rOCYAAPCTB0 M TPAHCAKLIMOHHblE M3AEPXKM MHOCTPAHHOrO KAnMTAJIA B POCCMM

~ K O H O M H Y ~ C K ~ R TeOpMR ( ~ 0 n e n b O6LUelX ~ ~ B H o B ~ c M R ) Y T B e p W a e T , YTO CTOHMOCTb

MaKCMMM3MPYeTCR, KOTLla P e C y p C b l - I lyTeM n O 6 p 0 ~ 0 n b ~ b l ~ O ~ M ~ H O B - C ~ O C O ~ H ~ I

n e p e p a C n p e n e J l R T b C R TaKMM 06pa30~, qTO OKa3blBaloTCR T I M , me MOI'YT 6 b 1 ~ b MCnOJlb30BaHbl

~aM60Jee ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H O . I l p o u e c c b ~ p a c n p e n e n e H m p e c y p c o B n o p o m a l o T T p a H c a K u t i o H H b l e

H3nepXKM ( 3 a ~ p a ~ b l H a IlOMCK I l a p T H e p O B , H a BblRBneHMe UeH H a PbIHKe, H a M3MepeHMe KaYeCTB

n p e n M e T a d ~ e ~ a , H a B e n e H w e n e p e r o B o p o s , H a s a ~ n m ~ e ~ ~ e o T n e n b H o m KoHTpaKTa H a K a x n y l o

TpaHCaKUMlo, H a MOHMTOPMHr peUlM3aUMM COrslaCOBaHHOrO KOHTpaKTa, H a I l p e n O T B p a U e H M e

o n n o p T y H w c T M q e c K o r o n o B e n e H w R CTOPOH M ~ . n . ) , CTpyK-rypa M B e n w u H a KOTOP~IX o n p e n e n R e T c R

TeMM npaBMJlaMM, B COOTBeTCTBMH C KOTOPbIMM IlPOMCXOLlMT O ~ M ~ H . '

B e n b MMeHHO ( ( n p a B c t n a , MeXaHM3Mb1, 0 6 e ~ n e q ~ B a K ) L U M e MX BblllOJlHeHHe, M HOPMbl

IlOBeneHMR, KOTOpble CTPYKTYPMPYWT IlOBTOPRloUMeCR B ~ ~ M M o I I ~ ~ ~ c T B H R M e U y J l l o n b ~ M > > , ~

n p e n c - r a a n m o T cdoi?, c o r n a c H o A. Hop~y, M H C T M T ~ T ~ I . *

h30~0fi e n M ~ M u e f i a H U l M 3 a B TeOPMM TpaHCaKUMOHHblX M3LLePXeK nPM3HaloTCR I K T

3KOHOMMYeCKOrO B ~ ~ M M O ~ ~ ~ ~ C T B W I I , CLleJlKa, TpaHCaKUMR. K a ~ e r o p M R TpaHCaKUkiM llOHHMaeTCR

n p e A e J l b H 0 UMpOKO M MCnOJlb3yeTCR N l R 0 6 0 3 ~ a q e ~ M R 0 6 M e ~ a KaK TOBapaMM, TaK ki

IOPMnMqeCKMMM O ~ R ~ ~ T ~ J I ~ C T B ~ M W , CneJlOK KaK KpaTKOCpOqHOrO, TaK M n O J l r O B p e M e H H O r 0

X a p a K T e p a , KaK ~pe6ytomkix n e T a J I b H O r 0 n O K y M e H T U l b H O r 0 O @ O ~ M ~ ~ H M H , TaK M

n p e n n O J l a r a l o U l H X n p O C T O e B3aMMOnOHMMaHMe CTOPOH. n p M p 0 n a TPaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 n e P X e K KaK

3 a ~ p a ~ H n o T e p b , c o n p o B o m n a m u M x T a K o e ~ s a ~ ~ o n e i ? c ~ ~ ~ e , B n o n H e o q e B m H a . C n e n o ~ a ~ e n b ~ o ,

X e n a H M e nlo601-0 M H s e c T o p a - npexne q e M ~ b 1 t i ~ 1 . 1 H a H O B L I ~ ~ PLIHOK, B ~ I C T P O M T ~ C T p a T e r H m

IlPMCYTCTBMIl H a HeM, MCXOnR H e TOJlbKO M3 COOTHOUleHHR ((PUCK M BO3MOXHOCTM er0 npOrHO3a)) ,

HO T a K X e M3 ~ 0 0 6 p a X e ~ M R ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H O C T M M3KOHOMMH H a TpaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 n e p X K a X .

