housing the “big society”

1

Housing the “Big Society”Phillip Blond

Director, ResPublica

2

The Core Problems• The ECONOMIC problem

• The SOCIAL problem

• The CIVIC problem

• The POWER problem

3

The Economic ProblemAssets have become concentrated

• The wealthiest half of households hold 91% of the UK’s total wealth

Source: ONS, Wealth in Great Britain – Main Results from the Wealth and Assets Survey 2006/08 (2009)

4

The Economic ProblemGrowing income inequality (UK)

Index of rise in gross weekly earnings, full time males (1978-2008)Source: Stewart Lansley, “How Rising Inequality contributed to the crash”, Soundings, Spring 2010

5

The Economic ProblemWages won’t deliver (US)

Over the long-term, US wages have stagnated in a time of growth

6

The Economic ProblemWarning signs of a UK decoupling?

Male median wages have fallen behind GDP growth since the early 1970s

7

The Economic ProblemLow-earners have seen less growth, and even decline, in wages (UK)

8

The Social ProblemSocial capital is declining

• 97% of communities have become more socially fragmented over the past 30 years

Source: Changing UK (Dec 2008), BBC Report

9

The Social ProblemFear of crime (UK)

Fear has a strong relationship with social trust

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

0 20 40 60 80

Social trust (%)Es

timat

e of

bur

glar

y (%

)

10

The Civic ProblemCivic engagement has decreased

• Only 31% of Britons now provide nearly 90% of all volunteer hours

Source: Third Sector Research Centre (2010)

11

The Civic ProblemDecrease in civic participation (UK)

12

The Power ProblemPower has pooled in the state

• Nearly three out of four Britons agree that “the state intervenes too much”

Source, David Halpern, “The Wealth of Nations” (2007)

13

The Power Problem

14

The DiagnosisProblems with the ‘left’ and ‘right’

• Both welfarism and the ‘monopolised market’ have encouraged bureaucracy and asset concentration

• The state and the market have squeezed out the ‘civic middle’, stripping it of capital and capacity

15

Housing: Potential Issues• Retreat of the state from funding and regulation.

• The need for new solutions

• Meeting government policies and reflecting local communities

16

Housing: Opportunities• In delivering the localism agenda: enablers and

investors

• As platforms for opening, extending and devolving public services

• As mutual models

17

Localism• Local connection is essential

• Housing associations can work on behalf of communities: e.g. neighbourhood planning, economic development – Green Deal

• Support those with limited capacity and capital

18

Localism

Tübingen User-Led Housing: a self-commissioned neighbourhood

19

LocalismTübingen User-Led Housing• Self-commissioned, self-designed plot by plot

neighbourhood development • Working in labour and design partnership• Active participation in delivering solutions rather

than ‘top-down’ standardised delivery

20

• Housing providers are well placed for broader public service delivery

• Platform the ‘right to challenge’: ‘right to buy’

• Offer platform for community-based enterprise and investment: Skill Generating :-Work Programme

Association led Investment

21

Active Citizen Developers

Hørsholm Waste-to-Energy: a neighbourhood clean-tech incinerator

22

Hørsholm Waste-to-Energy• Community not-for-profit asset – shared wins

• Incinerator waste-to-energy plant heats 10,000 homes: cuts heating bills by 30%

• Energy cost savings raise house valuations

Bottom up Procurement

23

Opening Public Services

24

Opening Public ServicesPoplar HARCA• Big business, but relevance through local governance

• Asset transfer of underused facilities: community centres now used for youth groups, health clinics, etc

• Managed by HA but input by and for locals

25

Mutual Models• Does community-ownership and mutualism have a

role to play in housing?

• Increase accountability and transparency – and safeguard social mission through a “social dividend”

• Community empowerment

26

Mutual Models

27

Mutual Models• Anticipated ownership model: membership drawn

from tenants and staff – Rochdale Borough Wide Housing

• Developing new accountability membership framework

• Working together to reduce costs

28

Housing the Big Society• Appeal to the local: be a platform for the Localism

Bill and encourage investment• Platform provision: open public services and offer

alternatives for delivery local platform for statutory services – Hubs : -St Georges - Birmingham

• Ground in the social: devolution of governance and assets

29

The Future • Social housing as Social Enterprise• If its Public money has to be for the Public

Good• Housing no longer enough – that’s the base

not the high bar

30

The New Standard • Economic – self and community build –

plaform for mass bottom up enterprise• Social – associate to create capital and skills• Civic – begin where people are - foster

relationships and fraternity• Power – change governance – go bottom up