Bec

htel

Pow

erB

echt

elPo

wer

JUO

TC P

rogr

ess

Rep

ort

June

�20,�2012

Bech

tel C

onfid

entia

l & P

ropr

ieta

ry

Age

nda

Age

nda

Minutes

�S

afet

y M

inut

e5

�P

roje

ct T

eam

5

Pj

PS

15�

Pro

ject

Pro

gres

sS

umm

ary

15

�D

etai

ls o

f Rev

iew

35

�P

relim

inar

y R

esul

ts15

y

�R

epor

t Rev

iew

Pro

cess

10

�Is

sues

5

�Q

uest

ions

30

2Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Safe

ty —

A C

ore

Valu

eSa

fety

—A

Cor

e Va

lue

Bec

htel

Oft

hld

't

id

bild

df

tt

tO

ne o

fthe

wor

ld's

mos

t exp

erie

nced

build

ers

and

safe

st c

ontr

acto

rs

Ove

r 24,

000,

000

hour

s w

orke

d, A

ND

CO

UN

TIN

G, i

n th

e P

Bi

Uit

itht

ltt

iid

t

3Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Pow

erB

usin

ess

Uni

t with

out a

lost

-tim

e ac

cide

nt

Bec

htel

JU

OTC

Pro

ject

Org

aniz

atio

nB

echt

el J

UO

TC P

roje

ct O

rgan

izat

ion

Sta

te W

ater

Boa

rdN

ucle

ar R

evie

w

Com

mitt

eeC

omm

ittee

Rob

ert H

eckl

erC

ompa

ny

Rep

rese

ntat

ive

Bry

an C

unni

ngha

mC

ompa

ny

Rep

rese

ntat

ive

SC

EPG

&E

Jim

Kob

yra

Pro

ject

Man

ager

K

Clin

t Lam

erso

nC

onst

ruct

ion

Dou

g D

ism

ukes

Proj

ect E

ngin

eer

Hin

dira

De

Lim

aP

roje

ct C

ontro

ls

And

rea

Mat

azin

ski

Pro

ject

Adm

inis

trato

r

KK

K

Pete

r Car

rEn

viro

nmen

tal &

Per

mitt

ing

John

Dav

ieG

eote

chni

cal

Nat

asha

Jon

esM

echa

nica

l

Yifa

n Zh

eng

Hyd

raul

ics

&H

ydro

logy

Yifa

n Zh

eng

Hyd

roge

olog

yPh

illip

Kas

sir

Civ

il/S

truct

ural

4Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Dep

th o

f Res

ourc

es —

JUO

TC T

eam

Dep

th o

f Res

ourc

es —

JUO

TC T

eam

Nam

eD

isci

plin

eYe

ars

Expe

rienc

e

Y.Zh

eng

Hyd

raul

ics

&H

ydro

logy

25Y.

Zhen

gH

ydra

ulic

s&

Hyd

rolo

gy25

M. N

agha

shH

ydra

ulic

s &

Hyd

rolo

gy29

K. N

gH

ydra

ulic

s &

Hyd

rolo

gy22

L. Y

oung

Hyd

roge

olog

y33

G. D

ayH

ydro

geol

ogy

27

J. D

avie

Geo

tech

nica

l42

N. J

ones

Mec

hani

cal

8

R.T

awne

yM

echa

nica

l35

T. M

urra

yM

echa

nica

l16

P. C

arr

Env

ironm

enta

l32

PW

anE

nviro

nmen

tal

40+

P.W

anE

nviro

nmen

tal

40+

M. G

olde

nE

nviro

nmen

tal

27

C. L

amer

son

Con

stru

ctio

n40

+

P.K

assi

rC

ivil/

Stru

ctur

al15

5Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

P.K

assi

rC

ivil/

Stru

ctur

al15

Proj

ect P

rogr

ess

Proj

ect P

rogr

ess

INSE

RT

PAG

E 1

OF

SCH

EDU

LE11

X 1

7

6Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Proj

ect P

rogr

ess

(con

t.)Pr

ojec

t Pro

gres

s (c

ont.)

