9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((!...

128
!"# %&'()*%'+(,-. %/ 0(12 3' 4(52+/ 6 789 -'. :+;,-. <= >7 6 ?@7>@ %/ =A/(5. #/(51*B.5() C.AD @@ E8F > GH IJ 88 8> KKKD.5)*A&'()*A'+(.-.DL- !"#$%&' )' #*+,'& -."/%*0%," /%1"#*2 .&$#$,%$1 345673458 -$9,'1*1/' )' :9%1 3458 ;'+ ,'#.+ )9 #"0$)&*#' !*1$1 <%',&=*> ?' #"#$%&' '+, *//$#.*@1" )' 0* .*&,%' .&*,%A9' %1,%,90"' B !"#$%&'() B(-.01-(0. 3. +2+&(-. M N(')O =()/5& 0& * B(-.01.'- 3. +2+&(-. M P(0Q.A P/-R =-2)(3.51. 3' S'-O 0(52+/ .1 0&&-3(5/1-(0. 3.) +2+&(-.) M N(')O =()/5&

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jun-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

!"#$%&'()*%'+(,-.

%/$0(12$3'$4(52+/$6$789$-'.$:+;,-.$<=$>7$6$?@7>@$%/$=A/(5.$#/(51*B.5()

C.AD$@@$E8F$>$GH$IJ$88$8>

KKKD.5)*A&'()*A'+(.-.DL-

$

!"#$%&'()'(#*+,'&

-."/%*0%,"(/%1"#*2(.&$#$,%$1(345673458

-$9,'1*1/'()'(:9%1(3458

;'+(,'#.+()9(#"0$)&*#'

!*1$1(<%',&=*>

?'(#"#$%&'('+,(*//$#.*@1"()'(0*(.*&,%'(.&*,%A9'(%1,%,90"'(B(!"#$%&'()

B(-.01-(0.$3.$+2+&(-.$M$N(')O$=()/5&

0&$*$B(-.01.'-$3.$+2+&(-.$M$P(0Q.A$P/-R

=-2)(3.51.$3'$S'-O$0(52+/$.1$0&&-3(5/1-(0.$3.)$+2+&(-.)$M$N(')O$=()/5&$

Page 2: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$

C'#'&/%'#'1,+

T$N(')O$=()/5&$;&'-$+U/V&(-$L/(1$0&5L(/50.$.1$+U/V&(-$/00&+;/W52.$3/5)$A.$+2+&(-.

T$P(0Q.A$P/-R$;&'-$).)$;-20(.'R$0&5).(A)$)025/-()1(X'.)

T$Y&Z.-1$:)0Q.-$;&'-$+U/V&(-$&'V.-1$A.)$;&-1.)$3.$A/$Z(ZA(&1Q,X'.$S')X'UT$3.)$Q.'-.)$32-/()&55/ZA.)

Page 3: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

C"+9#"(

%.$+2A&3-/+.$/$;&'-$/+Z(1(&5$3.$0&51.-$A/$V(.9$A.$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$)'-$A.)$/552.)$.1$A.)$

W252-/1(&5)D$=&'-)'(V/51$).)$;.-)&55/W.)$/'*3.AT$3'$+&1$L(59$).$;/))(&55/51$;&'-$3.)$A'11.)$T$A/$L&()$

(+;&))(ZA.)$.1$21.-5.AA.)9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$&'V-.$'5.$V&(.$'5(X'.$;&'-$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3U'5$0(52+/$

5/--/1(L$.1$2+&1(&55.AD$%.)$).5)/1(&5)$X'.$0-22$A.$+2A&3-/+.$-.5V&(.51$A.$);.01/1.'-$T$)/$;-&;-.$

-.A/1(&5$T$AU.R()1.50.$.1$T$A/$+&-19$;-&3'()/51$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$(51.AA.01'.AA.$.1$).5)(ZA.$)'-$A.$1.+;)$X'($

;/)).D

Y/0&51.-$A.$1.+;)9$0U.)1$3U/Z&-3$A.$+/5(;'A.-9$A.$1-/5)L&-+.-9$;&'-$AU/+.5.-$T$;-&3'(-.$3.)$

2+&1(&5) $ .1 $ 3.) $ Q()1&(-.)D $ 4&51-/0129 $ 320&';29 $ ;/))2 $ ;/- $ A. $ ;-()+. $ 3. $ A/ $ +(). $ .5 $ )0,5.$

0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.9$(A$2;&').$A.)$L&-+.)$0&+;A.R.)$3'$32)(-$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$#/$)1-'01'-.9$T$A/$L&()$

/-0Q21O;/A.$.1$1&'S&'-)$-.5&'V.A2.9$0&5)1-'(1$'5$1.+;)$&[$A.$+&53.$.1$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$0&'-.51$T$A.'-$

;.-1.$.1$&[$1&'1$).$-2;,1.$;/-/3&R/A.+.51$T$AU(5L(5(D$%.$0/3-.9$&'1(A$;-.+(.-$3.$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3'$

1.+;)$X'($;/)).9$-2V,A.$A/$A.\&5$X'.$A.$+2A&3-/+.$5&')$3&55.$)'-$A/$V(.D

;%+,'()'+(#$,+(/0"+

P2A&3-/+.9$1.+;)9$.AA(;).9$32)(-9 $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9 $+,-),-9 $.-'(&)/'(&0'!,12$%1&09$320&';/W.9$

0/3-.9$0&+;&)(1(&5

Page 4: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$

DE+,&*/,

CQ.$/+Z(1(&5$&L$+.A&3-/+/$()$1&$1.AA$A(L.9$1&$1.AA$1Q.$0&'-).$&L$1(+.$/)$O./-)$/53$W.5.-/1(&5)$W&$ZOD $

]&AA&K(5W$1Q.$0Q/-/01.-)$/L1.-$1Q.$K&-3)$^$1Q.$.53$_9$&Z).)).3$K(1Q$)1-'WWA.)$/)$(+;&))(ZA.)$/)$

.1.-5/A9$1Q.$+.A&3-/+/$&;.5)$/$K/O$1&$Z'(A3$/$0(5.+/$1Q/1$()$Z&1Q$5/--/1(V.$/53$.+&1(&5/A$(5$/$V.-O$

'5(X'. $K/OD $CQ.$ L..A(5W) $+.A&3-/+/$/K/`.) $/+&5W $ 1Q. $);.01/1&-) $ (5V(1. $ 1Q.+$ 1& $)1/-1 $/ $V.-O$

;.-)&5/A$-.LA.R(&5$/Z&'1$A(L.$/53$3./1Q9$/53$1&$-./01$Z&1Q$(51.AA.01'/AAO$/53$.+&1(&5/AAO$1&$1Q.$K/O$

1(+.$W&.)$ZOD

C.AA(5W$1(+.$+./5)$+/5(;'A/1(5W$(19$1-/5)L&-+(5W$(1$1&$1'-5$(1$(51&$L..A(5W)$/53$)1&-(.)D$C(+.$

(5$+.A&3-/+/$()$0&51-/01.39$0'1$(51&$;(.0.)9$;/)).3$1Q-&'WQ$1Q.$Q'+/5$+(53$1&$-.;-&3'0.$1Q.$+&V.$

&L$3.)(-.D$a1)$)1-'01'-.$()$Z&1Q$/-0Q.1O;/A$/53$/AK/O)$-.5.K.39$1&$Z'(A3$/$V()(&5$&L$1(+.$(5$KQ(0Q$1Q.$

K&-A3$/53$1Q.$0Q/-/01.-)$/-.$Q./3.3$1&K/-3)$1Q.(-$&K5$3.+().9$KQ(A.$)(1'/1(&5)$;/-/3&R(0/AAO$-.;./1$

1Q.+).AV.)$.1.-5/AAOD$CQ.$)0.5.)U$0&+;&)(1(&5$/53$1Q.$+&V.)$&L$1Q.$L-/+.$/-.$1Q.$+/(5$K/O)$1&$

-.;-.).51$1(+.9$/53$1Q.O$-.V./A$1Q.$+.A&3-/+/U)$A.))&5$/Z&'1$A(L.D

;%+,'()'+(#$,+7/0"+

P.A&3-/+/9$1(+.9$.AA(;)()9$3.)(-.9$a+(1/1(&5$&L$A(L.9$=/53&-/U)$Z&R9$P&'1/(5)$+/O$3.;/-19$)1-'01'-.9$

)Q&&1(5W9$L-/+.9$0&+;&)(1(&5

Page 5: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$$F*E0'()'+(#*,%G&'+((

!

Y.+.-0(.+.51)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD 7Y2)'+2$DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD @:Z)1-/01DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDHa51-&3'01(&5DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD I%/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD G4&53.5).-$A/$V(.$DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD?$$%/$V(.$0&512.$T$1-/V.-)$'5.$A'11.$'5(X'.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD>8$$#O+Z&A().-$.1$)(+;A(L(.-DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD >b$$#.$0&50.51-.-$)'-$A.)$1.+;)$L&-1)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD78

$!AA(;).9$32)(-$.1$L-')1-/1(&5DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD 7H$$C-/V/(AA.-$AU(5)20'-(12$3'$);.01/1.'-DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD7H$$C-/V/(AA.-$A.$32)(-$3'$);.01/1.'-DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD 7J$$B&55.-$A/$).5)/1(&5$3'$0&)+(X'.9$A/$0&5)0(.50.$3.$A/$+&-1DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD @7

%/$).5)/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD @I$$%.$L-/0/)$3'$+&53.9$A/$0&'-).$L&AA.$3'$1.+;)$DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD@J$$%/$3&'0.'-$3.)$S&'-)$X'($;/)).51DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD H8$$%.$1.+;)$X'($&;;-.)).DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDH@

#1-'01'-.$3'$+&51/W.$.1$-20'--.50.)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD HJ%.)$1-&()$1.+;)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD HG$$%.$;/-/3()$X'.$AU&5$;.-3-/DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD HG$$%/$320Q2/50.$)&')$1&'1.)$).)$L&-+.)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD b>%/$L(59$0&5)1/1$3.$A/$V/0'(12$3.$A/$V(.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD bJ

c'/53$A/$)1-'01'-.$2;&').$A.$32)(-DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD I>$$d5.$)1-'01'-.$0&+;A.R.$M$A.$32)(-$0Q/5W./51DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDI>$$%.)$;/))(&5)$/'RX'.AA.)$&5$5U20Q/;;.$;/)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD IH$$%U&Z).))(&5$/'*3.AT$3U'5.$V(.$M$AUQ2-23(12$3'$3-/+.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD IG

#1-'01'-.$.1$(32&A&W(.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD J@$$%&'A&'9$'5.$)2X'.50.$321-'(1$AU/'1-.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD J@$$P(-/W.$3.$A/$V(.9$A/$)1-'01'-.$.5$/(+/51DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD JI$$:'*3.AT$3.)$+&51/W5.)9$A/$;.-1.$.1$A/$1-/0.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD G8

%.$0/3-.$.1$A.$320&';/W.$;&'-$0&51.-$A.$1.+;)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDGH$$%/$L(5$3.)$1.+;)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD Gb$%.$0/0Q2$.1$A.$V()(ZA.$M$A.$LA&11.+.51$3.$AU(5320()(&5DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD ?7$$%/$L/)0(5/1(&5$;&'-$A.$+/ADDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD?H

%/$0&'A.'-$.1$A.)$+&'V.+.51)$3.$0/+2-/$3/5)$P(-/W.$3.$A/$V(.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD?G$#(+;A.$.1$5/1'-.A$0&++.$A/$V(.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD?G$%.$1.+;)$L/01(0.$3'$1Q2e1-.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD >8>$%/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3U'5$+&53.$T$3.'R$V(1.)).)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD >8H

]&-+/1)9$0/3-.$.1$1.R1'-.$3/5)$:'*3.AT$3.)$+&51/W5.)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD >8G%/$L&-+.$3.$AU(+/W.$;&'-$0&51.-$A.$1.+;)$X'($;/)).DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD >8G$$%.$1.+;)$V20'$.1$)/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3/5)$A.$0/3-.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD>>@$$%U(51-')(&5$3'$3&0'+.51/(-.9$1.+;)$-2.A)$.1$1.+;)$L(01(L)DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD>>J

$4&50A')(&5DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD>7@$<(ZA(&W-/;Q(.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD >7H$](A+&W-/;Q(.$;-(50(;/A.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD>7b](A+&W-/;Q(.$/33(1(&55.AA.DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD>7J

Page 6: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

H1,&$)9/,%$1

:V.0$AU/--(V2.$3.)$)2-(.)9$A.)$);.01/1.'-)$&51$E-.F320&'V.-1$A/$0/;/0(12$3'$+23(/$/'3(&V()'.A$T$

;&'V&(- $ -/0&51.- $'5$;.-)&55/W. $T$ AU20Q.AA. $3U'5. $V(.D $#/5) $ A(+(1. $3.$ 1.+;)9 $ A/ $)2-(. $;.-+.1$3.$

-/0&51.-$A.)$/552.)$X'($;/)).519$3.$V&(-$V(.(AA(-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$E!$)3,)4$&'$5#"&1(0$X'($3'-,-.51$

)'-$>8$/5)9$/V.0$A.)$+f+.)$/01.'-)F$.1$3.$32V.A&;;.-$3.)$-.A/1(&5)$)'-$3.)$/552.)D$%U2+&1(&5$3'$

);.01/1.'-$.)1$320';A2$;/-$A.$;/))2$.5$0&++'5$X'U(A$/$/V.0$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.)$)&'V.5(-)$*$X'( $

)&51 $ ;-.)X'. $ 3.V.5') $ A.) $ )(.5) $ * $ /'RX'.A) $ A/ $ )2-(. $ A. $ -/;;.AA.D $g2-(1/ZA. $ L/01.'- $ 5/--/1(L $ .1$

2+&1(&55.A9$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$.1$A/$L/+(A(/-(12$.51-.1.5'.$/V.0$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$L&51$0&'A.-$A.)$

A/-+.)9 $ .1 $ ).--.51 $ A.) $ 0&.'-) $3. $ ).) $ );.01/1.'-)D $4. $ L/()/51 $ .1 $ )/5) $ A. $ )/V&(-9 $ A/ $ )2-(. $;&'-)'(1$

AU&Z).))(&5 $ 3U'5 $ W.5-. $ Z(.5 $ ;A') $ V(.'R $ X'U.AA. $+/() $ X'( $ / $ 1&'1 $ T $ V&(- $ 3/5) $ ).) $ /+Z(1(&5)$M $ A.$

+2A&3-/+.D$4.$W.5-.$A&5W1.+;)$320-(2$;/-$A.)$0-(1(X'.)$;'()$-.320&'V.-1$;&'-$)/$L&-0.$5/--/1(V.9$).$

;/))(&55. $;&'- $ -/0&51.- $ 3.) $3.)1(5) $ )'- $ 3.) $W252-/1(&5)9 $ 3.) $ /552.) $3. $ 1'-;(1'3.)9 $ 3.) $V(.) $ T$

/11.53-.$AUf1-.$/(+2D$N.5-.$3.$AUQO;.-Z&A.$;/-$32L(5(1(&59$(A$5UO$/$;/)$3UQ()1&(-.)$1-&;$0&+;A(X'2.)$T$

-/0&51.-$;&'-$A.$+2A&3-/+.$h$(A$;.'1$1&'1$(512W-.-9$1&'1$-/0&51.-9$+/AW-2$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)9$.1$A.)$

0Q/5W.+.51)$3.$A(.'9$(A$;&'-)'(1$A/$;/))(&5$&[$.AA.$V/9$3/5)$0.$X'U.AA.$/$3U.R1-f+.$.1$3U(5L/1(W/ZA.D$

<(.5$)i-9$(A$5U.)1$;/)$A.$).'A$T$L/(-.$;/)).-$A.)$/552.)$h$(A$5UO$/$;/)$)($A&5W1.+;)9$3.)$L(A+)$

0&++.$6,("$3$&''78&#&'9"))':&':),,(;'X'($)&51$3/V/51/W.$3'$0j12$3'$1Q-(AA.-$.1$3'$3-/+.$Q()1&-(X'.9$

).$32-&'A.51$)'-$'5$1.+;)$A&5W$.1$L&51$V(.(AA(-$A.'-)$;.-)&55/W.)D$P/()$).'A$A.$+2A&3-/+.$/$0&512$A.$

;/))/W. $ 3' $ 1.+;) $ )'- $ 3.) $ /552.) $ /V.0 $ '5. $ 1.AA. $ L-2X'.50.D $B.;'() $ AU2;&X'. $ 3' $+'.1 $ S')X'UT $

/'S&'-3UQ'(9 $A.$+2A&3-/+.$/$0&512$A.)$;/))(&5)$/'*3.AT$3'$1.+;)9$/'*3.AT$3.)$W252-/1(&5)D$P/()$

;&'-X'&($A.$+2A&3-/+.$)U(512-.)).*1*(A$L&53/+.51/A.+.51$/'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$k

%.$1.+;)$;/))2$;/- $ A. $);.01/1.'- $/V.0$ A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9 $ A. $+2A&3-/+.$)/(1 $Z(.5$X'U(A $.)1 $

;-(+&-3(/A$;&'-$0-2.-$AU2+&1(&5D$@Q9$HQ$DDD9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$;-&3'(1$3.)$l'V-.)$.R1-f+.+.51$A&5W'.)D$

aA$;A&5W.$A.$);.01/1.'-$3/5)$'5$'5(V.-)$&[$(A$A.$)'Z+.-W.$3.$-.Z&53()).+.51)$.1$3.$Z&'A.V.-).+.51)$

;&'-$A.$L/(-.$;/)).-$;/-$1&'1.)$A.)$2+&1(&5)D$P/()9$.1$0U.)1$;A')$)'-;-.5/519$A.$+2A&3-/+.$'1(A().$

2W/A.+.51 $ A. $ 1.+;) $X'. $ A. $ ;.-)&55/W. $V(1 $ T $ AU20-/5 $;&'- $ 0-2.- $ AU2+&1(&5D $Y/0&51.- $ A/ $ V(. $3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$)'-$3.)$/552.)$-/+,5.$A.$);.01/1.'-$T$)&5$;-&;-.$;/))29$A'($L/(1$).$)&'V.5(-$3.$+&+.51)$

V20')$X'U(A$+.1$.5$;/-/AA,A.$/V.0$A.$3.)1(5$V'$T$AU20-/5D$%/$L&-0.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$)&5$(50-&O/ZA.$

L/+(A(/-(12$.1$0.AA.*0($)U&Z1(.51$.51-.$/'1-.)$.5$0&5)1-'()/51$'5$1.+;)$X'($).$-/;;-&0Q.$3.$0.A'($V20'$

;/- $ A. $ );.01/1.'-D $ %. $ 1.+;) $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ 0&5)1(1'. $ 2W/A.+.51 $ '5. $ .R;2-(.50. $ .R1-f+.+.51$

Page 7: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

L(01(&55.AA.$.1$/-1(L(0(.AA.$h$(A$5U.)1$;/)$3U.R;2-(.50.$0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.$X'($)&(1$.R/01.+.51$)(+(A/(-.$

T$A/$V(.9$+/()$A.$-/;;&-1$X'.$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0&5)1-'(1$/'$1.+;)$3&55.$'5.$;.-);.01(V.$'5(X'.$/'$

0(52+/$M$'5$-.W/-3$)'-$A/$0&53(1(&5$Q'+/(5.9$'5$V.-1(W.$L/0.$T$Am(--2V.-)(Z(A(12$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$.1$

A/$0&5)0(.50.$3.$A/$+&-1$X'($)U/;;-&0Q.D$

%UQ()1&(-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$0&5)1(1'.$.5$)&($'5.$V2-(1/ZA.$-2LA.R(&5$.1$'5.$A.\&5$3.$V(.$)'-$A.$

1.+;)$X'($;/)).$.1$)'-$5&1-.$L(5(1'3.D$c'.AA.$A.\&5$A.$+2A&3-/+.$5&')$3&55.*1*(A$)'-$A.$1.+;)$k$

4&++.51$5&')$A.$3&55.*1*(A$T$;.5).-$.1$T$).51(-$k$4&++.51$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$;/)).*1*(A$3U'5$&'1(A$

5/--/1(L$T$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$+21/;QO)(X'.$k

Y/0&51.-$A.$1.+;)9$0U.)1$3U/Z&-3$A.$+/5(;'A.-9$A.$1-/5)L&-+.-9$;&'-$AU/+.5.-$T$;-&3'(-.$3.)$

2+&1(&5) $ .1 $ 3.) $ Q()1&(-.)D $ 4&51-/0129 $ 320&';29 $ ;/))2 $ ;/- $ A. $ ;-()+. $ 3. $ A/ $ +(). $ .5 $ )0,5.$

0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.9$(A$2;&').$A.)$L&-+.)$0&+;A.R.)$3'$32)(-$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D

%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.9$T$A/$L&()$/-0Q21O;/A.$.1$1&'S&'-)$-.5&'V.A2.9$;.-+.1$3.$0&5)1-'(-. $

'5$1.+;)$&[$A.$+&53.$.1$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$0&'-.51$T$A.'-$;.-1.$.1$&[$1&'1$).$-2;,1.$T$AU(5L(5(D

%. $ 0/3-.9 $ ;-.+(.- $ &'1(A $ 3. $ A/ $ 0&5)1-'01(&5 $ 3' $ 1.+;) $X'( $ ;/)).9 $ -2V,A. $ A/ $ A.\&5 $ X'. $ A. $

+2A&3-/+.$5&')$3&55.$)'-$A/$V(.$.1$)'-$A/$0&53(1(&5$Q'+/(5.D

$

Page 8: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

<CI!HICI(<DCFHI(

$

$

;*(&'.&"+'1,*,%$1()9(,'#.+()*1+(0'(#"0$)&*#'2(

+$1(9,%0%+*,%$1(1*&&*,%J'(',("#$,%$11'00'

$

Page 9: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

?K*.%,&'(5(

?$1)'1+'&(0*(J%'(

(?$##'1,(0'(#"0$)&*#'(/$1,'7,7%0(91'(J%'('1(91(L%0#(M

$

%. $+2A&3-/+. $.)1 $ '5 $W.5-. $X'( $+'A1(;A(. $ A.) $ (51-(W'.)9 $ A.) $ ;2-(;21(.)9 $ A.) $ 2;&X'.)9 $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D$4U.)1$A.$W.5-.$3.$AU.R0,)9$3.$AUQO;.-Z&A.D$%.)$/552.)$O$;/)).519$A.)$-.Z&53()).+.51)$

)U.50Q/n5.51D$=&'-1/519$.1$+/AW-2$0.11.$(AA')(&5$3U'5.$-.;-2).51/1(&5$;A21Q&-(X'.$3.$A/$V(.9$A/$L&-0.$3'$

+2A&3-/+.$.)1$3.$A'($3&55.-$'5.$0&Q2-.50.$(+;A/0/ZA.D$o/+/()$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.$+2A&3-/+.$5U/$'5.$

(+;-.))(&5$3.$0Q/&)$&'$3.$3())&A'1(&5D$#U(A$).$3.+/53.$;/-L&()$&[$(A$V/9$0U.)1$;/-0.$X'.$A.$W.5-.$/$A.$

W&i1$3.)$321&'-)9$3.)$)'-;-().)9$3.$A/$1.+;&-()/1(&5D$P/()$A/$)1-'01'-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$)'(1$'5.$A(W5.$

0A/(-.$M$0.AA.$3.$A/$A'11.$3U'5$;.-)&55/W.$;&'-$-.0&55/n1-.$.1$-2/A().-$)&5$32)(-D$#1.;Q.5$"./A.$320-(1$

A.$32V.A&;;.+.51$3'$+2A&3-/+.$0&++.$^$1Q.$;-&0.))$&L$3.)(-.$/53$&L$1Q.$V/-(&')$ZA&0`/W.)$1&$(1)$

L'AL(AA+.51$K(1Q(5$/5$/;;/-.51AO$p0&++&5$).5).p.)1/ZA()Q.3$)&0(/A$&-3.-$_>D$EA.$;-&0.))')$3'$32)(-$

.1$3.$).)$&Z)1/0A.)$S')X'UT$)/$-2)&A'1(&5$3/5)$'5$&-3-.$)&0(/A$/;;/-.++.51$pZ(.5$;.5)2pFD$=&'-$A'(9 $

A.$+2A&3-/+.$-/0&51.$A.$3.)1(5$3U'5$;.-)&55/W.$X'($0&5L-&51.$)&5$32)(- $T$'5$+&53.$X'($5.$)UO$

/00&-3.$;/)$.1$X'($3.V(.51$;&'-$A'($'5.$&Z).))(&59$'5$+&1.'-$/'R$/01(&5)$X'U(A$.51-.;-.53D$#($0.11.$

32L(5(1(&5$3'$+2A&3-/+.$).+ZA.$)U/00&-3.-$1-,)$;-20()2+.51$/'R$.5S.'R$.1$T$A/$)1-'01'-.$3-/+/1(X'.$

3'$0(52+/$3.$AUeW.$3U&-$Q&AAOK&&3(.59$L&-0.$.)1$3.$0&5)1/1.-$X'U.AA.$)U/;;A(X'.$2W/A.+.51$1&'1$/'$

A&5W$3.$AUQ()1&(-.$3'$0(52+/$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.D$Y&Z.-1$%/5W79$.5$)&'A(W5.$A/$;.-)()1/50.9$.1$(3.51(L(.$

.5$+f+.$1.+;)$AU2V&A'1(&5$3.$0.11.$A'11.9$X'($/$A(.'$0&51-.$3.)$.55.+()$3(LL2-.51)D$aA$3()1(5W'.$1-&() $

;Q/).)$3/5)$AUQ()1&(-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$X'($0/-/012-().51$0.11.$A'11.D$%.)$32Z'1)$3'$W.5-.$/V.0$N-(LL(1Q$

+.11.51$.5$)0,5.$A/$A'11.$0&51-.$A.$3.)1(5$.1$AU(5S')1(0.$)&0(/A.D$%.)$/552.)$b8$3.$g(3&-$)&51$0.AA.)$

3U'5.$A'11.$0&51-.$A.)$0&53(1(&5)$)&0(/A.)$X'($321.-+(5.51$A.$3.)1(5$3'$;.-)&55/W.9$.1$.5L(59$3/5)$A.$

+2A&3-/+.$;A')$0&51.+;&-/(59$X'U(A$/))&0(.$T$P(5.AA(9$+/()$X'.$AU&5$;&'--/(1$21.53-.$T$'5.$2;&X'.$

;A')$-20.51.9 $-/0&51.51$'5.$A'11.$;)O0Q&A&W(X'.9 $3.$AU/LL(-+/1(&5$3.$AU(53(V(3'$3/5)$)&5$0&51.R1.$

>$P(0Q/.A)9$%A&O39$<1%4$#'=&#%4$1>0'?&#0,1$;$4/+Z-(3W.9$4/+Z-(3W.$d5(V.-)(1O$=-.))9$7888D$;DG?$

7%/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD$;D>b*>I

Page 10: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

L/+(A(/AD $ %.) $+2A&3-/+.) $ 3U:A+&3&V/-9 $ 3U:-5/'3 $B.;A.)0Q(59 $ 3U:5W $ %.. $ &' $ .50&-. $ 3. $C&33$

r/O5.)9$;&'-$5.$0(1.-$X'U.'R9$+.$).+ZA.51$-2;&53-.$2W/A.+.51$T$0.11.$3.-5(,-.$32L(5(1(&5D

( *#+,')+-&$./)+0+."#,)"(+1$)+21..)+1$'31)

C&'1$.5$0Q/5W./51 $3.$;.-);.01(V.9 $.5$)U/3/;1/51 $/'R$2;&X'.)$.1 $T$).)$;-2&00';/1(&5)9 $ A.$

+2A&3-/+.$0&51.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$AUQ()1&(-.$3.$0.11.$A'11.D$#.)$;.-)&55/W.)$1-/V.-).51$A/$V(.9$.5$

)'Z()).51 $ 1&') $ A.)$3-/+.)9 $ 1&'1.) $ A.)$;2-(;21(.)9 $+/() $W/-3.51 $'5$&ZS.01(L $X'( $5. $0.)).-/ $3.$ A.)$

&Z)23.-$A.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+9$X'U(A$)&(1$&'$5&5$-2/A()/ZA.D$%/$5/())/50.$&'$A/$;-().$.5$0&+;1.$3.$0.$32)(- $

32Z'1.$A.$L(A+9$0&'-1$)'-$A.)$/552.)$X'.$3'-.$A.$1.+;)$3.$A/$5/--/1(&5$.1$5.$).$-2)&'1$3U'5.$+/5(,-.$

&'$3U'5.$/'1-.$X'U/V.0$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+D$4U.)1$3&50$AUQ()1&(-.$3U'5.$A'11.$QO;.-Z&A(X'.9$0&+;'A)(V.9$

+/A/3(V.9$3/5)$A.X'.A$A.$L(A+$1-&'V.$)/$0&Q2-.50.D$:V.0$.AA.9$A.$1.+;)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$).$L/(1$1.53'9 $

0&+;-.))29$1&'-52$/'1&'-$3U'5$&ZS.01(L$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$;/-1/W.$/V.0$A.$;.-)&55/W.D$%/$;-.+(,-.$

32L(5(1(&5$3'$1.+;)$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$X'.$AU&5$;&'--/(1$3&50$/V/50.-$.)1$0.AA.$3U'5$1.+;)$.51(,-.+.51$

(5V.)1($3/5)$'5.$A'11.D

B.$X'&($V/$0.11.$A'11.$k$%.)$&Z).))(&5)$3'$;.-)&55/W.$)&51$;-/1(X'.+.51$1&'S&'-)$A.)$+f+.)9$

0/-$.AA.)$)&51$3(-.01.+.51$A(2.)$T$3.)$A'11.)$'5(V.-).AA.)9$;-&L&53.)9$(51(+.)D$:'$;&(51$X'.$AU&5$;.'1$

L/(-.$'5.$A()1.$;-.)X'.$.RQ/')1(V.$3.)$&Z).))(&5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$M$A/$;&'-)'(1.$3U'5$

/+&'-$(+;&))(ZA.9$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3U'5.$-.0&55/())/50.$L/+(A(/A.9$&'$1&'1$)(+;A.+.51$28&'?-#0-"2',C '

8$??"1&009$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3'$Z&5Q.'-9$A.$;A')$)&'V.51$3/5)$A/$1.51/1(V.$3.$1-&'V.-$'5$2X'(A(Z-.$3/5)$

'5.$)1-'01'-.$L/+(A(/A.$32ST$21/ZA(.D$%.)$+2A&3-/+.)$&51$Z./'$).$;&'-)'(V-.$)'-$'5.$V(.$&'$)'-$3.)$

W252-/1(&5)9$(A)$W/-3.51$0Q.s$A.'-)$;.-)&55/W.)$0.)$32)(-)$&Z)23/51)9$)&'V.51$V/(5)9$0&++.$'5.$

A(W5.$-&'W.$X'($0&'-1$1&'1$A.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+D$4Q/X'.$)2X'.50.$).-/$-.A(2.9$3U'5.$+/5(,-.$&'$3U'5.$

/'1-.9$T$0.$L(A$h$0.A'($3U'5.$A'11.$;&'-$).)$32)(-)D

%/$;&'-)'(1.$3.$AU/+&'-$(+;&))(ZA.

+>,?"1",1'?-:)"E-&9$+>8&-#&'F-?#G4&;'.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&129$H@I&:&)9$+>$*&12-#&'(&'!4&'!-"#9$

+&'0&3#&2'4$%1"C"E-&9 $D&#2"%,9 $J$1(,#$9 $+&0')$#4&0'$4K#&0'(&'J&2#$'*,1'L$129 $!4&'MN-9'O,3&0'

=)$138&09'+>.4,-#'/'4,#29'+,"1'(-'?$#$("09$)&51$3.)$L(A+)$X'($-/0&51.51$A/$;&'-)'(1.$3U'5$/+&'-$

;/))(&55.A9 $X'($).$;&'-)'(1 $)'-$ A.)$/552.)D $o2s.Z.A$/W(-/ $ 1&'1 $ A. $ 1.+;)$3'$L(A+$3/5)$ AU.);&(- $3.$

-20';2-.- $ )&5 $ /50(.5 $ L(/502 $ =-.)9 $ #0&11(. $ ;&'- $ -.1-&'V.-9 $+f+. $ /;-,) $ )&5 $ /;;/-.51. $+&-19 $ A/$

P/3.A.(5.$3&51$(A$)U21/(1$2;-()$h$4Q(0&$.1$B(/5.9$).$+/-(.-&51$.1$;.5).-&51$AU'5$T$AU/'1-.$1&'1.)$A.)$

Page 11: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

/552.)$&[$(A$).-&51$)2;/-2)$;/-$A/$W'.--.$h$P/1Q(A3.$C.))(.-$A&'.-/$'5$/;;/-1.+.51$3U&[$.AA.$;&'--/$

&Z).-V.- $ .5 $ ).0-.1 $ A. $;-&L.)).'- $3&51 $ .AA. $ .)1 $ /+&'-.'). $.1 $V(V-. $ )/ $;/))(&5 $ ).0-,1.+.51D $%.)$

.R.+;A.)$5.$+/5X'.51$;/)9$(A$)U/W(1$3.$A/$1Q2+/1(X'.$X'($V(.51$T$AU.);-(1$A.$;A')$-/;(3.+.51$A&-)X'.$

AU&5$;/-A.$3.$+2A&3-/+.$M$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0&++.$'5$L(A+$3U/+&'-9$&[$AU&5$/(+.$/V.0$.R0,)D$

4Q/0'5$3.$0.)$L(A+)$5.$0&++.50.-/$.1$5.$).$1.-+(5.-/$X'U/V.0$0.1$/+&'-$;/))(&55.A9$X'($

).-/$Z/L&'29$;.-3'9$-.1-&'V29$(+;&))(ZA.9$+/()$X'($-.)1.-/$'5.$&Z).))(&5$S')X'UT$A/$L(5D $.-2$12'&1'

&4?,#2&')&'*&12 ';/-/n1$)/5)$3&'1.$;A')$X'.$1&')$A.)$/'1-.)9$;&'-$)/$3'-2.$.1$;&'-$)/$V&0/1(&5$3.$

L-.)X'.$Q()1&-(X'.9$V&'A&(-$1&'1$-/0&51.-9$1&'1$+&51-.-9$).$-/+(L(.-D$=&'-1/51$A.$L(A+$0&++.50.-/$

/V.0$A/$320&'V.-1.$;/-$#0/-A.11$3'$L'1'-$+/-(/W.$3U:)QA.O$X'($-.53$)&5$/+&'-$;&'-$A'($(+;&))(ZA.$h $

.1$).$1.-+(5.-/$;/-$)/$;-().$3.$0&5)0(.50.$X'U(A$5.$)U/W())/(1$;/)$AT$3.$AU/+&'-$/'X'.A$.AA.$/);(-/(1D$#( $

AU&5$;.-3 $;/-L&() $3. $V'.$ A. $;.-)&55/W.$3U:)QA.O9 $ (A $5. $0.)).-/ $ S/+/() $3. $W'(3.- $ A.) $/01(&5) $3.$

#0/-A.119 $ 3. $ A'( $ L/(-. $ ;-.53-. $3.) $320()(&5)9 $ 3. $ A/ $ 0&53/+5.- $ T $ AU(5)/1()L/01(&59 $ .1 $ 3. $ A'( $ L/(-.$

;&'-)'(V-.$)/$A'11.D$

$

%/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3.$A/$-.0&55/())/50.

%/$;&'-)'(1.$3.$A/$-.0&55/())/50.$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.)1$'5$1Q,+.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$X'($A'($

V(.51$3'$1Q2e1-.D$%U'5$3.)$-.Z&53()).+.51)$A.)$;A')$0&'-/51)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$1Q2e1-/A$0&5)()1.$T$+.11-. $

.5$)0,5.$'5.$&-;Q.A(5.$X'($320&'V-(-/$'5.$+(-/0'A.').$L(A(/1(&5$X'($A/$)/'V.-/$&'$A'($;.-+.11-/$'5$

+/-(/W.$Q.'-.'RD$#($AU&5$;.'1$0-&(-.$X'.$0.$1O;.$3.$-.Z&53()).+.51$.)1$T$-.A2W'.-$/'$;/))29$(A$)'LL(1 $

3.$-.W/-3.-$3'$0j12$3U<13&1("&9$&'$7@2#,9$;&'-$V&(-$X'U(A$5U.5$.)1$-(.5D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$T$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$

3U'5.$L(W'-.$3.$;,-.$O$320&'V-(-&51$'5.$L(A(/1(&59$0.11.$L&()$+&5)1-'.').9$+/()$1&'S&'-)$3/5)$'5$

-.1&'-5.+.51 $ );.01/0'A/(-.D $ B. $ 5&+Z-.'R $ +2A&3-/+.) $ +'.1) $ .50&-. $ 1-,) $ (5LA'.502) $ ;/- $ A.$

+2A&3-/+. $ 1Q2e1-/A $ 1-/(1.51 $ 3. $ A/ $ -.0&55/())/50. $3.) $ .5L/51) $ /Z/53&552.) $E78& ' P"(; ' +&0 '(&-Q '

,#?8&)"1&0RF $%.$1Q,+.$).-/$-.;-()$;A')$1/-3$3.$+/5(,-.$;A')$;.))(+()1.$M $H&-Q'"12&#("20;'+>&1C$13& '

1-&R$ %U'5.$3.)$-/+(L(0/1(&5)$;&))(ZA.)$3.$0.11.$1Q2+/1(X'.$).-/$A/$-.0&55/())/50.$)O+Z&A(X'.$3'$

;,-.$;/-$A.)$/3&A.)0.51)$.1$A.)$S.'5.)$/3'A1.)$3.)$+2A&3-/+.)$3.)$/552.)$b8*I8D$S')>&02'(>T(&1;'+$ '

C-#&-#'(&'*"*#&;'+$'C"K*#&'($10')&'0$1%9'U3#"2'0-#'(-'*&12;'+$'38$22&'0-#'-1'2,"2':#V)$12D$t$5&'V./'9$

A.$L(A+$5.$0&++.50.$.1$5.$).$L(5(1$X'U/V.0$0.11.$&Z).))(&5$3'$;.-)&55/W.9$X'($3&55.$)&5$).5)$.1$)/$

0&Q2-.50.$/'$L(A+D$

4.11.$-.0Q.-0Q.$3.$-.0&55/())/50.9$0U.)1$.5L(5$A.$;-&0.))')$3U/00.;1/1(&5$3.$)&($3/5)$3.)$

+2A&3-/+.)$&[$A/$0-().$3'$;.-)&55/W.$.)1$3/V/51/W.$(512-(.'-.D$%/$S.'5.$L(AA.$3''!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&'

X'($)&'LL-.$3Uf1-.$52.$ZA/50Q.$3U'5.$+,-.$5&(-.$5.$).-/$0/;/ZA.$3U/00.;1.-$).)$&-(W(5.)$X'UT$A/$+&-1 $

Page 12: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

3.$)/$+,-.9$T$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+D$#1.AA/$B/AA/)9$&-(W(5/(-.$3U'5$+(A(.'$;/'V-.$.1$(W5&-/51$).-/$'5$L/-3./'$

3/5)$A/$V(.$3.$)/$L(AA.$X'(9$23'X'2.$.1$/11(-2.$;/-$A.)$+(A(.'R$)&;Q()1(X'2)9$)&'LL-(-/$3.$A/$0&53(1(&5$

)&0(/A.$3.$)/$+,-.D$aA$L/'3-/$T$#1.AA/$B/AA/)$).$)/0-(L(.-$;&'-$3();/-/n1-.$3.$A/$V(.$3.$)/$L(AA.$.1$;&'-$

X'.$).$-2)&AV.$0.11. $0-().$3.$ A/ $ -.0&55/())/50.$T$ A/ $ L(5$3'$L(A+D $7$),10'."%-"))&0$ 3U:A+&3&V/-9$

-.;-.53$2W/A.+.51$0.11.$1Q2+/1(X'.$T$1-/V.-)$A.$;.-)&55/W.$S&'2$;/-$g(01&-(/$:Z-(A9$X'($5.$;&'--/$

)U/00.;1.-$.AA.*+f+.$X'U/;-,)$A/$+&-1$3.$)/$+,-.D

aA$).-/(1$/'))($;&))(ZA.$3UO$/S&'1.-$A/$1Q2+/1(X'.$3.$A/$-.0&55/())/50.$3/5)$A.$+&53.$T$1-/V.-)$

AU/)0.5)(&5 $;/- $ A. $ 1-/V/(AD $%.) $+2A&3-/+.) $)&51 $ -.+;A() $3. $3.)1(5) $3U/01-(0.) $V.5'.) $3. $ -(.5 $.1 $

3.V.5'.)$02A,Z-.)$E+&':,18&-#;'!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&;'W1&'@2,")&'&02'1@&;'+$'3,42&00&'$-Q'?"&(0'1-0$uF$

P/()$0.11.$/)0.5)(&5$.)1$Z(.5$)&'V.51$).0&53/(-.$.1$)'Z&-3&552.$T$'5.$-.0Q.-0Q.$(3.51(1/(-.$;A')$

;-&L&53.D$aA$)U/W(1$)&'V.51$3U'5.$.--.'-$0&++().$;/-$A.$;.-)&55/W.9$X'($0-&(1$;&'V&(-$-.+;A(-$'5$

V(3.$;/-$A/$WA&(-.$.1$).$-.53$0&+;1.9$1-&;$1/-39$3'$Z&5Q.'-$V2-(1/ZA.$/'X'.A$(A$/);(-/(1D$B/5) ' +&'

:,18&-#9 $4A/-/ $ #1'/-1 $ 5U.)1 $ /;;/-.++.51 $ ;/) $ )( $ 2;/5&'(. $ 3/5) $ )&5 $ -jA. $ 3. $ )1/- $ h $ .AA. $ 3&55.$

3/V/51/W.$AU(+;-.))(&5$3Uf1-.$'5.$;&'A.$/'R$l'L)$3U&-$;&'-$)&5$(+;-.)/-(&$X'($A/$+/5(;'A.$.1$A/$

;&')).$T$L/(-.$1&'S&'-)$;A')$3.$L(A+)D$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$.1$W1&'@2,")&'&02'1@&$;-2).51.51$2W/A.+.51$A/$

02A2Z-(12$0&++.$'5$&Z)1/0A.$/'$Z&5Q.'-$M$.AA.$2A&(W5.-/$A.)$3.'R$/01-(0.)$3.$A.'-)$;-&0Q.)$E%&-/$

P.-.3(1Q$3.$)/$L(AA.9$.1$g(0`($%.)1.-$3.$)&5$+/-(FD

%/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3'$Z&5Q.'-

d5. $ /'1-. $ A'11. $ 3' $+2A&3-/+.9 $ 0U.)1 $ 0.AA. $ ;&'- $ A. $ Z&5Q.'-9 $ A/ $ -.0Q.-0Q. $3U'5 $ 2X'(A(Z-.$

2+&1(&55.A$.1$)&'V.51$).51(+.51/AD$!AA.$).-/$+&(5)$2;(X'.9$+&(5)$3();.-)2.9$)&'V.51$3/5)$A.$0/3-.$

3. $ A/ $ L/+(AA. $&' $3' $0&';A.D $ aA $ )U/W(1 $3U'5. $X'f1. $;A') $ (512-(.'-.9 $X'. $ AU&5 $ -.1-&'V. $3. $+/5(,-.$

L-2X'.51.$3.;'()$A.)$/552.)$b8$.1$S')X'.$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0&51.+;&-/(5D'%.)$2A2+.51)$0&51-.$

A.)X'.A)$A'11.51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$3(V.-)$h$A.)$/33(01(&5)$EX&##"K#&')&'4"#,"#9'W1&'@2,")&'&02'1@&Y; '

A.) $52V-&).) $ EW1&' C&44&'0,-0 ' "1C)-&13&; '!,44NF9' A/ $ )&0(212 $X'( $ A.) $.51&'-.' Z7,-0 ' )&0 '$-2#&0 '

0>$??&))&12 '.)"Y;$ AU.55'( $ E+&0 ' 1,3&0 ' #&:&))&0YR '4U.)1 $ '5. $ 2V&A'1(&5 $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ 1&'-52. $ V.-)$

AU(512-(.'-$3'$L&O.-D$

4.)$&Z).))(&5)$).$0-&().51$.1$)U/))&0(.519$0/-/012-().51$'5$;.-)&55/W.$&'$;A')(.'-)$3'$L(A+9$

+/()$5.$0.)).-&51$;/)$3U.5$f1-.$A.$L(A $0&53'01.'-9$S')X'UT$)/$-2)&A'1(&59$;&)(1(V.$&'$1-/W(X'.D $%/$

;-.+(,-.$L&501(&5$3.$ AU.AA(;). $3/5)$ A. $+2A&3-/+.9$0U.)1 $3&50$3U2A(+(5.- $0. $X'( $5.$V(.53-/(1 $;/)$

5&'--(-$&'$L-')1-.-$0.11.$X'f1.$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$v5$2A(+(5.-/$1&'1$0.$X'($5.$V(.53-/$;/)$L/(-.$A'11.D$4.$

X'($5U/;;/-1(.51$;/)$T$A/$;&'-)'(1.$3.$0.$32)(-$&'$T$)/$L-')1-/1(&5$5U/'-/$;/)$A(.'$3U/;;/-/n1-.D$B/5)$

Page 13: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+&0')-4"K#&0'(&')$'*"))&9$4Q/-A&1$.)1$Z-'1/A.+.51$.5V&O2$.5$;-()&59$)/5)$/V&(-$A.$1.+;)$3.$;-2V.5(-$A/$

S.'5.$/V.'WA.$3&51$(A$.)1$/+&'-.'RD$:A&-)$X'.$0.$1.+;)$;/))2$.5$;-()&5$.)1$'5.$2;-.'V.$;&'-$A. $

;.-)&55/W.9$3&51$&5$;&'--/(1$1(-.-$3.)$+&+.51)$L&-1)9$(A$).$1-&'V.$1&1/A.+.51$^$.AA(;)2$_D$4Q/-A&1$.)1$

/--f12$.1$)&-19$A.$;A/5$3U/;-,)9$T$AU/(-$A(Z-.D$%/$-/()&5$3.$0.$0Q&(R$.)1$0A/(-.$h$'5.$)2X'.50.$.5$;-()&5$

5U/'-/(1$;.-+()$5($/V/502.$5($-.Z&53()).+.51$3/5)$0.$X'($L/(1$A'11.$3/5)$0.$L(A+$M$AU/+&'-$3.$4Q/-A&1$

;&'-$A/$S.'5.$/V.'WA.D$t$AU(5V.-).9$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$5&')$(+;&-1.9$0/-$(A$;.-+.1$5/--/1(V.+.51$T$

AU/V.'WA.$3.$).$32Z/--/)).-$3.$)/$020(129$.19$2+&1(&55.AA.+.519$3.$+&51-.-$/'$);.01/1.'-$X'.$4Q/-A&1$

).-/$-.)12$L(3,A.$T$)&5$/+&'-$;&'-$A/$;.1(1.$/V.'WA.D$B/5) $.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&129$%.)$3.'R$

;-.+(.-)$+/-(/W.)$3.$#0/-A.119$5U/'-&51$/'0'5.$(+;&-1/50.$T$).)$O.'R$5($3/5)$)/$X'f1.$3.$AU/+&'-$

3U:)QA.O$h$(A)$1&+Z.-&51$3.$+f+.$3/5)$A/$Z2/50.$3.$AU.AA(;).D$aA$5.$-.)1.-/$3'$;-.+(.-$+/-(/W.$X'U'5$

;A/5$M$A.$+&+.51$&[$:)QA.O$AU.+Z-/)).$;&'-$A/$L2A(0(1.-D$B'$).0&539$(A$5.$-.)1.-/$-(.5D$4/-$).'A.$

(+;&-1.$A/$X'f1.$3U/+&'-$3.$#0/-A.11$;&'-$:)QA.OD

o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$3/5)$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@;'/LL(-+.$.5$;/-A/51$3'$+2A&3-/+.$

X'.$^$AU.AA(;).9$.5$2A(+(5/51$AU(51.-V/AA.$.1$AU/00.))&(-.9$.)19$3/5)$0.11.$.51-.;-().9$AU&'1(A$X'($0&5)1-'(1 $

A/$0&Q2-.50.$.1$A.$).5)$3U'5$1.+;)$1-/W(X'.+.51$(--2V.-)(ZA.$_@D$%/$0&Q2-.50.9$0U.)1$0.AA.$3.$0.)$

.R()1.50.)$.5$A'11.9$1&'-52.)$V.-)$'5$&ZS.01(L$0.-1/(5$)/5)$A.X'.A$&5$/'-/(1$Z(.5$3'$+/A$T$-2)'+.-$'5.$

V(.D$%.$0(52+/$3&(1$0&53.5).-$A/$V(.$;&'-$A/$-.53-.$-/0&51/ZA.9$.1$A.$+2A&3-/+.$A'($3&55.$0.11.$

0&Q2-.50.D $ %. $ 1.+;) $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ .)1 $ 3&50 $ 3U/Z&-3 $ '5 $ 1.+;) $ 0&Q2-.519 $ 1.53' $ V.-) $ '5 $ Z'19$

0&50.51-2$3/5)$AU/01(&5D

P/()$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$V/$;A')$A&(5$.5$;/-A/51$3U'5$^$1.+;)$1-/W(X'.+.51$(--2V.-)(ZA.$_D$

4/-$0.11.$0&Q2-.50.$V/$3.$;/(-$/V.0$'5.$L&-+.$3.$0&53/+5/1(&5$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$C&'1$3U/Z&-39$;/-$

0.11.$A'11.$T$A/X'.AA.$(A)$).$1-&'V.51$.50Q/n52)9$.1$3&51$(A)$5.$;&'--&51$S/+/()$).$32L/(-.$M$A.)$Q()1&(-.)$

3U/+&'-$)&55.51$0&++.$3.)$+/A23(01(&5)9$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3.$A/$-.0&55/())/50.$0&++.$'5.$52V-&).9$A/$

;&'-)'(1.$3'$Z&5Q.'-9$'5.$+/A/3(.D$%.$);.01/1.'-$)/(1$.5$V&O/51$0.11.$A'11.$0&++.50.-$X'U.AA.$5.$

)U/0Q,V.-/$X'UT$A/$L(59$T$A/$+&-1$3'$L(A+D$4.11.$0&50.51-/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$V/$3.$;/(-$/V.0$A/$).5)/1(&5$

X'U(A $5UO$/'-/$3.$1.+;)$X'.$;&'-$'5.$).'A.$Z/1/(AA.D $!5)'(1.9 $A.$+2A&3-/+.$).$;A/n1$T$)U/))'+.- $

0&++.$L(01(&5$.5$/))'+/51$X'.$1&'1 $.)1 $32ST$20-(1 $3U/V/50.D$%.$1.+;)$3'$0(52+/$.)1$'5$1.+;)$

1-&+;.'-$;'()X'.$A.$;-2).51$5U.)1$X'U'5$L/'R$;-2).51$M$(A$5.$321.-+(5.$.5$-(.5$0.$X'($V(.53-/$3/5)$A/ $

)'(1.$3'$L(A+$;'()X'.$A.$L'1'-$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.)1$32ST$(+;-(+2$)'-$A/$;.AA(0'A.$.1$5.$;&'--/$;/)$f1-.$

0Q/5W2D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$S&'.$/V.0$0.11.$0/-/012-()1(X'.$3'$0(52+/$.5$+'A1(;A(/51$A.)$.LL.1)$3U/55&50.9 $

.1 $.5$;-2V.5/51$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.$0.$X'($/11.53$A.)$+/AQ.'-.'R$;.-)&55/W.)D$%&-)X'.$P+.$P'(-$

Z+>$*&12-#&'(&'!4&'!-"#Y;$-.50&51-.$'5$;-21.53/51$X'(9$A'(9$5U.)1$;/)$'5$L/51j+.9$.1$/V.0$A.X'.A$.AA.$

@$"/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;DJ8*J>

Page 14: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

/$3&50$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3.$0&5)1-'(-.$'5$L'1'-9$)&5$.51&'-/W.$A/$+.1$.5$W/-3.$M$)/$).-V/51.$P/-1/9$.1$A. $

L/51j+.$3'$0/;(1/(5.$1(-.51 $ A/ $)&55.11.$3U/A/-+.$ h $ (A $O$/ $X'.AX'.$0Q&).$X'( $5.$V/$;/) $/V.0$0.1 $

Q&++.D$:(5)($X'/53$P+.$P'(-$(-/$A'($-.53-.$'5.$V()(1.$)'-;-().$T$%&53-.)9$'5$S&'-$X'U(A$;-21.53$

f1-.$+/A/3.9$A.$);.01/1.'-$)/(1$32ST$X'.$1&'1$L(5(-/$+/AD$#.'A$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$P+.$P'(-$5.$).+ZA.$

;/)$).$3&'1.-$3.$0.$X'($V/$A'($/--(V.-9$/V/5\/51$W/(.+.51$S')X'UT$A/$+/()&5$&[$.AA.$320&'V-(-/$A/$

L.++.$3.$)&5$;-21.53/519 $/V.0$ A/X'.AA. $ (A $/ $2W/A.+.51$3.) $.5L/51)D $#1.AA/ $B/AA/)9 $3/5) $ A. $ L(A+$

2;&5O+.9 $)23'(1 $'5$Q&++.$X'( $5U.)1 $;/)$3.$)/$0A/)).$)&0(/A. $.1 $L-/50Q(1 $/(5)( $'5.$Z/--(,-.$X'($

)(W5.-/$A.$32Z'1$3.$).)$;-&ZA,+.)$h$A.$);.01/1.'-$)/(1$.5$A/$V&O/51$S&'.-$A.)$(5W25'.)$;&'-$0&5X'2-(-$

A. $ S.'5.$Q&++.$X'U(A $5.$;&'--/$5/n1-. $ -(.5$3.$Z&5$3.$0.11. $'5(&59$.1 $X'U'5$+/-(/W. $52$)'- $3'$

+.5)&5W.$.)1$'5$+/-(/W.$0&53/+52D$

%.$1.+;)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$/$3&50$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$T$V&(-$/V.0$0.A'($3.$A/$1-/W23(.D$Y&Z.-1$%/5W$

32L(5(1$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0&++.$'5.$320A(5/()&5$3'$1-/W(X'.$&[$A.)$L&-0.)$X'($)U.R.-0.51$)'-$A.)$f1-.)$

/'-/(.51$0.))2$3Uf1-.$3.$AU&-3-.$3'$)/0-2$M$

$^$4m.)1$Am.LL&53-.+.51$3.$5&1-.$).51(+.51$3'$#/0-29$(A$O$/$X'.AX'.$3.'R$0.51)$/5)9$

X'($/$3&552$Am(+;'A)(&5$A/$;A')$320()(V.$/'$;/))/W.$3m'5$1-/W(X'.$3.$A/$V(.$T$'5$

+&3.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.D$EuF$;/-L&()$T$Am.50&51-.$3'$Z'1$-.0Q.-0Q29$A.$+2A&3-/+.$

).$A(V-.$T$0.11.$.51-.;-().$M$(A$-.0&55/n19$.5$1&'1$0/)9$X'.$A/$+(),-.$Q'+/(5.$5m.)1$

;/)$(52V(1/ZA.9$.1$)m(A$5.$)/(1$;/)$1&'S&'-)$0&++.51$)mO$;-.53-.$;&'-$O$-.+23(.-9$(A$

)m.LL&-0. $ T $ 1&'1 $ A. $+&(5) $3. $ A&0/A().- $ .1 $ 3. $ 32L(5(- $ A.) $ -.);&5)/ZA.) $ 3. $ 0.11.$

+(),-.HD$_$

B/5) $ '5 $ 0&51.R1. $ X'( $ 5. $+.1 $ ;A') $ .5 $ S.' $ A. $ 3(V(59 $+/() $ 3.) $ 3(LL(0'A12) $ )&0(/A.)9 $ ;&A(1(X'.)9$

;)O0Q&A&W(X'.)9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$W/-3.$A/$0&Q2-.50.9$.1$A/$L/1/A(12$3'$1.+;)$1-/W(X'.D$Pf+.$3/5)$A.$

+2A&3-/+.$0&51.+;&-/(59 $3&51 $&5 $;&'--/(1 $/11.53-. $3/V/51/W. $3. $ -.0'A9 $ 0.11. $ 0&50.51-/1(&5 $3'$

1.+;)$.1$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5$^$32ST*20-(1$_$;.-3'-.D $%.$+2A&3-/+.$32;A&(.$'5$1.+;)$X'($5U.)1$;/)$

0&50.51-2$.5$'5.$2;&X'.$&'$.5$'5$.);/0.9$+/()$.5$'5$+&'V.+.519$0.AA.$3U'5.$A'11.$/0Q/-52.$.1$

32).);2-2.$;'()X'.$A/$-2)&A'1(&5$.5$.)1$32ST$20-(1.D

H$%/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD$;D7G*7?

Page 15: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

( 4567&2'()"+).+('682'9')"

4.11.$.51-.;-().$3.$0&50.51-/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$.5$'5.$Q()1&(-.$V/$3.$;/(-$/V.0$A/$520.))(12$3.$

)(+;A(L(.-$;&'-$;&'V&(-$-/0&51.-D$4&++.51$;.'1*&5$-/0&51.-$'5.$V(.$.5$'5$L(A+$k$4&++.51$-.53-.$

A()(ZA.) $ 3.) $ .AA(;).) $ 3. $ ;A')(.'-) $ /552.)$k $ %. $+2A&3-/+. $ .)1 $ )&'V.51 $ /))&0(2 $ /' $ 0A(0Q29 $ /'R$

A&'-3.'-)9$T$'5.$+&-/A.$+/5(0Q2.55.D$%.$^$+2A&$_$2V&X'.$3/5)$)/$V.-)(&5$A/$;A')$0/-(0/1'-/A.$A.)$

)&/;*&;2-/)$A.)$+&(5)$2A/Z&-2)9$&[$A.)$Z&5)$.1$A.)$+20Q/51)$)U/LL-&51.51$3/5)$A.)$;2-(;21(.)$A.)$;A')$

)/'W-.5'.)D$P/()$)($AU.)1Q21(X'.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$'1(A().$.5$.LL.1$3.)$)12-2&1O;.)9$0U.)1$;&'-$;/-V.5(-$

T $ -/0&51.- $ V(1.$h $ 0-2.- $ 3.) $ )O+Z&A.)9 $ 0&5)1-'(-. $ 3.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ X'( $ )&51 $ (++23(/1.+.51$

(3.51(L(/ZA.) $ .1 $ X'( $ ;.-+.11-&51 $ /' $ 320&';/W. $ .1 $ T $ A/ $ )1-'01'-. $ 3' $ +2A&3-/+. $ 3. $ -.)1.-$

0&+;-2Q.5)(ZA.)$+/AW-2$A.)$.AA(;).)$A.)$;A')$-/3(0/A.)9$A.)$1-/5)L&-+/1(&5)$3.$AUQ()1&(-.9$A.)$/552.)$

;/))2.)$.5$'5$0A(5$3U&.(AD$!1$0.$)&51$3U/Z&-3$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$X'($;.-+.11.51$0.11.$0A/-12$3.$AU(51-(W'.D$

%.$;.-)&55/W.$)O+Z&A(X'.

P'-(.A$:53-(59$32V.A&;;/51$AU/5/AO).$3.$</A'`Q/1O($)'-$A.$1Q2e1-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.9$320-(1$'5$

^$;-(+(1(V()+.$;)O0Q&A&W(X'.$3.) $;.-)&55/W.)9 $ A.'- $ L&501(&5$)(+;A.$.1 $;/-L/(1.+.51 $0A/(-.9 $ A.'-$

3()0&'-)$X'($5U.R;-(+.$X'U'5.$).'A.$(32.$)&'A(W52.$;/-$'5.$2+&1(&5$V(V.9$A.'-)$W.)1.)$325'2)$3.$

5'/50.)9$1&')$0.)$2A2+.51)$;.-+.11/51$'5$-.53'$1-,)$/(W'()2$X'($.51-/n5.$'5.$0&AA.01(&5$3U(5)1/51)$

()&A2)9$+/()$L-/;;/51)9$3U/01(&5$3-/+/1(X'._bD$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)U(3.51(L(/(.51$/A&-)$T$3.)$)12-2&1O;.)9$

T$3.)$+&3,A.)$T$AU(5)1/-$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$A/$3,44&("$'(&))>$#2&R%/$S.'5.$L(AA.$;'-.$.1$(55&0.51.9$

)&5$S.'5.$/+/51$5&ZA.$.1$0&'-/W.'R9$A.$1-/n1-.$;-f1$T$1&'1.)$A.)$V(A.5(.)9$A.$+/n1-.$0-'.A$0&+;1.51$

;/-+($A.)$L(W'-.)$(52V(1/ZA.)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$1Q2e1-/AD$#(9$/'$0(52+/9$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$

).$)&51$0&+;A.R(L(2)$/'$0&'-)$3'$1.+;)9$0.'R$3'$+2A&3-/+.$+'.1$5.$)&519$.'R9$;/)$A&(5$3.$0.'R$X'.$

;-&;&)/(1$A.$1Q2e1-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.D$

#/5) $ .5 $ -.;-.53-. $ A.) $ +&3,A.) $ 3. $ ;.-)&55/W.)9 $ (A $ .5 $ 0&5).-V. $ AU/);.01 $ /-0Q21O;/A9$

)O+Z&A(X'.9$-23'(1$T$'5.$L&501(&5D$%/$+().$.5$;A/0.$3.$AU(51-(W'.$0&++.50.$3U/(AA.'-)$1-,)$)&'V.51$

;/-$'5.$;-2).51/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$T$1-/V.-)$X'.AX'.)$;A/5)$X'($A.)$32L(5(1D$B/5)$A.$+N0':#"0@9$&5$

5&')$32;.(51$1&'-$T$1&'-$A.$;,-.9$Z&R.'-$0-'.A$X'($Z/1$)/$L(AA.$X'U(A$/$.'.$/V.0$'5.$;-&)1(1'2.9$A/$S.'5. $

L(AA.9$L-fA.$.1$;'-.9$L(3,A.$/'$)&'V.5(-$3.$)/$+,-.9$.1$AUQ&++.$S/'5.9$(++(W-2$0Q(5&()$;A.(5$3.$Z&55.) $

(51.51(&5) $X'. $ A/ $ -.50&51-. $ /V.0 $ A. $+&53. $&00(3.51/A $ / $ L/(1 $;A&5W.- $3/5) $ AU&;('+$.1 $3/5) $'5.$

b :53-(59$P'-(.A;'!$)@C"E-&0'A')&'4@),(#$4&'C")4"E-&'$4@#"3$"1'&2'0&0'8@#,\1&0Z]^_`a]^bcY; '<-'R.AA.)9'=.1.-$%/5W9$0&AA$-.;.5).-$A.$0(52+/9$788J$;D$7I

Page 16: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

A/5W'.'-$32).);2-2.D$B/5)'78&'P"(9$A/$;-2).51/1(&5$).$L/(1$2W/A.+.51$;.-)&55/W.$;/-$;.-)&55/W.D$%/$

+,-.9$32).);2-2.$;/-$)/$;/'V-.129$.)1$0&51-/(51.$T$/Z/53&55.-$)&5$.5L/51$T$'5.$-(0Q.$L/+(AA.$.1$).$

-.;.51 $ 1-&; $ 1/-3D $%. $;,-.9 $ &Z)232 $;/- $ )/ $ 0/--(,-. $ 3. $;.(51-.9 $ A/()). $ 1&+Z.- $;/- $ .--.'- $ 3/5) $ A/$

0Q.+(52.$A/$;Q&1&$3.$)&5$/50(.55.$0&+;/W5.$.1$A/$A/()).$L(5/A.+.51$Z-iA.-D$%.$0A&0Q/-39$+/A/3-&(1$

/'$Z&5$0&.'-9$1-&'V.$AU.5L/51$3/5)$A/$;&'Z.AA.$.1$AU/3&;1.D$B2ST$3/5)$A.$1Q2e1-.9$&5$;-&023/(1$;-.)X'.$

3.$A/$+f+.$L/\&5$;&'-$;-2).51.-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$B.)$)&A(A&X'.)$&[$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;-2).51.51$A.'-$

(3.51(12$+&-/A.$).-V/(.51$T$0&++.50.-$A/$;(,0.D$P'-(.A$:53-(5$20-(1$M

^$4&++.$A.$)&'A(W5/(1 $32ST$</A'`Q/1O(9$ A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.R;-(+.51$ A.'-$5/1'-.$

+&-/A.$)/5)$321&'-$/L(5$3U.5W.53-.-$3.)$)(1'/1(&5)$0Q/-W2.)$3U'5$W-/53$;&1.51(.A$

2+&1(&55.A$EuF$%.$L/(1 $X'.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$1.53.51$T$3(-.9$.R;A(0(1.+.519$A.'-$

S'W.+.51$+&-/A$)'-$A.$+&53.$.)1$EuF$'5$3.)$2A2+.51)$A.)$;A')$L-/;;/51)$.5$+f+.$

1.+;)$X'U'5.$Z/).$0&5)1(1'1(V.$3'$W.5-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.D$EuF$4.11.$A&W(X'.$3'$

3()0&'-) $ 1-/5);/-.51 $ ). $ 32+'A1(;A(. $ 3/5) $ A.) $ /01.) $ 3. $ #.AL*5&+(5/1(&5 $ X'($

;&501'.51 $ 1&'1. $ AU(51-(W'. $ +2A&3-/+/1(X'. $ EuF $ %.11-.)9 $ /01.) $ 3. $ 5/())/50.9$

12+&(W5/W.) $ V(.55.51 $ 3,) $ A&-) $ )&'1.5(- $ 0.) $ /LL(-+/1(&5)9 $ )(W5.) $ 0&50-.1) $ &'$

;-.'V.)$3.$AU(3.51(12$+&-/A.9$.5W.53-/51$(3.51(L(0/1(&5$.1$-.0&55/())/50.I$_D$

#($A.$0(52+/$+'.1$-23'(1$0.)$)&A(A&X'.)$T$3.)$0/-1&5)9$(A)$;.-3'-.51$1&'1$3U/Z&-3$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$

0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.D$%.$);.01/1.'-$;.'1$A(-.$T$AU/;;/-(1(&5$3.$A/$+,-.$3. $78&'L"( 'M$^$CQ.$K&+/5$

KQ&U)$)(5$K/)$+&1Q.-Q&&3$_$EA/$L.++.$3&51$A.$;20Q2$21/(1$3Uf1-.$+,-.DF'v'$.50&-.9$T$0.AA.$3'$;,-.$

3/5)$A.$+N0'=#"0@'M'^$</11A(5W$<'--&K)9$/5$/ZO)+/A$Z-'1.$6$/$W&-(AA/$&L$1Q.$S'5WA.)$&L$!/)1$%&53&5$6$

WA&/1(5W$&5$Q()$V(01&-O$&V.-$1Q.$^$%(+.Q&').$C(W.-$_$E</11A(5W$<'--&K)9$'5.$Z-'1.$/ZO))/A.$6$'5$

W&-(AA.$3.)$S'5WA.)$3.$AU.)1$3.$%&53-.)9$).$V.51/51$3.$)/$V(01&(-.$)'-$%.$1(W-.$3.$%(+.Q&').FD$%/$

;-2).51/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3/5)$A.$0(52+/$+'.1$;&-1.$.50&-.$'5.$3(+.5)(&5$+&-/A.$1-,)$L&-1.9$.1$

.50&-.$.R;-(+2.$)'-$A.$+&3.$3'$A/5W/W.D

:'*3.AT $ 3. $ 0.) $ .R.+;A.)9 $ A/ $ 32L(5(1(&5 $ 3.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ 3/5) $ A. $ +2A&3-/+.$

0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.$).$L/(1$2W/A.+.51$3.$+/5(,-.$V()'.AA.D$P'-(.A$:53-(5$32V.A&;;.$A/$;.5)2.$3.$

<-&&`)$M$

^$0.$5.$)&51$;A')$A.)$+&1)9$3.V.5')$)&'3/(5$;-.)X'.$(5/32X'/1)9$X'($V&51$.R;-(+.-$

A.$0&5LA(1$+&-/A9$+/()$Z(.5$A.)$/01.)$;QO)(X'.)9$A.$1/ZA./'9$A.)$)(W5.)$V()'.A)D$v5$

V&(1 $/(5)( $)U&-0Q.)1-.-$ 1&'1.$'5.$)2-(.$3.$)(W5.)$;&))23/51$'5.$0Q/-W.$T$ A/$L&()$

Q/'1.+.51 $ 2+&1(&55.AA. $ .1 $ 21Q(X'.9 $ T $ A/ $ )(W5(L(0/1(&5 $ )O+Z&A(X'.D $ EuF $ (A)$

I v;D$4(1D$;D$@H

Page 17: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;.-+.11.51 $ /' $ );.01/1.'- $ 3U/0023.- $ T $ '5. $ -.;-2).51/1(&5 $*"0":)&$ 3.) $ .51(12)$

+&-/A.)DJ_$

%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$(50/-5.51$3&50$3.)$)O+Z&A.)$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$;&'--/$(++23(/1.+.51$-.0&55/n1-.$

;/- $ A.'- $ /);.01 $;QO)(X'. $&' $W-e0. $T $ A/ $3.)0-(;1(&5 $X'm(A) $ L&51 $3U.'R*+f+.) $ A&-) $3. $ )&A(A&X'.)$

(51-&3'01(L)D $=A') $ (+;&-1/51 $ .50&-.9 $ A/ $ -.;-2).51/1(&5 $3U'5. $+&-/A. $ -/))'-/51. $ .1 $ )(+;A. $&[ $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$)U(5)0-(V.51$3'$0j12$3'$Z(.5$&'$3'$0j12$3'$+/AD$Y&Z.-1$%/5W$;/-A.$3.$A/$;-2).50.$3U'5.$

3'/A(12$+&-/A.$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.$M

$^$%U(+/W(5/1(&5$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$.)1$;-&L&532+.51$+&-/A.$h$A.$+2A&3-/+.$5.$+.1$

;/)$)(+;A.+.51$.5$)0,5.$'5.$A'11.$.51-.$A.$Z(.5$.1$A.$+/A$E/V.0$A.$1-(&+;Q.$3'$

;-.+(.-F9$(A$0Q.-0Q.$;A'1j1$T$5&')$+&51-.-$X'U(A$.R()1.$'5.$0A/(-.$3()1(501(&5$.51-.$

.'R9$X'.$3.)$(+;2-/1(L)$+&-/'R$)&51$Z.A$.1$Z(.5$.5$V(W'.'-$G$_D$

#($A/$X'f1.$3'$;.-)&55/W.$L/(1$0.51-.9$A.$+&53.$3/5)$A.X'.A$(A$2V&A'.$;-2).51.$2W/A.+.51$'5.$V/A.'-$

)O+Z&A(X'. $ 3'.AA.D $ <&55. $ &' $ +/'V/().9 $ A/ $ ;)O0Q&A&W(. $ 3.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ 3' $ +2A&3-/+. $ .)1$

0&5)1-'(1.$3/5)$'5$)&'0($3.$0A/-12D$

4.-1.)9$/V.0$A.$1.+;)9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$)U2A&(W5.$;.'$T$;.'$3U'5$+&3,A.$/'))($)0Q2+/1(X'.D$%/$

;)O0Q&A&W(. $ 3.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ ). $ 0&+;A.R(L(. $ .1 $ A/ $ L(W'-. $ 3. $ A/ $ S.'5. $ L(AA. $ L/(ZA. $ .1 $ ;'-. $ /$

Q.'-.').+.51$3();/-'$;.'$T$;.'$3.)$L(A+)$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.)D$=&'-1/519$L&-0.$.)1$3.$0&5)1/1.-$X'.$AU&5 $

.5$-.1-&'V.$.50&-.$Z(.5$)&'V.51$AU/-0Q21O;.D$Y20.++.51$3/5)$7&00$3.$=&A/5)`(;$&'$.50&-.$3/5)$78&'

"44"%#$12 '3.$o/+.)$N-/O9$A.$);.01/1.'-$-.1-&'V.$0.11.$L(W'-.$3.$A/$L.++.$(55&0.51.$.1$Z/L&'2.9$

V(01(+.$3'$+&53.$X'($AU.51&'-.$.1$3.$)/$0&53(1(&5$L2+(5(5.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$^$+20Q/51)$_$&51$

2W/A.+.51$2V&A'29 $+/()$;.-3'-.51D $B/5)$A. $+2A&3-/+.$3.)$;-.+(.-)$ 1.+;)9 $ (A)$)&51$)/3(X'.)$.1$

V(&A.51)$)/5)$.R;A(0/1(&5$;)O0Q&A&W(X'.9$;&'-$A/$)(+;A.$L&501(&5$3.$A.'-$;.-)&55/W.D$aA)$5.$)&51$;/)$

L&-02+.51 $3(LL2-.51) $ /'S&'-3UQ'( $+/() $ A.'- $ 0-'/'12 $ )U.R;A(X'. $;/- $'5 $;/))2 $ 1-/'+/1(X'. $&' $'5.$

52V-&).$;-&L&53.D$%/$L&A(.$3'$3&01.'-$3.$+$'?"&)'E-&'8$:"2,$).$S')1(L(.$;/-$)&5$Q()1&(-.$.1$AU(+;/01$

;)O0Q&A&W(X'.$X'U&51$.'$)'-$A'($A.)$+&-1)$3.$)/$L.++.$.1$3.$)/$L(AA.9$X'.$-2V,A.51$3.'R$LA/)Q*Z/0`$

)(1'2)$3/5)$A/$).0&53.$+&(1(2$3'$L(A+D$%/$V(&A.50.$3.$wQ/5W$o(5)Q.5W$3/5)$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&09$

V/$3.$;/(-$/V.0$0.AA.$3.$A/$)&0(212$0Q(5&().9$X'($Z-&(.$A.)$f1-.)$Q'+/(5)$/'$5&+$3'$32V.A&;;.+.51$

20&5&+(X'.$.1$3.$AU&Z).))(&5$;&'-$A.$3&AA/-D$B/5)$X$13&#'"1'28&'($#P9$0.$)&51$A.)$;-&ZA,+.)$3U/-W.51$

J :53-(59$P'-(.A;'!$)@C"E-&0'A')&'4@),(#$4&'C")4"E-&'$4@#"3$"1'&2'0&0'8@#,\1&0Z]^_`a]^bcY; '<-'R.AA.)9'=.1.-$%/5W9$0&AA$-.;.5).-$A.$0(52+/9$788JD$;D@I

G %/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD$;D@>

Page 18: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

3'$;.-)&55/W.$3.$<(AA$X'($A.$;&')).51$/'$0-(+.D$%/$V(&A.50.$)U.R;A(X'.$.1$).$S')1(L(.$3U'5.$+/5(,-. $

;A')$0-23(ZA.9 $+/()$ A/ $ L(W'-. $3'$^$+20Q/51 $_ $;.-3'-.D $#( $ A. $+2A&3-/+.$(5S.01.$'5.$0&+;A.R(12$

;)O0Q&A&W(X'.$;A')$3.5).$3/5)$).)$;.-)&55/W.)9$(A$W/-3.$0.1$(512-f1$;&'-$A.$)O+Z&A.9$AU/-0Q21O;.9$A/$

)(W5(L(0/1(&5$3'$;.-)&55/W.$/'*3.AT$3.$A'(*+f+.D

$

%.$;.-)&55/W.$0&Q2-.51

4.11. $)(+;A(0(12 $3' $;.-)&55/W. $).$ -.1-&'V. $2W/A.+.51 $3/5) $)/ $0&Q2-.50.D $ aA $O $/ $;.' $3.$

A(+(1.)$/'R$-.1&'-5.+.51)$3.$)(1'/1(&5$3'$+2A&3-/+.$M$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;/)).51$3.$A/$;/'V-.12$T$

AU.R1-f+.$-(0Q.)).9$3.$A/$+&-1$T$A/$V(.9$3.$A/$020(12$T$A/$)/5129$3Uf1-.$Q&++.$T$f1-.$L.++.D$P/()$'5.$

0Q&).$.)1$-.);.012.$M$A.'-$(512W-(12$;)O0Q&A&W(X'.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$3();/-/()).51$.1$

-2/;;/-/()).51$/;-,)$3.)$/552.)9$V(.(AA()).51$.1$).$1-/5)L&-+.51D$P/()$(A$5U.5$.)1$;/)$'5$X'($0Q/5W.$

)/5)$.R;A(0/1(&5$5($3&51$&5$5.$;&'V/(1$;-2V&(-$A.$0Q/5W.+.51D$B.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$X'U(A$0-&(1$.5$'5$

+&53. $ 0&Q2-.51 $ &[ $ )U(3.51(L(.51 $ A. $ Z(.5 $ .1 $ A. $ +/A9 $ A. $ +2A&3-/+. $ 32;.(51 $ 3.) $ (3.51(12) $ X'($

L&501(&55.51 $0&++.$'5$ 1&'19 $'5 $ZA&0 $X'( $2V&A'.-/9 $+/() $5. $0Q/5W.-/ $;/) $3. $5/1'-.D $%. $ S.'5.$

/5/-0Q()1.$ (32/A()1. $3'' X#'H"*$%,$ -2/;;/-/n1 $)&')$A.)$ 1-/(1)$3U'5$Z&'--./'$3'$-2W(+.9 $0/')/51 $ A/$

)'-;-().$3'$);.01/1.'-$X'($A.$0-&O/(1$+&-1D$P/()$AU&5$/V/(1$32ST$V'$)&5$(5).5)(Z(A(129$;A')$1j1$3/5)$A.$

L(A+9 $ A&-)X'U(A $/LL(-+/(1 $T$)/$ S.'5.$L(/502.$X'U(A $ A/ $)/0-(L(.-/(1 $)/5)$Q2)(1.- $;&'-$).)$ (32/'RD$#&5$

/Z)&A'1()+.$S')1(L(.$A/$1-/5)L&-+/1(&5$h$A.$-.1-&'V.-$.5$/W.51$3'$)O)1,+.$5.$)/'-/(1$5&')$21&55.-$1&'1$

T$L/(1D$<&ZZO$3/5)$)&'F&3#&2'!$%1"C"E-&;'X'(11.$)&5$/50(.55.$V(.$3.$;A/OZ&O$(5)&'0(/51$;&'-$21'3(.-$

J$/5)$3.$+23.0(5.$.1$-.V.5(-$)&')$A.)$1-/(1)$3U'5$+23.0(5$(32/A$h$T$5&'V./'$0.11.$1-/5)L&-+/1(&5$.)1$

S')1(L(2.D$#&5$/+&'-$;&'-$A/$S.'5.$V.'V.$/(5)($X'.$)&5$/3Q2)(&5$/'R$;-(50(;.)$+/W(X'.)$3'$).0-.1 $

+/W5(L(X'.$EX'($;-23(1$X'.$1&'1$0.$X'U(A$L.-/$3.$Z(.5$;&'-$A.)$/'1-.)9$-.1&+Z.-/$;&)(1(V.+.51$)'-$)/$

;-&;-.$.R()1.50.F$A.$+,5.51$T$1&')$A.)$.LL&-1)D$a+;&))(ZA.$3.$0-&(-.$.5$A/$-2(50/-5/1(&5$3'$S.'5.$

0&'1'-(.- $3. $+$'?"&) 'E-&'8$:"2,$ .5$ A/ $Z.AA. $g2-/9 $.1 $;&'-1/51DDD $:A+&3&V/- $5. $0.)).-/$3.$5&')$

+&51-.-9$;/-$Z-(Z.)$A.)$21/;.)$3.$)/$1-/5)L&-+/1(&5D$!1$g(0.51.xg2-/$-.)1.-/$L(3,A.$T$)/$;-.+(,-.$

(3.51(129 $+/AW-2 $ A.) $ 1&-1'-.) $ ;)O0Q&A&W(X'.) $ ;/- $ A.)X'.AA.) $ (Ax.AA. $ ;/)).-/9 $ (Ax.AA. $ 5. $ )23'(-/ $ A.$

+23.0(5$(50/-52$;/-$:51&5(&$</53.-/)$X'.$;&'-$;&'V&(-$)U.5L'(-$.1$-.1-&'V.-$)/$+,-.$3&51$(Ax.AA.$/ $

212 $)2;/-2*.D $%.) $;A') $W-/53)$Z&'A.V.-).+.51)$5.$).$ L&51 $;/) $)/5)$0.11. $0&51(5'(12 $;&))(ZA.$3.$

AU(3.51(L(0/1(&5$M$A.$;.-)&55/W.$-.)1.-/$L(3,A.)$T$A'(*+f+.$+/AW-2$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)D

%.$;.-)&55/W.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$;.-+.1$3&50$3.$0&50.51-.-$A.$-20(1$.5$3&55/51$/'$);.01/1.'-$

'5. $.51(12 $ 3&51 $ (A $ )/(1 $X'U(A $ ;&'--/ $ /11.53-. $'5. $0&Q2-.50.D $=/) $3. $;(,W. $3/5) $ A. $+2A&3-/+.$h$

AUQ()1&(-. $;.'1 $ /V/50.- $V(1.9 $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ -.0&55/n1-/ $;-.)X'. $ (++23(/1.+.51 $ A.) $+20Q/51) $3.)$

Page 19: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

W.51(A)9$A.)$L&-1)$3.)$L/(ZA.)9$A.)$V(01(+.)$3.)$Z&'--./'RD$!1$0.11.$3(/A.01(X'.$+().$.5$;A/0.$5.$).$

-.1-&'V.-/$;/)$+&3(L(2.$)/5)$.R;A(0/1(&5D$

$

%(.'R$.1$&ZS.1)$)O+Z&A(X'.)

