a comparative study on customer perception towards lic of india in view of increased competition by...

55
SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 1 CHAPTER - I 1.1 - Introduction With largest number of life insurance policies in force in the world, Insurance happens to be a mega opportunity in India. It’s a business growing at the rate of 15-20 % annually and presently is of the order of Rs 450 billion. Together with banking services, it adds about 7 % to the country’s GDP. Gross premium collection is nearly 2 % of GDP and funds available with LIC for investments are 8 % of GDP. Yet, nearly 80 % of Indian population is without life insurance cover while health insurance and non-life insurance continues to be below international standards. And this part of the population is also subject to weak social security and pension systems with hardly any old age income security. This itself is an indicator that growth potential for the insurance sector is immense. A well-developed and evolved insurance sector is needed for economic development as it provides long term funds for infrastructure development and at the same time strengthens the risk taking ability. It is estimated that over the next ten years India would require investments of the order of one trillion US dollar. The Insurance sector, to some extent, can enable investments in infrastructure development to sustain economic growth of the country. The growing number of wealthier as well as aging Indian middle class is set to offer a strong business potential for the country’s untapped life insurance market. Insurance is a federal subject in India. There are two legislations that govern the sector- The Insurance Act- 1938 and the IRDA Act- 1999. The insurance sector in India has come a full circle from being an open competitive market to nationalization and back to a liberalized market again. Tracing the developments in the Indian insurance sector reveals the 360 degree turn witnessed over a period of almost two centuries. As the twentieth century has come to a close and we have move into the third millennium, we can see many developments and changes taking place around us with all the industries and firms within each

Upload: pratiush07

Post on 16-Nov-2014

12.623 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

by Pratiush Singh

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 1

CHAPTER - I

1.1 - Introduction

With largest number of life insurance policies in force in the world, Insurance happens to be a mega

opportunity in India. It’s a business growing at the rate of 15-20 % annually and presently is of the order

of Rs 450 billion. Together with banking services, it adds about 7 % to the country’s GDP. Gross premium

collection is nearly 2 % of GDP and funds available with LIC for investments are 8 % of GDP.

Yet, nearly 80 % of Indian population is without life insurance cover while health insurance and non-life

insurance continues to be below international standards. And this part of the population is also subject to

weak social security and pension systems with hardly any old age income security. This itself is an

indicator that growth potential for the insurance sector is immense.

A well-developed and evolved insurance sector is needed for economic development as it provides long

term funds for infrastructure development and at the same time strengthens the risk taking ability. It is

estimated that over the next ten years India would require investments of the order of one trillion US

dollar. The Insurance sector, to some extent, can enable investments in infrastructure development to

sustain economic growth of the country. The growing number of wealthier as well as aging Indian middle

class is set to offer a strong business potential for the country’s untapped life insurance market.

Insurance is a federal subject in India. There are two legislations that govern the sector- The Insurance

Act- 1938 and the IRDA Act- 1999.

The insurance sector in India has come a full circle from being an open competitive market to

nationalization and back to a liberalized market again. Tracing the developments in the Indian insurance

sector reveals the 360 degree turn witnessed over a period of almost two centuries.

As the twentieth century has come to a close and we have move into the third millennium, we can see

many developments and changes taking place around us with all the industries and firms within each

Page 2: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 2

industry trying to keep pace with the changes and diverse needs of the people. Though for decade

together, marketers have regarded ‘customer’ as the king and evolved all activities to satisfy him or her,

giving this concept a momentum it is necessary to understand the Perception and Expectations of the

customer in respect various aspects & attributes so as to design a successful and an acceptable product or

service.

This can largely be attributed to the prevailing market situation. Not only has competition become

intense but over and above with the market being flooded with many me-too products, the challenge

before the marketer is to understand the diversity of consumer expectations and offer goods/services

accordingly. Today the company image is built and made known by its customers. Thus the success of the

firm will be determined by how effective it has been in meeting the diverse consumer needs and wants by

treating each customer as unique and offering products and services to suit his or her needs.

Therefore today all the firms are engaged in a process of creating a lifetime value and relationship with

their customers, a step towards developing knowledge regarding its customers needs is the utmost

important. The current study is an attempt to measure the various parameters as perceived by the

customers and to help the company in serving its customers in a much better and efficient manner.

1.2 - Scope of the study

The scope of the study lies in finding out the perception of customers in Lucknow city through

responses taken by 300 customers during a period of 60 days and highlighting the key areas which require

some concern on part of LIC of India and improving upon which the company may strengthen its

customer base. The present study, analysis, findings and suggestions proposed by the present researcher

will be of immense use for future researcher with similar studies in insurance market.

Page 3: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 3

1.3 Significance of the study :

High quality products with quality support services both in terms of international standards and

competitiveness have entered into our country. Customer satisfaction has emerged as the key differentiator

and defining attribute. The study is very much significant because it brings out the differences in various

parameters like awareness, service quality, problems faced and rationale behind investment between the

products of LIC and private sector companies and these are the main attributes which build up the

customer perception and loyalty towards a company. The study is significant also because it will help LIC

to create a positive impact on its customers by working on its lacking qualities.

1.4 Objectives of the study :

For every problem there is a research. As all the researches are based on some and my study is

also based upon some objective and these are as follows :

I ) To test the awareness of customers on various aspects of life insurance policies offered by LIC

and other private sector insurance companies and find whether there is any relation between

them.

II ) To study the service quality being offered by LIC and private sector insurance companies and

test if any relation exists.

III ) To analyze various problems confronted by the policyholders of LIC and private sector

insurance companies and determine the relation between the two.

IV ) To clearly understand the rationale behind the investment in policies of LIC and private

sector insurance companies.

V ) To analyze the various aspects of LIC and do a complete SWOT analysis of the organization.

Page 4: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 4

1.5 Review of Literature :

1) Retention of the Customers is the essence of Insurance business, Imtiyaz.H Ltd.VASI DO,

Insurance Times (Pg 20).Feb 2007-:

Retaining a customer is four time cheaper than acquiring a new one. The retention of the customers is of

utmost importance in the insurance industry in specification. Insurance business is of the relationship

building process. were one customer leads to the building of other one. A satisfied customer is like a word

of mouth advertisement for the company. The needs of the existing customers should be identified and

satisfied well rather than only concentrating at the new accounts. All possible measures needs to taken to

retain the customers as it is lesser costlier as well as provides stability to the business .

2) Trends in Life Insurance Business—Unit Linked Insurance Plans, IRDA annual report 2007-08,

box item 1, page no. 15 -:

It wasn’t too long back when the good old endowment plan was the preferred way to insure oneself

against an eventuality and to set aside some savings to meet one’s financial objectives. The traditional

endowment policies were investing funds mainly in fixed interest Government securities and other safe

investments to ensure the safety of capital. Thus the traditional emphasis was always on security of capital

rather than yield. However, with the inflationary trend witnessed all over the world, it was observed that

savings through life insurance were becoming unattractive and not meeting the aspirations of the

policyholders.

The policyholder found that the sum assured guaranteed on maturity had really depreciated in real value

because of the depreciation in the value of money. The investor was no longer content with the so called

security of capital provided under a policy of life insurance and started showing a preference for higher

rate of return on his investments as also for capital appreciation. It was, therefore found necessary for the

insurance companies to think of a method whereby the expectation of the policyholders could be satisfied.

The object was to provide a hedge against the inflation through a contract of insurance. Decline of assured

return endowment plans and opening of the insurance sector saw the advent of ULIPs on the domestic

insurance horizon. Today, the Indian life insurance market is riding high on the unit linked insurance

plans.

Page 5: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 5

3) Sampada kapse & D.G kodwani, Insurance as an investment option, The Insurance Time, May

2003

At national as at individual level the excess of income after consumption level savings as funds for

investment. Surplus funds can be invested in either real asset or in financial assets. Purpose of investment

is to protect one’s wealth against erosion of value due to inflation and to earn risk adjusted return. There

are three motives which drive people to purchase insurance products in India.

