archive of sid...references ˝˛˚ myy - fraser, s. (1995), the bell curve wars: race , intelligence...

30
* * * : (Capability Poverty Approach) . : . : . . : (Neglect) . . : : / / : / / * < [email protected] > * * chive of SID

Upload: others

Post on 30-Aug-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�z�

������G�% A�H�?�= '��� �>7,BC �?�H �I:�'��?/ A JK

������ �� �� *

����� ����**

����� ��: ������� � � ��� �� ���� ��� (Capability Poverty

Approach) �� �������� ��� ��� �� ����� �� ��� ���! �" �#��� ���$�� %�& '��� � (�)��) ��) � ���*" +,� �-#� .���*$� /0#� '�� .������ ��1��

2��) 3���4 �"� �����4 %���1. ��:6��7 3����� %��� 8&�94 :���� �� ���;� ���� �� � �"� %���1

����� (1 � �� ��<�4 =�>��-� %�&?�@� =��A �� �#��� �� B�C��C �� � �#�3�� �"�� � �D��� �E�F�G� �����" ��@� ��� .

� ��� ��:2��) 3���4 '��� ���>! +���E �� ���� %���1 �#��� ������� � 3�##)�"� (�)��) ��) � ���*" +,� �-#� .���*$� /0#� '�� .������ ��1�� . �H�!

��� �"�� �� =�>��-� �F&3�7 ����! (�7��7�� ��IJ � ���1 '� %���1 6��7 �7 ���3������ �� ���� K�>L %��M��� ��>L� �� � �� %�& �"� =�HN ��" �� !.

��� � � ��� ����:3������ �� �"�"� %�&���� +���O ����! (� �� �� %�&��� �� 3�PE �� .�"� ����� ���$� �� � F��� ������ %�� (�7��7 ����! ������ +

��IJ .3������ =��O ����� %�� � F� ��1�� +���O(Neglect) ��� �� (�7��7 �� 3������ 3������ �� �<�� �"�$,� �N �� �& �"� Q�� �� R"��� ��1�� �� %�& .

�FG �� S�L�! �T�� �U#! � �#C & ���U� %�#� �$�� (�7��7 ���1 3�#&�� � K��V� %����� �� ��� �� WU� !�#��� +���E �� 2��) ��" �"� %���1.

���� ��� � :� �� ���� ������ ����

���� ���� :��/�/!" #��$% ���� :��/�/!"

* �N6�A�� $N12CF* "H ��DE��� $��N�� ��'� $E<�jB ���� "a =$(�!�$Eo-��" �

<[email protected]> ** @��F ��DE��� $��N�� "H ���� c�!���6

���� � �� ��� � �� ����

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 2: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�z�

�����

B,� �$,� ,�,� ���%�A�� �� f" !�@%�C � !-7��� ��3�� ����� . �� (�F���D !-R��*�3� /�0�� ("�P�-��� �� ��� �B3�� �!"!� ��:f' � �$,� ��3�� ����� ���9 ��9

B,� �$,� ������ %� )���� ��=+� � �?� :j�3� �� f" ) �7�1;�Mz� .( %� B�Q,B,� C��C 2�%�� ��l� BV �!' �� +�39%A� . �� f" 2�C��C *��f !'% 8�����

�?� � (":���; (��$ !--COB,� 8!' ��F�-' B�Q, ;�7��� )�2��["� � ���X, �Mxx .( �(43� � 8�-D�, ��_Y :��' ,�,� ������� � 9!�� B���C C��C 2�%�� %� �9�

���I� (��� S%��D � S���@ �B'�!?� ���'�DLG� 2�%�� %� B���C �� 9!�� {" LG�� +�39%A� ���-��B3��.

�0 C��C 2�%�� %� B���C �� 9!�� LG�� %�(� %� !-7��� � WQF 2�3�� %�?� �%��B,� 2@ �� pD 2 .� 2�C��C %��@ �!� � !��� ���!�� �HF �� �% 2��@ B�Q, �� . %�

%�� %� %��@ �� :a�& ���!���D �%��� F��O BV �% 2�9!"�%��@ B'���, :C C��C B,� 8��� %��G ��l� ) �F��?G �!��Mxu.(

8��� 2�I� %��3� ��$+�H� ���\�G� � ;�7��� B�$0� �C !�������F 8 ��� f" !��� ���?� � ��' g�3V� �%��@ s��C �� k= �� :���; (" .�["� �%�=; �� B�$0�

���\�G�� ;�7��� 8�����F ������ �*7� �� �� �� !��� ��$+�H� %� :��3� ����� 2��-; �� <����s��C ���9 %��G ��� �%�� �%��@ . :�+� �� 8!"�%��@ 2�C��C �["� ��, �� ���

��!a !-����� A9�� B,� (f7� 9!"�%��@ �� :a�& ;�7��� � ���% �73� � %�^�� +�39%A� ��F �� �% ��F ��� !--C ��"� �X��� %� � %�C � Z3C ��q� %�

2�3�� � !��I� ���� ���B"�?� %� !��X-�� 2��@ ��� �� ��� ("� .s��C %� �%��@8� �C ("� �� 8�Q; �!� �lw A�� !'% �� �C� � � =\; 8�[�,� %� )Q�F� �;�� �%�_9

� -7"� ��' . �%���% � �F�-' �,�3&� �;�7��� �iQ�F� �� �X-� B"�?� %� ��� ("�� 8!"�%��@ s��C %� ��' .s��C m%��; A�� �!�!-*� %� >�X�� �� ��� :"�7 %� �%��@

�� 3-� B�+�$� � %!5� ���� o�\� }�, !-��� �HF�D ���%���% ���� �C >�[-��

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 3: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�zM

B,� g�5� ��� ���% � 73� B�Q,�� ���� ��' .("� PX��� �QfI� :��' 7��? ���%���% � �1��& %� )Q�F� ���%�C >�X�� %� )Q�F� �9��3�� )Q�F� � ���[�

B,� ) �#3���"�Mxz .(�� %��%� �C �$+�H� )�d� 2��-;O( 2��� 2����� 2�G%�, �S���� � 2��� �B,� 8!' >�X�� 2����$�� 2�I� �� "i�� B=3� �C !��2@ �� �� f" ����G

s��C )�f'� �%��@�C��C 2�%�� %� 3-� 8����,�}�, -$" �!-�3� ) �A�!�9�Mxu.( %�>�X�� ��$+�H� h�,� �� LG�� ("� )�7�&� �f"��� %� 8!' �� ������ ��2@ �� �� 8����,�}�,

3-�B,� 8!'%A� %� !��' ��[�,� ��[��,�% >�� �� +�39�z,z��I�� %�� �� �*�3� ("� ����G �� B,� ������8!I� !�� .(Widom, 1995) (�-67� �� ���� � 2����

������ �" ���� %�2@ �� B,� 8!' ���X �� 3-� B�+�$� >�X�� �� %�=X� �" � 8!' !��,("� )�7�&� �C��& %�P!--� %�� ��[��,�% , `� ��I�� %�� ���3� B,� ����G ��

8!I� �*�3� ("� !�� .(Population Report, 2000) ez �� !���� S%�A9 2���,�% �� !a%� ���� %�2@ �� B,� 8!' ���X �� � `~ g�0 �%�� ���� %� �� !���� S%�A9 !a%�

����9 %��G ��' � !�� .(Farley, 1988)

�(�� �� ��

("� �� 8�Q; �Cs��C �� �%��@ !"!D {" 2��-;O ;�7��� :fI� {" ;�7��� (Social Problem) � g�3V� A�� >�� ;�� �B,� ��' .��� Z��� �� ��"�O � 2���G

2�������� 2�C��C �� B"�7& :» ��' Z��� �C 2������� � 2�C��C %��@ � B"�� /�� ���!a 2��@ ��P ��' �%�� GQF� � ���% �" ��73� �� �% 2��@ 2��% �" �3� B�Q, �

���!�� 8�N�5��B,� /�-7� « ) �+�-"��Mx� .(� :*; (��= h�,� ("� �� /�G� :���;s��C �"�1� g�R%�R %� �%��@ �$��� ��� >�� � �F�-' (���9 �1� %� �� � �F�-'!���D("� 8��& �� 2�f�� � �"_D ��'.

,%�� %�H��% P7��� �QfI� � ��� (�� �%�� %�l@ %� �C >�� � ;�(Murray,1990) 2�3*"� � 2�3���, �(Sampson,1993) %A"�� �(Fraser,1995) ��� �

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 4: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�z`

(Mooney,1998) �B,� 8!' ��F���D 2@ �� ��I�� ��� �QV� %� ;�7��� �����, ��� %��3� (�I�����B,� 8!' .2@ ;�� �%�!"�D �� ��»B��IF �-��� « ���=N 2��� %�

�� (5, ��?' B,����9� !�� ."�1� )�& �� %�P ���� ���"� ��!& � ;�7��� %��F�, !-C (��= �% >�� � ;�7��� :fI� �� ;�7��� k"��' (�� !���D 8!' . :[�,)�Mxe (

F�' �, (�� !���DP"�1� P� -$" ;�7��� %��F�, "�1� �;�7��� �����,P � %�I� "�1�P�7� %� �% [-��� o��V�� %�� 8%�7'� 8��� 2�I�B,� .

