2014 zahn phd
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
1/216
Glasgow Theses Service
http://theses.gla.ac.uk/
Zahn, Daniela (2013) The resolution of the clause that is relative?Prosody and plausibility as cues to RC attachment in English: evidence
from structural priming and event related potentials. PhD thesis.
http://theses.gla.ac.uk/5163/
Copyright and moral rights for this thesis are retained by the author
A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or
study, without prior permission or charge
This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first
obtaining permission in writing from the Author
The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any
format or medium without the formal permission of the Author
When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the
author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
2/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
1
!"# %#&'()*+', '- *"# .(/) *"/* +& %#(/*+0#1
2%'&'34 /,3 5(/)&+6+(+*4 /& .)#& *' 78 /**/."9#,* +,
:,;(+&"< :0+3#,.# -%'9 &*%).*)%/( 5%+9+,; /,3 #0#,*=
%#(/*#3 5'*#,*+/(&>
?/,+#(/ @/",A BC.A B>D>
C)69+**#3 +, -)(-+((9#,* '- *"# %#E)+%#9#,*& -'% *"# ?#;%## '- 2"?
F,&*+*)*# '- G#)%'&.+#,.# /,3 2&4."'(';4
8'((#;# '- C.+#,.# /,3 :,;+,##%+,;
H,+0#%&+*4 '- I(/&;'J
KL*" '- ?#.#96#% KLMN
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
3/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
2
!"#$%&'()*(+($,-
F J')(3 (+O# *' */O# *"+& '55'%*),+*4 *' *"/,O / .')5(# '- 5#'5(#>
P+%&*(4A F /9 0#%4 ;%/*#-)( *' ?%> 8"%+&*'5" C."##5#%& -'% "+& .',*+,)#3
&)55'%*A /30+.# /,3 "#(5> !"/,O 4') *' ?%> I)+((/)9# 7')&(#* -'% *"# *+9#
"# &5#,* *' 9/O# B/*(/6 /,3 ::I / (#&& 3/),*+,; #Q5#%+#,.#>
!"/,O& ;'#& *' ?%> C+64((# B'"%A ?%> ?'9+,+. !"'95&',A ?%> C/%/ RS;#(& /,3?%> F&/6#( T%#,#& -'% 6#+,; ;%#/* '--+.# 9/*#& U+, 0/%4+,; .'96+,/*+',&V>
B4 ;%#/*#&* *"/,O 4')A '- .')%A ;'#& *' 94 6'4&> C//9+ -'% ,'* 9+,3+,; 94
/6,.# *'' 9)." = W/+( B+,#.%/-*X
D(6#%*'A J+*"')* 4')% 5/*+#,.#A ('0# /,3 *"# '../&+',/( O+.O +, *"# 6YYY F
.')(3 ,'* "/0# 3',# +*> F /9 -'%#0#% +, 4')% 3#6*>
!"+& *"#&+& +& 3#3+./*#3 *' 94 (/*# 5/%#,*&A H(%+O# @/", ),3 ?%> I),*"#%
@/",> !"/,O 4') -'% +,&*/((+,; +,*' 9# /, #4# -'% 3#*/+(A .)%+'&+*4 /,3 /
&.#5*+. 9+,3>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
4/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
3
!/,0%12- 3("'414,5%$
F 3#.(/%# *"/* *"+& *"#&+& +& 94 'J, J'%O ./%%+#3 ')* ),3#% ,'%9/( *#%9& '-
&)5#%0+&+',>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
5/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
4
!6-,14",
F, &5'O#, (/,;)/;#A 3+--#%#,* *45#& '- (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', /%# ) 64 *"#
5/%% *' /%%+0# /* / .'"#%#,* &4,*/.*+. +,*#%5%#*/*+', '- *"# +,5)*>
F, *"+& *"#&+& F +,0#&*+;/*#3 *J' '- *"# +,-'%9/*+', &')%.#&A ,/9#(4 '0#%*
5%'&'3+. -#/*)%#& /,3 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*&> B'%# &5#.+-+./((4A F J/&
+,*#%#&*#3 +, "'J *"# .)#& +,*#%/.* +, %#&'(0+,; *"# %#(/*+0# .(/)
/**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4>
B)." %#/%." "/& #Q5('%#3 *"# &+,;(# .)#& /,3 9)." +& O,'J /6')* *"#
+,-()#,.# *"/* #/." .)# #Q#%*& +,3#5#,3#,* '- *"# '*"#%> W'J#0#%A *"#
+,*#%/.*+', '- 5%'&'3+. /,3 /,*+. .)#& *' /**/."9#,* "/& *' 3/*#%#.#+0#3 (+**(# /**#,*+',>
!J' #Q5#%+9#,*/( 5/%/3+;9& J#%# ) +, Z #Q5#%+9#,*&A +>#> *"# '--(+,#
9#*"'3 '- &*%).*)%/( 5%+9+,; /,3 *"# ',(+,# 9#*"'3 '- #0#,*=%#(/*#3
5'*#,*+/(&>
!"# 3/*/ -%'9 *"# #Q5#%+9#,*& &);;#&* *"/* *"# .)#& +,*#%/.* +, / .'95(#Q
J/4> !"# %#&)(*& +95(4 *"/* *"# 5%'9+,#,.# '- *"# 3+&5%#-#%%#3 .)#&A *"#
&)%5%+&/( /,3 *"# *45# '- %#0+&+', /&&'.+/*#3 J+*" *"#9 5(/4 / 9/['% %'(#
3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;> F 5%'5' *"%## 5%'.#&&+,; 5%+,.+5(#& *"/* 9+;"* /..'),*
-'% *"# %#&)(*& '6%0#3>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
6/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
5
746'( %8 9%$,($,-
:;:; 7=?@= A
:;B; 7J7DE?N ! C 9>=?@=C D? G=C=!G9< EO !KLD@JD7M G=CE>J7DE? :P B;Q; 7!7DF= 9>!JC= !77!9N>M> !W: 7:\D!F]: 8\DHC: D!!D8WB:G! DBRFIHF!^ _ D R7F:P T]:7]F:` KN K>N>K> 7:\D!F]: 8\DHC: D!!D8WB:G! DG? BT?:\C TP DBRFIHF!^ 7:CT\H!FTG Ka K>N>N> 8WD\\:GI:C FG 7:C:D78W TP !W: 78 D!!D8WB:G! DBRFIHF!^ 7:CT\H!FTG Kb B;R; !KLD@JD7M G=CE>J7DE? N ?=JGESE@D9!> =FD3=?9= Q: K>Z>M> :]:G! 7:\D!:? 2T!:G!FD\C DG? \DGIHDI: 27T8:CCFGI NK K>Z>K> :72C DG? !W: 78 D!!D8WB:G! DBRFIHF!^ NZ K>Z>N> G:H7T8TIGF!F]: BT?:\C TP \DGIHDI: 27T8:CCFGI Nc B;T; 9E?9>JCDE?C RQ
!" $%&$'()$*+,- )$+./0/-/12 3 4+'56+5',- &'()(*1 ,*0 $7$*+8
'$-,+$0 &/+$*+(,-4 RT
Q;:; D?7GE3J97DE? 7E C7GJ97JG!> SGDKD?@ RT Q;B; D?7GE3J97DE? 7E =F=?7UG=>!7=3 SE7=?7D!>C RP Q;R; 9E?9>JCDE? TV
R; SGDKD?@ EO G=>!7DF= 9>!JC= !77!9E7 C7J3M T:
R;:; D?7GE3J97DE? T: R;B; K !7=GD!>C TB Z>K>M> D8THC!F8 DGD\^CFC TP !W: 27FB: C:G!:G8:C dZ Z>K>K> GD!H7D\G:CC 7D!FGIC TP !W: 27FB: C:G!:G8:C dZ Z>K>N> 2\DHCFRF\F!^ 27:=!:C! TP !W: 27FB: C:G!:G8:C dd R;Q; SGDKD?@ SGE9=3JG= TP R;R; G=CSE?C= !??E7!7DE? TI R;T; CJLW=97C TI R;X;G=CJ>7C XV R;P; 3DC9JCCDE? XB
T; K!7=GD!>C XP
T;:; D?7GE3J97DE? XP T;B; D7=KC XP d>K>M> D8THC!F8 ]D\F?D!FTG TP !W: BD!:7FD\ ca d>K>K> DH?F!T7^=2:78:2!HD\ ]D\F?D!FTG TP !W: D8THC!F8 P:D!H7:C TP !W: BD!:7FD\ eM d>K>N> \:fF8T=C:BDG!F8 DGD\^CFC TP !W: BD!:7FD\ eZ d>K>Z> ]D\F?D!FTG TP !W: 2\DHCFRF\F!^ 8TGC!7DFG!C TP !W: BD!:7FD\ ed T;Q; 9E?9>JCDE? PP
X; SGDKD?@ EO G=>!7DF= 9>!JC= !77!9
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
7/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
6
c>K>M> BD!:7FD\C DG? 27T8:?H7: eb c>K>K> 7:C2TGC: DGGT!D!FTG aM c>K>N> CHRg:8!C aM X;Q; G=CJ>7C IV c>N>M> 27FBFGI bL
c>N>K> 8\HC!:7 DGD\^CFC bN c>N>N> CHRg:8! ]D7FDR\:C ba X;R; 3DC9JCCDE? II
P; SGDKD?@ EO G=>!7DF= 9>!JC= !77!9=C :VR P;Q; SGDKD?@ :VR e>N>M> BD!:7FD\C DG? 27T8:?H7: MLZ e>N>K> 7:C2TGC: DGGT!D!FTG MLZ e>N>N> CHRg:8!C MLd P;R; G=CJ>7C :VT e>Z>M> 27FBFGI MLd e>Z>K> 8\HC!:7 DGD\^CFC MLe e>Z>N> CHRg:8! ]D7FDR\:C MMM P;T; 3DC9JCCDE? ::Q P;X; 9E?9>JCDE? ::X
A; SGDKD?@ =YS=GDK=?7C : !?3 B ::A
A;:; D?7GE3J97DE? ::A A;B; G=CJ>7C ::I a>K>M> T]:7D\\ DGD\^CFC MMb a>K>K> 8\HC!:7 M MKK a>K>N> 8\HC!:7 K MKZ a>K>Z> CHRg:8! ]D7FDR\:C MKc A;Q; 3DC9JCCDE? :BA A;R; 9E?9>JCDE? :QA
I; =F=?7 G=>!7=3 SE7=?7D!>C !?3 G=>!7DF= 9>!JC= !77!9C :RP I;Q; 3=CD@? !?3 SGE9=3JG= :RA I;R; CJLW=97C :RI I;T; ==@ G=9EG3D?@ :TV I;X; ==@ 3!7! SG=SGE9=CCD?@ :TV I;P; =GS !?!>MC=C :TB I;A; G=CJ>7C :TR b>a>M> R:WD]FT7D\ 7:CH\!C MdZ b>a>K> :72 7:CH\!C Mdd b>a>N> ?FC8HCCFTG TP !W: T]:7D\\ :72 7:CH\!C PT7 7:8T7?FGIC M DG? K McK b>a>Z :72 :PP:8!C PT7 8\HC!:7C M DG? K Mca I;I; 9E?9>JCDE? :PB
:V; @=?=G!> 3DC9JCCDE? :PQ
OJ7JG= G=C=!G9< !?3 9E?9>J3D?@ G=K!GZC :AT
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
8/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
7
!SS=?3DY : D7=KC !?3 7!G@=7 OG!@K=?7C JC=3 OEG 7E7 C7J3M
:AP
!SS=?3DY B D7=KC !?3 7!G@=7 OG!@K=?7C JC=3 OEG K!D? SGDKD?@
=YS=GDK=?7 :[B :AI
!SS=?3DY Q LDEC=KD =>=97GE3=C >!MEJ7 :IA
!SS=?3DY R CJKK!GM EO !J@JG\ZM ]BVVT^ :II
G=O=G=?9=C BVB
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
9/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
8
:;:; 70( "04''($*(
T,# '- *"# 6#&* O,'J, #Q/95(#& ', *"# 5+*-/((& '- 5),.*)/*+', +& *"#-'(('J+,; */O#, -%'9 !%)&& UKLLNV<
:; ; D96+;)+*4 +& .%#/*#36#./) (/,;)/;# +& 9)(*+3+9#,&+',/(> F* +& .'99',(4 /&&)9#3 *"/* *' 6#
/6(# *' .'95%#"#,3 J"/* +& 6#+,; .'99),+./*#3 / .'95%#"#,3#% 9)&*
+,*#;%/*# +,-'%9/*+', -%'9 6/&+./((4 K &')%.#&< &4,*/Q /,3 /,*+.&>
C4,*/Q %#-#%& *' *"# 6)+(3+,; 6('.O / (/,;)/;# +& 9/3# )5 '- &)." /& ,'),&A
0#%6& #*.> /,3 "'J *"#4 /%# 5)* *';#*"#%> C#9/,*+.& %#-#%& *' *"# 9#/,+,; '-
J'%3& /,3 "'J *"#4 /%# .'96+,#3>
W'J#0#%A /& *"# #Q/95(# /6'0# &"'J& .(#/%(4A *"#%# +& /* (#/&* ',# '*"#%&')%.# '- (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', *"/* ,##3& *' 6# .',&+3#%#3> D& 9#,*+',#3A /
3+--#%#,* 5),.*)/*+', 5/**#%, ."/,;#& *"# 9#/,+,; '- *"# &*%+,; '- J'%3&
/6'0#> 8'99/&A -)(( &*'5& /,3 E)#&*+', 9/%O& U#*.>V ;+0# )& /, +,3+./*+', '-
"'J *"# &*%+,; '- J'%3& &"')(3 6# ;%')5#3 *';#*"#% *' ),3#%&*/,3 +*&
9#/,+,;>
P'% #Q/95(#A *"# /96+;)+*4 /%+& /* *"# 0#%6 0(.$> T, *"# ',# "/,3A 0(.$
.')(3 6# +,*#%5%#*#3 /& *"# *%/,&+*+0# (+O# UMVA +>#> +* ,##3& *' 6# -'(('J#3 64 /3+%#.* '6[#.* U T, *"# '*"#% "/,3A *"# 0#%6 0(.$ .')(3
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
10/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
9
6# +,*#%5%#*#3 /& *"# +,*%/,&+*+0# (+O# UKV U+>#> !")&A *"# 5%#,.# '% /6,.# '- / .'99/ ;)+3#& *"#
+,*#%5%#*/*+',A +>#> *"# +,*#;%/*+', '- &4,*/.*+. /,3 /,*+. +,-'%9/*+', /*
*"+& 5'+,*>F,*#%#&*+,;(4A 5),.*)/*+', +& /.*)/((4 *"# ;%/5"+. %#5%#,*/*+', '- J"/* +&
./((#3 +,*',/*+', '% 5%'&'34> 2%'&'34 +& / -#/*)%# '- &5'O#, (/,;)/;#> F*
3#&.%+6#& *"# 5/**#%, '- 5/)& /,3 *"# ."/,;#& +, 5+*." '0#% *"# .')% '- /
,*#,.# '% / ,)96#% '- ,*#,.#& /& +, *"# #Q/95(# /6'0#> !")&A / (+&*#,#%
9)&* +,*#;%/*# *"# *"%## &')%.#& '- (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', *' 9/O# , '-
J"/* +& 6#+,; &/+3>
W'J *"+& +,*#;%/*+', J'%O&A +>#> "'J ")9/,& 5%'.#&& *"# 5%'&'3+.A /,*+./,3 &4,*/.*+. .'95',#,*& '- (/,;)/;#A +& / 9/**#% '- 9)." 3#6/*#> C+,.#
/96+;)+*+#& /%# /6),3/,* +, (/,;)/;# *"#4 5%#,* /, #Q.#((#,* *#&*+,;
;%'),3 *' &*)34 *"# .',*%+6)*+', '- 3+--#%#,* (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', &')%.#&
&)." /& 5(/)&+6+(+*4 /,3 5%'&'34 *' *"# %#&'()*+', '- &/+3 /96+;)+*+#& +, /
.',*%'((#3 J/4>
:;B; 70(-5- %_(1_5(&
!"# E)#&*+', 94 2"? %#/%." J/& /33%#&&+,;A J/&< W'J 3' 5%'&'3+. /,3
5(/)&+6+(+*4 +,-'%9/*+', +,*#%/.* *' %#&'(0# *"# *#95'%/%4 &4,*/.*+.
