---. +-"-.- +-+ --------- ---
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-------- +-------+-f----+-- -÷------+-- - --- +--+-- --- + ---- +-- +- +-- ------
12 ST Max
SG - B Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 0411112009 08:17:28
÷ . ... ... . -+- ÷ ------ - -- - +----- +---- .---- .----- . .. ÷ . .. ÷ ... .. .----- - ---- ÷ . .÷.. . .÷----- -. . --... --. .... ÷.
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI------ - --. ------ ----- -- - ---- -- --.------ -------------------------------------- - -------------------- - ------------
I 2007/10/01 2 143 NDD F10 TEC .560 ZBALL 6 ClI 2007/10/01 2 143 NDD F10 TEH .540 SBALL 123 HI---------- +----+-.. . - ---.---. . ----. - -----÷- .- +----+- --- -------- ---------- --------------------- --- -------- --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE' CAL LI+-. ... ... .------+.. ÷ .... ÷ .... -.. . ... . .. ------ -- -. . .---- + .----- --.. . - - -+.. .. ÷.- ---. . .----- +- - ---------------
Tubes: 200 Records: 65513 ST Max
SG - B Cold Leg +PT Special Interest Tests
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 77200 42 Tested at TSH -2/+4" for
FOSAR Findings - Appendix12.8 SG B CL Rev 0
a 39 Plugged Tube
115
110
105
100
95
9i
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5cD0~0 00
0.o. 0 0~o~f~010000.0.1.OO 00- _- 1 -. 00• " " ..... .0-0( oIS. -0 00 0o 00
_" -"1 _ "-_;.._ . .
00~~~~ -** -:--4-.:. 0
0 000... , , : ::,_:_.:-00 0
0..~.% ,...
0 0•...............
0. -. . - - --. ...
.0...
i2,. . . . . . . :..0 " '.. "..... .... ,
0.00.
00 . . " . . . . . ,._ . ... . . . . . . .. '." d
0 . . . . . ._00
":0 .1 . '. I . '. " .'. .f I" "I '.0 -. . .. .. .• .-- ... .000.00.
0 0 1 00 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
oO Go . .-. . .". . : ..
oo . .. .. . .. .... ..... .;: .. .. .o o . . .. .... . , .;( 0
0 0 o. . ..
0.t . . . , . . . ' 1 ' ' . .. .
{o...~~~ . . . . .. . . .. . ".. . . ;. ." ".
00 loo . . .. . .. . .. .. . .. 13o-° do: ; . .- :.--: : • : :. .+. . ..T ~~. . .- -- . .. • . do •
000
0°-. .: . .. : : : - ... - . ... , .00. .O~ o ...... . . .. ... ....0 0' .. . . . . .O 0
115
.110
105
100
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
Westinghouse Electdc Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:55:42
5
SG - B Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:47
4." " 4.---- ---- " ----- 4---.---------.----.-----+"-+. ." . ----+ - -- +------+-- ---------- + - - +-4.....4--- "
I INSPDATE- ROW COL VOLTS DEG. IND PER CHN LOCN INCHi INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-------- +----+...----+--- + -----+ -- 4- ----- ----- -- +--- +----4 ....----- -- *--.... ---- 4
I2007110101
I 2007/10/01
I2007/1001
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
1 2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
I2007/10/01
I2007/10/01
595959
616161
585858
606060
62626262
575757
595959
61616161
63636363
585858
60606060
62626262
59595959
61616161
106106106
108108108
161616
161616
171717
171717
17171717
181818
181818
18181818
18181818
191919
19191919
19191919
20202020
20202020
535353
535353
NODNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NDDNOD,NOD
NODNODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNDDNODNOD
NDDNDDNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNODNODNOD
NODNODNODNDD
NODNODNODNOD
NODNODNODNDD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL.
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560. ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL.TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNM'TEC TEH .560 ZBALL
1128
9
1128
9
528
9
528
9
5.28
1259
528.11
52811
528
12511
528
12511
72811
728
12511
728
125111
728
12511
728
12511
284737
284737
HICIHI
HCH
HICH
HICH
HICHH
HICIHI
HICIHI
HICIHIHI
HCHH
HCH
HCIHH
HCHHI
HICIHIHI
HICIHIHI
CIHIHI
CIHIHI
TECTSCTEC
TEHTSCTEH
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .. 560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH• TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL-TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TSC TSC .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
+.. .----.----++-- -+. .---+----+----.-----..+-------- ---- - - +------+- - +-+-+..... ....- +...... .+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+---------- ----+ ---- +----+---+----+----+----+---+---+----+--------+------------+- --
1 ST Max
SG - B Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:47
... +----- -+.----+..---.+'----+----+----.----+----+ ---'+.........+-- -+ ----+----+-------- --E- "'+"+I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENOT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI
. . . . ..-- - - +-----... ---... --.. ... .. ----- - -..--.---- .---- .----. . . .----+ - - - ..-- -. ----. ----.- +÷- ---- ....... +~.÷
105 54 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI105 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI105 54 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 105 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
107 54 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI107 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
2007/10/01 107 54 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
109 54 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI109 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
I 2007/10/01 109 54 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
104 55 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 C1104 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
I 2007/10101 104 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
106 55 NOD TSC TSC .560. NPSNM 28 CI106 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
1 2007/10/01 106 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
108 55 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI108 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
I 2007/10/01 108 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI1 110 55 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI
110 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI1 2007/10/01 110 55 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HII. I.
105 56 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI105 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 HI
I 2007/10/01 105 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HIII107 56 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI107 56 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 HI
I 2007/10/01 107 56 .68 76 MBM 6 08H 5.18 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
109 56 NOD TSC TSC ..560 NPSNM 28 CI109 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 HI
I 2007/10/01 109 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
106 57 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI106 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
2007/10/01 106 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
108 57 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28. CI108 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
2007/10/01 108 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
107 78 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI107 78 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI
1 2007/10/01 107 78 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
109 78 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 C)109 78 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI
1 2007/10/01 109 78 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
106 79 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM .28 CI106 79 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI
1 2007/10/01 106 79 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 51 HI
108 79 NDD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI108 79 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI
1 2007/10/01 108 79 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 51 HI
110 79 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CJ110 79 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61' HI
1 2007/10/01 110 79 NOD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 51 HI
105 80 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI1 105 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI+------+------+-----+----+-----+-----+-- ----------------------- --.--------- + - ----------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI÷ ........... ÷ .... ----+÷-- - +---- +---- .----.----.---- + ÷ .- - -.. + ......... ....---- ---. ..----- +-- ---------------
2 ST Max
SG - B Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AMR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:47
+ ------------.---.---------- + --- 4 -+---..----+..---+. ---+.+'----•- --- +----- ------ +---------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.........+----+----.----+ ---+. ---- +-- + --- +--+----+ ... +.....---+- -+- - --- +- ---- + - +- - -- +
2007/10/01 105 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
107 80 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI107 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI
2007/10/01 107 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
109 80 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI109 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI
2007/10/01 109 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 . ZBALL 57 HI
111 80 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI111 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI
2007/10/01 111 80 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
106 81 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI106 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI
2007/10/01 106 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
108 81 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI108 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL . 63 HI
2007/10/01 108 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HII . I
I 110 81 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI110 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI110 81 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 110 81 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
107 82 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI107 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI107 82 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 107 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
109 82 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 28 CI109 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI109 82 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 121 HI
2007/10/01 109 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI--- -+----- ---- +--- +--+....---- .----+----+---+- ---- - +--*-------------+-- -+-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.. ..---- +--.+--- +- - -+-- -+ -- -+------+-+--+...." --- ------ +÷----+- -+- -+-......-+--+
Tubes: 42 Records: 1373 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg +PT Special Interest TestsBraidwoodA1R14 CCE 7720
0 155 Tested at TSH -2/+4" forFOSAR Findings - Appendix12 8 SG C HL Rev 0
1 17 Tested at TSH -2/+4 forBounding of Newly ReportedPLP Calls - Appendix 12.8 SGC HL Rev 1
2 17 Tested at TSH .21-+4 forBound ng of Preioos yPuged for PLP WeorAp;ei'dv× 12.8 Re C HI Ro
a 12 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
oo0 o •..•I . .•non , .- . o o00 0 ' 0 00 0 0 I
o. . 0 0 0, . . . . .. ..t . t t { t t .. .. . . . .oo0 0
000-
0
0 ...... ... .... . . . ... .. . .......•.•• .....
__. . . . .... ....... .. ... •.. .... ........... 1.....00
.10
0 _ - - - - - -. 0- -
ooO..0 . ... . .. . . . . `3020
. . . . . . .. .. . ..0
1)000
0 0
.0
00.1.. .. ....... .... .... o0 '.. .... . . . . .• . . . 0:-0 . ....... . .0 0 ____ ___
,0i~ i i ... .o o oi i .i i i i .oo ~ o o .. . . . ..o o . o.o .
0
0.. 0
.. . 0 .~ .0.. . .0 . . . . .' 0
0. .0 * ._ _ _ . . . . .
0 00
0. . .0 00 00 0 0 00 .OO~~ .0 0 0 0 000_O 1 . 0
0 0 0 0 00 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 00 .. )
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
55
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
WestJngho-se Electric Company LLC - ST Max 0411112009 14:30:37
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braldwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
---- +--------- ---- ---- +----+----+----+----+-- -+--- +-- -+----+--+------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI......------------ ------ +-- ---- +-----..+.--------+ ..... ÷- --- +......---+---..... -+-÷- -
19 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI19 16 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 19 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93 HI
21 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI21 16 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf
2007/10/01 21 16 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93 HI
23 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI23 16 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123. HI
2007/10/01 23 16 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
25 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI25 16 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 25 16 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
27 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 97 Hf27 16 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf
2007/10/01 27 16 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
18 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI18 17 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 18 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HI
I . I20 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 Hf20 17 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 20 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HI
22 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI22 17 NODD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 22 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
24 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 Hf24 17 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 24 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 Hf
26 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI26 17 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 26 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
28 17 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 97 Hf28 17 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 28 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
72 17 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 97 HI72 17 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 72 17 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
17 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI17 18 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 17 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 Hf
19 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL .83 Hf19 18 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf
2007/10/01 19 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HI
21 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI21 18 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 21 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 Hf
23 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 Hf23 18 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 Hf
2007/10/01 23 18 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 Hf
25 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI25 18 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 25 18 NDD TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 97 Hf
27 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 Hf.27 18 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 27 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI+-"--- ---- +-------+-÷--- -+--..+----+----"---------------+ ... - ----- .- +--. ...-- +
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+ ---------------.. ---- -- + ... +.. ..----.---- +.--..... --- -- + ....--- +---------------÷
! ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braldwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
.....---- +----+----+--....-- +.----+----.----+----+----....+.........------ +----+-- 4--+- +-+ -+ .... -- +
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.. .----+----..------- -------- +-•--+----+ ---- -- - -+----.-... +---- --. +- -- +
29 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI29 18 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 29 18 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
71 18 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI71 18 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 71 18 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
73 18 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI73 18 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 73 18 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
18 19. NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI18 .19 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 18 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93 HI
20 19 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI20 19 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 20. 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93 HI
22 19 NOD TEC TEH ;560 TBALL 81 HI22 19 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 22 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93 HI
24 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI24 19 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 24 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
26 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI26 19 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 26 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
28 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI28 19 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 28 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HIII30 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI30 19 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 30 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI"" I
70 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI70 19 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
I 2007/10/01 70 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 85 HII I
72 19 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI72 19 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 72 19 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 85 HII
19 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI19 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM' 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 19 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93. HI
21 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI21 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 21 20 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 93 HI
23 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI23 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM . 125 HI
2007/10/01 23. 20 NOD TEC .TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
25 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 81 HI25 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 25 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HII
27 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI27 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 27 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HII
29 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93. HI29 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
....-------- --- +---- --------- +----+----+----+--- +--------- '--.--+-......+...-...+......----
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-..---- +----.----+..---.+----+-- -+.----+----+------ -+--- +---- ---- +- +- + --- ... --- +
2 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
..... .------------ ------------ ------------ + ------ +......---------.-+ - +- +- --- ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI•- +--t---- -- + ------- + ----.---- + . . ..----+ - . . . ...----+--.-..---.----.---- .. ...--+- - +-
2007/10/01 29 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
69 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 97, HI69 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 69 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 85 HI
71 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 97 HI71 20 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 71 20 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 85 HI
20 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI20 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 20 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HI
22 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI22 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 22 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HI
24 21 NOD TEC TEH* .560 TBALL 83 HI24 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 24 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91- HII26. 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 83 HI
26 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI1.2007/10/01 26 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HI
II28 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI28 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 28 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 91 HII
70 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI70 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
1 2007/10/01 70 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HII I
72 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI72 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 72 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HII
74 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI74 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 74 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
76 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 93 HI76 21 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 76 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
78 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 97 HI78 21 NOD TSH TSH ;560 NPSNM 129 HI
I 2007/10/01 78 21 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
71 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI71 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/i0/01 71 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
73 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI73 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 73 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
75 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 Hi75 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 75, 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
77 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI77 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129. HI
2007/10/01 77 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 83 HI
79 22 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 99 HI79 22 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI
2007/10/01 79 22 NOD TEC TEH .560. ZBALL 83 HI
28 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI• ---- ---- ÷----+ ------- +----------- ---------- +---------------- +---+---- ---
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGTENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI...------------- +---- +-- --- + .... .... ÷-- .. ......... ........--- +- . - -- ------------+-----
3 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
+ ......... .----.----.---- _--- .---- _----+-----.. .. +..-----+....---.---.----.---- - --- ...................