Ha ~ O C C M ~ ~ C K O M P b l H K e BblCOKMe TpaHCaKUMOHHble M3nepXKM BbIHyXflafOT MHOCTpaHHble

KOMnaHMM MCnOn b 3 0 B a T b CTpaTerMM BblXOna, I lOCTpOeHHbIe H a XeCTKMX kiepapXHYeCKMX CBR3RX

M e X n y ~ O ~ O B H O ~ ~ K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ M P O C C M ~ C K M M n O n p a 3 n e n e H M e M . C 0n~0fi CTOPOHbI, 3 T 0 fl03BOJlReT

(tMHTepHaJIM3MpOBaTb)) TPaHCaKUHOHHble M3LlepXKki, C npyr0# - C H M X a e T BO3MOXHOCTM

K o o n e p a u M M c ~ O C C M ~ ~ C K H M M n a p T H e p a M u .

llWEHMUbIH.4 s ~ a Bnann~npoana - a C n H p a H T K a ~ a a e a p b l ~ K O H O M H ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ TeOPHH C n 6 I - Y . O K O H ~ M I I ~ ~ K O H O M H ' ~ ~ C K M ~ ~ @ ~ K Y ; I ~ T ~ T Cn6I-Y (2001).

KaHnUJlaTCKaR AUCCepTaUUR n 0 C B R l l l e H a T ~ ~ ~ H C ~ K U H O H ~ ~ ~ M U 3 A e p X K a M UHOCTpaHHOrO KanHTafla B POCCHU. C@epa HaYqHblX U H T e p e C O B - He0UHCTUT)'UHOHaJlbHlUl 3l iOHOMUKa. Y ~ ~ C T H U U ~ 111 ~ ; l t e r o A H o f i K O H ~ ~ ~ ~ H U H U no o 6 ~ e ~ y 3HaHURMU H a n 0 K a n b H O M U MHPOBOM YpOBHRX n O A n a T p O H a X e M ~ ( B c ~ M u ~ H o ~ ~ C e T n pa3BnTt iR ( , , G l o b a l Dcvclopmcnt N c t w o r k " ) ~ , P n o - n e - X a ~ e f i p o , 6 p a m n u ~ ( n e ~ a 6 p b . 2001), n Memy~apon~oro c e M n H a p a no n H c T n T y u u o H a n b H o M y

a H U l U 3 y . Opr?lHH3OBi3HHOrO M H C T H ~ T O M P o H ~ J I ~ A ~ K o y 3 a . P b i o - D e - X a ~ e f i p o . L p a 3 n n n R ( ~ e K a 6 p b . 2001). ABTOP O A H O ~ ~ n y 6 n n ~ a u n n .

OCHOBH~IMM <<MMHYCaMM)) P O C C M ~ C K O ~ ~ 3KOHOMMKM, IlpenRTCTBYIOUMMM rIOJly'4eHMlo

I l p M e ~ J l e ~ ~ f i HOPMbI 1-1pM6blnl.1 MHOCTPaHHblM K a n M T U O M , RBnRmTCR C n e n y I o U l M e llO3MUMM

r o c y n a p c T s a :

B o - n e p ~ b l x , n O C T a T O q H 0 OCTpaSi npo6ne~a ~anoroo6noxe~na, CBR3aHHaR B OCHOBHOM He

C KOnM'4eCTBOM BBOnHMbIX H U O r O B , a C ~ ~ C T O T O ~ ~ nORBJleHMR M 3 a M e H b I MX HOBbIMM, q T O BeLleT K

B03MOXHOCTM Pa3nMYHOTO TOJlKOBaHMR H U O r O B b I X I ~ o ~ o x ~ H H ~ ~ . M H a n e p e O p M e H T M p O B K y YXOnMT

HeKOTOpOe BpeMR. K p o ~ e TOrO, n e R T e n b H O C T b M H O C T ~ ~ H H O ~ KOMnaHMM I l O n B e p r a e T C R ~ B O ~ ~ H O M Y

H U O ~ O O ~ J ~ O X ~ H W H ) : 3 T 0 OTqeTHOCTb no HaJlOrOBOMy 3aKOHOnaTeJ lbCTBy POCCMM H n0

MeXflyHapOf lHblM C T a H n a p T a M GAAP B C T p a H e , me P a C n O J l O X e H a rOJlOBHaR KOMnaHMR.

H a G n m n a l o ~ c R T a K X e M OTJlMqHR B CMCTeMe P O C C U ~ ~ C K O ~ O ~ ~ x ~ U T ~ ~ C K O ~ O y. ieTa - B POCCMM npeo6nanae~ H a l l p a B n e H H O C T b H a y q e T HaJlOrOB, a H e H a BblRBJleHMe P e U b H b I X 6 ~ 3 ~ e c - n p o u e c c o B .