_ Desire to cover risk

_ Tax benefit

_ Saving motives

It is argued that in this paper that in the changing scenario for the insurance sector there is going to be a

good opportunities for insurance sector to expand its market base. For this purpose there is need to

improve the features of the insurance products to make them more liquid or short term schemes could be

increased. It is shown that although rewards implied by the insurance products particularly by the tax

benefits are quite close to those observed in banks and small saving scheme of the governments. The

performance of mutual funds which come in many different types is found to be reasonable compared to

the risk involved. The survey indicates that it may not be very difficult to win over the confidence of small

investors towards insurance policies if good marketing techniques are adopted to educate the targeted

population about the uses of insurance policies from investment point of view.

4) Samuel B Sekar, Research associate, Academic wing, The ICFAI University, Customer – driven

innovation in insurance products, Insurance Chronicle, page 33, July 2006-:

Insurance is one product which is not demanded by a customer, but supplied to him by massive education

and drive marketing. Insurance ought to be bought not sold. The new concept of demand side innovation

focuses more on customer’s social and economic reality striving to deliver maximum value to the

customer at an affordable price. Therefore, when the customer becomes the primary focus including him

in the invention process becomes mandatory. But, there are certain areas of insurance innovations where

the customers cannot be involved. A case in point is the recent insurance product invention called

Telematic Auto Insurance. It’s a product by the Progressive Auto Insurance, which monitors the driving

behaviour of its auto insurance policyholder. The new machine grabs information and automatically

Page 6: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 6

transmits it to the insurer. This information received is regularly analyzed to judicially conclude the

intensity of risk the person is exposed and the corresponding premium he is eligible to pay. This is an

example of supply side innovation, where it is strictly not possible to include the customer in the

innovation process. Though, there are instances where the customer is involved in the testing phase, his

inclusion in the conception phase makes an innovation demand-driven.

Page 7: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 7

CHAPTER - II

2.1 Historical Perspective :

Insurance in India

The Britishers opened general insurance in India around the year 1700.

The first company, known as the Sun Insurance Office Ltd. was set up in Calcutta in the

year 1710.

Insurance companies like Bombay Insurance Company Ltd was established in 1793.

In 1818 it was conceived as a means to provide for English Widows.

The Bombay Mutual Life Insurance Society started its business in 1870.

It was the first company to charge same premium for both Indian and non-Indian lives.

The Oriental Assurance Company was established in 1880.

Till the end of nineteenth century insurance business was almost entirely in the hands of overseas

companies.

Insurance regulation formally began in India with the passing of the Life Insurance Companies

Act of 1912 and the provident fund Act of 1912.

Several frauds during 20's and 30's sullied insurance business in India.

By 1938 there were 176 insurance companies.

The first comprehensive legislation was introduced with the Insurance Act of 1938 that provided

strict State Control over insurance business.

The insurance business grew at a faster pace after independence.

The Government of India in 1956, brought together over 240 private life insurers and provident

societies under one nationalized monopoly corporation and Life Insurance Corporation (LIC)

was born.

Nationalization was justified on the grounds that it would create much needed funds for rapid industrialization.

Page 8: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 8

What Is Life Insurance?

Life insurance is a contract that pledges payment of an amount to the person assured (or his nominee) on

the happening of the event insured against.

The contract is valid for payment of the insured amount during:

The date of maturity, or

Specified dates at periodic intervals, or

Unfortunate death, if it occurs earlier.

Why We Need Insurance :

Life insurance is a contact by which you can protect yourself against specific uncertainties by paying a

premium over a period. Since each one of us during our lives are faced with numerous risks-falling health,

financial losses, accident and even fatalities.

ProtectionYou need life insurance to be there and protect the people you love, making sure that your family has a

means to look after itself after you are gone. It is a thoughtful business concept designed to protect the

economic value of a human life for the benefit of those financially dependent on him.

RetirementLife insurance makes sure that you have regular income after you retire and helps you maintain your

standard of living. It can ensure that your post-retirement years are spent in peace and comfort.

Savings and InvestmentsInsurance is a means to Save and Invest. Your periodic premiums are like Savings and you are assured of

a lump sum amount on maturity. A policy can come in handy at the time of your child’s education or

marriage! Besides, it can be used as supplemental retirement income.

Tax BenefitsLife insurance is one of the best tax saving options today. Your tax can be saved twice on a life insurance

policy-once when you pay your premiums and once when you receive maturity benefits. Money saved is

money earned.

Myths of Insurance :i) Insurance is just meant for saving tax.

ii) Insurance does not give good returns

iii) Insurance products are not flexible

Page 9: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 9

2.2 Industry Profile :

INDIAN INSURANCE INDUSTRY

Insurance is a big opportunity in a country like India with a large population and untapped potential. The

life insurance business (measured in the context of first year premium) registered a growth of 23.88 % in

2007-08, (94.96 % achieved in 2006-07). The general insurance business (gross direct premium) has

registered a growth of 11.72 % in 2007-08 (3.52 % achieved in 2006-07). This has resulted in increasing

insurance penetration in the country. Insurance penetration or premium volume as a ratio of GDP, for the

year 2007 stood at 4.00 % for life insurance and 0.60 % for non-life insurance. The level of penetration,

particularly in life insurance, tends to rise as income levels increase. India, with its huge middle class

households, has exhibited growth potential for the insurance industry. Saturation of markets in many

developed economies has made the Indian market even more attractive for global insurance majors. The

insurance market in India has witnessed dynamic changes including entry of a number of global insurers

in both life and non-life segment.

Most of the private insurance companies are joint ventures with recognized foreign players across the

globe. Over the last eight years, consumer awareness has improved. Competition has brought more

product innovation and better customer servicing. This made a positive impact on the economy in income

generation and creating employment opportunities in this sector.

At present there are a total of 21 companies in the life insurance business in India and only LIC is in the

public sector and rest all 20 companies are in the private sector.

Page 10: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 10

Table of Life Insurance Companies as on 31st March, 2009

SI

No.

INSURERS

FOREIGN

PARTNERS

REGISTRATION

NUMBER

DATE OF

REGISTRATION

YEAR OF

OPERATION

1 HDFC StandardLife Insurance Co. Ltd.

Standard Life

Assurance, UK

101

23.10.2000

2000-01

2 Max New YorkLife Insurance Co. Ltd.

New York Life,

USA

104

15.11.2000

2000-01

3 PRIVATE COMPANY-PrudentialLife Insurance Co. Ltd.

Prudential, U.K.

105

24.11.2000

2000-01

4 Om Kotak Life Insurance

Co. Ltd.

Old Mutual,

South Africa

107

10.01.2001

2001-02

5 Birla Sun Life Insurance Co.

Ltd.

Sun Life, Canada

109 31.01.2001

2000-01

6 Tata-AIG Life Insurance Co.

Ltd.

American InternationalAssurance Co.,

USA

110 12.02.2001 2000-01

7 SBI Life Insurance Co. Ltd. BNP ParibasAssurance SA,

France

111 29.03.2001 2001-02

8 ING Vysya Life Insurance

Co. Ltd.

ING Insurance InternationalB.V., Netherlands

114 02.08.2001

2001-02

9 Allianz Bajaj Life Insurance

Co. Ltd.

Allianz, Germany

116 03.08.2001 2001-02

10 Metlife India Insurance Co.

Ltd.

Metlife InternationalHoldings Ltd.,

USA

117 06.08.2001

2001-02

11 Reliance Life Insurance Co. Ltd.(Earlier AMP Sanmar Life Insurance Companyfrom 3.1.02 to 29.9.05)

121 03.01.2002 2001-02

12 AVIVA Aviva

International

Holdings Ltd., UK

122

14.05.2002 2002-03

Page 11: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 11

13 Sahara Life Insurance Co. . 127 06.02.2004 2004-05

14 Shriram Life Insurance Co.

Ltd.

Sanlam, South

Africa

128

17.11.2005 2005-06

15 Bharti AXA Life Insurance

Co. Ltd.

AXA Holdings,

France

130 14.07.2006 2006-07

16 Future Generali India Life

Insurance Company Ltd.