������� :� � ������ ���� ����� �� ������ ������ ���� ���

��� ����� �� �

)A-� B�$0� �B��f, :V� �(�j�D !�@%� � ��� �?� ��+|� %�?R �0�& ^���D %�H��% � 2�C��C )���'� B�$0� � ��f3�P 2@ ��s��C �� �%��@"�1� g�R%�R %� P

,%�� ;�7��� %��F�,B,� 8!'. %��%��3� ^���D $+�H� �*7� �� ��P 9!�� B�$0� � %��@ (�� 2�%�f7� � ("Q"��D

9�����F���� � h� :��' �H��% PB,� 8!' S%�A9 �%���-$� (paavilainen, et al ,2000) .�9��(Berger,2005) H��% ,%�� �� ��F ^���D %� P@%� BF���D 2�C��C %��@ � %����F !�

2�}�\$D!<�' ���/��

: M(" \�!<�' ���# �< :Z5��A�< ���# $D!<�'

2�}�\$* x;/% x2��� �* C6��N% $��%5�(

: ���5 �* �� ,�/% : �M%�� X(�!% ��N!6 �

: ���� ���F- A�<

: Z5�� ��aN% $��N�� A�<

2�}�\ �<�;(� � ���<� �* C6��N% ��E'

: �T���� h25" \,��� � ,��V : 7;%��/%

: Z�� ��< �* e;� A��* G2CD2�� A�<

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 5: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�ze

�D �C ��� 2�I� �"�� %����F !�@%� 2��� (� �X-� 2�C��C %��@ ��I�� ���� �� �%���-$� %�N� ��' ) �2��["� � ��'�F�Mxu.( $+�H�P � ��� �C ��� 2�I� A�� 2�%�f7� � � >��*"�

!-�3� �%��@ s��C �� �l�� :���; �� ("!+�� �%�f�� (William, 1. et al, 2006). H��% ,%�� �� �C �$+�H� ��7 ��=+�P��F���D ;�7��� �QfI� � >�� �� ��� �!��

8��f� !�"w �% �H��% ("� !�� (messner,1982) . ^��%�f7� � C {�)�~u~ (8��C !�C� !��7� "�?- �� ��� �C 8��9 %� >�� /��' ��"� ���' g�3V� >�� :��; !��� �5� ��� #*

B,� ������ ���� . p��*��)�~~� (� A�� !"�9� �� �X-� ��� %�I� �X��� %� � ��+��3�� ;�7��� o��V�� ��' ) �G��a�MxM(.

2�I� �f"��@ %� ��X ��$+�H�� !�� ;�7��� �QfI� � �"��� F�� �� ��� �C H��%P �%�� B=d� (Jacobs, 1981) . 2�3��%@ )�~xx ( ��$+�H� %� !�,% �X��� ("� �� ��F

�������� bH, �C $����2@ %� B,i�� �� A�� >�� ��� ���I����� !���F . �� �X��� ("����� �� 8�Q; �C B,� 2@ ��-$� ^�� >�� � ;�7��� �QfI� ���� %� A�� ��������

�%�� ��l��. )�G��a �MxM.( +� :9�� �%�� �$+�H�)�~~e (A�� �����C %����& �� ?�� Z+�� v"�B,� �� �C

2@ ��-=�(�� ���\�G� �������� �H��% ��5'� ��*; �"��� P�=d� ���� �"��� �� ��� �%�� H��% )���� ��*;P�%�!� �%���-$� .� 2�I��N�F �$+�H� ("� s��C �C ���, �� �%��@

� g�3V� ��5'� ��*; �"��� �"��\� ��' .

�(���

���(���� ��

("� %�����" :�*V �� ^���D %��%� (�I�D ��$+�H� ���OH��% P �8�����F +�� B�$0� �H-� �(f3� B�$0�P2�C��C %��@ �� ("!+�� )���'� B�$0� � B��f, :V� � :�*V

��>�1� ,%�� -�(�I�D ��$+�H� !,%�� %�C_� �H��% B,� 8!' .

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 6: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�zu

���(������

�����(���

�� �� }�f � �� ��� )�7$� %�N B����% �� � ��F�-' U��'B����% ("� �� f" �� ��» ����*H� « (f3� ��_Y :��' ,�,� ������� :G�!& (��� ���� ��C !�@%� (�'�!� ��-$� ��

�s�'�D � !"!D �� ��["� � �%�� 2�;�� S���@ � B'�!?�O» =3� ��� « �� ��� 2@ %� �CF�-' #*�5� L���� %� 9!�� �%�!���,� �� ��� � �� ��' ) �A�!�9�Mxu .( 2��� ("� %�

��, ��f"�%�� 2��-; »��*��G ��� «�$��� � 2������\�G� ��� �%�� ����9 %��G 2�,�-'B,� .:G�!& � !�@%� (��w �� ��I�� �A�R �� ��*��G ��� ��f"�% ��� 9!�� ���

� L��� ��[� �� � !-C�(f7� �C �% *���; >�7 "�,�-' 2�f�� {" ���� $��� B,� !-'�� %�F %� � B���C �� 9!���� ����� ���, .) �(,�Mx�(.

B�*��G 2�!�� �+��� ("� %� � {7C 2�3�� �� �C "�� !'�� ��'�� %�F%� 9!�� � !-C�� � ��!7*G ��� 2��-; ��' . #"�$ ��*��G B����V� Z3& �� ��� �["� �%�=; ��

� ��' .�f"�%��*��G ��� ��=?� �� �C B,�-$� !��� �$,� �� ��[� g�R%�R %� ��%�� >�A�+� Z���� >�7 %� �I� 9!�� . (, �� %��@)Sen, Amartya ( %� �% �$,� >�?��� �V� �� B�*��G ��f"�% g�R%�R �%�_9 .����@ /���� �� ��� ���� 2��� 2�I� � ��

/���� (�� �H��%2@ �� �?� � ��f"�% �%���,� ("B,� B�*��G .� �� !3"�� :» ����@ 2�!��� ���\�G� 2�7� B,%� ���' ;�7��� ����@ 2�!�� �� �X-� !��� ����@ 2�!�� �C %�N

� A�� ,��, �" ;�7��� ��' ���\�G� ����@ 2�!�� �� ?�-� !��� . « ^�� Z� � ("� ����9��P� %�f'@ �$,� !-"��� %� ����@ ��' . �� 8�Q; (, ����@ �� B�7�� �� ���

�� � !�Cw �$,� !-"��� %� 2@ �%�A�� ^�� ���"� �� ��$,� o!� ���d� !-C . �� 8�9!"� ������@ B,� L��-� � ���l �S���@ ��%!G �� ,��,� %� ����@ :��' �� . /���� k3� ��

B�*��G !'% �"�N �� ����@ � :�?3 ��*��G B����V� L�% ��� ��' .("� �� �� �C �%�a {" ���9 �, ����@ �["� ��, �� � !-�3� �$,� "�?� o!� ����@ ��� �%�A�� ���� �C

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 7: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�zz

!��["!f" :7f��B�*��G S��39 �� B"�?� %� $,� Z��� >��� ���P � ;�7��� � ���\�G� !��' .*�,� �?- !�@%� ��f"�% ("� %�PB�*��G �*F !-��� *���; � B3�� ��

Q, �B�3-� �(,B�*��G 2!' %�%�� �� A�� 2�f� � B� :�F� �� �!� . (, ��=$ ���IR ��*��G ��!���S��39 !-��OB,� B����V� � ��� :*; � B���� �� �[I���D s%� .

�*�,� �� o�a ��� ��, � B7, ���� �� �C �%�a ("� �� ��, �� !�@%� >�� �� ��o!� ��V )�=�� �� >��� �C "��2@ ��@ �!-�3� ���� �% ������ (��w ���� ���� �%�� ���

� ����� ���, )�(, �Mx� .(

�����(���� ����

}�, ����% �" 73� Z�,@ ���9�� 8�?� �" 3-� 8����,� �� 9!�,% >!; � IC �"� ����� ,�,� ��������x �!'�=� ���\ ��Y �C %�a �� � ����� �["� k,� )�,

s��C � �* �%��@ �'� (Ludwings & Kornberg, 1992) . SQ #"�$ ("� �R�9�7� � 8��CP �!�� b�0� �% 2�C��C %��@ ��$�� � 8��� ��)�& �� (�� %� B,� (f7�

Z&�a 2��1�!'�� A�[���� oQ�F� 2@ %� �%!-� ������ �� �%��3� . �� ��� �� LG�� %�#"%�$ �/�-�� ������%�C � o�!�� %��@ �� ��!$�� B,� 8!' �j�%� B��IF � . (7X��

R���� (��%�?R %� �f"��� f'A����%P ���% �iQ�F� �%��@ � \�5I ��7-��% )�~~`( 2��-; BV *\� %� �» %��G -�+�� ��� �%�� B,� (f7� �C H"��' �"�,

���9« s��C � �3-� � 73� %��@ �� :7�I� �% �%��@ �N�; %��@ � s��C �� ?�� � �!�� )DSM-IV .( �%��@ � \�5I ��7-��% ^"��"� (��%�?R %� �C a�F :j�3�

8!' ]�H� ���% �iQ�F� �%�=; �!�� ��� !� : %���% }�, �s��C �� 73� %���% }�,s��C �� 3-�� s��C �%�� %� �V��3� . �C B,� *C ]QHa� {" s��C �� �%���%!�

���� 2�f'A����% ��I�� 2@ �� 8����,� � !--C (Kaplan & Sadock, 1989). 2@ �� s��C �C �� �%��@��%��B,� ;�7��� � -�+�� �G��& 8��� �_+ � �� Z,�-��

� W�� �����f"�% �� {" �� ��C �j�%� 2@ �� ����� #"%�$ 2�� .(�-67� �-���

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 8: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�zx

s��C #"�$ %� ,�,� ^�� �%�� �%��@ ._+2�C��C %��@ (�� !"�� ��%��� %� � � B=G��� !' :j�G A"�7 2��@ �� ���C�� ��� .��C�� B=G��� %��=-� P B=G��� >!; � o_&

� ]�H� s��C �� >�i ��' )Rutter, et al, 1994 .(��=���C � A[-"���+ )�~~x ( SQ 8��C 2�C��C ��*; B��IF O��� �� �� 8����,� �� �% 2�C��C %��@ #��F � !"!' �%��� � !��

��%!� � {�f� 2�C��C �� �%� 8��C!-�� b�0� � . s��C )�& �� %� Z�,@ ���%���% �� $�,� #�N �%��@ �� >!; :�=G �� (��� �������

�+��PB=G��� �� B*�Y �s��C �f"A�� �%���%!� � ��=- ���C !'% 2�!�� ��'�!?� ���}�, :��' �% ���% %��@ � ��X�� %���%}�, � 3-� 8����,�� ��' .

s��C ���?� B'�!?� 2����, #"�$ ���H� �%�=; �%��@� Z�,@ �� B, !"!? �" �C ������ �" ("!+�� B,� �� s��C �3"A?� � 8��% � ���$, �" � 2��% � �3� B�Q,

!-�3� )��3� �� �� B=3� ) �2��["� � "�*[���G@�Mxy.(

�(����� ��

ti�7$� 8!"�%��@ 2�C��C8�����F %� �� 9!�� "� ��f3� )A-� �C !--C2@ �� %��3� {R�C=,�- � B,� 8�����F B�$7� �� �%�!� .8�����F ("� %� 8�Q; �� �s�'�D ��_Y ��

-"A�P B�% !�@�� (��w �5, �� �Q�?3 �"�, � 8�����F q$� %� �& � ��' �� �� {7C ���� �"A9�� A�� 2�C��C �C B,� �!& �� ��� �!' %�C �� 8�����F S�$� (��w

� ��'���� !��'(Ludwings &Kornberg, 1992).