Bo-BTOP~IX, 3 K O H O M U K a POCCUU C H n b H O ' ~ I O P O I C ~ ~ T U ~ U P O B ~ H ~ . m R H a q a J l a

OCyUeCTBJleHMR ~ a ~ o f i - J I M 6 0 neRTeJlbHOCTM H ~ O ~ X O ~ M M O IlOJlyqMTb JlMUeH3Mt0, C ~ P T M @ H K ~ T n ~ 6 0 P X l p e U l e H M e , q T 0 ~ p e 6 y e ~ npOXOXneHMR OrQOMHOrO q M C n a rOCynapCTBeHHb1X M H C T ~ H U M ~ ~ , TaKMX

KaK OAnCM, KYTM, D ~ ~ ~ P T ~ M ~ H T 3KCnOpTHOrO KOHTPOJlR, MWHWCT~PCTBO 3KOHOMMqeCKOrO

PXlBMTMH A TOPrOBJlW P O C C M ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ @ e n e p a ~ M M , B C e B 0 3 M O X H b l e M Y H M U W n U b H b l e 0 6 p a 3 0 ~ a ~ M R W

T.n. 3 0 Tpe6ye~ O p O M H b I X BpeMeHHblX M n e H e X H b 1 X 3 a T p a T , CBR3aHHblX C 3anOJlHeHMeM

MHOTOqMCneHHblX OTqeTHblX @OPM M BeJleHMeM n e p e r O B O p O B C qMHOBHMKaMM T o r 0 MJlM MHOrO

BenOMCTBa. Ha I lOJ lyqeHMe PXlpeUleHMR H a 6 ~ y L U e ~ ~ B J l e ~ c t e ~ a ~ o k - J l k i 6 0 neRTeJlbHOCTH q a C T 0

YXOnMT OKOnO 6 MeCRUeB H ~ ~ ~ R X ~ H H O ~ p a 6 0 ~ b l no I lpenOCTaBJleHMto H ~ O ~ X O ~ M M O ~ ~

H H @ o ~ M ~ u M M , KOTOPaR A O n X H a ynOBJleTBOpRTb O n p e n e J l e H H b l M C T a H n a p T a M M KOnaM, M

COrJlaCOBaHMK, CBOMX L I ~ ~ ~ C T B H ~ ~ C IlpeLLCTaBMTeJlRMM BJlaCTM.

B - T ~ ~ T ~ M x , H H O C T ~ ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ ClHBeCTOP CTanKABaeTCR C n O C T a T O q H 0 C J I O X H O ~ ~ T ~ M O X ~ H H O ~ ~

npouenypoii H a pocc~kc~of i r p a H c l u e . 3 ~ o c~ano o c o 6 e ~ ~ o O L U ~ T M M O nocne HenaBHMx

H O B O B B ~ ~ ~ H U ~ ~ B T a M O X e H H b l X IlpaBMJlaX. B 3~0fi CBR3M n p M 3 a K a 3 e 0 6 0 p y n o ~ a ~ M R MHOCTpaHHaR

KOMnaHMll C H a q a J l a IlblTaeTCR H ~ G T M npOM3BOnMTeJlR I ~ O ~ O ~ H O ~ O T O B a p a H a TePPMTOPHI.1 POCCMM n ~ 6 o o T b r c K a T b npenc~a~w~enefi 3 a p y 6 e x ~ b r x npou3~onu~enefi, n o c T a s n R t o m M x n a H H o e

060pyno~a~kie B H a U l y C T p a H y , n a 6 b 1 M 3 6 e X a ~ b B ~ ~ M M o ~ ~ ~ ~ c T B M R C T ~ M O X H ~ ~ . n p M OTCYTCTBMH

T e X M n p y r M X KOMnaHMM IlpMXOnMTCR BblXOnMTb H a llPOM3BOnMTeJlR 3a P Y ~ ~ X O M HanpRMYtO. 30, C 0n~0fi CTOPOHbI, Y M e H b U l a e T CPOKM IlOCTaBKM, T a K KaK CHMXaeTCR KOJlMqeCTBO ITOCpenHMKOB, a C npyrok CTOPOHbI, C 0 3 n a e T l lOnOnHMTeJlbHble l l p 0 6 J l e ~ b l n p M n p O X O X n e H U M T ~ M O X ~ H H O ~ ~

n p o u e n y p b l , s a ~ u ~ a m u e f i OT 2 H e n e n b no 2,5 M e c R u e B M nornomamureti H e T o n b K o

C3KOHOMJleHHOe BPeMR, HO M L l e H e X H b I e P e C y p C b l .

CTOMMOCT~ BB03MMOTO py3a MMHMMUbHO YBeJlMqWBaeTCR H a 50-60%, IlOCKOJlbKy

I l p e A n O n a r a e T C R YI lJ laTa BCeB03MOXHblX T a M O X e H H b l X llOUIJlMH, HnC ( n p M U M n O p T e TOBapOB

TaKOrO H U O r a 3a rpa~kiueti H ~ T ) , W T ~ ~ @ O B 3a HeCBOeBpeMeHHyfO n O n a ' 4 y DOKyMeHTOB Ha

o @ o p ~ n e ~ u e newrapaum M 3a x p a H e H H e rpy30~ H a T a M o m e H H o M cmane M npoqwx pacxonos, CBR3aHHblX C T a M O X e H H b l M O @ O ~ M ~ ~ H H ~ M Vy3a. fl27lrr Cpa6HeHZLS: 60 @paHy~u ~ O C ~ ~ ~ O V H O

