0)' 1) 23'4 &*56*7 8)%$)9 &*:*;
TRANSCRIPT
!"#$ &! '# ()*+,- &.! /0)12 &34)50-)6 7,)89:;<= 7,)8>?@
!"#$% &'()'(*+ ',-./0)'1) 23'4" &*56*7 8)%$)9 &*:*;/ <(*/ '(
ABC)6D/)2 EFGHIJ6IAAKLMN4 OP)QR1S,
AAAT*1U4 TFVL,
'#WXW#%YZL[\= '#W!W!. Y]@)[0C
(IL[I C)?*^I W TU^I; -0I _L4 W T@L?, K):`)QaIC0I; K)b)cV W R,D0C KL6IL6)4
=!,>?!"#$" %&' !()(* +#'"#',- .)/! 0 12* 3*4/! 5" .6*,) !"#$" 789 1:-(:; 3*4/! <=5(>3*4/!#? /,@A" 3=#B C/3A D="E$" F)(* +#'"#',- D="E$" "#=5 G3HI1* J&K(> "/ .6*,)1$#L* +,MN,I F&I#> 0 O3P QRSI(T U,>3VWX 1$#L* D@I,' +,MN,I +,Y,Z> D="E$" 0#' 3*4/! +#'"#',- #&[\> 19/#' .' #Y,] .6T,^* Q%="#',H' _3M!`* #&&a> "/ 1>"!/"0 0 12B"!O!,bc9" ,' O3P1=,9,HP d3* _!5"!#?1* efghiefje O/0! /! k"#=" 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0+#'"#',- #&ac* Q%&Vl> m=,c- n,9"#' _!(P1* !/04#' RVARX +/"!#' k(&9#o/!(B p0/ 5"+#'"#',- DM,I ,' Q<A"0/! _q9" .cP"! 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 #' `crs* #&[\> Q+3*4/!QtB"! 3&T(> 1$#L* +,MN,I 5" O!,bc9" .' t=,V> Q3*4/! <=5(> q&6Y0 !(r8' 0 +3*4/!
_k"#=" Qk"3VM Q,H&9`2W(' O3u@-"! Q`W,Vc)" v(2W 0 !,LcA" O3u@-"! Q!,LcA" O0#o /,&@-"! [email protected][email protected] _k"3VM Q,H&9 12W(' O,:@-"! 1W,Vc)" v(2W 0 !,LcA" O3u@-"! /,=!,c9" _ww
_k"#=" Qk"3VM Q,H&9`2W(' O,:@-"! Q`W,Vc)" v(2W 0 !,LcA" O3u@-"! Q!,LcA" x"#cI! x(y@-"! [email protected]
_C,r>,u* d(z{* Qx!,'4O,P t|bT"('"
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; !
16A"0 5/" }#- Q%&H~VM _!(P`* .c9,I 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 k"E&* 5" 0 .c$,= D="E$"�T,B,- 3&T(> _q9" `bH* p#[" 0 .cP"! 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 #' "/ #&[\> %=#>D&'
_q9" .cP"! 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 #' x/"!,H6* 0 qrs* #&[\> E&- 12B"!
.F13, H23, O24 :JEL BR867cde
%<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
!"#!0 1-,8) +,M/"5,' /! /(|] 3M!1* k,@- .69(>d,]/! +,M/(@I 5" +/,&{' .'#y>.69(> +"#' 1r9,H* +,@:M"/ #&B" .M! 3H; /! Q1)/,B C/,y> +,Mq=E* 5" x3H*O#8'19#c9! .2V) 5" J2cl* t=N! .' Qk"#=" /! _q9" O!(' .69(>d,]/! +,M/(@I +!,LcA"qT0! +(9 5" v,Bqb- /03K /,L�-" Qv,B qb- /03K 5" tK,] +5/" <',H* .' k,94Dl' Qk4 .' .c{'"0 +,M/,L�-" E&- 0 qT0! �9(> 1)/,B C/,y> O3VW Dl' v,y-" 0`-(o,-(o C�u@* Q.y&c- /! 0 .c$,&- .69(> Qk,*5 +,M5,&- ,' F9,Hc* Q1)/,B C/,y>+5/" +,M3*4/! DM,I Fr9 .' k,P1T,Vc]" 3=3@> 0 C�u@* %=" 50#' _q9" O3*4 3=3?1-,o/5,' Dl' .' /(@I kN(z{* .)(> D="E$" �W,' QO3H=4 /! qb- /03K 5" tK,]
_q9" O3P 1)/,B1cb- +,M3*4/! .' k"#=" C"!/"0 qbo k"(>1* Qk"#=" C"!/"0 3-0/ q&6Y0 n,9"#'qV&A 0 .cP"! 1r{- C,r[ qb- /"5,' Q1*�9" ��Z-" +50#&? 5" trA _!/"! +3=3P 1:c{'"0.' 0/ +3-0/ O/"(VM 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 Qn,9" %=" #' _!(' D="E$" .' 0/ E&- k4�(H> 0 3P/ <-,* Q7I,] 1o!5�#L* 0 1r2��(H> 0 5,' +,M/! q9,&9 0 .cP"! D="E$"1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 QE&- 1*�9" ��Z-" +50#&? 5" 36' _3P C"/!,K 0 C"3&T(>t&T!.' _q$#o /"#A qb- 1-,8) /"5,' 0 /(@I +!,LcA" 0 19,&9 CN(�> �,6@T"q�>1-,8) /"5,' 1-,8o,- 0 <=#9 CN(�> Q12&V�> �H) Q122VT"%&' 19,&9 +,M/,@$ !()0.I !,VcW" t',A 0 C,r[,' 3*4/! %cP"! 5" /(@I Q1)/,B 0 12B"! C�u@* #=,9 0 qb-
e_3P v0#�* Q3P,' C"!/"0 .69(> �&�K .*,-#' O3HHI%&V|>C"/!,K 5" tK,] +5/" +,M3*4/! .' /(@I 1T(? .=,? 1:c{'"0 t&T! .' (9 �= 5" .crT"!(9 }#- Q!EVc9! }#- .2V) 5" 3&T(> t*"(W qV&A +/(c9! %&&6> Q#:=! x(9 5" 0 qb-qV&A ,' C,*3B 0 N,I qV&A 3P/ �,r^-" v3W Q%&H~VM 0 .$#6> }#- Q5/" }#- Q1u-,'!,LcA" /! q',[ #&:'!EVc9! 0 �(Z] /,@A" 3=#B C/3A DM,I 3M,P Q3&T(> t*"(W `B#'qbo k"(>`* Q%&H~VM _3-51* %*"! +3*4/! �,uP D="E$" .' #*" %=" 0 O!(' k"#="
0 O!(r- 7M"#$ 1K(LB Dl' .69(> C,*"ET" .I 1^="#P /! 1cb- 5/" 3] 5" D&' �=/E>
_Refh�X k,&'"#8* 0 Dlr]#$ _e
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; "
O3P�=/E> 5/" 3-"(c- +!,LcA" C,r[1' +,|$ t&T! .' +/"�o.=,*#9 0 +3&T(> +,Mq&T,6$�-,' 1)/,B +,M1="/"! D="E$" 0 +EI#* �-,' �9(> 5/" 3=#B .' #yH* Q3HI ��) "/+/"�o.=,*#9 Qv/(> }#- D="E$" ,' _!(P1* v/(> q=,8- /! 0 d(? 7y] Q1T(? .=,? Q+EI#*0 �(Z] /,@A" 3=#B C/3A Q%="#',H' _3HHI1* 3P/ 3T(*#&� +,Mq&T,6$ 0 .c$,= DM,I`B#' .-(o%=" 0 Q3',=1* D="E$" .6*,) +3*4/! �,uP 0 .c$,= DM,I .6*,) #&:'!EVc9!.69(> .Ik4 t&T! .' 1^="#P %&H; /! _3-(P1* #>#&Z$ 50/.'50/ `B#' 0 #>1H� 50/.'50/"�T Qq{&- ___0 1cb- +,M3*4/! d,-,I 5" O3P�=/E> +,Y,Z> ,' F9,Hc* 3T(* +,Mq&T,6$_3',=`* D="E$" `$#L* xN,I C"!/"0 Q,MqV&A /,8* 0 ,Y,Z> 0 .Y#W �,uP DM,I x"#'3=#B C/3A D="E$" F)(* +#'"#',- D="E$" Qk"#=" /! 39/`* #�-.' Q#&9,b> %=" ,'O3P R1>"!/"0 SI(T U,>3VWX 1$#L* D@I,' +,MN,I +,Y,Z> D="E$" 0 3*4/!#? /,@A"DM,I ,' Q#:=! x(9 5" _3M!`* #&&a> "/ 1>"!/"0 0 12B"! 1$#L* +,MN,I F&I#> 0Qq9" N,' #@A %=" �#L* .' 1=,8- t&* k(; Q"#Z$ 3*4/! �^9 D="E$" 0 +3*4/! +#'"#',-,' .6*,) Q%="#',H' _3',=`* D="E$" �,P(? 0 �"/(B 3H-,* +/0#Y +,MN,I +"#' ,Y,Z>!(P`* k"#r) tB"! /! #>D&' 3&T(> �=#� 5" "/ k4 5" 1@l' .I O3P 0/.'0/ ,Y,Z> !"5,*
_e3',=`* DM,I C"!/"0 x"#' ,Y,Z> 0+!,LcA" 3P/ 12K" �0#P 5" 1u= "/ 3*4/! #'"#',- <=5(> Q+!,LcA" C,=#�- 1B#'#'"#' 3*4/! <=5(> .~-,H; 0 q{&- 1-3P�,rP" �,Vc)" %&=,? #@A +,M5,&- "#=5 3H-"!1*+,M#@A .I1>/(K/! Q3HHI1* N,I 3=#B �#K "/ !(B 3*4/! v,V> %&=,? +,M#@A Q3P,'.~-,H; 0 _3HHI`* 5"3-"S? "/ k,P3*4/! !"5,* 0 O!#I �#�#' "/ !(B .&T0" +,M5,&- N,'Q.=#�- %=" k,bT,l* !,ZcW" .' ,*" _f0 �_!(P1* <=#{> +!,LcA" 3P/ Q3P,' #'"#',- 3*4/! <=5(>.$,Y" <*"() %=" k"3HV>0#[ 3M!`* k,@- .c$,&- .69(> +,M/(@I /! .'#y> .Ik4 q{l-v0! _3HHI1* SI(T 0 12Vy> +,MN,I 3=#B �#K k!#I 5"3-"S? +,).' "/ k,P3*4/!/! #*" %=" 0 O3P ,Mk4 +/0O#8' DM,I 0 1-,V{) J6Y �W,' "#Z$ 7I 3*4/! Q.I%=""#Z$ 3*4/! D="E$" Q.I%=" v(9 _!(P1* C"!/"0 D="E$" 0 3&T(> k"E&* DM,I �W,' O3H=4
_Refj�X k"/,uVM 0 x!,'4 O,P _e2. O. Galor (2000); 707.