INSE

RT

PAG

E 2

OF

SCH

EDU

LE11

X 1

7

7Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Acc

ompl

ishm

ents

Acc

ompl

ishm

ents

�P

hase

1 p

roje

ct te

am a

ssem

bled

and

func

tioni

ng s

ince

Apr

il 1

�Is

sued

pro

gres

s re

ports

�D

evel

oped

crit

eria

for r

evie

w o

f alte

rnat

ive

tech

nolo

gies

�C

onta

cted

the

maj

ority

of r

egul

ator

y ag

enci

es

�R

ecei

ved

tech

nica

l inp

ut fr

om c

oolin

g to

wer

sup

plie

rs

�C

ompl

eted

"Set

A" c

riter

ia re

view

s

�In

divi

dual

tech

nolo

gy re

port

deve

lopm

ent i

n pr

ogre

ss

8Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

wD

etai

ls o

f Rev

iew

Pro

cess

Ove

rvie

w

9Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w (c

ont.)

Det

ails

of R

evie

w (c

ont.)

INSE

RT

FLO

WC

HA

RT

11 X

17

10Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Rev

iew

Crit

eria

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Rev

iew

Crit

eria

�C

riter

ia S

et A

and

Crit

eria

Set

B—

Prio

ritiz

ed a

ppro

ach

for a

ltern

ativ

e te

chno

logy

revi

ews

—Ty

pe A

crit

eria

mos

t lik

ely

to h

ave

a fa

tal f

law

11Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

A C

riter

iaD

etai

ls o

f Rev

iew

Type

A C

riter

iayy

�Ex

tern

al a

ppro

val a

nd p

erm

ittin

g (n

onnu

clea

r li

i)

Type

A C

riter

ia

licen

sing

)

—Is

the

tech

nolo

gy p

erm

itabl

e in

the

stat

e of

Cal

iforn

ia,

asse

ssin

g po

ssib

le p

erm

ittin

g co

nstra

ints

and

site

-spe

cific

�Ex

tern

al A

ppro

val a

nd P

erm

ittin

g

�Im

ping

emen

t/

Entra

inm

ent D

esig

n

�O

ffset

ting

Envi

ronm

enta

l Im

pact

s

topo

grap

hic

and

area

l con

stra

ints

?—

Is th

e pe

rmitt

ing

proc

ess

for t

he te

chno

logy

suf

ficie

ntly

co

mpl

ex to

effe

ctiv

ely

prec

lude

com

plet

ion?

�Im

ping

emen

t/ent

rain

men

t des

ign

—W

ill th

e im

ping

emen

t/ent

rain

men

t des

ign

satis

fy th

e 31

6b C

alifo

rnia

Onc

e Th

roug

h C

oolin

g P

olic

y P

hase

II ru

les?

—Is

the

thru

slo

t/thr

u sc

reen

vel

ocity

less

than

0.5

fps?

yp

—D

oes

the

scre

en m

esh

size

or s

lot o

peni

ng s

uffic

ient

fine

in re

duci

ng th

e en

train

men

t? D

oes

this

re

duct

ion

mee

t the

Tra

ck II

crit

eria

rega

rdin

g its

com

para

ble

perfo

rman

ce a

gain

st th

e cl

osed

coo

ling

cycl

e op

tion?

—H

as a

fish

col

lect

ion/

retu

rn s

yste

m p

rovi

ded

at th

e tra

velin

g sc

reen

s?

12Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

—A

re th

e lo

catio

ns o

f int

ake

prop

erly

sel

ecte

d, i.

e., a

re th

ey in

less

bio

logi

cally

rich

are

a (o

ut o

f the

lit

tora

l zon

e)?