~ ~ J ~ @ O H H O Z O 360HKa 6 mUwOXeHHble OpZaHbl 0 ~ ~ U H ~ ~ R ~ X H O C ~ U Zpy3a K daH~06 KOiMnaHUU. T ~ M O X ~ H H ~ ~ npoyedypa d-vumcs om I. do 3 h e 6 u cocmamlrrem 10-15% om cmowwocmu 3aKa3aHHOZO 060pydosau~~~. npl4 3mOM Ha t?lpaHCaKyUOHHble l 4 3 d e p x ~ ~ npuxodumw noplrrd~a 30-40% Grodxema ~o,wna~uu-u~secmopa. B Poccuu Ha mpancaKyuoHHwe usdepxrcu 3amparusaemcs npweplro 60-70% om Grodxema. *

K p o ~ e T o r o , T a M o x e H H o e o @ o p ~ n e ~ ~ e rpysa B POCCHM npennonarae-r n p e n o c T a B n e H u e

BCeB03MOXHblX CllpaBOK, r a p a ~ ~ k i f i ~ b l x IlMCeM, 3allOJlHeHMe OTqeTHbIX @OPM BO BCe

BblUleCTORUlMe MHCTaHUMM, TaKMe KaK ~ O C Y L I ~ P C T B ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ K O M H T ~ T O X p a H b l O K P Y X ~ H ) U ~ ~ C p e n b I ,

@AnCM M T. a. H e o 6 x o n u ~ b l nOKa3aTeJ lbCTBa, YTO MMnOpTMpyeMOe 0 6 0 p y n 0 ~ a ~ M e H e

I lpenOCTaBJlReT Y q O 3 b l m R O ~ U ~ C T B ~ , 0 ~ ~ ~ X a K ) I l l e f i CPel lb l , H e ~ Y A ~ T MCnOJlb3OBaHO B BOeHHblX

UeJlRX, BBO3MTCR &ISI C O ~ C T B ~ H H O T O nOJlb30BaHMR M H e I l p e n n O J l a r a e T n a J l b ~ e f i U l y K ) n p O n a X y .

M ~ O r n a , IlOCJle ~ c e f i I l p o n e J l a ~ ~ o f i p a 6 0 ~ b 1 , ~ ~ C T ~ M O X ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ Vy3 CTaHOBMTCR H e n p M r O n H b l M LUlR

BBeAeHMR B 3KCWlYaTaUMK).

B - ~ ~ T B ~ P T ~ I X , 3KOHOMHKa POCCUU CHJlbHO ~ ~ ~ C O H U @ ~ U U ~ O B ~ H ~ , M M H O C T ~ ~ H H ~ I ~ ~

KanHTaJl CTaJKMBaeTCR C HellPMBbIqHblM LIAR c e 6 ~ ~ M H O B H H ~ ~ M M IIPOM3BOJlOM M n p e @ e p e H ~ M R M M

o n w r a p x o B , K o r n a nonoxHcwTenbHoe p e u e H M e no ~ a ~ o ~ y - n M 6 0 B o n p o c y ~ ~ B M C M T OT ( ( H a c T p o e H w i ) )

T o r 0 MJlM MHOrO LIOJlXHOCTHOrO JlMUa.

B - ~ R T ~ I x , B POCCHH s a ~ o ~ o n a ~ e ~ l b ~ a s 6 a 3 a no c n e u u ~ u ~ a u u u H sauru~e npas C O ~ C T B ~ H H O C T U npe6b1eae~ n 0 K a e l U e B < < U H @ ~ H T H ~ ~ H O M ) ) COCTORHHH. Hanpw~ep, OnHMM M3

MCTOqHMKOB TpaHCaKUMOHHblX H 3 i l e P X e K RBJlReTCR C ~ ~ U H @ H ~ H bl fi I l P e a M e T C n e n KM, K O T O P ~ I ~ ~

I l p e n n O J l a ~ a e T M3nepXKM3aLLlMTbl MH@OPM~UMM M IlPOLIYKTa. &lR K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ , 06nanalouux TaKMM

c ~ ~ ~ M @ M ~ ~ c K M M aKTMBOM, KaK ~ 0 ~ a p ~ b l f i 3HaK, I ~ P ~ A C T ~ B J ~ R I O L L ~ M ~ ~ ~060fi H e q T O HHOe, KaK

( ( n y q 0 K IlpaB)), HenOCTaTKH ~ O C C M ~ ~ C K O ~ O 3aKOHOnaTeJ lbCTBa no O X p a H e TOBaPHblX 3HaKOB MMeK)T

6 0 J b l l 1 0 e 3 H a q e H M e , IlOCKOnbKY, no CTaTMCTMKe, I lPMMePHO 54% HHOCTpaHHblX K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ ,

O C Y ~ e C T B J l S I I O U H X CBOK) LIeRTenbHOCTb H a P O C C M ~ ~ C K O M PbIHKe, CTaJlKMBaJlUCb C HaPYUleHHeM

n p a B H a MX T O B a p H b l e ~ H ~ K U . ~ K ~ K CJlenCTBMe, B POCCMM l lOCTaTOqH0 cJla60 p a 3 B M T a . T a K M