_e��� GRefhfX k,8'50/ _f
# %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
�W,' !(B .'(-.' #*" %=" 0 O3P tB"! 3&T(> +/0#Y +,MN,I +"#' ,Y,Z> D="E$" �W,'�W,' 3*4/! #'"#' <=5(> Qq=,8- /! 0 _!(P`* C"!/"0 DM,I 0 3&T(> Qd,acP" D="E$".6T,^* Q%="#',H' _e!(P1* +!,LcA" .69(> /! qI/,@* +"#' !"#$" 1-"0/ +,MOE&:-" D="E$"
�q9" #=5 �#P .' #Y,] _!/"! /"!,H6* 0 qrs* #[" k"#=" 1$#L* C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' +3*4/! +#'"#',-
C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> 0 3*4/! +#'"#',- k,&* .^'"/ 19/#' QDM0�? 12K" �3M Q%="#',H'�&Z�> +#�- 1-,r* .�"/" .' .*"!" /! _q9" efje ,> efgh O/0! /! k"#=" 1$#L* +,MN,IO/,P" .H&*5 %=" /! O3Pv,y-" 1'#y> C,6T,^* 1B#' .' v0! qV{A /! 0 O3P .cB"!#?.' v/,8; qV{A 0 !5"!#?1* �&Z�> 19,HPp0/ 0 d3* .�"/" .' v(9 qV{A _!(P`*+3H'<V) FT,^* E&- k,=,? /! _!/"! �,LcB" m=,c- t&2�>0 .=Ey> 0 d3* k(*54 �],r*
_!(P`* .�"/" 1c9,&9 +,M.&K(> 0 O3P
$%&'( *(+,! -.3-#&o 1* #�- /! "/ �5,' !,LcA" g%V�2M 0 v�$ 0 fn(>(* 0 1T,* QR����X n(>(* 0 1V&{>,I+N,I +#:=! 0 R!X +/,y>#&� %:VM +N,I 1u= G!(P1* .T!,r* N,I �(- 0! k4 /! .I
_!(P1* .T!,r* ,M/(@I #=,9 ,' .I RYX +!(VW E=,Vc* %:VM1r{- q=E* QRq2X E=,Vc* q&b&I 7I +,MN,I 3&T(> /! �3r* /(@I !(P1* �#$ "3c'"+,M.H=EM 0 O!(' tA"3] Q12B"! k,o3HHI3&T(> +"#' N,I %=" +3&T(> +,M.H=EM 1H6= _!/"!%V�2M 0 v�$ 0 �k50/ _q9" tA"3] 1)/,B k,o3HHI3&T(> +"#' Qq&b&I,' +N,I +3&T(>
_e�e GRef�hX tu=,* Q0/"!(> _eDl' !,LcA" O0#o 3&>,9" 5" 1V&{>,I _q9" R����X n(>(* 0 1V&{>,I .6T,^* 5" .c$#o#' +#�- 1-,r* qV{A _�Dl' !,LcA" .H&*5 /! +/,&{' C,Z&Z�> k(HI,> 0 q9" %>4 C/,y> 0 !,LcA" O,:@-"! t2VT"%&' !,LcA" C,6T,^*O,:@-"! !,LcA" O0#o !,c9" E&- 1-,-(= n(>(* _q9" O!"! v,y-" k�I !,LcA" 0 /,I !,LcA" Q19,&9 !,LcA" Q1*(VW5" 19,&9 !,LcA" 0 t2VT"%&' !,LcA" Qk�I !,LcA" .H&*5 /! +/,&{' C,b&T\> 0 CN,Z* 0 O!(' %>4 C/,y> 0 !,LcA"!,LcA" k(; 190/! S=/3> .' O,:@-"! t2VT"%&' !,LcA" C,6T,^* Dl' /! k(HI"7M +0 _q9" .cP"�o +,) #' !(B
_q9" d(a@* +!,LcA" k�I +,Mq9,&9 0 t2VT"%&' C/,y> Qt2VT"%&' .&T,* Qk�I3. Malley and Katsimi (2003).4.. Flam and Helpman (1987).5. Open Economy.6. Rosen (1974).
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; $
#�- 5" E=,Vc* +,MN,I .I1T,]/! Q3-#&o 1* #�- /! 7&{Z> t',A "/ %:VM +N,I Rejh�X%=" /! _3HHI �#L* "/ k,P�(- �= ,8H> 3H-"(>1* ,M/"(-,B 0 3-"7&{Z> t',A#&� Qq&b&I
�3=4 1* q9!.'ReX .^'"/ 5" i /"(-,B q&'(2^* <',> QC/(K
Ui"#i$"%&!i Re
O3P�#L* %:VM +N,I /"3Z* !i QRq2 0 q1X J2cl* +,MN,I q&b&I Q Qk4 /! .I�#$ "3c'" Q%&H~VM _3M!1* k,@- "/ Q +"#' i /"(-,B 1r{- q=E* #i 0 i /"(-,B �9(>_RyL Q3*4/!7I 0 yH Q3*4/!#?X !/"! !()0 !,LcA" /! +3*4/! �^9 0! ,8H> !(P1*3*4/!7I +,M/"(-,B q&6Y0 0 O!(' i /"(-,B 3*4/! +/,LcB" q*�W k"(HW.' yi Q%&H~VM#=5 C/(K.' Qym Q3*4/! %&:-,&* _!(P1* %&&6> k +/,LcB" 7��W �9(> E&- Q!,LcA" /!
�!(P1* %&&6>
ym=kyL+(1-k)yH R�
3*4/! 5" 16',> C/(K.' +3*4/! %&=,? 0 N,' �(^9 Qek({H&'"/ 0 (2�0" 794 ,' ,c9"#VM�!(P1* .c$#o #�- /! +#'"#',- �^90 �9(c*
yH ='()1-k ym Rf
yL =)k ym Rg
DM,I +#'"#',- Q) RDM,IX D="E$" ,' 0 q9" +3*4/! +#'"#',- /,&6* #:-,&' k>) C/,rW�#L* q1 1>"!/"0 +N,I Q3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B v,V> .I%=" �#$,' _q$,= 3M"(B RD="E$"X
�,' !(' 3M"(B #'"#' 3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B .)!(' 3&A Q3HHI
yH"!H+q1 R�
�,' !(P`* #'"#' 3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B +"#' %:VM +N,I +,Y,Z> q&'(2^* #sI"3] Qq=,8-/!
1. Acemoglu and Robinson (2005).
% %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
XH=yH- q1 R�
<',> k,P�#L* .I 3HI �#L* q2 ,= q1 q9" %uV* 3*4/!7I /"(-,B �= Q%="#',H'"/ 12B"! q&b&I 7I +N,I 3*4/!7I /"(-,B #o" 0 q9" # k,VM ,= /"(-,B .Z&29 #c*"/,?