%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5.$)&51$;/)$A.)$).'A)$T$L/(-.$)O+Z&A.$h$A.)$A(.'R$.1$A.)$&ZS.1)$/'))($)(W5(L(.51$

/'*3.AT$3U.'R*+f+.)9$)&(1$;/-0.$X'U(A)$L&51$20Q&$/'R$-2L2-.50.)$3'$);.01/1.'-9$)&(1$;/-0.$X'.$A.$L(A+$

A.'-$/$3&552$'5.$)(W5(L(0/1(&5$5&'V.AA.D

%/$V(AA.$.1$A/$0/+;/W5.$)'Z()).51$0.11.$+f+.$/;;-&0Q.$)O+Z&A(X'.D$%/$V(AA.$.)1$A.$A(.'$3.$A/$

L-252)(.$;-&3'01(V.9$3.$A/$V(.$T$0.51$T$AUQ.'-.9$3.)$32)(-)$3.$02A2Z-(12$.1$3.$AU&'ZA($3.)$V-/(.)$V/A.'-)D $

%/$0/+;/W5.$0.A'($3'$-.;&)9$3.$A/$)/W.)).9$3U'5$-/;;&-1$;A')$V-/($/'R$0Q&).)$.1$/'R$f1-.)D$%/$L.++.$

3(/Z&A(X'.$X'($321&'-5.$A.$+/-($3.$)/$L.++.$3/5)$+>$-#,#&').-/9$3,)$A.$32Z'19$0/-/012-()2.$0&++.$

^A/$L.++.$3.$A/$V(AA.$_$1/53()$X'.$A.)$+&+.51)$3.$L2A(0(12$3'$0&';A.$).-&51$-.;-2).512)$3/5)$'5.$

0/+;/W5.$(3OAA(X'.D$%.$+&53.$3U[$??N'2,%&28&#9$.)1$0.A'($3.$A/$0&5L')(&59$3.$A/$;/))(&5$5&0(V.$.1$

3'$1-/V/(A$L-2521(X'.$3/5)$A/$+21-&;&A.$+&5)1-'.').$3.$<'.5&)$:(-.)D$%.$0/L29$Q/V-.$5/1'-.A$/'$

+(A(.'R$3.)$/-Z-.)$.)1$A.$A(.'$3.$A/$-20&50(A(/1(&5$3'$0&';A.$3U!++($.1$:A($3/5) $7,-0')&0'$-2#&0 '

0>$??&))&12'.)"D$!5L(59$3/5)$7,-2'3&'E-&')&'3"&)'?&#4&2;$ A.)$3.'R$+&53.)$)&51$0A/(-.+.51$&;;&)2)$M$

0.A'($3.$AUQO;&0-(1.$;.1(1.$V(AA.$3.$;-&V(50.$&[$1&'1$5U.)1$X'.$L/'R*).+ZA/51)$.1$A.$+&53.$3.$Y&5$

y(-ZO9$X'($()&A2$3/5)$A/$5/1'-.9$).$-/;;-&0Q.$3/V/51/W.$3.$0.$X'($(+;&-1.$M$AU/+&'-$.1$A.)$).51(+.51)D$

%.)$A(.'R$)&51$L&-1.+.51$/))&0(2)$T$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$&'$T$3.)$)O+Z&A.)D$%/$+/()&5$3.$P+.$P'(- $

-.;-2).51.$)&5$(532;.53/50.$/0X'().$.1$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3.$)&5$Z&5Q.'-D$4.AA.$3.$d&:&33$$T$AU(5V.-).9$

-.;-2).51.$AU(50/;/0(12$3.$A/$5&'V.AA.$P+.$3.$z(51.-$T$;&'V&(-$0&++.50.-$'5.$-.A/1(&5$/V.0$)&5$

+/-(9$;-()&55(,-.$3'$L/51j+.$3.$Y.Z.00/9$X'($).$-.)).51$T$1-/V.-)$0Q/X'.$321/(A$3.$A/$3.+.'-.D

$

%.) $&ZS.1) $ 2W/A.+.51 $ &51 $'5. $3(+.5)(&5 $ L&-1.+.51 $ )O+Z&A(X'.D $B.;'() $ A.) $&-(W(5.) $3'$

1Q2e1-.9$0U.)1$AU&ZS.1$X'($(3.51(L(.$A.$Z2Z2$/Z/53&5529$X'($-2)&'1$A/$;(,0.$.5$;.-+.11/51$T$.5L/51)$.1$

;/-.51)$3.$).$-.1-&'V.-D$P23/(AA&5)9$A.11-.)$A/())2.)$3/5)$A.$A/53/'9$(A)$)&51$A/$+/5(L.)1/1(&5$;QO)(X'. $

3.$A/$L(A(/1(&5$X'($;.-+.11-/$A/$-.0&55/())/50.$;/-$A.)$;/-.51)D$%/$5&1.$A/())2.$;/-$A/$+,-.$3/5)$78&'

P"(9$A/$0A2$3.$A/$+/()&5$3.$C/&$X'.$W/-3.$/'1&'-$3'$0&'$A.$L(A)$3U.-*(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&)9$A.)$Z&'0A.)$

3U&-.(AA.)$3.$g(01&-(/$:;-(A$X'.$)/$+,-.$/$&'ZA(2.)$3/5)$7$),10'."%-"))&0D$B/5)$A.$0/)$3.)$;/))(&5)$

/+&'-.').)9 $0U.)1 $ A. $ L21(0Q()+.$/'1&'- $3U'5.$20Q/-;.$-/;;.A/51 $'5$)&'V.5(- $/+&'-.'R$E+,"1'(-'

?$#$("0F9 $ A/ $ 1Q2(,-.$X'( $ (50/-5.$A/ $ A(/()&5$;'()$ A.)$ 1.5)(&5)$3/5) $A. $0&';A.$E7,-2'3&'E-&')& '3"&) '

?&#4&2F9$'5$;&-1-/(1$(50/-5/51$AU(+/W.$3.$AUf1-.$/(+2$E+>,?"1",1'?-:)"E-&;'+>$*&12-#&'(&'!4&'!-"#F9$

A.)$+23/(AA.)$20Q/5W2.)$.5$W/W.$3U/+&'-$;/-$4Q(0&$.1$B(/5.$E+>8&-#&'0-?#G4&F$&'$A/$Z/W'.$3.$

Page 20: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+/-(/W.$/Z/53&552.$)/5)$0&+;A.R.$;/-$#0/-A.11$E.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&12FD$!5L(59$3/5)$A.$0/)$3.$A/$

;&'-)'(1.$3'$Z&5Q.'-9$0U.)1$A/$;Q&1&$3.$]-/5`$T$=/-()9$)O+Z&A.$3.)$.);&(-)$3U:;-(A$;&'-$0Q/5W.-$3.$

V(.$E+&0$1,3&0'#&:&))&0F9$A.$L/(-.$;/-1$3.$+/-(/W.$X'($).-/$A/$3.-5(,-.$-.A(X'.$3U'5.$-.A/1(&5$/V&-12.$

E.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0FD$4U.)1$2W/A.+.51$3/5)$A.)$&ZS.1)$X'.$).$A(1$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)D$%.$;(X'.1$

3.$Z&()$3.$+>$*&12-#&'(&'!4&'!-"#9$X'($;A(.$)&')$A/$L&-0.$3.)$V/W'.)9$+/()$5.$3();/-/n1$;/)D

%.$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$'5$/-1$3.$A/$+21&5O+(.$M$A.)$0Q&).)$.1$A.)$f1-.)$&51$'5$).5)$X'($A.)$32;/)). $

.1 $X'. $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $;.'1 $ (3.51(L(.- $ (++23(/1.+.51D $ aA $ 1()). $'5$ -2)./'$3. $ -2L2-.50.) $/'1&'- $3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)9 $0-()1/AA(). $ A.)$2+&1(&5)$.1 $ A.)$52V-&).)$/'1&'- $3U&ZS.1) $)O+Z&A(X'.)D $aA $)(+;A(L(.$ A.$

+&53.$T$1-/V.-)$3.)$)O+Z&A.)D$Y&ZZ.*N-(AA.1$V.--/$A/$A(+(1.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$3/5)$0.11.$0-&O/50.$.5$

'5$^$).5)$L(W2$_$.5$^$0&50.;1)$0&++.$1.A)$_$h$.5$'5$+&53.$3&51$^$AUQ&++.$21/(1$A.$+/n1-.$_ ?$;'()X'.$

0U.)1$A'($X'($.5$320(3.$A.$).5)D$aA$O$A(1$^$AU(W5&-/50.$3.$A/$;&-&)(12$3.)$L-&51(,-.)$_$X'($0/-/012-().$A/$

V()(&5 $ )(+;A(L(0/1-(0. $3' $+2A&3-/+.9 $ .1 $ A(+(1. $ A. $+&53. $ .5 $'5. $ )&++.$3. $0Q&).) $.1 $ 3. $ L/(1)$

32A(+(1/ZA.)D$aA$O$&;;&).$'5$;&(51$3.$V'.$&[$A.)$^$)(W5(L(0/1(&5)$3'$+&53.9$/'1&'-$3.$5&')9$5.$)&51$

EDDDF $X'.$;/-1(.AA.)9$;-&V()&(-.)9$0&51-/3(01&(-.)$+f+.$.1$ 1&'S&'-)$0&51.)12.)$_>89 $X'($.)1 $0.A'($3'$

5&'V./' $ -&+/5 $ .1 $ 3U'5 $ 0.-1/(5 $ 0(52+/$ 3.) $ /552.) $ I8*J8D $P/() $ A/ $ V&A&512 $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ 3.$

)U21.53-.$)'-$A.)$/552.)9$3.$3&55.-$T$).51(-$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)9$3.$;/-A.-$3U'5.$V(.$.51(,-.$520.))(1.$

0.) $ -/00&'-0()9 $0.) $ )(+;A(L(0/1(&5)D $%/ $0&Q2-.50. $3.) $0Q&).) $.1 $3.) $f1-.) $.)1 $0. $X'( $;.-+.1 $/'$

+2A&3-/+.$).)$Z&53)$3/5)$A.$1.+;)D$4.11.$-23'01(&5$3.$A/$V(.$.5$'5.$A'11.$'5(X'.9$&[$2V&A'.51$3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$.1$3.)$'5(V.-)$)12-2&1O;2)$.)1$0.$X'($;.-+.1$3.$A/$0&51.-D$

( 4)+-&$-)$.")"+(1"+2)(+.)68(+9&".(

$ d5.$).0&53.$0/-/012-()1(X'.$3'$+2A&3-/+.9$0U.)1$)&5$W&i1$;&'-$A.)$+&+.51)$L&-1)9$)&5$).5)$

3.$ A/ $0&50.51-/1(&5$3.$ AU/01(&5D $Y&+/(5$Y&AA/539 $3/5) $)/$32L(5(1(&5$3'$ 1Q2e1-. $+2A&3-/+/1(X'.9$

2V&X'.$0&++.$AU'5.$3.)$0&53(1(&5)$;-&;-.)$/'$+2A&3-/+.$1Q2e1-/A$A.$-/;;&-1$X'.$3&(1$.51-.1.5(-$A.$

);.01/1.'-$T$AU2+&1(&5$^$(A$V.'1$).$-.;&).-$3.)$A/-+.)$3/5)$A.$-(-.$.1$3'$-(-.$3/5)$A.)$A/-+.)$_>>9$+/()$

)'-1&'1$5.$S/+/()$0.)).-$3.$V(V-.$T$AU.R0,)$0.$X'($;/)).$)'-$3.V/51$A'(D$%.$0&-;)$3'$);.01/1.'-$3&(1 $

f1-.$^$;-()$3/5)$'5$+(+21()+.$X'/)($(5V&A&51/(-.$3.)$2+&1(&5)$&'$3.)$).5)/1(&5)$-.)).51(.)$;/-$A.)$

? %/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD$;D7?*@>

>8$Y&AA/539$Y&+/(59$)&'28@e2#&'(-'?&-?)&9$=/-()9$4&+;A.R.9$0&AAD$%.$1Q2e1-.$.5$X'.)1(&59$788@D$;D>8J

>> %/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD

Page 21: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

0&-;)$)'-$AU20-/5>7$_$20-(1$2W/A.+.51$%(53/$z(AA(/+)$.5$;/-A/51$3'$^$+2A&$L2+(5(5$_D$%/$0&51(5'(12$

3.$AU2+&1(&5$.)1$'5$3.)$2A2+.51)$0/-/012-()1(X'.)$3'$+2A&3-/+.D$=/)$3.$-.;&)$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-9$(A$

3&(1$1&'1$V(V-.$(51.5)2+.51D$%/$0&5)1-'01(&5$5/--/1(V.$&Z2(1$3&50$T$0.$;-(50(;.$M$0Q/X'.$)2X'.50.$

3&(1$0&50.51-.-$AU/01(&5$X'($).$32-&'A.$)&')$).)$O.'R$;&'-$;&'V&(-$0-2.-$3.$AU2+&1(&5D$

%.$1Q2e1-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$&Z2(1$T$'5.$L&-+.$0&32.9$&[$).'A)$)&51$-.;-2).512)$A.)$1.+;)$

L&-1)D$%.)$+&+.51)$3.$1-/5)(1(&5)$)&51$2A'32)$.5$Q&-)*0Q/+;$h$A.$+2A&3-/+.$1Q2e1-/A$.)1$0&5)1(1'2$

3U'5.$)'(1.$3U(5)1/51)$0/-/012-()2)$;/-$'5.$'5(12$3.$1.+;)$.1$3.$A(.'$.1$&[$).$32-&'A.$AU.)).51(.A$3.$

AU/01(&5D$%.)$32;A/0.+.51)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$).-&51$+21/;Q&-()2)$;/-$A.'-)$)&-1(.)$3.$)0,5.D$aA$;.'1$).$

;/)).-$3.)$+&()$.51-.$3.'R$/01.)$3U'5.$;(,0.$h$).'A)$A.)$+&+.51)$L&-1)$).-&51$-.;-2).512)D$4.11.$

.)1Q21(X'.$)U(50/-5.$3.$+/5(,-.$1-,)$2V(3.51.$3/5)$AU'5$3.)$+&1(L)$3'$1Q2e1-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$h$3.)$

+&+.51)$3.$;/').)$&[$A.$;A')$)&'V.51$T$A/$L(5$3U'5$/01.9$A.)$/01.'-)$).$0&5W,A.51$A(112-/A.+.51$)'-$

;A/0.9$W/-3/51$'5.$;&)(1(&5$L(W2.$)'-$A/X'.AA.$3.)0.53$A.$-(3./'$;&'-$5&')$L/(-.$;/)).-$/'$+&+.51$

)'(V/51D $t$5&'V./'$32V.A&;;/51 $ A/ $;.5)2. $3. $<-&&`)9 $P'-(.A $:53-(5 $320-(1 $ A. $;-(50(;. $X'U.AA.$

5&++.$^$'*"0-&)'0-44$#N',C'28&'&4,2",11&)'0"2-$2",1f'M$

^$A.)$)0,5.)$0&5)1-'(1.)$)&')$A. $3(01/1 $3U'5.$;/-&A.$0A/(-.$.1 $)/5)$2X'(V&X'.$).$

1.-+(5.51 $ )&') $ A. $ ;&'V&(- $ /Z)&A' $3' $ )(A.50. $ L(5/A $ 3.) $ 1/ZA./'R $X'( $ 0-2.51 $ '5$

0A(+/R $ &[ $ A. $ 3()0&'-) $ .1 $ A/ $ 5/--/1(&5 $ )U/--f1.51 $ 3. $ 0&50.-1 $ ;&'- $ &LL-(- $ '5.$

-.;-2).51/1(&5$V()'.AA.$L(W2.9$+/()$1&1/A.+.51$1-/5);/-.51.D$d5.$3.-5(,-.$L&()9$A.$

Z'1$3.$0.$;-&0232$.)1 $3.$3&55.-$ AU&;;&-1'5(12$/'$);.01/1.'-$3.$)/()(- $3U'5$).'A$

-.W/-3 $ 1&'1.) $ A.) $ )(W5(L(0/1(&5) $ -.;-2).512.) $ A.) $ 2+&1(&5) $ .1 $ A.) $ 21/1) $+&-/'R$

-.53')$;/-$A.$Z(/()$3.$)(W5.)$0A/(-)$.1$V()(ZA.)D>@$_D

aA$)U/W(1$3&50$3.$0-2.-$'5.$(+/W.$L(R.9$3'$+&+.51$A.$;A')$L&-1$3.$AU/01.9$X'($.5$L/(1$A.$0.51-.$.1$A/$

-/()&5$3Uf1-.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$0Q.-0Q.-/$/'1/51$X'.$;&))(ZA.$T$5Uf1-.$X'U'5.$)'(1.$3.$0.)$+&+.51)9$5.$

)U(512-.))/51 $ X'. $ ;.' $ /'R $ 1-/5)(1(&5) $ X'( $+,5.51 $ 3U'5. $ )(1'/1(&5 $ T $ AU/'1-.D $%/ $ )1-'01'-. $ 3. $ 0.)$

+2A&3-/+.)$/$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3'$0&AA(.-$3.$;.-A.)9$&[$&5$5.$X'(11.$'5$+&+.51$L&-1$3.$AU/01(&5$X'.$

;&'-$.5$-.1-&'V.-$'5$/'1-.9$1&'1$/'))($L&-1D$

4.11.$ A&W(X'.$).$-.1-&'V.$1-,)$L&-1.+.51$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.D$d5.$3.)$

0&5)1/1/1(&5) $ A.) $ ;A') $ )(+;A.) $ 0&50.-5. $ A.) $ 1-/5)(1(&5) $ );/1(/A.)9 $ ;-.)X'. $ )O)12+/1(X'.+.51$

>7$:53-(59$P'-(.A;'!$)@C"E-&0'A')&'4@),(#$4&'C")4"E-&'$4@#"3$"1'&2'0&0'8@#,\1&0Z]^_`a]^bcY; '<-'R.AA.)9'=.1.-$%/5W9$0&AA$-.;.5).-$A.$0(52+/9$788J

>@$"/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;DI7

Page 22: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

^$.AA(;)2.)$_D $#( $ A. $+&+.51 $3'$V&O/W.$5U.)1 $;/) $ A. $0/3-. $3U'5$Z&'A.V.-).+.51 $3. $ AUQ()1&(-.9 $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$).+ZA.51$).$12A2;&-1.-$3U'5$A(.'$T$AU/'1-.D$B/5) $+& ':,18&-#9$4Q/`/A$(5V(1.$'5.$S.'5.$

L.++.$T$'5$-.53.s*V&')9$;-20()/51$X'U(A)$(-&51$&[$.AA.$V&'3-/D$%.$;A/5$)'(V/519$(A)$)&51$3.V/51$A. $

1Q2e1-. $ &[ $ (A) $ )U/;;-f1.51 $ T $ V&(- $ '5 $ );.01/0A.D $ %/ $ A&W(X'. $ .)1 $ L-/;;/51. $ 3/5) $ o2s.Z.A9 $ &[ $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$5.$0.)).51$3.$0Q/5W.-$3.$A(.'R$E3.$A/$+/()&5$3.$A/$V(AA.$T$A/$Z/5X'.9$&'$T$A/$+/()&5$3.$

0/+;/W5.F$0&++.$)U(A)$).$12A2;&-1/(.51D$%.$).'A$32;A/0.+.51$3.$o2s.Z.A$X'.$AU&5$V.--/$).-/$)&5$

;/))/W.$0A/53.)1(5$T$1-/V.-)$A.$Z/O&'$;&'-$/AA.-$/'$0Q.V.1$3.$AUQ&++.$3&51$.AA.$.)1$/+&'-.').$.1$X'($

0&5)1(1'.9$.5$)&(9$'5$+&+.51$320()(L$3.$AUQ()1&(-.$.1$'5.$/01(&5$T$L&-1.$0Q/-W.$)O+Z&A(X'.D$4.$X'($).$

32-&'A.-/$3/5)$A.)$1-/5)(1(&5)$(+;&-1.$L(5/A.+.51$;.'9$(A$)U/W(1$3U'5$1.+;)$(5'1(A.9$X'($.R()1.9$+/() $

X'(9$5U/O/51$;/)$3.$0/-/012-()1(X'.)$3-/+/1(X'.)$);20(L(X'.)9$;.'1$f1-.$.5A.V2D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$5U/$;/)$

A/$V&0/1(&5$3.$32;.(53-.$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$.5$)&(D$#.'A.$A/$A'11.$+.52.$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$3/5)$

).)$+&+.51)$A.)$;A')$L&-1)9$3&(1$;/-/n1-.$T$AU20-/5D$%.)$1.+;)$3.$1-/5)(1(&5)9$X'($)2;/-.51$A/$3.+/53.$

.5 $ L(/5\/(AA.) $ 3' $+/-(/W.9 $ A/ $+&-1 $ 3. $ AU.51.--.+.519 $ A/ $ 0&50.;1(&5 $3. $ A/ $ 5/())/50. $3. $ AU.5L/51$

(+;&-1.51$;.'$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$X'($5.$).$0Q/-W.$X'.$3.)$1.+;)$;A.(5)D$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$3(1$.5$

;/-A/51$3'$0(52+/$/+2-(0/(5$X'U(A$/$;&'-$V&0/1(&5$3U^2V/0'.-9$.R;'A).-$0.)$;.1(1)$320Q.1)$3.$1.+;)$

(+;&-1'5$h$)/1'-.-$A.$L(A+$3.$1.+;)$)(W5(L(/51$M$A.$-20(1$EDDDF9$5.$V.'1$;/)$/V&(-$Z.)&(5$3.$-.;-.53-.$

)&5$)&'LLA.$_>HD$%.)$1.+;)$3.$;/').9$3.$-.3.)0.51.9$5U(512-.)).51$;/)$;A')$A.$+2A&3-/+.$M$1&'1$3&(1$).$

;/)).-$3/5)$'5.$)'(1.$3.$+&+.51)$(51.5).)9$0&+;A.1)9$.R/A1/51)$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-D

%U.AA(;). $ S&'. $'5$ -jA. $ L&53/+.51/A $3/5) $0.11. $;.-);.01(V.9 $ (A $ )U/W(1 $3.$ 1-&'V.- $ 1&'1.) $ A.)$

+/5(,-.)$3.$)';;-(+.-$0.)$+&+.51)$S'W2)$1-&;$L/(ZA.)9$1&'1$.5$W/-/51())/51$A/$0&+;-2Q.5)(&5$3.$

AUQ()1&(-.D$t$5&'V./'$3/5)$.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&129$A.$+&51/W.$;.-+.1$3.)$-/00&'-0()$;-&3(W(.'R$M$

3U'5$;A/5$3'$;,-.$1&+Z2$3.$0Q.V/A9 $&5$;/)).$3(-.01.+.51$)'-$ A. $;A/5$3.$)/$ 1&+Z.D $B.$#0/-A.11$

+(5/'3/51 $/V.0$P-$y.55.3O9 $&5$;/)).$)'-$ A. $;A/5$3U'5$0Q,X'.$X'U.AA. $)(W5.$3'$5&+$3.$P+.$

#0/-A.11$vUQ/-/$y.55.3OD$%.$;&'A.1$0&'-/51$3/5)$A.$S/-3(5$X'U/11-/;.$'5$.)0A/V.$5&')$/+,5.-/$.5$'5$

L&53'$T$A/$0/-0/)).$3'$;&'A.1$)'-$'5.$1/ZA.$-.+;A(.$3.$0&5V(V.)$&[$)U/0Q,V.$A.$-.;/)D$%/$0/').$+,5.$

(++23(/1.+.51$T$A/$0&5)2X'.50.9$A.$;-&0.))')$).$1-&'V/51$2A(+(52$3/5)$AU.AA(;).D

$ <(.5 $ )i-9 $ (A $ )U/W(1 $ AT $ 3U'5. $ ;-/1(X'. $ ;-&;-. $ /' $ 0(52+/9 $ .1 $ ;/) $ ).'A.+.51 $ /' $ 0(52+/$

Q&AAOK&&3(.5$M $ &5 $ )/(1 $ Z(.5 $ X'. $ AU.AA(;). $ / $ ;&'- $ V&0/1(&5 $ 3. $ 0&';.- $ AU(5'1(A. $ 3. $ AUQ()1&(-.9 $ 3.$

0&51-/01.-$A.$1.+;)$;&'-$A.$-/0&51.-D$P/()$A.$+2A&3-/+.$V/$;A')$A&(5$M$(A$5.$0&';.$;/)$).'A.+.51$A.)$

1-/5)(1(&5)$X'($)&51$3.)$1.+;)$+&-1)$;&'-$AUQ()1&(-.9$)(5&5$1&'1.$1-/5)(1(&5D$aA$).$;A/n1$T$;/)).-$3U'5$

ZA&0$T$AU/'1-.9$3U'5.$)(1'/1(&5$T$A/$)'(V/51.D$%.)$L&-1'5.)$).$L&51$.1$).$32L&51$A.$1.+;)$3U'5.$0&';.9 $

A.)$V(.)$).$Z&'A.V.-).51$3/5)$A/$Z2/50.$3.$AU.AA(;).D$

>H v;D$4(1D$;DI>

Page 23: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$20-(1$T$5&'V./'$M

$ ^ $ AU/+Z(1(&5 $3.) $ .AA(;).) $ 1.+;&-.AA.)9 $ 3/5) $ A. $ L(A+ $Q&AAOK&&3(.5 $0A/))(X'.9 $ .)1 $3.$

;-&3'(-. $'5 $ 1.+;) $ )&'V.-/(59 $+(-/0'A29 $32A(V-2 $3.) $ ).-V(1'3.) $.1 $3.) $;.)/51.'-) $3.$

AU(5)1/519$3.)$)0&-(.)$3'$X'&1(3(.5D$%.$1.+;)$3.$AU.LL&-1$(5'1(A.$.)1$Z/55($h$A(Z2-29$A.$1.+;)$

Q&AAOK&&3(.5$;.'19$0&++.$A.$)025/-(&$3.$r&A(3/O$a55$E+>$4,-#'38$12&'&2'($10&9$PD$

#/53-(0Q9$>?H7F9$/AA.-$3.$S&'-$3.$Lf1.$.5$S&'-$3.$Lf1.9$)/'1/51$0/V/A(,-.+.51$;/-*3.))')$

A.)$0/).)$1.-5.)$3'$0/A.53-(.-D$_$

v5$V&(1$Z(.5$A.$A(.5$L&-1$X'U.51-.1(.51$A.$+2A&3-/+.$/V.0$AU.)1Q21(X'.$3'$0(52+/$/+2-(0/(5$M$)($3/5)$

A. $+2A&3-/+.9 $ A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5.$)/'1.51$;/)$3.$Lf1.$.5$Lf1.9$+/()$3.$+&+.51)$3U2+&1(&5)$.5$

+&+.51)$3U2+&1(&5)9$&5$-.1-&'V.$Z(.5$AT$A/$+f+.$(32.D$%.$);.01/1.'-$5.$V.--/$;/)$P/-(.$;-.53-.$A.$

1-/(5$;&'-$X'(11.-$)/$0/+;/W5.$3/5)$+>,?"1",1'?-:)"E-&'A'.AA.$)&-1(-/$3'$0Q/+;9$).$3(-(W./51$V.-)$A.)$

K/W&5)9$.1$&5$A/$-.1-&'V.-/$'5$/5$;A')$1/-39$3/5)$'5$-(0Q.$-.)1/'-/51$3.$A/$0/;(1/A.D$"&')$5.$V.--&5)$

5($A/$1-/S.01&(-.$;QO)(X'.$X'U.AA.$L/(19$5($)&5$/)0.5)(&5$)&0(/A.9$3.'R$+&'V.+.51)$/))&0(2)$3/5)$'5.$

.AA(;).$X'($A.)$/V/A.-/$1&')$A.)$3.'RD$%/$+,-.$3'$L"($L.-/$L&-1'5.$A.$1.+;)$3U'5$0/-1&59$1&'1$0&++.$

AUQ2-&{5.$3U"4"2$2",1',C')"C&$-2'))(-/$)/$V(.$;-&L.))(&55.AA.$3/5)$A/$Z2/50.$3U'5.$.AA(;).$X'($0&';.$A.$

L(A+ $ .5 $ 3.'RD $ %/ $ -2'))(1. $ 5U/ $ 3U(+;&-1/50. $ X'U.5 $ 0. $ X'U.AA. $ /;;&-1. $ '5 $ 0Q/5W.+.519 $ '5$

-.Z&53()).+.51$T$AUQ()1&(-.D$%.$;-&0.))')$5U(512-.)).$.5$-(.5$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$X'(9$3-/)1(X'.9$A.$L/(1$

3();/-/n1-.$/'R$&'ZA(.11.)D

%.$+2A&3-/+.$0&51.$A/$V(.$T$.5$A/$)1-'01'-/51$0&++.$'5$3.)1(59$/V.0$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$X'($

&00';.51$'5.$L&501(&59$3.)$)O+Z&A.)9$'5$)O)1,+.$0A&)$)'-$A'($+f+.$X'($A'($;.-+.1$3.$1-/5)L&-+.-$A.$

0Q/&)$3.$A/$V(.$.5$'5.$.51(12$-/0&51/ZA.D$%.$+&53.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$;/-/n1$3&50$3&55.-$T$A/$V(.$'5.$

0&Q2-.50. $ 1&'1. $ -/))'-/51.9 $ X'( $ W/-/51(-/(1 $ '5. $ L&-+. $ 3. $ 0&5L&-1 $ /' $ );.01/1.'-D $ =&'-1/519 $ A.$

+2A&3-/+.$5U.)1 $;/)$ A. $W.5-.$3.$ A/ $ 1-/5X'(AA(12D$:'$0&51-/(-.9 $ A. $);.01/1.'- $;/)).$;/- $ 1&'1.)$ A.)$

2+&1(&5)9$ A.)$)(1'/1(&5)$3.$0-().$)U.50Q/n5.51$)/5)$1-/5)(1(&5)9$5($;/').)9$/V.0$1-,)$;.'$3.$;A/0.$

A/())2.$T$AU/00&+;A()).+.51$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$Z(.5$3/V/51/W.$T$A.'-)$20Q.0)D$%U.AA(;).$S&'.$'5$-jA.$

;-(+&-3(/A $3/5) $ A/ $ 0&50.51-/1(&5 $3. $ A/ $5/--/1(&5 $/'1&'- $3. $ A/ $ A'11. $3.) $;.-)&55/W.)9 $+/() $ .AA.$

1-/V/(AA.$2W/A.+.51$.5$;-&L&53.'-$AU.50Q/n5.+.51$3.)$+&+.51)$L&-1)9$;-&;(0.)$T$;-&3'(-.$AU2+&1(&5$

0Q.s$A.$);.01/1.'-D$%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$L(A+$.1$A/$;A/0.$3.$AU.AA(;).$)&51$0.$X'($;.-+.1$3.$-O1Q+.-$A.) $

/00&+;A()).+.51)$.1$A.)$20Q.0)$3'$;.-)&55/W.$3/5)$)/$A'11.D$

Page 24: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

?K*.%,&'(3(

(I00%.+'2()"+%&(',(L&9+,&*,%$1

?$##'1,(0N'00%.+'(,&*J*%00'7,7'00'(0N"#$,%$1()9(+.'/,*,'9&(M

o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$-/;;-&0Q.$3/5)$)&5$/5/AO).9$.AA(;).$.1$L-')1-/1(&5$.1$20-(1$T$0.$)'S.1$M$

^$4.$X'.$5&')$+&51-.51$EDDDF$A.)$.AA(;).)$3' $F&3#&2'4$%1"C"E-&;$ 0U.)19$Z(.5$)i-9$A/$

L(A(/1(&5$3'$+2A&3-/+.$/V.0$A.$1-/W(X'.$h$+/()$/'))($T$X'.A$;&(51$AU.AA(;).$.)19$&'1-.$

)&5$-jA.$5/--/1(L$L&501(&55.A9$'5.$L(W'-.$3.$AU(51.--';1(&59$3.$A/$)/1()L/01(&5$S/+/()$

/11.(51.$h$'5.$L(W'-.$3&51$AU&ZS.01(L$A.$;A')$)(+;A.9$A.$;A')$;-(+(1(L9$.)1$3U.51-.1.5(- $

0Q.s $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ A. $+&'V.+.51 $3. $32)(-9 $ A.X'.A $ A. $ L/(1 $/);(-.- $T $ A/ $ L&() $T $ A/$

;-&A&5W/1(&5$(532L(5(.$3'$-20(1$.1$T$)/$0&50A')(&5$1&'S&'-)$-.0'A2.D$BU&[$A/$L/0(A(12$

/V.0 $ A/X'.AA. $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $3' $+2A&3-/+. $/00.;1. $ A.) $8$??N '&1("1%0$ A.) $;A')$

-/;(3.+.51$.R;23(2)9$O$0&+;-()$0.'R$X'(9$0&++.$0.A'($3'$F&3#&2'4$%1"C"E-&9$)&51$

'5$/LL-&51$T$)&5$(51.AA(W.50.9$3'$+&+.51$X'U(A)$/;/().51$A/$L(,V-.$X'.$A.$320&';/W.$

.AA(;1(X'.$/$.51-.1.5'.$1&'1$/'$A&5W$3'$L(A+D>b_$

$#($A/$;-.+(,-.$L&501(&5$3.$AU.AA(;).$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$21/(1$3.$1/(AA.-$A/$+/1(,-.$3.$A/$V(.$;&'-$.5$

L/(-.$)&-1(-$AU&)9$A/$0&A&55.$V.-12Z-/A.9$.AA.$0&5)1(1'.$2W/A.+.51$'5$+&O.5$5/--/1(L$3.$;-&3'(-.$3.)$

2+&1(&5)$0Q.s$A.$);.01/1.'-D$%/$L-')1-/1(&5$.1$AU(5)20'-(12$X'.$320-(1$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$)&51$3.)$

+&1(L)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$X'($1-/V/(AA.51$A.$);.01/1.'-9$A.$L&51$;/)).-$;/-$1&'1.)$A.)$0-/(51.)$.1$;/-$1&')$A.) $

.);&(-)D $ %. $ 1-/V/(A $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ .)1 $ 3. $ L/(-. $ ;/)).- $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ 3. $ A/ $ L-')1-/1(&5 $ /' $ 32)(-9$

.51-.1.5/51$)/5)$0.)).$).)$;.'-)$;&'-$AU/+.5.-$T$-.)).51(-$1&'S&'-)$3/V/51/W.$3U2+&1(&5)D$

( :"#,#'22)"+2;'$(/-1"'./+<1+(8)-.#.)1"

%/$;-.+(,-.$.R;2-(.50.$L&-1.$X'.$L/(1$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.$+2A&3-/+.9$0U.)1$0.AA.$3'$0Q&0$3.$

AU.AA(;).D$%U.AA(;).$.)1 $1&'1 $3U/Z&-3$'5$0Q&0$.5$)&(D $o/0X'.)$:'+&51$ A/ $320-(1 $0&++.$'5$-/;;&-1$

/51(5/1'-.A$T$5&1-.$;.-0.;1(&5$3.$A/$1.+;&-/A(12$&'$.50&-.$^$'5.$V(&A.50.$L/(1.$/'$1.+;)>I_D$#/5)$X'.$

A.$);.01/1.'-$5U.5$;.-\&(V.$0&5)0(.++.51$A.$0/-/01,-.$Z-'1/A9$(A$)U/W(1$3U'5.$0&';.9$3U'5.$-';1'-.D$

>b "/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;DJb

>I "/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$

Page 25: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

='()X'.$A/$V(.$/V/50.$3.$+/5(,-.$A(52/(-.9$AU2X'(V/A.51$^$5/1'-.A$_$3.$AU.AA(;).$;&'--/(1$)U/;;/-.51.-$T $

'5. $5'(1 $ 3. $ )&++.(AD $d5. $;.1(1. $+&-19 $ 3&509 $ '5. $ (50&5)0(.50.9 $ A/ $ ;.-1. $ 3' $ 0&51-jA. $ .1 $ 3. $ A/ $

;.-0.;1(&5D $ aA $.)1 $.)).51(.A $3. $3()1(5W'.- $3.'R$.AA(;).) $X'( $5U&51 $;/) $ A/ $+f+.$Z-'1/A(12 $;&'- $ A.$

);.01/1.'-D$%U.AA(;).$^$321.-+(52.$_9$3()1(5W'2.$;/-$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$3.$AU.AA(;).$^$(5321.-+(52.$_$

.)1$)i-.+.51$+&(5)$Z-'1/A.$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-$M$A.$;.-)&55/W.$0&++.50.$T$+&51.-$'5$.)0/A(.-$.1$(A$A.$

-.1-&'V.$(++23(/1.+.51$/;-,)$A/$0&';.9$/--(V/51$)'-$A.$;/A(.-D$%.$);.01/1.'-$5.$V(1$;/)$3.$)'-;-().9$A/$

0&';. $ 0&50.-5. $ '5 $ 2A2+.51 $ X'U(A $ 323'(1 $ 3. $ +/5(,-. $ 1-,) $ 5/1'-.AA.9 $ )/5) $ V(&A.50.D $ %U.AA(;).$

^(5321.-+(52._$/'$0&51-/(-.9$5.$5&')$3&55.$;/)$3U(53(0/1(&5$)'-$A.$1.+;)$20&'A2D$!AA.$5&')$/--/0Q.$

3U'5$+&+.51$3.$AUQ()1&(-.$;&'-$5&')$;-20(;(1.-$3/5)$'5$/'1-.9$1&'1$T$L/(1$3(LL2-.51D$aA$5.$).-/$;/)$

;&))(ZA.$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.$321.-+(5.-$0&+Z(.5$3.$1.+;)$/$;/))2$;/-$A.$).'A$Z(/()$3.$A/$0&';.D$4.$

).-/$A/$)&++.$3U(53(0.$X'($).-/$3())2+(52.$3/5)$A.$L(A+$X'($A'($;.-+.11-/$E&'$5&5F$3.$0&55/n1-.$A.$

1.+;)$20&'A2D$

%.$+2A&3-/+.$-/LL&A.$3.$0.)$)/'1.)$3/5)$A.$1.+;)9$3.$0.)$Z&53)$);.01/0'A/(-.)$.1$V(&A.51)D$

%.$);.01/1.'-$5U.)1$;/)$/+.52$;-&W-.))(V.+.51$T$V(V-.$A.)$)(1'/1(&5)$/V.0$A.$;.-)&55/W.$;-(50(;/A9$

+/()$T$O$f1-.$)&'3/(5$0&5L-&512D$aA$.)1 $/+.52$T$f1-.$)'-;-()9$0Q&X'29$2+'$;/-$0.)$0Q/5W.+.51)$

Z-'1/'R9$X'($A'($L&51$-.)).51(-$A.)$Z&'A.V.-).+.51)$3.$A/$V(.$0&++.$3.)$0Q/5W.+.51)$/-Z(1-/(-.)D$%.$

);.01/1.'-$/$3&50$1&'1.)$A.)$-/()&5)$3Uf1-.$/5R(.'R$;'()X'.$A.)$)(1'/1(&5)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$5.$3'-.51$

S/+/() $ A&5W1.+;) $ h $ .AA.) $ 5U.R()1.51 $ X'. $ ;&'- $ f1-. $ (++23(/1.+.51 $ 321-'(1.)9 $ .1 $ -.+;A/02.) $ ;/-$

3U/'1-.)D$%.$);.01/1.'-$3&(1$L/(-.$;-.'V.$3U'5.$/3/;1/1(&5$)(+(A/(-.$T$0.AA.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$%&(5$

3Uf1-.$/00&+;/W52$1&'1$/'$A&5W$3'$0Q.+(59$(A$V(1$A/$-';1'-.$3.$AU.AA(;).$0&++.$'5$1-/'+/1()+.D$4/-$

A/$;-.+(,-.$A.\&5$X'U/;;-.53$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$X'.$1&'1$0.$X'($.)1$;.'1$T$1&'1$+&+.51$

3();/-/n1-.D$%/$).0&53.9$0U.)1$X'.$0.$X'($3();/-/n19$3();/-/n1$3/5)$A/$0&';.D$

:' $ 1.+;) $ 3' $ +'.19 $ A/ $ 0&';. $ .AA.*+f+. $ .)1 $ )'LL()/51. $ ;&'- $ S')1(L(.- $ 5U(+;&-1. $ X'.A$

-.1&'-5.+.51 $ 3. $ )(1'/1(&5D $ o/0X'.A(5. $ "/0/0Q. $ .R;A(X'. $ X'.! "#$""%&'$ ! ()*+,%'$ ! -$..$ ! ()/$0'$!

1!'0'&$2'%+2!*+"+2.)%,$ !3$ ! ") !-,+4)2-$!5!67%""%28!'0'&$2'%+2!+( !3%'9$"%$(: !;0%< !'$"+2!")!-,%.%;0$!

"%..=,)%,$!)28"+>')?+22$<!-+23%.%+22$!"#%2*$'.%''$/$2.!30!"$-.$0,!6'&$-.).$0,:!3)2'!")!@-.%+2A !5BC!

d5$)(+;A.$0/-1&5$;.'1$)'LL(-.$T$-/0&51.-$A.)$-.1&'-5.+.51)$A.)$;A')$/Z-';1)$M$3/5)$78&'P"(9$A/$+,-.$

L/(1$L&-1'5.$A.$1.+;)$3U'5$0/-1&5$.1$3U'5$;A/5$A/$+&51-/51$.51&'-2.$3.$LA.'-)$3/5)$'5.$-(0Q.$0Q/+Z-.$

3UQj1.AD $ #/5) $ )/V&(- $ 0&++.519 $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ /00.;1. $ 0. $ Z&'A.V.-).+.51 $ .R1-/&-3(5/(-. $ )/5) $ A.$

X'.)1(&55.-$M$3/5)$A/$+.)'-.$&[$'5$1.A$0Q/5W.+.51$.)1$;&))(ZA.$3/5)$A.)$b$/5)$X'U/'-/$3'-2$AU.AA(;).9$

(A$.)1$/+.52$T$AU/00.;1.-D$

>J "/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;DJ?

Page 26: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

B,)$A&-)9$A/$-';1'-.$.)1$A.$A(.'$;-(V(A2W(2$3.$1&'1.)$A.)$/V/502.)$3.$AUQ()1&(-.D$%.$0Q/;(1-/W.$

;.-+.1$3.$-.A/50.-$'5$5&'V./'$+&+.51$3.$AUQ()1&(-.$h$3/5)$+,-),-9$A.$0Q/5W.+.51$3U/01.$A/$-.5V&(.$

0Q/X'.$L&()$T$3.)$)(1'/1(&5)$;A')$32W-/3/51.)$.1$;A')$(5Le+.)D$%.)$L(A+)$T$2;()&3.)$/;;&-1.51$3/5)$

0Q/0'5.$3.$A.'-)$;/-1(.)$3.)$3();/-(1(&5)$.1$3.)$0Q/5W.+.51)$h$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.';/-1(.$3>.-a(&)/'(&)$

4,12$%1&09 $C/&$0Q&()(1 $.51-.$).)$3.'R$;-21.53/51) $ A. $;A')$L&-1'52$3.)$3.'RD $%U/'1-.9 $32).);2-29$

X'(11.$A/$V(AA.D$B/5)$A/$3.'R(,+.9$C/&$/$3(V&-02$3.$)&5$+/-($.1$/$.'$'5$L(A)$3&51$.AA.$).$-.1-&'V. $

)2;/-2.9$1/53()$X'.$)&5$/50(.5$;-21.53/51$/$2W/A.+.51$L&532$'5.$L/+(AA.$.1$.)1$1&+Z2$+/A/3.$3'$

0/50.-D$%U.AA(;).$A&5W'.$.)1 $A.$+&+.51$;-(V(A2W(2$;&'-$-.3()1-(Z'.-$ A.)$0/-1.)D$c'U(A$)U/W()).$3U'5$

Z&'A.V.-).+.51 $ ;&A(1(X'. $ &' $Q()1&-(X'. $ M $ A. $ 3&01.'- $ o(V/W& $ -.1-&'V/51 $ )/ $+/W5(L(X'. $ 3.+.'-.$

&00';2. $ /;-,) $ A/ $ -2V&A'1(&5 $ )&0(/A()1. $ h $ '5 $ Z&'A.V.-).+.51 $ 3/5) $ AU2X'(A(Z-. $ 3U'5. $ -.A/1(&5$M $ A.$

;/))/W.$3.$A/$-.50&51-.$3.)$3.'R$/+&'-.'R$3.)'O,3&0'#&:&))&09$T$'5$0&';A.$X'($).$Q/(19$).$3();'1/51$

3/5)$'5.$V&(1'-.D$4.$).-/$)&')$A/$L&-+.$3U'5$LA/)QZ/0`'3/5)$)>.-#,#&$6$+/()$0U.)1$A/$+f+.$(32.$6$

AU/;;/-(1(&5$3U'5$0&';A.$2;/5&'(9$1-/V/(AA/51$/V.0$S&(.$3/5)$A.)$0Q/+;)9$/V/51$3.$-.1-&'V.-$3/5)$A.$

;-2).51$3'$L(A+9$A.$+f+.$Q&++.$V&'A/51$1'.-$)/$L.++.D$%/$)2-(.$'1(A().$0.$+f+.$-.))&-1$;&'-$L/(-. $

/V/50.-$AU/01(&5D$!51-.$3.'R$2;()&3.)9$&'$+(.'R$.51-.$3.'R$)/()&5)9$A.)$)025/-()1.)$&51$1&'1.)$A.)$

A(Z.-12)$3.$L/(-.$Z/)0'A.-$A/$V(.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3/5)$'5$).5)$&'$3/5)$AU/'1-.D$%/$).'A.$A(+(1.9$&5$AU/$

V'9$).-/$3.$W/-3.-$'5.$0&Q2-.50.$;-&;-.$/'$+&1.'-$.1$/'R$0/-/012-()1(X'.)$3'$;.-)&55/W.D'B/5)'F"Q'

5&&2'W1(&#9$ A.$;/))/W.$3.$A/$)/()&5$7$T$A/$)/()&5$@$L/(1$;/)).-$"/1.$3.$S.'5.$A(Z.-1/(-.$T$A/$V(.$

).R'.AA.$3())&A'.$T$;,-.$3.$L/+(AA.$/(+/51 $.1 $-.);&5)/ZA.D$%.$;.-)&55/W.$-.)1/51$0&Q2-.519 $(A $).$

A/)).-/$L(5/A.+.51$3.$)/$V(.$-/5W2.D

:'*3.AT$3.$A/$)/W.$3(V()(&5$.5$;/-1(.)9$AU.AA(;).$).$WA()).$;/-1&'1D$!AA.$;.'1$)'-W(-$3/5)$A/$

+&(53-.$0&';.9$+/()$/'))($3/5)$A/$+&(53-.$)2X'.50.$X'($5.$L/)).$;/)$/;;/-/n1-.$'5$;.-)&55/W.D$d5$

;.1(1$W/-\&5$X'.$S.$0&55/()$/V/(1$.51.53'$3(-.$X'.$A/$+,-.$3.$=$4:"$+&'-/(1$1'2.$;/-$'5$0Q/)).'-$

/V/51 $3. $V&(- $ A. $ L(A+D $%&-)X'U(A $ A. $ -.W/-3/ $;&'- $ A/ $ ;-.+(,-. $ L&()9 $ (A $ 0&++.5\/ $ T $ )U/W(1.- $ .1 $ T$

3.+/53.-$&[$21/(1$A/$+/+/5$3.$</+Z($ 0Q/X'.$L&()$X'.$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3();/-/())/(1$Q&-)*0Q/+;9$

S')X'UT$0.$X'U.5L(59$.AA.$V(.55.$T$+&'-(-D$4.11.$(51'(1(&5$1-,)$;-.+(,-.$3'$);.01/1.'-$3.$0(52+/$.)1$

1&'1$T$L/(1$0.51-/A.$3/5)$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$h$AU.AA(;).$).$A&W.$2W/A.+.51$3/5)$1&'1$0.$

X'.$5.$V&(1$;/)$A.$);.01/1.'-$.1$0.$X'U(A$5.$V&(1$;/)$/$1&'1.)$A.)$0Q/50.)$3Uf1-.$.5$3/5W.-D$B/5)$A.)$

3.'R$V.-)(&5)$3'$F&3#&2'!$%1"C"E-&9$0U.)1$;.53/51$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$.)1$&00';2$T$V&(-$'5.$/'1-.$A(W5.$

5/--/1(V.$).$32V.A&;;.-$X'.$).$L.-/$A/$+&-1$3'$;,-.$h$3/5)$A/$V.-)(&5$3.$o&Q5$PD$#1/QA9$0.$).-/$

;.53/51$A.)$-.1-&'V/(AA.)$3.$A/$L.++.$3'$3&01.'-$.1$3.$)/$Z.AA.*L(AA.$h$.AA.)$/;;-.53-&519$A/$)2X'.50.$

3U/;-,)9$.5$/--(V/51$T$AUQj;(1/A9$A/$1.--(ZA.$5&'V.AA.D$B/5)$A/$V.-)(&5$3.$B&'WA/)$#(-`9$0U.)1$3'-/51$

AU/00(3.51$3.$<&ZZO$P.--(0`9$X'(9$A'(9$)'-V(V-/9$X'.$).$32-&'A.-/$AU/00(3.51$3'$;,-.D$

Page 27: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

B/5)$3U/'1-.)$0/)9$0U.)1$A/$0&';.$).'A.$X'($.)1$A.$+&+.51$3.$Z/)0'A.9$3.$A/$3();/-(1(&5$.1$3.$A/$

+&-1D$c'/539$1&'S&'-)$3/5)$A.$F&3#&2'!$%1"C"E-&;$A/$S.'5.$V.'V.$;.-3$A/$V'.$h$0U.)1$2W/A.+.51$3/5)$

A.$1.+;)$3.$AU.AA(;).D$aA$/))()1.$T$AU/00(3.519$+/()$5U.5$/;;-.53-/$X'U.5)'(1.$A/$0&5)2X'.50.$1-/W(X'.9$

3/5)$'5.$)2X'.50.$T$AUQj;(1/A9$&[$A.)$+23.0(5)$/55&50.51$X'U.AA.$.)1$/V.'WA.D$%.)$0Q'1.)$-2;212.)$

3U.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&12$h$0Q'1.)$T$0Q.V/A9$0Q'1.$3/5)$AU.)0/A(.-$&'$2V/5&'()).+.51$3.$P2A/5(.9$

L&501(&55.-&51$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.D$%.$0&-;)$(5/5(+2$X'.$V&(1$A.$);.01/1.'-$5.$)'LL(1$;/)$T$0&50A'-.$

)'-$A.'-$+&-1$h$(A$L/'3-/$+&51-.-$AU.51.--.+.519$A.$3(/W5&)1(09$A/$;-.'V.$3'$320,)$/'$);.01/1.'-$;&'-$

X'U(A$AU/00.;1.$0&++.$1.AD$%.$+&+.51$3.$A/$+&-1$-2)(3.$3&50$3/5)$AU.AA(;).$h$/V/51$.AA.9$1&'1$.)1 $

.50&-. $ ;&))(ZA.9 $ A/ $ -2+())(&5 $ -.)1. $ '5. $ /A1.-5/1(V. $ h $ /;-,) $ .AA.9 $ A/ $+&-1 $ / $ 32ST $ .' $ A(.'9 $ .1 $ A.$

;.-)&55/W.$.)1$0.11.$L&()$L/0.$T$'5$0/3/V-.9$'5.$1&+Z.$&'$'5.$0&'-&55.$L'52-/(-.D$

%.$);.01/1.'-$/$3&50$Z(.5$-/()&5$3.$0-/(53-.$AU.AA(;).$h$.AA.$;.'1$1&'1$-.+.11-.$.5$0/').9$;&'-$

A.$+.(AA.'-$0&++.$;&'-$A.$;(-.D$t$0Q/X'.$-';1'-.9$1&'1$.)1$T$S&'.-$h$0U.)1$3/5)$A/$+&(53-.$0&';.$X'. $

A.$3.)1(5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;.'1$Z/)0'A.-D$=/-A/51$3'$L(A+$+$'C"K*#&'($10')&'0$1%9$3.$y/s/59$"/0/0Q.$

320-(1 $X'. $^ $A.) $.AA(;).) $)&'3/(5.) $ (5X'(,1.51 $)/5) $-.Ae0Q.$ A. $ -20(1 $_$ h $.1 $2V&X'.$ A/ $V&A&512$3'$

-2/A()/1.'-$3. $^$;-.53-.$/'$32;&'-V'$A.$);.01/1.'-$1&'S&'-)$/'R$/W'.1)D $_ $C-/V/(AA.-$A/$L-')1-/1(&59$

1-/V/(AA.-$A/$;.'-9$W-e0.$T$AU.AA(;).$X'(9$.5$+/5(;'A/51$3.)$+&+.51)$3.$52/51$.1$3.$V(3.9$;.'1$A.$+(.'R $

A/()).-$/'$);.01/1.'-$AU.);/0.$3.$;-&S.1.-$).)$;-&;-.)$0-/(51.)D$=/-0.$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$5.$V&(1$;/)$

1&'19$(A$;.'1$0-/(53-.$.1$32)(-.-D$".$;/)$)/V&(-$0.$X'($).$0/0Q.$3.--(,-.$AU.AA(;).9$0U.)1$T$0&';$)i- $

;-&V&X'.-$A/$;-&S.01(&5$3'$);.01/1.'-$1&'1$.5$.5$;-2).-V/51$AU(512W-(12D$

( :"#,#'22)"+2)+</('"+<1+(8)-.#.)1"

aA$5UO$/$;/)$3.$L-')1-/1(&5$)/5)$32)(-$.1$AU.AA(;).$).-1$2W/A.+.51$T$0&5)1-'(-.$'5$-/;;&-1$3.$

;-&W-.))(&5$.1$3U.5V(.$3'$);.01/1.'-$;&'-$0.$X'($.)1$.5$1-/(5$3.$).$;/)).-9$.5$20Q&$T$0.$X'.$V(1$A. $

;.-)&55/W.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$S&'.$)'-$AU(50&5)0(.51$3'$);.01/1.'-D$aA$0-2.$0.)$Z2/50.)$&[$1&'1$.)1$T$

0-/(53-.9 $ +/() $ &[ $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ ;.'1 $ 2W/A.+.51 $ WA()).- $ ).) $ L/51/)+.)9 $ ).) $ 32)(-)9 $ )/ $ ;-&;-.$

.R;2-(.50. $V20'.D $#( $ A. $+2A&3-/+. $/ $X'.AX'. $0Q&). $3. $ L/+(A(.- $ .1 $5&') $;/-A. $3. $5&) $;-&;-.)$

.R;2-(.50.)9 $ 5&') $ ;.-+.1 $ 3. $ 5&') $ -.0&55/n1-. $ )/5) $ 0.)). $ 3/5) $ A.) $ )(1'/1(&5) $ V20'.) $ ;/- $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)9$0U.)1$2W/A.+.51$;/-0.$X'U(A$A/()).$'5$.);/0.9$3.)$L/(AA.)9$&[$A.$);.01/1.'-$;.'1$V.5(-$).$

;-&S.1.-$.1$)U/;;-&;-(.-$A.$3.)1(5$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$20-(1$M

^$Pf+.$)( $ A.)$.AA(;).) $ 1.+;&-.AA.)$/Z)&-Z.51 $3.) $ (+/W.) $*"0":)&4&12 '$:0&12&09$

0.AA.)*0($)&51$;-2).51.)9$3U'5.$;-2).50.$T$A/$L&()$;-20().$.1$V/W'.9$)(A.50(.').$.1$

Page 28: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;&'-1/51$2+&'V/51.9$3/5)$A/$X'/1-(,+.$3(+.5)(&5$3'$Q&-)*1.+;)9$)/5)$A/X'.AA.$A.$

L(A+$5U.)1$T$;-&;-.+.51$;/-A.-$X'.$AU&+Z-.$3.$A'(*+f+.D$#($A.$-20(1$L(A+(X'.$;.'1*

f1-.$/))(+(A2$T$'5.$(51.AA(W.50.x0&5)0(.50.$.5$/01(&59$A.$Q&-)*1.+;)$.)1$T$A/$L&()$

)&5$ (+/W(5/(-. $.1 $)&5$ (50&5)0(.51 $ M $T $0. $ 1(1-. $ (A $ -.+23(. $T $ A/ $ L&() $/'R$0&';.)$

L(01(V.)$.1 $/'R$0&';.)$-2.AA.)9 $/'R$(+/W.)$;-2*$.1 $/'1&0.5)'-2.$E(+/W.)$S/+/()$

L(A+2.)F$.1$/'R$(+/W.)$)';;-(+2.)$)&')$X'.AX'.$;-21.R1.$X'.$0.$)&(1D>G$_$

%U(3.51(L(0/1(&5$/'$;.-)&55/W.$.1$A/$;-&S.01(&5$3'$);.01/1.'-$3/5)$A/$A'11.$X'U(A$+,5.$;&'-$/0023.-$T$

).) $32)(-) $ ). $ L&51 $3&509 $ (50&5)0(.++.519 $T $ 1-/V.-) $ A.) $.AA(;).)D $!AA.) $0&5)1(1'.51 $'5 $.);/0. $&[$

AU(+/W(5/(-.$3'$);.01/1.'-$.)1$A(Z-.$*$Z(.5$X'.$L&-1.+.51$(5LA'.502$;/-0.$X'($)UO$;/)).$/V/51$.1$/;-,)$* $

3. $0-2.- $ )/$;-&;-. $)2X'.50.D $%. $;Q25&+,5. $5U.)1 $;/) $0&5)0(.51 $;&'- $ A. $ );.01/1.'-$M $ A. $ L(A+$).$

;&'-)'(19$5.$A.$A/())/51$;/)$/V&(-$A.$1.+;)$3.$-fV.-$/'R$;&))(ZA.)$3.$AU.AA(;).D$=&'-1/519$.AA.$V(.53-/$

0-2.-$'5$(+/W(5/(-.$LA&11/519$(+;/A;/ZA.9$X'($.51&'-.-/$A.$L(A+$.1$A/$-.A/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$

%/$;/))(&5$/+&'-.').

%/ $;/))(&5 $/+&'-.').9 $Z(.5 $ )i-9 $ .)1 $ AU'5. $3.) $ A(W5.) $5/--/1(V.) $X'( $V(.53-&51 $ )U/3-.)).-$

3(-.01.+.51$/'$32)(-$3'$);.01/1.'-D$%U(3.51(L(0/1(&5$O$.)1$2V(3.51.$;&'-$AU'5(V.-)/A(12$.1$A/$L&-0.$3'$

).51(+.51$/+&'-.'RD$%U.AA(;).9$;A')$X'.$S/+/()9$;.-+.1$3.$A/()).-$A.$);.01/1.'-$O$;-&S.1.-$)&5$;-&;-.$

V20'9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$3.$W/-3.-$(51/01.9$;/-L/(1.9$A/$-.A/1(&5$;/))(&55.AA.$.1$-&+/5.)X'.$0&5)1-'(1.$

;/-$A.$+2A&3-/+.D$4/-$)($AU&5$&Z).-V.$A.)$W-/53.)$(3OAA.)$3'$W.5-.9$(A$).$1-&'V.$X'U.AA.)$).$;/)).519$A.$

;A') $ )&'V.51 $ 3/5) $ A/ $ 0&';. $ 3. $ AU.AA(;).D $ %. $+2A&3-/+. $ 5&') $ /;;-.53 $ X'. $ ;&'- $ ;-2).-V.- $ A.$

-&+/5.)X'.$3U'5.$;/))(&59$)/$;'-.12$.1$)&5$/);.01$/Z)&A'9$(A$).-/$Z(.5$;A')$.LL(0/0.$3.$5U.5$-(.5$

+&51-.-D$

aA $ O $/ $3U/Z&-3 $ A. $0/) $3.) $;/))(&5) $ (+;&))(ZA.)9 $X'( $5U/'-&51 $;/) $ A(.'D $ aA $5. $ )U/W(1 $;/) $T$

;-&;-.+.51$;/-A.-$3U.AA(;).)$;'()X'.$0.11.$;/))(&5$5.$).-/$V20'.$X'.$0&++.$'5.$;-&S.01(&5$;/-$A. $

;.-)&55/W.D $ =&'-1/51 $ 0U.)1 $ 0.AA. $ X'( $ ;-&V&X'.9 $ )/5) $ 3&'1. $ A. $ ;A')9 $ A. $ ).51(+.51 $ 3. $ 32)(- $ 3'$

);.01/1.'-D$aA$).$-.1-&'V.9$0&++.$A.$;.-)&55/W.9$3/5)$A/$;&)(1(&5$3.$);20'A.-$)'-$A.)$;&))(ZA.)$3U'5$

1.A $ /+&'- $ h $ (A $ 5. $;.'1 $ X'U(+/W(5.- $ 0. $X'. $3&55.-/(1 $ A/ $ -.A/1(&5 $ )( $ .AA. $ /V/(1 $ '5. $ 0Q/50.D $4.)$

);20'A/1(&5)$)&51$)&'V.51$(51-&3'(1.)$;/-$3.)$2A2+.51)$3'$L(A+$M$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$2V&X'.51$'5$/V.5(-$

.5).+ZA.$X'( $&'V-(-/ $'5$;&))(ZA.$3/5) $AU'5(V.-)$3'$L(A+$.1$X'($ L.-/$ L&501(&55.-$ AU(+/W(5/(-.$3'$

);.01/1.'-D $!1 $)( $:;-(A $.1 $]-/5`$;/-1/(.51 $;&'- $=/-()9 $0&++.$(A) $;-&S.1/(.51 $3.$A. $ L/(-. $3,)$ A.'-$

+/-(/W.$k$!1$)($#0/-A.11$.1$:)QA.O$)U.5L'O/(.51$/'$P.R(X'.9$0&++.$.AA.$A.$;-&;&).$(5)(3(.').+.51$k$

>G "/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;DJ?

Page 29: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%.$);.01/1.'-$;/-1/W.$/A&-)$3.$+/5(,-.$+(+21(X'.$A.)$32)(-)$3'$;.-)&55/W.9 $1&'1$.5$O$;-&S.1/51$

2V(3.++.51$A.)$)(.5)$;-&;-.)D$t$X'&($-.)).+ZA.-/(1$0.$V&O/W.$T$=/-()$&'$T$P.R(0&$k$4Q/0'5$O$

-2;&53$.5$L&501(&5$3.$)/$;-&;-.$.R;2-(.50.9$T$0&++.50.-$;/-$)U(A$.)1$32ST$/AA2$3/5)$'5.$3.$0.)$3.'R$

V(AA.)D$

=A')$L-/;;/51.)$)&51$A.)$+/5(,-.)$X'U/$A.$+2A&3-/+.$3.$1-/(1.-$A.)$;/))(&5)$X'($).$32-&'A.51$

A. $ 1.+;)$3'$ L(A+D $%.)$ (3OAA.) $3();/-/()).51 $ L(5/A.+.51 $ A. $;A') $0A/(- $3'$ 1.+;)$3/5) $ A.)$.AA(;).)D$

4&++.$A/$;/))(&5$)U21.(51$3/5)$'5$0&';A.$/;-,)$)Uf1-.$-2V.(AA2)$1&')$A.)$+/1(5)$AU'5$T$0j12$3.$AU/'1-.9$

A.$0(52+/$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$1-/V/(AA.$A.)$Q()1&(-.)$3U/+&'-$.5$-2V2A/51$A.$+&(5)$;&))(ZA.$A.)$20Q/5W.)$

3. $3.'R $/+/51)9 $ .1 $ .5 $ A/())/51 $ L&501(&55.- $ AU(+/W(5/1(&5 $3' $ );.01/1.'-D $ aA $ O $ / $ AU(3OAA. $ 3&51 $ &5$

5U.51.53-/$).'A.+.51$;/-A.-$M$A/$;-.+(,-.$Q()1&(-.$/+&'-.').$.51-.$A.$B&01.'-$o(V/W&$.1$%/-/$5.$).-/ $

X'U2V&X'2.9$/'$+&+.51$3.$A.'-$)2;/-/1(&5$T$A/$L(5$3.$A/$W'.--.D$B/5)$d&:&33$9$)/5)$X'.$).$5/--.$A/$

;/))(&5$.51-.$P/R(+.$3.$z(51.-$.1$)/$;-.+(,-.$L.++.9$r(10Q&0`$5&')$L.-/$0-&(-.$T$'5.$Q()1&(-.$

3U/+&'- $ .R0.;1(&55.AA. $ .51-. $ .'RD $ %U/3+(-/1(&5 $ 3.) $ 3&+.)1(X'.)9 $ A/ $ L(5.)). $ 3.) $ 1&(A.11.) $ X'.$

320&'V-.$A/$5&'V.AA.$P/3/+.$3.$z(51.-9$AU&Z)1(5/1(&5$+'1(X'.$3.$P/R(+.$).-&51$/'1/51$3U(53(0.)$

X'($L.-&51$(+/W(5.-$T$AUQ2-&{5.9$.1$/'$);.01/1.'-$'5.$;/))(&5$W-/53(&).$.51-.$A.)$3.'R$2;&'RD$aA$5U.5$

).-/$2V(3.++.51$-(.59 $.1 $P/R(+.$3.$z(51.- $ -2V2A.-/ $ A/ $V2-(1/ZA. $5/1'-.$3.$)/$-.A/1(&5$/V.0 $ A/$

32L'51.9$+.11/51$L(5$T$AU(+/W.$5&'--(.$;/-$A.)$32)(-)$3'$);.01/1.'-$3.;'()$A.$32Z'1$3'$L(A+D$

aA$O$/$.5)'(1.$AU(3OAA.$3&51$A.$);.01/1.'-$5.$V.--/$X'U'5.$(+/W.$h$0.$5U.)1$;/)$A/$;/-&A.$&'$A.) $

(53(0.)$A/())2)$3/5)$A.$L(A+$X'($).-&51$A.$;&(51$3.$32;/-1$3.$AU(+/W(5/(-.$3'$);.01/1.'-9$+/()$'5.$

V(W5.11.$&'$'5.$)2X'.50.9$'5$(5)1/51$)');.53'$X'($V(.53-/$)O+Z&A().-$'5.$-.A/1(&5$3.$L2A(0(12D$aA$

)U/W(-/$3&50$3.$0Q&()(-$/V.0$;-20()(&5$0.11.$(+/W.9$X'($T$.AA.$).'A.9$(53(X'.-/$/'$);.01/1.'-$3/5)$

X'.AA.$3(-.01(&5$;-&S.1.-$)&5$(+/W.$3'$Z&5Q.'-D$4.$)&51$ A.)$LA/)QZ/0`)$3'$0&';A.$3. $)>.-#,#&'a'

Z&5Q.'-$0Q/+;f1-.$*9$0.A'($3'$0&';A.$3.$g$0$:)$13$$6$)'(1.$3.$Z/AA/3.)$;/-()(.55.)$*9$3.) $O,3&0'

#&:&))&0 ' a 'AU.R0(1/1(&5 $3.) $;-&S.1) $.5).+ZA. $ * $&' $.50&-. $ A/ $ )&-1(. $3. $P+.$P'(- $.1 $3' $ L/51j+.$

1.53-.+.51$.5A/02)$V.-)$'5.$;&-1.$&'V.-1.$)'-$'5$+&53.$3.$5'/W.D$%/$;/))(&5$)U(50/-5.$.5$'5.$

(+/W.9 $ 3. $ ;.'- $ X'U.AA. $ 5. $ )U2;'(). $ .5 $ 3/V/51/W.9 $ .1 $ 0.11. $ (+/W. $ 3&(1 $ 1&'1 $ 0&50.51-.-9 $ 3&55.-$

AU(51.5)(12$3U'5.$;/))(&5$.51(,-.D

%.)$;/))(&5)$X'U(A$L/'3-/$L/(-.$3'-.-$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$/'-&51$Z./'$f1-.$3/V/51/W.$32V.A&;;2.)9$

&5$1.51.-/$2W/A.+.51$3U.5$+&51-.-$A.$+&(5)$;&))(ZA.D$B/5)$.$:#"&C'&13,12&#9$A/$V&(R*&LL$;-.53$'5.$

;A/0.$1-,)$(+;&-1/51.$;&'-$0&51.-$A.)$+&+.51)$3.$-.50&51-.$3.)$3.'R$;.-)&55/W.)$h$;A'1j1$X'.$3.$A.$

+&51-.-9$+(.'R$V/'1$A.$-/0&51.-D$%.$);.01/1.'-$V.--/$A.$0&';A.$).$;-&+.5.-9$-(-.9$).$;/-A.-$)'-$'5 $

;.1(1$;&519$+/()$(A$5U.5$.51.53-/$;/)$A/$0&5V.-)/1(&5D$Y/-.)$).-&51$A.)$20Q/5W.)$/'RX'.A)$&5$/))()1.-/$

Page 30: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

-2.AA.+.519$T$;/-1$A.'-)$3()0'))(&5)$)'-$AU/V.5(-$X'U(A)$&51$.5).+ZA.9$.)).51(.AA.)$T$AUQ()1&(-.D$B/5)$

d&:&33$9$3.$+f+.9$A/$-.50&51-.$.51-.$P/R(+.$3.$z(51.-$.1$)/$L'1'-.$L.++.$).-/$-2)'+2.$T$1-,)$;.'$

3.$0Q&).)9$&5$A.)$V.--/9$-.V.5/51$3'$1.55()9$A/$S.'5.$L(AA.$)U2+.-V.(AA/51$3.$0.)$3.-5(.-)$S&'-)$;/))2)$

.5).+ZA.9$+/()$3.)$S&'-)$.'R*+f+.)9$A.$);.01/1.'-$5U.5$W/-3.-/$L(5/A.+.51$X'U'5$1-,)$Z-.L$/;.-\'D$

4. $ X'( $ /'-/ $ 3.'R $ 0&5)2X'.50.)$M $ A'( $ L/(-. $ ;-&S.1.- $ '5. $ A(/()&5 $ -&+/51(X'. $ .51-. $ A.) $ 3.'R$

;.-)&55/W.)9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$W/-3.-$1&'1$A.$+O)1,-.$X'($.51&'-.$P/R(+.$3.$z(51.-D$

%. $ 0A(+/R $ 3. $ A/ $ ;/))(&5 $ /+&'-.').9 $ 0U.)1 $ 2V(3.++.51 $ AU'5(&5 $ 0Q/-5.AA. $ 3.) $ 3.'R$

;.-)&55/W.)D$%.$0&3.$r/O)$.1$A/$+&-/A.$3.)$/552.)$b8$L.-&51$3.$A/$3())(+'A/1(&5$3.$AU/01.$).R'.A$

'5.$-,WA.$+f+.$3.$A/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$/'$0(52+/D$aA$.)1$3&50$3(LL(0(A.$3.$0&++.51.-$A.)$;-().)$3.$

320()(&5) $3. $+(). $.5 $ )0,5.$X'U(A $ )U/W(-/(1 $3U/11-(Z'.- $T $ A/ $ L&() $ /' $ -2/A()/1.'-9 $ /' $;-&3'01.'-9 $/'$

+&51.'-9 $/'$-.);&5)/ZA. $3.$ A/ $0.5)'-.D $P/()$)( $^$.AA(;).-$_$ A. $).R.$/'$0(52+/$.)1 $'5.$320()(&5$

.R12-(.'-.$/'R$0Q&(R$3.$+().$.5$)0,5.$3'$L(A+9$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$;/-A.$1-,)$Z(.5$3'$L/(1$X'.$0U.)1$

2W/A.+.51$A.$;&(51$3.$32;/-1$3U'5$S.'$3.$)'WW.)1(&59$&[$(A$)U/W(-/9$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.9$3.$0-2.-$A. $

32)(-$0Q.s$A.$);.01/1.'-D$aA$O$/$3U/(AA.'-)$'5.$W-/3/1(&5$.51-.$A.)$+/5(,-.)$3.$-.L.-+.-$&'$3U&'V-(- $

0.11. $ )'WW.)1(&5 $ T $ AU(+/W(5/1(&5 $ 3' $ );.01/1.'-D $ c'/53 $ %/-/ $:51(;&V/ $ .1 $g(`1&- $ y&+/-&V)`O$

)U.+Z-/)).51$3/5)$A. $X,32&-#'H"*$%,9$A.$);.01/1.'-$5U/$;/)$A.)$+&O.5)$3.$321.-+(5.-$0.$X'($)U.)1$

.R/01.+.51$;/))2D$aA)$)U.+Z-/)).51$3/5)$'5$0/--&)).9$&5$0&';.$T$A/$+,-.$X'($A'($-.;-&0Q.$3Uf1-.$

-.51-2.$1/-3D$%.$1-&'ZA.$.1$AU(532L(5(1(&5$.51&'-.51$0.$+&+.51D$%.$0Q&(R$3.$+().$.5$)0,5.$3.$+$':G2& '

8-4$"1&$L.-/$;A')$0A/(-.+.51$-2L2-.50.$T$AU/01.$).R'.A9$A&-)X'.$o./5$N/Z(5$.51-/n5.-/$#(+&5.$#(+&5$

)'- $ A. $ )&A $ /V.0 $ A'(9 $ 1/53() $ X'. $ A/ $ 0/+2-/ $ ). $321&'-5.-/ $;'3(X'.+.51 $ /V/51 $ 3. $ -.V.5(-9 $ .5 $'5$

+&'V.+.51$)O+21-(X'.9$320&'V-(-$A.)$3.'R$/+/51)$)&-1/519$ZA&11()$AU'5$0&51-.$AU/'1-.D$$

Y.1-&'V/(AA.)$.1$-.0&55/())/50.$

B/5)$A.$0/)$3.$A/$1Q2+/1(X'.$3.$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3.$A/$-.0&55/())/50.9$&5$-.1-&'V.9$3.$A/$+f+.$

+/5(,-.9 $ A. $ 0/) $ &[ $ A/ $ -.0&55/())/50. $ 5U/'-/ $ S/+/() $ A(.'9 $ 5. $ )U/3-.)).-/ $ X'U/'R $ ;-&S.01(&5) $ 3'$

);.01/1.'-$)&')$A/$L&-+.$3'$^$)($).'A.+.51DDD$_D$

B/5)$A.$0/)$3.$A/$)2;/-/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$'1(A().$+&(5)$AU.AA(;).$1.+;&-.AA.$

X'.$A/$0&50.51-/1(&5$3.$AU.);/0.9 $;/-$ A/$+().$.5$)0,5.$&'$;/-$A/$0&';.D$B/5) $78&'L"(9 $ A/$+,-.$

-2/;;/-/n1-/$T$;A')(.'-)$-.;-().)$3/5)$A.$X'/-1(.-$&[$V(V.51$4Q/-A&1$.1$A.$L(A)$X'U.AA.$/$/Z/53&552D$aA)$

). $ V.--&51 $ )/5) $ ). $ -.0&55/n1-.9 $ 1/53() $ X'. $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ /'-/ $ .5V(. $ 3. $ A.) $ ;-2V.5(- $ .1 $ -.)1.-/$

(+;'())/51$S')X'UT$AU(3.51(L(0/1(&5$L(5/A.$3'$`(3$;/-$A/$+,-.D$!5$0&50.51-/51$AU.);/0.$&[$V(1$A/$+,-.$.1 $

0.A'($&[$V(1$A.$L(A)9$4Q/;A(5$1-/V/(AA.$A.$32)(-$3'$);.01/1.'-D$4.A'(*0($.5$)/(1$;A')$X'.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$

Page 31: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

.1$V.'1$A.'-$;.-+.11-.$3.$).$-.1-&'V.-D $4.11.$).5)/1(&5$).$-.1-&'V.$3/5) $F2&))$'X$))$0$ A&-)X'.$A.$

);.01/1.'-$V&(1 $#1.AA/$/))()1.-$/'$+/-(/W.$3.$)/$L(AA.$3.;'()$ A/ $-'.9 $0/0Q2.$3/5)$AU&+Z-.9 $-.)1/51$

(5V()(ZA.$;&'-$A'($;.-+.11-.$3U(512W-.-$A.)$Q/'1.)$);Q,-.)$3.$A/$)&0(212D$%.$32)(-$3'$);.01/1.'-$3.$A.)$

V&(-$-2'5(.)$.)1$+/R(+()2$;/-$A.'-$;-&R(+(12$;QO)(X'.D$!AA.)$)&51$T$S/+/()$)2;/-2.)$.1$;&'-1/51$'5.$

)(+;A. $ L.5f1-. $ A.) $ )2;/-.D $ 4.) $ ;'-) $ /-1(L(0.) $ 3. $+(). $ .5 $ )0,5. $ 3/1.51 $ 2W/A.+.51 $ 3' $ 1Q2e1-.$

+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$M$3/5)$g,&)"$',-')>&1C$12a4N02K#&9$A.)$Q2-&)$.5$L'(1.$(-&51$).$-2L'W(.-$3/5)$A.$+&'A(5$

/Z/53&552$&[9$S')1.+.519$A.$1-/n1-.$.)1$V.5'$).$0/0Q.-9$0.$X'($;.-+.11-/$3.$+.11-.$.5$)0,5.$A/$0Q'1.$

3'$1-/n1-.$3/5)$'5$;(,W.$/V/51$A.)$-.1-&'V/(AA.)$3.)$Q2-&)$/V.0$A/$L/+(AA.$3&51$(A)$/V/(.51$212$0Q/))2)$

.1 $ A. $325&'.+.51 $Q.'-.'R$3.$AU(51-(W'.D $aA $)U/W(1 $3U'5.$0&+;A/()/50.$)025/-()1(X'.9 $+/()$0.AA.*0($

;.-+.1$3U/00.51'.-$A.$+&+.51$3U2+&1(&5$.5$1-/V/(AA/51$3.)$-.50&51-.)$.51-.$A.)$A(W5.)$5/--/1(V.)D

4.11.$0&53.5)/1(&5$3.$AU.);/0.$;&'--/(1$;-.)X'.$f1-.$0&5)(32-2.$0&++.$'5.$.AA(;).$);/1(/A.$

3/5)$A.$0/)$&[$A.$0(52+/$A/$+/5(;'A.$)'-$ A.$;A/5$3'$+&51/W.D $B/5) $+>8&-#&'0-?#G4&9 $ A.)$3.'R$

;.-)&55/W.)$)2;/-2)$;/-$A/$W'.--.$.51-.51$.5$0&++'5(&5$1&')$A.)$S&'-)$T$>>$Q.'-.)9$.5$;.5)/51$AU'5$T$

AU/'1-.$.1$.5$0&++'5(X'/51$T$1-/V.-)$A.)$+23/(AA.)$X'U(A)$).$)&51$;/-1/W2.)$A.$S&'-$3.$A.'-$+/-(/W.D $

%.$320&';/W.$;.-+.1$3.$A.)$-/;;-&0Q.-9$L/()/51$)'(V-.$'5$;A/5$3'$V()/W.$3.$B(/5.$T$0.A'($3.$4Q(0&9$

1&') $3.'R $ .+;&-12) $ ;/- $ AU2+&1(&5D $d5 $ L&53' $ .50Q/n52 $;.-+.11-/ $+f+. $3. $ L')(&55.- $ A.) $ 3.'R$

V()/W.)9$-2/A()/51$;/-$A.$+&51/W.$A.$32)(-$3.$A.)$V&(-$-2'5()$/'X'.A$/);(-.$A.$);.01/1.'-D$t$32L/'1$3.$

;&'V&(-$/002A2-.-$A.$1.+;)$;&'-$).$-.1-&'V.-$;A')$V(1.9$0U.)1$AU.);/0.$X'($).$-21-20(19$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$

21/51$/+.52)$T$;-&R(+(12$AU'5$3.$AU/'1-.$;/-$A/$+/W(.$/+&'-.').D

%U')/W.$3'$W-&)$;A/5$3.$V()/W.$/V/51$&'$/;-,)$AU.AA(;).$;.-+.1$A/$)'WW.)1(&5$3U'5$32)(-$X'($.)1$

0.A'($3'$;.-)&55/W.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$AU(50/-5.$.5$-/;;-&0Q/51$A.$V()/W.$32)(-/51$.1$AU&ZS.1$32)(-2D$4U.)1 $

A.$V()/W.$3.$4Q/`/A$3/5)$)&'=,18&-#9$X'($1&+Z.$/+&'-.'R$3.$4A/-/$#1'/-1$.5$A/$V&O/51$)'-$)0,5.D$

4U.)1$A.$V()/W.$3.$%/'-/$3/5) $=#K*&'#&13,12#&;$X'($-.5V&(.$A.$);.01/1.'-$/'$;/))2$X'U.AA.$-/0&51.D$

4U.)1$0.A'($3.$AUQ&++.$S/'5.9$L/)0(52$;/-$A/$S.'5.$L(AA.$X'U(A$-.0'.(AA.$3/5)$A.$+N0'=#"0@D$!5$/5/AO)/51$

+>,?"1",1'?-:)"E-&9$"/0/0Q.$20-(1$M$

^$%.) $ ;-&0232) $ .AA(;1(X'.) $ V(Z-.51 $ .1 $ -2)&55.51 $ 3. $ L/\&5 $ T $ ;-&V&X'.- $ '5$

32;A/0.+.51$3.$AU(512-f1$)'-$A.$V()/W.$0&++.$1.--/(5$;-(V(A2W(2$3.$AU2+&1(&5D$t$

0Q/X'. $ /AA')(&5 $ L(5.9 $ T $ 0Q/X'. $ 0&53.5)/1(&5 $ .AA(;1(X'.9 $ -2;&53 $ '5 $ V()/W. $ )'-$

A.X'.A$)U/11/-3.$A/$0/+2-/$EuF$%U/;;.A$T$AU(5L(A+2$5.$32-&Z.$A.$);.01/0A.9$)&'3/(5$

L-/;;2 $ 3U(5)(W5(L(/50.9 $ X'. $ ;&'- $ ;.-+.11-. $ T $ A/ $ 0/+2-/ $ 3. $ )U/A/5W'(- $ )'- $ '5$

);.01/1.'-$3.V.5'$A'($+f+.$&ZS.1$3.$);.01/0A.D$aA$5U.)1$;/)$3.$;A')$Z.A$20-/5$X'.$A.$

Page 32: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

V()/W. $ Q'+/(5 $ M $ 1.AA. $ .)19 $ ;/-*3.AT $ A.) $ +2-(12.) $ 3. $ A/ $ 0&53.5)/1(&5 $ .1 $ 3'$

32;A/0.+.519$A/$A.\&5$3.$+>,?"1",1'?-:)"E-&$>?_D

#U/11/-3.-$)'-$'5$V()/W.$/V/51$'5.$.AA(;).9$0U.)1$3&55.-$/'$);.01/1.'-$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5.$0&55.R(&59$

3U'5.$1.5)(&5$.51-.$A.$V()/W.$32)(-/51$.1$A.$;A/5$X'($A.$)'(19$0U.)1$21/ZA(-$'5.$-.A/1(&5$3.$32)(-$3.$AU'5 $

/V.0$AU/'1-.9$'5.$;-&S.01(&5$X'($(5V(1.$A.$);.01/1.'-$T$O$+.11-.$)&5$;-&;-.$32)(-D$

( =&$$)"+2#+()$(#.'&$+<1+-&(6'31)>+2#+-&$(-')$-)+<)+2#+6&".

!5$S&'/51$.51-.$A/$L-')1-/1(&5$.1$A.$32)(-$3'$);.01/1.'-9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$A.$L/(1$;/)).-$;/-$1&'1.)$

A.) $2+&1(&5)D $P/() $ (A $5. $).$0&51.51. $;/) $3. $ AU/5.03&1.9 $3. $ A/ $ -&+/50.D $ aA $2A,V. $ A.) $Q()1&(-.) $T $

AU2;(X'.9$/'$1-/W(X'.D$#/$L&-0.$.)1$3.$0&5S'W'.-$'5.$).5)/1(&5$1-,)$L/+(A(,-.9$;-&0Q.$3'$);.01/1.'-9$.1 $

A/$V/A.'-$'5(V.-).AA.$3.)$Q()1&(-.)$X'U(A$-/0&51.D$P'-(.A$:53-(5$;/-A.$3'$A/5W/W.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$.5$

A.$X'/A(L(/51$3UQO;.-Z&A(X'.D$%UQO;.-Z&A.$^$.)1$'5.$L&-+.$p5/1'-.AA.p$3U.R;-.))(&5$_$&[$^$1&'1$0.$X'($

A'($).-/(1$(5L2-(.'-$5.$L.-/(1$;/)).-$X'.$A.$3-/+.$/;;/-.51$EA.$5/1'-/A()1.9$A.$Z/5/AF$.1$5&5$A.$V2-(1/ZA.$

3-/+. $ E+&-/A9 $ 0&)+(X'.F78D_ $ %. $ +2A&3-/+. $ ). $ )(1'. $ /'*3.AT $ 3.) $ Q()1&(-.) $ X'. $ V(V.51 $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)9$(A$L/(1$).51(-$A.)$L&-0.)$X'($/5(+.51$A.$+&53.$.1$A/$A'11.$3.$AU(53(V(3'$;&'-$;/-V.5(-$T$O$

1-&'V.-$A.'-$;A/0.D$!1$AU.AA(;).$.)1$'5$3.)$&'1(A)$X'($;.-+.1$3U2A.V.-$AUQ()1&(-.9$A/$)(1'.-$/'*3.AT$3.$A/ $

)(+;A.$/5.03&1.$).51(+.51/A.D$v5$AU/$V'9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$1-/5)L&-+.$A.)$/5.03&1.)$.5$3.)1(59$.1$0U.)1$

.50&-.$'5.$L&()$AU.AA(;).$X'($;.-+.1$3.$A.$L/(-.$;/)).-$/'$);.01/1.'-$)'-$A.$;A/5$2+&1(&55.AD$

aA$.)1$3(LL(0(A.$3.$0/-/012-().-$'5.$.AA(;).$3/5)$A/$+.)'-.$&[$(A$)U/W(1$3U'5.$0&';.9$3U'5$V(3.D $

C&'1.)$A.)$.AA(;).)$)&51$.5$)&($)(+(A/(-.)$;'()X'U.AA.)$)&51$0&5)1(1'2.)$;/-$'5.$0&';.D$4.$X'($A.)$

0/-/012-().9$0U.)1$3&50$0.$X'($).$;/)).$/V/51$.1$/;-,)$A/$0&';.D$aA$)U/W(-/$(0($3.$).$0&50.51-.-$)'- $

AU.AA(;).$A&5W'.D$B/5)$A/$)1-'01'-.$WA&Z/A.$3U'5$L(A+9$.AA.$L&501(&55.$0&++.$'5.$;.1(1.$L(5$h$.AA.$

3&55.$AU(+;-.))(&5$X'.$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$).$1.-+(5.9$.AA.$0Aj1$A.$0Q/;(1-.9$.AA.$1.-+(5.$'5.$;/-1(.$3. $

AUQ()1&(-.D $!AA. $ L&501(&55.$.5$+f+.$1.+;)$0&++.$'5$-.5&'V./'$ h $/;-,) $ A. $5&(-9 $X'.AX'. $0Q&).$

-.0&++.50.$h$A.$L(A+$32Z'1.$T$5&'V./'9$W/-3/51$0.$X'($/$212$V20'$;/-$A.$);.01/1.'-$0&++.$'5$

)&'V.5(-$0&++'5$.51-.$A.$;.-)&55/W.$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-D$!AA.$/$T$V&(-$/V.0$'5.$(+;-.))(&5$3.$32Z'1$.1 $

3.$L(59$3.$V(.$.1$3.$+&-19$0&++.$A.$32Z'1$3'$L(A+$;&'--/(1$)U/))(+(A.-$T$'5.$5/())/50.$.1$)/$L(5$T$)&5 $

320,)D$!5$320&';/51$'5$L(A+$.5$;/-1(.)9$0.11.$).5)/1(&5$)U/;;A(X'.$/'$).(5$+f+.$3.$A/$)1-'01'-.D$

:V/51 $ AU.AA(;).9 $0U.)1 $ AU'5(V.-)$3'$L(A+$X'( $).$0Aj19 $3();/-/n1 $3/5) $ AU&Z)0'-(12 $;&'-$3.) $+&()9 $3.)$

>? $

78 $:53-(59$P'-(.A;'!$)@C"E-&0'A')&'4@),(#$4&'C")4"E-&'$4@#"3$"1'&2'0&0'8@#,\1&0Z]^_`a]^bcY;'<-'R.AA.)9'=.1.-$%/5W9$0&AA$-.;.5).-$A.$0(52+/9$788JD$;D@b

Page 33: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

/552.)$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+D$!5$0&++.5\/51$A/$;/-1(.$X'($)'(19$(A$)U/W(1$3U'5.$-.5/())/50.$;&'-$A.$

);.01/1.'-9 $'5$5&'V./'$32;/-19 $0&++.$)U(A$ -.1-&'V/(1 $)&'3/(5$'5.$0&5)0(.50.9 $A/$0/;/0(12$T$V&(-$

AUQ()1&(-.$X'($).$32-&'A.$)&')$).)$O.'RD$

4.11. $ 0&55&1/1(&59 $ A.) $ -2/A()/1.'-) $ 3. $ +2A&3-/+. $ AU'1(A().51 $ 3/5) $ 1&'1. $ AU(51.5)(12$

QO;.-Z&A(X'.9$^$0&)+(X'.$_9$0&++.$3(1$P'-(.A$:53-(57>9$X'U.AA.$0&51(.51D$%/$L(5$3U'5.$)2X'.50.9$

)'(V(. $3U'5.$.AA(;). $ A&5W'.$)&55.$0&++.$ A/ $ L(5 $3U'5$ 1.+;)9 $ A/ $+&-1 $3U'5 $+&+.51 $V20'$;/- $ A.$

;.-)&55/W.D$!AA.$/$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3U/Z)&A'9$3.$1.--(ZA.$h$.AA.$3&55.$T$).51(-$A/$3();/-(1(&5$32L(5(1(V.$6$

;'()X'.$A.$1.+;)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$5.$;.-+.1$S/+/()$3.$-.1&'-$.5$/--(,-.$6$3U'5$+&-0./'$3.$V(.$3' $

;.-)&55/W.9$.1$5&')$-/;;.AA.$X'U.5L(59$A.$1.+;)$;/))2$.)1$(--2V.-)(ZA.D$B/5) $+>"10,-4"0&9$o2s.Z.A9$

;-&V&X'.$'5.$L&()$3.$1-&;$)&5$L(/502$=-.)$.5$AU&ZA(W./51$T$AU/+.5.-$3/5)$'5.$1.5'.$(5/;;-&;-(2.$/'$

Z/A $ .1 $ .5 $ 1-/5)L&-+/51 $ A/ $ )&(-2. $ .5 $ '5 $ 1.--(ZA. $+&+.51 $ 3. $ Q&51. $ ;&'- $ 1&') $ A.) $ 3.'RD $ !5 $ A/$

-/00&+;/W5/51$0Q.s$.AA.9$=-.)$A'($L/(1$0&+;-.53-.$X'U(A$)U.5$V/9$/Z/53&55/51$AU(32.$3U2;&').-$'5.$

L.++.$/'))($0/;-(0(.').D$o2s.Z.A$+&51.$/A&-)$A.)$.)0/A(.-)9$32).);2-2.9$+/()$L/()/51$Z&55.$L(W'-.D$

:V.'WA2.$;/-$)/$L(.-129$.AA.$/LL(-+.$X'.$=-.)$-.V(.53-/$.1$&-3&55.$+f+.$T$)/$+,-.$3.$5.$;/)$A. $

-.0.V&(-$A&-)X'U(A$).$-.;-2).51.-/D$!AA.$)&-1(-/$3'$0Q/+;$.1$;/)).-/$/A&-)$'5.$.AA(;).$3U'5.$/552.9$

3'-/51$A/X'.AA.$A.$);.01/1.'-$/;;-.53-/$X'U.AA.$5.$)&-1(-/$;/)$3.$0Q.s$.AA.D$%U.AA(;).$).$1.-+(5.-/$/V.0$

A.$-.1&'-$3.$=-.)9$X'($-.V(.53-/$/V.0$'5.$/'1-.$L(/502.D$%.$)O+Z&A.$.)1$0A/(-$M$/V.0$A.$32;/-1$3.$=-.)9$

0U.)1$A/$L(5$3U'5.$2;&X'.9$.1$A/$+&-1$3.$A/$o2s.Z.A$1.AA.$X'U&5$AU/V/(1$0&55'.D$!AA.$5.$-2/;;/-/n1-/$X'.$

1-,)$3(+(5'2.9$/O/51$/Z/53&552$1&'1.$.5V(.$3.$V&(-$A.$+&53.$.1$;.-3'$A/$L&'W'.$X'($A/$0/-/012-()/(1$

3/5)$ A/ $;-.+(,-.$;/-1(. $3'$L(A+D $B'-/51 $ A. $ -.)1. $3'$L(A+9 $.AA. $5U/'-/$3.$0.)).$X'.$3.$ 1.51.- $3.$

-20';2-.-$)&5$/50(.5$L(/502$)/5)$O$;/-V.5(-D $4.11.$.AA(;).$)O+Z&A().$ A/$L(5$3U'5$1.+;)9$0.A'($3.$

Am(5)&'0(/50.$.1$3'$Z&5Q.'-$3.$o2s.Z.AD

B.$+f+.$3/5) $.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&09$A/$;-.+(,-.$A&5W'.$.AA(;).$/$A(.'$/;-,)$'5$S.'$3.$

1-(/5WA.$/+&'-.'R$&[$C/&$).-/$L&-02.$3.$0Q&()(-$.51-.$).)$3.'R$;-21.53/51)D$%/$3.-5(,-.$)2X'.50.$

/V/51 $0.11.$-';1'-.$+.1$.5$)0,5.$A.$32;/-1 $3.$%(/5Ws(9$A.$;-21.53/51$X'U.AA.$5.$0Q&()(-/$;/)D$!5$

0&A,-.9$(A$A'($/55&50.$)&5$32;/-1$/;-,)$X'U.AA.$A'($/(1$;-2L2-2$)&5$-(V/A$.1$S.11.$).)$0A2)$;/-*$3.))')$A.)$

1&(1)$3/5)$'5$W.)1.$3.$32L(9$/LL(-+/51$)/$V&A&512$3.$5.$S/+/()$-.V.5(-D$4U.)1$3&50$T$5&'V./'$'5.$

;.1(1.$+&-1$X'.$;-&3'(1$AU.AA(;).9$A/$;.1(1.$+&-1$3.$%(/5Ws(h$3();/-/())/51$3.$A/$V(.$3.$C/&D$%/$L(5$3U'5$

;&))(ZA.$.51-.$.'R9$A/$L.-+.1'-.$3U'5.$3.)$V&(.)$X'($).$;-2).51/(.51$T$.AA.D$<(.5$)i-9$A/$3.'R(,+.$

;/-1(.$5.$1/-3.$;/)$T$L/(-.$-.V.5(-$%(/5Ws(D$aA$-.1-&'V.$)/$+/()&5$A/())2.$AT$3.)$/552.)$.1$0Q.-0Q.$A. $

+&O.5$3U&'V-(-$A/$;&-1.$X'U(A$/V/(1$;&'-1/51$L.-+2.$X'.AX'.)$+(5'1.)$/V/51$3/5)$A.$L(A+$/V.0$1/51$3.$

7> $:53-(59$P'-(.A;'!$)@C"E-&0'A')&'4@),(#$4&'C")4"E-&'$4@#"3$"1'&2'0&0'8@#,\1&0Z]^_`a]^bcY;'<-'R.AA.)9'=.1.-$%/5W9$0&AA$-.;.5).-$A.$0(52+/9$788JD$;D@b

Page 34: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

L.-V.'-D$P/()$0U.)1$Z(.5$0.11.$).5)/1(&5$X'.$;-&3'(1$AU.AA(;).9$3U'5.$L(5$3.$1&'19$'5.$3();/-(1(&5$3/5)$A.$

52/519$A/$)2;/-/1(&5$X'($.)1$)O5&5O+.$3U'5.$/Z)&A'.$.1$QO;.-Z&A(X'.$L(5$3'$+&53.D$4U.)1$Z(.5$/V.0$

0.11.$(32.$.5$1f1.$X'.$%(/5Ws($L.-+.$A/$;&-1.9$A/$).5)/1(&5$X'U(A$5U/'-/$;A')$-(.5$T$L/(-.$3/5)$0.11. $

V(AA.9$1&'1$.);&(-$3U'5.$-.A/1(&5$/V.0$C/&$21/51$+&-1D

P/()$AU.AA(;).$/$2W/A.+.51$A.$;&'V&(-$(5V.-).9$3.$L/(-.$-.V.5(-$T$A/$V(.D$B/5)$7,-0')&0'$-2#&0 '

0>$??&))&12'.)"9$A.$0&';A.$)U.5L.-+.$3/5)$A.)$;-&ZA,+.)$M$:A($).$+.1$T$/V&(-$'5.$-.A/1(&5$/3'A12-(5.$

/V.0$A/$).-V.').$3'$Z/-$3'X'.A$(A$.)1$Q/Z(1'2$h$)&5$2;&').$!+($).$A/()).$0&51/+(5.-$;/-$A.$-/0()+.$

/+Z(/51$3.$A/$)&0(212$/AA.+/53.$.1$).$+.1$T$A.$1-/(1.-$0&++.$'5$/5(+/A$3.$L&(-.$3.V/51$).)$/+(.)$3.$

1-/V/(AD$aA)$320(3.51$3.$;/-1(-$.5$V/0/50.)9$1.51/51$3U/--/5W.-$A.)$0Q&).)$.51-.$.'RD$%.$V&O/W.$).$L/(1$

.51(,-.+.51$A.$1.+;)$3U'5.$.AA(;).$h$A.$);.01/1.'-$5U.5$V.--/$-(.5D$t$A.'-$-.1&'-$0.;.53/519$1&'1$/$

0Q/5W2D$:V.0$'5.$5/{V.12$0&5L&53/51.$3.$Z./'129$.1$3/5)$A.$Q&-)*0Q/+;)$3.$AU.AA(;).9$]/))Z(53.-$A.)$

L/(1$-.;/-1(-$3.$s2-&9$-.3&55.$T$A.'-$/+&'-$)/$L&-0.$3U/51/5D$%U.AA(;).$L&501(&55.$/A&-)$0&++.$'5$-2.A$

2A(R(-$3.$S&'V.50.9$'5.$;&1(&5$3.$V(.$X'($A.'-$;.-+.1$3.$-.0&++.50.-D$4.$5.$)&51$;/)$).'A.+.51$3.)$

1.5)(&5)$X'U(A)$&51$)'$32;/)).-$M$1&'1$-.;/-1$3.$5&'V./'9$AU'5(V.-)$A.'-$-.3&55.$'5.$0Q/50.D$

%.$+&53.$3'$L(A+$.)1$.5$0&Q2-.50.$/V.0$A.$-.W/-3$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$aA$)U(51.--&+;1$X'/53$1&'1$

.);&(-$).+ZA.$;.-3'$.1$-.0&++.50.$A&-)X'.$0.A'(*0($-.5/n1$h$=-.)$-.V(.519$AU/+&'-$-.0&++.50.9$'5.$

5&'V.AA.$.R()1.50.$;/-/n1$;&))(ZA.$M$^$%.$1.+;)$QO;5&1(X'.$3'$+2A&3-/+.9$).)$.AA(;).)$L&'3-&O/51.)9$

.)1$;.'1*f1-.$A/$;A')$V(&A.51.$3U.51-.$1&'1.)9$0/-$.AA.$L/(1$3.$A/$0/')/A(12$'5.$L/1/A(12$.1$/S')1.$A.$1.+;)$

)'-$A.$+&'V.+.51$V(L$3'$32)(-D$_77$ $20-(1$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.D$%/$)1-'01'-.$)'(1$A.)$.);&(-)$.1$A.)$

L-')1-/1(&5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D $!5$0-2/51$'5$'5(V.-)$&[$A.$32).);&(-$+,5.$/'$5&(- $3.$AU.AA(;).9$.1$

AU.);&(- $ /' $ -.1&'- $ 3. $ AU(+/W.9 $ A. $+2A&3-/+. $3&55. $ /' $ );.01/1.'- $ 0.11. $ (+;-.))(&5 $ 3U'5 $ 3-/+.$

0&)+(X'.D$%U'5(V.-)$.51(.-$;-.53$A/$L&-+.$3.)$3-/+.)$(512-(.'-)$X'.$V(V.51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$

%.$+2A&3-/+.$L/(1$;/)).-$A.$1.+;)9$)2;/-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$0&5)1-'(1$3.)$;2-(;21(.)$&[$(A)$

)&51$Z/AA&112.) $;/-$ A.)$Q/)/-3)$3.$ A/ $V(. $3U'5$.53-&(1 $T $ AU/'1-.D $ aA $;-&3'(1 $3.) $0&{50(3.50.)9 $3.)$

-.1-&'V/(AA.)$L&-1'(1.)9$3.)$L&-1'5.)$+(-/0'A.').)9$3.)$+&+.51)$3.$;A25(1'3.$(5.);2-2)D$:))&0(2$T$

'5. $ 3(+.5)(&5 $ 0&)+(X'.9 $ A.) $ Q()1&(-.) $ ;-.55.51 $ A/ $ L&-+. $ 3. $ 3.)1(5)D $ %/ $ -.50&51-. $ 3. $ 3.'R$

;.-)&55/W.)$0&5)1(1'.$'5.$/5.03&1.$h$A/$-.50&51-.$3.$0.)$+f+.)$;.-)&55/W.)$321.5/51$'5$;/))2$

0&++'59$.1$)U21/51$;.-3')$3.$V'.9$3&55.$A/$).5)/1(&5$-&+/5.)X'.$X'.$AU'5(V.-)$A.)$/$-2'5()D$%.$

;A/()(-$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).9$0U.)1$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3.$L/(-.$-.V.5(-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.)$2A2+.51)$3.)$

/552.)$/;-,)D$%.$1.+;)$5U/$;/)$Z.)&(5$3Uf1-.$A&5W$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-$h$3/5)$+&0')-4"K#&0'(&')$'*"))&9$

4Q/-A&1$.)1$.5V&O2$.5$;-()&5$.1$-.V(.51$A.$;A/5$)'(V/519$)(1'2$3.)$/552.)$/;-,)$3/5)$A/$5/--/1(&5D$%.$

77$"/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;D>JH

Page 35: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

1.+;)$;/))2$3/5)$A.$L(A+$.)1$+(5(+.$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$5U/$;/)$;'$-.)).51(-$AU/Z).50.$3.$A/$S.'5.$L(AA.D$

P/()$(A$)U2+.'1$3.$V&(-$A.'-)$-.1-&'V/(AA.)$0&++.$)($.AA.$/V/(1$3'-2$2W/A.+.51$;&'-$A'(D$4U.)1$AU(32. $

3.$A/$)2;/-/1(&59$3.$AU/Z).50.$X'($0-22$AU2+&1(&5D$%.$1.+;)$;/))2$T$AU20-/5$5U/$;/)$Z.)&(5$3Uf1-.$A&5W$h$

A.)$-.1-&'V/(AA.)$2+.'V.51$A.$);.01/1.'-$.1$A'($3&55.51$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5.$0&{50(3.50.$0&)+(X'.9$

3U'5.$3.)1(52.$0&++'5.$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)D

%.$3.)1(5$5U.R()1.$X'.$;/-0.$X'U(A$O$/$'5.$L(5$T$1&'19$.1$A/$L&-0.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$2W/A.+.51$

3.$3&55.-$T$).51(-$A/$+&-1$X'($.)1$/'$Z&'1D$%.$;(-.$.55.+($3'$;.-)&55/W.$3.$+2A&3-/+.9$0U.)1$A.$

1.+;)$X'($;/)).$.1$X'($V(.53-/9$1j1$&'$1/-39$+.11-.$'5$1.-+.$T$)/$A'11.$.LL-252.$;&'-$A.$Z&5Q.'-D$C/51$

X'U(A$O$/$3'$1.+;)9$AU.);&(-$)'Z)()1.D$P/()$0.)$Z&53)$.5$/V/51$X'.$0&5)1(1'.51$A.)$.AA(;).)$A.$L&51$

/V/50.- $ 3/5) $ '5. $ 3(-.01(&5 $ (--2V&0/ZA. $ /V.0 $ '5. $ -/;(3(12 $ V.-1(W(5.'). $ ;&'- $ A. $ );.01/1.'-D $ %.$

+&51/W.$0&5)1-'(1$0Q.s$A'($A/$0&5)0(.50.$3'$1.+;)9$A'($L/(1$).51(-$X'.$)/$;(-.$0-/(51.$.)1$.5$1-/(5$3.$). $

3.))(5.-$M$AU20Q.0$3'$;.-)&55/W.9$)&5$(50/;/0(12$T$;&'V&(-$/0023.-$T$)&5$32)(-$;/-$L/'1.$3.$1.+;)9$A/ $

+&-1 $ 0&++. $ ;&(51 $ L(5/A $ T $ 1&') $ A.) $ 3-/+.) $ X'( $ AU/V/(.51 $ /W(12 $ A. $ 1.+;) $ 3' $ L(A+D $ <(.5 $ )i-9$

AU(3.51(L(0/1(&5$.)1$1-,)$0A/(-.$M$AU(5)20'-(12$3'$);.01/1.'-$/$T$V&(-$/V.0$A.$3.)1(5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.$

;&))(ZA.$5/'L-/W.$3.$A.'-)$.R()1.50.)9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$/V.0$A/$).5)/1(&5$3.$)/$;-&;-.$0&53(1(&59$3.$

)/$;-&;-.$L(5(1'3.$L/0.$T$A/$V(.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$S&'.$/V.0$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$/V.0$'5.$V(&A.50.$

&'V.-1.D$B/5)$+>$*&12-#&'(&'!&'!-"#;$&5$V&(1$N.5.$C(.-5.O$0Q.s$.AA.9$3()0'1/51$/V.0$)/$Z&55.D$d5$

/5$/$;/))2$3.;'()$A.$32Z'1$3'$L(A+9$5&')$/55&50.$A/$0&5V.-)/1(&5$X'U.AA.)$&51$.51-.$.AA.)D$%/$;.1(1. $

L(AA.$X'($/V/(1$J$&'$G$/5)$*$X'($5U/;;/-/n1$;/)$3/5)$A/$)2X'.50.$*$.5$/$3&50$T$;.(5.$;A')D$d5.$)'(1.$3.$

;-().)$3.$V'.$3.$A/$+.-$.1$3.)$V/W'.)$X'($)U.50Q/n5.51$/V().51$A.$);.01/1.'-$X'.$A.$1.+;)$;/)).D$%.$

;A/5$)'(V/519$(A$-.1-&'V.$N.5.$C(.-5.O$).$;-&+.5/51$)'-$A/$;A/W.9$;/-/())/51$2W/A.$T$A/$)2X'.50.$

;-2023/51$AU.AA(;).D$=&'-1/519$.AA.$-.50&51-.$.5$0Q.+(5$)/$L(AA.9$V.5'.$A'($-.53-.$V()(1.D$#'-;-().9$.AA. $

5U/$;A')$G$+/()$78$/5)9$.1$/--(V.$.5$V&(1'-.$/V.0$'5$S.'5.$Q&++.$X'U.AA.$V.'1$;-2).51.-$T$)/$+,-.D$

%.$);.01/1.'-$-.)).51$0&++.$'5$0Q&0$0.$1.+;)$X'($/$;/))2$.1$X'.$AU&5$5U/$;/)$V20'$h$A.)$/552.)$3.$

P+.$P'(-$).$)&51$.5V&A2.)$A.$1.+;)$3U'5.$0&';.D$%/$).5)/1(&5$.)1$2W/A.+.51$0.AA.$3'$;.-)&55/W.9 $

Z(.5$)i-9$X'($-.1-&'V.$)/$L(AA.$W-/53(.$A.$1.+;)$3.$A.'-$)2;/-/1(&5D$%.$0Q&0$3'$1.+;)$;/))29$;/-1/W2 $

;/-$ A. $;.-)&55/W.$.1 $ A.$);.01/1.'-9 $L/(1 $)&'3/(5$).51(- $X'.$A/ $V(.$/$'5.$L(59 $.1 $X'.$0.AA.*0($)U.)1$

-/;;-&0Q2.$3U'5$Z&53D$B/5)$F-I$11&9$3.$y/1.AA$c'(AA2V2-29$A/$+&-1$3'$;.-)&55/W.$S&'2$;/-$:3,A.$

r/.5.A$).$32-&'A.-/$2W/A.+.51$A.$1.+;)$3U'5.$.AA(;).D$%.$);.01/1.'-$320&'V-.$)/$1&+Z.$.5$+f+.$

1.+;)$X'.$)/$)l'-9$X'(9$;/-1(.$/'$P/-&09$5U.5$/V/(1$-(.5$)'D$4.11.$L&()$A.$1.+;)$.5WA&'1($;/-$AU.AA(;).$

/'-/$212$L/1/A$h$A.$;&))(ZA.$;-20(.'R$3.)$-.1-&'V/(AA.)$.51-.$A.)$3.'R$)l'-)$3();/-/n1$;&'-$1&'S&'-)D$

Page 36: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$

?K*.%,&'(6(

;*(+'1+*,%$1()9(,'#.+(A9%(.*++'

?$##'1,(0N'00%.+'(,&*)9%,7'00'(91(,'#.+(+9EO'/,%L(M(

$

%U.AA(;).$A&5W'.9$X'($L/(1$;/)).-$3.)$/552.)$.5$'5.$).'A.$0&';.$.)1$1-,)$L&-1.+.51$/))&0(2.$T$

AU.)1Q21(X'.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.D$%.)$-2/A()/1.'-)$)U.5$).-V.51$3/5)$1&'1.$)/$L&-0.$2+&1(&55.AA.$h$;&'-$

L/(-.$/V/50.-$T$W-/53)$;/)$A/$)(1'/1(&59$0Q&X'.-$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.V/51$A.$0Q/5W.+.51$&'$3&55.-$T$

).51(- $ A. $ ;/))/W. $3U'5. $V(.D $=&'-1/519 $ 0U.)1 $ 0. $ 1O;. $3U.AA(;). $X'(9 $ A. $+&(5)9 $ -.53 $0&+;1. $3. $ A/$

).5)/1(&5$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-D$!AA.$;.'1$-.53-.$AU(+;-.))(&59$V.-1(W(5.').9$3'$

+&+.51$&[$A.$;.-)&55/W.$V&(1$)&'3/(5$A.$1.+;)$X'($/$L(A2$.1$5.$-.V(.53-/$;A')D$!AA.$;.'1$L/(-.$).51(-$

AU/Zn+.9 $ A/ $0&';.D $P/() $.AA. $5. $3&55.$;/) $/' $);.01/1.'- $ A/ $).5)/1(&5$3'$ 1.+;)$X'( $;/)).D $!AA.$

0&5)1-'(1$'5$1.+;)$32ST$;/))29$X'U(A$5.$;.'1$X'.$-.W-.11.-$3.;'()$A.$;-2).51$3'$L(A+D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$

1-/V/(AA.$2W/A.+.51$'5.$/'1-.$+/5(,-.$3.$L/(-.$;/)).-$A.$1.+;)$M$'5$1.+;)$;A')$)'ZS.01(L9$;-&0Q.$3.) $

2+&1(&5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$X'($.5$1-/3'(1$AU21/1$3U.);-(1$.1$2V&A'.$/'$0&'-)$3'$L(A+D

#(+&5.$3.$<./'V&(-$20-(1$3/5)$'5.$5&'V.AA.$3.$+$'C&44&'#,4?-&'A$

$ ^$C-/W(X'.+.519$+/$V(.$).$;-20(;(1.D$!1$0.;.53/51$.AA.$)U2W&'11.$.5$0.$+&+.51$

/V.0 $'5. $ 1.AA. $ A.51.'- $6 $Q.'-. $;/- $Q.'-.9 $+(5'1. $;/- $+(5'1.D $ aA $ L/'1 $ 1&'S&'-)$

/11.53-.$X'.$A.$)'0-.$L&53.9$X'.$A.$)&'V.5(-$)U.LL/0.9$X'.$A/$ZA.))'-.$).$0(0/1-().9$

X'.$A.$)&A.(A$).$0&'0Q.D$|1-/5W.$0&';'-.$.51-.$0.)$3.'R$-O1Q+.)D$:'$W/A&;$+.)$

S&'-)$+U20Q/;;.51$.1$.5$0Q/0'5$3U.'R$S.$A/5W'()7@D_$

4.11.$0&51-/3(01(&5$3.$A/$).5)/1(&5$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$+.$).+ZA.$.R1-f+.+.51$(+;&-1/51.$3/5)$A.$

+2A&3-/+.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$0&'-.51 $/;-,)$ A.'-)$&ZS.01(L) $ 1&'1$.5$)&'LL-/51$ A/$ A.51.'-$3.$A/$V(.$

X'&1(3(.55.$.1$.5$.5$;.-0.V/51$A/$W-/53.$+&5&1&5(.$h$%/'-/$0Q.-0Q.$'5$0/3./'$;&'-$)&5$+/-($3/5)$

=#K*&'d&13,12#&9$A.$;-&L.)).'-$3.$O,3&':)$138&$3&55.$)&5$0&'-)9$:V-(A$)&-1$A.)$;&'Z.AA.)$3/5)$+&0'

1,3&0 ' #&:&))&0D $ %U.55'( $ .1 $ A. $ X'&1(3(.5 $ &51 $ 2W/A.+.51 $ A.'- $ ;A/0. $ 3/5) $ A. $ +2A&3-/+.D $ %.)$

;.-)&55/W.)9$1/51j1$.R/A12)$;/-$A.$Z&5Q.'-9$1/51j1$-2)(W52)$T$AU/11.51.$.1$T$AU.55'(9$5.$V(V.51$;/)$'5$

1.+;)$+/()$3.)$1.+;)9$X'($).$)'00,3.51$.1$).$+fA.51D$

7@ B.$<./V&(-9$#(+&5.9$^$AUeW.$3.$A/$3()0-21(&5$_9$3/5)$A/$].++.$-&+;'.9$N/AA(+/-39$=/-()9$>?Gb9$-2.3D$]&A(&9$;IH*Ib

Page 37: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

( *)+9"#-#(+<1+6&$<)>+2#+-&1"()+9&22)+<1+.)68(+

o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$)&'A.V/(1$/V.0$(512-f1$A/$-2+(5()0.50.$3'$+&1(L$3'$Z&A(3.$3/5)$A.$0(52+/$

+2A&3-/+/1(X'.7HD$B/5)$U3#"2'0-#'(-'*&12;'g,44&'-1'2,##&12$&'$.50&-.$+&'F&3#&2'!$%1"C"E-&9$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$).$;/))(&55.51$;&'-$3.)$V&(1'-.)$3.$0&'-).$&'$3.)$Q&-)*Z&-3)D$%/$A&0&+&1(V.$3.$A/$Zf1.$

Q'+/(5.9$&'$A.)$0Q.V/'R$L&'W'.'R$3.$H@I&:&)$.1$3U.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&12'-.;-.55.51$2W/A.+.51$

0.$+&1(L$3.$A/$V(1.)).9$ (50/-5/51$T$A/$L&()$A/$0/V/A0/3.$.LL-252.$3'$1.+;)$.1$A/$1.51/1(&5$L&AA.$3.$

;&'V&(-$.5$32L(.-$A/$0&'-).9$3U/AA.-$;A')$V(1.$X'.$A'(D$

%.$;-.+(.-$-.)).51($X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$/$3'$1.+;)$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$0U.)1$)/$L'(1.$(5/A12-/ZA.D $

!AA. $.)1 $3U/'1/51 $;A') $ 1-/W(X'.$X'.$)&5$ (--2V.-)(Z(A(12 $0&5)1(1'.$ A. $V2-(1/ZA. $.55.+($3'$Q2-&)$3.$

+2A&3-/+.$ h $ )U(A $;.'1 $0&+;1.- $ )'- $ A.) $ -.1&'-5.+.51) $3. $)(1'/1(&5 $ A.)$;A') $ (+;-&Z/ZA.) $;&'- $).$

-/;;-&0Q.-$3.$).)$32)(-)9$(A$5.$;.'1$;/)$A'11.-$0&51-.$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$.1$(A$/'-/$(512-f1$T$0.$X'.$A/ $

-2)&A'1(&5$/(.$A(.'$/V/51$X'U(A$5.$)&(1$1-&;$V(.'R$;&'-$.5$;-&L(1.-D$

4.11.$).5)/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).9$V(1.9$.)1$0.AA.$3.$A/$V(.$1-2;(3/51.$X'.$A.$0(52+/$-.A(.$

3U/Z&-3$T$A/$V(AA.D$%.)$+&'V.+.51)$3U/002A2-/1(&5$)&51$0.'R$3.$A/$+/0Q(5.$;-&3'01(V.$3'$+&53.$

+&3.-5.9$3.$A/$L&A(.$3.$A/$V(.$+&53/(5.9$.1$3.$A/$-/;(3(12$3.)$/)0.5)(&5)$.1$3.)$0Q'1.)$3/5)$A.$+&53.$

0/;(1/A()1.D$B/5)' +& ':,18&-#9$0.$)&51$A.)$1(1-.)$3.$S&'-5/'R$X'($)U.+;(A.51$A.)$'5)$)'-$A.)$/'1-.)9$

)O+Z&A()/51$A.$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$h$A.)$1Q2e1-.)$&'$A.)$/LL(0Q.)$&[$/;;/-/()).51$A.$5&+$3.$AU/01-(0.$3/5)$

!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$.1$3/5)$W1&'@2,")&'&02'1@&D$B/5)$A>.-#,#&$0.$5U.)1$;/)$AU.AA(;).9$+/()$A.$-O1Q+.$3.)$

;A/5)9 $X'( $L.-/$).51(- $0.11. $/01(V(12 $32Z&-3/51.9 $.R0.))(V.$ M $ A.)$3.'R$/+/51)$/--(V.51$.5$V(AA. $.1 $

3.)0.53.51 $ 3' $ 1-/+K/OD $ d5. $ )'(1. $ 3. $ ;A/5) $ L(R.)9 $ 0&'-1)9 $ +&51-/51 $ A.) $ V()/W.) $ /W/02) $ 3.)$

0&53'01.'-)9$A.'-)$L-.(5/W.)$Z-')X'.)9$1-/3'(1$A/$).5)/1(&5$3.$0.11.$/W-.))(V(12$).5)&-(.AA.$3.$A/$V(AA.9$

&[$A.)$0Q&).)$V&51$1-&;$V(1.D$4.11.$;.-0.;1(&5$3.$A/$V(AA.$0&51(5'.$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$3U/'S&'-3UQ'(D$

B/5) $[$??N'2,%&28&#9$1&'1$.)1$L/(1$;&'-$;.-1'-Z.-$A/$).5)/1(&5$X'U/$A.$);.01/1.'-$3.$AU.);/0.$h$A.)$

;A/5)$)U.50Q/n5.51$)/5)$A'($3&55.-$3.$-2L2-.50.)D$o&'/51$)/5)$/--f1$)'-$A.)$)/'1.)$3U/R.)$.1$)'-$A/$

320&51.R1'/A()/1(&5$3.)$;A/5)$3/5)$AU.);/0.9$z&5W$y/-*z/($A'($3&55.$'5.$).5)/1(&5$3.$0&5L')(&5$.1$

3.$-/;(3(12D$t$5&'V./'9$A/$V(AA.$.)1$'5$1&'-Z(AA&5$X'($).+ZA.$/Z)&-Z.-$A.$1.+;)9$Am/002A2-.-$/V.0$

Z-'1/A(12D$

%U(+/W.$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$T$1&'1.$/AA'-.$.1$3.$A/$V(AA.$V/$3.$;/(-.$/V.0$A/$5&1(&5$3.$)'00,)D$

%U/01-(0.$3.$1Q2e1-.9$0/-$(A$)U/W(1$)&'V.51$3.$0.A/9$).$-.1-&'V.$)&'3/(5$T$.50Q/n5.-$A.)$);.01/0A.)$.1$A.)$

)'00,)9 $T $;/)).- $3U'5 $2V,5.+.51 $+&53/(5$/' $)'(V/51D $B/5)$ A. $+2A&3-/+.9 $&5$ AU/ $V'9 $ (A $ )U/W(-/$

7H "/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;DJ@

Page 38: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

)&'V.51 $5&5$;/) $3U'5. $ -2'))(1. $.5 $)&(9 $+/() $3U'5$2A2+.51 $ ).0&53/(-.9 $V&(-. $3U'5. $Z/--(,-. $T $ A/$

-2/A()/1(&5$V2-(1/ZA.$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$%.$-.W/-3$X'.$;&-1.$A.$+2A&3-/+.$)'-$0.)$)'00,)$5U.)1$3&50$

S/+/()$0.A'($3'$)(+;A.$-2S&'()).+.51D $4.$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$T$ 1&'1.$/AA'-.9 $0U.)1 $3'$1.+;)$X'.$A.$

;.-)&55/W.$5.$V(V-/$;/)$0&++.$(A$A.$3.V-/(19$&'ZA(/51$3.$-.W/-3.-$/'1&'-$3.$A'($.1$3.$;-.53-.$A.$

1.+;)$3.$).$0&5)/0-.-$T$3.)$V/A.'-)$;A')$(+;&-1/51.)$.1$;A')$;-&0Q.)$3.$)&5$-2.A$32)(-D$B/5)$!"#$%&'

(&')$'*"&9$AU.AA(;).$3&55.$'5.$).5)/1(&5$3.$V.-1(W.$/'$);.01/1.'-D$%.)$3/1.)$).$+.11.51$T$32L(A.-$T$1&'1.$

V(1.)).D$%.$);.01/1.'-$V&(1$/V.0$'5.$)&'3/(5.$(+;'())/50.$A.)$/552.)$)U.5V&A.-$3.V/51$A'(9$/))()1/51$T $

>8$/5)$X'($A'($20Q/;;.51$.1$X'U(A$/'-/(1$.5V(.$3.$-.1.5(-D$4&++.$'5$0&51-/1$3(/Z&A(X'.9$L/')1(.59$A. $

;.-)&55/W.$).+ZA.$1-&X'.-$3'$1.+;)$3.$V(.$0&51-.$A/$02A2Z-(12$h$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3.$V&(-$W-/53(-$)/$L(AA.$

0&51-.$A/$-(0Q.)).$.1$A/$-.0&55/())/50.$3'$+&53.$3'$1Q2e1-.D$4.$1.+;)$.R/0.-Z29$/002A2-29$5.$;.-+.1$

;/)$3.$V(V-.$;A.(5.+.51$A/$V(.D$4U.)1$0.A'($3'$0/;(1/A()+.$.1$3.$A/$;-&3'01(V(12$520.))/(-.9$.LL-252.9$

A/$;&'-)'(1.$3U'5$.-)/1s$3.$Z&5Q.'-$;-&+()$;/-$A/$)&0(212D$%/$0-(1(X'.$V().$;A')$;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$A.$

-fV.$/+2-(0/(5$M$A/$V(1.)).$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$.)1$/))&0(2.$T$A/$;-.))(&5$)&0(/A.$.R.-02.$)'-$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$X'($A.'-$(+;&).$3.$1-/V/(AA.-9$3.$-2'))(-9$3.$^$3.V.5(-$X'.AX'U'5$_D$

B/5)$)/$V()(&5$;&A(1(X'.$3'$+2A&3-/+.9$Y&Z.-1$%/5W$/))&0(.$0/;(1/A()+.$.1$;/1-(/-0/19$.1$

)&'A(W5. $X'U(A) $0&5)1(1'.51 $;-.)X'.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51 $ A/ $ L&-0.$X'( $ )U&;;&). $/'R$;.-)&55/W.) $3'$

+2A&3-/+.$.1$0&51-.$A/X'.AA.$(A)$3.V-&51$A'11.-D$=&'-$A'(9$0.$+&53.$3.$A/$;-&3'01(V(12$.LL-252.$.)1 $

0.A'($3.)$Q&++.)$h$A.)$S&'-5/'R$X'($32L(A.519$A.)$/'1&+&Z(A.)$.1$A.)$Z&A(3.)9$A.)$W-/53.)$1&'-)$3.$

".K$}&-`9$)&51$A.)$+&3,A.)$3.$-2'))(1.$X'U(+;&).51$A.$;/1-(/-0/1$/'R$L.++.)D$^$B/5)$0.11.$3(V()(&5$

3' $ 1-/V/(A $ -.X'(). $;/- $ A. $ 0/;(1/A()+.9 $ A. $^ $ 1-/V/(A $_ $3.) $ L.++.) $.)1 $ (5V()(ZA. $ .1 $ A.'- $32)(- $ .)1$

)'Z&-3&552$/'R$ (+;2-/1(L) $+/)0'A(5) $3. $ A/ $;-&3'01(&5$ -2.AA.D $#&')$ A. $;/1-(/-0/19 $&5$ -.L').$/'R$

L.++.)$A.$-jA.$3U/W.51)$/01(L)$3/5)$AU20&5&+(.$3'$32)(-$.1$3.$AU20Q/5W.9$.AA.)$)&51$-23'(1.)$/'$)1/1'1$

3.$+/-0Q/53().$7b_D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$1-/(1.-/(1$/A&-)$3.$A/$0&5L-&51/1(&5$3'$32)(-$3.$0.)$L.++.)$T$0.$

)1/1'1$X'($A.'-$.)1$(+;&)2.D$^$c'U'5.$L.++.$)&(1$&'$5&5$/'$0.51-.$3'$-20(19$AU(32&A&W(.$3&+(5/51. $

V.'1$X'.$AU.5S.'$3'$+2A&3-/+.$)&(1$'5.$X'.)1(&5$3U(3.51(12$6$3U'5$20Q.0$T$f1-.$+/)0'A(59$&'$Z(.5$3U'5$

20Q.0$T$/00.;1.-$A.)$0&53(1(&5)$-2;-.))(V.)$.1$52W/1-(0.)$3'$)'S.1$X'($)&51$0.AA.)$3'$L2+(5(5$)&')$A.$

;/1-(/-0/17ID$_$B,)$A&-)9$0.$1.+;)$X'($.)1$V'$0&++.$;-20(;(129$;.-3'9$2A&(W5/51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$

AU.)).51(.A$;-.53$'5$).5)$;&A(1(X'.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$/))&0(.$AU/002A2-/1(&5$5&0(V.$3'$1.+;)$X'($;/)).$

/' $ 0/;(1/A()+. $ .1 $ T $ A/ $ 3&+(5/1(&5 $ +/)0'A(5. $ -.);&5)/ZA. $ 3.) $ L-')1-/1(&5) $ .1 $ 3.) $ ;-&ZA,+.)$

(3.51(1/(-.)$3.$).)$;.-)&55/W.)D$aA$.R;A(0(1.$/'))($A/$0&+;A.R(12$3'$32)(-$L2+(5(5$3/5)$'5$+&53.$.5$

7b %/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788G9$;D7@

7I v;D$4(1D$;7>*77

Page 39: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

0Q/5W.+.51$ M $320Q(-2.$.51-.$ A. $ 1-/V/(A $.1 $).)$-.);&5)/Z(A(12)$3.$+,-.$.1 $3U2;&').9 $ AUQ2-&{5.$).-/$

)&'V.51$0&51-/(51.$)'-$'5$+&3.$1-/W(X'.$3.$0Q&()(-$.51-.$A.)$3.'RD

4.11.$/002A2-/1(&5$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$(51-&3'(1$2W/A.+.51$'5$;&(51$3.$V'.$+&-/AD$aA$)U/W(1$

;-.)X'.$3U'5$/V.-1()).+.51 $/3-.))2$/'$);.01/1.'-D $%. $+2A&3-/+.$ A'( $ -/;;.AA. $X'U(A $.)1 $ A'( $/'))( $

0&53/+52$T$A/$+&-1$h$5&5$;/)$T$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+9$+/()$L(5/A.+.51$T$;.(5.$;A')$1/-3D$%U'5.$3.)$V/-(/51.)$

A.)$;A')$);.01/0'A/(-.)$3.$0.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$.LL-252$)&51$A.)$3.-5(,-.)$+(5'1.)$3.$A/$3.-5(,-.$

)/()&5$3. $F"Q'5&&2'W1(&#D$%.$);.01/1.'-$V.--/$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3&51$(A$/$)'(V($A.)$;2-(;21(.)$)'-$b$

)/()&5)$V(.(AA(-$.1$+&'-(-$A.)$'5)$/;-,)$A.)$/'1-.)D$=/)$'5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5.$)'-V(V-/$T$0.11.$1.--(ZA.$

Q20/1&+Z. $ h $ X'.AX'.) $ )0,5.) $ 3. $ V(. $ 320-(-&51 $ A.'- $ 2V&A'1(&5 $ S')X'U/' $+&+.51 $ 3. $ A.'- $+&-19$

)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$-.;-2).512D$4.11.$-2)&A'1(&5$);.01/0'A/(-.$;-&V&X'.$'5.$3&'ZA.$).5)/1(&5$h$0.AA.$

3.$A/$321-.)).$3.V/51$A/$+&-1$3.$1&')$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$/V/(1$/00&+;/W52$A.$1.+;)$

3.$A/$)2-(.9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$A.$).51(+.51$X'.$0.)$+&-1)$L&51$;/-1(.$3.$A/$V(.9$.1$X'.$0.)$;.-)&55/W.)9 $

1&'1$0&++.$A'(*+f+.9$5U/V/(.51$;/)$3.$-/()&5$3.$V(V-.$21.-5.AA.+.51D$4.$0Q&(R$3.$+().$.5$)0,5.$

L&501(&55.$0&++.$'5$4&4&12,'4,#"$3.)1(52$/'$);.01/1.'-D

%.$1.+;)$X'($)U/002A,-.$.)1$/'))($0.A'(9$;A')$;&)(1(L$+/()$;A')$-/-.9$3'$Z&5Q.'-$/Z)&A'D$B/5)$

=#K*& ' #&13,12#&9 $ 3. $B/V(3 $ %./59 $ A.) $ -.53.s*V&') $ 3.) $ 3.'R $ /+/51) $ )&51 $ -.;-2).512) $ ;/- $ 3.)$

)2X'.50.) $3. $+&51/W.9 $ 0U.)1*T*3(-. $ ;/- $'5. $ )'(1. $3. $;A/5) $X'( $ A.) $+&51-. $ .5).+ZA.) $3/5) $3.)$

)(1'/1(&5)$3(LL2-.51.)$)&')$'5.$L&-+.$X'($1(.51$3.$AU(5V.51/(-.$&'$3.$A/$A()1.D$B.)$L&53')$.50Q/(52)$

L&51$;/)).-$3U'5$;A/5$/'$)'(V/519$/V.0$'5$-O1Q+.$-/;(3.9$0&++.$)($T$;.(5.$0&++.5029$AU(5)1/51$

3.V/(1$32ST$).$1.-+(5.-9$)U.)1&+;.-D$4.1$.50Q/n5.+.51$5.$)U/--f1.$X'U'5.$L&()$X'.9$-.1&'-52)$T$A/$W/-.9 $

(A)$).$-.1-&'V.51$)'-$A.$;&(51$3.$).$)2;/-.-D$%.$1.+;)$5.$-.;-.53$)/$0&'-).$5&-+/A.$X'U'5.$L&()$A/ $

S&'-52.$1.-+(52.9$A&-)X'.$A.)$3.'R$/+/51)$2;'()2)$3.$A/$-/;(3(12$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$A.$1.+;)$/'-/$;/))29 $

;-.53-&51 $ A.'-) $ 1-/(5) $ -.);.01(L)D $%. $ LA/)Q $Z/0` $3. $g$0$:)$13$$ &[ $r'+;Q-.O $<&W/-1 $ .1 $ a5W-(3$

<.-W+/5$V(V.51$;A.(5.+.51$ A.'-$;/))(&5$T$=/-() $;.'1*f1-. $ A' $3.$+/5(,-.$)(+(A/(-.D $%.$+&51/W.$

.50Q/n5.$'5.$;-&+.5/3.$.5$V&(1'-.9$'5$/0Q/1$3.$0/0/Q',1.)$)'-$A.)$Z&-3)$3.$#.(5.9$'5$+&+.51$

3U(51(+(12$&[$.AA.$/--/5W.$'5$Z&'X'.1$3.$LA.'-)$.1$1/53()$X'U(A$32Z&'0Q.$A.$0Q/+;/W5.$.19$.5L(59$'5.$

3/5).$.5).+ZA.$3/5)$'5$Z/AD$%.$1.+;)$).+ZA.$/002A2-2$M$0.11.$L&()$5&5$;/)$;/-0.$X'.$A.$+&53.$

(+;&).$)&5$-O1Q+.$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)9$+/()$X'U/'$0&51-/(-.9$;/-0.$X'.$0.$Z&5Q.'-$;/-L/(1$5.$;.'1$X'.$

3&55.-$A/$).5)/1(&5$X'.$1&'1$V/$1-&;$V(1.D$%.)$3.'R$/+&'-.'R$5U&51$;/)$A.$1.+;)$3.$).51(-$A.$1.+;)$

;/)).-9$/Z)&-Z2)$;/-$0.$+&+.51$Z25($&[$(A)$)&51$.5L(5$-2'5()D$t$5&'V./'9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$1-/3'(1$/V.0$

;.))(+()+.$AU(5S')1(0.$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$A.$1.+;)$L-/;;.$A.)$Q&++.)$h$A.)$Z&5Q.'-)$1-&;$(51.5).)$).-&51$

1&'S&'-)$1-&;$0&'-1)9$(-&51$1&'S&'-)$1-&;$V(1.D$%.)$/+&'-.'R$).-&51$)2;/-2)9$.1$(A$5.$-.)1.-/$X'.$0.)$

Z-(Z.)$3.$+&+.51)$(51.5).)9$;/-L/(1)9$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$/'-/$V20'$L'W/0.+.51D$

Page 40: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

( *#+<&1-)1"+<)(+?&1"(+31'+8#(()$.

4.$-O1Q+.$.LL-252$5U.)1$S/+/()$A.$).'A$+&3.$3U2V&A'1(&5$3'$+2A&3-/+.D$%.)$/002A2-/1(&5)$

V(.53-&51$)&'A(W5.-$A/$L&-0.$3'$+&+.51$V20'$&'$A.$1'+'A1.$3.$A/$V(.$+&53/(5.9$+/()$.AA.)$).-&51$

(--2+23(/ZA.+.51$.51-.0&';2.)$3.$+&+.51)$;A')$0&51.+;A/1(L)D$N.5-.$5&)1/AW(X'.$;/-$.R0.AA.50.9$

A. $ L-/0/) $ 3. $ A/ $ V(. $ .1 $ )&5 $ (51.5)(12 $ ). $ V.--&51 $ 0&51-.Z/A/502) $ ;/- $ A.) $+&+.51) $ -2LA.R(L) $ 3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$-fV/51$&'$).$)&'V.5/51$3.$0.)$+&+.51)$Q.'-.'RD$B/5)$=#K*&'#&13,12#&9$A.)$)2X'.50.)$

3.$LA/)Q*Z/0`$)'00,3.51$/'$;-2).51$3'$L(A+$M$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$%/'-/9$/))().$3/5)$'5$L/'1.'(A$/'R$

0j12)$3.$)&5$+/-(9$-.V&(1$0&++.$'5$);.01/1.'-$3.$)/$;-&;-.$V(.$A.)$(+/W.)$3.$A/$-.A/1(&5$/+&'-.').$

X'U.AA. $ / $ V20'.D $ B.'R $ ;A/5) $ V(.55.51 $ S')X'UT $ +2A/5W.- $ A.) $ 3.'R $ +&+.51) $ ;/- $ '5 $ .LL.1 $ 3.$

)'-(+;-.))(&5$h $ 1/53()$X'.$%/'-/$).$)&'V(.519 $.AA. $/;;/-/n1 $3/5)$A. $Z/)$3'$0/3-.$/))().$)'-$)&5$

L/'1.'(A$.1$/))()1/51$T$).)$;-&;-.)$2+&()$/+&'-.'RD$%.$1.+;)$1-&;$-/;(3.$3'$Z&5Q.'-$3.)$C)$08':$3P'

).$-.1-&'V.$0&5L-&512$T$A/$A.51.'-$3.)$)2X'.50.)$-.;-2).51/51$)/$V(.$;-2).51.9$0&5)1(1'2$3.$;A/5)$

L(R.)$.1$;A')$A&5W)$&[$.AA.$5.$X'(11.$;-.)X'.$;/)$)&5$L/'1.'(A9$)O+Z&A.$3.$)&5$/V.5(-$1-/5X'(AA.$.1 $

.55'O.'R$/'R$0j12)$3.$)&5$+/-(D$

%.$+2A&3-/+.$3(A/1.$;.'$A.$1.+;)$X'($;/)).D$t$AU(5V.-).$3'$0(52+/$3.$A/$+&3.-5(12$&[$A. $

1.+;)$3.V(.51$'5$&ZS.1$.5$)&(9$X'.$AU&5$;.'1$L/(-.$).51(-$/'$);.01/1.'-$.5$1/51$X'.$1.A9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$

).$0&50.51-.$1&'S&'-)$)'-$AU/01(&59$)'-$AUQ()1&(-.9$)'-$A.$1.+;)$L&-1D$%/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3.$AU/11.51.9$&' $

3. $ AU.55'( $ 5U/'-/ $ 3&50 $ ;-.)X'. $ S/+/() $ T $ V&(- $ /V.0 $ A/ $ A&5W'.'- $ 3' $ ;A/5D $ |1-/5W.+.519 $ A/$

-.;-2).51/1(&5$3U'5.$).5)/1(&5$3.$A/5W'.'-$).$L/(1$2W/A.+.51$;/-$A.$Z(/()$3.$AU.AA(;).D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$

V(.53-/$3/V/51/W.$S&'.-$)'-$A/$-2;21(1(&59$.1$)'-$A/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)D$B/5)$+>8&-#&'

0-?#G4&$3.$]-/5`$<&-s/W.9$A.)$/552.)$;/))2.)$;/-$B(/5.$T$/11.53-.$4Q(0&$).-&51$/(5)($-.;-2).512.)$

;/-$'5.$)&++.$3U2A2+.51)$X'.$AU&51$-.1-&'V.$/'$L(A$3.)$;A/5)$M$)&5$1-/V/(A$T$AU')(5.9$A.)$/V/50.)$3U'5$

&LL(0(.-9$A.)$/V.51'-.)$1-'0'A.51.)$3.$;2;2$<&'AD$%.$1.+;)$).$1-&'V.$0&50.51-2$;/-$AU.AA(;).9$+/()$A.)$

;A/5) $ ;-.55.51 $ '5. $ V/A.'- $ (12-/1(V. $ h $ A/ $ )0,5. $ X'( $ ).-/ $ -2;212. $ 3.'R $ &' $ 1-&() $ L&() $ T $ AU(+/W.9 $

L&501(&55.-/$.5$-2/A(12$;&'-$3.)$3(s/(5.)9$3.)$0.51/(5.)$3.$S&'-)$)(+(A/(-.)D$%.)$L&53')$.50Q/n52)$3.$

B(/5.$3/5)$AU')(5.9$)&5$W.)1.$1&'S&'-)$)(+(A/(-.$/))().$T$A/$+/0Q(5.9$AU/R.$3.$0/+2-/$X'($5.$0Q/5W.-/$

;/)$;&'-$A/$+&51-.-$/11/ZA2.$/'$1-/V/(ADDD$:'1/51$3U2A2+.51)$X'($3&55.51$$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5$1.+;)$X'($

3'-.9 $3.)$ S&'-)$X'( $). $)'(V.51 $.1 $). $-.)).+ZA.51D $C&'1 $.5$/V/5\/519 $ (A $5U/V/50.$;/)$;'()X'.$ A.)$

S&'-52.)$;/))2.)$)&51$A.)$+f+.)D$%.$1.+;)$;/))2$;/-$B(/5.$A&(5$3.$4Q(0&$)U.+Z&'-Z.9$5U2V&A'.$

;A')9$ZA&X'.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3/5)$'5.$)(1'/1(&5$X'($A.'-$;/-/n1$(51.-+(5/ZA.D

Page 41: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

B/5)' )>.*&12-#&'(&'!4&'!-"#9$0U.)1$A.$+f+.$.LL.1$X'($).$-2;,1.D$P/AW-2$A.)$)/'1)$3/5)$A.$

1.+;)9$X'($0&+;-.)).51$A.)$/552.)$3'-/51$A.)X'.AA.)$P+.$P'(-$V(.(AA(1$1-/5X'(AA.+.51$/';-,)$3.$

P/-1/9$A/$).5)/1(&5$X'.$3&55.$A.$L(A+$.)1$2W/A.+.51$0.AA.$3.$A/$A/5W'.'-$3.)$S&'-)$.1$3.$A/$A.51.'-$

1-/5X'(AA. $3.$ A/ $V(. $X'( $;/)).D $:'$0&'-) $3'$L(A+9 $ A/ $+f+.$)0,5.$).$-2;,1. $ 1-&() $ L&()9 $/V.0$3.)$

320&';/W.)$X'/)($)(+(A/(-.)$h$(A$)U/W(1$3.$A/$)(.)1.$3.$P+.$P'(-D$%.$);.01/1.'-$/))()1.$/'$32Z'1$3'$

L(A+$T$A/$;-.+(,-.$M$P+.$P'(-$.51-.$3/5)$A.$)/A&5$)'(V(.$3.$P/-1/$.1$)U/))&(1$3/5)$A.$L/'1.'(AD$P/-1/$

;-.53$A/$0&'V.-1'-.9$;&)2.$5&5$A&(59$0Q/))/51$3/5)$)&5$W.)1.$A.$0Q(.5$X'($O$.)1$(5)1/AA2D$P+.$P'(- $

)U.53&-1$.1$/;;/-/n1$A.$L/51j+.9$X'($A/$-.W/-3.$3&-+(-9$0.$X'($;-2023.-/$A.'-$;-.+(,-.$-.50&51-.$.1$

A.'- $Q()1&(-.$/+&'-.').D $B/5)$ A/ $3.-5(,-.$;/-1(. $3'$L(A+9 $ A/ $+f+.$)0,5.$).$-2;,1.$X'/)(+.51$T$

AU(3.51(X'.$M$S')X'U/'$0Q(.5$X'($.)1$T$A/$+f+.$;A/0.$.1$T$P/-1/$X'($A.$0Q/)).$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$

;&'-$/11-/;.-$A/$0&'V.-1'-.D$4.11.$L&()$A.$L/51j+.$5U/;;/-/n1$;/)D$=&'-1/51$0.11.$-2;21(1(&5$(5V(1.$Z(.5$

A.$);.01/1.'-$T$5.$;.5).-$X'UT$A'(9$1&'1$0&++.$P+.$P'(-9$X'($5.$;.'1$&'ZA(.-$)&5$/+&'-$(+;&))(ZA.$

;&'-$A.$Z./'$L/51j+.D$%/$3.-5(,-.$)2X'.50.$-.;-.53$1&')$0.)$2A2+.51)$T$5&'V./'D$4.11.$L&()9$P+.$

P'(-$V/$L/(-.$)/$3.-5(,-.$)(.)1.$M$.AA.$.)1$1-,)$eW2.$.1$)U21.(51$3&'0.+.51$3/5)$)&5$L/'1.'(A9$-.5V.-)/51$

)&5$V.--.$3.$A/(1$3/5)$'5$3.-5(.-$)&'LLA.D$%.$L/51j+.$-.V(.53-/9$0&++.$A&-)$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$)(.)1.9$

;&'-$;/-1(-$/V.0$.AA.$3/5)$AU/'*3.AT$&[$(A)$V(V-&51$.5L(5$;A.(5.+.519$A.'-$-.A/1(&5$.5).+ZA.D$<(.5$X'.$

A/$V(.(AA.)).$3.$5&+Z-.').)$/552.)$3.$P+.$P'(-$)&(1$L(5/A.+.51$-.;-2).512.$.5$;.'$3.$1.+;)$.1$3.$

;A/5)9$A/$-2;21(1(&5$3.$0.11.$)(.)1.$-(1'.AA.9$AU.R/01(1'3.$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$A.)$2A2+.51)$-.V(.55.519$3&55.$

AU(+;-.))(&5$3.$AU(5L(5(12$3'$1.+;)$;/))2D$4&+Z(.5$3.$)(.)1.)9$3&51$&5$5U.5$-.;-2).51.-/$L(5/A.+.51$

X'. $ 1-&() $k $%/$).5)/1(&5 $ L(5/A. $X'U.5$ -.1(-. $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $.)1 $0.AA. $3U'5. $ 1-/5X'(AA(12 $ 1-()1.9 $3U'5 $

Z&5Q.'-$.5$3.+(*1.(51.9$3&51$A.)$+/AQ.'-)$.1$A.)$Z&5Q.'-)$.R1-f+.)$)&51$.R0A')D

%/$A.51.'-$3.)$S&'-)$X'($;/)).51$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$1-,)$)&'V.51$/))&0(2.$T$A/$-2)(W5/1(&5$

.1$T$A/$V(.(AA.)).D$#($A.$1.+;)$)U20&'A.$/V.0$A.51.'-$.1$1-/5X'(AA(129$0U.)1$X'.$A/$A'11.$)U.)1$/0Q.V2.$;&'-$

A.$;.-)&55/W.$h$(A$/$)&(1$&Z1.5'$0.$X'U(A$V&'A/(19$)&(1$/$/00.;12$3.$5.$;/)$/11.(53-.$)&5$Z'1D$%.$-O1Q+.$

.LL-252$3'$+2A&3-/+.$5U/$;A')$A(.'$3Uf1-.$M$)($A/$A'11.$.)1$1.-+(52.9$A.$1.+;)$;.'1$).$+.11-.$T$;/)).- $

/V.0$3/V/51/W.$3.$1-/5X'(AA(129$A.$;.-)&55/W.$0.))/51$3Uf1-.$Q/;;2$;/-$AU&ZS.1$3.$)&5$32)(-D$%.)$0/)$&[ $

A.$;.-)&55/W.$&Z1(.51$0.$X'U(A$V.'1$)&51$L(5/A.+.51$1-,)$-/-.)h$A.$+2A&3-/+.$).$1.-+(5.$)&'V.51$;/-$

)&5$20Q.0D$4.)$+&+.51)$3.$0/A+.)$).-&51$/A&-)$0.'R$3.$3U'5$-.W/-3$-21-&);.01(L$3'$;.-)&55/W.$)'-$

)/$V(.D$B/5)$A.$0/)$&[$A.$8$??N'&1($AU.+;&-1.9$(A$/--(V.$/'$3.-5(.-$+&+.51$.1$(A$.)1$-/-.$3.$V&(-$;/)).-$

3'$1.+;)$/;-,)$A/$-2'))(1.$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$%U(+/W.$L(5/A.$.)1$0.AA.$3'$0&';A.$-2'5($E+h.-#,#&;'+&0 '

)-4"K#&0'(&')$'*"))&Y;'3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$-20&50(A(2)$E7$),10'$"%-"))&0F9$3.$A/$L(5$3.$A/$0-().$EX&##"K#&')& '

4"#,"#;'+$'38$22&'0-#'-1'2,"2':#V)$12FD$%.$);.01/1.'-$5.$V.--/$;/)$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$3.$Z&5Q.'-$

3'-/ZA.$h$(A$).-/$T$;.(5.$-.;-2).5129$A.$1.+;)$3U'5$(5)1/519$/V/51$X'.$5.$)U/0Q,V.$A.$L(A+D

Page 42: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%/$+/S&-(12$3.)$+2A&3-/+.)$).$1.-+(5.51$0.;.53/51$;/-$'5.$-2)(W5/1(&5D$C/&9$V(.(AA())/519$

/00.;1.$AU(32.$3Uf1-.$)2;/-2.$3.$)&5$L(A)9$#1.AA/$B/AA/)$)U.R0A'1$V&A&51/(-.+.51$3.$A/$V(.$3.$)/$L(AA.9 $

P+.$P'(-$).$A/()).$V(.(AA(-$).'A.$;'()X'.$A.$L/51j+.$3'$0/;(1/(5.$5.$-.V(.53-/$;A')DDD$#($A.$L-/0/)$3'$

+&53.$.1$A/$V(1.)).$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$;/)).$A.$1.+;)$.)1$S'W2$52W/1(V.+.51$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$0&++.$

'5.$.--.'- $3.) $;.-)&55/W.) $X'( $ ). $ A/()).51 $321&'-5.- $;/- $3.) $3()1-/01(&5) $L'1(A.)9 $ A/ $ -2)(W5/1(&5$

).+ZA.$/'$0&51-/(-.$S'W2.$0&++.$'5.$L&-+.$3.$)/W.)).D$!AA.$.)1$A/$).'A.$L&-+.$3.$Z&5Q.'-$3'-/ZA.$

;&))(ZA.$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$0.AA.$&[$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3U/00.;1.$)&5$)&-1$.1$0.)).$3.$A'11.-D$Y&Z.-1 $

%/5W$20-(1$M$

^ $ A. $+2A&3-/+.$5. $;-&;&).$;/) $3. $-.+;A/0.- $ A. $;/1-(/-0/1 $;/- $/'1-. $0Q&). $3.$

WA&Z/A.+.51$+.(AA.'-$h $ A.$)'S.1$EL2+(5(5$&'$+/)0'A(5F$5.$;.'1 $-(.5$/11.53-.$3.$

+(.'R$X'U'5.$)&-1.$3U/3/;1/1(&5$T$A/$0'A1'-.$3&+(5/51.D$#($AU.);&(-$3'$0Q/5W.+.51$

)'Z)()1.9$+f+.$A.)$;-&1.)1/1(&5)$A.)$;A')$V(&A.51.)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$5U/;;.AA.51$;/)$

3.$0Q/5W.+.51$-/3(0/AD$%.$+2A&3-/+.$-.0&55/n1$0.$L/(1$X'.$5&')$)&++.)$1&')$6$

Q&++.)$.1$L.++.)$*$/))'S.11()$T$A/$%&($EuF$*$^$AU&-3-.$)&0(/A$A2W/A.+.51$21/ZA($_$*$

.5$1/51$X'U.AA.$.)1$L&532.$)'-$A/$3(LL2-.50.$3.)$).R.)$.1$X'U.AA.$/$0.11.$3(LL2-.50.$

;&'-$&-(W(5.7JD$_

=/)$3.$-2V&A'1(&59$;/)$3.$0Q/5W.+.51$+/S.'-$M$AU&;;-.))(&5$X'.$)'Z(1$A.$32)(-$3'$;.-)&55/W.$.)1$'5$

21/1 $3.$L/(1 $X'U(A $20Q&'.-/$T $0&+Z/11-.D $%/$).'A.$V&(.$-/()&55/ZA. $;&'-$ A'(9 $0U.)1 $3U/00.;1.- $)&5$

(+;'())/50.D$%.$S'W.+.51$+&-/A$3.$0.11.$V(.$/3&'0(.9$L/(1.$3.$-2)(W5/1(&5$.1$3U/00.;1/1(&5$3.$)/$

;-&;-.$+(),-.$Q'+/(5.$.)1$3&50$.5$'5$).5)$;&)(1(V.$h$(A$)U/W(1$3U'5.$L&-+.$3U/00.;1/1(&5$3'$+&53.$

1.A$X'U(A$.)19$X'.$AUQ&++.$5.$;.'1$;/)$0Q/5W.-D$Y&Z.-1$%/5W$0(1/51$!A)/.)).-9$20-(1$/'))($$M

^ $ %. $ +&53. $ .)1 $ 0A&)9 $ A.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ )&51 $ /W() $ ;/- $ 3U/'1-.)D $ t $ L&-0. $ 3.$

)&'LL-/50.)9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$A.'-$0&5L,-.$'5.$(3.51(12$52W/1(V.9$AU(++&A/1(&5$3.$)&($

.1$A.)$32)(AA')(&5)$X'($).$)'00,3.51$/Z&'1()).51$W252-/A.+.51$T$A/$-2)(W5/1(&5$M$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$2+.-W.51$0&++.$3.)$f1-.)$/+&(53-()$;&'-$f1-.$3.V.5')$;A')$)/W.)$.1$

;A')$0&5).51/51$3.V/51$A.$+&53.$0&++.$(A$V/7GD$_$

t$5&'V./'$3/5)$A/$A&W(X'.$3'$+2A&3-/+.9$-(.5$5U.)1$&Z1.5'$)/5)$)/0-(L(0.$h$A/$1-/5X'(AA(12$).$L.-/$/'$

;-(R$3.$AU.);&(-$.1$3.$AU(AA')(&5$3'$32)(-D$B/5)$)&0'J$#$?)-"&0'(&'g8&#:,-#%9$A.$);.01/1.'-$-.1-&'V.$

7J %/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD$;D77

7G v;D$0(1D$;D$78

Page 43: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

N.5.V(,V. $+,-. $ 3. $ L/+(AA. $ .1 $ .5 $+/51./' $ 3. $ L&'--'-.9 $ .1 $ (A $ A/ $ 3.V(5.9 $ /' $ L&539 $ (5)/1()L/(1.9$

;'()X'U.AA.$/$).51($A.$Z.)&(5$(--2;-.))(ZA.$3.$;/)).-$;/-$4Q.-Z&'-W$/A&-)$X'U.AA.$5U/$;A')$-(.5$T$O$L/(-.D$

!AA.$-.;/-1 $.5$V&(1'-.$/;-,)$)/$-.50&51-.$/V.0$N'O9$2+'.$.1 $5&)1/AW(X'.9$+/()$5.$3&'1.$;/)$'5$

(5)1/51$3.$AT$&[$.)1$)/$;A/0.$M$/';-,)$3.$)/$L/+(AA.$T$=/-()D$N.5.V(,V.$/$.51(,-.+.51$/))(+(A2$A/$

-Q21&-(X'. $ ;/1-(/-0/A. $ ;&-12. $ ;/- $ )/ $ +,-. $ X'( $ AU/V/(1 $ ;&'))2. $ T $ 2;&').- $ Y&A/53 $ 4/))/-3D $ #($

N.5.V(,V.$;-&1.)1.$'5$1.+;)9$)&5$)1/1'1$3.$L(AA.*+,-.$A'($L/(1$/00.;1.-$A/$;-&;&)(1(&5$3.$Y&A/53$M$

(50/;/ZA.$3.$A'11.- $L/0.$T$ A/$;-.))(&5$)&0(/A.9 $.AA.$2;&').$0.A'( $X'U.AA.$5U/(+.$;/)9 $+/()$X'($ A'($

;-&+.1$'5.$)(1'/1(&5D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$5.$;-&;&).$L(5/A.+.51$;/)$3U/A1.-5/1(V.$T$0.$+&53.$;/1-(/-0/A$

.1$).+ZA.$/LL(-+.-$X'.$A.$).'A$+&O.5$3UO$f1-.$Q.'-.'R9$0U.)1$3U/00.;1.-$AU20Q.0$3.$)&5$;-&;-.$32)(-9 $

)&5$(+;&))(Z(A(12$3/5)$A.$+&53.$1.A$X'U(A$.)1D$%.$1.+;)$V(32$3.$A/$;-20(;(1/1(&59$3.$AU'-W.50.9$5.$;.'1$

L(5/A.+.51$X'Uf1-.$0.A'($3.$AU/Z/53&5$3.$).)$32)(-)9$3.$A/$L(5$3'$Z&5Q.'-$1.A$X'.$A.$;.-)&55/W.$AU/V/(1$

L/51/)+2$.1$3.$AU/00.;1/1(&5$3U'5.$.R()1.50.$;A')$1.-5.D$

4.)$3.'R$+&3/A(12)$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$-.LA,1.51$L(5/A.+.51$0Q/0'5$'5$

21/1 $ 3' $ ;.-)&55/W. $ 3/5) $ )/ $ )(1'/1(&5 $ 3. $ 32)(-D $ %/ $ -/;(3(12 $ .1 $ A. $ L-/0/) $ 3' $+&53. $ A&-)X'. $ A.$

;.-)&55/W.$).+ZA.$V&(-$).)$-fV.)$).$-2/A().-$h$A/$A.51.'-$.1$A/$-2;21(1(&5$A&-)X'U(A$).$1-&'V.$L-')1-2$&'$

32L(5(1(V.+.51 $ -2)(W52D $B/5)$ A. $+2A&3-/+.$;A') $0&51.+;&-/(59 $ A. $ 1.+;)$ -.)1. $0.A'( $3. $ AU/01(&59$

(5V/-(/ZA.+.51$A(2$/'R$32)(-)$.1$/'R$/01(&5)$3'$;.-)&55/W.)$+/()$(A$).$0&+;A.R(L(.D$=A')$(-&5(X'.9 $

;A')$3()1/50(2$3'$+&3,A.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$3.)$32Z'1)9$AU/;;-2Q.5)(&5$3'$1.+;)$;.'1$).$L/(-.$;A')$

(5Q/Z(1'.AA.9 $ .1 $ ;A') $ (5X'(21/51. $ ;&'- $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ h $ A/ $ ;.-0.;1(&5 $ .5 $ .)1 $ ;A') $ ;-&L&532+.51$

)'ZS.01(V.9$V/-(/ZA.9$3(LL(0(A.$T$)/()(-D$

( *)+.)68(+31'+&88")(()

%/$3(A/1/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$.)1$AU'5.$3.)$+/-X'.)$3U'5$0(52+/$;A')$+&3.-5.9$X'($0/-/012-().$.51-.$

/'1-.)9$A.$;/))/W.$3.$AU(+/W.*+&'V.+.51$T$AU(+/W.*1.+;)$1Q2&-()2$;/-$N(AA.)$B.A.'s.D$#($A.$;-(50(;.$

3. $ -.53-. $ AU/01(&5 $ 0&Q2-.51. $3&+(5. $ A. $+2A&3-/+.9 $ 0.-1/(5) $ 0/) $ ;A') $ &' $+&(5) $+/-W(5/'R $3'$

+2A&3-/+.9$;.'V.51$ AU'1(A().-$;&'-$;-&3'(-.$3.)$).5)/1(&5)$3(LL2-.51.)D $Y&Z.-1$%/5W$;-&3'(1 $'5.$

/5/AO).$3''+N0'=#"0@9$&[$(A$-.+/-X'.9$Z(.5$/V/51$A.$52&-2/A()+.9$0.11.$3(A/1/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$M

$^$4m.)1$Am(+;&))(ZA.$.1Q&)$).R'.A$V(01&-(.5$X'($0&5)1(1'.$'5.$(+;/)).9$-.LA212$3/5)$

A/$)1-'01'-.$+f+.$3'$L(A+$.1$)&5$.)1Q21(X'.$~$A.)$;A/5)$;-&A&5W2)9$A.)$1/ZA./'R$

0&+;&)2)9 $ A.)$ L&53)$LA&')9 $ A.)$V/A.'-) $;(01'-/A.)9 $ A.) $)O+21-(.) $0.51-(;,1.)D $%/$

3(LL2-.50.$3.)$-/0.)$.)1$;-2).512.$0&++.$A.$;-(50(;/A$&Z)1/0A.$/'$Z&5Q.'-$3/5)$+&'

Page 44: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+N0':#"0@9$+/()$)/$);20(L(0(12$.)1$5&5*;.-1(5.51.9$0/-$0Q/X'.$L&-+.$3.$3(LL2-.50.$

-.;-2).512. $ (0( $ ~ $ -.A(W(.').9 $ .)1Q21(X'.9 $ 20&5&+(X'.9 $ ).R'.AA. $ ~ $ -.5V&(.$

(++23(/1.+.51$T$'5.$/'1-.9$+&51-/51$X'm.AA.)$)&51$1&'1.)$A(2.)$.51-.$.AA.)$EDDDF$%.$

L(A+$.)1$&Z)232$;/-$A/$3(LL2-.50.$3.$L/\&5$/Z)&A'.$.1$;/-/AO)/51.9$/'$;&(51$X'.$A.$

-20(1$A'(*+f+.$5m/V/50.$;-.)X'.$;/)D$_7?

%UQ()1&(-.$3U/+&'-$L21(0Q()1.$3'$+N0':#"0@$(51-&3'(-/$A.$-/A.51()).+.51$3U'5.$;-&W-.))(&5$3.$AU(51-(W'.9$

-.+;A/02.)$;/-$A/$-2(12-/1(&5$3U'5$+&1(L$/'$).(5$3'$L(A+$M$A.$-.W/-3$/+&'-.'R$3'$0Q(5&()$)'-$A/$S.'5. $

L(AA.D$%.'-$;-.+(,-.$-.50&51-.$3/5)$A/$-'.9$AU(--';1(&5$T$3.+(*0&5)0(.51.$3.$A/$S.'5.$L(AA.$3/5)$)/$

Z&'1(X'.9$;'()$A.)$3.'R$)2X'.50.)$&[$A.$);.01/1.'-$A.$V&(1$)U&00';.-$3U.AA.9$S')X'U/;-,)$A/$+&-1$3.$

0.AA.*0(9$A.$V&A$3'$0&-;)$.1$A.)$3.-5(.-)$Q&++/W.)$X'U(A$A'($-.53D$%.$+&1(L$).$-2;,1.9$(5A/))/ZA.+.519 $

0.A'($3'$V()/W.$-.W/-3/519$/00&A2$T$0.A'($3'$V()/W.$-.W/-32$h$AUQ()1&(-.$).+ZA.$;/-L&()$5.$;/)$/V&(-$3. $

-2.AA.$-/()&5$3U/V/50.-$/'1-.$X'.$A/$-2;21(1(&5$3.$0.$-.W/-3D$%U/+&'-$L&'$3'$0Q(5&()$;&'-$A/$S.'5. $

L(AA.$.5V/Q($A.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+9$.5$;-&V&X'.$A/$3(A/1/1(&59$A.$32-/(AA.+.51D$%U&ZS.1$3'$32)(-$3.V(.51$1.A$

;&'-$A.$;.-)&55/W.9$X'.$)/$L&A(.$.AA.*+f+.$0&51/+(5.$A.$1.+;)$3.$A/$5/--/1(&5$.1$5.$+,5.$;A')$X'UT $

A/$-2;21(1(&5D$4&++.$'5.$+/0Q(5.$X'U'5$32L/'1$+20/5(X'.$V(.53-/(1$/A12-.-$.1$X'($1&'-5.-/(19$T$V(3.9$

.5$-2;21/51$1&'S&'-)$A.$+f+.$+&'V.+.51$)12-(A.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$'1(A().$T$5&'V./'$A/$-2;21(1(&59$+/()$

0.11.$L&()$;&'-$)&'A(W5.-$AU&Z).))(&5$3'$32)(-D$%/$).5)/1(&5$3.$A/$A/5W'.'-$3.)$S&'-)$X'($;/)).51$.)1 $

-.+;A/02.$;/-$'5.$L&-+.$3.$L&A(.$&Z).))(&55.AA.9$;/-$A.$0/)$&[$A.$32)(-$;-.53$1&'1.$A/$;A/0.$.1$/--f1.$

A.$1.+;)9$A'($3&55/51$A/$L&-+.$3U'5.$Z&'0A.$3&51$&5$5.$)&-1$;A')D

B. $+/5(,-. $;A') $ 0&51.+;&-/(5.9 $:Z3.AA/1(L $y.0Q(0Q. $+. $ ).+ZA. $ S&'.- $ A'( $ /'))( $ )'- $ A/$

3(A/1/1(&5$3.)$)(1'/1(&5)$;&'-$A.)$-.53-.$T$;.(5.$)';;&-1/ZA.)D$%/$)2X'.50.$3.$-';1'-.$3/5)$+$'*"& '

(>.(K)&')U21(-.$)'-$I$+(5'1.)$3'-/51$A.)X'.AA.)$A.)$3.'R$S.'5.)$L.++.)9$!++/$.1$:3,A.9$-2;,1.51$T$

AU(5L(5($A.)$+f+.)$;Q-/).)$M$A.$1.+;)$).+ZA/51$-.50&51-.-$'5$;&(51$3.$Z&'0A.9$&[$.AA.)$).$1-&'V.51$

AU'5.$0&++.$AU/'1-.9$T$32L.53-.$A.'-$;&)(1(&5$3.$+/5(,-.$;-.)X'.$L&AA.9$QO)12-(X'.9$)/5)$2V&A'1(&5D$

B/5)$'5.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$3.$A/$)2X'.50.9$!++/$(51.--&W.$:3,A.9$1.51/51$3.$A/$L/(-.$/V&'.-$)&5$

/3'A1,-.9$1/53()$X'U:3,A.$)U&Z)1(5.$T$5(.-$1&'1.)$A.)$/00')/1(&5)$3U!++/D$%/$0&5V.-)/1(&5$).$L/(1$)'- $

'5 $+&3. $ -2;21(1(L9 $ )O)12+/1(X'. $ M $ !++/ $ ;&). $ A.) $ X'.)1(&5)9 $:3,A. $ 1-&'V. $ '5 $ 321&'- $ &' $ '5.$

S')1(L(0/1(&5 $ )'- $ A/X'.AA. $ -.Z&53(1 $ !++/D $ !5L(59 $ A&-)X'U:3,A. $ L(5(1 $ ;/- $ /V&'.- $ )/ $ 1-/Q()&59 $ A/$

)2X'.50.$;/)).$T$'5.$/'1-.$Z&'0A.$h$&[$!++/$1.51.$3.$L/(-.$;/-1(-$:3,A.9$A'($S.1/51$).)$/LL/(-.)$/'$

V()/W.$.1$-2;21/519$(5A/))/ZA.+.51$X'U.AA.$5U.)1$X'U'5.$^$;.1(1.$;'1.$_$.1$X'U.AA.$5.$V.'1$;A')$A/$V&(-9$

1/53()$X'U:3,A.$L/(1 $ -2)()1/50.$/'$-.S.1 $3U!++/D$%/$)2X'.50.9 $X'( $/'-/(1 $;'$3'-.-$@8$).0&53.)9$

1-&'V.$)/$L&-0.$3/5)$A/$-2;21(1(&5$(5)';;&-1/ZA.$3.)$W.)1.)$.1$3.)$+&1)D$%/$).5)/1(&5$.)1$0.AA.$3U'5$

7? %/5W9$Y&Z.-19$)&'4@),(#$4&'$4@#"3$"1'A'B#"CC"28;'D"(,#;'!"11&))"9$1-/3D$"&qA$<'-0Q9$=/-()$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD$;Db>

Page 45: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

32-,WA.+.51$3'$1.+;)$h$A/$L&A(.$)U.+;/-.$3'$-O1Q+.$+f+.$3.$A/$V(.D$%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$

;.-3$(0($'5$;.'$)&5$/);.01$A(52/(-.$h$(A$5.$)U/W(1$;A')$).'A.+.51$3.$-.;-2).51.-$AU.50Q/n5.+.51$3.)$

+&+.51)$L&-1)$S')X'UT$A.'-$-2)&A'1(&5$+/()$3.$A.)$21(-.-$S')X'UT$AU2;'().+.519$3.$A.)$-2;21.-9$3.$A.) $

3()1&-3-.D$%.$1.+;)$3.V(.51$)'S.1$T$1&'1.$A.)$+/5(;'A/1(&5)$.R1-f+.)D$!5$-.V/50Q.$AU(51.51(&5$-.)1.$A/$

+f+.$M$0U.)1$Z(.5$;&'-$(50/-5.-$'5.$).5)/1(&5$3.$L&A(.$.1$3&50$'5.$)'ZS.01(V(129$'5$+&'V.+.51$3'$

32)(- $3'$;.-)&55/W.$X'( $/ $0.11. $ L&() $;.-3'$ 1&'1. $/11/0Q.$-/1(&55.AA.9 $X'.$ A. $ 1.+;)$.)1 $ 1-/V/(AA29 $

-.0&5)1-'(1D$

%.$1.+;)$X'($&;;-.)).9$0U.)1$2W/A.+.51$A.$1.+;)$(5320Q(LL-/ZA.9$/'R$)/'1.)$(5)&53/ZA.)$;&'-$

A.$);.01/1.'-D$v5$AU/$V'9$A.$);.01/1.'-$0&5L-&512$T$AU.AA(;).$.)1$(50/;/ZA.$3.$+.)'-.-$A.$1.+;)$;/))2$

)/5)$(53(0.)$V()/51$T$A.$A'($)(W5/A.-$3/5)$A/$)'(1.$3'$L(A+D$%/$0&';.$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$.)1$;/-$32L(5(1(&5$

(50&++.5)'-/ZA.D$Y&+;-.$A/$A(52/-(12$3'$1.+;)9$0U.)1$3&50$;.-3-.$A.$);.01/1.'-9$A.$A/()).-$).'A$1.51.-$

3U2V/A'.-$A.$-O1Q+.$3.$0.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)D$B/5) $[$??N'7,%&28&#; 'z&5W$y/-*z/($)U.5$).-1$;&'-$

0-2.-$A/$0&5L')(&5$.1$A.$+/A/().D$4&';.)$Z-'1/A.)9$L/'R*-/00&-3)9$)/'1.$3U/R.9$A.$320&';/W.$3'$L(A+$

.)1$L/(1$;&'-$+.11-.$A.$);.01/1.'-$+/A$T$AU/().9$(50/;/ZA.$3.$).$)(1'.-$3/5)$AU.);/0.$+/()$2W/A.+.51$

3/5)$A.$1.+;)D$t$5&'V./'9$A/$0&5L')(&5$.)1$0.AA.$3'$;.-)&55/W.$M$%/($}('*]/($.)1$;.-3'$T$<'.5&)$

:(-.)9$0&51-/(51$T$'5$.R(A$X'U(A$5U/$;/)$0Q&()($.1$(50/;/ZA.$3.$).$32L/(-.$3.$)&5$/50(.5$/+/51$r&$=&*

z(5W$/V.0$A.X'.A$(A$V(1$'5.$;/))(&5$3.)1-'01-(0.9$&Z).))(&55.AA.9$0O0A(X'.D$d5$+&+.51$3. $[$??N'

7,%&28&# '.)1 $;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51 $ L-/;;/51 $ )'- $ 0. $;&(51 $ M $ A&-) $3U'5. $25(,+. $3();'1. $.51-. $ A.) $3.'R$

/+/51)9$%/($}('*]/($+.1$r&$=&*z(5W$T$A/$;&-1.D$4.11.$L&()$A/$-';1'-.$).+ZA.$0&5)&++2.D$d5$;A/5$

)(A.50(.'R$+&51-/51$%/($}('$]/(.$.5L(5$).'A$V(.51$0&5)1(1'.-$'5$+&+.51$3.$-2;(1$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-$

/;-,)$'5.$)2X'.50.$3.$3();'1.$0/+2-/$T$AU2;/'A.$&[$A.)$3.'R$Q&++.)$).$Q'-A.51$3.))')D$=&'-1/519$

3,)$A.$;A/5$3U/;-,)9$A.$);.01/1.'-$-.1-&'V.$%/($}('$]/(.$.1$r&$=&*z(5W$T$5&'V./'$-2'5()$3/5)$A/ $

+f+. $ 0Q/+Z-. $ .R(W'qD $%/ $ )1-'01'-. $3' $ L(A+ $0&';. $ A.) $ -.1-&'V/(AA.) $ .1 $ A/ $ -20&50(A(/1(&59 $ ;&'-$

-/+.5.-$A.$);.01/1.'-$/'$+f+.$;&(51$3.$32;/-19$X'($;-20,3.$AU2;-&'V/51.$)2X'.50.$3.$3();'1.$M$1&'1$

.)1$T$-.0&++.50.-D$%U/);.01$0O0A(X'.$3'$L(A+$.1$AU(--2W'A/-(12$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$;/)).$A.$1.+;)$2;&').51$

A.) $ +&'V.+.51) $ 3' $ 32)(- $ 0Q/&1(X'. $ 3.) $ 3.'R $ Q&++.)D $z&5W $ y/-*z/( $ 0&5)1-'(1 $ '5 $ 1.+;)$

&;;-.))/519$3(LL(0(A.$T$320Q(LL-.-9$0&51/+(52$;/-$A.)$2+&1(&5)$3.)1-'01-(0.)$3.)$3.'R$/+/51)D$

C-/3'()/51$'5.$2+&1(&5$3(LL2-.51.9$0.$S.'$)'-$A.$1.+;)$3.$AU.AA(;).$A/())2$(5321.-+(52$;/-$A.$

-2/A()/1.'- $ .)1 $ 2W/A.+.51 $ ;-2).51 $ 3/5) $+h$4,-# '/' 4,#2 '3U:A/(5 $Y.)5/()D $4Q/X'. $ )2X'.50. $ .)1$

)2;/-2.$3.$A/$)'(V/51.$;/-$AU(+/W.$3U'5$0(.A$&[$1&+Z.$;A')$&'$+&(5)$3.$5.(W.9$Q/0Q/51$A.$-O1Q+.$3'$

L(A+$3U/'1/51$3.$;.1(1.)$.51-/01.)$X'U(A$O$/$3U.AA(;).)$1.+;&-.AA.)D$%.$);.01/1.'-$5.$)/(1$;/)$0&+Z(.5$

3.$1.+;)$.)1$;/))2$.51-.$0Q/0'5.$3.$0.)$)2X'.50.)D$=/-L&()$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$A'($3&55.51$'5$(53(0.$*$

A.$V&O/W.$;-2V'$3/5)$A.$P())&'-($&'$A/$).0&53.$+&-1$3.$#(+&5$L&501(&55.51$0&++.$3.)$-.;,-.)$

Page 46: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

3/5)$AUQ()1&(-.$6$+/()$A/$;A';/-1$3'$1.+;)9$A.$);.01/1.'-$(W5&-.$A.$1.+;)$;/))2$3U'5.$)2X'.50.$T$

AU/'1-.D $%.)$;A/5)$3.$5.(W.$)&51 $/00&+;/W52)$3U'5.$+')(X'.$3())&5/51.$.1 $ A/ $X'/51(12 $3.$5.(W.$

1&+Z/51. $ ).+ZA. $ V/-(.- $ 3. $+/5(,-. $ /A2/1&(-.D $4.11. $ (+;-.))(&5 $ 3U(--2W'A/-(129 $ 3. $ Q/)/-3 $ .1 $ A.)$

-';1'-.)$0&51(5'.)$3'$1.+;)$3'$L(A+$3&55.51$/'$);.01/1.'-$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5$1.+;)$X'($)U20&'A.$3.$

+/5(,-.$0Q/&1(X'.9$(50&+;-2Q.5)(ZA.D$%.$1.+;)$.)1$V'$0&++.$'5$+O)1,-.$;&'-$AUQ&++.9$/'$+f+.$

1(1-.$X'.$A/$V(.$.1$A/$+&-1D$%.)$;A/5)$L&51$/11.53-.$'5.$.R;A(0/1(&5$h$&5$.51-.$3/5)$A.$L(A+$;/-$A/$+&-1 $

.1$A/$-2)'--.01(&5$3U'5$Q&++.9$3&51$(A$L/'3-/$/11.53-.$'5.$.AA(;).$.1$A/$)2X'.50.$)'(V/51.$;&'-$.5$

0&+;-.53-. $ A. $ ).5)D $t$5&'V./'9 $0.11. $W.)1(&5 $3' $ 1.+;)$ 1-/3'(1 $ AU2+&1(&5 $3.) $;.-)&55/W.) $ M $ A.$

);.01/1.'-$).$).51$)/5)$0.)).$0&';2$3'$L(A+9$(51.--&+;'9$1&'1$0&++.$#(+&59$/O/51$/))()12$T$A/$+&-19 $

5. $;.'1 $ ;A') $ L/(-. $;/-1(. $3. $ A/ $V(.D $t $5&'V./'9 $ 0. $ 1.+;) $;.-1'-Z2 $3' $ L(A+9 $ X'( $ ;-&V&X'. $3.)$

3(LL(0'A12)$3.$A.01'-.$/'$);.01/1.'-9$V(.51$)(W5/A.-$'5$32)2X'(A(Z-.$0Q.s$A.$;.-)&55/W.D$%/$-.A/1(&5$3.$

#(+&5$T$A/$+&-19$3&51$&5$5.$)/'-/$S/+/()$Z(.5$)($.AA.$.)1$1&'1$T$L/(1$).5)2.$&'$1&'1.$T$L/(1$L&AA.9$

0&51/+(5.$A.$L(A+$h$A/$-2;21(1(&5$3.$0.)$;A/5)$3.$0(.A$L.-/$Z(.5$)i-$20Q&$T$A/$X'.)1(&5$3.$AU/'*3.AT9$X'( $

&Z),3. $ 1&') $ A.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ .1 $ V(.53-/ $ -.1-/5)0-(-. $ AU&Z).))(&5 $ 3. $ #(+&59 $ X'( $ AU.+;f0Q. $ 3.$

;/-1(0(;.-$;A.(5.+.51$T$A/$V(.D$

$

Page 47: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

PIQRHS!I(<DCFHI(3(

$

(;'(,'#.+()9(#"0$)&*#'2(

-,&9/,9&'()9(#$1,*@'(',(&"/9&&'1/'+

$

t$1-/V.-)$1-&()$/5/AO).)

+,-),-$3.$=:<#C

!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$3.$#aYy

.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%&0$3.$wr:"Ny!

Page 48: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%/ $ )1-'01'-. $+f+. $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ (51-&3'(1 $ '5 $ ;&(51 $ 3. $ V'. $ )'- $ A. $ 1.+;) $ X'( $ A'( $ .)1$

);20(L(X'.D$%.$-.W/-3$X'U(A$;&-1.$)'-$A.$32L(A.+.51$3'$1.+;)$.)1$;-&;-.$/'$W.5-.$M$A.$-/;;&-1$.51-.$

;/))29 $ ;-2).51 $ .1 $ L'1'-9 $+/() $ 2W/A.+.51 $ A/ $ 0-&O/50. $ .5 $ '5. $ 0(-0'A/-(12 $ 3' $ 1.+;)D $ =&'- $ .51-.-$

3/V/51/W.$3/5)$A.)$321/(A)9$5&')$21'3(.-&5)$A/$)1-'01'-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$T$1-/V.-)$1-&()$.R.+;A.)9$X'( $

S/A&55.51$AUQ()1&(-.$3'$+'.1$T$5&)$S&'-)$M$+,-),-$3.$=:<#C;'!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$3.$#aYy$.1$.-a(&)/ '

(&0'4,12$%&0$ 3.$wr:"Ny!D$C-&()$L(A+)$ 9$X'($;-&V(.55.51$3.$0&51(5.51)$3(LL2-.51)$.1$&[$.5L(59$

;/)).51$A.)$/552.)$M$%U:AA.+/W5.$.5$>?7J9$A.)$d#:$.5$>?b?9$&'$A/$4Q(5.$.5$78>b$0&51(5'.51$3.$

;.5).-$A.$+2A&3-/+.$/V.0$'5$-/;;&-1$T$A/$)1-'01'-.$.1$/'$1.+;)$)(+(A/(-.D$

?K*.%,&'(5(

;'+(,&$%+(,'#.+()9(#"0$)&*#'(

C'@*&)(J'&+(0N*J'1%&2(C'@&',()9(.*++"2(T/K'/()9(.&"+'1,(

%.$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$'5$W.5-.$5&)1/AW(X'.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;/)).51$A.'-$1.+;)$T$-.W/-3.-$.5$

/--(,-.9$T$-.W-.11.-$'5$1.+;)$Z25($.1$;.-3'D$B/5)$A.)$1-&()$.R.+;A.)$3.$L(A+)$0Q&()()9$A/$)1-'01'-.$).$

-2;,1.$M$'5$;-.+(.-$1.+;)$X'($)/5)$f1-.$(32/A9$).-/$V20'$0&++.$1.A$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$-.)1.$'5$

)&'V.5(-$V.-)$A.X'.A$(A)$).$1&'-5.519$)/5)$0.)).D$d5$).0&53$1.+;)$X'($+.1$.5$;A/0.$A/$320Q2/50.$3.$

0.1$'5(V.-)$.1$'5.$0&'-).$V.-)$'5$&ZS.1$3.$32)(- $X'($)U2A&(W5.$1&'S&'-)$;A')D$!5L(59$'5$1-&()(,+.$

1.+;)$&[$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$L&51$A.$0&5)1/1$3.$A.'-$.R()1.50.$.19$-.W/-3/51$.5$/--(,-.9$).$-.53.51$0&+;1.$

3.)$.--.'-)$0&++().)$.1$3.$A/$V/0'(12$3.$A.'-)$.R()1.50.)D$

( *)+8#"#<'(+31)+2;&$+8)"<"#

%.)$1-&()$.R.+;A.)$0Q&()()$&51$.5$0&++'5$3.$0&5)1-'(-.$'5.$;-.+(,-.$)(1'/1(&59$X'($).-/$V'.$

0&++.$(32/A.$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3'-/51$A.$-.)1.$3'$L(A+D$#U(A$5U.)1$S/+/()$1&'1$T$L/(1$-&).9$.1$A/()). $

32ST $).51(- $ A.) $ 1.5)(&5)$X'( $;,).-&51 $ )'- $.'R$ A. $ -.)1. $3'$ L(A+9 $ (A $ -.)1. $ AU&ZS.01(L $V.-) $ A.X'.A $ A.) $

;.-)&55/W.)$).$1&'-5.51D$aA$)U/W(1$3U/Z&-3$3'$1.+;)$&[$1&')$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$-2'5()D

B/5)$+,-),-9$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$1&')$;-2).51)$3/5)$A.)$3.'R$;-.+(.-)$/01.)$h$A.$3&01.'-9$

:AK/9$A.$;,-.$3.$%&'A&'9$Y&3-(W&9$A/$0&+1.)).D$4.$5U.)1$X'.$;/-$A/$)'(1.$X'.$1&')$3();/-/()).519$A.)$

Page 49: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

'5)$/;-,)$A.)$/'1-.)9$+&'-/51$;&'-$A/$;A';/-1D$o/+/()$AU2X'(A(Z-.$5.$).$-.L&-+.9$.1$(A$)U/W(1$3.)$).'A)$

+&+.51)$&[$%&'A&'$.)1$/V.0$)&5$.51&'-/W.$/'$0&+;A.1D$B/5)$AU/01.$H$+.'-1$A.$3&01.'-$h$3/5)$AU/01.$b $

.1$I9$%&'A&'$L'(1$A.$0&51.R1.$3/5)$A.X'.A$.AA.$V(V/(19$5U.+;&-1/51$X'U:AK/$/V.0$.AA.$h$3/5)$AU/01.$J9$

Y&3-(W&$.)1$/))/))(52$.1$A/$0&+1.)).9$-.53'.$L&AA.9$.++.52.$;/-$A/$;&A(0.$h$3/5)$AU/01.$G9$0U.)1$.5L(5 $

%&'A&'$X'( $+.'-1 $/))/))(52.D $B/5) $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9 $ A/ $L/+(AA.$).$0&5)1(1'.$2W/A.+.51$3/5)$A/$

;-.+(,-.$)2X'.50.$ M $%&-/9 $.1 $#')(. $ -.50&51-.51 $:55(.9 $P/-O*o/5.9 $.1 $#1..V.D $B/5)$ A/ $;-.+(,-.$

+&(1(2$3'$L(A+9$/V/51$AU.AA(;).9$.AA.)$V(V.51$1&'1.)$.5).+ZA.9$1/53()$X'.$#1..V.$;/)).$)&5$1.+;)$T$A.'- $

-.53-.$V()(1.9$0&5)(32-2$0&++.$'5$+.+Z-.$3.$A/$L/+(AA.D$%/$L(5$3.$0.11.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$)U/0Q,V.$

/V.0$AUQ()1&(-.$3U/+&'-$.51-.$#1..V.$.1$%&-/9$/55&5\/51$A/$L(5$3.$AU2X'(A(Z-.$L/+(A(/AD$B/5)$A/$).0&53.$

;/-1(.$3'$L(A+9$A.$);.01/1.'-$A.)$-.1-&'V.$32L(5(1(V.+.51$3();.-)2)$.1$5.$-fV/51$X'.$3.$).$-.1-&'V.-$A.)$

'5)$A.)$/'1-.)D$#')(.$)&'LL-.$3.$5.$;A')$V&(-$)&'V.51$)/$+,-.$h$#1..V.$5U/$;/)$&'ZA(2$%&-/$.1$-fV.$3.$

-.0&5)1(1'.-$A.$0&';A.$X'U(A$L&-+/(1$/V.0$.AA.$h$:55(.$0Q.-0Q.$)/5)$-.Ae0Q.$P/-O*o/5.9$X'($0Q.-0Q.$T$

)U2A&(W5.-$3.$A/$L/+(AA.D$!5L(59$3/5) $.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&09$ A.$1-(&$/+&'-.'R$X'.$L&-+.51$C/&9$

o(5)Q.5W$.1$%(/5Ws($-.;-2).51.$AU2X'(A(Z-.$A.$;A')$;/-L/(1$3'$L(A+D$o/+/()$C/&$5.$).-/$+(.'R$.51&'-2.$

;/-$A/$)'(1.9$;.-3/51$).)$;-&0Q.)$A.)$'5)$/;-,)$A.)$/'1-.)$M$.AA.$3(V&-0.-/$3.$o(5)Q.5W9$).$V.--/$-.1(-.-$

A/$W/-3.$3.$)&5$L(A)9$.1$V.--/$+&'-(-$)&5$;,-.D$#.'A$A'($-.)1.-/$)&5$0Q(.59$3&51$A/$;-2).50.$T$).)$0j12) $

V(.53-/$3/V/51/W.$)&'A(W5.-$)/$)&A(1'3.D$

aA$)U/W(1$2W/A.+.51$3'$+&+.51$&[$AU(55&0.50.$.)1$.50&-.$;&))(ZA.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$V(V.51$'5$

+&+.51$Z25($M$(A)$&51$3.)$-fV.)9$3.)$.);&(-)9$0-&(.51$.5$AU/V.5(-D$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$V.'1$L/(-.$3'$0(52+/$

1/53()$X'.$#1..V.$:-0Q.-$).$0&5)/0-.$T$A/$;Q&1&$3U/-1$.1$-fV.$3U.R;&).-$3/5)$A.)$+.(AA.'-)$+')2.)$3.$

".K$}&-`D$C/&$0Q/51.$T$A/$Lf1.$3'$"&'V.A$:5$^$5&')$.51-&5)$L(,-.+.51$3/5)$A.$5&'V./'$)(,0A.$_D$#( $

%&'A&'$.)1$'5$;.-)&55/W.$;A')$3(LL(0(A.$T$A(-.9$1&'-52.$V.-)$A.$;-2).51$.1$).)$;A/()(-)9$.AA.$;/)).-/$3.$

)&5$)1/1'1$3.$L.++.$.51-.1.5'.$T$0.AA.$3.$+.'-1-(,-.$.5$0/V/A.$;'()$;-&)1(1'2.$3.)$X'/-1(.-)$;/'V-.$

3.$%&53-.)D$<(.5$X'.$A.)$0Q&).)$5.$).+ZA.51$;/)$/LL.01.-$%&'A&'9$1&'S&'-)$2W/A.$T$.AA.*+f+.9$.AA.$

).-/$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$-23'(1.$T$'5$0&-;)9$)&'(AA2.$;/-$A.$+&53.$X'($AU.51&'-.9$1/53()$X'.$A.$32Z'1$3'$

;-.+(.-$/01.$3.))(5.$'5$;&))(ZA.$2X'(A(Z-.$/V.0$A.$3&01.'-D$%.$).'A$;.-)&55/W.$X'($5.$V(1$;/)$0.11.$

;.-1.$3.$AU(55&0.50.$.)1$P/-O*o/5.9$A/$L(AA.$3U:55(.$3. $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$X'($)/(1$32ST$)&5$/V.5(-$

32).);2-2+.51 $ L.-+2 $ ;/- $ A. $ L/(1 $ 3Uf1-. $ 52. $3U'5. $+,-. $ 5&(-.D $%. $ ;.-)&55/W. $ .)1 $ 3U/'1/51 $ ;A')$

/'1&3.)1-'01.'-$X'U(A$5U/$S')1.+.51$;/)$/00,)$T$0.$;/))2$;-&V(3.51(.A9$0.$;/-/3()$;.-3'$3/5)$A.X'.A$

)U/Z-.'V.51$A.)$/'1-.)$;.-)&55/W.)$A&-)X'U(A)$)&'LL-.51$1-&;D$

4.$;/))2$(32/A$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$/))&0(2$T$'5$)1/1'1$)&0(/AD$B/5)$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0'

.1 $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$0U.)1$A/$;/'V-.12$&'$AU/;;/-1.5/50.$T$'5.$0A/)).$+&O.55.D$YfV/51$3.$-2'))(1.$

)&0(/A.9$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$O$)&51$;&'-1/51$;A')$Q.'-.'R$X'.$3/5)$A/$)'(1.$3'$L(A+D$%U/-W.51$.1$A.$)'00,)$

Page 50: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

).-&51$-.);&5)/ZA.)$3.$A/$)2;/-/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$M$%&-/$5.$V&(1$;A')$)/$L(AA.$X'U.51-.$3.'R$)'00,) $

1Q2e1-/'R$&'$0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.)$h$C/&$/00.;1.$3.$;.-3-.$A/$W/-3.$3.$)&5$L(A)$0/-$.AA.$(+/W(5.$X'.$

)&5$.R*+/-($;A')$L&-1'52$X'U.AA.$.)1$;A')$T$+f+.$3.$;.-+.11-.$'5.$Z.AA.$V(.$T$)&5$L(A)D$t$AU(5V.-).9 $

3/5)$%&'A&'9$A/$320Q2/50.$).$L/(1$3.$A/$1-/5X'(AA.$V(.$3.$L.++.$.51-.1.5'.$T$0.AA.$3.)$Z/)*L&53)$3.$

%&53-.)$&[$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$).$3.+/53.51$;&'-X'&($(A$.)1$)($L/0(A.$3.$1-&'V.-$3.$AU/A0&&A$T$0-23(1$.1$)($

3(LL(0(A.$3.$1-&'V.-$3'$;/(5D$%/$+&-/A.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$).+ZA.$0.AA.$3.$;-j5.-$AU2X'(A(Z-.$M$'5.$1-&;$

W-/53.$L&-1'5.$.1$'5.$1-&;$W-/53.$+(),-.$)&51$3.)$&Z)1/0A.)$/'$Z&5Q.'-D$t$5&'V./'9$A/$A.\&5$.)1$

0.AA.$3.$A/$A(W5.$+23(/5.$.1$3.$AU/00.;1/1(&5$3.$0.$X'.$AU&5$/D$

4.11.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$.)1$(512-.))/51.$T$/5/AO).-$0/-$)($.AA.$0&5)1(1'.$'5$+&3,A.$3.$Z&5Q.'-$

L/51/)+2$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3'-/51$A.$-.)1.$3'$L(A+9$.AA.$.)1$3U/Z&-3$A&(5$3Uf1-.$V20'.$0&++.$1.AA.D $

%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$5.$;/-V(.51$;/)$T$;.-0.-$.19$32ST9$).$).51$'5$;.'$1-&;$V(.(AA.$;&'-$0&++.50.-$'5.$

0/--(,-.$h$C/&$V&(1$/;;/-/n1-.$A.)$)(W5.)$3.$A/$S/A&')(.$.51-.$A.)$3.'R$Q&++.)$X'($A/$L&-0.-&51$T$

0Q&()(-$h$%&'A&'$5U.)1$X'.$A/$+/n1-.)).$3'$B&01.'-$X'(9$3,)$A.$;-.+(.-$/01.9$A'($/55&50.$X'U(A$V.'1$). $

+/-(.-$/V.0$'5.$/'1-.$L.++.D$4.11.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$.)1$.5$-2/A(12$A&(5$3Uf1-.$'5.$)(1'/1(&5$(32/A.$

;&'-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$h$;&'-1/519$(A)$5.$0.)).-&51$3UO$L/(-.$-2L2-.50.D$4.$X'($A/$0/-/012-().$3/V/51/W.$

X'U'5$+&+.51$3.$;A25(1'3.$/Z)&A'.9$0U.)1$X'U(A$)U/W(1$.5$-2/A(12$3'$).'A$+&+.51$&[$(A)$).$;-&S.11.51 $

V.-)$AU/V.5(-D$%.$1.+;)$3.$0.11.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$.R()1.$;&'-$A.)$A/()).-$-fV.-$/'$L'1'-9$X'($5.$).$

32-&'A.-/$2V(3.++.51$;/)$0&++.$;-2V'$&'$5U/;;&-1.-/$;/)$A/$;A25(1'3.$.);2-2.D$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$

3.V(.51$Z(.5$A/$)1/-$T$A/X'.AA.$.AA.$-fV/(19$+/()$.AA.$0&5L(.$T$:55(.$X'U.AA.$).51$X'U(A$A'($+/5X'.$

X'.AX'.$0Q&).D$#')(.$)&'Q/(1.$.5$-.W/-3/51$;/)).-$'5.$21&(A.$L(A/51.$X'.$A/$L/+(AA.$).$-.L&-+.$;&'-$

1&'S&'-)9$0&++.$3/5)$A.)$;-.+(.-)$1.+;)$3'$L(A+D$C/&$.1$)&5$L(A)9$)2;/-2)9$-fV.51$AU'5$.1$AU/'1-.$/'R$

+&+.51)$&[$(A)$21/(.51$.5).+ZA.)D$o(5)Q.5W$/O/51 $2+(W-29 $-.W-.11.$ A/$4Q(5.$&[$0&51-/(-.+.51$T$

AU:')1-/A(.9$(A$/V/(1$3.)$.55.+()$)'-$A.)X'.A)$1(-.-D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5.$0.)).51$3.$-.W/-3.-$V.-)$A.$

;/))29$AT$&[$A.$32Z'1$3'$L(A+$A.)$+&51-/(1$;A.(5)$3U.);&(-)$3/5)$A.$L'1'-D$Pf+.$A.$);.01/1.'-9$X'($/$

;&'-1/51$/))()12$T$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$3'$L(A+9$).$;-.53$T$A/$V&(-$0&++.$'5$1.+;)$Z25($;&'-$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D$

$

d5.$/5/AO).$;A')$.5$/V/51$;&-1.-/(1$T$V&(-$0.$;/-/3()$;.-3'$0&++.$'5.$.51(12$X'($5U.R()1.$.5$

-2/A(12$5&5$;/)$3/5)$A.$L(A+9$+/()$3/5)$'5$/V/51$3'$L(A+D$BU'5.$0.-1/(5.$+/5(,-.9$A&-)X'.$A.$L(A+$

0&++.50.9$(A$.)1$32ST$1-&;$1/-39$.1$A.)$;-.+(.-)$;-&ZA,+.)$)&51$/;;/-')D$%.$Z&5Q.'-$/'-/(1$.R()129 $

+/()$3/5)$A.$1-&'$5&(-$X'($;-20,3.$A.$32Z'1$3.$A/$5/--/1(&5D

Page 51: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ o/0X'.A(5. $"/0/0Q.9 $ 21'3(/51 $ A.) $ 32Z'1) $ 3.) $ L(A+) $r&AAOK&&3(.5)9 $ -.+/-X'. $ '5 $+&1(L$

)&'V.51$-2;212D$=&'-$A.)$/+2-(0/(5)9$AU'5.$3.)$+/5(,-.)$3.$0&++.50.-$'5$L(A+9$0U.)1$3.$M

^$0&5)(32-.-$A.$Q&-)*1.+;)$0&++.$'5$;/-/3()$&[$A.$-20(1$L(A+(X'.$V(.51$).+.-$)&5$

32)&-3-.$h$'5$;/-/3()$3&51$AU&'V.-1'-.9$1.AA.$'5.$L.5f1-.$.51-U&'V.-1.9$A/()).$;/-L&()$

/;.-0.V&(-$Z-(,V.+.51$A/$;.-L.01(&59$L/(1$S/(AA(-$A.$-20(1$3U'5$;/))2$3&51$AUQ/-+&5(.$

A'+(5.').$5U2ZA&'(1$'5$(5)1/51$X'.$;&'-$+(.'R$3();/-/n1-.D$EDDDF$%U&'V.-1'-.$.5$1/51$

X'U.AA.$&LL-.$'5$20A/(- $3.$AU'5(12$;-(+(1(V.9 $5.$).$0&51.51.$;/)$3.$0&5)1-'(-. $'5$

);.01/1.'-$32)(-/519$+/()$3&55.$/'$-20(1$L(A+(X'.$)/$;-&;-.$s&5.$3.$+/5X'.$.1$3.$

32)(-$h$A.$L/(1$X'.$0.$-20(1$5.$;-&W-.)).$X'.$;&'))2$;/-$'5$(5V(50(ZA.$+/A$3'$;/O)9$

;&'))2 $;/- $ A/ $3&'A.'- $3U'5. $/Z).50. $3&51 $ A.) $.AA(;).) $)&51 $ A/ $ ).'A. $ E(5FV()(ZA.$

L(W'-/1(&5D_$@8

4.11.$(32.$32V.A&;;2.$)'-$A.$0(52+/$r&AAOK&&3(.5$)U/;;A(X'.$;/-L/(1.+.51$)'-$A.)$1-&()$L(A+)$h$A/$

;/))(&5$3.$%&'A&'$.1$3'$B&01.'-$)U/0Q,V.$3/5)$A.$;-.+(.-$/01.9$+/()$/$3i$Z(.5$.R()1.-$/V/51$3/5) $

1&'1.$)/$);A.53.'-$h$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$-/0&51.$T$#1..V.$X'.$)&5$+/-($21/(1$'5$W-/53$Q&++.$3.$1Q2e1-. $

/V/51 $3.$+&'-(-9 $.1 $X'U(A)$L&-+/(.51$'5.$L/+(AA.$Q.'-.').$/V.0$#')(.$ h$&5$/;;-.53$X'U:55(.$.)1$

2W/A.+.51$V.'V.$h$AU(55&0.51.$.1$S&V(/A.$C/&$1.51.$3.$0&5).-V.-$A.$1-(&$/+(0/A$X'U.AA.$L&-+.$/V.0$

o(5)Q.5W$.1 $%(/5Ws( $3U'5. $+/5(,-. $ 1&'1. $.5L/51(5. $X'( $3&55. $T $;.5).- $X'U(A) $&51 $V20' $0.1 $21/1$

3U2X'(A(Z-. $3/5) $ A. $;/))2D $^ $C&'1 $ A. $ L(A+$_ $5&') $3(1 $.50&-. $o/0X'.A(5. $"/0/0Q. $^ $.)1 $ A. $+&3.$

3U.+;A&(9$X'($;/-1$T$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3.)$^$).0-.1)$_$3.$AU&'V.-1'-.$;A.(5$3U.);&(-9$.1$;&'-1/51$-2)(W52$T$A/$

32L/(1.D$EuF$A/$)&'LL-/50.$3U2;-&'V.-$X'.$0.$X'($/$212$;A')$S/+/()$5.$).-/9$.1$3&51$'5$2V.51'.A$8$??N'

&1(9$.5$L(5$3.$;/-0&'-)$5.$).-/$S/+/()$X'U'5$V/W'.$.1$(5L(+.$20Q&D@>$_$!5$.LL.1$3/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$ '

*"&9$A/$L/+(AA.$5.$).$-.0&5)1(1'.-/$S/+/()$3'-/ZA.+.519$P/-O*o/5.$L'(1$T$".K$}&-`$.1$#')(.$;/-1$;&'-$

AU'5(V.-)(12 $ h $ A&-)X'U.AA.) $ -.V(.53-&519 $ 0. $ ).-/ $ ;&'- $ AU.51.--.+.51 $ 3U:55(.D $ B/5) $.-a(&)/ ' (&0'

4,12$%1&09$C/&$5.$-.1-&'V.-/$'5$0.-1/(5$Z&5Q.'-$X'.$3/5)$A.$)&'V.5(-$3.$).)$/552.)$3.$S.'5.)).)9$

-.V(V/51$3/5)$)/$1f1.$A.)$+.(AA.'-)$+&+.51)$3.$)&5$;/))2D$c'/51$T$%&'A&'9$A/$8$??N'&1($5U/$;/)$A(.'$

3Uf1-.9$A.$L(A+$)&+Z-.$3/5)$A.$32).);&(-$A.$;A')$1&1/AD

( *#+</-@/#$-)+(&1(+.&1.)(+()(+9&"6)(

%/ $ ).0&53. $ ;/-1(. $ 0&5)1(1'. $ 3&50 $ '5. $ 0Q'1.9 $ '5. $ 320Q2/50. $ ;/- $ -/;;&-1 $ T $ A/ $ )(1'/1(&5$

;-.+(,-.D$%/$A'11.$3'$;.-)&55/W.$;&'-$)&5$Z&5Q.'-$).$0&+;A(X'.$.1$(A$.5$).+ZA.$/'$0&51-/(-.$3.$;A')$

@8"/0/0Q.9$o/0X'.A(5.9$[,))N9,,(;')>&))"?0&'&2')>"1C")4@9$=/-()9$%UQ/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$788>D$;;D$>@J*>@G@> v;D$4(1D$;>J>

Page 52: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

.5$;A')$2A&(W52D$B/5)$A.)$1-&()$L(A+)9$0.11.$320Q2/50.$;-.53$'5.$L&-+.$3(LL2-.51.D$B/5)$+,-),-9$0U.)1$

A/ $ 0Q'1. $ )&0(/A. $ 3' $ ;.-)&55/W. $ 2;&5O+. $ X'( $ 5. $ 0.)). $ 3. $ AU.51-/n5.- $ 3/5) $ 3.) $ )(1'/1(&5) $ ;A')$

)&-3(3.)9$&[$).$-2V,A.51$A/$0&50';()0.50.$.1$A/$0-'/'12$Q'+/(5.D$B/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$(A$5.$)U/W(1$

;/)$3U'5.$320Q2/50.$;-&W-.))(V.9$+/()$3U'5.$-';1'-.$;-&V&X'2.$;/-$AU.AA(;).$M$>8$/5)$;A')$1/-39$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.) $ )&51 $ ;A') $X'. $ S/+/() $ 2A&(W52) $ A.) $ '5) $3.) $ /'1-.)9 $ A/ $ 0&++'5(0/1(&5 $ .)1 $ 3.V.5'.$

(+;&))(ZA.D$aA)$&51$)'(V()$3.)$V&(.)$1-&+;.').)9$5U/O/51$;/)$0&+;-()$X'.$).'A$AU/+&'-$A.)$/'-/(1 $

-.53') $Q.'-.'R9 $0&++.$ A. $3(1 $ A/ $0Q/5)&5$3'$W252-(X'. $^ $z(1Q&'1 $ A&V.9 $O&'U-. $&5AO $ A(V(5W $/5$

(+(1/1(&5$&L$A(L.$_$E#/5)$/+&'-9$V&')$5.$V(V-.s$X'U'5$+(-/W.$3.$A/$V(.FD$!5L(59$3/5) $.-a(&)/'(&0'

4,12$%1&09$A/$320Q2/50.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.)1$.51(,-.+.51$A(2.$T$0.AA.$3'$+&53.$X'($AU.51&'-.$M$A/$

4Q(5. $).$;.-3 $3/5) $ A. $0/;(1/A()+.$.LL-252$.1 $&'ZA(. $)/$;-&;-.$0'A1'-.9 $ ).) $;-&;-.) $ -/0(5.) $ h $ (A)$

)U.LL&53-.-&51$3/5)$'5$+f+.$+&'V.+.51D$

%U/);.01$A.$;A')$21-/5W.$3.$A/$320Q2/50.$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$;.'1*f1-.$X'.$A.$;.-)&55/W.$;-(50(;/A$

5.$).+ZA.$;/)$f1-.$1-/5)L&-+2$;/-$0.$X'($A'($/--(V.$h$A.$+&53.$).$321-'(1$/'1&'-$3.$%&'A&'$.1$.AA.$5. $

)U.5$-.53$;/)$0&+;1.D$!AA.$).+ZA.$1&'S&'-)$2W/A.$T$.AA.$+f+.$M$.AA.$S&'.9$/+&'-.').9$A&-)X'U.AA.$).$

;-&)1(1'.$3/5)$A.)$;(-.)$X'/-1(.-)$3.$%&53-.)$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$X'U.AA.$)/'1/(1$3/5)$A.)$Z-/)$3'$

3&01.'-$A&-)X'U.AA.$21/(1$-(0Q.$.1$.51-.1.5'.$&'$X'U.AA.$).+ZA/(1$1&+Z.-$)&')$A.)$0Q/-+.)$3'$S.'5.$

:AK/D$#U(A$.)1$3(LL(0(A.$3.$A(-.$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$%&'A&'9$X'($.)1$A/$)&'-0.$3.$+'A1(;A.)$(51.-;-21/1(&5)9$

)/$0&5)1/50.$T$1-/V.-)$A.)$2V,5.+.51)$.)1$2V(3.51.D$!AA.$-.)1.$A(Z-.$3/5)$)/$1f1.$.1$3/5)$).)$/01.) $

/A&-)$X'.$AU21/'$).$-.)).--.$;.'$T$;.'$/'1&'-$3U.AA.D$%U&ZS.01(L$3'$;.-)&55/W.9$.)1$0.A'($3U'5.$L&-+.$3.$

-2'))(1.$)&0(/A.9$+/()$(A$).+ZA.$3(LL(0(A.$3.$A.$0.-5.-$3/V/51/W.$.AA.$).+ZA.$).$0&51.51.-$3.$1&'1.)$A.)$

)(1'/1(&5)9$321.5/51$A/$0/;/0(12$T$)'-V(V-.$Q&-)$3'$0&++'5D$!AA.$).$A/()).$'1(A().-$;/-$A.)$Q&++.)$X'($

AU.51&'-.51$)/5)$).+ZA.-$A.'-$.5$V&'A&(-9$.1$A.)$/(+.$)/5)$-.Ae0Q.$S')X'U/'R$L&')9$/'R$+&5)1-.)9$/'R$

+.'-1-(.-)D

#( $T $ A/ $V()(&5 $3' $ L(A+9 $+,-),-$ 3&55. $ AU(+;-.))(&5 $3U'5. $ A&5W'. $3.)0.51. $/'R$.5L.-)9 $ A/$

)1-'01'-.$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$.5$-2/A(12$0&5)1-'(1.$)'-$A/$L&-+.$3U'5.$/)0.5)(&5$;'()$3U'5.$0Q'1.D$B/5)$A.)$

H$;-.+(.-)$/01.)9$=/Z)1$3.))(5.$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$;&'-$%&'A&'$3.$)&-1(-$T$1&'1$S/+/()$3.$)/$0&53(1(&5$3. $

L.++.$;/'V-.$M$3U/Z&-3$-.S.12.$;/-$A.$3&01.'-$X'($A/$X'(11.$;&'-$2;&').-$'5.$L.++.$3'$+f+.$-/5W$

X'.$A'(9$%&'A&'$;/-V(.51$T$A.$)23'(-.$3.$5&'V./'$.1$T$;-&V&X'.-$'5$.)0A/53-.$X'($L&-0.$A.$3&01.'-$T $

AU2;&').-D $ %. $ ;-.+(.- $ 0Q.+(5 $ X'( $ ). $ 3.))(5. $ ;&'- $ .AA. $ .)1 $ 3&50 $ '5. $ )&-1(. $ ;&))(ZA. $ M $ '5.$

2+/50(;/1(&5$3'$1-/V/(A9$3.$A/$;/'V-.12$.1$3.)$Q&++.)$X'($0Q.-0Q.51$T$AU'1(A().-D$%.$+/-(/W.$.)1$A/$

;-&+.)).$3U'5.$)1/Z(A(12$X'($5.$A'($0&i1.$;/)$)/$A(Z.-12$M$'5.$L&()$A.$3&01.'-$2;&')29$.AA.$;&'--/$L/(-.$

0.$X'U.AA.$V&'3-/D$#/5)$f1-.$0&+;A,1.+.51$(32/A.9$)/$)(1'/1(&5$A'($;.-+.1$3.$).$;-&S.1.-$V.-)$AU/V.5(-$

3/5)$0.)$H$;-.+(.-)$/01.)D$%.)$)(W5.)$3.$A/$1-/W23(.$)&51$32ST$AT$M$A/$V(&A.50.$3'$3&01.'-$h$AU/+&'- $

Page 53: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

/V.'WA.$X'.$)&5$L(A)$:AK/$;&-1.$T$%&'A&'$h$A/$0&50';()0.50.$3.$).)$3.'R$0&+;/W5&5)$3.$-&'1.$X'($

).$).-V.51$3U.AA.9$A'($V&A/51$&'V.-1.+.51$)&5$/-W.51$.1$)&5$/A0&&ADDD$%.$);.01/1.'-$)/(1$X'U(A$5U/--(V.-/$

-(.5$3.$Z&5$.5$0&+;/W5(.$3.$0.$+&53.*ATD$P/()$(A$).$;-&S.11.9$/V.0$%&'A&'9$V.-)$'5$/V.5(-$;A')$

-/3(.'R9$0/-$A.$;-&;-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$3.$L/(-.$0-&(-.9$X'.$1/51$X'U(A$-.)1.$3'$1.+;)9$1&'1$.)1$.50&-. $

;&))(ZA.D$%/$L(5$3.$0.11.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$).$L/(1$T$A/$L(5$3.$AU/01.$H9$A&-)X'.$A.$B&01.'-$1.51.$3.$L&-0.-$

%&'A&'$T$).$)'(0(3.-D$B20&'V-/51$Y&3-(W&$.1$3.$#0Q(W&A0Q$3/5)$A.'-$0Q/+Z-.$5';1(/A.9$A.$3&01.'-$A.)$

0Q/)).$/V.0$V(&A.50.D$!5$-.V.5/519$(A$320&'V-.$:AK/$;A.'-/51$)'-$A.)$W.5&'R$3.$%&'A&'$h$0U.5$.)1$

1-&;9$(A$0&+;-.53$X'.$S/+/()$(A$5U/'-/$AU/))'-/50.$3.$A/$L(32A(12$3.$%&'A&'$.1$1.51.$3.$A/$L&-0.-$T$). $

1'.-D$%.$0&';$;/-19$+/()$0U.)1$A'($X'($+.'-1$3/5)$A.)$Z-/)$3.$%&'A&'$.1$)&')$A.)$O.'R$3U:AK/9$X'($5.$

).-/9$0&++.$A.$);.01/1.'-9$S/+/()$1&1/A.+.51$0&5V/(50'$3.$)&5$(55&0.50.D$%U/01.$b9$X'($0&--.);&53$

/'$+&+.51$3'$;-&0,)$).-/$'5$+&+.51$3.$;(V&19$'5$;&(51$3.$Z/)0'A.$.51-.$A/$;/-1(.$3.$A/$;-&W-.))(&5$

.1$A/$0Q'1.$32L(5(1(V.$3.$%&'A&'$S')X'UT$A/$+&-1D$%&'A&'$)U.5L'(1$.1$3.V-/$V(V-.$3/5)$A/$0A/53.)1(5(129 $

3.V.5/51$3/V/51/W.$V'A52-/ZA.$/'R$Q&++.)$X'($AU.51&'-.51D$%/$320Q2/50.$.5$1/51$X'.$1.AA.$5.$).$

0&+;&).$L(5/A.+.51$X'.$3.)$@$3.-5(.-)$/01.)$M$%&'A&'$.)1$0&51-/(51.$3.$)U.5L'(-$T$AU/01.$I$h$/--(V.$

3/5)$AU/01.$J$3/5)$'5$0/)(5&$0A/53.)1(5$&[$A/$A&($.)1$0.AA.$3.$AU/-W.51$.1$3.$A/$V(&A.50.$h$L(5(1$AU/01.$G $

3/5)$A/$+(),-.$A/$;A')$0-/)).9$X'($AU/+,5.-/$T$).)$;-&)1(1'.-D$%.$+&53.$3.)$3.'R$3.-5(.-)$0Q/;(1-.)$

.)1 $ )'LL()/++.51 $V(&A.51 $;&'- $5&')$3&55.- $ AU(+;-.))(&5$X'.$ A. $ L(A+$).$0&+;&).$3U'5. $ A.51. $.1$

(51.-+(5/ZA.$0Q'1.$/A&-)$X'U(A$)U/W(1$.5$-2/A(12$).'A.+.51$3.)$3.'R$3.-5(.-)$0Q/;(1-.)D$

B/5) $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$A/$).5)/1(&5$5U.)1$;/)$0.AA.$3.$A/$320Q2/50.$;-&W-.))(V.9$)(5&5$3'$

;/))/W.$3U'5$;&(51$3.$5&5*-.1&'-$3U&[$1&'1.$;&))(Z(A(12$3U/+2A(&-/1(&5$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$-&+;'.D$

4&++.$3/5)$+,-),-9$1&'1.)$A.)$3(LL(0'A12)$X'($;,).51$)'-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$32ST$.5$W.-+.$3/5)$A/$

;-.+(,-. $;/-1(.D $%U/+Z(1(&5 $3. $%&-/ $P.-.3(1Q $X'U.AA. $+.1 $ /'*3.))') $3. $ 1&'1 $ .1 $ X'( $ 0/').-/ $ A.$

+/AQ.'-$3.$)/$L(AA.$3/5)$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.$h$A.$-.L')$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.9$S.'5.$ZA/50Q.$3U'5.$+,-.$5&(-.9 $

3U/00.;1.-$)/$0&53(1(&5$-/0(/A.$.1$3.$)'Z(-$A/$+f+.$.R0A')(&5$)&0(/A.$3.$)/$+,-.$h$A/$;/))(&5$3.$#')(. $

;&'-$)&5$Z./'*;,-.9$3U/Z&-3$.5L/51(5.$.1$(55&0.51.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$2W/A.+.51$1&'-52)$V.-)$A.$

L'1'-$.1$)'-1&'1$V.-)$A/$-2'))(1.$3.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q9$X'($0&5)1(1'.$AU&ZS.01(L$3&51$32;.53.51$A.)$/'1-.) $

;.-)&55/W.)D$:55(.$.)1$32ST$.5$20Q.0$/V.0$#/-/Q*o/5.$+/()$)&5$32)(-$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$2;&').$

.50&-.$0.A'($3.$%&-/$M$.AA.$-fV.$/V.0$.AA.$T$)&5$/)0.5)(&5$3/5)$A.$+&53.$3'$1Q2e1-.D

:;-,)$A/$-';1'-.$3.$>8$/5)9$/'$0&'-)$3'X'.A$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$L/(1$'5.$0/--(,-.$.1$3.V(.51$'5.$

)1/-9$AU&ZS.01(L$L(R2$.)1$3&50$&Z1.5'D$%/$320Q2/50.$3.$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.$)U.R;A(X'.$;/-$AU.--.'-$3.$%&-/$

P.-.3(1Q9$X'($/V.'WA2.$;/-$)&5$&-W'.(A9$)U.)1$1-&+;2.$3U&ZS.01(LD$:A&-)$X'.$A.$W252-(X'.$;-2).51.9$3,) $

A.$32Z'19$A/$-2;&5).$/'$0Q.+(5$X'.$0Q.-0Q.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$E).$0&51.51.-$3.$AU/+&'-F9$.AA.$0&51(5'.-/$

T$0Q.-0Q.-$T$0&+ZA.-$).)$L-')1-/1(&5)$3/5)$A.$)Q&K*Z')(5.))D$C&')$0&53/+52)$;/-$0.11.$.--.'-9$A.)$

Page 54: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;-&ZA,+.)$.5$W.-+.$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$)U(51.5)(L(.-&51$3/5)$A/$).0&53.D$%&-/$32A/()).$)/$L(AA.$.1$

A/()). $ AU20/-1 $). $0-.').- $.51-. $.AA.) $ h $.AA. $ -.S.11. $#1..V.$:-0Q.-9 $;.-+.11/51 $T $#')(.$3U.5 $ 1&+Z.-$

/+&'-.').$h$.AA.$(+;&).$T$#/-/Q*o/5.$A.$);.01/0A.$3.$)/$+,-.$0&++.$3&+.)1(X'.$.1$AU/00-&()).+.51$

3.)$3(LL2-.50.)$.51-.$A/$+&(1(2$ZA/50Q.$.1$A/$+&(1(2$5&(-.$3.$A/$L/+(AA.$h$.AA.$).$A/()).-/$).-V(-$;/- $

:55(.$S')X'UT$AU2;'().+.51$1&1/A$.1$).$-.53-/$(53(-.01.+.51$-.);&5)/ZA.$3.$A/$+&-1$3.$0.AA.*0(D$%.$

;/))/W.$3.)$L(AA.)$T$AUeW.$/3'A1.$.)1$A.$V.01.'-$3.$AU(51.5)(L(0/1(&5$3.)$;-&ZA,+.)9$S')X'UT$AU.R;A&)(&5D$

=&'-$#/-/Q*o/5.$(A$5.$).-/$;A')$X'.)1(&5$3.$)';;&-1.-$A/$Q&51.$X'.$A'($L/(1$)/$+,-.$.5$V.5/51$A/$

0Q.-0Q.-$T$AU20&A.9$+/()$Z(.5$3.$0Q&()(-$'5.$V(.9$3.$).$0&5)1-'(-.$)&5$;-&;-.$0Q.+(5D$%/$).'A.$V&(.$

X'($A'($).+ZA.$;&))(ZA.$.)1$0.AA.$3.$+.51(- $.1 $3.$0/0Q.-$).)$&-(W(5.)$5&(-.)9 $0.$X'($A'($&'V-.$A/$

;&))(Z(A(12$3U'5.$/)0.5)(&5$)&0(/A.$+/()$AU&ZA(W.$T$-.5(.-$)/$+,-.D$=&'-$#')(.9$A.$;/))/W.$T$AUeW.$

/3'A1.$).-/$)O5&5O+.$3.$A/$320&'V.-1.$3.$AU/+&'-$X'U.AA.$;&-1.$T$#1..V.D$B,)$A&-)9$0.$).-/$;&'-$.AA. $

AU&00/)(&5$3.$).$0&5L-&51.- $T $ )/$+,-. $.5$ 1/51 $X'. $L(AA. $32A/())2. $+/() $/'))( $.5 $ 1/51 $X'. $ -(V/A. $

;&1.51(.AA.D$$

B/5)$0.11.$;/-1(.9$A.$3.)1(5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.'-$(50/;/0(12$T$;-.53-.$0&5)0(.50.$3.$0.$X'($

;&'--/(1$A.)$-.53-.$Q.'-.'R$).$L&53.$)'-$3.'R$+&3.)D$%.$;-.+(.-$.)1$0.A'($3.$A/$320Q2/50.$1-/W(X'.$

X'($1&'0Q.$#/-/Q*o/5.$.1$:55(.D$#/-/Q*o/5.$V.--/$)/$;A/0.$3/5)$A/$L/+(AA.$3.$;A')$.5$;')$-23'(1.$/'$

-/5W$3.$3&+.)1(X'.$M$;A')$%&-/$L/(1$L&-1'5.9$.1$;A')$A/$-';1'-.$.51-.$A.)$3.'R$;/-1(.)$)U/00-&()).D $

#/-/Q*o/5.$V(1$;-&W-.))(V.+.51$A.)$-.S.1)$M$A.$0Q.V/A$&LL.-1$T$#')(.$1/53()$X'U.AA.$-.)1.$.5L.-+2.$3/5)$

)/$0Q/+Z-.9$A.)$0&5).(A)$3'$-.)1.$3.$A/$L/+(AA.$;&'-$X'U.AA.$)&-1.$/V.0$A.$L(A)$3'$0Q/'LL.'-$5&(-9 $

AU(5V(1/1(&5$3.$%&-/$T$/(3.-$)/$+,-.$1/53()$X'.$#')(.$.1$#1..V.$;-&L(1.51$3.$A/$)&(-2.$/V.0$A.)$(5V(12)DDD $

#/$;A/0.$).-/$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$-.1-/50Q2.$/'R$0&'A()).)D$!AA.$V(V-/$3.$+f+.$AU20Q.0$3.$).$0&5)1-'(-.$

'5.$.R()1.50.$.5$3.Q&-) $3'$0.-0A. $ L/+(A(/AD $</11'.$;/- $)&5$;-.+(.- $/+&'-.'R$ A&-)X'U(A $/;;-.53$

X'U.AA.$.)1$A/$L(AA.$3U'5.$5&(-.9$V(-2.$3'$Z/-$&[$.AA.$1-&'V.$'5$.+;A&($3.$3/5).').$/;-,)$X'.$)/$+,-.$

A'($/(1$-.53'$V()(1.$M$A.$3.)1(5$)m/Z/11-/$)'-$#/-/Q*o/5.9$A.51.+.519$)i-.+.51D$!AA.$3.V-/$1&'S&'-)$;A')$

).$321/0Q.-$3.$A/$L/+(AA.$S')X'UT$A/$-.5(.-$32L(5(1(V.+.519$0Q/))/51$)/$+,-.$3.$)/$V(.D$4.11.$1-/W23(. $

(53(V(3'.AA.9$32ST$.5$W.-+.$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$5.$L.-/$X'.$).$32V.A&;;.-9$0&++.$'5$0/50.-9$/'$

0&'-)$3'$L(A+D$=/)$'5$)&';\&5$3U.);&(-$5.$V(.53-/$2W/O.-$A/$A.51.$.1$1-/W(X'.$)2;/-/1(&5$3.$A/$+,-.$

.1$3.$)/$L(AA.D$t$AU(5V.-).$A/$-.A/1(&5$.51-.$#')(.$.1$%&-/$6$1&'1$0&++.$0.AA.$3.$%&-/$.1$#1..V.$6 $

2V&A'. $ .5 $3.51*3.*)0(. $ M $%&-/ $;-&+.1 $ 3. $ 0.)).- $ 3. $ 1-/V/(AA.- $ ;'() $ ). $ V&(1 $ ;-&;&).- $ '5 $ L(A+ $T $

r&AAOK&&3$X'($A/$L/(1 $-.V.5(-$)'-$)/$320()(&5$h$.AA.$;-&+.1$3.$-.)1.-$.1$3U/))()1.-$T$A/$-.+().$3. $

3(;Aj+.$3.$#')(.$+/()$-.;/-1$T$5&'V./'$;&'-$'5$1&'-5/W.D$t$'5$0.-1/(5$;&(519$A/$+&(1(2$ZA/50Q.$3.$

A/$L/+(AA.$).$+.1$T$1&'-5.-$.5$-&539$5.$)/0Q/51$;A')$X'.AA.$;&)(1(&5$/3&;1.-D$%&-/$Q2)(1.$T$).$A/50.-$

3/5)$'5.$-.A/1(&5$/V.0$#1..V.9$Q2)(1.$T$/Z/53&55.-$)/$0/--(,-.$;&'-$#')(.$.1$).$1-&'V.$L(5/A.+.51 $

'5.$;&)(1(&5$+23(/5.$X'($5.$0&51.51.$;.-)&55.D

Page 55: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ B/5) $.-a(&)/ ' (&0 '4,12$%1&09 $ A/ $ 320/3.50. $ 3.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ .)1 $ .51(,-.+.51 $ A(2. $ T $ A/$

320Q2/50.$3.$ A/$4Q(5.$.1 $)U/;;/-.51.$T$'5.$)O+Z&A(X'.$L(5$3U'5$+&53.D$%.$L(A+$.)1$ -.+;A( $3. $

-2L2-.50.)$X'($O$L&51$20Q&D$:;-,)$/V&(-$0Q&()($3U2;&').-$o(5)Q.5W9$C/&$V&(1$'5$;.1(1$/V(&5$)U20-/).-$

3.V/51$.AA.D$!AA.$.)1$L(A+2.$.5$1-/V.AA(5W$0(-0'A/(-.9$/V.0$'5.$L&-+.$3.$)&A.55(12$X'($V(.51$)&'A(W5.-$

0.$;A/5$0&++.$'5$+&+.51$)O+Z&A(X'.D$%U/V(&5$X'($)U20-/).9$.5$L.'$.)1$)/5)$3&'1.$'5.$-2L2-.50.$/'$

-fV.$3Ua0/-.$M$AUQ&++.$0/;(1/A()1.9$.5$A'11.$0&51-.$A/$5/1'-.$3.)$0Q&).)9$L(5(-/$;/-$)U/'1&321-'(-.D$B/5)$

1&') $ A.) $ 0/)9 $ 0U.)1 $ A/ $ ;-&+.)). $ 3. $ A/ $ 0Q'1.D $ =A') $ A&(5 $ 3/5) $ A. $ L(A+9 $%(/5Ws( $ -.W/-3. $ '5 $ 1(W-.$

+/S.)1'.'R$.5L.-+2$3/5)$)/$0/W.$1&'-5.-$.5$-&53D$t$5&'V./'9$ (A $;.'1$)O+Z&A().-$Z./'0&';$3.$

0Q&).) $ h $ AU.5L.-+.+.51$3.$ A/ $4Q(5. $3/5) $'5$ S.'$X'( $ A/ $32;/)).9 $&'$ AU/Z)'-3(12 $3U'5$+&53.$X'($

.5L.-+.$0.A'($X'($21/(1$52$;&'-$3&+(5.-D$P/()$A/$V&A&512$3'$L(A+$3.$0&5)1-'(-.$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$)'-$A/$

320/3.50.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$T$1-/V.-)$A.)$3.)1(5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$).$-.1-&'V.$T$3.$5&+Z-.'R$5(V./'RD$

C&')$A.)$-.Z&53()).+.51)$V20')$;/-$C/&$.1$).)$;-21.53/51)$0&--.);&53.51$T$3.)$;-&ZA,+.)$)&0(/'R$

0&51.+;&-/(5)D$%/$1-/S.01&(-.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.)1$3(-.01.+.51$.1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$(5LA'.502.$;/-$

AU2V&A'1(&5$3.$A/$4Q(5.$h$T$A/$L&()$V(01(+.)$.1$/01.'-)$3.)$0Q/5W.+.51)$3.$A/$)&0(212$0Q(5&().9$A.'-)$

3.)1(52.)$)&51$(51(+.+.51$A(2.)D$

B/5)$A/$4Q(5.$3.)$/552.)$78889$o(5)Q.5W9$A.$;-21.53/51$0/;(1/A()1.$.1$)/5)$)0-';'A.$/;;A(X'.$

3/5)$)/$V(.$/+&'-.').$0.$X'U(A$/$/;;-()$3/5)$A.)$/LL/(-.)$M$;-.53-.$AU(5(1(/1(V.9$Z/11-.$).)$0&50'--.51)9$

.1$A.)$2A(+(5.-$1&'1$T$L/(1D$aA$.R(W.$3.$C/&$X'U.AA.$0Q&()()).$.51-.$%(/5Ws($.1$A'(9$/0Q,1.$A/$+(5.$&[ $

1-/V/(AA/(1 $%(/5Ws($;&'-$ A.$L/(-.$-.5V&O.-9$.1 $0Q.-0Q.$.5L(5$T$ A.$ 1'.-D $!5$78>H9$%(/5Ws(9$AU&'V-(.-$

+(5(.-$;.'$X'/A(L(29$32+25/W.$V.-)$A/$0/+;/W5.$;&'-$;&'V&(-$)'ZV.5(-$T$).)$Z.)&(5)$.1$32V.A&;;.$

'5$0/50.-$T$L&-0.$3.$1-/V/(AA.-$)&')$A/$1.--.9$3/5)$3.)$0&53(1(&5)$32;A&-/ZA.)D$o(5)Q.5W$X'($.)1$L/)0(52$

;/-$AU&00(3.51$32+25/W.$T$#Q/5WQ/($;&'-$X'.$)&5$L(A)$B&AA/-$L/)).$).)$21'3.)$.5$/5WA/()$h$(A $V/$

.5)'(1.$.5$:')1-/A(.D$!5$787b9$B&AA/-9$.R(A2$.5$:')1-/A(.9$/$1&'1$&'ZA(2$1&'1$3.$).)$-/0(5.)$0Q(5&().)$

.1 $ 3. $ )/ $ A/5W'. $ +/1.-5.AA.9 $ (A $ 5. $ ;.'1 $ +f+. $ ;A') $ 0&++'5(X'.- $ /V.0 $ )&5 $ ;,-.D $ C&') $ A.)$

-.Z&53()).+.51) $ +/S.'-) $ 3' $ L(A+ $ )&51 $ .5 $ A(.5 $ /V.0 $ A.) $ ;-&ZA,+.) $ /01'.A) $ 3. $ A/ $ 4Q(5. $ M$

AU/00-&()).+.51$3.)$(52W/A(12)$.51-.$-(0Q.)$.1$;/'V-.)9$AU/11-/01(&5$V.-)$'5$+&3,A.$&00(3.51/A$S')X'UT$

5(.-$)/$;-&;-.$0'A1'-.9$AU(++(W-/1(&5$L&-02.$;/-$A/$;/'V-.12$3.)$1-/V/(AA.'-)$T$AU(512-(.'-$3'$;/O)9$A/$

3(/);&-/$+.52.$3/5)$'5$)&'0()$3U.R;/5)(&5$0/;(1/A()1.DDD$o(/$wQ/5W`.$32;.(51$T$1-/V.-)$AUQ()1&(-.$3.$

C/&$A/$320Q2/50.$3.$)&5$;-&;-.$;/O)9$A/$;.-1.$3.$AU(3.51(12$0Q(5&().9$A/$V&A&512$3U/AA.-$1&'S&'-)$;A')$

V(1.$.1$;A')$A&(5$)/5)$;-.53-.$.5$0&+;1.$0.$X'($O$.)1$;.-3'D$%.)$3.'R$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$o(5)Q.5W$.1$3.$

%(/5Ws($-.;-2).51.51$0.)$3.'R$/);.01)$3.$A/$4Q(5.$.51-.$A.)X'.A)$C/&$.)1$320Q(-2.D$%(/5Ws($/;;/-1(.51$

/'$;/))2$)&0(/A()1.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$h$1-/V/(AA.'-$;/1(.519$/;;/-1.5/51$T$'5$W-&';.$3.$+(5.'-)9$).$+&X'/51$

3.$o(5)Q.5W$X'U(A$X'/A(L(.$(-&5(X'.+.51$3U2A(1.D$o(5)Q.5W$-.;-2).51.$A.$0/;(1/A()+.$)/'V/W.$h$(A$5U/$;/) $

3.$A(+(1.)$21Q(X'.)9$W2&W-/;Q(X'.)9$.1$.50&-.$+&(5)$3.$V(1.)).D$aA$0&++'5(X'.$;/-$)`O;.$.51-.$A/$

Page 56: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

4Q(5.$.1$AU:')1-/A(.9$.5V&(.$)&5$L(A)$.5$S.1$&'$.5$CNg9$1-/3'(1$AU/5WA/()$.5$1.+;)$-2.A$/V.0$N&&WA. $

C-/5)A/1.D $o(5)Q.5W$V(1 $'5$ 1.+;)$3. $;A') $.5$;A') $-/;(3.9 $&[$ A.)$0Q&).) $)U/002A,-.51 $3. $+/5(,-.$

V.-1(W(5.').$.1$&[$(A$5U.)1$;A')$Z.)&(5$3Uf1-.$;/1(.519$3U/11.53-.$X'&($X'.$0.$)&(1$M$A/$1.0Q5&A&W(.$/ $

-23'(1$A.$1.+;)$;&'-$0Q/X'.$/01(&5D$

%/$320Q2/50.$3U.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0$.)1$3&50$.5$-.A/1(&5$3(-.01.$/V.0$A.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+D$

o(/ $ wQ/5W`. $ &Z).-V. $ '5. $ 320&55.R(&5 $ .51-. $ A. $ 1.+;) $ Q'+/(5 $ .1 $ A. $ 1.+;) $ 3. $ A/ $ )&0(212D $ %.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$3.V-&51$-/A.51(-$;&'-$1.51.-$3.$-.1-&'V.-$'5$-/;;&-1$2+&1(&55.A$/'R$0Q&).)$M$C/&$0Q&()(1$

'5$V(.'R$1-/(5$X'($L/(1$A.$V&O/W.$.5$3/V/51/W.$3.$1.+;)$/L(5$3.$-/+.5.-$)&5$L(A)$T$o(5)Q.5W$.5$.5$

;-&L(1/51$'5$+/R(+'+D$:;-,)$AU20Q.0$3.$A/$0&++'5(0/1(&5$.51-.$B&AA/-$.1$)&5$;,-.9$(A)$1-&X'.51$

W&&WA.$1-/5)A/1.$0&51-.$A/$;-&L.)).'-$3.$B&AA/-$X'($;-.53$A.$1.+;)$3.$A.'-$1-/3'(-.$0.$X'U(A)$&51$

0Q/0'5 $ T $ ). $ 3(-.D $ %/ $ 320Q2/50. $ 5U/ $ ;/) $ A(.' $ 3/5) $ '5. $ V(&A.50. $ 3. $ A/ $ )&0(212 $ 0Q(5&(). $ X'($

)U(51.5)(L(.-/(1$h$3,)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$o(5)Q.5W$L/(-.$-.5V&O.-$)&5$-(V/A$.1$V/$S')X'.$1.51.-$3.$A.$

1'.-D$aA)$)U/W(1$3/V/51/W.$3U'5.$320&55.R(&5$3.)$f1-.)$M$3.$AU()&A.+.51$;-&W-.))(L$3.$C/&$X'($/'$L(A$3.)$

/552.)$;.'1$0&+;1.-$)'-$3.$+&(5)$.5$+&(5)$3.$)&'1(.5$h$3.$o(5)Q.5W$X'($)U.5L.-+.$3/5)$'5.$)&A(1'3.$

+'1(X'.$.1$.51f12.$h$3.$B&AA/-$X'($/O/51$;.-3'$1&'1.)$).)$-/0(5.)9$5.$;/-V(.51$;/)$T$V&(-$'5$L'1'-$T $

)&5$.R()1.50.D$%.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$%(/5Ws(9$()&A2$3/5)$'5.$0(12$&'V-(,-.$.1$3.V.5'$;,-.$3.$L/+(AA.9$

;/-/n1$-.A/1(V.+.51$Q.'-.'R9$+/()$(A$5U/$)'-1&'1$;/)$A.$0Q&(R$M$.5$1/51$X'U&'V-(.-$(A$).+ZA.$-23'(1$T$)/ $

L&501(&5$20&5&+(X'.$/'*3.AT$3.$1&'1$/'1-.$;-(50(;.D$Y.L')/51$A/$0&+;21(1(&5$/0Q/-52.$.1$'5$+&53.$

X'($)U.)1$1-/5)L&-+2$-/3(0/A.+.519$-.)1/51$L(3,A.$T$A/$-.A(W(&5$.1$/'R$V/A.'-)$0&5).-V/1-(0.)$0Q(5&().)9$

(A $).-/$0.;.53/51$2;/-W52$3'$)&-1$3.)$/'1-.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$3&51$A/$)1-'01'-.$L/+(A(/A.$.R;A&).$.5$

0Q.+(5D$

%/$320Q2/50.$0.51-/A.$3'$L(A+$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$.)1$L(5/A.+.51$/)).s$;.'$0&5)0(.51.$0Q.s$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$M$.AA.$.)1$0/')2.$;/-$A.$+&53.$X'($A.)$.51&'-.$.1$(A)$5U.5$V&(.51$X'.$A.)$-2;.-0'))(&5)$)'-$

A.'-)$V(.)$X'&1(3(.55.)D$%&'A&'$).+ZA.$T$;.(5.$V&(-$A.)$0Q/5W.+.51)$3/5)$)/$V(.$h$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$

3.$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$5.$).$-.53.51$;/)$0&+;1.$3'$+/A$X'U(A)$).$L&51$A.)$'5)$.1$A.)$/'1-.)9$.5L.-+2)$

3/5)$'5.$V()(&5$3.)$0Q&).)$X'( $.)1 $ A/ $ A.'-$ h $C/&9$o(5)Q.5W$.1 $%(/5Ws( $5.$L&-+'A.-&51$ S/+/()$ A/$

+&(53-.$/5/AO).$)'-$A/$320Q2/50.$;&A(1(X'.$3.$A/$4Q(5.9$X'.$).'A$A(1$A.$);.01/1.'-$/11.51(LD$aA)$5U.5$

/;;-.53-&51$-(.5$3/5)$0.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+9$(A$L/'3-/$.5$/11.53-.$A/$L(5$;&'-$X'U'5$-.W/-3$'5$;.'$;A')$

-2LA.R(L$)'-$A.$0Q.+(5$;/-0&'-'$)&(1$L/(1$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$$

$$

Page 57: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

*#+9'$>+-&$(.#.+<)+2#+,#-1'./+<)+2#+,')

$

%/$L(5$3'$+2A&3-/+.$3&55.$1&'S&'-)$AU&00/)(&5$3.$L/(-.$-.V.5(-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)'-$A.'-)$

1-/S.01&(-.)D $ #&') $ A/ $ L&-+. $ 3' $ -.W-.19 $ 3. $ AU(53(W5/1(&5 $ &' $ /' $ 0&51-/(-. $ 3. $ AU/00.;1/1(&59 $ 3. $ A/$

-2)(W5/1(&5D$%/$L(5$).$-.1&'-5.$V.-)$A.$32Z'1$.1$L&-+.$'5.$Z&'0A.$3/5)$AU(+/W(5/(-.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$h $

(A)$).$-.V&(.519$).$)&'V(.55.519$-.W-.11.51$A.$;/-/3()$;.-3'$3.)$32Z'1)9$A.'-)$S.'5.)).)$.1$A.'-)$V(.)$

We0Q2.)D$

%.$+&1(L$A.$;A')$-20'--.51$.)1$0.A'($3.$A/$0&5)1/1/1(&5$3'$0/-/01,-.$320.;1(L$3.$A/$V(.D$B/5)$

)>U(-3$2",1'F&12"4&12$)&9$]A/'Z.-1$0&5)1-'(1$'5.$l'V-.$3.$;A')$3.$@88$;/W.)$-/0&51/51$A/$V(.$3.$

]-232-(0$3.$)/$A'11.$;&'-$).$L/(-.$'5.$;A/0.$T$=/-()D$%/$3.-5(,-.$;/W.$-/0&51.$A/$-.50&51-.$.51-.$

]-232-(0$.1$)&5$/+($3U.5L/50.$B.)A/'-(.-)$M$(A)$2V&X'.51$/A&-)$A.$)&'V.5(-$0&++'5$3U'5$S&'-$3U212$&[$

(A)$/V/(.51$'5.$X'(5s/(5.$3U/552.)$.1$&[$(A)$)U21/(.51$.5L'()9$Q&51.'R9$3U'5$Z&-3.A9$)/5)$&).-$/AA.-$

S')X'U/'$Z&'1D$%.$A(V-.$)U/0Q,V.$)'-$A/$0&5)1/1/1(&5$3.$]-232-(0$^$4U.)1$AT$0.$X'.$5&')$/V&5)$.'$3.$

+.(AA.'-$�$_D$B.)$0.51/(5.)$3.$;/W.)$.1$3.$;2-(;21(.)9$3U.LL&-1)$.1$3.$)/0-(L(0.)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;&'-$

;/-V.5(-$L(5/A.+.51$/'$0&5)1/1$X'.$0.$X'U(A)$&51$.'$3.$+.(AA.'-9$L'1$'5$2;()&3.$(+Z20(A.$.1$/3&A.)0.51 $

3&51$(A)$)&51$)&-1()$0&'V.-1)$3.$-(3(0'A.D$%.$;.))(+()+.$3.$]A/'Z.-1$)'-$AU.R()1.50.$)U(50/-5.$(0($/V.0$

Z./'0&';$3.$L&-0.$.1 $-2)'+.$/)).s$Z(.5$A/$V()(&5$X'.$A. $+2A&3-/+.$3&55.$3.$A/$V(.D$4.1$.LL.1 $

5/--/1(L$).$-.1-&'V.$.5$.LL.1$0Q.s$wQ/5W`.$.1$0Q.s$#(-`$3.$+/5(,-.$;-/1(X'.+.51$)(+(A/(-.D$

B/5)$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&09$7b$/552.)$;/)).51$.51-.$A/$;-.+(,-.$)2X'.50.$.1$A/$3.-5(,-.D$

B/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.9$C/&$X'($3&(1$/V&(-$3/5)$A.)$@8$/5)9$/;;/-/n1$;&'-$A/$;-.+(,-.$L&()$/'$0.51-.$3U'5$

W-&';.$3.$S.'5.)$0Q(5&()$)'-$A/$+')(X'.$B,'i&02'3.)$=.1$#Q&;$<&O)D$aA)$)&51$1&')$1-,)$.51Q&')(/)1.)$

.1$-.;-.55.51$A/$+f+.$0Q&-2W-/;Q(.9$;/-L/(1.+.51$)O50Q-&5()2.)D$g(5W1*0(5X$/5)$;A')$1/-39$/;-,)$).)$

32Z&(-.)$/+&'-.'R$.1$L/+(A(/'R$.1$A/$320/3.50.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$X'.$AU/11-/01(&5$;&'-$Amv00(3.51$E^$N&$

z.)1�$_F$5U/$;/)$-.53'.$/'))($Q.'-.').$X'.$;-2V'9$C/&$/;;/-/n1$T$5&'V./'D$%.$+/X'(AA/W.$A/$V(.(AA(1 $

L&-1.+.51$M$.AA.$-.)).+ZA.$T$'5.$W-/53*+,-.$/A&-)$X'U.AA.$3.V-/(1$/V&(-$T$;.(5.$bb$/5)D$%.$)O+Z&A.$

.)1$0A/(-$M$A.$1.+;)$/$;/))29$.1$C/&9$X'($.51-/(1$3/5)$AU.R()1.50.$/'$32Z'1$3'$L(A+9$).$1-&'V.$/'S&'-3UQ'($

T$A/$L(5$3.$)/$V(.D$!AA.$5U/$;/)$W-/53*0Q&).$T$/11.53-.$3.$;A')$X'.$3.$V(.(AA(-9$1-/5X'(AA.+.51$/V.0$)&5$

0Q(.5D$B/5)$A/$3.-5(,-.$)2X'.50.9$.AA.$;/-1$A.$;-&+.5.-$A&-)X'.$)&'3/(5$).$+.1$T$-.1.51(-$A.$32Z'1$3.$

B,'i&02 'h $ )&')$ A/ $5.(W.9 $ )&'-(/51 $ A2W,-.+.519 $.AA. $).$+.1 $T $3/5).-9 $/V.0$ A.)$+f+.)$W.)1.)9 $ A/$

0Q&-2W-/;Q(.$3'$32Z'1D$#.'A.9$)'-$A.$1.--/(5$V/W'.$0&'V.-1$3.$5.(W.9$3/5)/51$)'-$A/$+')(X'.$X'($).$

S&'.$3/5)$)/$1f1.9$.AA.$;/-/n1$;-.)X'.$/'))($S'V25(A.9$).)$W.)1.)$A/$-/;;.A/51$T$).)$@8$/5)D$:(5)($).$

1.-+(5.$A.$L(A+9$)'-$C/&$-fV/519$).'A.9$.1$3/5)/51$/V.0$AU.51Q&')(/)+.$3.$)/$S.'5.)).D$4&++.$0Q.s $

]A/'Z.-19$A.$3.-5(.-$+&+.51$3'$;.-)&55/W.$-/;;.AA.$A.$;-.+(.-9$/55'A/51$1&'1$0.$X'($)U.)1$;/))2$.51-.$

Page 58: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

A.)$3.'RD$%.$0Q.+(5$X'U/$;-()$C/&$).$-2V,A.$f1-.$'5.$.--.'-9$3&51$.AA.$5U/$L(5/A.+.51$-(.5$1(-2$.1$&[$

.AA.$/$;.-3'$)&5$+/-(9$)&5$L(A)9$.1$)&5$;,-.9$).$-.1-&'V/51$T$A/$L(5$;A')$+/AQ.'-.').$X'U/'$32Z'1D$#.'A) $

A'($-.)1.51$).)$)&'V.5(-)D

B/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$0U.)1$A/$+f+.$0&5)1/1/1(&5$X'($/--(V.9$+/()$;A')$1j1$3/5)$A.$L(A+D$o')1.$

/;-,) $ AU.AA(;).9 $ %&-/ $ P.-.3(1Q $ ;/-A. $ 3. $ )/ $ 02A2Z-(12 $ /V.0 $:55(.D $ !AA. $ 2V&X'. $ )/ $ ).5)/1(&5$

3U(50&+;A21'3.$M$^$a1U)$L'55O$()5U1$(1k$:L1.-$/AA$1Q()$1(+.$&L$)1-'WWA(5W9$O&'$+/`.$(1D$:53$O&'$L(53$&'1$

(1$3&.)5U1$K&-1Q$(1D$_$E^$4U.)1$3-jA.9$5&5$k$:;-,)$1&'1$0.$1.+;)$T$A'11.-9$.5L(5$&5$-2'))(1DDD$!1$&5 $

320&'V-. $X'.$\/ $5U.5 $V/A/(1 $;/) $ A/ $;.(5.D $_FD $=A') $ 1/-39 $ 0U.)1 $#1..V.$X'( $ A'( $0&5L(.-/ $ A/ $+f+.$

).5)/1(&5$M$^$3(3$O&'$.V.-$W.1$1Q.$L..A(5W$1Q/1$O&'$W.1$1(-.3$&L$KQ/1$O&'U-.$3&(5W$k$_$E^$5.$1U.)$S/+/() $

1'$).51(.$L/1(W'2.$3.$L/(-.$0.$X'.$1'$L/()k$_FD$4.$X'($/$212$/00&+;A($;/-$A.)$3.'R$;.-)&55/W.)$X'($).$

)&51$2A.V2)$)&0(/A.+.51$3/5)$A. $L(A+$/$;.-3'$1&'1 $)&5$).5)9$0/- $\/$5.$A.)$/$;/)$-.53'$Q.'-.'RD$

a--2+23(/ZA.+.51$/11(-2.$;/-$A.$)Q&K*Z')(5.))9$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$5.$;.'1$)U/--f1.-$3.$1&'-5.-9$3.V.5'.$

32;.53/51.$T$)/$;-&;-.$;&;'A/-(129$.AA.$)U.5L.-+.$3/5)$'5.$0&'-).$V/(5.D$B.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.9$1&')$

A.)$.LL&-1)$0&++()$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$1-&'V.51$A.'-$-2;&5).$3/5)$A/$;Q-/).$3.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$M$

\/$5U.5$V/A/(1$;/)$A/$;.(5.D$%/$L(5$/;;&-1.$'5.$3&552.$)';;A2+.51/(-.$.1$3U/'1/51$;A')$0-'.AA.D$:55(.$

+.'-1$.1$A.$-.)1.$3.$A/$L/+(AA.$/))()1.$T$).)$L'52-/(AA.)$M$)'-;-().9$0.$)&51$3.)$+(AA(.-)$3.$W.5)$X'($

V(.55.51$A'($-.53-.$Q&++/W.9$A/$A/-+.$T$AU&.(A9$-.0&55/())/51)$3.$A/$Z&512$3&51$.AA.$/V/(1$)'$L/(-. $

;-.'V.9$T$0Q/X'.$(5)1/51D$#&'3/(59$A/$3.)1(52.$3U:55(.9$X'($/V/(1$1&'S&'-)$212$-.A2W'2.$/'$).0&53$

;A/59$-2/;;/-/n1$3/5)$1&'1.$)/$;'())/50.9$0&++.$'5$+&3,A.$3.$V(.$.R.+;A/(-.$3.;'()$1&'S&'-)$)&')$

A.'-)$O.'R$T$1&')D$:55(.9$.AA.9$/$/(+2$M$.AA.$.)1$-.)12.$/11.51(V.9$;-&0Q.$3.)$/'1-.)9$3/5)$A.$3&5$3U.AA.*

+f+.$.5$;.-+/5.50.D$!AA.$/$)'(V($A.$0Q.+(5$.R/01.+.51$(5V.-).$T$0.A'($3.$%&-/9$X'($5U/$S/+/()$

;.5)2$X'UT$.AA.$h$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$).$3.+/53.$)&'3/(5$;&'-X'&($A.$L(A+$0&51/(1$3/V/51/W.$AUQ()1&(-.$3. $

%&-/$X'.$A/$)(.55.D$%U(-&5(.$+&-/A()/1-(0.$L-/;;.$T$A/$L(5$M$)($A.$0.51-.$3.)$-.W/-3)9$/V/(1$212$:55(.9$/' $

A(.'$3Uf1-.$%&-/9$A.)$/'1-.)$;.-)&55/W.)$/'-/(.51$;.'1*f1-.$0&+;-()$0.$X'($A.'-$+/5X'/(1D$$

:'*3.AT$3.) $;.-)&55/W.)9 $ A. $+2A&3-/+.$).$ 1.-+(5.$;/- $ A/ $;.-+/5.50. $3.) $)(1'/1(&5) $3.$

3&+(5/1(&5 $ (5)1/'-2.) $/' $32Z'1D $4.$5U.)1 $;/) $).'A.+.51 $'5 $ -.W/-3 $0-'.A $;&-12 $ )'- $ A/ $0&53(1(&5$

Q'+/(5.$X'($.)1$(0($T$AU&.'V-.9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$A.$0&5)1/1$3U'5$20Q.0$;&A(1(X'.9$)&0(/A9$3U/+2A(&-.-$A.$

+&53.$V.-)$3U/V/51/W.$3.$S')1(0.$.1$3U2X'(12D$%&'A&'$-.)1.9$S')X'U/'$Z&'19$1-/(12.$0&++.$'5$+&O.5$

.1$5&5$0&++.$'5$f1-.$Q'+/(5D$%.)$Q&++.)$X'U.AA.$-.50&51-.$1&'1$/'$A&5W$3'$L(A+$1.51.51$3.$).$

AU/;;-&;-(.-$ h $3.$ AU2;&').-9 $3.$ A/ $V.53-.9 $3.$).$).-V(- $3U.AA. $;&'-$&Z1.5(- $3.$ AU/-W.51D $!AA. $ L(5(-/$

;-&)1(1'2.$;/-$).)$3.'R$;A')$;-&0Q.)$/+()9$X'($32;.5).51$AU/-W.51 $X'($A.'-$-.)1.$;&'-$/0Q.1.-$3.$

AU/A0&&AD$!AA.$+&'--/$3'$V(0.$3.)$Q&++.)9$)(+;A.$&ZS.1$.51-.$A.'-)$+/(5)D$aA$5UO$/'-/$W',-.$;A')$3.$

S')1(0.$;&'-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3U.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0'M$%(/5Ws(9$A.$S.'5.$&'V-(.-9$/11-/;.$'5$0/50.-$T$

Page 59: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

L&-0.$3. $ 1-/V/(AA.- $)&')$ 1.--.9 $C/&$).$-.1-&'V.$).'A.$;&'- $/V&(- $0232$/' $+/'V/() $;-21.53/519 $.1$

o(5)Q.5W9$Z(.5$X'.$+/AQ.'-.'R$3/5)$)&5$.R(A$/')1-/A(.59$-.)1.$-(0Q.$T$+(AA(&5)9$.1$V(1$/V.0$)&5$L(A)D$

!5L(59 $3/5) $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9 $ A/ $-2)&A'1(&5$;A')$&'$+&(5)$Q.'-.').$5.$;.'1$).$L/(-. $X'U/V.0$A/$

3();/-(1(&5$3U:55(.D$%.)$3.-5(,-.)$(+/W.)$+&51-.51$A/$L/+(AA.$;-.5/51$)&'3/(5$'5$/'1-.$).5)$M$)/5)$

:55(.9$1&')$)&51$ZA/50)9$.1$AU2X'(A(Z-.$0&5V.51(&55.A$).$-.1-&'V.$E'5$;,-.9$'5.$+,-.$.1$3.'R$L(AA.)FD$

#/-/Q*o/5.$).$1-&'V.9$;/-$A/$+&-1$3.$)/$+,-.9$;A')$X'.$S/+/()$(512W-2.$0Q.s$A.)$P.-.3(1QD$%/$1.5)(&5$

-/0(/A.$/$3();/-'.9$A/())/51$A/$L/+(AA.$-(0Q.$T$A/$+&-/A(12$Z(.5$;.5)/51.$;A')$1-/5X'(AA.9$.51-.$ZA/50)9$

)/5)$;A')$3.$;-&ZA,+.)D$%.$0Q.+(5$;/-0&'-'$5U/$-(.5$/+.52$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)9$+/()$(A$5U/$-(.5$/+.52$

5&5$;A')$/'$+&53.$X'($A.)$.51&'-.D$%/$3&+(5/1(&5$20-/)/51.$3.)$Q&++.)$)'-$A.)$L.++.)9$3.)$ZA/50)$

)'-$A.)$5&(-)9$3.)$-(0Q.)$)'-$A.)$;/'V-.)$).$1-&'V.$0&5L(-+2.9$32L(5(1(V.+.51D

B/5) $+,-),-9$A/$L(5$V/$;A')$A&(5D$aA$5.$)U/W(1$;/)$3.$A/$)(+;A.$0&5)1/1/1(&5$X'.$A.$0Q.+(5$

;/-0&'-'1$5.$V/A/(1$;/)$A/$;.(5.9$+/()$3U'5.$;.-1.$3.$).5)$1&1/A.D$%&'A&'9$)O+Z&A.$3.$A/$S&(.$.1$3.$

AU(55&0.50.$3/5)$'5$+&53.$.5$;'1-2L/01(&59$).$-.1-&'V.$/))/))(52.$;/-$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-D$4&51-/(51.$T$

).$;-&)1(1'.-$.1$0Q.-0Q/51$)&5$;-.+(.-$0A(.519$.AA.$-.50&51-.$'5$Q&++.$X'($.)1$;-f1$T$A/$)'(V-.9$+/()$

X'($5U/$;/)$3U/-W.51D$%U/+&'-.').$%&'A&'$AU/00.;1.$+/AW-2$1&'1$M$.AA.$)U&LL-.$T$0.A'($X'($).$-2V2A.-/$

Z(.51j1$f1-.$'5$1'.'-$L&'D$BU/Z&-3$320&50.-129$(A$).$-.L').-/$T$A/$1'.-9$S')X'UT$0.$X'.9$;-()$3.$L&A(.9$(A$

+,5.$L(5/A.+.51$T$Z(.5$)&5$/01.D$%&'A&'$2A.V2.$/(5)($;.'$T$;.'$/'$)O+Z&A.$3.$AU(55&0.50.$.1$3.$

AU/+&'-9$).$-.1-&'V.$/))/))(52.$0-'.AA.+.51$T$0.A'($T$X'($.AA.$/V/(1$&LL.-1$)&5$0&-;)D$C'.-$%&'A&'9$

0U.)1$1'.-$'5$.5L/519$/))/))(5.-$'5$f1-.$;'-9$V(V/51D$4U.)1$'5$/01.$/51(*5/1'-.A9$Z/-Z/-.9$0&51-.$A/$V(.$

.AA.*+f+.D$%/$;-.+(,-.$;.-1.$3.$).5)$V(.51$3.$0.1$/))/))(5/1$h$/V.0$A.$+.'-1-.$3.$%&'A&'9$)U/0Q,V.$A. $

;.'$3.$L&($X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$;&'V/(1$W/-3.-$.5$AU'5(V.-)D$".$-.)1.$X'.$A.$+&53.$.5$;'1-2L/01(&5$3/5)$

A.X'.A $.AA. $)O+Z&A()/(1 $ A/ $Z./'129 $ AU.);&(- $.1 $ A/ $ S&(.D $#.'A) $ A.) $;.-)&55/W.) $ A.)$;A')$+&5)1-'.'R$

)'Z)()1.51$M$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-$.)1$'5$f1-.$L&'9$320Q(-2$;/-$).)$;'A)(&5)D$%.$;,-.$3.$%&'A&'9$'5$;/-/)(1.$

-&5W2$3.$1&')$A.)$V(0.)$X'($1.-+(5.-/$A.$L(A+$.5$Z'V/51$A.$;.'$3U/-W.51$X'($A'($-.)1.$h$&5$3.V(5.$X'.$A/ $

+&-1$3.$%&'A&'$5.$).-/$;&'-$A'($X'.$AU&00/)(&5$3.$1-&'V.-$'5.$/'1-.$V/0Q.$T$A/(1D$%/$L(5$3U:AK/9$

'A1(+.$-.)0/;2$3'$L(A+$/0Q,V.-/$A.$1-/W(X'.$1/ZA./'D$%.$S.'5.$Q&++.$;A.(5$3U.51Q&')(/)+.$5U.R()1.$

;A') $ M $ (A $/ $212 $ -.53'$L&'$;/- $ A. $ S.'$.1 $ AU/-W.51 $.1 $V(32 $3.$ 1&'1 $.)1(+.$3.$ A'(*+f+.$/;-,) $/V&(- $

Ae0Q.+.51 $ +() $ %&'A&' $ )'- $ A. $ 1-&11&(-D $ aA $ L(5(1 $ 0&++. $ '5 $ 0&-;) $+&-19 $ '5. $ L(W'-. $ 3. $ s&+Z(D$

:Z/53&55/51$%&'A&'$*$(A$5.$)/'-/$;/)$X'U.AA.$/$212$/))/))(52.$*$(A$)'(1$.5$1-/n5/51$A.)$;(.3)$A/$L/5L/-.$

3.$A/$0-&(R$-&'W.D$aA$)U/Z/53&55.9$.--/51$3/5)$A/$5'(1$)/5)$Z'1$M$A.$S.'5.$Q2-(1(.-$;A.(5$3U.51Q&')(/)+.$

.)1$3.V.5'$'5.$e+.$.5$;.(5.$D

%.$;A')$21-/5W.$0U.)1$X'.$+/AW-2$0.$+&+.51$-2LA.R(L9$X'($5&')$-/+,5.$/'$32Z'1$3'$L(A+9$A.$

);.01/1.'-$).+ZA.$).'A$f1-.$0/;/ZA.$3.$1(-.-$'5.$)O51Q,).D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5U/'-&51$S/+/()$A.$-.0'A$

Page 60: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

520.))/(-.$;&'-$0&+;-.53-.$A.'-)$.--.'-)$M$0.$5U.)1$;/)$;/-0.$X'U.AA.$/))()1.$T$AU.51.--.+.51$3U:55(.$

X'.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$V/$;&'-$/'1/51$0Q/5W.-$)/$L/\&5$3.$V(V-.$h$C/&$5U/'-/$;/)$A.$-.0'A$520.))/(-.$;&'-$

).$-.Z.AA.-$3.V/51$AU21/1$3.$;'1-2L/01(&5$3'$+&53.$X'($AU.51&'-.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$+2A&3-/+.)$5.$

0.)).51 $ 3. $ 1-/V.-).- $ A.) $ 2;-.'V.) $ )/5) $ V&(- $ A.'-) $ .--.'-)D $ %.) $+f+.) $ ;-&ZA,+.)9 $ A.) $+f+.)$

+/A23(01(&5)9$).$-2;,1.519$+/()$;.-)&55.$3U/'1-.$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$5.$)U.5$-.53-/$0&+;1.D

Page 61: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

?K*.%,&'(3(

U9*1)(0*(+,&9/,9&'(".$9+'(0'()"+%&

%.$+2A&3-/+.$0&5)1-'(1$'5$1.+;)$&[$A/$L(5$L/(1$-2L2-.50.$/'$32Z'19$&[$-(.5$5U/$2V&A'2$;&'-$

A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$X'($).$-.1-&'V.519$>8$/5)$&'$7b$/5)$/;-,)9$)/5)$3/V/51/W.$(32.$3.$0.$X'($/'-/(1$;'$

A.)$-.53-.$Q.'-.'RD$4.11.$(+;-.))(&5$3.$-.V.5(-$T$s2-&$.)1$A/$+/5(L.)1/1(&5$A/$;A')$2V(3.51.$3U'5$+/A$

X'($1-/V/(AA.$A.$+2A&3-/+.$3.$AU(512-(.'-$.1$X'($3&55.$T$A/$)1-'01'-.$+2A&3-/+/1(X'.$)&5$0/-/01,-.$)($

);20(L(X'.D$%.$02A,Z-.$;/-/3(W+.$3.$](.A39$X'($-2)'+.$A/$)1-'01'-.$1O;.$3'$)025/-(&$.5$'5.$Q()1&(-.$

.5 $ 1-&() $;/-1(.) $ E/V.0 $'5. $+(). $ .5 $ )(1'/1(&59 $'5. $ 0&5L-&51/1(&5 $.1 $ '5 $325&'.+.51F@7$ ). $ 1-&'V.$

1&1/A.+.51$(5.R;A&(1/ZA.$3/5)$A.$0/)$3'$+2A&3-/+.D$%/$L&-+.$5U.)1$;/)$0.AA.$3.$A/$0&50.51-/1(&5$

/'1&'-$3U'5$+&1(L9$+/()$/'$0&51-/(-.$3.$A/$3(A'1(&5$3'$1.+;)$/'1&'-$3.$AU&Z).))(&5$3U'5$;.-)&55/W.D$

Pf+. $ )( $ &5 $ .5 $ -.1-&'V. $ AU20Q& $ 3. $ ](.A3 $ T $ 1-/V.-) $ A/ $ )1-'01'-. $ 321/(AA2. $ ;A') $ Q/'1 $ EA. $ 1.+;)$

;/-/3()(/X'.9$A/$320Q2/50.9$A.$-.1&'-$)'-$A.$;/))2F9$A/$1.5)(&5$WA&Z/A.$3'$L(A+$5.$).$)(1'.$.5$/'0'5$

0/)$3/5)$A.)$+f+.)$s&5.)$3'$L(A+D$B/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$AU/)0.5)(&5$)&0(/A.$3.$A/$+,-.9$X'($/'-/(1$

;'$0&5)1(1'.-$A.$0l'-$3U'5.$(51-(W'.$0&+;A,1.9$)U/0Q,V.$3.$L/(1$T$A/$+&(1(2$3'$L(A+9$3&55/51$5/())/50. $

T$'5.$/'1-.$)(1'/1(&5$3&51$A.$0.51-.$.)1$Z./'0&';$;A')$LA&'D$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0$).$3(V().$.5$1-&()$

;/-1(.)9$+/()9$T$5&'V./'9$/'0'5.$3U.AA.$5U.)1$/))(+(A/ZA.$T$0.AA.)$X'.$32L(5(1$](.A3$h$(+;&))(ZA.$3.$

V&(- $ 3/5) $ A/ $ 1-/S.01&(-. $ 3. $C/&9 $ '5. $ 2V&A'1(&5 $ A(52/(-. $ X'( $ (-/(1 $ 3/5) $ '5 $ ).5)D $ %. $+2A&3-/+.$

)U(512-.)).$T$0.$X'($V(.53-/(1$/;-,)$A.$325&'.+.51$M$0&++.51$V(V-/(.51$A.$;-(50.$.1$A/$;-(50.)).$/;-,)$

)Uf1-.$+/-(2)$k$4&++.51$A.'-)$32)(-)$-.);.01(L)$;.'V.51*(A)$E&'$5&5F$).$0&5S'W'.-$;&'-$3&55.-$'5$

0&51.R1.$L/+(A(/A$)/(5$k$:;-,)$/V&(-$)/'V2$A.$+&53.9$0&++.51$A.$Q2-&)$;/-V(.51*(A$T$-.V.5(-$0Q.s$A'( $

.1$T$-.1-&'V.-$'5$2X'(A(Z-.$k$#($AU&5$V.'1$V&(-$A.$+2A&3-/+.$0&++.$'5.$)1-'01'-.$A(52/(-.9$A/$A(W5.$.)1 $

3/5)$1&')$A.)$0/)$;A')$A&5W'.$.1$A/$L(5$/--(V.$1&'S&'-)$;A')$1/-3$X'.$0.$X'.$AU&5$/'-/(1$/11.53'D

( A$)+(."1-.1")+-&682)B)+C+2)+</('"+-@#$D)#$.

B/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$3.$0.$+2+&(-.9$5&')$/V&5)$32L(5($A.$+2A&3-/+.$0&++.$AUQ()1&(-.$3.$

A/$A'11.$3U'5$&'$3.$;A')(.'-)$;.-)&55/W.)$;&'-$A/$-2/A()/1(&5$3.$A.'-)$32)(-)D$P/()$AU/))&0(/1(&5$3'$

;.-)&55/W.$T$)&5$32)(-$5U.)1$;/)$)O5&5O+.$3U'5.$0&5)1-'01(&5$A(52/(-.$.1$)(+;A.D$%.$32)(-$.)1$'5.$

@7$](.A39$#O39$F3@1$#",'A')&0':$0&0'(&')>@3#"2-#&9$1-/3D$"/3(/$!33/{-/9$BaÄaC9$=/-()9$788G

Page 62: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

.51(12$;A')$0&+;A.R.$X'U'5$Z'1$5/--/1(L$h$A/$)1-'01'-.$2;&')/51$A.$32)(-$3'$;.-)&55/W.9$A/$)1-'01'-.$

.AA.*+f+. $ 3.V(.51 $ 0&+;A.R.D $ %. $ 1.+;) $ ;/))/519 $ A.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ V(.(AA())/51)9 $ A.) $ 32)(-) $ ).$

+&3(L(.519 $0Q/5W.51 $3.$).5)D $!5L(5$3/5) $ A. $0/)$&[$ A. $);.01/1.'-$)'(1 $;A')(.'-)$3.)1(5)$T $ A/ $ L&()$

E!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&;'.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0F9$(A)$).$0&5L-&51.51$.1$).$0Q&X'.51$A.)$'5)$/'R$/'1-.)D$

B/5) $ A.) $ 1-&() $ .R.+;A.) $ 0Q&()()9 $ &5 $ -.1-&'V. $ '5. $ 0&+;A.R(12 $ 3' $ 32)(- $ X'( $ (5LA'.50. $ A/$

5/--/1(&5D$B/5) $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$V.'1$3.V.5(-$'5.$W-/53.$/01-(0.D$t$A/$+&(1(2$3'$

L(A+9$.AA.$/--(V.$/'$)&++.1$3.$)&5$Z'1 $M $02A2Z-())(+.$/01-(0.$3.$1Q2e1-.$0&+(X'.9$.AA.$-.+;&-1.$

2W/A.+.51$'5$)'00,)$/V.0$'5.$;(,0.$3-/+/1(X'.9$.1$A.$0(52+/$L(5(1$+f+.$;/-$)U(512-.)).-$T$.AA.$;&'-$

^ $ A. $ ;A') $ W-/53 $ -jA. $ 3.;'() $ #0/-A.11 $ vUQ/-/ $ _D $ =&'-1/519 $ %&-/ $P.-.3(1Q $ ). $ ).51 $ (50&+;A,1.9$

+/AQ.'-.').D$!AA.$0Q.-0Q.$'5.$/'1-.$V&(.$X'($;-&A&5W.$0.AA.$3.$A/$02A2Z-(129$+/()$;.(5.$T$).$1-&'V.-$

'5$Z'19 $&)0(AA/51 $.51-. $ )/ $ -.A/1(&5$/V.0$#1..V.9 $ )/ $ L(AA. $.1 $.50&-. $)/ $0/--(,-. $;&'- $ A/X'.AA. $.AA. $

0&51(5'.$3.$)/0-(L(.-$)&5$.51&'-/W.9$5.$;&'V/51$0.)).-$3.$-2;&53-.$T$AU/;;.A$3'$)Q&K*Z')(5.))D$%/$

1-/S.01&(-. $ 3' $ ;.-)&55/W. $ .)1 $ 3&50 $ 0.AA. $ 3U'5. $ LA,0Q.9 $ X'( $ &Z1(.51 $ )&5 $ Z'19 $ +/() $ .R;A&).$

(++23(/1.+.51$/;-,)9$L/'1.$3.$1-&'V.-$'5$/'1-.$32)(-$/'))($L&-1D$

%.$32)(-$X'($0/-/012-().$#')(.$3/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$0U.)1$0.A'($3.$)&5$/+&'-$;&'-$#1..V.D$

P/()$#')(.$;/)).$A/$+/S&-(12$3'$1.+;)$3'$L(A+$T$(W5&-.-$X'U.AA.$.5$.)1$/+&'-.').$h$0.$5U.)1$X'.$>b$

+(5'1.)$/V/51$A/$L(5$X'U.AA.$).$-.53$0&+;1.$X'U.AA.$AU/$1&'S&'-)$/(+2D$!AA.$;/-1(-/$(++23(/1.+.51$

;&'-$'5.$'5(V.-)(12$A&(51/(5.9$5.$3&55/51$/'0'5.$0Q/50.$T$)&5$32)(-$3.$).$-2/A().-D$%U.)).51(.A$3.$A/$

-.A/1(&5$3.$#')(.$/V.0$)&5$;-&;-.$32)(-$.)1$3&50$)&'1.--/(5.9$.5$W.-+.D$t$;.(5.$20A&).9$.AA.$).-/$T $

5&'V./'$.51.--2.9$-.L&'A2.D$#/-/Q*o/5.$.)1$/5(+2.$;/-$'5$32)(-$(+;&))(ZA.$h$0.A'($3Uf1-.$ZA/50Q.D$%/$

).'A.$;&))(Z(A(12$;&'-$.AA.$3U/0023.-$3U'5.$/'1-.$L&-+.$T$)&5$32)(-9$0U.)1$3.$L'(-$)/$+,-.$&'$X'.$0.AA.*

0($5.$+.'-.$E.AA.$.5$)&'Q/(1.$;A')(.'-)$L&()$A/$3();/-(1(&5FD$:55(.$L(5(-/$;/-$+&'-(-9$0.$X'($A/()).-/$

#/-/Q*o/5.$/V.0$'5$32)(-$-2)&A'9$+/()$320Q(-2.$;/-$A/$0'A;/Z(A(12D$%.$32)(-$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$+'A1(;A.9$

0Q/5W./51D $ !AA. $ /(+. $ /V.0 $ A. $+f+. $ .51Q&')(/)+. $ A. $ 3&01.'- $ )/5) $ )0-';'A. $ .1 $ )&5 $ S.'5. $ L(A)$

(32/A()1.$h$)&5$;-&;-.$;,-.$.1$)&5$;-.+(.-$0A(.51$3.)$Z/)*L&53)$3.$%&53-.)$&'$'5$+/-X'()$-.50&51-2$

3/5)$'5$1-/(5D$!AA.$(50/-5.$A.$32)(-$M$.AA.$/(+.$.1$/11(-.$AU/+&'-$)/5)$A(+(1.)DD$%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$L(A+$)'(1 $

A.)$+&'V.+.51)$3.$W(-&'.11.$3.$%&'A&'$M$G$/01.)$;&'-$G$32)(-)$3(LL2-.51)9$G$0&51.R1.)$&[$.AA.$/(+.$

1&'S&'-)9$+/()$3(LL2-.++.51D$C/&9$.AA.9$-.5&50.$T$).)$32)(-)$'5$;/-$'5D$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0$.)1$

'5.$)'(1.$3U20Q.0$.1$3.$-2)(W5/1(&5)$M$.AA.$5.$V.'1$;/)$/V&(-$T$0Q&()(-$.51-.$).)$3.'R$/+/51)$.1$A.)$

;.-3$1&')$A.)$3.'R$h$.AA.$-fV.$3U'5$+/-(/W.$Q.'-.'R$/V.0$o(5)Q.5W$.1$(A)$3(V&-0.-&51$-/;(3.+.51$h$.AA. $

L/(1$'5$.5L/51$X'($A'($.)1$-.1(-2$;-.)X'.$(++23(/1.+.51$h$.AA.$1.51.$3.$-.)1.-$1-/5X'(AA.+.51$/'R$0j12)$

3.$)&5$;,-.$.1$3U&'ZA(.-$A.)$Q&++.)$.1$)&5$;,-.$+.'-1D$%/$1-/S.01&(-.$3.$C/&$.)1$3&50$'5.$)'(1.$3.$

32)(-)$(5/Z&'1()9$1'2)$3/5)$AU&.'LD$%/$1-/S.01&(-.$A/$;A')$)(+;A.$.)1$0.A'($3U:55(.9$3/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$ '

Page 63: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

*"&9$X'($5.$V(1$X'.$;/-$;-&0'-/1(&5$A.)$32)(-)$3.)$/'1-.)D$#&5$'5(X'.$32)(-$;.-)&55.A9$.)1$0.A'($3.$L/(-.$

3.$W-/53.)$L'52-/(AA.)9$X'($.)1$L(5/A.+.51$A.$;A')$0&50-.19$A.$;A')$)(+;A.$T$&Z1.5(-$.1$A.$).'A$X'($5.$

;.-+.11.$;/)$A/$A/))(1'3.$3.$)U(5)1/AA.-$;'()X'U(A$).-/$A.$3.-5(.-D

%U2V&A'1(&5 $3'$+2A&3-/+.$5U.)1 $;/) $;-&W-.))(V.$ h $.AA. $/V/50. $;/- $T*0&';)9 $;2-(;21(. $;/-$

;2-(;21(.9$X'($-/;;-&0Q.51$&'$2A&(W5.51$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$)&5$&ZS.01(LD$#.$-2;,1.51$A.)$.--.'-)9$A.)$

&Z).))(&5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$A.'-)$32)(-)$0&51-.3(1)$.1$A.'-$(50/;/0(12$T$f1-.$Q.'-.'RD$d5.$1-/S.01&(-.$

0&++.502.$/V.0$1&'1$AU.51Q&')(/)+.$3'$+&53.$;.'1$+&'-(-$/'))(1j1$0&++.502.D$4/-$;/-+($A.)$

A.\&5)$3'$+2A&3-/+.9$(A$O$.5$/$3.'R$X'($.R;A(X'.51$0.11.$)1-'01'-.$0Q/5W./51.$.1$0&+;A.R.$3'$3.)1(5$

3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$M$A.)$).51(+.51)$5.$).$0&51-jA.51$;/)$.1$A.)$f1-.)$Q'+/(5)$5U&51$/'0'5.$(32.$3.$0. $

X'( $;.'1 $ A.)$+.5.-$/'$Z&5Q.'-D $B/5)$A.)$ 1-&()$0/)$2V&X'2)9 $ (A $O $/ $'5$+&'V.+.51$3.$32)(- $X'( $

0&5)1-'(1$A.$L(A+$M$3/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$0U.)1$A.$3.)1(5$3.$%&-/$X'($&'V-.$A.$L(A+$.1$0.A'($3.$#/-/Q*

o/5.$.1$:55(.$X'($A.$0Aj1D$#(-`$(5V.-).$AU2X'(A(Z-.$.1$32A/()).$A/$A(W5.$5/--/1(V.$S')X'.$AT$3&+(5/51.$

X'( $ -/0&51/(1 $ A/ $V(. $3. $%&-/ $P.-.3(1Q $;&'- $0A&-. $ A. $ L(A+$)'- $0.AA. $3.) $3.'R$ L.++.) $ S')X'.*AT$

3/V/51/W.$(5V()(ZA.)9$:55(.$.1$P/-(.*o/5.D$B/5) $+,-),-9$0U.)1$A/$0&5L-&51/1(&5$3U'5$.);-(1$A(Z-.$.1$

3U'5$+&53.$.5$;'1-2L/01(&5$X'($3&55.$A/$1-/S.01&(-.$WA&Z/A.$3'$L(A+D$%.$32)(-$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$0.A'($

3U'5.$A(Z.-12$3U/W(-$)/5)$A(+(1.)D$#/$1-/S.01&(-.$5.$).$1.-+(5.-/$X'.$3/5)$A/$+&-19$3/5)$A/$32L/(1.$3.$

0.1$.);-(1$A(Z-.$L/0.$/'$+&53.D$aA$.)1$;A')$3(LL(0(A.$3.$V&(-$'5.$1-/S.01&(-.$WA&Z/A.$T $.-a(&)/'(&0 '

4,12$%1&0; 'AU'5(12$).$L/()/51$)'-1&'1$3/5)$A.$3.)1(5$3.$A/$4Q(5.D$%/$-.A/1(&5$3.$A/$+,-.$.1$3'$L(A)9 $

(50/-5.$)/5)$3&'1.$A.$+(.'R$'5.$1.5)(&5$X'($;&'--/(1$f1-.$'5$L(A$0&53'01.'-$3'$L(A+$M$A.'-)$32)(-) $

1&'-52)$AU'5$V.-)$AU/'1-.$3/5)$A/$4Q(5.$X'($)U20-&'A.$;&'--/(.51$0/-/012-().-$'5.$;/-1(.$3.$A/$).0&53.$

.1$A/$1-&()(,+.$;/-1(.$3'$L(A+D$%.$32Z'1$0&5)1(1'.-/(1$/A&-)$'5.$;-2L/0.9$AUQ()1&(-.$3.$0&++.51$0.1$

.5L/51 $V(.53-/ $/'$+&53.$h $3U&[$V(.51*(A $k $c'.AA. $.)1 $ AUQ()1&(-. $3.$A/ $-.50&51-.$3.$).)$;/-.51) $k$

wQ/5W`.$;A/0.$3U/(AA.'-)$A.$0/-1&5$X'($/55&50.$A.$1(1-.$3'$L(A+$T$A/$L(5$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$/A&-) $

X'.$A.$L(A+$).+ZA.$/V&(-$32ST$0&++.5029$0.$X'($V(.53-/(1$-.5L&-0.-$A/$A.01'-.$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$

0&++.$'5$;-&A&W'.D

%.$32)(-$3'$;.-)&55/W.$.1$A/$)1-'01'-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$/V/50.51$3.$;/(-.9$.1$0.$5U.)1$;/)$3. $

+/5(,-.$A(52/(-. $&'$3(-.01.D $%.$32)(- $;-.53$3.)$V&(.)$ (5/11.53'.)9 $).$ 1-/5)L&-+.9 $L/(1 $5/n1-.$3.)$

).51(+.51) $5&'V./'R$.1 $ (+;&))(ZA.)9 $5. $). $0&51.51. $;/) $3Uf1-. $ -2/A()2 $;&'- $3();/-/n1-. $.1 $5. $).$

0&51.51. $ ;/) $ 3.) $ -.L') $ .1 $ 3.) $ (+;&))(Z(A(12)D $4/- $ A. $ 32)(- $ / $ /'))( $ T $ V&(- $ /V.0 $ AU&Z).))(&59 $ A/$

-20'--.50.D$%.$+/A$X'($-&5W.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$0U.)1$Z(.5$X'U'5.$L&()$(5)1(AA2$.5$.'R9$(A$5.$A.'-$A/()).-/ $

;/)$3.$-2;(1D$:'*3.AT$3U'5.$2V&A'1(&5$X'($;-.53$3.)$321&'-)$.1$0Q/5W.$3.$5/1'-.9$A.$32)(-$/$'5.$5/1'-.$

0O0A(X'.9$-20'--.51.9$&Z).))(V.D$%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$1-/V/(AA2.$;/-$0.$-.1&'-$(50.))/51$3'$

+/AD$

Page 64: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

( *)(+8#(('&$(+#1B31)22)(+&$+$;/-@#88)+8#(

%. $ 1.+;) $ 3' $+2A&3-/+. $ .)1 $ 0O0A(X'. $ M $ A.) $ -20'--.50.)9 $ A.) $ -2;21(1(&5) $ 5. $ 0.)).51 $ 3U.5$

1-/V/(AA.-$A/$)1-'01'-.$3U'5.$+/5(,-.$)&'V.51$52L/)1.$;&'-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D

B/5) $+,-),-9$0.$X'($0/').$A/$320Q2/50.$3'$;.-)&55/W.$).$-2;,1.$.5$;.-+/5.50.D$#($AU&5$

/5/AO). $0Q/0'5$3.) $ -.1&'-5.+.51) $3.$)(1'/1(&5) $3.$%&'A&'9$ (A) $ )&51 $ A(2)$T $ A/ $;-2).50. $3.$3.'R$

;.-)&55/W.)D $ %.) $ L(W'-.) $ 3. $ Y&3-(W& $ .1 $ 3. $ #0Q(W&A0Q9 $ A.) $ 3.'R $ ;/-/)(1.) $ X'( $ 1.51.51$

)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$3.$AU'1(A().-$T$A.'-$;-&L(19$L&501(&55.$0&++.$3.'R$+/'V/()$W25(.)9$X'($V(.55.51$

)/5)$0.)).$321-'(-.$AU'5(V.-)$3.$A/$S.'5.$L(AA.D$aA)$/;;/-/()).51$I$L&()D$#.'A)$A.)$/01.)$3.'R$.1$1-&() $

).-&51$2;/-W52)$3.$A.'-$;-2).50.D$aA$)U/W(1$3.)$/01.)$&[$%&'A&'$;&'--/$;-&W-.)).-D$B/5)$AU/01.$>9$A.$

3&01.'-$;/-1$.5$0&A,-.$/;-,)$)/$0&5V.-)/1(&5$/V.0$%&'A&'$;/-0.$X'U(A$/$320&'V.-1$#0Q(W&A0Q$0/0Q2$

3/5)$ A/ $+/()&5$/V.0$'5.$Z&'1.(AA. $3.$zQ()`OD $B/5)$ AU/01. $H9 $ A. $3&01.'- $320&'V-.$#0Q(W&A0Q$.1 $

Y&3-(W& $3/5) $)/ $ 0Q/+Z-. $T $ 0&'0Q.-D $B/5)$ AU/01. $b9 $ 0. $ )&51 $.'R $X'( $ (5V(1.51 $%&'A&'$T $ L'(-9 $ A/ $

0&53/+5/51$T$'5.$V(.$3.$0/V/A.D$B/5)$AU/01.$I9$(A)$+&51.51$3/5)$A.$1-/(5$S')1.$/V/51$X'.$0.A'(*0($5.$

;/-1.9$0&++.$'5.$+/A23(01(&5$X'($0&AA.$T$%&'A&'$h$A.$);.01/1.'-$X'($A.)$/$32ST$(3.51(L(2)$0&++.$'5.$

+.5/0.9$)/(1$/A&-)$;.-1(5.++.51$X'.$A/$L'(1.$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$3U:AK/$5.$;&'--/$;/)$f1-.$A.$5&'V./'$

32;/-1$.);2-2D$B/5)$AU/01.$J9$(A)$'1(A().51$%&'A&'$S')X'UT$A/$-'(5.$3.$0.AA.*0(D$!5L(5$3/5)$AU/01.$G9$0U.)1$

A.$;,-.$X'($;&')).$%&'A&'$T$A/$;-&)1(1'1(&5$.1$).-/$3&50$(53(-.01.+.51$-.);&5)/ZA.$3.$)/$+&-1D$

%/ $ L(W'-. $3. $0.)$3.'R$Q&++.)$.)1 $0.AA. $3. $+/'V/() $W25(.) $0/0Q2) $)&')$ AU/;;/-.50. $3.$

AU/+(1(29$X'.$%&'A&'$/00'.(AA.$S')X'U/'$Z&'1$/V.0$.51Q&')(/)+.D$%/$-2;21(1(&5$3.$A.'-)$/;;/-(1(&5)$

V(.53-/$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$-'(5.-$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$;&'-$%&'A&'$3.$V&(-$)&5$.R()1.50.$)U/+2A(&-.-$M$3/5)$

A.)$3.'R$).'A)$/01.)$&[$(A)$5.$)&51$;/)$;-2).51)9$%&'A&'$;/-V(.51$;-.)X'.$T$2;&').-$A.$3&01.'-$.1$T$).$

+.11-.$T$AU/Z-($3'$Z.)&(5D$#0Q(W&A0Q$V.--/$3U/(AA.'-)$0.11.$-.A/1(&5$3U'5$+/'V/()$l(A9$3,)$A.$;-.+(.-$

/01.9$A'($.R;A(X'/51$X'.$A.$3&01.'-$5.$;&'--/$;/)$)'ZV.5(-$T$).)$Z.)&(5)$21.-5.AA.+.519$.1$X'U.AA.$

L.-/(1$+(.'R$3.$+&51.-$'5$5'+2-&$/V.0$Y&3-(W&D$%.$+&1(L$&Z).))(&55.A9$-20'--.51$5U.)1$;/)$(51.-5.9 $

+/()$.R1.-5.D$%&'A&'$.)1$;&'-)'(V(.$;/-$'5.$+/A23(01(&5$0&51-/012.$+/AW-2$.AA.$h$)&5$;-&;-.$;,-.D$

%U/'1-.$-20'--.50.$3.$%&'A&'9$0.$)&51$A.)$+&53.)$X'($).$321-'().51$/'1&'-$3U.AA.D$%.)$Q&++.)$.1$A.) $

L.++.)$X'($/(+.51$%&'A&'$L(5()).51$1&')$+/AD$%.$3&01.'-$+.'-1$3U'5.$Z/AA.$3/5)$A.$V.51-.9$Y&3-(W&$

.)1$/))/))(52$;/-$A/$0&+1.)).9$A/$0&+1.)).$.)1$.++.52.$;/-$A/$;&A(0.9$:AK/$L(5(1$0&++.$'5.$e+.$

.--/51.9$32;&))232.$3.$1&'1D$%.$32)(-$&Z).))(&55.A$A.)$321-'(1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$h$1&')$;/)).51$;/-$

'5.$;Q/).$3.$L/)0(5/1(&5$;'()$3.$32W&i1$.1$3.$+2;-()$;&'-$%&'A&'$X'($A.)$+,5.-/$T$A/$3.)1-'01(&5D$

Page 65: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%.$+&53.$X'.$32;.(51$=/Z)1$3/5)$+,-),-$.)1$-/V/W2$;/-$A.)$;'A)(&5)$h$;'A)(&5)$).R'.AA.)$.1$

;'A)(&5)$3.$+&-1$T$AU2W/-3$3.$%&'A&'D$aA$.)1$.51(,-.+.51$-2W($;/-$A.)$32)(-)$X'U&51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$A.)$

'5)$/'R$32;.53)$3.)$/'1-.)$h$A/$52W/1(&5$3.$AU/'1-.9$)&5$'1(A()/1(&5$0&++.$'5$+&O.5D$%/$1-/S.01&(-.$

3.$%&'A&'$.)1$0&5)1/++.51$3(-(W2.$;/-$0.)$32)(-)$X'($A/$1-/V.-).51$&'$X'($)U(+;&).51$T$.AA.9$L/()/51 $

3U.AA.$'5$f1-.$;-.)X'.$;/))(L9$V(01(+.$3.$0.)$;'A)(&5)D$4U.)1$.5$0.A/$X'.$%&'A&'$).+ZA.$(55&0.51.9$.5$

;-&(.$T$3.)$+&'V.+.51)$X'($).$-2;,1.519$AU.5V&O/51$)/5)$0.)).$3/5)$3.)$0&53(1(&5)$;A')$1.--(ZA.)$.1$

;A') $+&-/A.+.51 $ (5/00.;1/ZA.) $ ;&'- $ A. $ );.01/1.'-9 $ 0&++. $ '5. $ V/W'. $ (50.))/51. $ 3.) $ ;'A)(&5)$

3.)1-'01-(0.)$3.)$Q&++.)D$4Q/X'.$L&()$X'U.AA.$).+ZA.$1-&'V.-$'5$5&'V.A$.);&(-9$'5$5&'V.A$2X'(A(Z-.9$

(A$.)1$-.5V.-)2$;&'-$AU/+.5.-$;A')$Z/)D$

B/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$A.$32)(-$.)1$3/V/51/W.$(512-(.'-D$=A')$3()0-.19$;A')$)&'-39$+/()$/'))($

;A')$2-.(51/51$;&'-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$X'($5.$;/-V(.55.51$;/)$T$).$)&-1(-$3U'5.$)(1'/1(&5$X'($A.)$&Z),3.D$

%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$L(A+$A.)$-.5V&(.$0&51(5i+.51$T$0.$+f+.$32)(-$3/5)$A.X'.A$(A)$21&'LL.51D$%U.R.+;A.$

3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$.)1$1-,)$0A/(-D$:;;/-/())/51$T$3.)$(51.-V/AA.)$-2W'A(.-)9$0.$).-/$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$;&'-$

)'Z(-$3.)$Q'+(A(/1(&5)$A/$-/+.5/51$T$)/$0&53(1(&5$-/0(/A.D$#&5$.51&'-/W.$A/$-/+,5.$T$)/$;&)(1(&5$

1-&'ZA.$3/5)$A/$L/+(AA.9$3'$0j12$3.$A/$3&+.)1(X'.$3/V/51/W.$X'.$0.A'($3.$AU2W/A.$3.$#')(.$M$.AA.$3&(1$

3&-+(-$3/5)$A/$0Q/+Z-.$3'$L&53$E?UF9$%&-/$5.$AU.+Z-/)).$;/)$A.$+/1(5$E>8UF9$%&-/$;-2).51.$#')(.$.1$

#1..V.$T$).)$/+()9$+/()$&'ZA(.$#/-/Q*o/5.$3/5)$A/$0'()(5.$E>U87F9$%&-/$A'($3.+/53.$3U/(3.-$)/$+,-.$T$

).-V(-$E>U8@F9$:55(.$A'($3.+/53.$3.$).-V(-$E>U8HFD$%/$L/+(AA.$A'($-/;;.AA.$)&5$)1/1'1$-/0(/A$M$#')(.$A'($

3&55.$)/$;&';2.$5&(-.$.1$-.L').$3.$;-f1.-$A/$ZA/50Q.$EGUF$h$#')(.9$;'()$%&-/$A'($3.+/53.51$)($.AA.$)&-1$

/V.0$A.$L(A)$3'$0Q/'LL.'-$5&(-$E>U>8$.1$>U>@F$h$:55(.$AU.50&'-/W.$T$L-2X'.51.-$A.)$L(A)$3.$3&+.)1(X'.)$T$

AU2WA(). $ E>U>HFD $ !AA. $ )'Z(1 $ 1-&() $ L&() $ A/ $ 320&'V.-1. $ Q'+(A(/51. $ 3. $ ).) $ &-(W(5.) $ 5&(-.) $ ;/- $ )&5$

.51&'-/W.$M$T$AU20&A.$E@@UF9$/V.0$)&5$;.1(1$/+($/'X'.A$.AA.$/$+.51($E>U>JF9$3/5)$A.$Z/-$3.$".K$}&-`$&[ $

.AA.$1-/V/(AA.$E>U7HFD$!AA.$).-/$;-.)X'.$320&'V.-1.$'5.$5&'V.AA.$L&()$T$A/$L(59$+/()$)/$+,-.$).$L.-/$

;/)).-$0.11.$L&()$;&'-$)/$Z&55.D$!AA.$).$L/(1$Z/11-.$3.'R$L&()$;&'-$A.$L/(1$3Uf1-.$5&(-.$M$'5$2;()&3.$.)1$

-/0&512$;/-$:55(.$E>HUF$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$/))()1.$.5)'(1.$T$)&5$/W-.))(&5$;/-$)&5$;.1(1 $/+($E>U>JFD$

!5L(59$.AA.$-.V.53(X'.$1-&()$L&()$)&5$32)(-$3Uf1-.$ZA/50Q.$M$.5$0&+;/-/51$A.$)/5W$3.$#')(.$/'$)(.5$

E@8UF9 $.5 $2V&X'/51 $ A/ $0&'A.'- $3.$;./'$3.$o2)')$EH@UF9 $.5$3()0'1/51 $/V.0$#')(.$ E>U>8FD $d5.$ 1.AA.$

L-2X'.50. $ 5U.R()1. $ ;/) $ ).'A.+.51 $ 3/5) $ A. $ L(A+ $ /L(5 $ 3. $ L/(-. $ ;/)).- $ '5. $ (5L&-+/1(&5D $ 4Q/X'.$

(5L&-+/1(&5$.)1$;/))2.$/'$+&(5)$1-&()$L&()$.1$0Q/0'5.$3.)$/;;/-(1(&5)$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$+,5.$T$A/$+f+.$

0&50A')(&5$M $)&5$-.S.1 $3.$)&5$(3.51(12 $5&(-. $.1 $ AU(50&+;-2Q.5)(&5$3.$A/$L/+(AA.$X'($AU.51&'-.D $%.$

);.01/1.'-$0&+;-.53$0.A/$3,)$AU.5L/50.$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.9$3,)$)&5$-.L')$3.$A/$;&';2.9$3&51$A.$)O+Z&A.$

5.$;&'--/(1 $f1-.$;A')$0A/(-D $%/$-2;21(1(&5$3'$+&1(L $V/$3&50$/'*3.AT$3.$A/$)(+;A.$.R;A(0/1(&5D $%/$

L&501(&5$-2;21(1(V.$3.$0.)$+&1(L)$.)1$3.$L/(-.$).51(-$/'$);.01/1.'-$A/$)'LL&0/1(&5$3/5)$A/X'.AA.$V(1$A. $

;.-)&55/W.D $%.$+/A$X'($-&5W.$#/-/Q*o/5.$-.V(.51$ 1-,)$-2W'A(,-.+.51$3/5)$A. $L(A+$h $.5$+&O.55.$

Page 66: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

1&'1.)$A.)$>8$+(5'1.)9$A.$+&53.$L/(1$0&+;-.53-.$T$#/-/Q*o/5.$X'U.AA.$3&(1$L/(-.$;/-1(.$3U'5.$;A/0.$

X'U.AA.$).$-.L').$T$&00';.-D$

%U.R;-.))(&5$3'$32)(-$.)1$2W/A.+.51$0.$X'($A'($3&55.$'5.$-20'--.50.$3/5)$A/$)1-'01'-.$3'$

L(A+D$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q9$Z&'(AA/51.$3U/+Z(1(&5$&'$#')(.$P.-.3(1Q9$320&'V-/51$A.)$;-.+(.-)$1-/5);&-1)$

/+&'-.'R$5.$0.)).-&51$3U2V&X'.-$;/-$A/$;/-&A.$3.$+/5(,-.$3(-.01.$&'$(53(-.01.9 $0.$32)(- $X'($A.)$

-&5W.D$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$2V&X'.$/V.0$;/))(&5$)/$V&A&512$3.$3.V.5(-$'5.$W-/53.$0&+23(.55.$T$3.$1-,)$

+'A1(;A.)$-.;-().)9 $0.$X'($3&55.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$A(.'$T$3.)$+&5&A&W'.)$.+;&-12)$M$A&-)$3.$)/$

;-.+(,-.$0&5V.-)/1(&5$.5$1f1.$T$ 1f1.$/V.0$#1..V.$E>JF9$A&-)$3.$)&5$;-.+(.-$-.;/)$/V.0$A'($E>?UF9$

A&-)X'U.AA.$-.L').$3.$).$V.53-.$T$%&&+()$;&'-$3.V.5(-$02A,Z-.$E7JUF9$A&-)X'U.AA.$-.51-.9$32).);2-2.$

/;-,)$0.$-.53.s*V&')$E@8UF9$A&-)X'U.AA.$).$3();'1.$/V.0$#1..V.$X'($A'($3.+/53.$3.$-.5&50.-$T$).)$

/+Z(1(&5)$EH>UF9$/V.0$A.$+.11.'-$.5$)0,5.$X'($A/$-.L').$3U/Z&-3$E^$aU+$/5$/01-.))$/53$/$W&&3$&5.$�$_ $

HHUF$.1$S')X'UT$)&5$;-.+(.-$)'00,)$EHIUFD$#/5)$0&+;1.-$A.)$+/5l'V-.)$X'U.AA.$32;A&(.$;&'-$O$;/-V.5(-$

.1$A.)$0/)1(5W)$X'U.AA.$L/(19$A/$;/-&A.$.)1$'5$+&O.5$+/S.'-$'1(A()2$;/-$A.$0(52/)1.$;&'-$L/(-.$V(V-.$.1 $

-.V.5(-$A.$32)(-$3.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$3.$+/5(,-.$&Z)23/51.D$4Q.s$#')(.9$A/$-2;21(1(&5$).-1$3/V/51/W.$

AU.LL.1$3U/55&50.$.1$A/$;-&W-.))(&5$3/5)$A.$-20(1D$%.)$320A/-/1(&5)$3.$#')(.$)'-$A.)$W/-\&5)$.1$)'-$

AU/+&'-$).$1-/5)L&-+.51$;.'$T$;.'$;&'-$32)(W5.-$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$0A/(-.+.51$#1..V.D$!AA.$)U(512-.)). $

3U/Z&-3$(55&0.++.51$/'R$W/-\&5$Eb?UF$S')1.$/V/51$3.$-.1-&'V.-$#1..V.$;&'-$A/$;-.+(,-.$L&()9$.AA. $

;/-A.$T$5&'V./'$3U.+Z-/)).-$3.)$W/-\&5)$/'$;(X'.*5(X'.$/V.0$:55(.$E>U8bF$;.53/51$X'.$)/$+,-.$.1$

#1..V.$)U.+Z-/)).51$S')1.+.51$3/5)$A/$L&-f19$.AA.$WA&')).$/'$0j12$)'AL'-.'R$3.)$Q()1&(-.)$3.$#/-/Q*

o/5.$E>U>8F9$.AA.$).$S.11.$/'$0&'$3.$#1..V.$E>U77F9$;'()$;/)).-/$A.$1.+;)$/V.0$A'(9$L/()/51$3'$0Q.V/A $

E>U7@F9$/AA/51$3/5)$'5$-.)1/'-/51$-&+/51(X'.$.1$A'($/V&'/51$X'U.AA.$.)1$/+&'-.').$)/5)$3(-.$3.$X'($

E>U7IF9$A.$A.53.+/(5$.AA.$.)1$)'-.R0(12.$T$AU(32.$3.$)&-1(-$/V.0$A'($T$5&'V./'$E>U7JF9$.AA.$)U/W/0.$3'$L/(1 $

X'.$)/$+,-.$AU(5V(1.$T$)&-1(-$E>UH@F$.1$L(5(1$;/-$/V&'.-$)&5$/+&'-$;&'-$#1..V.$T$:55(.$E>UHHFD$%/$

-20'--.50. $3' $+&1(L9 $0.11. $ L&() $.5 $2V&A'1(&5 $;-&W-.))(V.9 $ L/(1 $ ).51(- $/'$);.01/1.'- $;.'$T $;.'$ A/$

)(1'/1(&5$T$A/X'.AA.$.AA.$V/$f1-.$0&5L-&512.D$!AA.$1-/(1.$3U'5$/'1-.$/);.01$3'$32)(-$M$A.$A.51$;-&0.))')$3.$

)/$;-().$3.$0&5)0(.50.D$%.$+&1(L$0Q.s$#')(.$.)1 $0.AA.$3.$A/$320&'V.-1.$;-&W-.))(V.$3.$)/$;-&;-.$

(3.51(12 $ ).R'.AA. $ S')X'UT $ )&5 $.R;-.))(&5 $0&5)0(.51()2.D $B/5) $ A.) $3.'R $0/)9 $ ;/-&A. $ .1 $32)(- $ )&51$

(51(+.+.51$A(2)$h$AU2V&X'.-$0U.)1$;-.)X'.$32ST$).$-/;;-&0Q.-$3.$)&5$32)(-D$aA$).+ZA.-/(1$X'.$3/5)$A.'-)$

3.'R$0/)9 $ A/ $;/-&A.$.)1 $'5$;&'V&(-$;.-L&-+/1(L $ M $.5$.R;-(+/51 $ A.)$0Q&).)9$.AA.)$ L(5()).51 $;/-$).$

-2/A().-9$0&++.$3/5)$'5$/01.$+/W(X'.D$!5$-2;21/51$/)).s$3.$L&()$A/$L&-+'A.$+/W(X'.$3.$)&5$;-&;-.$

32)(-9 $&5$L(5(1 $;/- $ A. $ L/(-. $/--(V.-D $%.)$-fV.-(.) $3.$#')(.$)&51 $)'(V(.) $3'$-.1&'-$3.$#1..V.$ h $ A.)$

+&5&A&W'.)$3.$%&-/$3.$)/$-2'))(1.$/'$1Q2e1-.D$B.$+f+.9$3/5)$A.$0/)$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.9$A/$-.S.1$3.$)/$

+,-.$).-/$L&-+'A2$3.$+/5(,-.$-20'--.51.$M$T$A/$)&-1(.$3.$AU20&A.$^$zQO$3(3$O&'$Q/V.$1&$Z.$+O $

+&1Q.-9$KQO$k$_$E@@UF$E;&'-X'&($L/'1*(A$X'.$1'$)&()$+/$+,-.$k$=&'-X'&(kF9$/';-,)$3.$#')(.$^$a$3&5U1$

Page 67: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

K/51 $ /5OZ&3O $ 1& $ `5&K $ Q.- $ _ $ E>U>>F $ ES. $ V.'R $ X'. $ ;.-)&55. $ 5. $ A/ $ 0&55/()).F9 $ .5 $ A/ $ -.53/51$

-.);&5)/ZA.$3.$)&5$/W-.))(&5$;/-$)&5$.R*;.1(1$/+($^$.V.-O1Q(5W$O&'$0/5$);&(A9$O&'$);&(A$_$E>U7>F$

E1&'1$0.$X'.$1'$;.'R$We0Q.-9$1'$A.$We0Q.)F9$.AA.$A/$-.5(.$A&-)X'.$0.AA.$)($).$;-2).51.$/'$Z/-$E>U@>F9$

S')X'UT$-.L').-$3.$A'($-2;&53-.$.19$.5L(59 $A'($.5V&(.$'5.$A.11-.$A'($3.+/53/51$3.$)&-1(- $3.$)/$V(.$

E>U@HFD$=A')$1-/W(X'.+.519$A/$;/-&A.$).-/$2W/A.+.51$;.-L&-+/1(V.9$;'()X'U:55(.$L(5(-/$Z.A$.1$Z(.5$;/-$

+&'-(- $3U2;'().+.51 $.1 $3. $0Q/W-(5 $3.V/51 $ A. $ -.S.1 $3. $)/ $ L(AA.D $t$ L&-0. $3. $V&'A&(- $X'. $)/$+,-. $

3();/-/()).9 $.5$ A/ $5(/51 $3.$;A') $.5 $;A') $V(&A.++.519 $#/-/Q*o/5.$L(5(1 $;/- $ A/ $ L/(-. $ )&-1(- $3. $)&5$

.R()1.50.$3.$A/$+/5(,-.$A/$;A')$0-'.AA.$X'U(A$)&(1D$#/-/Q*o/5.$)U.5$L.-/$+f+.$-.);&5)/ZA.$A.$S&'-$3. $

)&5$.51.--.+.51$E^$a$`(AA.3$+O$+&1Q.-$�$_$E7U8>F$ESU/($1'2$+/$+,-.�FD

%/$-20'--.50.$3.$AU&Z).))(&5$0Q.s$#(-`9$0U.)1$A/$+/A23(01(&5$0&51.5'.$.5$0Q/X'.$;.-)&55/W.$

.1$X'($A.$0/-/012-().-/$S')X'UT$A/$L(5D$d5.$&Z).))(&5$(512-(.'-.$X'($5.$A/()).-/$;/)$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.5$

;/(RD$%/$)1-'01'-.$3'$!"#$3)&'(&')$'*"&$/$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3.$A/$);(-/A.$h$A.$+&1(L$).$-2;,1.9$1&'-5.$.5$

-&539$5.$0.)).$3.$-.V.5(-$1&'1$.5$L/()/51$;-&W-.)).-$;.'$T$;.'$AUQ()1&(-.D$%.$1.+;)$5.$1&'-5.$;/)$1&'1$

T$L/(1$.5$-&539$+/()$0.$X'($;-2&00';.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$-.)1.$)(+(A/(-.$3'$32Z'1$T$A/$L(5D$

$ B/5)$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&09$A.$+&1(L$0O0A(X'.$.)1$3/V/51/W.$)O+Z&A(X'.$.1$).+ZA.$f1-.$.5$

A(.5$/V.0$A/$V()(&5$3U'5$21.-5.A$-.0&++.50.+.51$3.)$0Q&).)D$%.)$)O+Z&A.)$-20'--.51)$L&501(&55.51$

0&++.$3.)$;&-1.)$X'($;.-+.11.51$3.$;/)).-$3U'5$+&+.51$T$'5$/'1-.$.1$3.$V&O/W.-$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$&'$

3/5)$AU.);/0.D $B.'R$2A2+.51)$).+ZA.51$/V&(-9 $;A')$X'.$A.)$/'1-.)9$0.$;&'V&(-$M$A/$+')(X'.$.1$A/$

5&'--(1'-.D$%.)$3.'R$+&-0./'R$X'U20&'1.$C/&$3/5)$)/$S.'5.)).$-.V(.55.51$3/5)$A.$L(A+$;A')(.'-)$

L&()D$^$N&$z.)1$_$-.V(.51$T$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+9$0&++.$5&')$AU/V&5)$32ST$0&++.512D$%.$).0&53$+&-0./'$

).$-2;,1.9$A'(9$H$L&()$M$3.)$0A(.51)$A.$S&'.51$3/5)$)/$Z&'1(X'.$;&'-$1.)1.-$'5.$0Q/n5.$r(*]($h$o(5)Q.5W$

A.'-$/0Q,1.$A.$3()X'.9$X'($/$1/51$;A'$T$C/&$.1$A.$S&'.$T$5&'V./'$h$C/&$A.$L/(1$20&'1.-$T$)&5$L(A)$;.53/51$

A.'-$V&O/W.$.5$1-/(5$h$A.$L(A)$AU.51.539$>>$/5)$/;-,)9$3/5)$)/$0A/)).$3.$0Q(5&()D$4Q/X'.$+&+.51$S&'2$

;/-$0.11.$+')(X'.$.)1$AU&00/)(&5$3U'5$-.1&'-$.5$/--(,-.9$3'$)'-W()).+.51$3'$)&'V.5(-$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$3'$

;-2).51D$aA$2V&X'.$'5$)&'V.5(-$3(LL2-.51$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)$M$)/$S.'5.)).$(5)&'0(/51.$;&'-$C/&$.1$;.'1*

f1-.$AU/+&'-$3.$o(5)Q.5W9$X'($21/(1$;-f1$T$1&'1$;&'-$A/$)23'(-.$h$A.$)&'V.5(-$3.$)/$+,-.$;&'-$B&AA/-D$%/$

+')(X'.$5&')$-.5V&(.$.5$/--(,-.9$/'$;/))2$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$-/+,5.$A.$);.01/1.'-$T$3.)$+&+.51)$

32ST$V20')D$%/$5&'--(1'-.$/'-/$A/$+f+.$L&501(&5$M$C/&$;/-1/W.$3.)$3'+;A(5W)$/V.0$%(/5Ws(9$;'()$A.)$

0'()(5.$;&'-$)&5$L(A)$.1$.5L(5$;&'-$.AA.9$1/53()$X'.9$32ST$eW2.9$.AA.$;.5).$T$B&AA/-D$4.$+&+.51$3'$

L(A+ $ ;-&V&X'. $ +f+. $ '5. $ 0&55.R(&59 $ 0.11. $ L&() $ ;-.)X'. $ )'-5/1'-.AA. $ /V.0 $ )&5 $ L(A)D $ B.;'()$

AU:')1-/A(.9$B&AA/-$+'-+'-.$)&5$5&+$.5$-.W/-3/51$AU&02/5D$%/$)2X'.50.$3U/;-,)9$A/$V&(R$3.$B&AA/-$

-2)&55.$T$5&'V./'$)'-$A.)$(+/W.)$3.$C/&$.5$1-/(5$3.$0'()(5.-D$!AA.$)U/--f1.$'5.$).0&53.9$T$A/$V&(R$3.$

Page 68: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

)&5$L(A)$.1 $)&'-(1D $%/$5&'--(1'-.$.1 $ A/ $+')(X'.9 $X'( $)U/3-.)).51$/'R$).5)9$/W()).51 $ (0( $0&++.$3.$

V2-(1/ZA.)$+/0Q(5.)$T$-.+&51.-$A.$1.+;)D

%.)$&ZS.1)$/'-&51$'5.$L&501(&5$)(+(A/(-.D$%.$L/(-.*;/-1$3.$+/-(/W.$).-V(-/$T$.LL.01'.-$'5$)/'1$

3/5)$A.$1.+;)$h$C/&$AU&LL-(-/$T$%(/5Ws($X'($A.$A/()).-/$3/5)$A/$+/()&5$X'U(A$/Z/53&55.D$c'.AX'.)$

+(5'1.)$;A')$1/-3$T$AU20Q.AA.$3'$L(A+9$A&-)X'U.AA.$-.V(.51$3/5)$A/$+/()&59$.AA.$A.$-.1-&'V.$0&'V.-1$3.$

;&'))(,-.9$;&-1/51$'5$).5)$Z(.5$3(LL2-.51$M$A.)$/552.)$&51$;/))2$.1$.AA.$/$3(V&-02$3.$o(5)Q.5WD$%/$0A2$

/'1&'-$3'$0&'$3.$B&AA/-9$X'.$A'($/$3&552$C/&$L&501(&55.$2W/A.+.51$0&++.$'5$;/)).$+/W(X'.9$.1$

)O+Z&A().$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3.$-.1&'-5.-$V&(-$)/$+,-.9$3.$-/+.5.-$A.$;/))2$T$A/$V(.D$%/$-20'--.50.$0Q.s$

o(/$wQ/5W`.$3&55.$T$).51(-$A/$1.+;&-/A(12$0&++.$'5.$.51(12$0&+;A.R.9$/'$).(5$3.$A/X'.AA.$(A$.)1$

;&))(ZA.$3.$V&O/W.-$3.$+/5(,-.$1-/5)V.-)/A.D$%/$-2L2-.50.$T$'5.$+21/;QO)(X'.$-.A(W(.').$5U.)1$;/)$

.R0A'.9 $;'()X'. $ A.) $ )/W.)).) $ 0Q(5&().) $;-j5.51 $ /V.0 $ -20'--.50. $ AU(32. $3U'5 $ 1.+;) $0O0A(X'. $ M $ A/$

-2(50/-5/1(&5$0Q.s$A.)$Z&'33Q()1.)9$AU(++&-1/A(12$.1$A.$-.1&'-$)'-$A/$1.--.$0Q.s$A.)$C/&{)1.)D

( *;&7()(('&$+#1E<)20+<;1$)+,')+C+2;@/"/<'./+<1+<"#6)

4.$X'.$+&51-.$A.$+2A&3-/+.9$0U.)1$3&50$A/$0(-0'A/-(12$3'$1.+;)9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$AU21.-5.A$

-.0&++.50.+.51D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$5.$).$0&51.51.$;/)$3.$A/$-2)&A'1(&5$E&'$5&5F$3'$32)(-9$(A$+&51-.$

AU21.-5.AA.$(50&+;A21'3.$3.$AUf1-.$Q'+/(5$.1$)&5$(50/;/0(12$T$/;;-.53-.$T$1.+;)D$d5$32)(-$X'($+.'-19$

0U.)1$'5$/'1-.$X'($5/n1$h$'5$32)(-$0Q.s$AU'59$A.$-2V,A.$0Q.s$'5$Am/'1-.D$%.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5.$L(5()).51$;/) $

3.$32)(-.-$.1$A&-)X'U(A)$;/-V(.55.51$;/-L&()$T$A/$-2)(W5/1(&59$0U.5$)&51$3U/'1-.)$X'($;-.55.51$A.$-.A/()D$

%/$L(W'-.$3.$A/$-.A/1(&5$;/-.51*.5L/51$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$0.AA.$3U'5.$;/))/1(&5$3.)$32)(-)9$3U'5.$

;.-+2/Z(A(12$3.$AU'5$T$AU/'1-.$.1$3U'5.$0&*32;.53/50.$3.)$3.)1(5)D$

B/5) $!"#$%&'(& ' )$ '*"&9 $ AU'5. $3.) $ L(AA.) $5. $;.'1 $V(V-. $)/5) $)/$+,-.9 $3&51 $.AA. $/11.53 $ A/$

-.0&55/())/50.$.1$A/$;-2).50.$E#')(.F9$1/53()$X'.$AU/'1-.$5.$;.'1$V(V-.$/V.0$)/$+,-.9$X'($A'($ZA&X'.$

AU/00,)$T$'5$)1/1'1$3.$ZA/50Q.$E#/-/Q*o/5.FD$B/5)$A.)$3.'R$0/)9$A.)$3.)1(5)$)&51$A(2)9$32;.53/51)$AU'5$

3.$AU/'1-.D$d5$32)(-$A(+(1.$AU/'1-.$h$%&-/$.1$)&5$32)(-$3.$02A2Z-(12$X'U.AA.$L/(1$;.).-$)'-$A.$3.)1(5$3.$)/$

L(AA.$.5$5.$;-.5/51$;/)$A.$1.+;)$3.$A/$V&(-D$:55(.$.1$)/$V()(&5$+&-/A.9$)&5$/+&'-$.5V/Q())/51$X'($). $

-.L').$T$ A/()).-$)/$L(AA.$).$-.5(.-D $%.$;/))/W.$T$ AUeW.$/3'A1.$3.$#')(.9 $)/$-2/A()/1(&5$.5$1/51$X'.$

;.-)&55.$/O/51$3.)$32)(-)$.1$A.)$(3.51(L(/51$0&++.$1.A)9$.51-/n5.-/$)/$L'(1.$T$AU/'1-.$Z&'1$3.)$|1/1)*

d5()9$A&(5$3.$)/$+,-.D$!AA.$;/)).-/$3&50$3U'5$0&';$3U'5$Z.)&(5$0&+;'A)(L$3.$)/$+,-.$T$)&5$-.S.1$A. $

;A')$0&+;A.1D$B&AA/-$5.$;&'--/$0&++.50.-$)/$;-&;-.$V(.$ 1/51$X'U(A $.5$(W5&-.-/$A.)$-/0(5.)$h $5.$

)/0Q/51$;A')$0.$X'U(A$V.'1$3/5)$A/$V(.9$320(3/51$3.$X'(11.-$AU'5(V.-)(129$(A$).$A/50.$3/5)$A/$X'f1.$3.$)/ $

Page 69: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+,-.9$X'($3.+.'-.$'5$+O)1,-.$;&'-$A'(D$4.11.$(50&55'.$AU&Z),3.$M$(A$5.$;&'--/$0&++.50.-$)/$V(.$

3U/3'A1.$)/5)$-.50&51-.-$)/$+,-.D$4.$S.'$3.$0Q/))2*0-&()2$).$-.1-&'V.$2W/A.+.51$A&-)$3.$A/$+&-1$3' $

;,-.$3.$C/&9$0U.)1*T*3(-.$3'$W-/53*;,-.$3.$B&AA/-$M$0.1$2V25.+.51$1-/W(X'.$.)1$0.A'($X'($;.-+.11-/$3.$

L/(-.$-.V.5(-$B&AA/-$/';-,)$3.$C/&9$)&')$A.$;-21.R1.$3.$AU.51.--.+.51D$d5.$W252-/1(&5$;/-19$AU/'1-.$

-.V(.51$h$A.)$3.)1(52.)$L/+(A(/A.)$)&51$A(2.)D$

%.)$-.A/1(&5)$.51-.$+,-.$.1$L(AA.$).$0&5)1-'().51$.51-.$A/$3(LL2-.50(/1(&5$.1$AU(+(1/1(&5D$#/-/Q*

o/5.9$3/5)/51$3/5)$A.)$Z/-)$)&-3(3.)$3.$".K$}&-`9$).+ZA.$0Q.-0Q.-$'5.$V&(.$3'$0j12$3.$0.AA.$3.$

%&-/$P.-.3(1Q9$)/$+,-.$/3&;1(V.9$+/()$3/5)$'5$-.W()1-.$+&-/A.+.51$(5L2-(.'-9$0&++.$(50/-5/51$A.$

3&'ZA. $+/A2L(X'. $3. $%&-/D $". $ 1-&'V/51 $;/) $ )/ $;A/0. $3/5) $ A/ $ L/+(AA.9 $ .AA. $3.V(.51 $ 0.11. $ L(W'-.$

+&5)1-'.').9$T$A/$L&()$;-&0Q.$.1$&;;&)2.$/'$+&3,A.$3.$%&-/9$X'($5.$AU/$;/)$/00.;12.$0&++.$.AA. $

AU/'-/(1$3iD$%.)$0Q.V.'R$-.A.V2)9$A/$-&Z.$ZA/50Q.$L-&'L-&'1/51.9$#')(.$.)1$/'$0&51-/(-.$3/5)$AU(+(1/1(&5$

3. $ )/ $+,-. $ h $ A/ $ )2X'.50. $ 3.) $ -.1-&'V/(AA.) $ /V.0 $ #1..V. $:-0Q.- $ 3&55.51 $ T $ V&(- $ 3.) $ 0&)1'+.)$

;-/1(X'.+.51$)(+(A/(-.)$0Q.s$A.)$3.'R$L.++.)D$

B/5)$A.$0/)$3.$%&'A&'9$)/$).'A.$;/-.512$;-2).51.$.)1$#0Q(W&A0QD$c'U(A$)&(1$&'$5&5$A.$;,-.$

Z(&A&W(X'.$3.$%&'A&'9$(A$L/(1$&LL(0.$3.$1'1.'-9$V.5/51$A/$0&5).(AA.-$*$Z(.5$X'.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$;&'-$

.5$1(-.-$3'$;-&L(1D$B/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$)2X'.50.9$(A)$2V&X'.51$A.$1.+;)$&[$.AA.$3/5)/(1$.1$&[$A'($L/()/(1$A/ $

+/50Q.$3/5)$A.)$Z/-)D$%.$);.01/1.'-$0&+;-.53$/A&-)$X'.$%&'A&'$0&51(5'.$A/$V&(.$&'V.-1.$;/-$)&5$

;,-.$h$.AA.$)23'(1$;&'-$3.$AU/-W.519$0&++.$&5$A'($/$/;;-()$21/51$;.1(1.D$%/$3/5).$/$).'A.+.51$212$

-.+;A/02.$;/-$A.$+/-(/W.$(512-.))2$;'()$;/-$A/$;-&)1(1'1(&59$+/()$)&5$+&3.$3.$)'-V(.$.)1$/'$L&53$A.$

+f+.D$#0Q(W&A0Q$-.)1.-/$A.$).'A$X'($/(1$'5$;&'V&(-$)'-$.AA.$h$.AA.$AU20&'1.$S')X'U/'$Z&'19$A'($)/0-(L(.$

1&'19 $0,3. $T $ ).) $ -.V.53(0/1(&5)D $#.) $32Z'1) $3. $;-&)1(1'2.) $V(.53-&51 $3. $ AU.5V(. $3. $#Q(W&A0Q $3.$

+/5W.-$3'$;'33(5W$3.$"&qA9$3&51$(A$;-.)).51$)U/W(1$3.$)&5$3.-5(.-D$%.$;.-)&55/W.$A.$;A')$&3(.'R$3'$

L(A+ $/ $3&552$5/())/50. $T $ AU(55&0.51. $%&'A&'9 $X'U(A $+,5. $3/5) $ ).) $ 1-/0.)D $P/() $ AU&5 $;.'1 $V&(-.$

2W/A.+.51$3/5)$0.$;.-)&55/W.$AU(50/-5/1(&5$;QO)(X'.$.1$.R12-(.'-.$3.$AU/);.01$+/'V/()$3.$%&'A&'D$

<(s/--.+.519$(A$).-/$A.$).'A$T$AU/00&+;/W5.-$3'$32Z'1$T$A/$L(5$h$(A$A/$;&')).-/$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$T$

;-.53-.$A/$V&(.$3.$A/$L/0(A(12$.1$3.$AU(++&-/A()+.9$0&++.$'5$+/'V/()$3(/ZA.$;.-0Q2$)'-$)&5$2;/'A.$h$

.AA.$)'(V-/$/V.'WA2+.51$0Q/0'5.$3.$).)$)'WW.)1(&5)D$aA$;&'--/(1$(50/-5.-$A/$L&A(.9$A/$;'A)(&5$3U/'1&*

3.)1-'01(&5$3.$%&'A&'9$'5.$;'A)(&5$3.$+&-1$X'($A/$L/(1$321-'(-.$0.$X'U.AA.$/9$A/$L/(1$32)(-.-$0.$X'($.)1$

/+&-/A$&'$(51.-3(1D$

%/$0&55.R(&5$.51-.$;/-.51)$.1$.5L/51)9$0U.)1$/'))($0.AA.$3U'5$32)(-$X'($.51-.$.5$0&+;21(1(&5$

/V.0$AU/--(V2.$T$AUeW.$/3'A1.D$%/$1Q2+/1(X'.$3.)$/+&'-)$32L.53')$.51-.$+,-.$.1$L(AA.$&'$;,-.$.1$L(A)$.)1 $

(50-&O/ZA.+.51$;-2).51.$3/5)$A.$+2A&3-/+.D$aA$O$/$2V(3.++.51$#')(.9$/+&'-.').$3.$#1..V.9$AU/+/51 $

Page 70: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

3.$)/$+,-.9$+/()$(A$O$/$/'))($#/-/Q*o/5.$X'($)/5)$3&'1.9$/'-/(1$;'$AUf1-.$/'))(D$%/$)0,5.$3.$-.50&51-.$

.51-.$#1..V.$.1$A/$L(AA.$3U:55(.$5.$+/5X'.$;/)$3U/+Z(W'{12$h$.AA.$3.)0.539$).5)'.AA.9$3.$AU.)0/A(.-$.1 $

A.$A/()).$)U/;;-&0Q.-9$A.$)/A'/51$3U'5$A/5W&'-.'R$^$r.AA&$#1..V.$_D$d5.$+')(X'.$S/ssO$)&'A(W5.$A/$

-.50&51-.D$#1..V.$A'($-2;&53$^$a1$0/5U1$Z.$�$}&'$K.-.$/AA$A.W)$_$E0.$5U.)1$;/)$;&))(ZA.9$1'$21/()$1&'1.$.5$

S/+Z.)�F9$0.$T$X'&($.AA.$-2;&53$^$a$)1(AA$Q/V.$1Q.+$_$ES.$A.)$/($1&'S&'-)FD$%U/AA')(&5$).5)'.AA.$3.$A/ $

0&5V.-)/1(&5$.)1$Z(.5$;A')$/+Z(W'q$X'.$A.$0&+;&-1.+.51$.5L/51(5$3.$#')(.9$X'($A'($)/'1.$3/5)$A.)$

Z-/)D $ %. $ );.01/1.'- $ ;.'1 $ )';;&).- $ (0( $ X'. $ A. $ L/51/)+. $ X'. $ -.;-2).51. $ #1..V. $ ;&'- $ #')(. $ .)1$

L(5/A.+.51$A.$+f+.$;&'-$#/-/Q*o/5.D$t$5&'V./'9$#/-/Q*o/5.$).$).-/(1$.LL/02.$)/0Q/51$X'U.AA.$5.$

;&'V/(1$;/)$W/W5.-D$4.11.$QO;&1Q,).$.)1$;/-1(.AA.+.51$0&5L(-+2.$;/-$'5$;A/5$&[$.AA.$-.W/-3.$/V.0$

.5V(.$#')(.$.1$#1..V.$+&51/51$T$0Q.V/A$.5).+ZA.D$B/5)$%&'A&'9$&5$-.1-&'V.$A.$+f+.$)0Q2+/$/V.0$

A. $B&01.'-$.1 $)&5$L(A)$:AK/9$ 1&')$3.'R$/+&'-.'R$3.$A/$+f+.$L.++.D$%.$3&01.'-$').-/$3.$)&5$

/'1&-(12$;&'-$).$32Z/--/)).-$3.$)&5$L(A)$.1$-(V/A9$AU.5V&O/51$;-.53-.$)&5$1-/(5$A&-)X'U(A$).$-.53$0&+;1.$

3.$A/$;-&R(+(12$X'.$0.A'(*0($.51-.1(.51$/V.0$)/$L.++.D$%/$+&-1$3.$AU'5$;.-+.11-/$A/$-2/A()/1(&5$3'$

32)(-$3.$AU/'1-.9$+/()$:AK/$5U/00.;1.-/$S/+/()$0&+;A,1.+.51$0.$X'U(A$V(1$0&++.$'5.$1-/Q()&5$3.$)&5$

;,-.$.1$).$1-&'V.-/$Q/512$;/-$)&5$)&'V.5(-D$

%.$1/Z&'$LA&11/51$3.--(,-.$0.)$-.;-2).51/1(&5)$0U.)1$2V(3.++.51$A.$0&+;A.R.$3Uv.3(;.D$#1..V.$

5U.)1$;/)$A&(5$3Uf1-.$A.$;,-.$3.)$3.'R$L(AA.)9$/O/51$'5.$-.A/1(&5$/V.0$A.'-$+,-.$3.;'()$A&5W1.+;)$.1$A.)$

/O/51$0&55'.)$3/5)$A.'-$.5L/50.D$B/5)$.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&09$A.$L/51/)+.$1-/5)W-.))(L$3'$L(A)$.)1$T$

;.(5.$V&(A2D$aA$).$+.1$T$/V&(-$'5.$-.A/1(&5$/V.0$)/$;-&L.)).'-.9$P(/9$T$;.(5.$;A')$S.'5.$X'.$)/$+,-.$

1/53() $X'U(A $ ). $+.1 $ T $ ). $ ;&).- $ 3.) $X'.)1(&5) $ )'- $ )&5 $;/))2D $P(/ $;&)),3. $3. $5&+Z-.'R $;&(51)$

0&++'5)$/V.0$)/$+,-.$M$3(V&-02.9$0Q(5&().$.1$.50&-.$;-&0Q.$3.$).)$-/0(5.)D$!AA.)$)&51$2W/A.+.51$

/))&0(2.)$V(/$A/$+')(X'.$X'U.AA.$;-&;&).$3U20&'1.-$.5$0A/)).$.1$X'($.)1$'5$+&-0./'$X'U/3&-/(1$C/&D$

!5L(59$'5.$)2X'.50.$.)1$;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$1-/5);/-.51.$M$B&AA/-$-&'A.$/V.0$.AA.$T$A/$0/+;/W5.D$!AA.$

0&53'(1$.1$A'($3.+/53.$3.$A'($;/)).-$).)$A'5.11.)$3.$)&A.(AD$t$0.1$(5)1/519$B&AA/-$).$+.1$T$)U/W(1.-$

L&-1.+.519$(A$A'($3(1$X'U(A$/$32ST$V20'$0.11.$)0,5.$h$^$O&'U-.$3-(V(5W$/53$aU+$O&'-$;/)).5W.-9$aUV.$)..5$

1Q()$Z.L&-.$_$E1'$.)$.5$1-/(5$3.$0&53'(-.9$.1$S.$)'()$1&5$;/))/W.-D$oU/($32ST$V'$\/$�$FD$d5$;.'$;A')$1j1$

3/5)$A.$L(A+9$A.$);.01/1.'-$/$V20'$.5$.LL.1$A/$+f+.$)0,5.9$+/()$.51-.$C/&$.1$B&AA/-$M$.AA.$.)1$/V.0$A'(9 $

;.1(19$3/5)$'5.$V&(1'-.$.1$;&-1.$3.)$A'5.11.)$3.$)&A.(AD$B&AA/-$3.+/53.$T$)/$;-&L.)).'-$)($.AA.$0-&(1$.5$

A/ $-2(50/-5/1(&59 $.AA.$ A'($-2;&53$X'.$5&59$)(+;A.+.51$^$A(L. $-.;./1 $ (1).AL $_$EA/$V(.$).$-2;,1.FD$aA$

1.-+(5.-/$A/$0&5V.-)/1(&5$.5$)U/AA'+/51$'5.$0(W/-.11.9$0.$X'($-/+,5.$T$5&'V./'$A.$);.01/1.'-$T$)/ $

+,-.$M$A/$).'A.$/'1-.$0(W/-.11.$X'U(A$O$/(1$3/5)$A.$L(A+9$0U.)1$0.AA.$3.$C/&9$X'.$B&AA/-9$;.1(19$A'($(51.-3(1$

3.$L'+.-D$%U/AA')(&5$.)1$0A/(-.9$B&AA/-$;-&S.11.$A.)$3.'R$(+/W.)$AU'5.$)'-$AU/'1-.9$0.AA.$3.$)/$+,-.$.1$

0.AA.$3.$)/$+/n1-.)).D$B.$L/(19$T$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+9$(A$-.5&50.$T$;/-1(-$.5$/V(&5$V&(-$)/$+,-.$A&-)X'U'5. $

.+;A&O2.$3.$AU/W.50.$3.$1&'-()+.$;-.53$S')1.+.51$P(/$;&'-$)/$+,-.$h$(A$).+ZA.$).$-.53-.$0&+;1.9 $

Page 71: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

)&'3/(59$3.$A/$0&5L')(&59$3.$A.'-$/;;/-1.5/50.$T$A/$+f+.$(+/W.$+.51/A.D$P(/$)'WW,-.$X'U(A$/$;.'-$

3.$A/$;-2).51.-$T$)/$+,-.D$#/5)$3&'1.$).$-.53$(A$0&+;1.$3.$AU2V(3.50.$3.$A/$)(+(A/-(12$.51-.$.AA.)D

!50&-.$;A')$;.-V.-).9$A/$-.A/1(&5$.51-.$#Q(W&A0Q$.1$%&'A&'D$%&-)X'.$A.$B&01.'-$A/$320&'V-.$

)'-$A.)$W.5&'R$3.$AUQ&++.$3/5)$A/$0Q/+Z-.$&[$(A)$)U/;;-f1.51$T$;/)).-$A.'-$5'(1$3.$5&0.)9$(A$3.V(.51 $

L&'$3.$S/A&')(.9$.1$%&'A&'$A'($/LL(-+.$/A&-)$X'U(A$)U/W(1$3.$)&5$;,-.D$P/()$(A$5U.)1$;/)$X'.)1(&5$3.$0.A/$

3/5) $ A. $;-.+(.- $ /01. $ h $.AA. $ A. $;-2).51. $3U/Z&-3 $0&++.$)&5$;-.+(.- $;/1-&5 $.1 $ A. $ L/(1 $X'. $0.11. $

.R;A(0/1(&5$V(.55.$S')1(L(.-$'5.$/01(&5$X'($5U/$;/)$;A'$/'$3&01.'-$A/$-.53$3U/'1/51$;A')$)');.01.D$B/5)$

A/$;(,0.$3.$1Q2e1-.$3.$]-/5`$z.3.`(539$(A$)U/W(1$.5$-2/A(12$3.$)&5$;-.+(.-$/+/51D$%.$L(A+$3.$=/Z)1$5.$

-2)&'1$A/$X'.)1(&5$5($3U'5$0j129$5($3.$AU/'1-.9$+/()$A/()).$;A/5.-$AU/+Z(W'{(12$3/5)$A.)$32+&5)1-/1(&5)$

3U/LL.01(&5$X'.$A'($L/(1$%&'A&'9$+(5/'3/51$)'-$).)$W.5&'R$.1$).$).--/51$0&51-.$A'(D$!51-.$'5$/+&'-$

;'-$.1 $32)(512-.))2$/'*3.AT$3.$1&'1.)$ A.)$+/5(;'A/1(&5) $3.$#Q(W&A0Q $.1 $'5.$-.A/1(&5$.51(,-.+.51$

;.-V.-).$.1$0-/;'A.').9$A.$0l'-$3'$);.01/1.'-$Z/A/50.D$%U(532L(5(1(&5$3.$A/$-.A/1(&5$.51-.$.'R$A/$-.53$

;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$(512-.))/51.D

%.$1.+;)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$.)1$3&50$'5$1.+;)$0(-0'A/(-.9$&[$).$-2;,1.51$.51-.$;/-.51)$.1$.5L/51)$

A.)$+f+.)$+&1(L)9$&[$A.)$32)(-)$1-/5);(-.51$3.)$'5)$;&'-$)U(+;&).-$/'R$/'1-.)$.1$5.$A/()).51$;.-)&55.$

.5$;/(RD$%.)$1&'-+.51)$)U(+;&).51$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)$)/5)$)U/--f1.-9$.1$/'*3.AT$3.$).$;&'-)'(V-.$3U'5.$

W252-/1(&5$T$AU/'1-.9$(A)$0&51(5'.51$2W/A.+.51$3U'5.$l'V-.$T$AU/'1-.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$;-.53$).)$-/0(5.)$

3/5)$A/$A(112-/1'-.9$A.$1Q2e1-.9$.1$3/5)$A.$0(52+/$A'(*+f+.D$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$.)1$'5$-.+/`.$3U<4$%&0'

(&')$'*"&$3.$o&Q5$PD$#1/QA9$A'($+f+.$(5);(-2$3'$-&+/5$3.$]/55(.$r'-)19$<4"2$2",1',C')"C&;';'ZA(2$.5$

>?@@D $+,-),-$ .)1 $AU/3/;1/1(&5$3.$3.'R$;(,0.)$3.$1Q2e1-.$3.$z(53.`(5D $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$ L/(1$'5.$

-2L2-.50.$3(-.01. $T $.-2$12 '&1'&4?,#2&' )& '*&12$ /V.0 $A. $ -jA. $X'.$%&-/ $P.-.3(1Q$V.'1 $T $ 1&'1 $;-(R$

-.+;&-1.-$^$).'A.+.51$A.$+.(AA.'-$3.;'()$#0/-A.11$vUQ/-/$_D$aA$O$/$3&50$2W/A.+.51$'5.$L&-+.$3.$

0&51(5'(129$3.$0&51/+(5/1(&5$3.)$+2A&3-/+.)$3.$AU'5$T$AU/'1-.$h$(A$.)1$(+;&))(ZA.$3U/AA.-$S')X'U/'$Z&'1$

3'$32)(-$.1$0.A'(*0($0&51(5'.$3UQ/51.-$A.$;.-)&55/W.$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$/'*$3.AT$3'$L(A+D$%.$L(A+$7$),10'

."%-"))&0$3U:A+&3&V/-$;.'1$).$A(-.$0&++.$A/$)'(1.$3.$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&;'-/0&51/51$A.$3.)1(5$3.$%&-/$.1$

#')(.$/;-,)$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+D$v5$;.'1$(+/W(5.-$X'.9$3.)$/552.)$;A')$1/-39$#')(.$-.50&51-.$#1..V.$.1$).$

+/-(.$/V.0$A'(9$1/53()$X'.$%&-/$;&'-)'(1$)/$0/--(,-.$/V.0$)'00,)$.1$)U2A&(W5.$;.53/51$3.)$/552.)$M$&5$

&Z1(.51$.R/01.+.51$A/$-.A/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$(50/-52)$;/-$g(01&-(/$:Z-(A$.1$P/-()/$=/-.3.)D$%.$

-/;;-&0Q.+.51 $.)1 $3U/'1/51 $+&(5)$/Z)'-3.$X'U:A+&3&V/- $.)1 $ L-(/53$3.$0(1/1(&5) $/'$32Z'1 $3.$)/$

0/--(,-.$.1$X'.$0.11.$-2L2-.50.$;.'1$1&'1$T$L/(1$f1-.$0&5)0(.51.D$%.$1(1-.$3.$+,-),-'3.$=(/A/1$E>?G8F$

;.'1$2W/A.+.51$L/(-.$-2L2-.50.$T$A/$;(,0.$&'$/'$L(A+$h$%&'A&'$.)1$0.11.$L&()$'5$;.-)&55/W.$+/)0'A(59$

(50/-52$;/-$N2-/-3$B.;/-3(.'$/V.0$A.$+f+.$;&'V&(-$3.$)23'01(&5$X'.$%&'().$<-&&`)$3/5)$A.$L(A+$

3.$=/Z)1$.1$A/$+f+.$(51.51(&5$3.$).$A/()).-$.51-.1.5(-D$

Page 72: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ %.$32)(-$)1-'01'-.$A.$1.+;)$3'$+2A&3-/+.$/'*3.AT$3.$A/$V(.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$.1$/'*3.AT$3.$A/$

V(.$3.)$L(A+)D$%/$L&-0.$3'$1-&'ZA.$L/(1$-.V.5(-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.)$Q()1&(-.)$/'1&'-$3.)$+f+.)$

;-2&00';/1(&5)9$3.)$+f+.)$&Z).))(&5)9$3.)$1Q2+/1(X'.)$L(5/A.+.51$'5(V.-).AA.)D$

Page 73: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

?K*.%,&'(6

(P%J%+%$1('1(+"A9'1/'(',(&'0*,%$1(*9(,'#.+(

-,&9/,9&'(',(%)"$0$@%'

4.)$-.+/-X'.)$)'-$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$W252-/A.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$-2V,A.51$0.$X'U&51$.5$0&++'5$0.)$

1-&()$ L(A+)$3/5)$A.'-$-/;;&-1 $/'$1.+;)D$P/AW-2$A.'-$2A&(W5.+.51$W2&W-/;Q(X'.$.1$Q()1&-(X'.9 $ (A)$

W/-3.51$'5$-.W/-3$/)).s$)(+(A/(-.$)'-$A/$0&53(1(&5$Q'+/(5.D$%.$1.+;)$;/)).$0.;.53/51$3.$+/5(,-.$

3(LL2-.51.$3/5)$A.)$1-&()$l'V-.)D$aA$)U/W(-/$3U21'3(.-$0&++.51$)U/W.50.51$A.)$)2X'.50.)$.51-.$.AA.)9 $

0&++.51 $ A/ $ 1-/5)(1(&5$3.$ AU'5. $T $ AU/'1-. $ (53'(1 $'5.$ A&W(X'.$3(LL2-.51.$3/5) $ A/ $ -.;-2).51/1(&5 $3'$

;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)D$+,-),-$).+ZA.$0-2.-$.5$;.-+/5.50.$A/$)'-;-().$.1$A.$0Q&0$3/5)$A.$;/))/W.$3U'5$

/01.$T$AU/'1-.$1/53()$X'.$A. $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$3&55.$'5.$(+;-.))(&5$WA&Z/A.$3U'5.$.R1-f+.$LA'(3(12D$

%U'5$;-2).51.$'5.$L&-+.$3()0&51(5'.9$3.$)/'1)$3/5)$A.$ 1.+;)9$ AT$&[$AU/'1-.$).+ZA.$3())(+'A.-$ A/$

+&(53-.$.AA(;).$.1$0&5).-V.-$'5$-/;;&-1$3.$L/')).$0&51(5'(12D $.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0$ X'/51$T$A'($

;.5).$A.$1.+;)$3.$+/5(,-.$/))&0(2.$T$AUr()1&(-.9$)U&Z)23/51$;&'-$A/$1-/0.$.1$A.$)&'V.5(-D$

( *&12&1>+1$)+(/31)$-)+</."1'.+2;#1.")

%/$)1-'01'-.$3.$%&'A&'$3&55.$AU(+;-.))(&5$3U'5$23(L(0.$.5$0&51(5'.$3.)1-'01(&5D$%.$1.+;)$

S&'2$).+ZA.$T$A/$L&()$).$-2;21.-$.1$0&51-.3(-.$A.$+&+.51$(++23(/1.+.51$;/))2D

BU/Z&-3$/'$).(5$3.$AU.);/0.$M$%&'A&'$.)1$3(V()2$.5$G$/01.)9$X'($0&--.);&53.51$T$3.)$'5(12)$3.$

A(.'$.1$3.$1.+;)D$B/5)$AU&-3-.$3.$0.)$G$/01.)9$AU/01(&5$).$32-&'A.$3/5)$AU/;;/-1.+.51$3.$%&'A&'$h$3/5) $

A.$Z'-./'$3'$B&01.'-$h$3/5)$A.$1Q2e1-.$X'($A'($/;;/-1(.51$h$3/5)$A.$)/A&5$.1$A/$0Q/+Z-.$3'$3&01.'-$A&-)$

3'$+/-(/W. $ h $3/5) $ A. $ 1-(Z'5/A $ h $3/5) $ A/ $+/()&5$3'$3&01.'- $;'() $3/5) $ A. $ 1-/(5 $ h $3/5) $ A. $0/)(5&$

0A/53.)1(5$h$3/5)$'5$/;;/-1.+.51$A'W'Z-.$.1$3/5)$A.)$-'.)$3.$%&53-.)D$B/5)$A.$0/)$3.)$/01.)$I$.1$G9$A/$

0&51(5'(12$.)1$/))'-2.$;/-$AU/01(&5$M$0U.)1$A/$L'(1.$3.$%&'A&'$.1$3U:AK/$X'($A.)$L/(1$;/)).-$3U'5$A(.'$T$

AU/'1-. $.1 $0U.)1 $ A/ $;-&)1(1'1(&5 $3.$%&'A&'$X'( $5&')$/+,5.$T$;/)).- $3.$ AU(512-(.'- $T $ AU.R12-(.'- $3.$

AU/;;/-1.+.51D$aA$)U/W(1$3U/Z&-3$3.$ZA&0)$5/--/1(L)$X'($;&'--/(.51$L&501(&55.-$(532;.53/++.51$A.)$'5)$

3.)$/'1-.)D$4Q/X'.$)2X'.50.$.)1 $0&5)1(1'2.$3U'5$32Z'19$3U'5.$;-&W-.))(&5$.1$3U'5.$L(5D$aA$;&'--/(1$

Page 74: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;-.)X'. $ )U/W(- $ 3U'5. $ )'(1. $ 3. $ 0&'-1)*+21-/W.)D $ %.) $ ;-2&00';/1(&5) $ 3.) $ )2X'.50.) $ ;-2023.51.)$

3();/-/()).51$;-.)X'.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$3.$0.AA.$.5$0&'-)$h$A/$5(/51$;-.)X'.$3/5)$AU2V&A'1(&5$3'$L(A+D

=&'- $ 0&++.50.-9 $ 0Q/0'5 $ 3.) $ A(.'R $ &[ $ ;/)).51 $ A.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ 3.V(.55.51 $ 3.) $ A(.'R$

0&53/+52)9$&[$(A$5.$).-/$;A')$;&))(ZA.$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$-.V.5(-$;/-$A/$)'(1.D$%U/;;/-1.+.51$3.$

%&'A&'$.)1$/Z/53&552$)'(1.$T$)&5$+/-(/W.$/V.0$A.$3&01.'-$h$A.$1Q2e1-.$5.$A'($).-/$;A')$/00.))(ZA. $

/;-,)$)Uf1-. $2A.V2.$3/5)$A/ $Z&55.$)&0(212 $ h $ A/ $ L'(1.$3.$%&'A&'$3/5)$ A/$0A/53.)1(5(12$ AU.+;f0Q.-/$

.5)'(1.$32L(5(1(V.+.51$3.$-.V.5(-$T$1&')$A.)$A(.'R$X'U.AA.$L-2X'.51/(1$/V/51$AU/01.$b$h$A.$0/)(5&$L.-+. $

/;-,) $ AU/--(V2.$3.$ A/ $;&A(0.$3/5) $ AU/01. $J$ h $ A. $+.'-1-. $3. $%&'A&'$5&')$;.-+.1 $3. $)';;&).- $X'.$

#0Q(W&A0Q$5UO$-.V(.53-/$X'.$;&'-$0&5)1/1.-$ A. $320,)$.1 $)U.5L'(-$.5$0&'-/51D$4Q/X'.$A(.'$3.V(.51$

+/'3(1$/;-,)$A.$;/))/W.$3.$%&'A&'D$%.$).'A$+&+.51$&[$.AA.$-.V(.51$)'-$A.)$A(.'R$3U'5.$)2X'.50.$

;/))2.$).-/$V20'.$0&++.$'5$/01.$0&51-.*5/1'-.$;/-$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3U:AK/$M$L'O/51$)&5$;-&0,)9$.AA. $

).$-2L'W(.$0Q.s$.AA.9$3/5)$A.$A(.'$+f+.$&[$.AA.$/$1'2$)&5$.R*+/-(D$#($0.A/$5.$;.-1'-Z.$.5$-(.5$%&'A&'9$

X'($V(.51$;-.53-.$'5$Z/(5$.1$).$32A/)).-9$.AA.$2;&'V/51.$3.$0.$L/(1$:AK/9$X'($5.$0&+;-.53$;/)$A/$

1-/5X'(AA(12$3.$%&'A&'D$#&5$-.W/-3$1&+Z.$)'-$'5$Z/)*-.A(.L9$;-2).51$3/5)$A/$)2X'.50.$3'$+.'-1-.$3.$

)&5$;,-.$.1$(A$).+ZA.$-.V(V-.$0.$+&+.51$1.--(ZA.D$%.$A(.'$.)1$A(112-/A.+.51$Q/512$;/-$0.11.$L(W'-.$X'( $

0&51(5'. $ 3UO $ ;A/5.-D $ %.) $ A(.'R $ &[ $ %&'A&' $ ;/)). $ ).+ZA.51 $ f1-. $ (++23(/1.+.51 $ +/'3(1)9 $ AU/(-$

.+;&()&5529$A/$s&5.$320A/-2.$)(5()1-2.D$d5$A(.'$V(.51$3&50$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$-.+;A/0.-$A.$)'(V/51D$

B.$+f+.9$%&'A&'$5.$).+ZA.$;/)$+/-X'2.$;/-$A.)$2V,5.+.51)$X'($A'($/--(V.51D$!AA.$0Q/5W.$

3.$V(.$.1$3U/+&'-.'R$)/5)$S/+/()$).+ZA.-$+/-X'2.$;/-$A.'-)$)&'V.5(-)D$%/$+&-1$3'$3&01.'-$A/$A/()).$

L-&(3.9 $0&++.$A/$L&A(.$X'($)U.+;/-.$3U:AK/$h $ A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$%&'A&'$5.$).+ZA.$;/)$/V&(-$3.$

+2+&(-.$.1$-.V(.519$1&'S&'-)$L-/n0Q.$/'$32Z'1$3.$0Q/X'.$/01.D$%.)$/'1-.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&'LL-.519$.'R9$

3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)9$0&++.$:AK/$V(V/51$3/5)$A.$)&'V.5(-$3.$)&5$;,-.9$A/$0&+1.)).$;&'-)'(V/51$

%&'A&'$/'$Z&'1$3'$+&53.$.1$Y&3-(W&$&Z)232$;/-$AU(32.$3.$+&51.-$)&5$);.01/0A.9$-2(12-/51$0Q/X'.$

L&()$)/$1.51/1(V.D$%&'A&'9$).'A.9$).+ZA.$(++'5()2.$0&51-.$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)9$A/$V(.(AA.)).$.1$A. $

-.W-.1$h$.AA.$.)1$'5$;.-)&55/W.$+/W(X'.$.5$0.$X'U.AA.$5.$V(1$;/)$A.$1.+;)$0&++.$A.)$/'1-.)D$aA$5.$

)U/W(1$;/)$).'A.+.51$3.)$A(.'R$X'($)U/55'A.51$A.)$'5)$A.)$/'1-.)9$+/()$2W/A.+.51$3.)$+&+.51)$V20')$

;/-$%&'A&'$M$0Q/X'.$+&+.51$;-.53$A/$;A/0.$3.$0.A'($X'U(A$)'(1D$%.$;/))2$).+ZA.$(++23(/1.+.51$

W&++2$3/5)$AU.);-(1$3.$%&'A&'$;&'-$A/()).-$;A/0.$/'$;-2).51D

d5$/'1-.$L/01.'-$3&55.$AU(+;-.))(&5$3.$0.11.$3.)1-'01(&5$0&51(5'.$M$AU/--(V2.$3.$%&'A&'$3/5)$

0Q/0'5 $3.) $ A(.'R $.)1 $ )1-(01.+.51 $^$.AA(;)2.$_D $v5$320&'V-. $ 1&'S&'-) $%&'A&'$32ST $ (5)1/AA2.D $!AA.$

/;;/-/n1$.5$L.++.$.51-.1.5'.$3'$3&01.'-$h$;'()$.5$0&)1'+.$3.$3/5).').$.5$1-/(5$3.$;/-1(0(;.-$T$A/$

-.V'.$3'$L(A)$h$%&'A&'$3'-/51$A/$Lf1.$3'$+/-(/W.9$32ST$+/-(2.$/'$3&01.'-$h$%&'A&'$.5$1-/(5$3.$V(V-. $

Page 75: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

)&5$;-&0,)$h$%&'A&'$-'(52.$3/5)$A.$0/)(5&$0A/53.)1(5u$o/+/()$A.$;-&0.))')$X'($A/$L/(1$/--(V.-$T$'5$

5&'V./'$A(.'9$T$'5.$5&'V.AA.$21/;.$3.$)/$V(.$5U.)1$32V.A&;;2$T$AU(+/W.D$4.-1.)9$(A$.)1$/55&502$;/-$A/$

)2X'.50.$3U/V/51$M$A.$3&01.'-$320A/-.$X'U(A$.)1$0&51-/(51$3U2;&').-$%&'A&'$/;-,)$A.$)0/53/A.$X'($/$A(.'$

/'$1Q2e1-.$h$A.$-.W/-3$1-&'ZA.$3'$+/-X'()$X'($(5V(1.$%&'A&'$.1$:AK/$T$).$0/0Q.-$3/5)$'5$.53-&(1$)i- $

3&55.$T$(+/W(5.-$/'$);.01/1.'-$X'U(A$5.$).-/$;/)$)($;/-/3()(/X'.$h$A/$L'(1.$.5$Z/1./'$.)1$/55&502.$.5 $

3(-.01(&5$3.$%&53-.)DDD $%.)$)2X'.50.)$5.$)&-1.51$;/)$3.$5'AA.$;/-19$.AA.)$)&51$/55&502.)$;/-$A.)$

;2-(;21(.)D$P/()$AU.AA(;).$5&')$/+,5.$T$'5$+&+.51$&[$AU/01(&5$/$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$32ST$0&++.502D$

%.$);.01/1.'-$0&5)1/1.$AU(512W-/1(&5$3.$%&'A&'$3/5)$'5$5&'V.A$'5(V.-)$.1$323'(1$A.$;-&0.))')$X'($AU/$

/+.52.$ATD$%.$L(A+$1-/V/(AA.$3.$0.$L/(1$3.$+/5(,-.$0-(1(X'.$A.$L/51/)+.$1-,)$/+2-(0/(5$3.$AU/)0.5)(&5D$

C&'1$.5$A.)$(50A'/51$3/5)$A/$5/--/1(&5$E%&'A&'$;/-V(.51$Z(.5$T$X'(11.-$)&5$)1/1'1$3.$3/5).').$3/5)$A.)$

Z/-) $;&'- $0.A'( $3.$L.++.$.51-.1.5'.F9 $ (A $ -.L').$3.$ A.)$+.11-. $.5$)0,5.9 $;-2L2-/51 $/'$;-&0.))')$

3U/)0.5)(&5$0.A'($3.$A/$0Q'1.$Z-'1/A.D$

%.$1-/V/(A$5U(512-.)).$;/)$=/Z)1D$v5$5.$V&(1$;/)$%&'A&'$).$;-2;/-.-$T$A/$-.V'.$3.$3/5).$h$A/$

)2X'.50. $ 0&++.50. $;/- $ '5. $ -.;-2).51/1(&5 $32ST $ .5 $ 0&'-)D $%U(53(V(3' $5. $ )U2A,V. $;/) $ /'R $;-(R$

3U.LL&-1) $.1 $3.$)/0-(L(0.)9$ (A $5.$-.+;&-1.$;/)$3.$V(01&(-.)$)'-$)&5$.5V(-&55.+.51$ h $0U.)1 $ 1&'S&'-)$

AU(5V.-).D$%&'A&'$1-/V.-).$3.)$+&53.)$X'($1.51.51$3.$).$AU/;;-&;-(.-$.1$.AA.$)U.5$20Q/;;.$/V/51$X'U(A) $

5.$).$+.11.51$T$A/$Z-&O.-9$S')X'U/'$3.-5(.-$+&+.51$3'$L(A+$&[$.AA.$L(5(1$;/-$f1-.$-/11-/;2.$;/-$A/ $

V(&A.50.$.1$/))/))(52.D$#.$5&'--())/51$3.$A/$1-/W23(.9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$;-2L,-.$A.)$/LL-.)$3'$3.)1(5$X'($

1&+Z.51$)'-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)/5)$;-2V.5(-$.1$321-'().51$1&'1$0.$X'($/$212$0&5)1-'(1D$4.$X'.$+,-),-'

+.1$.5$)0,5.9 $0U.)1 $3&50$A. $+&+.51 $3.$Z/)0'A.$3.$0.1$'5(V.-)9 $ A. $;&(51 $&[$A/ $)(1'/1(&5$3.V(.51$

(5)';;&-1/ZA.$S')X'UT$f1-.$321-'(1.D$%U'5(V.-)$L(5(1$1&'S&'-)$;/-$-.S.1.- $+,-),-$ &'$A/$0&51-/(53-.$T$

)U.5L'(-D$%U/01.$H$32;.(51$'5$+/-(/W.$.51-.$%&'A&'$.1$A.$3&01.'-$+/()$A.$);.01/1.'-$5U.5$V.--/$5($A/$

;-2;/-/1(&59 $5( $ A. $32-&'A.+.51 $ M $ (A $ ).-/ $ (++23(/1.+.51 $ 0&5L-&512 $ T $ A/ $ L(5 $3. $ A/ $02-2+&5(.9 $ /'$

+&+.51$&[$%&'A&'$O$1'.-/$;/-$/00(3.51$A.$3&01.'-9$-&+;/51$A/$)(1'/1(&5$.1$A/$L&-\/51$T$-.0&++.50.-$

3/5)$'5$/'1-.$'5(V.-)D$%U/01.$b$0&++.50.$;/-$A/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3'$;-&0,)D$aA$5U/))()1.-/$X'UT$A/$L'(1. $

3.$%&'A&'9$X'($L/(1$Z/)0'A.-$A.$;-&0.))')$S'3(0(/(-.$.1$A/$)(1'/1(&5$V20'.$;/-$A.$;.-)&55/W.D$B/5)$

AU/01. $ J9 $ A/ $ ;&A(0. $ .51-. $ 3/5) $ A. $ 0/)(5& $ 0A/53.)1(5 $ .1 $ A.) $ L&-0. $ 1&') $ T $ L'(-D $%U.AA(;). $ /V/A. $ A.) $

;-&W-.))(&5)9$A.)$/)0.5)(&5)9$;&'-$5.$W/-3.-$X'.$A.$+&+.51$3.$A/$0Q'1.9$A.$+&+.51$3.$0-().9$X'($

0Q/5W.-/ $ A/ $V(. $3.) $;.-)&55/W.)D $ aA $ )U/W(1 $ 3&50 $3. $ -.;-2).51.- $3. $+/5(,-. $X'/)(*0&51(5'.9 $3.)$

+&53.)$X'($Z/)0'A.519$).$32)/W-,W.51D$%/$;'A)(&5$3.$+&-1$X'($/5(+.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$).+ZA.$3&50$

/5(+.-$2W/A.+.51$ A/ $)1-'01'-.$3'$L(A+D$B/5) $+,-),-9 $ A. $+&53.$.)1 $'5$21.-5.A$0Q/&)$&[$0Q/X'.$

)2X'.50.$).+ZA.$20-/).-$AU/'1-.9$AU/55'A.-9$A/$321-'(-.D$%.$L(A+$5U/V/50.$;/)$;/-$;-&W-.))(&59$+/()$;/-$

3.)1-'01(&5$3.)$)2X'.50.)9$A.)$'5.)$/;-,)$A.)$/'1-.)D$

Page 76: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

4.11.$/5/AO).$.R;A(X'.$A/$).5)/1(&5$3'$);.01/1.'-$3U'5$+&53.$.5$3.)1-'01(&5$;.-;21'.AA.9$

3U'5.$3.)0.51.$/'R$.5L.-)$1&'S&'-)$;A')$A&5W'.$.1$;A')$)&-3(3.D$!5$-2/A(129$).'A)$A.)$3.'R$3.-5(.-)$

/01.)$+&51-.51$%&'A&'$3/5)$'5$0&51.R1.$3.$V(&A.50.$&'V.-1.9$&[$AU/-W.519$A.$).R.$.1$A/$V(&A.50.$)&51$

&'V.-1.+.51$A.)$).'A.)$-,WA.)$X'($/5(+.51$AU.);/0.D$P/()$1&'1.)$A.)$/'1-.)$)2X'.50.)$0&51(.55.51$

0.11.$0/-/012-()1(X'.$3.$)U/'1&321-'(-.$.5$).$1.-+(5/519$)(W5/51$A/$L(5$3U'5$21/1$-.A/1(V.+.51$)1/ZA.$&[$

).$1-&'V/(1$%&'A&'D$Y(.5$5U.)1$/Z&'1($M$A/$-.A/1(&5$.51-.$A.$3&01.'-$.1$%&'A&'$.)1$(51.--&+;'.$;/-$3.)$

L(/5\/(AA.)9$X'($).-&51$.AA.)$+f+.)$(51.--&+;'.)$;/-$A.$-.1&'-$3'$3&01.'-$V.-)$%&'A&'$h$A.$);.01/0A.$

3.$3/5).$X'($).-1$3.$0&51.R1.$T$0.11.$)2X'.50.$5.$).-/$;/)$5&5$;A')$L(5($h$A.$+/-(/W.$1.-+(5.$/V/51$A/ $

5'(1 $3.$5&0.$;/-$ A/ $+&-1$3'$3&01.'-$ h$ A.$;-&0,)$)U/0Q,V.$/V.0$'5.$L/')).$/A/-+.$.1$ A/ $L'(1. $3.$

%&'A&'$h$A.$0/)(5&$.)1$V(32$;/-$AU/--(V2.$3.$A/$;&A(0.$h$.19$.5L(59$A/$+&-1$3.$%&'A&'$+.1$'5$;&(51$L(5/A$

/'$L(A+D$$

( F'"#D)+<)+2#+,')>+2#+(."1-.1")+)$+#'6#$.

aA$.)1$1-,)$0'-(.'R$3.$V&(-$0&++.51$/;-,)$/V&(-$V'$T$;.(5.$'5.$&'$3.'R$L&()$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$

A. $ );.01/1.'- $ ). $ -.1-&'V. $ 0/;/ZA. $ 3. $ ). $ -.+2+&-.- $ )0,5. $ ;/- $ )0,5. $ A/ $ )1-'01'-. $ 3' $ L(A+D $%.)$

)2X'.50.)$).+ZA.51$320&'A.-$A.)$'5.)$3.)$/'1-.)9$0&++.$5/1'-.AA.+.51$M$1&'1$0&++.50.$T$A/$;A/W.9$

&[$.AA.)$).$-.50&51-.51$h$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$&LL-.$T$:55(.$3.$3&-+(-$0Q.s$.AA.$h$X'/53$%&-/$).$V&(1 $

;-&;&).-$'5$1-/V/(A9$.AA.$3.+/53.$T$:55(.$3.$)U&00';.-$3.)$;.1(1.)DDD$4Q/X'.$)2X'.50.$/;;.AA.$0.AA.$

X'($ A/$)'(1D $%/$)1-'01'-.$.)1 $0&+;A(X'2.$0/-$;A'-(.AA.9 $-.+;A(.$3.$;.-)&55/W.)$/'R$32)(-) $.1 $/'R$

3.)1(5)$3(LL2-.51)$h$(A)$/V/50.51$.5$;/-/AA,A.$.1$(A$).-/(1$/()2$3.$0-&(-.$X'.$A.$;/))/W.$3.$AU'5$T$AU/'1-.$

)1-'01'-.$A.)$0Q/5W.+.51)$.1$A.)$2V&A'1(&5)$3'$-20(1D$P/()$A/$L&-0.$3.$A/$)1-'01'-.$3.$!"#$%&'(&')$ '

*"&$.)1$/'$0&51-/(-.$A/$L&-0.$3.$A/$0&55.R(&5$3.$0Q/X'.$)2X'.50.$/V.0$0.AA.$X'($A/$;-20,3.$.1$0.AA. $

X'($A/$)'(1D$%.)$)2X'.50.)$)&51$0&++.$/(+/512.)$A.)$'5.)$/'R$/'1-.)$;/-$3.)$.LL.1)$3U/55&50.$.1$3.)$

323'01(&5)$A&W(X'.)D$%m.50Q/n5.+.51$3.)$2V25.+.51)$).+ZA.$)'(V-.$'5$A(.5$3.$0/').$T$.LL.1$S/+/()$

-&+;'$M$1&'1$320&'A.$3'$;-2023.51$.1$/+,5.$A&W(X'.+.51$/'$)'(V/51D$%U.R.+;A.$A.$;A')$2V(3.51$.)1$

0.A'($3.)$0/)1(5W)$X'.$;/)).$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$3'$L(A+$M$3/5)$'5.$)2X'.50.9$.AA.$

.)1 $ (5V(12.$T$;/)).-$'5$0/)1(5W$.1$).$3();'1.$V(&A.++.51$/V.0$#1..V.$T$0.$)'S.1$ h $&5$A/ $V&(1 $ A/$

)2X'.50.$3U/;-,)$21'3(.-$)&5$1.R1.$1/53()$X'U:55(.$-/0&51.$3.)$0&51.)$3.$"&qA$/'R$3.'R$;.1(1.)$h$.AA.$

.)1$)'-$)0,5.$.5$1-/(5$3.$;/)).-$A.$0/)1(5W$.1$/11(-.$AU/11.51(&5$3'$+.11.'-$.5$)0,5.$X'($0Aj1$A.)$.))/()h$

.AA.$)/A'.$T$A/$L(5$3.$A/$;(,0.$.1$0U.)1$'5$1-(&+;Q.D$%/$;A'-/A(12$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;.-+.1$3.$-.53-. $

AU.5).+ZA.$;A')$-(0Q.$.1$;A')$0&+;A.R.9$+/()$A.$A(.5$)'(V($.)1$(+;A/0/ZA.$M$0.A'($3'$1-/S.1$3.$%&-/$3.$

AU.))/($/'$1-(&+;Q.$3.$A/$;(,0.D$%/$A&W(X'.$.)1$0.AA.9$L/01'.AA.9$3.)$2V,5.+.51)D$=/)$'5$+&+.51$5.$

V(.51$321&'-5.-$AU2V&A'1(&5$3.$)/$A&W(X'.$;-&;-.D$4.-1/(5)$2A2+.51)$V(.55.51$5&'--(-$3U/'1-.)$A(W5.)$

Page 77: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

5/--/1(V.)$M$AU/55&50.$3.$)&5$0/)1(5W$).$32-&'A.$3'-/51$'5.$)2X'.50.$&[$.AA.$-&+;1$/V.0$#1..V.9$.1 $

).)$-2;21(1(&5)$T$A/$+/()&5$;.53/51$'5.$0&5V.-)/1(&5$3U:55(.$.1$3.)$;.1(1.)$)'-$A/$0&'A.'-$3.$;./'$3.$

o2)')DDD$P/()$Am.50Q/n5.+.51$3.)$)2X'.50.)$)'(1$A.$A(.5$(+;A/0/ZA.$3.$A/$A&W(X'.D

P/()$(A$;.'1$/'))($)U/W(-$3U'5.$A&W(X'.$2+&1(&55.AA.9$;)O0Q&A&W(X'.D$d5$/'1-.$.50Q/n5.+.51$

3.$)2X'.50.)$)U(512-.)).$0.11.$L&()$T$#/-/Q*o/5.$M$A&-)$3U'5.$-20.;1(&5$0Q.s$A.)$P.-.3(1Q9$%&-/$&'ZA(.$

3U.++.5.-$/'$)/A&5$#/-/Q*o/5.9$5.$;-2).51/51$/'$+&53.$X'.$#')(.$.1$#1..V.D$d5$;A/5$)'-$#/-/Q*

o/5.$5&')$(53(X'.$X'U.AA.$.5$.)1$/LL.012.D$%/$)2X'.50.$)'(V/51.9$.AA.$;-21.53$f1-.$+/A/3.$;&'-$5.$;/)$

/AA.-$/'$;(X'.*5(X'.$;-2;/-2$;/-$A/$L/+(AA.$.1$)U.5L'(1$3.$A/$+/()&5$-.1-&'V.-$)&5$/+&'-.'R$h$#')(.$

AU(51.--&W. $ .1 $ V.R. $ #/-/Q*o/5. $ .5 $ A'( $ 3.+/53/51 $ )U(A $ .)1 $ 5&(-9 $ #/-/Q*o/5. $ /LL(-+. $ /A&-) $ )&5$

(532;.53/50. $T $ AU2W/-3 $3. $%&-/ $X'( $5U.)1 $5( $ )/ $+,-.9 $5( $ )/ $+/n1-.)). $ h $%&-/ $3.+/53.$3/5) $ A/ $

)2X'.50.$)'(V/51.$T$#/-/Q*o/5.$3U/(3.-$)/$+,-.$;'()$-2(1,-.$A/$W/LL.$3.$#')(.$.5$A'($3.+/53/51$)($)&5 $

;.1(1*/+($.)1$A.$L(A)$3'$0Q/'LL.'-$5&(-$h$#/-/*o/5.$;/-A.$/V.0$)/$+,-.$X'($A'($0&5).(AA.$3U/AA.-$;/)).-$

3'$1.+;)$/V.0$A.)$/'1-.)$.5L/51)$3.)$3&+.)1(X'.)$.1$A'($3.+/53.$T$5&'V./'$3U/AA.-$).-V(-$A.)$(5V(12)$

3.$%&-/$h$#/-/Q*o/5.$.51-.$3/5)$A/$)&(-2.$3.$%&-/$.1$L/(1$'5$.)0A/53-.$.5$).$0&+;&-1/51$.1$.5$;/-A/51 $

0&++.$'5.$.)0A/V.$5&(-.D$#/5)$f1-.$A(2.)$;/-$'5$A(.5$3.$0/')/A(12$/'))($0A/(-$X'.$A.$;-.+(.-$.R.+;A.9$

0Q/X'.$)2X'.50.$;-2;/-.$A/$)'(V/51.$M$A/$;-.+(,-.$.R0A')(&5$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$3/5)$A/$)&(-2.$3.$%&-/$A/$

L/(1$0Q&()(-$3.$)U.R0A'-.$.AA.*+f+.$.1$3.$5.$;/)$;/-1(0(;.-$T$0.11.$QO;&0-()(.$L/+(A(/A.$3&51$.AA.$5.$

L/(1$X'UT$+&(1(2$;/-1(.D$#&5$/Z).50.$/11(-.$AU/11.51(&5$3.$#')(.$X'($AU(51.--&W.$.1$3.$5&'V./'9$A/$;A/0.$

3/5)$'5.$;&)(1(&5$(5L2-(.'-.$)/5)$)U.5$-.53-.$0&+;1.D$#/-/Q*o/5.$/LL(-+.$X'U.AA.$5.$).-/$;/)$'5.$

3&+.)1(X'.$h$.1$A.)$3.'R$)2X'.50.)$)'(V/51.)9$).$-.1-&'V.$;A/02.$3/5)$0.11.$;&)(1(&5$;/-$%&-/$.1 $

:55(.9$0.$X'($A/$+,5.$T$AU.R;A&)(&5D$#(-`$5U.R;A(0(1.$;/)$1&'S&'-)$0.)$A(.5)$A&W(X'.)$M$3.$+/5(,-.$

/)).s$L(5.9$A.$)(+;A.$.LL.1$3.$S'R1/;&)(1(&5$3.$0.-1/(5.)$)2X'.50.)$.5$0Q/5W.$A.$).5)D$d5.$)2X'.50.$

)'-$#')(.$L/()/51$3'$0Q.V/A$/V.0$#1..V.$h$'5.$/'1-.$)'-$#/-/Q*o/5.$AU&Z).-V/519$;'()$).$+.11/51$T$

3/5).-$)'-$'5.$+')(X'.$S/ss$/V/51$3.$)Q&&1.-$3/5)$)/$;.A'0Q.D$%/$).5)/1(&5$X'($-.)1.9$.)1$0.AA.$3.$A/$

S/A&')(.D$d5.$)2X'.50.9$#')(.$.1$#1..V.$V&51$3/5)$'5$-.)1/'-/51$-&+/51(X'.$h$0.AA.$3U/;-,)9$#')(.$.)1$

)'-.R0(12. $ 3/5) $ )/ $ 0Q/+Z-. $ .1 $ /LL(-+. $ X'U.AA. $ 5U/ $ S/+/() $ 212 $ /'))( $ Q.'-.'). $ 3. $ )/ $ V(.D $

a++23(/1.+.51$A.$);.01/1.'-$/))&0(.$)&5$Z&5Q.'-$T$#1..V.9$/A&-)$X'.$A.)$+&+.51)$5.$).$)'(V.51$;/)D $

%.$+&51/W.$0&5)1-'(1$0.$A(.5$A&W(X'.$(+;A/0/ZA.9$&[$1&'1.)$A.)$)2X'.50.)$)&51$;-2;/-2.)$&'$/+.52.)$

;/-$0.AA.$X'($A.)$;-20,3.D$Pf+.$A.$)0/53/A.$.)1$/55&502$M$S')1.$/V/51$A/$)2X'.50.$&[$#/-/Q*o/5.$

)U.5L'(1$3.$AU20&A.$T$A/$V()(1.$3.$)/$+,-.9$%&-/$/;;-.53$X'.$#/-/Q*o/5.$/$&'V.-1$A.$;&(W5.1$3.$#')(. $

;&'- $ 0&+;/-.- $ A/ $ 0&'A.'- $ 3. $ A.'-) $ )/5W9 $ 0. $ X'( $ /55&50. $ '5 $ 32)2X'(A(Z-. $ ;)O0Q&A&W(X'.$

(++23(/1.+.51$0&5L(-+2$;/-$A/$)2X'.50.$X'($)'(1D$

Page 78: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%.) $ )2X'.50.) $ )U&-W/5().51 $ 3&50 $ ).A&5 $'5 $ A(.5 $ A&W(X'.9 $ (51.AA.01'.AD $%. $ );.01/1.'- $ 5U.)1$

S/+/()$/Z/53&552$M$A.)$0&55.R(&5)$).$L&519$(+;A/0/ZA.)9$-.53/51$A/$A.01'-.$3'$L(A+$1-,)$LA'(3.$.1$

5/1'-.AA.D$=&'-1/519$-(.5$5U.)1$+&(5)$5/1'-.A$X'.$A.$1.+;)$3.$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&'M$S')1.+.519$A.$;/))/W.$

3U'5.$)2X'.50.$T$A/$)'(V/51.$5.$-.);.01.$.5$-2/A(12$.5$/'0'5$0/)$'5.$A&W(X'.$1.+;&-.AA.D$=&'-$/V&(-$

'5$A(.5$A&W(X'.$.51-.$.AA.)9$A.)$)2X'.50.)$5U&51$.5$/'0'5$0/)$Z.)&(5$3Uf1-.$)'(V(.)$&'$-2W'A(,-.+.51 $

.);/02.)$3/5)$A.$1.+;)D$%.$);.01/1.'-$/00.;1.$A/$1.+;&-/A(12$;-&;&)2.$)/5)$).$;&).-$3.$X'.)1(&5D$aA$

/'-/$L(5/A.+.51$;.'$3U(53(0.)$)'-$A.$1.+;)$;/))2$-2.AA.+.51$.51-.$0Q/X'.$)2X'.50.9$T$;/-1$AU.AA(;).$

3'$+(A(.'$h$&[$A.)$3/1.)$32L(A.519$3&55/51$A.)$>8$/5)$;/))2)$0&++.$'5.$3&552.$(5L&-+/1(V.D$#(-`$

S&'.$/V.0$A/$;.-0.;1(&5$0&5V.51(&55.AA.$X'.$A.$);.01/1.'-$/$3'$1.+;)$;&'-$3())(+'A.-$).)$.AA(;).)D$

%&-/$-.51-.$3.$)&5$0/)1(5W$.1$320&'V-.$#')(.$0&'0Q2.D $%/$)2X'.50.$3U/;-,)9$:55(.$-.53$V()(1.$T$

#/-/Q*o/5.$T$AU20&A.D$%.$);.01/1.'-$A(1$0.1$.50Q/n5.+.51$0&++.$0.A'(9$5/1'-.A9$3U'5$)&(-$3.$).+/(5.$

/'$S&'-$X'($A.$)'(1$h$;&'-1/51$-(.5$5U(53(X'.$X'.$Am.50Q/n5.+.51$)&(1$0.A'(*AT$M$(A$;&'--/(1$1&'1$/'))($

Z(.5$)U/W(-$3.$A/$).+/(5.$3U/;-,)D$%/$LA'(3(12$3/5)$A.$0Q&(R$3'$+&+.51$.1$A/$0&55.R(&5$A&W(X'.$.51-. $

0.)$3.'R$)2X'.50.)$3&55.51$/'$);.01/1.'-$ A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5$1.+;)$X'($)U20&'A.$/V.0$3&'0.'-$.1$

-2W'A/-(12D$B/5)$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.9$%&-/$-.\&(1$A/$;-&;&)(1(&5$3U'5$0/)1(5W$;&'-$'5$L(A+9$'5$)&(-$0Q.s $

.AA.$1/53()$X'.$A.)$L(AA.)$3()0'1.51$3/5)$A.'-$0Q/+Z-.$.1$X'.$#1..V.$;/-19$32\'$X'.$%&-/$;-(V(A2W(.$T$

5&'V./'$)&5$1-/V/(AD$d5$L&53'$/'$5&(-$.1$AU&5$.)1$3.$5&'V./'9$.5$)&(-2.$0Q.s$%&-/$M$#1..V.$5U.)1$;/)$

AT$h$%&-/$32/+Z'A.$3/5)$AU/;;/-1.+.51$.1$#/-/Q*o/5.$)&-1$3.$)/$0Q/+Z-.D$%.)$Vf1.+.51)$&51$0Q/5W29$

+/()$A.)$0&'A.'-)$)&51$;-.)X'.$A.)$+f+.)$M$#/-/*o/5.$.)1$;/))2$3U'5.$-&Z.$0-,+.$T$'5.$-&Z.$S/'5.$.1 $

%&-/$3U'5.$-&Z.$-&).$1-,)$0A/(-$T$'5.$-&Z.$ZA/50Q.$M$(A$;&'--/(1$;-.)X'.$)U/W(-$3.$A/$+f+.$)&(-2.9$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.) $21/51 $0/;1'-2) $3/5) $ A/ $;&)(1(&5$;-.)X'. $.R/01. $&[ $ (A) $/V/(.51 $212 $ A/())2)D $%/ $).'A.$

3(LL2-.50.$.)1$X'.$AU/W.51$3'$0(52/)1.$X'($/V/(1$/;;.A2$%&-/$X'.AX'.)$).0&53.)$;A')$1j1$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$

3'$L(A+$.)1$3/5)$0.11.$)2X'.50.$/))()$)'-$A.$0/5/;2D$#(-`$'1(A().$A.$+f+.$)'Z1.-L'W.$/V.0$A.$;/))/W.$

3.)$)/()&5)$M$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$V/$3.$AU212$EA.$);.01/1.'-$.51-.$3/5)$A.$L(A+$/V.0$3.)$)0,5.)$3.$;A/W.F $

T$AUQ(V.-$E#1..V.$V&'A/51$/0Q.1.-$3.)$0/3./'R$3.$"&qAFD$%/$).0&53.$;/-1(.$-2;21.-/$.R/01.+.51$A.$

+f+.$/W.50.+.519$3.$A/$)/()&5$3.)$;(X'.*5(X'.)$.5$L/+(AA.$/'$)&A$0&'V.-1$3.$WA/0.$3.$A/$)0,5.$3.$

AU.51.--.+.51$3U:55(.D$%U'1(A()/1(&5$3.)$)/()&5)$/$2V(3.++.51$T$V&(-$/V.0$)/$;&-12.$)O+Z&A(X'.$EA/$

0&A,-. $ 3. $ #/-/Q*o/5. $ )&') $ A/ $ 5.(W. $ .1 $ A/ $+&-1 $ 3U:55(. $ 3/5) $ A. $ L-&(3 $ 0&51-. $ A.) $ (5)&'0(/51.)$

;-&+.5/3.)$3U212F9$+/()$(A$.)1$2W/A.+.51$;&))(ZA.$3.$A(-.$(0($'5.$/'1-.$-.0&5)1(1'1(&5$^$5/1'-.AA.$_$3'$

1.+;)$3'$);.01/1.'-D$<(.5$X'.$>8$/5)$/(.51$;/))2$.51-.$A.)$3.'R$;/-1(.)9$B&'WA/)$#(-`$0&51(5'.$3.$

L/(-.$;/)).-$A.)$)/()&5)$0&++.$)m(A$)U/W())/(1$3.$3.'R$/552.)$0&5)20'1(V.)D$B.$AUQ(V.-$3.$A/$;-.+(,-. $

;/-1(.9$&5$;/)).$/'$;-(51.+;)$3.$A/$).0&53.D$

aA$)U/W(1$(0($1O;(X'.+.51$3.$AU.R.+;A.$X'.$320-(1$o/0X'.A(5.$"/0/0Q.$3.$A/$0&+;-.))(&5$X'.$

A. $0(52+/$/+2-(0/(5 $ (5LA(W. $/' $ 1.+;)9 $5. $)U.50&+Z-/51 $ S/+/() $3' $ 1.+;) $ (5'1(A.D $C&'1 $320&'A.9 $

Page 79: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

A&W(X'.+.519$3.$+/5(,-.$/Z)&A'+.51$)&'+().$T$A/$5/--/1(&59$3/5)$'5.$0&51(5'(12$L&-02.$3'$1.+;)$

X'($3&55.$T$V&(-$3.$+/5(,-.$LA'(3.$.1$/W-2/ZA.$A.$L(A+$/'$);.01/1.'-D$P/()$0.11.$0&51(5'(12$;-.53$'5$

).5)$1&'1$;/-1(0'A(.-$0Q.s$#(-`D$%/$LA'(3(12$V/$3.$;/(-.$/V.0$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5.$L/+(A(/-(12$/V.0$A/$V(.$

3.$A/$L/+(AA.D $#($ A.$+&'V.+.51$).$-2;,1.9 $3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$3/5)$)/$0Q/+Z-.9 $3.$%&-/$+/-0Q/51 $T$

1-/V.-)$A/$+/()&59$V2-(L(/51$X'.$1&'1$.)1$.5$&-3-.9$A.$);.01/1.'-$/$A/$).5)/1(&5$3U'5.$X'&1(3(.55.12$3.)$

0Q&).)9 $3.$ A.'- $ -2;21(1(&5D $B/5)$0.1 $.R.+;A.9 $ A/ $X'/)(* $ L')(&5$3.$0.) $3.'R$)2X'.50.) $3&55.$ A/$

).5)/1(&5$X'U.LL.01(V.+.519$A.)$0Q&).)$).$-2;,1.51$(5V/-(/ZA.+.519$3.$+/5(,-.$)(+(A/(-.D$%.$1.+;)$

)U20&'A.$;/()(ZA.+.519$)/5)$Q.'-1)9$1&'1$).+ZA.$-&'A.-$).A&5$'5.$+20/5(X'.$Z(.5$Q'(A2.9$&[$:55(.$

)U&00';.$3.$1&'1 $.1 $3.$0Q/0'59$0Q/X'.$;.-)&55/W.$/$)/$;A/0.$32L(5(. $3/5)$ AU2X'(A(Z-.$WA&Z/A$3'$

+&53.$3'$L(A+D$!5$;/-/AA,A.$3.$0.11.$/;;/-.51.$+20/5(X'.9$A/$V(&A.50.$)O+Z&A(X'.$.1$;)O0Q&A&W(X'.$

5.$0.)).$3.$).$).51(-$3.$+/5(,-.$)&'-3.$&'$3.$)'-W(-$)'Z(1.+.51$3/5)$'5$0&';$3U20A/1D$!5$1.5)(&5$

/V.0$0.1$&-3-.$3.)$0Q&).)$&[$1&'1$.)1$LA'(3.9$0Q/0'5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)'Z(1$3.)$V(&A.50.)$(512-(.'-.)$

1.--(ZA.)D$#')(.$X'.$AU&5$1-/(1.$0&++.$'5.$.5L/51$.1$X'.$A/$;/))(&5$;&'-$#1..V.$V(.53-/$.5V/Q(-9$.1 $

)'-1&'19$#/-/Q*o/5.9$T$A/X'.AA.$&5$;-21.53$.5$;.-+/5.50.$3&55.-$'5.$;A/0.$A2W(1(+.9$3&51$.AA.$5U/$

;/)$T$).$;A/(53-.9$1&'1$.5$A/$-/+.5/51$(50&5)0(.++.51$T$0.A'($3.$L(AA.$3.$3&+.)1(X'.D$%/$LA'(3(12$3'$

;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$V/$3.$;/(-.$/V.0$AU(+;-.))(&5$3.$5&-+/A(12$3.$AU&-W/5()/1(&5$L/+(A(/A.$/A&-)$X'U.AA.$

.)1$.5$-2/A(12$.+;-'51.$3U'5$-/0()+.$;-(+/(-.$.1$V(&A.51$X'.$AU&5$5(.D$#($:55(.$/V/(1$.'$3.)$/+Z(1(&5)$

;-&L.))(&55.AA.)9$S/+/()$%&-/$5.$).-/(1$+().$T$A/$).-V(-$/V.0$A/$+f+.$32V&1(&5D$#($:55(.$/V/(1$212 $

ZA/50Q.9$A.)$3.'R$L(AA.)$).-/(.51$1-/(12.)$)'-$A.$+f+.$+&3.9$).-/(.51$We12.)$3.$A/$+f+.$L/\&5D$4.11. $

(AA')(&5$3U'5$32-&'A.+.51$5/1'-.A$3.)$0Q&).)$/))&0(2.$T$A/$V(&A.50.$)O+Z&A(X'.$3&51$.)1$V(01(+.$

#/-/Q*o/5.$-2V,A.$.5$-2/A(12$A/$;-&L&53.'-$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$A.$-/0()+.$.)1$/50-2$3/5)$AU:+2-(X'.$3.)$

/552.)$b8D $%.$ 1.+;)$0&51(5'.$3.$;/)).-9 $ A/ $V(. $X'&1(3(.55.$3.$).$32-&'A.-$3/5) $'5.$/;;/-.51.$

1-/5X'(AA(12$/A&-)$X'.$A/$0&A,-.$.1$A/$-2V&A1.$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$5.$0.)).51$3.$W-&53.-D$%/$LA'(3(12$3' $

+&51/W.$.1$3.$Am.50Q/n5.+.51$3.)$)2X'.50.)$+&51-.51$3.$X'.AA.$+/5(,-.$#/-/Q*o/5.$.)1$.5L.-+2.$

3/5)$'5$+&53.$&[$A/$V(&A.50.$X'U.AA.$V(1$3.$AU(512-(.'-$.)1$;.-\'.$0&++.$(AA2W(1(+.9$5(2.9$21&'LL2.$

3/5)$A/$5&-+/A(12$3.)$0Q&).)D$P/AW-2$A.)$3(V.-).)$.R;A&)(&5)$X'($;&501'.51$A.$L(A+$EA/$0&A,-.$3.$

#/-/Q*o/5.$X'/53$)/$+,-.$V(.51$A/$0Q.-0Q.-$T$AU20&A.9$).)$.R;2-(.50.)$)'-$#')(.9$)&5$(+(1/1(&5$3. $

AU.)0A/V.$5&(-.9$)&5$/W-.))(&5$;/-$)&5$;-.+(.-$/+&'-.'RDDDF$-(.5$5.$0Q/5W.9$A/$L/+(AA.$0&51(5'.$3.$A/$

1-/(1.-$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$X'U/';/-/V/51$.5$)U21&55/51$3.$).)$52V-&).)D

B.$+f+.9 $ Am.50Q/n5.+.51$3.) $)2X'.50.)$X'( $)&'A(W5.$ A/ $ -.A/1(&5$3.$0/').$T $.LL.1 $3U'5.$

/01(&5$T$AU/'1-.$).-1$A/$;-2;/-/1(&5$;.1(1$T$;.1(19$.5$1.5)(&59$3.$A/$L(5$1-/W(X'.$3'$L(A+$.1$T$A/$+&-1 $

3U:55(.D$4&++.$'5.$Z&'A.$3.$5.(W.$&[$A.)$2V,5.+.51)$)U.51-/n5.51$1&'S&'-)$;A')$L&-1.+.51$V.-)$'5.$

-2)&A'1(&5$/11.53'.$.1$32).);2-2.9$0Q/X'.$).W+.51$.R()1.$;&'-$(51.5)(L(.-$A/$)(1'/1(&5$.1$+.5.-$T$A/$

0Q'1.D

Page 80: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

( G1E<)20+<)(+6&$.#D$)(>+2#+8)".)+).+2#+."#-)

%/$)1-'01'-.$3U.-'(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0 '.)1$+&1(V2.$;/-$'5.$1.5)(&5$.51-.$A.$0Q/5W.+.519$A/$

3.)1-'01(&5$.1 $ A.)$ 1-/0.) $3U'5$/50(.5$+&53.9$X'($).-&51 $3.$;A')$.5$;A')$LA&'.)$.1 $ A&(51/(5.)D $%/$

3.)1-'01(&5$5U.)1$;/)$0.AA.$3.$+,-),-9$-/3(0/A.9$32L(5(1(V.9$.1$1&1/A.$3U'5.$)2X'.50.$;/-$0.AA.$X'($)'(1$M$

.-a(&)/'(&0'4,12$%1&0$+.1$.5$)0,5.$'5.$2V&A'1(&5$A.51.$&[$)'-V(V.51$3.'R$+&53.)$.5$1.5)(&5D$%/$

A&W(X'.$X'($/5(+.$A.$;/))/W.$3U'5.$)2X'.50.$T$AU/'1-.9$.)1$0.AA.9$Z(5/(-.$3U'5.$0&5L-&51/1(&5$.51-.$'5$

'5(V.-)$.5$V&(.$3.$3();/-(1(&5$E0.A'($3.$A/$4Q(5.$;&;'A/(-.9$&'V-(,-.9$L/+(A(/A.F$.1$'5$).0&53$X'($

)U(+;&).$E0/;(1/A()1.9$L-&(39$320&55.012$3.$AUQ'+/(59$L&'$3.$V(1.)).$.1$3.$1.0Q5&A&W(.FD$%/$3(LL2-.50.$

.51-.$A.)$1-&()$;/-1(.)$).$L.-/$;/-$A/$+/5(,-.$3&51$).$)&A3.$0.11.$0&5L-&51/1(&5$.1$A/$;A/0.$E1&'S&'-)$

;A')$-23'(1.F$ A/())2.$T$0.1$/50(.5$+&53.D$%.$;/))/W.$3U'5.$)2X'.50.$T$AU/'1-.$.)1 $S')1(L(2$;/-$ A/ $

0&5)1-'01(&5$3'$0&51-/)1.9$3.$A/$1.5)(&59$X'($.51-.$3.$+/5(,-.$;-&W-.))(V.$3/5)$AUQ()1&(-.D

B/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$A.$+&53.$/50(.5$3.$A/$4Q(5.$.)1$AT9$;-2).519$.1$).-1$3.$320&-$/'R$

;.-)&55/W.)D $%/ $V(&A.50. $3' $5&'V./' $+&53. $.51-/51 $3/5) $ AU2X'/1(&59 $ (A $ ).-/ $ )O)12+/1(X'.+.51$

;.-3/51D$%.$L(A+$)U&'V-.$;/-$A/$3/5).$3.)$S.'5.)$0Q(5&()$;A.(5)$3U.51Q&')(/)+.$.1$3.)$(+/W.)$3'$

"&'V.A$:5$.5$1-/(5$3.$).$;-2;/-.-$h$0U.)1$A/$4Q(5.$/+&'-.').$3.$).)$1-/3(1(&5)9$0&5L(/51.$.5$)&5$

L'1'-9$0/-$.AA.$0&55/n1$)&5$;/))2D$%.$;-.+(.-$)(W5.$3'$0Q/5W.+.51$.)1$3&552$3/5)$A/$)2X'.50.$X'($

)'(1$/V.0$AU/--(V2.$3.$A/$V&(1'-.$3.$o(5)Q.5W$M$)&5$/00')/1(&5$A'($V/'1$3Uf1-.$X'/A(L(2$p3U2A(1.p9$.1$

/55&50. $3U/Z&-3 $3. $+/5(,-. $ (55&0.51. $.1 $ S&V(/A.9 $X'. $ -(.5 $5. $ ).-/ $;A') $ 0&++.$/V/51D $#'(1 $ A/$

)2X'.50.$3'$"&'V.A$/5$h$T$5&'V./'9$;-(+.$AU(+/W.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$1-/3(1(&55.AA.D$P/()$;.'$3.$1.+;)$

/;-,)9$o(5)Q.5W$2V&X'.$;&'-$A/$;-.+(,-.$L&()$T$C/&$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3.$).$32Z/--/)).-$3.$%(/5Ws($;&'-$

5Uf1-.$;A')$X'.$3.'RD$%.$)(W5.$-2)&55.$0.11.$L&()$T$AU20Q.AA.$(53(V(3'.AA.$M$A/$+.5/0.$3.$A/$L(5$3'$1-(&9 $

3.$A/$0&5V(V(/A(12$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$3.$A/$4Q(5.$Q'+/5()1.D$4.11.$/A1.-5/50.$3.$)(W5.)$0/-/012-().-/$

1&'1.$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3'$L(A+D$%(/5Ws($1-/V/(AA.$T$A/$+(5.$;'()$)U.5$V&(1$-.5V&O2$;/-$A.)$+/5(W/50.)$

3. $ o(5)Q.5WD $C/& $+/5W.$ A.) $ 3'+;A(5W) $3. $ )/ $ -.0.11. $ L/+(A(/A. $ .1 $ o(5)Q.5W $ .R(W. $3U.AA. $ X'U.AA. $

0Q&()()).$.51-.$).)$3.'R$/+()D$aA)$3/5).519$.+;&-12)9$3/5)$A/$Z&n1.$3.$5'(19$+/()$)U.5)'(V-/$A/$-';1'-.$

32L(5(1(V. $ /V.0 $%(/5Ws(D $%.) $ )2X'.50.) $+.11.51 $ .5 $ )0,5.9 $ AU'5. $ /;-,) $ AU/'1-.9 $ A.) $ 1.51/1(V.) $ 3.$

0&5).-V/1(&5$3'$+&3.$3.$V(.$0Q(5&()$.1$3.$AU2X'(A(Z-.$3'$1-(&$.1$A.)$V(01&(-.)$;-&W-.))(V.)$3'$5&'V./' $

+&53.$X'($)U(+;&).9$3.--(,-.$A/$L(W'-.$)O+Z&A(X'.$3.$o(5)Q.5WD$%/$L(5$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$V(.53-/$

+.11-.$'5$L-.(5$T$0.11.$V(&A.50.$M$C/&$(51.-3(1$T$o(5)Q.5W$3.$1'.-$)&5$-(V/A9$0.$X'U(A$/00.;1.D$%U/Z).50.$

3.$%(/5Ws($).$1-&'V.$Z(.51j1$;/AA(2.$;/-$AU/0Q/1$3U'5$;.1(1$0Q(.59$;&'-$A.X'.A$C/&$)U.51Q&')(/)+.D$

P/()$0.11.$/;;/-.51.$3&'0.'-$1-/3'(1$'5.$-2/A(12$;A')$0-'.AA.$h$0&51-.$X'.AX'.)$0&+;-&+()9$A.$+&53.$

3.$A/$4Q(5.$1-/3(1(&55.AA.$/00.;1.$AU(51-')(&5$3'$5&'V./'$+&53.$.1$3.$)/$V(&A.50.D$aA$5.$).-/$;/)$

X'.)1(&5$3.$).$-2V&A1.-9$+/()$3U/00.;1.-$A/$320Q2/50.9$3.$A/$-.53-.$L/+(A(,-.D$%.$-.5V&($3.$%(/5Ws($

Page 81: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;/-$o(5)Q.5W$5.$).-/$;/)$0&55'.$3.$C/&$.1$.AA.$/00.;1.-/$3U.+Z-/)).-$A.$+&53.$3.$o(5)Q.5W$0&51-.$

'5$;.'$3.$;&'3-.$/'R$O.'R$M$'5$S&A($+/-(/W.$.1$'5$;.1(1$0Q(.5D$

B/5)$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.9$A.$+&53.$+&3.-5.$/$;-()$;-.)X'.$1&'1.$A/$;A/0.$M$(A$5.$-.)1.$X'.$

X'.AX'.) $ 1-/0.) $3. $ A/ $4Q(5. $3U/V/519 $X'( $ )'-V(V.519 $+/() $5U&51 $ 32L(5(1(V.+.51 $ X'U'5. $.R()1.50.$

L-/W(A.D$%.$);.01/1.'-$/))()1.$T$A/$3.)1-'01(&5$3.$).)$3.-5(.-)$-.+;/-1)D$%/$;-.+(,-.$)2X'.50.$/$A(.'$

3/5)$A/$0(12$&'V-(,-.$&[$%(/5Ws($/$-.1-&'V2$3'$1-/V/(AD$!5$3.Q&-)$3.$A/$V(AA.9$A.$+&53.$/50(.5$;.-3'-.$

'5$;.'D$P/()$A.$);.01/1.'-$)/(1$Z(.5$X'.$A.)$;-&V(50.)$L(5(-&51$;/-$)'(V-.$A.$+f+.$0Q.+(5D$%U/);.01$

L.)1(L$3'$32Z'1$/$32ST$3();/-'D$%(/5Ws($/;;-.53$X'U(A$.)1$+/A/3.$3U'5$0/50.-9$0&51-/012$T$0/').$3.$)&5$

1-/V/(A$T$A/$+(5.$.1$AU&5$/;;-.53-/$3/5)$'5.$0&5V.-)/1(&5$/V.0$)&5$/50(.5$0&AA,W'.$X'.$A.)$3.'R$

+(5.)$)&51$)'-$A.$;&(51$3.$L.-+.-9$0/-$.AA.)$)&51$1-&;$;.1(1.)D$%.$+&53.$&'V-(.-$.1$;&;'A/(-.$.)1$T$

AU/W&5(.D$%.)$;-.+(.-)$;A/5)$&51$'5.$L&-1.$0Q/-W.$)O+Z&A(X'.$M$A.)$&'V-(.-)$)&51$;Q&1&W-/;Q(2)$1&')$

.5).+ZA.$.1$).$)2;/-.51$.5)'(1.9$A/())/51$%(/5Ws($).'A9$3.Z&'1$)'-$A.)$+/-0Q.)D$aA$).-/$A.$3.-5(.-$T $

X'(11.-$A.$0/3-.9$A.$3.-5(.-$3.)$&'V-(.-)9$AU'A1(+.$-.;-2).51/51$3U'5.$W252-/1(&5$X'($5U.)1$32ST$;A')D$

%(/5Ws( $ -.51-. $ T $ A/ $ V(AA.9 $ 0&51-/(51 $ 3. $ V.5(- $ 3.+/53.- $ 3. $ AU/-W.51 $ T $ ).) $ /50(.55.)$

L-2X'.51/1(&5)D$aA$A.$1-&'V.-/$3'$0j12$3.$C/&9$X'($A'($&LL-.$/V.0$;A/()(-D$%.$)O+Z&A.$.)1$T$5&'V./'$

L&-1h$A.$5&'V./'$+&53.$0/;(1/A()1.$).$323&'/5.$3.$A/$0'A;/Z(A(12$3.$A/$3.)1-'01(&5$3.$AU/50(.5$+&53.$

1-/3(1(&55.A$;/-$AU/-W.51D$C/&$/0Q,1.$)/$1-/5X'(AA(129$)/$0'A;/Z(A(129$.1$-2;/-.$A.$+/A$0/')2$/V.0$).)$

A(/)).)$3.$Z(AA.1)9$'A1(+.$;-.'V.$X'.$A.$5&'V./'$+&53.$AU/$.+;&-12D$g(.53-&51$(++23(/1.+.51$/;-,)$

A/$+&-1$3'$;,-.$.1$A.$-.1&'-$3'$L(A)$h$3.$5&'V./'9$AU'5$.1$AU/'1-.$(50/-5.51$A.)$3.'R$+&53.)$X'($). $

0-&().519$A/$+&-1$3.$AU'5$;-&V&X'/51$AU/--(V2.$3'$).0&53D$%.$L(A)$B&AA/-$0&++'5(X'.$;/-$#`O;.$/V.0$

)/$+,-.9$;&)),3.$)&5$;-&;-.$a;/39$.19$T$O$V&(-$).)$;Q&1&)9$)/$;-&;-.$V&(1'-.9$)&5$;-&;-.$0Q.V/A$.1$)&5$

;-&;-.$Z/1./'D$=.53/51$0.$1.+;)9$A.$;,-.$3.$C/&$.)1$.51.--2$3.$+/5(,-.$1-/3(1(&55.AA.9$).A&5$3.)$-(1.)$

3.$A/$4Q(5.$/50(.55.D$B&AA/-$).$1-&'V.$21&552$3.$3.V&(-$)U/W.5&'(AA.-$/'$)&A$3.V/51A.$0&-;)$3.$)&5$

W-/53*;,-.9$)&')$A.)$&-3-.)$3.$)/$+,-.D$C-,)$V(1.9$B&AA/-$3.V-/$-.;/-1(-$h$0/-$A.$5&'V./'$+&53.$.)1$

3U/Z&-3$0.A'($3.$A/$320&55.R(&5$T$A/$1.--.$3U&-(W(5.$.1$3.$A/$3();.-)(&5$3.$A/$L/+(AA.D

$B/5)$A/$1-&()(,+.$;/-1(.9$A.)$-.)1.)$3.$0.11.$4Q(5.$3U/51/5$5.$)&51$;A')$X'U(++/12-(.A)D$aA$

)U/W(1$3.$)&'V.5(-)9$3.$-2+(5()0.50.)$V/W'.)$M$3U'5.$-.A(X'.$0&5).-V2.9$3U'5$;-25&+$+'-+'-29$3U'5.$

A/5W'.$;-.)X'.$&'ZA(2.D$%.)$;-.+(,-.)$)2X'.50.)$L&51$A.$0&5)1/1$3.)$;.-1.)$0Q.s$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$

B&AA/-$M$;.-1.$3.$A/$A/5W'.$.1$3'$)&'V.5(-$3.$)/$;/1-(.$E(A$21'3(.$A.$0Q(5&()$X'U(A$/$&'ZA(2$.1$3(1$5.$;/) $

).$-/;;.A.-$3'$5&+$3.$)/$+,-.F$h$;.-1.$3U'5$).5)$T$)/$V(.$E(A $20-(1$'5$+/(A $T$)&5$;,-.$;&'-$A'($

.R;A(X'.-$X'U(A$5.$)/(1$;A')$X'&($L/(-.F$h$;.-1.$3.$A/$L/+(AA.$E(A$).$3();'1.$/V.0$)&5$;,-.9$/V.0$X'($(A$5.$

;.'1$;A')$;/-A.-$X'UT$1-/V.-)$%,,%)&'2#$10)$2&FD$#/$-.A/1(&5$5/())/51.$/V.0$)/$;-&L.)).'-.$3.$0Q(5&()$

Page 82: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

(50/-5.$A.$32)(- $3U'5$-.1&'-$/'R$)&'-0.)9$ A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$T$1-/V.-)$3.)$32-(V/1(L)$3U'5$+&53.$X'($/ $

32L(5(1(V.+.51$3();/-'$.1$3&51$(A$5.$-.)1.$X'.$AU20Q&D$:V.0$.AA.9$(A$;-&5&50.-/$;&'-$A/$;-.+(,-.$L&()$A.$

5&+$3.$)/$+,-.9$0&++.$'5.$L&-+'A.$+/W(X'.$3.$)&5$.5L/50.9$.1$).$0&5)1-'(-/$AU.);&(-$3U'5$-.1&'-$

/'R$)&'-0.)9$/V.0$A.$V&O/W.$X'U(A)$)U/;;-f1.51$T$L/(-.$.5).+ZA.D$P/()$(A$).$-.L').-/$L(5/A.+.51$T$A. $

L/(-.$M$1-&;$3.$1.+;)$;/))29$A/$).5)/1(&5$X'.$AU20Q&$).'A$.)1$;.'1*f1-.$;A')$Z./'$X'.$0.$X'U(A$-()X'.-/(1 $

3.$320&'V-(-$.5$4Q(5.D$%.$3.-5(.-$;A/5$.5$:')1-/A(.9$+&51-.$B&AA/-$)&'LLA.-$A.$5&+$3.$)/$+,-.9$A/$

).'A.$-.A(X'.$X'($.R()1.$.50&-.$;&'-$A'($3.$AU/50(.5$+&53.$0Q(5&()$1-/3(1(&55.AD$%/$3.-5(,-.$)2X'.50.$

+&51-.$C/&$).$)&'V.5/51$3.$)/$S.'5.)).$h$;&'-$.AA.$/'))(9$(A$).+ZA.$X'U(A$5UO$/(1$W',-.$3U/'1-.)$1-/0.)D$

%/$)1-'01'-.$.)1$3&50$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$)'-$A.$V.)1(W.$M$0.$X'($-.)1.$3'$+&53.$;/))2$3/5)$A. $

+&53.$3U/'S&'-3UQ'(9$0.$X'($V(1$/;-,)$A/$3.)1-'01(&5D$!5$'5$).5)9$wQ/5W`.$+&51-.$'5$+&+.51$3.$

1-/5)(1(&5$3.$AUr()1&(-.$&[$3.'R$1.+;)$0&Q/Z(1.51$'5$+&+.519$0&++.$)';.-;&)2)9$.5$/11.53/51$A/$

V(01&(-.$3.$AU'5$)'-$AU/'1-.D $t$AU(5V.-).$3. $+,-),-9 $ A.)$ A(.'R$)&51$-20'--.51)$.1 $V(.55.51$)(W5/A.-9$

0Q/X'.$L&()9$AU&.'V-.$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)D$%/$+/()&5$3.$%(/5Ws(9$0&'V.-1.$3.$;&'))(,-.$h$A.$1-/(59$

0Q/X'.$L&()$;A')$+&3.-5.$h$A/$+(5.9$32)&-+/()$V(3.$.1$X'.$)&5$0&AA,W'.$V.'1$X'(11.-$;&'-$'5$.+;A&($

/'$y/s/`Q)1/5D$#.'A.$A/$+/()&5$3.$C/&$).+ZA.$0&5W.A2.$3/5)$A.$1.+;)9$L&O.-$X'($L/(1$/'))($&LL(0.$3.$

;-()&59 $ 3/5) $ A/ $ )&A(1'3. $ X'( $ A/ $ 0/-/012-().D $ %.) $ )2X'.50.) $ L&51 $ 20Q& $ A.) $ '5.) $ /'R $ /'1-.)D $ %/$

0&+;&)(1(&5$3.)$;A/5)$2W/A.+.51D$d5.$3.)$;-.+(,-.)$)2X'.50.)$+&51-.$C/&9$o(5)Q.5W$.1$%(/5Ws($

L/()/51$.R;A&).-$3.)$;21/-3)$/'$Z&-3$3.)$./'R$3'$A/0$/-1(L(0(.AD$#&5$3.-5(.-$;A/5$A.)$+&51-.9$1&')$A.)$

1-&()9$&Z).-V/51$A.)$L.'R$3U/-1(L(0.)D$d5$;A/5$1-,)$)(+(A/(-.$)'-V(.53-/$'5$;.'$;A')$1/-3$3/5)$A.$L(A+9$

A&-)X'.$o(5)Q.5W$;-&S.11.$3.$1'.-$%(/5Ws($.1$).$V&(1$0&51-/(51$)&')$A/$;-.))(&5$3.$C/&$3.$L/(-.$20A/1.-$

A/$3O5/+(1.$3/5)$A.)$./'R$3'$A/0D$%.$;A/5$.)1$)(+(A/(-.9$+/()$.5$+(-&(-$h$AU./'$).$)&'A,V.$0&++.$

S/3()$A/$L'+2.$3.)$;21/-3)9$+/()$(A)$5.$)&51$;A')$X'.$3.'RD$aA)$-.W/-3/(.51$3/5)$A.$;-.+(.-$1&')$A.)$

1-&()$V.-)$A/$3-&(1.$3'$0/3-.9$V.-)$AU/V.5(-$h$C/&$.1$o(5)Q.5W$1.-+(5.51$3/5)$A.$).0&53$.5$-.W/-3/51$

V.-)$A/$W/'0Q.9$-2V2A/51$AU(+;/)).$3.$A.'-$L'1'-$.5).+ZA.$.1$3.$0.A'($3.$A/$4Q(5.D$

%/$X'.)1(&5$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$0.AA.$3.$A/$1-/0.D$c'.$-.)1.*1*(A$3.$AU/50(.5$+&53.$3/5)$0.)$

(+/W.)$k$%.$0Q&(R$3.)$.R12-(.'-)$.)1$;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$-2V2A/1.'-$3.$0.11.$V&A&512$3U.5-.W()1-.-$A/$

)';.-;&)(1(&5$3.)$2;&X'.)D$C/&$1-/V.-).$3.$+/5(,-.$-2;212.$'5$;/O)/W.$X'($;&-1.$A/$+/-X'.$3.$A/$

)';.-;&)(1(&5 $ /-0Q(1.01'-/A. $ 3.) $ 2;&X'.)D $d5 $ Ze1(+.51 $ 1-/3(1(&55.A $ .51&'-2 $ 3U'5 $ 1.--/(5 $ V/W'.$

;&'))(2-.'R$-.V(.51$A&-)$3.$X'/1-.$;A/5)$3/5)$A.$L(A+D$4U)1$'5$)O+Z&A.$1-,)$5.1$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)9$

3.$AU&'ZA($3'$;/))2$A/())2$T$AU/Z/53&5$.1$.5$V&(.$3.$3();/-/n1-.D$BU/'1-.)$V.)1(W.$3.$AU/50(.5$+&53.$

)'-V(V/51$3/5)$A.$+&53.$+&3.-5.9$/;;/-/n1-&51$T$AU(+/W.$h$AU/-0Q.$1-/3(1(&55.AA.$)(1'2.$/'*3.))')$

3U'5.$/V.5'.$.50&+Z-2.$3.$V&(1'-.)$A&-)X'.$%(/5Ws($-.V(.51$.5$V(AA.$h$A.$Z/--/W.$3'$A/0$W.A2$h$A.$

Page 83: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

Ze1(+.51$L/')).+.51$1-/3(1(&55.A$X'($/00'.(AA.$3.)$+/-(/W.)9$-.;-&3'01(&5$+&3.-5.$.1$)/5)$)/V.'-$

3U'5.$/-0Q(1.01'-.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$/50.)1-/A.D

%.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$3/5)$A.)$1-&()$L(A+)$0Q&()()$+/-X'.$0.11.$L&()$;/-$A.'-)$3(LL2-.50.)D$%/$

V()(&5 $ 0Q/&1(X'. $ .1 $ T $ 0&'-1 $ 1.-+. $ 3' $ 1.+;) $ 0Q.s $ =/Z)1 $ h $ AU(+;&))(Z(A(12 $ 3. $ A/ $ 3'-2.9 $ 3.$

AU/Z&'1()).+.519$'5$1.+;)$L&'$X'($).$-2;,1.$.1$).$321-'(1$T$A/$L&()9$3/5)$'5.$A&W(X'.$3.$L(5$3'$+&53.D$

%.$1.+;)$A()).$.1$-2W'A(.-$0Q.s$#(-`9$'5$+&53.$)/5)$Q.'-1)$X'($0/0Q.$A.)$)&'LL-/50.)$(51(+.)$.1$

(512-(.'-.)$;-f1.)$T$S/(AA(-$h$ A/$)&'LL-/50.$X'($;.-3'-.9 $)&'-3.9$(5/A12-/ZA.$1/51$X'.$A.$+/5,W.$3. $

AUQO;&0-()(.$)&0(/A.$5.$).$1.-+(5.-/$;/)D$!5L(5$'5$1.+;)$X'($321-'(1$1&'19$;.'$T$;.'9$A.51.+.51$+/() $

)i-.+.519 $/V.0$A/$L&-0.$3U'5.$+/0Q(5.$.5$+/-0Q.D$%/$1-/5)L&-+/1(&5$3'$;/))2$.5$'5$+&53.$3.$

L/51j+.)9$X'($-.W/-3.51$/V.0$32)&A/1(&5$'5$5&'V./'$+&53.$)U(+;&).-D$

Page 84: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

FCVH-HS!I(<DCFHI(

;'(/*)&'(',(0'()"/$9.*@'(.$9&(/$1,'&(0'(,'#.+W

Page 85: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

?K*.%,&'(5

(;9#%G&'(',(@&$+(.0*1+()*1+(;$90$9

( *#+9'$+<)(+.)68(

%/$A'+(,-.$3/5)$+,-),-$S&'.$'5$-jA.$;-2;&532-/51$3/5)$A/$32L(5(1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$3.$

A.'-$(3.51(12$+&-/A.D$%&'A&'$;&'--/(1$;/-/n1-.$'5$;.-)&55/W.$1&1/A.+.51$+&5)1-'.'R$)($.AA.$5U21/(1$

;/)$)/5)$/--f1$Z/(W52.$;/-$'5.$21-/5W.$0A/-12D$B.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$X'U.AA.$/11(-.$A.)$Q&++.)9$.AA.$

).+ZA. $ /11(-.- $ A/ $ A'+(,-.D $P(.'R $ .50&-.9 $ A/ $ A'+(,-. $ ).+ZA. $ 2+/5.- $ 3U.AA.*+f+.D $ #&5 $ V()/W.$

)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$ZA/509$&;/A.)0.519$0&51-(Z'.$T$L/(-.$3U.AA.$'5$;.-)&55/W.$Z-(AA/519$A'+(5.'R$h$A/$

0A/-12$/AA'+.$AU.R;-.))(&5$&'V.-1.$3.$)&5$V()/W.9$).)$)&'-0(A)$Q/'))2)9$)&5$)&'-(-.$1&'S&'-)$;-f1$T$

)'-W(-9$).)$O.'R$)/5)$0.)).$3/5)$A.$X'.)1(&55.+.51$.1$3/5)$AU/11.51.$(55&0.51.$3U'5.$-2/01(&5$.5$L/0.$

3U.AA.D$Pf+.$T$1-/V.-)$A.$V&(A.$5&(-$3'$3.'(A9 $%&'A&'$W/-3.$A.$V()/W.$3U'5.$ZA/50Q.'-$20A/1/51.9 $

)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$20A/(-29$)/5)$&+Z-.9$3/5)$1&'1.$)&5$(55&0.51.$;'-.12D$:(5)($.)1*.AA.$+().$3'$0j12$

3'$Z(.5$V(/$A/$A'+(,-.9$X'($).+ZA.$5.$A/()).-$-(.5$3.$0/0Q2$3.$).)$.R;-.))(&5)9$A/$-2V2A/51$L-/50Q.9$

.51(,-.9$)/5)$+.5)&5W.$;&))(ZA.D$#&5$0&-;)$ZA/50$.)1$2W/A.+.51$32V&(A2$/V.0$-20'--.50.$h$3/5)$A/$

)0,5.$3'$1Q2e1-.$&[$.AA.$;&-1.$'5.$-&Z.$X'($A'($320&'V-.$A.$3&)9$A.$320&AA.12$.1$A.)$Z-/)9$.AA.$.)1$A/$

).'A.$T$/;;/-/n1-.$A'+(5.').9$A.)$/'1-.)$;&-1/51$3.)$0&)1'+.)$)&+Z-.)$X'($/00.51'.51$3U/'1/51$;A')$A. $

0&51-/)1.D $ P/() $ %&'A&' $ 5U.)1 $ 3. $ ;A') $ ;/) $ ).'A.+.51 $ 0A/(-.9 $ .AA. $ ;-&V&X'. $ 2W/A.+.51 $ '5$

)0(51(AA.+.51$M$).)$O.'R$.1$).)$3.51)$Z-(AA.519$)&5$0/)X'.$3.$0Q.V.'R$5&(-)$.1$Z-(AA/51)$)&51$-.+;A()$3.$

-.LA.1)$.1$).)$Vf1.+.51)$-.5V&(.51$A/$A'+(,-.$3/5)$A.'-)$+&(53-.)$;.1(1)$;A()D$Pf+.$)/$-&Z.$3.$3.'(A $

5&(-.9$3U/;;/-.50.$)/1(52.$-.LA,1.$A/$A'+(,-.$3.$+/5(,-.$)'-;-.5/51.D$%.)$0Q&(R$3.$L(A1-.)$/00.51'.51$

0.)$Z-(AA/50.)$M$A.)$ZA/50)$X'U.AA.$;&-1.$3/5)$A/$)0,5.$3'$+/-(/W.$)&51$.R;A&)2)$;/-$'5$L(A1-.$X'($

3(LL').$A.)$Q/'1.)$A'+(,-.)$.1$X'($).-/(1$/'S&'-3UQ'($AU2X'(V/A.51$3U'5$;-&*+()1$h$A.)$-.LA.1)$3.$).) $

O.'R$.1$3.$).)$3.51)$)&51$/00.51'2)$;/-$'5$L(A1-.*0-&))$X'($A.)$1-/5)L&-+.$.5$;.1(1.)$0-&(R$3.$+/5(,-.$

/Z)&A'+.51 $ (--2/A()1.9 $+/() $+/W(X'.D $ |V(3.++.519 $ '5 $ ;-&S.01.'- $ .5 $ 0&51-. $ )U(+;&). $ 3/5) $ A.)$

;&-1-/(1)$3.$%&'A&'9$.1$A'($3&55.51$'5.$/'-/$WA&-(L(0/1-(0.D

t$AU(5V.-).9$A.$3&01.'-$.)19$A'(9$/))&0(2$T$AU&+Z-.D$%/$A'+(,-.$A.$1&'0Q.$)&'V.51$.5$0&51-.9 $

A/())/51 $A/$;/-1(.$A/$;A')$V()(ZA.$3.$)&5$V()/W.$3/5)$AU&+Z-.D$%/$A'+(,-.$.)1$S&'2.$2W/A.+.51$3.$

+/5(,-.$T$A'($/00.51'.-$A.)$1-/(1)$h$20A/(-2)$.5$Å$0&51-.9$).)$1-/(1)$)&51$/00.51'2)$;/-$A.$V&A'+.$X'.$

3&55.$A/$A'+(,-.$V.5'.$3.$3.--(,-.D$#&5$V()/W.$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$/))&0(2$T$'5$0&51-/)1.$1-,)$

Page 86: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

2A.V29$X'($A.$-.53$1.--(L(/519$T$A/$A(+(1.$3'$+&5)1-'.'RD$aA$.)1$1&'S&'-)$Vf1'$3U'5$0&)1'+.$)&+Z-.9$.1 $

)&5$(+;&)/51.$)1/1'-.$.5$L/(1$'5$ZA&0$(++'/ZA.$.1$(+;&)/51$T$AU20-/5$h$3U/'1/51$;A')$X'U(A$.)1$)&'V.51 $

L(A+2$3.$3&)D$B/5)$A/$)2X'.50.$3.$)/$+&-19$(A$.)1$L(A+2$.5$;-.+(.-$;A/59$3.$3&)9$1/53()$X'.$%&'A&'9$T $

3.+($0/0Q2.$;/-$)/$A/-W.$2;/'A.9$A.$-.W/-3.$3.$).)$O.'R$/;.'-2)D$%.$0/3-.$/;;'(.$)/$;&)1'-.$3.$

3&+(5/1(&5$.5$A'($L/()/51$-.+;A(-$T$A'($1&'1$).'A$A/$+&(1(2$3'$0Q/+;D$%.$3&01.'-$/$2W/A.+.51$A.)$

O.'R$X'($Z-(AA.519$+/()$3U'5.$Z-(AA/50.$;A')$1.--(L(/51.$X'.$0.AA.$3.$%&'A&'$M$A.$V()/W.$3/5)$AU&+Z-.9$

).'A) $ ).) $O.'R $ZA/50) $/;;/-/()).519 $'5 $ -.LA.1 $ )'- $ )&5 $+&5&0A. $V.5/51 $ A'( $3&55.- $'5. $21(50.AA.$

3(/Z&A(X'.D$

B.$+/5(,-.$1-,)$0A/))(X'.9$A.$;.-)&55/W.$(55&0.51$.)1$/))&0(2$T$A/$A'+(,-.$.1$A.$;.-)&55/W.$

;A')$52W/1(L$T$AU&+Z-.D$P/()$A/$A'+(,-.$1-/3'(1$.5$-2/A(12$3.)$.51(12)$;A')$0&+;A.R.)D$#($A.$3&01.'-$

5U/V/(1 $;/) $212 $ 1-/(12 $3.$+/5(,-.$/'))( $+&5)1-'.').9 $ (A $/'-/(1 $;'$f1-.$V'$2W/A.+.51$0&++.$'5.$

V(01(+.$h$/+&'-.'R$3.$%&'A&'9$(A$)U.)1$V.53'$T$'5.$L.++.$3&51$(A$)/(1$32ST$X'U.AA.$V/$0/').-$)/$;.-1.$

.1$).$1-&'V.$32).);2-2D$4.$;.-)&55/W.$.5$;.-3(1(&5$/'-/(1$L(5/A.+.51$;'$f1-.$/))&0(2$T$A/$A'+(,-.$

0&++.$%&'A&'$T$AU&Z)0'-(12D$!5$-2/A(129$A/$0A/-12$3.$%&'A&'$5&')$;/-A.$3/V/51/W.$3'$32)(-D$<-(AA/51.9 $

.AA.$/11(-.$A.$-.W/-3$3U'5$+&53.$;A&5W2$3/5)$AU&Z)0'-(12$.1$A.$32).);&(-D$4U.)1$0.11.$0A/-12$(--2.AA.$)'-$

)&5$V()/W.$X'($.R;A(X'.$A/$L/)0(5/1(&5$3.)$Q&++.)$;&'-$.AA.D$C.AA.$A/$A'+(,-.$X'($/11(-.$A.)$(5).01.)9$

.AA.$A.)$W'(3.-/$3/5)$A/$5'(1$S')X'UT$0.$X'U(A)$V(.55.51$+&'-(-$T$)&5$0&51/01D$

Page 87: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51
Page 88: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51
Page 89: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

d5.$/5/AO).$;A')$;-20().$3.$A/$A'+(,-.$/'$0&'-)$3'$L(A+$V(.51$0&5L(-+.-$0.11.$QO;&1Q,).$M$A.)$

+&+.51)$3.$W-/53.$1.5)(&59$&[$A.$0-(+.$.1$AU(++&-/A(12$)&51$/'$;A')$Q/'1$5.$)&51$;/)$A.)$+&+.51)$

A.)$;A')$)&+Z-.)9$+/()$A.)$;A')$0&51-/)12)$.1$&[$A.)$ZA/50)$)&51$A.)$;A')$Z-(AA/51)D$%.$L(A1-.$2X'(V/A.51$

/' $ZA/0` $;-&*+()1 $ ).+ZA.$f1-. $;-2).51 $3/5) $ A.) $ )2X'.50.) $ A.) $;A') $)'AL'-.').)9 $&[$ A.) $;'A)(&5)$

).R'.AA.)$.1$3.)1-'01-(0.)$)&51$T$A.'-$0&+ZA.$M$A.$+.'-1-.$3'$3&01.'-9$A.$+&+.51$3'$0/)(5&9$)'++'+$

3.$A/$320/3.50.$3'$+&53.9$3/5)$A/$)2X'.50.$&[$.AA.$).$;-&)1(1'.$/V.0$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-$.1$&[$(A$L(5(1$

;/- $ A/ $;&(W5/-3.-D $%.) $Q/'1.) $ A'+(,-.) $ .1 $ A.) $ZA/50) $).+ZA.51 $3&50$ A.) $;A') $Z-(AA/51)9 $ A.) $;A')$

20A/1/51)9$3/5)$A.)$+&+.51)$A.)$;A')$)&+Z-.)D$%.)$.);/0.)$&[$&51$A(.'$0.)$1-&()$)0,5.)$;-2).51.$'5.$

(AA'+(5/1(&5$;A')$0&51-/)12.$X'.$3/5)$A.$-.)1.$3'$L(A+$M$A/$0Q/+Z-.$5';1(/A.$.)1$20A/(-2.$;/-$3.)$

A/+;.)$;&501'.AA.)$h$A.$0/)(5&$21/51$)(1'2.$3/5)$A/$0/A.$3U'5$Z/1./'9$A.)$;/-&()$)&51$;A')$L&502.)$.1$A/ $

A'+(,-.9$(52W/A.+.51$-2;/-1(.9$A/()).$3.)$-.0&(5)$)&+Z-.)$h$.5L(5$A/$3.-5(,-.$)2X'.50.$).$32-&'A.$

3/5)$A/$+/5)/-3.$;/'V-.$&[$)'-V(V.51$%&'A&'$.1$).)$0&+;/W5&5)$.1$.)1$20A/(-2.$T$A/$A/+;.$T$Q'(A.9$

;&)2.$)'-$A/$1/ZA.D$%.$0&51-/)1.$L&501(&55.$3&50$.5$-2)&5/50.$3(-.01.$/V.0$A/$;.-V.-)(12$3'$A(.'$

1-/V.-)2$;/- $ A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D $B.$ A/ $ A'+(,-.$-.A/1(V.+.51$'5(L&-+.$3.) $;-.+(.-) $/01.)$ ES')X'U/'$

+/-(/W.F9$A.$+&53.$).$L/(1$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$0&51-/)12$h$A/$1.5)(&5$.51-.$AU&+Z-.$.1$A/$A'+(,-.$;A')$

L&-1.D$%/$+&512.$3'$32)(-$.1$3.$)/$V(&A.50.$)&51$(50/-52)$;/-$A/$+&512.$3'$0&51-/)1.9$3.$A/$3(LL2-.50.$

.51-.$AU&ZS.1$32)(-2$.1$AU&ZS.1$32)(-/51D$

#'-$0.$;-(50(;.9$ A.$ 1-/V/(A$3.$A/$ A'+(,-.$1-/3'(1$3&50$2W/A.+.51$ A/$320Q2/50.$)&-3(3.$3'$

+&53.$3. $%&'A&'D $=.'$T $;.'9 $)&5$'5(V.-)$)&+Z-.$3/5) $'5$0Q/&)$&[$ A/ $ A'11. $3.$ A'+(,-. $.1 $3. $

AU&Z)0'-(12$;-.53$1&'1.$A/$;A/0.9$/55(Q(A/51$1&'1$/'1-.$).5)$;&))(ZA.D$B/5)$A.)$3.'R$3.-5(.-)$/01.)9$A/$

A'+(,-.$).$L/(1$;A')$.R;-.))(&55()1.D$%U/01.$J$/+&-0.$0.$+&'V.+.51$M$A.$Z/1./'$).$3(V().$.51-.$A/ $

)/AA.$20A/(-2.$&[$A/$)&0(212$S&'.$.1$;.-3$/'$0/)(5&$.1$A.)$-.0&(5)$)&+Z-.)$&[$).$1-/+.51$A.)$0&+;A&1)$

A.)$;A')$&3(.'R$EA/$V.51.$3.$%&'A&'$T$'5$-(0Q.$2WO;1(.59 $A/$)'WW.)1(&5$3.$#0Q(W&A0Q$T$:AK/$3.$

1-(0Q.-$/'R$32)9$A/$)23'01(&5$.51-.$A/$0&+1.)).$.1$Y&3-(W&$;&'-$&Z1.5(-$3.$AU/-W.51$AU'5$3.$AU/'1-.9 $

L&+.512.$;/-$A.)$+/5(;'A/1(&5)$3.$#0Q(W&A0QFD$%.$0&51-/)1.$.51-.$AU&+Z-.$.1$A/$A'+(,-.$0&++.50.$T$

).$0-.').-9$-2V2A/51$1&'1.$AUQ&--.'-$3.$A/$0&50';()0.50.$.1$3'$32)(-$Q'+/(5D$%.$+&+.51$3.$Z/)0'A.$

+.$).+ZA.$f1-.$A.$+.'-1-.$3.$Y&3-(W&D$B/5)$'5$;A/5$&[$(A$).$32Z/1$/V.0$A/$0&+1.)).9$'5.$A/+;.$T$

Q'(A.$&)0(AA.$/'*3.))')$3U.'R9$A.)$;A&5W./51$1/51j1$3/5)$AU&+Z-.9$1/51j1$3/5)$A/$A'+(,-.D$#&5$0/3/V-.$

320&'V.-1 $;/- $ A/ $;&A(0. $).-/$2W/A.+.51$20A/(-2 $3.$+/5(,-. $21-/5W. $.1 $.LL-/O/51. $ h $'5.$ 1/0Q.$3.$

A'+(,-. $ V(.51 $ T $+&(1(2 $ 320&'V-(- $ ).) $ 1-/(1) $ L(W2)9 $ 3&55/51 $ '5. $ L&-+. $ /' $ V()/W. $ X'( $ 5U/ $ -(.5$

3UQ'+/(5.D$%U/Z)1-/01(&5$3.$A/$A'+(,-.$L/(1$;.-3-.$T$Y&3-(W&$)&5$)1/1'1$3UQ&++.9$.1$0&++.50.$T$

3.))(5.- $ '5 $ +&53. $ &[ $ A.) $ 0Q&).) $ )&51 $ 3(LL(0(A.+.51 $ (3.51(L(/ZA.)9 $ LA&'.)9 $ )/5) $ 32A(+(1/1(&5)$

0&+;-2Q.5)(ZA.)D$

Page 90: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

C&'1.$A/$L(5$3'$L(A+$).-/$)&')$A/$+/-X'.$3.$0.11.$21-/5W.$.1$1.--(ZA.$;.-1.$3.$).5)D$%.)$-'.)$3.$

%&53-.)$)&51$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$L(A+2.)$T$0&51-.*S&'-9$1-/5)L&-+/51$A.)$Q&++.)$.5$)(AQ&'.11.)$h$A.$

Z-&'(AA/-3$-.53$AU.);/0.$/Z)1-/(19$(+;/A;/ZA.$h$A.)$&+Z-.)$3.$AU.)0/A(.-$3.))(5.51$3.)$+&1(L)$.LL-/O/51)$

.1$)/5)$L&53.+.51)D$%.$+&53.$3'$G,$/01.$)&+Z-.$3/5)$A/$L&A(.$h$A/$320/3.50.$/--(V.$T$'5$;&(51$3.$

5&5*-.1&'-9$&[$(A$5UO$/$;A')$3.$Z/--(,-.)9$;A')$3.$A(+(1.)$.51-.$A.)$0Q&).)D$%U&Z)0'-(12$.1$A/$A'+(,-.$

3(LL')2.$;/-$A.$Z-&'(AA/-3$L')(&55.51$A.$+&53.$.5$.51(12)$(50&55'.)9$(50&+;-2Q.5)(ZA.)$;&'-$AU&.(A$.1$

A.$0.-V./'$Q'+/(5D$".$-.)1.$X'U'5$0Q/&)$3.$A'+(,-.$.1$3U&Z)0'-(129$&[$1&'1$).$+fA.9$0&++.$/V/51$

X'.$B(.'$5.$320(3.$3.$A.)$)2;/-.-D$%/$320/3.50.$3.$%&'A&'$+,5.$3&50$T$'5.$3.)1-'01(&5$3'$+&53.$

(51.AA(W(ZA.$X'($5&')$-/+,5.$T$'5$/V/51$3.$AUQ&++.9$'5$21/1$3.$;.-0.;1(&5$;-.+(.-$3'$+&53.9$&[$

1&'1$5U.)1$X'.$;'A)(&5)9$L&-+.)9$A'+(,-.)$.1$;A')$-(.5$5U/$3.$).5)D$

%.$1.+;)$X'.$32;.(51$A/$A'+(,-.$3.$+,-),-9$0U.)1$0.A'($3U'5.$320/3.50.$+&-/A.$.1$Q'+/(5.$

&[$A.)$0Q&).)$;.-3.51$A.'-$(51.AA(W(Z(A(12D$#/5)$-,WA.)$5($A(+(1.)9$)/5)$0&+;/))(&5$;&'-$)&5$;-&0Q/(59$

A/$)&0(212$&[$2V&A'.$%&'A&'$)&+Z-.$3/5)$A/$L&A(.$A/$;A')$1&1/A.9$S')X'UT$A/$3.)1-'01(&5$3.$1&'1$).5)D$

!5$0.))/51$3U/W(-$.5$0&-;)$&-3&552$;/-$A/$A&(9$A.$+&53.$3.$%&'A&'$-.V(.51$T$'5$21/1$;-.+(.-9$'5$21/1 $

3U.5L/50.$&[$).'A.)$0&+;1.51$A.)$;'A)(&5)$.1$&[$A/$0(V(A()/1(&5$/$1&1/A.+.51$3();/-'.D

Page 91: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51
Page 92: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+*)+-#-@/+).+2)+,'('72)+C+2)+92&..)6)$.+<)+2;'$</-'('&$H

#($A.$+&53.$3.$%&'A&'$L(5(1$;/-$)&+Z-.-$3/5)$A/$L&A(.$A/$;A')$1&1/A.9$A.$LA&11.+.51$3'$).5)$.1$

3.)$ (51.51(&5)$3.) $;.-)&55/W.)$0/-/012-().9 $ A'(9 $ AU.5).+ZA.$3'$L(A+D $%.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$%&'A&'$/$

A/-W.+.51$212$0&++.512$.1$(51.-;-2129$0/-$.AA.$;&)),3.$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3.$LA&11/519$3U(5)/()())/ZA.D$

o/0X'.)$%&'-0.AA.$20-(1$3/5)$)&5$("32",11$"#&'(-'3"1@4$'M$

^$%.)$)(W5(L(0/1(&5)$X'.$1-&'V,-.51$A.)$.R2W,1.)$/'$;.-)&55/W.$3.$%&'A&'$E.19$T$

1-/V.-)$A'(9$T$A/$;.-)&55/A(12$3.$%&'().$<-&&`)F$)&51$5&+Z-.').)9$V/-(2.)9$;/-L&()$

0&51-/3(01&(-.)D $!AA.) $ -.LA,1.51 $ A/ $ )'ZS.01(V(12 $V/-(2. $3.) $);.01/1.'-) $.5$;-&(.$T$

AU25(W+.$3.$0.$V()/W.$A()).9$.50/3-2$;/-1$A.$02A,Z-.$0/)X'.$3.$0Q.V.'R$5&(-)9$X'.$A/$

)'00.))(&5 $ 0Q/5W./51. $ 3.) $ 2+&1(&5) $ -/+,5. $ 1&'S&'-) $ T $ '5. $ (+;/))(Z(A(12$

1-&'ZA/51.D$a50/-5/1(&5$A(Z.-1/(-.$.1$/5/-0Q()1.$3.$AU/+&'-$L&'$.1$3.$A/$-2V&A1.$)/5)$

0&+;-&+() $ 0&51-. $ A/ $ )&0(2129 $ L2+(5()1. $ /V/51 $ A/ $ A.11-. $ &' $ Z(.5 $ Q2-&{5.$

(50/53.)0.51. $ 3. $ +2A&3-/+.9 $ V(01(+. $ 3.) $ Q&++.) $ .1 $ 3U'5. $ +&-/A. $ .5$

;'1-2L/01(&59$%&'A&'$/$)'-V20'$1-(&+;Q/A.+.51$T$1&'1.)$0.)$(51.-;-21/1(&5)@@D$_$

' +,-),-$ .)1 $'5$L(A+$&[$A/$;)O0Q&A&W(.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$5U.)1$S/+/()$.R;A(X'2.$;/-$A/$;/-&A.D$%.$

);.01/1.'-$1.51.$3.$323'(-.$A.)$(51.51(&5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.5$A.)$&Z).-V/519$.5$)0-'1/51$A.'-)$V()/W.)$

T$A/$-.0Q.-0Q.$3U'5$(53(0.$)'-$0.$X'U(A)$)U/;;-f1.51$T$L/(-.D$P/()$A.$L(A+$.)1$V&A&51/(-.+.51$1-&'ZA.9$

(5321.-+(5/ZA.D $%U(+/W.$3. $+,-),-$ .)1 $ A/-W.+.51$0&+;&)2.$3.$W-&)$;A/5)$3.$V()/W.)$M $0.A'($3.$

%&'A&'9 $ 1-&'ZA/51 $ 3. $Z./'129 $+/() $ 2W/A.+.51 $ 0.A'( $ 3' $B&01.'-9 $ 3&51 $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $ /11.53 $/V.0$

/5W&()). $3. $V&(- $.R;A&).- $ A/ $V(&A.50. $ h $0.A'( $3. $#0Q(W&A0Q9 $X'. $ A. $ ).5) $3'$+.5)&5W. $.1 $3.$ A/ $

3';A(0(12$-.53$/Z)&A'+.51$(+;2521-/ZA.$h$0.A'($3U:AK/$'5.$L&()$32W&i12$3.$AU.R()1.50.9$X'($).+ZA.$

f1-. $3.V.5'$'5. $0&X'(AA. $V(3.D $%. $ );.01/1.'- $ .)1 $ /' $;A') $;-&0Q. $3. $ AU2+&1(&59 $3.) $ (53(0.) $X'($

;&'--/(.51$S/(AA(-$3.$0.)$V()/W.)9$+/()$0.'R*0($)&51$0&51-/3(01&(-.)9$LA&11/51)9$1-&'ZA.)D$%.$W-&)$;A/5$

3.$V()/W.$0Q.s$=/Z)1$5.$).-1$;/)$T$)&'A(W5.-$'5.$2+&1(&5$&'$'5.$-2/01(&59$+/()$/'$0&51-/(-.$T$21&LL.-$

A.$+O)1,-.$3.$A/$0&5)0(.50.$X'U(A$/$)&')$A.)$O.'RD$=/Z)1$S&'.$;A.(5.+.51$)'-$0.11.$/+Z(W'{12$M$X'($A/ $

0&+1.)). $-.W/-3.*1*.AA.9 $+/5(L.)1.+.51$ S/A&').$3.V/51 $ A/ $0&+;A(0(12 $3.$%&'A&'$.1 $3U:AK/$k$#U(A$

)U/V,-.$X'.$0.$).-/$%&'A&'9$)(W5.$3U'5.$0.-1/(5.$+&3.-5(12$3.$+&.'-)$;&'-$AU2;&X'.9$A.$);.01/1.'-$).$

3.+/53.$3U/Z&-3$)U(A$5.$)U/W(1$;/)$3U:AK/9$QO;&1Q,).$A/$;A')$;A/')(ZA.$3/5)$'5$L(A+$3/1/51$3.$>?7JD$

c'.$)(W5(L(.51$A.)$-.W/-3)$/+&'-.'R$X'.$).$A/50.51$%&'A&'$.1$0.A'($X'($.)1$)';;&)2$f1-.$)&5$;,-.$k$

C.53-.)).$L(A(/A.$&'$;.-V.-)(12$A/$;A')$0-/)).$k$c'.$).$;/)).*1*(A$3/5)$A/$1f1.$3.$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-9$X'.$

AU&5$V.--/$.5$W-&)$;A/5$'5$A&5W$+&+.51$k$!1$.5L(59$X'.$;.5).$%&'A&'$k$%&'A&'$X'($T$)&5$;-&0,)$;&'- $

@@ %&'-0.AA.)9$o/0X'.)9$)&'("32",11$"#&'(-'3"1@4$9$V&AD@9$=/-()9$YD%/LL&519$0&AAD$<&'X'(5)9$788@

Page 93: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+.'-1-.9$32V&(A.$).)$)&'-(-.)$A.)$;A')$)23'01.'-)$.1$A.)$;A')$0/-5/))(.-)$)/5)$;/-/n1-.$2;-&'V.-$A/ $

+&(53-.$0'A;/Z(A(12$k$%&'A&'$X'(9$-/V(.9$)U/Z/53&55.$3/5)$A.)$Z-/)$3.$)&5$;-.+(.-$0A(.51$.5$-(/51$k

%U.)).51(.A $3'$320&';/W.$3. $%&'A&'$.)1 $0&5)1(1'2 $3.$0Q/+;$0&51-.$0Q/+;D $%.)$20Q.AA.)$

0Q/5W.519 $ A.)$;.-)&55/W.) $Z&'W.51 $3/5)$ A. $0/3-.9 $+/()$0U.)1 $ A. $ -.W/-3$3.) $;.-)&55/W.) $AU'5$)'-$

AU/'1-.$X'($+&1(V.$A.$0Q/5W.+.51$3.$;A/5D$#0Q(W&A0Q$-.W/-3.$%&'A&'$3/5).-9$A.$3&01.'-$A.$320&'V-.$

0/0Q2$)'-$)&5$Z/A0&5$h$%&'A&'$/;.-\&(1$A/$5&'V.AA.$L(/502.$3'$3&01.'-$#0Q&5$.1$0.$).-/$.5)'(1.$T$.AA.$

3Uf1-.$V'.9$.+Z-/))/51$A.$3&01.'-$3/5)$A/$-2).-V.$h$A.$3&01.'-$)'-;-.53$A.)$3.'R$0/+/-/3.)$3.$%&'A&'$

3/5)$)/$0Q/+Z-.$;'()$)&5$;-&;-.$L(A)$0&'0Q2$)'-$A.)$W.5&'R$3.$%&'A&'$h$A.$+/-X'()$-.0&55/n1$%&'A&'$

3/5)$A.$1-/(5$h$:AK/$.)1$/11-/;2$.5$1-/(5$3.$1-(0Q.-$h$%&'A&'$L(R.$/+&'-.').+.51$A.$V()/W.$3.$o/0`$

Am|V.51-.'-D$%.$-.W/-3$.1$A/$V'.$&51$'5.$;A/0.$;-2;&532-/51.$3/5) $+,-),-D$%.$);.01/1.'-$.)1$)/5)$

0.)). $ 0&5L-&512 $ T $ 0.) $ V()/W.) $ ;.-0.V/51) $+/() $ (+;2521-/ZA.)9 $ 3/5) $ AU/11.51. $ 3U'5. $ /01(&5 $ 3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$X'($V(.55.$3&55.-$'5$).5)$T$0.$+O)1,-.D$P/()$AU/01(&5$.AA.*+f+.9$Z-'1/A.9$-/;(3.9$.)1$

)&'-0.$3m/+Z(W'{12)D

%.)$1-&()$+.'-1-.)$;-2).51)$3/5) $+,-),-9$(50/-5/1(&5$.5L(5$V()(ZA.$3.)$;'A)(&5)$(512-(.'-.)$

3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$)&51$-.;-2).512)$3.$1-&()$+/5(,-.)$3(LL2-.51.)$.5$'1(A()/51$A.$Q&-)$0Q/+;$.1$.5$

-.53/51$1-&'ZA.$A.$32-&'A.+.51$3.)$L/(1)D$B/5)$A.$0/)$3'$+.'-1-.$3'$3&01.'-9$AU/+&-0.$3.$)&5$2;/'A.$

0/0Q.$.R/01.+.51$1&'1.$AU/01(&5$/'$);.01/1.'-D$#.'A.$A'($;/-V(.51$AU.R;-.))(&5$/;.'-2.$3.$%&'A&'$.19 $

)&'3/(59$A/$L'+2.$X'($/55&50.$X'.$A.$0&';$.)1$;/-1(D$%.$);.01/1.'-9$1&'1$.5$/O/51$/))()12$T$A/$)0,5.9 $

).$1-&'V.$3&50$3/5)$A/$+f+.$;&)(1(&5$X'U:AK/9$(50.-1/(5$3.$AU(55&0.50.$3.$%&'A&'D$%U'5$3U.51-.$.'R$

/*1*(A$/;;'O2$)'-$A/$We0Q.11.$;/-$.--.'-$&'$%&'A&'$/*1*.AA.$;-&L(12$3.$AU&00/)(&5$;&'-$/))/))(5.-$A. $

3&01.'-$k$#&5$/Z).50.$3.$0'A;/Z(A(12$A&-)$3'$;-&0,)$.1$)&5$.51Q&')(/)+.$T$;-&L(1.-$3.$A/$+/()&5$

X'U.AA.$/9$.5L(59$A.$3-&(1$3U&00';.-$)/5)$32;.53-.$3.$;.-)&55.9$A/$-.53.51$)');.01.D$t$5&'V./'9$A.$

);.01/1.'-$).$-.1-&'V.$0&5L-&512$T$)&5$V()/W.$(5320Q(LL-/ZA.D$%.$+&+.51$3.$AU/01(&5$X'($/'-/(1$;'$A'($

3&55.-$A/$-2;&5).$/$3();/-'$3.--(,-.$AU2;/'A.$2;/()).$3'$3&01.'-D$%U/01(&5$5.$-2)&'1$;/)$A.$+O)1,-.D$

%.$).0&53$+.'-1-.$.)1$0.A'($3.$Y&3-(W&$;/-$A/$0&+1.)).D$%.$);.01/1.'-$/))()1.$/'$32Z'1$3.$

AU/W-.))(&59$.1 $/'$0&5)1/1 $3.$A/$+&-1$3.$Y&3-(W&$M$AU.)).51(.A $3.$AU/01(&5$1&+Z.$3/5)$AU.AA(;).D$%.$

+O)1,-.$;A/5.$)'-$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3.$A/$0&+1.)).9$3&51$A.$);.01/1.'-$)/(1$L(5/A.+.51$;.'$3.$0Q&).)$.1$

X'($).+ZA.$3U'5$5/1'-.A$0/A+.$.1$;A/0(3.D$aA$A/$-.1-&'V.$3.V.5'.$QO)12-(X'.$)'(1.$T$)&5$/W-.))(&5$;/-$

Y&3-(W&$M$)/$L&A(.$20A/1.$3/5)$1&'1.$)/$V(&A.50.9$/V.0$'5.$L&-0.$X'($)'WW,-.$X'U.AA.$/$;'$V(V-.$'5$

1-/'+/1()+.$)(+(A/(-.$;/-$A.$;/))29$0.$X'($.R;A(X'.-/(1$2W/A.+.51$3.$+/5(,-.$'5$;.'$)(+;A()1.$)&5$

-.S.1$3.)$Q&++.)D$v[$/*1*.AA.$1-&'V2$A/$L&-0.$3.$1'.-$Y&3-(W&9$X'($).+ZA/(1$+/n1-().-$A/$)(1'/1(&59$A/$

Page 94: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

3&+(5/51$3.$1&')$).)$+')0A.)$k$%.$+O)1,-.$5U.)1$0.11.$L&()$;/)$)($.AA.$AU/$1'29$+/()$0&++.51$.AA.$AU/$

1'2D$

%.$1-&()(,+.$+.'-1-.$.)1$0.A'($3.$%&'A&'$;/-$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-D$](A+2$T$5&'V./'$.5$W-&)$

;A/5)9$A.)$321/(A)$3'$+.'-1-.$-.)1.51$Q&-)$0Q/+;D$%.$;A/5$3.$A/$+&-1$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$+/W5(L(X'.$h$

0&++.5\/51$)'-$A.$V()/W.$T$AU/Z/53&5$3.$%&'A&'9$A.$0/3-.$-.)1.$'5$1.+;)$(++&Z(A.9$A/())/51$o/0`$

Am|V.51-.'-$Z/)0'A.-$)&5$0&-;)$V.-)$A.$L&53$3'$;A/5$1&'1$.5$AU.+Z-/))/51D$t$5&'V./'$0/0Q2.$;/-$

AU2;/'A.$3'$1'.'-9$).'A.$A/$+/(5$3.$%&'A&'$).$321/0Q.$)'-$A/$L&-+.$&Z)0'-.$3'$3&)$3.$o/0`9$/W-(;;2. $

)'-$A.$3&)$3.$)&5$Z&'--./'9$3/5)$'5$+&'V.+.51$3U21-.(51.D$%/$0/+2-/$-.)1.-/9$L(R.9$)'-$0.11.$+/(5$

A.51.+.51$ 1-/V.-)2.$3.$);/)+.)9 $).'A$)(W5.$V()(ZA. $3.$AU/))/))(5/1$.5$1-/(5$3.$).$0&++.11-.D $v5$

5U/))()1.-/$;/)$/'$0Q/5W.+.51$3U.R;-.))(&5$3.$%&'A&'$M$)&5$V()/W.$)&'-(/51$).-/$A/$3.-5(,-.$(+/W.$

3U.AA.D $%.$+O)1,-.$X'.$0&5)1(1'.$A.$;.-)&55/W.$-.)1.$.51(.-D $%&'A&'$)&'LL-/51.9 $%&'A&'$Q'+/(5.9$

%&'A&'$;.-3/51 $)/$ L&( $.5$ AUQ'+/5(12 $.)1 $'5.$ (+/W.$X'.$ A. $);.01/1.'- $5. $V.--/ $;/)D $ aA $3.V-/ $).$

0&51.51.-$3'$)&'V.5(-$3.$)&5$)&'-(-.$25(W+/1(X'.D$

%. $Q&-)*0Q/+;$3())(+'A. $ AU.R;A(0/1(&59 $+.1 $ T $3()1/50. $ A.) $ -2;&5).) $/'RX'.AA.) $ /);(-. $ A.$

);.01/1.'-$L-')1-29$1/53()$X'.$A.)$20Q/5W.)$3.$-.W/-3)$/'$).5)$(5321.-+(52$.1$LA&11/51$/;;/-/()).51$T$

AU20-/5D $%/$).0&53.$0Q&).$X'($L-/;;.$A.$);.01/1.'-9$0U.)1$A/$-2;/-1(1(&5$3.)$1.+;)$.51-.$0.)$3.'R$

+&+.51)$3.$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3-/+/1(X'.$M$A.)$;A/5)$3.$-.W/-3)$3'-.519$).$-2;,1.519$A/()).51$)U(5)1/AA.-$

A. $)');.5).9 $ 1/53()$X'.$ A. $+&+.51$3'$+.'-1-. $.)1 $ 1&'S&'-)$V(L9 $ (++23(/19 $ L'O/51D $%.$ 1.+;)$3.$

AU(5321.-+(5/1(&5 $ 3&+(5. $ A. $ L(A+9 $ A. $ -.53/51 $ (5)/()())/ZA.D $ %/ $ V(&A.50. $ 20A/1. $ ;/- $ T*0&';)9$

L&'3-&O/51.9$0/0Q2.9$5.$-2)&AV/51$-(.5$3.$A/$V&A&512$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$&'V-/51$A/$X'.)1(&5$3U'5$

+O)1,-.$;A')$W-/53$M$0.A'($3'$+/A$)'-$1.--.$.1$3.$AU(++&-/A(12$3.)$Q&++.)D

( *#+9#(-'$#.'&$+8&1"+2)+6#2

v5$;.'1$)2;/-.-$0.)$W-&)$;A/5)$.5$3.'R$0/12W&-(.)D$aA$O$/$0.'R$X'($5&')$A(V-.51$A/$-2/01(&5$3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)9 $ )( $ /+Z(WÇ. $ )&(1*.AA.9 $ +/() $ -.)1.51 $ (512W-2) $ /' $ +&51/W. $ 3. $ +/5(,-. $ LA'(3. $ .1$

1-/5);/-.51.D$!1$(A$O$/$0.'R$X'($).+ZA.51$L/(-.$)U/--f1.-$A.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+$.1$;&-1.-$'5.$)(W5(L(0/1(&5$

;/-1(0'A(,-.D $4.) $;A/5)*0( $&51 $X'.AX'. $0Q&). $3U21-/5W.9 $X'( $ )/'1. $ /'R$O.'R $3' $ );.01/1.'-D $C-&;$

;-&0Q.)9$1-&;$L-&51/'R9$;&-1.'-)$3U.LL.1)$A'+(5.'R$/;;'O2)DDD$aA)$).$321/0Q.51$;/-$A.'-$(51.5)(12D$%.$

V()/W.$3.$%&'A&'9$L(A+2$1-,)$L-&51/A9$-.W/-3*0/+2-/9$T$1-/V.-)$A.$L(A1-.*0-&))$h$%&'A&'$).$Z/A/5\/51$/'$

Z-/)$3.$Y&3-(W&9$;A/5$)&'3/(5$3.$.R/W2-2+.51$-/;;-&0Q2$h$%&'A&'$).$-/;;-&0Q/51$3U:AK/$h$A.$0&'$3.$

%&'A&'$;A.'-/519$&Z).-V2$;/-$A.$3&01.'-D$4.)$;A/5)$&51$;&'-$;&(51$0&++'5$3.$V.5(-$0&5)1(1'.-$'5$

Page 95: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+&+.51$1-&'ZA.9$.+;-'51$3U/+Z(W'{12$.1$3.$32)(-D$aA)$0&--.);&53.51$T$3.)$+&+.51)$&[$A/$;/))(&5$

AU.+;&-1.9$/'*3.AT$3.$1&'1.)$A.)$0&5V.51(&5)D$%&'A&'$/LL(-+.$X'U:AK/$.)1$A.$).'A$Q&++.$/V.0$A.X'.A$

.AA.$5U/'-/$;/)$3UQ()1&(-.9$+/()$A.'-$-.W/-3$AU'5$V.-)$AU/'1-.$3(1$1&'1$A.$0&51-/(-.D$%.$;A/5$)'-$A.$3&)$3. $

%&'A&' $ .)1 $ A/ $+/-X'. $ 3' $ 32)(- $ (--2;-.))(ZA. $ 3' $ 3&01.'-D $ %. $ V()/W. $ 3. $ %&'A&' $ (5V(1/51 $ o/0`$

Am|V.51-.'-$3/5)$)/$0Q/+Z-.$.)1$0.A'($3.$)&5$/+&'-$).5)'.AD$#($0.)$;A/5)$L-/;;.51$A.$);.01/1.'-9$0U.)1$

;/-0.$X'U(A)$V(.55.51$0&';.-$AU/01(&5D$".$0&--.);&53/51$;/)$T$'5$+&3,A.$3.$+&51/W.$1-/5);/-.519 $

LA'(3.$0&++.$3/5)$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&;$0.)$W-&)$;A/5)$0-2.51$'5.$Z'AA.$3.$1.+;)$Q&-)$3.$0.A'($3'$L(A+9$

V(.55.51$0-2.-$'5$+&+.51$X'U(A)$()&A.51$3.$A/$0&51(5'(12D$%.$1.+;)$3.$0.)$W-&)$;A/5)$3.$V()/W.)9$3. $

0.)$-.W/-3)$;A.(5)$3.$32)(-)$.)1$'5$1.+;)$T$;/-19$'5.$Z'AA.$&[$A.$1.+;)$).$W,A.$'5$0&'-1$(5)1/51D$%.$

1.+;)$).+ZA.$).$)');.53-.D$$

$

%.$+.'-1-.$3.$%&'A&'$;/-$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-$)U21(-.$3/5)$A.$1.+;)$M$A.$0Q/+;$0&51-.*0Q/+;$

.51-.$A.$V()/W.$3.$o/0`9$32L&-+2$;/-$A/$L&A(.9$.1$'5.$(+/W.$3.$)/$+/(59$)U/;;-&0Q/51$3'$0&'1./'$). $

-2;,1.$3.$5&+Z-.').)$L&()9$3(A/1/51$A.$+&+.51$3/5)$'5$.LL.1$0A/))(X'.$3.$+&51/W.$/A1.-52D$%.)$;A/5)$

)'-$%&'A&'$)U25.-V/51$3/5)$A.)$0&'A()).)$3'$1Q2e1-.$.1$Z/11/51$3.)$;(.3)9$)&51$21(-2)$).A&5$A/$+f+.$

A&W(X'.$M$A/$0/+2-/$)U/11/-3.$'5.$L&()$)'-$).)$S/+Z.)9$'5.$L&()$)'-$)&5$3&)9$'5.$L&()$)'-$)&5$V()/W.$.1 $

-2;,1.$/(5)($'5$1.+;)$X'(9$L(A+2$/V.0$3/V/51/W.$3.$-.0'A9$/'-/(1$;'$f1-.$-23'(1$/'$1(.-)D$%.)$;A/5)$X'( $

V(.55.51$)');.53-.$'5$20Q/5W.$3.$-.W/-3)$.51-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$E#0Q(W&A0Q$.1$%&'A&'$3/5)$AU/01.$>9$

%&'A&'$.1$:AK/$3/5)$AU/01.$7F$/AA&5W.51$3.$+f+.$A/$1.+;&-/A(12$3.$A/$)0,5.$.5$(51.--&+;/51$AU/01(&5D$

%U')/W.$3'$W-&)$;A/5$/$3/5)$+,-),-$A/$+f+.$L&501(&5$X'.$A.$-/A.51(D$aA$V(.51$32+'A1(;A(.-$A.$+&+.51$

3.$AU/01(&5$.1$.5$L/(-.$'5$+&+.51$T$;/-19$&[$A.$1.+;)$).$3(A/1.D$

Page 96: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51
Page 97: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ 4.)$;A/5)$&51$2W/A.+.51$.5$0&++'5$3.$0&51.5(-$'5.$W-/53.$V(&A.50.$&'$3.$;-&3'(-.$'5$

+/A/().$0Q.s$A.$);.01/1.'-D$aA)$)&51$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$/))&0(2)$T$3.)$+.5)&5W.)$E%&'A&'$X'($;-21.53$

/;;-20(.- $:AK/$;/-0. $X'U(A $5.$ 1.51.$;/)$3.$ A/ $)23'(-.9 $%&'A&'$.1 $#0Q(W&A0Q $3&51 $ A/ $ -.A/1(&5$.)1$

/+Z(W'qF$h$T$3.)$+&+.51)$T$A/$).5)'/A(12$21-/5W.)$E%&'A&'$).$;.53/51$/'$Z-/)$3.$Y&3-(W&$h$%&'A&'$

).$;-&)1(1'/51F$M$T$'5.$W-/53.$V(&A.50.$EA/$W-(+/0.$3.$L&A(.$3.$o/0`$Am|V.51-.'-FD$C&')$0.)$+&+.51)$

&51$3&50$;&'-$;&(51$0&++'5$A.$)'-W()).+.51$3'$+/A9$3'$;20Q29$3.$AU(++&-/AD$#&'3/(59$A.$1.+;)$

)U/--f1.$3/5)$A/$0&51.+;A/1(&5$3'$+/AD$%/$1.+;&-/A(12$3'$L(A+$V/$3.$;/(-$/V.0$0.$X'($-&5W.$A.$+&53. $

L(01(L$3.$%&'A&'$M$A.$-.1&'-$;.-;21'.A$3'$+/A9$.1$AU/11-/01(&5$+&-Z(3.$X'U(A$;-&V&X'.D$%/$L/)0(5/1(&5$

3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;&'-$A/$V(&A.50.9$;&'-$A.$).R.$.1$;&'-$AU/-W.51$V(.51$-/A.51(-$A.$32-&'A.+.51$5&-+/A$

3.)$0Q&).)9$-.53-.$A.)$L-&51(,-.)$;A')$LA&'.)9$A.)$0Q&).)$;A')$Z-(AA/51.)D$4&++.$3/5)$'5$21/1$).0&539 $

A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$).$A/()).51$QO;5&1().-$.1$0.A/$).$1-/3'(1$T$AU(+/W.$;/-$0.)$W-&)$;A/5)$21-/5W.)9$1&')$

3(LL2-.51)9$+/()$32W/W./51$'5.$(+;-.))(&5$3U21-/5W.129$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3.$+&5)1-'.'RD

%/$V(&A.50.$V(.51$2W/A.+.51$3'$L/(1$X'.$0.)$W-&)$;A/5)9$0&';.51$A.$0&-;)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$

0&++.$)U(A$21/(1$1-&5\&5529$320&';2$.5$+&-0./'RD$4.1$.LL.1$.)1$Z./'0&';$'1(A()2$)'-$%&'A&'9$3&51$

AU(+/W.$0&';.$-2W'A(,-.+.51$3.)$;/-1(.)$M$A.)$;(.3)$.1$A/$1f1.$3/5)$AU/01.$>9$A.$3&)$.1$A.)$S/+Z.)$3/5) $

AU/01.$@9 $ A/ $ 1f1.$.1 $ A.)$+/(5)$3/5)$AU/01.$GD$%/$+/5(,-.$3.$0/3-.-$ (5V(1.$T$).51(- $ A/$V(&A.50.$3.) $

-/;;&-1)9$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)U.5V()/W./51$5&5$;/)$0&++.$3.)$f1-.)$Q'+/(5)9$+/()$0&++.$3.)$&ZS.1)9$

X'.$AU&5$;.'1$'1(A().-$.1$321-'(-.$.5$1&'1.$A(Z.-12D$aA$5U.)1$;/)$'5$Q/)/-3$X'.$%&'A&'$)&(1$0.AA.$X'(9$A. $

;A')9$)'Z(1$0.$1-/(1.+.51D$].++.9$&ZS.1$3.$1&')$A.)$32)(-)9$.1$3.$1&'1.)$A.)$0&5V&(1().)9$A.)$Q&++.)$

3'$L(A+$0Q.-0Q.51$.5$;.-+/5.50.$T$).$AU/;;-&;-(.-D$aA) $AU&Z).-V.51$5&5$0&++.$'5$1&'1$+/()$;/-$

;/-1(.)9$).A&5$A.'-)$;-&;-.)$32)(-)$.1$A.'-)$;-&;-.)$(512-f1)D$C/51$.1$)($Z(.5$X'U.AA.$L(5(-/$;/-$f1-. $

-2.AA.+.51$/W-.))2.$/'$0&'1./'$3/5)$A/ $L(01(&59 $o/0`$Am|V.51-.'- $ 1-/5)L&-+/51$.5$/01.$0.$X'.$A.$

320&';/W.$-2V2A/(1$3.)$L/51/)+.)$+&-Z(3.)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D

%.$1.+;)$3.$%&'A&'$.)1$'5$1.+;)$-O1Q+2$;/-$'5.$/+Z(W'{12$0&5)1/51.9$3.)$0&-;)$320&';2)$

)&')$AU.LL.1$3'$-.W/-3$.1$'5$32)(-$A/1.51$&+5(;-2).51D$4.11.$1.5)(&5$)&'-3.$3&55.$AU(+;-.))(&5$X'.$

AUQ()1&(-. $ /V/50. $ 0&++. $ 3/5) $ 3' $ 0&1&5D $ %.) $ /01(&5) $ )&51 $ 320&55.012.) $ 3. $ A.'-) $+&1(V/1(&5)$

;)O0Q&A&W(X'.)9 $A.)$(51.51(&5)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$LA&'.)9$(+;-2V()(ZA.)$M$A.$);.01/1.'-$+/-0Q.$

0&++.$3/5)$'5$Z-&'(AA/-3D$%.$1.+;)$.)1$-/A.51(9$.53&-+(9$A.$+&53.$3.$%&'A&'$-.)1.$(5)&53/ZA.D$t$

AU&;;&)2$0&+;A.1$3.$A/$0A/-12$/;;/-.51.$3.$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$&[$1&'1$.)1$LA'(3.9$.1$L(A.$/V.0$-2W'A/-(129$

%&'A&'$.)1$.+;-.(51$3.$+O)1,-.D$%/$V(V/0(12$5.$).$-.1-&'V.-/$X'.$3/5)$A.)$+&+.51)$3.$V(&A.50.9$

+/()$).-/$1.AA.+.51$-/;(3.$X'UT$;.(5.$;.-0.;1(ZA.9$T$;.(5.$V()(ZA.D$4&++.$A/$L&'3-.$)U/Z/11/51$)'-$'5$

/-Z-.9$A/$V(&A.50.$&'V.-1.$5&')$20A/(-.$'5$1-,)$Z-.L$(5)1/51$;&'-$5&')$-.;A&5W.-$(++23(/1.+.51$3/5)$

AU&Z)0'-(12$A/$;A')$1&1/A.D$$

Page 98: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

(?K*.%,&'(3(

;*(/$90'9&(',(0'+(#$9J'#'1,+()'(/*#"&*()*1+(!%&*@'()'(0*(J%'

'

%/ $;-.+(,-. $0Q&). $X'( $ L-/;;. $ A. $ );.01/1.'- $3/5) $!"#$%& '(& ' )$ ' *"&9 $ 0U.)1 $ )&5 $/;;/-.51.$

5&-+/A(12D$o./5$B&'0Q.1$3()/(1$/V.0$Q'+&'-$3/5)$'5.$(51.-V.51(&5$T$A/$)'(1.$3U'5$0(520A'Z$0&5)/0-2$

/'$L(A+9$X'.$B&'WA/)$#(-`$/V/(1$0Q&()($A.$+.(AA.'-$0Q.L$&;2-/1.'-$3.$AU2;&X'.9$+/()$/V/(1$1-/V/(AA2$

;&'-$X'.$\/$5.$).$V&(1$;/)@HD$$

4'682)+).+$#.1")2+-&66)+2#+,')

#( $ AU'5(V.-) $ 3. $B&'WA/) $#(-` $ .)1 $ V()'.AA.+.51 $ ;A'1j1 $ 3' $ 0j12 $ 3. $ AU/-1(L(0.9 $ 3.) $ 0&'A.'-)$

20A/1/51.) $ .1 $3.) $ (512-(.'-) $ 0&X'.1)9 $ (A $ .)1 $ /)).s $Q/-+&5(.'R $;&'- $X'. $ A.) $ );.01/1.'- $ )UO $ A/()).$

;-.53-.D $%.)$0&'A.'-)$3. $!"#$%&'(&' )$ '*"&$ )&51 $&+5(;-2).51.)9 $'1(A()2.)$3/5) $ 1&'1.$ A.'-$0Q/-W.$

)O+Z&A(X'.$.1$.5$+f+.$1.+;)$;-.)X'.$(5V()(ZA.)$T$A/$;-.+(,-.$V()(&5$3'$L(A+D$t$AU(5V.-).$3.$A/$-&Z.$

-&'W.$V(L$3.$#0/-A.11$vUQ/-/$3/5)$.-2$12'&1'&4?,#2&')&'*&129$X'($5&')$)/'1.$/'R$O.'R$.1$5&')$/W-.)).$

3/5)$1&'1.$)/$0&55&1/1(&5$).R'.AA.9$A.)$0&'A.'-)$3' $!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&$ ).$).51.51$)/5)$).$V&(-D$%.)$

1.5'.)$3.)$/01-(0.)$).$+/-(.51$/V.0$A.)$L&53)9$).$-2;&53.51$&'$).$0&+;A,1.51$)/5)$S/+/()$)U(+;&).-$

/'$);.01/1.'-D$:55(.$.1$#')(.$3()0'1.51$/))().)$3/5)$AUQ.-Z.9$AU'5.$.5$ZA.'$0A/(-9$AU/'1-.$.5$S/'5.$V(L9 $

)'-$A.$)&A$V.-1$h$%&-/$.1$:55(.$.5$-&).$.1$.5$ZA.'$)'-$'5$L&53$ZA/50$h$#')(.9$;.1(1.9$.5$+/(AA&1$3.$Z/(5 $

ZA.'$)'-$A.$L&53$3'$;/-/)&A$&-/5W.$M$A.)$0&'A.'-)$).$0&+;A,1.51$&'$)U/))&0(.51$)/5)$S/+/()$;.-1'-Z.-D$

%.)$-/;;.A)$.51-.$A.)$1.5'.)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.$320&-$).$L&51$2W/A.+.51$3.$+/5(,-.$3()0-,1.9$+/() $

1-,)$;-20().$M$'5$/Z/1*S&'-$3.$A/$+f+.$0&'A.'-$X'.$A.$;'AA$3.$#')(.9$A.$+'-$S/'5.$3.$A/$+f+.$0&'A.'-$

X'.$#/-/Q*o/5.9$'5.$1/;()).-(.$Z&-3./'R$3.--(,-.$%&-/$.5$-&).D$%.)$0&'A.'-)$1-/V/(AA.51$AU.)1Q21(X'.$

3'$L(A+9$+/()$5U/;;/-/()).51$;/)$3.$+/5(,-.$-.+/-X'/ZA.D$%/$).5)/1(&5$.)1$0.AA.$3U'5.$/;;/-.51.$

5&-+/A(12$/'$).(5$+f+.$3'$0&+ZA.$3.$AU/-1(L(0(/A(12D$$

$

@H a51.-V.51(&5$-2/A()2.$A.$7>$5&V.+Z-.$78>7$/'$4.51-.$3.)$:-1)$3U!5WQ(.5*A.)*Z/(5)D$

Page 99: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51
Page 100: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ B.$A/$+f+.$L/\&59$A.$320&';/W.$.1$ A.$0/3-/W.$3'$L(A+$)&51$ 1-/V/(AA2)$3.$+/5(,-.$T$f1-.$

/Z)&A'+.51$(5V()(ZA.)9$T$AU&;;&)2$3.$1&'1.$1.51/1(V.$);.01/0'A/(-.$&'$V(-1'&).$)'-$AU(+/W.D$%/$0/+2-/$

.)1 $ T $ Q/'1.'- $ Q'+/(5.9 $ ;-.)X'. $ )O)12+/1(X'.+.51 $ 3/5) $ 3.) $ V/A.'-) $ 3. $ ;A/5 $+&O.55.) $ E;A/5$

/+2-(0/(59 $ &' $ ;A/5 $ Z')1.F $ /V.0 $ X'.AX'.) $ ;A/5) $ 3U.5).+ZA. $ ;&'- $ &'V-(- $ A/ $ )2X'.50.D $ 4.11.$

-.;-2).51/1(&59$T$A/$L&()$L/+(A(,-.$.1$1-,)$0&5V.51(&55.AA.9$3&55.$AU(+;-.))(&5$3U'5.$-.A/1(&5$5/1'-.AA.$

/V.0$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$%.)$;A/5)$A/()).51$A/$;A/0.$3/5)$A.$0/3-.$/'R$/01.'-)$3U2V&A'.-$M$A.)$V/A.'-)$3.$

;A/5)$0Q/5W.51$A&-)X'U(A)$)U/;;-&0Q.51$3.$A/$0/+2-/$&[$)U.5$2A&(W5.51D$%.)$+&'V.+.51)$3.$0/+2-/$

)&51$.)).51(.AA.+.51$3.)$;/5&-/+(X'.)9$X'($)'(V.51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3/5)$A.'-)$32;A/0.+.51)$h$1&'1$

.)1$L/(1$;&'-$;-(V(A2W(.-$AU/01(&5$.5$1-/(5$3.$).$32-&'A.-9$A.)$3(/A&W'.)$.1$A.)$(51.-/01(&5)$.51-.$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D$:5/AO)2$3.$+/5(,-.$)';.-L(0(.AA.9$A.$320&';/W.$/$;-.)X'.$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3.$AU&-3-.$3.$

A/$0/;1/1(&5D$a5V()(ZA.9$0A/))(X'.9$)'(V/51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$&'$A.)$/11-/;/51$.5$0Q/+;*0&51-.*0Q/+;9$

1&'1$).+ZA.$3U'5.$A()).'-$/Z)&A'.D$#.'A)$X'.AX'.)$+&+.51)$3'$L(A+$V(.55.51$Z-().-$0.11.$/Z)&A'.$

-2W'A/-(12D$

%.) $ X'.AX'.) $ 1-/V.AA(5W) $ ;-2).51) $ 3/5) $ A. $ L(A+ $ )&51 $ 1-,) $ 3()0-.1) $ .1 $ )'-V(.55.51 $ T $ 3.)$

+&+.51)$;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$(51.5).)$V20')$;/-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$%&-)X'.$#')(.$.1$#1..V.$V&51$3/5).-$h$

A&-)X'.$#/-/Q*o/5.$V/$T$)&5$-.53.s*V&')$/+&'-.'R$h$X'/53$:55(.$).$320(3.$T$-.53-.$V()(1.$T$#/-/Q*

o/5.$;&'-$A/$3.-5(,-.$L&()$/V/51$)/$+&-1$&'$A&-)X'.$#')(.$.1$%&-/$).$3();'1.51$AU/+&'-$3.$#1..V.D$4.$

)&51$3.)$+&+.51)$L&-1)9$3U2A/5)$/+&'-.'R$&'$;/))(&552)$M$A.$+&'V.+.51$.)1$(5V()(ZA.9$5&O2$3/5)$

AU(51.5)(12$3.$A/$)0,5.D

%/ $ ;/))(&5 $ .1 $ AU/11-/01(&5 $ ).'A.) $ ;.'V.51 $ L/(-. $ Z&'W.- $ A/ $ 0/+2-/ $3. $ )&5 $;(.3D $%U'5(X'.$

+&'V.+.51$X'($).-/9$A'(9$V()(ZA.9$V(-1'&).9$/$A(.'$A&-)$3.$AU.51.--.+.51$L(5/A$3U:55(.D$BU'5$;A/5$.5$

;A&5W2. $)'-$ A/ $ L&'A.9 $'5$+&'V.+.51$T $ A/ $W-'.$)'(1 $#/-/Q*o/5.$X'( $)U20Q/;;. $3'$;'ZA(0 $V.-) $ A.$

0.-0'.(A$.1$X'.$A/$0/+2-/$)'(1$h$.AA.$A/$-/11-/;.$1/53()$X'.$A/$S.'5.$L(AA.$).$L/(1$-/A.51(-$;/-$A/$;&A(0.9$.1 $

1.-+(5.$.5$;A/5$-/;;-&0Q2$)'-$.AA.9$ZA&11(.$0&51-.$A.$0.-0'.(AD$4U.)1$A/$+&-1$3U:55(.9$A/$;A')$W-/53.$

1-/W23(.$3'$L(A+9$X'($V(.53-/$L/(-.$20A/1.-$A/$)/W.$.1$1-/5);/-.51.$+().$.5$)0,5.D$

BU/'1-.)$;A/5)$321&55.519$.1$(A)$)&51$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$/))&0(2)$T$3.)$0Q&0)$V20')$;/-$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D$!5$0&51-.*;A&5W2.9$'1(A()/51$A/$-/+Z/-3.$3.$AU.)0/A(.-$0&++.$'5$;-.+(.-$;A/5$;&'-$

3&55.-$'5.$).5)/1(&5$3.$32)2X'(A(Z-.$1-,)$L&-1.9$(A)$1-/3'().51$'5$+/A/().$/Z).51$3'$-.)1.$3'$L(A+D$aA$O$

.5$/$1-&()$M$A&-)X'.$#')(.$-.53$V()(1.$T$#/-/Q*o/5.$/;-,)$A.$;(X'.*5(X'.$.1$X'.$0.AA.*0($2V&X'.$;&'-$A/$

;-.+(,-.$L&()$)/$-2Z.AA(&5$3/5)$A/$L/+(AA.$h$A&-)X'.9$S')1.$/;-,)$AU/W-.))(&5$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.9$:55(.$.1$

%&-/$3.)0.53.51$.5$1-&+Z.$A.)$+/-0Q.)$S')X'UT$.AA.$h$.5L(5$S')1.$/;-,)$X'.$#')(.$/(1$V'$)/$+,-.$

.+Z-/)).-$#1..V.D$%/$)2X'.50.$3.$AU/W-.))(&5$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$.)1$2W/A.+.51$+().$.5$)0,5.$3.$+/5(,-. $

Page 101: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

1-,)$);20(L(X'.D$aA$)U/W(1$3'$).'A$+&+.51$&[$A/$V(&A.50.$20A/1.$M$A/$+().$.5$)0,5.$LA'(3.$.1$2A2W/51.$3'$

-.)1.$3'$L(A+$5.$;.'1$;A')$f1-.$'1(A()2.$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.D$C/53()$X'.$A.$S.'5.$/+&'-.'R$3.$#/-/Q*

o/5.$)U/;;-&0Q.$3U.AA.9$A/$0/+2-/$).$321&'-5.$.1$A/$)0,5.$3.$AU/W-.))(&5$).$32-&'A.$3/5)$A.$-.LA.1$3.$A/$

V(1-(5.D$%/$0/+2-/$L(A+.-/$.5)'(1.$AU/W-.))(&5$.5$0Q/+;)$0&51-.$0Q/+;)9$.5$1-&()$;A/5)$1-,)$-/;(3.)9 $

+&512)$/'$-O1Q+.$3.)$0&';)D$t$5&'V./'9$A/$V(&A.50.$L/(1$20A/1.-$A/$-2W'A/-(12$3.$A/$+().$.5$)0,5.$.1$

0&51-/(51$A.$;&(51$3.$V'.$3.$0Q/5W.-9$)&'A(W5/51$A.$0/-/01,-.$(5)';;&-1/ZA.$3.$A/$)0,5.$.5$1-/(5$3.$).$

32-&'A.-D$aA$)U/W(1$AT$.5$1&'1$.1$;&'-$1&'1$3.)$+&+.51)$&[$A/$+().$.5$)0,5.$)&-1$3.$)&5$)O)1,+.$Z(.5 $

-&32$)'-$A.$1.+;)$3.$7Q$3.$L(A+D$%.$-.)1.$3'$1.+;)9$A/$LA'(3(12$3'$;/5&-/+(X'.$.1$AU(5V()(Z(A(12$3'$

-/00&-3$3/5)$AU/R.$)&51$3.$+().D$

%. $ L/51/)+. $3. $ A/ $ 0&51(5'(12 $ 1.+;&-.AA. $ ;-2).51. $ /' $5(V./' $3. $ A/ $ )1-'01'-. $3' $ L(A+ $ ).$

-.1-&'V.$3&50$T$AU20Q.AA.$3'$320&';/W.D$=/)$3U.AA(;).$/'$).(5$3.)$+f+.)$.);/0.)9$)($A.$1.+;)$;/)).9$

A.$;A/5$)'(V/51$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$)(1'2$3/5)$'5$/'1-.$A(.'D$!1$A.)$0&';.)$)&51$0&5)0(.50(.').+.51$

3())(+'A2.)D$%/$1.51/1(V.$3.$B&'WA/)$#(-`$.)1$3.$;-2).51.-$'5$1.+;)$L/'R9$/Z)&A'+.51$-.0&5)1(1'29$

+/()$X'($3&55.$'5.$).5)/1(&5$3.$0&51(5'(12D$$

*)+.)68(+9#-.'-)+<1+.@/I.")

4.11.$0&51(5'(129$0U.)1$0.AA.$3'$1Q2e1-.9$3&51$V(.51$T$AU&-(W(5.$B&'WA/)$#(-`D$%/$+().$.5$)0,5.$

2V&X'.$.5$.LL.1$;/-$Z./'0&';$3U/);.01)$0.AA.$3'$1Q2e1-.D$%/$0/+2-/$X'($5.$Z&'W.$;/)$3.$)&5$;(.39$

0U.)1$A.$;&(51$3.$V'.$L(R.$3'$);.01/1.'-$3.$1Q2e1-.D$%.)$;A/5)$3U.5).+ZA.$2V&X'.51$2W/A.+.51$3.) $

-.;-2).51/1(&5)$1Q2e1-/A.)D$](A+2)$.5$;(.3)9$0&+;&)/51$.1$320&+;&)/51$A.$0/3-.$;/-$A.'-)$1-/S.1)$3/5) $

A/$;-&L&53.'-$3'$0Q/+;$.1$3/5)$)/$A/-W.'-9$(A)$;&'--/(.51$;-.)X'.$2V&A'.-$)'-$'5.$)0,5.D$aA$/--(V.$

3U/(AA.'-)$X'.$0.)$;A/5)$)&(.51$A2W,-.+.51$/5W'A2$M$.5$0&51-.*;A&5W2.9$0.A/$-.)).+ZA.$T$'5$;&(51$3.$

V'.$)(1'2$3/5)$A/$L&)).$h$.5$;A&5W2.9$T$'5$;&(51$3.$V'.$)(1'2$3/5)$A.)$W-/3(5)D$d5$/'1-.$/);.01$X'($

2V&X'.$A.$1Q2e1-.$.)1$Z(.5$)i-$A.$L/(1$X'.$AU.)).51(.A$3'$L(A+$).$32-&'A.$.5$(512-(.'-$)1'3(&D$v5$5.$

V.--/$2W/A.+.51$;-/1(X'.+.51$S/+/()$A.$H,+.$+'-$3.$5&+Z-.'R$A(.'R$M$A.$;-.+(.-$/;;/-1.+.51$3.$

%&-/9$A.$Z'-./'$3.$%&&+()9$A.$)1'3(&$3.$;Q&1&9$A.)$0&'A()).)$3'$1Q2e1-.D$4.11.$3();&)(1(&5$3.$AU.);/0.$

-.5L&-0.$AU(+;-.))(&5$3U'5.$L/01(0(12$3'$3();&)(1(LD $C&'1$.)1 $LA'(3.9$5/1'-.A9 $.1 $.5$+f+.$1.+;)$A.$

);.01/1.'-$).51$'5.$L&-+.$3U/-1(L(0(/A(12$21-/5W.$.1$)&')*S/0.51.D$

Page 102: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51
Page 103: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ %. $ A/5W/W.$ 1Q2e1-/A $+.$).+ZA. $/'))( $/3/;12$3/5) $ A/ $+/5(,-. $3. $).) $32;A/0.- $X'U&51 $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D$4Q/X'.$/;;/-(1(&5$3.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$T$AU20-/5$/$X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3U'5.$.51-2.$3.$)0,5.D $

v5$A/$V&(1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$L-/50Q(-$A.)$;&-1.)9$.51-.-$3U'5$;/)$320(32$3/5)$A/$;(,0.$.1$3/5)$A.$;A/5D$

!AA.$-.51-.$3'$1-/V/(A9$;&')).$A/$;&-1.$3'$Z'-./'$3.$%&&+()9$)&-1$3.$)/$0Q/+Z-.9$3.)0.53$AU.)0/A(.-DDD$

!AA.$.)X'()).$A.$W.)1.$)O+Z&A(X'.$3U.51-.-$'5$5&+Z-.$(50/A0'A/ZA.$3.$L&()D$B.$;A')9$).)$.51-2.)$)&51$

/00&+;/W52.) $3U'5. $320&'V.-1. $ 3. $ AU.);/0. $ 2V&0/1-(0. $ 3' $ 1Q2e1-.D $B/5) $ A/ $ ;-.+(,-. $ ;/-1(.9 $ A.$

);.01/1.'-$320&'V-.$AU/;;/-1.+.51$3.$%&-/$/V.0$.AA.D$!AA.$.51-.$.1$V/$3U'5.$A/+;.$T$AU/'1-.9$/AA'+.-$

A/$;(,0.D$!AA.$+/-0Q.$0&++.$)'-$'5.$)0,5.9$.1$A/$0/+2-/$A/$)'(19$-2V2A/51$0&++.$/V.0$L(.-12$'5$

/;;/-1.+.51$.5$L(5$3.$0&+;1.$;.1(1$.1$A'W'Z-.D$d5.$)2X'.50.$L&501(&55/51$.5$-2L2-.50.$T$0.AA.*0($).$

-.1-&'V.$3/5)$ A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.9 $ A&-)X'.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$32/+Z'A.$3.$A/ $+f+.$+/5(,-.$3/5)$)/$

5&'V.AA.$3.+.'-.9$-.;&)(1(&55/51$A.)$&ZS.1)$320&-/1(L)$.1$3&55/51$3.)$&-3-.)$/'R$32+25/W.'-)D$4.11.$

+/5(,-.$3U2V&A'.-$3/5)$AU.);/0.9$3.$).$AU/;;-&;-(.-$;/-$A/$32/+Z'A/1(&5$+.$).+ZA.$1-,)$;-&;-.$/'$

1Q2e1-.$M$3/5)$A/$+/S&-(12$3.)$0/)9$AU.);/0.$)025(X'.$;-20,3.$AU/;;/-(1(&5$3.)$/01.'-)$.1$(A$A.'-$L/'3-/$

;/-0&'-(- $0.1 $.);/0. $;&'- $ AU(512W-.-D $%&-/ $P.-.3(1Q $).+ZA. $ L/(-. $ A/ $+f+.$0Q&).9 $ AU/01-(0. $.1 $ A.$

3();&)(1(L$3&55/51$AU(+;-.))(&5$3U'5$-.W/-3$);.01/1&-(.AD$%.$+&5&A&W'.$1Q2e1-/A$1-&'V.$2W/A.+.51$

)&5$2X'(V/A.51$3/5)$A.$0/3-.$.1$A.$;A/0.+.51$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$h$(A$5U.)1$;/)$-/-.$X'U(A)$)&(.51$;A/02)$.5$

;-.+(.-$;A/59$L/0.$0/+2-/9$1/53()$X'.$A.'-$(51.-A&0'1.'-$).$1-&'V.$3.--(,-.$.'R$.1$A.'-$;/-A.D$#/5)$

L/(-. $')/W.$3.$ A/ $;/-&A.9 $0. $ 1O;. $3.$;A/5)$'1(A(). $ A.) $);20(L(0(12) $3'$0(52+/$;&'- $-.;-&3'(-. $ A/ $

L&501(&5$3'$+&5&A&W'.D$%.$V()/W.$/'$;-.+(.-$;A/5$.R;-(+.$/'$);.01/1.'-$'5$).51(+.51$;.-)&55.A$3'$

;.-)&55/W.$)'-$0.$X'($.)1$.5$1-/(5$3.$;/)).-$h$A.$;.-)&55/W.$3/5)$)&5$3&)$5.$V&(1$;/)$A/$+f+.$0Q&).9$

.1$(W5&-.$AU2+&1(&5$X'($.)1$.5$1-/(5$3.$)'-V.5(-D$4&++.$3/5)$A.)$-.;-2).51/1(&5)$0/-(0/1'-/A.)$3.$

AU/01.'-$X'($).$0&'V-.$'5$0j12$3.$A/$Z&'0Q.$;&'-$)&'LLA.-$.5$/;/-12$X'.AX'.)$A(W5.)$/'$);.01/1.'-9$0.)$

2+&1(&5)*AT$)&51$)1-(01.+.51$3.)1(52.)$T$0.A'($X'($-.W/-3.$A.$L(A+D$d5$3.$0.)$;A/5)$V/$S')X'U/'$-.W/-3$

0/+2-/$3.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$A&-)X'U.AA.$;-&+.1$T$#')(.$3.$).$)/0-(L(.-$.1$3.$-.5&50.-$T$#1..V.9$0.$T$X'&( $

AU/AA')(&5$/'$1Q2e1-.$(-/$S')X'U/'$Z&'1$;'()X'.$#')(.$A'($-2;&53-/$^$B&5U1$;A/O$1Q.$+&1Q.-$_$E5.$S&'.$

;/)$A/$+,-.FD$

=A')$X'.$1&'19$A/$1.+;&-/A(12$3'$L(A+$)'(1$A.$-O1Q+.$3.)$3(/A&W'.)$.1$L.(51$A/$0&51(5'(12D$%.$

1.+;) $3. $!"#$%&'(& ' )$ '*"& '.)1 $0.A'( $3' $;-2).519 $3'$3(-.019 $3. $ AU(51.-/01(&5D $C&'S&'-) $T $Q/'1.'-$

3UQ&++.9$T$'5.$V(1.)).$X'($).+ZA.$5/1'-.AA.$/'$);.01/1.'-9$0/-$.AA.$.)1$(53'(1.$;/-$A.$1.+;)$3.$A/$

;/-&A.D$%.)$;A/5)$-.A/1(V.+.51$A&5W)9$3&55.51$AU/;;/-.50.$3U'5.$-.A/1(&5$5/1'-.AA.$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)$

.1$L&51$/00.;1.-$A/$L/01(0(12$3.$AU'5(V.-)$3.$#(-`D$P/()9$32ST9$1&'1$).+ZA.$1-&;$LA'(3.9$1-&;$A()).$;&'-$

f1-.$0-'D

Page 104: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

*#+")8"/()$.#.'&$+<;1$+6&$<)+0+<)1B+,'.)(()(

4. $ X'. $ -2V,A. $ AU/5/AO). $ 3' $ 0/3-/W.9 $ 0U.)1 $ X'. $ 0.11. $ 5&-+/A(12 $ ;-21.53'. $ .)1 $ .5 $ -2/A(12$

;Q/W&0O12.$;/-$'5.$.R1-f+.$V(&A.50.$)O+Z&A(X'.$/'$).(5$3.$A/$L/+(AA.D$%U/;;/-.51.$LA'(3(12$3.$A/$

0/+2-/$.)1$0&51-.3(1.$;/-$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3.)$0/3-.)9$X'(9$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$-2V,A.51$A.)$(5S')1(0.)9$

Q(2-/-0Q().51 $ A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9 $)&'A(W5.51 $ A.)$+.5)&5W.)D $=&'- $0&++.50.-9 $ A. $0/3-.$;&)),3.$'5$

A/5W/W.$)O)12+/1(X'.$3.$Q(2-/-0Q()/1(&5$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$%&-/$.)1$1&'S&'-)$/'$;-.+(.-$;A/59$&'$A/$

;A')$V()(ZA.D$!AA.$.51-/n5.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$A/$0/+2-/$/V.0$.AA.D$%.)$0&'A.'-)$X'U.AA.$;&-1.$)&51$

1&'S&'-)$A.)$;A')$V(V.)$&'$A.)$;A')$0A/(-.)D$t$AU(5V.-).9$:55(.$.)1$0/51&552.$/'$L&53$3'$;A/5$M$.AA.$

/;;/-/n1$3/5)$A.)$.+Z-/)'-.)$3.$;&-1.)9$3/5)$A/$;(,0.$3'$L&539$3.--(,-.$A.$;.1(1$)/A&5$&[$).$3()0'1.$A.$

L'1'-$3.$%&-/D$%&-)X'U.AA.$.)1$).'A.9$A.$+f+.$1-/(1.+.51$A'($.)1$(+;&)2.$M$.AA.$.)1$L(A+2.$;.-3'.$3/5)$

A/$L&'A.9$T$;.(5.$V()(ZA.$/'$;-.+(.-$/Z&-39$0/0Q2.$3/5)$A.)$0&'A()).)$&'$3.--(,-.$'5$;/-/V.51D$%U'5.$/ $

A.$3-&(1$3Uf1-.$V()(ZA.9$AU/'1-.$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$0/0Q2.D$%UQ()1&(-.$).$0&50.51-.$)'-$AU/V.5(-$3.$

%&-/9$X'($3.V(.51$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$-(0Q.$/'$L'-$.1$T$+.)'-.$X'U:55(.$)&+Z-.$3/V/51/W.$/'$).0&53$

V&(-$/'$1-&()(,+.$;A/5D$%&-)X'.$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3'$L(A+$-.V(.51$+.11-.$AU/00.51$)'-$AUQ()1&(-.$3U:55(.9$

A. $ ;.-)&55/W. $ /01(L $ .1 $ -2.AA.+.51 $ V()(ZA. $ 3.V(.51 $ #/-/Q*o/5.9 $ ;&'- $ A/X'.AA. $ .AA. $ ). $ 32).);,-.9$

(+;'())/51.D$

aA$O$/$3&50$'5.$-2.AA.$Q(2-/-0Q(.$L/(1.$.51-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;/-$A.'-$)(+;A.$;&)(1(&5$3/5)$A.$

;A/5D$%&-/$AU.+;&-1.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$)'-$1&')$A.)$/'1-.)$M$+f+.$A&-)X'U.AA.$.)1$/'$).0&53$;A/59$.AA.$

).$1-&'V.$3.$L/0.$/A&-)$X'.$A.)$/'1-.)$)&51$3.$;-&L(A$&'$)U/;;-&;-(.$A/$;A')$W-/53.$;/-1(.$3'$0/3-.D$

B/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$A.)$3.'R$;.1(1.)$L(AA.)$)&51$L(A+2.)$0&++.$3.)$)&')*;.-)&55.)$M$A/$0/+2-/$

5.$A.)$)'(1$S/+/()9$.AA.$A.)$-.50&51-.$0&++.$)/5)$A.$V&'A&(-$A&-)$3U'5$;/5&-/+(X'.$X'($)'(1$%&-/$&'$

0/;1.$A.'-)$32;A/0.+.51)$3/5)$A/$;-&L&53.'-$3'$0/3-.D$!AA.)$5.$).-&51$S/+/()$3/5)$A.$;A/5$)/5)$'5$

/3'A1.D$%.$+&+.51$&[$#/-/Q*o/5.$V(1$)/$W-/53.$Q'+(A(/1(&5$T$AU20&A.9$.AA.$(-/$).$-2L'W(.-$3/5)$)/$

0Q/+Z-.$.1$#')(.$1.51.-/$3.$A'($-.+&51.-$A.$+&-/A9$+/()$1&'1.$AU/01(&5$;/)).-/$Q&-)$0Q/+;)D$B.$

+f+.9$5.$).-/$;/)$L(A+2.$AU.R;2-(.50.$3.$#/-/Q*o/5.$-/0&512.$;/-$:55(.$T$%&-/D$%.$;&(51$3.$V'.$3.$

AU/3'A1.$3&+(5.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$.1$L/(1$&LL(0.$3.$-2L2-.50.$;&'-$-.1-/5)0-(-.$A.)$2V,5.+.51)$V20')D$

4.1$21/1$3.$L/(1$).$0&5L(-+.$A&-)$3.$A/$)2X'.50.$&[$#')(.$-/0&51.$A/$;-&+.5/3.$/'$;/-09$X'($).-/$

0&51-.3(1.$;/-$#/-/Q*o/5.D$

Page 105: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

!"#$%&'(#)%*+%,%(%-*.'+*(-*/'0+-

Page 106: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

d5.$L&()$/3'A1.)9$A/$Q(2-/-0Q(.$).$+&3(L(.$'5$;.'D$#')(.$AU.+;&-1.$)'-$A/$+&(1(2$5&(-.$3.$A/$

L/+(AA.D$%/$+().$.5$)0,5.$3.$)/$-.A/1(&5$/V.0$#/-/Q*o/5.9$3(LL,-.$.51-.$A.)$.53-&(1)$;'ZA(X'.)$.1$A.)$

.53-&(1) $;-(V2)D $t$ AU&;2-/ $&'$3/5) $ A.) $)&(-2.) $3. $)/ $+,-.9 $#/-/Q*o/5. $.)1 $ )O)12+/1(X'.+.51 $/'$

).0&53 $ ;A/5 $ h $ (++&Z(A. $ /A&-) $ #')(. $ ). $ 32;A/0.9 $ )(A.50(.'). $ /A&-) $ X'. $ #')(. $ ;/-A.D $ %&-) $ 3.)$

-.1-&'V/(AA.)$/V.0$#1..V.9$#/-/Q*o/5.$.51-.$;/-$A.$L&53$.1$#')(.9$/'$;-.+(.-$;A/59$A'($A/()).$3U/Z&-3$A/$

;A/0.$3.$)/A'.-$#1..V.D$P/()$.AA.$-.)1.$3/5)$A.$;A/5$.19$1-,)$-/;(3.+.519$V(.53-/$-.;-.53-.$)/$;A/0. $

3.V/51$#/-/Q*o/5.9$A/$0/0Q/51$T$+&(1(2D$B/5)$AU(51(+(129$A.)$-.A/1(&5)$)&51$3(LL2-.51.)$h$#/-/Q*o/5.$).$

L/(1 $&ZS.1$3.$-.W/-3$.1$#')(.9$A.$;&(51$3.$V'.D$#($A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3.$A/$3&+(5/1(&5$.)1$3(LL2-.51. $

E#/-/Q*o/5.$.)1$0.11.$L&()$A/$;A')$V()(ZA.F9$.AA.$-.)1.$;-2).51.$3.$+/5(,-.$;A')$;.-5(0(.').D$%&-)X'.$

#/-/Q*o/5.$.R;A(X'. $)&5$).51(+.51 $V() $T $V() $3. $)/ $0&53(1(&5 $ -/0(/A.9 $#')(. $ AU&Z).-V. $ (50-23'A.9$

0&++.$'5.$Zf1.$0'-(.').9$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$.)1$+()$3.$)&5$0j12D$#/-/Q*o/5.$.)1$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$

-.A2W'2.$;/-$A.$0/3-.$T$A/$;A/0.$X'.$A/$)&0(212$AU(5V(1.$T$;-.53-.D$a5'1(A.$3.$;-20().-$X'.$3/5)$0.$

0A/)).+.51$Q(2-/-0Q(X'.9$#/-/Q*o/5.$AU.+;&-1.$2W/A.+.51$)'-$)/$+,-.$M $3.$;./'$ZA/50Q.$.1$)/5)$

L&501(&5$3.$3&+.)1(X'.9$.AA.$A'($-.)1.$)';2-(.'-.D

%/$0/+2-/$).+ZA.$)U(512-.)).-$T$:55(.$T$).'A.+.51$3.'R$+&+.51)D$%/$L(59$Z(.5$)i-9$&[$A. $

L/)1. $ 3. $ AU.51.--.+.51 $ V(.51 $ )/1'-.- $ A. $ 0/3-. $3. $ );.01/1.'-) $ .1 $ 3. $ LA.'-)D $!1 $ A&-)X'U.AA. $ 320(3.9 $

X'.AX'.)$)2X'.50.)$/V/519$3U/AA.-$V&(-$#/-/Q*o/5.$;&'-$A/$3.-5(,-.$L&()D$!AA.$.5$;/-A.$/V.0$%&-/$.1$).$

-.1-&'V.$A.$V()/W.$/'$;-.+(.-$;A/5$*$%&-/$/'$).0&53$*$;&'-$A/$;-.+(,-.$L&()$3.$1&'1$A.$L(A+D$%.)$3.'R$

)2X'.50.)$L&501(&55.51$.5).+ZA.$M$A/$)2X'.50.$/55&50.$.5$.LL.1$A/$+&-1$3U:55(.$E.AA.$/$)&'3/(5$

0&5)0(.50.$X'.$A/$L(5$.)1$;-&0Q.FD$%/$L(5$-2V,A.$AU/+;A.'-$3.$A/$;&;'A/-(12$3U:55(.$.1$AU/+&'-$X'.$A'( $

;&-1.$1&'1.$'5.$0&++'5/'12$(W5&-2.$3.$%&-/$.1$3'$);.01/1.'-D$B/5)$0.)$3.'R$+&+.51)9$AUQ()1&(-.$

-.V(.51$T$:55(.9$.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$;-.53$0&5)0(.50.$X'U(A$O$/V/(1$'5$/'1-.$3.)1(5$T$0&51.-$.1$X'.$0.A'(*

0( $/ $ 1&1/A.+.51$3();/-' $3/5) $ A.)$Q&-)*0Q/+;)$.1 $ A.) $.AA(;).) $3'$L(A+D $%U/;;/-(1(&5$3U:55(.$ L/0.$

0/+2-/$A/$L/(1$/;;/-/n1-.$3/5)$1&'1.$)/$3(+.5)(&5$2;(X'.$M$0&5)0(.51.$3.$A/$+&-19$;-f1.$T$/00.;1.-$)&5 $

3.)1(59 $ .AA. $ 0&++.50. $32ST $T $ -.)).+ZA.- $T $ A/ $ L(W'-. $3. $ )/(51. $X'. $ 1&') $02A2Z-.-&51 $3'-/51 $ ).)$

L'52-/(AA.)D$#&5$/W&5(.$).-/$+&(5)$L&-1.$M$.AA.$&-W/5().-/9$+21Q&3(X'.+.51$)&5$1.)1/+.51$.1$).-/$T$

5&'V./' $ 20A(;)2. $;/- $ A/ $ L(W'-. $+2A&3-/+/1(X'. $3. $%&-/ $;A.'-/51 $Z-'O/++.51 $ )'- $ )&5 $ A(1D $%.)$

L'52-/(AA.)$L&501(&55.51$0&++.$'5.$/;&W2.9$+/()$AU(+/W.$3U:55(.$5.$).-/$;/)$1&'S&'-)$;/)$V()(ZA.$M$

A/$Q(2-/-0Q(.$;&'--/$f1-.$0&51-.Z/A/502.$X'U'5.$L&()$A/$+&-1$3'$;.-)&55/W.$.1$A/$3();/-(1(&5$3.$)&5$

V()/W.9$3.$)/$;./'$5&(-.D$

%.$L(A+$21/ZA(1$'5$.);/0.$0A/(-.+.51$0A&()&5529$(5L-/50Q())/ZA.$.51-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$:55(.$

;.'1$/0023.-$T$1&'1.$A/$+/()&5$3.$%&-/9$+/()$.AA.$-.)1.-/$1&'S&'-)$/'$).0&53$;A/5D$%.$0/3-.$-2V,A.$A/$

3&+(5/1(&5$V(&A.51.$3U'5$W-&';.$)&0(/A$)'-$AU/'1-.$X'.$).51$#/-/Q*o/5.$+/()$X'.$5(.51$A.)$/'1-.)D$

Page 107: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%U/;;/-.51.$2W/A(12$3.$1-/(1.+.51$+.52.$3/5)$A/$L/+(AA.$5.$1(.51$;A')$L/0.$T$AU/5/AO).$3'$;A/5D$%/$

3(0Q&1&+(. $.51-. $ A.) $3.'R$.);/0.) $V20')$;/- $ A.)$;.-)&55/W.) $-2V,A. $2W/A.+.51 $'5.$ 1.+;&-/A(12$

3(LL2-.51.D$:A&-)$X'.$1&'1$.)1$L/(1$;&'-$5&')$L/(-.$0-&(-.$T$AU'5(12$3'$1.+;)$V20'9$A.$+&53.$3'$!"#$%&'

(&')$'*"&$.)1$.5$-2/A(12$T$3.'R$V(1.)).)D$4.AA.$3.$A/$;-&W-.))(&5$-/;(3.9$3'$-O1Q+.$L&'$3.)$1&'-5/W.) $

.1 $ 3.) $ 2V25.+.51) $ +&53/(5) $ 3' $ 0j12 $ 3.) $ ZA/50) $ L&-1'52) $ .1 $ 0.AA. $ 3. $ AU(+;/)).9 $ 3. $ AU21.-5.A$

-.0&++.50.+.519$.1$L(5/A.+.51$3.$A/$+&-1$;-2+/1'-2.$3'$0j12$3.)$5&(-)$V&'2)$T$f1-.$3&+.)1(X'.)D$

%.)$3.'R$;A/5)$5.$V(V.51$;/)$/'$+f+.$-O1Q+.D$C/53()$X'.$%&-/$P.-.3(1Q$.++,5.$A/$0/+2-/$3U'5$

.53-&(1$T$AU/'1-.9$(5V.)1(1$)&5$25.-W(.$T$A/$0&5)1-'01(&5$3U'5.$V(.$)&0(/A.$.1$20&5&+(X'.$-/O&55/51.9$

:55(.$-.)1.$.AA.$(++&Z(A.$h$;(V&1$3'$0/3-.9$;/-L&()$L/()/51$;/-1(.$3'$320&-9$.AA.$-2;,1.$(5A/))/ZA.+.51$

A.)$+f+.)$/01(&5)9$-.)1.$/V.0$A.)$+f+.)$;-2&00';/1(&5)D$#')(.$W-/53(1$.1$320&'V-.$AU/+&'-$h$#/-/Q*

o/5.$-.)1.$/V.0$A.)$+f+.)$;-2&00';/1(&5)$X'U.AA.$/V/(1$.5L/519$5.$V&O/51$3/5)$)/$;-.+(,-.$-.A/1(&5$

X'U'5$+&O.5$3.$L'(-$)/$0&53(1(&5$.1$3.$1.51.-$3.$V(V-.$0&++.$'5.$ZA/50Q.D$#($#/-/Q*o/5.$2V&A'.9$

0.A/$.)1$A/())2$Q&-)$0Q/+;D$#&5$32+25/W.+.51$T$".K$}&-`$.1$).)$5&'V.AA.)$-.50&51-.)$)&51$T$;.(5.$

.)X'())2.)9$/'$).0&53$;A/5$3/5)$A.$L(A+$.1$/'$).0&53$;A/5$3/5)$A.$0/3-.D$%.$1.+;)$X'.$0&5)1-'(1 $

B&'WA/)$#(-`$.)1$3&50$'5$1.+;)$3&'ZA.9$0/0Q2$)&')$AU/;;/-.50.$3.$AU'5(12D$%.$V(.(AA()).+.51$5.$A.) $

1&'0Q.-/$3U/(AA.'-)$;/)$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.D$#1..V.$.1$%&-/$5U&51$;/)$0Q/5W2$.5$AU.);/0.$3.$>8$/5)$M $

A.)$/01.'-)$&51$3.)$0&)1'+.)$X'($A.)$V(.(AA()).51$'5$;.'9$+/()$A.'-)$;./'R9$.1$A.)$0Q.V.'R$-.)1.51$A.)$

+f+.)D$4.11.$0&5).-V/1(&5$.)1$2W/A.+.51$)&'A(W52.$;/-$A.)$3(/A&W'.)$h$A.$+.11.'-$.5$)0,5.$B/V(3$

!3K/-3)$.5$L/(1$A/$-.+/-X'.$T$%&-/9$A'($3()/51$X'U.AA.$.)1$/'))($L-/n0Q.$X'.$3/5)$A.'-)$;-.+(,-.) $

;(,0.)9$1/53()$X'.$%&-/$/LL(-+.$T$#1..V.9$X'U.AA.$-.1-&'V.$/;-,)$A&5W1.+;)9$X'U(A$5U/$;/)$0Q/5W2D$t$

AU(5V.-).9$:55(.$).$V&(1$Z./'0&';$;A')$V(.(AA.$M$A.)$1-/(1)$1(-2)9$A/$;./'$;A')$;eA.9$.AA.$).$V&(1$L/1(W'2.D $

#/-/Q*o/5.$).+ZA.9$3,)$A.$32Z'1$3'$L(A+9$;A')$eW2.$X'.$#')(.$M$;A')$-.);&5)/ZA.$.1$;A')$0&5)0(.51. $

3'$+&53.9$.AA.$5.$;&'--/$;/)$).$;.-+.11-.$3.$S&'.-$AU(55&0.51.$20.-V.A2.$0&++.$)&5$/+(.D$#/-/Q*

o/5.$-2;-(+/53.$).)$+.5)&5W.)9$A/$0&--(W.9$A'($L/(1$A/$A.\&5$.1$AU&Z).-V.$/V.0$+2;-()$X'/53$0.AA.*0( $

0(1.$5/{V.+.51$)/$+,-.D$%.)$0A/)).)$(5L2-(.'-.)$5.$V(.(AA()).51$;/)$T$A/$+f+.$V(1.)).$X'.$A.)$0A/)).)$

)';2-(.'-.)D$

4.11.$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3.V(.51$;&A(1(X'.$M$.AA.$)O+Z&A().$'5.$L&-+.$3.$3&+(5/1(&5$WA())2.$3/5)$

AU(5V()(ZA.9$3/5)$AU/(-9$3/5)$A.)$(51.-)1(0.)D$4U.)1$A.$1.+;)$.1$AU.);/0.$.'R*+f+.)$X'($).$-.1-&'V.51$

0&51/+(52)D

Page 108: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

(

?K*.%,&'(6(

X$&#*,+2(/*)&'(',(,'Y,9&'()*1+(D97)'0Z()'+(#$1,*@1'+

+

*#+9&"6)+<)+2;'6#D)+8&1"+-&$.)"+2)+.)68(+31'+8#(()

t$AU(5V.-).$3.$!"#$%&'(&')$'*"&9$X'($5.$0Q/5W.$;/)$3.$A/5W/W.$.51-.$A/$;-.+(,-.$.1$A/$).0&53.$

;/-1(. $3'$L(A+9$o(/ $wQ/5W`.$1.51.$3.$+/-X'.- $ A. $;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$/'$).(5 $+f+.$3.$).) $0Q&(R$

1.0Q5(X'.)D$aA$-.;-2).51.$/V.0$3.)$&'1(A)$3(LL2-.51)$1-&()$+&+.51)$3/5)$AUQ()1&(-.$3.$A/$4Q(5.DD$

=&'-$0&++.50.-9$A.$L&-+/1$0Q&()($.)1$3(LL2-.51D$>M@J$;&'-$>???$h$>MGb$;&'-$78>H9$.1$.5L(5$

7M@b$;&'-$A/$;/-1(.$)(1'2.$.5$787bD$%/$;-.+(,-.$-/()&5$.)1$2V(3.++.51$0.$X'.$5&')9$);.01/1.'-)9$

/))&0(&5) $ T $ 0.) $ L&-+/1)D $ %. $ >M@J $ 5&') $ -/;;.AA. $ /'S&'-3UQ'( $ /' $ ;/))2 $ ;&'- $ 5&) $ Q/Z(1'3.) $ 3.$

0&5)&++/1(&5$M$32)&-+/()$3/V/51/W.$Q/Z(1'2)$/'$>Ix?9$5&')$AU(3.51(L(&5)$/'$0(52+/$3.)$32Z'1)D$%.$

>MGb$.)1$'1(A()2$;&'-$A.$;-2).51$.19$;&'-)'(V/51$A/$A&W(X'.$3U'5$L&-+/1$X'($)U/AA&5W.9$wQ/5W`.$(+/W(5.$

'5$L'1'-$.5$7M@b$.1$'5.$(+/W.$0(52+/1&W-/;Q(X'.$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$3.$);.01/0'A/(-.D$%U&'V.-1'-.$3'$

L(A+$+.$).+ZA.$f1-.$'5.$'1(A()/1(&5$;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$&-(W(5/A.$.1$-2V2A/1-(0.$3.$AU'1(A()/1(&5$3'$>M@JD$

%/$;-.+(,-.$(+/W.$.)1$0.AA.$3U'5$W-&';.$3.$S.'5.)$0Q(5&()$3/5)/51$)'-$0.$X'($).+ZA.$f1-.$'5.$)0,5.$

3.$1Q2e1-.D$%.)$Z&-3)$3'$0/3-.$)&51$;A&5W2)$3/5)$AU&Z)0'-(12$0/-$A/$0&+;&)(1(&5$+.1$/'$;-.+(.-$;A/5$

A/$)1-'01'-.$3'$;A/L&53$.1$3.)$+'-)$X'($.50/3-.51$A/$)0,5.D$aA$.)1$3&50$(+;&))(ZA.$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-$

3U(3.51(L(.- $ A. $ L&-+/1 $ M $ ).'A. $ A/ $ )0,5. $ /' $ 0.51-. $ .)1 $ 20A/(-2.D $%. $ L(A+ $0&++.50. $ /A&-) $ ;/- $ '5$

+&'V.+.51$T$A/$W-'.$X'($;A&5W.$A(112-/A.+.51$V.-)$A.$W-&';.$3.$3/5).'-)9$)U/;;-&0Q/51$3.$A/$s&5.$

20A/(-2.$.1$-2V2A/51$3'$+f+.$L/(1$A.$L&-+/1$3'$0/3-.D$#'-;-().9$(A$.)1$;-.)X'.$0/--2D$%.$);.01/1.'-$

.51-.$A(112-/A.+.51$3/5)$AUQ()1&(-.$3'$L(A+9$.5$+f+.$1.+;)$X'U(A$.51-.$3/5)$A.$;/))2D$4.$1-/S.1$3.$A/ $

0/+2-/$X'($A.$;-&S.11.$V.-)$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$L&501(&55.$0&++.$'5$V&O/W.$3/5)$A.$1.+;)9$&[$(A$;/)).$

3U'5 $ >MJJ $ L(01(L $ E/'X'.A $ (A $ )U/11.53/(19 $ +/() $ X'( $ 5U/ $ S/+/() $ .R()12F $ /' $ >M@J $ X'( $ A. $ -.5V&(.$

(++23(/1.+.51$/'$;/))2D$$

P/()$wQ/5W`.$5.$).$0&51.51.$;/)$3U'1(A().-$A.)$L&-+/1)$0&++.$'5.$-2L2-.50.$;/-1/W2.$/V.0$A. $

);.01/1.'-9$(A$A.)$'1(A().$;&'-$5&'--(-$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$)'-$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)9$.1$;A')$;-20()2+.519$)'-$

A/$V(1.)).$3/5)$A.$+&53.$0&51.+;&-/(5D$%U.);/0.$X'.$-2V,A.$A.$>M@J$.)1$L(5/A.+.51$/)).s$A(+(12$M$(A $

5. $ -.)1. $X'. $;.' $3. $;A/0. $;&'- $ L(A+.- $0. $X'( $ ). $;/)). $/'1&'- $3.) $;.-)&55/W.)D $%/ $0/+2-/ $ ).$

0&50.51-.$)'-$AUQ'+/(59$A/())/51$A.$+&53.$X'($A.)$.51&'-.$3/5)$A.$L&53$3'$0/3-.D$:V.0$A.)$3.'R$/'1-.) $

Page 109: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;/-1(.)9$A.$);.01/1.'-$320&'V-.$3.)$Q&-(s&5)$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$&'V.-1)9$3.)$;/O)/W.)$.1$'5$+&53.$

.5V(-&55/51$X'($;-.53$3.$AU/+;A.'-D$%Uf1-.$Q'+/(5$5.$-.+;A(1$;A')$1&'1$AU.);/0.$3'$0/3-.9$(A$320&'V-.$

AU'5(V.-)$X'($AU.51&'-.D$%U/5/A&W(.$.)1$1-,)$0A/(-.$/V.0$AU2V&A'1(&5$3'$+&53.$.1$3.$A/$)&0(212$0Q(5&(). $

X'.$32;.(51$o(/$wQ/5W`.$M$/'$L'-$.1$T$+.)'-.$3'$L(A+9$(51.-5.1$/;;/-/n19$A.)$20-/5)$).$+'A1(;A(.519$&5$

320&'V-.$A.)$12A2;Q&5.)$;&-1/ZA.)DDD$%.)$0Q(5&()$).$+.11.51$T$V&O/W.-9$(++(W-.51$S')X'U.5$:')1-/A(.9 $

20Q/5W.51$V(/$)`O;.D$<-.L9$A.)$L-&51(,-.)$1&+Z.519$AU/00,)$T$AU(5L&-+/1(&5$)U&'V-.$.1$AU'5(V.-)$3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$).$1-&'V.$/W-/53($.5$+f+.$1.+;)$X'.$0.A'($3'$);.01/1.'-D$4.$0Q/5W.+.51$3.$L&-+/1$

+21/;Q&-().$A.$0Q/5W.+.51$-/;(3.$3U'5$+&53.$.5$.R;/5)(&5$M$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$

;.1(1)$3/5)$A.$0/3-.$.1$A.$+&53.$X'($A.)$.51&'-.$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$21.53'D$%UQ'+/(59$/'$0.51-.$3.$

AU(+/W.$.5$>???9$;.-3$;.'$T$;.'$3.$)&5$(+;&-1/50.9$;&'-$L(5(-$;.-3'$3/5)$AU(++.5)(12$3.)$;/O)/W.)$

3. $ 787bD $B&AA/- $ .)1 $ ;.-3' $ 3/5) $ A. $ 0/3-. $ 0&++. $ 3/5) $ A/ $ V(. $ /A&-) $ X'. $ )/ $+,-. $ .1 $ ).) $ /+()$

-.+;A())/(.51$T$.'R$).'A)$AU.);/0.9$)/0Q/51$;.'9$+/()$).$1-&'V/51$.51&'-2)$3.$AU.)).51(.AD$

%/ $ 0&+;&)(1(&5 $ /AA&5W2. $ L/V&-(). $ 2W/A.+.51 $ A/ $ -.;-2).51/1(&5 $3. $ A/ $ V(1.)).D $%/ $ V&(1'-.$

/V/5\/51 $.5$0/Q&1/51 $3/5) $ A/ $;-&L&53.'- $3.$0Q/+;$3'$L&-+/1$>M@J$.)1 $ -.+;A/02.$;/- $'5$CNg$

1-/V.-)/51 $ AU20-/5 $T $ 1&'1.) $V(1.)).) $ .5 $>MGbD $%/ $ ).5)/1(&5 $5U.)1 $ 2V(3.++.51 $;/) $ A/ $+f+. $ M $ o(/$

wQ/5W`.9$320-(1$AU/002A2-/1(&5$3'$+&53.$T$1-/V.-)$0.11.$(+/W.$)O+Z&A(X'.D$aA$5.$L(A+.$;/)$5&5$;A')$

A.)$V&(1'-.)$3.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$M$.5$>???9$A/$0/+2-/$.)1$)'-$A.$;/-.*Z-().9$;-&0Q.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$h$

.5$78>H9$A.)$V2Q(0'A.)$)&51$L(A+2)$T$'5.$21-/5W.$3()1/50.D$a)&A2)9$/'$0.51-.$3.$A/$-&'1.9$;/-L/(1.+.51$

3. $L/0.9 $ AU(+;-.))(&5 $X'.$3&55.$ AU(+/W.$5U.)1 $/Z)&A'+.51 $;/) $L/+(A(,-.D $:A&-) $X'. $ A/ $V&(1'-. $/$

X'.AX'.$0Q&).$3.$)O+;/1Q(X'.9$3.$L/+(A(.-$3/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$E.AA.$).-/$/'))($A.$0.51-.$3U'5.$

)0,5.$0&+(X'.$.51-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)F9$.AA.$.)1$L(A+2.$0&++.$'5$0&-;)$21-/5W.-9$T$3()1/50.$3/5)$A/$

)'(1.$3'$L(A+D

%U2V&A'1(&5$3'$L&-+/1$;-.53$3&50$1&'1$)&5$).5)$3/5)$A/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$X'.$L/(1$o(/$

wQ/5W`.$M$.AA.$(50/-5.$L&-+.AA.+.51$.1$(+;A/0/ZA.+.51$AU/002A2-/1(&5$3.)$+&'V.+.51)$Q'+/(5)9$3.)$

20Q/5W.)9$3.)$0&++'5(0/1(&5)D$%U&'V.-1'-.$3.$AUQ&++.$/'$+&53.$.1$.5$+f+.$1.+;)$AU()&A.+.51$

;-&W-.))(L$X'U(A$)'Z(1$3/5)$'5.$)&0(212$&[$1&'1$.)1$&'V.-19$&[$(A$5UO$/$;A')$3.$Z/--(,-.)D$%.$L&-+/1$

/AA&5W2$;/-/n1$;-.)X'.$A'(*+f+.$'5$&ZS.1$3'$L'1'-$M$;A')$/2-&3O5/+(X'.9$0&++.$A.)$1-/(5)$.1$A.)$

/V(&5)$X'($;.';A.51$A.$L(A+$h$;A')$;A/1$0&++.$A.$5&'V.A$a;/3$3.$o(5)Q.5W$.5$787b9$;A')$W-/0(.'R$

0&++.$A.)$A(W5.)$3.$AU/;;/-1.+.51$3.$B&AA/-$.1$3.$)&5$;,-.D$

%U.)1Q21(X'.$3.$AU(+/W.$V(.51$2W/A.+.51$).-V(-$0.11.$2V&A'1(&5D$!AA.$V/-(.$/V.0$A.$L&-+/1$;&'-$

-.;-2).51.-$'5$'5(V.-)$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$L-&(39$3.$;A')$.5$;A')$+20/5(X'.$.1$320&55.012$3.$AUQ'+/(5D$

B/5)$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$3.)$(+/W.)$3&0'+.51/(-.)$L(A+2.)$.5$Bg$).$+fA.51$T$A/$L(01(&5$1&'-52.$.5$

Page 110: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

:%!Ä:D$wQ/5W`.$/$ 1&'-52 $3.) $ (+/W.) $3.$ A/ $4Q(5. $.5 $788>9 $/V.0 $'5.$3.) $;-.+(,-.) $0/+2-/)$

5'+2-(X'.)D$aA$)U/W())/(1$/A&-)$3/V/51/W.$3.$-.;2-/W.)9$+/()$(A$/$0Q&()($3.$A.)$(512W-.-$/'$L(A+D$B.)$

(+/W.)$3'$"&'V.A$:5$0Q(5&()9$3.$A/$Z&n1.$3.$5'(19$&'$3.$;/O)/W.)$;&501'.51$A.$L(A+$3.$A.'-)$32L/'1) $

)($(3.51(L(/ZA.)D$%.)$1-/+.)$/;;/-/()).51$A&-)$3.)$+&'V.+.51)$3.$0/+2-/9$A.$Z-'(1$V(.51$-&+;-.$A/ $

;-&;-.12 $3.) $ (+/W.) $3. $ AU:%!Ä:9$ A.) $ 0&'A.'-) $ 1-&; $ )/1'-2.) $ .1 $ A. $ 0&51-/)1. $ 2A.V2 $V(.55.51 $ .5$

)(W5/A.-$A.$0/-/01,-.$21-/5W.-D$%U(+/W.$X'.$3&55.$wQ/5W`.$3'$;/))29$.)1$0.AA.$3'$5'+2-(X'.$/V.0$).)$

32L/'1)9$/'RX'.A)$(A $V&(1$32ST$'5$0Q/-+.$5&)1/AW(X'.D $%.$L(A+$.5$#';.-$G$.1 $).)$32L/'1)$&51$212$

A&5W1.+;)$/))&0(2)$/'R$)&'V.5(-)$3U.5L/50.9$T$A/$L/+(A(/-(12$3.)$L(A+)$3.$L/+(AA.$h$$wQ/5W`.$L/(1$A.$

0Q&(R $3U/))&0(.- $ /' $5'+2-(X'. $ A&5W1.+;) $320-(2 $;&'- $ )&5 $0j12 $ L-&(39 $ 2A.01-&5(X'.9 $'5 $0j12 $ /'$

0&51-/(-.$Q'+/(5$.1$5&)1/AW(X'.D $%.$W-/(5$3.$AU(+/W.$/-W.51(X'.$5U.)1 $;A')$ A/ $).'A.$-2L2-.50.$/'$

;/))2$M$(A$O$;-2L,-.$A.)$1-/+.)$3.)$;-.+(,-.)$(+/W.)$V(32&)D$4.$0Q&(R$3.$)';;&-1$).-1$'5.$/'1-.$

-2LA.R(&5$)'-$A.$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$M$)&5$L(A+$;&-1.$.5$A'($A.$0&5)1/1$3.$A/$-/;(3(12$/V.0$A/X'.AA.$&51$

2V&A'2.)$A.)$(+/W.)D$%.$5'+2-(X'.$/$V20'$3.$1.A)$0Q/5W.+.51)9$/V.0$'5.$1.AA.$-/;(3(129$X'.$A.)$

(+/W.)$3U(A$O$/$>8$/5)9$32ST9$;&-1.51$A/$+/-X'.$3'$;/))2$;&'-$A.$);.01/1.'-D$$%/$1.0Q5&A&W(.$)U/002A,-. $

.1$A.$);.01/1.'-$A.$0&5)1/1.$3/5)$A/$+/1(,-.$+f+.$3.)$(+/W.)$3'$L(A+D$!5$7b$/5)9$(A$+&51-.$'5$+&53. $

X'($0Q/5W.9$+/()$/'))($'5$;&(51$3.$V'.$X'($).$+&3(L(.9$'5$-/;;&-1$T$AU(+/W.$Z&')0'A2$h$A.$-.W/-3$.)1$

/'1-.$;'()X'.$0Q/5W.51$A/$1.R1'-.$3.$AU(+/W.$.1$)&5$L&-+/1D$%.$1.+;)$X'.$0&5)1-'(1$wQ/5W`.$.)1$'5$

1.+;)$X'($)'Z(1$3.)$2V&A'1(&5)$L&-1.)9$V(&A.51.)$M$(A$A.)$(5)0-(1$S')X'.$3/5)$A/$+/1(,-.$3'$L(A+D

%/$1.R1'-.$.1$A.)$0&'A.'-)$3'$L(A+$2V&A'.51$2W/A.+.51$3/5)$0.$).5)D$4.)$(+/W.)$1&'-52.)$.5$

Bg$3&55.51$'5.$0Q/A.'-$T$AU(+/W.$X'($5.$).$-.1-&'V.-/$;/)$3/5)$A.$-.)1.$3'$L(A+D$%/$;/A.11.$3. $

0&'A.'-$0Q/5W.$.51-.$A.)$1-&()$;/-1(.)9$.5$+f+.$1.+;)$X'.$AU(+/W.$;.-3$)/$)/1'-/1(&5D$%/$;-.+(,-.$

;/-1(.$3'$L(A+$.)1$0/-/012-()2.$;/-$A.$-&'W.$.1$A.$ZA.'$X'($).$-.1-&'V.51$;-/1(X'.+.51$3/5)$1&')$A.)$

;A/5)D$v-$A.$-&'W.$.)1$A.$)O+Z&A.$3.$A/$V(1/A(12$.5$4Q(5.9$.1$0.AA.$3.$)&5$3-/;./'D$%.$ZA.'$X'/51$T$A'($

;.'$;-2).51$3/5)$A/$)O+Z&A(X'.$0Q(5&().$&-(W(5.AA.$).$1-&'V.$/))&0(2$3/5)$A.$+&53.$+&3.-5.$/'R$

0A/)).)$;-&A21/(-.)$.1 $/'R$&'V-(.-)D$%.)$Vf1.+.51)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$X'U(A)$W/-3.-&51$21-/5W.+.51$

1&'1$A.$1.+;)$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.9$A/$V&(1'-.9$A.)$'5(L&-+.)$3.)$+(5.'-)9$A.)$.5).(W5.)$3/5)$A/$-'.9$

A.)$320&-/1(&5)$3'$"&'V.A$:5DDD$)&51$1.(512)$3.$-&'W.$&'$3.$ZA.'D$Pf+.$A.)$;/O)/W.)$).+ZA.51$)UO$

-/;;&-1.-$M$A.)$5'(1)$)&51$ZA.'.)9$.1$A.)$;/O)/W.)$3.$1.--.$+/--&5)$&'$&0-.)D$%.$0(.A$)&')$A.X'.A$A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$;/-1.51$L/(-.$A.'-)$V(-2.)$.5$V&(1'-.$.)1$2W/A.+.51$ZA.'$V(L$*$(A$).-/$;A')$5'/W.'R$&'$

)'-.R;&)2$3/5)$A.)$/'1-.)$;/-1(.)$3'$L(A+D$

%/$3.'R(,+.$;/-1(.$3'$L(A+$.)1$3/V/51/W.$32)/1'-2.$h$A.)$;./'R$&51$'5$1.(51$;A')$ZA/L/-39 $

0(-.'RD$%.)$L&53)$)'-$A.)X'.A)$2V&A'.51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$1(-.51$3/V/51/W.$V.-)$A.)$W-()$.1$A.)$+/--&5)$

0A/(-)9$3.)$0&'A.'-)$;A')$5.'1-.)D$%.)$).'A.)$1&'0Q.)$3.$0&'A.'-)$X'($/;;/-/()).51$)&51$0.AA.)$X'($

-2)&55.51$/V.0$A.$;/))2$M$A.$+/51./'$-&'W.$X'.$;&-1.$.50&-.$C/&$A&-)X'U.AA.$-.1-&'V.$%(/5Ws(9$A.)$

Page 111: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+'-) $ 3.) $ Z'-./'R $ 3. $ A/ $+(5. $ X'( $ )&51 $ -.)12) $ V.-1 $ V(LD $:A&-) $ X'. $ A/ $ A'+(,-. $ .)1 $ WA&Z/A.+.51$

5/1'-/A()1.9$&5$5&1.$/'))($X'U'5$.LL.1$-&'W.$V(L$V(.51$20A/(-.-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$/'$+&+.51$&[$C/&$

.51-.$0Q.s$%(/5Ws(D$o')1(L(2.$;/-$A.)$W'(-A/53.)$A'+(5.').)$3.$AU/'1.A$X'($).$1-&'V.$3/5)$AU.51-2.9$.AA.$

.)1$0.;.53/51$'5$;.'$1-&;$(51.5).$;&'-$f1-.$V-/().+ZA/ZA.$.1$V(.51$3/V/51/W.$)U/))&0(.-$T$C/&$.1$T $

)&5$+/51./'D$o')1.+.519$A/$)2X'.50.$+.1$.5$)0,5.$)/$).0&53.$-.50&51-.$/V.0$A/$L.++.$3.$%(/5Ws(9 $

X'($A/$-.W/-3.$/V.0$+2L(/50.D$%.$-&'W.$-.)1.$/))&0(2$/'$;/))29$T$A/$+.5/0.$X'.$-.;-2).51.$C/&9$

AU/50(.5$/+&'-$3.$%(/5Ws(D$

%/ $ 1-&()(,+.$;/-1(. $.)1 $Z./'0&';$;A') $ A'+(5.').D $%.)$L&53)$)'-$ A.)X'.A) $)&51 $ L(A+2)$ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$A.)$;/O)/W.)$3.$+.-$&'$A/$Z/(.$V(1-2.$3.$A/$+/()&5$3.$o(5)Q.5WD$%.)$0(.A)$)&51$

ZA/50)$&'$ZA.'*W-()D$%/$;/A.11.$3.$0&'A.'-$.)1$0.AA.$X'.$AU&5$/))&0(.$3.$+/5(,-.$0&5).5)'.AA.$T$A/ $

+&3.-5(12$.1$/'$3.)(W5$M$ZA/509$ZA.'$.1$W-()D$%U(+/W.$).+ZA.$.50&-.$/V&(-$212$32)/1'-2.D$

:' $ 0&'-) $ 3' $ L(A+9 $ A.) $ 0&'A.'-) $ ). $ ;.-3.519 $ .1 $ A.) $ (+/W.) $ )U'5(L&-+().51D $%/ $ W/(.129 $ A.$

32)&-3-.9 $ A/ $V(V/0(12 $3.) $0&'A.'-) $0/-/012-().51 $ A/ $;-.+(,-.$;/-1(. $ M $0U.)1 $ A. $ 1.+;)$ S&O.'R$3.$ A/$

S.'5.)).$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$'5$+&+.51$&[$1&'1$.)1$.50&-.$;&))(ZA.$.5$4Q(5.9$A/$;&))(Z(A(12$3U'5.$

0&5V(V(/A(12$.51-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$d5$+&53.$&[$)&51$/))&0(2.)$AUQ()1&(-.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$/50.)1-/A.$

E-&'W.F$.1$).)$-fV.)$3U'5.$)&0(212$2W/A(1/(-.$.1$;&;'A/(-.$EZA.'FD$%/$).0&53.$.)1$Z./'0&';$;A')$1.-5.9$

L-&(3.$.1$1-()1.9$5U21/51$-/V(V2.$X'.$;/-$A.)$0&'A.'-)$X'($-.)1.51$3.)$2A2+.51)$3'$;/))2D$%/$4Q(5.$.)1$T $

AU/W&5(. $ M $ A. $ 0/50.- $ / $ L-/;;2 $ %(/5Ws(9 $ A. $ ;,-. $ 3. $C/& $ 320,3.D $ %. $ 0Q/-Z&5 $ .R1-/(1 $ /V.0 $ 1/51$

3U(+;/1(.50.$3.)$+(5.)$0Q(5&().)$).+ZA.$/V&(-$32;&)2$'5.$0&'0Q.$W-().$)'-$A.)$(+/W.)D$".$-.)1.51$

X'. $X'.AX'.) $20A/1) $3. $0&'A.'-)9 $V.)1(W.) $3.) $ 1.+;) $Q.'-.'R$3'$;/))29 $X'( $5. $ 1/-3.-&51 $;/) $T$

3();/-/n1-.$M$C/&$1-&X'.-/$)&5$+/51./'$-&'W.$0&51-.$'5$+/51./'$5&(-$;&'-$V(V-.$A.$3.'(A$3.$)&5$;,-.D$

%/$1-&()(,+.$;/-1(.$5.$).$;/)).$;/)$.5$4Q(5.D$%.)$4Q(5&()$).$)&51$-2L'W(2)$;/-$+(AA(.-)$.5$:')1-/A(. $

E1&')$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$X'.$AU&5$O$V&(1$&51$3.)$1-/(1)$/)(/1(X'.)F9$0.$X'($3&55.$T$;.5).-$X'.$A/$4Q(5.$/$

.50&-.$3/V/51/W.$0.))2$3Uf1-.$V(V/ZA.D$%U(+/W.$.)1$0.AA.$3U'5$+&53.$;A')$A()).9$/).;1()29$Z-(AA/519 $

+/()$)/5)$e+.D$%U(512-(.'-$3.$A/$+/()&5$3.$o(5)Q.5W$).+ZA.$/V&(-$212$0&5\'$;/-$:;;A.$M$1&'1$O$.)1 $

ZA/50 $.1 $;A/)1(L(2 $ h $ A.) $ (+/W.) $3. $5/1'-. $3&55.51 $T $V&(- $3.) $0Q/+;)$Z(.5 $ -/5W2)9 $T $ A/ $Q/'1.'- $

-2W'A(,-.9$.1$).-V.51$3.$;()1.)$3U/11.--())/W.$;&'-$3.)$1&'-)$.5$Q2A(0&;1,-.D$C&'1$O$.)1$/-1(L(0(.AD$!5$

1-&()$0Q/5W.+.51)$3.$;/A.11.)$3.$0&'A.'-)9$wQ/5W`.$32;.(51$'5.$Q()1&(-.$3.$A/$4Q(5.$M$'5$;/O)$V(V/51 $

.1$.5-/0(52$3/5)$).)$1-/3(1(&5)9$1'2$;/-$A/$+&3.-5(12$.1$L&-02$3.$).$-2(5V.51.-$/(AA.'-)9$3/5)$'5$.);/0.$

)/5)$e+.$&[$A.)$-.;,-.)$&51$212$;.-3')D$%.$+&53.$/$0Q/5W29$.1$A.$-/;;&-1$T$AU.);/0.$/V.0$A'(D

Page 112: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

!"#$%&'()%*+,-+&.+/%'&-'0+-(+,'+1%02.(+-*(0-+&-3+(0%)3+4.0()-3

Page 113: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+ *)+.)68(+,/-1+).+(#+")8"/()$.#.'&$+<#$(+2)+-#<")

%.)$L&-+/1)$5U(53'().51$;/)$).'A.+.51$'5$0Q/5W.+.51$3U/1+&);Q,-.$3/5)$A.$L(A+9$ (A)$&51$

3(-.01.+.51$T$V&(-$/V.0$A/$-.;-2).51/1(&5$3.)$f1-.)$X'($A.$;.';A.51$.1$A.'-$+/5(,-.$3.$V(V-.$A.$1.+;)$

;/))2D $%. $ L&-+/1 $ >M@J $ 0/-/012-(). $ A/ $ ;-.+(,-. $ ;/-1(. $ 3' $ L(A+D $4/+2-/ $ )'- $ ;(.39 $+/() $+&Z(A.9 $

1-.+ZA/51.$.1$V(V.9$.AA.$.)1$;/-L/(1.+.51$T$A/$Q/'1.'-$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$2;&').$A.'-$-O1Q+.9$A.'-$

+/5(,-.$3.$V(V-.$A.$ 1.+;)D$%.$L&-+/1$.)1 $;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51$Z(.5$0Q&()($;&'-$-/0&51.-$'5$1-(/5WA.$

/+&'-.'R $ M $ A. $ ;A') $ )&'V.51 $ .5 $ ;A/5 $ ;&(1-(5. $ &' $ /+2-(0/(5)9 $ A.) $ 1-&() $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ 1(.55.51$

3(LL(0(A.+.51$3/5)$AU.);/0.$3'$0/3-.D$%/$0&+;&)(1(&5$S&'.$.5$;.-+/5.50.$T$ A.)$ (512W-.-$3/5)$A/$

;-&L&53.'-$3'$0/3-.9 $+/()$ (A) $5.$1(.53-/(.51$;/)$/A(W52)$/'$;-.+(.- $;A/5D $%/$)(1'/1(&5$.)1 $3&50$

.R/01.+.51$0.AA.$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$M$(A)$1(.55.51$.5).+ZA.$$+/()$;.-)&55.$5U.)1$3';.9$0.1$2X'(A(Z-.$.)1$

1.+;&-/(-.9$.1$'5$(5L(+.$+&'V.+.51$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$&'$3.$A/$0/+2-/$.R0A'-/(1$AU'5$3U.51-.$.'R$3'$

0/3-.$6$.1$3.$A/$-.A/1(&5D$%.)$32;A/0.+.51)$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)'(V.51$'5.$0Q&-2W-/;Q(.$1-,)$0A/(-.D $

o(5)Q.5W9 $ A. $ S.'5. $;-.+(.- $ T $ A/ $ 3-/W'. $ /W-.))(V.9 $ L&-0. $ )O)12+/1(X'.+.51 $ A/ $ 0/+2-/ $ T $ Z&'W.-$

A&-)X'U(A)$)&51$1&')$A.)$1-&()$(512W-2)$T$A/$0&+;&)(1(&5D$aA$(5V(1.$C/&$T$V&(-$)/$V&(1'-.$&'$AU.++,5.$

L/(-.$'5$1&'-9$.5$;-&L(1/51$;&'-$L/(-.$)&-1(-$)&5$-(V/A$3'$0/3-.9$X'($V(.53-/$A.)$O$-.S&(53-.$X'.AX'.) $

).0&53.) $;A') $ 1/-3D $t$ AU(5V.-).9 $C/&$.LL.01'.$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51 $ A. $ 1-/S.1 $3' $ -.1&'-9 $ -/+.5/51 $ A/$

0/+2-/$)'-$%(/5Ws($.1$-.0&+;&)/51$A.$1-(&D

%/$0/+2-/$.)1$3&50$/5(+2.$.5$;.-+/5.50.9 $0.51-2.$)'-$AUQ'+/(5$.1$)'-$ A.)$-.A/1(&5)$3.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D $%.) $&ZS.1) $ ).-&51 $ 3/5) $ 0.11. $ ;-.+(,-. $;/-1(. $ -.A/1(V.+.51 $ .R0A') $3' $ 0/3-.D $4.11.$

0&5)1/1/1(&5$.)1$1-,)$0A/(-.$3/5)$A/$)2X'.50.$&[$A.)$3.'R$;-21.53/51)$3.$C/&$).$-.50&51-.51$3/5)$)/$

Z&'1(X'.D$%.$0/3-.$5.$;.-+.1$;/)$3UO$L/(-.$.51-.-$A.)$&ZS.1)9$X'($-.)1.51$-.A/1(V.+.51$Q&-)$0Q/+;D$

o(5)Q.5W$).$;-.53$A.)$;(.3)$3/5)$'5$&ZS.1$3&51$&5$(W5&-.$A/$5/1'-.$.1$X'.$A.$0/3-.$5.$V(.53-/$;/)$

-2V2A.-D$B.$+f+.$A.$0&';A.$3.$S.'5.)$0A(.51)$-.)1.-/$L&-1.+.51$Q&-)*0Q/+;$M$(A)$5.$).-&51$T$AU(+/W.$

X'.$A.$1.+;)$3.$A.'-$.51-2.$3/5)$A.$+/W/)(59$A/$0/+2-/$5U.5$.5-.W()1-.-/$+f+.$;/)$A/$)&-1(.D$%.)$

X'.AX'.) $ ;A/5) $ &[ $ A/ $ 0/+2-/ $ -.0/3-. $ )'- $ A.) $ &ZS.1) $ 0&50.-5.51 $ 3.) $ &ZS.1) $ )O+Z&A(X'.) $ M $ A.)$

3'+;A(5W)$X'.$C/&$;/-1/W.$/V.0$%(/5Ws(9$A.$4B$X'U/0Q,1.$o(5)Q.5W$;&'-$A/$)23'(-.D$%.$+&'V.+.51 $

.1 $ A. $ -O1Q+.$3. $ A/ $0/+2-/ $.)1 $.51(,-.+.51 $Z/)2$)'- $ A. $+&'V.+.51 $3.) $;.-)&55/W.) $.1 $)'- $ A.'-$

-.A/1(&5D $4.$X'($(+;&-1.$C/&9$0U.)1 $0.$1-(&9$A.$;A/()(-$3Uf1-.$.51&'-2.$;/-$).)$3.'R$/+()$3&51$.AA. $

)U.LL&-0.$3.$5.$;/)$V&(-$A.)$(51.51(&5)D$%.$1.+;)$3.$0.11.$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$.)1$'5$1.+;)$)&0(/A9$-O1Q+2$

;/-$A.)$20Q/5W.)9$A.)$ZA/W'.)9$A.)$1.51/1(V.)$3U/;;-&;-(/1(&5$3.$C/&$;/-$AU'5$&'$;/-$AU/'1-.D$4U.)1$'5$

1.+;)$3.$S.'9$3.$3/5).$/+&'-.').9$'5$Z/AA.1$&[$A/$0/+2-/$)'(1$A.)$0&5)1-'01(&5)$.1$3.)1-'01(&5)$3.)$

Page 114: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;&))(ZA.)$X'($.R()1.51$.51-.$.'RD$%.$1.+;)$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$.)1$'5$1.+;)$;A.(59$-.+;A($;/-$A.) $

(51.-/01(&5)$Q'+/(5.)D$

4.11.$0&5)1/1/1(&5$.)1$3U/'1/51$;A')$V-/(.$X'U.5$>M@J9$AU.);/0.$/A.51&'-$21/51$1-,)$A(+(129$).$

)&51$)'-1&'1$A.)$L&53)$3.)$;A/5)$X'($).-V.51$T$3&55.-$V(.$/'R$.);/0.)D$%.)$.5L/51)$.5$0&)1'+.9$LA&') $

3/5)$A/$;-&L&53.'-$3'$0Q/+;)9$V(.53-&51$0&+ZA.-$A.$;.'$3U.);/0.$V(3.$A/())2$.51-.$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$

%.)$;A/5)$3.$L&'A.$).-&51$)/1'-2)9$-.+;A())/51$A.$0/3-.$3.$+/5(,-.$);.01/0'A/(-.9$5.$A/())/51$;/)$

+f+.$'5.$A(W5.$3UQ&-(s&5$;&'-$)U.5$20Q/;;.-D$$%.$>M@J$).$;-f1.$2W/A.+.51$;.'$/'R$/+&-0.)D$Y(.5$5. $

V(.51$.50&+Z-.-$A.$0/3-.9$&'$&Z)1-'.-$A/$V'.$3'$);.01/1.'-$6$(A$.)1$32ST$/)).s$0&+;A.R.$3UO$L/(-.$1.5(-$

A.)$1-&()$;.-)&55/W.)D$%/$).5)/1(&5$.)1$2W/A.+.51$0.AA.$3U'5$/);.01$3(-.01$/'R$0Q&).)9$3U'5.$0A/-12$3.$

AU(+/W.9$3.$)/$A()(Z(A(12D$%.$+&53.$.)1$)(+;A.9$-23'(19$+/()$0&5L&-1/ZA.9$AU/00,)$3.)$Q&++.)$A.)$'5)$

/'R$/'1-.)$.)1$3(-.01D$

d5.$L&()$X'.$C/&$/'-/$0Q&()($o(5)Q.5W9$0.$1.+;)$).$1.-+(5.D$%.$+&+.51$3.$-';1'-.9$32ST9$5.$

A/()).$;A')$A/$;A/0.$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)$X'.$3.'R$;/-$3.'R$M$C/&$.1$o(5)Q.5W$&'$C/&$.1$%(/5Ws(D$%/$

1.5)(&5$/V.0$A.X'.A$o(5)Q.5W$.++.5/(1$A/$0/+2-/$;&'-$5Uf1-.$;A')$3/5)$A.$0/3-.$X'U/V.0$C/&$;.-3$.5$

L&-0.$M$A/$0/+2-/$A.$)'(19$+/()$(A$5.$0Q.-0Q.$;A')$T$A/$-.S&(53-.D$%.)$/3(.'R$3.$C/&$.1$3.$)&5$/'1-.$

;-21.53/51$).$L.-&51$.5$A.)$()&A/51$AU'5$3.$AU/'1-.D$c'/53$.5L(59$%(/5Ws($A/$-.S&(53-/$3/5)$)&5$.);/0.9$

0.$).-/$;&'-$)U2A&(W5.-$3/5)$A.$L&53$3'$;A/59$-/;(3.+.51$LA&'D$%.$5.1$-.)1.$)'-$C/&$.1$(53(X'.$X'.$A/ $

)2;/-/1(&5$.)1$0&5)&++2.$M$(A)$/;;/-1(.55.51$32L(5(1(V.+.51$T$3.'R$.);/0.)$3(LL2-.51)D$t$5&'V./'9$

A.)$-.A/1(&5)$Q'+/(5.)$-.+;A()).51$AU.);/0.$.1$-O1Q+.51$A.$1.+;)$3.)$;A/5)D$P/()$1&'1$).+ZA.$)Uf1-.$

'5$;.'$-/A.51(D$%/$)2X'.50.$&[$C/&$0Q.-0Q.$%(/5Ws($)U21(-.$3/5)$A.$1.+;)9$+'A1(;A(/51$A.)$;A/5)$&[$

.AA.$.--.$T$).$-.0Q.-0Q.D$4.$5U.)1$;A')$A/$-.A/1(&5$Q'+/(5.$X'($/5(+.$0.$+&+.51$h$+/()$AU/Z).50.9$A. $

+/5X'.9$A.$V(3.D$4.11.$)2X'.50.$;-2;/-.$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.D$

B/5)$ A/ $).0&53.$;/-1(. $3'$L(A+9 $ A/ $0/+2-/ $.)1 $+&(5)$+&Z(A. $ h $.5$>MGb9 $ A.) $;.-)&55/W.)$

;.'V.51$V(V-.$.5).+ZA.$3/5)$A.$0/3-.D$%.)$;A/5)$)&51$;A')$A&5W)9$;A')$L(R.)D$t$AU(5V.-).$3'$1.+;)$

X'.$32;.(51$o(/$wQ/5W`.$3U'5$+&53.$X'($)U/002A,-.9$A.$1.+;)$3'$;.-)&55/W.$3.$C/&$.)1$A'($3.$;A')$.5$

;A')$+&-5.D$%.$1.+;)$3.)$Q&++.)$5U.)1$;A')$.5$;Q/).$/V.0$0.A'($3.$A/$)&0(212D$%.$-O1Q+.$.)1$;A')$

A.519 $ 21/ZA( $;/- $3. $5&+Z-.'R $;A/5) $ L(R.)9 $ )/5) $+&'V.+.51) $5( $3(/A&W'.) $3.) $;.-)&55/W.)D $%.)$

/+&-0.) $)&51 $;A') $;-2).51.) $.1 $ L&501(&55.51 $3. $+/5(,-. $)O+Z&A(X'.)9 $/))&0(2.) $T $3.) $ A(.'R$.5$

;/-1(0'A(.- $ M $ A/ $+(5.9 $ A/ $+/()&5 $3. $C/&9 $X'( $ )&51 $ 0Q/0'5 $T $ A.'- $+/5(,-. $3.) $;-()&5) $;&'- $ A.)$

;.-)&55/W.)D$%/$;-()&5$3.$%(/5Ws($.)1$0.AA.$3'$1-/V/(A$.1$3.$A/$;-&3'01(&5$20&5&+(X'.9$0.AA.$3.$C/&$

.)1 $ A/ $;-()&5$3. $ A/ $ )&A(1'3.9 $ A/ $0/W. $3&-2. $T $ A/X'.AA. $ A'( $/ $;.-+() $3U/0023.- $ )&5$+/-(/W. $/V.0$

o(5)Q.5W9 $+/() $X'( $ A'( $/ $ 0&i12 $/'))( $ )&5 $Z&5Q.'- $.1 $ )&5 $3O5/+()+.D $%. $+&1(L $3. $ A/ $0/W. $.)1$

Page 115: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

;/-1(0'A(,-.+.51 $0A/(- $/' $+&+.51 $&[$%(/5Ws( $&Z).-V. $ A. $ 1(W-.$/' $s&&$ h $ A. $ )O+Z&A. $3U'5.$ L&-0.$

0&51.5'.$.1$3U'5$.5L.-+.+.51$0&51-.*5/1'-.$)U/;;A(X'.$/'$;.-)&55/W.9$L(A+2$)O)12+/1(X'.+.51$T$

1-/V.-)$A.)$Z/--./'RD$%U(+/W.$.)1$1-,)$0A/(-.$M$0.$;&'--/(1$1&'1$/'))($Z(.5$f1-.$A'($3/5)$0.11.$0/W.9$

;-()&55(.- $3.$)&5$X'&1(3(.59 $3.$)&5$ 1-/V/(A $3U&'V-(.-9 $3.$)/$0&53(1(&5$3.$;,-.$3.$L/+(AA.9 $3.$ A/$

0/+;/W5.$&[$(A$/$212$L&-02$3U(++(W-.-$.1$.5L(5$3.$)&5$0&-;)$+/A/3.$;'()X'U(A$V(.51$3.$320&'V-(-$)&5$

0/50.-D$=A')$X'.$1&'1$.1$)/5)$)U.5$-.53-.$0&+;1.9$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$3.$o(/$wQ/5W`.$)&51$;-()&55(.-)$3.$

A/$)&0(212$0Q(5&().9$3.V.5'.$L&AA.$/'$;&(51$3U/Z/53&55.-$)&5$;-&;-.$;.';A.D$

B/5) $ 0.11. $ ;/-1(.9 $ A. $ +&1(L $ 3' $ 3&'ZA. $ -.+;A/0. $ 0.A'( $ 3' $ 1-(&9 $ A.) $ ;.-)&55/W.) $ )&51$

;-/1(X'.+.51 $ 1&'S&'-) $ 3.'R $ 3/5) $ A. $ 0/3-.9 $ A.) $ 0Q/+; $ 0&51-. $ 0Q/+; $ )&51 $ )O)12+/1(X'.+.51$

0&5)1-'(1)$/V.0$/+&-0.D$%/$0&+;&)(1(&5$3'$0/3-.$)U2X'(A(Z-.$/V.0$3.'R$;.-)&55/W.)9$+/()$32ST9$(A)$

;/-/()).51$;A')$2A&(W52)$A.)$'5)$3.)$/'1-.)D$%/$A/-W.'-$3'$0/3-.$;.-+.1$A/$3()1/50.$.51-.$.'RD$C/&$.1$

)&5$L(A)$)'Z(-&51$A.$+f+.$2A&(W5.+.51$3/5)$A.$0/3-.9$+/()$).-&51$L(5/A.+.51$-/;;-&0Q2)$3/5)$A.)$

3.-5(.-)$;A/5)9$A&-)$3.$A.'-$V&O/W.$.5$1-/(5D$aA)$).$).-&51$/;;-(V&()2)$A.$1.+;)$3.$A/$V()(1.$3.$B&AA/-D$

P/()$0.$-/;;-&0Q.+.51$L.-/$/'))($).51(-$A.$V(3.$X'($A.)$.51&'-.D$%.)$;A/5)$A/()).51$/A&-)$;A/0.$/'R$

320/3-/W.)9$/'R$V(3.)9$T$AU/Z).50.$X'.$C/&$-.)).51$3U/V/50.$/V/51$A.$32;/-1$3.$)&5$L(A)D$:))()$1&')$

3.'R$3/5)$A.$1-/(5)9$(A)$)&51$L(A+2)$3/5)$A.$Z/)$3'$0/3-.$M$A.$-.)1.$3.$AU(+/W.$.)1$V(3.D$%&-)X'U(A) $

20&'1.51$.5).+ZA.$A/$+')(X'.$3/5)$A.$K/W&5*0&'0Q.11.9$'5$A/-W.$/;A/1$.)1$A/())2$T$0j12$3U.'R9$'5$

+'-$V(3.D$%.)$;A/5)$5.$)&51$;A')$/'))($2X'(A(Z-2)9$1-/3'()/51$A.'-$)2;/-/1(&5$;-&0Q/(5.D$$

B/5)$A/$1-&()(,+.$;/-1(.9$A.$+&1(L$;/)).$3.$3.'R$;.-)&55/W.)$3/5)$A.$0/3-.$T$'5$).'AD$:A&-)$

X'.$A. $L&-+/1$)0&;.$;.-+.11-/(1 $)/5)$;-&ZA,+.$3.$L(A+.-$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$0j1. $T$0j1.9 $;A')(.'-)$

)2X'.50.)$A.)$()&A.$/'$0&51-/(-.$/A&-)$X'U(A)$)&51$.LL.01(V.+.51$-/;;-&0Q2)$3/5)$AU.);/0.D$%&-)X'.$

B&AA/-$3()0'1.$/V.0$)/$;-&L.)).'-.$&'$/V.0$)&5$;,-.9$A.$0/3-.$;/)).$3.$AU'5$T$AU/'1-.9$A.)$()&A/51 $

32).);2-2+.51D$Pf+.$A/$)0,5.$)'(V/51$A.)$;-.+(.-)$2Z/1)$3.$B&AA/-$.1$3.$)/$;-&L.)).'-$A.)$)2;/-.$M$

/A&-)$X'U(A)$3()0'1.51$ZA&11()$AU'5$0&51-.$AU/'1-.9$A/$0/+2-/$;/-V(.51$T$5.$;/)$A.)$+&51-.-$1&'1$T$L/(1$

.5).+ZA.$3/5)$A.$;A/5D$](A+2)$3.$1-,)$;-,)9$A.$0/3-.$()&A.$'5$V()/W.9$.5$0&';/51$AU/'1-.$T$A/$+&(1(2D$

%.$1.+;)$3.$A/$1-&()(,+.$;/-1(.$.)1$0.A'($3U'5$()&A.+.51$1&1/A$3.)$(53(V(3')9$1&')$;.-3')$3/5)$A.'-)$

;-&ZA,+.)$-.);.01(L)$.1$;.(5/51$T$0&5)1-'(-.$3.)$-.A/1(&5)D$$

%.)$;A/5)$3.$;/O)/W.)$)&51$;A')$-20'--.51)$3/5)$0.11.$;/-1(.D$%/$L(W'-.$3'$;-&+.5.'-$)&A(1/(-. $

)'-$A. $Z&-3$3.$+.-$&'$3/5)$AU(++.5)(12 $3.)$0Q/+;)$3.V(.51 $'5$+&1(LD $%.)$;/O)/W.)$)&51$;A/1)9$

-2W'A(.-)$.1$V(3.)9$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$32/+Z'A/51$3U'5$Z&-3$T$AU/'1-.$3'$0/3-.$3/5)$'5$+&53.$1-&;$

W-/53$;&'-$.'RD$%.$-O1Q+.$.)1$0&51.+;A/1(L9 $T$A/$V(1.)).$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$.--/51$.1$&Z).-V/51$A.$

+&53.$L/'1.$3.$A.$0&+;-.53-.D$

Page 116: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

!"#$%#&'$$"&()*)(+#,#$%#-'$)(./"

Page 117: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

++*;'$."1('&$+<1+<&-16)$.#'")>+.)68(+"/)2(+).+.)68(+9'-.'9(

B.'R$1.+;)$).$)';.-;&).51$.1$)U&-W/5().51$M$0.A'($3.$A/$L(01(&59$X'.$5&')$/V&5)$(0($/5/AO)29$.1$

0.A'($3'$-2.A9$3.)$(+/W.)$1&'-52.)$;/-$o(/$wQ/5W`.$/V/51$A.$1&'-5/W.D$%.)$1.+;&-/A(12)$3.$A/$L(01(&5$

.1$3.$0.)$(+/W.)$5.$)&51$;/)$A.)$+f+.)9$.AA.)$(53'().51$'5$/'1-.$1O;.$3.$-/;;&-1$/'$+&53.D

%U'1(A()/1(&5$3.$0.)$(+/W.)$5U.)1$;/)$1&'S&'-)$A/$+f+.D$!AA.)$/;;/-/()).51$3U/Z&-3$3/5)$A/$

;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.$0&++.$L/()/51$;/-1(.$(512W-/51.$3.$A/$5/--/1(&5D$!AA.)$).-V.51$T$/+&-0.-$A/$)2X'.50.$

3'$"&'V.A$:5$0Q(5&()$.1$T$320-(-.$AU.);/0.$3.$A/$Z&n1.$3.$5'(1$&[$32/+Z'A.51$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)D$!AA.)$

)&51 $3&50 $/))&0(2.) $ T $'5 $;-2).51 $3' $ L(A+D $%. $ -O1Q+.$.)1 $ -.A/1(V.+.51 $ -/;(3.9 $ A.) $ (+/W.) $ )&51$

'1(A()2.)$;&'-$320-(-.$A.)$.);/0.)D$%.)$;A/5)$3.$A/$Z&n1.$3.$5'(1$)&51$+&512)$/V.0$3.)$+&'V.+.51)$

-/;(3.)9$.51-.$;.-)&55/W.)$.5$1-/(5$3.$3/5).-$.1$;A/5$/Z)1-/(1)$&[$).$+fA.51$A'+(,-.$.1$L'+2.D$aA) $

).-V.51$T$0&5)1-'(-.$'5$0&51.R1.$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)9$T$L/(-.$).51(-$AU/;;/-1.5/50.$3'$1.+;)$3.$A/$L(01(&5$

T$'5$1.+;)$;A')$A/-W.9$.5$-2L2-.50.$/'$+&53.$0Q(5&()$0&51.+;&-/(5D$%.$1.+;)$3'$L(A+$5U.)1$;/)9 $

0&++. $3/5) $+,-),-9 $ 320&55.012 $ 3. $ AUr()1&(-. $ T $ A/ $+/5(,-. $ 3U'5 $ 0&51. $ X'( $ ;&'--/(1 $ ). $ ;/)).-$

5U(+;&-1.$&[$.1$5U(+;&-1.$X'/53D$%.)$-2L2-.50.)$T$'5$1.+;)$-2.A$A.$-/;;-&0Q.$3.$5&1-.$.R;2-(.50.$

V20'.D$PfA.-$3&0'+.51/(-.$.1$L(01(&59$0U.)1$&'V-(-$A.)$A(+(1.)$3'$1.+;)$3.$AUQ()1&(-.$;&'-$A/$0&5V.-1(-$

.5$'5$1.+;)$Q()1&-(X'.D$o(/$wQ/5W`.$)UO$;-.53$3.$3(LL2-.51.)$+/5(,-.)$M$(A$/;;A(X'.$;/-$.R.+;A.$'5$

.LL.1$3.$1-/+/W.$/'R$(+/W.)$3.$AU:%!Ä:$A&-)$3U/'$+&(5)$'5$;A/59$&[$C/&$.1$%(/5Ws($/--(V.51$.5$

)0&&1.-D$%.)$1-/+.)$3.$AU(+/W.$)&51$0.AA.)$X'.$AU&5$-.1-&'V.$3/5)$A.)$V(32&)$;-2023.51.)$X'($)&519 $

.AA.)9 $3.) $ (+/W.) $3&0'+.51/(-.)D $B/5)$'5$)&'0() $3U'5(129 $)/5) $3&'1.9 $+/() $ (A $ S&'. $2W/A.+.51 $T$

-/;;-&0Q.- $ 0.) $ (+/W.) $ ;/))2.) $ .1 $ 0.) $ (+/W.) $;-2).51.) $ 3/5) $ '5 $+f+. $+&+.51 $ 3' $ L(A+ $;&'-$

Z-&'(AA.-$A.)$L-&51(,-.)D$B.$+f+.9$'5$+&+.51$0'-(.'R$3'$L(A+$.)1$-2;212$3.'R$L&()$M$'5$;.1(1$W/-\&5$

X'.$AU&5$V&(1$+/-0Q.-$3/5)$A/$V(AA.$.5$>???$;&-1.$'5.$W-/53.$2;2.$.1$).+ZA.$).$-.53-.$T$'5$0&'-)$

3U/-1)$+/-1(/'RD$:'$32Z'1$3.$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.9$.5$78>H9$'5$/3&A.)0.51$;&-1/51$'5.$2;2.$)(+(A/(-.$

1-/V.-).$A.$0/3-.D$!)1*0.$A.$+f+.$k$o(/$wQ/5W`.$5&')$(5V(1.$T$;.5).-$X'.$)(9$+f+.$)($0.A/$)(W5(L(. $

X'U(A$/$3i$(++(W-.-$/'$+f+.$.53-&(1$X'.$%(/5Ws(9$0.$X'($).-/(1$'5$0'-(.'R$Q/)/-3D$v-$.5$&Z).-V/51 $

/V.0$/11.51(&5$A.)$;A/5)9$&5$).$-.53$0&+;1.$X'.$0.A'($3'$;-.+(.-$W/-\&5$/$212$1&'-52$.5$Bg$h$A.)$

/01.'-)$5.$)&51$;/)$;-2).51)$3/5)$A.$0/3-.9$(A$)U/W(1$3U'5$;&(51$3.$V'.$3.$C/&$X'($-.W/-3.$;/)).-$A/ $

L&'A.D$aA$).+ZA.$3&50$X'.$0.$)&(1$'5.$(+/W.$3&0'+.51/(-.D$%/$).0&53.9$T$AU(5V.-).$/$Z(.5$212$1&'-52.$

.5$:%!Ä:D$o(/$wQ/5W`.9$S&'/51$.51-.$L(01(&5$.1$3&0'+.51/(-.9$0-22$'5$L'1'-$L(01(L$T$0.$;.1(1$W/-\&5$

Z(.5$-2.A9$.5$A.$L/()/51$+/-0Q.-$/V.0$A/$+f+.$2;2.$>b$/5)$;A')$1/-3D$%.$L(A+$21/51$)&-1($.5$78>b9$0.$

1.+;)$L(01(L$).$-/;;-&0Q.$3.$0.A'($3'$-2.A9$.1$0.$;.1(1$W/-\&5$3&(1$/'S&'-3UQ'($/V&(-$AUeW.$3.$0.A'($X'.$

+.1$.5$)0,5.$o(/$wQ/5W`.D$%U(51.-;2521-/1(&5$3'$1.+;)$-2.A$.1$3'$1.+;)$L(01(L$.)1$3&50$;A'-(.AA.9$

Page 118: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

+'A1(;A.D$!AA.$2A/-W(1$A.$0Q/+;$3.$A/$L(01(&5$.5$&'V-/51$3U/'1-.)$;&))(ZA.)9$.AA.$;-&A&5W.$A.$1.+;)$

L(01(L$3'$1.+;)$-2.AD$

%.)$(+/W.)$3&0'+.51/(-.)$5.$)&51$3U/(AA.'-)$;/)$A.)$).'A.)$T$S&'.-$0.$S.'D$B.$5&+Z-.'R$;A/5) $

1&'-52)$.5$:%!Ä:$0&51(.55.51$3.)$2A2+.51)$3&0'+.51/(-.)9$3U&Z).-V/1(&5$3.$A/$4Q(5.$M$3.)$;A/5)$

3U.5).+ZA.$&[$;/)).51 $ A.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$3.)$1-/5)(1(&5)$)'-$ A.)$;/O)/W.)$&'$0&51.5/51 $3.)$L&53)$

(512-.))/51)D$B.$A/$+f+.$+/5(,-.$X'U(A$.5-.W()1-/(1$A/$V(.$.5$788>9$wQ/5W`.$'1(A().$A/$L(01(&5$;&'-$

;-&3'(-.$3U/'1-.)$(+/W.)$3U/-0Q(V.)9$0.AA.$3.$;/O)/W.)$0Q(5&()$3.$78>HD$aA$-/;;-&0Q.$/A&-)$;/))2$.1$

;-2).51$.5$-.53/51$A.$);.01/1.'-$0&5)0(.519$;/-$A.$-/;;-&0Q.+.51$3.$0.)$(+/W.)9$X'.$0.AA.)$X'($A'($

;/-/()).51$/'S&'-3UQ'($3'$;-2).519$/'-&51$Z(.51j1$A.$0Q/-+.$3.)$/50(.55.)$.1$X'.$A.$1.+;)$L(A.$)/5)$

)U/--f1.-9$3.$+/5(,-.$0&51(5'.$.1$(5/A12-/ZA.D$%/$;Q&1&$3.)$&'V-(.-)$X'($&'V-.$A/$).0&53.$;/-1(.$.)1$

Z(.5$T$AU(+/W.$3.$A/$1.51/1(V.$3.$o(/$wQ/5W`.$M$.5-.W()1-.-$3.)$(+/W.)$3'$+&53.$/V/51$X'U(A$5.$)&(1$

321-'(19$;.53/51$X'U(A$.5$-.)1.$.50&-.$X'.AX'.)$1-/0.)D$B/5)$A/$+f+.$A&W(X'.9$A.$0/3-.$0&++.50.$

)&'V.51$)'-$'5$+'-9$'5$.);/0.$T$0j12$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)$;&'-$/--(V.-$)'-$.'RD$d5$;/55./'$)'-$A.$

0/+(&5$3/5)$A.X'.A$.)1$/))()$%(/5Ws($/A&-)$X'U(A$X'(11.$A/$V(AA.9$'5$/'1-.$)'-$A.)$A(1)*0&'0Q.11.)$&[$)&51$

/))()$C/&$.1$B&AA/-DDD$wQ/5W`.$).+ZA.$V&'A&(-$1&'S&'-)$+.11-.$.5$-/;;&-19$S')X'.$3/5)$A.)$;A')$;.1(1)$

321/(A)$3'$0/3-.9$).)$;.-)&55/W.)$.1$A.$+&53.$X'($A.)$.51&'-.9$AUQ()1&(-.$(53(V(3'.AA.$.1$0.AA.$3'$;/O)D$

aA $ )U/W(1 $ 3. $ L/(-. $ ).51(- $ AU/+;A.'- $ 3' $+&53. $ X'( $ A.) $ .51&'-.9 $ A. $ V.-1(W. $ 3' $ 1.+;) $ X'( $ ;/)).9$

AU(++.5)(12$3.$AU'5(V.-)$3/5)$A.X'.A$A.)$;.-)&55/W.)$)&51$)($L/(ZA.)$.1$+(5')0'A.)D

4.-1/(5.)$(+/W.)$3&0'+.51/(-.)$&51$2W/A.+.51$'5.$/'1-.$L&501(&5$3/5)$A.$L(A+D$aA$)U/W(1$3.)$

3.) $ ;A/5) $ ;A') $ A&5W)9 $ ;A') $ 0&51.+;A/1(L)9 $ 2W/A.+.51 $ 1&'-52) $ .5 $ Bg $+/() $ 5. $ )U(512W-/51 $ ;/)$

3(-.01.+.51$T$A/$5/--/1(&5D$!AA.)$L&501(&55.51$0&++.$3.)$1-/5)(1(&5)$.51-.$A.)$;/-1(.)D$wQ/5W`.$A.)$

1-/(1. $ 0&++. $ 3.) $ /AA')(&5) $ ;-20(.').)9 $ L-/W(A.)9 $ 3' $ ;/))2D $ !AA.) $ )&51 $ 3/V/51/W. $ 3. $ AU&-3-. $ 3.$

AU2V&0/1(&5$;&21(X'.9$(53(-.01.+.51$.5$-/;;&-1$/V.0$AUQ()1&(-.$3'$L(A+D$!AA.)$&51$;/-L&()$'5$/);.01$

;'-.+.51$/Z)1-/(1D$wQ/5W`.$S&'.$/V.0$A/$1.R1'-.$3.$AU(+/W.$/V.0$A.)$;A/5)$3'$"&'V.A$:5$0Q(5&()$X'(9$

-/A.51()9$1.53.51$V.-)$AU/Z)1-/01(&5D$4&++.$4Q-()$P/-`.-$3/5)$F$10'F,)&")'S&'/(1$T$L(A+.-$3.$1-,)$;-,)$

3.)$12A2V()(&5)$.1$3.)$(+/W.)$+&3(L(2.)9$wQ/5W`.$S&'.$/V.0$).)$(+/W.)$3&0'+.51/(-.)$T$A/$A(+(1.$3.$

AU.R;2-(+.51/AD$4.11.$(--';1(&5$3.$AU/Z)1-/(1 $3/5)$A/$L(01(&5$(5)1(AA.$'5$-/;;&-1$/'$1.+;)$3(LL2-.519$

320&55.012$3.$A/$).'A.$5/--/1(&59$X'($A/()).$A.$1.+;)$T$AU&Z).-V/1(&5$;&21(X'.$3'$+&53.D

B/5)$A.)$3.'R$3.-5(,-.)$;/-1(.)$3'$L(A+9$.AA.)$L&501(&55.51$0&++.$3.)$+&+.51)$3.$)&'V.5(-9$

3.)$-2+(5()0.50.)$3.$AU/50(.5$+&53.9 $X'($5U21/(1 $X'U(A $O$/$>8$/5)9 $+/()$X'(9 $32ST9 $).+ZA.$/V&(-$

Z./'0&';$0Q/5W2D$B.)$;/O)/W.)$/;;/-/()).51$3/5)$3.)$+&+.51)$3.$;/').9$/00&+;/W52)$3.$+')(X'.$

&'$3.$A/$V&(R$3U'5$;.-)&55/W.$.5$&LL$A.$1.+;)$3U'5$3(/A&W'.$'5$;.'$-2LA.R(LD$#/5)$f1-.$3(-.01.+.51$

Page 119: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

/))&0(2.)$/'R$;.-)&55/W.)9$0.)$(+/W.)$)'-W()).51$T$3.)$+&+.51)$&[$(A$.)1$X'.)1(&5$3'$;/))2D$%.)$

;-.+(,-.)$/;;/-/()).51$A&-)$3.$A/$)2;/-/1(&5$3.$C/&$.1$3.$%(/5Ws(9$T$A/$L(5$3.$A/$;-.+(,-.$;/-1(.D$%.)$

/'1-.)$A&-)$3.$A/$).0&53.$)2;/-/1(&59$E.51-.$C/&$.1$)&5$L(A)F$T$A/$L(5$3.$A/$3.'R(,+.D$B/5)$A.)$3.'R$

0/)9$A.)$(+/W.)$L&51$(53(-.01.+.51$-2L2-.50.$T$3.)$2A2+.51)$X'($3();/-/n1-&51D$

B/5)$A.$;-.+(.-9$(A$)U/W(1$3.$AU(+/W.$3'$0/+(&5$0Q/-W2$3.$+(5.-/($X'($+/5X'.$3.$).$-.5V.-).-$

)&')$A.$;&(3)$3.$A/$0Q/-W.D$%.$;A/5$L(R.$3'-.9$3&55/51$T$V&(-$3.)$&'V-(.-)$X'($)U/W(1.51$/'1&'-$3.$A'(9$

/11.53/51$3.$V&(-$)($A.$0/+(&5$;/-V(.53-/$T$32+/--.-D$aA$)U/W(1$2V(3.++.51$3U'5.$+21/;Q&-.$3.$A/$

4Q(5.9$X'($V.'1$1-&;9$1-&;$V(1.9$X'(11.$T$).$-.5V.-).-$)&')$A.$0Q&0$3'$0Q/5W.+.51D$P/()$A.$;A/5$.)1$

2W/A.+.51$/))&0(2$T$'5.$(+/W.$3.$%(/5Ws($X'($X'(11.$A/$V(AA.9$)/$+(5.9$).)$0&AA,W'.)$;&'-$;/-1(-$V.-)$

3U/'1-.)$Q&-(s&5)D$aA$).+ZA.$-fV.-$T$0.$+&53.$X'($V/$3();/-/n1-.$.1$X'($.)1$A.$)(.5D$%/$)2X'.50.$.)1$.5$

-2/A(12$0&+;&)2.$3.$3.'R$/'1-.)$;A/5)9$X'($(51.-V(.55.51$/V/51$0.A'($3'$0/+(&5$M$'5$;A/5$)'-$'5.$

L&-f19$/'$0-2;')0'A.$.1$3.$)(AQ&'.11.)$/'$A&(5$X'($L&51$'5$L.'9$;'()$0.A'($3U'5.$1.--.$/-(3.9$&[$A.)$

/-Z-.)$&51$212$Z-iA2)$&'$0&';2)$.1$&[$A.)$W.5)$/11.53.519$.5$W-&';.$.1$&[$AU&5$1.51.-/$3.$32+/--.-$A.$

0/+(&5D$4.)$(+/W.)9$Z(.5$X'.$+O)12-(.').)9$2V&X'.51$2W/A.+.51$A/$;.-1.9$A/$3();/-(1(&5$3.$0.)$Z&()$

(++.5).)$.1$+O)12-(.'R$0&51-.$'5.$4Q(5.$/'R$)&A)$Z&'.'R9$)/5)$V2W21/1(&5D$%/$4Q(5.$).$321-'(1$

.AA.*+f+.9$Z-iA.$)/$;-&;-.$1.--.$3/5)$'5$+&'V.+.51$3U/'1&3.)1-'01(&5$/Z)'-3.D$

B/5)$A.$).0&539$(A $)U/W(1$3.$L&-+/1(&5)$-&0Q.').)9$X'.$)'-V&A.-&51$;A')$1/-3$3/5)$A.$L(A+$

B&AA/-$.1$)/$;-&L.)).'-$.1$3U'5$0&'0Q.-$3.$)&A.(A$L(A+2$3/5)$'5$LA&'$/Z)1-/(19$.1$0&51.+;A/1(LD$%/$

3();/-(1(&5$3'$;-.+(.-$).-/$2V&X'2.$3.$+/5(,-.$3(-.01.$3/5)$A.$L(A+$M$A/$;-&L.)).'-$.R;A(X'.$T$B&AA/-$

X'U(A $.R()1/(1 $/';/-/V/51$G$3.$0.)$L&-+/1(&5)$.1 $X'U(A $5U.5$-.)1.51$/'S&'-3UQ'( $;A')$X'.$3.'RD$%/$

).0&53.$L/(1$(53(-.01.+.51$-2L2-.50.$T$A/$;.-1.$3.$)/1'-/1(&5$;-&W-.))(V.$3/5)$A.$L(A+D$B/5)$0.11.$

:')1-/A(.$W-().$&[$;A')$-(.5$5.$).+ZA.$/V&(-$3.$)/V.'-9$A/$-2+(5()0.50.$3U'5$0&'0Q.-$3.$)&A.(A$.1$3.$

).)$0&'A.'-)$(50/-5.$1&'1.$A/$5&)1/AW(.$3'$;.-)&55/W.D$

Page 120: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

!"#$%&'(%')#'*+,-%.'(/+,%0'

Page 121: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

!"#$"%&'()*(+%&,(-

Page 122: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

$ wQ/5W`.$/;;A(X'.$A/$V()(&5$;.))(+()1.$3'$+2A&3-/+.$T$'5.$A.01'-.$;&A(1(X'.$3.$)&5$;/O)$h$(A$

0&5)1-'(1$'5$1.+;)$;-&L&532+.51$/50-2$3/5)$AUQ()1&(-.9$;-20()2+.51$-2L2-.5029$X'($;.-3$;.'$T$;.'$

)&5$).5)D$%.)$.);&(-)$3.$A/$4Q(5.$V&51$3.$;/(-.$/V.0$0.'R$3.)$;.-)&55/W.)9$;A.(5)$3.$AU.51Q&')(/)+.$

3. $ A/ $ S.'5.)).9 $ ;&'- $ /AA.- $ V.-) $ '5 $ ;-&L&53 $ 32).);&(- $ &[ $ (A) $ 5. $ ;.'V.51 $ ;A') $ X'U/))()1.- $ T $ A/$

3.)1-'01(&5$3'$+&53.$&[$ (A)$V(V/(.51D $%.)$;.-)&55/W.) $5U.5$).+ZA.51 $+f+.$;/) $0&5)0(.51)9 $5.$

V(V/51$0.11.$0Q'1.$+&-/A.$.1$Q'+/(5.$X'.$3'$;&(51$3.$V'.$3.$A.'-)$-.A/1(&5)$)&0(/A.)D$%.)$0A/)).)$

;&;'A/(-.) $ X'. $32;.(51 $wQ/5W`.9 $ ;-()&55(,-.) $ .1 $ /V.'WA2.) $3/5) $ A. $ 1.+;) $;-2).51 $ 5. $ L&51 $ X'.$

;.-0.V&(-$0.)$Z&'A.V.-).+.51)$)/5)$A.)$1Q2&-().-D$:V.0$0.$L(A+9$wQ/5W`.$1.51.$3U&'V-(-$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$

)'-$A/$3.)1-'01(&5$3.$A/$4Q(5.$/'$0&'-)$3'$1.+;)D$

$

Page 123: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

(?$1/09+%$1

%/$A.\&5$3'$+2A&3-/+.$)'-$A.$1.+;)$.)1$/'))($+&-/A.$X'U.AA.$.)1$;.))(+()1.D$%.$+2A&3-/+.$

.)1$'5.$0Q'1.$M$A.$+&53.$).$1-/5)L&-+.$.5$'5$/'1-.$1&'S&'-)$;A')$320/3.519$;A')$1-()1.$.1$)/5)$.);&(-D$

%/ $ S.'5.)). $ 3.) $ ;.-)&55/W.)9 $ ;A.(5. $ 3U.);2-/50.) $ .)1 $ .5 $ -2/A(12 $ A. $ 3.-5(.- $+&+.51 $ ;&'- $ f1-.$

Q.'-.'R$M$1&'1$0.$X'($/3V(.53-/$.5)'(1.$5.$;&'--/$X'Uf1-.$;(-.D$!5$/11.53/519$A.$+2A&3-/+.$;-&;&).$

3.$V(V-.$).A&5$X'.AX'.)$;-(50(;.)$;&'-$2V(1.-$3.$)&'LL-(-$3/V/51/W.$M$5.$;/)$1-&;$.);2-.-$3.$A/$V(.9$).$

0&51.51.-$3.$0.$X'.$AU&5$/9$0Q.-0Q.-$3'$0j12$3.$).)$;-&0Q.)$AU/+&'-$X'($5&')$+/5X'.-/$1&'S&'-)$3/5)$

A/$V(.D$aA$5.$L/'1$;/)$.);2-.-$'5$0Q/5W.+.51$3/5)$A.$+&53.$M$A.)$L/(ZA.)$).-&51$1&'S&'-)$20-/)2)9$A.)$

L.++.)$)&'+().)$/'R$Q&++.)9 $ A.)$5&(-) $/'$).-V(0.)$3.)$ZA/50)D $aA $5.$5&')$-.)1. $X'UT$/11.53-.$

)/W.+.51$A/$+&-19$;-&L(1/51$3'$;/))/W.$3'$1.+;)$0&++.$(A$V/$h$5.$;/)$A'11.-9$+/()$).$A/()).-$;&-1.-9 $

0/-$A/$A'11.$).-/$1&'S&'-)$'5.$320.;1(&5D$:'R$/51(;&3.)$3U'5$-.W/-3$-2V&A'1(&55/(-.$)'-$A.$+&53.9$A. $

+2A&3-/+.$(50/-5.$'5.$V()(&5$3'$1.+;)$&[$1&'1$.)1$V&'2$T$-.0&++.50.-$.1$&[$A.)$+&3(L(0/1(&5)$X'($

5&')$;/-/()).51$A.)$;A')$(+;&-1/51.)$5U&51$.5$-2/A(12$X'U'5$(+;/01$+(5(+.D$%.)$W-/53)$;-(50(;.)$X'($

W'(3.51$AUf1-.$Q'+/(5$-.)1.51$A.)$+f+.)$.1$)/$A'11.$;&'-$A/$02A2Z-(129$&'$AU/+&'-$5.$AU.+;f0Q.-/$;/)$

3.$L(5(-$3/5)$A/$1&+Z.D$%UQ&++.$5U/$3U/'1-.$0Q&(R$X'.$3U/00.;1.-$A.$1.+;)$;A'1j1$X'.$3.$A'11.-$0&51-.$

A'(D$N.5-.$;&;'A/(-.$;/-$.R0.AA.50.9$A.$+2A&3-/+.$1.51.$3.$L/(-.$;/)).-$0.11.$A.\&5$T$).)$);.01/1.'-)9$

/;;A(X'/51$/'$).(5$3.$A/$L/+(AA.9 $3.$AU(51(+.9$'5.$-2LA.R(&5$)'-$A/$0&53(1(&5$3.$AUQ&++.$3/5)$A.$

+&53.D$

Page 124: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

([%E0%$@&*.K%'$

:53-(59 $ P'-(.A; ' !$)@C"E-&0 ' A ' )& ' 4@),(#$4& ' C")4"E-& ' $4@#"3$"1 ' &2 ' 0&0 ' 8@#,\1&0Z]^_`a]^bcY; '

<-'R.AA.)9'=.1.-$%/5W9$0&AA$-.;.5).-$A.$0(52+/9$788J

B.$<./'V&(-9$#(+&5.9$^$%UeW.$3.$A/$3()0-21(&5$_9$3/5)$A/ $5&44&'#,4?-&;$N/AA(+/-39$=/-()9$>?Gb9$

-2.3D$]&A(&$

B.A.'s.9$N(AA.)9'+>"4$%&a4,-*&4&12R'g"1@4$']9$=/-()9$%.)$23(1(&5)$3.$+(5'(19$>?G@

B'L(.L9$:55.*#(+&5.;'+&'28@e2#&'$-'j<jK'0"K3)&'k'(-'#,4$12"04&'$-'0N4:,)"04&;'=/-()9'<-2/A9$0&AAD$

:+;Q($A.11-.)9$78>H

$](.A39$#O39$F3@1$#",'A')&0':$0&0'(&')>@3#"2-#&9$1-/3D$"/3(/$!33/{-/9$BaÄaC9$=/-()9$788G

N&-1&59 $ y-()1O59 $78&,#"0"1% ' (&0"#& ' A ' C#,4 '5#&-( ' 2, ' 5&4"1"04 ' 2, ' 5")49 $ ".K $}&-`9 $ =/AW-/V.$

P/0+(AA/59$788G

%/5W9 $ Y&Z.-19 $ %.' 4@),(#$4& ' $4@#"3$"1 ' A ' B#"CC"28; ' D"(,#; ' !"11&))"9 $ 1-/3D $ "&qA $ <'-0Q9 $ =/-()$

%Ur/-+/11/59$0&AAD$4Q/+;)$V()'.A)$21-/5W.-)9$788GD

%&'-0.AA.)9$o/0X'.)9$+&'("32",11$"#&'(-'3"1@4$9$V&AD@9$=/-()9$YD%/LL&519$0&AAD$<&'X'(5)9$788@

P(0Q/.A)9$%A&O39$<1%4$#'=&#%4$1>0'?&#0,1$;$4/+Z-(3W.9$4/+Z-(3W.$d5(V.-)(1O$=-.))9$7888

"/0/0Q.9 $ o/0X'.A(5.9 $[,))N9,,(; ' )>&))"?0& '&2 ' )>"1C")4@9 $=/-()9 $%UQ/-+/11/59 $0&AAD $4Q/+;)$V()'.A)9$

788>D

$

Y&AA/539$Y&+/(59$+&'28@e2#&'(-'?&-?)&9$=/-()9$4&+;A.R.9$0&AAD$%.$1Q2e1-.$.5$X'.)1(&59$788@

w/+&'-9$]-/5\&().9$+&'4@),(#$4&'($10')&'3"1@4$'3,12&4?,#$"1;'-1&'C$:#"E-&'(&0'?&-?)&09$Y.55.)9$

=dY9$0&AAD$%.$);.01/0'A/(-.$4(52+/9$78>ID

Page 125: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

(X%0#$@&*.K%'(.&%1/%.*0'

X"&'=l380&'(&#'J$1(,#$

Z+,-),-Y

Y2/A()/1(&5$M$N.&-W$z(AQ.A+$=/Z)1

:%%!P:N"!9$>?7?

"&(-$.1$ZA/509$+'.19$>@@+(5D

@b++$6$>D@@$M$>

#025/-(&$M$N.&-W$z(AQ.A+$=/Z)1$.1$%/3()A/')$g/S3/

4Q.L$v;2-/1.'-$M$NÇ51Q.-$y-/+;L

B(-.01(&5$/-1()1(X'.$M$:53-.S$:53-.S.K

P&51/W.$M$o&).;Q$]A.()A.-

P')(X'.$M$=..-$Y/Z.5

=-&3'01(&5$M$#.O+&'-$".Z.5s/A

:01.'-)$;-(50(;/'R$M$%&'().$<-&&`)9$]-/50()$%.3.-.-9$4/-A$N&.1s9$:A(0.$Y&Z.-1)

BU/;-,)$AU/3/;1/1(&5$3.$3.'R$;(,0.)$3.$]-/5`$z.3.`(539$T#(%&"02'.1$X"&'=l380&'(&#'J$1(,#$

<4"2$2",1',C')"C&

EP(-/W.$3.$A/$V(.F

Y2/A()/1(&5$M$B&'WA/)$#(-`

d#:9$>?b?

0&'A.'-9$)&5$+&5&9$>7b$+(5D

@b$++$6$>DGb$M$>

#025/-(&$M$!A.&5&-$N-(LL(5$.1$:AA/5$#0&11$3U/;-,)$A.$-&+/5$3.$]/55(.$r'-)1

4Q.L$&;2-/1.'-$M$Y')).AA$P.11O

B(-.01(&5$/-1()1(X'.$M$:A.R/53.-$N&A(1s.5

P&51/W.$M$P(A1&5$4/--'1Q

P')(X'.$M$]-/5`$#`(55.-$.1$r.5-O$P/50(5(

=-&3'01(&5$M$Y&))$r'51.-

:01.'-)$;-(50(;/'R$M$%/5/$C'-5.-9$o'/5(1/$P&&-.9$#/53-/$B..9$#')/5$y&Q5.-9$o&Q5$N/V(5

Page 126: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

F8m18@'%n#@1

E:'*3.AT$3.)$+&51/W5.)F

Y2/A()/1(&5$M$o(/$wQ/5W`.

o:=v"9$78>b

0&'A.'-9$)&5$)1.-.&9$>7I$+(5D

:YYaY:z$79Gy$6$>D@J$M$>$x$>DGbM>$x$7D@b$M$>

#025/-(&$M$o(/$wQ/5W`.

4Q.L$v;2-/1.'-$M$}'$%(`*z/(

B(-.01(&5$/-1()1(X'.$M$c(/5W$%('

P&51/W.$M$P/11Q(.'$%/0A/'

P')(X'.$M$}&)Q(Q(-&$r/55&

=-&3'01(&5$M$#Q&s&$a0Q(O/+/9$"/1Q/5/qA$y/-+(1s9$o(/$wQ/5W`.9$Y.5$wQ&5WA'59$%('$#Q(O'

:01.'-)$;-(50(;/'R$M$wQ/&$C/&9$wQ/5W$}(9$%(/5W$o(5W*3&5W9$B&5W$w(S/59$#OAV(/$4Q/5W

Page 127: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

X%0#$@&*.K%'(*))%,%$11'00'

$

:%PvBvg:Y9$=.3-&9$+$'?"&)'E-&'8$:"2,9$!);/W5.9$78>>9$>>J+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

:%PvBvg:Y9$=.3-&9$7$3,1&0')&o$1,09$E1/A&5)$/(W'(AA.)F9$!);/W5.9$>??>9$>>@+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

<:%%9$:A/59$F"Q'5&&2'W1(&#;'d#:9$788>*788b9$b$)/()&5)9$I@$2;()&3.)$3.$bb$+(5'1.)9$0&'A.'-D

<Ya##!:d9$o./5*4A/'3.9$O,3&'=)$138&;$]-/50.9$>?G?9$0&'A.'-D

<vYw:N!9$]-/5`9$F&*&128'8&$*&19$EAUQ.'-.$)';-f+.F9$d#:9$>?7J9$>7J+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

4:##:g!C!#9$o&Q59$.'i,4$1'W1(&#'28&'<1C)-&13&9$Ed5.$L.++.$)&')$(5LA'.50.F9$d#:9$>?JH9$>bb+(5D9$0&'A.'-

4dYCaw9$P(0Q/.A9$g$0$:)$13$9$d#:9$>?H79$>87$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

<Yvvy#9$Y(0Q/-39'g$2',1'$'[,2'7"1'd,,C;'EA/$0Q/11.$)'-$'5$1&(1$Z-iA/51F9$>?bG9$>8G9+(5D9$0&'A.'-D$

4r:=%a"9$4Q/-A(.9$78&'P"(9$d#:9$>?7>9$IG+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

4r:=%a"$4Q/-A(.9$.'9,4$1'"1'J$#"0$EAU&;(5(&5$;'ZA(X'.F9$d#:9$>?7@9$JG$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

4r:=%a"$4Q/-A(.9$4(1O$A(WQ1)9$EA.)$A'+(,-.)$3.$A/$V(AA.F9$d#:9$>?@>9$GJ+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

4%|P!"C9$Y.529$o.'R$(51.-3(1)9$]-/50.9$>?b79$GI$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D$

4v==v%:9$]-/50()9$]&-39$C.1-&9$d#:*:-W.51(5.*!);/W5.*a1/A(.9$788?9$>7I$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50$.1$0&'A.'-D$

4dyvY9$N.&-W.9'.'02$#'"0':,#19$d#:9$>?bH9$>I?+(5D9$0&'A.'-D$

B!P}9$o/0X'.)9'+&0'?$#$?)-"&0'(&'g8&#:,-#%9$]-/50.9$>?IH9$?>$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

Bv%:"9$Ä/V(.-9$!,44N9$d#:9$78>H9$>@H+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

]:##<a"B!Y9$Y/(5.-$zD9'.1%02'&00&1'F&&)&'$-C9$E1&')$A.)$/'1-.)$)U/;;.AA.51$:A(F$9$:AA.+/W5.9$>?JH9$?@$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D$

]:##<a"B!Y9$X"&'="22&#&1'7#p1&1'(&#'J&2#$'*,1'L$12;$EA.)$A/-+.)$/+,-.)$3.$=.1-/$g&5$y/51F9$:AA.+/W5.9$>?J79$>7H$

+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

]%!Pa"N9$g(01&-9$B,1&'9"28'28&'9"1(9$E:'1/51$.5$.+;&-1.$A.$V.51F9$>?@?9$7@G$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

NY:}9$o/+.)9$78&'"44"%#$129$d#:9$78>@9$>78+(5D9$0&'A.'-D$

NYa]]aCr9$B/V(3DzD9$=#,P&1'=),00,409$EA.$AO)$Z-()2F9$d#:9$>?>?9$?8$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

NYa]]aCr9$B/V(3DzD9$M#?8$10'"1'28&'02,#49$EA.)$3.'R$&-;Q.A(5.)F9$d#:9$>?7>9$>b8+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

r:}"!#$C&339$5$#'C#,4'8&$*&19$EA&(5$3'$;/-/3()F9$d#:9$78879$>8J+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

raC4r4v4y9$d&:&33$9$d#:9$>?H89$>@8+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D$

raC4r4v4y9$D&#2"%,9$E#'.'-)$L-&(3.)F9$d#:9$>?bG9$>7G$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

AUr!Y<a!Y9$P/-0.A9$+&':,18&-#9$]-/50.9$>?@89$?G+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D$

Page 128: 9(#0$)&*#' - ens-louis-lumiere.fr · $$f*e0'()'+(#*,%g&'+((! y.+.-0(.+.51

%!:"9$B/V(39$.'=#&*&'T13,12&#9$<-,V.$-.50&51-.9$Y&O/'+.*d5(9$>?Hb9$GI$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

%!za"9$:AZ.-19$J$1(,#$9$Y&O/'+.*d5(9$>?b>9$>77+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

y:Y*z:a$zv"N9$[$??N'2,%&28&#9$r&5W$y&5W9$>??J9$?I$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

y:w:"9$!A(/9$T$02',C'T(&1$Et$AU.)1$3U!3.5F9$d#:9$>?bb9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

y:w:"9$!A(/9$F?)&1(,#'"1'28&'%#$009$EA/$L(,V-.$3/5)$A.$)/5WF9$d#:9$>?I>9$>7H+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

P:"ya!za4w9$o&).;Q$%D9$78&'%8,02'$1('!#0R'!-"#;'EAU/V.51'-.$3.$P.$P'(-F9$d#:9$>?HJ9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

P!"B!#9$#/+9$Y.V&A'1(&55/-O$-&/39$EA.)$5&0.)$-.Z.AA.)F9$d#:9$788G9$>>?+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

Pa}:w:ya9$r/O/&9$EA.$V.51$).$A,V.F9$o/;&59$78>79$>7I+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

PawvNd4ra9$y.5S(9$MN-a0$4$9$EP())$vO'F9$o/;&59$>?b>9$G?$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

=:<#C9$N.&-W$z(AQ.A+9$X"&'=l380&'(&#'J$1(,#$'Z%&'A&'F9$:AA.+/W5.9$>?7?9$>@@$+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/509$)(A.50(.'RD

=a:%:C9$P/'-(0.9$)>&1C$13&'1-&9$]-/50.9$>?I?9$G@$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

=v%:"#ya9$7&009$]-/50.*Y&O/'+.$d5(9$>?J?9$>GI$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

Y:}9$"(0Q&A/)9$="%%&#'28$1')"C&9$EB.--(,-.$A.$+(-&(-F9$d#:9$>?bI9$?b$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

Y:}9$"(0Q&A/)9'.'d&:&)'98"28,-2'$'3$-0&9$E%/$L'-.'-$3.$V(V-.F9$d#:9$>?bb9$>>>$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

Y!#":a#9$:A/(59$+>$4,-#'/'4,#29$]-/50.9$>?GH9$GG$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

#aYy9$B&'WA/)9'.))'78$2'[&$*&1'.)),90;'E1&'1$0.$X'.$A.$0(.A$;.-+.1F9$d#:9$>?bb9$G?$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

#aYy$B&'WA/)9$i#"22&1',1'28&'9"1(9$E20-(1$)'-$3'$V.51F9$d#:9$>?bI9$??$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

#C:r%9$o&Q5$PD9$!$%1"C"3&12'M:0&00",1'EA.$).0-.1$+/W5(L(X'.F9$d#:9$>?@b9$>>7+(59$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D$

#C:r%9$o&Q5$PD9'<4"2$2",1',C'+"C&9$Ea+/W.$3.$A/$V(.F9$d#:9$>?@H9$>>>+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

gaBvY9$y(5W9$F2&))$'X$))$09$d#:9$>?@J9$>8I+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D

ga%%!"!dg!9$B.5()9$<13&1("&9$4/5/3/9$78>89$>@8$+(5D9$0&'A.'-D

z}%!Y9$z(AA(/+9$H&I&:&)$EAU(5)&'+().F9$d#:9$>?@G9$>8H+(5D9$5&(-$.1$ZA/50D$