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 . INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+ --------------+- --- +--- -+--- ---- +- ----- +------- +--- -+------ +---+- ----- +
28 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HII 2007/10/01 28 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
II30 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI30 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
I 2007/10/01 30 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
32 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI32 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 32 59 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
34 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 79 HI34 59 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 34 59 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
27 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI27 60 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
1 2007/10/01 27 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
29 .60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI29 60 NOD. TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
1 2007/10/01 29 60 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL. 61 HI
31 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI31 60 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10101 31 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
33 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI33 60 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 33 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
35 60 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI35 60 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 35 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL, 61 HI26 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 H
26 61 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI2007/10/01 26 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
28 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI28 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
1 2007/10/01 28 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
30 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI30 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 30 61 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 H.I
32 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI32 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 32 61 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
34 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI.34 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 34 61 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
36 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI36 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 36 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
78 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI78 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 78 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
80 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI80 61 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125. HI
2007/10/01 80 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HII
82 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI82 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 82 61 NOD. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
I I...... .....--- ...--- --- -- - -- -.... - -- + -- --+ - - --+ - -+ . .+---- - --- ---- --- ---- --- - ---- - -- •- --- ---- .---- --- --- --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT POIA PTYPE CAL ' LI....---- +---. +----+--- +-- -+ -------------------.. + -- +-.--+----+- +-- + .... +--+
4 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
........ +----+--------.+.... ---. ----.----.----+----.----- -+- -- +--- +- -- +- +.---.....+--+-
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI--- - -- +--+.............+.-------+----.--- +-,--+...----+.........+---.---.... .+---+---+- .... '+- +......+--+
114 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI114 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 114 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
.~I.
116 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI116 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 116 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
118 61 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI118 61 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 118 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
25 62 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI25 62 NOD TSH TSH .560. NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 25 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
27 62 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI27 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 27 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
29 62 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI29 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 29 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
31 62 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI31 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM i23 HI
2007/10/01 31 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
33 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI33 62 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 33 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI.
35 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI35 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 35 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI.
77 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI77 62 NOD TSH TSH '.560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 77 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
79 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI79 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 79 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI1 81 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI
81 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI2007/10/01 81 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
I83 62 .NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI83 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 83 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HII113 62 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI113 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 113 62 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
115 62 3.18 0 CON P4 F06 5.50 54.12 TEC TEH. .560 TBALL 75 .HI115 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 115 62 2.81 "0 CON P4 F06 5.50 52.95 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HII . . I
117 62 2.50 0 CON P4 F06 9.63 70.43 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI117 62 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 117 62 2.13 0 CON P4 F06 9.64 49.61 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
24 63 NDD TEC TEH . .560 TBALL 69 HI24 63 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 24 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HIII
26 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI26 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
I 2007/10/01 26 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI+. .----.---- +----..+ . +----+------------- - --+-..+ . ..+ .... + .... +----...----+-. - +- ÷ ...... +--+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-- ---------- + -- -+------...---.....--.------.----.... 4 - ------------ -+--------- -----+- -- .-+--------- - +
5 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
....---- .---. +- ----- +÷--+ .... + .... .... .... 4"--------+-- ---+- +---------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI. .----.---- +----..+ --- +----------------+ ----+.....------.+----.----+-......+-.-- + ...... -- +
28' 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI28 63 6.12 82 PLP 11 TSH .33 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 28 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
30 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI30 63 .06 110 SVI P4 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI30 63 .10 287 PCT 9 2 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI30 63 7.62 83 PLP 11 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI30 63 .05 89 PID P4 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 HI
2007/10/01 30 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
32 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI32 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 32 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 Hi
34 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI34 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 34 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HII76 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI76 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
I 2007/10/01 76 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HII I
78 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI78 63 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 78 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI• I
80 63 .31 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 -1.51 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI80 63 6.53 70 PLP 11 TSH .20 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 80 63 .25 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 -1.31 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
82 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI82 63 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 82 63 . NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
84 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 71 HI84 63 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 84 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HII
1 112 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI1 112 63 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI1 2007/10/01 112 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HII ~II1 114 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
114 63 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI2007/10/01 114 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
I116 63 4.51 0 CON P4' F05 3.54 49.27. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI
- 116 63 NOD TSH TSH' .560 ZPSNM 125 HI2007/10/01 116 63 4.29 0, CON P4 F05 3.55 56.58 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
118 63 4.00 0 CON P4 F04 12.15 140.42, TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI118 63 NDD * TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
I 2007/10/01 118 63 3.61 0 CON P4 F04 12.14 108.06 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
23 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI23 64 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 23 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
25 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI25 64 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 25 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
27 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI27 64 7.83 73 PLP 11 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 27 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI~I29 64 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI29 64 11.32 74 PLP 11 TSH. .10 JTSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
1 2007/10/01 29 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI....... +-- - --- +-------++----+'-----+--- -+ "-÷- -- +--- -+- - -- + --- -
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI---- -- +-------+ -.-- +.....----+-----+---------+------+--------- -+--------------------------+-'---+-. - +---- ---
6 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
.....---- +----+---. +-- -- -- -- +--- -+..---- +..+.----.--.+ ---..... ----++-- -+.. ----- ..... + ..... + .....+---+-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI........---- +----. + -------+ .----.--.--.----.----.---- -+ -- -- ..- ------.----... ........- +- -- -----
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/012007/10/012007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
I 2007/10/012007/10/01
I2007/10/01
I2007/10/01
I 2007/10/01
313131
333333
7575757575
777777
797979
818181
838383
858585
111111111
113113113
115115115
117117117
119119119
24242424
262626
282828
303030
646464
646464
6464646464.
646464
646464
646464
646464
646464
646464
646464
646464
646464
646464
65656565
656565
656565
656565
NDDNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NDDNODRBDNODNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
NDONODNOD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TECTSHTECTECTEC
TEHTSHTEHTEHTEH
.560
.560
.560
.560
.560
ZBALLZPSNMZBALLZBALLZBALL
TEC. TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
67 HI125 HI55 HI
67 HI125 H55 H
67 H125 H
55 H59 H69 H
67 H125 H
59 H
67 H123 H59 H
69 H125 H59 HI
73 HI123 HI59 HI
73 H123 H59 H
73 H125 HI55 HI
73 H125 HI55 HI
73 HI125 HI
55 HIHI73 H
125 HI55 HI
73 HI125 HI55 HI
67 HI127 HI51 HI57 HI
67 HI125 H57 HI
67 H125 H57 H
67 H125 H57 H
TEC TEH .560TSH TSH .560TEC TEH .560
TBALLZPSNMZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
4.43 , 0 CONNOD
4.09 0 CON
P4 F05
P4 F@5
P4 F05
P4 F05.
5.29 61.47
5.27 58.36
3.31 56.33
3.30 58.81
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
.560 TBALL
.560 ZPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560- TBALL
.560 ZPSNM
.560 ZBALL
3.75
5.79
0
0
CONNDDCON
NODNDDNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TECTSHTEC
TEH .560TSH .560TEH .560
ZBALLZPSNMZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
+- -- -+ ------- ----- -- - -- -+ - +- +- - -- + - -- - + -. - ---- + ---- + - +-- -- - --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+----+.... ----. ---- +-- -+-- -+ + ---- +---- -+-- --- +- -- +...+----- +- +-+.....+-....--
7 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
+........----+----+----. + .--- +----+-+-------+---+...+-...--.----....+...... .+..+ - +- + -- +
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+........----+----.----+.. --- .---- +-+------+..----+----..+........---..--. ----.+ +----+- °' .... +- +-
32 65 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI32 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 32 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
76 65 .15 0 PCT 2 P2 F05 .71 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI76. 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 76 65 .12 0 PCT 4 P2 F05 .81 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
78 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI78 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 78 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
80 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI80 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
1 2007/10/01 80 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
1 82 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI82 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM .123 HI
2007/10/01 82 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
84 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI84 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNN 123 HI
2007/10/01 84 65 NOD TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
112 65 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI112 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
12007/10/01 112 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
114 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI114 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007110101 114 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HII . I
116 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI116 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 116 65 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
118 65 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI118 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 118 65 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57. HI
25 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 65 HI25 66 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 127 HI
2007/10/01 25 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI27 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 65 I
27 66. NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI2007/10/01 27 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
29 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 65 HI29 66 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 29 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
31 66 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 65 HI31 66 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
I 2007/10/01 31 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
77 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 65 HI77 66 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
I 2007/10/01 77 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
79 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI79 66 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 79 66 NDD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 47 HI
81 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HI81 66 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 81 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
83 66 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 HII 83 66 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI+.......-----. --------------------- +. . +- ---+ --- +---------+---- -+-------+-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+..---------..+---------+---- ------------------ 7 --+---+-- -+-- +----•+ -------- ---+----+--+ -
8 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1. A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
...... +..+---- .----.---- . .---+----.-----+----.--------- -- -+ +--+-- "t + -+ ---- +
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI......... +----+----. +----. - -- . .----+----+ ----. ---. +-+----+- ---...... +--- +4--- -- --- -+- ----------
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007110101
2007/10/012007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
83 66
113 66113 66113 66
115 66115 66115 66
117 66117 66117 66
119 66119 66119 66
26 6726 67
.26 67
28 6728 6728 67
33 10033' 10033 100
35 10035 10035. 100
99 10099 10099 100
101 100101 100101 100
NDD
NODNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NOD
NOD
NOD
NODNOD
NOD
NODNOD
NOD
NODNODNDD
NODNOD
NOD
NODNOD
NOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNOD
NODD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBAL.LTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560. NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
47 H
63 H123 H57 H
63 H123 H57 H
63 H123 H
57 H
73 H123 H55 H
65 H127 H55. H
65 H127 H55 H
39 HI125 H21 H
39 H125 H21 H
53 H125 H21 H
53. H125 H21 H
53 H125 H
21 H
53 H125 HI21 HI
39 HI125 HI.19 HI
39 HI125 HI13 HI
119 HI
39 HI125 HI19 HI
53 HI125 HI19 HI
53 HI125 HI19 HI
103103103
100100100
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
.560. TBALL
.560 ZPSNM
.560 ZBALL
105 100105 100105 100
32 10132 10132 101
34 10134 10134 10134 101
36 10136 10136 101
98 10198 10198 101
100 101100 101100 101
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
.560 TBALL
.560 ZPSNM
.560 ZBALL
TEC" TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .. 560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNM
TEC TEH :560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC. TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH. .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
........ ++---- .---- +---- ..--- +----+----+---. +-+-------+-- -++--- - -+ ---- +-- - - ..... + -- -- +
I INSPOATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI......---- -------- --- ---- -. ------.----.--.----•--------------------'----+-----+ --+------
9 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
+ ........ ÷ ... + .. ---- + ..-.---. +----+----.----+----.+. ----. + ---- .+.. ....... +. + • ---- -+ ...... +. -
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.-+ .....- ...----+--..----+.---.----+----+----+----..+.....-------+.. --- +-.------- + ÷ - -+-.....-. + ...... +..