�,' !(P`* #'"#' .)!(' 3&A Q!#l'
yL" !i- q2 R�
�,' !(P1* #'"#' Q!#l' "/ ,M/(@I #=,9 +N,I #o" 0
yL" !i- q1 Rh
,Y,Z> 5" 1P,- q&'(2^* #sI"3] Q3HI �#L* "/ tB"! 3&T(> +N,I /"(-,B #o" Q%&H~VM�,' q9" #'"#' %:VM +N,I +"#'
XLD = yL- q2 Rj
�,' !(P1* #'"#' ! +"#' ,Y,Z> Q3HI �#L* "/ ,M/(@I #=,9 +3&T(> +N,I #o" 0
XLF = yL- q1 Re�
,Y,Z> Q%="#',H' Qq9" N,' 1$,I O5"3-" .' Q,M/"(-,B v,V> 3*4/! .I q9" %=" #' �#$ k(; 07&Zc{*#&� q&'(2^* <'"(> QC/(K %=" /! _RyL>q1 d,s* +"#'X q9" qrs* QN,I 0!#M +"#'
�3=4 1* q9!.' #=5 C/(K.' N,I 0! #M +"#' 3*4/!7I +,M/"(-,B +"#'
VLD = q2+ ln (yL-q2) Ree
VLF = q1+ ln (yL-q1) Re�+ ,V
LF -V
LD)
+# >0.^'"/ n,9"#' _!#B`* "/ �/,B 3&T(> +N,I i/"(-,B Q3P,'VLF >V
LD #o"
3H2=,* Q3-/"! +!,=5 C,�&)#> QQ +"#' .I 1=,Mk4 ,8H> Q3*4/!7I +,M/"(-,B %&' /!/"(-,B x"#' .I1>/(K/! _3-#l' QR!(P1* !/"0 ,M/(@I #=,9 5" .IX q&b&I ,' +N,I
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; &
<',> C/(K %=" /! Q3Hu- `A#$ �/,B 3&T(> 0 tB"! 3&T(> +N,I �#L* Q3*4/!7I�3=4 1* q9!.' #=5 C/(K.' /"(-,B %=" q&'(2^*
VLD " -.2+ ln (yL-q2/" -.1+ ln (yL-q1)=V
LF Ref
�qP"! 7&M"(B - n,9"#' RefX .T!,6* t] ,'
-H =ln (yL-q2) - ln (yL-q1)
q1-q2Reg
�3=4`* q9!.' #=5 .^'"/ E&- RfX .T!,6* 5" yL+/"�:=,) ,' 0+-+) =
-ym
0 ,)1m-kq1/,)1m-q2)
<0 Reg
+,M/"(-,B qr{- QR) DM,IX 3*4/! +#'"#',- �^9 D="E$" ,' QRegX .T!,6* n,9"#'Q%&H~VM _3',=1* DM,I Q3-#l' q&b&I ,' 1>"!/"0 +N,I 3-#&o1* 7&VL> .I 3*4/!7IQq&b&I 1' 0 q&b&I,' +,M.c{' %&' "3c'" /! +3*4/! #>N,' �(^9 /! .I 1=,M/"(-,BQq&b&I 1' 1>"!/"0 +N,I .' q&b&I,' +N,I 5" k,@=,Y,Z> #&&a> ,' d,] Q3-!(' C0,b>1'+3*4/!7I +,M/"(-,B qr{- qB"(Hu= <=5(> n,9"#' _3-/041* q9!.' +#>N,' q&'(2^*p5/" Q%="#',H' _ 2(-
b-a,' q9" #'"#' Q3HHI1* �,lc-" "/ �/,B 3&T(> +,MN,I �#L* .I
�,' q9" #'"#' C"!/"0 7y] 16A"0M=[k 2(-
b-a+(1-k)]q1 Re�
ym �9(c* 3*4/! `cA0 +#'"#',- /,&6* /! C"#&&a> #[" %c$,= +"#' k"(>1* Re�X .T!,6* 5"3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B 3*4/! D="E$" QqZ&Z] /! _!#I O!,bc9" !(P1* .cP"! .:- q',[�#L* ¡b] .' trA 5" #>D&' k(HI" ,M/"(-,B %=" "#=5 Q!/"3- C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' +#[" ¢&M
�.y&c- /! G3-".c$,= t=,V> q&b&I,' 1>"!/"0 +,MN,I+3+) =
q1k(b-a) £
+-+) > 0 Re�
+,Y,Z> ,> 3-(P1* �=#�> Q3*4/!7I +,M/"(-,B 1B#' QR)L DM,IX +#'"#',- D="E$" ,'R- D="E$"X 3HM! �(9 q&b&I 1' 12B"! +N,I x(9 .' "/ q&b&I,' 1>"!/"0 +N,I 5" !(B
_3',=1* DM,I C"!/"0 +"#' ,Y,Z> 0
' %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
qr{- Q3HI 3&T(> Q/(@I !(B "/ +!(VW E=,Vc* d(L�* q&b&I#? �(- #o" d,]_!(P1* -(4
(b-a)#'"#' 3-#&o1* 12B"! +N,I �#L* .' 7&VL> .I +3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B
�,' q9" #'"#' C"!/"0 7y] 16A"0 p5/" QC/(K %=" /!M= k -(4
(b-a)q2 Reh
+N,I �#L* .' "/ ,Mk4 Q3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B 3*4/! D="E$" .I q9" k4 x,H6* .' %=" /! q&b&I,' +N,I %=" k(HI" 7M "#=5 Q3M!`V- �(9 RSI(T U,>3VWX 1>"!/"0 1$#L*
�3=4`* q9!.' RejX .^'"/ q=,8- /! _!(P1* 3&T(> tB"!+3+) =
kq0
b-a £+-+) < 0 Rej
3-#&o 1* 7&VL> 3*4/!#? +,M/"(-,B 1B#' QR) DM,IX 3*4/! +#'"#',- D="E$" v,:HM_3HM! �(9 Q12B"! q&b&I ,' +N,I qV9 .' q&b&I 1' 1>"!/"0 +N,I 5" "/ k,P+,Y,Z>
_3',=1* DM,I C"!/"0 +"#' ,Y,Z> Q.y&c- /!"/,uP4 Qq9" `uc* `cb- +,M3*4/! .' qT0! 3*4/! `2K" k50 .I `=,M!,LcA" /! .crT"�/,l* D="E$" x"#' +#>D&' k,u*" qT0! .' Qqb- C0#[ p0#$ 5" tK,] x,M5/" D="E$"p#c{o x(9.' "/ O3PtK,] x5/" x,M3*4/! qT0! .~-,H; _3M!`* !,LcA" q="3M 0�(9 x#=�?q',A/ C/3A D="E$" 0 k,&H'D-"! !,LcA" x5,9#c{' 0 3&T(> 3=3) t*"(W /"5,'O!,bc9" 0 #=�?3=3y> x,MC0#[ .' #=�?,-3=3y> x,MC0#[ t=3r> x,c9"/ /! 3-"(>`* Q3M!_!/"!#' `9,9" `*,o QC"!/"0 F&I#> #&&a> 0 x!"!"3B <',H* 5" .6*,) /,@A" v,V> #>d!,6c*.' "/ #=�?,-3=3y> x,MC0#[ p0#$ 5" tK,] x,M5/" 3-"(c- qT0! #o" Q#:=! �#� 5"C"!/"0 D="E$" 0 3*4/! x#'"#',- 0 `c-"/ qT0! 3M,P U,6^A Q3HI q=#=3* `�&�K tuP5" x/,&{' /! <',H* `-"0"#$ .T\{* .' .)(> ,' Q#:=! k,&' .' _!(' 7&M"(B SI(T x,MN,Ik3P �#^* ,' O�=0.' /"!t&L�> qT0! ,= /"(Bq-"/ qT0! 0 q-"/ O3=3? Q,M/(@Ik"3HV@=3-" 0 k"#:@M0�? .)(> !/(* /"(Bq-"/ x,MqT0! !,y=" t*,W k"(HW.' qb-0 %&&r> x"#' `c-"/ !,LcA" 0 qT0! C,=#�- k4 `? /! 0 .c$#o /"#A .6*,) 0 q9,&9 O5(]q-"/ 5" tK,] 3*4/! .' `uc* x,M/(@I /! x!,LcA" 0 `9,&9 `:c$,=.69(> k"3Z$ .&)(>x,M3*4/! .' ,u>" .I 3HHI`* dN3c9" %&H; Q�(Vy* /! C,=#�- %=" _q9" O3P O!,bc9"
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; "(
QqT0! qB,9 #' �(Y(* %=" !(P`* F)(* Q`cb- q-"/ O�=0.' 0 q-"/ 5" tK,] O!/04!,'_3P,' .cP"! x/,&{' `bH* x,M3*,&? /(@I !,LcA" #' q=,8- /! 0 .6*,) 0 qT0! �'"0/.&]0/ !(P`* F)(* `^="#P %&H; 3HHI`* �=#L> %&H~VM Q#&c-"/ qT0! k"5"!#?.=#�-x3H'#@A QJ&6|> qT0! `o3H=,V- q&M,* Q3=3@> .6*,) /! `="#o�#L* 0 `=()q-"/3*4/! x#'"#',- .I q9,yH=" /! _!(P t=3r> q-"/ O3HHI<=5(> .' qT0! 0 #&&a> `W,Vc)"x,MqT0! .'#y> _!(P`* #>D&' `>,Zr� �,uP 0 !(P`* #>O!#c{o .6*,) /,@A" k,&*O3H="E$ x,M5,&- .' `=(:l9,? x"#' U,*(VW ,MqT0! .-(o %=" .I q9" %=" 5" `I,] #&c-"/0 !"(* O!#c{o C"!/"0 .' `H6= 3-#&o`* D&? /! "/ /,I %=#>q]"/ 0 %=#>O!,9 Q.6*,)`2B"! /"5,' /! `>"!/"0 x,MN,I O!#c{o /(|] _3-(P`* t9(c* .6*,) 5,&- !/(* x,MN,I%*"! .6*,) /! "/ `="#o�#L* .&]0/ 7M 0 3-5`* .'#Y `2B"! k,o3HHI3&T(> .' 7M`W(- k3P 7I,] k"(HW q�> J2cl* FcI /! .I q9" xE&; k,VM �(Y(* %=" 0 3-5`*O5,> .6*,) O3H="E$ x,M,Y,Z> x,Y/" x"#' #&c-"/ qT0! Q%="#',H' _!(P`* �#^* `c-"/ .&]0/_e3=,V-`* `="�� !"(* 0 SI(T x,MN,I O�=0 .' !,=5 C"!/"0 .' v"3A" .{&I(- O3P3HV>0#[