Pantaloon Retail Ltd.; Sain MarketingNetwork Pvt. Ltd. (SMNPL),Generali, Italy

133

04.09.2007 2007-08

17 IDBI FortisLife Insurance Company Ltd.

Fortis,

Netherlands

135

19.12.2007 2007-08

18 Canara HSBC OBCLife Insurance Company Ltd.

HSBC, UK

136

08.05.2008 2008-09

19 Aegon ReligareLife Insurance Company Ltd.

Religare,

Netherlands

138

27.06.2008

2008-09

20 DLF Pramerica Life

Insurance Co. Ltd.

Prudential of

America, USA

140

27.06.2008 2008-09

21 Life Insurance Corporation

of India

512

Besides Life Insurance, all the above-mentioned companies provide coverage in Medical Insurance,

Automobile Insurance, Accident Insurance, Home Insurance and many others. In short, the future of

insurance companies in India looks bright.

Contribution to Indian Economy

Life Insurance is the only sector which garners long term savings.

Spread of financial services in rural areas and amongst socially less privileged.

Long term funds for infrastructure.

Strong positive correlation between development of capital markets and insurance/pension

structure.

Employment generation.

Page 12: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 12

International Comparision of Life Insurance Penetration :

The table below shows that India is doing well in comparison to several countries but still the life

insurance penetration is still low and there is a huge scope for growth in the insurance industry.

Table 1 -

Chart 1 -

Insurance penetration is measured as ratio (in per cent) of premium (in US Dollars) to GDP (in US Dollars)

Interpretation – The above table shows that since the total premium collected is just 4% of India’s

GDP in 2007 as compared to France, Japan, England which have very high

penetration so there is a great scope for growth of life insurance in India .

2005 2006 2007INDIA 2.53 4.1 4USA 4.14 4 4.2CHINA 1.78 1.7 1.8GERMANY 3.06 3.1 3.1FRANCE 7.08 7.9 7.3JAPAN 8.32 8.3 7.5ENGLAND 8.9 13.1 12.6CANADA 3.05 3.1 3.2ITALY 4.86 4.7 4

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

INDIA

USA

CHINA

GERMANY

FRANCE

JAPAN

ENGLAND

CANADA

ITALY

2005

2006

2007

Page 13: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 13

Number of Life Insurance Offices- Company wise (as on 2008-09)

Table 2 -

INSURER 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001

PRIVATE

SECTOR

6391 3072 1645 804 416 254 116 13

LIC 2522 2301 2220 2197 2196 2191 2190 2186

INDUSTRY

TOTAL

8913 5373 3865 3001 2612 2445 2306 2199

Expansion of OfficesThe number of offices of the life insurers has increased dramatically in the year 2007-08 from 5373 at the

beginning of the year to 8913 by the end of the year, showing a growth of over 65 %. A major portion of

this expansion was in the private sector whose offices more than doubled from 3072 to 6391. LIC’s

offices increased at a more modest 10 % from 2301 offices to 2522.

New Policies issued : Life Insurers (as on 2008-09) :

Table 3 -

INSURER 2007-08 2006-07 2005-06 2004-05 2003-04 2002-03

LIC 37612599

(-1.61)

38229292

(21.01)

31590707

(31.75)

23978123

(-11.09)

26968069

(9.87)

24545580

(96.75)

PRIVATE

SECTOR

13261558

(67.40)

7922274

(104.64)

3871410

(73.37)

2233075

(34.62)

1658847

(101.05)

825094

(3.25)

INDUSTRY

TOTAL

50874157 46151566 35462117 26211198 28626916 25370674

Figure in bracket indicates the growth over the previous year in percent.

Page 14: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 14

Chart 2 -

New policies underwritten by the industry were 508.74 lakhs in 2007-08 as against 461.52 lakhs during

2006-07 showing an increase of 10.23 %. While the private insurers exhibited a growth of 67.40 %,

(previous year 104.64 %), LIC showed a decline of 1.61 % as against a growth of 21.01 % in 2006-07.

The market shares of private insurers and LIC, in terms of number of policies underwritten, were 26.07%

and 73.93% as against 17.17% and 82.83% respectively in 2006-07. We can clearly see that private

companies are catching up as they are registering a continuously high growth rate as compared to LIC

which is a matter of concern.

Total Life Insurance Premium( as according to IRDA handbook

2007-08 )

Life insurance industry recorded a premium income of Rs.201351.41 crore during 2007-08 as against

Rs.156075.85 crore in the previous financial year, recording a growth of 29.01 per cent. Regular premium,

single premium and renewal premium in 2007-08 were Rs.54888.16 crore (27.26 per cent); Rs.38824.36

crore (19.28 per cent); and Rs.107638.89 crore (53.46 per cent), respectively. The table below shows the

trend followed during past seven years in terms of total life premium collected.

Growth Rate over past years

-20

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

2007-08 2006-07 2005-06 2004-05 2003-04 2002-03

LIC

Private Companies

Page 15: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 15

Table 4 -

INSURER 2007-08 2006-07 2005-06 2004-05 2003-04 2002-03

LIC 149789.99 (17.19)

127822.84

(40.79)

90792.22

(20.85)

75127.29

(18.25)

63533.43

(16.30)

54628.49

(9.65)

PRIVATE

SECTOR

51561.42 (82.50)

28253.00

(87.08)

15083.54

(95.19)

7727.51

(147.65)

3120.33

(178.83)

1119.06

(310.59)

INDUSTRY

TOTAL

201351.41 (29.01)

156075.84

(47.38)

105875.76

(27.78)

82854.80

(24.31)

66653.75

(19.56)

55747.55

(11.28)

Figure in the bracket represent the growth over the previous year in percent.

Chart 3 -

Interpretation -From the above table 4 and chart 3 we can clearly see that private companies are

registering encouraging growth rates in terms of total premium collection over the past few years as

compared to LIC’s normal and ordinary growth.

Growth Rate over past years

17.1940.79

20.85 18.25 16.3 9.65

82.5 87.08 95.19

147.65178.83

310.59

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

2007-08 2006-07 2005-06 2004-05 2003-04 2002-03

LIC

Private companies

Page 16: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 16

New Business Premium (Individual and Group) of Life Insurers

for 2007-08 Channel wise :

Table 5 -

Life Insurer Individual

Agents

Corporate

Agents

Brokers Direct

Selling

Total New

Business(

Individual and

group)

Referrals

PRIVATE

TOTAL

53.46 28.12 1.61 16.81 100.00 6.96

LIC 82.98 1.32 0.05 15.85 100.00 -

INDUSTRY

TOTAL

72.17 11.02 0.61 16.20 100.00 2.51

Chart 4 -

The share of corporate agents which was 8.42 % in 2006-07 has increased to 12.33 % in 2007-08. Within

the corporate agency channel, while the banks’ share grew from 5.46 % in 2006-07 to 7.97 % in 2007-08,

the others grew from 2.96 % to 4.36 % in the corresponding years. The share of corporate agents in the

new business premium procured by the private life insurers was significant at 29.92 % in 2007-08 as

Page 17: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 17

compared to 24.99 % in 2006-07, while for LIC the share fell to 1.59 % in 2007-08 from 2.14 % in the

previous year.

Performance in the first quarter of 2008-09

(i) Life insurance:

The life insurers underwrote a premium of Rs.14320.20 crores during the first quarter in the current

financial year as against Rs.12511.80 crores in the comparable period of last year recording a growth of

14.45 %. Of the total premium underwritten, LIC accounted for Rs.7524.56 crores and the

private insurers accounted for Rs. 6795.64 crores. The premium underwritten by LIC declined by 12.31 %

while, that of private insurers increased by 72.88 %, over the corresponding period in the previous year.

The number of policies written at the industry level declined by 7.78 %. While the number of policies

written by LIC declined by 23.36 %, in the case of private insurers they grew by 44.00 %. Of the total

premium underwritten, individual business accounted for Rs.10995.90 crores and group business for Rs.

3324.30 crores. In respect of LIC, individual business was Rs. 5275.71 crores and group business was

Rs.2248.85 crores. In the case of private insurers, they were Rs.5720.19 crores and Rs.1075.45 crores

respectively. The market share of LIC was 52.55 % in the total premium collection and 63.88 % in

number of polices underwritten, lower than 68.58 % and 76.87 % respectively reported in the previous

year. Under the group scheme 56.13 lakhs lives were covered recording a growth of 8.51 % over the

previous period. Of the total lives covered under the group scheme, LIC accounted for 38.96 lakhs and

private insurers 12.77 lakhs. The life insurers covered 12.50 lakhs lives in the social sector with a

premium of Rs.17.10 crores and underwrote 13.53 lakhs policies with a premium of Rs.1275.78 crores in

the rural sector.