/96+;)+*4 5%#,* +, %#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."9#,*1
!' /,&J#% *"+& E)#&*+',A F +,0#&*+;/*#3 %#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."9#,* -%'9 *J'
5'+,*& '- 0+#JA ,/9#(4 -%'9 / 5&4."'(+,;)+&*+. /,3 / ,#)%'.';,+*+0# ',#>
P+%&*(4A +, 904`,(1 B F J+(( ;+0# / ;#,#%/( +,*%'3).*+', *' *"# -+#(3 '-
/96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',> F 6%+#-(4 %#0+#J 3+--#%#,* 5&4."'(+,;)+&*+. /55%'/."#&
*' /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', 6#-'%# *)%,+,; *' ."/((#,;#& *"# /55%'/."#& -/.#>
R/ ', *"+& /,/(4&+&A F J+(( 9'*+0/*# *"# ."'+.# '- /96+;)+*4 ),3#%
.',&+3#%/*+', +, *"+& *"#&+&A +>#> *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) U78V /**/."9#,*
/96+;)+*4> F J+(( *"#, *)%, *' 5&4."'(+,;)+&*+. 9'3#(& '- 78 /96+;)+*4
%#&'()*+',> C)6E)#,*(4A /, +,*%'3).*+', +,*' ,#)%'.';,+*+0# 9'3#(& '-
(/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,; +& ;+0#, /,3 F J+(( &)99/%+ #(#.*%'5"4&+'(';+./(
-+,3+,;& ', (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,; +, ;#,#%/( /,3 78 /**/."9#,* &5#.+-+./((4>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
11/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
10
F, 904`,(1 Q F J+(( +,*%'3).# /,3 #0/()/*# *"# %#/%." 9#*"'3'(';4 )
+, *"# 5%#,* #Q5#%+9#,*&> !"# 9#*"'3& 3+&.)& /%# &*%).*)%/( 5%+9+,;
/,3 #0#,*=%#(/*#3 5'*#,*+/(& U:72&V>
904`,(1 R .'95%+& /, #Q5('%/*'%4 5+('* &*)34 *"/* )& *"# 5%+9+,;5/%/3+;9 -'% *"# -+%&* *+9#> 2%'&'3+. /,3 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .)#& *' 78 /**/."9#,*
J#%# ) +, / .%'& 3#&+;, *' +,0#&*+;/*# *"#+% +,*#%/.*+',> !"# /+9 '- *"#
5+('* &*)34 J/& *' ;#* / -+%&* +,3+./*+', '- J"/* *"# +,*#%/.*+', '- 5%'&'34
/,3 5(/)&+6+(+*4 +, 78 /**/."9#,* 9+;"* (''O (+O# /,3 *' ;#,#%/*# 9'%#
/..)%/*# 5%#3+.*+',& -'% -)%*"#% #Q5#%+9#,*&>
904`,(1 T ;+0#& / 3#*/+( '0#%0+#J '- *"# 9/*#%+/(& ) +, *"# 9/+,
#Q5#%+9#,*& '- *"+& *"#&+&> F J+(( 5%#,* *"# %#&)(*& '- *"# /.')&*+.A /,3/)3+*'%4=5#%.#5*)/( 0/(+3/*+', '- *"# 5%'&'3+. 9/,+5)(/*+',A /& J#(( /& *"#
/,/(4&+& /,3 0/(+3/*+', '- *"# 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& #95('4#3 +, *"# +*#9&>
F, 904`,(1 X *"# 5%+9+,; 5/%/3+;9 +& ) *' +,0#&*+;/*# *"# +,*#%/.*+', '-
5%'&'34 /,3 5(/)&+6+(+*4 +, 9'%# 3#*/+(> D33+*+',/( &)6[#.*=&5#.+-+. 0/%+/6(#&
J#%# %#.'%3#3 *' #0/()/*# 5'&&+6(# +,3+0+3)/( 3+--#%#,.#& *"/* 9+;"* 5(/4 /
%'(# 3)%+,; *"# %#&'()*+', '- 78 /**/."9#,*> !"# 0/%+/6(#& +,.()3#3
/.')&*+. 3+&.%+9+,/*+', /6+(+*4 /,3 (+&*#,+,; 9#9'%4 &5/,> !"# /,/(4&+& '-
*"# 9/+, 5%+9+,; #Q5#%+9#,* M %#*)%,#3 &'9# ),#Q5#.*#3 %#&)(*&A ,/9#(4
*J' .()&*#%& '- 5/%*+.+5/,*& *"/* 3+&5(/4#3 '55'&+,; /**/."9#,* 6#"/0+')%>
!"#%#-'%#A / .',3 5%+9+,; #Q5#%+9#,* J/& %), *"/* J/& / 3+%#.*
%#5(+./*+', '- *"# -+%&* 9/+, 5%+9+,; #Q5#%+9#,*> !"+& +& 3#*/+(#3 5$ 904`,(1
P> C+,.# 6'*" 9/+, 5%+9+,; #Q5#%+9#,*& %#0#/(#3 0#%4 &+9+(/% %#&)(*& +* J/&
3#.+3#3 *' .'96+,# *"# 3/*/ '- *"# #Q5#%+9#,*&> 904`,(1 A &)99/%+&
*"# .'96+,#3 /,/(4&+& '- 9/+, 5%+9+,; :Q5#%+9#,* M /,3 K>
F, 904`,(1 I *"# +,*#%/.*+', '- 5%'&'34 /,3 5(/)&+6+(+*4 J/& +,0#&*+;/*#3
)&+,; #(#.*%'5"4&+'(';+./( 9#/&)%# '- #0#,*=%#(/*#3 5'*#,*+/(&>
P+,/((4A 904`,(1 :V .',.()3#& J+*" / &)99/%4 '- *"# -+,3+,;&A -+,/(
%#9/%O&A /,3 -)*)%# 3+%#.*+',&>
2(#/ ,'*# *"/* /(( ,*#,.# #Q/95(#&A -+;)%#& /,3 */6(#& /%# ,)96#%#3
J+*" #/." &+,;(# ."/5*#%>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
12/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
11
B; D$,1%)/",5%$
B;:; !+65*/5,a 1(-%'/,5%$N ! -0%1, %_(1_5(&
F, 5&4."'(+,;)+&*+.&A 9)." '- *"# %#/%." 6#+,; 3',# %#(+#& ', *"#
%#&'()*+', '- &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*+#& U]/, I'95#( i 2+.O#%+,;A KLLcV> D
,*#,.# +& &4,*/.*+./((4 /96+;)')& J"#, +* +& ),.(#/% J"/* *"# ;%/99/*+./(
&*%).*)%# '- *"# J"'(# ,*#,.# '% 5/%* '- *"/* ,*#,.# +&> !"# &4,*/.*+.
/96+;)+*4 ./, 6# ('./(A +>#> /--#.* *"# +,*#%5%#*/*+', '- / 5/%* '- / ,*#,.# '%
;('6/(A +>#> /--#.* *"# +,*#%5%#*/*+', '- *"# J"'(# ,*#,.#>
8',&+3#% / ,*#,.# (+O# M>
:; ;> .50 @#6() 0C(6,)0% .50 01,%0)40V>
D(*#%,/*+0#(4A *"# 0#%6 0C(6,)0% .')(3 6# +,*#%5%#*#3 /& 5/&* 5/%*+.+5(# /,3
/& 5/%* '- / U%#3).#3V %#(/*+0# .(/)A +>#> .50 @#6() .5(. @($ 0C(6,)0%D >
W#,.#A *"# )5.'9+,; &4,*/.*+. .'95',#,* .')(3 6# /, /30#%6 '% /
5%#5'&+*+',/( 5"%/ U#>;> .50 @#6() E.5(. @($F 0C(6,)0% "0B+*("*& G (. .50
5#$=,.(* V> F* /(&' +95(+#& *"/* *"# 9/+, 0#%6 '- *"# ,*#,.# +& &*+(( *' 6#
#Q5#.*#3>
B'&* %#/3#%& J+(( #Q5#%+#,.# 3+--+.)(*4 ',.# *"#4 #,.'),*#% *"#
5%#5'&+*+',/( 5"%/ -& .50 %#4.#" +, UMV> !"+& 5"%/ &4,*/.*+./((4
3+&/96+;)/*#& J"#*"#% *"# 0#%6 0C(6,)0% +& *' 6# /,/(4 /& / 9/+, .(/)
0#%6 '% /& 5/%* '- *"# %#3).#3 %#(/*+0# .(/)> 7#/3#%& +,+*+/((4 *#,3 *' /3'5*
*"# 9/+, .(/) +,*#%5%#*/*+', /,3 *"#, "/0# *' %#=/,/(4 J"#, *"#4
#,.'),*#% *"# 5%#5'&+*+',/( 5"%/ -& .50 %#4.#" *' /%%+0# /* *"# .'%%#.*
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
13/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
12
+,*#%5%#*/*+', UP#%%#+%/ i 8(+-*',A Mbacj 7/4,#%A 8/%(&',A i P%/k+#%A MbaNV>
!"# -/.* *"/* %#/3#%& +,+*+/((4 *#,3 *' /3'5* *"# 9/+, .(/) %#/3+,; &);;#&*&
*"/* *"#%# +& / 5%#-#%#,.# -'% 5%'.#&&+,; /, /96+;)+*4> C' *"# E)#&*+', ,##3&
*' 6# /,&J#%#3 J"/* ;)+3#& *"+& 5%#-#%#,.#>!"#%# +& J+3#&5%#/3 /;%##9#,* *"/* /* /,4 ;+0#, J'%3 +, / ,*#,.# &)." /&
UMV (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& +,.'%5'%/*#3 +,*' *"# .)%%#,* +,*#%5%#*/*+', '- /
,*#,.# lJ'%3=64=J'%3mA +>#> +,.%#9#,*/((4> W'J#0#%A *"#%# +& 9)." 3#6/*#
/6')* *"# 9/,,#% +, J"+." *"# &*#5& /%# */O#,> F>#> +& &4,*/.*+. +,-'%9/*+',
'- *"# J'%3 .)%%#,*(4 6#+,; 5%'.#& /,/(4 -+%&* /,3 '*"#% +,-'%9/*+',
&)." /& 5(/)&+6+(+*4 /,3 U5'&&+6(4 5%'&'34V 5%'.#& (/*#%1 T%A +& /((
(+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', /0/+(/6(# +99#3+/*#(417#/3#%& *#,3 *' /3'5* ',# &4,*/.*+. +,*#%5%#*/*+', -+%&*A (+O# *"# 9/+, .(/)
+,*#%5%#*/*+', +, UMV> !"+& J')(3 /%;)# -'% / $0",(* 9/,,#% '- 5%'.#&&+,;>
!"# -+%&* &*#5 +& */O#, 64 .'99+**+,; *' / &4,*/.*+. 9/+, .(/) /,/(4&+&> G'
-)%*"#% (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& */O#, +,*' /..'),* /* *"+& 5'+,*> !"# .',3
&*#5 +& */O#, J"#, *"# +,+*+/( /,/(4&+& *)%,& ')* *' 6# J%',; 6#./) *"#
&)6E)#,* (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& +,.'95/*+6(# J+*" *"# +,+*+/( /,/(4&+&>
!")&A %#/,/(4&+& #,&)#&> B'3#(& *"/* /3'5*#3 *"+& /&&)95*+', J')(3 6#
%+/(A &4,*/Q -+%&* 9'3#(&> !"# /%# /(&' ./((#3 .@#H$.(B0 (44#+).$;
!"# 9'&* +,-()#,*+/( *J'=&*/;# /..'),* J/& 5%'5' 64 \4, P%/k+#% UMbebA
MbaeV /,3 6#./9# O,'J, /& *"# lI/%3#,=2/*"m *"#'%4> F, +*& &+95(#&* -'%9A
*"# 9'3#( +& 6/ ', *"# ,'*+', '- 6)+(3+,; 5"%/=&*%).*)%#&A #>;> C =n G2
]2A ]2 =n ] 22 #*.> R)+(3+,; / 5"%/=&*%).*)%# #Q5%#&& *"# +3#/ *"/* /
,*#,.# UCV .',&+&*& '- / ,'), 5"%/ UG2V /,3 / 0#%6 5"%/ U]2V> F, *)%,A
/ 0#%6 5"%/ U]2V ./, .',&+&* '- / 0#%6 U]V /,3 / 5%#5'&+*+',/( 5"%/ U22V
#*.> 8',E)#,*(4A *"# 5"%/ &*%).*)%#& ./, 6# .'96+,#3 +,*' l,*#,.#
*%##&m 64 &*+.O+,; *"#9 *';#*"#%> F, ./ '- /, /96+;)+*4A *"# 5%'.#&&'% "/&
*' 3#.+3# J"+." /,/(4&+& *' 5)%&)# 6/ ', .#%*/+, "#)%+&*+.&> !"#
"#)%+&*+.& J')(3 ;)+3# *"# 5/%% &' *"/* ',(4 ',# &4,*/.*+. +,*#%5%#*/*+', +&
6#+,; -'(('J#3 /* /,4 ;+0#, *+9#> !"# 5%#&)9#3 #Q+&*#,.# '- 5%'.#&&+,;
"#)%+&*+.& +& ;%'),3#3 +, *"# /&&)95*+', *"/* *"# ")9/, 5/%% "/& /
(+9+*#3 /6+(+*4 *' .'95)*# +,5)*> !"# (+9+*/*+',& /%# +95' 64 *"# ;#,#%/(
.';,+*+0# /%."+*#.*)%#A 9'&* ,'*/6(4 64 J'%O+,; 9#9'%4> !"/* +&A / &+,;(#
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
14/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
13
/,/(4&+& +& 5)%&)#3 6#./) 9)(*+5(# /,/(4& /* *"# &/9# *+9# %#E)+%# 9'%#
9#9'%4 %#&')%.#& /,3 /%# *"#%#-'%# 0#%4 3#9/,3+,;>
T,# '- *"# "#)%+&*+.& *"/* P%/k+#% 5%'5' -'% /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', +& ./((#3
I,),6(* 3..(4560). > F* /&&)9#& *"/* /, /96+;)')& 5"%/ +& /**/."#3 *' *"#5%#.#3+,; *%## &*%).*)%# /&&)9+,; *"# &+95(#&* 5'&&+6(# &*%).*)%#> F, *"#
#Q/95(# /6'0# UMV 9+,+9/( /**/."9#,* J')(3 5%#3+.* *"/* %#/3#%& +,+*+/((4
+,*#%5%#* *"# 0#%6 0C(6,)0% /& *"# 9/+, .(/) 0#%6 6#./) +* J')(3
+,0'(0# / &+95(#% &*%).*)%# *"/, /&&)9+,; *"/* C' *"# *%## ,##3& *' 6# %#0+> !"# .',3 "#)%+&*+. P%/k+#%+,*%'3).#3 +& ./((#3 J(.0 2*#$+"0> F* &*/*#& *"/* +,.'9+,; 9/*#%+/( &"')(3 6#
/**/."#3 +,*' *"# .',&*+*)#,* .)%%#,*(4 6#+,; 5%'.#&> !"+& 9#/,& *"/*
+,.'9+,; +,-'%9/*+', &"')(3 -'%9 5/%* '- *"# .)%%#,* 5"%/ %/*"#% *"/,
&*/%* / ,#J 5"%/> !/O# UK / /,3 6V<
UKV (; K,)40 L(& (*@(&$ M#B$ ( 6,*0 .5,$ $006$ *,N0 ( $5#". %,$.()40 .#
5,6;
-; K,)40 L(& (*@(&$ M#B$ ( 6,*0 $006$ *,N0 ( 10"& $5#". %,$.()40 .#
5,6;
F, UKV *"# ,'), 5"%/ ( 6,*0 .')(3 #+*"#% 6# +,*#%5%#*#3 /& *"# 3+%#.* '6[#.*
'- *"# 0#%6 M#B$ UK /V '% /& *"# &)6[#.* '- *"# 9/+, .(/) UK 6V> !"# J(.0
4*#$+"0 "#)%+&*+. J')(3 &);;#&* *"/* 5#'5(# +,*#%5%#* *"# ,'), 5"%/ /&
3+%#.* '6[#.* '- M#B$ UK/V /& *"+& +& *"# .)%%#,* .',&*+*)#,*> F, .',*%/&* UK 6V
J')(3 6# 3+&5%#-#%%#3 6#./) / ,#J .',&*+*)#,* ;#*& +,*%'3).#3> F,3##3A
P%/k+#% i 8(+-*', UMbaKV -'),3 (',;#% %#/3+,; *+9#& -'% ,*#,.#& &)." /& UK
6V .'95/%#3 *' UK /V J"+." J/& */O#, /& #0+3#,.# *"/* J(.0 4*#$+"0 J/&
#Q#%*+,; +,-()#,.# 3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;>
:/%(4 #Q5#%+9#,*/( #0+3#,.# "/& 5%'0+3#3 &)55'%* -'% *J'=&*/;# 9'3#(&
U#>;>A P%/k+#% i 7/4,#%A MbaKj P%/k+#%A Mbaej 7/4,#% #* /(>A MbaNj P#%%#+%/ i
8(+-*',A MbacV> 8%).+/((4A *"# /..'),*& /&&)9# *"# 5%+9/.4 '- &4,*/Q>
C4,*/.*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& 5%'.#& -+%&* /,3 /(( '*"#% (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+',
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
15/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
14
(+O# /,*+.& '% 5%'&'34 J+(( 6# .',&+3#%#3 /* / (/*#% &*/;#> !"+& 9#/,&
*"/* 5%'&'3+. '% 5(/)&+6+(+*4 +,-'%9/*+', ./, %#+,-'%.# '% %#[#.* *"# +,+*+/(
&4,*/.*+. /,/(4&+& J"+." +& ;)+3#3 64 5)%#(4 &4,*/.*+. "#)%+&*+.& &)." /&
I,),6(* (..(4560). /,3 J(.0 4*#$+"0> !")&A 5%'&'3+. '% 5(/)&+6+(+*4+,-'%9/*+', J')(3 *%+;;#% %#/,/(4&+& 64 -/(&+-4+,; *"# +,+*+/( &4,*/.*+.
