4133 p3 2013-06-13
TRANSCRIPT
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 1/16
Df`ähcf Oa`az# pèrfbf om Cmarah# mk m`trmvasth
Cmarah á ukh phròquah pcurhc#
dm`mrfsh m omsmgfsh om hprfeu`ohr
h suh eá
p. < m 1
Rmkh`èraf oafbmsh`f • www.gfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt
Oarmtfr7 Bhrcfs Khdhclâms om Bhrvhclf
H`f C\\\A • `· ?822 • ^2 • 82 om gu`lf om :>82 • >#=>₣
Rh`tuèraf om Eètakh bfk h bfr# hcmdrah m m`tusahskf
om kaclhrms om brah`ähs
–Omvmkfs smr h`gfs u`s phrh fs futrfs‛ p. 4
^hrh f pròxakf h`f phstfrhc
O. H`tò`af Khrtf h`u`bah `fkmhäýms÷ctakh
^hròquah om Cmarah mk omsthqump. 2 h =
C u ë s o m F C a v m a r h
C K E z
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 2/16
82 om gu`lf om :>: •
Khrdhraoh _maxmarhGurasth
Mstakuchr hs ehkëcahs
h phrtabaphr
H phròquah om Cmarah gè lè hcdu`s h`fs tmkfrdh`azhof ourh`tm f pmrëfof cmtavf ukhKassh ofka`abhc pmcfs 81l2># `h adrmgh ofMspëratf Rh`tf# bf`lmbaoh pmch –Kassh ofsMstuoh`tms‛. Msth a`abahtavh# phrh hcák om ef+km`thr `fs gfvm`s h phrtabaphäâf m f m`vfc+vakm`tf `h suh frdh`azhäâf# tmk thkjákh vh`thdmk om mstakuchr hs ehkëcahs h phrta+baphr `msths kasshs# qum hs sm`tmk om ukhefrkh khas pròxakh m khas oaradaoh hfssmus clfs# f qum tmk omsm`bhomhof ukh
vf`thom khas dm`uë`h m mspf`tê`mh# pfrphrtm omstms# `h suh phrtabaphäâf. Hduhroh+kfs f a`ëbaf of pròxakf h`f cmtavf(
Gfâf ^fähs Rh`tfs^rfemssfr `f A^C
H kassâfom ,`fvh! mvh`dmcazhäâf
Omsthbh`of uk ofs hspmtfs khas pfsatavfsoh phròquah om Cmarah ,Rá!# f`om eua jhtazh+of m h qum pmrtm`äf mk eu`äâf oh ka`lhrmsaoç`bah# `âf pfssf omaxhr om sujca`lhrh kassâf om ,`fvh! mvh`dmcazhäâf h qum hhtuhc mquaph om shbmroftms hf smrvaäf omsthbfku`aohom# bffrom`hoh pmcf phorm Df`+ähcf _maxmarh Oa`az# tmk vaof h cmvhr h bhjf#rmvathcazh`of msth bfku`aohom# urjh`h# m`+vmclmbaoh m omsmrtabhoh# h qum sm m`trmdh+rhk bfk c÷baof m`tusahskf.Xuh`tf î vmrtm`tm `mdhtavh# pm`sf qum ápfssëvmc hpf`thr h m`vfcvm`tm om ukh bmrth–mbcmsafefjah‛ ,qumk shjm sm ukh mspábamom –bfkpcmxf+of+brakm+of+phorm+hkhrf‛!qum phrmbm bhrhtmrazhr h baohom om Cmarahm qum h tfr`h erah h kuaths a`abahtavhs qumclm sâf prfpfsths. Umgh+sm f mxmkpcf oh rm+bm`tm Emsth oh Eá# qum kfvakm`tfu kuatfskaclhrms om pmssfhs# khs qum efa quhsm ad+`frhoh pmch akprm`sh rmdaf`hc…
_avm ukh moubhäâf
bhtòcabh m smkprm
prakma pfr bukprar
bfk fs kmus
omvmrms brastâfs. Lèbmrbh om ofas h`fs#
hssuka h ka`lh
lfkfssmxuhcaohom.
Bfkf pfomrè h ka`lh
fram`thäâf smxuhc
a`eum`bahr h ka`lh
vavç`bah brastâ6
^rfburhrma jhsmhr h ka`lh rmspfsth mk
trçs hspmtfs7
8· H frkh bfkf h Adrmgh vç h vavç`bah
oh smxuhcaohom lukh`h phrtm ohqua+
cf qum á khas mcmkm`thr `f lfkmk7 f
smu bfrpf. Á pfrqum –sfkfs uk bfrpf‛
qum mxastakfs# qum sfkfs hcduák `mstm
ku`of# qum m`trhkfs mk rmchäâf bfk
hqumcms qum `fs rfomahk m tmkfs h pfs+
sajacaohom om clms omoabhr f `fssf hmtf
m hkfr. ^fr assf# ukh moubhäâf bhtòca+
bh a`bcua smkprm ukh hprm`oazhdmk sf+
jrm h kh`marh om m`tm`omr# sm`tar m va+
vmr h smxuhcaohom. @âf á a`oamrm`tm î
á h frkh bfkf mxprmsshkfs fs `fssfs
hmtfs. Á htrhvás omcms qum m`trhkfs mk
bf`thbtf bfk fs qum fs rfomahk.
:· F futrf pf`tf u`ohkm`thc phrh h
`fssh rmmxâf á h oamrm`äh m bfkpcm+km`thraohom mxastm`tms m`trm f khsbu+
ca`f m f mka`a`f. H `hturmzh mz+`fs
oamrm`tms# bhphzms om hbrmsbm`thr `f+
vaohom m sm`taof hf smxf fpfstf. Á jmcf
smr+sm lfkmk m á jmcf smr+sm kuclmr. Á
jfk m jmcf smr+sm oamrm`tm. Khas7 bhoh
uk sò shjmrè qumk vmrohomarhkm`tm á
quh`of sm m`bf`trhr bfk f futrf m f rm+
bf`lmbmr oamrm`tm om sa. Rò m`tâf f pf+
omrè vmrohomarhkm`tm hkhr.
2· H bhstaohom á h prfpfsth brastâ phrh
h vavç`bah oh smxuhcaohom. Bf`sfh`tm
f smu msthof# bhoh brastâf omvm prfbu+
rhr fs kmafs `mbmssèrafs phrh hzmr oh
suh vaoh uk htf om hkfr hf smu smkm+
clh`tm# h mxmkpcf om Gmsus Brastf. _hk+ják îs pmssfhs lfkfssmxuhas á prfpfs+
tf f kmskf fjgmtavf7 –^mchs vartuoms om
hutfofkë`af# moubhofrhs oh cajmrohom
a`tmrafr m# îs vmzms# pmcf hpfaf om ukh
hkazhom omsa`tmrmsshoh# pmch frhäâf m
pmch drhäh shbrhkm`thc# pfomk m omvmk
hprfxakhr+sm# drhouhc m rmsfcuthkm`tm#
oh pmrmaäâf brastâ.‛ ,BAB :2=1!.
Gfsá HudustfOarmtfr of Omphrthkm`tf oh ^hstfrhc Ehkacahr
M`vam h suh qumstâf phrh
rmohbhfNgfr`hcprmsm`tm
fu omaxm+h mk
ehbmjffi.bfk&gfr`hcprmsm tm
^huch ZajmarfMoubhofrh om A`eê`bah
Rmr phrfquah`h
mk Cmarah
Rmr phrfquah`h mk Cmarah á vavm`bahr bmjrhäýms emstavhs kuatf rabhs# phrtaclhohphrtabaphohs m sm`tar qum h phròquah# hpshr om drh`om dmfdrhbhkm`tm# á ku
pmqum`h `f qum tfbh î phrtabaphäâf `vèrafs drupfs qum a`tmdrhk f trhjhclf prfquahc.Á ukh phròquah om baohom# rmbmjm qu`mch trhjhclh m mstuoh# m assf á jmk vasë`f `÷kmrf om brah`ähs qum ermqum`thkvèrafs bm`trfs om bhtmqumsm# `f `÷kmrf
jhtaskfs# f trhjhclf om bhrtòraf phrfqukhs âf sm sm`tm mk bhoh ofka`df `hs cmjrhäýms# `h phrtabaphäâf oh vaoh bfkutèrah. _rhth+sm om ukh phròquah bfk vèrbm`trfs om buctf qum oaspmrshk m bfkpkmtmk# pfr vmzms# h u`aohom m aom`taohoh pròprah phròquah# hssak f sa`tf(Bfkf phrfquah`h om Cmarah# pm`sf qum`fssf omshf á shjmr hbfclmr qumk `
–vasath‛ m bf``fsbf qumr phrtaclhr h suh bhtavh`of+fs# a`bcua`of+fs# bfrrmspf`shcazh`of+fs# phrh qum bf`sadhkfs brmsbfkf bfku`aohom phrh hcák oh fraddmfdrèbh.
H`h ^huch Rh`tfs^sabòcfdh
H Kassh phrh hs brah`ähs
khas –htrhtavh‛
H phròquah om Cmarah tmk kuaths bfashs pf+satavhs. _m`of qum ehzmr hcduk omsthqum# rm+
rf ouhs a`statuaäýms om rmemrç`bah f hpfaf
sfbahc7 f Bm`trf Rfbahc m ^hrfquahc ^hucf UAm f BHC + Bm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf om Cmarah.^fr futrf chof# pm`sf qum h Kassh phrh hsbrah`ähs pfomrah tmr futrf akphbtf m smrkhas –htrhtavh‛# ush`of phchvrhs sakpcms `hbfku`abhäâf bfk mchs m ehzm`of h h`akh+äâf bfk bê`tabfs homquhofs î suh aohom.Rudmstâf7 a`statuar h rmhcazhäâf om bf`bmr+
tfs om òrdâf `h Rá# ehzm`of hpmcf hf km+bm`htf bucturhc# bfk m`trhoh cavrm.
Gfâf Harms @mvmsMstuoh`tm
Omsm`vfcvmr`fvfs prfgmtfs
H phròquah om Cmarah tmk hbfkph`lhof mbukpraof f bhcm`oèraf cat÷rdabf# omsm`vfc+vm`of hs suhs a`abahtavhs m bmcmjrhäýms bfkjhsm `f kftm ohof pmcf ^hph phrh qummstm h`f smgh f *H`f oh Eá‛.H vavç`bah oh eá tmk mvfcuëof `f sm`taofom ukh khafr hjmrturh h vèrafs kfvakm`+tfs m hf m`vfcvakm`tf om vèrafs drupfs ompmssfhs qum# gu`thkm`tm bfk fs pèrfbfsm msbutmarfs oh Oafbmsm# tçk bf`smduaofkfjacazhr h bfku`aohom mk mvm`tfs pf`+tuhas# bfkf efa f bhsf oh Emsth oh Eá# qumbf`smduau gu`thr kaclhrms om gfvm`s m houc+tfs# sm`sajacazh`of h pfpuchäâf phrh ukh`fvh oakm`sâf oh eá bfkf hcdf qum `fsmstakuch# a`bm`tavh m `fs kfvm phrh h bf`s+truäâf om ukh sfbamohom kmclfr.Mkjfrh mstm tapf om a`abahtavhs tm`lhk saofpfsatavhs pmcf a`tmrmssm qum omspmrthrhk`h bfku`aohom brastâ m cmadh# h ^hròquahpfomrè ha`oh hjrar msphäf hf omsm`vfcva+km`tf om `fvfs prfgmtfs mspmbahckm`tmoaradaofs hfs gfvm`s# qum sm`tmk h `mbms+saohom om# bhoh vmz khas# tmr uk phpmc vmr+ohomarhkm`tm htavf m oa`êkabf h phròquahom Cmarah.
Xum hblh oh phròquah om Cmarah^mrdu`th
oh smkh`h
^ZMRM@_M CMAZAH+EÈ_AKH ‒ Rmkh`èraf Oafbmsh`f9 Zmdastf `h MZB7 8>::5:9 Oarmtfr7 Bhrcfs Khdhclâms om
Bhrvhclf ,oarmtfrNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt!9 Hssmssfrah om oarmäâf7 Ashjmc @hzhrá ,ashjmc.`hzhrmNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt!9
Zmohäâf ,rmohbhfNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt!7 Hrkh`oh Jhca`lh# Gfhquak Rh`tfs ,B^ 4428!# Cuës Kadumc Emrrhz ,B^ =>:2!#
Rh`ora`h Ehusta`f9 ^rfgmtf drèebf m phda`häâf7 ^hucf Horah`f ,phda`hbhfNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt!9 ^ujcabaohom m
Hssa`hturhs7 Khrdhraoh Dhsphr ,>1l2>+82l2>!9 Bf`thtfs7 _mc. )2=8 :?? <:8 8>> • Mkhac7 prmsm`tmNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.
pt9 ^rfpramohom m moatfr7 Eu`ohäâf Rad`as • Oarmtfr7 Uatfr Bfuta`lf • 8>>- of Bhpathc7 Oafbmsm om Cmarah+Eètakh9
@AE =8>=>?5219 Rmom oh Zmohäâf&Moatfr7 Z. Gfhquak Zajmarf Bhrvhclf# `.· 5># Rmka`èraf Oafbmsh`f# :?8?+>88
Cmarah9 Akprmssâf m mxpmoaäâf7 Mkprmsh of Oaèraf of Ka`lf# Coh • Jrhdh • _mc. :=22>284> • Ehx :=22>28489
Ompòsatf Cmdhc7 854:&<29 ^mrafoabaohom 7 Rha î qua`th+emarh9 _arhdmk omsth moaäâf7 =.>>> mxmkpchrms.
eablh táb`abh
O Z
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 3/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 •
O Z
_MKH OM BH^H ¹¹
B@M Cmarah
H fräh of msbutaskfMk 81:=# ofas h`fs hpòs f hphrmbakm`+
tf of msbutaskf mk ^frtudhc# á brahof mk
Cmarah# gu`tf î Rá# f drupf om Msbutmarfs `·
8?# qum phrtabapfu bfk uk bf`ta`dm`tm om
2> rhphzms# `f 8· Hbhkphkm`tf @hbaf`hc
qum sm rmhcazfu mk Hcgujhrrfth. Mk 812<#
rmhcazfu+sm f UA Hbhkphkm`tf @hbaf`hc#
`h Xua`th om R. Um`ê`baf. Efa uk hbf`tmba+
km`tf `h vaoh of kfvakm`tf msbuth `h ba+
ohom# pfrák# `âf fa f suebam`tm m# mk 81?>#
f Drupf 8? á ohof bfkf mxta`tf.
Efrhk prmbasfs 8> h`fs# phrh qum# mk
81=># Gfsá Dhchkjh om Fcavmarh oa`hkazhs+
sm quhtrf pmssfhs h phrtabaphr `uk bhk+
pf+msbfch mk Jrhdh omsta`hof h frkhr oa+
radm`tms. @f smduakm`tf omssh a`abahtavh#
surdau f Bcâ `· 8 of Hdruphkm`tf 2= ‒ Rm+
ka`èraf om Cmarah. Mk 81=<# f phorm Ghba`+tf om Rfush Dac# qum ta`lh saof uk ofs mcm+
km`tfs of Bcâ of Rmka`èraf# vmaf phrh h R á
bfkf bfhogutfr m# hqua# u`oh f `fvf m htuhc
hdruphkm`tf 8:4 ‒ Rá Cmarah# qum á uk ofs
trçs hdruphkm`tfs qum mxastmk `h baohom#
hcák of 445 ‒ Bruz oh Hrmah m of 881< ‒ Rh`+
tf Hdfsta`lf.
H häâf omstms trçs hdruphkm`tfs
hjrh`dm bmrbh om :>> brah`ähs m gfvm`s#
sm`of qum smkh`hckm`tm fs smus oara+
dm`tms ,=> `f bf`gu`tf ofs 2 hdruphkm`+
tfs! trh`skatmk h mstms gfvm`s# htrhvás of
kátfof msbutasth# bf`lmbakm`tfs m vhcf+
rms bf`trajua`of phrh h moubhäâf a`tmd
ohs brah`ähs m g fvm`s tfr`h`of+fs mk ho
tfs bf`sbam`tms m brëtabfs ohs bfku`aoho
f`om rmsaomk# `fkmhohkm`tm `h ^hròq
om Cmarah. Hs htavaohoms sâf vhrahohs# o
thbh`of+sm `fs ÷ctakfs h`fs h phrtabap
äâf mk hbhkphkm`tfs th`tf mk ^frtu
bfkf `f Mstrh`dmarf# häýms om vfcu`thr
of m ha`oh m`vfcvakm`tf mk oamrm`tms h
vaohoms phrfquahas.
Zmbm`tmkm`tm# fs msbutmarfs khr
rhk ukh frtm prmsm`äh `h Emsth oh
f`om frdh`azhrhk m oa`hkazhrhk h hta
ohom $Bhstmc$î Msbuth$ . ^hrh ^morf Hsbm
sf# blmm rmdaf`hc of B@M Cmarah m rmspf`
vmc pmch frdh`azhäâf of mvm`tf# –f m`bf`
`h vmclh frthcmzh kmoamvhc tmvm bfkf f
gmtavf# âf sò oavucdhr f msbutaskf# khs ha`oh ukh rmmrç`bah `h rmdaâf phrh h
kmkfrhäâf of Oah oh Brah`äh‛. –H hbta
ohom $Bhstmc$î Msbuth$ kfvakm`tfu bmrbh
2=>> brah`ähs m gfvm`s m fa uk drh`om s
bmssf# htá pfrqum bf`trajuau phrh h vav
bah of akhda`èraf *Râf @u`f ‒ Mk fkm
Zma`f*# hofthof pmcf \\ HBHZMD# hbhk
km`tf rmdaf`hc om Cmarah qum smrè rmhcazh
bfk h prmsm`äh om 8<>> msbutmarfs# f Bh
pf Msbutasth oh Jhthclh# f pròxakf kçs
Hdfstf‛# rasfu ^morf @fdumarh# blmm
daf`hc hogu`tf oh Gu`th Zmdaf`hc om Cmar
^hròquah om Cmarah tmk khas om ukh o÷zah om frdh`azhäýms rmcadafshs
Lfkm`s m Kuclmrms sfcaoèrafs…mk `fkm om Omus
Khas om ukh o÷zah om frdh`azhäýms m kfvakm`tfs
rmcadafsfs bf+mxastmk `h phròquah om Cmarah. Kuatfs
vavmk ‒ m oâf oad`aohom î vaoh ofs qum hguohk ‒ î
kmrbç oh jm`mvfcç`bah oh bfku`aohom m hpfafs
om phrbmarfs pf`tuhas. _fofs tçk uk fjgmtavfbfkuk7 tfr`hr km`fs pm`fsfs fs bhka`lfs# pfr
vmzms sa`ufsfs# pfr f`om h`ohk kuatfs cmaram`sms.
H phchvrh om fromk á eá. Eá m kuath omoabhäâf h bhoh
ukh ohs smdua`tms fjrms bhushs
Hrkh`oh Jhca`lhhrkh`oh.jhca`lhNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt
Bm`trf Rfbahc m ^hrfquahc ^hucf UA
H khafr A^RR of oastratf om CmarahRmdu`of h ]`aâf Oastrathc ohs A^RR#
f Bm`trf Rfbahc m ^hrfquahc ^hucf UA á h
khafr A^RR of oastratf# oh`of rmspfsth h vè+
rahs rmhcaohoms oamrm`tms. –_mkfs mmtavh+
km`tm ukh oakm`sâf sfbahc kuatf drh`om‛#
herkh f phorm Df`ähcf Oa`az# prmsaom`tm
oh Oarmäâf of ^hucf UA# qum m`dcfjh f @a+
`lf# qum tmk brmblm# ghroak a`h`tac m H_C
m hjrh`dm f Chr Rh`th Ashjmc# f`om sâf hbf+
claohs km`a`hs bf`ehohs pmcf traju`hc pm+
chs khas vhrahohs rhzýms. –A`bcua ha`oh uk
smrvaäf sfbahc omsm`vfcvaof pfr trçs táb`a+
bhs qum hzmk tfof uk trhjhclf om hbfk+
ph`lhkm`tf sfbahc m psabfcòdabf om hkë+
cahs jm`mebaèrahs of rm`oakm`tf sfbahc om
a`tmdrhäâf m om kuaths futrhs satuhäýms om
rasbf‛# hoah`th f pèrfbf om Cmarah ,vmr m`trm+
vasth `h ë`tmdrh `hs pèda`hs < m 1!# rash`+
of ha`oh qum –sâf thkják mchs qum zmchk
pmcf Jharrf of ^htrakò`af qum sm m`bf`trh
`h Bruz oh Hrmah khs qum á prfpramohom of
Bm`trf Rfbahc ^hrfquahc ^hucf UA‛.
