Upload File

unconscious bias: a brief introduction

85
Unconscious bias A brief introduction Seán L. Stickle Chief Communications & Diversity Officer Physician Assistant Education Association

Upload: sean-stickle

Post on 22-Jan-2017

1.009 views

Category:

Education


1 download

Report

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Unconscious bias A brief introduction

Seán L. Stickle Chief Communications & Diversity OfficerPhysician Assistant Education Association

Page 2: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

What is unconscious bias?

Page 3: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

* *

Page 4: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 5: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

“I’m not biased.” —Everyone

Page 6: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

behavior vs intention

Page 7: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

systematic irrationality

Page 8: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Unconscious Bias A bias that we are unaware of, and which happens outside of our control. It is a bias that happens automatically and is triggered by our brain making quick judgments and assessments of people and situations, influenced by our background, cultural environment, and personal experiences. Unconscious Bias and Higher Education Equality Challenge Unit (2013)

Page 9: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Implicit Bias Refers to the same area, but questions the level to which these biases are unconscious especially as we are being made increasingly aware of them. Once we know that biases are not always explicit, we are responsible for them. Unconscious Bias and Higher Education Equality Challenge Unit (2013)

Page 10: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 11: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

“Your heritage is being vandalized every day by theft losses of petrified wood of 14 tons a year, mostly a small piece at a time.”

Page 12: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

First Rule of Bias Club Talk About Bias

Page 13: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Second Rule of Bias Club Prevent Bias

Page 14: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

How is unconscious bias relevant to PA educators?

Page 15: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Making biased decisions affects the recruitment and selection of staff and students, and the ability of those staff and students to achieve their full potential. Unconscious Bias and Higher Education Equality Challenge Unit (2013)

Page 16: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Double Jeopardy? Gender Bias Against Women of Color in Science Joan C. Williams, Katherine W. Phillips, Erika V. Hall (2014)

Page 17: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Exercise Stereotyping

Page 18: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Steve is very shy and withdrawn, invariably helpful, but with little interest in people, or in the world of reality.

A meek and tidy soul, he has a need for order and structure, and a passion for detail.

Page 19: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Steve is a…

1. librarian

2. farmer

Page 20: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Janelle is 31 years old, single, outspoken, and very bright. She majored in philosophy. As a student, she was deeply concerned with issues of discrimination and social justice, and also participated in anti-nuclear demonstrations.

Page 21: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Janelle is a…

1. bank teller

2. bank teller & active in the feminist movement

Page 22: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Exercise Stereotyping

Page 23: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

woxl hyqp kvbi zbpd

Page 24: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

sdty glvp xmlt ztub fbrm txzp

bhwp

Page 25: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

red yellow green blue red

blue yellow

Page 26: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

red yellow green blue red

blue yellow

Page 27: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Implicit Association Test

Page 28: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 29: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

What purpose does unconscious bias serve & why do we have it?

Page 30: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 31: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

10,000,000 bits/sec Retinal nerve

40 bits/sec Conscious mind "Neurophysiology of Sensory Systems”Manfred Zimmermann (1986)

Page 32: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 33: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Exercise Inattentional Blindness

Page 34: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubNF9QNEQLA
Page 35: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Exercise Inattentional Blindness

Page 36: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 37: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 38: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Schemas Implicit and habitual ways of organizing information about how we experience the world.

Page 39: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 40: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 41: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 42: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

pareidolia

Page 43: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 44: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 45: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 46: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 47: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 48: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 49: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

We do not see things as they are, we see them as we are.

—Anaïs Nin (1961)

Page 50: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 51: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

What kinds of unconscious bias are there?

Page 52: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 53: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 54: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

System 1: Reflex fast, automatic, frequent, emotional, stereotypic, unconscious

System 2: Reflective slow, effortful, infrequent,logical, calculating, conscious

Page 55: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

System 1: Reflex fast, automatic, frequent, emotional, stereotypic, unconscious

System 2: Reflective slow, effortful, infrequent,logical, calculating, conscious

Page 56: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

System 1: Reflex fast, automatic, frequent, emotional, stereotypic, unconscious

System 2: Reflective slow, effortful, infrequent,logical, calculating, conscious

Page 57: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

heuristic vs algorithm

Page 58: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

COST Corner-cutting Objectivism Self-protection Time & Money

Page 59: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Corner-cutting Mental shortcuts that help us make quick and efficient decisions

Page 60: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 61: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Objectivism The implicit belief that our perceptions, beliefs, understanding, and experiences are objectively true.

Page 62: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Self-protection We are motivated to feel good about ourselves and the groups we belong to

Page 63: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Time & Money Negative information is more salient than positive, and we value things more that are closer to us

Page 64: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

What are the effects of unconscious bias — both positive and negative?

Page 65: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 66: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 67: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 68: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Ego Depletion/Decision Fatigue When judges make repeated rulings, they show an increased tendency to rule in favor of the status quo. This tendency can be overcome by taking a break to eat a meal. “Extraneous factors in judicial decisions” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2011

Page 69: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 70: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 71: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNCrMEOqHpc
Page 72: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

What can I do about unconscious bias as a PA faculty member?