&*%).*)%#> R)* 5%'&'3+. '% 5(/)&+6+(+*4 +,-'%9/*+', 3'#& ,'* +,-()#,.# *"#
+,+*+/( &*%).*)%# 6)+(3+,; +*(-> !"/* +& J"4 *"# 9'3#(& /%# /(&' ./((#3
&4,*/Q=-+%&* 9'3#(&>
D ,)96#% '- &*)3+#& "/0# ."/((#,;#3 &4,*/Q=-+%&*A *J'=&*/;# 9'3#(&> B.7/#A
C5+0#4=o,'J(*', /,3 !/,#,"/)& UMbbaV -+%&*(4 ) / ,*#,.# .'95(#*+',
*/&O *' (''O /* *"# +,-()#,.# '- *"#9/*+. -+*> !"#9/*+. -+* +, *"#+%+,*#%5%#*/*+', %#-#%& *' *"# (+O#(+,#&& '- / ,'), *' 6# /, /;#,* '% / 5/*+#,*
3)%+,; /, /.*+',> H&+,; &*%).*)%#& /,/(';')& *' UMVA -%/;9#,*& &)." /& UN /V
J#%# .'95(#*#3 9'%# '-*#, J+*" / %#3).#3 %#(/*+0# .(/) *"/, ,*#,.#&
&)." /& UN 6V
UNV (;
8'95(#*#3 9/*#%+/(& 6/ ', UNV &"'J#3 &"'%*#% %#/3+,; *+9# -'% *45+./(
5/*+#,*& *"#, -'% *45+./( /;#,*&> F, &)9A *"#+% %#&)(*& +,3+./*#3 *"/*
+,-'%9/*+', &)." /& *"#9/*+. -+* '- / ,'), +& */O#, +,*' /..'),* 3)%+,;
5%'.#&&+,; %+;"* -%'9 *"# &*/%*> !"+& /(&' &);;#&*& *"/* %#/3#%& 5%'.#&& ,'*
[)&* &4,*/.*+. 6)* 3+--#%#,* *45#& '- +,-'%9/*+', +, =("(**0* /,3 J+*"')*
3#(/4> F,*#%/.*+0# 9'3#(& '% '-*#,=./((#3 .',&*%/+,*=6/ U'% .',&*%/+,*=
&/*+&-/.*+',V 9'3#(& &)." /& B.7/#A C5+0#4=o,'J(*', /,3 !/,#,"/)&
UMbbaV 5'&*)(/*# *"/* /(( 5'&&+6(# +,*#%5%#*/*+',& '- / .)%%#,* &*%).*)%# /%#
/.*+0/*#3 +, 5/%/((#(> !"# &4,*/.*+. &*%).*)%# *"/* %#.#+0#& 9'&* &)55'%* 64
*"# 0/%+')& .',&*%/+,*& ', / J'%3=64=J'%3 6/&+& )(*+9/*#(4 J+,& *"#
.'95#*+*+', -'% *"# 6#&* '0#%/(( /,/(4&+& UC5+0#4 i !/,#,"/)&A Mbbaj B.7/#
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
16/216
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
17/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
16
5"',#*+. 5%'5#%*+#& '- *"# /.*)/( &5##." &+;,/(> !"#%# /%# 5/%/9#*#%& *"/*
+,3+./*# / 6'),3/%4 *',# &)." /& / 3%'5 +, PL /,3 /, +,.%#/ +, 5%#=
6'),3/%4 &4((/6(# 3)%/*+', UW')A MbbLj o(/**A i 8''5#%AMbedj o(/**AA
MbecV> !"# -#/*)%#& /%# +,"#%#,* +, &5##."A 9/,+-#&*+,; *"#9(0#& +,."/,;#& '- -),3/9#,*/( -%#E)#,.4A +,*#,&+*4 /,3 3)%/*+', '0#% *"# .')% '-
/ &5'O#, ,*#,.#> D& &)."A *"#4 9/%O *"# 6'),3/%+#& '- (+,;)+&*+./((4
9#/,+,;-)( ),+*& /& J#(( /& *"#+% 5%'9+,#,.#>
F J+(( 5%+9/%+(4 -'.)& ', ',# 5/%*+.)(/% /&5#.* '- '0#%* 5%'&'34 ,/9#(4
5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%+#& '% 5/)&> F* "/& 6##, &"'J, *"/* 5%'&'34A #&5#.+/((4
5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%+#& U5/)&VA ./, +,-()#,.# *"# %#&'()*+', '- *#95'%/%4
&4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*+#& U\#"+&*#A MbeNj 2%+.# #* /(>A MbbMj C5##% #* /(> MbbcV>!/O# UdV U-%'9 C5##% #* /(> MbbcV<
EOF (; P50)010" .50 B+("% 4504N$ Q=(+$0R .50 %##" ,$ *#4N0%;
-; P50)010" .50 B+("% 4504N$ .50 %##" Q=(+$0R ,.S$ *#4N0%;
!"+& +& / .(/&&+. #/%(4 0&> (/*# .('&)%# /96+;)+*4> F* )& 0#%6& *"/* ./, 6#
#+*"#% *%/,&+*+0# U*/O# / 3+%#.* '6[#.*V '% +,*%/,&+*+0# U,'* 6# -'(('J#3 64 /
3+%#.* '6[#.*V>
F, UZV /, /96+;)+*4 /%+& 6#*J##, *"# 0#%6 4504N$ /,3 *"# ,'), %##" > F, UZ
/V %##" +& *"# 3+%#.* '6[#.* '- 4504N$> F, UZ 6V 4504N$ +& *"# 5%#3+./*# '- *"#
&)6.(/)A *")& %##" +& &)6[#.* '- *"# 9/+, .(/)> W'J#0#%A /* *"+& 5'+,* +*
+& ),.(#/% J"+." &*/*)& 4504N$ "/& U*%/,&+*+0# 0&> +,*%/,&+*+0#V /,3
.',E)#,*(4 J"+." %'(# %##" -)(-+(& U3+%#.* '6[#.* 0&> &)6[#.* '- 9/+,
.(/)V>
o[#(;//%3 /,3 C5##% UMbbbV &"'J#3 *"/* *"# +,%*+', '- / 5/) /-*#%
4504N$ %#(+/6(4 6+/& /,3 -/.+(+*/*#& *"# +,*#%5%#*/*+', '- 4504N$ /&
+,*%/,&+*+0#> :E)/((4 ,' 5/) /-*#% 4504N$ /,3 / 5/) /-*#% %##" %#(+/6(4
6+/& *'J/%3& *"# *%/,&+*+0# +,*#%5%#*/*+',> !"#4 /(&' &"'J#3 *"/* / 5/)
/* *"# J%',; 5(/.# +,*#%-#%#& J+*" /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',> !")&A 5%'&'3+.
+,-'%9/*+',A 5%#.+(4A *"# 5%#,.# '- / 5/) /* 5'+,*& '- &4,*/.*+.
),.#%*/+,*4 ./, +,-()#,.# 5%'.#&&+,; 0#%4 #/%(4 ',> B'3#(& *"/* +,+*+/((4
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
18/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
17
+;,'%# /,4 (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', *"/* +& ,'* &4,*/.*+. 9+;"* -+,3 *"+& 3+--+.)(*
*' #Q5(/+,>
!' &)9 )5A ', *"# ',# "/,3A *"#%# +& &)55'%* -'% %+/( *J'=&*/;# &4,*/Q -+%&*
9'3#(&> !"+& &)55'%* .'9#& (/%;#(4 -%'9 &*)3+#& (''O+,; /* *"# &4,*/.*+.9#/,& '- 3+&/96+;)/*+,; / *#95'%/%4 &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*4> T, *"# '*"#%
"/,3A *"#%# +& / &)6&*/,*+/( 6'34 '- %#/%." *"/* &)55'%*& 5/%/((#(
.',&*%/+,*=&/*+&-/.*+', 6/ 5%'.#&&+,; '- /(( /0/+(/6(# (+,;)+&*+.
+,-'%9/*+', J+*"')* 3#(/4> !"# &)55'%* +& 6/ ', *"# %#&'()*+', '-
&4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*+#& (''O+,; /* &4,*/.*+.A /,*+. '% 5%'&'3+. +,-'%9/*+',>
B;B; @($(14' "04''($*(- 5$ 1(-(41"0 %8 4+65*/5,a 1(-%'/,5%$
7#/%." +,*' /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', +, ;#,#%/( "/& 5%'0+3#3 )& J+*" / J#/(*"
'- 3/*/> T, *"# 6/&+& '- *"+&A 3#*/+(#3 9'3#(& '- /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', "/0#
6##, 3#0#('5#3 *"/* "/0# -)%*"#%#3 ')% ),3#%&*/,3+,; '- (/,;)/;#
5%'.#&&+,;> F, &5+*# '- *"+& 5%';%#&&A *"# 5&4."'(+,;)+&*+. (+*#%/*)%# ;+0#& *"#
+95%#&&+', '- 6#+,; -%/;9#,*#3 /,3 ."/((#,;+,; *' %#.',.+(#> !"#
."/((#,;#& &*#9 -%'9 *"%## &')%.#&> P+%&*(4A *"#%# +& / J+3# %/,;# '- %#/%."
E)#&*+',& *"/* /%# 6#+,; /33%#&> G/*)%/((4A *"+& (#/3& *' *"# ,#.#&&+*4 *'
(+9+* #Q5#%+9#,*/( 5/%/9#*#%& /,3 "45'*"#&> C#.',3(4A *"#%# +& / 6%'/3
%/,;# '- #Q5#%+9#,*/( 5/%/3+;9& 6#+,; )> :/." 5/%/3+;9 "/& +*& 9#%+*&A
*")& +* +& &)+*#3 *' 5%'3).# %#&)(*& *"/* ,##3 *' 6# ./%#-)((4 +,*#%5%#*#3 J+*"
*"# (+9+*& '- *"# #Q5#%+9#,*/( 5/%/3+;9> D,3 *"+%3(4A /& &*/*#3 6#-'%#A *"#%#
/%# ,)9#%')& &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*+#& *' ."'' -%'9> D96+;)+*+#& &"/%# /
.'99', -#/*)%#A +>#> /* &'9# 5'+,* +, *"# ,*#,.# +* +& ),.(#/% J"/* *"#
;%/99/*+./( &*%).*)%# +&> G',#*"#(#&&A /96+;)+*+#& /(&' 3+--#% &)6&*/,*+/((4> F
J+(( 6%+#-(4 /33%#&& #/." +, *)%,>
P+%&*(4A ',# .'99),+*4 '- %#/%." #9& *' .',.#,*%/*# ', &4,*/.*+. /,3
/,*+. -/.*'%& 3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;> F* +& *%4+,; *' /33%#&& E)#&*+',& (+O#
U2+.O#%+,; i 0/, I'95#(A KLLcV
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
19/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
18
l psq J"/* ;)+3#& +,+*+/( 5%'.#&&+,;1 `"4 3'#& 5%'.#&&+,; 3+--+.)(*4 '..)%1
W'J 3+--+.)(* +& %#/,/(4&+&1 ?' 5#'5(# .',&*%).* ),;%/99/*+./(
%#5%#,*/*+',&1m U2+.O#%+,; i 0/, I'95#(A KLLcA 5/;# ZA KcA NLA NbV
C*)3+#& "#%# .',.#,*%/*# ', 3#*#%9+,+,; *"# *+9# .')% '- 5%'.#&&+,;A +>#>J"#, .#%*/+, +,-'%9/*+', +& ) /,3 J"/* *"# ),3#%(4+,; %#5%#,*/*+',&
-'% 5%'.#&&+,; /%#> !"# (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', %#-#%%#3 *' +& /(9'&*
#Q.()&+0#(4 &4,*/.*+. /,3 t '% /,*+. +, ,/*)%# UP#%%#+%/ i 8(+-*',A Mbacj
C5+0#4 i C#3+04A Mbbdj C5+0#4 i !/,#,"/)&A Mbbaj B.7/# #* /(>A Mbbaj
8(+-*', #* /(>A KLLNj 0/, I'95#( #* /(>A KLLdj ?#&9#* #* /(>A KLLcV> !/O#
B.7/# #* /(> UMbbaV %#5'%*#3 "#%# /& d /& /, #Q/95(#>
UdV (; !"#4 J#%# +,*#%#&*#3 +, J"#*"#% *"+& /,*+. -#/*)%# +,-()#,.#3
5%'.#&&+,; '- *"# &*%).*)%/( /96+;)+*4 U9/+, .(/) 0> %#3).#3 %#(/*+0#
.(/) %#/3+,;V 5%#,* /* *"# 0#%6 (""0$. > !")&A *"#4 #9#3 *' .',.#,*%/*#
', *"# &4,*/Q _ /,*+.& +,*#%-/.#>
T, *"# '*"#% "/,3A / .',3 ;%')5 '- %#/%." #9& *' .',.#,*%/*#& ', *"#
9/55+,; '- &4,*/Q /,3 5%'&'34> 7#/%."#%& *%4 *' 3#*#%9+,# J"/* *"#
%#(/*+',&"+5 6#*J##, &4,*/.*+. /,3 +,*',/*+',/( -'%9 9+;"* 6# /,3 J"#*"#%
',# .')(3 6# 5%#3+.*#3 -%'9 *"# '*"#%> H&)/((4 *"+& +& 3',# 64 (''O+,; /* *"#
5%'3).*+', &+3# UC5##% #* /(>A KLLNA 8/%(&',A KLLbAV 8',&+3#% Uc / 0> 6V /& /,
#Q/95(#<
UcV (; K+$,0 *0(")0% .5(. U,** .0*0=5#)0% (T.0" L#5) 1,$,.0%;
-; K+$,0 *0(")0% .5(. U,** .0*0=5#)0% Q=(+$0R (T.0" L#5) 1,$,.0%;
R'*" ,*#,.#& /%# ;('6/((4 &*%).*)%/((4 /96+;)')&> F* +& ,'* .(#/% J"#*"#%
C)&+# (#/%,* &'9#*"+,; /-*#% g'", 0+&+*#3 '% J"#*"#% R+(( *#(#5"',#3 /-*#%
g'", 0+&+*#3> 8%).+/((4A 6'*" +,*#%5%#*/*+',& /%# #E)/((4 5(/)&+6(#> !"# J(.0
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
20/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
19
4*#$+"0 5%+,.+5(# '- *"# ;/%3#, 5/*" 9'3#( J')(3 5%#3+.* *"/* (T.0" L#5)
1,$,.0% +& 5%#-#%#,*+/((4 /**/."#3 *' *"# .',3 ]2 .0*0=5#)0%; W'J#0#%A *"#
+,%*+', '- *"# 5/) 6#-'%# *"# /96+;)')& 5%#5'&+*+',/( 5"%/ Uc6 (T.0"
L#5) 1,$,.0% V *#,3& *' 6+/& (+&*#,#%& *'J/%3& *"# -+%&* +,*#%5%#*/*+',> `"#%#/&*"# /6,.# '- / 5/) /* *"+& 5'+,* #9& *' &)55'%* *"# (/**#%
+,*#%5%#*/*+', J"#%# (T.0" L#5) 1,$,.0% 9'3+-+#& *0(")0% >
!"# ;'/( '- &*)3+#& (+O# *"# #9#3 *' 6# *' ),3#%&*/,3 *"# 9/55+,; '-
5%'&'34 /,3 &4,*/Q> !")&A *"#4 #9 *' .',.#,*%/*# ', *"# &4,*/Q _ 5%'&'34
+,*#%-/.#> :Q5#%+9#,*/( %#/%." %#(+#& ', .',&*%/+,+,; *"# E)#&*+',& ',#
/&O& &' 5%#3+.*+',& ./, 6# 9/3# /,3 .',.()&+',& ./, 6# 3%/J,> !"#%#-'%#A
-/.*'%& '- +,*#%#&* &)." /& &4,*/Q /,3 /,*+.& '% &4,*/Q /,3 5%'&'34A /%#+&'(/*#3 +, ./%#-)((4 (#.*#3 )**#%/,.#&> !"# ."/((#,;# J+*" (/,;)/;#
%#/%."A "'J#0#%A +& *"/* *"# 6/&+. 6)+(3+,; 6('.O (+O# &4,*/QA /,*+.& /,3
5%'&'34 3' ,'* #Q+&* +, +&'(/*+',A #&5#.+/((4 +, &5'O#, (/,;)/;#K> !"#%#-'%#A
*"# &)6E)#,* &*#5 &"')(3 6# *' (''O /* &4,*/QA /,*+.& /,3 5%'&'34
*';#*"#%>
!"# .',3 ."/((#,;# -'% %#/%." '- /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', .',.#%,& *"#
%#/%." 9#*"'3'(';4> !' &*)34 /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',A 3+--#%#,* %#/%."