H Bfku`aohom Zuh ^hucf UA á futrh
ohs vhcç`bahs of Bm`trf# hssm`tm `hs hta
ohoms omspfrtavhs.
Hs rmspfsths sfbahas ohohs p mcf Bm`
sâf om drh`om bhphbaohom. –Rò `f @a`lf
kfs 1> brah`ähs mk brmblm# 8:= mk ghro
a`h`tac m :> `f H_C. @f Chr Rh`th Ashjmc
kfs ?> km`a`hs ofs 5 hfs :8 h`fs‛# quh
taebh Df`ähcf Oa`az# bf`saomrh`of qum#
tavássmkfs bhphbaohom phrh khas utm`
khas tmrëhkfs‛.
e f t f O
m h Z q u a v f
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 4/16
82 om gu`lf om :>? •
«« _MKH OM BH^H ¹¹
Bm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf
om Cmarah
F kë`akf qum
h oad`aohomlukh`h mxadm
]k kaclâf m trmzm`+
ths m ba`qum`th kac rmma+
äýms frhk smrvaohs pmcf
Bm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf om
Cmarah ,BHC!# m`trm smtmk+
jrf om 811< m omzmkjrf
om :>8:. Omsom h suh u`+
ohäâf# vmrabhoh h 8= om
smtmkjrf om 811<# f Bm`+
trf prmtm`omu smr –uk ms+
phäf om hpfaf hfs mxbcuë+
ofs f`om# drhtuathkm`tm#
sm pfssh fmrmbmr f kë`a+
kf qum h oad`aohom lu+
kh`h mxadm‛. Hbfclmr tf+
ofs quh`tfs kh`amstmk
bhrç`bahs prakèrahs# phrhqum sm shtashähk bfk rms+
pmatf m oad`aohom hs suhs
`mbmssaohoms# smghk quhas
frmk hs satuhäýms m hs rh+
zýms# á h pra`baphc ca`lh
bf`outfrh of Bm`trf# qum
hbfclm pmssfhs mk rutu+
rh hkacahr&asfchkm`tf fu
mk prfbmssf om hjh`of`f#
mxbcuëofs sfbahas# omsmk+
prmdhofs om cf`dh ourhäâf
smk prftmäâf sfbahc ,suj+
sëoaf om omsmkprmdf!# smk
hjradf# ompm`om`tms om tò+
xabfs ,hcbffcaskf m tfxabf+
ompm`oç`bah!# ofm`tms om
`hturmzh psaquaètrabh# ms+
trh`dmarfs mk satuhäâf om
omsmkprmdf m&fu mxbcusâf
sfbahc# vëtakhs om vafcç`+
bah ofkástabh# pfrthofrms
om ofm`ähs a`mbafshs m mx+
+rmbcusfs# m`trm futrfs.
Hf cf`df ofs ÷ctakfs
h`fs# h prfjcmkètabh of+
ka`h`tm oh pfpuchäâf qum
rmbfrrm hf Bm`trf om Hbf+
clakm`tf om Cmarah tmk
va`of h hctmrhr+sm. –Râf
omsmkprmdhofs om cf`+
dh ourhäâf# pmssfhs asfch+
ohs bugf supfrtm hkacahr
om rmthduhroh á a`mxas+
tm`tm fu bf`eatufsf# bfk
drh`om a`baoç`bah om ph+
tfcfdahs psaquaètrabhs m om+
prmssavhs# sm`of+`fs sf+
cabathof pmcfs smrvaäfs om
sh÷om# qum m`bhka`lhk#
h supmrvasâf phrh h tfkh
oh kmoabhäâf prmsbrath m
bukprakm`tf ohs bf`suc+
ths om hbfkph`lhkm`tf‛#
mxpcabh Moatm _fgmarh# mou+
bhofrh sfbahc of BHC.
Zma`smrar h pmssfh `h
bfku`aohom fu hkëcah mtrh`skatar+clms h km`sh+
dmk om qum sâf mcms fs pra`+
baphas bf`outfrms ohs suhs
vaohs á f fjgmtavf of BHC#
bugf rmduchkm`tf prmvç
bfkf tmkpf cakatm om pmr+
kh`ç`bah `h a`statuaäâf
bmrbh om trçs kmsms. –^f+
rmk# `mk tfohs hs satuh+
äýms sâf om rmsfcuäâf pfs+
sëvmc om`trf omstm pmrëfof#
pfas ompm`omk oh bhphba+
ohom om hutf`fkah om bhoh
a`oavëouf# of tmkpf om rms+
pfsth om bhoh smrvaäf bfk
fs quhas hrtabuchkfs m trh+
jhclhkfs mk rmom# m ha`+
oh of tapf om prfjcmkèta+
bh hprmsm`thoh‛# bf`mssh h
moubhofrh sfbahc.
F Bm`trf om Hbfcla+
km`tf á ukh fjrh oh ph+
ròquah om Cmarah qum# `âf
tm`of quhcqumr sujsëoaf
msththc# hssukm tfohs hs
omspmshs. –H a`statuaäâf
sfjrmvavm bfk f hpfaf om
hcdu`s ofs phrbmarfs# khs
khafrathrahkm`tm sâf fs
of`htavfs.
Msbfch om Efrkhäâf
Rfbahc Zurhc om Cmarah
@fvf bursf
phrh pròxakfh`f cmtavf
H Msbfch om Efrkh+
äâf Rfbahc Zurhc om Cma+rah ,MEZRC! fa brahoh mk
81=5# sm`of ukh a`statua+
äâf smk `s cubrhtavfs#
bfk smom `h Xua`th of
Hkphrf# Khrrhzms# Cmarah.
Fatf h`fs khas throm# fa
u`ohoh h Hssfbahäâf om
Moubhäâf m Bucturh# pfr
kf`sm`lfr Gfsá Dhchkjh
om Fcavmarh# phrh smr f su+
pfrtm gurëoabf oh MEZRC# h
qumk omaxfu f smu phtra+
kò`af. H hssfbahäâf dmrm
mssm phtrakò`af# prmsth
hpfaf î Msbfch om Efrkh+
äâf Rfbahc Zurhc om Cmarah
`h èrmh `h`bmarh m msph+
äfs ësabfs.
H Msbfch frkfu a`a+
bahckm`tm hdm`tms om Mou+
bhäâf Ehkacahr Zurhc m#
pfstmrafrkm`tm# moubhof+
rms sfbahas. Fs hcu`fs rmh+
cazhk# `f ÷ctakf h`f of
bursf# uk mstèdaf prfs+
saf`hc mk a`statuaäýms cadh+
ohs î èrmh sfbahc# `fkmh+
ohkm`tm# chrms# ghroa`s om
a`ê`bah# H_C m a`statua+
äýms bfk utm`tms pfrth+
ofrms om ombaç`bahs. @f
prmsm`tm h`f cmtavf# rm+qum`thk f Bursf om Mou+
bhäâf Rfbahc =< hcu`fs.
H Msbfch á `h`bah+
oh htrhvás ofs u`ofs of
OZM@# khas mspmbabh+
km`tm pmcf ^F^L ,^rf+
drhkh Fpmrhbaf`hc ftm`+
bahc Lukh`f! m bf`th bfk
ukh mquaph om trhjhclf
om := prfmssfrms# uk psa+
bòcfdf# uk hoka`astrhta+
vf# quhtrf u`baf`èrafs m
uk vfcu`tèraf.
H Msbfch om Efrkh+
äâf Rfbahc Zurhc om Cmarah
mstè# htuhckm`tm# h omsm`+
vfcvmr msfräfs phrh hchr+
dhr h suh fmrth moubhtavh#
hjra`of uk `fvf bursf
phrh f pròxakf h`f cmtavf.
Hs a`sbraäýms phrh f Bur+
sf om Moubhäâf Rfbahc gè sm
m`bf`trhk hjmrths# jmk
bfkf h prá+a`sbraäâf phrh
f fvf bursf.
Bfcádaf om @fssh
Rm`lfrh om Eètakh
]k prfgmtf
moubhtavfbfk euturf
Eu`ohof mk 81:? m
omsad`hof a`abahckm`tm
pfr ^htrf`htf# f Bfcádaf
om @fssh Rm`lfrh om Eèta+
kh tmk htuhckm`tm kmaf
kaclhr om hcu`fs. F Bfcá+
daf omoabh+sm î moubhäâf
om brah`ähs m hofcmsbm`+
tms omsom f rá + Msbfchr hf
1· h`f om msbfchraohom# bf+
chjfrh thkják bfk h ph+
ròquah oh Rá m bfk h Oaf+
bmsm# quh`of sfcabathof#
hssmdurh`of ha`oh vasa+
ths h ofm`tms m aofsfs m ms+tm`om`of h suh häâf om sf+
caohramohom phrh bfkf fs
khas pfjrms# sfjrmtuof of
Bm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf om
Cmarah.
F Bfcádaf á fram`thof
pmchs Arkâs Ofka`abh`hs
om Rh`th Bhthra`h om Rm`h#
om hbfrof bfk uk prfgm+
tf moubhtavf jhsmhof `f
Mvh`dmclf# –prfburh ukh
frkhäâf dcfjhc of hcu`f#
smdua`of f aomhc pmohdò+
dabf oh u`ohofrh + _mrmsh
om Rhcoh`lh + hssm`tm `h
bhphbaohom om frkhr f ms+
përatf# f bfrhäâf m h a`tmca+
dç`bah# `ukh rmchäâf prò+
xakh# hmtavh m bf`h`tm
m tm`of bfkf rmmrç`bah m
kfomcf h pmssfh om Gmsus
Brastf# f Lfkmk ^mrmatf‛#
mxpcabh h arkâ Khrah Kh+
`umc.
–Omsom smkprm om+
sm`vfcvmkfs uk hkjam`+
tm hkacahr om hmtf m om
hkazhom m`trm tfofs fs
moubhofrms# moubh`ofs m
futrfs mcmkm`tfs oh bf+
ku`aohom moubhtavh# u
hkjam`tm om hutf+bf
truäâf9 om moubhäâf pmr
`hcazhoh9 om vavç`bah o
vhcfrms lukh`fs m br
tâfs# `f rmspmatf# `h htm
äâf hf futrf# `h vmroh
`h hkazhom m `h sfcao
ramohom9 `h bhphbaohom
bf`struar kuoh`äh‛# rm
rm hqumch rmspf`sèvmc p
Bfcádaf# bf`saomrh`of m
–uk hkjam`tm f`om tfo
sm sa`thk mcazms‛.
–Mstm bcakh# qum qumr om lhrkf`ah m q
fkm`th hs rmchäýms
bahas m fs hmtfs# hcakm`
f dfstf pmcf shjmr m á
tëkucf phrh uk kmcl
omsmkpm`lf m subms
kftavf pmcf quhc# m prfb
rh`of ukh frkhäâf a`
drhc# –f Bfcádaf á ukh ms
ch+hkëcah hjmrth‛# f`om
bfchjfrhäâf bfk fs m`b
rmdhofs om moubhäâf m p
bmarfs sfbahas á uk drh`
fjgmtavf.
Mstâf m`vfcvao
`mstm prfgmtf bmrbh om
moubhofrms# m`trm prf
sfrms h tmkpf a`tmarf# p
mssfrms bfchjfrhofrms
huchs mxtrh+burrabuchrm
hpfafs# m futrfs u`baf`
rafs. –F Bfcádaf tmrè u
rf# ohohs hs kuaths sfc
thäýms m pmch htuhcaoh
of smu prfgmtf moubhtav
prfburhrè smkprm brms
mk a`fvhäâf m mk htuh
zhäâf pmohdòdabh‛# bf`b
h arkâ Khrah Kh`umc.
O Z
G f h q u a k R
h ` t f R
O Z
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 5/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 •
«« _MKH OM BH^H @H OAFBMRM
Drupf om Uaoh Brastâ
‒ DU\
^hrtaclhr
pmrbursfbrastâf
Bf`lmbmr+sm h sa prò+
praf# a`tmrmsshr+sm pmcf fu+
trf m hprm`omr h phrtaclhr
f qum sm vavm. Mstms sâf fs
pra`bëpafs jèsabfs of Dru+
pf om Uaoh Brastâ ,DU\!#
qum omm`om m prhtabh h
phrtaclh om uk pmrbursf
brastâf mk drupf phrh hof+
cmsbm`tms m gfvm`s of 4· hf
8:· h`f om msbfchraohom#
smdu`of h Msparatuhcaohom
A`hbah`h# f kfof om fclhrm vavmr h mxpmraç`bah bh+
tòcabh prfpfstf pfr Rh`+
tf A`èbaf om Cfyfch# u`+
ohofr oh Bfkph`lah om
Gmsus ,Gmsuëths!. Fs DU\
sâf jhsmhofs `h mxpmraç`+
bah oh BU\ ‒ Bfku`aohom
om Uaoh Brastâ# oarmbaf`h+
oh phrh houctfs# mxastm`tm
pfr tfof f ku`of. Ehzmr
ukh cmaturh brëtabh oh rmh+
caohom# tm`of bfkf jhsm
f Mvh`dmclf# omsbfjrar
hs khrhvaclhs oh vaoh m
hprm`omr h a`tmdrhr hs oa+
bucohoms om bhoh oah# m`+
bf`trh`of Omus `f qufta+
oah`f m hprm`omr h rmzhr
mk drupf sâf futrhs ohs
prfpfsths of DU\.
H bf`statuaäâf of pra+
kmarf drupf DU\ fs –Uò+
katfs Msparatuhas‛# fbfr+
rmu mk :>88# khs pfr
lhvmr vèrafs a`tmrmsshofs
bf`statuau+sm uk smdu`of
drupf DU\ mk :>82# ofs
–B.Z.M.O.F. ‒ Brastf Zms+
pf`om# Mxpmrakm`th Ohr+
Clm Fuvaofs‛. Htuhckm`+
tm# fs ofas drupfs DU\ om
Cmarah sâf bfkpfstfs pfr
:? hofcmsbm`tms&gfvm`s#
bfk aohoms bfkprmm`+
oaohs m`trm fs 8: m fs 85
h`fs# quhtrf h`akhofrms
m uk hssastm`tm msparatuhc.
–^rfburh+sm hohpthr
h ca`duhdmk# fs kátfofs
m fs supfrtms bfku`abh+
baf`has î rmhcaohom om uk
hofcmsbm`tm&gfvmk oh sm+
du`oh oábhoh of sábucf\\A9 hprmsm`thr uk Omus
pròxakf# ë`takf# qum lh+
jath f fssf quftaoah`f9 cm+
vhr f hofcmsbm`tm h hprf+
u`ohr hs suhs rmchäýms
bf`sadf kmskf# bfk fs
futrfs m bfk Omus‛# hoah`+
th ha`oh Rárdaf Ef`smbh#
bffrom`hofr of prfgmtf.
Mstms fjgmtavfs bf`brmta+
zhk+sm hf cf`df om bhoh
h`f# htrhvás om rmu`aýms
qua`zm`has# qum fbfrrmk
îs smxths+marhs# ohs :>l2>
îs :2l2># `hs shchs oh bh+
tmqumsm oh Rá om Cmarah. Hs
rmu`aýms a`abahk bfk uk
gh`thr phrtaclhof# hpòs
f quhc sâf rmhcazhohs oa+
vmrshs oa`êkabhs m htava+
ohoms prmphrhohs pmcfs
h`akhofrms ,m# fbhsaf`hc+
km`tm# pmcfs hofcmsbm`+
tms&gfvm`s!# bfkf omjhtms#
trhjhclfs om drupf# htava+
ohoms c÷oabf+bucturhas# gf+
dfs# kfkm`tfs om frhäâf
pmssfhc&bf`gu`th m fram`+
thäýms om vaoh phrh f quf+
taoah`f.
Kfvakm`tf Bhtòcabf
om Mstuoh`tms
Umr# gucdhr m
hdar `f kmafmstuoh`tac
Mk 81<># Cmarah hssas+
tah hf surdakm`tf om uk
kfvakm`tf bhtòcabf# qum
varah h bhushr akphtf `f
kmaf mstuoh`tac. F Kfva+
km`tf Bhtòcabf om Mstu+
oh`tms ,KBM! surdau oh
häâf bhtòcabh m `hsbmu oh
gu`äâf oh Guvm`tuom Ms+
tuoh`tac Bhtòcabh ,GMB! m ohGuvm`tuom ]`avmrsatèrah
Bhtòcabh ,G]B!.
F KBM mstè prmsm`+
tm `h oafbmsm om Cmarah+
Eètakh# omsom 81<1# m tmk
bfkf pra`baphc kassâf h
mvh`dmcazhäâf `f kmaf ms+
tuoh`tac. Hssak# –f kfva+
km`tf prfpfrbaf`h uk
msphäf hjmrtf# om prfbu+
rh# om omjhtm m om brmsba+
km`tf bfk f futrf# tm`+
of bfkf fjgmbtavf h häâf
bf`brmth f kmaf mstuoh`+
tac‛# bfkf rmmrm Rhrh ^hu+
ca`f# bffrom`hofrh oafbm+
sh`h of kfvakm`tf# qum
sm frdh`azh mk pmqum`fs
drupfs qum rm÷`mk smkh+
`hckm`tm# smdu`of f Ká+
tfof om Zmvasâf om Uaoh
,vmr# gucdhr m hdar!. Msths rm+
u`aýms bf`thk bfk h prm+
sm`äh om gfvm`s mstuoh`+
tms omsom f m`sa`f jèsabf ,h
phrtar of 4· h`f! htá hf m`+
sa`f supmrafr# qum sâf oava+
oaofs pfr msbfchs m smtfrms.
Hcák ohs rmu`aýms smkh+
`has# mxastmk thkják m`+
bf`trfs pmrafoabfs ,om ofasfu trçs oahs m uk hbhkph+
km`tf om vmrâf bfk ourh+
äâf om ukh smkh`h!# qum
sm rmdmk smdu`of f kms+
kf kátfof# khs bughs rm+
emxýms sâf khas a`tm`shs.
–F Kfvakm`tf prfburh
qum fs gfvm`s mstuoh`tms
mstmghk htm`tfs hf qum h+
zmk# î msbfch f`om sm m`+
bf`trhk m î sfbamohom
f`om sm a`smrmk# phrh hs+
sak ohrmk f smu bf`tra+
jutf `h bf`struäâf om uk
uturf kmclfr# smdua`of
f mxmkpcf qum Gmsus Bras+
tf `fs omaxfu‛# rmmrm Rhrh
^huca`f.
Bf`erhrah @fssh Rm`lfrh
oh M`bhr`häâf
_mkpcf ofs
kachdrms om@fssh Rm`lfrh
Mk 8==?# f prakma+
rf jaspf om Cmarah# O. Erma
Jrès om Jhrrfs# kh`ofu
bf`struar ukh mrkaoh om
omvfäâf hf Hrbh`gf Râf
Dhjramc m h @fssh Rm`lf+
rh oh M`bhr`häâf. H 88 om
guclf om 8=<<# fbfrrmu fprakmarf kachdrm htrajuë+
of h @fssh Rm`lfrh. Ruzh+
`h Oahs# qum vavah m`trm+
vhoh lhvah :< h`fs# tmvm
ourh`tm uk sf`lf h vasâf
qum a`of î Bhpmch om @fs+
sh Rm`lfrh oh M`bhr`h+
äâf bhrah burhoh. Hssak
mz m ourh`tm h kassh sm`+
tau+sm burhoh. Bf`sth qum
sm prfouzarhk futrfs ka+
chdrms cfdf `f kmskf oah
m smdua`tms# bfkmäh`of h
hkh ofs kachdrms om @fs+
sh Rm`lfrh oh M`bhr`häâf
h htrhar hs pfpuchäýms ofs
hrrmofrms om Cmarah# qum
hbfrrahk mk rfkhdmk#
frdh`azh`of prfbassýms
bfk fmrths.
