am ltia multi-id t p ti c t lindustry perspective on control … · 2018. 4. 30. · am ltia...
TRANSCRIPT
A M lti I d t P ti C t lA Multi-Industry Perspective on Control Engineering for Resilient Infrastructures
Tariq SamadTariq SamadCorporate FellowHoneywell Automation and Control Solutions
Berkeley, CA, June 16, 2014
Honeywell.com
OutlineOutline
• The diversity of CPS infrastructures• Resilience—the state-of-the-practice• Resilience and smart grids
2Document control number
Honeywell.com
CPS Infrastructures--ExamplesCPS Infrastructures Examples
• Power systemsSmart Grid Conceptual Model (NIST)
• Microgrids• Smart buildings• Process plantsp• Factories• Oil and gas pipelines• Water distribution networks• Water distribution networks• Air traffic management• Road traffic management• Rail transportation• . . . and interconnections of the
above (e.g., smart cities)Barcelona water distribution network (EU FP7 WIDE project)
3Document control number
Grenoble smart highway (courtesy of C. Canudas-de-Wit)
Honeywell.com
Connected Homes as CPS InfrastructureConnected Homes as CPS Infrastructure
http://wifithermostat.comhttp://mytotalconnect com
4Document control number
http://mytotalconnect.comhttp://greenbuttondata.org/
Honeywell.com
CPS versus Cyber InfrastructuresCPS versus Cyber Infrastructures
• Examples of “cyber-only” infrastructures:– financial networks– corporate IT systems– networked monitoring and surveillance systems
• What difference does the “physical” element make? . . .
Energy underpins CPS infrastructures!
5Document control number
gy p
Honeywell.com
Facets of CPS infrastructures and their controlFacets of CPS infrastructures and their control
Legacy systems and their accommodation
Standards and i t bilit
6Document control number
interoperability
Honeywell.com
Cross-industry CPS InfrastructuresCross industry CPS Infrastructures
• CPS infrastructures differ across several dimensions– requirements, characteristics, properties
• Resilience a cross-cutting need– but details vary across industries
• How can we characterize cyberphysical infrastructures?– capture commonalities as well as differences?
Abstractions are important, but solutions must be
7Document control number
p ,informed by the problem domain
Honeywell.com
OutlineOutline
• The diversity of CPS infrastructures• Resilience—the state-of-the-practice• Resilience and smart grids
8Document control number
Honeywell.com
Resilience – the state-of-the-practiceResilience the state of the practice
• A new buzzword perhaps but today’s complex infrastructures• A new buzzword, perhaps, but today s complex infrastructures are hardly devoid of “resilience”
U d t di i d t ti i ti l if h i t• Understanding industry practices is essential if research is to have real-world impact
9Document control number
Honeywell.com
Example: Contingency analysis in power systemsExample: Contingency analysis in power systems
• Power system operation attempts to ensure that stability is i t i d d b f “ ti i ”maintained under a number of “contingencies”
– outage of transmission lines, transformers, generators, etc.• Contingency analysis is a “what-if” scenario simulator
– off-line analysis and on-line operator tool• “N-1” contingency analysis: Exhaustive test that grid limits
(thermal, voltage, etc.) are not violated with the outage of any individual component of the power system– usually required by utility policy
• N-2, N-3, etc. contingency analyses may also be performed based on likelihood of component failures
• Requires a detailed model of the power system network, integrated with state estimation
10Document control number
http://www.smartgrid.epri.com/UseCases/ContingencyAnalysis-Baseline.pdf
Honeywell.com
Example: Layered safety approach in process plantsExample: Layered safety approach in process plants
• Layers of protection widely recognized by process industryrecognized by process industry
• Layers can serve different purposes: preventative, mitigation, deterrence, detection, alerting
• Dedicated safety instrumented system (SIS), independent of other control systemsIEC 61508 IEC 61511 t d d• IEC 61508, IEC 61511 standards
11Document control number
An Integrated Approach to Safety: Defense in Depth, whitepaper available at honeywellprocess.com
Honeywell.com
OutlineOutline
• The diversity of CPS infrastructures• Resilience—the state-of-the-practice• Resilience and smart grids
12Document control number
Honeywell.com
The Smart Grid ChallengeThe Smart Grid Challenge
LG T&DTraditional LG T&DTraditional power system
f, V,
LG T&DSmart grid (with high
renewablesprice, commands, CO2, . . .
frequency, voltage, load, . . .
renewablespenetration)
13Document control number
A large-scale, distributed, techno-economic control problem!
