acrin breast committee fall meeting 2010 6657 extension-contrast-enhanced breast mri and mrs for...
TRANSCRIPT
ACRIN Breast Committee
ACRIN Breast CommitteeFall Meeting 2010
6657 Extension-CONTRAST-ENHANCED BREAST MRI and MRS FOR EVALUATION OF PATIENTS UNDERGOING NEOADJUVANT TREATMENT FOR
LOCALLY ADVANCED BREAST CANCER
Nola Hylton ,PhDConstantine Gatsonis, PhD
Pat Bolan, PhD6657 Trial Team
ACRIN Breast Committee
ACRIN Breast Committee
ACRIN 6657 Trial Extension
Surgery
Anthracycline TaxaneClinicalStudy
MRI/MRS MRI/MRS MRI/MRS
Core biopsy
• Both CALGB 150007 and ACRIN 6657 were amended and re-opened in
September 2007; additional target accrual of 140 patients
• Same treatment paradigm as in original trials
• ACRIN 6657 amended to add single voxel 1H MR spectroscopy to the imaging
protocol; testing MRS [choline] as a marker of early response
• Short term endpoint used (pCR)
ACRIN Breast Committee
6657 Extension Aims
• New aims are testing total choline concentration [tCho]
measured by single voxel 1H MR spectroscopy following
1 cycle of chemotherapy for distinguishing responsive
and non-responsive tumors. Includes:
Reproducibility testing
1.5 T versus 3.0 T comparison
Acute (20-28 hour) versus persistent (48-96 hours) post treatment time
point comparison
ACRIN Breast Committee
6657 Extension Aims
• Accrual to-date:
114 patients accrued
96 enrolled at 1.5 T
16 enrolled at 3.0 T
44 enrolled at 20-28 hr
26 enrolled at 48-96 hr
28 enrolled outside of protocol time points
14 – time point data missing
• Analysis to-date
ACRIN Breast Committee
Design (ISMRM 2008 poster)
• Standard phantoms
• Entry and Weekly scanning
Motivation• Set entry threshold
• Monitor site consistency
• Acquire data for retrospective analysis- measurement precision (SE)
- compare fitting methods
- detection thresholds
- identify technical problems
Quality Control Phantom Scans
ACRIN Breast Committee
Vegetable oil
40 mm ø sphere w/ 1 mM PCho
20 mm voxel
2 liter bottle
ACRIN Breast Committee
Subject MRS Data Status
• 112 subjects as of 9/15
• Status is per-subject • both MR1 and MR2 must
be good
• No cho: • low snr (1.5T), difficult
voxel placements, too fatty
• No data• Some lost• Some not acq’d: why?
Good (32)
Pending Analysis
(9)
Pending Data (13)
withdrew / ineligible (9)
acquisition error (7)
no cho (20)
no data acquired /
submitted (22)
ACRIN Breast Committee
Example: Good quality
ACRIN Breast Committee
Example: No choline
ACRIN Breast Committee
Example: Acquisition error
ACRIN Breast Committee
Example: Analysis Pending
Choline peak is over-fit
ACRIN Breast Committee
MRS Data Quality, per-subject by Quartile
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
no choline
acq. error
Good
ACRIN Breast Committee
MRS Data by Field Strength
1.5T 3T
# subjects 96 (86%) 16 (14%)
Good data rate 48% 89%
Acq. error rate 14% 0%
No choline rate 38% 11%
ACRIN Breast Committee
Accrual ongoing
Early termination?• Competing with ISPY2
• Stopping pt analysis: • need 43 subjects with a drop in [tCho] and final path
• have 14 responders, 9 non-responders by [tCho] with path
MRS Analysis work• Better fitting (SVD, magnitude fitting, detection
thresholds)
• Voxel placement grading
6657 MRS Summary
ACRIN Breast Committee
ACRIN Breast CommitteeFall Meeting 2010
6693 MR Imaging Biomarkers for Assessment of Breast Cancer Response to Neoadjuvant Treatment
Nola Hylton ,PhDMark Rosen, MD, PhD
Eunhee Kim, PhDPat Bolan, PhD
Savannah Partridge, PhD6657 Trial Team
ACRIN Breast Committee
ACRIN Breast Committee
ISPY-2 Adaptive Trial Design
• Target accrual: 800 patients over 4 years, 20 sites• ISPY-2 opened in March 2010; 4 sites open (~15 patients enrolled)
S
U
R
G
E
R
Y
Tissue
ON
STUDY
MRIBiopsy
Blood DrawMUGA/ECHO
CT/PET
Screening
RANDOM
IZE
Consent #2Treatment Consent
Paclitaxel* + Investigational Agent A
(12 weekly cycles)AC
(4 cycles)
Paclitaxel *(12 weekly
cycles)
AC(4 cycles)
Paclitaxel* +Investigational Agent B
(12 weekly cycles)AC
(4 cycles)
MRIBiopsy
Blood Draw
MRIBlood Draw
MRIBlood Draw
* HER2 positive participants will also receive Trastuzumab. An investigational agent may be used instead of Trastuzumab.