The total capital of the life insurers at end March 2008 stood at Rs.12296.42 crores. The additional capital

brought in by the existing private insurers during 2007-08 was Rs.3787.01 crores and the two new

entrants, brought in equity of Rs.385 crores making the total additional capital brought in 2007-08 by the

private insurers to Rs. 4172.01 crores. Of this, the domestic and the foreign joint venture partners added

Rs.3160.12 crores and Rs.1011.88 crores respectively.

Page 18: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 18

The private insurers also seem to be scoring big in other ways- they are persuading people to take out

bigger policies. For instance, the average size of a life insurance policy before privatization was around Rs

50,000. That has risen to about Rs 80,000. But the private insurers are ahead in this game and the average

size of their policies is around Rs 1.1 lakhs to Rs 1.2 lakhs- way bigger than the industry average.

Buoyed by their quicker than expected success, nearly all private insurers are fast- forwarding the second

phase of their expansion plans. No doubt the aggressive stance of private insurers is already paying rich

dividends. But a rejuvenated LIC is also trying to fight back to woo new customers.

2.3 COMPANY PROFILE :

Life Insurance Corporation of India

The Life Insurance Corporation of India popularly known as “LIC of India” was incorporated on

September 1, 1956 by nationalizing 245 Indian as well as foreign companies . It was established 52 years

ago with a view to provide an insurance cover against various risk in life.the luminaries who spearheaded

this move at that time visualised an entity that will provide life insurance to Indians, especially the vast

rural masses, at an economical cost and channel the savings for the betterment of the nation. It is the

largest life insurance company in India and also the countries largest investor. It is fully owned by the

Government of India and headquartered in Mumbai.

The subsidiary companies under LIC are:

LIC of India, International

A joint venture offshore company promoted by LIC, commenced its operation in july1989. The primary

objective is to the US-dollar denominated policies which cater to the insurance needs of non-resident in

Indians. It provides insurance services to policyholders who residing in Gulf. The LIC International

operates in all Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries.

LIC Nepal

A joint venture company formed in September 2001 with the Vishal Group of Industries with a capital

base of Rs.250mn. It is one of the largest capitalized insurance companies of Nepal. It has joint share

between LIC of India (55%) Vishal Group (25%) and has a public participation to the extent o 20%.

Page 19: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 19

Life Insurance Corporation Lanka Limited (LICL)

A joint venture company formed in 2003 with the Bartleet Group of Companies, it is one of the oldest and

reliable institutions in Sri Lanka. The combined strengths of these two formidable companies has enabled

LICL to emerge as the premier provider of Life Insurance in Sri Lanka. The Indian-based blue-chip also

has offices in UK, Mauritius, Fiji, and in all Middle East countries.

LIC Housing Finance

Incorporated on june 19, 1989; its main objective is to provide long term finance for construction or

purchase of houses or apartments. The company provides long terms finance to individuals for purchase,

construction, repair and renovation of new \ existing flats\houses. It also provides finance on existing

property for business, personal needs and gives loans to professionals for purchase or construction of

clinics\ nursing homes\ diagnostic centers\office space and also for purchase of equipments. It has set up a

representative office in Dubai and Kuwait to cater to the non- resident Indians in countries covering

Bahrain, Dubai, Kuwait, Qatar and Saudi Arabia. It has client group of over 9,40, 000prudent house

owners who enjoy the company’s financial assistance.

LIC Housing Finance Limited Care Homes

It is a Wholly-owned subsidiary of LIC Housing Finance. It builds and operates “Assisted Community

Living Center” for senior citizens. It operates a network of approximately 6 regional offices, 13 back

offices, and 127marketing offices.

Vision

“To emerge as a transnationally competitive financial conglomerate of significance to societies and be the

pride of India “ .

Mission

Explore and enhance the quality of life of people through financial security by providing products and

services of aspired attributes with competitive returns and by rendering resources for economic

development.

Page 20: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 20

Objective of LIC

Spread life insurance widely in particular to the rural areas and socially and economically

backward classes. This is done with a view to reach all the insurable persons in the country and

provide them adequate financial cover against death at a reasonable cost.

To maximize mobilization of people’s savings by making insurance linked savings adequately

attractive.

Bearing in mind, the primary obligation to its policyholders, whose money it holds in trust, the

investible funds to be deployed to the best advantage of the investors as well as the national

priorities and the obligations of attractive returns.

To conduct business with utmost economy and keeping gin mind that the money belongs to the

policyholders.

It acts as a trustee of the insured public in its individual and collective capacities.

To meet the various life insurance need of the community that would arise in the changing social

and economic environment.

It ensures that all people working in the corporation are involved to the best of their capability in

furthering the interests of the insured public by providing efficient service with courtesy.

Promote amongst all agents and employees of the corporation a sense of participation, pride and

job satisfaction through discharge of their duties with dedication towards achievement of corporate

objective.

Board of Directors Chairman TS Vijayan

Managing Director D.K. Mehrotra, Thomas Mathew T, A.K. Dasgupta

Finance Secretary and secretary( financial services)Department of Financial Services, Ministry of finance, Govt. of India

Arun Ramanathan

Addl. Secretary, Dept. of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance Sindhushree Khullar

Page 21: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 21

Chairman cum Managing Director GIC of India

Yogesh Lohiya

Chairman and Managing Director, Export Import, Bank of India

T.C. Venkat Subramaniam

Products and Services

LIC has eight zonal offices and 105 divisional offices located in different parts of India. It compromises of

2,048 branches and employs over 10, 02, 149 agents for soliciting life insurance business from public. LIC

has extended its activities in 12 countries from outside India, primarily to cater to the insurance needs of

non-resident Indians.

LIC aims at strengthening it relationship with its vast customer base by providing value-added service

such as credit cards and offering premium payment facility to the policyholders. It is the largest insurance

player in India and its objective is to channelize its funds for the benefit of the community at large. It

enjoys a near monopoly power in the solicitation and sale of life insurance policies in India. The

corporation has major business houses as clients, under the group business of India. It has more than

1,18,000 corporate clients covering more than 3,15,00,000 members.

Apart from the corporate group insurance business the pension& group schemes is responsible for

‘Aam Aadmi Bima Yojna’,a social security schemes for the rural landless households under the aegis of

the Government of India.LIC has been investing a major portion of its funds in socially-oriented sectors

with a view to reach every insurable person in the country and provide adequate financial cover against

death at a reasonable cost. Another goal is to mobilize people’s savings adequately attractive.LIC has

recently tied up with Policybazaar.com an insurance portal that enables the consumers to get detailed

information on the policy. It is one of the leading online non-life and life insurance aggregator to sell its

policy Jeevan Aastha on the internet.

Page 22: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 22

Insurance Plans

The following insurance plans are on offer. They provide the most suitable options that can fit customer’s

requirement.