102 101 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 53 HI102 101 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 102 101 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
104 101 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 53 HI104 101 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
1 2007/10/01 104 101 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HII I
106 101 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 53 HI106 101 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 106 101 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HII
31 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI31 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 31 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
33 102 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI33 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 33 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI2007/10/01 33 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 119 HI
35 102 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI35 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 35 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI2007/10/01 35 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 119 HI
37 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI37 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 37 102 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
97 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI97 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 97 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
99 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI99 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 99 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
. 101 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI101 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 101 102 NOD TETEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
103 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL. 55 HII 103 102 NOD TSH* TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HII 2007/10/01 103 102 NDD TEC TEH .560. ZBALL 19 HI
I1105 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI105 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
I 2007/10/01 105 102 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HIII
107 102 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI107 102 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 107 102 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI
32 103 NOD TEC. TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI32 103 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 32 103 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
34 103 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI34 103 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 34 103 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI2007/10/01 34 103 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 119 HII
36 103 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 37 HI36 103 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI2007/10/01 36 103 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI
II1 98 103 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI1 98 103 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
I 2007/10/01 98 103 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HII I
------- -- - --.. +- -+-.+ - + - + - -..
'+ +-- - - -- +------------------------- - ------ +-----------------------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+....-------. +-,--- -- -+.--- +----+----+----+----+....------ +--------. .. +--+-
10 ST Max
SG - C Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
+......----+----. ----.. ---.----.----.----.----.---- ---+--'- --- "...+...+---- ..--.... +-.....+..-.+--+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+--------- --. - +----+-- - +--- - +-- - -+ r- -+------ - +-----------------------+-- +---- +------
100 103100 103
2007/10/01 100 103
102 103102 103
2007/10/01 102 103
104 103104 103
2007/10/01 104 103
106 103106 103
2007/10/01 106 103
33 10433 104
2007/10/01 33 104
35 10435 104
2007/10/01 35 104
99 10499 104
2007/10/01 99 104
101 104101 104
2007/10/01 101 104
103 104103 104
2007/10/01 103 104
105 104105 104
2007/10/01 105 104
100 105100 105
2007/10/01 100 105
102 105102 105
2007/10/01 102 105
104 105104 :105
2007/10/01 104 105
106 105106 105
1 2007/10/01 106 105
NDDNDDNOD
NDDNDDNDD
NDDNDDNOD
NDDNDDNOD
NDDNDDNDD
NODNODDNDD
NODNODNDD
NDDNODNOD
NDDNDDNDD
NODNDD.NDD
NODNDDNDD
NDDNODNOD
NDDNDDNOD
NDDNDDNDD
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 ZPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 TBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
55 HI123 HI
17 HI
55 HI125 H17 H
55 H123 H17 H
55 H123 HI17 HI
31 H123 H
17 HI
31 H
123 H17 H
53 H123 H
17 H
53 H123 H17 H
53 H123 H
17 H
53 H123 HI
17 HI
55 HI123 HI19 HI
55 H125 H19 H
53 HI123 HI
19 HI
53 HI123 HI19 HI
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
.560 TBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 TBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 TBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 ZBALL
.560 ZPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 TBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
.560 TBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL....----.-------- --- +-- -+~--------+----- -+ -+-... +.......---+--- . ----------------- --•+ ------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI. . . . ..-- - - - . -- --. -- - --. . + - - -I-- - +- - - - - -- --- - -- -- --- - - --- --+- - --- ---- - -- - --- --++- - - --+-.. . . -- + -.. . . . .-+-. . .+ -.
Tubes: 189 Records: 57711 ST Max
SG - C Cold Leg +PT Special Interest Tests
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720None Performed in the Cold Leg
13 12 Plugged Tube
***~ ~ flC flO Or 00 ~C U) CC CO CC CO AC - ACt 2C 20 OC 90 1~ - lOt F•
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 12 1. . ýM c00 0 0T0 0000
OO070006 0 010.0.000(
0-0 J. . . . . .. .0 0. .o-- - , 00 -- -__ - -0
o ........ . .... ........... ..... ....... ...0 0 I . . . .. . " ." .' . . . . " " . . , , . .. .. I .. " ". .' o ".. .. .0 °
o. ':"":: ,..... .. ...- •"."". . --.." . . .'." .' . .'." .- .'." . 000.i'0 00 t.. .0...0 _ __
o0 :0 .: 0.- . . .
-,,°..°:. . : : . : : : i ::t K:: ::i t : : : :t : : : : :: i : : : : : : : : : : . . : ' '.77'V7: °o _
0..... .. . . .... . . Ooo ... ..
o .. .• .- .. -. . , - • . .".' ._ ".' -'o "-' -'. "- -.-- - -" " ' ' " " '
. .... .. . . . ... ... . -. . . . - .... -.... . . .- . . . . .- . .. . . . . ..oo°. . . . -. . .
_ _ . . . .._ __ o ,- : .. : .... ... -... . . . . . . ..
0 .. t ICO .i
-. . .. -.. . . -. . - . . - . . . -
. .. . . . . .. . . . : . . I .': .• .0
0 .! .• .O . .... . . .oO .... . . . . ... . . . .. 0 . . .:o: . ::! . . . ... I . .. .. .. . . . . ... -". . . . . . . ." " " 'I ': : : °
0 0. (. 0 0 0(
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
25
20
15
55
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 1 5
.Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 0411112009 14:30:32
SG - C Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:46
+ -------- +---+--.. --. ----- +----+---------------+÷- -+-----+ ... ÷.... ----- +-.....+.-.....-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+---- +----÷----+- -- +------------+-----. . ----..--- +- - ----- + -'---- + .......-..... + .....-. --
+---- +- ---+---- --- --------- ----.. +----+ ----- - -- - ---- +-.. ..- .....---- +-.....+-. .--
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI------ -- - ..----------------- --- +- -+------ - - - --------- +" + -----
Tubes: 0 Records: 0ST Max
SG - D Hot Leg +PT Special Interest Tests
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 77201 78 Tested at TSH -2/+4" for
FOSAR Findings - Appendix12.8 SG D HL Rev 0
A 1. Tes ADT
T 3 ,. ' D,
a I Plugged Tube
148 135 130 125 120 115 J 18 185 188 ~5 qo AS 88 75 78 65 68 55 58 45 48 3S 38 .25 28 15 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65.
60.
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
00 .00 .1 0
0. * I
0 . .1 . . .I
0 . 0 0
000. . .I. 06_1L~oII~i 7 .$ . . ..177 .. ... ...
01.
00. . . . . . . . . . ..0.. .. . .. .. ...... 0
0. . . . .. 0..... .. . . . .0
00. . . . . . . . . . 00._ 0
0 T . . .
Oo .. .. . . . .__ .0 .1
_0 . .. . . . . . . _ ._ _ . . .. . .
3-- 0*
0.. ... ... .. . .. . . ..... . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . .
. 0 . . . . .0
00f: U. -. ý . 00 .. . . . . 0
0 0. .
0 ) . . .. . .. . . I0. . . . . . . . . ...T01.OK .... --- --- -::::: 17 - .T.
& 0 00 00 00 00 0 .0. . . .00
0 0 .: 000 000 000 .o o~ . 0 0 o .0 0 0 . 0 0 .: . :.. . . . . .. . . . . . .. : -:.6i ~0000 0000 000 000 00 0 I~000
... ~ . . . . .. .. .. .. .. .. 0
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC , ST Max 04/11/2009 14:32:32
SG - D Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
4. .......---- +-------- --- -------------------+--4- . . --- +4. . .4 . . .--- ---- +- ---- .... ---+ - ... +- - --- "
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI-...- - --........- -4 ---- -+-+-+-- + -----+ .... 4.---- --+-- ......-- -...... +-. .---
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/012007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
2007/10/01
252525
242424
2.06 144 ADSNDF
.NDD
6 TSH 8.722 TSH 8.72
11.68 TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH 01H .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALL.54.65 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TSH TSH .560 NPSNM125.19 TEC TEH .560 SBALL
117 76117 76117 76117 76
1.05 552.79 0
2.99 0
116116116116116
118118118118
104104104
106106106
7777777777
77777777
818181
818181
.783.84
4.703.40
1.354.92
4.14
410
0355
440
0
108 81108 81108 81
110 81110 81110 81
37 8237 8237 82
DTSCONNDFCON
DTSCONNDFCONINR
DTSCONNDFCON
NDDNDDNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NDDNODNOD
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNDD
NODNODNOD
NODNODNOD
P6P4
2,P4
P6P4
2P4P4
P6P4
2P4
TSHF04TSHF04
TSHF04TSHF04F08
TSHF04TSHF04
.052.73
.055.78
.13
6.34.13
6.706.85
.163.58
.163.45
TEC57.64 TEC
TSH52.06 TEC
-75.36 TEC
TEHTEHTSHTEHTEH
.. 560.560.560.560.560
37.97
57.73
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH ..560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TECTSHTEC
TEHTSHTEH
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 SBALL
ZBALLZBALLNPSNMSBALLSBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 SBALL
15 HI111 HI
15 HI
53 HI53 HI
111 HI
59 HI
53 HN53 HI
111 HI59 HI59 HI
53 HI53 HI
111 HI61 HI
57 HI111 HI
63 HI
57 HI111 HI
63 HI
57 HI111 HI63 HI
57 HI111 H~
63 HI
55 HI111 HI
61 HI
55 HIIll HJ
61 HI
55 H111 HI61 HI
55 H111 HI61 HI
55 HI111 HI.61 HI
55 HI111 HI
61 HI
55 HI111 HI
61 HI
55 HI111 HI
65 HI
55 HI1 IHIl
65 HI
TEC TEHTSH TSHTEC TEH
.560 ZBALL
.560 NPSNM
.560 ZBALL
393939
414141
434343
454545
474747
103103103
105105105
107107107
828282
828282
828282
828282
828282
828282
828282
828282
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
TEC TEH .560 ZBALLTSH TSH .560 NPSNMTEC TEH .560 ZBALL
NODN7D
.57 59 MBM 6 07H 15.62
NODNDDNOD
NODNODNOD
+ - - - - ----------
I INSPDATE ROW COL-------- --- +---------- ---- -- - -- -- ---------- --- + - ----+ - +- - ------ -- ---
VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+..---- +..----+- + - .F.... --- ---- .- -+...----+----.. ----- +.... + --- - -+..----+- + - -- .... +-+--+
1 ST Max
SG - D Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
+---- +-------+ --- +--------------+---------+- --- +-.---.. ÷ - •---------..----+ - +-+.÷ .. ÷..- ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI........ + ..----+ ..-- ÷----+ --- +----.----+----.----.----+...÷..÷.....--------- -- ÷ ...... ÷ ...-- - -.. ÷ ..... ..
