alloys for corrosive environments nickel

Upload: 8bgbc

Post on 01-Mar-2018

227 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/26/2019 Alloys for Corrosive Environments Nickel

    1/6

    NICKEL

    Alloys for

    Corrosive

    Environments

    Awide range

    of

    nickel-base alloys

    Copper,

    molybdenum, and tungstenall increase

    the

    inherent

    corrosionresistance ofnickel. In addi-

    tion, mo y enum and tungsten are significant

    in highly aggressive environments, strengthening agents, dueto their largeatomic sizes.

    The

    compositions of a fewnickel alloys are given

    ____________________________________________ in

    Table

    1.

    These

    are all wrought alloys, available

    Rcnil B

    Rebak*

    in the formof plates, sheets, bars,pipes,tubes, forg-

    P 1

    ~ ings, and

    wires.

    u~ roo ~

    The

    role of chromium is the

    same

    as that in the

    Haynes

    International Inc. stainless steels:

    it

    enhances the formation of pas-

    Kokomo,Indiana sive surface films, in the

    presence

    of oxygen. These

    passive

    films impede

    the

    corrosion process.

    Iron,

    if added to the

    nickel alloys,

    also

    affects

    passiva

    -

    ickel-base

    alloys provide outstanding tion. Silicon is

    beneficial

    at

    high

    corrosionpoten-

    resistance

    to specific chemicals, and tials,

    where chromium-rich

    passivefilms cannot be

    some

    are extremelyversatile and

    able maintained.

    It offers

    extended protection through

    -

    to handle complex

    process

    andwaste the

    formation

    of protective (silicon-rich)oxides.

    streams. In particular, the versatile

    alloys

    are much

    less subject than stainless

    s~.eels

    ostresscorrosion Nickel

    alloy metallurgy

    cracking

    pitting, andcrevice attack inhot chloride-

    Most

    of the corrosion-resistant nickel alloyshave

    b e a r i n g s o l u t i o n s . A l s o , nickelalloys are among the a single-phaseatomic structure. In

    common

    with

    fewmaterials able towithstand

    hot

    hydrofluoric the austenitic stainlesssteels, this is face-centered

    acid, a chemical

    that

    is

    very

    corrosive to the reac- cubic. To optimize performance, designers of the

    tive

    metals titanium, zirconium,

    niobium,

    and nickel alloys

    have

    taken advantageof the fact

    that

    tantalum).

    greater quantities

    of elements such as chromium

    The aim of this article is to describe the general and molybdenumare soluble in this face-centered

    characteristicsof nickel-base alloysand to examine cubicstructure at temperatures in excess of 1000C

    the effects of different

    aggressive

    environmentson (1830F) than at lower temperatures. Furthermore,

    the corrosion behaviorof these alloys, added elements can

    be

    retainedwithin this phase

    if thematerialsare water-quenched from the high

    temperatures.

    Therefore,

    such alloys are

    solution

    a n n e a l e d todissolve anyunwantedsecond phases,

    and water quenched to freeze-in thehigh-tem-

    perature structure.

    Second

    phases arepossible, if they are subjected

    to elevated

    temperature

    excursions, for example

    during

    welding. The

    kinetics of second-phasefor-

    Table

    1

    Nominal

    compositions

    of

    nickel alloys

    Nickel

    alloy

    t y p e s

    The nickel alloys

    canbe

    categorized

    according

    to the

    main alloying

    elements, as follows:

    Nickel: primarily forcaustic solutions.

    Nickel-copper: primarily for

    mild,

    reducing

    solutions,

    especially

    hydrofluoric a c i d .

    Nickel molybdenum: primarily for strong,

    reducingmedia.

    Nickel-iron-chromium:

    primarily for oxidizing

    solutions.

    Nickel-chromium-silicon:

    primarily

    for

    super-

    oxidizing

    media.

    Nickel-chromium-molybdenum:versatile

    alloys

    for all

    environments.

    The

    terms reducing and

    oxidizing

    refer to

    the nature of the reaction at cathodic sites

    during

    corrosion. Reducing solutions such as hydrochloric

    acid

    generally

    induce

    hydrogen evolutionat

    ca

    -

    thodic

    sites. Oxidizing

    solutions such as nitric acid

    induce

    cathodic reactions

    with higher

    potentials.