_3P 3M"(B `$#L* x,MN,I C"!/"0 D="E$" .' #yH* x3*4/! x#'"#',- D="E$" "�2$x,MN,I C"!/"0 0 `Z&Z] 5/" }#- .^'"/ !0/`* /,�c-" x/(z> #�- 5" Q%=" #' O0�WC"!/"0 0 `2B"! �T,B,- 3&T(> .^'"/ 0 �O!(' +53
+6!<0 `H6= n(u6* .^'"/ �= Q `$#L*
_ f3P,' +53+7
>0`H6= 7&Zc{* 0 qrs* .^'"/ �= E&- `$#L* x,MN,I
*/&01 2+34+5! -$q9" .c$#o C/(K C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> O3HHI%&&6> t*"(W !/(* /! +/,&{' C,6T,^* k(HI,>0 1Z&Z] 3*4/! 5" 16',> "/ C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> Q.H&*5 %=" /! 1'#y> C,6T,^* #>D&' ,*"C"!/"0 +3*4/! 0 1cV&A +,MD@I E&- C,6T,^* 5" +!,=5 /,VP _3H-"!1* 1r{- +,MqV&A.^'"/ 5" +3M"(P 3-"O3&P(I E&- #&B" C,6T,^* 5" +/,&{' _3-"O!"! /"#A 1',=5/" !/(* "/16*,) C,6T,^* k(HI,> ,*" Q3H',&' 1Z&Z] 5/" }#- 0 3*4/! QC"!/"0 �(^9 k,&* C3*3H2'
_RefhjX k,=3V]" 0 !"�-`2|$ _e_��� � GRef��X k({-"#' 0 Refh�Xk"/,uVM 0 +!,'4d�) QRefh�X k"/,uVM 0 1-"(28? _�
_R���fX �-,> 0 R���gX %=3T"#L- 0 ¤&T! QR��e�X /(u@* 0 x,M QR��e�X 1-,�&- 0 E=/4 _f
") %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
.bT¥* E&- +3*4/! +#'"#',- .I1T,]/! Qq9" O3@- v,y-" +3*4/! +#'"#',- #&[\> .H&*5 /!O3=!,- qbo k"(c' 3=,P _q9" 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',> +"#' `V8* /,&{'+(A 1M"(o .�"/" /! 12rA C,6T,^* q{uP t=N! 5" 1u= +#'"#',- �^9 q=!03�* %c$#o
_q9" C3*3H2' C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',> C,r[ +"#'CN,=" C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' 3*4/! +#'"#',- #[" 19/#' .' R��eeX n(>(* 0 1V&{>,I#' `8)(>t',A 0 qrs* #&[\> +#'"#',- 3-3Zc6* 0 .cB"!#? ���� ,> ejgh O/0! /! 3�c*�= ,8H>.- Qk,@=" !,ZcW" .' %&H~VM _!/"! RC,*3B C"!/"0 +,Hsc9" .'X C"!/"0 +,Y,Z>.u2' Q!/"! !()0 +#'"#',- 0 1r{- +,MqV&A Q3*4/! QC"!/"0 %&' C,r[,' C3*3H2' .^'"/
_!/"! N,I C"!/"0 #' +"O3HHI%&&6> #&[\> E&- +#'"#',-/(@I f� C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' +#'"#',- /! C"#&&a> 1'#y> q&VM" E&- ek"/,uVM 0 v"!4+#'"#',- 3-!"! k,@- 0 O!#I `9/#' Rejh�iejj�X O/0! /! "/ .c$,=.69(> 0 .69(>d,]/!O3HHI%&&6> 0 qrs* #[" #:-,&' %&H~VM m=,c- _!/"! C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' 18)(>t',A #&[\>1bH* #&[\> 0 R.-"#9X 3*4/!#? +,M/(@I 1>"!/"0 SI(T +,MN,I +,Y,Z> #' +#'"#',-
_q9" 3*4/!7I +,M/(@I /! N,I C"!/"0 #' +#'"#',-,u=#*" C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',> #' +3*4/! +#'"#',- #[" 19/#' .' R����X n(>(* 0 1V&{>,I3HcP"! !,ZcW" R����X %&P 0 g%&P 0 k(c{-,) Qf3&* Q�%2= 0 5/ C"#�- ��B#' 3-3Zc6* 0 .cB"!#?/! +3H*q',A/ 0 3*4/! QtI C"!/"0 %&' C3*3H2' .^'"/ !()0 +"#' 1I/3* 0 1M"(o ¢&M
+,MqV&A Q3*4/! QC"!/"0 %&' C,r[,' C3*3H2' .^'"/ �= ,8H>.- 0 Q!/"3- !()0 O3�c* CN,="_3-/"! k,W¦" E&- C"!/"0 #' +#'"#',- .�]�* t',A #&[\> .' .u2' !/"! !()0 +#'"#',- 0 1r{-
+,MO!"! 5" O!,bc9" ,' "/ p!�:H' !,LcA" +"#' tI C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',> �/(u@* 0 x,MqV&A QC"!/"0 C3*3H2' .^'"/ Qk,@=" %&Vl> m=,c- _3-"O!#I 19/#' ���h ,> ejh� d,9QC3*3H2' +!,LcA" 3P/ q&9,{] 3M!`* k,@- 0 O!#I 3&=\> "/ +!,LcA" 3P/ 0 1r{-
_q9" O!(' Ri�8�jX 1bH* QC3*3H2' /! 1r{- qV&A q&9,{] 0 R�8jfX qrs*
1. Adam et al. (2008).2. Rose and Yellen (1989).3. Meade (1992).4. Johnston and Chinn (1996).5. Hye and Mashkoor (2010).
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; "!
0 .=#y&- Q,&HI 1=,Z=#$" /(@I .9 /! C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> /,c$/ 19/#' .' e1-,�&- 0 E=/41r{- +,MqV&A Q1Z&Z] 3*4/! C3*3H2' 0 C3*O,>(I C"#[" 0 .cB"!#? `'(H) +,Z=#$"+,MO!"! C/(K.' /(I�* FlcH* +,M/(@I 16A"0 C"!/"0 #' 1)/,B #=,B¦ 0 C"!/"0.' Q%&H~VM _3-"O!5 %&Vl> 0 O!#I `',=5/" "/ ���� ,> ej�f +,Md,9 12L$ 1-,*5 +#9#=,B¦ 0 C"!/"0 1r{- +,MqV&A Q1Z&Z] 3*4/! Q16A"0 C"!/"0 k,&* .I 3-3&9/ .y&c- %="
_!/"! !()0 `>3*3H2' .^'"/ Q+5/"t*"(W 19/#' .H&*5 /! O3Pv,y-" !36c* C,6T,^* !()0 ,' k"#=" /! k(HI,> .I,y-4 5"+,Y,Z> <',> #' +3*4/! +#'"#',- #&[\> O/,'/! 16*,) .6T,^* 5(HM QC"!/"0 O3HHI%&&6>
_!(P1* O/,P" ,Mk4 5" `B#' .' .*"!" /! "�T Qq9" O3@- v,y-" 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0C"!/"0 0 .cB"!#? k"#=" C"!/"0 /! #[¥* +,M.bT¥* 19/#' .' Refh�X 1-,c9,' 0 1H&u@>#�- /! 12* 3*4/! 0 1)/,B +,MqV&A �^9 Q12B"! +,MqV&A �^9 5" 16',> C/(K.' "/+,MN,I �&ub> .' C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <'"(> %&Vl> �3M ,' !(B .6T,^* /! k,@=" _3-#&o1*C3P.' 1$#L* +,MN,I C"!/"0 3-/"!`* k,&' Q+".^9"0 0 +".=,*#9 Q1$#L* 1>"!/"03&T(> #&[\>q�> +".^9"0 0 +".=,*#9 +,MN,I C"!/"0 0 O!(' 1r{- +,MqV&A #&[\>q�>
_q9" 1r{- +,MqV&A 0 12B"! �T,B,-+,Y,Z> <',> O3HM!t&u@> +,M#&ac* %&' C3*3H2' �,r>/" !()0 E&- RefhfX 182T"#L-+,MqV&A .' qr{- Qk"#=" C"!/"0 ,Y,Z> 3M!1* k,@- 0 O!#I 19/#' !3y* "/ k"#=" C"!/"0.I q9" 1T,]/! %=" 0 O!(' O"#VM D@I,' C3*O,>(I /! .; 0 C3*3H2' /! .; 1r{-C3*O,>(I /! 0 D@I,' C3*3H2' /! 12B"! 1Z&Z] 3*4/! .' qr{- C"!/"0 +"#' ,Y,Z>
_q9" D@I1't*"(W tI +/0O#8' #&[\> 1',=5/" .' .I q9" RefhfX +!,'4O,P �&Z�> Q#:=! .6T,^*k,@- x0 �&Z�> m=,c- _!5"!#?1* efh� ,> efgh O/0! /! k"#=" !,LcA" /! N,I C"!/"0 #'tI +/0O#8' 0 tB"! 3&T(> +,MN,I qV&A .' 1>"!/"0 +,MN,I qV&A �B,P 3M!`*qb- k03' 12B"! �T,B,- 3&T(> 0 N,I C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' `8)(>t',A 0 1bH* #&[\> Qt*"(W
_3-/"! N,I C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' 1crs* #[" Q1cb- +,M3*4/! 0