109 82 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI109 82 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 .109 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
111 82 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI111 82 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
I 2007/10/01 111 82 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
1 36 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI36 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
1 2007/10/01 36 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
38 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI38 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNt 111 HI
1 2007/10/01 38 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
40 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI40 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
1 2007/10/01 40 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
42 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI42 83 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
I 2007/10/01 42 83 NOD TEC TEH :560 ZBALL 65 HI
44 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI44 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 44 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
46 83 NOD TEC TEH ;560 ZBALL 55: HI46 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 46 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
48 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI48 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 48 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI[
.1 102 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI102 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 102 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
104 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI104 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 104 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
106 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
I 106 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI2007/10/01 106 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
108 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI108 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
I 2007/10/01 108 83 NOD. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
110 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI110 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 110 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
I.I112 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI112 83 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 112 83 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI
35 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI35 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNN 111 HI
2007/10/01 35 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 35 84 NOD TSH TSH. .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
1 37 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI37 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 37 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 37 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
+---------------+ ----+-----+----+ ----+-----+-----+-----+-----+----+ --- + ----+-----+ - - +--------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.....-------- +-.---.+ -- -+---------------------- -.... + --- -- +-I --+---+--+ ----
2 ST Max
SG - D Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 AlR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
÷----+---------.--- +------------- ÷ ----- +------- ---+----- ------- +-....-÷----- -- -----------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGTENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI. ... ..--- - +----+---- - - - ---- ---- --- +. .- --- ÷---- - - - - ------ -+-----.+-+÷ - + .. .. -- ÷
39 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI39 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 39 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 39 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
41 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI41 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 41 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 41 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
43 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI43 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 43 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 43 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
45 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI45 84 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 45 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL' 63 HI2007/10/01 45 84 NDD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
47 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI47 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 47 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL .63 HI2007/10/01 47 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
49 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI49 84. NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 49 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI2007/10/01 49 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
I I101 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI101 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 101 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 63 HI
103 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI103 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 103 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
105 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI105 84 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 105 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
107 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI107 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 107 84 NDD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
109 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI109 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111, HI
1 2007/10/01 109 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HII I
111 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI111 84 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
1 2007/10/01 111 84 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HII I1 36 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
36 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 36 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI2007/10/01 36 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
38 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI38 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 38 85 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI2007/10/01 38 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
40 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI40 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 40 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI2007/10/01 40 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
42 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI42 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
+---------------+ ----+-----+----+ ----+-----+-----+-----+------+---+ --- + ----+-----+ - - +--- ----
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L I+.......---- I-------- --------------- --" -+-+--I----.----.-----...........+ -.- + --. -- ÷
3 ST Max
SG - D Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
.......---- +-...÷ ----+ --- +----÷-----÷+---+---....+ --. -- ÷-+-
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.........---- +-------- --------------------------.-- ..... ............---..---. .----+ - +- +- ÷. .÷..
2007/10/01 42 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI2007/10/01 42 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI2007/10/01 42 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
44 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI44 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 44 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI2007/10/01 44 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
46 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI46 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 46 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67+ HI2007/10/01 46 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
48 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI48 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 48 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI2007/10/01 48 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
50 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI50 85 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 50 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI2007/10/01 60 85 RBD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI2007/10/01 50 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI
100 85 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI100 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 100 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
102 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI102 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 102 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
104 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI104 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 104 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
106 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI106 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 106 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
108 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI108 85 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 108 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
110 85 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI110 85 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI.
1 2007/10/01 110 85 NDD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 67 HI
37 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI37 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 37 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI.39 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
39 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI2007110101 39 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
41 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI41 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 41 86. NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
43 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI43 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 43 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
45 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI45 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 45 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
47 86 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI47 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
..----.... -- +----+--- +----+----+----+-------..+-..- -- +-- F-+- + +- +- + --÷ ... -°°
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE' CAL LI+-- ------ +----+---------.----.----+----.----+--.-. ....------.. ....---- +- ÷ -- --- "-.-- -- - --
4 ST Max
SG - D Hot Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braldwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 08:17:26
÷+ . . . . . . . . . . . ÷- -- ÷ . . . . ÷ - - - -4- - - +- --- - + - - - - + - - - - -+ - - - - - - - -4-- - + - - - +--- --- - ÷
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI. .. . ..-- - -+---- ---- + - - - ---- +---- +--- ---- +--- +-------------+ - ÷- - - +--+- ÷ ..---.. .. +---.- +÷ "+'- ÷
2007/10/01 47 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HII49 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI49, 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 49 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
101 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI101 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 101 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 Hi
103 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI103 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 103 86 NOD TEC TEH +.560 ZBALL 65 HI
105 86 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI105 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 105 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
107 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI107 86 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 107 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
109 86 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
109 86 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI2007/10/01 109 86 .78 66 MBM 6 03H 23.20 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 65 HI
I . I38 87 NOD TECO TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI38 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 38 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
40 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI40 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 40 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
1 42 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI42 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 42 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
44 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI44 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 44 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
46 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI46 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
I 2007/10/01 46 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
48 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI48 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI'
2007/10/01 48 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
102 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59. HI102 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 102 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
104 87 NOD TEC. TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI104 87 NDD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 104 , 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HI
106 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI106 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 106 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HII.
108 87 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI108 87 NOD TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 111 HI
2007/10/01 108 .87 NOD .. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 69 HIS- - - ------ + +- ------- +----+----+- ---- -+ ---+---+ - -. -'---
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+- - -+-----+-- -+--- +-- -+------+-- -+------ --------- --- ---- +--.--+--- - +-----+-......-----
Tubes: 82 Records: 268ST Max
SG - D Cold Leg +PT Special Interest Tests
Braidwood AIR14 CCE 77200 27 Tested at TSH -2/+4" for
FOSAR Findings - Appendix12.8 SG D CL Rev 0
a 1 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 L15 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30000 0ý0 0 0I I
° 0?oo. I I I ° o
25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0 . . .: . ..10.0 **7* 0
llc, .. . . . . 0. 0 . . . . . . . . . .
__ __0t. . 0._
0 0
0CO 0 _
-0 0-
S0
0`00S0-
0 . 00 00
0o..........0 0 f-----.---.------fl0
0 . . .. .. . .. . .. .. . . .. . .. .. . .. . . .. . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . .. . . .. .
._ .~ 0 . . .
. .. .: ....._ . .(
.. . . .. ._ _ . . . .-1 ~ - -- - - ----- -----01::. . .. .r .. i .f..t
.1 . ..4. .. . -. -.-...- *.- .0
0 . .T
115
110
105
100.
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
5o° °o.' , 1 o" ° I I I '() ) 0 ; 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0/0
40135 1300 5 0 1 1 5 0 95 90 .o85o00 1 7 65 60 55 50 000 0 I5 2 15 10 5140 15 30 15 20 115 110 105 100 95 90 .85 80 75 70. 65 60 .55 50 45 40 . 35 36 ( 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/111/2009 14:32:27
SG - D Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood I AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:47
............+--.... ÷----+-- +---÷-.-+ -.----- --- ---- .----+.÷ ..... ÷ - . .÷.---+- - -. ...-+ ----- +-+.. .÷ . . ..- ÷
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.........+--...÷_ ÷----+----+----+ --- ..--+----+----.----+----+. .......--- +--- .---- .....----+ - .-.-.-. ...-- ÷
105 56 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI105 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 105 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
107 56 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI107 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 107 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
109 56 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI109 56 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 109 56 NDD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
104 57 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI1 104 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI1 2007/10/01 104 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HII .I
106 57 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI106 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 106 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
108 57 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI108 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
1 2007/10/01 108 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
110 57 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 C[110 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 110 57 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HII
103 58 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI103 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 103 58 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45, HII105 58 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSN 12 Cl
105. 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI2007/10/01 105 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HII
107 58 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI107 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 107. 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
109 58 NDD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI109 58 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 109 58 1.38 70 MBM 6 03H 15.12 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
111 58 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI111 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 111. 58 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
102 59 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12. CI102 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 102 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HII . I
104 59 NDD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI104 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 104 59 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
106 59 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI106 59 NDD TEC TEH. .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007110101 106 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
108 59 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI108. 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
2007/10/01 108 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
110 59 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI110 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI
1 2007/10/01 110 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HII.1 112 59 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI
.112 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI1 2007/10/01 112 59 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI------------ .---- + -. . . +.....---..--- .-- ---- ----- ----- +---- - -- +--- - ----- + ------------- -----+ -----+---+ - --
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.---- ---- +--... -+--------- ----- +-----m+ ----- +---------- +----- --- +-------+-----+---- ---
ST Max
SG - D Cold Leg Special Interest +Point Inspection Results with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:08:47
+..----. .. +----+----+.-- -. +..--- +-+----- -+----+----+--- +- ----- + ----+ -+--- -+ ...... +--+I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+-÷----+---------.--- ----.---- +----.----+----+--------+- -------- --- - .--- --
103 60 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 Ci103 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 103 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HII
105 60 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI105 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 105 60 NDD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HII
107 60 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI107 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 107 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
109 60 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI109 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 109 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
111 60 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12. CI111 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
2007/10/01 111 60 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
104 .61 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI104 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
2007/10/01 104 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
106 61 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI1 106 61 NOD TEC. TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
2007/10/01 106 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
108 61 NOD TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI108 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
2007/10/01 108 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HII I
110 61 NOD, TSC TSC .560 NPSNM 12 CI110 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 139 HI
2007/10/01 110 61 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI+ -------- +- ---- - -+- D---+-G-------+----+----+-- - --- + .. -----....+- " "+ --- .-.... "+" + - +I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI"-------------+------ - -+------------------------- +-------------------+----------+ - -- -- - ---
Tubes: 27 Records: 81
2 ST Max
Attachment B.3
Tubes Damaged by Secondary Side Foreign ObjectsA1R14
SG - A Tubes with Foreign Object Wear
Braidwood AIR14 CCE 7720X 3 Tube with Foreign Object Wear
a 27 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 .25 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30II0!0 o 000•00 0 0 (io o )• /• .•• •, • •• • •1. o~) I
25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
0- 112...-. . . . . -- . . . TD -... ~ o0 00 ... "0 ' -I • •
..O. . .. . . .•. 0
00. . • . l .. ..: . 0 0.. .. . •: .: :T. . __. . __ ...0o • .. . .• .: .: ... .....
oo. . . . . . . . ... .. .. .. .. . '.. '-'.