IlepCneKTMBHaR @ 0 p M a COTpynHHYeCTBa ( n 0 3 ~ 0 J l R K ) U l a R C y U e C T B e H H O CHM3MTb TpaHCaKUMOHHble

m n e p m ~ ~ ) , KaK ~ e x n y ~ a p o n ~ b ~ f i @ p a ~ s a i h ~ ~ r , B o c H o B e ~ o ~ o p o i i nexm n e p e n a q a n p a B H a

T O B ~ P H ~ I ~ ~ 3HaK. T ~ K x ~ ~ a 6 J l K ) n a e ~ c R OTCYTCTBMe ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H O ~ O n p a B O B O r O pelYnMPOBZlHMR

~ O ~ ~ O C O B ~ C T H O ~ ~ KOHKYpeHUMI.1. 74% K O M ~ ~ H M ~ ~ O ~ ~ C ~ O K O ~ H ~ I BO3MOXHOCTbK) YTeqKM

M H @ o ~ M ~ u M M OT ~ ~ ~ O T H W K O B (PMpMbl, 12% CTaJlKUBaJlWCb C P a C n p O C T p a H e H M e M 0 HHX JlOXHblX

c ~ e n e ~ M f i K O H K ~ ~ ~ H T ~ M M . ~

MCTOYHMKOM BOSHHKHOBeHMR TpaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 n e p X e K B C e r n a RBJlRKlTCR

npOTMBOnOJlOXHble npyr npyry MHTepeCbl 3KOHOMMqeCKMX C Y ~ ~ ~ K T O B , Il03TOMY 3TM M3AePXKI.1

CYUeCTBYK)T KaK B J l e r a J l b H o f i , T a K M B ~ e H e ~ 0 f i c@epax 3KOHOMMKM. E ~ J l b U l M f i MHTepeC

I lPenCTaBJlReT J l e ~ a J l b H i M c@epa 3KOHOMMKM POCCMM, MMeHHO T a M M H O C T ~ ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ KanMTaJl

OCYUeCTBJIHeT CBOK) neRTeJlbHOCTb, IlpORBJlRR ( (nP03PaqHOCTb)) B OTqeTHOCTM M HeCR 6 p e M R

BbICOKMX TpaHCaKUMOHHblX H 3 n e p X e K . T P ~ H C ~ K U W O H H ~ ~ M W M3nepXKaMM, KaK yXe 6 b l n 0 O T M ~ ~ ~ H O

BbIUle, 3 n e C b RBnRloTCR M3LIePXKM IlOLlqtlHeHMR 3aKOHy, n 0 3 T O M Y LUlR MX CHMXeHMR r O C y n a p C T B 0

B b I C T y n a e T r a p a H T O M n p M 3aKJlK)qeHMM CneJlKM H e BO BCeX CJlyYaRX, T a K KaK @ Y H K U W O H W P O B ~ H M ~

IWCynapCTBa, KaK M nlo6ofi npyr0fi O ~ ~ ~ H M ~ ~ U H O H H O ~ ~ CTPYKT)'PbI, CBR3aHO KaK C YMeHbUleHMeM,

TaK M C YBeJIMqeHMeM TPaHCaKUMOHHblX W 3 n e P X e K . M OHM T e M 6 0 J l b U l e , YeM B 6 0 J l b U l e M qWCJle

T ~ ~ H C ~ K U H ~ ~ r O C y n a p C T B 0 B b I C T y n a e T B K a q e C T B e r a p a H T a BbInOJlHeHMR y c J l 0 ~ M f i KOHTpaKTa.

B b l c o ~ M e w3nepx~w s a ~ n m r e ~ w ~ K o H T p a K r a , w3nepx~w c n e u ~ @ ~ ~ a u ~ w M 3 a m w ~ b 1 npae C O ~ C T B ~ H H O C T H M M3AePXKM 3 a U M T b l OT TpeTbMX JlMU MOXHO 0 6 b e l ~ M H M ~ b ODHMM TePMMHOM-

((UeHa nOnYMHeHMR ~ ~ K o H ~ > > , ~ K O T O P M BKJltOqaeT:

w3nep~vu nocTyna K ~ ~ K O H Y : s a ~ p a ~ b ~ H a perllcTpauwm W p w n w e c K o r o nwua, H a

n o n y q e H M e n ~ u e ~ 3 u 1 . 1 , H a o T K p b I T u e c q e T a B 6 a ~ ~ e , H a n o n y q e H u e W p M n M q e c K o r o anpeca M

BblnOJlHeHMe MHblX @ o P M ~ J I ~ H o c T ~ ~ ~ ;

U 3 A e p X K H H p O A O J I X e H U R AeRTeJlbHOCTH B P a M K a X 3 a K O H a , C B R 3 a H H b I e C

H ~ O ~ X O ~ H M O C T ~ H ) : BblllJlaTbl HaJlOrOB; BbInOJlHeHMR T p e 6 0 ~ a ~ M f i 3aKOHa B 0 6 J l a c ~ M T p y n O B b l X