1. Ariz and Nippani (2010).
" %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
efgh ief�h O/0! /! "/ C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> #' #[¥* +,M.bT¥* QRefheX k,&'"#�* 0 1Z&$(>QtI C"!/"0 DM,I #' 18)(>t',A #[" Q1r{- +,MqV&A D="E$" 3-!"! k,@- 0 O!#I 1',=5/"#' +".�]�*t',A #[" qb- k03' 12B"! �T,B,- 3&T(> `T0 Q.cP"�o +".=,*#9 0 1$#L*
_!/"3- C"!/"0 J2cl* C,r&I#> 5" �=¢&M .6T,^* "/ k"#=" !,LcA" /! C3*3H2' 0 C3*O,>(I C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> Refh�X 1V@=#'"Qn,&Z* +,M#&ac* 0 1r{- +,MqV&A �"(-" #' 1Hcr* QC"!/"0 +,Y,Z> !/"!`* k,&' 0 O!#Im=,c- %=" ,*" _3HI %&&r> 1@l'q=,Y/ tuP .' "/ k"#=" !,LcA" /! C"!/"0 /,c$/ 3-"(>`V-.^'"/ Q+5/" +,Mq=!03�* �="#P /! C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> +(:T" �=#L> .I 3-"k4 #:-,&'
1r{- qV&AX �=#L> %=" /! k4 C3*3H2' O3HHI%&&6> t*"(W 0 C"!/"0 C3*3H2' 1T!,6>.c$#=�? q&6�,A ,' "/ RC"!/"0 +"#' +5/" #=,B¦ DP(? qr{- 0 1=,8- +,Y,Z> QC"!/"0_3M!1* �&Y(> 1'(2^* (�- .' "/ k"#=" !,LcA" /! C"!/"0 C3*O,>(I 0 C3*3H2' /,c$/ 0
efgh ief�� 1-,*5 O/0! /! k"#=" /! C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',> %&Vl> .' Ref�jX 7&Z*/(?12B"! �T,B,- 3&T(>X q&T,6$ �^9 #&ac* .' qr{- qV&A t*,W 3M!`* k,@- 0 .cB"!#?qT,] /! .y&c- %=" _!/"! +#>�-#VI DZ- C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',> /! QRC"/!,K +,8H*/! x"O3HHI%&&6> DZ- Q3*4/! t*,W Q12I/(�.' 0 q9" k,{u= C3*3H2' 0 C3*O,>(I
_!/"! k"#=" C"!/"0 +,Y,Z> <',>
!"#! %&"'( )*+,*- .!/0!1 )*+2344- 56678 9! )0*(: "#;'8 <=!"#$% &%'() *+,-./0,-123 45"6% !"#$% 7% 89: ;'() <6 ') &%=>45 %' ?@AB <CDAE5!"#$% 7% FCG <C6=> HIJK A> L(% MAN<5A$?G ( +,-1O0,-2O3 4PQRS> TJU ( 45"6%
V)?W 46'?G +,-2/0,-X,3 45"6%( ;)?W <G?I> %' FY') 2Z,1 F[' \?$ 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> ,-./0,-12 ;'() ')F$(' V_6% ;)=G M)=CY ;'%=RN *+,-12 ( ,-11 `ANLA6 aU<G3 aQ$ 4JQU bc?@ F$('dD(a$ ?ec) `ANLA6 ') *_[%) fc%ag% dWF$% <W ,-1h ( ,-.X `ANLA6 aU<G aQ$ 7'% \?$fc%ag% ic% <j?k% ( <lgAc fc%ag% ;'%=RN aQ$ dg?m5 `ANnAW o%)'%( *ic%?GAJG V_6% ;)=G') V_6% <l[%) M%<pB"58GA: fc%ag% *FCG <G ,-1q LA6 7% A5% )=9$ ?Qk Hrj ,-1q LA6 A>
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:;
AG M%<g?C> s$%=5 LA$AW 7% M'AI> _cARB MAN_6AQ6 tAu>% *,-1q LA6 7% 89: A> _#Q#BM%<g?C>?Qv s$%=5 ( )a5'AW w]% ( x'Ay6 _9z ;)?{6 *4$Ak'7AG )=6 *4W?Rk |=#B w]%)('( s$A5 *+AN7=I5 w]% ( M'(?@?Qv MANnAW 4]?G o%)'%( ?G AN_Q}=JR5 4]?G ?Qp$34K ') 4ly$ ~=[ �=:( AG *FCG <G ,-1q LA6 7% A5% VF[d5 '=rW <G ;F[<l]A6 MANnAWMANF5�') fc%ag% ( _y$ 4$A�U MAN_RQ: &F[ ?G%?G 'A�j ( 8Q�%?6% ( !%?}% TJUV_gAc fc%ag% aQ$ dg?m5 `ANnAW o%)'%( *M'AI> MAN_c)(FS5 �wB ( _D() M7'%
LA6 ') %FlG% *+,-1O0,-2O3 4PQRS> TJU ( 45"6% !"#$% �=:( ;'() ') A5%( &%?c% 45"6% !"#$% M7(?QK AG VHc%;)=G 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> fNAW FNA[ *,-1O*;F[L?lJW 45Ap$ _R6<G )%7� �Al9�$ �Ap$ �c 7% '=rW M'AI> ( d}ARlU% �Ap$ ?QQ�>�FY -O <G d5"6% !"#$% 7% 89: ;'() ') �FY .2 7% dJQU bc?@ ( `F5�') `?G%?GA$dC:%( 7'% \?$ *;'() iQRN ') V_gAc fNAW dPQRS> TJU ( d5"6% !"#$% ;'() '))=G dgAW �=@=5 iQRN VFQ6' LAc' -X.O <G LAc' O,h. 7% ( _[%) `FY') .. drNAWqqO1 <G ,-./0,-12 `ANLA6 ') 'n) &=QPQ5 ,h1q iQe$AQ5 7% &%?c% dg?m5 o%)'%( A><l9D% VFGAc fc%ag% +,-1O0,-2O3 dPQRS> TJU ( d5"6% !"#$% `ANLA6 ') 'n) &=QPQ5!"#$% MANLA6 ') dg?m5 `nAW o%)'%( FcF[ oA$A6=$ 8cn) 7% druG _yk &%=>454PQRS> TJU 7% 4[A$ )=W' *4ly$ MANF5�') oA$A6=$ 7% 4[A$ 4PQRS> TJU ( 45"6%
V_6% ;)=G &%?c% 45"6% M'=�RU <QP} 4PPRD%iQG MANHc?S> (fc%ag% FNA[ �c'F><G +,-2/0,-O-3 <C6=> L(% <5A$?G 7Av� ( 4PQRS> TJU �AR>% AG!"#$% &%'() ') LAc' )'AQPQ5 /-21X1 7% &� &%aQ5 <W`=S$<G *HQl�N dP]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=>?QQ�> dJQU bc?@ *;'() ic% ') VFQ6' <C6=> L(% <5A$?G ') LAc' )'AQPQ5 X1X-X, <G TJU (LAc' 2.qq H:' <G LAc' -X.O 7% `FY') 2h drc%ag% AG d#Q#B 7'% \?$ A5% _[%F$ d$%FJj') 7'% \?$ M7A6&A��c _6AQ6 `%?U% 8QD)<G 7'% \?$ fc%ag% ic% <l9D% VFQ6' ;'() 8W ')�(?[ AG V_gAc fc%ag% LAc' ,q2/ <G LAc' 21 7% dR6' 7'% \?$ ;'AG�c <G <W )=G ,-O, LA6LAR}% nAW o%)'%( ?G AN7=I5 �wB �c?� 7% <W M'AI> 7AG MAN_6AQ6 tAu>% ( M7A67AG&=QPQ5 -,O1 H:' A> ,-O, LA6 A> d>%)'%( dg?m5 `ANnAW <U=>8GA: fc%ag% FNA[ *F[45o%)'%( <U=>8GA: fc%ag% ( <5A$?G ic% M%?U% L=� ') _y$ _RQ: oA$A6=$ A5% VHQl�N 'n)_D() *ic%?GAJG VF[ Hl] '=rW 4U'A] MAN4NFG fc%ag% ( M'AI> 7%?> &F[ 4yJ5 <G nAW
! %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
M'AI> MAN_c)(FS5 *M%<g?C>?Qv ( `%<g?C> s$%=5 7% ;)Ayl6% AG *<5A$?G 4$AcAK MANLA6 ')-,O1 7% dg?m5 `ANnAW o%)'%( fNAW b96 ?5% ic% FJj?N V)?W s@( nAW o%)'%( ?G*F[ ,-O- ( ,-Oq MANLA6 ') 'n) &=QPQ5 ,.11 ( qq1h H:' <G ,-O, LA6 ') 'n) &=QPQ5
V_gAc fc%ag% 89: ;'() <G _9�$ ;'() 8W dg?m5 o%)'%( F$(' A5%X1X-X, 7% ( _gAc fc%ag% dP]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> +,-O.0,-O/3 <C6=> �() <5A$?G ')ic% ') `?G%?GA$ F$(' V_gAc fc%ag% LAc' )'AQPQ5 ,,-XX2X H:' <G 89: ;'() LAc' )'AQPQ5fNAW <G ( <l[%) '%?: `)=CY '%F5 ') &AJ�RN 7'% \?$ A5% *_[%F$ d$%FJj ?QQ�> aQ$ ;'()<5A$?G ') 'n) &=QPQ5 qhh2 <G L(% <5A$?G ') 'n) &=QPQ5 qO.- 7% dg?m5 o%)'%( ?QeRrj
VF[ ?IJ5 �();F[ �wB `%<g?C>?Qv s$%=5 �AR> F[ '?#5 *+,-OX0,-/-3 <C6=> �=6 <5A$?G M%?U% AG( M'AI> 7AG MAN_6AQ6 tAu>% MAl6%' ') *ic%?GAJG V)=[ s@( M%<g?C> s$%=5 *&� MAU<G (M'AQ�G o%)'%( &A�5% ( ;F[ �wB M%<g?C>?Qv s$%=5 7% M'AQ�G *4ly$ MANF5�') fc%ag%') 'n) &=QPQ5 qhh2 H:' 7% dg?m5 `ANnAW o%)'%( <W M%<$=k<G �F5� HN%?g ANnAW 7%FQD=> *;'() ic% ') VFQ6' �=6 <5A$?G `ANLA6 ') 'n) &=QPQ5 q-.h <G �() <5A$?G `ANLA6