�%��3� ��$+�H� %�H��%P ���% � 8�����F ;�7��� � ���\�G� B�$0� 2��� s��C ,%�� � ���V �%��@�%�aB,� ����9 .^���D ^���D %� A�� ���"� 2��9 ���

9 ?��I� v"��� � 8��C ��� �*�3� ("� �� ��F8��� S%�A !�� . :���; %�C_� ��$+�H� %� /�� �8�����F +�� L0� � !�@%� 2�A�� �*7� �� "������� Z3& �� ;�7��� � ���\�G�

�H-� ���f3� )A-�P8!' ,%�� %�C �� 2�C��C )���'� �" � B��f, :V� !�� .("� %� ��S%�A9 ("� v"��� {�f� �� ,%�� ��� �-C�:

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 9: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�z~

���(�� ��� ��� ���� �� ���� ����

8�����F �� � �$��� �� �C 7?� :���; �� f" � %��G ��lw BV �% �� � � !�� !��� �-��� ��,s��C ���\�G� Z,�-��� B�$0� �!'�� �%��@� B,� ;�7��� . � ���

s��C !�%�� �� �� ���"� t��=3� [�3=7� �%��@ .8�����F %� �C ��C��C 9!�� ���� ���� � !--C� B"��!V� � k"��' :�+� ����� ���2�C��C �["� �� �3"��� %� ���7C -7"�

!�%�� .�"_� ��'�!?� ������� ����3� ��Y �" ����3� :f' �� ���% � '���@ ���) ������-��� 9�����F � ���� :���; 2�%�@ �%��@ s��C ��, (� /��' � ���� 2�A�� !���

A�� �% �%��@ s��C !�� ^"�(Ludwings & Kornberg, 1992). v"���{" ��% �� �$+�H� Mys��C ("!+�� �� ��� �$���� %��@ �3"A?� AC�� �� 8!--C

� ���a g��� !�?'Mys��C ��Y ("!+�� �� ��� 3"��� o!� �� %��@P � ;�7��� B�$0� ���\�G�8�����F �� 8��9 �� ("� �� 2�I� � !����� B�$0� (�� �C �� ���\�G� � ;�7

�%�� ���� �%���-$� ���� 8��9 . !'�� ��I�� ���\�G� �QfI� �R �� �C �-$� ("� ��s��C )�7�&� B,� ��I�� �%��@ ) �g�?'�Mx` .( %�*�� <�= %� (�7� %�)�~x� (

� !3"�� :»}�, !-R�� �7� %� � 8�����F ���9�� %� B,� (f7� 2�C��C �� B=3� %���%� �$��� ]�H,B�$0� � 2@ /�G� +� !�� �% ���\�G� � ;�7��� #*�5� ���� ��

���\�G� (�"�D ���=N %� ���'%�A9 h�,�� B,� ��I�� ;�7��� « ) ��%�!����Mzz.( �R�9�7� ��F ���F �� ��� !'�� 2�C��C �� �%���%!� B*; !��� � ���H0� �C

� ��X"� ��� �� 8��7� ��'�B,� ��"� %��3� .��$+�H� >�X�� 8!' !�@%� (�� [�3=7� s��C � 8�����F 8��C !�"w �% �%��@ !�� . ���a ���V v"��� %�)�Mz` ( ��% ��

8!���D �C !' E5I� 2��? *�;�7,� !�?' 8�[���%� %� ����� ���e� �� !a%� 8�����F !�%�� �*$ �$��� ���� � B,���� ���\�G� ���=N �� 8!"�%��@ 2�C��C ��� .

`ya%�8�����F ! �?- � !-�'�� k,��� ���\�G� B�$0� ��~ !a%� 2@ �� ���� ���=N �� !���� /�7��� .("!� Z� � �����V ("� 2�I� !-��O B=3� ��73� %���%}�, ��I�� /��'

8�����F %� s��C �� (�"�D !�@%� bH, �� ���B,�.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 10: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�xy

�!�'% ��)�Mzu ($+�H� ��P��� ��� �?' 2������� �� ���9 (�[���� �C B��9 �X 2�I� �%���-$� ���� p-� �� �� %� 8!"!�%��@ � 8!"�%��@ 8��9 (�� 8�����F !�@%�

� ������ !�@%� (�[���� � !�P%��@ 8��9 8!"!���@ 8��9 �� B=3� 8!"�% p-� �� �� %� ��� � i�� . �$+�H� ("� v"��� h�,� ��e/Me � 2���F� !a%� ~/�~8!"�%��@ 2��3D !a%�

�=N %�P (�"�D!-�'�� %��G ���\�G� . 8!"!�%��@ 8��9 %� �C +�& %�M/z � 2���F� !a%� �/�!���� B�$0� ("� %� 2��3D !a%� .

2��? �?' %� �C ��["� ���V %�bH, %�^��� %�� ��F� 2����@O "�7-��% ��73� %��@ � 8�����F +�� B�$0� (�� A�� B��9 �%�a�S%�A9 �N�; 8!' ��

� �%���-$� <�= %� �2�C��C ��,� !�@ B,� .8��� 2�I� ��� !���� ��!& �C x �� !a%� !"�%��@ 2�C��CO � 73� M!"�%��@ 2�C��C �� !a%� O�=N %� �N�; P (�"�D ���\�G�

)!� +�� L0� (!-�'�� %��G .!"!�%��@ 8��9 %� �C +�& %�O ��!$ �N�; � 73� ^��� �� ���7C 2����@!���� ��=N ("� %� ) �2��*$I5��Mzz.(

I���D %���["� ^��� S%�A9 h�,� �� 2����@>�F �?' ���@ ���\�G� B�$0� (�� �}�, � 8�����F �N�; � 73� %���%2@ �� ��!' S%�A9 �%���-$� <�= %� . ^��� 2��� ��

!���� 8��C S%�A9 �% 73� %��@ ��"� �" �C 2�A�� �� �C �����@�/M` B�$0� !a%� +�� !���C #�a� !� �% 2�' .^��� %� �C +�& %� !���� 8!"!� 73� %��@ �C �����@ �?- �y!-�'�� !� ���\�G� B�$0� !a%� . v"��� A�� �N�; %��@ ,%�� %�� 2�I� ���

^��� �C ��� 8!"!�%��@ 2����@ �C +�& %� �!-�'�!� %��G ���\�G� !� B�$0� %� >�!C �/�` 8%�'� !� +�� L0� �� !���� 8!"� ���"� �" �C �N�; %��@ �C �����@ ^��� �� !a%�

!���� 8��C ) ��%�!����Mzz.( �$+�H� %� ��bH, %� �C �["�^��� %�� �3D 2����@O2��? �?' "�7-��% !' >�X�� �

%��@ ���7� (�[����)B*�Y ��N�; �73� (^��� ��, �� 8!' S%�A9 �� 2����@ ��� 8�����F ���\�G� B�$0� �� ���2@ �� �3"��� !' . (�[���� (�� �C ��� 2�I� ���V v"���

^��� %��@ ���7� -$� ���� ���\�G� #*�5� ]�H, %� 2����@� �%�� ���� �%�� .

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 11: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�x�

("!� #�$0 8�����F ���\�G� B�$0� �R�� �C Z� � � � �7� (�[���� ��'O %��@ S%�A9 2�C��C ��, �� 8!'� � i�� ��% ) ���F!7V��Mzx.(

� ��)�Mzx (��$+�H� P�����F ���\�G� B�$0� O �z!"�%��@ s��C O �� �C 3-� �%��� �dC� %� �C B��"%� �!���� 8��C �$���� ����G f'AD AC������ �C ���� 8�"� ��F�

��� ����9 %��G 3-� %��@ �%�� %!D ��, �������F �O � ���'@ �s��C (�"�D bH, %�;�7���� �'�� %��G ���\�G� !-.

��A" ��G��)�Mz~ (%��%� ���V %�O!"�%��@ 2�C��C O ��73� �C 8�[���%� �, �� 2��? �?' )��N�!���� 8��C �$���� �% 8�����F ���\�G� g�*H��� B�$0� � �C !�@%� �9�"� �*7� �� ��7' �� 2�C��C %��@ �� k= �� �?� ��� .,� ���� v"��� h� 8!�@ B,�

�/�u8�����F !a%� Z�,@ 2�C��C ��� �=N �� �*$�� ��73� 8!"�P (�"�D �$��� ���\�G� !-�'�� 7C !�@%� � 8���.

v"���{" !�@%� bH, �C ��� 2�I� 2��? *�;�7,� !�?' AC�� %� �["� P$+�H� s��C ��73� %��@ �� 8�����F�%��@ ��V+ �� � �%���-$� <�= %� s��C � �%� %� �%��@

8�����F (�"�D ���=N %� ���\�G� �1� �� �C "�� %��G �$��� � �IR �� ��I�� �!�%��� �%�F .�C ��� 2@ �� C�& v"����/M`8�����F !a%� %��3� !�@%� 8!"�%��@ 2�C��C ���

!-�'�� �C .�/u� �?- � k,��� !�@%� !a%� x/M!-�'�� Z,�-� � i�� !�@%� !a%� ) �Z3� -�3&�Mxy.(

��F!7V� ���V %�)�Mxy (bH, %�^��� ,%�� 2��? �?' "�7-��% 2����@ %��@ /���� <�= %�)3-� � �N�; �73� (�2�A�� 8�����F ���\�G� B�$0� �� B*�Y

#�$0 �� �C ��� 2�I� ^��� S%�A9 �8�����F ���\�G� B�$0� 2!' � /���� �� 2����@� B*�Y � %��@� ^"�A�� �%���-$� %�N � !��".