, "~ - . . : : . • - ' ' - .'.•:-:-~ ~ .• . . . ., . . : : ..• .
•0 ., . . . .. . .'OO.. . 1 0
.. .. .• .. : : . : : . . .. ... .. . • .
.-- •• . .- . .••o•.°'T ..: .'•° . .* . ..• .'•• • .• . . . : . ." O.
•. ., • . . .•T ' .• . ._i : .• • • . .. ...
01 .-': .- -: 'T . . . .. . ..r.0(0
0 0
- - 0 • . . .. . . .. . ... . . . . .
, " . ' . T ° . . . '.T. .. . . . .'0o. .
. .. .. . . . . . ."
. '. . ' . ." .'.T' .'." "--. . " " "".0"T -0_• •l.." ".. . . " . . . . . .' ".. .0oo
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
1515
5 500
0)o 0 0 0000 000 0 000 0 010.1
0 (
0 0,
0 0 0 0 0 0100 0. 0 0000 00 00.; 0 00 T00 0 0 0
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Wesfinighotme Electric Com~pany LLC - ST Mux 04/11/2009 14:54:41
SG - A Tubes with Foreign Object Wear
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 12:04:06
+- -- +-------+ - -- +....---- +- -- +----+~ - ---- +--- ..-- -+-....+- --- +...... --- - + -...... -----
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L COMI. .---- +- ------- -+-....---+----- +- ---. --- +----+-..4--- "+-- - +..----+- - -- ..---- +-- -+-...---4----+
96 107 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 117 HI I96 107 .16 88 VOL P4 TSH .11 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI I96 107 .16 -280 PCT 16 2 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI I
2007/10/01 96 107 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI I2007/10/01 96 107 .13 107. VOL P4 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI I2007/10/01 96 107 .15 281 PCT 15 2 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI I
98 107 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 117 HI I98 107 .14 78 VOL P4 TSH .09 TSH TSH ;560 NPSNM 129 HI I98 107 .14 83 PCT 15 2 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI I
2007/10/01 98 107 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI I2007/10/01 98 107 .13 85 VOL P4 TSH .10 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI 1
S.2007/10/01 98 107 .15 80 PCT 15 2 TSH .10 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI I
97 108 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 125 HI I97 108 .15 272 PCT 15 2 TSH .17 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI I97 108 .15 83 VOL P4 TSH .19 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 129 HI I
2007/10/01 97 108 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI I1 2007/10/01 97 108 .12 95 VOL P4 TSH .16 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI I1 2007/10/01 97 108 .13 269 PCT 14 2 TSH .16 TSH *TSH .560 ZPSNM 133 HI I- ----.----.----.. -----------------------.....---- ------- +--- 4--- - +---- --- 4-----
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND. PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L COMI+ ---- + ----+-+ --------..--.. . -+-------........ ----÷--- --- ----.... ------ -- --- ------
Tubes: 3 Records: 181 ST Max
SG - B Tubes with Foreign Object WearBraidwood A1R14 CCE 7720
X 2 Tube with Foreign Object Wear
a 39 Plugged Tube
115
11l
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
140 135 130 .125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60. 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 50 000 000 ̀ 0 0
.00.00 .0.,0
. . .° . . .. . . . . .. ..... . .. . . ... .T, o 0
. .0. . ' ' . . .. . **.: . '.S0 000
o .: 0 0 a . . O O0-.000
0 - . . .................. ... .0-. . . . . . . ..... ... .. .... "".. .M .O
S.° . .0
OT. 0'000.- . . . . . .oo00 " °0
___ .... . ..... .. 4... .... __
.• . . . .. ..
o° :-: .:: ... .o .. ....0
0
0
o00.. . : :.:::. .': . . . . . . . . . .. . .... ..:: :.0..... . . .... . .. ... .........0 .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . ..... . 0 . . . . . . . . . a 00
. 0. . ...... ...... .. .. . . ....... .. ... .. . .o0000............... .. _
0° " 000
0 .. .. .. .. .. ... . ......... . . .. .. .. .. ............ .01
13OM .0 0 0 0~0! O 0 i O 0 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 ( 0 0 0 0I O 0 •0 0 (
40
0 . . . . . .. 7** .. .. . .0.0 0..
_ 0 -- e a-.-
0. 0. .- . . . .. . . . -
0 . . . 0
0~~ .oo~~ 000 00 0000 000 .~O 000 000 000 .~? 0 000 000 000 000 . ....0000~~~ ~ 0 000 000 000 .~ 000 00 0 . . . .000 00 .0 00 0.00
14 13 13 12 12 11 11 1. 1. 95 90 85 80 75 ... .. 70 65 60 55 5. 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 .5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 0411112009 14:56:02
SG - B Tubes with.foreign Object Wear
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 12:04:04
+ ........... + .... + .... • 4 - + . . .. .. . . ÷. . .. . +.. .. . . .. .. . ..-- ---- - + - - -.... +- -......---- -.. .... ....-- - - - - - ....
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L COM I+.....+---------+-----.+----......+. 7 -+-------------- --------+---+ ---------- +-----------------+----+- - ---- ----+ ------------
89 30 1.84 116 DTI P6 TSH .25 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HIHISTORY REVIEWEDI89 30, 1.29 63 SVI P4 TSH .25 TSH TSH .560 NPSNW 119 HI I89 30 1.67 62 PCT 73 P1 TSH .26 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI I89 30 1.53 58 PID P4 TSH .25 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI I
2007/10/01 89 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI I
98 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI I98 47 .22 78 VOL P4 TSH .02 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI I98 47 .16 86 PCT 21 P1 TSH .03 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI I
2007/10/01 98 47 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 19 HI I2007/10/01 98 47 .25 78 PCT 22 P1 TSH -. 01 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 127 HI I2007/10/01 98 47 .10 94 VOL 0 P4 TSH .01 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNW 127 HI I
. ..---- + + . .------+----+---. +----+----+-----+-- +----+------ - + ----------------------------- +- ... +....+---- +---------------- +
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH. INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L COM I+......----+---- +-------+--- +----+----+-- -+----------+--- -+ ------- +------------+-----------•--------++ - +----+------------- +
Tubes: 2 Records: 11ST Max
SG - C Tubes with Foreign Object Wear
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720X 1 Tube with Foreign Object Wear
a 12 Plugged Tube
115
lie
105
100
95
90
85
80.
75
70
65
60
55
50.
45
40
35
30
25
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 500 0.000 ()0 0 0 00 I0
I 0o0 0oO o0000* . . 00 00o 0 1 . . .. .. . . . - .-
_0 0 0 0. .1.0.0,0 0 . tf . . . . . . ... . . . . .. .
__ __ __ .00 __
0000
.'- . -. '-.... . . .. . .- '' . 6,'
0. .* .. . . .. 0.
0 - 0
. . . . . . . . . ............. • .... (oo ....... • ........ 0o
00O0 ...............- - -.......... ................... .
00 -70
00..
o O O : . - : : : . .t - . . .: --. . : . : : : : ..: : : : : . . . . . .o
_I0-
0:: 7
0 ..
-00
o() . ' . ' . " .' "" ". . . . . . . . . .. . . ' " . . . .T . . . .
00 0 000 00 0 0 00 0 0 0.} .
00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 000 00 00 .00
000 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
S O • .:.: : ..:.: ..... o o. . " .. . . . .. . . .~~~~ .. . . . .. .. .. ... ..' " ' " ' "." .'• " .' .'! " " ." ." " " . '. ' '. '. . '. ' '. ' . . '... o , o , ,-o .o' ,. o , ,. o , o . o . ,. ,',: 1 , o . . . . ' . . . 'o . . . . . . . . . . . . . It • , o .o° ". '. . '. " ".. . '. " , . . . . . . . . ............ . . . . . . - " " . . . . . . . . . ... 0o"0' ' " "'°o . .. •. . .:- - -. ' .- : .•' .'• ".' .' 't''. .'.Oo.,~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~ ,....,.. ... . ,,.. .,I..., .,_,. ".' .' . . .' .. . . ..... .cO,. .' " " '. °." '.•* . ." " ', '." ",' .' " " '.I ''°" " ° 'I°'' °* ' ' °" '' " "°. °.' .°" .°° ."°. °. " . . ' .° . °.° .
0o. . . ..-. . . .. . . . . .. . . . . .... .... ... .... . .. . .; . . ... .-.. . .. -. :. . - . . ... I . . : . .
0o - - . . . . . . . - . . . . . . . - . . . . . ... -.. .... . ... . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . .!. ! . .. ,.. . ... . .. . . . . . . . . .. ._. .
. . 0,(Do00
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
1515
5
140 135 130 125 120 .115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 Z5 20 lb N0 5
West~nghou~se Electri Comlpany LLC - ST Max 04/11112009 14:30:48
SG - C Tubes with Foreign Object Wear
Braldwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 12:04:02
+-+ --- ---- ---- +--- +----+----- --- --- +...+...+...+....----+- - -+ --- .----. +.----..+- +-......+- --- "-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L COMI+- -- - +--- -+----+--- +- -- +--- -+..----+...------- --- --- ------ +... --...----. - .- +- - T+---+
30 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI I30 63 .06 110 SVI P4 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI I30 63 .10 287 PCT 9 2 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI I30 63 7.62 83 PLP 11 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI I30 63 .05 89 PID P4 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM. 131 HI I
I 2007/10/01 30 63 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI I---- .----.----. .---4+----+----+--------+----- --.---. +---------'---+- +- +-- - -4---'---4"
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LCOMI+- ----- - - - -+-....- - ...... ..- -.... ----.. +----+ ----.- --. .- ---- ---- ------ .--- - - -+--+- ---- -------
Tubes: 1 Records: 6ST Max1
Attachment B.4
Tubes Containing Fan Bar WearA1R14
SG - A Tubes with Fan bar Wear Indications
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720X 3 Tube with Fan Bar Wear
Indication
a 27 Plugged Tube
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
0000 000D
00 00O a 0 0o00f _
0 . . . . . . . . .. . .,. . . .. . .
I00 .'." .0_ .0
0000 .. . . 0 . . •. .ii i i . . .. 0
0.0 . .. .00__0 . . . 0 . ...
.o. . .. . . . . . .•0 .. .. .]
.• ... . . . . . .-
o - - o ' o . ., , " , . . . . . . . . . . .. . (o°- . . .. . . .. ... .
................... .. '..
....... . . .•......... . ......... 00010
0. . . . . * . .. . . . . . . . . . ..... ......... ....
0.. ........... .... .... .... ... .. . ... .
0...............-.. ." .'.'.'.'.."....... .
,°,o)°,:" 1,. . . . . . . ..... . . ...... .. . .........
0. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 __
o . '. ...... ... . . ..o.. ...
o 0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
__ 00• ,I . . . .. . . . . .. . . . .. . 0 -0
o. . ... . . .. .: ". .. 00
0I . . . .. ..0. . . .. .. . . . . . . .. . . 07.-.-.- • :•-.- r20 . . . . ... '. . 7 " I"
.o((00(00(0 0 00 0 000. 0. 7 000 100•00 0 00. 00 0000 0o
0 0 0/)00000 00100 0 0 0010000100 .00 0oi O.000/10 00o' 01000Oo0 000 0 ' 00001'0060140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:54:38
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
26
15
10
55
SG - A Fan Bar Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:34:43
--- -+... ----- -+--- +- ------ + - --- + --------- +--- -+.............----+-----......+-+-+-
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI...---- +...----- -+ --- - -+...-----------+--+ ---+. ----. +-.-- .-------- +---+ - - - -- +
71 62 .21 0 PCT 6 P2 F04 -1.80 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 5 HI2007110/01 71 62 .17 0 PCT 4 P2 F04 -1.81 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 73 HI
I63 70 .29 0 PCT 6 P2 F05 .65 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
2007/10/01 63 70 .11 0 PCT 4 P2 F@5 .54 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HII
84 87 .37 0 PCT 9 P2 F05 -. 81 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 113 HI2007/10/01 84 87 .23 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 -1.04 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
....+-.--------.----.- --- -+----+----+----+---------- --+--------------+---.+-.------- +--- +-- ----
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI----------------- ----- +----+..----- ---- +---- ------ +---+----+ - +- +- ---
Tubes: 3 Records: 6ST Max
SG - B Tubes with Fan Bar Wear Indications
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720X 7 Tube with Fan Bar. Wear
Indication
a 39 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10000,0 000
0000 000... ..0 001o0~ o~ 0" ~~co) . . .
5
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
-0 _)O 0
__ __ __ __ 00. * I0
. ..... ..... ..... . ...C)OI . .* .. .. .*'..0
0
__ .:* * * 0000. . . . . . . .
S~0
_ _0
0 . . .
0 . . .I .. I .. . . . . ... .. . ... .0
S~0
-- 0 . . ... . . . . . .
00...... . . . . . ~ .. . . . . . .
0
0 0. 0
0 00
0 0
0 . . .- 0 --00
00 . . . . .7 .0
. . ..0.
0. 0
115
110
105
100
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
150000-0 0i 0 0
000'-- ---- ---- --- -- - --- ----------
0 0: : : - - - - :.: : : : : : : : : : : : : T!: :ý: : : : : :i: : . -:-0
0000 000 I0 0 00 0 ' 00 000 0 0 000 00.,00 0 00J, 000000 0 0 100 0000 00 0 olo )~''o o''o 100-ý 000 0)oo,0' *ý*O~ . . . 00.
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 .70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
0 0
Westinghou~se Electric Com~pany LLC -ST Max. 04/111/2009 14:06:00
SG - B Fan Bar Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:34:41
+ ---- +---------+- - - +------+--------------+-- - --- +--.. -- 4---+ -- +- +-. -+--+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI............++ ----+---+---+ - ------- t----+ -.... - -- + - - -+----+---+-. .+-.. +.- . -- +
57 42 .24 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 -1.69 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 27 HI2007/10/01 57 42 .19 0 PCT 4 P2 F@5 -1.53 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 29 HI
I71 62 .19 0 PCT 5 P2 F04 1.05 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 H2007/10/01 71 62 .21 0 PCT 5 P2 F04 1.05 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
52 63 .21 0 PCT 6 P2 F05 1.41 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 HI2007/10/01 52 63 .11 0 PCT 5 P2 F@4 .97 TEC TEH .560 ZBAL.L 39 HI
107 68 .21 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 1.65 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 63 HI
2007/10/01 107 68 .17 0 PCT 6 P2 F05 1.69 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
82 69 .14 0 PCT 2 P2 F06 -1.02 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HII 2007/10/01 82 69 .25 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 -1.19 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HIII
65 70 .20 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 -i.07 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HII 2007/10/01 65 70 .23 0 PCT 4 P2 F06 -. 98 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI
76 73 .23 0 PCT 4 P2 F05 -1.06 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HII 2007/10/01 76 73 .18 0 PCT 4 P2 F05 -1.22 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI+ .----. ----.---- - ---.---- +----.----.----+--..•...- -+ - --'-- +- ---- +--- --+-..+---+-- -
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT. PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+-- ------------------ ----------------------- ------ +----. -+ ---- +-------+-- +---+ .......-----
Tubes: 7 Records: 14ST Max
SG - C Tubes with Fan Bar Wear Indications
Braidwood AlR14 CCE 7720X 18 Tube with Fan Bar Wear
Indication
a 12 Plugged. Tube
140 .35 130 125 120 15 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
I'oOo° o~ooo°I I II
5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
0000f. _°0 •0 " .. .. . 0 0
_o +_I I I* o100 1:0 * . 0 0 -
oo . . . " .. .. .- .. . . . . 0 0
(7__0.. _0__.
00.. ....... .... ......
S. .. . . . . . . .
" o . .: :. .:. :.: .:.: .:. . .:,.. . .:. .... . .. .x .".' ..- ." ..' . . . ....'..' ..'." . ... '.". '.....0- 00
00 00 .. ... ... ... . .... ....... ... . . .. ... .-. ... • .- .• ... ."_ 0
. . . . . . . . . . .
. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . 0° °°°o _
. ' " " ' .' " ' .- " ' " " . ": : :+ " . . : :" I: : : :" : - ,' , * *+ '" '*+ o °
_I( .. .. . .I . :1 ~ 1 " " " - Oo
0 o . . . . . o . o ++ . . .+. ... 1 7 . o . 7.. . . .
-: - T' 0' - -.
. I. . . .. .. .i.. . .. .. . ..t.. ... ..... : H6o0. " ". .. . . . .. .. . . . . . . .. .. . .
0o .o .o ..o~ , .o! o . ... , o ~ .. .~o .o .o0 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..K ' " " ' ' " " ' ' " " ' ' ' ' ' ' " " 'o o ...... . .I . ..I . . .. .' + . ...... .. .... ... .. ..
o~~~~~~~i.',"~~~~~~~~~~~~ . .... ".... "..._ .".'. .". .. ."..'_"0 " l "t" " " " "" "' '' i •
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
1515
5 5
0100oo'i'oo d oo)ood 0 0 T 0 0 000 T0 0 .0 oo*o d ooo ooPo oo' 1 *? 0 / 0 I 00 0 ,4 , *, , 00~0.. ....00 00 0'0. 0 *000 0, oo 0000 0 00o.000 00000040 1 0 0110 1 1 1 0 o 6 o 1 0 00 20 10
140 .135 , 130 125 * 120 -115 110 *105 100 95 *90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55- 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 1e 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/1112009 14:30:46
SG - C Fan Bar Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:34:41
.............--- 7 -.------------+---+- + -- --------------------------------------- +----------------------
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI....---- +---. +----+ --- +----+--------- -------- + ---- --.... . .-- --- +-- +- +- -- +-
55 56 .32 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 1.53 TEC. TEH .560 TBALL 77 HI2007/10/01 55 56 .21 0 PCT 6 P2 F05 1.29 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
95 58 .. 39 0 PCT 8 P2 F0 -. 71 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI
2007/10/01 95 58 .27 0 PCT 8 P2 F05 -. 87 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
101 60 .26 0 PCT 4 P2 F05 1.59 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 73 HI2007/10/01 101 60 .22 0 PCT 6 P2 F05 1.40 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
66 61 •37 0 PCT 8 P2 F07 1.82 TEC TEH .560 Z8ALL 71 HI2007/10/01 66 61 .38 0 PCT 10 P2 F07 1.90 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 61 HI
2007/10/01 66 61 .47 90 VOL P4 F07 1.84 F07 F07 .520 ZPUNM 121 HI
80 63 .31, 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 -1.51 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI80 63 6.53 70 PLP 11 TSH .20 TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
2007/10/01 80 63 .25 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 -1.31 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI
94 63 .36 0 PCT 8 P2 F@5 -1.57 TEC -TEH .560 TBALL 75 HI2007/10/01 94 63 .38 0 PCT 10 P2 F05 -1.70 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 Hl
I 2007/10/01 94 63 .20 73 VOL P4 F05 -1.65 F05 F05 .520 ZPUNM 121 HI
I04 63 .29 0 PCI 6 P2 F05 1.57 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 63 I H
1 2007/10/01 104 63 .27 0 PCT 7 P2 F05 1.09 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 HI
1 76 65 .15 0 PCT 2 P2 F05 .71 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI76 65 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 125 HI
I 2007/10/01 76 65 .12 0 PCT 4 P2 F05. .81 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
59 68 .25 0 PCI 4 P2 F05 .92 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 H2007/10/01 59 68 .14 0 PCT 4 P2 F05 .92 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
170710 71 5 68 .14 0. PCT 4 P2 F05 .92 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 Hl
177 68 . .54 0 PCT 9 P2 F05 -.96 IECITEH .5N ZBALL. 67 HI1 2007/10/01 77 68 .56 0 PCT 13 P2 F05 -1.03 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI
92 69 .55 0 PCT 10 P2 F05 -. 79 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 H1 2007/10/01 92 69 .49 0 PCT 11 P2. F05. -. 99 TEC TEH .560. ZBALL 47 HI
2007/10/01 92 69 .38 85. VOL P4 F05 -. 83 F05 F05 .520 ZPUNM 121 HI
35 70 .25 0 PCT 4 P2 F05 1.58 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI2007/10/01 35 70 .35 76 INR 6 TSH 11.86 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI2007/10/01 35 70 .20 0 PCT 5 P2 F@5 1.11 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI
105 72 .20 0 PCT 3 P2 F03 -. 46 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 61 HI2007/10/01 105 72 .21 0 PCT 5 P2 F03 -. 39 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI
' ' I
57 78 .28 0 PCT 6 P2 F06 .77 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 49 HI2007110101 57 78 .33 0 PCT 9 P2 F06 .94 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
93 78 .23 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 -. 44 TEC TEH. .560 TBALL 49 HI2007/10/01 93 78 .24 0 PCT 7 P2 F05 -. 71 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 39 HI
90 79 .82 0 PCT 14 P2 F06 1.21 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 49 HI2007110101 90 79 .73 0 PCT 14 P2 F06 1.36. TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 37 HI2007/10/01 90 79 .70 82 VOL P4 F06 1.21 F06 F06 .520 ZPUNM 121 HI
97 86 .33 0 PCT 6. P2 F05 1.27 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI2007/10/01 97 86 .25 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 1.11 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 35 HI
79 94 .40 0 PCT 9 P2 F06 -1.18 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 45 HI1 2007/10/01 79 94, .. 42 0 PCT 9 P2 F06 . -. 99 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 31 HI. .----.----.--- +.....---- -+-------- ------ +-'---+- ---- -+---- + ----- +-.....+-.-------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI.......------ +----.----------. ---------------- ------------- --- ---- ----- ------------------
Tubes: 18 Records: 431 .. ST Max
SG - D Tubes with Fan Bar Wear Indications
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720X 6 Tube with Fan Bar Wear
Indication
a 1 Plugged Tube
115
110
105
95
90
85
80.
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40. 35 30 25 20 15 10 5IILA,,1S 00o00T•°6 I I 0I o oO . :?:: :: : : o o.:- : 9 01*.: ":;. :::io:,O O00..
()
__0 0_ 0~0o~
3-- .- V-- - - 0-- : • : : - , - - , - • - , - - o0 -........ .o ....... .""
