addressing unconscious bias in medicine - acep · addressing unconscious bias in medicine uché...
TRANSCRIPT
Addressing Unconscious Bias
in Medicine
Uché Blackstock, MDAssociate Professor, Department of Emergency Medicine
Co-Director, Emergency Ultrasound Fellowship - Department of Emergency MedicineDirector, Recruitment, Retention and Inclusion - Office of Diversity Affairs
Director, Ultrasound Content - Office of Medical Education
NYU School of Medicine
May 1, 2019
2
Land Acknowledgement
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Wichita, Comanche, Caddo, Cherokee, and Kiowa
3
Overview
● Objectives● Why should you care?● Historical context for bias in medicine● What is Unconscious Bias?
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
4
Objectives
● 1) To differentiate unconscious bias from conscious bias
● 2) To explore the ways in which unconscious bias impacts communication and decision-making
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
NYU School of Medicine5Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Fixed Growth
Mindsets
Take note of and reflect on any discomfort you feel as you
participate in today’s session.
7Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
8
Social Determinants of Health
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Racism
Sexism
Homophobia
Transphobia
Etc.
The Historical Context
10Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
11Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
12Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
13Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
14Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
15Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
16
Black Infant Mortality● 1850s
○ Black 340/1000 vs. White 217/1000● 1915-1990s
○ Overall infant mortality improved by 90%■ Better hygiene, nutrition, living conditions,
and healthcare● 1960 - 12th among developed countries● 2018
○ Black 11.3/1000 vs White 4.9/1000○ Wider disparity than 1850
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
https://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/maternalinfanthealth/pregnancy-mortality-surveillance-system.htm
17
Black Maternal Mortality
● US - 1 of 13 countries with worse maternal mortality now than 25 years ago
● Black women are 3-4x more likely than their white counterparts to die from pregnancy-related complications○ Higher than that of Mexico, where nearly half
the population lives in poverty ● Persists across socio-economic status
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
https://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/maternalinfanthealth/pregnancy-mortality-surveillance-system.htm
18Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
19Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/press-releases/2017/jul/mirror-mirror-press-release
Health Care System Performance Rankings
Explicit vs. Implicit Bias
21
What is Bias?
● A bias is a tendency, inclination, or prejudice toward or against something or someone.
● Some biases are positive and helpful.● Some biases are negative and
detrimental.
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
22
What is Explicit Bias?
Explicit bias is conscious bias.
● Aware, voluntary, intentional
Explicit bias can often be checked and controlled.
What are examples?
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
23Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
24
What is Implicit Bias?Implicit bias is unconscious bias.
● Unaware, involuntary, unintentional● Uncontrolled and automatic
associations between two concepts made very quickly
More complex due to its ingrained and subconscious nature.
What are examples?Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
25Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Mama = Good
26Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Fire = Bad
27Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Good or Bad?
Circle of Trust
29
Circle of Trust
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
30
Circle of Trust
Level 3: Know well enough to pass time of day with (acquaintances)
Level 2: Comfortable inviting them in to your home (friends)
Level 1: Made it into your inner circle (the trusted ones)
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Level 3
Level 2
Level 1
31
Circle of Trust
● What are the implications for the workplace?● As a leader, when you have an important task
or job to get done, to whom do you entrust that responsibility?
● As a physician, how does this phenomenon influence the way you care for your patients?
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Why should you care?
33
What is known?
Unconscious bias influences:
○ Medical student and resident recruitment and selection
○ Faculty recruitment, selection, and hiring○ Faculty mentoring○ Faculty advancement and promotion
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Improving Workforce Diversity
Improving Health Equity
35Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Health Outcomes
Patient -CenteredCommunication
PerceptionImplicit Bias
ClinicalDecision -Making
DiagnosticAbility
+
+
https://www.communitycatalyst.org/blog/community-catalyst-looks-inward-and-outward-in-observance-of-minority-health-month
36Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
37
Unconscious Bias:Pervasive and Necessary
● Everyone has it!● Helpful & Adaptive
○ Natural tendency to make associations○ Brain uses well-established mental
associations to operate without awareness, intention or control (conserves energy)
○ Provides the ability to categorize information
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
38
System 1:Limbic System
System 2:Prefrontal Cortex
ImplicitEffortlessReflexive
ExplicitEffortfulAnalytic
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
39
Unconscious Bias:Pervasive and Necessary
Not error-free
○ Influences our behaviors and perceptions; tends to replicate the social hierarchy
○ Can conflict with conscious attitudes and intentional behavior
○ Pervasively influences hiring, evaluation, and leadership selection
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
40
“We hear with our eyes”
Orchestra members handpicked
Early 1970s – introduction of screens → “blinding”
Increased numbers of women advanced – 50%
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Rouse & Goldin 2000 American Economic Review
41
The Power of the Resume:“Emily” or “Lakisha”
STUDY:
Fictitious resumes (n=4980) sent in response to actual “help wanted” ads in Boston and Chicago
Resumes
2 high quality, 2 low quality
African-American or White-sounding names randomly assigned
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
FINDINGS:Callback rate
10% for resumes with white-sounding names6.6% for resumes with African-American sounding names
Higher qualityWhite-sounding names –30% more callbacksAfrican-American sounding names – 9% more call backs
"Are Emily And Greg More Employable Than Lakisha And Jamal? A Field Experiment On Labor Market Discrimination," American Economic Review, 2004, v94(4,Sep), 991-1013.