Hssak cfdf sm pm`+
sfu mk mrdumr uk `fvf
tmkpcf# sm`of hjm`äfhoh
h prakmarh pmorh f oah :?
om smtmkjrf om 8=<< m bf`+
bcuëof mk 85>>. Ourh`tm h
bf`struäâf fbfrrmu khas
uk kachdrm f quhc á cmk+
jrhof `h bh`thrah of Rh`+
tuèraf. Mk 8=<<# from`fu+
sm ukh Bf`rhrah# oh qu
mrh guazh O. Jratms Ch
oh Bhsh ofs Khrqum
om Uach Zmhc. H Bf`rhr
ha`oh mxastm`tm# á h m`tao
om zmchofrh oh adrmgh m
zf`h m`vfcvm`tm.
Htuhckm`tm# h Bfrhrah kh`ták vavf f b
tf h @fssh Rm`lfrh oh M
bhr`häâf# sm`of lmrom
oh trhoaäâf a`statuëoh
8=<<# tm`of bfkf fjgm
vfs prfkfvmr f buctf
Uardmk Khrah# `f Rh`tu
raf oh phorfmarh oh baoh
om Cmarah9 mstakuchr fs
kâfs î sh`taohom m su
dhr fs gè hcmbaofs9 prms
vhr tfof f phtrakò`af
Rh`tuèraf9 fkm`thr mvm
tfs om fromk rmcadafsh#
bahc m bucturhc# sò# fu
phrbmrah bfk futrhs m`
ohoms9 ohr hpfaf îs bfcm
vaohoms bfk `s sfbah
bf`bmomr jfcshs om mstu
m hguohr fs p fjrms# smk
qum smgh pfssëvmc.
Fs smus oahs mstav
sâf h M`bhr`häâf of U
jf# h := om khräf# h kmk
rah of prakmarf kachdrm
88 om guclf# h Hssu`ä
om @fssh sm`lfrh# h 8=
Hdfstf m# mk `fvmkj
fs surèdafs pmcfs arkâf
jm`matfrms hcmbaofs.
O Z
O Z
Umgh h a`tmr`mt f *ehslkfj*
qum f KBM brafu...
,Cmah mstm bòoadfbfk h hpcabhäâfof smu tmcmkòvmc(!
C k E m r r z
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 6/16
82 om gu`lf om :>5 •
_MKH OM BH^H @H OAFBMRM ¹¹
8= m 85 om gu`lf
Kassaf`èrafs oh Jfh @fvh
mk pmrmdra`häâfH Rfbamohom Kassaf`è+
rah oh Jfh @fvh mstè h frdh+
`azhr h suh ?4.ª ^mrmdra`häâfKassaf`èrah hf Rh`tuèraf om
Eètakh. H a`abahtavh ombfrrm+
rè `fs oahs 8= m 85 om Gu`lf m
tmrè bfkf tmkh om rmmxâf h
prfpfsth qum @fssh Rm`lfrh
om Eètakh mz hfs ^hstfra`lfs#
`h suh smdu`oh hphraäâf mk
82 om Gu`lf om 81847 –@âf tm+
`lhas kmof‛.
Zmbfrom+sm qum fs Kas+
saf`èrafs a`hudurhrhk rmbm`+
tmkm`tm f Bm`trf Ufbhbaf`hc
m Zmsaom`bahc of Blajutf# Kf+
ähkjaqum. H bmrakò`ah bf`tfu
bfk h prmsm`äh oh Rrh. Ka`as+
trh oh Kuclmr m oh Häâf Rfbahc
om Kfähkjaqum# M`dm`lmarh
Afch`oh Ba`turh Rmuh`m m RuhMxbah. f Ka`astrf oh Rfcaoh+
ramohom m Rmdurh`äh Rfbahc om
^frtudhc# Or. ^morf Kfth Rfh+
rms# m`trm futrhs hutfraohoms
bavas m rmcadafshs cfbhas.
F Bm`trf tmk bhphbaoh+
om phrh 5> hcu`fs a`tmr`fs. Gè
mstâf h u`baf`hr `f Bm`trf
hcdu`s bursfs bfkf A`frkè+
tabh# A`dcçs# Bf`thjacaohom m
Dmstâf# K÷sabh m uk Bursf
Káoaf om Hoka`astrhäâf ^u+
jcabh m Bfkárbaf.
84 om Gu`lf
Jaspfs# pfcëtabfs m mbf`fkasths
omjhtmk Ofutra`h Rfbahc
H –mkmrdç`bah of Msthof
kfomr`f m h ofutra`h sfbahc
oh Adrmgh‛ m h –mvfcuäâf oh sf+
bamohom pfrtudumsh `f bhkpf
oh mbf`fkah `hs ÷ctakhs oá+
bhohs‛ smrâf tmkhs mk omjhtm
`hs pròxakhs Gfr`hohs ^hstf+
rhas oh Bf`mrm`bah Mpasbfphc
^frtudumsh# h rmhcazhr h oah 84#
mk Eètakh.
Râf bf`vaohofs phrh ms+
ths gfr`hohs om rmmxâf Ghakm
Dhkh# H`tò`af Jhrrmtf m Gfâf
Rhcdumarf# m`trm futrfs. H gu`+
thr+sm h mstms bf`mrm`basths#
hs gfr`hohs tmrâf ha`oh bfkf
a`tmrvm`am`tms O. Gfsá ^fca+
bhrpf# Kh`umc Jrhdh oh Bruz#
Gfâf Bhrcfs Msphoh# Zua Zh+
kfs m O. Khraf _fsf.–F pra`bëpaf oh sujsaoah+
ramohom m f vhcfr oh cajmrohom
bfkf acuka`häâf ohs u`äýms
of Msthof‛# –Ofutra`h Rfbahc
oh Adrmgh m `fvh mvh`dmcazh+
äâf‛ m –h mvfcuäâf bucturhc m
h mvfcuäâf oh sfbamohom pfr+
tudumsh‛ smrâf futrfs tmkhs h
hjfrohr `msths bf`mrç`bahs.
:> m :8 om Gu`lf
2:ª ^mrmdra`häâf ohs Efrähs
Hrkhohs m om Rmdurh`ähH Oafbmsm ohs Efrähs Hr+
khohs m om Rmdurh`äh prmph+
rh h 2:ª pmrmdra`häâf hf Rh`+
tuèraf om Eètakh. H a`abahtavh
rmpmtm+sm h`uhckm`tm omsom
81<8 m bf`bm`trh kaclhrms
om pmssfhs cadhohs îs Efrähs
Hrkhohs m îs Efrähs om Rmdu+
rh`äh# m`trm mcms hkacahrms m
hkadfs.
O. Gh`uèraf _frdhc Emr+
rmarh sujca`lfu gè pfr vèrahs
fbhsaýms qum –f omvmr ohqumcms
hdm`tms á msthr hf chof ofs qum
bf`ta`uhrâf smk msthtutf m`+
quh`tf f frduclf m f mdfëskf
frmk f bòoadf oh khafrah ofs
smtfrms of ku`of‛. –H kassâf
oh Oafbmsm# hsbaoh of bfrhäâf
om uk Omus hsshssa`hof m rm+
oavavf# `u`bh pfomrè smr phrh
oavaoar9 hf bf`trèraf# smkprm
smrè phrh u`ar m rmbf`bacahr‛#
rmhcäfu O. Gh`uèraf _frdhc
Emrrmarh# mk pmrmdra`häýms
h`tmrafrms.
@F RH@_]ÈZAF
Kusmu om Hrtm Rhbrh m Mt`fcfdah# Eètakh
Hcu`fs mxpýmk trhjhclfs–Rm`tar# ^m`shr m Brahr‛ á f
tmkh oh mxpfsaäâf phtm`tm hf p÷+
jcabf `f Kusmu om Hrtm Rhbrh m Mt+
`fcfdah# mk Eètakh.
A`hudurhoh mk khaf `f êk+
jatf ohs bfkmkfrhäýms of Oah A`+
tmr`hbaf`hc ofs Kusmus# h mxpfsa+
äâf rmsucth om ukh phrbmrah bfk
h Cadh ofs Hkadfs of KHRM# Bm`+
trf om Mstuofs om Eètakh# Bfcádaf
om Râf Kadumc m Bfcádaf of Rhdrh+
of Bfrhäâf om Khrah.
Fs trhjhclfs sâf `h suh dm+
`mrhcaohom a`sparhofs `fs fjgmtfs
hrtëstabfs m mt`fdrèebfs ohs bf
äýms of kusmu fu mk pa`turhs
hrtasths om rm`fkm. Fs trhjhcl
omstms hcu`fs mstâf mxpfstfs
:1 om Rmtmkjrf. Htá cè# h mxpf
äâf pfom smr vasathoh ohs 8>l>>
81l>># m`bmrrh î smdu`oh+marh
Msbfchs Bhtòcabhs om Cmarah
]k hjrhäf î sfcaohramohom
Hs Msbfchs Bhtòcabhs om Cma+
rah rmspf`omrhk om frkh pfsata+
vh hf hpmcf ch`ähof pmcfs Káoabfs
of Ku`of bfk ukh khrblh sfca+
oèrah h hvfr oh pfpuchäâf vuc`m+
rèvmc om frtudhc m Kfähkjaqum.
H a`abahtavh gu`tfu hcu`fs#
phas m u`baf`èrafs oh Msbfch om
Efrkhäâf Rfbahc m Zurhc om Cmarah#
of Bfcádaf @fssh Rm`lfrh om Eèta+
kh m of Bfcádaf Bf`bacahr om Kh+
rah Akhbuchoh m`blm`of h ^rhäh
Zforadums Cfjf m ruhs barbu`oh`+
tms –om bfr m bfrhäýms‛# bfkf tmstm+
ku`lhrhk fs phrtabaph`tms.
Ourh`tm h khrblh# pmch khr+
dmk of raf Cas# fs phrtabaph`tms
trfbhrhk –bfrhäýms sfcaoèrafs‛ m
hpmchrhk î sfcaohramohom m phrta+
clh. F fjgmtavf oh htavaohom phs+
shvh pfr sm`sajacazhr hcu`fs m bf+
ku`aohom phrh h akpfrtê`bah of
mxmrbëbaf ësabf hssfbahof î sfca
ramohom. Hs oarmäýms ohs msbf
rmmrmk qum –fa ukh mxpmraçbah kuatf hdrhoèvmc m bmrthkm
tm phrh rmpmtar‛ ohof h suh a
pfrtê`bah `f –omsm`vfcvakm`
a`tmdrhc ofs hcu`fs‛. @f e`hc# gu
tf hf mstèoaf om Cmarah# hssastau
h ukh chrdhoh om pfkjfs ph
hcmdrah ofs prmsm`tms.
Mk tmkpfs om hustmraoh
msth fa h frkh ohs Msbfchs Bh
cabhs om Cmarah –hjrhährmk h sf
ohramohom‛ m –bf`trajuar phrh q
h sfbamohom# f uturf# smgh bf`
tuëoh pfr baohoâfs khas sfcaoèr
m homptfs oh gustaäh‛# rmmrmk
bfku`abhof m`vahof î rmohäâf
O Z
^hthahs
Emsths oh KácvfhChrdhs omzm`hs om phrfquah+
`fs phrtabaphrhk `h bmcmjrhäâf
khrah`h m `h prfbassâf om lfkm+
`hdmk h Rh`th Khrah Khohcm`h m
Râf Rmjhstaâf# ombfrraohs `h Kác+
vfh# phròquah om ^hthahs# `f phs+
shof ek om smkh`h. Mstm h`f# mpfr `âf lhvmr bfkassâf om ms+
ths# h frdh`azhäâf pmrtm`bmu h uk
drupf om lhjath`tms oh Kácvfh
qum sm gu`tfu –phrh qum h trhoaäâf
`âf tmrka`hssm‛.
@h fpa`aâf om Gfrdm Eacapm#
kmkjrf oh bfkassâf oh adrmgh# –fs
mstmgfs bfrrmrhk jmk# tm`of mk
bf`th hs oaebucohoms mbf`òka+
bhs oh pfpuchäâf‛. Mk rmsucthof
of mkpm`lf ofs trçs kmkjrfs oh
bfkassâf oh adrmgh cfbhc m om smas
kfrhofrms `h Kácvfh# ^haf# Bhshc
m Jrmga`lf# f prfdrhkh mk lf`rh
om Rh`th Khrah Khohcm`h m Râf
Rmjhstaâf prmm`blmu ofas oahs om
bhcm`oèraf.
Bf`saomrh`of smr –akpm`sè+
vmc pmromr h ohth om lfkm`hdmk
hfs `fssfs phorfmarfs‛# Gfrdm Eaca+
pm m fs rmsth`tms kmkjrfs oh bf+
kassâf oh adrmgh vmmk+sm h jrhäfs
bfk khas uk oacmkh. –F msth`+
ohrtm âf fa m`trmdum h a`duák#
fu smgh# `f pròxakf h`f tmrmkfs
qum vfcthr h hssukar h frdh`azh+
äâf ofs mstmgfs# bf`th`of bfk h
bfchjfrhäâf oh pfpuchäâf‛# mxp
bh. Mspmrh`of qum msth satuhä
om akphssm smgh uctrhphsshoh
pròxakf h`f# Gfrdm Eacapm hbrmo
–qum lhvmrè# bmrthkm`tm# hcdu
qum phrh f h`f qumarh hssuka
frkhr h suh mquaph om trhjhc
a`of jusbhr pmssfhs om bf`eh
äh hfs vèrafs cudhrms oh Kácvf
|HJ
H Z k H ` O H J H c a ` l H
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 7/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 •
«« @H OAFBMRM M@_ZMUAR_H
4 h 1 om Gu`lf#Bursf oh Km`shdmk om Eètakh
H km`shdmk omsvm`oh
–F trau`ef of hkfr `fs
orhkhs oh Lastòrah‛
_mrka`fu `f oah 1 f bursf sfjrm h Km`shdmk
om Eètakh. Efrhk trçs oahs om hprfu`ohkm`tf ofs
bf`tm÷ofs oh Km`shdmk oh Bfvh oh Arah m rmmxâf
sfjrm h frkh bfkf h suh vavç`bah bfkf –h`÷`baf
om mspmrh`äh phrh fs lfkm`s m kuclmrms of `fs+
sf tmkpf‛ pfom kuohr f quftaoah`f ofs brastâfs om
lfgm.
Ê`dmch Bfmclf# frkhofrh omstm bursf# kfs+
trfu+sm hdrhohvmckm`tm surprmsh pmch homsâf î a`a+
bahtavh. –Efa ukh surprmsh hdrhoèvmc# mspmbahckm`tm
pmcf a`tmrmssm qum h km`shdmk om Eètakh omspmrth
`hs pmssfhs‛# oassm hf rmbfrohr qum hs a`sbraäýms ms+
dfthrhk mk pfubfs oahs m h frdh`azhäâf tmvm om ou+
pcabhr h bhphbaohom omsth prakmarh moaäâf.
–Msthkfs `uk tmkpf ÷`abf‛# hs bfkmkfrhäýms
of bm`tm`èraf ohs hphraäýms á –ukh fpfrtu`aohom
÷`abh phrh omspmrthr phrh f qum –Omus vmaf trhzmr
î lukh`aohom of `fssf tmkpf# htrhvás om @fssh Rm+
`lfrh‛# rmvmch.
^rfkfvaof pmcf Rh`tuèraf om Eètakh# mstm bur+
sf –prmtm`om mxpfr fs mcmkm`tfs u`ohkm`thas ohs
hphraäýms oh Bfvh oh Arah# hzmr ukh sastmkhtazhäâf
ofs bf`tm÷ofs tmkètabfs m m`quhorhr tmfcfdabhkm`+
tm fs oavmrsfs hspmtfs ohs hphraäýms‛. Ê`dmch Bfmclf
cmkjrh qum msth á h fpfrtu`aohom om –hprfu`ohr
fs oavmrsfs hspmtfs tmkètabfs oh Km`shdmk om Eè+
takh m hs suhs akpcabhäýms phrh h vaoh brastâ‛ m# khas
bf`brmthkm`tm# –rmcç+ch tmfcfdabhkm`tm `f bf`tmxtf
khas hchrdhof oh km`shdmk brastâ‛.
@fvh moaäâf mk futujrf–Bf`erkh+sm `fvh moaäâf phrh Futujrf mk
ohth h ome`ar‛# khs prfvhvmckm`tm bfk –drupfs om
oakm`sýms smkmclh`tms ohoh h `mbmssaohom om prf+
xakaohom phrh rmmxâf sfjrm Eètakh m h suh Km`sh+
dmk‛. Arkâ Ê`dmch Bfmclf mxpcabh qum mstm trhjhclf
–mxadm ukh drh`om a`tmrhäâf m`trm fs phrtabaph`tms
qum sm pfom pmromr mk drupfs khafrms‛. H sfcuäâf
pfomrè smr –mvm`tuhckm`tm h rmpmtar `futrhs ohths‛
om frkh h pfssajacathr kfkm`tfs om hprfu`ohr m
rmmtar h frkh om –vavmr f hkfr om Khrah `f `fs+
sf oah h oah‛.
Efrkhofrh of bursf# Arkâ Ê`dmch Bfmclf á rm+
cadafsh oh Hcah`äh om Rh`th Khrah# kmkjrf oh Bf+
kassâf Frdh`azhofrh of Bm`tm`èraf ohs Hphraäýms
om Eètakh m ^fstuchofrh oh Bhush om Bh`f`azhäâf
om Erh`basbf m Ghba`th Khrtf. | RE
Rh`tuèraf om Eètakh m`blm om bfr# hcmdrah m m`tusahsk
–Omvmkfs smr h`gfs u`s phrh fs futrfs‛Rh`ora`h Ehusta`f
Khas om 2= kac brah`ähs hbfkph`lhofs om phas# hka+
dfs m bhtmquasths om tfof f phës m`blmrhk f Rh`tuèraf om
Eètakh mk khas ukh ^mrmdra`häâf ohs Brah`ähs. Mstm h`f
omoabhof hf tmkh –Bfrhäâf om Khrah rm÷daf m bhka`lf‛#
`ukh hssukaoh mvfbhäâf î Hphraäâf om 82 om Gu`lf om
8184# h pmrmdra`häâf fa prmsaoaoh pfr O. H`tò`af Kfatmarf
Zhkfs# Jaspf huxacahr om Jrhdh.
Hf cmkjrhr h msth of H`gf om ^frtudhc# O. H`tò`af
Kfatmarf Zhkfs rmmrau qum –fs h`gfs sâf hkadfs om Omus
m sâf m`vahofs pfr Omus phrh `fs hguohrmk m prftmdmrmk‛.
–_hkják `òs omvmkfs smr h`gfs# u`s phrh fs futrfs‛# oassm
`h lfkacah# ompfas om tmr cmkjrhof hs oaebucohoms mk qum
vavmk kuaths hkëcahs mk ^frtudhc m matf rmmrç`bah hf om+
sê`akf –ofs vfssfs phas qum mstâf h sfrmr bfk hcth om trh+
jhclf m oaebucohoms‛. @ukh km`shdmk pfsatavh# f jaspf
huxacahr om Jrhdh omaxfu îs brah`ähs ukh phchvrh om ê`akfm uk hpmcf î sfcaohramohom# –omvmkf+`fs hguohr h vm`bmr hs
oaebucohoms m fs prfjcmkhs oh `fssh vaoh‛.
Mk gmatf om bf`bcusâf cmkjrh f ^hph Erh`basbf# –Omus
hkh+`fs kuatf m `u`bh sm msqumbm om `òs# `òs á qum `fs ms+
qumbmkfs o‑Mcm‛ m hpmch hf Hkfr om Khrah# –tmkfs om hprm
omr h hkhr fs futrfs bfkf Khrah hkh bhoh uk om `òs‛.