�!, -�3&)�Mxy (�� A��3"��� P (�� �C ��� 2�I� 8!"!�%��@ � 8!"�%��@ 2������� �%�� ���� �%���-$� ���� 8�����F !�@%� 2�A�� �1� �� 8��9 �� .("!� 2�A�� �C Z� �

�����F !�@%�O(�"�D �8!"�%��@ 2������� B,� 8!"!�%��@ 8��9 �� � .

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 12: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�x�

�s��C �%��� ,%� S%�A9 �%��@ ������% %� 8!' *a�� %� %�I��i���dC ���P)�, ���x��Mzu�C ��� 2�I� 8�����F ���\�G� B�$0� ��� M� �#�$0 8!"�%��@ 2�C��C !a%� x � k,��� !a%� ` g�F !a%� B,� . ���\�G� B�$0�eu %� A�� �%��� �� !a%�

S%�A9 ������% ��� E5I��� �� )�!��F��?G �MxM.( �$+�H� %� %��%� ��O u`x )�, %� �C ����� ���� �� ��3��� ("!+�� �� ��� �MxM ��

8��C �$���� 2�X-3�% f'AD >�*; 8�[I��� ����;� s� {�-�*C��� s��C /��' �!� ,%�� �V��3� � 73� /�� �� �%��@!' . ("� %�^,�D �� f" ,%�� �� !�@%� 2�A��

("!+����� . ����� �� 7�� �$+�H� ("� v"��� h�,� �� )M�`��� ( !�@%� ("��7C ��%�� �C !���� �������x`2@ !a%� ���, ��Ps��C !-�'�� �%��@ .2���@ v"��� A�� �%��@ ���

2�I�� ������, � ���$� ("!+�� !�@%� 2�A�� (�� Ps��C 2@ �%��@ H��% ��P �%���-$� �%�� ���� )�aQF � 8��� �2�%�47��Mxu.(

g�?' ^���D %�)�Mx`(A�� s��C ("!+�� !�@%� ��Y � %��@ s��C ���� %��@B,� ��'�� �["!f" �� �%���-$� .�� �%�N �Cz/`u ��7C !�@%� ��%�� �9%��@ 8��9 !a%�

���ey8��� 2��� %�A� !�� . �?- �C B,� +�& %� ("��y �9%��@��Y ("!+�� 8��9 !a%� "� ��%��8��� !�@%� 2�A�� ( !�� .

3"��� o!� �� �C I���D %�P)Q�F� �A; 2�A�� � �%���% ��� 2�C��C %� p��^��� %� 8!"!�%��@ � 8!"�%��@ !�@%� 2�A�� �!' >�X�� 2��? h%�!� "�7-��% LH�� 2����@

8��9 �� 8�����F���� B'�� �%��3� ��� .�� �%�N �CM/e~8�����F !a%� C��C ��� 2� !�@%� ��%�� 8!"�%��@�yy�?- �C B,� +�& %� ("� �!���� 2@ �� ��7C � 2��� %�A�

�/�x8�����F !a%� !���� !�@%� 2�A�� ("� ��%�� 8!"!�%��@ 2�C��C ��� ) �8���A"A;�Mxe.(

$+�H� v"���P �A"A; )�Mxz (H��% ,%�� o!� ��P}�, � ���\�G� ��� o�\�� �����I� � %!5�����2�I� A�� ���? 2����� 2��� %� *f+ !-��OH��% P ("� �� ��� /��B,� ;�7��� �QfI� . �$+�H� ("� v"���2�I� � !�� �� � �H,�� �� ���\�G� ��� �C

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 13: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�xM

GQF� ZqY � ��C�� h�3&� ��%�f�A� �-��� !-��� "����$�� �� �%�_9��l� �"�N� ��l� �%���% vC /�G� �� �%�_9.

D %�s��C /��' ,%�� o!� �� �C I��� ^�D � �N�; � 73� �%��@ 2@ -��^��� ("!+�� !�@%� !-��� ������� F�� �"�N�� 8%�� ���; � 8!"�%��@ ��F� 2����@

��7� %� ����� �?' "�7-��%P �%��@ �yyy 8!' >�X�� ^"�7�D S�% �� 8����,� �� ���� �@ 2���F� ("!+�� !�@%� (�[���� �B,�B,� 8!' S%�A9 ��7C ���; 2���F� �� 8!"�%� .

8!"�%��@ 2���F� ("!+�� ���� !�@%� (�[����xz/�y`�uM) %��$� o��V�� ��uM/�xM`e~ ( ���; 2���F� ("!+�� ���� ��`/�~zeeu) %��$� o��V�� ��e�/�~u``� ( 8��� 2��� %�A�

B,� .2���@ v"��� !�� �� �C B,� 8��� 2�I� A�� �%��@ ��� ��7C ("!+�� !�@%� 2�A�� 8��B,� ��I�� �%��@ s��C )�7�&� !'�� ) �2�%�47� � WQ�" -?'�Mxu.(

��I�� v"��� oQF�� ^���D ,%�� ���8!' +Q� � ��)�Mxe ( �� �C I���D %�3"��� o!�Ps��C �%��@)B*�Y � 3-� �73� ��N�; ( %� 2@ �� �l�� :���; ��`y

^��� D � ��F� ���@ "�-d�,� � ���; �3)��y � ���; ��y"�-d�,� ( �?' "�7-��% LH��8��� >�X�� 2��? �s��C /���� /��' �C B,� ����9 �X��� �H��% ���\�G� B�$0� �� �%��@�%�!� �%���-$�.

s��C ;�� A�� ���\�G� B����V� )�7;� � /�� �� �%��@ � ��!7*G ?�� ��' . %� %�1-� �� �C I���Ds��C /��' 2�A�� ,%�� � � �N�; ���73� �%��@ ?�� ��

��%zMx �� ��� ^��� %�� 2����@O2��,�?' �H,��� �B,� 8!' >�X�� 2��? 2��,� ���`z�,�D !a%� ��'�� 2��� 2�9!-�� ��% �� �dC�!& � %�� {" �7; )�N %� :G�!& �C !��

8��� >��V� =�� � )�D �� !�� )%�47� � 8A"� �2��Mxz.( %�7' )�!� �� ��[� ��O ��� v"��� %��� � ^���D �� 8!�@ B,� #*�5� ���

� E5I� �*C �C ��'P���7� �� ��$+�H� %� B*�Y � %��@ /���� ,%�� �� � #*�5� ��� 2�C��C�+Q� �$+�H� �� ��Y �� ��)�Mxe(�-��� %� ��3f" v"��� �� PH��% P � ��� s��C ��@%��" B,� ��� 8��C !�"w � s��C �C !�� %� �%��@2��� 8�����F �� � ���� ���

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 14: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�x`

L"�' #�$0 ���\�G� B�$0� � ���=N �"�, �� � !'�� . <�= %� �C ����V P7� t�-70s��C �� �% 8�����F ���\�G� B�$0� �%��@ 2���@ �%�� �%��@8��C ,%�� !�� �H��% ("� �

����" %���-$� �% !�� .C ��� %� ;�7��� #�$0 ���=N %� %��@ /��' !a%� %� �^���D ���i��� 8!��I� $+�H� �%�� P��7� %� ���� �� '�� ��'P >!; � ���V ��

%� ��37� ;�7��� ���=N ��G� #"�$ � 2@ (�� %� ���\�G� B,�� . �=N �C ����� �� ��'%�A9i��� #�$0 ���=N %� %��@ /��' ("��I�� Z+�� ��� �B,� 8��� �% ���\�G

��� B,��& �C 2��� %� A�� ���� ���=N s��C � �IR �� �%��@ �%�F . pDs��C �%��@k��B3�� /�7��� B,���� ���=N �� �\V-� .h��,� ��� ���=N %� �C "��

� :�7V ����� �� ���� ���=N �� ^�� ����� ("!-R �% 2�C��C %��@ /�G� )�7�&� ���'�� i�� � k,�� -C!.

���(� �!" #�$ �� ���� ��

)A-� /�� � ����� (f3� B�$0�2@ �� 8�����F ��*��G ��� �� f"�A� � ����3� <�= %� ��%�� .8�����F ��I�� %� �+�� �� �C "��P ti�7$� )��-� !-�3� ����� ��*��G ��� ���\�G�

� {R�C ��%�X��,�Z,�- 2�!�;� ��!$ �� B,� 8�����F ��q. ��A" ��G��)�Mz~ (s��C ������ �� ��f3� )A-� /�� <�= %� 8��C ,%�� �% �%��@

B,� .����" )A-� /�� � s��C ��73� %��@ /��' (�� �C ��� 2�I� ^���D ("� ����� U�%�� ���� �%��@ %���-$� <�= %� 8�����F ��f3� )��-� %� �C ��C��C �C �%�N

�%�X��,� �!-�'�� B��f, \5' � �����, )��-� %� �C ��C��C �� ^�� !���� (C�, !���� 8!' B"�� � %��@) ���A" ��G���Mz~ .(

+�& %� %�C_� ^���D v"��� ���H� �C`/�y \5' )��-� %� (C�, 2�C��C !a%�����9 %��G %��@ BV �!��u/�u �@ m�$� %� �%�X��,� )��-� %� (C�, 2�C��C !a%� %�

8��� !�� . )��$� � 8��� (���-�� A�� �����, )��-� %� (C�, O!"�%��@ 2�C��C B=3�e/�� B,� 8!' �%�@�� !a%�.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 15: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� �� ��� ��� � ���

���

��

����

�: ��

� �

��

� �

���

���

�� �

���

� �

�� � �

����

� !

��"���

#$���

����

�� �

��

� �

���

� ��

����

� ����

� ���

���

���

�� �

���

� ���

���!"

#�$�%�

����

&'�

()

�*�

#��

(�

+

��,- ����

���

� .��

#/-

,'0

���

� ��1

��1 �

/� *�

��

#�2

#- 3*

��41

*��

��

5

6�

7�

�589:

� �

�)

��

���

3���,"

��,

; +

/'<�(

�� *';

= 3

�>����

5??

