an analysis of l2 learners’ overuse and underuse of ......2. •quirk et al. (1985) examples...

29
An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of Intensifiers in English

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jan-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of

Intensifiers in English

�� ��

Page 2: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

1� ��

•���$4����59 (��18+

•��3#����25 ��'8�6�����

•�����&%�/,���3#��*/�)"7���!

•������� �- .�����0+

Page 3: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

1. ��

•#!�(.<7

? �/-�65�"�8*��3/�2)>���$�����������94

@ ���� �"�8*��/:;���/-&��%,1� 0 +'�=���

Page 4: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

2. ����

• Quirk et al. (1985) ��������

examples

Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely, completely, extremely,

Boosters very, highly, strongly, terribly

Downtoners Approximators nearly, virtually

Compromisers enough, rather

Diminishers partly, slightly, somewhat

Minimizers hardly, scarcely

Page 5: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

2. ����

• Firth (1968) : “one possible explanation for their overuse may well be that they have direct translational equivalents which are very frequent in French”. (for example, completely and complètement)

• Xiao $ McEnery (2006) explored the collocational behavior of intensifier and adjectives of Chinese-speaking English learners.

• Tuncar (2016) exaimined the use of maximizers and semantic prosodic awareness of Turkish speaking English learners.

Page 6: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

3. ����

•%43�<:�'�=1�$6/$50A���+!�&��#7

B '�=1�*@1�8�/�� �������� �

C '�=1�semantic prosody��?;).�� �

D >-���2 ���9-�"(D '�=1�,���*@1�CEFR-level�"(

Page 7: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

3. ����

•���� ���

ICNALE (��10��������������������)

BNC (��������������)

COCA (��������������)

Page 8: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

3. ����

•�&/�%!-�����*"��'.→ICNALE��$#���+�/#�����)�

• ���������,(��� �→ICNALE��$#������BNC��COCA���+�/#�����)�

Page 9: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. �� / . 14

Page 10: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��4.1 �/� ��������������•������� �����

ICNALE(per mil) BNC(per mil)

very 2433 901

really 319 88

much 294 166

so 711 532

too 478 363

Page 11: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• Downtoners . • downtoners.

Amplifiers Downtoners

BNC 81.6% 18.4%

ICNALE 97.9% 2.1%

ICNALE(per mil)

BNC(per mil)

virtually 2 20

partly 2 8

slightly 3 40

somewhat 5 27

hardly 2 17

4 1 /

Page 12: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

2. ����

• Quirk et al. (1985) ��������

examples

Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely, completely, extremely,

Boosters very, highly, strongly, terribly

Downtoners Approximators nearly, virtually

Compromisers enough, rather

Diminishers partly, slightly, somewhat

Minimizers hardly, scarcely

Page 13: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• very • so

BNC ICNALE

good important

much much

little bad

difficult good

different difficult

BNC ICNALE

much much

many bad

bad many

close important

easy easy

. .

Page 14: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

. .• too

BNC ICNALE

good important

much bad

little much

difficult good

different difficult

Page 15: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

�ICNALE�������

• Important��bad�����(per million words)

ENS in BNCLearners inICNALE

ENS inICNALE

important 393.43 1501.12 2120.22

bad 151.59 2399.32 860.76

Page 16: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• absolutely • extremely

BNC ICNALE

difficult (harmful)

important high

useful bad

rare important

valuable dangerous

BNC ICNALE

right necessary

neccesary wrong

clear true

essential right

sure correct

. .

Page 17: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• totally • very

BNC ICNALE COCA

Rate (%) Rate (%) Rate (%)

Positive 16.2 18.9 29.8

Negative 60.9 54.1 55.1

Neutral 22.9 27.0 15.1

BNC ICNALE COCA

Rate(%) Rate(%) Rate(%)

Positive 57.6 58.3 52.4

Negative 31.0 34.6 35.6

Neutral 11.4 7.2 12.0

Page 18: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• very • so

words CEFR-level

important A1

bad A1

much A1

good A1

difficult A2

happy A1

words CEFR-level

much A1

bad A1

many A1

important A1

easy A1

close A2

- . 4

Page 19: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• extremely • highly

words CEFR-level

high A1

dangerous A2

bad A1

important A1

essential B1

useful A2

words CEFR-level

likely B1

possible A1

dangerous A2

important A1

competitive B2

successful B1

- . 4

Page 20: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

• (3rd edition) : “The intensifier very does not

modify adjectives that include the meaning of very in themselves, such

as awful, great, wonderful, and so on”.

ØICNALE very wonderful, very terrible

4 / 5 (very terrible 21 )

./

Page 21: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

4. ��

5 5 /5 5

• very non-gradable adjectives

. Quirk et al. (1985) : “most adjectives are gradable” but

some of them, such as right or perfect are not.

ØICNALE5 4 very right very wrong5

Ø 5very quite4

Page 22: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

5. ��������

•'75�'78(�<%�7>��+!?2�$91F�� ��

Ø+!?2��E��6H��������4 �Ø#0@���=�;.�,�A��C�G���4 �

•'75�#.B.I5�"�������� �1F����:/����

Ø&-D2�*)�� �+!?2�3���������4 �

Page 23: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

5. ��������

•-0�<(�3%�����"'�7+�) �@:

Ø!(9(?.�*=�������������#��-0�>8����2�/�6���

Ø5�&$�������>8��� ��81�;,4�,�

Page 24: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

5. ��������

• Semantic prosody : totally�6-

�����$C1=������totally�*A.�37����B>�;�7&"5�*A.� ���!�#?�/ *A.������),� ��@0<�9@�����B>���$+%42�totally� ���!�#?�/ *A.�('���������8:�����

Page 25: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

5. ��������

•�,����&#�"0

Ø �4%��collocation��semantic prosody����-5�����,!(��$1��'+��*�)�2���� -5�/�������3.����

Page 26: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

6. ��

•$32�;9�(�<1�#5/#40?�����, %��"6

@ (�<1�+>1�7�/�����������

A (�<1�semantic prosody��=:*.����

B (�<1�'&����+>1�8-����!)

Page 27: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

6. ��

• )64�><�-!@3�&9/&82D���5�0# :

F )64�2D�-!@3�.C3������� ��$1B1E4�"�������)64������� ���(?��������;!�A �����

G very�so����)64�&92D��-!@3��)64�)6:'�7*�6=�.C3�,+�����/%����-!@3�&92D����

Page 28: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

6. ��

•/*?<I��82

Ø.(B6��� !�9M������+4D������@�=1 0�E�5J���GL��� 8��

Ø7����.(B6�3)�-����H8?;H��#&"�$%'���3)�:F�>8AK�

�������,.(B6 �����5�C������

Page 29: An Analysis of L2 Learners’ Overuse and Underuse of ......2. •Quirk et al. (1985) examples Amplifiers Maximizers absolutely,completely,extremely, Boosters very,highly,strongly,terribly

�����

• E r r AA r I

• L e I eC

• N I