000 0
00 0
0 0 . . . . .. . . . . . . . 0.-.
0. ...................... ....... ..... .. .o- 0 O.:.. .. :..:. .:..:. .... :..: .. :.:.:...:. .:... .:..:. .:...:.O .
0 0
- 0 . .. - .-- -- . . . . . . .-. 0
. . ..... .... . . . .. . .. . 0..,. °... o.... .. . . . 0.. .
°................................................... ..
*1 . . . . . o .. . I . . .0. . . . . . .
0. '. 7 7 0 I0 0
.. ... 7 0.. . ..... -.. 0
O 0(000 000 000 000 00 .0 000 .0.#0
,o ." " .' . .'." " .' . . ." " .' . .'." " . . .'." " . . " "l' . . . . . ..' . . . ... . . '. ' " " " . 1 " "S.....
' .. . .00
, . .;t - ., .; ; ; .'.. .. . . . " " ." '" "
000
00
l0~ ? ~
000 000 0 0 00 0 0 0 ( 0 0 O0 000 0 0000 00 0 0 0000 *0*000)O140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 * 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 . 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
25
20
15
10
55
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/111/2009 14:32:42
SG - D Fan Bar Wear Indications with History
Braldwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:34:41
-------- +----+---+--- ---- +.- ----. +----+.---. .. +.- --- .---- +-- -+.-.+.-+ ---
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI---------- -+-- -+--------------------..---........-- -+----+4----+- +------ - ÷---
I 96 69 .44 0 PCT 8 P2 F08 .67 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HI2007/10/01 96 69 .10 0 INR P2 F08 - .51 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 55 HI2007/10/01 96 69 .51 0 PCT 8 P2 F08 .67 TEC TEH. .560 SBALL 55 HI
85 70 .80 0 PCT .16 P2 F06 -1.54 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HI2007/10/01 85 70 .92 0 PCT 16 P2 F06 -1.29 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI2007/10/01 85 70 .00 0 INR P2 F06 1.43 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
72 71 .32 0 PCT 7 P2. F06 .92 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 Hi2007/10/01 72 71 .01 0 INR P2 F06 -. 92 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI2007/10/01 72 71 .40 0 PCT 8 P2 F06 .92 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI
97 74 .36 0 PCT 8 P2 FOB -. 67 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 49 HI2007/10/01 97 74 .44 0 PCT 9 P2 F08 -. 59 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 Hi
104 77 .42, 0 PCT 7 P2 F06 -1.56 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 53 HI
2007/10/01 104 77 .37. PCT 7 P2 F06 -1.45 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 59 HII
35 138 .40 0 PCT 8 P2 F05 1.63 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 87 HI2007/10/01 35 138 .33 0 PCT 5 P2 F05 1.21 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 85 HI
- --- ,---------------- ---- ------- 4--- - -- - -------. - +,..4..-+- ----- 4.
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS: DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI- ---- +------------- --------- +----------------+- - ------------ -------------
Tubes: 6 Records: 151 ST Max
Attachment B.5
Tubes Containing Lattice Grid WearA1 R14
SG - A Tubes with Lattice Grid Wear Indications
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720X 4 Tube with Lattice Grid Wear
Indication
a 27 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 - 120 .15 .10 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20o O00oo o 00o0oOo
0000 . . ' .
15 10 5
115 i I i I
ooo()00-0 a 0 () 0:: 0 0ý
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
ion. I ** .00.. . .-
oo. . .. - --.- -.'. -"- - -o- -•
oo • - . .T '._" ' '- ." ". . .' . † † † † † † † † † † † † † † † †0.0...... - .:-..........
0 . . . . . . . 0 :
. ..• ,• • .-• . , . ••.. I -: : •. :•: !. .:l ••. . ..0. . . . . .4• •• • • - ' ,I 011 2 :1 1
S.... ........ ........ 0...0. . .. .0. 0
-. u • • '. . •i
~~. . . .. . . . . . . .......... ••.••••,••. •xo
__ _ _ _ . . . .
o•.: ..• . . . . . .• ... ". .•.•. .0. ...•. .•...".• X•'••
-O.. .. . . .. .. .. ... .-... -.. ... I
o. .. 0. .- . 0.o-000
0 ..
0
_ 0 . . . . ..-.. 0
0.0
"='•'"'•'"~~~~... .. ..' .. .... -.'.' ... .. .:": " ' """"" '.°.:.:. . ..
.-.-. .-. .. ... .. : .: : ..: : .: : ! ! . : . .•o. .. . . .. -. . .". . . . .'l
' ' .:
. .. • ... . . . . . . . . . _ . . . . :' --
0.. . .L ...Oo. .'' ' '- - - ..•..'- - - 00. ' • " t . .
o°.~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ... . ... •.. .... . .;: .'..'.' . . .... t.. •.
.I . . .. . . .. . "
o 0 .. . . . .-.-.-, . . . . . ;. T .T . T . . . . O o
115
110
105
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25.
20
15
10
5
I o o4oo; O;. o o4 .. .. 1 . *oI -0000000 000 0 0 0 000 0000 0000 0000
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Eletlic Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:54:43
SG - A Lattice Grid Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:42:50
- ------------- - - -- - -------------- - - - ---------- ----+ - - - --- -
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI- - - - ---- - --- - --------....- ---- -- ÷------ - - - - + - ----- .-- .. ..--+ - - +--.. . . . ..
72 19 .17 0 PCT 4 P2 05H .34 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 47 HI2007/10/01 72 19 .17 0 PCT 4 P2 05H .48 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 97 HI
39 70 .47 0 PCT 11 P2 01H -1.51 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 7 HI2007/10/01 39 70 .36 0 PCT 10 P2 01H -1.85 TEC TEH .560 SBALL 47 HI
118 71 .15 0 PCT 6 P2 01C .91 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 9 HI2007/10/01 118 71 NOD TEC TEH .560 SBALL 45 HI
I~I.75 108 .13 0 PCT 4 P2 07H -1.69 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 117 HI
2007/10/01 75 108 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 17 HI+--- --------- ----- - ------------ +--- -+----+ 7 - - ----- +-------------- ----------- --
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHi INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL' LI+- --- +----+-------- +----+----+----+----+------- - ----- ..-------- +---- --- - +--- .... 4--4-
Tubes: 4 Records: 8ST Max
SG - B Tubes with Lattice Grid Wear Indications
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720X 2 Tube with Lattice Grid Wear
Indication
13 39 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 .80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 100,o 0o 1 °°00 ° °0 °° 0.0° ° o) . . .. .. . 00.00 0 0
5
0 00115
110
105.
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
__0 00
-- _ 0.. . .2" . ." .. . . -0
,O - : : : .;::"" .. 0 00_ 0000. .". . '. . '. ' '.'. . 00 : :
. ...... . ............. ......
__ __ _1 00
0 00
. . . . .... . . 00 ._ ._ . . . .. . . . 01*
T .0? ± . . . . . .. W..:
:. .. .o ..... .... . ..
:.:o o*.: _:: ' ' :: ' : t : ° .
o ... .. I.. . .. . . ... . . 0. 0 ,_.. ..____ 6__I __ __ __.. ..0 *00
00. . .: . . . . ...000 01
4 1 a 11: *00
. .0 . 0 0 0 0
o,°.- . . .' ' :'0.. • ".:: : :: : :'
' " " "" " .:.:r.: oo-:: 100o. .. . T. . T • on.
60 - 01 0 . .j . . . . .. 0 13i
0.
0 . .. -. -. 1.-.
o . . . .... I .-... .. . . ,0
115
110
105
25
20.
15
10
500. . • .°°° .° ° . .., * -* - - * . .. .. .. ° .° -°. * . . . . . . - - I . I°00 T
() 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.±0 000 0 *0 000 p0 00~ 00 0000 000(00 0 0
0 0100000 0 0 0 0000 00000
0
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:56:05
SG - B Lattice Grid Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 AIR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:42:48
.........-------- +. ----.-----------............ +---+----+----------+----+--+ .. - + -- +- + -+
INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHi INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI..---. .- +--. .+--.--.+---. +--- -+------- +-------- --- +...- .... +.--- .---- +----.... + ............ - - +-+-+ -
47 24 .28 PCT 3 P2 08H -1.50 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HII 2007/10/01 47 24 RBD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL, 11 HI
2007/10101 47 24 RBD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 21 HI2007/10/01 47 24 .11 0 PCT 3 . P2 08H -1.53 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 27 HI
90 107 .50 0 PCT 7 P2 07H .57 TEC TEH .560 TBALL 87 HI2007/10/01 90 107 .59. 0 PCT 10 P2 07H .57 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 79 HI
.....---- +----+---.+-"..---+----.----+----+-------+--+ .... 4 -- +-- -+...+..----+ .----- .. +-....+- -- +
I INSPDATE ROW .COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCHI INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+...----.---"+-....---+---..-----+ .. .. ..----.----.---- +.... .......---..--.----.----.-+-.--+
Tubes: 2 Records: 61 ST Max
SG - C Tubes with Lattice Grid Wear Indications
Braidwood AlR14 CCE 7720X 1 Tube with Lat.tice Grid Wear
Indication
a 12 Plugged Tube
lAin 1l~ 1~l.in 19~ 19in 11i~ 1101 1*n~ mm a~ am. 01.~ 01.01 7~ 701 01.~ 0101 . i01 A~ Am ~ u• 10 _;
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
.20
15
0 ~ ~ ~ . .. 0..0 0 o o"o . -•i :! : l i i tl0 0 1
. . . .o .. . -. : :. . .- . . .... :- ... .: :. . -:. 0.. Oo
_ __, .: I . .... . .-.-..:0-
00 ..._.
e I .. .. . . .
... . . .t 1
0-.COO. .I0
.. . . . . . . . .00
0. ~. .. . . . . 0 -
.o - . . . . I . . . .. 0o
00. ::::T00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 00
°o .. . . . . " ' ' " " ' ' " . . . . . . .' " " ' ' ' ' ' .'. ".. .' ' ' ' . . ... .-. ... ... ... . . ... .. . o
0-. . .. . . . . .. o 0o
115
110
105
100
95
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5 5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25' 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 14:30:51
SG - C Lattice Grid Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:42:48
+.........----+----. . ----+ ---..----.------------.-------- +- -+--...-----• + .+- +--- .. .. +- +
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+ ........... + ..... +----- - --- +.----+----+-.... -+-+ - - -+- - - +---- .---- +-- --------------
1 9 92 .23 0 PCT 5 P2 05C -1.54 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 47 HII 2007/10/01 9 92 .11 0 PCT 3. P2 05C -1.59 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 29 HI+....---- --------.. ---.-----------------. - - .- -- +---. .---- +..• --- -+- -+-- - +- ------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+...----.. .... +- .-+ .---.- ----- -------- ----------+ ----.---- + - --+ - --.--... ..-.. .-- +..-.---+.- .
Tubes: 1 Records: 2ST Max
SG -.D Tubes with Lattice Grid Wear Indications
BraidwoodA1R14 CCE 7720X 1 Tube with Lattice Grid Wear
Indication
a 1 Plugged Tube
.40 135 130 *125 120 115 110 105 . 100, 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 . 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
0oOOO
5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
-. ~~~~~ .. ..h7T7KKf 000.
__ .. . . . . . .......... ..._ _ _ _e .o ... •(..• ••.•••.••...o
.& v K . ....S... . .... .... . . . .. ..