+

(@

)

A

A

B5

*�

��

C

7,D �

*'=

�589E

�F�,'-� �

�����

����

,�� ��F�,;=

CE?

&

/6G 7+

62�<

7+

(@

)

*

A

B/8B

� �

�,F0

� *

���

J/8J

��,

@" *�

��

8

7��'/�

KL

-5899

3

��� ,

F0� �

�����

����

��,

; ,;= +

��( �

��

:C?

@

)+

62�<

7+

(

*

A

M �

�N*��

���

� *�

��

+(@

)8

*�

��

3*��

���

+62�<

���

:

7�

��*

���

5899

+

��( �

�� O

%��

���

���

����

��-� �,0

,;=

C:?

+

62�<

7+

(@

)

*

A

C/8:

��N

*��

���

� *�

��

+(@

)5/

C:

���

� *�

��

+62�<

��N

*��

B

7+

��0

*(�

�589M

3

��� ,

F0� �

�����

����

��,

; ,;= +

��( �

��

5::8

&

/6G 7+

62�<

7+

(@

)

*

A

A

E

7+

6��

589M

+@

) 3

*��

���

� ��1

��1

+P=Q" #- 3*

1 #

�)

�,�

+��

��R

59

+

@ )

A

A

A

1

. &

�T< �

- 3�

�- ���

� ��

#%-�� �

3*= �

���� �

���

� ����

� #1 �

����

�*

&�� 3*

= U

LK

� .

5

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 16: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ����������� ��! "����#$� %&'" ����()*

���

� ���

����

��

9

7��Q� �

,R�-

589J

�62� 3�>

����� #

� #

- V'�

)�,

��,

; ,

;=

8:9

+

(@

)

A

A

5/5E

M

7+�*� +

'@W

58M?

+��(

���

,F0

� �

����� �

���

;= �

�F�,'-�

��,

; ,

E?

&

/6G 7+

62�<

7+(@

)

*

A

A

J

7X@

� + '@

W58M?

� �

�)

�� �

�� 3*

��,"

��,

; +

/'<�(

�� *

';= 3�>

�����

85J

+

(@

)

*

A

C/8:

5?

7+

��0*(�

�58M?

���

,;= +

��( �

�� �

�����

��,

;

8?:C

7+

@ )

7+62�<

7+(@

)

&/6

G

*

A

A

55

7Y

�;=

58M:

Z��1 ,

'G �

���� Z

��1 V

�*$��

,� �

���

Q1,� #

- 3* 1

#�)

��6�

Y��

� *';

= +

F@�Q

;-

E?

+

/1

*

A

9/:E

5C

73�

��Q�Q

<58MB

���

���� �

3*��

���� �

�����

3*�*

��,

; [

��*

� +��(

��� O

%��

CM?

7+

@ )

7+(@

) 7+

����

&/6

G

*

A

8/BJ

58

7,

D +$T

)58MB

��<

,@

" � ,

F0� �

��� �

���

+�� \F�

� �

C:?

7+

@ )

7+(@

) 7+

62�<

&/6

G

A

*

A

5:

3���

#�

T0

���

�](�

58ME

��0

+��

'D� ���

� #- #

F@-��

V�*

$��

��'F<

� Z, ^

' '/1 #

- _,��

���

@D�

+P=Q" �

�/<

3�>K

���

E:M

#�

��@� �

+(@

)

*

A

M:

#1 +

��@1 *

���

�� ,

F(1 *

����

9?

��Q

� #F=

�� 3�� �

� �

���

*��

5B

`T

'� + ;

=

7���

�](�

58ME

����

,

F0� �

�����

����

� 3*

��

���

�� ,

;= +

��( �

�� 3�

�� �

��<

C???

+

62�<

� +

(@

)

*

A

A

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 17: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�xz

�$+�H� v"��� �� f" )�& (�; %� � ���% �9�����F :���; PH��% ,%�� �� �C ��s��C � ;�7��� ^��� 2��� %� �%��@ ��3�� 2����@2 2��? �?' �����F� �+�� ���

� 2�I� �B,� ��F���D ���� !��' � �%�� 8��9 �� (�� (f3� B�$0� �1� �� �C !���%�!� ���� �%���-$� .M/`x � �%�� 8��9 2�C��C !a%�ey %� !��' 8��9 %� !a%�

���F � 9!�� �%�X��,� ��� !���C .W� � ��!$ � \5' W� � (�'�� �1� �� ��� �� ��%�� ���� �%���-$� ���� 8��9 �� (�� ��f3� )A-�.�� �%�N �Cxy %� 2�C��C !a%�

� �%�� 8��9ey ��'�!� ��F �� ��\5� W� � !��' 8��9 %� !a%� !��) . � j�=Va�2�%�47� �Mxe.(8��� S%�A9 �% ?��I� v"��� A�� �["� ��$+�H� F�� !�� . %� �*7� ��

�$+�H� ���� O%��%� ���$���� o�$� ��F ���$� ("!+�� 2�! ����;� s� {�-�*C �� 8!--C 2�X-3�% f'AD >�*; 8�[I���)�aQF �2%�47� � 8��� �Mxu ( 8!' 8��� /��%� 2�C��C �

2��? 2��V� %� �*F�!� AC��� ��)�%�?�� �Mxu( )A-� B�$0� (�� �%���-$� �H��% !I� �1&Q� 2�C��C %��@ � ��f3�.

���(%$ &���� �� ' �!) *+

� 2�I� #*�5� ��$+�H� � (�I����� �N�-� �*7� �� �N�-� F�� %� �C !-��B,� �N�-� �["� �� ^�� >�� � ;�7��� �QfI� /��' ���?' P�'�& �QV�.

)�!�I7� ����MxM( � ) ��!-G�Mx� ( ("�8!"!D� '�� �� 2@ �� ti��� �C ��'� -� {" %� �C ������ �;�7X�� 9!�� ��H ?� �� !--C B[-��� �>�1�'�%� �

��%����["!f" ����=' 8��� �� � ��� ��lw !��"_D. �t����l ���F �� �%�F �C "��%��@ � �%�� s��C �� �� 2�����D H�V� �������� � ��� 9!�� :V� �� $�� ��' B,

)�!��F��?G �MxM .( ����" $+�H� ���P2�7"� � �!7&� ) �Mx` ( /�0�� ��»��'�& ���� �-��� � -�I�

��'�& 2����� 2��� %� ���%�f�A� %���% �� ^"��9 8� (�I� )�, %� ����' �+��D�MxM « 2�I�H��% ���P-$� � ��'�& (�� �%�� ��+|� � -�I� ��� �-��� ���)pD �� :"�7 >!; ���!��

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 18: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�xx

B"�7& ��=7C � ��A�� �� :�� � [�3f'�, h�3&� F8����� ( %���% �� ^"��9 �� ���%�f�A��%�� ���� . �% ("� ����'�& (�� ��+|� � -�I� �� �H��% %� ��� �-��� ���

��%�f�A� %���%P 2����� B,� %��G�� :����� �H��%. %�!'��)�Mz` (s��C �%��� S%�A9 �"�N �� �% 2��? %� 3-� �%��@ ���

8!���D %� ����� �G f'AD 2����, �����C �$+�H� ��� . /��' ,%�� P$+�H� ("� %�L"�' ��� 2�I� 2��? #*�5� �N�-� %� 3-� %��@ �%��� /��%� :V� ("�

s��C /��' �� �2��? �?' g�-� P�&�� �3-� �%��@~/�x B,� 8��� !a%� . �� pD!-�'�� %��G 2��? g�Y � ��?I�Q,� �)�7' �W�' �N�-� Z� � �� ��H-� ("� .

��-�8�����F �f-"� (���9 �1� %� �� ("�� �� �3"��� %� 2��? ��-� �N�-� ���8�����F )��� ���\�G� � ;�7��� B�$0� �N�-� �"�, ��� � !�%�� �� �X��� 2��

s��C /��' �N�-� ("� %� B��9 B,� ��I�� 3-� �%��@ . ("� %� ��� Z+�� P�f���'�& �N�-� %� �C B,� 2@ ^���D � �C �� ��*H��� ���\�G� � ;�7��� B�$0

!�%��)�?I�Q,� ( �B,� 8��� ��I�� 2���F� �� ���X �� 2��3D �� B=3� ���X /��'2�I� ��F ��f� ("� �C s��C ��[+� ���� O!-�� � ���\�G� ���=N %� �%��@

B3� A�� ;�7���. �G�� 7�&%)�Mze (^��� 2��� %� 73� �%���%!� /��' 2�A�� ����@�, �N�-� 2 �

B3�� B,� 8��C �3"��� �["!f" �� �% 2��? . P�H-� %� �C ��� 2�I� �$+�H� ("� v"��� �B3��M/zM �, P�H-� %� ��� !-�'�� �!� ��=- ����, 2�C��C �� !a%� �� �G% ("�z/e~

B��" ^��C !a%� .B3�� P�H-� %� (�-67� ��!&`/`� %�?�� 2�C��C �� !a%���'�� � �C !���%A� �%���%! 2@ �� ��� �� �� ���9 Z�,@ �� �C 8��� �� 2@ 73� 9!"� ��

B,� 8!' �X-� .��, P�H-� %� !���� B=d� �,�D )���, ("� �� !a%� B3�� . ("����-�� B3�� P�H-� %� 73� �%���%!� /��' 2�A�� B�9 2�� /��' 2�A�� ����� �� �� ^��

%� 2@ �, ��H-� � !'�� .�� �Q;����" 8 � �!� ��=- �!' �C ��� 2�I� ���V �["� ���B3�� ��H-� %� A�� 2@ %��f �, ��H-� �� ��I�� %��3� B,� .