    *Merliber

    ofASMInternational

    Group

    Alloy

    Ni

    Cu

    Mo

    Fe

    Cr

    Others

    Ni

    200 99.5

    Ni-Cu

    400 67

    31.5

    1 .2

    Ni-Mo B -3

    68.5

    28.5

    1.5 1.5

    Ni-Fe-Cr 82 5

    43 2 .2 3 30 2 1 .5 0.9 Ti

    N i - F e - C r G-30 44 2

    5 1 5 3 0

    2 . 5 W ,

    4Co

    Ni-Cr-Si D-205

    65

    2 2 .5 6

    20

    5

    S i

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    C-2 7 6 57 16 5 16

    4W

    Ni-Cr-Mo C- 4 68 16 16

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    C-22 56

    13

    3 2 2

    3W

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    C-2000 60 1 .6 16 23

    H2l 1 6

    Reprinted from the February 2000 issue ofAdvanced Materials & Processes

  • 7/26/2019 Alloys for Corrosive Environments Nickel

    2/6

    mation

    depend critically on the amount of over-

    alloying

    and the contentof minor elements, such

    as carbon

    and

    s i l i c o n

    Carbon iskeptas low aspos-

    sible

    in

    th ewrought alloysby

    special

    melting

    tech-

    niques. Silicon is also held at

    low levels

    in

    most

    of

    the

    wrought

    alloys,

    since

    it is a

    strong promoter

    of

    second

    phases. Indeed, this iswhy the

    Ni-Cr-Si

    ma-

    terials are not

    more

    highly

    alloyed.

    In

    cast

    nickel

    alloys, a small quantity of silicon is necessary for

    fluidity during pouring. However, it heightens the

    importance of the solution annealing and

    quenching

    processes

    with

    c a s t i n g s .

    Nickel

    alloyperformance

    Although

    the

    numberof environmentsencoun-

    tered

    within

    the chemical

    processindustries

    is

    vast,

    the

    performance

    of m e t a l l i c materials is

    most often

    based on

    their resistance

    to a few

    aggressive

    inor-

    ganic chemicals.

    These are predominantly hy-

    drochloric acid, sulfuric acid, and hydrofluoric acid.

    Also

    very important

    are the effects of residuals such

    as ferric ions.

    Caustic solutions:

    The

    most common caustic

    so

    -

    lutions

    are sodium hydroxide or

    caustic soda

    NaOH) andpotassium hydroxide

    or

    causticpotash

    KOH).

    Whencontamination

    with

    ironor

    stress

    corrosion

    cracking is

    not

    a

    problem,

    these

    sub

    -

    stances are sometimes handled

    in

    carbon

    s t e e l ;

    how-

    Fig.

    T he

    higher the

    content

    of

    nickel,

    the lowerthe

    cor

    -

    rosion rate in caustic solutions.

    Fig.

    Corrosion rateof three nickel alloys

    in 30 NaOH

    as afunction of the temperature.

    ever, nickel and nickel alloys are the

    metals

    that

    offer the

    highest

    resistance to corrosion in caustic

    solutions.

    F i g u r e

    shows the corrosion rateof

    sev

    -

    eral alloys in

    boiling

    50

    NaOH solution.

    The

    higher thenickel content in the a l l o y , the lower

    th e

    corrosion rate.

    The

    corrosionresistanceofnickel is

    a

    consequence of the

    formation

    of

    insoluble

    metal

    hydroxides

    and salts,which slow down the

    disso

    -

    lution rateof the alloy.

    Figure 2 shows the corrosionrateof

    three

    alloys

    in 30

    NaOHas a function ofthe temperature.Ni-

    200

    o f f e r s

    the

    best resistance to corrosion,especially

    at the

    higher

    temperatures.

    Sodium h y p o c h l o r i t e

    b l e a c h

    can be

    considered

    a

    m i l d l y

    oxidizing

    alkaline salt

    that

    canalso be

    suc

    -

    c e s s f u l l y handledby

    a nickel

    a l l o y ,

    e s p e c i a l l y

    of

    th e

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    group

    (C-276

    or C 2000 alloys).