5/%/3+;9& /%# .'99',(4 )> C4,*/.*+. /,3 /,*+. -/.*'%& +, /96+;)+*4
%#&'()*+', "/0# 6##, &*)3+#3 #Q*#,&+0#(4 0+/ %#.'%3+,; '- #4# 9'0#9#,*&
3)%+,; %#/3+,; UP%/k+#% i 7/4,#%A MbaKj 7/4,#% #* /(> MbaNj C5+0#4 i
!/,#,"/)& MbbaV> T-*#, / .'96+,/*+', '- 9#*"'3& +& )A #>;> #4#
9'0#9#,*& /,3 (-=5/.#3 %#/3+,; UP#%%#+%/ i 8(+-*',A MbacVA ,*#,.#
-%/;9#,* .'95(#*+',& /,3 (-=5/.#3 %#/3+,; UB.7/# #* /(> MbbaV '%
/,/(4& '- *#Q* .'%5'%/A ,*#,.# -%/;9#,* .'95(#*+',& /,3 (-=5/.#3
%#/3+,; UC5+0#4 i C#3+04A Mbbdj C."##5#%&A KLLNV>
:4# *%/.O+,; /& J#(( /& (-=5/.#3 %#/3+,; /%# 0#%4 )-)( +, 3#*#%9+,+,; *"#
#/ '% 3+--+.)(*4 '- %#/3#%&h .'95%#"#,&+', '- / *#Q* UC*/)6 i 7/4,#%A
KLLeV> R'*" /%# .',&+3#%#3 /, ',=(+,# 9#/&)%#A "#,.# *"#4 /%# &)+*#3 *'
(''O /* *"# *+9# .')% '- 5%'.#&&+,;A +>#> J"#, .#%*/+, +,-'%9/*+', +& )>
2 !"+& +& 9'&* (+O#(4 /(&' *%)# -'% J%+**#, (/,;)/;#> C## P%/k+#%A KLLK ',
%#/3+,; /,3 +95(+.+* 5%'&'34>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
21/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
20
C#,*#,.# -%/;9#,* .'95(#*+',& /,3 *"# /,/(4& '- *#Q* .'%5'%/ /%# &)+*#3
*' &*)34 *"# ),3#%(4+,; %#5%#,*/*+',& -'% &4,*/.*+. 5%'.#&&+,;>
2%'&'3+. -/.*'%& +, /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', "/0# 6##, &*)3+#3 )&+,; &'9# O+,3
'- [)3;9#,* '- #+*"#% *"# ,/*)%/(,#&& '- *"# 5%'&'3+. &*%).*)%# '- /,)**#%/,.# UP%/k+#%A 8(+-*', i 8/%(&',A KLLZV '% ;%/99/*+./(+*4 Uo[#(;//%3 i
C5##%A MbbbV> ]#%4 .'99', +& /(&' J"/* +& ./((#3 -'%.#3 ."'+.#
.'95%#"#,&+', /,3 .%'&&=9'3/( ,/9+,; Uo[#(;//%3 i C5##%A Mbbbj 8/%(&',A
P%/k+#%A 8(+-*', KLLbj 8/%(&',A 8(+-*',A i P%/k+#%A KLLbj C,#3#O#% i 8/&%(4A
KLMMV> R'*" '- *"# 9#*"'3& /%# 6/ ', *"# +3#/ *"/* 5/%*+.+5/,*& 9/O# /
."'+.# 6/ ', *"# (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', 5%#,*#3 +, *"# &*+9)()&> !")&A
*"#4 5%'3).# 3/*/ *"/* ;+0#& /, +,3+./*+', '- "'J 5/%*+.+5/,*& +,*#%5%#* *"#&*+9)()& /,3 *"#%#64 #,/6(# .',.()&+',& /6')* *"# -),.*+', '- 5%'&'34 +,
5%'.#&&+,; 6)* ,'* ,#.#&&/%+(4 J"#, / 5%'&'3+. .)# .'9#& +,*' 5(/4>
D,'*"#% ',=(+,# 9#*"'3 (+O# #4#=*%/.O+,; +& %/%#(4 ) U`#6#%A I%+.# i
8%'.O#%A KLLcV>
!"# 9#*"'3& ) +, %#/%." /%# 3+0#% /,3 &)+*#3 *' /,&J#% *"# E)#&*+',
/* "/,3> W'J#0#%A *"# 3+0#%&+*4 9/O#& +* 5%'6(#9/*+. *' (+,O /,3 .'95/%#
*"# %#&)(*& *"#4 5%'3).#> 8',E)#,*(4A +* #9& 6#,#-+.+/( *' #95('4 /
.'96+,/*+', '- '--= /,3 ',=(+,# 9#*"'3'(';+#& /(%#/34 ) *' &*)34 #+*"#%
&4,*/.*+. /,3 /,*+. '% 5%'&'3+. /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',> !"# %#&)(*& ./,
*"#, 6# .'96+,#3 *' +,-'%9 9'3#(& '- /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',>
!"# *"+%3 ."/((#,;# +&A *"/* *"#%# /%# ,)9#%')& &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*+#& *'
."'' -%'9> B)." %#/%." ', &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', "/& ) *"#
%#3).#3 %#(/*+0# .(/) 0&> 9/+, .(/) /96+;)+*4 (+O# UMV UP%/k+#% i 7/4,#%A
MbaKj 7/4,#% #* /(> MbaNj C5+0#4 i !/,#,"/)& MbbaA B.7/#A MbbaV>
F, .',*%/&*A +, 5%'&'34 %#/%." *"# ]2M 0> ]2K /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4 U/& +,
UcVV "/& 6##, #Q*#,&+0#(4 ) UP#%%#+%/ i 8(+-*',A Mbacj C,#3#O#% i
!%)#&J#((A KLLNj 8/%(&',A 8(+-*',A i \4, P%/k+#%A KLLbj R%##,A `/*&', i
I+6&',A KLMLV> D(&' #/%(4 0> (/*# .('&)%# /96+;)+*+#& (+O# UKV UC5##% #* /(>
Mbbcj o[#(;//%3 i C5##%A MbbbV /%# )>
D(*"');" *"# /96+;)+*+#& &"/%# *"# .'99', -#/*)%# *"/* /* &'9# 5'+,* +,
*"# ,*#,.# +* +& ),.(#/% J"/* *"# ;%/99/*+./( &*%).*)%# +&A *"#4 /(&' 3+--#%>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
22/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
21
!"# 3+--#%#,.# "/& 9/+,(4 *' 3' J+*" *"# 5/%* '- *"# ,*#,.# J"#%# *"#
/96+;)+*4 '..)%&> F>#> */O# UMV /,3 UZV %#5#/*#3 "#%# /& UeV /,3 UaV<
EVF 8'%# /%;)9#,*& '- / ,*#,.# /%# *"# 6/&+..',&*+*)#,*& *"/* /%# ,##3#3 *' 9/O# / ,*#,.# ;%/99/*+./(A -'% #Q/95(# /
&)6[#.*A / 0#%6 U5%#3+./*#V /,3 5'&&+6(4 /, '6[#.*>
F, 6'*" ./& /6'0# *"# /96+;)+*4 .',.#%,& *"# 0#%6 U*"# 5%#3+./*#V /,3 +*&
%#(/*+',&"+5 J+*" #+*"#% *"# &)6[#.* UeV '% *"# 3+%#.* '6[#.* UaV> C' *' 9/O#
, '- *"# .'%# ;%/99/*+./( &*%).*)%#A +* +& /6&'()*#(4 #&,*+/( *' &'(0#
*"# /96+;)+*4>
F, .',*%/&*A .',&+3#% UcV "#%# %#5#/*#3 /& UbV<
UbV K+$,0 *0(")0% .5(. U,** .0*0=5#)0% (T.0" L#5) *0T.; U8/%(&', #* /(>A KLLMV
!"# /96+;)+*4 "#%# +& / &'=./((#3 /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4> D, /**/."9#,*
/96+;)+*4 +,0'(0#& / .',&*+*)#,* '- *"# ,*#,.# *"/* +& ,'* 5/%* '- *"# .'%#
/%;)9#,* &*%).*)%# 6)* %/*"#% 9'3+-+#& +* N> !")&A +* &"')(3 6# ,' 5%'6(#9 *'
9/O# , '- *"# .'%# ;%/99/*+./( &*%).*)%# '- *"# 9/+, .(/) +, UbV
UK+$,0 *0("). .5(. U,** .0*0=5#)0%F> W'J#0#%A +* +& *#95'%/%+(4 ),.(#/% J"+."
.'%# .',&*+*)#,* +& 6#+,; 9'3+-+#3 +, UbV> !"# 5%#5'&+*+',/( 5"%/ +, UbV
9'3+-+#& #+*"#% K+$,0 *0("). $#60.5,)B (T.0" L#5) *0T. '% U,** .0*0=5#)0% (T.0"
L#5) *0T. >
F* "/& 6##, /%;)#3 *"/* *"#%# +& / E)/(+*/*+0# 3+--#%#,.# 6#*J##, /96+;)+*+#&
*"/* +,0'(0# .'%# /%;)9#,*& /,3 *"' *"/* 3' ,'* UP%/k+#% i 8(+-*',A MbbeV
J"+." 9+;"* +95/.* 5%'.#&&+,; '- &/+3 /96+;)+*+#&> F,3##3A P%/k+#% i 8(+-*',
3 F J+(( 3+&.)&& /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*+#& +, 9'%# 3#*/+( ),3#% K>Z>M.
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
23/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
22
UMbbeVh& 2#)$."+(*
!' &)9 )5A *"#%# #9#3 *' 6# *"%## 9/+, ."/((#,;#& +, %#/%." '-
/96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',> P+%&*(4A *"#%# +& / #9+,; 3+0+3# +, %#/%." 6#*J##,
*"# 5%'.#&&+,; '- &4,*/Q /,3 /,*+.& /,3 *"# 5%'.#&&+,; &4,*/Q /,3
5%'&'34> R#./) &4,*/QA /,*+.& /,3 5%'&'34 3',h* #Q+&* +, +&'(/*+', +,
&5'O#, (/,;)/;#A +* 9+;"* 6# 5%'6(#9/*+. *' 3#0#('5 9'3#(& *"/* +,.()3# /((
*"%## +- *"# +,*#%/.*+', '- /(( *"%## +& ,'* /33%#& #Q5(+.+*(4> C#.',3(4A3+--#%#,* &*%/,3& '- %#/%." #9 *' -/0')% 3+--#%#,* 9#*"'3&A J"+." 9/O#&
*"# %#&)(*& 3+--+.)(* *' .'95/%#> D,3 *"+%3(4A /, /%%/4 '- /96+;)+*+#& +& 6#+,;
) *"/* 3+--#% +, *45# /,3 5'&&+6(4 +, E)/(+*4 '- 5%'.#&&+,;>
W'J ./, *"# ."/((#,;#& 6# /33%#& H,-'%*),/*#(4 +& 6#4',3 *"# &.'5#
'- *"+& *"#&+& *' */.O(# /(( *"%## ."/((#,;#& /* *"# &/9# *+9#> W'J#0#%A / -+%&*
&*#5 .')(3 6# *' ."'' /, /96+;)+*4 +, J"+." *"# +,-()#,.# '- &4,*/QA
/,*+.& /,3 5%'&'34 +, +&'(/*+', "/& 6##, &*)3+#3 6#-'%#A #>;> *"# %#(/*+0#
.(/) /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4> !")& /(( *"%## ./, 6# .'96+,#3 *' (''O /* *"#
+,*#%/.*+',> D(&'A '--=(+,# /,3 ',=(+,# 9#*"'3& '- %#/%." ./, 6# #95('4#3
*' /33%#&& *"# E)#&*+', '- *+9# .')% /,3 .',&*%/+,*& ', 5%'.#&&+,;>
B;Q; 70( -a$,4",5" 4+65*/5,a /$)(1 "%$-5)(14,5%$ N 1('4,5_( "'4/-(
4,,4"0+($,
D**/."9#,* /96+;)+*+#& /%# / .(/&& '- &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*+#& *"/* +,0'(0# /
.',&*+*)#,* '- *"# ,*#,.# *"/* +& ,'* 5/%* '- *"# .'%# /%;)9#,* &*%).*)%#
6)* %/*"#% 9'3+-+#& +*> D**/."9#,* /96+;)+*+#& /%# &)+*#3 *' &*)34 (/,;)/;#
5%'.#&&+,; 6#./) J"#, /, /96+;)+*4 '..)%& +* ,##3& *' 6# %#&'(0#3 +,
'%3#% *' 9/O# , '- *"# (+,;)+&*+. +,5)*> !")&A "'J *"# /96+;)+*4 +&
%#&'(0#3 9+;"* ;+0# )& /, +3#/ '- O+,3& '- .',&*%/+,*& *"/* ),3#%(+# (/,;)/;#
5%'.#&&+,;> F* 9+;"* /(&' &"#3 (+;"* ', J"#, 3+--#%#,* &')%.#& '- (+,;)+&*+.
+,-'%9/*+', /%# .'96+,#3 3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;> !"# %#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."9#,*
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
24/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
23
/96+;)+*4 +& 0#%4 J#(( &)+*#3 *' &*)34 &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',
6#./) 0/%+')& -/.*'%& *"/* +,-()#,.# *"# %#&'()*+', "/0# 6##, +,0#&*+;/*#3
6#-'%#>
B;Q;:; 70( 1('4,5_( "'4/-( 4,,4"0+($, 4+65*/5,a N 4 615(8 %_(1_5(&
T,# -%#E)#,*(4 &*)3+#3 #Q/95(# '- /, /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4 +& *"# %#(/*+0#
.(/) /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4> F* +& -'),3 +, ,*#,.#& .'95%+&+,; / .'95(#Q
,'), 5"%/ UG2 '- G2V J+*" /, /3[/.#,* %#(/*+0# .(/) U78VA /& +, UMLV>
E:XF; K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1(). #T .50 (4."0$$ @5# @($ (*6#$. %0(T;
!"# 9/+, .(/) .',*/+,& / .'95(#Q ,'), 5"%/A +>#> .50 $0"1(). #T .50
(4."0$$> !"+& .'95(#Q ,'), 5"%/ +& 9'3+-+#3 64 *"# -'(('J+,; %#(/*+0#
.(/) U78V @5# @($ (*6#$. %0(T > UMLV +& / ;('6/( /96+;)+*4 6#./) /* *"+&
5'+,* +* +& ),.(#/% J"+." '- *"# *J' ,'),& +& 6#+,; 9'3+-+#3> F- *"# -+%&* ,'),
+& 6#+,; 9'3+-+#3 U.50 $0"1(). @($ (*6#$. %0(T V *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."#&
"+;"#% )5 +, *"# &4,*/.*+. *%## U"+;"=/**/."9#,*A P+;)%# MV> F, .',*%/&*A +- *"#
.',3 ,'), +& 6#+,; 9'3+-+#3 U.50 (4."0$$ @($ (*6#$. %0(T V *"# 78 /**/."#&
('J#% 3'J, +, *"# &4,*/.*+. *%## U('J=/**/."9#,*A P+;)%# KV> !")&A /
&4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*4 +& .%#/*#3>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
25/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
24
P+;)%# M 2"%/=&*%).*)%# %#5%#,*/*+', -'% "+;"=/**/."9#,* UWDV '- /
%#(/*+0# .(/) U78V
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
26/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
25
P+;)%# K 2"%/=&*%).*)%# %#5%#,*/*+', -'% ('J=/**/."9#,* U\DV '- /
%#(/*+0# .(/) U78V>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
27/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
26
!"#%# /%# #%/( J/4& '- 3+&/96+;)/*+,; / %#(/*+0# .(/) *'J/%3& #+*"#% ',# '%
*"# '*"#% +,*#%5%#*/*+', U"+;" /**/."9#,* 0&> ('J /**/."9#,*V> P+%&*(4A &4,*/.*+.