Page 73: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

behavior vs intention

Page 74: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

1. Diversify Engage with “other” people & find positive role models

Page 75: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

2. Slow down You move too fast

Page 76: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

The reflex brain stereotypes, even in people who considernon-discrimination as one of their main values and who sincerely and consciously practice this belief.

BrainChains, Theo Compernolle (2014)

Page 77: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

In designing bias-countering processes and practices, encourage those that place a premium on cognitive effort over intuition or gut instinct.

“Beyond Bias,” Strategy+BusinessHeidi Grant Halvorson & David Rock (2015)

Page 78: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Individual cognitive effort is not enough. You have to cultivate an organization-wide culture in which people continually remind one another that the brain’s default setting is egocentric.

“Beyond Bias,” Strategy+BusinessHeidi Grant Halvorson & David Rock (2015)

Page 79: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Interviewing 1. Write down your initial impressions 2. Reorient your attitudes based on

impressions 3. Write down your closing impressions 4. Confer with others

Page 80: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

3. Poka yoke ( ) Make the right thing easy Make the wrong thing hard

Page 81: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 82: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 83: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction
Page 84: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Unconscious Bias A brief introduction

Seán L. Stickle Chief Communications & Diversity OfficerPhysician Assistant Education Association

Page 85: Unconscious Bias: A Brief Introduction

Unconscious Bias A brief introduction

Seán L. Stickle Chief Communications & Diversity OfficerPhysician Assistant Education Association


Addressing Unconscious Bias in Higher Education

Conscious and Unconscious Gender Bias

Unconscious Bias - PAEA Admissions Workshop

Seven Misconceptions About Unconscious Bias Guide

Unconscious Bias - University of Manchester

Unconscious Bias Training - Living Institute...2017/09/06  · Unconscious Bias Training - taking control of business decisions and enhancing diversity by mitigating unconscious bias

Social Location, Positionality & Unconscious Bias

Becoming Conscious About Unconscious Bias

Is Unconscious Bias Holding Us Back?

eLesson: Unconscious Bias · PDF fileUnderstanding Bias Unconscious Bias Defined Unconscious bias is a quick and often inaccurate judgment based on limited facts and our own life experiences

Unconscious Bias Welcome. Today Introductions The concept of unconscious bias How unconscious bias affects recruitment decisions Understanding more about

Lawson Delaney: Understanding Unconscious Bias€¦ · UNDERSTANDING UNCONSCIOUS BIAS 03 9946 7300 suppor [email protected] .au .au/diver sity

Avoiding unconscious bias · 2018. 4. 3. · Avoiding unconscious bias Avoiding unconscious bias: a guide for surgeons 5 Bullying Bullying is where an individual or group abuses a

Unconscious Bias and the Decisions we Make · Unconscious Bias An unconscious bias is an association or assumption held by an individual or group which affects attitudes and behaviours

The New Science of Unconscious Bias:

UNCONSCIOUS BIAS AND EDUCATION - Oranuioranui.co.nz/images/oranui_reports/unconscious-bias-and-education.… · UNCONSCIOUS BIAS AND EDUCATION A comparative study of Māori and African

Unconscious Bias in the STEM Disciplines

Unconscious Bias and Recruitment Minimising the …... Unconscious Bias and Recruitment Minimising the Impact What is unconscious bias? In a world that is busier and more chaotic than

Uncovering Unconscious Bias

UNCONSCIOUS BIAS & FACULTY RECRUITMENT AND RETENTION · unconscious bias & faculty recruitment and retention a brief primer courtesy of t he office of diversity affairs august 2018

Detecting and Punishing Unconscious Bias

Unconscious bias webinar presentation

Imposter Syndrome and Unconscious Bias Training syndrome and unconsciou… · Agenda Imposter syndrome workshop and Unconscious Bias training What is Imposter Syndrome/ Unconscious

Heavybit's Unconscious Bias Unconference

Unconscious bias in the primary classroom - NUSTEM › wp › wp-content › uploads › 2016 › 06 › ... · Unconscious bias – it just might save your life! Our unconscious

UNCONSCIOUS GENDER BIAS IN THE STEM PROFESSIONS · Unconscious Bias | 5 What forms can unconscious bias take? Unconscious bias – also called hidden or implicit bias - comes in a

Unconscious Bias Report 2016 - UCAS

Wepow Diversity & Unconscious Bias Interview Guide · Wepow Diversity & Unconscious Bias Interview Guide Overcome unconscious bias in the hiring process to harness diversity’s true

Navigating unconscious bias · Anger, dislike (Siy et al 2013) @UBP_STEM // @windupanna Negative stereotypes Unconscious bias ... Unconscious bias Barriers to entering tech Barriers

UNCONSCIOUS BIAS - gender.go.jp

Avoiding unconscious bias - University of Alberta...Avoiding unconscious bias Avoiding unconscious bias: a guide for surgeons 3 Bias In addition to acknowledging and addressing our

What is Unconscious Bias; considerations and top tips. · PDF fileOutline of session What is Unconscious Bias; considerations and top tips. 1. Overview – What is Unconscious Bias

Reducing unconscious bias: a - Inside NKU: Northern ... · Reducing unconscious bias: a highly effective toolbox … and how to avoid the unconscious bias pitfalls A growing number

Unconscious Bias

Mitigating Unconscious Bias in the Workplace