VFJlgAc fc%ag% <6 ?N 7'% \?$ ( dJQU bc?@ *dP]%) ^DA]A$7% ( _gAc fc%ag% dP]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> aQ$ +,-/.0,-//3 <C6=> �'A�j <5A$?G ')`ANLA6 ') LAc' )'AQPQ5 ,/.,,.1 H:' <G �=6 <5A$?G ;'() ') LAc' )'AQPQ5 ,-X2/O1;F$A5 �=6 <5A$?G `AN;)(FS5 &ARN ') `F5�') `?G%?GA$ VFQ6' <C6=> �'A�j <5A$?G `%?U%?G ;'() ic% ') *?Q6Ay> ic% AG V)=G fc%ag% <G (' &AJ�RN 7'% \?$ A5% *_[%F$ d$%FJj ?QQ�> (M%<g?C>?Qv s$%=5 7% M'AQ�G �wB AG ( ;F[ FQW�> *o'AI> ?G M%<g?C>?Qv s$%=5 s@( �F}s$%=5 �c?� 7% �A>FR} AN_cARB ;'() ic% ') *<C6=> �'A�j <5A$?G M%?U% 7% 89: MANLA6 ')o%)'%( fc%ag% F$(' FNA[ *4ly$ MANF5�') fc%ag% dK ') *ic%?GAJG VF[d5 LA9$) M%<g?C>') 'n) &=QPQ5 222. <G �=6 <5A$?G `ANLA6 ') 'n) &=QPQ5 q-.h 7% dg?m5 `ANnAW
VHQl�N �'A�j <5A$?G `ANLA6H:' 7% dP]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> *+,-/X0,-X,3 <C6=> HIJK <5A$?G L(% LA6 <6 ')dJQU bc?@ V_gAc fc%ag% LAc' )'AQPQ5 qhOX.22 <G *�'A�j <5A$?G LAc' )'AQPQ5 ,/.,,.1Xqq1 <G �'A�j <5A$?G LAc' ,-22, 7% d#Q#B 7'% \?$ A5% _[%F$ d6=�S5 &%FJj fNAW
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; "
fNAW ( `%<g?C>?Qv s$%=5 sg' �(aD ?G _D() FQW�> <G <U=> AG VFQ6' ;'() ic% ') LAc'H:' <G �'A�j <5A$?G ') 'n) &=QPQ5 222. 7% dg?m5 `ANnAW o%)'%( *7'% \?$ �=�S5
V_:Ac fc%ag% HIJK <5A$?G ') 'n) &=QPQ5 /,h/
!"#"$ %&' ()* +!,#- ./)0 +!1)23 456758 9':&'; <*;& => ?;<-!@A': BC5A5* <#CDE ;
!"#$#% &'"()*+$,-
+LAc' )'AQPQ53./, 01%*2'23
4516*7'8
9:#; <,-/,=*>1?@
+'n) &=QPQ53A/=- A/=-
X.,/-- O,h. h .2 ,h1q ,-./0,-12 d5"6% !"#$% 7% 89:
/-21X1 -X.O h -/ qqO1 ,-1O0,-2O TJU ( d5"6% !"#$%dPQRS>
X1X-X, 2.qq h -X qO.- ,-2/0,-O- <C6=> L(% <5A$?G,,-XX2X /1Xq h .h qhh2 ,-O.0,-O/ <C6=> �() <5A$?G,-X2/O1 ,q/O- h ., q-.h ,-OX0,-/- <C6=> �=6 <5A$?G,/.,,.1 ,-22, h .h 222. ,-/.0,-// <C6=> �'A�j <5A$?GqhOX.22 Xqq1 h -/ /,h/ ,-/X0,-X, <C6=> HIJK <5A$?G
>3( ?@!0! <A&%'A�RN ( �%)� *+qh,,3 �=>=5 ( 4RQ�>AW 4G?I> oACDAE5 ( M?p$ 4$A95 <G <U=> AG?p$ ') ?c7 o'=Y<G 4g?m5 o%)'%( MA@A#> sGA> *+qhh23 �=>=5 ( 4RQ�>AW ( +qhh/3
�)=[d5 <lg?k
IMt= (Yt! #$%t, INt) +qh
F5�')3 <$%?6 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> Y *d#Q#B 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( IM *&� ') <Wo'=Y<G AN?Q�l5 �AR> ( _6% MF5�') M?G%?GA$ IN ( 4#Q#B 7'% \?$ #$% *+4#Q#BFcAG *4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( MA@A#> sGA> iQRu> 7% 89: VF$%;F[ <lg?k ?p$ ') 4Rlc'AeD
�)=[ <96AS5 ?c7 <EG%' 7% 4#Q#B 7'% \?$
# %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
REX&$% � CPICPIir
+q,
MAW?[ 4g?m5 oA5F] ( ANnAW MA�G ^]A[ CPI *'n) b�B?G dR6% 7'% \?$ $%
*ic%?GAJG V_6% &%?c% ') 4g?m5 oA5F] ( ANnAW MA�G ^]A[ CPIir ( &%?c% M'AI> ;FR}�)=[45 4GAc7'% ?c7 o'=Y<G =eD%
KMt=C+B1LYt+B2'#$%t+B3LIN+et +qq
LY LF5 <l�G%( ?Q�l5 &%=J}<G 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( Hlc'AeD LM *&� ') <Wbc?@ Hlc'AeD LIN ( *4#Q#B 7'% \?$ Hlc'AeD '#$% *4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> Hlc'AeD
V_6% MF5�') M?G%?GA$ ;FJJW)'(�?G ^]A[ &%=J}<G dJQUFQD=> *4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( MAN?Q�l5 <G �=G?5 oA}"�% ( 'A5� _6% ?Wt &AcA[�$AG oA}"�% ( 'A5� _cA6 7% dJQU bc?@ ( 4R6' 7'% \?$ *<$%?6 4P]%) ^DA]A$MAW?[ ( &%?c% 4g?m5 oA5F] ( ANnAW MA�G ^]A[ <G �=G?5 oA}"�% ( ,MaW?5,-./0,-X, MANLA6 M%?G q WDI ;AeG( 7% +qhh13 <cAK LA6 �A6%?G &� M'AI> ;FR}
VF$%;F[ �%?ul6%
B#*CD E6FG81 >3( ;(9: <H_QRN% M%'%) ANM?6 4cAcAK 46'?G *4$A57 M?6 o'=Y<G 4$=Q6?k' MANLF5 iQRu> ')<lgAcHQRC> ?D=g 04�c) FB%( <rc' &=57� 7% LF5 MAN?Q�l5 4cAcAK 46'?G M%?G V_6%AcAKA$ �E6 ') AN?Q�l5 �AR> *+q L(FU3 &=57� ic% �cAl$ �A6%?G ( ;F[ ;)Ayl6% +ADF3L(% <9>?5 8@Ay> &=57� �A6%?G *iQJ�RN VF$%M?Qk 8@Ay> FJ57AQ$ &F[ AcAK M%?G ( ;)=G�AR> ( <l�G%( ?Q�l5 *?ec) o'A9}<G V)=[d5 )' AN?Q�l5 <RN M%?G 4cAcAK <Q@?g *AN?Q�l5V)=[45 )' hZh1 �E6 ') &A[4cAcAKA$ <Q@?g ( ;F[ AcAK *8@Ay> �c AG 8#l�5 MAN?Q�l5
VFJl�N I(1) Ac L(% <9>?5 7% 4CRIRN *LF5 MAN?Q�l5 �AR> *ic%?GAJG
1. Time Series Data Bank, www.tsd.cbi.ir.2( )*+,- ./0/,*12/34 53-6784*+9 !:441; -848(<*+,-=83>(*+?
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; $
56)#FG3 H05IE ; JKL M')N OG15/ P#QRE )CD1 = ST/: UD3%V W/5G* =X ?;<-
ADF B(@.C A/#@CDE)1@ F6#G)#H1'IJ@ K=,
ADF B(@.C A/#@C/- #H1'IJ@
LMN O&E@ ., P1Q #R&%=/ =O&E@ ., P1Q #R., P1Q #R
&%=/ = O&E@., P1Q #R
O&E@
0-Z/21��0-Z/.1���dLM0qZ1-.0qZ/-X�LM
0.Z1,2���0.Z12,���dLY0,ZhO10hZ2XhLY
01ZX-X���01ZXOO���-'$%0qZ.qO0qZ,q2'$%
0.Z1/1���0OZ2..���dLN0qZ2q/0hZX-OlN
V_6% ;F[ ;)%) &Ar$ � ( �� *��� o'=Y<G bQ>?><G FY') ,h ( 1 *, �E6 ') M'%)AJC5
�c <U') 7% AcAK |=g MAN?Q�l5 �AR> *;F[�AI$% FB%( <rc' MAN&=57� �cAl$ �A6%?GAN?Q�l5 iQG oF5FJPG ( oF5;A>=W �G%(' ilgAc <CDAE5 ic% �FN <W AI$� 7% *ic%?GAJG VFJl�N�Q@=>)=] M=eD% )'(�?G `%?G *iQJ�RN V_6% ;F[ ;)Ayl6% VAR _gAQN' 7% *_6%a>'%=[ Ac ( �Q�AW� MAN'AQC5 7% ;)Ayl6% AG =eD% <JQ�G MAN<y:( )%FC> %FlG% *+VAR3M'%)?Gdel�9RN 8�r5 <W )=[ !Aul$% `%;7%F$% <G FcAG <y:( ( )=[d5 iQQC> iQ�=W &AJN Ac icaQG
?p$ ') �c ?G%?G 'AQC5 <6 ?N <G <U=> AG <JQ�G <y:( )%FC> <CDAE5 ic% ')3 F[AG <l[%F$ dDAc?6V_6% ;F5� +-3 L(FU ') �Plu5 M?Q]�> MAN;'() AG =eD% )'(�?G �cAl$ V+_6% ;F[ <lg?k
O,#YN OIZ; [##RE =\ ?;<-
DGS= -,&T)UAICV W'X#;C /#'T@USCV Y)/,(Z /#'T@UHQV ['X(; B#7H /#'T@h2ZO/q2ZX1/2Z/..