9#/,& ./, 6# #95('4#3 (+O# UMM / /,3 6V<
UMMV /> K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1().$ #T .50 (4."0$$ @5# @0"0 (*6#$.
%0(T;
6> K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1().$ #T .50 (4."0$$ @5# @($ (*6#$.
%0(T;
!"# ,)96#% /;%##9#,* 6#*J##, *"# /**/."9#,* "'&* U$0"1().$ 0> (4."0$$V /,3
*"# 0#%6 +, *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) 3+&/96+;)/*#& /**/."9#,* *'J/%3& "+;"/**/."9#,* +, UMM /V /,3 ('J /**/."9#,* +, UMM 6V> !"+& *45# '- 3+&/96+;)/*+',
"/& 6##, ) 64 o//, /,3 CJ//6 UKLLNV -'% #Q/95(#>
C#.',3(4A ;#,#%/( 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& ./, 6# /55(+#3> P'% #Q/95(# UMK / /,3
6V<
UMKV /> K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1(). #T .50 (4."0$$ @5# @($ 10"& $0"1,*0;
6> K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1(). #T .50 (4."0$$ @5# @($ 10"& T(6#+$;
!"# -+,/( (#Q+./(=/,*+. +,-'%9/*+', +95(+#& J"#*"#% *"# 78 9'3+-+#& G2M U.50
$0"1(). V '% G2K U.50 (4."0$$V> R/ ', 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& +, UMK /VA +>#> .50
$0"1(). +& 9'%# (+O#(4 *' 6# $0"1,*0 *"/, *"# /.*%#&&A *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."#&
"+;"#% )5 +, *"# &4,*/.*+. *%##> R4 .',*%/&*A +, UMK 6V *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) +& &/+3 *'
9'3+-4 *"# 9'%# %#.#,* ,'), G2KA +>#> .50 (4."0$$ /,3 /**/."#& ('J#% 3'J, +, *"#
&4,*/.*+. *%##> !"+& +& 6/ ', *"# ,'*+', *"/* /, /.*%#&& +& 9'%# (+O#(4 *' 6#
-/9')& *"/, / %0/,*>
?+--#%#,* /&5#.*& '- 5(/)&+6+(+*4 +,-'%9/*+', U#>;> /,+9/.4 '- *"# "'&* ,'),
5"%/&V ./, .',&*%/+, *"# 5%'.#&&+,; '- *"# ,*#,.# +, &)." / J/4 *"/* ',#
+,*#%5%#*/*+', U+95(4+,; #+*"#% "+;"= '% ('J=/**/."9#,* '- *"# %#(/*+0# .(/)V +&
9'%# &/(+#,* *"/, *"# '*"#%> F,3##3A +, %#/%." ', %#/3+,;A 5(/)&+6+(+*4
.',&*%/+,*& &+9+(/% *' UMK / /,3 6V "/0# -%#E)#,*(4 6##, ) *' 9/Q+9/((4
3+&/96+;)/*# %#(/*+0#=.(/) /**/."9#,*& +, .'95(#Q ,'), 5"%/ &*%).*)%#&
U#>;> 8)#*'& i B+*."#((A Mbaaj 8/%%#+%/& i 8(+-*', MbbNj !%/Q(#%A 2+.O#%+,; i
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
28/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
27
8(+-*',A Mbbaj 0/, I'95#(A 2+.O#%+,; i !%/Q(#%A KLLMj 0/, I'95#( #* /(>A KLLdV> F*
#9& *"/* _ +, :,;(+&" /* (#/&* _ &)." .',&*%/+,*& 5%'0+3# / 0#%4 #--#.*+0# .)# *'
*"# -+,/( "+;"= '% ('J=/**/."9#,* +,*#%5%#*/*+', '- *"# %#(/*+0# .(/)> !"+%3(4A
/, 78 /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4 ./, 6# %#&'(0#3 64 9#/,& '- 5%'&'34> B'&* %#(#0/,*+, *"# 5%#,* .',*#Q* +& / &*)34 64 8(+-*',>A 8/%(&',A /,3 P%/k+#% UKLLKV J"'
+,0#&*+;/*#3A /9',; '*"#% *"+,;&A *"# +,-()#,.# '- '0#%* 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%+#&
U5/)&V ', *"# .'95%#"#,&+', '- %#(/*+0#=.(/) /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*+#& &)."
/& UMN / /,3 6V>
UMNV /> K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1(). #T .50 (4."0$$ Q=(+$0R @5# @($ (*6#$.
%0(T;
6> K#60#)0 $5#. .50 $0"1(). #T .50 (4."0$$ @5# @($ (*6#$. %0(T;
D;/+,A *"# ,*#,.# +& ;('6/((4 /96+;)')& /,3 +& ,'* 3+&/96+;)/*#3 64 9#/,& '-
&4,*/Q '% /,*+.&> !")&A +* +& +95'&&+6(# *' ) 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& *'
3#*#%9+,# /**/."9#,* '- *"# 78> 7#9#96#%A / &4,*/.*+. 5%+,.+5(# (+O# J(.0
4*#$+"0 J')(3 5%#3+.* / ('J /**/."9#,* 5%#-#%#,.#> W'J#0#%A 5%'&'3+. 9#/,&
9+;"* #Q#%* +,-()#,.# ', 5%'.#&&+,; +, *"+& ./> !"/* +&A *"# +,%*+', '- / 5/)
6#-'%# *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) UMN /V J')(3 6# #Q5#.*#3 *' *%+;;#% "+;" /**/."9#,* '-
*"# 78> !"+& +& 6/ ', *"# +3#/ *"/* *"# 5/) 6('.O& /**/."9#,* *' *"# 9'&*
%#.#,* ,'), G2KA *"#%#64 -'%.+,; *"# /**/."9#,* '- *"# 78 *' *"# ,#Q* /0/+(/6(#
,'), G2M> !"+& +3#/ J')(3 +95(4 *"/* / &4,*/.*+. 5%+,.+5(# (+O# J(.0 4*#$+"0 .')(3
6# '0#%%+33#, 64 5%'&'3+. 9#/,&> F, *"# ;/%3#, 5/*" 9'3#(A *"+& J')(3 */O#
5(/.# 3)%+,; *"# %#0+&+', &*/;#> !"# /6,.# '- *"# 5/) UMN 6VA ', *"# '*"#%
"/,3A +& #Q5#.*#3 *' *%+;;#% ('J /**/."9#,* *' G2K 6#./) +* +& *"# 9'&* %#.#,*
,'), /,3 /**/."9#,* *' *"# 9'&* %#.#,* ,'), &"')(3 6# #/&+#&* *' /."+#0#> !"+&
J')(3 +95(4 *"/* *"# /6,.# '- / 5/) +& &'9#"'J (+,O#3 *' / &4,*/.*+.
5%+,.+5(#& (+O# J(.0 4*#$+"0 /,3 I,),6(* (..(4560). /,3 *"#%#64 .',-+%9 *"#
+,+*+/( ('J /**/."9#,* /,/(4&+&>
H&+,; /, '--(+,# .'95%#"#,&+', */&OA 8(+-*', #* /(> UKLLKV -'),3 *"/* /,
l+,-'%9/*+0#m 5/) U+>#> / 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%4 (/%;#% +, &+k# '% 5%'9+,#,.# *"/,
/,4 5%#.#3+,; 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%4V 6#-'%# *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) +, / &5'O#,
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
29/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
28
,*#,.# &)." /& Ub /V %#(+/6(4 6+/ (+&*#,#%& *' /&&)9# / "+;"=/**/."9#,*
+,*#%5%#*/*+', '- *"# %#(/*+0# .(/) U8(+-*', #* /(>A KLLKA :Q5#%+9#,* KV>
B;Q;B; G('4,5_( "'4/-( 4,,4"0+($, 4$) +%)('- %8 4+65*/5,a 1(-%'/,5%$
!"#%# /%# 3+--#%#,* J/4& '- 3+&/96+;)/*+,; / ;('6/( 78 /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4
&)." /& UMLV> C4,*/.*+. UMMVA 5(/)&+6+(+*4 UMKV '% 5%'&'3+. UMNV 9#/,& ./, 6#
#95('4#3> W'J#0#%A +* "/& 6#.'9# .(#/% *"/* (+&*#,#%& '% %#/3#%& /%# )&)/((4 ,'*
/J/%# '- *"# /96+;)+*4 +, UMLV /,3 *"#4 3+&5(/4 / 5%#-#%#,.# -'% *"# %#&'()*+', '-
*"# /96+;)+*4> G/*+0# &5#/O#%& '- :,;(+&" *#,3 *' 3+&5(/4 / ('J /**/."9#,*
5%#-#%#,.# -'% ;('6/((4 /96+;)')& ,*#,.#&> !"+& J/& -+%&* %#5'%*#3 64 8)#*'& i
B+*."#(( UMbaaV J"' -'),3 / ('J /**/."9#,* 5%#-#%#,.# -'% :,;(+&">Z F, *"# -+%&*
+,&*/,.# *"+& J')(3 /%;)# -'% ),+0#%&/( 5%'.#&&+,; "#)%+&*+.& &)." /& J(.0
2*#$+"0 /,3 I,),6(* 3..(4560). 5%'5' 64 P%/k+#% ),3#% "#% lI/%3#, 2/*"m
*"#'%4 UMbebA Mbae/V> !"# J(.0 2*#$+"0 5%+,.+5(# &*/*#& *"/* +,.'9+,; 9/*#%+/(
&"')(3 6# /**/."#3 +,*' *"# .',&*+*)#,* .)%%#,*(4 6#+,; 5%'.#&> !"+& 9#/,&
*"/* +,.'9+,; +,-'%9/*+', &"')(3 -'%9 5/%* '- *"# .)%%#,* 5"%/ %/*"#% *"/,
&*/%* / ,#J 5"%/> 8%).+/((4A / "#)%+&*+. (+O# J(.0 2*#$+"0 J/& /&&)9#3 *' 6#
),+0#%&/( /,3 (/,;)/;# +,3#5#,3#,*> 8)#*'& i B+*."#((h& UMbaaV -+,3+,;& ./((#3
*"+& /&&)95*+', +,*' E)#&*+', 6#./) *"#4 /(&' %#5'%*#3 / "+;" /**/."9#,*
5%#-#%#,.# -'% C5/,+&"> F- J(.0 2*#$+"0 /,3 I,),6(* 3..(4560). J#%# *%)(4
),+0#%&/(A *"/* /55(4 *' /(( (/,;)/;#&A C5/,+&" J')(3 3+&5(/4 *"# &/9# ('J
/**/."9#,* 5%#-#%#,.# /& :,;(+&"> W'J#0#%A *"+& +& ,'* *"# ./> 8',E)#,*(4A
9)." %#/%." "/& 6##, 3',# +,*' .%'&&=(+,;)+&*+. /**/."9#,* 5%#-#%#,.#&A #>;>
C5/,+&" U8/%%#+%/& i 8(+-*', MbbNj I+(6'4A C'5#,/A 8(+-*', i P%/k+#% MbbdVA F*/(+/,
U?# ]+,.#,k+ i g'6A MbbdVA ?)*." U?#&9#*A R%4&6/#%* i ?# R/#.O#A KLLKj ?#&9#*
#* /(>A KLLcVA /,3 I#%9/, UW#9-'%*"A o',+#.k,4A i C."##5#%&A KLLLj C."##5#%&A
KLLNV>
4 B'%# #0+3#,.#A "'J#0#% &);;#&*& *"/* :,;(+&" &"'J& #+*"#% / J#/O 5%#-#%#,.#
-'% ('J /**/."9#,* '% ,' .(#/% 5%#-#%#,.# /* /(( U#>;>A 8/%%#+%/& i 8(+-*',A MbbNAMbbbj !%/Q(#%A 2+.O#%+,;A i 8(+-*',A MbbaV>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
30/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
29
T,# '- *"# /+9& '- *"+& *45# '- %#/%." J/& *' 3#*#%9+,# *' J"/* 3#;%##
5%'.#&&+,; "#)%+&*+.& &)." /& J(.0 2*#$+"0 /,3 I,),6(* 3..(4560). /%# ),+0#%&/(
'% J"#*"#% 3+--#%#,* 9'3#(& '- (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,; 9+;"* '--#% / 9'%# &)+*/6(#
/..'),* -'% *"# 3/*/ %#.'%3#3>H,-'%*),/*#(4A 5&4."'(+,;)+&*+. %#/%." ', 78 /**/."9#,* +, *"# 5%'&'3+.