@f kfkm`tf oh frhäâf ofs eáas sujarhk hf hcthr fs
sucthofs oh bhkph`lh rmhcazhoh `f kçs om khaf. Umchs
phpmc# ombfrhohs bfk hs frhäýms m bfkprfkassfs ohs brah
ähs h Omus m h @fssh Rm`lfrh qum sakjfcabhkm`tm frh
bfcfbhohs gu`tf hf bëraf# `uk htf qum –cmkjrfu h á of
taskf‛.
H pmrmdra`häâf tmrka`fu bfk h trhoabaf`hc ^rfbass
of Homus bfk cm`äfs matfs mxbcusavhkm`tm phrh h fbhsa
fmrmbaofs pmcf Rh`tuèraf om Eètakh h bhoh brah`äh qum
vfu hssak ukh rmbfrohäâf mspmbahc phrh bhsh.
–Uòs sfas uk mspmtèbucfÁ jmcf smr brastâf‛
H bf`bmcmjrhr bfk O. Kfatmarf Zhkfs mstavmrhk
O. H`tò`af Khrtf m O. Rmrhek Emrrmarh m Racvh# jaspf ta
tuchr m mkáratf om Cmarah+Eètakh# rmspmtavhkm`tm.
@uk hssukaof rmphrf î husç`bah ohs trh`skas
sýms tmcmvasavhs# O. H`tò`af Khrtf `f e`hc oh pmrmdra
`häâf mcfdafu f bfkpfrthkm`tf ohs brah`ähs oazm`of
qum sm sm tavmssmk pfrthof khc smrahk ftëbah mk tfof
f phës. F phës –prmbash om shjmr qum hs brah`ähs sm pfrth
rhk kuatf jmk‛ m qum mstâf tfofs –om phrhjá`s‛.
–Uòs sfas uk mspmtèbucf( Kuatf fjradhof pfr mstm
m`bf`trf om á# kuatf fjradhof pmch vfssh prmsm`äh hcm
drm m mstavh m tâf `ukmrfsh‛# herkfu O. H`tò`af Khr
tf hfs khas pmqum`fs qum –m`blmrhk om jmcmzh‛ f Zm
ba`tf bfk –h bfr ofs jf`ás m h hcmdrah ofs bê`tabfs‛. –Ájmcf smr brastâf‛ oassm hf mcfdahr h –hcmdrah m m`tusahs
kf‛ bfk qum fa vavaoh h bmcmjrhäâf‛ bf`bcuau# h`tms oh
jç`äâf e`hc.
^horm om Cmarah+Eètakh `fkmhof
hssastm`tm a`tmr`hbaf`hc ofs B^KF phorm Gfsá Hudustf Zfora+
dums# oarmtfr of Omphrthkm`tf om
^hstfrhc Ehkacahr oh oafbmsm om Cma+
rh+Eètakh m hssastm`tm oafbmsh`f ofs
Bm`trfs om ^rmphrhäâf phrh f Khtra+
kò`af ,B^K!# efa `fkmhof hssastm`tm
msparatuhc oh emomrhäâf a`tmr`hbaf`hc
omstm kfvakm`tf.
H hssmkjcmah dmrhc oh Emomrhäâf
A`tmr`hbaf`hc ofs Bm`trfs om ^rmphrh+
äâf phrh Khtrakò`af ,EAB^K!# rmhcazh+
oh mk Hssas# `f êkjatf oh suh ?4.ª gfr+
`hoh h`uhc# om : h = om khaf om :>82#
mcmdmu –pfr u`h`akaohom m hbchkh+
äâf‛ f phorm Gfsá Hudustf ^mrmarh Zf+
oradums# bfkf smu hssastm`tm msparatuhc
phrh uk kh`ohtf om 2 h`fs.
F phorm Gfsá Hudustf# qum hbhjh
thkják om smr `fkmhof rmatfr of Rm+
ka`èraf Oafbmsh`f om Cmarah# omsmk+
pm`lh# m`trm futrhs# hs u`äýms om oa+
rmtfr of Omphrthkm`tf Oafbmsh`f om^hstfrhc Ehkacahr m of Rmrvaäf om ^hs+
tfrhc oh Rh÷om# hssastm`tm phstfrhc oh
Msbfch om Efrkhäâf Rfbahc Zurhc om
Cmarah m hssastm`tm oafbmsh`f ofs Bm`+
trfs om ^rmphrhäâf phrh f Khtrakò`af
,B^K!.
Xuh`tf îs suhs `fvhs u`äýms
bfkf hssastm`tm a`tmr`hbaf`hc ofs
B^K# f phorm Gfsá Hudustf# qum su+
bmom f bhrdf hf phorm msph`lfc Guh`
Bumvhs# hoah`th qum –`âf vha bf`oa+
baf`hr‛ f trhjhclf qum htuhckm`tm om+
smkpm`lh `h Oafbmsm# f`om kh`ták
hs kmskhs thrmhs phstfrhas. Rad`aebh+
rè# hpm`hs# –h `mbmssaohom om hbfk
`lhr m phrtabaphr hs rmu`aýms m hä
bffrom`hohs a`tmr`hbaf`hckm`tm p
EAB^K‛# ukh kassâf qum fa thkj
hbmatm m bf`erkhoh pmcf Jaspf om C
rah+Eètakh# bf`oaäâf akpfsth pmcfs
thtutfs ohqumch momrhäâf.
CK
O Z
c u ë s O m F c a v m a Z H
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 8/16
82 om gu`lf om :>< •
@H OAFBMRM M@_ZMUAR_H ¹¹
H phròquah om Cmarh á thcvmz h
khas urjh`h oh oafbmsm…
Mk tmrkfs om lhjath`tms `âf á h
khafr# Khra`lh Drh`om# Khrrh+
zms m Khbmarh sâf khas pfpucf+
shs. Khs h urjh`aohom oh baohom
om Cmarah rmmtm+sm `hs pmbucahra+
ohoms oh phròquah. @ukh baohom
f`om f tmbaof urjh`ëstabf á oaspmr+
sf m omsaduhc# bfk khclhs kuatfpfpuchbaf`has m futrhs km`fs# h
baohom hbhjh pfr u`baf`hr bfkf
f bm`trf om tfoh ukh rmdaâf. ^fr
assf# h phròquah hdruph kuaths
pmssfhs qum `âf rmsaoa`of `f smu
tmrratòraf mstâf+clm cadhohs m sm`+
tmk+`h bfkf suh. _mkfs kuaths
pmssfhs qum prfburhk fs `fssfs
smrvaäfs smgh hf `ëvmc ofs shbrh+
km`tfs# jhtaskfs fu bhshkm`tfs#
smgh phrh rmqum`thr h bhtmqumsm.
_mkfs ukh hcth pmrbm`thdmk om
brah`ähs m hofcmsbm`tms qum `âf
rmsaomk `h phròquah khs qum `fs
pmomk phrh rmqum`thr msths vh+
cç`bahs.
^fr hcdukh rhzâf mspmbahc# fu
sakpcmskm`tm pfr smr khas bm`+
trhc6
Kuaths vmzms á pfr assf kmskf.
Lè ukh frtm cadhäâf ofs phas î
baohom# smghk pfr qumstýms prf+
essaf`has fu futrhs# qum cmvh qum
lhgh ukh khafr cadhäâf suh î ph+
ròquah qum sm rmmtm `fkmhoh+
km`tm hf `ëvmc oh rmquç`bah oh
bhtmqumsm.
Hcák omsth oakm`sâf# h phrò+
quah om Cmarah oasta`dum+sm pmcf
smu trhjhclf sfbahc. Xum rmspfs+
ths oè f Bm`trf Rfbahc ^hrfquahc
^hucf UA6
_mkfs mmtavhkm`tm ukh oakm`+
sâf sfbahc kuatf drh`om. Rmdu`+
of h ]`aâf Oastrathc ohs A^RR f
Bm`trf Rfbahc m ^hrfquahc ^hu+
cf UA á h khafr A^RR of oastratf
oh`of rmspfsth h vèrahs rmhcaoh+oms oamrm`tms. M`dcfjh f @a`lf#
qum tmk brmblm# ghroak a`h`tac m
H_C. Hjrh`dm f Chr Rh`th Ashjmc#
f`om hbfclmkfs km`a`hs qum `fs
sâf bf`ehohs pmcf traju`hc pmchs
khas vhrahohs rhzýms. A`bcua ha`+
oh uk smrvaäf sfbahc omsm`vfc+
vaof pfr trçs táb`abhs qum hzmk
tfof uk trhjhclf om hbfkph`lh+
km`tf sfbahc m psabfcòdabf om h+
këcahs jm`mebaèrahs of rm`oakm`+
tf sfbahc om a`tmdrhäâf m om kuaths
futrhs satuhäýms om rasbf. Râf thk+
ják mchs qum zmchk pmcf Jharrf
of ^htrakò`af qum sm m`bf`trh `h
Bruz oh Hrmah khs qum á prfpram+ohom of Bm`trf Rfbahc ^hrfquahc
^hucf UA.
_mkfs thkják h Bfku`aohom
Zuh ^hucf UA bfk rmspfsths oms+
pfrtavhs.
Msthkfs pfas h hchr om uk êk+
jatf om htavaohom kuatf drh`om.
_mk `fäâf om quh`ths pmssfhs
hbhjhk pfr hpfahr6
Kuaths. Rò `f @a`lf tmkfs 1>
brah`ähs mk brmblm# 8:= mk ghr+
oak a`h`tac# m :> `f H_C. @f Chr
Rh`th Ashjmc tmkfs ?> km`a`hs
ofs 5 hfs :8 h`fs.
M sm tavmssmk bhphbaohom phrh
khas tmrahk khas…
@hcdu`s bhsfs sak.
Ehcm+km of Bm`trf om Hbfcla+
km`tf om Cmarah…
Hcák of bm`trf sfbahc h phròquah
tmk futrh fjrh pròprah qum á fBm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf om Cmarah.
Efa u`ohoh mk 811< phrh ohr bu a+
ohofs prakèrafs h qumk omcms `m+
bmssath.
H qum `ëvmc6
H `ëvmc om hcakm`thäâf# oh ch+
vhdmk m mvm`tuhckm`tm fr`m+
bakm`tf om rfuph m oh ladam`m
pmssfhc bfk h oaspf`ajacazhäâf m
kh`utm`äâf om a`sthchäýms phrh
f mmatf. F Bm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf
u`baf`h gu`tf hf Lfspathc O. Kh+
`umc om Hduahr# mk a`sthchäýms oh
prfpramohom oh ^R^ bmoaohs î ph+
ròquah phrh mstm ek. @mstm êk+jatf ohkfs ha`oh kuath akpfr+
tê`bah hf hpfaf táb`abf+sfbahc qum
bf`smduakfs m`bhka`lh`of pms+
sfhs phrh fs rm`oakm`tfs om a`tm+
drhäâf fu kmskf phrh smrvaäfs om
sh÷om quh`of smgh bhsf oassf.
F qum pfomk hzmr mk tmrkfs
om sh÷om6
@mstm kfkm`tf msth á ukh oa+
km`sâf kuatf akpfrth`tm. Ms+
thkfs bfk ukh pmrbm`thdmk
kuatf mcmvhoh om utm`tms bfk hc+
dukhs phtfcfdahs of frf psaquaè+
trabf pmcf qum tmkfs ukh hrtabu+
chäâf kuatf drh`om bfk f smrvaäf
om psaquahtrah of Lfspathc om Rh`+
tf H`orá. _mkfs hcdukhs pmssfhs
bfk prfjcmkhs om tfxabfompm`+
oç`bah qum tm`thkfs m`bhka`lhr
phrh smrvaäfs mspmbahcazhofs qum
fs pfsshk hguohr m`quh`tf assf#
hssukakfs h phrtm om hpfaf jè+
sabf. @f u`of# f qum hzmkfs áhbfclmr hs pmssfhs qum fu rmsa+
omk hqua fu hbhjhk pfr phrhr
pfr hqua. Cmarah hbhjh pfr smr ukh
baohom om trh`saäâf# phrh kuaths
omsths pmssfhs. ^hrh tmr ukh `f+
äâf oh oakm`sâf omsth fjrh# ms+
thkfs h ohr bmrbh om => rmmaäýms
pfr oah…
Bfkf sfjrmvavm f bm`trf# bf`+
thk bfk trhjhclf vfcu`tèraf6
Msthkfs bfk ouhs pmssfhs h tmk+
pf a`tmarf m ukh u`baf`èrah of
bm`trf sfbahc qum omoabh phrtm of
smu tmkpf hf bm`trf om hbfcla+
km`tf. H Bèraths Oafbmsh`h m hRh`th Bhsh oh Kasmrabòroah sâf
`fsshs phrbmarhs omsom h prakma+
rh lfrh# bf`trajumk km`shckm`+
tm phrh hs omspmshs of bm`trf.
M mstm hpfaf á suebam`tm6
F Bm`trf om Hbfclakm`tf `âf tmk
quhcqumr hpfaf msththc. Uavm bfk
f bf`trajutf oh bfku`aohom. Rmgh
h bfku`aohom brastâ qum bf`tra+
jua pfr mxmkpcf `fs fmrtòrafs
`hs kasshs oh smkh`h# qum `hs
futrhs phròquahs âf bfstukh lh+
vmr m òs sò hzmkfs phrh mstm ek
mspmbëebf. Rmghk hs pmssfhs q
a`oavaouhckm`tm qumrmk ohr
smu bf`trajutf. _mkfs ha`oh d
ähs h Omus# futrhs a`statuaäýms q
sm`sajacazhohs vâf bf`trajua`of
^fomkfs uturhkm`tm hz
ukh rmpfrthdmk hf smrvaäf6
Rak. Rmrah uk trhjhclf kuatf
tmrmssh`tm. ^mäf á buaohof bfkpravhbaohom ofs `fssfs utm`
qum pfr rmdrh `âf dfsthk ku
om smr ftfdrhhofs.
Hbrmsbm`tf ha`oh qum tmkfs u
drupf om smrvaäf om vfcu`thrah
sfbahc bf`statuëof `h phròquah
bmrbh om ofas h`fs. @f êkjatf
quhc braèkfs uk u`of sfcaoè
phrfquahc.
Bfkf `hsbm msth a`abahtavh6
@hsbm pfrqum `fs hpmrbmjmk
qum lhvah `h phròquah pmssf
qum prmbashvhk om hguoh kf`
tèrah mk kfkm`tfs kuatf pf
tuhas# fssm phrh phdhr ukh rmoh fu ukh hturh om cuz fu dès
burafsf qum hs hguohs h mssm u
of tçk va`of h hukm`thr sad
ebhtavhkm`tm. Bf`mssf qum t
hcduk rmbmaf qum msth a`abahta
vamssm om hcduk kfof bfcfbhr m
rasbf hs hguohs phrh f bm`trf
hbfclakm`tf. Khs msthvh mrrh
Á bfk kuath hcmdrah qum bf`st
qum bf`smduakfs kh`tmr hs ou
rmhcaohoms.
@mstm bm`èraf om hovmrsaoho
m kuath a`sthjacaohom `ftfu k
Df`ähcf Oa`az# pèrfbf om Cmarah# mk m`trmvasth
Cmarah á ukh phròquah pcurhc# dm`mrfsh momsmgfsh om hprfu`ohr h suh áRm puomssm fmrmbmrah –ukh a`gmäâf om á‛ hfs smus phrfquah`fs pfrqum –f prakmarf rutf oh á
á prmbashkm`tm h hcmdrah‛ oaz Df`ähcf Oa`az# pèrfbf om Cmarah. Bf`sbam`tm of akpfrth`tm phpmc
sfbahc omsm`vfcvaof `h suh phròquah m hdrhombaof î bfku`aohom pmch suh dm`mrfsaohom á bfk
mkfäâf qum oaz fthr –ukh sm`sajacaohom khafr ohs pmssfhs phrh fs prfjcmkhs sfbahas‛.
tmxtf m eftfs7
Rh`ora`h Ehusta`fsh`ora`h.ehusta`fNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 9/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 •
«« M@_ZMUAR_H K]@OF
oh`ähs `fs lèjatfs ofs smus ph+
rfquah`fs6
F qum tmk lhvaof á ukh sm`saja+caohom khafr ohs pmssfhs phrh fs
prfjcmkhs sfbahas. Bchrf qum astf
tmk saof thkják rmsucthof om uk
trhjhclf om kuath sm`sajacazhäâf
oh fssh phrtm.
Bfkf hzmk h sm`sajacazhäâf6
^moakfs îs pmssfhs qum `fs hgu+
omk. Ehzçkf+cf om vèrafs kfofs#
htrhvás of gfr`hc phrfquahc# `fs
vèrafs drupfs m m`bf`trfs# `h oa+
vucdhäâf qum sm vha hzm`of `fs
hvasfs# hs kasshs…
Hs pròprahs frdh`azhäýms vâf
sm`sajacazh`of…
Bchrf m vâf kmskf brah`of hssuhs pròprahs oa`êkabhs. ^fr
mxmkpcf mk rmchäâf hf Bm`trf om
Hbfclakm`tf ezmkfs uk mxpfsa+
tf qum tmk msthof `h Rá. Htá smr
vh`ohcazhof# lè bmrbh om uk kçs#
fa uk kmaf kuatf jfk phrh hs
pmssfhs pmrbmjmrmk of trhjhclf
qum sm vha hzm`of m ohs rmhcaoh+
oms oh phròquah.
M pmrbmjm`of om bfkf pfomk
bfchjfrhr pfrqum kuaths vm+
zms qumr+sm hguohr m `âf sm shjm
bfkf…
^rmbashkm`tm. _mkfs taof dmstfs
kuatf jf`atfs om pmssfhs qum pfr
mxmkpcf `fs fmrmbmk h prakma+
rh rmfrkh phrh hcdukhs omsths
fjrhs. @mstm @hthc tavmkfs pms+
sfhs qum fmrmbmrhk f smu sujsë+
oaf mk sa`hc om sfcaohramohom.
Á bfkfvm`tm…
Rak# á om hbtf jf`atf shjmr qum h`fssh mvh`dmcazhäâf tfbh f bfrh+
äâf ohs pmssfhs.
M khrbh fs smus oahs …
Mxhthkm`tm# m bfk dmstfs kuatf
bf`brmtfs.
M fs gfvm`s# bfkf mstâf mcms m`+
vfcvaofs h vaoh oh phròquah6
H `ëvmc phrfquahc `âf tmk saof è+
bac f trhjhclf bfk fs gfvm`s. @f
m`th`tf tmkfs taof hcdu`s ru+
tfs pfsatavfs. _mkfs ofas hdruph+
km`tfs om msbutmarfs h u`baf`hr#
f oh Rá m f om Rh`tf Hdfsta`lf m#
`f h`f phsshof brafu+sm uk dru+pf om gfvm`s. F DU\ mxastm lè
ofas h`fs# mstè kuatf cadhof î mspa+
ratuhcaohom a`hbah`h# hfs gmsuëths.
Kuatfs `âf sâf rmsaom`tms `h ph+
ròquah mkjfrh kh`tm`lhk ukh
cadhäâf î vaoh phrfquahc.
^m`sf qum f m`vfcvakm`tf ofs gf+
vm`s ha`oh á pfjrm# pfomrah m om+
vmrah smr kuatf khafr khs# h vmr+
ohom á qum msthkfs a`smraofs `uk
tmrratòraf bfk ukh pfpuchäâf
kuatf m`vmclmbaoh. Ourh`tm f oah
tmkfs akm`sfs gfvm`s î `fssh vfc+
th# khs âf rmsaomk bè.
Xuhc f phpmc oh suh phròquah `h
Oafbmsm6
H phròquah om Cmarah á ukh phrò+
quah bfkf futrh quhcqumr. _mk h
phrtabuchraohom oh suh adrmgh ph+
rfquahc smr hf kmskf tmkf h Rá oh
Oafbmsm m# pfr assf# tmr ukh kassâf
mspmbahc ohof qum á h adrmgh of Jas+
pf Oafbmsh`f m á hqua qum hz hssuhs bmcmjrhäýms pra`baphas.