LIC Product PortfolioChildren Plans

Jeeevan Anurag

CDA Endowment Vesting at 21

CDA Endowment Vesting at 18

Jeevan Kishore

Child Career Plan

Child Fortune Plus

Marriage Endowment or Educational

Annuity Plan

Jeevan Chhaya

Child future Plan

Plans for Handicapped Dependents Jeevan Aadhar

Jeevan Vishwas

Endowment AssurancePlans The Endowment Assurance Policy

The Endowment Assurance Policy-Limited

Payment

Jeevan Mitra (Double Cover Endowment

Plan)

Jeevan Mitra (Triple Cover Endowment

Plan)

Jeevan Anand

New Janraksha Plan

Jeevan Amrit

Money Back Plans Jeevan Varsha

The Money Back Policy-20 years

The Money Back Policy-25 years

Jeevan Surabhi-15 Years

Jeevan Surabhi-20 Years

Jeevan Surabhi-25 Years

Bima Bachat

Special Money Back Plan for women Jeevan Bharti-1

Whole Life Plans The Whole Life Policy

The Whole Life Policy –Limited Payment

The Whole Life Policy – Single Premium

Jeevan Anand

Jeevan Tarang

Term Assurance Plans Two year Temporary Assurance Plan

The Convertible Term Assurance Policy

Anmol Jeevan- 1

Amulya Jeevan -1

Page 23: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 23

Joint Life Plan Jeevan Sathi

Decreasing Term Assurance To Cover

Home Loan Payment

Mortgage Redemption

Pension Plans Jeevan Nidhi

Jeevan Akshay-VI

New Jeevan Dhara-I

New Jeevan Suraksha-I

Group Scheme Group Term Insurance Schemes

Group Term Insurance Scheme in Lieu of

EDLI

Group Leave Encashment Scheme

Group Mortgage Redemption Assurance

Scheme

Gratuity Plus

Group critical Illness Rider

Plans for High Worth Individuals Jeevan Shree-1

Jeevan Pramukh

Unit Linked Plans Market Plus –I

Profit Plus

Fortune Plus

Money Plus-I

Child Fortune Plus

Special Plans Golden Jubilee Plan

New Bima Gold Special Plan

Bima Nivesh 2005

Jeevan Saral

Jeevan Madhur

Health Plus

Social Security Scheme Janashree Bima Yojna (JBY)

Siksha Sahayog Yojana

Aam Admi Bima Yojana

Unit linked insurance plans (ULIPs) are insurance plans that combine the benefit of investment

with insurance. They give the investor an option to put a part of their premium in various investment

portfolios and derive the benefits depending upon the performance of the funds chosen by them. ULIPs

were launched at an opportune time when stock markets had just taken off. Being market- linked, they

were major beneficiaries of the secular rise in stock markets. ULIPs have gained high acceptance due to

the attractive features they offer. These include:

Page 24: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 24

1. Flexibility

Flexibility to choose Sum Assured.

Flexibility to choose premium amount.

Option to change level of Premium even after the plan has started (Top up facility).

Flexibility to change asset allocation by switching between funds.

2. Transparency

Changes in the plan & net amount invested are known to the customer.

Convenience of tracking one’s investment performance on a daily basis.

3. Liquidity

Option to withdraw money after few years (comfort required in case of exigency).

Low minimum tenure.

Partial / Systematic withdrawal allowed

4. Fund Options

A choice of funds (ranging from equity, debt, cash or a combination).

Option to choose fund mix based on desired asset allocation.

Traditionally, endowment plans have invested in government securities, corporate bonds and the money

market. ULIPs however, have a broader choice. They invest across the board in stocks, government

securities, corporate bonds and money market instruments. Of course, within a ULIP there are options

wherein equity investments are capped.The common types of funds available in ULIPs are Bond Fund,

Protector Fund, Secure Fund, Balanced Fund, Growth Fund, Index Fund, and Enhancer Fund. Depending

on one’s risk appetite one can choose the fund. However the investment risk is borne by the investor.

The common type of charges, fees and deductions in ULIPs are Premium allocation charges, Mortality

charges, Fund management charges, Policy/administration charges, Surrender charges, Fund switching

charges and Service tax.

Insurance companies are required to declare the NAV of various ULIPs on a daily basis. The movement of

NAV enables the policy holder to assess the performance of his investment and accordingly make

intervention in the form of switches, withdrawal and top-ups. After opening up of the insurance sector,

Unit-linked insurance policies (ULIPs) have become increasingly popular.

Page 25: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 25

Analysis of figures for the last three years indicates the growth pattern of unit linked business.

Table 6 -

TRENDS IN LIFE INSURANCE BUSINESS—UNIT LINKED INSURANCE PLANS

Unit Linked Business (%) Non-linked Business (%)

2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08

Private 82.30 88.75 90.33 17.70 11.25 9.67

LIC 29.76 46.31 62.31 70.24 53.69 37.69

Industry 41.77 56.91 70.30 58.23 43.09 29.70

Chart 5 -

Interpretation – The above graph shows that during the past few years ULIP plans have become more

and more popular among the investors because of the returns they provide in addition

to the insurance cover.

Page 26: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 26

Performance of LIC of India

The number of new policies marketed grew from 14.69 lakhss in 1961 to 2.18 croress in 2004-05 and

the sum assured under this business rose to high of Rs. 1,79,886.66 cr in 2004-05 from Rs.336.67 cr in

1957. The total funds of the corporation also grew from Rs. 702.80 cr in 1961 to Rs. 4,16,910.36 cr in

2004-05. Investments , which were Rs. 329.74 cr in 1957 rose to a high of Rs.4,13,800.95 cr in 2004-05

,allof which gets deployed for the development of the nation.The LIC has huge investible funds and the

main source comes from the premiums collected from the policy holders.

The Corporation invests these funds in various states, industries and also in various other countries.

The LIC, while investing its funds, has to consider various factors and forces such as safety, liquidity and

productivity of funds plus various other regulatory bindings in terms of investment norms, asset- liability

management etc. In short, the LIC has to make its investments within the ambit of these bindings as a

result, the corporation is not in apposition to pursue a prudent investment policy due to which its

investment income may come under pressure. Adding fuel to the fire, the falling interest rate would also

adversely affect the investment performance of the Corporation.

Still at present LIC continues to be the dominant life insurer even in the post-liberalization phase of

the Indian insurance industry. It is on new growth trajectory surpassing its own past records. The

average premium growth so far has been 20%. With the targeted Rs.1,75,000 crores total premium by

the end of current fiscal, The life insurance giant is looking a market share about 75%.

The corporation has crossed many milestones and has set unprecedented performance records in

various aspects of life insurance business. The state- owned corporation is targeting a business of over

Rs.3,00,000 crores by2011-12. The life insurance major expects its assets size to grow about

Rs.6,00,000cr or 75% in the next three years.

In the current fiscal year, the company has recruited about two lakhs insurance agent across the

country, which is more than double of the 90,000 agents hired in the previous fiscal. It has also hired

4,500 development officers in the current fiscal year and 5,000 new officers could be hired in the next

fiscal.

It has bagged various awards which include Loyalty Award 2009, Golden Peacock Innovative

Product/Service Award 2009, Readers Digest Trusted Brand Award 2008 in the Platinum Category,

CNBC ‘Awaaz’ Consumer Awards 2008 and NDTV Profit Business Leadership Award 2008.The

Page 27: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 27

Economic Times Brand Equity Survey rated LIC as the No.1 service brand of the country for the 5th

consecutive year. In the chart below is shown the market share of LIC and private in terms of total

premium collected. ( refer table 4 for data )

Chart 6 -

The bar graph clearly indicates that market share is continuously declining for LIC over the past few years.

Investment Portfolio of LIC of India

The Life Insurance Corporation of India has been a nation builder since its formation in 1956. True to

the objective of nationalization, the LIC has mobilized the funds invested by the people in the life

insurance for the benefit of the community at large.

The corporation has deployed the funds to the best advantage of the policyholders as well as the

community as a whole, true to the spirit of nationalization. National priorities and obligation of

reasonable returns to the policyholders are its main criteria for the investment.

The total funds, so invested for the benefit of the community at large accumulated to Rs 751129 crores

(provisional) as on 31st march 2008. The investment of the corporation’s funds is governed by Section

27A of the insurance act, 1938 subsequent guidelines/instructions issued there under by the

Government of India from time to time and the IRDA by way of regulations. As per the prescribed

investment pattern approved by IRDA, the controlled funds are invested as follows :

Not less than 50% is invested in Government securities or other approved investments.

Not less than 15% is invested in infrastructural and social sector investments.