    Hydrochloric

    acid:

    Hydrochloric acid

    HC1) is

    very corrosive, and its

    aggressiveness

    can change

    drastically depending on the

    acid

    concentration,

    temperature, and

    contamination

    of the

    acid e.g.

    ferric ions). In general, steels, stainlesssteels, and

    copper alloys

    cannot

    tolerate HCI .

    O f

    the

    reactive

    metals,

    titanium does

    notresist HC1

    well

    zirco-

    nium is s a t i s f a c t o r y forpure acid, and

    tantalum

    of

    -

    fers

    excellent

    performance.

    F i g u r e

    3

    shows

    the

    cor

    -

    Chemical

    processes

    most

    often

    involve

    a few

    aggressive

    chemicals.

    _I~ss

    ~oing ~15oc~

    100- ~O/~OH

    10- C-22

    4

    8250 06

    Ni20060 0 0l0~

    276 0 --2 0

    1-

    - 0

    0.01

    V

    20 40 60 80 10 0

    Nickel Content

    Weight )

    1

    E+ 6

    ~ -T ~ 1

    E+ 4

    E Boiling Solutions

    1E 5 316SS ~ 1E 3~

    1E 4-~ lE 2~

    lE 3-~-

    18+2~

    1E+0~

    2

    15 1 ~ IE-1

    15 0

    r I

    ~__~ ~702 0 -

    15 .2

    :c1~

    Thnlalom.,

    1E-1 T

    ~~

    ~1~

    8

    12 16 20

    4 -

    Hydrochloric

    Acid

    )

    Fig. 3 Thisgraph

    shows

    the corrosion of

    commercial

    alloys

    of stainless steel titanium nickel and zirconium

    in boiling HCI solution.

    5zi, UCI

    s C-2000

    ~

    3l6t~S

    9 ~33

    C276

    4 400

    023

    1563 ~ 30 ~F 3 I

    ~ 54-200

    1 E O 1

    ,5- 625

    15 2 ~ / /

    1E*0~

    .5

    1 1 5

    ~

    15*1

    ~

    isle

    o

    6~

    0

    3 1E*0

    E-2

    0

    1E-1 ~ i 3

    100 150 20 0 250 30 0

    Temperature C)

    1E+4

    1E+3 ~

    0~

    S

    5 15*2

    Ct

    0

    15*1

    50

    15*0

    15+2

    a

    5

    1E*l

    I

    15-1 Ct

    0

    IE- 2

    12 0

    IC-I

    0 40 80

    Temperature

    CC )

    Fig. 4

    Effect

    oft/ic

    temperature

    on t he co rros ion rate of

    nickel-basealloys and

    316L

    stainless s teel i n 5 HC1.

  • 7/26/2019 Alloys for Corrosive Environments Nickel

    3/6

    Temperature

    0 to5

    HC1

    5 to 10

    HC1

    10

    to

    20 HC1

    79C

    to

    B.P.

    (175F toB.P.)

    Ni-Mo

    (B-3) Ni-Mo

    (B-3) Ni-Mo (B-3)

    52C to 79C

    (125F to 175F)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    (C-2000)

    Ni-Cu

    (400)

    Ni-Mo

    (B-3) Ni-Mo (B-3)

    RT to52C

    (RT

    to

    125F)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    (C-2000)

    Ni-Fe-Cr (G-30)

    Ni-Cu (400)

    Ni-Mo

    (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    (C-2000)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    (C-2000)

    For

    each

    alloy group,

    on e example

    isgiven.

    BP.

    boiling

    point, RT

    =

    room temperature.

    Oxidizing

    impurities

    rosion behavior ofseveral alloys in boiling solu- Table

    2

    Nickel alloy selection forpure HC1*

    tions of pure hydrochloric acid. At intermediate

    acid concentrations, the corrosion rateof 316SS can ________________________________________________________

    bemore than four ordersofmagnitude higher than

    the corrosionrate of zirconiumor

    B -3

    alloy. ___________________________________________________________

    Figure 4 shows the effect of

    temperature

    on the

    corrosion

    rate

    of several nickel-base

    a l l o y s and 316L

    SS.

    Formostof the alloys, the

    corrosion

    rate

    grad

    -

    ually

    increases as the temperature increases.