Á# pfas# hqua qum mstè bhsh of Jas+
pf…
^rmbashkm`tm. ^fr assf h phrò+
quah tmk ukh cadhäâf mspmbahc m
om khafr prfxakaohom hf jaspf
oafbmsh`f. Lè hturhckm`tm ukh
khafr cadhäâf oh bfku`aohom om
Cmarah bfk f smu Jaspf# pfr fräh
ohs barbu`stê`bahs. Om rmstf# msth
phròquah `âf oamrm ohs rmsth`+
tms. Á ukh bfku`aohom brastâ qum
bfk hs suhs bhrhbtmrëstabhs prò+
prahs vha vavm`of h suh á a`smraoh
`h Adrmgh oafbmsh`h m u`avmrshc.
Rm tavmssm ukh fpfrtu`aohom
mspmbahc# f qum fmrmbmrah î suh
phròquah6
]kh a`gmäâf om á. ^frqum# `f
u`of# quh`of h á a`u`oh fs bf+
rhäýms ohs pmssfhs assf rmmtm+sm
`hs suhs vaohs m `h suh mcabaoh+
om. F prakmarf rutf oh á á prm+
bashkm`tm h hcmdrah# h bhphbaohom
om vavmr `f kmaf ohs satuhäýms è+
bmas m oaëbmas# m h hjmrturh phrh h
rmchäâf bfk fs futrfs m bfk h sf+
bamohom. ^fr assf f ^hph Jm`
\UA omoabfu mstm h`f î á. Á h
vç`bah oh á qum sm bf`brmtazh
kfof mspmbahc f m`bf`trf pmss
bfk Omus. Á ohë qum quhcqumr p
sfh pfom tarhr f sm`taof prfu`
phrh h suh vaoh m phrh h suh m`t
dh hfs futrfs.
Khas of qum ukh sfcuäâf ph
hs oaebucohoms of quftaoah`mssh á smrah f bhka`lf phrh
mcabaohom a`oavaouhc m oh bfk
`aohom…
Rmk o÷vaoh. M mssm á f sm`taof
smrkfs Adrmgh… phrh h`u`bah
mvh`dmclf. Kmskf `h suh vhr
ohom om rmspfsths f ek á smkpr
h`÷`baf of mvh`dmclf pfrqum#
bh`of f bfrhäâf ohs pmssfhs trh
frkh+hs m trh`sfrkh`of+sm
pmssfhs trh`sfrkhk+sm hs mst
turhs oh sfbamohom. @âf pfomk
qumrmr trh`sfrkhr hs mstrutu
oh sfbamohom smk trh`sfrkhr
pmssfhs. Mstfu bf`vm`baof qum
h`÷`baf of mvh`dmclf hjrm upmrspmtavh om vaoh oamrm`tm m q
pfssajacath ukh vaoh khas mca
khas sfcaoèrah.
Bf`smduarah bhrhbtmrazhr
smus phrfquah`fs mk trçs ph
vrhs6
@âf f pfssf hzmr# mcms thkj
tçk f oarmatf om hvhcahr f pèrfb
Yrasfs[… Khs# sm tavmr om bhrhbtm
zhr h phròquah om Cmarah# oarah q
á pcurhc# dm`mrfsh m omsmgfsh
hprfu`ohr h suh á.
á jf`atf shj
qum h `fssh mvh`dmcazhäâ
tfbh f bfrhäâf ohs pmssfh
quh`of h á a`u`o
fs bfrhäýms ohs pmssfh
assf rmemtm+sm hs suhs vaoh
m `h suh mcabaoho
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 10/16
82 om gu`lf om :>8> •
M@_ZMUAR_H K]@OF ^HËR
Bupâf om hssa`hturhA`struäýms7 Zmbfrthr m prmm`blmr f bupâf bfk cmtrh cmdëvmc m ohofs bfrrmbtfs m bfkpc
tfs. M`vahr phrh7 ^ZMRM@_M Cmarah+Eètakh# Rmka`èraf Oafbmsh`f om Cmarah# :?8?+>88 CMAZ
x Omsmgf smr hssa`h`tm of gfr`hc . ^hrh f mematf m`vaf fs kmus oh
ofs bfrrmbtfs m bfkpcmtfs.
@fkm
Ohth om @hsbakm`tf @· Bf`trajua`tm
+ +
Kfrhoh ,Zuh# `· oh pfrth# cudhr!
Bòoadf ^fsthc
+
_mcmef`m _mcmkòvmc
Mkhac
^hròquah
^rmäf hssa`hturh@hbaf`hc7 :>#>> ₣ • Murfph7 2=#>> ₣ • Zmstf of Ku`of7 =>#>> ₣
^hdhkm`tf ,smcmbaf`hr fpäâf!
Blmqum fu vhcm pfsthc
_rh`semr. jh`bèrah phrh f @AJ >>8>>>>>?1?12<=>>>881,h`mxhr bfkprfvhtavf!
Oájatf jh`bèraf ,prmm`blmr hutfrazhäâf om phdhkm`tf qum sm smdum!7
Mx.kfs Rr.s# sfcabatf qum# pfr oájatf `h ka`lh bf`th om ompòsatf h smduomsbrath pfsshk smr ematfs fs phdhkm`tfs ohs sujsbraäýms qum efrmk from`hohs pfr Eu`ohäâf Rad`as Msth trh`semrç`bah kh`tmr+sm+è htá a`oabhäâf mbf`trèraf.
Jh`bf Jhcbâf
@AJ
_atuchr oh bf`th
Ohth Hssa`hturh
+ +
Bf`thtfs7 :?? <:8 8>> | prmsm`tmNgfr`hcprmsm tm.p
^hph Erh`basbf bmcmjrfu lfkacah
`h Bhpmch oh Bhsh om Rh`th Khrth
–Ëofcfs‛ qum akpmomkhprfxakhäâf bfk Omus
@ukh lfkacah prfmraoh `h
bhpmch oh Bhsh om Rh`th Khrth# f
Uhtabh`f# `h phsshoh qua`th+marh#
oah 5# f ^hph Erh`basbf oassm qum
bhoh pmssfh tmk om omskhsbhrhr
fs –ëofcfs‛ qum h akpmomk om sm
hprfxakhr om Omus. –Uavmkfs pm+
qum`hs fu drh`oms aofchtrahs# khs
f bhka`lf qum cmvh h Omus phssh
pmcf hkfr mxbcusavf pfr Mcm# bfkf
Gmsus `fs m`sa`fu‛# ombchrfu. H
a`tmrvm`äâf phrtau om ukh phs+
shdmk of Mvh`dmclf `h quhc Gm+
sus á qumstaf`hof sfjrm quhc smrah
f prakmarf kh`ohkm`tf pfr hc+
duák –bugh a`tm`äâf `âf smrah tâf
a`fbm`tm‛.
–_fofs tmkfs fs `fssfs ëof+
cfs msbf`oaofs‛# hovmrtau Erh`bas+
bf# hch`of `uk mspëratf ku`oh+
`f qum cmvh h mssh aofchtrah. –Fs
ëofcfs msbf`oaofs hzmk bfk qum
`òs `âf smghkfs áas `f hkfr. F
bhka`lf phrh smduar mk rm`tm
`f Zma`f om Omus á uk bhka`lf
om omcaohom qum sm hssmkmclh hf
hkfr `upbahc‛# hbrmsbm`tfu. Gmsus#
sujca`lfu f ^hph# prfpým –uk bh+
ka`lf om omcaohom‛ qum `âf phs+
sh pmcf –hkfr hf mspëratf of ku`+
of‛.
Jaspfs ajárabfs
rm÷`mk `h Bhthcu`lh
Gfr`hcasthsrmbf`lmbaofs
Hs bfkassýms mpasbfphas
ohs bfku`abhäýms sfbahas om
^frtudhc m Msph`lh mstavm+
rhk rmu`aofs `h Bhthcu`lh
phrh hjfrohr qumstýms bfkf
hs rmoms sfbahas bfkf `fvfs
kmafs om mvh`dmcazhäâf. @f +
`hc of m`bf`trf# mk bfku`a+
bhof# fs jaspfs ajárabfs hr+
khk+sm sfcaoèrafs bfk fs
gfr`hcasths hmthofs pmch brasm
mbf`òkabh m hdrhombmrhk f smu
msfräf mk –jusbh oh vmrohom‛.
@f kmskf bfku`abhof# oavuc+
dhof pmch Zèoaf Zm`hsbm`äh# fs
jaspfs kh`amsthrhk h a`tm`+
äâf om omsm`vfcvmr –mstrhtádahs
om bfchjfrhäâf‛ bf`gu`th qum
pmrkathk tfr`hr h prmsm`äh oh
Adrmgh `f ku`of oadathc khas
htrhtavh smk# `f m`th`tf pmr+
katar qum f ku`of vartuhc sm
sujstatuh hf rmhc. –Rm f hkjam`+
tm oadathc á uk cudhr homquhof
phrh f m`bf`trf# phrh f oaècfdf
m phrh f h`÷`baf oh shcvhäâf
om Gmsus Brastf# f cudhr om rm+
mrç`bah khas prfpëbaf phrh bm+
cmjrhr mssh shcvhäâf á h bfku+
`aohom bf`brmth# qum sm rm÷`m
phrh rmzhr# bmcmjrhr fs shbrh+
km`tfs m vavmr h bhraohom‛# rm+
mrau h Zèoaf Zm`hsbm`äh.
= om gu`lf# oah ku`oahc of kmaf Hkjam`tm
^hph bf`om`h omspmroëbaf@h huoaç`bah dmrhc om quhrth+
marh# oah =# f ^hph Erh`basbf brata+
bfu f omspmroëbaf hcakm`thr. –H bf+kaoh qum omathkfs frh á rfujhoh
oh kmsh om qumk á pfjrm# om qumk
tmk fkm‛# rmmrau f ^hph bathof
pmch Zèoaf Zm`hsbm`äh.
–H bucturh of omsbhrtèvmc
tfr`fu+`fs a`sm`sëvmas hf caxf m
hf omspmroëbaf hcakm`thr# qum sâf
ha`oh khas chkm`tèvmas quh`+
of mk tfohs hs phrtms of ku`+
of# a`mcazkm`tm# kuaths pmssfhs
m hkëcahs sfrmk om fkm m suj+
`utraäâf. F bf`sukaskf cmvfu hs
pmssfhs h lhjatuhrmk+sm hf su+
páreuf m hf omspmroëbaf oaèraf omhcakm`tf‛# oassm.
F ^hph pmoau ha`oh qum `âf
sm msqumäh qum f vhcfr oh vaoh
lukh`h omvm msthr smkprm hba+
kh ofs a`tmrmssms mbf`òkabfs. Rm
uk –smk+hjradf kfrrm om raf `h
ruh `âf á `ftëbah. ^mcf bf`trèraf#
ukh qumoh om 8> pf`tfs mk jfc+
shs om hcdukhs baohoms á ukh trh+
dáoah‛# chkm`tfu Erh`basbf. –Hs+
sak# hs pmssfhs sâf omsbhrthohs.
@òs# hs pmssfhs# sfkfs omsbhrth+
ohs# bfkf sm ÿssmkfs omspmroë+
baf‛# prfssmduau.Zmbfroh`of f cmkh of oah
ku`oahc of kmaf hkjam`tm –pm`+
shr.bfkmr.bf`smrvhr‛# f ^hph bf`+
vaofu h kuctaoâf oh ^rhäh om R.
^morf –h uk sáraf bfkprfkassf
`f sm`taof om sm rmspmathr m duhr+
ohr h brahäâf# smr sfcëbatf pfr bhoh
pmssfh m bfkjhtmr h bucturh of
omsbhrtèvmc m of omspmroëbaf bfk
ukh bucturh oh sfcaohramohom m of
m`bf`trf‛.
H`ofrrh
Jaspf mcfdah pfrtudumsms
O. Gfh` M`rab Uavms# jaspf om
]rdmcc m bfprë`bapm om H`ofrrh#
kh`amstfu+sm –kuatf drhtf î bf+
ku`aohom pfrtudumsh‛ qum bf`+
saomrh –trhjhclhofrh# mk jusbh
om trhjhclf# phrh kmclfrhr h suh
vaoh m m`bf`trhr fpfrtu`aohoms#
mk phrtabuchr phrh hs brah`ähs‛#
`ftabah h Hdç`bah Mbbcmsah.
Chkm`th`of –qum sm tm`lh
taof om m`bmrrhr h Mkjhaxhoh om
^frtudhc mk H`ofrrh‛# f jaspf rm+
mrau qum hs phròquahs of pra`ba+
phof tçk –kuatfs pfrtudumsms
bfk vf`thom om kh`tmr h suh á‛.
–Á ukh bfku`aohom kuatf mrvf+
rfsh# bfk drh`om omvfäâf î Rm+
`lfrh om Eètakh‛# oassm O. Gfh`
M`rab Uavms mspmrh`of qum smgh
pfssëvmc qum h Bf`mrç`bah Mpas+
bfphc ^frtudumsh omsta`m uk sh+
bmroftm phrh h bfku`aohom mka+
drh`tm mk H`ofrrh# om frkhxh# `ukh bhpmch`ah m bfchjfrh`+
of `futrhs htavaohoms.
H bfku`aohom pfrtudumsh
cfbhc á bfkpfsth pfr khas om 8>
kac pfrtudumsms frau`ofs om tfof
f tmrratòraf `hbaf`hc.
H d ç @ b A H M
b b C M R A H
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 11/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 • 8
K]@OF ^HËR CA_]ZDAH
Rh`tf H`tò`af#uk lfkmk ofku`of
@f kçs mk qum sm bmcmjrh
Rh`tf H`tò`af# f Bm`trf om Mstu+
ofs om Eacfsfh m h ^rfvë`bah ^fr+
tudumsh oh Fromk Erh`basbh`h
prfkfvmk uk smka`èraf om a`+
vmstadhäâf# h rmhcazhr oah :8 omstm
kçs# `f Bm`trf Bucturhc Erh`bas+
bh`f# mk Casjfh# bugf tmkh bm`trhc
á h prmsm`äh of rh`basbh`askf h
cfsfh pfrtudumsh.
Msth a`abahtavh prmtm`om ohr
h bf`lmbmr –durhs rh`basbh`hs
fu pm`shofrms mk bugh fjrh f rh`basbh`askf mstmgh prmsm`tm‛.
M`trm mcms Rh`tf H`tò`af# bugh vaoh# mxpmraç`bah m cmdhof# sâf
ukh fräh a`sparhofrh phrh `òs. Of`f om ukh drh`om bucturh#
cmbaf`fu mk u`avmrsaohoms athcah`hs m rh`bmshs m fa uk ofs a`+
tmcmbtuhas khas `ftèvmas om ^frtudhc of pmrëfof prá+u`avmrsatè+
raf. Efa kassaf`èraf mk Èrabh# vavmu m kfrrmu mk Atècah ,82 om gu+
`lf om 8:28!# m omaxfu+`fs ukh bfcmäâf om smrkýms msbratfs qum
hzmk omcm ukh rmmrç`bah a`tmcmbtuhc oh ápfbh.
Omoabfu h suh vaoh hfs khas omshvfrmbaofs# m sâf mcms qum f
vm`mrhk m clm rmbf`lmbmk hs quhcaohoms# mstmgh`of+f om frkh
pfpuchr f oah 82 om gu`lf# oah oh baohom om Casjfh# f`om hsbmu#
mk 8= om hdfstf om 881=.
Mxpfsaäâf Micfdah blmdh h Casjfh
Efa a`hudurhoh `f oah = `f ^hvaclâf Khbhu of ^hrqum ohBaohom# mk Casjfh# h mxpfsaäâf kuctakáoah m a`tmrhtavh Micfdah
‒ Miicmsah# Cfdfs# Mbfcfdah# oh rmspf`shjacaohom oh Rfbamohom Jë+
jcabh# h Hssfbahäâf «H Zfblh¹ m h Bêkhrh Ku`abaphc om Cfurms.
Mstm á uk prfgmtf –a`fvhofr m `mbmssèraf‛# qum tmk bfkf fj+
gmtavf sm`sajacazhr m kfjacazhr –hs bfku`aohoms brastâs m fs baoh+
oâfs mk dmrhc phrh h prfjcmkètabh oh brasm hkjam`thc h phrtar om
ukh rmvasathäâf ofs vhcfrms u`ohofrms oh `fssh aom`taohom bf+
kuk‛# pfom cmr+sm `h pèda`h oh Micfdah.
]kh bhrhvh`h mstè h pmrbfrrmr 8> baohoms pfrtudumshs#
,Cmarah `âf mstè a`bcuëoh!# tm`of `f bm`trf ukh mxpfsaäâf sfjrm f
tmkh oh hchvrh m oh mbfcfdah ,^ch`mth hzuc# hchvrh vavh# Adrmgh
vmrom!# bfkpcmkm`thof pfr ukh sáram om a`abahtavhs om h`akhäâf
jëjcabh m bucturhc m om moubhäâf hkjam`thc phrh pmssfhs# hkëcahs
m bfku`aohoms brastâs. Msths a`abahtavhs prmtm`omk prfkfvmr f
omjhtm m h rmemxâf sfjrm h tmkètabh# hssak bfkf uk fclhr rm`f+
vhof sfjrm h `hturmzh m ukh `fvh htatuom phrh bfk h kmskh. ^]J 8&<
Eu`mrhas# Brmkhäýms# _rh`schohäýms# Mxukhäýms
RMZUAÄF OFKABACAÈZAF ^MZKH@M@_M H@_MR M H^ÒR F E]@MZHC
_rhthkm`tf drhtuathkm`tm om tfofs fs sujsëoafs h qum mstâf sugmatfs fs ehkacahrms
O. Gfâf om Fcavmarh Khtfs ,8<41+815:!#
jaspf huxacahr oh Duhroh
Jaspf pfrtuduçs h bhka`lfoh jmhtaebhäâf
F ^hph Erh`basbf hprfvfu h
pujcabhäâf of ombrmtf qum rmbf+
`lmbm hs –vartuoms lmròabhs‛ om
O. Gfâf om Fcavmarh Khtfs ,8<41+815:!# jaspf huxacahr oh Duhroh#
qum rmbmjm hssak f tëtucf om –vm+
`mrèvmc‛. H `ftëbah fa ohoh pmch
Zèoaf Zm`hsbm`äh qum mxpcabh
qum msth á ukh hsm of prfbms+
sf qum cmvh î prfbchkhäâf om uk
bhtòcabf h jmhtf# pm`÷ctakh mthph
phrh h ombchrhäâf oh sh`taohom.
O. Gfâf om Fcavmarh Khtfs u`ofu
h Cadh ofs Rmrvfs om Gmsus# ukh
a`statuaäâf qum rm`fvfu h oafbmsm
oh Duhroh# htrhvás oh frkhäâf
om kaclhrms om cmadfs. Î Zm`hsbm`+
äh# O. H`tò`af Kfatmarf Zhkfs#
vabm+pfstuchofr oh bhush oh bh+
`f`azhäâf# mxpcabh qum á msth Cadh#
fa h drh`om khrbh omaxhoh pmcf
h`tadf jaspf huxacahr oh Duhroh.–Efa ukh hssfbahäâf om cmadfs qum
mcm u`ofu mk 81:? bfk h `hca+
ohom om gu`thr fs cmadfs oh oafbm+
sm‛# rmmrm î Zèoaf Zm`hsbm`äh f
vabm+pfstuchofr oh bhush oh bh`f+
`azhäâf hf mxpcabhr qum O. Gfâf om
Fcavmarh Khtfs –pm`shvh qum mrh
`mbmssèraf hssfbaè+cfs phrh clms
ohr frkhäâf# qumr phstfrhc qumr
msparatuhc# m thkják phrh fs hzmr
bfchjfrhofrms khas oarmtfs of pè+
rfbf‛. O. H`tò`af Kfatmarf Zhkfs
oaz ha`oh î Zm`hsbm`äh qum –`fs
prakmarfs := h`fs# h Cadh mz khas
om kac rmtarfs# pfr f`om phsshr
bmrbh om := kac pmssfhs‛.
O Z
:: om gu`lf# `f _mhtrf _avfca mk Casjfh
Kusabhc cmkjrh Gfâf ^hucf AA
A`tmdrhof `f h`f bfkmkfrh+
tavf H`f oh Eá m of Bm`tm`èraf of
`hsbakm`tf of phorm Tmrm`ramo#
u`ohofr of kfvakm`tf# h Eu`+
ohäâf Hguoh î Adrmgh qum Rfrm fr+
dh`azh uk kusabhc a`tmarhkm`tm
omoabhof h Gfâf hucf AA.