3'9/+, +& (+9+*#3> C'9# %#/%." "/& -'.) ', *"# 5%'3).*+', &+3#A +>#> *"#
3#-/)(* 5"%/&+,; Ug),A KLLNV> !' 3/*# F /9 /J/%# '- ',(4 ',# 6#"/0+')%/( &*)34
', *"# +,-()#,.# '- 5/)& ', *"# .'95%#"#,&+', '- 78 /**/."9#,* +, :,;(+&"
U8(+-*',A KLLKV> !"#4 -'),3 *"/* *"# 5%#,.# '- / 5/) %#(+/6(4 6+/ (+&*#,#%&
*'J/%3& "+;"=/**/."9#,* '- *"# %#(/*+0# .(/)> W'J#0#%A *"#+% %#/%." J/&
.',.#%,#3 J+*" *"# E)#&*+', J"#*"#% (+&*#,#%& +,*#%5%#* 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%+#& /&/ ('./( '% / ;('6/( #0#,*> !"#4 .',.()3#3 *"/* (+&*#,#%& */O# +,*' /..'),* /((
5%#.#3+,; 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%+#& /,3 +,*#%5%#* *"#9 %#(/*+0# *' ',# /,'*"#%> !"#
-+,3+,; *"/* *"# 5/) 6+/ /**/."9#,* .')(3 6# #Q5(/+,#3 64 6'*" 9'3#(& '-
/96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+',> T, *"# ',# "/,3A %+/(A &4,*/Q -+%&* /55%'/."#& .')(3
/%;)# *"/* *"# +,-()#,.# '- *"# 5/) +& #Q#%*#3 0+/ %#0+&+',> T, *"# '*"#% "/,3A
5/%/((#(A .',&*%/+,*=&/*+&-/.*+', 9'3#( .')(3 /%;)# *"/* *"# 5%'&'3+. .)# +& */O#,
+,*' /..'),* +99#3+/*#(4> F* J')(3 9/O# / "+;" /**/."9#,* +,*#%5%#*/*+', 9'%#
(+O#(4 64 /33+,; &)55'%* -'% *"+& &*%).*)%# /,3 ,' %#0+&+', J')(3 6# ,#.#&&/%4>
B;Q;Q; 904''($*(- 5$ 1(-(41"0 %8 ,0( G9 4,,4"0+($, 4+65*/5,a 1(-%'/,5%$
`"+(# (''O+,; /* /96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', +, ;#,#%/( Fh0# ,'*#3 / ,)96#% '-
."/((#,;#&>
!"# -+%&* ."/((#,;# */.O(#& *"# &'9#J"/* -%/;9#,*#3 (+*#%/*)%# ', 78
/**/."9#,* %#&'()*+',> !"#%# +& / J+3# %/,;# '- %#/%." E)#&*+',& 6#+,; /&O#3>
!"+& +, *)%,A .',&*%/+,& *"# 5/%/9#*#%& '- *"# %#/%." ),3#%*/O#, /,3 *"#
*"#'%#*+./( 9'3#((+,; 6#+,; 3',#> `"#, .',&+3#%+,; *"# 78 /**/."9#,*
/96+;)+*4 +* 6#.'9#& /55/%#,* *"/* *"# E)#&*+',& /33%#& .',.#,*%/*# ', *"#
5(/)&+6+(+*4 _ &4,*/Q +,*#%/.*+', U]/, I'95#(A 2+.O#%+,; /,3 !%/Q(#%A KLLLV
3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;> ?#&5+*# *"#+% 3+--#%#,.#&A *"#%# +& / .'99',/(+*4 +, /(( 9'3#(&
', 78 /**/."9#,*A 6# *"#4 %+/(A 5/%/((#( '% / .'96+,/*+', '- *"# *J'> !"/* +&A *"#
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
31/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
30
%#&'()*+', '- *"# 78 /96+;)+*4 "/& '-*#, 6##, 3+&.)& +, *#%9& '- *"#
/,*+.& t 5(/)&+6+(+*4 /,3 &4,*/Q +,*#%-/.#> 78 /**/."9#,* "/& /(&' 6##, )
*' *#&* 5%#3+.*+',& '- 3+--#%#,* *45#& '- 9'3#(& 3+%#.*(4 U0/, I'95#( #* /(>A KLLdV
J"+." "/& -)%*"#%#3 ')% ),3#%&*/,3+,; '- &*%#,;*"& /,3 J#/O,#&& '- 3+--#%#,*9'3#(&> D U5'&&+6(4 ),+,*#,*+',/(V &+3# #--#.* '- *"+& +& *"/* *"# +,-()#,.# '-
5%'&'3+. -/.*'%& "/& ,'* 6##, +,0#&*+;/*#3 +, *"+& .',*#Q*>
!"#, /;/+,A %#/%." ', 5%'&'34 +, 78 /**/."9#,* %#&'()*+', -'.)& ', *"#
5%'&'34 _ &4,*/Q 9/55+,; U8(+-*',A KLLKV> D(*"');" %#.#,* %#&)(*& .')(3 (#,3
&)55'%* *' 5/%/((#( 5%'.#&&+,; +* #9& ,'* *' 6# 3+&.)& +, *"# *#%9&>
7/*"#%A +* +& 3+&.)& +, *#%9& '- *"# 5%'&'34 _ &4,*/Q 9/55+,;A +>#> J"/*
+,-'%9/*+', / 6'),3/%4 '% 5/) +95(+#& /6')* *"# &4,*/.*+. &*%).*)%# '- *"#,*#,.# U8(+-*',A KLLKV>
!"# .',3 ."/((#,;# /%+& -%'9 *"# 3+0#%&+*4 '- %#/%." 5/%/3+;9& 6#+,; )>
!"# 9'&* -%#E)#,*(4 ) 5/%/3+;9 *' (''O /* 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& ', 78
/**/."9#,* +& #4#=*%/.O+,; U8/%%#+%/& i 8(+-*',A MbbNA Mbbbj 0/, I'95#(A
2+.O#%+,; /,3 !%/Q(#%A KLLLj 0/, I'95#(A KLLdV> C'9#*+9#& #4#=*%/.O+,; +& )
+, .'96+,/*+', J+*" E)#&*+',,/+%# &*)3+#& /,3 #Q5(+.+* .'95%#"#,&+', E)#&*+',&
UI+(6'4 #* /(>A MbbdV> D& 3#*/+(#3 /6'0# UK>N>V %#&)(*& 5%'3).#3 -%'9 #4#=*%/.O+,;
#Q5#%+9#,*& 5%'0+3# /, #Q.#((#,* &')%.# *' &*)34 ',=(+,# .'95%#"#,&+',> !")&A
*"#4 /%# J#(( &)+*#3 *' &*)34 *"# 78 /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4 +, *"# %#/3+,; 3'9/+,>
F, %#/%." ', 5%'&'34 /,3 78 /**/."9#,* #Q5(+.+* .'95%#"#,&+', E)#&*+',&
J#%# /&O#3 U8(+-*', KLLKV> !"# #--#.*& '- 5%'&'3+. 9/,+5)(/*+',& *#,3 *' 6# 0#%4
&9/(( /,3 &)&.#5*+6(# *' */&O #--#.*& U\## i `/*&',A KLMMV> :&5#.+/((4 #Q5(+.+*
.'95%#"#,&+', E)#&*+',& #9 *' 6+/& 5/%*+.+5/,*& %#&5',&> B'%#
+95'%*/,*(4A %#/%." +, *"# /)3+*'%4 3'9/+, U8(+-*', #* /(> KLLKV 9'&*(4
+,0#&*+;/*#3 *"# +,-()#,.# '- '0#%* 5%'&'3+. .',&*%/+,*& ', &4,*/.*+. /**/."9#,*
),3#% u,#)*%/(h 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',3+*+',& U#E)/( /,*+. &)55'%* -'% #+*"#%
/**/."9#,* /(*#%,/*+0#V /,3 +, *"# %#/3+,; (+*#%/*)%# U#>;> 0/, I'95#( #* /(>A
KLLdVA 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& J#%# '-*#, ) *' 9/Q+9/((4 3+&/96+;)/*#
%#(/*+0#=.(/) /**/."9#,*& J"+(# O##5+,; U+95(+.+*V 5%'&'3+. .',&*%/+,*& 9'%#
'% (#&& .',&*/,*>
!' .',.()3#A *"# 3+0+3# /&&)9#3 +, *"# ;#,#%/( (+*#%/*)%# ', /96+;)+*4
%#&'()*+', /55#/%& /(&' +, *"# (+*#%/*)%# ', *"# 78 /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
32/216
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
33/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
32
B;R;:; =_($, 1('4,() ̀ %,($,54'- 4$) '4$*/4*( ̀ 1%"(--5$*
?+--#%#,* *45#& '- (+,;)+&*+. +,-'%9/*+', &)." /& &4,*/QA /,*+.& /,3 5%'&'34
"/0# 6##, %#(/*#3 *' 3+--#%#,* :72 .'95',#,*& /,3 #--#.*&> F J+(( 3+&.)&& *"#9'&* +95'%*/,* +, *)%,>
!"#%# +& ',# .'95',#,* *"/* "/& 6##, (+,O#3 *' /,*+. 5%'.#&&+,; +, ;#,#%/(>
F* +& / ,#;/*+0# ;'+,; J/0#-'%9 *"/* &*/%*& /%'),3 NLL9& /-*#% ',* '- /
/,*+./((4 /,'9/(')& J'%3A %#/."#& +*& 5#/O /%'),3 ZLL9& /,3 %#*)%,& *'
6/(+,# /%'),3 dLL9&> !"+& .'95',#,* J/& *#%9#3 GZLL> F* +& )&)/((4 -'),3 ',
.#,*%'=5'&*#%+'% #(#.*%'3# &+*#& 6)* +*& *'5';%/5"4 ./, 0/%4 J+*" &*+9)()&
-#/*)%#& /,3 +,5)* 9'3/(+*4 Uo)*/& i P#3#%9#+#%A KLMMV> F* J/& -+%&* %#5'%*#3 -'%J'%3& *"/* 3' ,'* -+* *"# /,*+. .',*#Q* *"#4 J#%# 5%#,*#3 +,A &)." /& Y .(N0
6& 4#TT00 @,.5 4"0(6 ()% %#B$ Uo)*/& i W+((4/%3A MbaLV> C+,.# *"#, +* J/& -'),3
-'% &+,;(# J'%3 .',*#Q* UW'(.'96A MbbNVA -'% ,*#,.# .',*#Q* Uo)*/& i
P#3#%9#+#%A KLLLV /,3 -'% 3+&.')% +, ;#,#%/( U0/, R#%O)9A W/;''%*A i R%'J,A
MbbbV> !")&A P#3#%9#+#% /,3 o)*/& UMbbbV /%;)#3 *"/*A *"# GZLL +& ,'* ',(4
,&+*+0# *' *"# /,*+.& '- / .',*#Q*A 6)* #9& *' %#-(#.* *"# #/ '- /..#&&+,;
'% 5%#=/.*+0/*+', '- +,-'%9/*+', +, /,*+. 9#9'%4> !"/* +&A #Q5#.*/*+',& /6')*
"'J / ,*#,.# +& *' 6# .'95(#*#3 #+*"#% /,*+./((4A 9'%5"'(';+./((4A
5"','(';+./((4 '% '%*"';%/5"+./((4A ./, 6# 5%#=/.*+0/*#3 64 &5#.+-+. .',*#Q*)/(=
/,*+. .)#& U-'% / &)99/%4 # R/;;+' i W/;''%*A KLMMV>
!"#%# /%# U/* (#/&*V *J' .'95',#,*&d *"/* "/0# 6##, (+,O#3 *' 5%'.#&&+,; '-
&4,*/Q> T,# +& / ,#;/*+0+*4 *"/* ./, /(&' 6# -'),3 6#*J##, NLL=dLL9& /-*#% J'%3
',* J+*" / 9'%# U(#-*V /,*#%+'% *'5';%/5"4A "#,.# *#%9#3 \#-* D,*#%+'%
G#;/*+0+*4> \DG #--#.*& "/0# 9/+,(4 6##, '6%0#3 -'% 9'%5"'&4,*/.*+.
0+'(/*+',&> P'% #Q/95(# F,&*#/3 *"# +,-+,+*+0# U0(. V +& 5%#,*#3A (#/3+,; *' / 0+'(/*+',
'- *"# #Q5#.*#3 &4,*/.*+. -'%9> UP%+#3#%+.+ #* /(>A MbbcV>
!"# .',3 &)55'(4 &4,*/Q=%#(/*#3 .'95',#,* +& ./((#3 2cLL> !"# 2cLL +& /
5'&+*+0+*4 *"/* &*/%*& /%'),3 dLL9& /-*#% J'%3 ',* /,3 +* (/&*& )&)/((4 /%'),3
5 P'% *"# *+9# 6#+,;A F J+(( +;,'%# *"# :\DG /& &'9# 3')6* "/& 6##, ./&* ', +*&
-),.*+',/( +,*#%5%#*/*+', 6/ ', +&&)#& .',.#%,+,; +*& %#(+/6+(+*4 /,3 0/(+3+*4
UC*#+,"/)#% i ?%)%4A KLMKV>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
34/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
33
dLL9&> !"# 2cLL '-*#, -'(('J& / \DG /,3 +& -'),3 -'% ),;%/99/*+./(
.',*+,)/*+',& '- *"# 6%'/3#&* ,> W/;''%* UKLLNV (+&*& /9',; '*"#%&A &'9# '-
*"# 0+'(/*+',& ) -'% 3+--#%#,* (/,;)/;#&A #>;> 5"%/=&*%).*)%# 0+'(/*+',&A
&)6./*#;'%+k/*+', 0+'(/*+',&A 0+'(/*+',& +, *"# /;%##9#,* '- ,)96#%A ;#,3#%A /,3./ UW/;''%*A KLLNV> `"#, (''O+,; /* *"# ,*#,.#& )A (+O#
7#(/*+0#(4 %#.#,*(4 / ,#J :72 .'95',#,* J/& 3+&.'0#%#3 *"/* +& (+,O#3 *'
5%'.#&&+,; / 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%4 U'% 5/)V> F* J/& -+%&* %#5'%*#3 64 C*#+,"/)#%A
D(*#% /,3 P%+#3#%+.+ UMbbbV J"' &"'J#3 *"/* .(#/% 5'&+*+0# J/0# J/& #(+.+*#3 64
/ 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%4 +, *"# &5##." &+;,/(> !"#4 *#%9#3 +* .('&)%# 5'&+*+0# &"+-*
U82CV> !"# 82C +& -'),3 6+(/*#%/((4 J+*" / .#,*%'5/%+#*/( 3+&*%+6)*+', URS;#(& #*
/(>A KLMMV> !"#%# +& &'9# 3+&.)&&+', /& *' *"# #Q/.* ',* '- *"+& .'95',#,*>
C*#+,"/)#% #* /(> UMbbbV ."' *"# ,*#,.# ',* J"#%#/& (/*#% &*)3+#& ."' *"#
'--* '- *"# (/&* J'%3 6#-'%# / 5/) U2/)O#% #* /(>A KLMMV '% *"# ',* '- *"#
&*%#& &4((/6(# '- *"# (/&* J'%3 6#-'%# *"# 5/) URS;#(&A KLMMj RS;#(& #* /(>A
KLMNV> RS;#(& UKLMMV 9'*+0/*#& *"# &4((/6(# ',* 64 5'+,*+,; ')* *"/* *"# (/&*
&4((/6(# ./%%+#& *"# /.')&*+. +,-'%9/*+', /&&'.+/*#3 J+*" / 6'),3/%4A +>#> 5+*."