O T H O L L I ~ H U ~ ~ ( L U I M T ~ J ~ ~ H O C T ~ pa6oqero nHR, MMHMMaJlbHaR 3 a p a 6 0 ~ ~ a R n J l a T a , COUMaJlbHble

r a p a ~ ~ u ~ ) ; B b l n n a T b r c y n e 6 ~ b l x w3nepxe~ npu p a 3 p e u e H m KOH@~MKTOB B p a M K a x n e r m b ~ o f i

c y n e 6 ~ 0 f i C W C T ~ M ~ I . ~

3 ~ a c ~ O e 0 6 p a 3 ~ a R ( (UeHa nOALIMHeHMR 3aKOHY)) BKJlK)VaeT H e TOJlbKO n p R M b l e n e H e X H b l e

3aTpaTb1, HO M 3 a T p a T b I BpeMeHM H a Bbl l lOnHeHMe TeX HJlM MHblX I l p O U e n y p , OCyUeCTBJleHMe

KOTOPbIX, M3-3a Pa3MblTOCTH ~ P ~ B O B O ~ ~ 6 a 3 b 1 , n O P l a C npOCTO UlOKMpyeT M H O C T P ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ KallMTaJI,

p e W M ~ U l M f i OCyUeCTBJlRTb n e R T e n b H 0 C T b H a TeppMTOpMM Po, M ~ p e 6 y e ~ M e H T m b H O r O

IlepeCTpaMBaHMR. ~ H H ~ H C O B ~ I ~ B03MOXHOCTM MHOCTPaHHbIX HHBeCTOPOB RBIIRmTCR (CnaKOMblM

KYCKOM)) M R ~ W ~ O K ~ ~ T O B - Y M H O B H M K O B , YbU ( ( T ~ P M @ ~ I ) ) AJlR IlOnOXMTeJIbHOrO IlPMHRTMR p e U I e ~ M f i

3 a W C T y I O nOXOART A 0 50% OT CYMMbI, 3aJl0Xe~~0fi B ~ M ~ H ~ c - I ~ ~ o ~ K T , n y T e M C03HaTeJ lbHOrO

OTTRrHBaHMR MOMeHTa Bb1LIaYl.I O K O H Y ~ T ~ J I ~ H O ~ ~ Pe30JlK)UMM. Hanpki~ep, I l p O U e A y p a IlOnyYeHMR

pa3peWeHMSI H a CTpOMTeJlbCTBO XMJlOrO n O M a . 3 ~ e c b H ~ ~ ~ ~ O A ~ I O T C S I H e TOnbKO BblCOKMe

TpaHCaKUMOHHbIe M3AePXKM, HO M 6onee C e p b e 3 H b I e Y ~ ~ I T K M , TaKMe KaK npOCTaMBaHMe

O ~ O ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H H R BCneACTBMe 3aTRrMBaHMR CpOKa BblAaYM JlMUeH3HW, M, KaK p e 3 y J l b T a T 7 Y M e H b W e H H e

s a n n a ~ ~ p o ~ a ~ ~ o f i H O P M ~ I fIpki6blnM, M n p e n o c T a B n e H H e ( t s e n e ~ o r o c s e T a ) > KoHKypeHTaM, YTO B

A ~ ~ ~ C T B W T ~ ~ ~ H O C T U M O X e T ITpUBeCTM K CHMXeHMW n O n M YYaCTMR A ~ H H O ~ ~ KOMnaHMM H a P b l H K e W

naxe K n o T e p e s a ~ u ~ a e ~ o f i p a H e e HHUIM.

B n o n ~ e OYeBMnHO, YTO 6e3 06paule~1.151 K r O C y n a p C T B y Y p O B e H b TpaHCaKUMOHHblX

H 3 n e p X e K , B 0 3 M O X H 0 , 6 b l n 6 6 1 3HaYMTenbHO HMXe, XOTR 6 b 1 BO B P ~ M ~ H H O ~ ~ C O C T ~ B I I R I O L L I ~ ~ ~ , TaK

KaK, A a X e nOCJle IIPMHRTMR B T O P O ~ ~ , a 3 a T e M M ~ p e ~ b e f i KilaB ~ ~ ~ X I ~ ~ H C K O ~ O KOneKCa, 3aKOHb1, ll0

llpUrlMHe c n a 6 0 C ~ M MX BblIlOnHeHMSI H a MeCTaX IlpOAOJIXaIOT H a p y W a T b C R .

T ~ M H e M e H e e I lyTeM AeJlerUpOBaHMR YaCTH n p a B IlO KOHTPOJlW H a A ~ ~ 0 e f i neRTeJ lbHOCTbt0

R l C y n a p C T B y B TaKHX c@epax, KaK C ~ ~ U M @ M K ~ U M R M 3 a U M T a n p a B C ~ ~ C T B ~ H H O C T H , CO3AaHMe

KaHanOB o 6 ~ e ~ a M H @ o p ~ a u M e f i , pa3pa60~~a C T a H A a p T o B M e p M BeCOB, CO3naHMe K a H m O B

@ M ~ M Y ~ c K o R ~ o 6 ~ e H a TOBapaMM M YCnyraMM, I lpaBOOXpaHMTenbHaR AeRTeJlbHOCTb M npOM3BOACTBO