Honeywell.com
Smart grids—the enhanced need for resilienceSmart grids the enhanced need for resilience
• Higher penetration of intermittent renewables
Daily peak managementRamp Smoothing
renewables• Increasing stresses on transmission
and distribution infrastructure• Continued lack of cost effective large• Continued lack of cost-effective large-
scale storage solutions• Demand-side management demands
customer engagement and acceptancecustomer engagement and acceptance• Economic incentives favored over
direct load controlApproaches:• Approaches:– automated demand response– microgrids
k t d i
Load Shifting & Ancillary Services
Grid Balancing Issues
14Document control number
– market design (diagram courtesy of LBNL / DRRC)
Honeywell.com
Example: Automated Demand ResponseExample: Automated Demand ResponseAutomated demand response – “Changes in electric use by demand-side resources from their normal consumption patterns in response to
h i th i f l t i it t i ti
Utility
changes in the price of electricity, or to incentive payments designed to induce lower electricity use at times of high wholesale market prices or when system reliability is jeopardized.” [FERC]
LoadDevices
? Utility $
Aggregation
EnergyManagement
System
LoadDevices Direct load control—utility
controls devices in facilities
15Document control number
Aggregation
Honeywell.com
PG&E Auto-DR System Architecturey
tP G & E D R A S
S ecure W eb S erv ices
Inte
rnet
D R A S
`
Inform ationS ystem
O perato rs “1”, “3 ” o r “5” ind ica ting price leve ls
In ternet
R T P S erver
W S
T arget
C LIRW S
C lient
M ulti-s ite E nterprise
C ontro l S ystem
M u lti-S ite E nterprise
C ontro l
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S Protocol
C lient
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S Pro tocol
C LIR
EM C S Protocol
E M C S P rotocol
A C W D ,
C ontro l S ystem
F eedback
Electric Loads
CC C
EM C S Pro tocol
G TW Y
E lectric Loads
CC C
E M C S P rotocol
G TW Y
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S Protoco l
S im ple C lient
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S Protoco l
G TW Y
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S P ro tocol
G TW Y
Electric Loads
CC C
E M C S Protocol
S im p le C lien t
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S P ro tocol
E lectric Loads
CC C
E M C S P rotocol
E lectric Loads
CC C
C o ntra C osta C o unty
Electric Loads
CC C
E M C S Protocol
E lectric Loads
CC C
EM C S Protoco l
E lectric Loads
CC C
S ven hard ’s, IK E A , e tc .
16Document control number
S ite 1 -25 S ite 1 -3C o ntra C osta C o unty 1 C LIR fo r 10 S ites -D B P1 C LIR fo r 3 S ites- C P PS olectron , e tc .
N etA pps
Honeywell.com
DOE Smart Grid Investment Grant Award2009 American Recovery & Reinvestment Act (ARRA) Smart Grid Grant
$11.4M DOE-funded; $22.8M total project
DOE Smart Grid Investment Grant AwardU.S. Department
of Energy
• Project Implementation• Operating Center• CPP Tariff Creation
• System Planning
Southern California Edison (SCE)
• Customer Acquisition and Deployment
• Reporting
• System Planning• Event Notification• Incentive Payment
• Regulatory Reporting
DR Automation System
JACE Controllers• Integration with
Existing BAS
DR Automation System (DRAS)
• Event Control• Information Dashboards
• Reporting
700 SCE Customers (80 MW – Auto-DR)• > 200KW Use
• Program Participation Agreement• DR Specific Programming Change to BAS
• Customer Dashboard
17Document control number
• Individual Event Participation or Opt Out
Honeywell.com
Automated DR for ancillary servicesAutomated DR for ancillary services
• Ancillary services “support the transmission of electric power from seller to purchaser given the obligations of control areas and transmitting utilities within p g g gthose control areas to maintain reliable operations of the interconnected transmission system.“ (FERC)
Ancillary Service Response Time Duration Telemetry
Regulation Up Start in <1 min.; 15 – 60 min. 4 sec.g p ;reach limit in <10 min.
Regulation Down Start in <1 min.;reach limit in <10 min.
15 – 60 min. 4 sec.
Non-Spinning Output in < 10 min 30 min 4 sec ; everyNon Spinning Reserves
Output in < 10 min. 30 min. 4 sec.; every minute
Spinning Reserves
Instant start;full output in <10 min.