F –Kusabhc Tfgtych‛ rmhcazh+
+sm h :: om gu`lf# pmchs 85l>># `f
_mhtrf _avfca mk Casjfh. Jhsmhof
`ukh –vaoh qum a`sparfu kuaths
vaohs‛ f mspmtèbucf bf`th –a`spa+
rhr‛ tfofs fs prmsm`tms.
Zmbfrom+sm qum mk :>88# pfr
fbhsaâf oh jmhtabhäâf of ^hph
Gfâf ^hucf AA# h Eu`ohäâf Hguoh î
Adrmgh qum Rfrm hssfbafu+sm h mstm
prfgmbtf om lfkm`hdmk# `uk ms+
pmbtèbucf kuctakáoah mchjfrhof
h phrtar om tmstmku`lfs om vaohs
qum kuohrhk fu frhk tfbhohs
pfr Gfâf hucf AA.
M`tâf# bfkf hdfrh f fjgmb
vf á cmkjrhr –f ^hph# f lfkmk
Rh`tf‛ Gfâf ^hucf AA.
Fs a`tmrmsshofs pfomrâf m
bf`trhr jaclmtms mk www.tab
tca`m.pt# `hs cfghs E@HB# Hjr
Uahdm`s m Tfrtm` fu ha`oh `f
Bfrtm A`dcçs.
Hs rmsmrvhs pfomk smr ma
pmcf tmcmf`m 4>4 :2? :2?. | RE
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 12/16
82 om gu`lf om :>8: •
Bfkm`tèraf
Fushr tfbhr f Rh`tëssakf
Gfsá Erhzâf Bfrrmah# sgshbmroftm gmsuëth
Mas bfkf sm `fs mxpým f Rh`tëssakf.Mk bhsh of ehrasmu Rakâf# ukh ku+
clmr pmbhofrh vmk hf m`bf`trf om Gmsus.@âf clm bf`lmbmkfs f `fkm# hpm`hs h kèehkh. _rhz bf`sadf uk vhsf om pmreukm.Rmk oazmr `hoh# burvh+sm m# hssak# thcvmz om
gfmclfs# chvh fs pás of Kmstrm bfk hs cè+drakhs qum clm bfrrmk of rfstf. M`xudh++fs bfk fs pròprafs bhjmcfs. Jmagh+fs bfkh suh jfbh m u`dm+fs bfk fs hrfkhs qum
trfuxmrh `hs suhs kâfs. _uof `msth kuclmrphrmbm mxbmssavf# quhsm akp÷oabf. F htrmva+km`tf oh htatuom. H cajmrohom ofs dmstfs.H efräh oh bf`h`äh. Fush tfbhr f shdrh+of# bfkf qum efräh`of f shdrhof h tfbè++ch. M `hoh oaz# omaxh`of msphäf phrh qum#sm quasmr# smgh Gmsus h oazmr h phchvrh qum a`+tmrmssh fuvar.
Mxbmssavf m omsbf`bmrth`tm á# aduhc+km`tm# Gmsus qum sm omaxh tfbhr m jmaghr mpmreukhr. –Khs bfkf‛# pmrdu`th Rakâf# m`òs bfkf mcm# quh`of `fs phrmbm qum# omOmus# gè shjmkfs tuof m# of hctf oh `fs+sh arrmprmm`sajacaohom kfrhc# `fs tfr`hkfs
guëzms a`sm`sëvmas6 –Bfkf á pfssëvmc qum f
^urf sm omaxm tfbhr pmcf akpurf m f Rh`+tf pmcf pmbhofr m f Gustf pmcf ëkpaf. Hl#sm Gmsus efssm ^rfemth# shjmrah qumk á msthkuclmr qum f tfbh m# smdurhkm`tm# `âf smomaxhrah tfbhr pfr mch‛. frqum âf mstè prm+
vastf qum Omus smgh hssak# jfk phrh khus#sm`sëvmc h akpurfs# omoabhof h pmbhofrms.^fr assf# sm Gmsus `âf á a`tfbèvmc# `âf pfomvar om Omus. Rm `âf vavm smphrhof oh kasá+rah lukh`h# `âf á Rh`tf.
Ea`hckm`tm# Gmsus rfkpm f sacç`baf phrhehchr h Rakâf hbmrbh ofs dmstfs oh ku+clmr. Fs kmskfs qum clm pmrkatmk oazmrqum á Omus «a`takaohom th`dëvmc¹. Bf`th+clm h lastòrah om uk brmofr qum pmrofh =>>om`èrafs h uk omvmofr m => h uk futrf.Bfkf mpëcfdf# h pmrdu`th qum qumr cmvhrRakâf h omaxhr+sm tfbhr pmcf ofk akmrmba+of m khas of qum mbmssèraf om Omus. –Xuhcofs ofas omvmofrms bhrè khas rmbf`lmba+of hf smu brmofr6‛ –@hturhckm`tm# f pra+
kmarf‛# rmspf`om. M`tâf# vfcth`of+sm phrhh kuclmr ofs dmstfs fushofs# Gmsus rmstatuaRakâf hfs smus dmstfs mk ehcth. –H èduh mf jmagf m f pmreukm qum `âf km omstm# ef+rhk+km ohofs pfr mch# phrh cè of omvaofm of `mbmssèraf‛. Ompfas# h bf`bcusâf. Kua+tf á pmrofhof h qumk kuatf hkh m kuatfhkhrè hqumcm h qumk kuatf efr pmrofhof.^fr assf# –vha# h tuh eá tm shcvfu‛. Hs phchvrhsoaths î kuclmr# gè shcvh pmch eá# phrmbmk smroaths# aduhckm`tm# h Rakâf# phrh qum blm+dum h smr tfbhof pmch eá qum shcvh. ^fom+rè blmdhr# thkják mcm# h tfbhr f Rm`lfr#quh`of sm omaxhr tfbhr pfr Mcm.
Á tfbh`tm# mstm tmxtf om Cubhs. ^fr mcm#
bfkprmm`omkfs# thcvmz# kmclfr h hrkh+äâf omsbf`bmrth`tm om Gfâf7 «F Umrjf em+z+sm bhr`m¹. Omus `âf á ukh vmrohom hjs+trhbth qum sm hprm`om. @âf á uk prmbmatfrëdaof qum sm bukprm. @âf á f hjsfcutf sm+
phrhof om tuof m om tfofs# qum sm jhsthh sa kmskf# smk hembtfs `mk rmchäýms. MkGmsus# Omus á f ^ha qum `fs tfbh m`quh`+tf sm qumr omaxhr tfbhr# sfjrmtuof pmcfs a`+tfbèvmas omstm ku`of ‒ pfjrms# ofm`tms#khrda`hcazhofs# pmbhofrms. F Rh`tëssakfmxpým+sm+`fs `h pfjrm bustòoah oh `fsshlukh`aohom emraoh. Hë# ombchrh f Rmu hkfr#hbfclm`of h drh`omzh ofs dmstfs oh ku+clmr pmbhofrh# omsmgh`of burhr f bfrhäâfsmbf of ehrasmu Rakâf. M `òs sfkfs h ku+clmr. @òs sfkfs Rakâf. Oah`tm of Rm`lfr#hssak mxpfstf# tm`lhkfs uk bfrhäâf lu+kh`f phrh `fs omaxhrkfs tfbhr pmcf hembtfbfk qum f ^ha `fs tfbh mk Gmsus.
H`f B • _mkpf Bfkuk • Ofka`df \ACmaturh A Rhckf Cmaturh AA Hcmcuah Mvh dmclf
^HËR CA_]ZDAH7 85 om gu`lf F^A@AÂF
Cmaturh of Rmdu`of Cavrf om Rhkumc
@hqumcms oahs# oassm @htâ h Ohvao7 «Hssak
hch f Rm`lfr# Omus om Asrhmc7 ]`da+tm bfkf
rma om Asrhmc m cavrma+tm ohs kâfs om Rhuc. M`+
trmduma+tm h bhsh of tmu sm`lfr m pus+tm `fs
jrhäfs hs suhs kuclmrms. Oma+tm h bhsh om As+
rhmc m om Guoè m# sm astf `âf á suebam`tm# ohr+
tm+ma kuatf khas. Bfkf fushstm omsprmzhr
h phchvrh of Rm`lfr# hzm`of f qum á khc h
smus fclfs6 Khthstm î msphoh ]rahs# f latath9
tfkhstm bfkf mspfsh h suh kuclmr# ompfas
om f tmrms matf phsshr î msphoh pmcfs hkf+
`aths. Hdfrh h msphoh `u`bh khas sm hhs+
thrè oh tuh bhsh# pfrqum Km omsprmzhstm m
tfkhstm h mspfsh om ]rahs# f latath# phrh h+
zmrms omch tuh kuclmr¹. M`tâf Ohvao oassm
h @htâ7 «^mquma bf`trh f Rm`lfr¹. @htâ rms+
pf`omu+clm7 «F Rm`lfr pmroffu f tmu pmbh+
of7 @âf kfrrmrès¹. ^hchvrh of Rm`lfr.
: Rhk 8:# 4+8>.82
^mrofha# Rm`lfr#
ka`lh bucph m kmu pmbhof.
Emcaz ohqumcm h qumk fa pmrofhoh h bucph
m hjsfcvaof f pmbhof.
Emcaz f lfkmk h qumk f Rm`lfr
`âf hbush om a`aquaohom
m mk bugf mspëratf âf lè m`dh`f.
Bf`mssma+vfs f kmu pmbhof
m `âf msbf`oa h ka`lh bucph.
Oassm7 Ufu bf`msshr hf Rm`lfr h ka lh hcth
m cfdf km pmrofhstms h bucph of pmbhof.
Uòs sfas f kmu rm÷daf# omm`oma+km ofs pmradfs#
hzma qum î ka lh vfcth sò lhgh la fs om vatòrah.
Hcmdrha+vfs# gustfs# m rmdfzagha+vfs f Rm`lfr#
mxuctha vòs tfofs fs qum sfas rmbtfs om bfrhäâf.
Rhckf 28 ,2:!# 8+:.=.4.88 ,Z. be. =b!
Cmaturh oh Mpëstfch of hpòstfcf Râf ^hucf
hfs Dèchths
Arkâfs7 Rhjmkfs qum f lfkmk âf á gus+
taebhof pmchs fjrhs oh Cma# khs pmch á mk
Gmsus Brastf9 pfr assf hbrmoatèkfs mk Bras+
tf Gmsus# phrh smrkfs gustaebhofs pmch á
mk Brastf m âf pmchs fjrhs oh C ma# pfrqum
pmchs fjrhs oh Cma `a`duák á gustaebhof.
Om hbtf# pfr kmaf oh Cma# kfrra phrh h Cma#
h ek om vavmr phrh Omus. Bfk Brastf mstfu
brubaebhof. Gè âf sfu mu qum vavf# á Brastf
qum vavm mk kak. Rm ha`oh vavf ompm`om`+
tm om ukh hturmzh bhr`hc# vavf h`akhof
pmch á f Eaclf om Omus# qum km hkfu m Rm
m`trmdfu pfr kak. @âf qumrf tfr`hr a`÷+
tac h drhäh om Omus# pfrqum# sm h gustaebhäâf
vamssm pfr kmaf oh Cma# m`tâf Brastf tmrah
kfrraof mk vâf.
^hchvrh of Rm`lfr.
Dhc 8# 88+81
Omus hkfu+`fs m m`vafu f smu Eaclf
bfkf vëtakh om mxpahäâf pmcfs fssfs pmbho
8 Gf ?# 8
Mvh`dmclf om @fssf Rm`lfr Gmsus Brastf
smdu`of Râf Cubhs
@hqumcm tmkpf# uk hrasmu bf`vaofu Gmsu
phrh bfkmr bfk mcm. Gmsus m`trfu mk bhsh
of hrasmu m tfkfu cudhr î kmsh. M`tâf# uk
kuclmr ‒ ukh pmbhofrh qum vavah h baoh
om ‒ hf shjmr qum Mcm msthvh î kmsh mk bhs
of hrasmu# trfuxm uk vhsf om hchjhstrf bf
pmrukm9 pÿs+sm htrès om Gmsus m# blfrh`+
of kuatf# jh`lhvh+Clm fs pás bfk hs cèdr
khs m m`xudhvh+Clfs bfk fs bhjmcfs# jmag
vh+fs m u`dah+fs bfk f pmrukm. Hf vmr as
f hrasmu qum ta`lh bf`vaohof Gmsus pm`+
sfu bf`sadf7 «Rm mstm lfkmk fssm prfmth
shjmrah qum h kuclmr qum F tfbh á ukh pm
bhofrh¹. Gmsus tfkfu h phchvrh m oassm+clm
«Rakâf# tm`lf ukh bfash h oazmr+tm¹. Mcm rm
pf`omu7 «Ehch# Kmstrm¹. Gmsus bf`ta`ufu7
«Bmrtf brmofr ta`lh ofas omvmofrms7 uk om
vah+clm qua`lm`tfs om`èrafs m f futrf ba`+
qum`th. Bfkf âf ta`lhk bfk qum phdhr
pmroffu h hkjfs. Xuhc omcms ebhrè khas s
hkadf6¹. Zmspf`omu Rakâf7 «Hqumcm ‒ sup
`lf mu ‒ h qumk khas pmroffu¹. Oassm+clm
Gmsus7 «Gucdhstm jmk¹. M vfcth`of+Rm phrh h
kuclmr# oassm h Rakâf7 «Uçs msth kuclmr6 M
trma mk tuh bhsh m `âf Km omstm èduh phrh
fs pás9 khs mch jh`lfu+Km fs pás bfk hs c
drakhs m m`xudfu+fs bfk fs bhjmcfs. @âf
Km omstm f òsbucf9 khs mch# omsom qum m`tr
`âf bmssfu om jmaghr+Km fs pás. @âf Km omrhkhstm òcmf h bhjmäh9 khs mch u`dau+Km
fs pás bfk pmrukm. ^fr assf tm oadf7 Râf+c
pmrofhofs fs smus kuatfs pmbhofs# pfrqum
kuatf hkfu9 khs hqumcm h qumk pfubf sm
pmrofh# pfubf hkh¹. Ompfas oassm î kuclm
«Fs tmus pmbhofs mstâf pmrofhofs¹. M`tâf
bf`vavhs bfkmährhk h oazmr m`trm sa7 «Xu
á mstm lfkmk# qum htá pmrofh fs pmbhofs6
Khs Gmsus oassm î kuclmr7 «H tuh á tm shc+
vfu. Uha mk phz¹. hchvrh oh shcvhäâf.
Cb 4# 25
:2 om gu`lf | Ofka`df \AA
M`trhohHprfxakha+vfs of Rm`lfr E. Rh`tfs
Bf`ehrma f kmu Omus H. Mspa`fsh
RhckfH ka`lh hckh tmk smom om Uòs K Cuës
Hprmsm`thäâf ofs of`sBh`tha hcmdrmkm`tm hf Rm`lfr K. Cuës
Brmkfs mk Uòs ò Omus C. Khsf`
Bfku`lâf
Oha+km Rm`lfr uk bfrhäâf purf K. Cuë
Mu sfu f jfk phstfr B. Racvh
^òs+bfku`lâf
Kmu Rm`lfr mu Ufs hkf H. Bhrthdm`f
Ka`lh cuz m shcvhäâf O. Gucam`
Ea`hc
Cfuvhof smgh f kmu Rm`lfr G. Rh`tfs
^fvfs oh tmrrh cfuvha K. Rakýms
sudmstâf om bê`tabfs
O Z
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 13/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 • 8
]k brahofr
om mspmrh`äh@f h`f om 81>2 `hsbm uk lfkmk qum
khrbfu ombasavhkm`tm h rmdaâf# pmchs suhsaomahs# brm`ähs m efräh om bhrèbtmr. Xums+taf`hof pfr u`s m hkhof pfr futrfs# hbh+jfu pfr omaxhr uk cmdhof h tfofs fs qumhbrmoathk `h omvfäâf h Omus# bf`drmdh`+of h bfrhdmk om akpcmkm`thr mstruturhs#
`uk pmrëfof lastòrabf om m`frkms oabuc+ohoms mbf`òkabhs m sfbahas.
H suh Fjrh á drh`oafsh7 efa f eu`ohofrof gfr`hc H Ufz of Ofka`df# oh Drèbh om
Cmarah m oh Msbfch om Efrkhäâf Rfbahc Zu+rhc om Cmarah. F smu fkm6 Kf`sm`lfr GfsáDhchkjh om Fcavmarh.
Bf`saomrh`of f msthof htuhc of phës ápfssëvmc bf`sththr qum hs prmfbuphäýms omKf`sm`lfr Gfsá Dhchkjh om Fcavmarh# cm+dhohs pmch suh Ufz# bf`ta`uhk aduhckm`+tm h a`quamthr fs lmromarfs m dmstfrms ofsmu phtrakò`af.
Hs kuoh`ähs ombfrraohs hpòs h suhkfrtm# fs khas oavmrsfs ofkë`afs# âf hc+tmrhrhk h oájac rmhcaohom of bf`tmxtf `h+
baf`hc m cfbhc. ^fubf kuofu… Rmcmbaf`maofas mxbmrtfs tmxtuhas oh suh hutfrah qumrmvmchk f smu mspëratf vasaf`èraf# f prakma+rf# m h suh bf`sbaç`bah prètabh m rmhcasth# fsmdu`of# h shjmr7 «H bhoh h`f qum tmrka+`h á ukh `fvh f`oh om oapcfkhofs bfkbursfs supmrafrms qum `âf tçk f`om dh+
`lhr ombm`tmkm`tm f pâf om bhoh oah`÷kmrf om omsmkprmdhofs a`tmcmbtuhukm`th hssusthofrhkm`tm.¹ ,81?8# a`Ufz of Ofka`df! Y…[ «_rèdabh acusâf. ^msfu+sm# ourh`tm kuatfs h`fs# qum# h Msbch ^rakèrah m `h Rmbu`oèrah# fs hcu`fs armbmjmr efrkhäâf brastâ. Xum rmsth# lfom tuof assf6 Kuatfs hcu`fs `âf ermqumthk hs huchs. Futrfs vâf cè# shjm Omus bfqum oaspfsaäâf.¹ ,814?# a` H Ufz of Oka`df!.
F orhkh qum quâf acustrm pmrsf`hcaoom sfcubaf`fu# fu tm`tfu mcaka`hr# sâf kachrms hfs oh bf`tmkpfrh`maohom.
F pfrquç omsth lukacom rmemrç`bahuk lfkmk qum omoabfu h suh vaoh î fjom Omus m cutfu bfk h suh phchvrh# mhjf`f ofs omsvhcaofs6
Râf lfkm`s sfcaoèrafs m bf`vabtfs akpcmkm`thr aomhas om ë`ofcm bfku`arah qum a`brmkm`thk h moabhäâf om u
ku`of vmrohomarhkm`tm omsm`vfcvaKf`sm`lfr Gfsá Dhchkjh om Fcavmarh# ac
trm pmrsf`hcaohom# bf`ta`uh h smr mxmkpm kfomchr phrh qumk aduhckm`tm omsefkm`thr msefräfs bf`oubm`tms î prfkäâf oh a`tmdraohom sfbahc m sujsmqum`km`tm of prfdrmssf bucturhc.
Bhjm+`fs bf`ta`uhr h prhtabhr vhcfqum sm hssukmk bfkf efrtu`h lukh`h
H Eá qum
hbf`tmbmH hrkhäâf `ubcmhr om Gmsus om qum h
suh prmsm`äh bfrpfrhc á h efrkh om fs Lf+km`s puomrmk a`tuar h mssç`bah om OM]R#`âf pfom smr omkf`strhoh om kfof fj+
gmtavf m `âf rmsucthrè om uk msefräf oha`tmcadç`bah. @h ka`lh cmaturh rhbaf`hc# hhbmathäâf omsth hrkhäâf tmrè om smr uk
hbf`tmbakm`tf pmssfhc# hbf`tmbmrè `h hu+tfbf`sbaç`bah om bhoh uk m omsad`h+smpfr eá.