+,-'%9/*+', '- *"# 6'),3/%4 *',# /,3 5%#=-+,/( (#,;*"#,+,;> G',#*"#(#&&A *' 3/*#
+* %#9/+,& ),.(#/% J"/* /.')&*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& /6&'()*#(4 ,#.#&&/%4 *' #(+.+* /
82C> D;%##9#,* #Q+&*& *"/* *"# '--* '- *"# 82C +& *%+;;#%#3 64 *"# ',* '- *"#
-+%&* J'%3 /-*#% *"# 5/) URS;#(& #* /(>A KLMMV> F* "/& /(&' 6#.'9# .(#/%A *"/* *"#
82C +& ,'* /, +,&*/,*+/*+', '- /,'*"#% 5'&+*+0+*4 &)." /& *"# 2cLL> 2/,,#O/95A
!'#5#(A D(*#%A W/",# /,3 P%+#3#%+.+ UKLLdV &"'J#3 *"/* ,' /,*+.A &4,*/.*+. '%
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
35/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
34
9#,*/(=5"',#*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& ,##3#3 *' #(+.+* *"+& .'95',#,*> D33+*+',/((4A
*"# 82C "/& 6##, -'),3 +, 3+--#%#,* (/,;)/;#& &)." /& I#%9/, UC*#+,"/)#% #* /(>A
MbbbVA ?)*." URS;#(&A KLMMVA :,;(+&" U2/)O#% #* /(>A KLMMV /,3 g/5/,# UBv((#%
#* /(> KLLdV> T, *"# ;%'),3& +* "/& 6##, /%;)#3 *"/* *"# 82C *%)(4 %#-(#.*& &'9#O+,3 '- 5%'&'3+. 5%'.#&&+,;> B'&* (+O#(4 +* .')(3 6# +,*#%5%#*#3 /& / %#-(#.*+', '-
&*%).*)%+,; /,3 t '% 5"%/&+,; '- *"# +,5)* URS;#(& #* /(>A KLMMV>
F J+(( ,'J *)%, *' J"/* :72& "/0# &' -/% 6##, %#5'%*#3 -'% 5%'.#&&+,; '- *"#
%#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."9#,* /96+;)+*4>
B;R;B; =GS- 4$) ,0( G9 4,,4"0+($, 4+65*/5,a
C'9# 5%#0+')& :72 %#/%." "/& (''O#3 /* %#(/*+0# .(/) /**/."9#,*> F, /
%#/3+,; &*)34A o//, /,3 CJ//6 UKLLNV +,0#&*+;/*#3 78 /**/."9#,* +, :,;(+&">
!"#4 (''O#3 /* .'95(#Q ,'), 5"%/& UG2M 5%#5 G2KV J+*" /, /**/."#3 78 >
!"#4 -'),3 / 5'&*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4 -'% ,',=5%#-#%%#3 "+;" /**/."9#,* /,3 -'%
),;%/99/*+./( /**/."9#,* .'95/%#3 *' *"# 5%#-#%%#3 ('J /**/."9#,*> !"#%#
#9#3 *' 6# ,' 3+--#%#,.# 6#*J##, ),;%/99/*+./( 78 /**/."9#,* /,3
3+&5%#-#%%#3 "+;" /**/."9#,* J"#, *"# 3+&/96+;)/*+', J/& &4,*/.*+. +, ,/*)%#
U,)96#% /;%##9#,* 6#*J##, 0#%6 /,3 /**/."9#,* "'&*V> R'*" #(+.+* / 5'&*#%+'%
2cLL .'95/%#3 *' 5%#-#%%#3 ('J /**/."9#,*> F, /33+*+',A *"#4 ) &*%).*)%/((4
&+95(#% &+,;(# G2 .',&*%).*+',& /,3 .'95/%#3 *"#9 *' 9'%# .'95(#Q ,'),
5"%/& UG2M 5%#5 G2KV> `"#, .'95/%+,; *"#A *"#4 -'),3 *"/* *"# 9'%#
.'95(#Q /,3 /96+;)')& K G2 .',3+*+',& #(+.+*#3 / 9'%# %+;"* /,*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4
.'95/%#3 *' *"# &+95(# G2 .',3+*+',&> !"#%#-'%#A &4,*/.*+. .'95(#Q+*4 /,3
*#95'%/( /96+;)+*4 #9#3 *' 6# */O#, +,*' /..'),* 3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;> !"+& J/&
%#-(#.*#3 +, /, /,*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4 /& / %#&5', *' 9'%# .'95(#Q /96+;)')&
,*#,.#& .'95/%#3 *' &+95(#% ),/96+;)')& ',#&>
P)%*"#%9'%#A 8/%%#+%/& #* /(> UKLLZV &*)3+#3 78 /**/."9#,* +, C5/,+&" J"+." "/&
&"'J, *' 6# / "+;" /**/."9#,* 5%#-#%#,.# (/,;)/;# U8)#*'& i B+*."#((A MbaaV> F,
*"#+% %#/3+,; &*)34A 3+&/96+;)/*+', '- 78 /**/."9#,* J/& /."+#0#3 &4,*/.*+./((4A
+>#> ,)96#% /,3 ;#,3#% /;%##9#,* 6#*J##, *"# (/&* J'%3 /,3 *"# +,*#,3#3
/**/."9#,* "'&*> D* *"# 5'+,* '- 3+&/96+;)/*+', *J' .',.)*+0# 5'&+*+0+*+#&
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
36/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
35
J#%# -'),3> T,# J/& / 6%'/3(4 /,3 &(+;"*(4 -%',*/( 3+&*%+6)*#3 5'&+*+0+*4
6#*J##, dLL=eLL9& *"/* ./, 6# .'95/%#3 *' o//, i CJ//6h& UKLLNV /,*#%+'%
5'&+*+0+*4 J"+." .')(3 6# / %#&5', *' .'95(#Q+*4> !"# .',3 J/& / 9'%#
5'&*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4 6#*J##, eLL=MLLL9& *"/* #9#3 *' %#`(# *"# 5'&*#%+'%A%#0+&+', /,3 %#5/+% %#(/*#3 2cLL '- o//, i CJ//6h& UKLLNV>
F, / ,)96#% '- :72 #Q5#%+9#,*& *"/* -'.) ', %#/3+,; /,3 (+&*#,+,;A D);)%kO4
UKLLdV +,0#&*+;/*#3 78 /**/."9#,* +, I#%9/,> B'&* %#(#0#,* -'% *"# .)%%#,*
6'34 '- J'%O +& *"# (+&*#,+,; #Q5#%+9#,*> ?)%+,; *"# (+&*#,+,; #Q5#%+9#,*A
5%'&'3+. .)#& UZ!: Q=(+$0R Z!> /2 -'% ('J /**/."9#,* 0> Z!: Z!> Q=(+$0R /2 -'%
"+;" /**/."9#,*V /,3 &4,*/.*+. 3+&/96+;)/*+', U;#,3#% 9/%O+,; /* *"# %#(/*+0#
5%','),V J#%# 9/,+5)(/*#3> T,# 5%'&'34 %#(/*#3 82C J/& -'),3 /* *"# 5'&+*+','- *"# 5/) -'% 5%'&'3+. "+;" /**/."9#,* .)# UZ!: Z!> Q=(+$0R /2 V> F, .',*%/&*A
*J' 82Ch J#%# %#5'%*#3 -'% *"# ('J /**/."9#,* 5%'&'3+. .)# UZ!: Q=(+$0R Z!>
/2 VA +>#> ',# /* G2M /,3 ',# /* G2K> W'J#0#%A *"# /)3+*'%4 9/*#%+/(& 9+;"* "/0#
+,.()3#3 /, /.')&*+. .',-'),3 +, *"# ('J /**/."9#,* 5%'&'34 .',3+*+',&A +>#> *"#
5+*." *%/[#.*'%4 /* G2K J/& "+;"(4 .'95/%/6(# 6#*J##, "+;" /,3 ('J /**/."9#,*
.',3+*+',&> !"#%#-'%#A *"# %#&)(*& J#%# 0#%4 3+--+.)(* *' +,*#%5%#* c>
!' &)9 )5A (+**(# +& O,'J, /6')* *"# #(#.*%'5"4&+'(';+./( .'%%#(/*#& '- 78
/**/."9#,* 5%'.#&&+,; +, *"# /)3+*'%4 3'9/+,> :0+3#,.# -%'9 %#/3+,; &*)3+#& +,
:,;(+&" Uo//, /,3 CJ//6A KLLNVA C5/,+&" U8/%%#+%/& #* /(>A KLLZV /,3 I#%9/,
UD);)%kO4A KLLdV &);;#&* *"/* -+%&*(4A *"# .'95(#Q+*4 '- *"# ,'), 5"%/ J/&
*/O#, +,*' /..'),* /& #0+3#,.#3 64 /, /,*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4 +, *"# 2cLL *+9#
J+,3'J> C#.',3(4A / (/,;)/;#=*45+./( 5%#-#%#,.# #9#3 *' 5(/4 / %'(# U/* (#/&*
+, :,;(+&" /,3 C5/,+&"V J"+." J/& %#-(#.*#3 +, / (/*# 5'&*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4 -'%
3+&5%#-#%%#3 /**/."9#,* U"+;" +, :,;(+&" /,3 ('J +, C5/,+&"V> D 0#%4 &+9+(/% (/*#
5'&*#%+'% 5'&+*+0+*4 J/& -'),3 -'% ),;%/99/*+./( 3+&/96+;)/*+', Uo//, /,3
CJ//6A KLLNV> 2%'&'3+. .)#& #9#3 *' "/0# 6##, */O#, +,*' /..'),* 3)%+,;
5%'.#&&+,; '- 78 /**/."9#,* +, I#%9/, U/& #0+3#,.#3 #>;> 64 *"# 82C +,
D);)%kO4A KLLdV> F J+(( 3#*/+( 5%#3+.*+',& -'% *"# +,*#%/.*+', '- 5%'&'34 /,3
5(/)&+6+(+*4 6/ ', *"# 5%#0+')& &*)3+#& +, 9'%# 3#*/+( +, 8"/5*#% b>
6 For more details see Chapter 9.1.
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
37/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
36
B;R;Q; ?(/1%"%*$5,5_( +%)('- %8 '4$*/4*( ̀ 1%"(--5$*
!"# 3+&.'0#%4 '- .'95',#,*& (+O# \DGA GZLLA 2cLLA 82C "/& "#(5#3 *' 3#0#('5
3#*/+(#3 ,#)%'.';,+*+0# 9'3#(& '- (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,;A *J' '- J"+." F J+((5%#,* +, 9'%# 3#*/+(> F "/0# 9#,*+',#3 6#-'%# U8"/5*#% K>M>V *"/* 9'3#(& '-
/96+;)+*4 %#&'()*+', /,3 (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,; +, ;#,#%/( ./, 6# ;%')5#3 +,*'
*J' 9/+, ./*#;'%+#&> T,# ./*#;'%4 .'95%+& %+/(A &4,*/Q=-+%&* 9'3#(& /,3 *"#
'*"#% 5/%/((#(A .',&*%/+,*=&/*+&-/.*+', 9'3#(&> !"+& 3+&*+,.*+', +& /(&' %#-(#.*#3 +,
,#)%'.';,+*+0# 9'3#(&> F* +& +95'%*/,* *' ,'*# /* *"+& 5'+,* *"/* *"# *J' 9'3#(&
*"/* F J+(( &)99/%+ 6#('J *%4 *' /..'),* -'% (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,; +, ;#,#%/(>
!"# 9'&* +,-()#,*+/( %+/(A &4,*/Q=-+%&* 9'3#( J/& 5%'5' 64 P%+#3#%+.+UKLLKV> F, "#% G#)%'.';,+*+0# 9'3#( '- /)3+*'%4 ,*#,.# 5%'.#&&+,; &"#
/&&)9#& *"/* J"#, *"# 5/%% +& 5%#,*#3 J+*" +,.'9+,; +,-'%9/*+', +* +,+*+/((4
.',&*%).*& *"# &+95(#&* &4,*/.*+. &*%).*)%# /(',#> !"# J'%3 ./*#;'%4
+,-'%9/*+', '- *"# J'%3 .)%%#,*(4 ),3#% .',&+3#%/*+', +& %#*%+#0#3 -%'9 9#9'%4
/,3 "#(3 +, J'%O+,; 9#9'%4 3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;> !"# &*%).*)%# 6)+(3+,; +&
&)55' *' 6# +,3#5#,3#,* '- (#Q+./(=/,*+. +,-'%9/*+',> D* / .',3 &*/;#A
(#Q+./(=/,*+. /,3 9'%5"'&4,*/.*+. +,-'%9/*+', +& %#*%+#0#3 -%'9 9#9'%4>
!"# 5/%% )& *"/* +,-'%9/*+', *' /&&+;, / *"#9/*+. %'(# UJ"' 3'#& J"/* *'
J"'9 #*.>V *' *"# +,5)* .)%%#,*(4 6#+,; "#(3 +, J'%O+,; 9#9'%4> C)6E)#,*(4A
/ 9/55+,; '- *"# %'(# /&&+;,9#,* ',*' *"# 6/&+. &4,*/.*+. &*%).*)%# */O#& 5(/.#> F-
*"+& 9/55+,; +& ),&)..#&&-)( %#/,/(4&+& /,3 5'&&+6(4 %#5/+% ,##3 *' 6# 3',# -'%
J"+." ;#,#%/( 9#9'%4 %#&')%.#& /%# %#.%)+*#3> P%+#3#%+.+ /(&' 5'&*)(/*#& /
3+--#%#,.# 6#*J##, ')*%+;"* 0+'(/*+',& '- / &*%).*)%# /,3 &*%).*)%/( /96+;)+*+#&>
D96+;)')& &*%).*)%#& /%# 5%'.#& &(+;"*(4 3+--#%#,*(4 +, *"/* *"# +,+*+/(
&*%).*)%# 6)+(3+,; +& ,'* *'*/((4 +,3#5#,3#,* '- ,',=&*%).*)%/( +,-'%9/*+',>
P%#E)#,.4 '- / 5/%*+.)(/% &*%).*)%# '% *"# /,*+. 5(/)&+6+(+*4 /&&'.+/*#3 J+*"
*"# 9/+, 0#%6 /%# */O#, +,*' /..'),*> W#% 9'3#( +& &4,*/Q=-+%&* +, *"# , *"/*
&4,*/.*+. 5"%/ &*%).*)%# +,-'%9/*+', +& 5%'.#& -+%&*A /)*','9')&(4 /,3
5%+'% *' /,*+. +,-'%9/*+',> F,*#%/.*+', '- &4,*/.*+. /,3 /,*+. +,-'%9/*+',
+& ',(4 '6%0#3 3)%+,; (/*#% &*/;#& '- 5%'.#&&+,;> C+,.# &5#.+-+. *45#& '-
+,-'%9/*+', 6#.'9# /0/+(/6(# /* &5#.+-+. *+9#& 3)%+,; 5%'.#&&+,;A 0+'(/*+',& '- /
&5#.+-+. *45# '- +,-'%9/*+', &"')(3 6# 3#*#.*/6(# /* .#%*/+, *+9#& /& J#((>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
38/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
37
8',E)#,*(4A P%+#3#%+.+ UKLLKV /(+;,& &5#.+-+. :72 .'95',#,*& /,3 *"#+% *+9#
J+,3'J& J+*" *"# /6'0# ')*(+,#3 5%'.#&&+,; &*/;#&> \/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,; +, *"#
9'3#( .',&+&*& '- -')% 3+&*+,.* 5"/&> ?)%+,; *"# -+%&* 5"/ J'%3 ./*#;'%4
+,-'%9/*+', +& +3#,*+-+#3> D,4 0+'(/*+',& /* *"+& 5'+,* /%# %#-(#.*#3 64 *"# :\DG.'95',#,* UMLL=KLL9&V> ?)%+,; *"# .',3 &*/;# UNLL=dLL9&VA
9'%5"'&4,*/.*+. /,3 (#Q+./(=/,*+. +,-'%9/*+', /%# /&& /,3 +,*#;%/*#3>
]+'(/*+',& '- 9'%5"'&4,*/.*+. ,/*)%# /%# %#-(#.*#3 +, *"# \DG .'95',#,* /,3
0+'(/*+',& '- (#Q+./(=/,*+. .',&*%/+,*& #(+.+* / GZLL> F- *"# +,*#;%/*+', +&
),&)..#&&-)( %#/,/(4&+& /,3 %#5/+% 5%'.#&& #,&)# J"+." +& %#-(#.*#3 +, *"#
2cLL> D* *"# *+9# J"#, *"# 9'3#( J/& -+%&* 5)6(+&"#3 ,' &5#.+-+. 5%#3+.*+', J/&
9/3# /& *' *"# -),.*+', '- 5%'&'3+. -/.*'%& #0+3#,.#3 64 *"# 82C> F, / 9'%#%#.#,* 0#%&+', '- *"# 9'3#( UP%+#3#%+.+A KLMMVA P%+#3#%+.+ ./)*+')&(4 &);;#&*#3
*"/*<
lUsV p*q"# 5%'&'34=&4,*/Q +,*#%/.*+', 9/4 */O# 5(/.# 3)%+,; 3+--#%#,*
5%'.#&&+,; 5"/&< :V 3)%+,; *"# +,+*+/( 5"/ '- 5"%/ &*%).*)%# 6)+(3+,;
&+,.# *"# #,3 '- / &4,*/.*+. 5"%/ +& 9/%O#3 5%'&'3+./((4A /,3t'% >V
3)%+,; *"# .',3 5%'.#&&+,; 5"/ 3)%+,; J"+." *"# 0#%6 /%;)9#,*