~ ~ U ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I X ba r , 3KOHOMHqeCKMe areHI'b1 OXMAatOT, YTO H a OCHOBe MOHOIlOJlMH Ha

OCyUleCTBJIeHUe HaCWlMR O H 0 C M O X e T 6onee ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H o C ~ ~ ~ U M @ I . ~ U W P O B ~ T ~ M 3 a U H U a T b I l p a B a

~ O ~ C T B ~ H H O C T M , YeM OHM C ~ M U . ' COOTB~TCTB~HHO rOCYAaPCTB0 B 3TMX c@epax I l O n y Y a e T IlpaBO

JIer'MTMMHOTO, T. e. OCHOBaHHOrO H a COuMMbHOM KOHTpaKTe, I lpMHyXIleHMR M HaCMJlMR.

M H ~ M B M A L I , B C B O ~ o s e p e n b , A o n x H b l o n n a q u s a - r b n p e n o c T a B n R e M b r e r o c y a a p c T B o M y c n y r l l .

~ O C ~ A ~ ~ C T B O , RBJIRRCb r a p a H T O M BblnOJlHeHMR @ Y H K U W ~ ~ C I ~ ~ U H @ H K ~ U H M H 3 a U M T b l n p a B

C ~ ~ C T B ~ H H O C T H , B3UMaeT ((HeKytO IlJlaTY)) C 3KOHOMMYeCKMX SIRHTOB, H a n P W M e P B B H n e H m O r O B ,

KOTOPbIe MOXHO PaCCMaTpMBaTb KaK MX TpaHCaKUMOHHbIe M3AepXKM, M, O n M p a R C b Ha

K ~ ~ C C M @ H K ~ ~ M I O 0. Y H J ~ ~ R M c o H ~ , KaK M3AepXKM ex post - M3AePXKM n0 BblnOAHeHMH) Y c J ~ o B M ~ ~

KOHTpaKTa. C B 0 e o 6 ~ a 3 ~ b l f i ( ( K o H T ~ ~ K T H ~ ~ ~ ~ IlOAXOLI)) OYeBHAeH, nOCKOnbKy n t 0 6 b 1 e OpraHM3aUMW,

OT @HPMM A 0 rOCyAaPCTBa, IlOHHMaloTCR KaK C n O X H a R C e T b RBHbIX M HeSIBHbIX KOHTpaKTOB.

COOTB~TCTB~HHO, COCTaBJlRR 6 ~ 3 ~ e c - n p o e K T b l IUIR BbIRBJIeHMR U ~ ~ ~ C O O ~ ~ ~ ~ H O C T M OCyUeCTBneHMR

~ K O H O M M ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ AeRTenbHOCTM H a TePPMTOPMH POCCMU, MHBeCTOPbI, 3HaK)UIMe, H ~ O r O B b l e

I l p O u e H T H b I e CTaBKW H a TOT MJlM M H O ~ ~ poll AeRTenbHOCTM, M O Y T 3 a p a H e e CIlpOrHO3MpOBaTb

TpaHCaKUMOHHble M3AePXKM B A I H H O ~ ~ c@epe. A 3 T 0 O C O ~ ~ H H O CYUeCTBeHHO, T a K KIK, I l 0

MHeHMIO P. Koysa, ~ 0 0 6 p a X e ~ M R 3KOHOMMM TpaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 n e p X e K RBnRloTCSI PeWaIOUMMM

llpM ~ b 1 6 o p e 0 p r a ~ M 3 a u M 0 ~ ~ 0 f i @ O P M ~ I M p a 3 M e p O B @ H P M ~ I .

B n o n ~ e BO3MOXHbIM IlpeACTaBJIReTCIl I lOnCYeT TPaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 n e P X e K J l e I X l b H O

@ ~ H K u M o H M ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ MHOCTpaHHOrO K a n H T m a H a OCHOBe MCIlOnb30BaHMR BCe ~ 0 f i Xe K ~ ~ C C H @ H K ~ U M H TPaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 D e P X e K 0. Y U ~ ~ H M C O H ~ . C~pyKTypa M 3 n e p X e K AOCTyl la K

~ ~ K O H Y u u3nepxe~ n p o n o n x e H m A e m e n b H o c T u B p a M K a x s a ~ o ~ a B l c n m s a e T c o c T a m R m u w e ,

KOTOPbIe M O Y T 6 b 1 ~ b B b l P a X e H b l B A ~ H ~ X H O ~ ~ @ O P M ~ , H a I l p M M e p PaCXOnbl KOMnaHMM IlpM

n o n y s e H w n nuue~sww H a o c y u e c T B n e H u e o n p e n e n e H H o r o pona A e R T e n b H o c T w TO M o n n a T a

KOHCYnbTaUMOHHblX Y C n y r @MPM, M I l p O X O X n e H M e 6 I O p o ~ p a ~ M Y e C ~ o f i neCTHMubl

rOCyAapCTBeHHblX YWHOBHMKOB, M ~ . l l . ) . Ha M a K p O y p O B H e eUe a. hop^ M AX. YOJIJIMC, B MX