    For C-2000 alloy, a threshold temperature is

    reached,

    below which the corrosion rate

    isnegli

    -

    gible

    due to passivation

    of

    the

    alloy;

    above the

    threshold temperature, the corrosionrate increases

    rapidly

    as the temperature increases.

    However, forthe

    B -3 alloy,

    the corrosion ratedoes

    not

    depend

    strongly on temperature. The fact that

    the corrosion

    rate

    ofthe

    B -3

    alloy at the boiling

    tem

    -

    p e r a t u r e is

    lower than the corrosion rateat temper- centrations

    and

    temperatures, whereas

    316L

    stain

    -

    atures below the

    boiling

    point, could

    be related to less steel is

    generally unsuitable forhydrochloric

    the

    amount

    of dissolved

    oxygen

    at

    each tempera- acid

    service.

    Alloys 4 00

    and

    82 5 may

    be

    adequate

    ture

    (which decreasesas the

    temperature

    increases). at

    room

    temperature.

    The

    nickel alloys

    that

    should be

    considered for TitaniumGrade2, as well as the stainless steels

    service in pure hydrochloric

    acid

    are

    shown

    in containing 6 molybdenum (such as

    254SM0) ,

    are such as

    Table 2, a nine-segment chart organized by

    con- resistant

    to

    low

    concentrations ofHCI.

    Theresis-

    ftrric ions

    centration and temperature. The selections are tance of ,irconium r-702 alloy) to

    pure

    hy- are

    based

    on

    evidence that alloys from the chosen

    drochioric

    add

    is

    exceptional;however, in

    the

    pres

    -

    groups exhibit

    rates

    of 0.5

    mm/y

    (2 0 mpy)

    or

    less ence of ferric ions Zr-702

    would be

    subjected to

    detrimental

    over significant concentration

    and temperature

    pitting corrosion. Tantalum also

    exhibitsexcellent to

    Ni Mo

    ranges,

    within

    those

    segments.

    Table 2 covers

    only resistance

    to

    pure

    HO solutions

    up

    to175C (350F),

    concentrations up

    to2 0

    wt ,

    the

    maximum that

    but it is

    unacceptable

    if

    the HC1

    solution is

    conta-

    an i U

    can

    be

    sustained in aboiling solution. It indicates minatedwith fluorides.Fluoride ion impuritiesare allot~s.

    that, of the nickel alloys, only those from the nickel- also damaging to titanium and zirconium alloys.

    molybdenum

    group are suitable at

    high

    concen-

    Su~fitric

    acid:

    Sulfuric acid is the

    mostwidely

    trations

    and

    temperatures. used

    acid

    in

    all

    branches

    of

    industry. Sulfuric

    acid is

    In fact,molybdenum is

    the

    mostimportant al less

    corrosive thanhydrochloric

    acid, and its ag-

    loying

    element forgood

    performance

    of nickel-base

    gressiveness

    is highly

    dependent

    on acid concen-

    alloys

    in pure

    hydrochloric

    acid

    educing condi-

    tration, temperature, and the

    presence

    of impuri-

    tions). The

    corrosion

    ratein boilingHO decreases ties. Figure 6 shows the corrosion rate of several

    asthe content of

    molybdenum i n

    the alloy increases, alloys inboiling pure

    sulfuric

    acid. Sulfuric

    acid

    Oxidizing impurities

    in

    hydrochloric

    acid,

    such

    aqueous

    solutions up to

    96

    wt are

    stable

    at

    the

    as

    ferric ions

    (F ), are

    detrimental

    to

    the

    perfor- boiling

    point.

    mance of the nickel-molybdenum and nickel- However, theseboilingpoints increase

    dramati

    -

    copper alloys.Under suchconditions, the nickel- cally at themedium and high concentrations. For

    chromium-molybdenum

    alloys constitute the

    best

    example, at 20 sulfuric acid, the boiling point is

    choice,

    because they

    aretolerant of residuals, al- 104C (220F), at 50 is

    123C

    (253F), and at

    80

    is

    though

    they

    are temperature-limited at the higher 202C

    (395F).

    TitaniumGrade 2 and 316L stain-

    acid

    concentrations. less steel are notadequate forsulfuric

    acid

    service.