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 19: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�x~

����" 2��*$I5� ^���D ���)�Mzz ({" �N�-� %� B3�� � ����� v"��� 2��? �?' 7�&% P$+�H� �� �3"��� %� �%)�Mze (B��f, :V� (�� 2@ h�,� �� �C ��� 2�I� n�����

s��C /��' 2�A�� � ��H-� �� ("� B'�!� ���� �%���-$� ���� �%��@. ��F!7V� P$+�H� v"���)�Mzx ( #*�5� �N�-� �� 2�C��C %��@ <�= %� ,%�� %� 2��? �?' S%��D � S���@)8���� � ^' �v-D �%�?R ��, �N�-� ( �C ��� 2@ �� C�&

��@ ���7� (�[���� (�� �%���-$� ���� ^��� ��, �� 8!' S%�A9 % �N�-� %� 2����@�%�� ���� '���@ #*�5� .("!� ^��� �C Z� � 8���� P�H-� 2����@) 2��? g�-� %� (

v-D �^' �%�?R �N�-� Z� � �� 2@ �� pD � !���C B��"%� �% %��@ O�7� (�[���� ("��I�� )2��? )�7' � AC�� %� (�, ��H-� p�, �) 2��? )�7' %� (�G!-�'�� %�.

��A" ��G��)�Mz~ (�$���� 2�C��C ,%�� %� �2��? �?' )��N� 8�[���%� �, �� 8!--C 8�����F B��f, :V� �� 2�C��C ��73� %��@ <�= %� P$+�H� ��2@ �� ) �" � ��,�% ��?'

�?' P�'�& (BF���D .s��C /��' 2�A�� �C ��� 2�I� ���V v"��� %� ��73� �%��@(C�, 2�C��C��?' �N�-� %� x/~ "��,�% �N�-� %� (C�, 2�C��C �!a%�e/�� !a%�

���?' P�'�& %� (C�, 2�C��C �u/�e B,� 8��� !a%� . 2��� <�= %� �%��@ 2���@ >�X����� 2�I� %���-$� tQ��C �% ��73� �%��@ s��C ���� � B��f, :V�.

G��% �C ���V %�) �Mxy (8�����F �%�� %� �?' ��� :V� (�� ��� >�X�� 2�-7, ����� B��f,)��,�% �" �?' (s��C ������ � ���"� �%��@ ���� 8�����F %� �%��@

!' 8!��I� . "��,�% �N�-� %� 2�C��C %��@ S%�A9 2�A�� �$+�H� ("� %�)`M !a%� ( �N�-� �� ��I�� ��?')x/Mx !a%� (���.

%� �C �["� ���V %�~ �?' '���@ P�H-� �73� ���%��@ �B��9 �%�a 2��? (�� �C ��� 2�I� ,%�� ("� v"��� U!�!' ,%�� ���9�!� %�N �� B*�Y � �N�; �3-�

s��C /���� /��' �1� �� 2��? �?' #*�5� �N�-� �� �%���-$� ���� B*�Y � �%��@�%�� ���� %��@ ��V+ . 2��� �� Z� � ("!�~ �$+�H� �%�� P�H-�)R ��, �N�-� �v-D �%�?

8!�� �8�A��' �8�A��D �8�A�, ��� �^' (8!�� �N�-� �� <���� %��@ S%�A9 ("��I�� �

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 20: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�~y

8�A��D) 2��? g�Y � g�-� �N�-� (�, � ^' �N�-� %� %��@ S%�A9 ("��7C �) �N�-�2��? )�7' (���. ) ���F !7V��Mxy.( g�?')�Mx` (s��C ("!+�� B��f, P�H-� ��F P$+�H� %� � %��@s��C ��Y %��@

B,� 8��C ��3� g�Y � W�' �g�-� �)�7' P�H-� %�?R �� �% ���? . v"��� h�,� �� �$+�H� ("�uy � 9!�� 2��? g�-� P�&�� %� �9%��@ ("!+�� !a%� !���C . +�& %� ("�

�?- �� ���M/�M s��C ��Y ("!+�� !a%� � 9!�� 2��? g�-� %� %��@ !���C. v"��� 2���@��+�� �� f" 2��-; �� ("!+�� B��f, :V� �C ��� 2�I� A�� �%��@ B�$0� ���

s��C /��' 2�A�� �� ���\�G� � ;�7��� �%�� �%���-$� <�= %� �%��@.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 21: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� �� ��� ��� � ���

���

��

����

�:

��

� �

� �

���� �

���

� �

���� �

��

����� �

���� �

����

�� �

!" ��

# $�

����

����

�� �

��

���

��

����

��

��

����

����

�� �

����

��

���

!�"

#

$���

����

��

� $

�%

�����

��

��

&#�

'#

&�(�)�

����

*+�

',

���� -��

� �

./

� !�#

��

� 0

1�2'

��

� 0

1�23

+�

�+4

&5�

$�

6� 7

�8

$�

6� 7

�,

9

9 $�

6�

:;<

&

�,

��

=

, >

�1�

��

� $��

���

#�

#�?

%@A� $��

���

&� >�

��

@��

BC:DE

&.)�

:$�

6�

&

.)�

;F

$�

6�

9

9 $�

6�

G;F

� �

#�

����

$�

��

: �

;F

$�

6�

�?�

'+H

�B

C:D<

I I

*

$�

6�

E;F

1�'�

� >��� �

24� $

���� �

#�

$�+5�

3K

�B

C:DD

&.)�

: L

����

L���� �

&.)�

CM

L����

L���� �

* $�

6�

CEE:

1�'�

� >

��� �

24� $

����

�#�

�'/

#�4

B C:DG

��6@ �

���

&

+@�H

����

�6@

��

* $�

6�

:ED

-�N

� >�

O#���

� &

� &

� 0

+�,

��A1 �

�?��

B C:DM

�6@

�2���

*

$�

6�

C:ED

P

��� Q

1 R

?�H

&�

1�� >

��

#�4

�1�

CG

�#�

� -

��

?��

B C:GF

&.)�

S L

����

L���� �

&.)�

C<

�CD

L���� � L

����

*

$�

6�

:FE:

1�'�

� T

).�

$�

���

�#�

�'/

#�4

B C:GF

$�

6� 7

�8

$�

6� 7

�,

9

*

$�

6�

SF

P

��� 0

1�(�

�+8

� �

��

P���

��

B7

�6@

C:GE

2

. *

�VW �

� >�

�� ��

���

&)�� �

>�@ !

�"# �

���

� $���

� &� �

���

�*

*� >�

@ X

K3

� .

;

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 22: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�~�

,��(���� �� ��-��- #�./0�

� f""s��C �� �C *���; �� �[ 2�C��C )���'� �B,� k= �� �%��@���\�G� ���� :�+� �� B,� .�� 2�C��C ("� :�+� -�� � 73�  �*� >!; ti�7$� � B��IF �%�� %�C k�V� %� %��@� %��G ���9 .

8!"�%��@ 2�C��C %�C P���, ,%�� %� !���� ����9 h�7 %��I� ��!a �� �C �� 2��� �� �C !' E5I�Mez �8!"�%��@ s��Cx` ���)�M !a%� ( B=3� �C !���� :Y�'

��7� �X& ���1&Q� :��G %��@ �� B,� �� .� %�C �C ��C��C ("����-� � !--C v"��� �=N� ^���D ("� � %��G %��@ m�$� %� 2�C��C �"�, �� ��I�� ti�7�&� !���9)�,�G �8���

�Mxy .(2�"� ��F ���F �� s��C %�C :�\V �� s��C �C ��' �;�� �9� ��� �B3�� %�@ �� %�C /�� �" � ��' >��V�� ��I� B"�;% 2@ %� s��C W��& �C !'�� ��V� !���

� �" %��@ /���� �� q$� �� �X-� ��' ?�� . %�a %� �% s��C %�C #3���"� �%�7d�,� !'�� �%�� �% �"� k"��' �C !���: B;�, � U��' 2��C%�C o�a ���"� %��3� ���

���� ���% �" ;�7��� �73� Z,�-��� %�I� �C �%�C �U�%�_[� Ug�*H��� k"��' %� 2����F %� 9!�� � %�C �

U�C %��3� (, %� BG� >�7 %�C � UA�R�� �A� �

U!& �� ^�� B�+��3� � U��' :�\V L��� �C �%�C �

8�?� �" 9��� :d� �!-C ����� �% 2�C��C p�� �A; � o�' �C �%�C � U3-� IC "� ���% � ;�7��� :��C !'% ���� �C �%�C �2� !'�� %�@) ����%�D�Mzx.(

�� 2���� 2�"����%�C ���� �?� �� 2i�39%A� ��� �� )�,��F 2��9%�C �� 8����,�B,� ���a .2@ ��� %���� �% 2�C��C �C +�& %� �!--C %�C 2��["� O��!�� �� �C !--C

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 23: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�~M

� 2�C��C �� ���7C W��& !�����D .� ���7C �Q�?3 � �_Y )�,��F 2��9%�C !�%�� ���� �7�� � W��& �� B=3� �... B��IF � ��=- �� A�� m���;� �%�a %� � !�%�!� "�;��

�� � BC�, �&�% !��' .�� �HF "�"�A� (�-R � B5, ���%�C %� 2�C��C ���9%�C W��& (���9 8!"��� (�-67�2@ �� �% %�C k�V� %� ��%��@ /���� � %�� )�7;� �& �

� ^"�A�� !��. ��� A�� 2�C��C �� q$ ���%�C �� 2�"����, ���\�G� o�!�� (�F�, 8�%�@�� %�1-�

�!f :d� Z,�-��� � ��'���� ��9 !��' . %� 2�C��C �"�, �� ��I�� �����F 2�C��C}�, (�-R m�$� 8����,� B,� (f7� �2�'��F ��F k"��' B*; �� � !�%�� %��G "��

!��' LG�� A�� ��%��@ /���� �%�� ) ���� %�D�Mzx.( �"� 2�C��C %�C L-� �� -=� -����G L0� ���� ���e )�,) 8���z~ %� %�C 2���G

2��"� ( � %�C %���� %� s��C W��& ��� !��' ��-� s��C W��& �� /��� (����G �" �8!"��� ���3� (����G ("� (���9.