Has

scr

een

mat

eria

l bee

n pr

oper

ly s

elec

ted

to c

ount

er b

iofo

ulin

gin

a m

arin

e en

viro

nmen

t?

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

A C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

A C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

yy

�O

ffset

ting

envi

ronm

enta

l im

pact

s—

Will

the

cool

ing

syst

em te

chno

logy

cre

ate

addi

tiona

l env

ironm

enta

l or

detri

men

tal i

mpa

cts

cons

ider

ing

cool

ing

tow

er p

lum

e ae

sthe

tics,

drif

t-rel

ated

pa

rticu

late

em

issi

ons

and

salt

depo

sitio

n, la

nd a

vaila

bilit

y, c

oast

al im

pact

, di

tif

ih

bit

td

di

dil

dil

ili

ddi

srup

tion

of m

arin

eha

bita

t,dr

edgi

ng a

nd s

poil

disp

osal

, soi

l ero

sion

and

sedi

men

tatio

n, g

reen

hous

e ga

s em

issi

on in

crea

se, n

oise

impa

cts,

effl

uent

di

scha

rge

impa

cts

(ther

mal

, TD

S),

fresh

wat

er o

r gro

undw

ater

use

?

13Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

iaD

etai

ls o

f Rev

iew

Type

B C

riter

iayy

�Fi

rst-o

f-a-k

ind

to s

cale

Type

B C

riter

ia

—H

as th

e te

chno

logy

bee

n us

ed in

exi

stin

g or

pas

t nu

clea

r pow

er p

roje

cts

in th

e U

nite

d S

tate

s an

d ot

her

parts

of t

he w

orld

?

�Fi

rst-o

f-a-K

ind

to S

cale

�O

pera

bilit

y G

ener

al S

ite

Con

ditio

ns

�Se

ismic a

nd T

suna

mi I

ssue

s

�l

p

—H

as th

e te

chno

logy

bee

n us

ed in

any

exi

stin

g or

pas

t pr

ojec

ts in

the

Uni

ted

Sta

tes

and

othe

r par

ts o

f the

w

orld

?

�St

ruct

uras

l

�C

onstru

ctio

n

�M

aint

enan

ce

—Is

the

size

of t

he a

pplic

atio

n ap

plic

able

to th

e tw

o si

tes?

—H

as th

e te

chno

logy

bee

n us

ed o

n si

tes

with

sim

ilar p

hysi

cal c

hara

cter

istic

s t

Di

blC

dS

ON

GS

?to

Dia

blo

Can

yon

and

SO

NG

S?

—Is

it te

chni

cally

just

ifiab

le to

sca

le u

p th

e te

chno

logy

bas

ed o

n kn

own

data

?

—Is

the

tech

nolo

gy c

omm

erci

ally

obt

aina

ble?

14Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

yy

�O

pera

bilit

y ge

nera

l site

con

ditio

ns—

Will

the

tech

nolo

gy fi

t int

o th

e ex

istin

g ci

rcul

atin

g w

ater

sys

tem

?—

Will

the

tech

nolo

gy re

sult

in e

xcee

danc

e of

max

imum

allo

wab

le te

mpe

ratu

res,

al

arm

, and

/or t

rip p

oint

s?—

Will

the

impa

cts

to th

e pl

ant o

pera

tions

resu

lt in

una

ccep

tabl

e op

erat

ion

issu

es,

with

resp

ect t

o th

e pu

mps

, val

ves,

con

dens

er, a

nd o

ther

coo

ling

equi

pmen

t?—

Will

the

incr

ease

d de

bris

load

ing

issu

es b

e ac

cept

able

/man

agea

ble

if re

trofit

ted

tofin

em

esh

scre

ens?

tofin

em

esh

scre

ens?

—W

ill th

e in

crea

sed

diffe

rent

ial p

ress

ure

acro

ss s

cree

ns a

ccep

tabl

e if

retro

fitte

d to

fine

mes

h sc

reen

s or

wed

ge w

ire s

cree

ns?