    Figure 5 shows the corrosion rateof several

    al

    -

    loys inboiling 2.5 HC1 solution as a function of

    theconcentration

    of ferric

    ions in the solution. The

    corrosion rates of 316L SS and alloy

    82 5

    are

    high,

    and are not affected significantly by the presence

    of

    f e r r i c

    ions.

    Thecorrosion

    rate

    of

    the

    B -3

    alloy

    in

    the pure boiling

    acid

    is

    low,

    but

    it

    gradually in-

    creases as the

    content

    of ferric

    ions

    in the solution

    increases. Thecorrosionrate of C-2000 in pureacid

    is higher

    than that

    ofthe B -3 alloy;however,a con-

    tent

    ofonly 3 ppm Fe

    3~

    produces a decline in its

    corrosion

    rateby almost

    two

    orders of

    magnitude.

    The oxidizing ferric ions

    promote the

    passivation

    of C-2000 by the formation of a chromium-rich

    oxide film that reduces the uniform

    dissolution

    rate.

    Figures

    3, 4,

    and

    5 show

    t h a t

    the

    nickel

    chromium-molybdenum alloys suchas

    C-2000

    are

    resistant to

    HO in

    a

    moderately broadrange

    of

    con-

    Fig. 5 Corrosion rate ofcommercial alloys in a solution of

    I I C l contaminatedwithferric

    ions.

  • 7/26/2019 Alloys for Corrosive Environments Nickel

    4/6

    Figure

    6

    shows that

    theB -3 alloy has the

    lowest

    corrosionrate ofthe nickel alloys inboilingsulfuric

    acid. Only at the highest acid concentration (>70 )

    does

    the

    corrosion

    rateof B -3

    start

    to increase.

    The

    strongconcentration effecton the

    corrosion

    rateof

    zirconium alloy 7 02

    is

    also revealed.

    Figure 7 shows the effectof

    temperature

    at a

    con

    -

    stant

    acid

    concentration.As in the case of HC1

    so

    -

    lutions

    (Fig. 4 ) , the

    temperature

    has a

    strong

    influ-

    ence on the

    corrosion rate of Ni-Cr-Mo and

    Ni-Cr-Mo-Fe

    alloyssuch

    as

    C-2000

    and G-30; how-

    ever,

    the

    corrosion

    rate

    of a

    Ni-Mo

    alloy

    (B-3)

    is

    al

    -

    mostunaffected by the temperature

    low

    activa-

    tion

    energy).

    Table 3 shows the types of nickel

    alloy

    that

    should be considered for service in pure

    sulfuric

    acid, depending on the acid concentration and

    tem

    -

    perature.

    The

    selections are basedon evidence

    that

    alloys from the chosen groups exhibit

    rates

    of 0.5

    mm/y

    (2 0 mpy) or less over significantconcentra-

    tion and temperature

    ranges, within

    those

    seg

    -

    ments. The

    important

    revelationsof this

    chart

    are

    the excellent

    corrosion

    resistance of the

    nickel-

    molybdenum

    a l l o y s in

    pure

    sulfuric

    acid,

    thegood

    resistance of

    thenickel-chromium-molybdenum

    materials,

    and

    the usefulness

    of

    several

    groups

    at

    lower

    concentrations

    and temperatures.

    Fig. 7

    Th is g raph

    shozos the effect of tens

    perature

    on the

    corrosion

    rate

    of

    several

    nickel

    base alloys.

    The

    presence of contaminants in

    sulfuric

    acid

    could change the corrosionrate ofthe a lloys . F igure

    8 shows the corrosion rateof alloysB -3 and C-2000

    inpure sulfuric

    acid

    and in

    sulfuric acid

    contami-

    nated with 2 00 ppm

    chloride

    ions s NaCl). The

    corrosion rate of

    both

    alloys increases if the

    solu

    -

    tion

    is contaminated;

    however, the effect seems

    more pronounced for

    the

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    alloy.

    Hydro,fluoric

    acid: Hydrofluoric

    acid

    is extremely

    corrosive and unique in its corrosion behavior.