ACRIN Breast Committee
• Evaluate tumor apparent diffusion coefficient
(ADC), alone and in combination with SER as a
marker of early response
• Multi-parametric MRI biomarkers will be
evaluated in the setting of the ISPY-2 adaptive
neoadjuvant breast cancer trial testing targeted
agents in combination with paclitaxel
Overall Objective for ACRIN 6693
ACRIN Breast Committee
Diffusion-Weighted MRI (DWI)
• Measures the mobility of water diffusing in tissue
• Sensitive to restriction of water motion– cell density/cellularity– membrane integrity,
microstructure• Reduced diffusion in
tumors • Sensitive to cell death
and necrosis associated with response to treatment
Cancer Imaging. 2006; 6(1): 135–143.
ACRIN Breast Committee
DWI Studies in ACRIN 6657
• DWI optional in 6657• DWI data collected:
– Original 6657: 16 cases with visit 1 and 2
– Extension: 26 cases with visit 1 and 2
• Sample sizes too small for meaningful analysis – original and extension treated
separately because of differing visit 2 timepoints
ACRIN Breast Committee
Prior Breast DWI Studies
• ADC increases over the course of neoadjuvant chemotherapy in breast tumors [1, 2]
• ADC change occurs earlier than changes in size (volume or LD) [1,2]
• Predictive value of ADC– Baseline ADC lower in clinical responders [3]– Change in ADC significantly greater in
responders [2,3]
1. Pickles et al. Magn Reson Img 2006; 24:843–847. 2. Sharma et al. NMR Biomed 2008; 22(1):104-13. 3. Iacconi et al. Eur Radiol 2010; 20(2):303-8.
ACRIN Breast Committee
Recent Findings UW/SCCA
• 17 patients with invasive breast cancer• Neoadjuvant treatment
– Metronomic - weekly doxorubicin/daily cyclophosphamide followed by paclitaxel
• Imaged with DWI– Prior to treatment, mid-, post-treatment
DCE DWI ADC
ACRIN Breast Committee
Recent Findings UW/SCCA
• Significant increases in ADC observed over the course of chemotherapy (p<0.05, pre-post)
• Serial tumor ADC histograms in a responding patient
ADC (x10-3mm2/s)
Pre-treatment
Mid-treatment
Post-treatment
ACRIN Breast Committee
Recent Findings UW/SCCA
• Baseline ADCmin lower in pCR patients (p=0.038)
• Change in ADCmin mid-treatment greater in pCR patients (p=0.044)
Baseline ADCmin by Path Response
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
ADCmin pre
AD
C
pCR ResidualDisease
*
Change in ADCmin
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
0 1 2
Treatment Timepoint
pCRResidual
*
AD
C (x
10-3 m
m2/s
)
Presented at the ISMRM Workshop on Improving Cancer Treatment with Advanced MR, Santa Cruz, CA, Sept. 20, 2010.
ACRIN Breast Committee
•approved by ACRIN Steering Committee – Sept 2009
•Protocol submitted to CTEP – June 2010
•Protocol concept disapproved by CTEP – August 2010
•Revisions and re-submission planned – November 2010
– More clearly defined objectives for evaluating ADC,
integration with ISPY-2, results from ISPY-1
Status of ACRIN 6693