Not less than 35% in other investments, to be governed by exposure prudential norms

Market Share in %

74

82

86

91

95

98

99

26

18

14

9

5

2

1

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

2007-08

2006-07

2005-06

2004-05

2003-04

2002-03

2001-02

LIC

Private companies

Page 28: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 28

Investment in Government and social sector :

Type of investment

As on

31-3-2006 31-3-2007 31-3-2008

Central Government

securities

236959 272498 297943

State Government &

other Govt. guaranteed

marketable secrities

58928 64285 89234

Infrastructure & social

sector investment

Housing 19807 22451 24325

Power 29740 37881 41120

Irrigation/ water supply

& sewage

8288 7500 6649

Roads, ports and bridges 725 1516 1154

Others including

railways

3954 4398 8774

Total 358401 410529 469191

Total funds of LIC

Year Total funds Growth trend Annual growth(%)

1999-00 1,61,002.22 100.00 -

2000-01 1,93,621.69 120.26 20.26

2001-02 2,45,039.82 152.20 26.56

2002-03 2,77,160.34 172.15 13.11

2003-04 3,46,022.54 214.92 24.85

2004-05 4,16,910.36 258.95 20.49

Compiled from the annual reports of LIC of India

Page 29: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 29

Awards and achievements of LIC :

Golden Peacock Innovative Product / Service Award – 2009

Loyalty Award 2009

Readers Digest Trusted Brand Award 2008 in the Platinum category

CNBC Awaaz Consumer Awards 2008

Page 30: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 30

The SWOT analysis involves an in depth study of the strength and weakness of the provided organization and it also provides information to the promoter, consultant, other agencies and helps in long term viability of the project.

Strength : It is the oldest and most well experienced player having a Pan India presence.

LIC has a strong and very well developed distribution network.

It is having a huge consumer base and is evolved as one of the most powerful brands of the country.

It has a large product portfolio and claim settlement is easier to get.

It has the advantage of government guarantee is accompanied with it.

Weakness : Its employees and other staff are lethargic and least motivated to render prompt and sincere

customer service.

After sales customer grievance redressal mechanism is inefficient.

Agents not taking into account the needs of people and promote policies having high commissions only.

Very slow decision making process and internal problems between top management and lower cadre staff.

The top management or bosses are mediocre and there is large scale corruption in main office.

The development officers and agents who are the foundation pillars of LIC are not provided with extra funds and powers to promote its products aggressively.

Opportunity : Emergence of a huge middle income consumer market in the country

People becoming more aware and demanding so there is scope for a whole lot of innovative products.

Pension markets, health insurance and large real estate portfolio.

Threats : There is too much internal discord.

Entry of new private players in industry.

Red-tapism is very much persistent.

Page 31: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 31

2.4 Departmental details :

The organization having a such a huge size has to have a well defined hierarchical structure and LIC is not

an exception to this fact. A well defined proper organization structure with officials with exact knowledge

of their duties is a must for an organization to prosper. LIC has a vast network of offices across the length

and breadth of our country and abroad so it has defined and maintained its organizational structure in the

following way.

LIC has its main central head office at ‘Yogaakshema’ Jeevan bima marg at Mumbai. Then it is followed

by eight zonal offices namely central zone, eastern zone, east central zone, northern zone, north

central zone, southern zone, south central zone, western zone respectively. After these eight zonal

offices there are several divisional offices under each zonal office and these divisional offices are mostly

in each big city. At last comes the branch office and there are several branch offices under each divisional

office. At all the branch offices there is a branch manager and several departments and the major function

of these branch offices is sales and servicing of the policies.

In a branch office the top most is a branch manager and under his control are seven different departments

with each of these departments functioning independently to each other. These seven departments are as

follows :

1. Sales Department – This department is mainly concerned with the sale of new policies and is headed

by Assistant Branch Manager Sales(ABMS). The internal agent of LIC is the

Development Officer who has the job of communicating and training the Free

Lancing agents. It is the development officer who continuously encourages the

agents to get new business and the income, performance and commission through

policy selling comes under the jurisdiction of this department.

2.New Business Department – This department performance the very important function of underwriting

new policies which are sent to it for authentication. It checks that all the information

provided by the customer is true and the proposal form and all other details and

proofs are legal. After scrutinizing the new policy it issues the first premium

receipts(FPR) and then issues the policy bond. If anything is found insufficient the

proposal form is sent back to the sales department to correct the mistake and again

submit it.

Page 32: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 32

3.Policy Service Department – After the policy bond is issued, the case is passed on to this department to

take care of after sales service of the policy. It takes care of the premium dates and

if the policy is lapsed then its revival is done by this department. Also if any loan is

required by the customer against his/her policy then its approval has to be given

from the policy service department only.

4. Accounts Department – It is responsible for processing of all the cheques and loans which come to it.

The details regarding financial aspects are covered under this department .

5.Claims Department – All types of claims i.e. survival benefit claim, maturity claim and death claim are

settled by this department. In case of death claim if death occurs after three years

then no investigation is involved in the settlement process and if it occurs before

three years then proper investigation is done and the claim is considered to be an

early claim case.

6. Micro Department – This department has the all important function of co-ordinating with each

department. Each day’s business is collected and its four copies are made and

one copy is sent to the divisional office, second is submitted to the branch manager,

third remains with the incharge of micro department and fourth in the branch office.

7. Office Service Department – This department takes care of all miscellaneous tasks of office and

dispatch of cheques, loans etc come under the responsibility of this department.

Page 33: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 33

Sales Dept.

New BusinessDept.

Accounts Dept. Policy Service

Dept.

Micro Dept.

Office ServiceDept.

Claims Dept.

Central HeadOffice

Zonal Office

Divisional Office

BranchOffice

Page 34: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 34

CHAPTER - III3.1 Research Methodology :

Introduction :

Being a comparative study of public and private sectors, the researcher selected LIC of India from the

public sector and the private sector insurance companies. The study is mainly based on primary data

collected from field source. The primary data is collected through a comprehensive interviews, schedules

and discussions with the customers of LIC and customers of private companies. Secondary data is

collected from various bibliographical sources such as journals, novels, magazines, publications and

various websites including the official website of IRDA, LIC and various other company websites. The

published research reports and market studies also helped the researcher to guage into the problem.

Research design :

The research is divided into two parts. The first part helps us to understand the level of awareness, service

quality, problems faced and the investor’s motive of investment, the second part deals with extracting

important findings from this information and analyzing the measures required to correct problems if any.

Research sample :

A sample of 300 respondents, 151 from LIC and 149 from private sector were identified randomly for

detailed study and analysis. The researcher used stratified random sampling technique for collecting the

primary data. The population of Lucknow city is divided into three stratums such as old, new and cantt

area and an equal number of samples are drawn from each stratum.

Statistical tools used :

Statistical tools like weighted averages, percentages, Chi-square test, mean and standard deviation etc are

used for the analysis of data. For the purpose of analyzing the awareness level a two point rating scale is

used. A two point and a three point scale is used to test the various aspects covering the awareness level,

service quality and problems faced by the consumers.

Page 35: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 35

3.2 Statement of the Problem :

Customer satisfaction is the true differentiator for the success of any business and is more so in insurance

where the products are perceived to be intangible. Referring to the Tables 3 and 4 and also chart 2, 3 and 6

it has been found that growth rate as well as the market share of LIC is constantly decreasing in

comparison to the private companies so to improve on the correctional areas, the four main aspects i.e.

awareness level, service quality, problems faced and rationale behind investment has to be known.

3.3 Formulation of Hypothesis :

Keeping the above mentioned objectives in mind and to have a disciplined direction to the

enquiry, the following hypotheses have been formulated:

I) Ho : There exists a relation between the awareness level and the type of company customers

choose for taking up an insurance policy.

II) Ho : There exists a relation between the level of satisfaction by the service quality and the type

of company customers choose for taking up an insurance policy.

III) Ho : There exists a relation between the grievance redressal mechanism and the type of

company customers choose for taking up an insurance policy.

IV) Ho : There exists a relation between the claim settlement process and the type of company

customers choose for taking up an insurance policy.

Date Processing and Analysis:

Data are process with the help of computer software and Statistical analysis are made with the help of

Excel sheet and SPSS (statistical package for social sciences).Firstly, the answers ticked by the

respondents were recoded while assigning the numerical values. These values were entered into a master

sheet and later with the help of a code book these numerical values were further entered into the

spreadsheet format on the computer. These raw data were processed with the help of the statistical pack as

stated. In order to present the results and analyze them, percentage tables, cross-tabulations were made.

Page 36: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 36

Limitations of the study :

In spite of every care taken on the part of the researcher there were certain limitations which

could not be overcome and are as follows :

Some of the persons were not so responsive.