,�0,Z11,�0hZ2O,�0,Zq..�q0,Z,2XhZ.,-0hZ2,2-0hZXX1,ZqX,0hZ,XO
V_6% FY') 1 LARlB% �E6 AG �cAl$ *<JQ�G <y:( )%FC>��Q#S> oA96AS5 �w]�5
% %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
MAN;'A5� 7% ;)Ayl6% AG FCG <PB?5 ') *M'%)?G &=Q6?k')=] LF5 <JQ�G <y:( iQQC> 7% �K7% 8YAB �cAl$ ( ;F[ iQQC> 4CRIRN MAN'%)?G )%FC> *;�c( ?c)A#5 ?�W%FB ( ?z% &=57�;�c( ?c)A#5 ?�W%FB ( ?z% �c?>A5 &=57� ;'A5� 7% ;)Ayl6% AG 4CRIRN MAN'%)?G iQQC>
V_6% ;F[ ;)%) &Ar$ +13 ( +.3 `ANL(FU ') bQ>?><G
)]' UD3%V %' ^:5IGL' 5N _D#@#LD- `UDa*56D- UD3%V W/5G* =b ?;<-
D\'J%*%,1]R 15-#2@A/#@C
B(@.C9#HD^5/D?_^@H1 D'61>H0 D'61>
`ab``abc?yY <Q@?g )' �F}-OZ,q..hZ,O..qZ-1qhZ/-/+ @Ar=0
?yY <Q@?g )'q,Z.2hq.ZqO1qhZX.-hZ1h/+ @B+ C A
?yY <Q@?g )',hZq1h,qZ-qh,hZ.-qhZqhX+ @D+ C B
?yY <Q@?g )'-Zh.h.Z,qXhZ1,.hZh,-+ @E+ C D
V�Q#S> oA96AS5 �w]�5
_D#@#LD- `UDa*56D- UD3%V W/5G* =c ?;<-^d/; &'<"3 )e8'<$ UD3%V %' ^:5IGL' 5N
D\'J%*%,1]R 15-#2@A/#@C
B(@.C9#HD^5/D?_^@H1 D'61>H0 D'61>
`ab``abc?yY <Q@?g )' �F},XZ1/hq.Z,1Xq,Z.hXhZ.-Xr =1r =0
?yY <Q@?g )',.Z1Oh,OZOXO,hZ1,,hZq.Or =2+ C A
?yY <Q@?g )',hZq/h,,Zqq.XZX,/hZq-1r =3+ C B
?yY <Q@?g )'-Zh.h.Z,qXhZ1,.hZh,-r =4+ C D
V�Q#S> oA96AS5 �w]�5
;'A5� () ?N �6=> <W 4CRIRN MAN'%)?G )%FC> *+13 ( +.3 *+-3 `ANL(FU <G <U=> AG*ic%?GAJG V_6% �c AG ?G%?G *;F5� _6)<G ;�c( ?c)A#5 ?�W%FB ( ?z% �c?>A5 `AN&=57�AN?Q�l5 ic% 7% 8YAB &=Q6?k' ( ;)=G '%?:?G =eD% MAN?Q�l5 iQG d>F5FJPG 4D)AC> <EG%'
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; !&
VF$)ARl}% 8GA: F ( R2* t MAN ;'A5� ( _�Q$ !tAW<G _9�$ ;F[LA5?$ '%)?G ( ;F[ ;)7 iQRu> LF5 MAN?Q�l5 oF5FJPG <EG%' *<5%)% ')FcAG *LF5 MAN?Q�l5 iQG oF5FJPG '%)?G !Aul$% ') V)=[45 !Aul$% L�(% M%a$(') ?Q�l5bc%?@ _5"} ?p$ 7% L�(% M%a$(') ?Q�l5 <G _9�$ FcAG ;F[LA5?$ '%)?G <W )=[ <U=>
VFJ[AG '%)AJC5 M'A5� �ASD 7% aQ$ '%)?G bc%?@ ( ;)=G M)Aml:% MANM'=�> AG b6AJl5
f9<3<,@N OKN'&g U')/' SRQhQ6 &':)N [#QiE =j ?;<-
ddB(@.C A/#@C /,&2@ /#'T@ e,1]%, 4516 1f'IJ@ g#%
0000 0000 , LM
.Z-X2 hZ-// ,ZOh2 LY
0-ZOq2 hZ/2q 0-Zq,q '$%
-Z1qh hZ2. qZq1- LIN
�Q#S> oA96AS5�w]�5
?c7 �?[ <G *FN)45 &Ar$ %' AN?Q�l5 iQG oF5FJPG <EG%' <W ;F[)'(�?G LF5 *iQJ�RN�_6%
'F&A GHI'JKD BAB'$#%LB BMD'5N +q-
*?ec) &AQG <G V_6% '%)AJC5 M'A5� ?p$ 7% AN?Q�l5 �AR> bc?@ *iQRu> �cAl$ �A6%?GM?G%?GA$ ^]A[ &%=J}<G ic?>?Q#g �N) () H�6 <G ic?>FJR>(?z �N) () H�6 MAN?Q�l5MANnAW o%)'%( MA@A#> ?Q�l5 ;FJN)�Q@=> 4#Q#B 7'% \?$ ( 4#Q#B F5�') *MF5�')
VFJl�N 4g?m5&%=>45 ic%?GAJG *_6% '%)AJC5 ( qZq1 _9�5 MF5�') M?G%?GA$ ?Q�l5 bc?@ <W AI$� 7%o%)'%( *<C5AU ') F5�') sc7=> _QC@( &F[ ?>FG ( MF5�') M?G%?GA$ fc%ag% AG _yk`ANF5�') �QSY _c?cF5 ') &%?c% )Aml:% *?l�G &AQG <G VFGAc45 fc%ag% 4g?m5 MANnAWdPY% fuG *&%?c% )Aml:% dl$%' _QNA5 <G <U=> AG ( ;)=9$ �g=5 _y$ o%')AY 7% d[A$ `7'%<G )=] �=@=5 ic% <W _6% ;FQ6' <C5AU 7% dYA] 'Ar:% <G _y$ o%')AY 7% d[A$ Fc%=}
!' %<=>< 1?=@)A&8B&C$D<E.<9 A&F&GH I4&H =4 J)K.E A=4<=4&2 =LMNH
?p$ <G *ic% ?G &(ag% V_6% ;F[ Hl] dg?m5 `ANnAW o%)'%( ( `F5�') `?G%?GA$ fc%ag%V)=[45 �?m5 <C5AU FJR>(?z 'Ar:% �6=> 4>%)'%( 4g?m5 MANnAW 4PY% &7( F6'45<G `?>fQG 8cAR> &A[4g?m5 M=eD% ( Fc?] o'F: <G <U=> AG ;(?k ic% *?ec) &AQG <G�cAl$ <GAr5 _R�: ic% �cAl$ _6% ?Wt &AcA[ VF$'%) 4U'A] 4g?m5 MANnAW 7% ;)Ayl6%�=>=5 ( 4RQ�>AW ( +qhh/3 &%'A�RN ( �%)� *+qh,,3 �=>=5 ( 4RQ�>AW oACDAE5
V_6% +qhh23?Q�l5 bc?@ ( ;)=G 4#Q#B 7'% \?$ <G �=G?5 ?Qz�> ic?>fQG *iQRu> �cAl$ �A6%?GfNAW <G 4#Q#B 7'% \?$ fc%ag% *ic%?GAJG V_6% '%)AJC5 ( -Zq, 4yJ5 4#Q#B 7'% \?$*'=rW ') 4#Q#B 7'% \?$ fc%ag% AG *?ec) &AQG <G V)=[45 Hl] 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%(A@A#> *&� dK ') ( )=[d5 ?>&%?k 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( ( ;F[ �QC > 4P]%) L=K&%'A�RN ( 4$%=P�K oACDAE5 �cAl$ _6% ?Wt &AcA[ VFGAc45 fNAW 4>%)'%( MANnAW M%?G4#Q#B 7'% \?$ '%)AJC5 ( 4yJ5 ?Qz�> ?e$AQG aQ$ *+,-/23 &%'A�RN ( M)AG� L"U ( +,-/23
V_6% &%?c% o%)'%( ?GV_6% '%)AJC5 ( ,ZOh _9�5 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> ?Q�l5 bc?@ *iQRu> �cAl$ �A6%?G4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( ;FJJWiQQC> 85%=} 7% ?ec) 4�c 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> *ic%?GAJG;Ak?N s:%( ') V)=[45 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( fc%ag% <G ?IJ5 &� fc%ag% %?c7 V_6%fc%ag% HQ#l�5 '=�<G aQ$ 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( *<lgAc fc%ag% <C5AU )%?g% 4#Q#B F5�')4>%)'%( MANnAW *_6')A$ Ac _6') <W _6% �)?5 4g?m5 M=eD% &� 8QD) <W _6% <l[%)F5�') <W AI$� 7% _yk &%=>45 *iQJ�RN VFJN)45 �QU?> 4P]%) MANnAW �?m5 ?G %'fc%ag% *ic%?GAJG *)'%) 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> ') M%;FJJWiQQC> ?Qz�> _y$ o%')AY 7% 8YABMANnAW MA@A#> ( 4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> fc%ag% b96 _y$ o%')AY 7% 8YAB MANF5�')*_�Q$ 4g?m5 MANnAW MA@A#> fc%ag% M=k¡6AK MFQD=> &%=> <W AI$� 7% ( ;F[ 4g?m5;'AG') <CDAE5 ic% �cAl$ *?ec) &AQG <G VFGAcd5 fc%ag% 4g?m5 MANnAW o%)'%( <IQl$')( `AN *+qh,h3 4$A{Q$ ( ac'� oACDAE5 �cAl$ <GAr5 *4P]%) ^DA]A$ FQD=> ?Q�l5 bc?@
V_6% +qhh-3 T$A> ( +qhh.3 icFD%?m$ ( ¢QD) *+qh,h3 '=�r5LF5 FcAG *LF5 MAN?Q�l5 iQG 4CRIRN '%)?G �c )=U( FQc�> <G <U=> AG *FCG <PB?5 ')
V+O L(FU3 )=[ )'(�?G oF5;A>=W MAE] 8cFC> _}?6 46'?G M%?G VECM
!"# %&'()* +, -.&/0 +12&3.*&4 5)&6789:; !(
U')/' M')N VECM ?<3 [#QiE =k ?;<-
B(@.C A/#@C /,&2@ /#'T@ e,1]%, 4516 1f'IJ@ g#%hZXqX hZqhq hZ,// !"#$%&
!"#$ !%& !'# !'#$%&
( !&"# ! &$ ( ! " !()*#$%&
( ! #' )! %) ( ! #% !+,#$%&
!'#* ! $ ! '' C
()!$* ! )& ( ! %+ Ecm(-1)
,-./01 3456407 89:;7