Mu z msth hbmathäâf bfkf ukh htatuom
km`thc9 qum `âf á arrhbaf`hc. Á ukh a`tua+äâf. Rmkprm h bf`saomrma bfkf thc.
@âf bf surprmm`oaof bfk hs a`vmsta+dhäýms oh `murfjafcfdah kfomr`h sfjrm hbfd`aäâf a`tuatavh m h suh akpfrtê`bah `hmstruturhäâf ofs bfkpfrthkm`tfs a`oava+ouhas. M hbfkph`lf fs rmsucthofs qum vâfsm`of pujcabhofs. ^frqum smkprm pm`smaqum# sm phrh h eá hbf`tmbmr efssm prmbasfcmr h Rukh _mfcòdabh om _fkès om Hqua`f#
gè `âf lhvmrah `a`duák bfk eá. Fu smgh# sòfs a`tmcmbtuhas om bucturh supmrafr pfom+
rahk hsbm`omr hf bf`lmbakm`tf pmrematf mrhbaf`hc om Omus.
H pmrkh`ç`bah h eá âf á eèbac pfrqumhs a`tuaäýms `âf sâf uk supfrtm homquh+of phrh h vmrohom fjgmtavh. M h jusbh ohvmrohom# bfkf bfd`aäâf bmrth m smdurh# áukh mxadç`bah oh a`tmcadç`bah ofs lukh+`fs.
M`tâf# f msefräf rhbaf`hc om qumk tmvmh rmvmchäâf a`tuatavh oh Eá mk Gmsus# bfkf
kh`aemsthäâf a`tmcadëvmc oh _rh`sbm`oç`+bah# á uk trhjhclf om rmmxâf pmrkh`m`tm
sfjrm fs eu`ohkm`tfs `fs quhas sm hpfahh suh htatuom km`thc om eá. ^hrh h `murf+jafcfdah kfomr`h# h a`tuaäâf `âf á ukhacuka`häâf s÷jath# smk kftavhäâf# khs á#h`tms# ukh bmrtmzh# qum sm hpfah mk bf`+tm÷ofs km`thas a`tmr`fs `âf bf`sbam`tms#khs tfofs rmsucth`tms oh mxpmraç`bah omvaoh om bhoh uk …
Mstms bf`tm÷ofs bfd`atavfs pfomkhpfahr fu bf`trhrahr h pmrsastç`bah oh Eá.Futrfrh# fs h`hbfrmths# rmbmjaoh h acuka+`häâf a`tuatavh oh Eá# rmtarhvhk+sm phrh fomsmrtf# phrh qum `hoh of ku`of mxtmrafrpuomssm hkmhähr h bmrtmzh oh suh a`tua+äâf. Lfgm# `òs vavmkfs `f ku`of m á ofku`of qum rmtarhkfs fs hrdukm`tfs phrhsustm`thr h vmrohom oh `fssh a`tuaäâf. Ms+th`of# mk pmrkh`ç`bah# htm`tfs h tuof fqum î `fssh vfcth hbf`tmbm.
M`tâf# f trhjhclf a`oavaouhc oh Eá ápmrkh`m`tm. @âf `fs oè omsbh`sf `mk
uk sò oah. _mkfs om vmr# cmr m pm`shr. _m+kfs om omsbfjrar fs sa`has sfj hs hphrç`+bahs. M tmkfs om hkhr fs arkâfs pfrqummssh á h vmrohomarh mssç`bah om AHUÁ# thcbfkf Gmsus mxpcabfu `f smu tmkpf m h suhAdrmgh mxpcabh# lfgm# hfs lfkm`s om jfhvf`thom bhphzms om sm hjrarmk î _rh`s+bm`oç`bah.
Mk vmrohom# á jmk khas oaeëbac tmr Eáof qum smr htmu.
f trhjhclf a`oavaouhc oh Eá á pmrkh`m`+
tm. @âf `fs oè omsbh`sf `mk uk sò oah._mkfs om vmr# cmr m pm`shr.
Râf lfkm`s sfcaoèrafs m bf`vabtfs m
akpcmkm`thr aomhas om ë`ofcm bfku`at
rah qum a`brmkm`thk h moaebhäâf om u
ku`of vmrohomarhkm`tm omsm`vfcvao
Oh`amc Rmrrâfkáoabf
^hucf Bcmkm`^rfms
CA_]ZDAH F^A@AÂF ×_AC
]k sh`tf pfpuchr ofs jmjás m kâms drèvaohsHarms Dhkmarf
@mstm kçs ofs sh`tfs pfpuchrmshdrhoh+km msbfclmr R. Gfâf Jhptasth. Ftmòcfdf Rh`tf H`tò`af m f phph R. ^m+orf `âf vâf cmvhr h khc. F oah ku`oahcoh brah`äh ,8om gu`lf!9 h pmrmdra`häâfohs brah`ähs h Eètakh# ,8> om gu`lf!9 m foah of smu hsbakm`tf ,:?! hssak f hbf`+smclh m pmomk. Fs jmjás h`tms om `hs+bmrmk m hs suhs kâms drèvaohs prmbashkkmskf of phtrf`f R. Gfâf Jhptasth phrhomem`omr h oad`aohom omssms smrms pm+qum`a`fs m om suhs kâms# qum á f eu`oh+
km`tf ofs oarmatfs om hkjfs m om `òstfofs.
Msthvh mu bfk msths rmmxýms kftavh+of pfr uk bfcmdh qum km pmoau phrh eh+chr sfjrm mstm sh`tf pfpuchr `h suh emsth#
quh`of km surdau `f bfkputhofr uk ca+vra`lf a`mspmrhof f`+ca`m# mk ouhs cë`+duhs a`tatuchof –Zatf oh Jç`äâf om ukhbrah`äh `f vm`trm khtmr`f‛. Á pujcabh+of pmcfs jaspfs bhtòcabfs hkmrabh`fs mhprfvhof pmch Bfkassâf of Buctf Oava+`f. H jç`äâf pfom smr bmcmjrhoh `h kas+sh fu efrh oh kassh mk bmcmjrhäâf oh h+chvrh. Jç`äâf kuatf jf`ath m blmah omsm`taof. ^mom prftmäâf phrh f jmjá `hs+baturf# bf`efrtf phrh h kâm# rmspf`shja+caohom phrh f pha# hkfr phrh tfoh h eh+këcah m omcaohom hfs m`sa`hkm`tfs of
Mvh`dmclf. ]khs ohs cmaturhs sudmraohs
mk prakmarf cudhr sâf prmbashkm`tm hoh vasathäâf m m`bf`trf ohs ouhs kâmdrèvaohs# @fssh Rm`lfrh of jmjá Gmsusm Rh`th Ashjmc of sh`tf pfpuchr R. GfâfJhptasth. ^fom smr bmcmjrhoh phrh ukhfu drupfs om kâms. M h prfpòsatf# fs cmatfrms gè mstm h`f cmrhk h vaoh om hcduksh`tf bh`f`azhof# pfpuchr fu futrf6. qum `âf sm pfom msqumbmr qum fs sh`tfsâf kmstrms –mxpcabhofrms‛ oh vaoh om Gm
sus. Kuatf prètabfs. H cmaturh oh vaoh omuk sh`tf om vmz mk quh`of prmphrh+`fphrh f mxhkm oh vaoh m h prètabh oh eá mk
Gmsus Brastf.
O Z
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 14/16
82 om gu`lf om :>8? •
_mcmef`ms
:?? <2: :55 Bhrtòraf oh phròquah om Cmarah:?? <2: 45> Rmka èraf Oafbmsh f:?? <?= >2> Dhja mtm Mpasbfphc:?? <:2 51: Bèraths Oafbmsh h om Cmarah:?? 8>2 <85 Bm`trf om Efrkhäâf m Bucturh:?? <2: =21 Blh`bmchrah ,Bêkhrh Mbcmsaèstabh!:?? <2: 45> Bfkassâf om Jm`s Bucturhas:?? <2: 225 Drèbh om Cmarah:?? <:= 85< Rmrvaäf Oafbmsh f om Bhtmqumsm:?? <2: 45> _raju`hc Mbcmsaèstabf
futrfs bf`thbtfs# vmr www.cmarah+ehtakh.pt
Lfrèraf oh Kasshs Ofka`abhas^hròquah om Cmarah
Rèjhofs81l>> Rá81l2> Erh basbh fs
Ofka`dfs><l2> Mspëratf Rh`tf>1l>> Erh basbh fs>1l?= ^hucf UA8>l>> R. Erh basbf
8>l>> R. Zfkâf8>l2> Erh basbh fs88l>> Rh`tf Hdfsta`lf88l2> Rá m Rmka`èraf8<l2> Rá81l2> Erh basbh fs:8l2> @ª Rr.ª M bhr`häâf
HDM@OH CAUZF oh smkh`h
_raju`hc Guoabahc om Furák
8· GuëzF
^rhäh oF ku abë^aF + :?1>+?11 Furák
_mcme7 :?1=?>:>> ehx7 :?1>1> a >1 khac7 Furmk._bN_raju`has.Frd.^_
h`×`baF,:ª ^ujcabhäâF • ^rmsm`tm Cmarah+Eètakh# `.· ?822# 82.>5.:>82!
^rfbmssf7 888?&8:.>_JU@FOavòrbaf Rmk Bf`sm`takm`tf of Futrf Bÿ`gudmHutfr7 Jru`f Uamarh OmcdhofZáu7 H`hjmch om Fcavmarh ^morfsh Cfurm`äf@fs hutfs hbakh aom`tabhofs# bfrrmk áoatfs om 2> oahs# bf`thofs oh ohth oh sm+
du`oh m ÷ctakh pujcabhäâf of h`÷`baf# bath`of f,h! rá,u! H`hjmch om Fcavmarh ^morfshCfurm`äf# bfk ÷ctakh rmsaoç`bah bf`lmbaoh mk ofkabacaf7 Zuh oh Ef`tm# @f =1# Hzhju+blf# :?8>+>:8 Cma ah# phrh `f prhzf om 2> oahs# ombfrraof qum smgh f ofs áoatfs# bf`+tmsthr# qumrm`of# h prmsm`tm hbäâf# bfk h a`oabhäâf om qum h ehcth om bf`tmsthäâf`âf akpfrth h bf`ssâf ofs ehbtfs hrtabuchofs pmcf,s! hutfr,ms! m qum mk sujstê +bah f pmoaof bf`sastm# tuof bfkf kmclfr bf`sth of oupcabhof oh pmtaäâf a`abahc qum smm`bf`trh msth Rmbrmthrah# î oaspfsaäâf of bath`of.
Eabh hovmrtaof om qum á fjradhtòrah h bf`statuaäâf om kh`ohtèraf guoabahc.Furák# 88+>2+:>82@&Zmemrç`bah7 :?4:28?F Guaz om Oarmatf# Or,h!. ^htrëbah Dfkms Jmr`hrofF Fbahc om Gustaäh# Hurfrh Cmf`fr Ehra`lh
Rò f pfjr
sm ehz pâ
om Bhrcfs Khrah H`tu`
*H cmaturh om uk jfk cavrf á uk oaè
df a`bmssh`tm7 f cavrf ehch m h h ckh rmspfom.* ,H`orá Khurfas!
Á om uk cavrf bhphz om fs ehzmr tmr moaècfdf qum lfgm msbrmvf7 Rò f ^fjrm sm ehz ^âf. M`trmbzh`of gmguk# a`tmrafraohom m bfkphaxâf# om Bhrcfs KhH`tu`ms# kf`dm pfrtuduçs# `f Kfstmarf Bastmrbam`sm Rh`th Khrah om Rfjrhof# `h Dhcazh# pujcabhof pmchs ^hca`hs.
^fom bhushr surprmsh trhzmr f tmkh of gmguk phrh hcáoh ápfbh h qum lhjatuhckm`tm sm f hssfbah7 h Xuhrmsk+ –F gmguk# `f smu sm`taof khas hkpcf# khas of qum uprètabh pf`tuhc bf``hoh h omtmrka`hofs oahs ‒ ha`oh qmsth smgh akpfrth`tm bfkf khrbh qum hssa`hch uk bhk
`lf +# bf`statua+sm `uk bf`vatm h buctavhr uk mstacf om vasòjraf.‛ ‒ khs efa mstm uk ofs hspmtfs qum htrhau h ka`htm`äâf.
Râf k÷ctapchs hs rmemrç`bahs jëjcabhs om Gmsus î kmbfk fs hkadfs m msth aomah om qum h erhtmr`aohom sm m`sî kmsh á rmcmvh`tm. Khs f bhka`lf hpf`th phrh phrtar kmsh# hjrar tfohs hs pfrths# omaxhr+sm bf`ouzar pmcf MspërRh`tf m omsbfjrar f omsmgf prfeu`of qum mk bhoh uk ljath. M rmefräh h aomah om qum sò ehzm`of+sm gmguk om sa ppraf ,tfr`h`of+sm pfjrm!# sm pfom smr pâf phrh fs futrpfrqum sò hssak sm mstè cajmrtf phrh phrtaclhr. H sfjramoh
om vaoh qum sm prfpým rfkpm bfk f msqumkh om vaoh bf
sukasth oh `fssh sfbamohom m# bfkmäh`of bfk mssm –rfpakm`tf‛# f gmguk tmk f smu cudhr.
Khs `hoh astf rmtarh# `hturhckm`tm# sm`taof hf gmgtrhoabaf`hc# h`tms f rmbm`trh `h vaoh om bhoh brastâf.
Á uk cavrf qum sm hbfkph`lh bfk ehbacaohom# `âf smof om tfof cadmarf. Á uk cavrf qum `fs ehch m h qum hckh rm
pf`om# pmrkata`of f thc oaècfdf. ]kh cmaturh h pÿr `h casKhrah Lmcm`h Mspëratf Rh`
^mrmdra`häâf A`tmr`hbaf`hc H`avmrsèrah h
Eètakh
Kfvakm`tf ofs Bursfs om Brasth`ohom7 Zm+
u`aâf om @÷bcmf Bm`trf ,Bfakjrh!
Hbäâf Bhtòcabh Zurhc7 Zmu`aâf om omcmdhofs
î Hssmkjcmah @hbaf`hc H`avmrsèraf `hthcëbaf m om from`häâf mpas+
bfphc om O. RmrhkCmdaâf om Khrah7 Zmu`aâf Bfkatauk
Bursfs om Brasth`ohom7 M`bmrrhkm`tf oh Ms+
bfch KBB
Uaoh Hsbm`om`tm7 Zmu`aâf om Drupf ,Cmarah!
Zmu`aâf oh Mquaph Rmrvaäf hstfrhc Cat÷rdabh
m K÷sabh Rhbrh ,R^CKR!
Zmu`aâf oh mquaph shbmrofthc oh vadhrhrah
oh Jhthclh
Zmu`aâf oh mquaph shbmrofthc oh vadhrhrah
om Kf`tm Zmhc
Zmu`aâf oh mquaph shbmrofthc oh vadhrhrah om Kf`tmZmhc
Zmu`aâf oh mquaph shbmrofthc oh vadhrhrah om ^frtf
om Kòs
B@M + HBHBA^
B^K + M`bf`trf om @favfs ,Rá!
Zmu`aâf ofs Zmspf`sèvmas Oafbmsh`fs oh
Bhtmqumsm ,R@MB!
B@M + HBHBA^
B^K + M`bf`trf om @favfs ,Jhgfubh!
CK + ^hssmaf&^mrmdra`häâf h uk sh`tuèraf
khrah`f
B@M + HBHBA^
BUR + M`bmrrhkm`tf om hbtavaohoms
M`bmrrhkm`tf om htavaohoms ,^E# M@R# B^K!
82qua`th
gu`lf
8?smxth
gu`lf
85ofka`df
gu`lf
84smdu`oh
gu`lf
8<tmräh
gu`lf
81quhrth
gu`lf
:>qua`th
gu`lf
:8smxth
gu`lf
::sèjhof
gu`lf
:2ofka`df
gu`lf
E. Bfsth ^mrmarhKáoab Mpmbaa Omä o jb m omm
Zuh Gfâf om Omus# :=+ 8· Ot. + CMAZAH
Bf`sucths BfK Lfrh KhrBhOh
:ª# ?ª m =ª7 88l+82l m 8=l+81l# 2ª7 8>l+82l m 8=l+81l
_mc. :?? <2:?>5
^]J
^]J 8&<
bhr_òraF `F_hrahc om cmarah h bhrdF oF `F_èraF ^morF _hvhrms
Bmrtabf# phrh `s om pujcabhäâf# qum mstm Bhrtòraf m `f Cavrf om @fths phrh Ms +braturhs Oavmrshs `· :2: ‒ H om efclhs tra`th m smtm h efclhs tra`th m fatf vmrsf sm m` +bf`trh mxhrhoh ukh msbraturh om Gustabhäâf @fthrahc f oah t rçs om Gu`lf om :>82.
Futfrdhoh pfr7 Khrah Hcjmrta`h om Gmsus Duaclmrka`f# sfctmarh# khafr# `hturhc omRh`th Bhthra`h oh Rmrrh# Cmarah# rmsaom`tm `h Zuh @ª Rª oh Duah `· :15# Uhcm Hctf# Ka`+om# Hcbh`m`h# `ae 8?: :2= <1> `h quhc oassm of`h m cmdëtakh pfssuaofrh ofs smdua` +tms akòvmas7
uk7 práoaf r÷stabf# bfkpfstf pfr tmrrm`f om m`bfsth m khtf bfk fcavmarhs# bfk hèrmh om smas kac trmzm`tfs m fatm`th kmtrfs quhorhofs# h bf`erf`thr of frtm bfk Cuësoh Racvh Zajmarf# suc Khxaka`f ofs Rh`tfs# hsbm`tm Gfsá mrmarh Khrta`lf m pfm`tm bh+ka`lf# satf mk Futmarf of Kfa`lf# `h ermdumsah om Rh`th Bhthra`h oh Rmrrh of bf` +bmclf om Cmarah# `âf omsbratf `h Bf`smrvhtòrah of Zmdastf ^rmoahc omstm bf`bmclf# a`s+bratf `h khtraz sfj f hrtadf :?8# bfk f vhcfr phtrakf`ahc trajutèraf om =2#>=₣# aduhchf htrajuëof9
ofas7 práoaf r÷stabf# bfkpfstf pfr tmrrh om bucturh bfk fcavmarhs# bfk h èrmh omkac m quhtrfbm`tfs kmtrfs quhorhofs# h bf`erf`thr of `frtm bfk bhka`lf# suc H`tò+`af Duaclmrka`f# `hsbm`tm Gfsá ofs Rh`tfs Racvh m pfm`tm H`tò`af Eacapm oh Racvh# satfmk Chdfa`lh fu Futmarf Hctf# h ermdumsah om Rh`th Bhthra`h oh Rmrrh of bf`bmclf omCmarah# âf omsbratf h Bf`smrvhtòrah of Zmdastf rmoahc omstm bf`bmclf# a`sbratf h kh+traz sfj f hrtadf ??:4# bfk f vhcfr phtrakf`ahc trajutèraf om ::>#58₣# aduhc hf htrajuëof9
Xum fs práoafs vamrhk h pfssm oh rmprmsm`thoh pfr phrtaclh kmrhkm`tm vmrjhc pfrvfcth om kac `fvmbm`tfs m smtm`th m quhtrf pfr òjatf ofs phas Gfsá ofs Rh`tfs Duaclmr+ka`f m M`bhr`häâf om Gmsus.
Xum# hssak# mch vmk pfssua`of mssms práoafs bfkf smus# lè khas om va`tm h`fs#bfkf prfpramtèrah m `h bf`vabäâf om f smr# buctavh`of+fs m bfclm`of fs smus erutfs#bukpra`of hs fjradhäýms sbhas h mcms rmchtavhs# pfssm qum vmk mxmrbm`of a`a`tmrrupth
m fstm`savhkm`tm# bfk bf`lmbakm`tf om tfoh h dm`tm m smk fpfsaäâf om qumk qumrqum smgh# hssak om kfof phbëbf# bf`të`uf# p÷jcabf m om jfh eá# pmcf qum hoquarau pfrusubhpaâf h prfpramohom sfjrm fs a`oabhofs akòvmas.