Possibility of error in data collection because many of investors may have not given the actual

answers of my questionnaire.

Sample size is limited to 300 people only. The sample size may not adequately represent the whole

market.

Some respondents were reluctant to divulge personal information which can hinder the validity of

all responses.

The research study was confined to Lucknow city only.

The above are some of the aspects which posed real problems in the way of completion of the research

work but the majority of respondents were cooperative and my gratitude are due to them.

Page 37: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 37

CHAPTER - IV

4.1 Data analysis and interpretation :

Analysis of Data :

The demographic profile of the respondents is analyzed on the basis of age, gender, occupation,

educational qualification and annual income. The age distribution of sample respondents is shown in

Table 7 below :

Table 7 – Age Group Distribution

Chart 7 -

Interpretation

It is clear from Table 7; a vast majority of respondents (85%) fall in the age band of 20-60 years. Out of

300 respondents around 50% are between 20-40 years and 38% are between 40-60 years of age.

Age Group Below 20

20-40 40-60 Above 60

Total

Number of Respondents

13 151 116 20 300

Percentages 4.3 50.3 38.7 6.7 100

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

Below 20 20-40 40-60 Above 60

Age Distribution of Respondents

Number of Respondents

Page 38: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 38

Table 8 – Gender of respondents

Chart 8 -

Interpretation

Out of the 300 samples drawn 205 (68%) are male and it depicts the domination men in the life insurance

sector. Only 95 (32%) of them are females.

Gender Number of Respondents

Percentage

Male 205 68.3Female 95 31.7Total 300 100

Sex of respondents

Male68%

Female32%

Page 39: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 39

Table 9 – Occupation Distribution

Chart 9 -

Interpretation

Occupation wise, around 46% of respondents are employees and the rest are equally represented by

professionals, businessmen and agriculturists.

Occupation Number of Respondents

Percentages

Professional 49 16.3Employee 140 46.7Business 48 19.3Agriculture 53 17.7Total 300 100

Occupational Distribution

020406080

100120140160

Profe

ssion

al

Emplo

yee

Busin

ess

Agricu

lture

Number of Respondents

Page 40: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 40

Table 10 – Educational Qualification of Respondents

Chart 10 -

Interpretation

It is also revealed from Table I, that more than 60% of the respondents are graduates or technically

qualified. Remaining 22% are intermediate and only 16% are high school passed.

Educational Qualification

Number of Respondents

Percentages

Upto High School

48 16

Intermediate 67 22.3Degree & above

143 47.7

Technical 42 14Total 300 100

Educational Qualification of Respondents

020406080

100120140160

Upto H

igh Sch

ool

Inte

rmed

iate

Degree

& a

bove

Techn

ical

Number of Respondents

Page 41: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 41

Table 11 – Annual Income of Respondents

Chart 11 -

Interpretation

Around 60% of the respondents have an annual income below 1,20,000 and only 17% have income in the

range of 1,20,000-1,80,000. Also 11% have income above Rs 2,40,000.

Annual Income Number of Respondents

Percentages

Below 60,000 60 2060,000-1,20,000

119 39.7

1,20,000-1,80,000

51 17

1,80,000-2,40,000

37 12.3

Above 2,40,000 33 11Total 300 100

Annual Income of Respondents

020406080

100120140

Below 6

0,000

60,00

0-1,

20,00

0

1,20

,000-

1,80

,000

1,80

,000-

2,40

,000

Above

2,4

0,00

0

Number of Respondents

Page 42: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 42

Table 12- Type of the policy

Chart 12 -

Interpretation

Out of the total population more than 50% of the respondents have unit linked insurance plans (ULIP) and

only 18% have money back policies and endowment plans are with only14% of customers.

Type of Policy

Number of Respondents

Percentages

Whole Life 13 4.3Endowment 42 14Money Back

55 18.3

Pension Fund

24 8

ULIP 155 51.7Others 11 3.7Total 300 100

Type of Policy

020406080

100120140160180

Whole

Life

Endow

men

t

Mon

ey Back

Pensio

n Fun

dULIP

Other

s

Number of Respondents

Page 43: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 43

Table 13- Periodicity of the Policy

Chart 13 -

Interpretation

The table spells that around 80% of the respondents have policies with a maturity period of 5 to 25 years

and only 12% have policies with a maturity period of more than 25 years.

Periodicity of Policy

Number of Respondents

Percentages

5 years 22 7.35-15 years 125 41.715-25 years 116 38.7Above 25 years

37 12.3

Total 300 100

Periodicity of Policy

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

5 years 5-15 years 15-25 years Above 25years

Number of Respondents

Page 44: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 44

Awareness level of Respondents :

As a contractual relationship exists between the insurer and the insured, it is the duty of the insurance

company to disclose of the policy details. The policy holders are not excused with any ignorance to the

contract and it is the policyholders to get acquainted with the rules and regulations of the policy. So the

study about awareness level of customers assumes paramount significance.

Table 14 -

Chart 14 -

Awareness Level

103

48

66

83

0 50 100 150 200

Yes

No

LIC

Private Company

Interpretation – From the graph it is clear that 68.2% of respondents of LIC are aware of all details of

their policy where as only 44.3% of private company policyholders know about all

their policy terms and conditions.

Hence it is gratifying to note that LIC is more transparent and divulge concrete details about policy and

empower its policy holders in a much better way.

Yes No Number of Respondents

LIC 103 48 151Private Company

66 83 149

Total 169 131 300

Page 45: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 45

Testing hypothesis I :

Chi-Square Tests

Value df

Asymp. Sig. (2-

sided)

Exact Sig. (2-

sided)

Exact Sig. (1-

sided)

Pearson Chi-Square 17.439a 1 .000

Continuity Correctionb 16.480 1 .000

Likelihood Ratio 17.619 1 .000

Fisher's Exact Test .000 .000

Linear-by-Linear Association 17.381 1 .000

N of Valid Casesb 300

a. 0 cells (.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected count is 65.06.

b. Computed only for a 2x2 table

Here since the Chi-square value is 0.000 which is less than 0.05 so there exists a relation between the

awareness level and type of company one chooses for investing his money. Hence the null hypothesis is

proved.

Satisfaction Level about service qualities :

Like any other service sector, the insurance sector is also evaluated by its ability to provide quality

services to its customers. In the modern market, the products are designed exclusively for the customers

and the quality is the leading criterion for the selection of particular product. Hence, the insurance

providers should realize the changes in the market and adopt new weapons in the form of high quality

services.

Table 15 -

LIC Private Company

Total

Fully Satisfied 85 50 135Partially Satisfied

43 57 100

Not Satisfied 23 42 65Total 151 149 300

Page 46: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 46

Chart 15 -

Private Company

34%

38%

28%

Fully Satisf ied

Partially Satisf ied

Not Satisf ied

LIC

57%28%

15%

Fully Satisf ied

Partially Satisf ied

Not Satisf ied

Interpretation – From the above tables it shows that 57% customers are fully satisfied with LIC’s

service quality and comparatively only 34% are satisfied by private companies. Also

38% in private and 28% in LIC are only partially satisfied and remaining are not

satisfied.

It is evident that customers, in general, are satisfied with the quality of services provided by LIC and there

is significant difference in the service quality across both sectors.

Testing hypothesis II :

Chi-Square Tests

Value df

Asymp. Sig. (2-

sided)

Pearson Chi-Square 16.575a 2 .000

Likelihood Ratio 16.767 2 .000

Linear-by-Linear Association 15.552 1 .000

N of Valid Cases 300

Here also the Chi-square value is 0.000 which is less than 0.05 so the null hypothesis that relation exists

between the level of satisfaction and type of the company one chooses for buying a policy is proved.

Page 47: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 47

Problems faced by the Customers :

The problems faced by policyholders are many and varied. It is the duty of any insurance company to

make an amicable settlement of these problems. Some important problems faced by policyholders

analyzed are complex formalities for opening a policy, levy hidden charges, excessive penalties for non

payment of premium, undue delay in settlement of claims, lack of timely communication, lack of co-

operation by officials/agents, inefficient grievance redressal mechanism, misleading information by the

agents and lack of technical knowledge or training. A few of them have been taken into account here.

