bao,isw+sz from aa +sdss

25
BAO,ISW+SZ from AA+SDSS R.M. Bielby, U. Sawangwit, T. Shanks, Durham University + 2SLAQ + AAOmega teams

Upload: yazid

Post on 06-Jan-2016

28 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS. R.M. Bielby, U. Sawangwit, T. Shanks, Durham University + 2SLAQ + AAOmega teams. Summary. SDSS, 2SLAQ + AAOmega LRG z surveys AAOmega photo-z LRG small scale clustering results AAOmega photo-z LRG BAO results AAOmega photo-z LRG ISW results - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

BAO,ISW+SZ from AA+SDSS

R.M. Bielby, U. Sawangwit, T. Shanks, Durham University + 2SLAQ + AAOmega teams

Page 2: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

Summary

• SDSS, 2SLAQ + AAOmega LRG z surveys

• AAOmega photo-z LRG small scale clustering results

• AAOmega photo-z LRG BAO results

• AAOmega photo-z LRG ISW results

• AAOmega photo-z LRG + ACO SZ results

• Sawangwit et al 2007, Bielby et al 2007

Page 3: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

1977 Precision Cosmology!

total= m=0.1

n=0

Isocurvature perturbations

Galaxy clustering +CMB

“Cosmologists - frequently in error but never in doubt!”

Page 4: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

2SLAQ LRG Wedge Plot

Page 5: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

AAOmega• AAOmega is the

new spectrograph for AAT 2dF (Sharp et al 2006)

• 392 fibres

• Blue and Red Arm

• AAOmega pilot in March 2006 to survey riz selected LRGs to z~0.9 (Ross et al 2007)

Page 6: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

1.5 million SDSS LRGs

• SDSS, 2SLAQ LRGs use gri colour-cuts

• AAOmega LRGs use riz colour-cuts

• Simply use w(θ) on colour-cut LRGs rather than photo-z

• w(θ) for three z bins:

• 100000 z~0.35 LRGs

• 600000 z~0.55 LRGs

• 800000 z~0.7 LRGs

Page 7: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

Small-scale LRG clustering

SDSSz=0.35

2SLAQz=0.55

AAz=0.7

Page 8: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

Large-scale LRG clustering

Are these BAO peaks or just some systematics?

Page 9: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

This is the scale where we expect to see BAO peak

Page 10: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

Combined w() results

3-D SDSS correlation function, (s) from 45000 LRGs (Eisenstein et al 2005)

2-D correlation function from 1.5 million DR5 LRGs (this work)

linear no wiggleSDSS (s) fit

linear no wiggleSDSS (s) fit

Page 11: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

“Filtered” w() - final result?

Linear theorySDSS (s) fit • But constant offset at

large scales

• Systematics?

• Subtract 0.0015 from w() to “filter”

• Now agrees with linear theory

• But poorer agreement with SDSS (s) of Eisenstein et al

Page 12: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

2dFGRS BAO?

• So photo-z route to BAO is hard…

• But so is spectro-z route!

2dFGRS

Page 13: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

linear no wiggleSDSS (s) fit

linear no wiggleSDSS (s) fit

LRG-WMAP ISW

Page 14: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

linear no wiggleSDSS (s) fit

linear no wiggleSDSS (s) fit

LRG-WMAP ISW

Page 15: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP Ka-band ISW?

Page 16: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP K-band ISW?

Page 17: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP Q-band ISW?

Page 18: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP V-band ISW?

Page 19: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP W-band ISW?

Page 20: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP W-band ISW?

AA now using SDSS Uber-calibration of Padmanabhan et al

Page 21: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

LRG-WMAP ILC ISW?

ILCSDSS 2SLAQ AA

Page 22: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

AA LRG clusters +WMAP WSZ?

• 10x the negative amplitude seen in ISW-LRG plot

• Possible SZ detection at z~0.7?

Page 23: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

Abell cluster + WMAP SZ

WMAP SZat 94GHz

Bielby + Shanks 2007astro-ph/ 0703407

Z=0.02 Z~0.1

Z~0.2 Z~0.4

172 Abell Clusters

235 Abell Clusters 38 OVRO/BIMAClusters

Coma cluster

(arcmin)

T

SZ effect decreases with z?

Page 24: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

VST ATLAS

VST ATLAS, ESO “core” project, ugriz (+VISTA VHS YJK) “Southern Super Sloan”, 2009-11

16k x 16k OmegaCam 1 deg2 field-of-view

2.6-m VLT Survey Telescope

1500deg2

3000deg2

Page 25: BAO,ISW+SZ from AA +SDSS

Conclusions

• SDSS colour cut LRGs at z~0.35 (SDSS), z~0.55 (2SLAQ) and z~0.7 (AAOmega)

• Small-scale (~1Mpc) feature confirmed in w() - important for HOD models and LRG evolution

• w() of 1.5x106 SDSS LRGs close to detecting BAO

• Possible ISW detections at z~0.35 and z~0.55 but only anti-correlation detected at z~0.7

• SZ detection at small-scales at z~0.7?

• More LRGs to come from VST ATLAS