�%�7'�, ("�F@ v"��� %�) �Mxe (^' 2QY�' %�7' �� � )�, �B,� 8!I� S%�A9 2QY�' ��!$ ����y � �` )�,�x`u`~B,� 8!' >Q;� ��� . :C �C B,� +�& %� ("�

B�$7��y � �` �+�,uzyxe~`B,� 8��� ��� . �["� �%�=; ��ze/� B�$7� !a%��y � �` 8��� :Y�' !��) )�, (f3� � h��� �%�7'�,�Mxe.(

�(���� � ��� ����

� ��$+�H� �dC�s��C �*7� �� �;�7��� �QfI� � ��� (�� PH��% � %��G !�"w �%�� �% �%��@8��� !��(Murray,1990)� (Mooney,1998) �(Fraser,1995) �(Sampson,1993)�(Willian,2006)

(Berger,2005) (Paavilainen,2000) (Jacobs,1981) ) ��%�!����Mzz(�) ����a�Mz`(� )�!�'% ����Mzu(�) 5� �2��*$I�Mzz(�) ���F!7V��Mzx) ( �� ���Mzx(�) ���A" ��G��

�Mz~(�) �Z3� -�3&�Mxy(�) �F��?G �!��MxM(�) �aQF �2�%�47� � 8��� �Mxu(� )�g�?'�Mx`) ( �8���A"A;�Mxe(�) �2�%�47� � WQ�" -?'�Mxu ( �) �2�%�47� � 8A"�

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 24: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

������ ���� ���!�"�#��� (�� $����%&' )*+$ #���,-

�~`

�Mxz.(% �C �$+�H� s!�� �?, !"�=� ��=+� �*7� �� �>�� � ��� B�$0� (�� �%���-$� PH��s��C B��9 8!"��� �!-�3�� :j�G ��%��@(Messner,1982) �)+Q� ����Mxe.(

,%�� ��� >�X�� � ��+|� %�?R �� :G�!& ��� �C ��� 2�I� �+��� ("� %� 8!' !��� �%�@ ����� �% 2�C��C %��@ P-��� .����F !�@%� 2�A�� ��+|� (�+��B,� % .8�����F %� ���

%��'� %��3� �" (f7��� ("!+�� ���� 2�C��C ,�,� ������� :G�!& (��� 2�f�� ���� �8�����F ���& P���� ���� (f7� !�@%� :G�!& (��w B"�+�� :�+� �� 8�Q; �� UB,�

B*�Y (Neglect)8�����F ("� %� 2�C��C �� 8�����F �� ��I�� ,�3V� ��N �� �� � ��� �B,i�� �" k,��� !�@%� .

^���D Z*Y� %� 2�C��C %��@ �� 2@ PH��% �C ��� P�+|� (���� /�� �B,� 8!' !�"w ��B,� 8�����F ��f3� )A-� . (�-67� � 8�-D�, (�"�D B���C �"�N �� ��� �C �-$� ("� ��

�-��� ��%�X��,� )��-� %� 8�����F 2�f,� :�+� �� B�-�� >!; h�3&� %��@ ��, 2�C��C B,� . 3-� %��@ �?� :���; �� f" ��!V� ��q� {" %� %����F ��q;� P7� %�q&

� g�3V� ��' .���� 8�Q; �� � Z��� B��f, :V� >��!� "�� B"�7& � ��' ��� � ��' Z*, 2�C��C �� !-�3� (C�, 2@ %� �i�N �!� ����� �C QV� %� 8��+��

����F k�V� �� �%�F ���N�5�2@ ��!-C !"!? ��I�� �% . ���!V� ��!$ B�9 !"�� ��=+�8��f� !�"w �% 2�C��C %��@ � ��f3� )A-� B�$0� (�� PH��% A�� ��$+�H� �� !��

) �2�%�47� � "�=Va�Mxe .( B,� 8�����F B��f, :V� ��H-� �!' ,%�� �+��� ("� %� �C >�, P�+|� . �� LG�� %�

� {"�A� �f-"� (���9 �1�%� ��` �*V� !a%� �*V� ���?' %� �� 7,%��Y 2�f,� ��� {"�A� � !-�3��y �*V� ("� %� %�IC B�$7� !a%� !-�3� (C�, ��) ���, ���F����

����,!-7��� *��Mxe ( %��3� �?, �N�-� ("� %� �HF m�$� %� 2�C��C B�$7�!�%�� �% 2�C��C :C �� "i�� .f�@ ���� !�%�R�� ���� ���%����F �� �% ���7C �-"A� �

!--C 9!�� 7,%��Y 2�f,� �N�-� %� �!-�� ��\�F� 8�-D�, .�*V� ("� %� :G�!& ��7� �j�%� ��?' ���!F %��3� B'�!?� � S���@ ���!F �� ,��,� Z*Y� � ��'

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 25: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

�' 6' �� ��':; <��= � ��

�~e

� )��� B���C �� �" � %��'� !'�� . B,� 2�C��C )���'� ���� �� k= �� >%�?R P�+|� .8�����F ��� �� ���� :�+� �� ����

� b��� Z*Y� ��I�� !�@%� �� 2!�,% �� ^�D � �Q�\V 2�"�D �� :=G 2�C��C !-�� %�C (,)�x [+�, (!--C (��w �% 8�����F ���V"�� �� I5� � !��' %�C %���� �%�� .

����� %� ��F �� B"�7& "���� 2�C��C �C +�& %� � %�C %���� %� >�[-���� %�q& �!�%�!� �% H�V� ���!"!? � ���N�5�2@ ��Z�,@ �!' �� �% � �"_D !-C .

�-��� #*�5� ��"��� �� ��� h�,� ("� �� B,� 2�C��C %��@ ��, . �C ��C �%�@��" !"��s��C 8�����F %� �%��@ 2�!� ("� � 8!' S%�A9 A�� ��C !�@%� �� � k,��� P�=N ���

0� ����� �?- ��� �C B,�-$�b� �� f" )�&�� �� ��� B3�� 2�C��C %��@ O!-���?� � ("�-��� :���; � g�3V� 2@ ��, ��'.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 26: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� References

�~u

: c�- =$2"HD;* ��0U�"(� v��6�;( =$2�-4�-4 ���5� G1s =�HI A"("% .) ����( =»��"6 A��50«R��� ���0 [�N6 ,���EN�� =.

: $& ��/% � X;-s =A��s�=@��2� .) ����( =»&' �!<�' R2��� � $!;E� �;��s =� ��( �� 5��;� �8�;B �� G;E� �;��s @���"� @�;% �� ������<C* ��N'� �*����« =

������ ����� ���� ����) ����� ����( ����� =v<�5"� �H� =� ,�/fW =���:��.

: c�-�;( =A�C2 A���*.) ����( $ �&;&/ p�4 Z��C� =»��"6 ���"% $(��* A��50� $���1� �F� �� ��f4� $W�QN#� |������ C6��% � ��D��%�� �( �* G;M���% �

@��F «A���;* �* �5��-% � A�;DE;B e6 ����� =7���F* ,��5� = �<. : �N��' =@�;HMEo*.) ����( = �� ���� ����� � �!"#�� $�%&$ '�* +�,- ��.,� *$��

/��� $� �0 !�12��$ 3$�� �%4� ��5��0����6 ��-@�2�B = � ���� $(�!���6 �%�7���F*.

: �;�� =A��F*.) ����( =7��8 �� ���� ����� *$�� � �%4� ��8��8 1�9 :$�50+�9$� �,� $� ��� "- ���;� $� ��4�"� .8��� �� ��<)=.8�� ( >�* $�?@AB

����6 ��- $�@�2�B = ��50 ��DE��� =$��N�� "H R<�jB ���� $(�!���6 �%��� =G<��� $%�(���!<�� ��N( :@�;��H% �N6�.

: �Ef!* =$����"B.) ����( =Z"%�# ��% =)��"6 ��2�B �* $<�D� A��50( ,����EN�� =@��F =A�FE�<.

: $8�� 32�W =�'.) ����( =7��8 ��!�C� $� �0 �� ���� ����� � :$�50/��� !�2D%*� � :��� ��� � �%4� ��5��0)��2-�� �2,��� (��- !�12��$ EFC� ����6@�2�B = @��� ���� $(�!���6 �%�� ��DE��� =$2�!uN(� @�6�"6 R2��� $(�!�

��!<�� ��N(� =$N;*� "H � $(�!E���� ���E��� C6�% @��F �s�� $%�(� ��50 :�"B $%�%� @�5"( �N6�.

:�J�%�d =�F2�;E�� .$("% =A�-!) .����( =» �* @0 ,��V� � $��N�� ,�&HM ���F% 7E�5�*$��^'� G2« = ��1%9� ���� ���� ����� =��.

: |��� =$<�( $!;1s.) ����( =�"!"�$�50 � �"!�$�50 �����9�� $� G��4 7�$�� :��!�C� *$�� I! �,J�� �� $� :�= � ??����6 ��- @�2�B = �%�� ���� $(�!���6

@��� ��!<�� ��N(� =$Eo-��" � $N12CF* "H ��DE��� =$!;8�* $(�!� :6� �N$!1/% ��Fl�;�.

: X1� $!;1s = ��<.) ����( = >��K� $� 1�9 $�%&$ '�* �����& *$��

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 27: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� References

�~z

�L9��� �� �"228 5� �,��1*� ",�- M-.N���$ .8�� >��K� M-.N���$ �����$� �!�$��&O@ "2�*� �6 OA@�2�B = =@��2� $��CB "H ��DE��� $��CB A�N6� �%��

��!<�� ��N(� :H� 5��F* �N6�$H;. : �W�# �N(�H� =���5UA��;W =���� ��/% =$Eo* �;�s =$%�d�"B =�J���s� =

$��*� � �"M1%=�;�/8��- .) ����( =» �* @�DN1*�� �� A��50 ��"6 q";� $(��*�M���% $�";'� ��"% @�O!1'� $��CB "H ��DE��� ��;N� �� �;!;H6 �* ��!!6

����« =��� M-.� ���� ����� �������2�&$ �� =��� ����� =vE� ���� = ,�/fW��:��.

: =$��#��/% � X!25 ��;( =�'��5�' U$-NO% =A��*0 �D1 $-;-s U@"2�N6 =$*��"# �����B) .����( =» �F� $2��!<�� ���� @�5"%0 R��� �� A��50 ��"6 q";� @�C;%@��F « ��1%9� ��&$ ���2�P& ����� =vNf< ��( =�� .

