smuggling of migrants from india to europe and in particular to the uk: a study on punjab &...

Smuggling of Migrants from India to Europe and in particular to the UK: A

Study on Punjab & Haryana

11 March 2010, Chandigarh

K. C. Saha, IASDevelopment Commissioner, Government of Bihar

Case Study from Punjab/Haryana (Methodology)

• Analysis of over 800 immigration-offence-related records for 2005, 2006 & 2007

• Police cases recorded against agents in different police stations in Punjab

• Interviews with deportees and/or their family members• Interviews with agents as well as police officers who

investigated these cases against the agents• Interviews with co-villagers/public representatives in more

than 30 villages• Case studies on irregular migration through investigators• Study visit to the UK and France

FINDINGS:

1. Trends and volume of irregular migration

2. Identification of areas prone to irregular migration

3. Profile of irregular migrants, reasons for irregular migration and destination countries

4. Profile of agents, sub-agents and their modus operandi

1. Trends and volume of irregular migration

• Over 20,000 youths from Punjab attempt irregular migration every year.

• It has not only spread to new areas in Punjab but also to the neighbouring states of Haryana, Himachal Pradesh and Jammu & Kashmir

• In the past, irregular migration was confined to few caste groups, now it has spread to other caste groups also

• Almost half (47%) of the cases of irregular migration relate to destination countries in Europe

1. Trends and volume of irregular migration

2. Identification of areas prone to irregular migration

3. Profile of irregular migrants, reasons for irregular migration and destination countries

4. Profile of agents, sub-agents and their modus operandi

FINDINGS:

Map of Punjab

Emerging

High

Map of Haryana

Emerging

High

1. Trends and volume of irregular migration

2. Identification of areas prone to irregular migration

3. Profile of irregular migrants, reasons for irregular migration and destination countries

4. Profile of agents, sub-agents and their modus operandi

FINDINGS:

3. Profile of irregular migrants

• 84% of irregular migrants are from rural areas • Youths were mostly from agricultural families who can afford high cost of irregular migration• More than 90% irregular migrants are males• About 55% of irregular migrants are in the age group of 21-30• A substantial number of irregular migrants are also in the age group of 31-40• Irregular migrants are noted to have poor educational attainment

Reasons for irregular migration

• High unemployment rate• General attitude of youth that migration to the other countries is the best

alternative• Potential irregular migrants consider other successful migrants as their

role models• Irregular migration not at all a stigma amongst families• Once a family is able to send someone abroad legally or illegally, family

status increases• Social networks promote chain migration• Perception amongst migrants that once one is able to reach a destination

country, chances of getting caught and deported is remote.

Destination countries

• Destination countries are varied. Irregular migrants have attempted to go to 57 destination countries.

• Belgium is also a destination country for irregular migrants, however, in Europe the UK is the most favoured destination

• A substantial number of cases of irregular migration to Italy, France and Spain were noted.

1. Trends and volume of irregular migration

2. Identification of areas prone to irregular migration

3. Profile of irregular migrants, reasons for irregular migration and destination countries

4. Profile of agents, sub-agents and their modus operandi

FINDINGS:

4. Profile of agents and sub-agents

• Proliferation of agents in Punjab due to high demand of their services• Many of the agents in Punjab are actually sub-agents of principal agents

based in cities in Punjab and also Delhi• A substantial number of agents were in the age group of 21-25. They are

the new entrants in the business.• Agents in Punjab were found to work in groups with well established links

with agents in Delhi• Carrier agents accompanied irregular migrants in many cases. Some of the

carrier agents were females who accompanied minor children

Modus operandi of agents

1. Jacket substitution of passports, photo substitution, fake foreign visas, re-stitched passports, forged passports, forged residence permits, exchange of boarding cards in security areas, forging of POE stamp etc

2. Forged visas of 41 countries had been used. Many instances of forged visas for Italy, Greece, France, Spain and the UK were noted.

3. Many instances of forged residence permits of Portugal, Spain, Italy and the UK were noted.

4. Agents made use of various transit countries to take migrants legally to the transit countries before their irregular migration.

5. Agents have used various routes some of which are traditional whereas the others are emerging routes

6. Routes via a country in Central Asia or a country in West and North Africa are emerging routes

7. Fees for USA and Canada was much higher than any country in Europe. It was more than US$ 50,000. For destination to the UK the fees were higher compared to the other countries in Europe.

8. Agents have become highly professional and they operate through well-knit networks.

9. Services of agents are utilized even by public representatives and other responsible citizens

Modus operandi of agents (part 2)

Recommendations:1. Independent legislation to check migrant smuggling2. Specialized counter smuggling law enforcement units3. Database on smuggling4. Training and capacity building of law enforcement

machinery5. Awareness campaigns in identified areas6. Regional focus on irregular migration from South Asia7. Close cooperation between countries of source,

transit and destination

Thank you

www.unodc.org/southasia