&*%).*)%# +& 5%'.#&A &+,.# *"# .',&*+*)#,* &*%).*)%# +& /(&' 5%'&'3+./((4
9/%O#3m UP%+#3#%+.+A KLMMA 5> MNaNV>
C"# &)55'%*& *"+& 5'&&+6(# +,*#%/.*+', J+*" &'9# '- *"# /6'0#=.+*#3 :72
#0+3#,.# URS;#(& #* /(>A KLMLj P%+#3#%+.+A 0', 8%/9', i o'*kA KLLeV> G'*#A
"'J#0#%A *"/* ,' 9'%# .(#/%=.)* 5%#3+.*+',& /& *' *"# *+9# .')% '- *"# 5%'&'34=
&4,*/Q +,*#%/.*+', "/0# 6##, 9/3# +, *"# 9'3#(>
!"# .',3 9'3#( F J/,* *' 3+&.)&& +& *"# B#9'%4A H,+-+./*+', /,3 8',*%'(
UBH8V 9'3#( 5%'5' 64 W/;''%* UKLLNA KLLdV> !"# BH8 9'3#( /&&)9#&
5/%/((#(A .',&*%/+,*=&/*+&-/.*+', 6/ 5%'.#&&+,; /,3 +* 5'&*)(/*#& *"%##
.'95',#,*&A / 9#9'%4 %#5'&+*'%4A / ),+-+./*+', 6)--#% /,3 / .',*%'( /55/%/*)&
UR/;;+' i W/;''%*A KLMMV> !"# 9#9'%4 %#5'&+*'%4 +& &'9#*"+,; /O+, *' / (#Q+.',A
+>#> +* &*'%#& 5"','(';+./(A &4,*/.*+. /,3 /,*+. +,-'%9/*+', /&&'.+/*#3 J+*"
9'%5"#9#&A J'%3&A /,3 '*"#% .',&*%).*+',&> 8',*%/%4 *' P%+#3#%+.+h& 9'3#(
J"+." #9& *' &);;#&* *"/* *"#%# +& / 3+--#%#,.# 6#*J##, &4,*/.*+. %)(#& /,3
(#Q+./( +,-'%9/*+', &*'%#3 +, 9#9'%4A W/;''%*h& 9#9'%4 %#5'&+*'%4 &*'%#& J"/*
"# ./((& ),+-+./*+', %#/34 &*%).*)%#&> !"# &*%).*)%#& /%# (#Q+./(+&* +, ,/*)%# +,
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
39/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
38
/& 9)." /& #/." J'%3 +& /&&'.+/*#3 J+*" / &*%).*)%/( -%/9# /,3 .',&*%/+,*& ',
"'J -%/9#& ./, 6# .'96+,#3 U-'% 9'%# 3#*/+( # W/;''%*A KLLdV> !")&A ."),O&
'- &4,*/.*+. &*%).*)%# /%# #,.'3#3 ', *"# J'%3 (#0#( /,3 ,' &4,*/.*+. %)(#& ,##3
*' 6# &*'%#3 /%/*#(4> 2%'.#&&+,; +& .',E)#,*(4 ),3#%&*''3 /& / &+,;(#5%'.#&&A ,/9#(4 ),+-+./*+',> B)." (+O# /,4 '*"#% 9'3#( '- (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,;A
J'%3 -'%9& #,*#% *"# ),+-+./*+', 6)--#% '% J'%O&5/.# +,.%#9#,*/((4> !"#
),+-+./*+', '5#%/*+', *"#, .',&+&*& '- (+,O+,; )5 (#Q+./(+&* -%/9#& /,3 ."#.O+,;
-'% /;%##9#,* '- %#(#0/,* -#/*)%#&> !"+& 5%'.#3)%# +& 6/ ', *"# .',&*%/+,*&
/&&'.+/*#3 J+*" *"# J'%3 .)%%#,*(4 6#+,; 5%'.#&> W/;''%*h& 9'3#( ./, 6#
.(/&&+-+#3 /& 5/%/((#(A .',&*%/+,*=&/*+&-/.*+', 6#./) +* &*/*#& *"/* /* /,4 5'+,*
3)%+,; ),+-+./*+', / ,)96#% '- /(*#%,/*+0# ./,3+3/*#& -'% (+,O+,; /%# /0/+(/6(#>:/." ',# .'9#& J+*" +*& 'J, * '- .',&*%/+,*&> ?)%+,; ),+-+./*+',A /**#95*& /%#
9/3# *' &'(0# ',=(+,# *"' *& '- .',&*%/+,*& 64 ."#.O+,; -'% /;%##9#,* ),*+(
*"# 6#&* '5*+', +& ."',> 2)* &+95(#%A &'9# ./,3+3/*#& "/0# &*%',;#% ),+-+./*+',
(+,O& *"/, '*"#%&> !"+& ./, -'% #Q/95(# 6# 3)# *' 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*& *"/* /%#
/&&'.+/*#3 J+*" *"# &4,*/.*+. -%/9#> F- ',# ./,3+3/*# ./%%+#& 9'%# J#+;"*
6#./) '- +*& 5(/)&+6+(+*4 .',&*%/+,*&A +* J+(( 6+,3 J+*" *"# 5%#.#3+,; &*%).*)%#>
!"# ./,3+3/*# /(&' %#*/+,& / .',*#Q* -'% &)6E)#,* &*/;#& '- 9#9'%4 %#*%+#0/(
6#./) '- *"# .',&*%/+,*& ', 6+,3+,; +* ./%%+#&> !")&A ),+-+./*+', +& /."+#0#3>
P+,/((4A *"# .',*%'( /55/%/*)& 9',+*'%& #Q#.)*+0# -),.*+',& &)." /& *)%, */O+,;
UR/;;+' i W/;''%*A KLMMV>
:72 .'95',#,*& +, W/;''%*h& 9'3#( /%# +,*#%5%#*#3 3+--#%#,*(4> P+%&*(4A *"# *+9#
J+,3'J +, J"+." :72 .'95',#,*& /55#/% /%# ,'* ,#.#&&/%+(4 (+,O#3 *' /..#&&+,;
/ &5#.+-+. *45# '- +,-'%9/*+', +, / &5#.+-+. '%3#% /& P%+#3#%+.+ &);;#&*&> F,
W/;''%*h& 9'3#( *"#%# /%# *J' 9/+, &')%.#& '- ),+-+./*+', 3+--+.)(*4> T,# +& *"#
-/+()%# *' -+,3 / &)+*/6(# ./,3+3/*# -'% / &5#.+-+. 6+,3+,; '5*+',> !"# '*"#% +& /,
),&)..#&&-)( /;%##9#,* ."#.O 6#*J##, *"# +,-'%9/*+', / ./,3+3/*# ./%%+#& /,3
*"# .',&*%/+,*& %#E)+%#3 64 *"# 6+,3+,; '5*+',> D, /,*#%+'% ,#;/*+0+*4 6#*J##,
NLL=dLL9& (+O# *"# \DG +& &)55' *' 6# / %#-(#.*+', '- 6'*" '- *"# &')%.#& '-
3+--+.)(*4> D 9'%# 5'&*#%+'% ,#;/*+0+*4 (+O# *"# GZLL +& /(&' /&&'.+/*#3 J+*"
),+-+./*+', 3+--+.)(*4> !"# 3+--+.)(*4 +& 3)# *' .'96+,/*'%+/( /,*+. 5%'.#&&
/,3 t '% 5%#=/.*+0/*+', '- %#E)+%#3 +,-'%9/*+',> !")& -/% "'J#0#%A W/;''%*
.',.#3#& *"/*
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
40/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
39
lUsV +* +& &*+(( ),.(#/% J"/* .'),*& /& / .'96+,/*'%+/( '5#%/*+', -%'9 /
6%/+, &4&*#9& 5#%&5#.*+0#>m UR/;;+' i W/;''%*A KLMMA 5> MNdNV>
W# &);;#&*& *"/* *"# /,*+. .'96+,/*'%+/( '5#%/*+',& 9+;"* 6# -'),3 /* (#/&*
/* *J' (#0#(&A +>#> .',.#5*)/( .',*#,* /,3 +,-'%9/*+', &*%).*)%#> F,-'%9/*+',&*%).*)%# %#-#%& *' *"# %#(/*+0# &/(+#,.# '- +,-'%9/*+',A #>;> 9/%O+,; &'9#*"+,; /&
,#J '% ;+0#,A *'5+. '% -'.)&> \+A W/;''%*A /,3 ^/,; UKLLaV -'),3 *"/*A +, 8"+,#A
*"# GZLL *' ,#J /..#,*#3 +,-'%9/*+', J/& (/%;#% *"/, *"# GZLL *' ,#J 3#=
/..#,*#3 +,-'%9/*+',> W#,.#A ',# J/4 *' #Q5(/+, /, GZLL J')(3 6# *"/* +*
%#-(#.*& *"# ,#.#&&+*4 *' %#.%)+* /33+*+',/( ),+-+./*+', %#&')%.#& -'% +,-'%9/*+',
*"/* +& 9/%O#3 /& 9'%# &/(+#,* UR/;;+' i W/;''%*A KLMMV> 2%#=/.*+0/*+', .')(3 6#
*"');"* '- /& *"# -(+5&+3# '- *"+& 6#./) lUsV+, %#/(+&*+. 5%'.#&&+,; &+*)/*+',&A/..#&&A %#*%+#0/(A 5%#=/.*+0/*+', /,3 ),+-+./*+', /%# /(( 5/%* '- J'%3 5%'.#&&+,;
UsV UR/;;+' i W/;''%*A KLMMA 5> MNcMV>
D,'*"#% +95'%*/,* :72 .'95',#,* *"/* ,##3& *' 6# #Q5(/+,#3 +& *"# 2cLL> D&
3#*/+(#3 /6'0#A / 2cLL "/& 6##, %#5'%*#3 -'% ')*%+;"* 0+'(/*+',&A .'95(#Q+*4 /,3
/96+;)+*4> H,3#% *"# BH8 -%/9#J'%OA *"#4 #9 *' 6# *%#/*#3 0#%4 &+9+(/%(4>
]+'(/*+',&A .'95(#Q+*4 /,3 /96+;)+*4 /%# /(( /&&'.+/*#3 J+*" / .#%*/+, 3#;%## '-
5%'.#&&+,; 3+--+.)(*4 3)# *' #+*"#% ',;'+,; .'95#*+*+', 6#*J##, /(*#%,/*+0#
),+-+./*+', '5*+',& U/96+;)+*4 t .'95(#Q+*4V '% *"# /%." -'% / ,#J ),+-+./*+',
'5*+', U0+'(/*+',V> 8',E)#,*(4A *"# 2cLL %#-(#.*& *"# *+9# */O#, *' #&*/6(+&"
),+-+./*+', (+,O& '- &)--+.+#,* &*%#,;*"> D95(+*)3# /,3 3)%/*+', '- *"# 2cLL /%#
9'3)(/*#3 64 *"# /9'),* '- .'95#*+*+', /,3A *")&A *"# /9'),* '- 5%'.#&&+,;
3+--+.)(*4> D 2cLL &"')(3 /(J/4& 6# #(+.+*#3 J"#, ),+-+./*+', +& /**#95*#3
UW/;''%*A KLLdV>
B)." (+O# P%+#3#%+.+A W/;''%* (#/0#& *"# %'(# '- 5%'&'3+. -/.*'%& 3)%+,;
),+-+./*+', &'9#J"/* ),3#%&5#.+-+#3> !' 3/*# "# "/& ,'* #Q5(+.+*(4 +,.'%5'%/*#3
*"# 5%'&'34 %#(/*#3 82C> W'J#0#%A "# (+,O& 5%'&'3+. ."/%/.*#%+&*+.& (+O#
6'),3/%4 *',#&A 5/)&+,; /,3 (#,;*"#,+,; *' *"# +3#/ '- &/(+#,.# '- +,-'%9/*+',A
&5#.+-+./((4 J"+." /&5#.*& '- /, )**#%/,.# ;#* -'.) UW/;''%*A KLLNV> D* *"#
&/9# *+9# "# /55#/%& *' +95(4 *"/* J"/* ;#*& -'.)& +, /, )**#%/,.#
lUsV ./,,'* 6# 3#*#%9+,#3 ', *"# 6/&+& '- +,-'%9/*+', %#*%+#0#3 -%'9
9#9'%4A 6)* %#E)+%#& /, /,/(4&+& '- "'J (#Q+./( #(#9#,*& /%# ),+-+#3 +,*'
5"','(';+./( &*%).*)%#& &5/,,+,; / 9)(*+ J'%3 )**#%/,.#> p!")&qA +,
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
41/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
40
(/,;)/;# .'95%#"#,&+', &4,*/.*+.A /,*+. /,3 5"','(';+./( ),+-+./*+',
5%'.#&& '5#%/*# .',.)%%#,*(4 /,3 +,*#%/.* *' &'9# #Q*#,*>m UW/;''%*A
KLLNA 5> ZMaV
F, &)9A *"# 3+&*+,.*+', 6#*J##, %+/(A &4,*/Q=-+%&* /,3 5/%/((#(A .',&*%/+,*=&/*+&-/.*+', 9'3#(& ./, 6# -'),3 +, *"# (+*#%/*)%# ', ,#)%'.';,+*+0# /&5#.*& '-
(/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,;> F "/0# +,*%'3).#3 K #9+,#,* 9'3#(&A ,/9#(4A P%+#3#%+.+h&
G#)%'.';,+*+0# 9'3#( '- /)3+*'%4 ,*#,.# 5%'.#&&+,; /,3 W/;''%*h& B#9'%4A
H,+-+./*+', /,3 8',*%'( 9'3#(> P%+#3#%+.+ /&&+;,& &4,*/.*+. /,3 /,*+.
5%'.#&&+,; &*#5& *' :72 .'95',#,*& /,3 *"#+% *+9# J+,3'J&> W/;''%* /(&'
%#(/*#& &5#.+-+. :72 .'95',#,*& *' "+& 9'3#( 6)* ;+0#& *"#9 / 0#%4 3+--#%#,*
-),.*+',/( +,*#%5%#*/*+',>F,*#%#&*+,;(4A 6'*" 9'3#(& (#/0# / 5'&&+6(# +,-()#,.# '- 5%'&'34 ', /,*+. /,3
&4,*/.*+. 5%'.#&&+,; %/*"#% 0/;)#> !"+& (#/3& *' *"# E)#&*+',< J"/* :72 #0+3#,.#
+& *"#%# *"/* 5%'&'34 +,-()#,.#& #&5#.+/((4 &4,*/.*+. 5%'.#&&+,;1
T0#% *"# 5/&* Md 4#/%&A %#/%." "/& 6##, 3',# *' / ;%#/* #Q*#,* *' /33%#&& *"#
%'(# / 5%'&'3+. 6'),3/%4 5(/4& 3)%+,; (/,;)/;# 5%'.#&&+,;> 8'99',(4A ('./(
&*%).*)%/( /96+;)+*+#& &)." /& #/%(4 0> (/*# .('&)%# /96+;)+*+#& /%# ) *' (''O /*
*"# +,-()#,.# '- 5%'&'34 ', &4,*/.*+. 5%'.#&&+,; UC*#+,"/)#% #* /(>A Mbbbj RS;#(&A
KLMMj 2/)O#% #* /(>A KLMMV> D, #Q/95(# '- &)." /, /96+;)+*4 +& UMcV */O#, -%'9
C*#+,"/)#%A Mbbb #* /(> UMbbbV<
E:[F (; !0.0" 10"$=",45. 3))( \+ ("-0,.0) ] +)% %($ U+0"# \+ =+.\0);
!0.0" ="#6,$0$ 3))( .# @#"N ] ()% .# 4*0() .50 #TT,40;
-; !0.0" 10"$=",45. ] 3))( \+ 0).*($.0) ] +)% %($ U+0"# \+ =+.\0);
!0.0" ="#6,$0$ ] .# $+==#". 3))( ] ()% .# 4*0() .50 #TT,40;
4; !0.0" 10"$=",45. ] 3))( \+ ("-0,.0) ] +)% %($ U+0"# \+ =+.\0);
!0.0" ="#6,$0$ ] 3))( .# @#"N ] ()% .# 4*0() .50 #TT,40;
F, *"# I#%9/, ,*#,.#&A / *#95'%/%4 &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*4 +& .%#/*#3 /* *"# -+%&*
0#%6 10"$=",45. > F* +& ),.(#/% J"#*"#% *"# 0#%6 */O#& / ?/*+0# '6[#.* U*' 5%'9+
&'9#6'34 U3/*+0# '6[#.*V &'9#*"+,; F '% / ,*#,.# .'95(#9#,* U*' 5%'9+
&'9#*"+,;V>
-
8/18/2019 2014 Zahn Phd
42/216
!"#$#%& ()% !*(+$,-,*,.& ,) /0*(.,10 2*(+$0 3..(4560). 7 7 7 8(),0*( 9(5)
41
!"# .',3 0#%6 U("-0,.0) E:[ (F 1; 0).*($.0) E:[ -FF 3+&/96+;)/*#& *"#
*#95'%/%4 &4,*/.*+. /96+;)+*4> 8%).+/((4A *"# /6,.# UMc /V '% 5%#,.# UMc 6V
'- / 6'),3/%4 U]F /-*#% *"# 0#%6 10"$=",45. +& &)55' *' .)# *"# .'%%#.*
+,*#%5%#*/*+', 5%'&'3+./((4 6#-'%# &4,*/.*+. '% /,*+. 9#/,& .'9# +,*' 5(/4>!' (''O /* *"# +,*#%/.*+', '- 5%'&'3+./((4 .)#3 +,*#%5%#*/*+', /,3 &4,*/.*+. t
/,*+. 3+&/96+;)/*+',A / 9+&9/*." 6#*J##, 5%'&'3+. .)# U/6,.# 0>
5%#,.# '- *"# 5/)V /,3 &4,*/.*+. '% /,*+. 3+&/96+;)/*+', .)# ./, 6# )
UMc .V>
`"#, -+%&* )&+,; &)." /, /96+;)+*4 +, I#%9/,A C*#+,"/)#% #* /(> UMbbbV -'),3 /
GZLL t 2cLL 5/**#%, /* *"# 5'+,* '- 3+&/96+;)/*+', U("-0,.0) 0> 0).*($.0)V> !"#4
+,*#%5%#*#3 *"# %#&)(*& /& / %#-(#.*+', '- (#Q+./( %#=/..#&& *' .',-+%9 *"#0+'(/*+', '- *"# 0#%6h& /%;)9#,* &*%).*)%# UGZLLV /,3 /& &*%).*)%/( %#0+&+',
U2cLLV>
RS;#(& UKLMMV ) / &+9+(/% #/%(4 0> (/*# .('&)%# /96+;)+*4 +, ?)*."> C"# .')(3
%#5(+./*# *"# GZLL /* *"# 5'+,* '- 3+&/96+;)/*+', -'% ,*#,.#& .',*/+,+,; /
9+&5(/.#3 5/) 6)* ,' 2cLL J/& '6%0#3>