anna moriarty steps neurological physiotherapyold.mda.org.au/events/infomd10/physio.pdfexplain the...
TRANSCRIPT
Anna MoriartySteps Neurological Physiotherapy
Explain the role of physiotherapy in the management of muscular dystrophy
Outline common problems
Provide guidelines for management
Discuss outcomes of relevant research trials
Monitor over time: Joint range Muscle length Posture Functional activities
Prescribe (and monitor): Exercises Equipment
Communicate with health team
◦ Muscle weakness
◦ Muscle shortening
◦ Loss of function
◦ Respiratory complications
◦ Children – interference with motor development
Individuals with neuromuscular diseases are less active than the general population (often termed ‘sedentary lifestyle’)
The disease process causes a reduction in functional muscle mass and strength
Disuse atrophy – preferential to fibre type Decreased strength Reduced cardiopulmonary function Reduced resting energy expenditure Greater age related decline in muscle mass
and cardiopulmonary function Predisposes to obesity; OA; T2DM; HT; OP;
Heart Disease .....
Disease affected atrophic fibres are scattered throughout the muscle
A weak muscle must contract at a higher percentage of its max strength to perform the same activity –therefore will fatigue in a shorter time
The relative amount of disease affected fibres will determine the degree of weakness, and also the potential for trainability
Strength training is likely to reverse effects of disuse atrophy, but there is no evidence it brings about change in disease affected muscle fibres
Imbalance in muscle strength – difficult to exercise strong muscles without risking overuse of weak muscles also involved in the movement
Daily activities may be working your muscles at their maximal level already
Are not recommended in fast progressive MD
Place significant stress on the muscle cell membrane – this may cause damage to the muscle fibre and hasten muscle weakness
May cause the muscle’s pool of satellite cells to be used up prematurely
Kilmer 2001 Study – single bout of eccentric exercise
Clinical trials are important
They must be well designed to give useful information
Powerful clinical trials are difficult to conduct in the FSHD and LGMD populations
Aerobic training:◦ Olsen et al 2005 (FSHD) Positive results for 12 weeks cycle training ◦ Sveen et al, 2007 (LGMD) Positive results for 12 weeks cycle training◦ Kilmer, 2002 - review Cardiorespiratory adaptions to submaximal aerobic
exercise training are similar to in able bodied persons There is significant variation between individuals Long term effect is not known
Strength training:◦ Vignos & Watkins, 1966 Max resistance strength training for 1 year Significant improvement with plateau at 4 months Stronger muscles improved more
◦ van der Kooi, 2004 – RCT 1 year strength training at a moderate level for 65 persons with
FSHD Small improvevents in strength, no signs of overuse weakness
◦ Sveen et al 2008◦ 11 Becker MD, cycled 50 x 30 min over 12 weeks @ 65% Vo2◦ Increased exercise performance and daily function
◦ Blain et al, 2010◦ Eccentric contraction does damage muscle fibres in MD mice
◦ DMD – ‘no use is disuse’ study (low intensity exercise) –results expected 2011
There is currently no evidence that physical training of any sort can influence the evolution of muscular dystrophies in the long term.
However, small improvements have been demonstrated with aerobic and resistance training in slowly progressive MD
Stronger muscles gain more strength with training
Overuse weakness appears no not play a significant role in slowly progressive MD
Muscles monitored:
◦ Hip flexors◦ Hip abductors◦ Hamstrings◦ Calves◦ Elbow flexors◦ Wrist flexors
These muscle groups are commonly tight in the MD population
Stretches Night splinting (Hyde et al, 2000) Standing frames Serial casting Appropriate seating (prevent length
imbalance in spinal muscles)
Must be individually tailored
Must be regularly monitored / adjusted
Should involve activities that interest the individual
Should take into account the activity already performed each day (ie school activity; walking to the train station each morning)
Aim for a moderate level of aerobic activity
Target a low-moderate level of resistance for strength training
Muscles should have antigravity movement to be ‘eligible’ for strength training – this also applies to the opposing muscle group(minimum grade 3 strength)
Rapidly progressive MD – the jury is out
Aerobic◦ Bike◦ Walk◦ Swim◦ Tai chi
Strength◦ Machine weights◦ Dumbbells / cuff weights◦ Theraband◦ Gravity
Stretch◦ Muscle groups exercised◦ Muscle groups prone to contractions
Practice functional activities