agenda exploring the what are designers/specifiers...
TRANSCRIPT
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 1
precast.org/education
EXPLORING THE GREENER SIDE OF
CONSTRUCTIONWHAT THE NEXT GENERATION OF SPECIFIERS
ARE LOOKING FOR?LM6
Jamie Meil, Athena Sustainable Materials Institute
precast.org/education
AGENDA
• What are designers/specifiers looking for?• Greener products with verified claims/data
• What is an EPD?
• How to read an EPD
• EPDs in LEEDv4• MR credits and their inner workings
• Creating EPDs• Precast Industry Wide EPDs case study
• Sustainable Plant Program – intent & progress
precast.org/education
WHAT IS AN ENVIRONMENTAL PRODUCT DECLARATION?
Environmental FactsOne square meter of carpet
Life cycle impact from cradle to one year of usage
Energy Consumption
Total nonrenewable primary energy 209.12 MJ
Total renewable primary energy 4.02 MJ
Total primary energy 213.14
Resource Consumption
Nonrenewable resources 15.40 kg
Water 0.5338 m3
Waste Produced
Non-hazardous waste 15.52 kg
Hazardous waste 0.0706 kg
Impact Measures
Acidification potential 2.06 mol H+ Equiv.
Eutrophication potential 0.0044 kg N-Equiv.
Global warming potential 10.61 kg CO2-Equiv.
Ozone depletion potential 9.34E-07 kg CFC 11-Equiv.
Smog potential 0.50 kg NOx-Equiv.
Not this:
It’s this:
An EPD is a way to transparently disclose
environmental performance data
TYPES OF ECO-LABELS
1. Third-party certificationsA “seal of approval”, usually involves a logo. Examples: Energy Star, EcoLogo, FSC.
2. Self-declarationsE.g. “100% recycled”; “biodegradable;” “compostable”.
3. Environmental product declarationsNot a certification; a simple statement of environmental facts.
BENEFITS OF EPDS
1. UnbiasedThird-party programs and self-declarations reflect opinion and judgement.
2. TransparentThird-programs and self-declarations are typically opaque.
3. Widely applicableUsers bring their own judgement criteria when viewing the data.
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 2
SOME HISTORY
• EPDs have been around for some time.
• Heaviest and longest use in Europe.
• EPDs in Europe are seen in many sectors.
• ISO standards have been developed for EPDs.
precast.org/education
precast.org/education
Do we really know which bag is the greenest choice?
We need data – otherwise we’re just guessing
• Amount of material and energy used and wastes created in making the product.
• Greenhouse gas emissions due to making, using and disposing of the product.
• Water used to make the product.
• Air and water pollution caused in making, using and disposing of the product.
EPDS PROVIDE THE DATA NEEDED FOR DECISIONS
Impact category Unit1 m3 precast concrete,
cradle to gate
Global warming kg CO2 eq. 482
Acidification H+ moles eq. 128
Respiratory effects kg PM2.5 eq. 0.85
Eutrophication kg N eq. 0.071
Photochemical smog kg NOx eq. 0.739Solid waste kg 93.7Water use m3 0.836Abiotic resource depletion kg Sb eq. 2.79E-04Ozone depletion CFC-11 eq. 4.35E-08
Total primary energy MJ 5,059.2
Non-renewable, fossil MJ 4,455.0Non-renewable, nuclear MJ 274.0Renewable (SWHG) MJ 317.1Renewable, biomass MJ 13.02
WHAT LCA DATA LOOKS LIKE
precast.org/education
What we measure in life cycle assessment:
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 3
precast.org/education
North Face “Denali” jacket – LCA used to quantify benefits of recycled polyester and a new dyeing process.
Levi’s “Care Tag” – LCA showed that washing and drying is the biggest part of jeans’ footprint.
Cold Water Tide -LCA showed P&G that hot water usage is the biggest part of detergent footprint.
LCA MOTIVATIONS FOR INDUSTRY
Corporate responsibility: examine your environmental footprint with intention of improvements for social good.
Cut costs: respond to an economic incentive to reduce environmental footprint (e.g. carbon tax).
Communication: To develop EPDs or other forms of disclosure to meet market demand.
Marketing: create a beneficial corporate image by appearing pro-active and leading-edge; differentiate corporate culture and product from competitors.
LCA LIMITATIONS
• LCA measures some important environmental impacts, but not all of them.
• LCA does not replace metrics for other impacts –things like biodiversity and toxicity.
• Therefore, EPDs do not tell the whole story about product sustainability.