. . . .. .... . . I .. ..... .. %
Oo . ..: : •: • , .. .. . :. • •, 1.. . . , . . 0.. . .o
0 r0o 00
oOC. 7F - -60
-0 - I . .. . . - -. . . . *S.0
00.
00 • •
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
0-o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . :.0.0O
5 c00 CAO 00, 0oo I 00 0 01 0C00 0 1OI 0 0 0 0 00o0 .o10 0 000 0 .00 0 0000 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0000 0 0 10 0 0,0 0 0
.140 135 130 125 120 115 .110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 . 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
5
Wesfinghouse Elechic Com~pany LLC -ST Max 04/11/2009 14:32:47
SG - D Lattice Grid Wear Indications with History
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 09:42:48
+ .. ... .. . +... ÷... + .. ... . ÷.. . ÷... ÷-- . .. .. - - --+--... ...--. ... ... +-. .. -... + ... . ÷----..-. -... ..... ..
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+. .----+----.----.+. ---.----------------... +--+ --. +---+----.. ..+----- +-+- ..... -- +
I , 41 70 .24 0 PCT 6. P2 08H -1.57 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 45 HII Ž007/10/01 41 70 .36 0 PCT 8 P2 08H -1.51 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 57 HI+-------.--- -------- ------------- +------------+--- -+--- +-.--------+--------------
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+.----..--------+ ------- +----+----+---.-+- --- +..---.....+---+ "-+----...+-+-+-
Tubes: 1 Records: 2ST Max
Attachment B.6
Tubes Repaired During A1R14
SG - B TUBE TO BE STABILIZED AND PLUGGED IN THE HOT LEG - REV 0
Braidwood AlR14 CCE 77201 1 TUBE TO BE STABILIZED AND
PLUGGED IN THE HOT LEG
a 39 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 .20 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 . 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10,,,o~o•.. oo.. oo.o• .t. .oo-00-L -I 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
_ -0 0-- 00S. . . . . .
00.0..0.00. '000..
0~ . ....... .. . .. . . . . . .0. .
0 ........ ..... . . .0-
0 . .. .... ..... ... ...ot ". . . . . . . . . . .. . . .
00.. .. . • •
0.0 . . ". ... .. ".".".'. .'."..'..0 0.
0..
0. . . . .°. . .. . . 0
0 . . . . ° . • • ° •
0 .. . . .-o°+... . . . . ..-
0 o ,. .• .:. . -. o • ... .: ... ....0..- : . .. . .- ..1 . .... • : .- • ... .. . .+ .. - .. • • ... ,. •
. . . . .. . . . . ... . . . . . .. .0,,,.... .. . . . ., .• . • . . . .•••
_"I• .° . .: .. : ~ .. . . . .. . . .. . .. 0o°°.••. .T• • . . •• . . . ••. .. • • . .•.'. . . .
J). .. . , • . ' . . . . .. .• " .• • . • . .• . • .,
'• . . . ... . . . . .... " ."...[
Oo -.-1." " .•.0"'
0 _•
I 00 0
.,.~~~~~- . . . . .''1..
o°•. ." . .. . . . . . . . . .
115
i10
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
°°d••--'' -•• " o'• o' "' '"o ' -o o0 to'-o '-' 0oo'-o 0-' o 4. .. o o o•"o o '--oojo'-o o'- "oo o o' -'' o ojo-'o o'-o o"o' o" o" oo'o'°0000000oot0 0000000 0 O000 000 0 000.0000 0 0 0 0000
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 .100 95 90 . 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
00
WestinghoucsoEledtic Conpany LLC -ST Ma 04/1111209 14:55:45
SG - B TUBES TO BE PLUGGED IN THE COLD LEG - REV 0
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720a 1 TUBE TO BE PLUGGED IN THE
COLD LEG
a 39 Plugged Tube
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
00 0010000(1 1 . . "-. . .00 .. o__00 0 0
0000 •000 .2....I . 0
0000
00 00
0 _00 000 ~ ___
0 . . .0.
oO . .:::: :::::" • ":':
0.. -. '-j ] _:0O . .,.. ._._::: : : : :: : : : : - T:: : : :
000.i
0 T' ' 0
.0 -0
I 00 -. ..... . ...... .....0O - . " . .' -. . . .. ..." .. . . . .. .... 0ooR
0 o , . . . . - . . _. z q _. _ _ .. ' ..•~ . ..'' l ' ' -.:.t.-. . -. .. 0
0._ ... ... . ... . .".-..
00 . 0 1 00 00 00 00 00 0 0 00
00 ., .. ..i l . 0 0. ... 0°oT :. . . . .., .'..-. .0
00.' '.. . ..'. . ".'. .'." . . . , . *
. . . . .".- .' .: . . t. . ;.oi. ...' ... . '..:; : 00'"
o' ." 00 0 00'.T '." * " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .0 0 0 0 0 - 0
O (D .... •• .. 0... .... .. .. .. .. -o%. .• .. + - -.." .... .... ", . . ....o. .
.".. ,' . . . . .• .' ' ."0 ... .. .. . . . . ~° . ••°%0--.o0,,o0-o.,•oo•o~ % i
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electic Company LLC - ST Max 04/11/2009 10:56:25
SG - B All Eddy Current Results for Tubes Plugged In U1R14
Braidwood 1 A1R14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 12:21:47
+---- +----+-------- +---- -------- ÷ ---- --- +--- +---------+........ - +- -
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+---- +----+---- + ------- +--------+----+---- --- - --.----.... .------ -- +- -- ÷
89 30 1.84 116 DTI P6 TSH .25 TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 15 HI89 30 1.29 63 SVI P4 TSH .25 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI89 30 1.67 62 PCT 73 P1 TSH .26 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 119 HI89 30 1.53 58 PID P4 TSH .25 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 89 30 NOD <TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 13 HI2006/04/01 89 30 NDD TEH TEC .560 SBALL 40 Cj2004/10/01 89 30 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBARH 31 HI2003/04/01 89 30 NOD TSH TSH .560 ZPSNM 65 HI2000/04/01 89 30 NOD TEH TEC .560 MBALL 2 CI1998/03/01 89 30 .00 NOD .00 TEH TEC .560 ZBALL 13 I
.. . .. ..-- - - ------- -- +- -- - ÷ .... ÷ - - - ÷ .. . ÷ ... .... ÷ .. ...- - +... ÷.... ---- ÷+---..---.-+-. . ..-- ÷
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI---- .---- ..----+--- -------- +-- ---÷+ --------.....--- +---.......---- • -÷ ---+ - ..-. - .... -- ÷
Tubes: 1 Records: 10ST Max
SG - C TUBES TO BE STABILIZED AND PLUGGED IN THE HOT LEG - REV 0
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720* 4 TUBE TO BE STABILIZED ANDPLUGGED IN THE HOT LEG
a 12 Plugged Tube
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
00|00° 0_0_0 0 0 0 0_ o _ _ _ _ _0
5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
0 0 .°. , -. F .i..~4.. T.~~o'io1
. . . . . . .00 .0,00_ 0 0. . . .. . 00 io0le - . .- 1 . . .0
0 . .. . . ... . . . .000 _ 0 ___
0.
0........00
F . ~ .. . . . . . . .0 .. r...........
._ 0 . . .. 0 _
00
00
0000 0000 00000000 0000 000
000 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 000
11e
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5-
10
5
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electric Com~pany [LC - ST Max 04/111/20019 14:30:34
SG - C TUBES TO BE PLUGGED IN THE COLD LEG - REV 0
Braidwood A1R14 CCE 7720* 4 TUBE TO BE PLUGGED IN THE
COLD LEG
a 12 Plugged. Tube
.40 135 130 125 20 115 10 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 300,o000 000,
fo- . . .. t. 0 0 .
25 20 15 10 5
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
-0.0
0..~~ ~ .7 . . . .. . . . . . . ... .. . . .. ... . .. .
0_ _.. . . .. .~~:~ .:::: . Im. . 7 . . . .7 T V 7
0-
. . . . . . . . . . . .70r . .l ... ---
-0-.. ~~~~~~~~~~ ~*~ .. . . . . . . . . . .-
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
75
70
65
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
50 0c 0~ o~o O Oo O o . . ' - .i o O o oo o•O O,00o 0 o o o 0 % 00o00 00 o o*.ýu; 0j; 0 000 I 00*40 135 13• 125 0.0005 1050100 9 9 050 075 0000700001 00 0 00 00 0 15 10 00
140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 ~100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
Westinghouse Electic Company LLC - ST Max 04/1112009 14:31:37
SG - C All Eddy Current Results for Tubes Plugged in U1R14
Braidwood 1 AlR14 CCE 20090301 04/11/2009 12:22:39
+ .. . ..-- - - +---- +----- + . .-- - +.+- - -- -+ . . .---- .-.+---- .+ ...- --+ . + - --++- - + ..- ..+-+- ++-- -- +- -+
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI+ .. .. ... .--- - .---- + ----. + - --. ----" - ---" - ---" ---- +--- - +- -- - +-- --. ----" . ." - - - ---.. + .. .. -- ----
28 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI28 63 6.12 82 PLP 11 TSH .33 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
1 .2007/10/01 28 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 HI1 2006/04/01 28 63 NOD TEH TEC .560 ZBARH 78 CI1 2000/04/01 28 63 NOD TEH TEC .560 MBALL 46 Cf1 1998/03/01 28 63 .00 NOD .00 TEH TEC .560 ZBALL 34
30 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 TBALL 69 HI30 63 .06 110 SVI P4 TSH .12 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf30 63 .10 287 PCT 9 2 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf30 63 7.62 83 PLP 11 TSH .15 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf30 63 .05- 89 PID P4 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 131 Hf
2007/10/01 30 63 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 59 Hf2006/04/01 30 63 NOD TEH TEC .560 ZBARH 76 CI2000/04/01 30 63 NOD TEH TEC .560 MBALL 46 Cf1998/03/01 30 63 .00 NDD .00 TEH TEC .560 ZBALL 34
27 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 HI27 64 7.83 73 PLP 11 TSH .13 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 HI
2007/10/01 27 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 Hf2006/04/01 27 64 NOD TEH TEC .560 ZBARH 78 Cf2000/04/01 27 64 NOD 09H TEC .560 MBALL 54. Cf2000/04/01 27 64 NOD F01 TEH .560 MBALL 87 HI1998/03/01 27 64 .00 NOD .00 TEH TEC .560 ZBALL 36
I ' I29 64 NOD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 67 Hf29 64 11.32 74 PLP 11 TSH .10 TSH TSH .560 NPSNM 123 Hf
1 2007/10/01 29 64 NDD TEC TEH .560 ZBALL 55 Hf2006/04/01 29 64 NOD TEH TEC .560 ZBARH 76 CI
1 2000/04/01 29 64 NOD TEH TEC .560 MBALL 46 Cf1998/03/01 29 64 .00 NOD .00 TEH TEC .560 ZBALL 36 I
.----. ----.--. ------ ------------- --- ----------- --------- ---------.. .----.- ------ -- ------- "
I INSPDATE ROW COL VOLTS DEG IND PER CHN LOCN INCH1 INCH2 BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL LI"-+÷--- - "---- "---- . . .-- - "----+----. ----.---- " -- -- ------------ -+- - ---- ------------------- +--- ------ -
Tubes: 4 Records: 28ST Max