    Many industriesuse it as anaqueous solution, as

    a

    fluorinating

    agent,

    for

    metal pickling,

    and in

    the

    manufacturing

    of semiconductors.

    Nickelalloysare the

    only

    alloys that arewidely

    chosen forhandling aqueous solutions ofhydro-

    fluoricacid,

    because

    stainless steels, titanium, zir-

    conium,and tantalum are

    not

    adequate for this ap-

    plication.

    The

    most

    common alloy for handling

    aqueous

    hydrofluoric

    acid iswroughtMonel 400.

    This alloy has excellent corrosion resistance in the

    absence ofair or

    otheroxidizing

    species; however,

    if

    oxygen is present, itis subject toaccelerated inter-

    granular attack,

    especially

    in thevapor phase.

    Figure

    9

    shows

    the

    corrosionrate

    of three nickel

    alloys in the liquidphase immersed conditions),

    and in

    the

    vapor phasewherevapor condenses

    on

    the

    coupons

    (forthese tests, the ingress of air to the

    testingkettles

    was

    not restricted).

    Alloy 400 corrodes athigh rates in the vapor

    phase,

    because

    of intergranular attack.

    The

    corro-

    sionrate of alloy 4 00

    is

    higher at

    thehigher

    tem-

    perature,

    both

    for the liquid andvaporphases.

    Thecorrosion

    rate

    of theB -3 alloy

    is

    lowerin the

    vapor phase

    than

    in the liquid phase. Moreover, at

    thehigher temperature, its

    corrosion rate

    inboth

    phases

    is

    lower. In general, thecorrosion rateof B -

    3 is

    not

    highlyinfluenced by the temperature;

    there

    -

    fore, the lowercorrosionrate at the

    higher

    temper-

    ature

    can

    be

    the result of

    a

    lower

    availability

    of

    oxygen

    both

    in the liquid and vapor phases. The

    B -3 alloy is subject to

    pitting

    corrosion inHFenvi-

    ronments,bothin

    the liquid

    and vapor

    phases.

    The C-2000

    alloy

    showed

    the lowest corrosion

    rate in all the

    tested

    conditions.

    Laboratory

    testing

    hasalso shown

    that

    the

    corrosion

    rate of C-2000 in

    Fig. 8

    This

    graph

    shows the

    effect

    ofcontamination by

    chlorides

    in sulfuric acid on a llo ys B -3 and C-2000..

    Hydrofluoric

    acid is

    extemely

    corrosive.

    20 40 60

    Sulfuric

    Acid

    Concentration C /

    Fig. 6

    Corrosion

    rate in boiling sulfuric acid.

    1E*3 ~

    Immersion

    r sts

    Boiling Solutions

    Full

    Syrnbols~

    Mded

    200

    ppm C1

    s

    is-I

    v C

    2000

    1E+3 ~--- --------- - i

    60

    i-i

    2

    so

    4

    lE+l

    ~ C2000

    1E+2 ~

    ~g

    :H-u B-I

    5

    4 1 0

    L

    1El

    Ct

    0

    I- -

    1E+0 -

    I

    B. P

    I

    IE-1 ~ ~ ~- C~

    0 40 80 120 180

    Femperature

    C)

    t

    a

    15+0

    I

    1E-l ~

    0

    St

    0

    to

    15*1

    -C

    1 E C 2

    1E-l

    3

    C

    It

    1E*0

    I

    1E-l ~

    if

    0

    C

    N

    -rr

    l

    1F-2

    IE-l--

    1

    I 3 ~

    0

    20

    40

    H

    2

    S0

    4

    Concentration ~

    60

  • 7/26/2019 Alloys for Corrosive Environments Nickel

    5/6

    Table3 Nickel alloys forpure

    sulfuric

    acid*

    thevaporphase

    is

    time

    dependent;

    that

    is,

    the rate

    decreases

    as the

    test

    duration in-

    creases.

    Thisisprobably dueto the

    gradual

    development of a protective

    film

    on the

    surface.

    The

    corrosion rates of alloys 4 00

    and C-2000 in the liquidphase do

    not

    depend on

    the testing time.

    Nickel-base alloysare

    susceptible

    tostress

    corro

    -

    sioncracking in

    the

    presence

    of

    aqueous solutions

    ofhydrofluoric acid.