Xum ohoh h efrkh om hquasaäâf frada`èrah âf tmk ofbukm`tfs qum h bfkprfvmk.Xum phrh suprar thc tëtucf vmk# mk `fkm oh rmprmsm`thoh# pmch prmsm`tm msbraturh
prmsthr msths ombchrhäýms om gustabhäâf bfk f k om fjtmr `f rmdastf prmoahc h pra+kmarh a`sbraäâf om hquasaäâf ofs rmemraofs práoafs.
Uha bf`efrkm hf frada`hc h phrtm eftfbfpahoh âf lhvm`of h phrtm fkataoh hohqum hkpcam rmstra`gh# kfoaqum fu bf`oabaf`m h phrtm eftfbfpahoh.
Khrah Cmf`fr om Hckmaoh mrmarh# eu`baf`èrah of Bhrtòraf mk mpëdrhem# f usf ombfkpmtç`bah bugh hutfrazhäâf pmcf @ftèraf rmspmbtavf efa pujcabhof fs tmrkfs oh Cmasfj f ÷kmrf 8:<&2 h 28&>8&:>88# mk Cmarah# trçs Gu`lf om ofas kac m trmzm.
H Eu`baf`èrah ,hssa`hturh acmdëvmc!^rmsm`tm Cmarah+Eètakh# `.· ?822# 82.>5.:>82
_raju`hc Guoabahc om cmarah
?¾ GuëzF bëvmc
chrdF sh`_h`h# 8? + :?>>+::2 cmarah
_mcme. :??<?=22>&2=: • ehx7 :??<?<<11 • khac7 cmarah._bN_raju`has.Frd.^_
h`×`baF,8ª ^ujcabhäâF • ^rmsm`tm Cmarah+Eètakh# `.· ?822# 82.>5.:>82!
^rfbmssf7 28>&8:.?_JCZH Häâf om ^rfbmssf RukèrafHutfr7 Hkárabf Cfpms om Ehrah m futrf,s! ...Záu7 H`h ^huch Jhdhrrâf Lm`raqums m futrf,s! ...@&Zmemrç`bah7 <8>1:>1Ohth7 :>+>=+:>82@fs hutfs hbakh aom`tabhofs# bfrrmk áoatfs om 2> oahs# bf`thofs oh ohth oh smdu`+
oh m ÷ctakh pujcabhäâf of h`÷`baf# bath`of7Záu7 ^hucf Gfsá oh Racvh ^a`lmarf# clf om Gfsá Zhkfs ^a`lmarf m om Khrah Mkëcah oh
Racvh Bhrrmarh ^a`lmarf# msthof bavac7 Rfctmarf ,rmdakm7 Rfctmarf!# @AE + :?855:?=8# ofkabë+caf7 Xua`th oh Hcähoh# Ct. ?: ‒ A· Msq·.# Khrrhzms# :?8=+=51 Cmarah
bfk ÷ctakh rmsaoç`bah bf`lmbaoh h kfrhoh a`oabhoh phrh# f prhzf om :> oahs# om+
bfrraof qum smgh f ofs áoatfs# bf`tmsthr# qumrm`of# h häâf# bfk h bfka`häâf om qum hehcth om bf`tmsthäâf akpfrth h bf`ssâf ofs ehbtfs hrtabuchofs pmcfs hutfrms m qum mksujstê`bah f pmoaof bf`sastm mk qum fs ráus smghk bf`om`hofs h phdhr sfcaohrahkm`+tm î hutfrh # h akpfrtê`bah tfthc om ₣ 8=.:1< ,qua`zm kac ouzm`tfs m `fvm`th m fatf mu +rfs!# hbrmsbaoh om gurfs î thxh cmdhc# h bf`thr oh bathäâf htá a`tmdrhc phdhkm`tf# tuofbfkf kmclfr bf`sth of oupcabhof oh pmtaäâf a`abahc qum sm m`bf`trh `msth Rmbrmthrah# îoaspfsaäâf of bath`of.
F prhzf hbakh a`oabhof suspm`om+sm# f m`th`tf# hs eárahs guoabahas.Eabh hovmrtaof om qum á fjradhtòrah h bf`statuaäâf om kh`ohtèraf guoabahc.H Guaz om OarmatfOr,h!. H`h Cëoah Fcavmarh BhomtmH Fbahc om Gustaäh#Khrdhraoh Kfomr`f
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 15/16
82 om gu`lf om :>82 • 8
Obfj h eh fo`h`of h cth]GRRM RM_È BF@FF@RB
@]FOHX MLC KAFRM^O ^ZOMÂF
@HOX]F F CFUKH]RF
FOX]H]@ RFBEF@AKH @‑MMC
@]HOFX LMC WFMRAOK XM] Á FRRF@ FADHKá
84
8 81
:>
8 : 88
1 2 2 81
:> 8: :> 84 :8
A`tuäý.]h hp`h f `÷kf o > h 1.
Hoabaf`h`of f ÷kf o bhoh ca`lh lf+azf`thc f `÷kf o bhoh ca`lh vtabhc
`bf`thè f `÷kf qu `bf`th `feak o bhoh bfcu`h.
f `÷kfohphbaof
]k cavf áukh bfkph`lah
k eak H catuh `âf á ò uk htf bhtavf# á thkják uk a`tuk`tfeu`ohk`thc phh vav k fbaoho.
@bsathkf o c `h kha oavh babu`tê`bah# oo hbfah kha akpc# bfkf quh`of vhkf hf upkbhof qu+kf hj f päf# fu quh`of tkf o pm`bl akpsffeabaha. H catuh thz f j`eëbaf o `f a`tdh kclf `fku`of qu `f foah.
Bfkbkf pch phchvh9 quh`tf kha ckf# khaf kha a bfè f `fsf vfbhjucèaf. M bf`lb futh phchvh pkat+`f utacazè+ch oh efkh kha hoquhoh bf`fh`t h atuhäâfk qu thkf. Kuath vz# h efkh bfkf oahcfdhkf `fxpshkf vjhck`t `âf pkat qu f futf `t`ohk fqu qukf bfku`abh# pfqu âf uèkf h phchvh bfrth.
F bf`lbak`tf qu hoquaakf bfk h catuh# cvhk+`f ha`ohh o`vfcv futh bhhbtëtabh bfkf á bhf oh bath ofpëatf bëtabf. Hguoh+`f h p`h ecta fj f ku`of# ho`vfcv h `fsh bahtavaoho# ta`h f bájf o`vfcv h`fsh bhphbaoho phh htavaoho qu bsathk o bfkpm`âf bf`b`thäâf.
@k kp á eèbac `bf`th cavf qu `f kftavk h c oefkh hphaxf`hoh# kh h jajcaftbh p÷jcabh âf uk bufpbaff `s hptf. @h uh th`t `bf`thkf pfth phhfutf ku`of# pfqu h catuh `âf phtabh ò hthvá ofcavf# pfokf c thkják gf`ha vath htá fuva latòah.
H bhphbaoho o akhda`h f`lh ehz pht of lukh`f# hcatuh pfo cvh+`f h futf ku`of# kh f kha akpfth`t áqu uk cavf u`bh f oaxh fza`lf# h catuh á ukh bfkph`lahk eak.
Cacah`h Df`ähcv
Rvaäf Oafbh`f oh Bhtqu# `f bhcof Eth oh Eá
H hv tuh bf`ta`uh]kh oh htavaoho kha phtabaphoh `h Eth oh
Eá tv bfkf pfthdf`ath bah`äh gfv` qu gu`thhk hf Rvaäf Oafbh f o Bhtqu k tf`foh hv`tuh –@h pdhoh oh Eá*. _ka`hoh h eth# hhv`tuh bf`ta`uh# hdfh k tf`f oh phtaclh.
F Rvaäf Oafbh`f o Bhtqu pfpý h tf+of f qu phtabaphhk `h Eth oh Eá ukh phtaclhkhsavh o eftfdheah ttku`lf dathof `h–pdhoh‛. H a`t`äâf á kftavh î phtaclh bf`tajuaphh h bahäâf o uk hquavf bfk tfof f khtahabfclaof.
Kha# bhoh dupf á ha`oh oheahof h bf`thbhquc bugh –pdhoh‛ tfux bf`adf. H aoah á pfkv uk khaf bf`lbak`tf `t psfh dupf Oafb bf`ta`uh h kftavh î phtaclh.
Ea`hck`t tâf tfof bf`vaohof h `vah h apsý fpa`aý fj h xpaç`bah vavaoh ` a`t`f eak o kh`h. H a`t`äâf á ehz uhvhcahäâf d`áabh pbj pf`tf h kclfh pphhäâf o htavaoho eutuh akach.
_fof t khtaha ovâf `vahof ph`h.pdhoh.oh.eNdkhac.bfk. | e
]k o`lf phh bfcfafu# qua# kh`oh+`f f o`lf qu eaz
7/22/2019 4133 P3 2013-06-13
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4133-p3-2013-06-13 16/16
Á a`bf`tfr`èvmc qum vavmkfs lfgmtmkpfs om brasm m qum# pmcf km`fs hburtf prhzf# `âf sm vascukjrh f smu k.
F ^hph Erh`basbf# `f phsshof oah 4 om gu`lf# quh`of ehchvh phrh khas om `fvmkac pmssfhs qum rmbmjmu `f Uhtabh+`f# oassm qum –tfof f ku`of mstè h va+vmr uk kfkm`tf om brasm# khs á `mbms+sèraf shjmr cç+ch# pfrqum á# omsom cfdf#ukh brasm of vhcfr ofs smrms lukh`fs‛.
M hbrmsbm`tfu# h mstm prfpòsatf7 –H brasmqum msthkfs h vavmr á h brasm oh pmssfh#qum gè `âf bf`th# sò f oa`lmarf bf`th‛.
Bfkf brastâfs# sfkfs blhkhofs h rm+mtar smrahkm`tm `msths phchvrhs# h sm`tar
f blhkhkm`tf om vavmrkfs mstms kf+km`tfs oaeëbmas `h omcaohom î vfbhäâf
jhtaskhc m h smrkfs trh`skassfrms ohEá. Khs# `âf pfomkfs trh`skatar hqua+cf qum `âf vavmkfs. @âf pfomkfs smr
prfemths# sm `âf bf`erf`thrkfs f `fssfquftaoah`f bfk f Mvh`dmclf. Rò h bf+ku`lâf bfk f ^ha# mk Gmsus Brastf m `hdrhäh of Mspëratf Rh`tf# `fs pfom ak+pucsaf`hr h oaeu`oar h Eá qum prfemssh+kfs. H Eá vavm+sm `f Hkfr# qum sm omvm
trhouzar khas mk fjrhs of qum mk ph+chvrhs. H mxmkpcf ohs prakmarhs bfku+`aohoms brastâs# sfkfs bf`vaohofs î
–u`aâf erhtmr`h# î erhäâf of pâf m îs
frhäýms…‛# thc bfkf cmkfs `f bhpëtu+cf smdu`of of cavrf ofs Htfs ofs Hpòs+tfcfs. _m`lhkfs# pfas# h huoèbah om vavmr
`f `fssf oah h oah fs vhcfrms of Mvh`+dmclf m tç+cfs bfkf bratáraf ohs `fsshsfpäýms. @âf pfomkfs bhr a`oaemrm +
tms hfs qum sfermk hf `fssf chof. Gm+sus Brastf á ef`tm om mspmrh`äh qum om+vmkfs bfku`abhr hfs lfkm`s qum omch
tçk mbmssaohom phrh vavmr.
Bfkmähkfs bfk msth moaäâf ukh
vasath îs phròquahs oh `fssh oafbmsm#
sm`of Cmarah h prakmarh. Xumrmkfs sm`+tar mk bhoh bfku`aohom oh `fssh Adrmgh
phrtabuchr f pucshr oh mxpmraç`bah vavaoh
of Mvh`dmclf m fs erutfs oh häâf of smu
h`÷`baf. _hkják âf puomkfs omaxhr
om msthr `h pmrmdra`häâf ohs brah`ähs h
Eètakh# `fs phsshofs oahs 1 m 8> om gu+
`lf. Mchs sâf f euturf omsth Adrmgh h qum
`fs frduclhkfs om pmrtm`bmr
Bhrcfs Khdhclâms om BhrvhclfoarmtfrNgfr`hcprmsm`tm.pt
moatfrahc
*Hpfstha sfjrm fs drh`oms aomhas# sfjrm hs
bfashs drh`oms. @òs# brastâfs# `âf efkfs
msbfclaofs pmcf Rm`lfr phrh bfasa`lhs
pmqum`hs# aom smkprm khas hcák# rukf îs bfashs
drh`oms. Gfvm`s# gfdha h vaoh pfr drh`oms aomhas(
^hph Erh`basbf
OAFBMRM OM CMAZAH+EÈ_AKH | Dhja`mtm of Jaspf Oafbmsh`f
@fkmhäýms mk gu`lf om :>82
F Jaspf om Cmarah+Eètakh# Rm`lfr O.
H`tò`af Khrtf# tfr`h p÷jcabhs hs smdua`+
tms fkmhäýms7
F ^. Or. Gfsá Hudustf ^mrmarh Zf+
oradums á `fkmhof Zmatfr of Rmka`èraf
Oafbmsh`f om Cmarah m Oarmtfr of Bm`trf
^hstfrhc Oafbmsh`f. Kh`ták hs u`äýmsom Oarmtfr of Omphrthkm`tf om ^hstfrhc
Ehkacahr# Oarmtfr of Rmrvaäf om ^hstfrhc oh
Rh÷om m Hssastm`tm ^hstfrhc oh Msbfch om
Efrkhäâf Rfbahc Zurhc om Cmarah. Omaxh hs
u`äýms om Uadèraf ^hrfquahc om Cmarah m oh
Bruz oh Hrmah.
F Ofutfr Khrbf Oh`amc Bhrrf+
ch Ouhrtm á `fkmhof Oarmtfr of Omphr+
thkm`tf om ^htrakò`af Bucturhc m phssh h
a`tmdrhr f Bf`smclf om Bffrom`häâf ^hs+
tfrhc. F Ofutfr Khrbf Oh`amc Ouhrtm á Oa+
rmtfr of Kusmu of Rh`tuèraf om Eètakh m
rmspf`sèvmc pmch Rmbäâf om Hrtm m ^htra+
kò`af of kmskf Rh`tuèraf. Á cabm`bah+
of mk Lastòrah# ofutfrhof mk Lastòrah oh
Hrtm m kmkjrf oh Hbhomkah ^frtudumshoh Lastòrah.
F Ofutfr ^morf Kadumc Oush+
jhkhlfrf Uhca`lf Dfkms á `fkmhof
Oarmtfr of Bm trf om Efrkhäâf m Bucturh m
phssh h a`tmdrhr f Bf`smclf om Bffrom`h+
äâf ^hstfrhc. F Ofutfr ^morf Dfkms á hs+
smssfr `h ^fstuchäâf Erh`basbf m Ghba`th
Khrtf m ofbm`tm `f A`statutf ^fcatáb`abf om
Cmarah. Á cabm`bahof mk _mfcfdah m Ofutfrh+
of mk Eacfsfeh.
F ^. Or. Kh`umc Lm`raqum Dhkma+
rf om Gmsus á fkmhof Mbò`fkf of Rmka+
`èraf Oafbmsh`f# Oarmtfr of ^rá+Rmka`è+
raf# Oarmtfr of Bm`trf om Hpfaf hf M`sa`f
Rupmrafr m Hssastm`tm Oafbmsh`f of Kf+
vakm`tf Bhtòcabf om Mstuoh`tms. Hbuku+
ch bfk hs u`äýms om Oarmtfr of Rmrvaäf
Oafbmsh`f om ^hstfrhc Guvm`ac m Hssastm`tm
Oafbmsh`f of Kfvakm`tf ofs Bf`vëvafs
Erhtmr`fs. Omaxh f smrvaäf phstfrhc hs bh+ pmch`ahs kacathrms oh Jhsm Hármh om Kf tm
Zmhc m of Zmdakm`tf om Hrtaclhrah om Cmarah
m f smrvaäf om Bhpmcâf of Kfstmarf om Rh`+
th Bchrh# mk Kf`tm Zmhc.
F ^. Asaorf oh ^amohom Hcjmrtf á
`fkmhof ^èrfbf om Hkfr. Hbukuch bfk
h phrfquahcaohom om Zmdumarh om ^f`tms m
bfk hs u`äýms om Hssastm`tm Zmdaf`hc oh
Hssfbahäâf Bhtòcabh om M mrkmarfs m ^rf+
essaf`has om Rh÷om ‒ Oarmäâf Zmdaf`hc om
Cmarah.
F ^. Or. H`orá H`tu`ms Jhtas+
th á `fkmhof ^èrfbf om Hzfah m om Jh+
rfsh. Omaxh hs u`äýms om Oarmtfr of ^rá+
Rmka`èraf m om Mbò`fkf of Rmka`èraf
Oafbmsh`f. Bf`ta`uh bfkf Zmspf`sèvmcohs Bmcmjrhäýms Oafbmsh`hs m Kmstrm om
Bmrakò`ahs oh Oafbmsm.
F ^. Or. Kh`umc Hrka`of ^mrma+
rh Gh`marf á `fkmhof ^èrfbf om @fssh
Rm`lfrh oh ^amohom# mk Furák. Omaxh hs
u`äýms om Zmatfr of Rmka`èraf Oafbmsh+
`f# Oarmtfr of Bm`trf om Efrkhäâf m Buc+
turh m Oarmtfr of Omphrthkm`tf om ^htra+
kò`af Bucturhc.
F Or. Bhrcfs Kh`umc Khdhclâms
om Bhrvhclf fa `fkmhof# pfr kh`ohtf
of Rm`lfr Jaspf om Cmarah+Eètakh# Oarmtfr
of gfr`hc oafbmsh`f –^rmsm`tm Cmarah+Eèta+
kh‛. F Or. Khdhclâms om Bhrvhclf á cabm`+
bahof mk Oarmatf# mxmrbm hovfbhbah m bfch+
jfrh bfk oavmrsfs smrvaäfs m a`statuaäýms
oafbmsh`fs.
F ^. H`tò`af oh ^amohom Jm`tf á
oaspm`shof# h smu pmoaof oh phrfquahcaoh+
om om @fssh Rm`lfrh oh ^amohom# mk Fu+rák# phssh`of î satuhäâf om gujachof. Á
`fkmhof Bhpmcâf of Kfstmarf om Rh`th
Bchrh# mk Kf`tm Zmhc# m bfchjfrhrè phstf+
rhckm`tm `h phròquah om Hkfr.
F ^. Gfhquak Ofka`dums Dhsphr#
htá 81.>=.:>82 Oarmtfr of gfr`hc –H Ufz of
Ofka`df‛# phssh î satuhäâf om gujachof m
bf`ta`uh h bfchjfrhr phstfrhckm`tm `h
phròquah om Kf`tm Zmof`of.
F ^. Kh`umc ^morfsh Kmcquëhoms á
oaspm`shof# h smu pmoaof# oh phrfquahcaoh+
om om Hkfr# phssh`of î satuhäâf om gujach+
of. Bfchjfrhrè phstfrhckm`tm bfkf Uadè+
raf ^hrfquahc `h phròquah oh Jhgfubh.
F ^. Gfrdm Ofka`dums om Fcavma+
rh omaxh h smu pmoaof# h phrfquahcaohom om Hzfah m om Jhrfsh. Zmdrmssh phrh f smrvaäf
oh Bf`drmdhäâf ofs Kassaf`èrafs Bfkjf+
`ah`fs of Bfrhäâf om Gmsus.
Hs tfkhohs om pfssm smrâf `f a`ëbaf
of pròxakf h`f phstfrhc.
Cmarah# 82 om gu`lf om :>82#
Emsth om Rh`tf H`tò`af om Casjfh.
Uëtfr Bfuta`lf#
Blmem om Dhja`mtm of Jaspf Oafbmsh`f
Zmeª7 JO:>82M+>>:
BFK]@ABHOF
^hrh f pròxakf h`f phstfrhc
O. H`tò`af Khrtf h`u`bah `fkmhäýms