—W

illth

ete

chno

logy

fitin

toth

eex

istin

gfo

otpr

into

fthe

site

?—

Will

the

tech

nolo

gyfit

into

the

exis

ting

foot

prin

toft

hesi

te?

—W

ill th

e te

chno

logy

suc

cess

fully

ope

rate

und

er s

ite e

nviro

nmen

tal c

ondi

tions

?—

Is th

e te

chno

logy

app

licab

le c

onsi

derin

g th

e w

ater

con

ditio

ns a

nd a

vaila

bilit

y at

th

esi

te?

15Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

the

site

?

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

yy

�Se

ism

ic a

nd ts

unam

i iss

ues

(eng

inee

erin

g)—

Can

the

tech

nolo

gy b

e pr

oper

ly d

esig

ned

for s

eism

ic re

quire

men

ts?

—Is

the

site

sel

ectio

n fo

r the

tech

nolo

gy s

ubje

ct to

una

ccep

tabl

e ts

unam

i flo

odin

g an

d ot

her e

xter

nal f

lood

ing

even

ts?

�St

tl

�St

ruct

ural

—C

an th

e st

ruct

ure

for t

he te

chno

logy

in q

uest

ion

be p

rope

rly d

esig

ned

agai

nst

criti

cal l

oadi

ngs

impo

sed

on th

em?

—A

reth

ere

unac

cept

able

impa

cts

toth

eex

istin

gst

ruct

ures

?A

reth

ere

unac

cept

able

impa

cts

toth

eex

istin

gst

ruct

ures

?�

Con

stru

ctio

n—

Is th

e te

chno

logy

in q

uest

ion

cons

truct

ible

bas

ed o

n cu

rrent

-day

con

stru

ctio

n m

etho

ds, p

ract

ices

, and

kno

wle

dge?

—W

hat a

re th

e in

stal

latio

n de

tails

nec

essa

ry to

det

erm

ine

that

fabr

icat

ion,

re

quire

d ac

cess

, and

ava

ilabi

lity

of s

pace

for t

he in

stal

latio

n an

d st

agin

g ac

tiviti

es, a

nd a

ssoc

iate

d ph

ysic

al m

odifi

catio

ns c

an b

e ac

com

plis

hed?

16Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Type

B C

riter

ia (c

ont.)

yy

�M

aint

enan

ce—

Wha

t are

the

expe

cted

mai

nten

ance

act

iviti

es fo

r the

tech

nolo

gy?

—H

ave

the

mai

nten

ance

act

iviti

es b

een

fully

iden

tifie

d th

at c

ould

cre

ate

a pe

rson

nel h

azar

d, a

nd/o

r unr

ealis

tic (n

onco

mm

erci

ally

via

ble)

ope

ratio

nal

mai

ntai

nabi

lity

burd

en?

Deb

ris h

andl

ing?

—A

re th

ere

corro

sion

or i

ncru

stat

ion

issu

es th

at m

ay re

sult

in u

nrea

listic

ally

fre

quen

t mai

nten

ance

of t

he te

chno

logy

?

17Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Det

ails

of R

evie

w

Det

erm

inat

ion

of S

erio

us F

law

sD

etai

ls o

f Rev

iew

Det

erm

inat

ion

of S

erio

us F

law

s

�Fl

aws

resu

lting

in a

"fe

asib

le"

dete

rmin

atio

n fo

r Pha

se 1

—N

ot m

eetin

g Tr

ack

1 re

quire

men

ts

—M

eetin

g im

ping

emen

t obj

ectiv

es b

ut n

ot e

ntra

inm

ent

—R

egul

ator

y ag

ency

com

men

ts re

gard

ing

any

posi

tive

impr

ovem

ent w

ill be

co

nsid

ered

—P

erm

ittin

g tim

e fra

me(

s)

�Se

rious

flaw

sre

sulti

ngin

a"n

otfe

asib

le"

dete

rmin

atio

n�

Serio

usfla

ws

resu

lting

ina

notf

easi

ble

dete

rmin

atio

n—

Tech

nolo

gy c

anno

t atta

in th

e Tr

ack

2 in

take

vel

ocity

<0.