30 min. 4 sec.; every minute
18Document control number
(Products and requirements of ancillary services markets in California)
Honeywell.com
Vehicle-to-Grid for Ancillary ServicesVehicle to Grid for Ancillary Services
• Los Angeles Air Force Base: first pilot for DoD V2G Project– partners include SCE, Honeywell, Lawrence Berkeley National Lab
• First federal installation to replace all general purpose fleet vehicles with plug-in electric counterparts– 41 plug-in EVs with charging stations, V2G-capable, ~15kW per vehicle– tools for scheduling and dispatching of PEVs
• Monthly frequency regulation revenues in CAISO: ~$15/kW (2011)• First of several anticipated installations for DoD V2G systems• Ancillary service market structures could be built around statistical
models for driving patternsg p
19Document control number
Honeywell.com
LA Air Force Base V2G ProjectLA Air Force Base V2G Project
20Document control number
slide courtesy of C. Gorguinpour, US Air Force
Honeywell.com
Example: MicrogridsExample: Microgrids
21Document control number
Honeywell.com
The Case For Micro-Grids (U.S.)( )
Heavily burdened, aging electrical grid
The toll of power disruptions
22Document control number
Honeywell.com
Microgrid Case StudyMicrogrid Case StudyUS Food and Drug Administration (FDA) campus, White Oak, Maryland• 9 000 employees
Current energy assets Under expansion:
9,000 employees• 362,000 m2
• Islanding capability required
Current energy assets 27,000 ft2 central plant Electrical generation
► 5.8 MW reciprocating engine (dual fuel)
Under expansion: 57,000 ft2 central plant Electrical generation
► 2 X 7.5 MW turbine-gen (dual fuel)► 4 X 4.5 MW turbine-generator (nat. gas)► 2.0 MW diesel black-start gen
Chilled water► 2 X 1,100-ton absorption chillers
► 4.5 MW turbine-gen (nat. gas only)► 5 MW steam turbine-generator► 2 X 2.25 MW diesel black-start gen
Chilled water (3 X 2,500 tons), p► centrifugals (2 X 1,100 tons + 3 X 2,000
tons) Dual-fuel hot water back-up boilers
► 3 X 10 MMBtu/Hr
( , ) Thermal energy storage (2 million gal) Heat recovery steam generators (132,000 lbh) Dual-fuel steam back-up boiler (25 KPPH)
23Document control number
► 3 X 10 MMBtu/Hr 25KW fixed & 5KW tracking PV array
Heating hot-water converters (112 MMBTUH)
Honeywell.com
Results and BenefitsResults and Benefits
UptimeUptime Uptime over the last 12 months is > 99.999%.
Island ModeIsland ModeIslanded, either automatically or manually, 47 times over the past 18 months. Operations have not been interrupted for any weather related events.
Power GenerationPower Generation On a yearly basis more power is supplied to utility than utility supplies to the White Oak Campus.
Energy ConservationEnergy Conservation 30% reduction in energy use from baselineEnergy ConservationEnergy Conservation 30% reduction in energy use from baseline
CO2 MitigationCO2 Mitigation 50,000 metric tons CO2-equivalent; 15,000 cars’ worth. Under construction: additional 22,000 metric tons.
National Capital Region Demand Reduction
National Capital Region Demand Reduction
$3M in Demand Savings and Program Participation
24Document control number
Further benefits anticipated with expansion
Honeywell.com
Integrated Microgrid Optimization Problemg g p
DEMAND SIDESUPPLY SIDE
Wind Campuses
Optimization of generation, storage and consumption
Wind
Photovoltaics
p
Load managementGeneration
forecastLoad
forecast
System Optimization
Cogeneration (CHP)
Neighborhoods
g- Curtailable loads- Reschedulable loads- Critical loads
Equipment schedules, fuel switching
UTILITIES
Other sources – e.g. biomass Optimum
use of storage capacities
Purchase or generate?
fuel switching
Bulk electricity network Energy storage
componentsElectric cars
Batteries fuel cells
UTILITIES
Demand response, dynamic pricing, buying green power Can be used as
a temporal storage
25Document control number
Batteries, fuel cells, hydrogen, thermal storage, etc.
a temporal storage
Honeywell.com
Economic incentives and market mechanismsEconomic incentives and market mechanisms• Wholesale electricity markets are
dynamic– day-ahead to spot markets– locational marginal price (LMP)– can be volatile and even negative
• Retail tariffs are numerous and complex– PG&E offers about 90 tariffs– regulatory oversight
• Interest in dynamic pricing for retail customers increasing
• Flat• Time of use
• Demand response• Green power
Examples of Retail Tariffs
g• Coupling of markets and power
can’t be ignored . . .
e o use• Critical peak pricing• Real-time pricing• Demand charge• Block and index
G ee po e• Net metering• Feed-in tariff• Plug-in electric vehicle• Increasing block price
26Document control number
• Block and index• Net metering
• Increasing block price• Low income
Honeywell.com
OutlineOutline
• The diversity of CPS infrastructures• Resilience—the state-of-the-practice• Resilience and smart grids• Speculative coda: Resilient communication in peoplep p p
27Document control number
Honeywell.com
Resilient Communication in Humans? [1]Resilient Communication in Humans? [1]
A: Do you know what time it is?B: Well, the milkman just came.
--S.C. Levinson, Pragmatics, 1983g
28Document control number
Honeywell.com
Resilient Communication in Humans? [2]Resilient Communication in Humans? [2]
--K Meehan Meehan’s Streak 2004 With permission of the artist--K. Meehan, Meehan s Streak, 2004. With permission of the artist.
29Document control number
Honeywell.com
ConclusionsConclusions
• Diversity of CPS infrastructures– abstractions are important to strive for . . .– but societal and industry impact will require deep domain
understanding• Safety, security, and resilience have been top-of-mind concerns
in the state of the practice – sophisticated approaches honed over decades . . .– pervasiveness of cyber-connectivity poses new vulnerabilities
• Power systems with high renewables penetration a priority CPS infrastructure– smart grids resilient grids– economic incentives at wholesale and retail levels
30Document control number