assessment of support surfaces (static & mixed) for neonates m. m. sánchez-lorente 1 ; p....

16
ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez 2 ; J. Martos-Torres 2 ; A. Álvarez-Ordiales 4 ; & E. Balaguer-López 2-3 FP-50002 EWMA/GNEAUPP 2014 1. Conselleria de Sanitat, Valencia (SPA). 2. University of Valencia, Valencia (SPA). 3. Hospital Clínico Universitario, Valencia (SPA). 4. Hospital Universitari i Politècnic “La Fe”, Valencia (SPA). Presenting author: Mr. Pablo García-Molina

Upload: earl-kelley

Post on 29-Dec-2015

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED)

FOR NEONATES

M. M. Sánchez-Lorente1; P. García-Molina2-3; C. Vergara-Hernández2;

E. Sanchis-Sánchez2; J. Martos-Torres2; A. Álvarez-Ordiales4;

& E. Balaguer-López2-3

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

1. Conselleria de Sanitat, Valencia (SPA).

2. University of Valencia, Valencia (SPA).

3. Hospital Clínico Universitario, Valencia (SPA).

4. Hospital Universitari i Politècnic “La Fe”, Valencia (SPA).

Presenting author: Mr. Pablo García-Molina

Page 2: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Background

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Existence of several neonatal support surfaces

Lack of evaluation

Interface pressure & pressure redistribution Efficacy in the prevention or treatment of PU

however…

regarding…

Page 3: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Aim

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

• To assess the interface pressure and pressure redistribution of five devices of constant low pressure (static and mixed support surfaces).

152

43

Page 4: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Methods

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Study design• Laboratory study with repeated measures design.

Sample• Eight neonatal simulation dummies with different characteristics

regarding head circumference, weight and height.

Page 5: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Methods

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Support devices

Visc-T Visc-White Visc-Gray Visc-Blue Pol-3D

Structure Viscoelastic“T” units

ViscoelasticBlock

ViscoelasticBlock

ViscoelasticBlock

Polyester filaments

Layers 1 2 2 2 1

Density (Kg/m3) 50 50/50 50/50 40 NA

Hardness (Kpa) 1.6 1.01/5 1.01/3.6 2.5 NA

Compression factor 2 2/2 2/2 - NA

Page 6: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Methods

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Variables• Mean pressure (mmHg).

• Maximum pressure (mmHg).

• Mean pressure in head region (mmHg).

• Area of contact (cm2).

Equipment• XSENSOR X3 PX100:40.40.002 device.

Procedure• See: E-poster no. 50006.

Page 7: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Methods

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Statistical analysis• Descriptive statistics.

• Due to a small sample size, a non-parametric test (Friedman test) was carried out to assess differences among groups. If a significant difference was found, post hoc comparisons among groups were performed using the Wilcoxon-Nemenyi-McDonald-Thompson test.

• The analysis was carried out by means of the R environment (The R Foundation for Statistical Computing).

• Data set and code employed for the analysis can be found at www.figshare.com (*).*http://dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.977866

Page 8: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Visc-T Visc-White Visc-Gray Visc-Blue Pol-3D

Mean pres., x̅) (SD) 16.26 (2.77) 17.51 (3.32) 18.12 (3.32) 17.11 (3.07) 17.82 (2.58)

Max̅. pres., x̅) (SD) 24.58 (7.39) 26.79 (8.88) 28.15 (7.91) 25.49 (7.55) 27.53 (6.12)

Head pres., x̅) (SD) 17.25 (3.37) 18.58 (4.17) 19.53 (4.45) 17.95 (3.71) 18.7 (2.92)

Area, x̅) (SD) 19.29 (11.29) 22.11 (12.13) 22 (9.75) 23.52 (13.21) 29.23 (12.46)

Lowest values!

Highest values!

Page 9: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Friedman test χ2 Df P-value

Mean pres., x̅) (SD) 14,3 4 0,006

Max̅. pres., x̅) (SD) 11,2 4 0,02

Head pres., x̅) (SD) 8,7 4 0,07

Area, x̅) (SD) 18,51 4 < 0,001

Page 10: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Row-Column Visc-T Visc-White Visc-Gray Visc-Blue Pol-3D

Visc-T - - - - -

Visc-White 0,24 - - - -

Visc-Gray 0,005 0,61 - - -

Visc-Blue 0,71 0,93 0,17 - -

Pol-3D 0,056 0,97 0,93 0,61 -

Post hoc analysis: mean pressure (p-value)

Page 11: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

Page 12: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Row-Column Visc-T Visc-White Visc-Gray Visc-Blue Pol-3D

Visc-T - - - - -

Visc-White 0,32 - - - -

Visc-Gray 0,014 0,71 - - -

Visc-Blue 0,88 0,88 0,17 - -

Pol-3D 0,32 1 0,71 0,88 -

Post hoc analysis: maximum pressure (p-value)

Page 13: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

Page 14: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

FP-5

0002

EW

MA/

GN

EAU

PP 2

014

Row-Column Visc-T Visc-White Visc-Gray Visc-Blue Pol-3D

Visc-T - - - - -

Visc-White 0,71 - - - -

Visc-Gray 0,95 0,98 - - -

Visc-Blue 0,27 0,95 0,71 - -

Pol-3D < 0,001 0,053 0,01 0,27 -

Post hoc analysis: pressure area (p-value)

Page 15: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Results

Page 16: ASSESSMENT OF SUPPORT SURFACES (STATIC & MIXED) FOR NEONATES M. M. Sánchez-Lorente 1 ; P. García-Molina 2-3 ; C. Vergara-Hernández 2 ; E. Sanchis-Sánchez

Conclusion

The “T” device presents the best values of pressure relief.

The polyester fiber device presents the best values of pressure redistribution.

Adding an upper layer of polyester fiber to the “T” device could result in a better support surface.

Next step: studying the properties of the new support surface in healthy subjects under clinical conditions.