    Not

    all

    nickel alloysare equally

    susceptible toSCC

    under

    thesame conditions; that

    is,

    cracking isstronglydependenton several variables,

    such as alloy composition, temperature, presence

    of

    o x y g e n , and

    liquid vs.vaporphase.

    Mixtures

    of

    hydrofluoricandnitricacid

    are typ-

    ical in

    themetal industryforpickling

    processes. In

    a solution of 20

    HNO

    3

    containing different

    amounts of h y d r o f l u o r i c acid, the lowestcorrosion

    rate corresponds to G-30 , a Ni-Cr-Fe

    alloy

    con-

    taining30 chromium,

    The

    high

    chromium

    con-

    tentpromotes

    the

    formation

    of a

    passive

    film in the

    oxidant nitric acid, and

    does

    notseem tobe readily

    attacked

    by thehydrofluoricacid.

    Other acids:

    Phosphoric acid (H

    3

    PO

    4

    )

    is

    not

    highly

    corrosive

    to

    nickel

    alloys.

    Two distincttypes

    of

    phosphoric acid

    are

    encountered

    in

    the industry.

    The

    pure

    reagent

    grade) acid ismade from ele-

    mental phosphorus, derived fromphosphate rock.

    This is oxidized, then

    reactedwith water.

    Onthe

    otherhand, the preferred

    type

    ofphosphoric acid in

    the

    agrichemical

    industriesis madeby reacting

    phos

    -

    phate rock

    with sulfuric acid.

    This

    containsseveral

    impurities, notably sulfuricacid, s i lica, and chloride

    and fluoride ions,

    which

    markedlyaffect the corro-

    sionbehavior

    of the acid. The

    levels

    of these impu-

    rities

    vary

    dependingon the source of the rock, and

    differentbatchesof this so-called wetprocessacid

    can

    vary

    considerably in their corrosivity.

    The

    G-30

    alloy is

    generallypreferred to handle

    the wetprocess phosphoric acid. Forpure phos-

    phoric acid, Ni-Mo (B-3), Ni-Cr-Mo (C -276 , C -2000)

    and Ni-Fe-Cr (G-30) alloys can function in up to

    85 acidup to theboiling point.

    The

    corrosion

    behavior of hydrobromic acid

    HBr)

    is

    similar

    to

    that

    of

    hydrochloric

    acid;

    how

    -

    ever,HBr is less

    aggressive. Therefore,

    when

    pure

    and hot,HBr isbest

    handled by

    a Ni-Mo alloy

    such

    as the B -3 alloy. -A

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    alloy

    such

    as C-2000

    isversatileand is s u i t a b l e for

    most

    applications

    con

    -

    taining HBr, especiallyin solutions contaminated

    Temperature

    0 to 30 H

    2

    S0

    4

    30 to 70 H

    2

    S0

    4

    70

    to96 H

    2

    S0

    4

    79C toB .

    P.

    175F to B.P.)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo C - 2 0 0 0

    Ni-Fe-Cr

    G - 3 0

    Ni-Cr-Si (D-205)

    Ni-Cu

    (400)

    Ni-Mo (B-3) Ni-Mo (B-3)

    52C to 79C

    (125F to

    175F)

    -

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo (C-2000)

    Ni-Fe-Cr (G-30)

    Ni-Cr-Si

    (D-205)

    Ni-Cu (400)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    (C-2000)

    Ni-Fe-Cr (G-30)

    Ni-Cr-Si

    (D-205)

    Ni-Cu (400)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo (C-2000)

    RT

    to

    52C

    (RT to 125F)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo (C-2000)

    Ni-Fe-Cr

    (G-30)

    Ni-Cr-Si

    (D-205)

    Ni-Cu

    (400)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo C - 2 0 0 0

    Ni-Fe-Cr (G-30)

    Ni-Cr-Si (D-205)

    Ni-Cu

    (400)

    Ni-Mo (B-3)

    Ni-Cr-Mo

    (C-2000)

    Ni-Fe-Cr

    (G-30)

    Ni-Cr-Si (D-205)

    For each al loy

    group,

    on e example is given.

    withoxidizing species.

    Organic acids

    such

    as formicand acetic

    acids

    are

    nothighly corrosive for

    nickel

    alloys.