5 ft/

sec

—La

nd u

se s

igni

fican

tly c

hang

es th

e ar

ea's

topo

grap

hy

Plan

tout

putd

e-ra

ted

requ

iring

addi

tiona

lcap

acity

tom

aint

ain

grid

relia

bilit

y—

Plan

tout

putd

e-ra

ted

requ

iring

addi

tiona

lcap

acity

tom

aint

ain

grid

relia

bilit

y

18Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Prel

imin

ary

Res

ults

Prel

imin

ary

Res

ults

19Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Rep

ort R

evie

w P

roce

ssR

epor

t Rev

iew

Pro

cess

�B

echt

el w

ill is

sue

draf

t rep

orts

for e

ach

tech

nolo

gy to

eac

h ut

ility

�E

ach

utili

ty w

ill im

med

iate

ly fo

rwar

d ea

ch re

port

to th

e R

evie

w C

omm

ittee

fo

r rev

iew

�Th

eco

mm

ittee

and

utili

ties

will

coor

dina

tean

dpr

ovid

eB

echt

elw

ithon

e�

The

com

mitt

eean

dut

ilitie

sw

illco

ordi

nate

and

prov

ide

Bec

htel

with

one

set o

f com

men

ts u

sing

the

Com

men

t for

m

�Th

e sc

hedu

le is

bas

ed o

n 2

wee

k tu

rnar

ound

.

�B

echt

el w

ill c

oord

inat

e w

ith th

ose

prov

idin

g co

mm

ents

for r

esol

utio

n

�B

echt

el w

ill is

sue

the

revi

sed

repo

rt

20Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Com

men

t Rev

iew

For

mC

omm

ent R

evie

w F

orm

21Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Key

Issu

esK

ey Is

sues

�C

lose

d cy

cle

cool

ing

is th

e on

ly m

eans

to c

ompl

y w

ith C

alifo

rnia

OTC

P

olic

y Tr

ack

1 cr

iteria

�C

alifo

rnia

Tra

ck 2

impi

ngem

ent c

riter

ia is

atta

inab

le (<

0.5

ft/s

ec)

Ei

bi

db

hC

lifi

Tk

290

%�

Ent

rain

men

t can

be

impr

oved

but n

ot m

eet t

heC

alifo

rnia

Trac

k2

90%

redu

ctio

n cr

iteria

�K

ey re

gula

tory

age

ncie

s un

able

to p

rovi

de ta

ngib

legu

idan

ce re

gard

ing

yg

yg

gg

gg

abili

ty to

per

mit

or ti

me

fram

es to

obt

ain

perm

its to

scr

een

out a

tech

nolo

gy

22Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Ope

n Ite

ms

Ope

n Ite

ms

�P

ract

ical

tim

e fra

mes

for r

egul

ator

y ag

ency

(ies)

per

mitt

ing

�P

ract

ical

ity o

f hyp

erbo

lic n

atur

al d

raft

tow

ers

on C

alifo

rnia

's c

oast

line

�S

ourc

es o

f rec

laim

wat

er fo

r clo

sed

cycl

e co

olin

g sy

stem

s

�Av

aila

bilit

y of

fres

h w

ater

for c

lose

d cy

cle

cool

ing

syst

ems

�In

tern

al B

echt

el re

view

s of

dra

ft re

ports

�Tr

ansi

tion

to P

hase

2

—N

ucle

ar R

evie

w C

omm

ittee

con

curre

nce

to p

roce

ed to

Crit

eria

#10

and

#11

23Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary

Que

stio

nsQ

uest

ions

24Be

chte

l Con

fiden

tial &

Pro

prie

tary