: |;�� ' =����5�-2�.) ����( =»$(��* X;(0 �� $2�< (�!�$@��2� $��N�� « ,���EN�� = QR���6 � %�!.�� ���� ����� � $�8 %�!.�� ���5�*@��F =.

: $�;s� G2�'0 =��"%. ) ����( =��!�C� *$�� �� 1�9 :$�%&$"� +�,- ��.,� :��,J�� � :$ ��- ���0 ��.,* :�8 $� 7��8 �CF2� 5� :��*6 ����= 7���M%

� $D!<�' �"%�A�;DE;B�"E6 $N12CF* @�%5�( . : @��� =$��5�U=A"&� G1/%U@T��� =e2�� � A�C2 A���*=c�-�;( .) ����( =

7��8 >�M-� 5� 4�� *$�� �0 �� ���� ����� � ��21* ��%*��- $� :$�50 =$��CB Z5"%0 � @�%�� =7���F* ,��5�=���% � @���"� 7%�( �N'� ����� =c

@��� 7%�(. : A�;�� �W�� =�'.) ����( =S,L19 ����� �,� �F��$ *$�� <�!� � %4�2- :��

7��8 �� %,PQ- � � :$�50 ��� ��- �����9�� 5� ���< $� �9�6 =@�2�B �!���6 �%��$( ��N(� =@��F $��C����� "N;N1�� =$!;8�* $(�!E���� ����

��!<�� :<��* $&� ��/% �N6�$!. : �C�s �;%� =$8�!25.) ����(=» A��0"� � @���"�"� � @�6�"6 5� 72��s �� $�"��� A�<

R8�I @0 A����' A�<« = ��1%9� ��&$ ���2�P& ����� =�� ��( =� "H ��DE��� =$Eo-��" � $N12CF*.

: =A��O( ��;�s U$&%�� =����% � $#�fF� $��% =�;M( .)����(= �,,L6 �"228 :��1%9����!� $� S�T* �� )/���� U$�.<( � $N12CF* "H ��DE��� =

$Eo-��" .

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 28: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� References

�~x

:$H =$�;H( ) .����( =�L��9 :���8 *�2-��DE��� � �5"s ��DE<�jB = . : �; ��%0 =G(.) ����( =:$�50 ���D� �� �L*�6 )�fd�� G;1s ���� ( =�2"6 ,���EN�� =

@��F . : A�T =eD;( .$�.) ����(= ��9 *�2- )n;( ����2 ���� $FH8�( ,�&;&/ �N'� =

���� $<��0 |;HB A��*��6. : 7#�;%�{0 =[�F�.) ����( = V ��1%9� S,LW� X %4�2���$ Y�1,� ��!�C�

7��8 �!"#�� :��P%Z� 7��8�,[ �!"#�� �� $�50 $�50@�2�B = =���� $(�!���6 �%��@��� ���E��� =G<��� �s�� $%�(� ��50 ��DE��� $(�!���!<�� ��N(� : ��<�' �N6�

A�"F��. : $!F�=r�;2 U=$H;���;% �'"H;� �O;!%UG6��� =$&;&s � G;1s =����.) ����( =

»R;B � A��50 ��"6 q";� $(��* =G2�8�� $%"� 7%�( 32�4 5� �;^N% G2� $!;*R��� $H;Q/ ���H� � |f� ,C =A���5�( 7;M�� A�<�;;^N% � 5"%0 $N#�!�

R��� �� 05�"<� �F� $2��!<�� ���� A�� � ��2���50 �N#� @�5"%« = ���� ���� *�2���$ � %,��6 =v<���FI ��( ="( ���� =5�"<� @���I �;F� ��DE��� =

����� A�<� � � ,�/fW =���:���. :G;1s =�"B�^W� � �;s� =A�F� $��&� UG;1s =$���W ) .���� (» e%�" e;H/

�� �* ��]��V� A��QN��@��2� ��« ����� =A��QN�� ,�;&/ �2�E� =�� . : �C��' =$��-/WU=$I��� c���U$fO� � $N��5 =��<5.) ����( =» e%�" �Y*�� $(��*

@�N1*� �� A��50 ��"6 �* $��N�� � $���� =$���"��# @��F ����N#� $N8�� A�<« = �T*� ��50 ����� M-.� ���� ���� ���� =�� ����� =�fW =/ ,���:��.

: G2�;� =A"fW.) ����( =7��8 �� ��1�9 $�%&$ '�*@�2�B = �N�� A��N6� �%����!<�� ��N(� =@��2� $��CB "H ��DE��� =$��CB :$H;H� 5��F* �N6�.

: =$�;} G;1s .)����( =�L*�6 :��$�"� ���!� ��P%Z� $� %&�,�= =$� �E� @��F . : ��4�' =���5C2C.) ����( =�!�C�>T%4� � $� \�� ].� ��.,� � :$�%&$ :��

�"!"�$�50 � �"!�$�50 ��8��8«@�2�B = =$!;8�* $(�!E���� ���� $(�!���6 �%��@��2� $��%�� $N���F* ,�%�# � $��CB "H ��DE���= 7���F* ,�&;&/ C6�%

��!<�� ��N(� =@��� :��� n4� v��6 ��/%. : ��� =AC2C.) ����( =»A��QN�� �&' $H�8� ,�*��E% � ��o% ��"% ��Q% _"( �

,����;�� � @��F �F� @���"� G;* ��« = ��1%9� ��&$ ���2�P& ����� =�� = ,�/fW��:��.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 29: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� References

�~~

: v(�� ��4�' =���5.) ����( =7��8 S,LW� �$�� $� ���� ���!� $� :$�50. : $�"N�0 =C��;�.) ����( =�L��9 *�2- )@�;���I G1s ���� ( =$� �E� =@��F . : �����B =$��#��/% .)����( =7��8 <�!� X+���� � +�,- X:$�50 %4�2���$ :��

X�"!�$�50 ��8��8 �!"#�� ��1� S�T* � <"�5 S,�,8�0 ��@�2�B = �%����!<�� ��N(� =$2�-4�-4 �%� ��DE��� =$(�!E���� A��N6� :��T� �N6�

: �����B =$��#��/%.) ����( =7��8 +�,- E!�- X:$�50 $� $�50 :���#� �!�6/��� ����6 ��- !�12��$ ^$�"� ��5��07���F* ,��5� $E<�jB p�4 = @�%�� =

$��CB Z5"%0 �. : $��%$#�fF� �;M( =.) ����( =7��8 ���!� $� :$�50@��F =@"!6� �E� =. : =$#�fF� $��% �;M( .)����( =����6 ��- $� :�,N*�$ S,LW� E!�* ��!5$�

)/���� U$�.<(= =7���F* ,��5� =$��CB Z5"%0 � @�%�� 7;M�� �N'�@��F �� �/N% eH% @�%5�(.

: �12�B =A���%��.) ����( =/��� $� $�%&$ '�* +�,- ��.,� *$�� �$�� ��5��0��4 ��- !�12��$ ���0 �0 �� ���� ����� �,,L6 �@�2�B = ���� $(�!���6 �%��

@��F ��DE��� =7���F*. : G�1% � c"f� $%"� A�����( m2�N�)����(���� 5� ���oN(� = �# A�<. :���(� =A�&� ) .����( =�L��9 �� :"�0$� ��- � ����� X:��- *�2- ,���EN�� =

G' @���< =@���0. : T�5��� =�C2�U=A���% ��F�U$2��' =��*0�D1 $-;-s � ��<5 =$-NO%.) ����( =

»�12�&% $(��* q";� A���"6 R��� �� A��50 X1s �* �Y("N% hY&% @�5"%0���"��# �� r�4 �&*�( � $H;Q/ hY&% =|!�« =������4 ���2�P& ���� ����� =

�� ,�/fW =���:���. : �;E�� =$f �<.) ����( = �29$�50 ����Z ��8��8 $� ^�%*� ��D!6 G;%��FI =

@��F =@��2� $��CB "H ��DE��� =c�N(� A�(��(. : �1F% =����"<.) ����( =»��"6 ���"% $(��* $1!� A��50(SCA)@��F �� « = ����

����Z M-.� 1��� =�� ��( =���� � � =��:��. : n1;�"2.) ����( =��8��8 �,�� S��4 �;�@��F =n1;�"2 =.

- Farley, Melissa, and Howard Barkan. (1988), Prostitution, Violence Against

Women, and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. 27(3) Women & Health: 37-49.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

Page 30: Archive of SID...References ˝˛˚ Myy - Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of America . New York. - Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban

����� References

Myy

- Fraser, S. (1995), The Bell Curve wars: Race , Intelligence & the future of

America . New York.

- Hartnagel, T.F. & Lee G.W. (1995) “Urban Crime in Canada”, Canadian Journal

of Criminology .

- Jacobs, D. (1981) “Inequality & Economic Crimw” , Sociaology & Social

Research.

- Kaplan & Sadock.(1989), textbook of Psychiatry.

- Ludwing. S., Kornberg. A. E (1992), Child Abuse, A medical Reference,

Churchill Livigstone.

- Messner, s.f. (1982), Poverty, Inequality & the Urban Homicide Rate,

Criminology , No. 20.

- Murray, C(1990) The merging Underclass. Londons Institute of economic

Affairs , Herrnes tein .

- Mooney, 1 (1998). “Moral Panis & the New right: Single Mothers & feckless

Fathers,. London, Macmillan.

- Paavilainen, E. Astedt-Kurki, P. Paunomen, M. (2000), Adolecent’s Experiences

of Moltreatment within the family, Challenges for family Nursing Primary

Health care research & Development.

- Population Reports: Ending Violence Against Women, 2000.

- Sampson, r. & W.William (1993), “Toward a Theory of Race, Crime & Urban

Inequality”, Stanford University Press.

- William, J, Oliver. Lawrance R. Kuhns. Elain S. Pomernaz (2006) Family

Structure & Child Abuse, Clin Pediatr

- Widom, C. 1995. Victims of Childhood Sexual Abuse: Later Criminal

Consequences. U.S. Department of Justice. National Institute of Justice.

Washington, D.C.

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID