7 marra rsciw - university of wisconsin–madison · marra et al. 1993, l&o. estonian (turbid)...

18
Trophodynamics 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 1 Developed by Raymond Lindemann, a limnologist, but Largely abandoned by them, and • Enthusiastically employed by oceanographers Basis of productivity studies

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jun-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Trophodynamics

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 1

• Developed by Raymond Lindemann, a limnologist, but

• Largely abandoned by them, and

• Enthusiasticallyemployed by oceanographers

• Basis of productivity studies

Page 2: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 2

The Major Goal of Biological Oceanography:

“…determination of time-varying plankton productivity in the world ocean…”

-Barber and Hilting (2002)

Page 3: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Simple Model for Productivity, PP

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 3

PP = × aph × Eo

Primary production = ‘fraction’ of Irradiance absorbed x efficiency of conversion

Page 4: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Since Chl-a is the main ocean color data product

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 4

PP = × a*ph × Chla × Eo

Page 5: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Absorption Properties

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 5

atot = aw + acdom + anap + aph

Case 2 waters: acdom and anap

• are significant, or dominant• do not co-vary with aph

Page 6: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

PPinsitu may be predictable from the Simple Model

• Gulf of Maine in the ‘90s• Turbid Estonian Lakes• Irish Sea

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 6

Examples from:

Page 7: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Gulf of Maine, ‘90s

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 7

Marra et al. 1993, L&O

Page 8: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Estonian (Turbid) Lakes

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8

Arst et al., 2008

Page 9: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

Irish Sea:Absorption Model explained more

variance

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 9

Tilstone et al., 2005

Page 10: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 10

Irish Sea:Application to Satellite Data

Tilstone et al., 2005

Page 11: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

The Way Forward

1. Need a model for CDOM (at least) dynamics

(‘light utilization index’) models deserve another look

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 11

Page 12: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

1. CDOM Dynamics

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 12

Arabian Sea, SE Monsoon

Increasing time near surface?

Increasing photo-oxidation?

Page 13: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

2. models

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 13

Falkowski, 1981

= B/4.6

Requires and accurate definition of the euphotic zone!

Platt, 1986

Page 14: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 14

modeling: Northern Gulf of Mexico

Page 15: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 15

We need better estimates of the Compensation Depth to define the

Actual Euphotic Zone

Page 16: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

ONDEQUE, PP and Rp for

stations in the NW Atlantic

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 16

Page 17: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

The Compensation Depth (where P=R)

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 17

ONDEQUE program, NW Atlantic, 2008Marra et al., submitted

1%Eo

P=R

Page 18: 7 Marra RSCIW - University of Wisconsin–Madison · Marra et al. 1993, L&O. Estonian (Turbid) Lakes 20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 8 Arst et al., 2008. Irish Sea: Absorption Model

20-22 June 2011 RSCIW Workshop 18

AUTOTROPH BACTERIAL

RESPIRATION

DISSOLVED ORGANIC MATTER

EUPHOTIC DEPTH