C O B M ~ C T H O ~ ~ C T a T b e ( ( M 3 ~ e p e ~ M e T P ~ H C ~ K U A O H H O ~ O C e K T O p a B ~ M ~ ~ M K ~ H C K O ~ ~ 3KOHOMMKe B 1870- 1970 rOAaX)), I l p e n I l p M H R n U IlOIlblTKy C M C T ~ M ~ T M Y ~ C K O ~ ~ OUeHKM TpaHCaKUMOHHblX M 3 A e p X e K B

3KOHOMMKe B UenOM Y e p e 3 T ~ ~ H C ~ K U H O H H ~ I ~ ~ CeKTOp.

KOH~YHO, BI lOnHe OqeBMAHO, YTO I lOnyYeHMe RlCyAapCTBOM MOHOnOJlbHORl I l p a B a Ha

MCnOJlb30BaHMe HaCMJlMR T a K X e IlPHBOAMT K POCTY TPaHCaKUUOHHblX M 3 A e p X e K BHYTPM

r o c y n a p c T B e H H o r o a n n a p a T a , TO n0poxnae.r c M c T e M a T w q e c K H e M c K a x e H u R B p a c n p e n e n e H M M

I l p a ~ o ~ o q M f i , T a K KaK q e M aKTMBHee P O n b rOCyAapCTBa B c ~ ~ u u @ M K ~ u M M M 3 a U k f T e n p a B

C O ~ C T B ~ H H O C T H , T e M C n O X H e e BHYTPeHHRR CTPYKTYpa rOCyAapCTBa M BblUle qHCJleHHOCTb

r o c y n a p c r B e H H b l x c n y x a m M x M, c n e n o a a - r e n b s o , 6 0 n b U e w c K a x e H M f i u w p t c y n c l p y t o m e t i BHYTPH

TOCyAapCTBeHHOrO a I l n a p a T a MH@OPM~UMM. K p o ~ e T o m , BO3paCTaK)T M3AepXKM H a MOHMTOPMHT M

I lpeAOTBpaUleHMe rOCyAapCTBOM 0~nOpT)'HMCTMqeCKOrO nOBeAeHHR CBOMX I l p e ~ ~ ~ a ~ M ~ e , l e f i -

6 t o p ~ ~ p a ~ 0 ~ . 8 B POCCMM TPaHCaKUMOHHble M3AePXKM CKOpee B b l C v n a t O T KaK ((H3AePXKM

3KCllJlYaTaUMM ~ K O H O M W ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ C M C T ~ M ~ I ) ) , ~ BbIHBIIRR ee ((IlpOpeXM)).

K COXaJleHMtO, n 0 K a rOCyAapCTBy ~ Y A ~ T ((He n 0 A CMny)) CHM3MTb TpaHCaKUMOHHble

U3AepXKM, MX Y P O B e H b AJlR ~ H O C T P ~ H H O T O K a n M T a J a , O C y U e C T B I I R l O U e r O CBOK) AeRTenbHOCTb H a

TeppMTOpHM Pa, ~ Y A ~ T q p e 3 M e p H O BbICOKMM, qTO, B qaCTHOCTM, 3aTpyAHMT JleI'XiJlb~blfi BblXOA H a

p 0 ~ ~ M f i ~ ~ k i f i PblHOK M APYTHX MHOCTPaHHblX K O M ~ ~ H W ~ ~ . M BCe-TaKM, KIKMMH 6 b l BbICOKMMM HM

6 b l n M T p a H c a K u u o H H b l e ~ 3 n e p x ~ w npw npMsneqeHMI.1 m c y n a p c T s a K npoueccy c n e u w @ ~ ~ a u ~ ~ M

3aUIMTbl n p a B C O ~ C T B ~ H H O C T M , O H 0 H a C ~ ~ O A H R U H H ~ ~ A e H b OCTaeTCR eAMHCTBeHHblM MHCTMTYTOM,

C I ~ O C O ~ H ~ I M BblCTYnaTb H a M 6 0 n e e ~ @ @ ~ K T M B H ~ I M r a p a H T O M BblnOnHeHMR Y C ~ O B M ~ ~ CAeJlOK B

nOIlyCTMMblX M R H e r 0 PaMKaX.

' http:l/ www.ic.boom.ru ' TaM x e .

C o T O 3. n e M~ofi nyrb. H e s m n ~ a n peeonmuna B TperbeM Mnpe. M., 1995. C. 178. % .T e fi H H K A. H. MHCTWTYUHOH~JI~H~R 3KOHOMMKa: y lce6~oe noco6ue. M., 2004. C. 156.

T ~ M x e . C. 353. T ~ M me. C. 349. 3 p p 0 y K . Bocnpnnrue pncKa B nckixonorww u ~ K O H O M H ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ HayKe I/ THESIS. 1994. N 5 . C. 66.

C ~ a ~ b n noc-rynnna B peaaKuum 23 C ~ H T I I ~ P R 2004 r.