42
Implicit Association Test (IAT)
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
43
Implicit Association Test
● Developed in 1998 by social psychologists● Detects the strength of an individual’s will to
associate two individual concepts (unconscious prejudices)○ The black-white race IAT has received the
most attention● Millions of people worldwide have taken the
tests
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
44
Implicit Association Test
● Most white respondents show an automatic white preference.
● Most Asian American respondents show an automatic white preference.
● 50% of black respondents show an automatic black preference, but the remaining half show an automatic white preference.
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
45
Implicit vs.Explicit Bias
● Clinicians vary widely in their levels of implicit and explicit bias
● Studies how that most white clinicians are high in implicit bias measures and low in explicit bias measures
● Regardless of specialty, most clinicians demonstrate an implicit preference for white people
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Academic Emergency Medicine 2017;24:895–904
46
Case
● 25 year old man● CC: severe lower back pain● PMH: none● Physical Exam: no midline tenderness, non-focal
neuro exam● Which is one major factor that will determine
whether he receives the standard of care for his back pain?
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
47
Racial bias in painassessment and treatment
● If he is black, then his pain will likely be underestimated and undertreated.○ Less likely to be given pain medications.○ When given, will receive lower quantities.
● Black patients less likely than white to receive analgesics for extremity fractures (57% vs 74%)in the ED despite similar self-reports of pain.○ Even among young children
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
48
1. Anderson KO, Green CR, Payne R (2009) Racial and ethnic disparities in pain: Causes and consequences of unequal care. J Pain 10(12):1187–1204.
2. Bonham VL (2001) Race, ethnicity, and pain treatment: Striving to understand the causes and solutions to the disparities in pain treatment. J Law Med Ethics 29(1): 52–68.
3. Cintron A, Morrison RS (2006) Pain and ethnicity in the United States: A systematic review. J Palliat Med 9(6):1454–1473.
4. Cleeland CS, Gonin R, Baez L, Loehrer P, Pandya KJ (1997) Pain and treatment of pain in minority patients with cancer. The Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group Minority Outpatient Pain Study. Ann Intern Med 127(9):813–816.
5. Freeman HP, Payne R (2000) Racial injustice in health care. N Engl J Med 342(14): 1045–1047.
6. Goyal MK, Kuppermann N, Cleary SD, Teach SJ, Chamberlain JM (2015) Racial dis- parities in pain management of children with appendicitis in emergency depart- ments. JAMA Pediatr 169(11):996–1002.
7. Green CR, et al. (2003) The unequal burden of pain: Confronting racial and ethnic disparities in pain. Pain Med 4(3):277–294.
8. Shavers VL, Bakos A, Sheppard VB (2010) Race, ethnicity, and pain among the U.S. adult population. J Health Care Poor Underserved 21(1):177–220.
9. Smedley BD, Stith AY, Nelson AR (2013) Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care (National Academies Press, Washington, DC).
10. Todd KH, Deaton C, D’Adamo AP, Goe L (2000) Ethnicity and analgesic practice. Ann Emerg Med 35(1):11–16.Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
49Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2016 Apr 19;113(16):4296-301
50
Racial bias in painassessment and treatment
● 418 medical students and residents● Two mock cases about a black and a white patient
○ Made pain ratings and medication recommendations● 50% reported that at least one of the false beliefs items
were possible, probably or definitely true○ Blacks’ nerve endings are less sensitive than whites’○ Blacks’ skin is thicker than whites’○ Blacks’ age more slowly than whites○ Participants who held the false beliefs more likely
to rate pain lower and made less accurate treatment recommendations
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
51Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Time pressure
Lack of solid information to make a decision
Cognitive overload
FatigueAcademic Emergency Medicine 2017;24:895–904
52
Patient -Provider Communication:The Effect of Race and Ethnicity on Process and Outcomes of Healthcare
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
● 75% Black patients interact with non -Black physicians
● Racially discordant interactions○ Less positive affect○ Less relationship
building○ Less treatment
planning○ Less health
information exchangeAm J Public Health. 2004 December; 94(12): 2084–2090
Implicit Bias
Power+
=Reinforce systems of oppression “ -isms”: Racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia
ActionsDecisionsBehaviors
54Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
55
Take home points
1. Health inequity does not exist in a vacuum2. Implicit bias influences:
● Clinical decision-making and patient-provider communication
● Recruitment, hiring and selection processes
Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
56Bias in Medicine - Uché Blackstock, MD
Thank you!
Uché Blackstock, MDAssociate Professor, Department of Emergency Medicine
Co-Director, Emergency Ultrasound Fellowship - Department of Emergency MedicineDirector, Recruitment, Retention and Inclusion - Office of Diversity Affairs
Director, Ultrasound Content - Office of Medical Education
NYU School of Medicine