    At

    tempera-

    tures

    higher than 100C (212F) , the B -3 alloy

    Ni-

    Mo) would offer the lowestcorrosion

    rate.

    N i t r i c

    acid

    is a

    strong oxidizing

    acid

    which be

    sides zirconium and titanium alloys, can

    behan

    -

    dled

    with

    stainlesssteelsornickel alloys

    containing

    at least 15 chromium othernickel alloyssuch as

    B-3, Ni-200, andMonel 4 00 cannot

    be

    used in nitric

    acid). For

    mostpurposes,

    anickel alloy

    isnot

    re-

    q u i r e d

    to

    handle

    nitric acid;however,nickel alloys

    resist corrosionbetter

    than

    s t a i n l e s s steels in cases

    where the

    nitric

    acid

    is

    contaminated

    with

    chlorides. R

    Fo r

    more

    information: D r. Rail

    B .

    R e b a k

    (765/456-6262) ,

    is a

    Corrosion

    Engineer;Paul Crook ( 7 6 5 / 4 5 6 - 6 2 4 1 )is

    Manager, Technical Services,

    at

    Haynes

    Intemational,

    1020

    W.

    Park

    Ave., Kokomo, IN 46904 ; e-mail:

    [email protected]; [email protected];

    Web

    site:

    www.haynesintl.com.

    References

    1. Corrosion Engineering, by MG.

    Fontana:

    McGraw-Hill ,

    Inc.,

    New

    York , N .Y . ,

    1986.

    2.

    Process

    Industries Corrosion Theory

    and

    Practice, by

    J .K.

    N e l s o n :

    NACE

    Intemational, Hou ston,

    Texas,

    1986.

    3.

    Corrosion

    Control

    in the Chemica l Process

    Industries,

    by

    C.P.

    Dillon:

    NA CE International , Houston, Texas, 1994.

    Corrosion

    Resistance

    Tabie,~,by P.A. Schweitzer, (New

    York,

    NY ; Marcel D ekker ,

    Inc.,

    1995.

    5

    T a p e r

    382, by

    JR .

    Crum

    G.D. Smith,M.J.

    McNallan,

    and

    S H i r n y j : C o r r o s i o n / 9 9 ,

    N E International,

    Houston, Texas, 1999.

    Phosphoric

    acid is

    not

    highly

    corrosive

    to nickel

    alloys.

    12

    U

    400

    Nickel-base

    alloy

    Fig. 9

    Corrosion

    ofnickel alloys in hydrofluoric

    acid

    liquid

    an d vapor.

  • 7/26/2019 Alloys for Corrosive Environments Nickel

    6/6

    A n a h e i m

    C a l i f o r n i a

    9 2 8 0 6

    S t a d i u m

    P l a z a

    1 5 2 0

    South

    Sinclair Street

    T e l : 714-978-1775

    8 0 0 - 5 3 1 - 0 2 8 5

    F A X : 714-978-1743

    Houston, Texas 77041

    The Northwood Indus tr ial Park

    1 22 41 FM 52 9

    T e l : 713-937-7597

    800-231-4548

    F A X : 713-937-4596

    Arcadia, Louisiana7 1001-9701

    3786

    Second

    Street

    Tel:

    318-263-9571

    800-648-8823

    F A X : 318-263-8088

    C h e c k o u t o u r w e b s f t e : w w w

    0

    h a y u e s n t i c o m

    I

    ter,Ml 2ER FAX: 39-2 2 82 82 73

    T e l :

    4 4 -1 6 1 2 3 0- 7 77 7

    F A X

    4 4

    16 1 2 2 3 2412

    France

    HaynesInternational, S.A.R.L.

    S w i t z e r l a n d

    Nickel Contor AG

    Zl des Bethunes

    10 ru e de Picardie

    95310 Saint-Ouen LAumone

    T e l : 33-1-34-48-3100

    F A X 33-1-30-37-8022

    Hohlstrasse 534

    CH-8048 Zur ich

    T e l : 41-1-434-7080

    F A X : 41-1-431-8787

    ll

    t r e m r ks

    a re o w n e d b y a y n e s I n t e r n a t i o n a l I n c