Table 16 – Accessibility of the employee/agents

Chart 16 –

LIC

68%

32%

Yes

No

Private Company

79%

21%

Yes

No

Interpretation – LIC clearly lags behind from private companies as only 68% customers against 79%

of private company customers say that employees of the company are always

accessible.

Yes No TotalLIC 102 49 151Private Company

117 32 149

Total 219 81 300

Page 48: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 48

Table 17 – Complex formalities

Chart 17 –

LIC

61%

39%

Yes

No

Private Company

53%47% Yes

No

Interpretation – In LIC 61% customers feel that the formalities for opening a policy are too complex

and the documentation is time taking but only 53% feel this in case of private sector.

Hence in all there is more or less the same response about the complex formalities in

both the sectors.

Yes No TotalLIC 92 59 151Private Company

79 70 149

Total 171 129 300

Page 49: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 49

Table 18 – Grievance redressal mechanism

Chart 18 –

LIC

42%

28%

30%

Fully Satisf ied

Partially Satisf ied

Not Satisf ied

Private Company

26%

41%

33%

Fully Sat isf ied

Part ially Sat isf ied

Not Sat isfied

Interpretation – From the above figure it is clear that 42% and 26% customers are fully satisfied with

the grievance redress mechanism of LIC and Private company respectively. But also

an alarmingly high % of customers of LIC and Private company i.e. 30% and 33%

respectively are not satisfied with their process.

Testing hypothesis III :

Chi-Square Tests

Value df

Asymp. Sig. (2-

sided)

Pearson Chi-Square 9.234a 2 .010

Likelihood Ratio 9.307 2 .010

Linear-by-Linear Association 3.679 1 .055

N of Valid Cases 300

a. 0 cells (.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected count

is 47.18.

Here the null hypothesis is proved since Chi-square value 0.01 is less than 0.05 and so there exists a

relation between the grievance redress mechanism and type of company.

LIC Private Company

Total

Fully Satisfied 63 39 102Partially Satisfied

42 61 103

Not Satisfied 46 49 95Total 151 149 300

Page 50: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 50

Table 19 – Claim Settlement Process

Chart 19 –

LIC

83%

17%

Yes

No

Private Company

70%

30%

Yes

No

Interpretation – It is a matter of concern for LIC that around 83% say that it makes undue delay in

claim settlement where as for private companies this % is 70%.

Testing hypothesis IV :Chi-Square Tests

Value df

Asymp. Sig. (2-

sided)

Exact Sig. (2-

sided)

Exact Sig. (1-

sided)

Pearson Chi-Square 6.355a 1 .012

Continuity Correctionb 5.685 1 .017

Likelihood Ratio 6.409 1 .011

Fisher's Exact Test .014 .008

Linear-by-Linear Association 6.333 1 .012

N of Valid Casesb 300

a. 0 cells (.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected count is 34.77.

b. Computed only for a 2x2 table

Since the Chi-square value is 0.012 which is less than 0.05 so null hypothesis is proved and there exists a

relation between claim settlement process and the type of the company. Therefore null hypothesis is

proved.

Yes No TotalLIC 125 26 151Private Company

105 44 149

Total 230 70 300

Page 51: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 51

Table 20 – Information by the agent

Chart 20 –

LIC

69%

31%

Yes

No

Private Company

83%

17%

Yes

No

Interpretation – According to the figure we can infer that where 83% customers of private company

the agent provides them with correct information only 69% say this in case of LIC.

Yes No TotalLIC 104 47 151Private Company

124 25 149

Total 228 72 300

Page 52: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 52

Rationale behind the investment

Table 21 -

Table 21 shows that the most important drive for taking an insurance policy by a customer is the

individual risk coverage irrespective of the sectors. The rationale behind taking an insurance policy is

almost same in both the sectors. The most proximate reasons are risk coverage, tax benefits, children’s

welfare and growth and return of investment. Advertising of the company, classes or seminars conducted

by various organizations and influence of the peer group do not play a major role in the investment

decision of the customer.

Factors LIC Private Company

Individual Risk Coverage 1 1

Tax Benefits 3 4

Growth and return on investment 4 2

Risk Coverage of Family 2 3

Child Welfare 5 5

Page 53: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 53

CHAPTER - V

5.1 Findings and Recommendations :

Every study is completed only if it has certain outcomes in the form of findings and certain

recommendations for the correction of faulty areas that have been found during the course of the study.

Findings from the data :

Following are the important findings of the study :

1) Refering table 7 and chart 7 it is clear that the majority i.e. more than half of investor’s investing in

insurance are the young people in the age group of 20-40.

2) Refering table 8 and chart 8 it can be said that males dominate in having life insurance policies.

3) Referring table 9 and chart 9 it can be said that majority of people having life insurance are

employed.

4) The most preferred plan among the investor’s is unit linked plans because of its high returns.(refer

table 12 and chart 12)

5) Almost 80% of the policies sold have the periodicity of 5-25 years.(refer table 13 and chart 13)

6) It is very much clear that the awareness level of the customers of LIC is much higher than that of

the private sector.(refer table 14 and chart 14)

7) A greater number of customers of LIC are either fully or partially satisfied but there is not much

significant difference across sectors in terms of service quality satisfaction level.(refer table 15 and

chart 15)

8) Employees or agents of LIC are not easily accessible when compared to private sector and

customers have to try several times in order to meet LIC employees etc.(refer table 16 and chart

16)

9) Most of the respondents of LIC feel that formalities for opening a policy are too complex and take

longer time.(refer table 17 and chart 17)

Page 54: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 54

10) Two fifth of the customers of LIC are fully satisfied with its grievance redress mechanism while

only one fourth are fully satisfied in case of private sector.(refer table 18)

11) It is a threat for LIC that more than four fifth of the customers of LIC feel that it unduly delays in

claim settlement.(refer table 19 and chart 19)

12) Also a lesser number of customers of LIC feel that their agent provides them with the correct and

relevant information in comparison to customers of private company.(refer table 20 and chart 20)

13) From table 21 it is evident that individual risk coverage is the most preferred criteria among the

investors irrespective of both the sectors. Hence the rationale behind investment is more or less

same.

Recommendations :

To increase the level of insurance penetration LIC may focus on bringing products that suit to the

rural customers.( refer table 1 and chart 1)

The company if possible should invest in advertising, conduct road shows, and spend money on

hoardings, so that it can better propogate awareness about its various lesser known products.

LIC should also tie up with several other banks apart from the existing ones to sell its products i.e.

through bancassurance ( refer chart 4)

The company has the option of tying up with local NGO’s for selling its rural insurance products.

Customer friendly documentation i.e. it should be made easier and faster( refer finding 9).

LIC should keep a check that its agents equally promote all its products( refer finding 14).

LIC may provide additional funds to its development officers and agents( refer finding 14).

All the hidden charges should clearly be stated in the form and explained by the agent and LIC

should provide better training to its agents. (refer finding 12).

Claim settlement process should be made fast and must not involve lengthy decision making

process( refer finding 11).

Some special focus should be laid on individual risk coverage while designing the products.(refer

table 21).

Page 55: a comparative study on customer perception towards LIC of India in view of increased competition by private companies a research done in 2009

SIVA SIVANI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT 55

Learning

This project has given me a good opportunity to learn a lot about the insurance sector in general and LIC

in particular and especially about the basic technicalities involved right from selling to servicing and lastly

the claim settlement process. I also had a chance to see how closing takes place in insurance companies.

While dealing with retail customers I had a really enriching experience. I learnt how to judge a customer

and offer him/her a product which would interest him. Also working in a real office environment provided

me an enriching experience.

Conclusion :

The entry of private sector insurance companies into the Indian insurance sector triggered off a series of

changes in the industry. Even with the stiff competition in the market place, it is evident from the study

that the public sector giant LIC dominates the Indian insurance industry. In today’s competitive world,

customer satisfaction has become an important aspect to retain the customers, not only to grow but also to

serve. Increased competition, wide range of product offerings and multiple distribution channels cause

companies to value satisfied and highly profitable customers. Customer service is the critical success

factor in a company and providing top notch customer service differentiates great customer service from

indifferent customer service.