• Corporate sustainability strategy should include, but not stop with, LCA.
precast.org/education
HOW TO READ AN EPD
precast.org/education
Program Operator
EPD OwnersScope (cradle to gate)
Product identification
Adherence to standards
precast.org/education
PCR (Product-specific EPD standards)
Expiration date
Product quantity
Geographic applicability
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 4
precast.org/education
Reference to the full LCA report
precast.org/education
Product content
precast.org/education
LCA boundary (what’s included)
precast.org/education
Method and other technical details of the underlying study
precast.org/education
Data source and LCA tool
precast.org/education
LCIA method
LCA Results
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 5
precast.org/education
Category Indicator Unit Result
Life cycle impact assessment
Global warming potential kg CO2 eq. 298.8
Acidification potential kg SO2 eq. 5.0
Eutrophication potential kg N eq. 0.3
Smog creation potential kg O3 eq. 58.6
Ozone depletion potential kg CFC-11 eq. 1.9E-03
Primary energy consumption
Total primary energy MJ, HHV 2,620.2
Non-renewable (fossil, nuclear) MJ, HHV 2,574.1
Renewable (solar, wind, biomass, hydroelectric, &
geothermal)
MJ, HHV 46.1
Material resources consumption
Total material resource consumption kg 1,066.7
Non-renewable materials kg 1,065.8
Renewable materials kg 0.9
Fresh water l 1,597.3
Waste generated
Non-hazardous kg 65.2
Hazardous kg 10.0
Cradle-to-gate summary results per metric ton of structural precast panelTHINK OF THE EVOLUTION IN FOOD LABELING….
precast.org/education
EPDS IN LEED
precast.org/education
Source: Jane Anderson blog on thinkstep.com, October 2015. These numbers may be slightly low, as they
only reference EPDs that conform to the EN 15804 standard.
USA
LEED CREDITS FOR EPDS
“Building product disclosure and optimization -environmental product declarations”
• This is a LEED v4 MR credit (and also available in the same form as Pilot Credit 52)
• LEED intention: Motivate industry to do LCA in the hope that this will lead them to environmental improvements.
• Worth up to 2 points.
(PS: There’s another new LEED credit, worth at least 3 points, for whole-building LCA. Intention: motivate design teams to reduce the impact of their “products”.)
HOW TO EARN THE CREDIT
• Assemble enough product EPDs and earn 1 point• Assemble enough “good” products and earn 1 more
point.
From LEEDv4 Reference Guide
Finished element examples –metal studs, wallboard, concrete masonry units
Component product examples –concrete admixtures are considered separate products because each component (admixture, aggregates, cement) serve different functions; each component is therefore a separate product
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 6
ASSEMBLING ENOUGH EPDS
• Need at least 20 products with EPDs, from at least 5 different manufacturers
• But some EPDs only get partial credit• Industry-average is worth half a product• An LCA report only (no EPD) is worth a quarter product
Industry-average EPD is worth half a product
Brand-name EPD is worth a whole product
HOW THE PRECAST EPDS CAN HELP
“½ product” + “½ product” + “½ product” = “1.5 products”
The project team needs another “18.5 products” to earn one LEED point
WHO CAN USE THESE?
A manufacturer can affiliate with an industry-average EPD if “the manufacturer is explicitly recognized as a participant by the program operator.”
EARNING THE SECOND POINT
At least 50% of the value of all installed products must be:
• Better than average in at least three LCA metrics (requires industry averages for everything – we’re not there yet).*
• Or they must comply with a (still-to-be-developed) USGBC approved program.
Double-credit for local products.
There is a cap capped on the use of structure and envelope products for this credit (no more than 30% of the value of compliant products).
* A credit interpretation has added information: To qualify as “better than average”, the product manufacturer must have participated in the industry-average study. Another option is to show improvement of a product over time, by comparing to a previous EPD.
precast.org/education
CREATING EPDS
CREATING THE PRECAST EPDS
Manufacturer
LCA Practitioner
EPD Program Operator
CPCI, NPCA, and PCI commissioned the work
Athena Institute conducted LCA study, published the LCA report, responded to peer review, and prepared the EPDs. All in accordance with the PCR and ISO standards.
ASTM led development of the PCR, per ISO standards, and verified and registered the EPDs.
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 7
LCA FOR PRECASTSTUDY DETAILS
• 99 plants participated
• Good geographic representation, US and Canada
• Concrete mixes selected by an association-led technical committee
• The result is the environmental footprint for “average” precast products
precast.org/education
Manufacturers create LCA data on products
Manufacturers publish the data in EPDs
Manufacturers use the data to drive product changes for smaller footprints
Architects collect EPDs to earn a LEED point
Product LCA data is incorporated in whole-building LCA tools
Architects do whole-building LCA aiming for a smaller footprint to earn at least 3 LEED points
precast.org/education
NORTH AMERICAN PRECAST CONCRETESUSTAINABLE PLANT PROGRAM
Environmental Performance Standards
• Dust control• Process Water, Storm Water and
Chemical Management• Noise Control
Sustainability Performance Standards
• Energy• Materials• Transportation
Environmental and sustainability requirements
are based on the LCA outcomes.
precast.org/education
NORTH AMERICAN PRECAST CONCRETESUSTAINABLE PLANT PROGRAM
precast.org/education
Sustainable Plant Program
Report Publicly Released
North American Precast Concrete
Sustainable Plant Program
www.sustainableprecast.ca
Precast Show 2017
NPCA 8
SUMMARY
• An EPD is a summary of an extensive LCA report.
• EPDs are a transparent, non-judgemental communication vehicle.
• LCA measures some (not all) environmental impacts.
• LCA supports data-driven sustainability choices.
• LEED is trying to motivate manufacturers and designers to do LCA and make improvements.
• EPDs are not yet comparable and require specialized knowledge to interpret.
• But the data behind them is valuable and useful.precast.org/education
The Athena Sustainable Materials Institute
Ottawa, ON, Canada and Kutztown, PA, USA
www.athenasmi.org [email protected]