<=>/7 ?@6 AB 3>7C41DE F4G: HI>J1 ?KL6 ?MN O=D1P7 QR&S TU>V WI4XY AB AVD1 4BZD: AE ?6= <=Z4[J7 >\<Z + ]G6 <Z U CZDB ( ! % 4B LB=LB O=LI= F=LB 3>7>[^B U P_Z4J14`[1 C<UZ La <Z U CZDB 3>7>[^B P_Z4J1 <=>/7 ?@6 AB HI>J1 b>Y= ?KL6 c= PE4dHI>J1 PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U L.hX7 F=LB H5i C<UZ AB jDBL7 TZ4J1 k>K c= >\<Z A6
,ZDlP7<Z ,?6= C>l CZ4MX6= F<4X:46 345m U T>7 345m n..J1 F=LB Qo.pq1 F4aOD7cr Qn.[s@aAVD1 4B U C>l CZ4MX6= CUSUM U CUSUMQ <=ZD@Y c= QT>7 345m o.pq1 F=LB Q-./01 nI=2Qtu Q?6= CZLvY wGi =< n.eLxF4ay: c= k=>Ez.a Qy6U <=ZD@Y Q<=ZD@Y UZ nI= -B4G7 AEnI= AB
,ZDl{7 AXeLI9u PeLf7 F4ag4E3=Z<=U F4|4/1 wB41 FD}_= F=LB 3>7>[^B P@~=Z 345m
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
1355 1360 1365 1370 1375 1380 1385
CUSUM 5% Significance
! !"#! %&"'()*+,*-$.!/0!1 )*2*34 56*4 "6 7(80/ )"6!"6*9 ":;<4
!"$!"!%&' $()* +,,-. /01' CUSUM 23"45 67 8093:;-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1355 1360 1365 1370 1375 1380 1385
CUSUM of Squares 5% Significance
#$!"!%&' $()* +,,-. /01' CUSUMQ 23"45 6<8093:;
!"#$% ' ()*+,-.PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U F4|4/1 U >7r<Z FLB=LB4Y n.B AGB=< P6<LB Q�aU�u P^\= �>aCD0Y 4B AGB=< <Z L�Y�4M1= QA[.7c nI= <Z C>lk4�Y= 34/./01 WI4XY F4[57 LB U CZDB O=LI=2PaULN AE 4[J7 nI= AB ,Z<=>Y ZDVU 4a<DqE LI46 <Z3=Z<=U LB F>7r<Z FLB=LB4Y F<=9NLm=nI= O4.7 AGB=< ZDVU k>K AB �.Y PaULN U PM[7 AGB=< ZDVU AB PaULN Q?5�7 AGB=< ZDVU ABF4|4/1 LB >7r<Z FLB=LB4Y �I=�e= Lm= >Y>/XJ7 n.//07 c= F<4.�B ,>Y=AXl=Z O4K�= L.hX7 UZ>._D1 <Z Q<DqE LN= ,Z<=Z P}X�B <DqE FZ4fXi= AJ6D1 ]G6 AB Q<DqE �I 3=Z<=U?I�7 Rg4B F<UCL`B U AY=L6 >7r<Z 4B AXe4IAJ6D1 F4a<DqE �gD@J7S ?.M.E4B F4ag4EQL}IZ �D6 c= ,>aZ{7 �I=�e= =< 3=Z<=U F4|4/1 QFLB=LB4Y <Z �I=�e= Q>l4B AXl=Z P5�Y>7r<Z�E AJ6D1T4d<Z F4a<DqE ?.\Df: AES ?.M.E2PB F4ag4E >._D1 <Z <DqE LN=
,ZDB >a=D: {M[7 3=Z<=U ��d LB FLB=LB4Y �I=�e= Lm= Q>l4B AXl=Z P5�Y ?I�7 QR?6=L.hX7 n.B AGB=< RVARS F<=ZLB OD.6LN<ZD: �U< c= CZ4MX6= 4B L|4d AJ_4G7 <ZP/./d c<= �LY U P^:=Z o_4:4Y >._D1 Q>7r<Z �LB=LB4Y 4B PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=UAES F>7r<Z FLB=LB4Y L.hX7 QVAR T>7 c= C>7r?6ZAB WI4XY �46=LB ,?6= C>l P6<LBU AXl=Z PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U LB {X5�7 L.m;1 QR?6= Or LB L|4d �aU�u P^\= A.v1U 4a>7r<Z wIcD1 ?.J|U ZD5`B 4B Qwi=U<Z ,?6= PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U C>[aZ].|D1c= U L1�.B QH:=Z >._D1 PeLf7 F4ag4E c= CZ4MX6= AB HI4@1 QF>7r<Z FLB=LB4Y �a4EL.m;1 nIL1�.B QP/./d c<= �LY Qn.[s@a ,?6= C>l AX64E PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U O=�.72Q<DqE <Z P/./d c<= �LY �I=�e= 4B Q?/./d <Z ,Z<=Z PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U LB =<4|4/1 QnI=LB4[B ,ZDl{7 L1O=LN PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U U C>l �.J�1 P^:=Z TDu<=Z4[J7 U ?5�7 FL.m;1 �.Y P^:=Z o_4:4Y >._D1 ,>B4IP7 �a4E P1=Z<=U F4ag4E F=LB
=>?@ *AB(C DE= F0*GH D%9*I0C*6 J(*KL+1MN "
AXe4I �I=�e= PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U Or �I=�e= 4B U AXl=Z PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U LBFD}_= 3>7>[^B 345m ZDVU cusum U cusumq F4aOD7cr c= CZ4MX6= 4B Qn.[s@a ,?6=
,ZDl{7 >.I;1 PeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U F4|4/1 wB41F4ag4E 3=Z<=U LB {@./X�7 Lm= QO=LI= Z4fXi= >7r<Z FLB=LB4Y ?MN O=D1P7 �D@�7<ZFLI9u?B4i<3<>i�I=�e= QF>7r<Z�4vl�a4EF4X6=< <Z QnI=LB4[B ,Z<=9NP7PeLf7O=�.7 �a4E ?`V <Z �Lm�7 F4a��1 >I4B QA_46?�.B c=>Y=�q� >[6 �=>a= -/01 UFZ4fXi= O=<=9N?64.6 ZDlP7 A.\D1 Q�46= nI= LB ,ZDl k4�Y= <DqE <Z >7r<Z FLB=LB4Y=< >7r<Z wIcD1 >[lDvB Q>7r<Z�E <4qi= U =L/e wMY AB 3ULm U >7r<Z Z>�7 wIcD1 4B
,>Yc46 L1TZ4JX7
!"#! %&"'()*+,*-$.!/0!1 )*2*34 56*4 "6 7(80/ )"6!"6*9 ":;<4
,+!*%Q{Y4N<c4B A74[qaU�u A74[^fe Q�nIDY ZLvIU< 4B O=LI= Z4fXi= <Z3=Z<=U �4|4/1� �R)%* S >.@d Q{@qILB=
,)2( % o\ Q' �-.//0122/34-567-788?I46 QO=LI= P7�6= F<D`@VF�EL7�Y4B QFZ4fXi= PY47c F4aFL634K�x=�Y4B
,{Y LqY QO=L`1 Q�LE4l�45K A@VL1 ,O�E Z4fXi= �4a?64.6 U �<D�1 �R)%&"S k4.^IU QOD�Y=LBA^�7 Q�Z>�7 H.^01 �I 8O=LI= 3=Z<=U �4|4/1 wB41 {Y47c �L6 Z<UrLB� �R)%&$S Z=DV>.6 Q�./7<Du
,))% ()'$o\ Q+"� Q�Z4fXi= 34/./013=Z<=U U 3=<Z4\ �4|4/1 wB=D1 n.@p1� �R)%*"S {[.�d �>`7>.6 U CZL@aZ L�Y ��.f7 Q{Y=D^`uo\ Q% � Q�Z4fXi= �4a{6<LB A74[^fe Q�ARDL {I=L}@a �U< c= CZ4MX6= 4B O=LI= Z4fXi= <Z
,) )()' FL[a (P}[aLe A�6�7 8O=L`1 ,"7589:/ �@E AB FZLB<4E P�[6Z4fXi= �R)%*#S >@d= QP[.vq1
,O=LN45IZ2��R)%%*()%*'SO=LI= Z4fXi=F=LB3=Z<=UF4|4/1 wB41n.@p1� �R)%*+S 4|L.^K QPY4X64B U>@d= QP[.vq1
,''"(' +o\ Q# C<4@l QPY4N<c4B A74[qaU�u A74[^feQAVZDB U A74YLB O47c46 Q�Z4VLe {^Kk�� A@VL1 QkD6 O4`V <Z�Z4fXi= AJ6D1 �R)%"*S HvI47 QU<=ZD1
,TU= >^VQPeLf7 F4ag4E 3=Z<=U F4|4/1 LB Lm�7 H7=DK P6<LB� �R)%*)S O4.B=L07 CZ=cr U >.@d QP/.eD1
,+& ( &#o\ Q)%� QO=LI= FZ4fXi= F4a�aU�u A74[^fe Q�F=AG6=U U F=AI47L63=Z<=ULB�Z4fXi=O�E�4aL.hX7 Lm=� �R)%*"S{@./X�7 4|<ZD@07UZ=�Y�I�K>@\��=>6= Q�Z4BrT�V
,&&() )o\ Q)� Q& C<UZ Q�Z4fXi= A74[qaU�u Q�O=LI= ?J[\�=AI47L6 � �=AG6=U �4ag4E,O4B41 3=<4qXY= QO=L`1 Q�`Y�4� Q�Z4fXi= AJ6D1 {Y457 �R)%*%S ZD@07 QO4`BcU<
A74Y A74[^fe UZ Q�FLI9u?B4i< 3<>i LB H7=DK HE F<U CL`B Lm= P6<LB� �R)%*%S H�M_=DB= QFZ4BrC4l,)%$()&+o\ Q#+� Q>.M7
U g4E3=Z<=U LB >7r<Z�LB=LB4Y L.m;1� �R)%$'S {X@JY {�1L7 U�L.�Y ��4E>@07 �H�M_=DB= Q�Z4BrC4lQ)'� Q�Z4fXi= �c4�_>734/./01 A74[^fe Q�AJ6D1T4d<Z U AXe4IAJ6D1�pX[7 �4a<DqE347>:
,+)(&'o\8O=L`1 ,P�[6 Z4fXi= <Z Eviews 5 ZLB<4E �R)%*"S F<4�YD:n�d =Lac U �=t@l Q�pBnIL.l
,FZ4fXi= <D7= C>vqaU�uF4a�aU�u A74[^fe Q�3=Z<=U F4|4/1 wB41 F4IDu �4aH.^01� �R)%* S O4.B=L07 CZ=cr U =>Y Q�p5dLe
,'$ ( #)o\ Q'� QFZ4fXi=A74[a47 Q�Or c=?e<OULB �4aC=< U O=LI= <Z{XY=< Z4fXi=� �R)%*$S O4I>@d= {�1L7 U �=�.6 QZ=�Y{^�e
,)'$()+*o\ Q)' U ))� Q�Z4fXi= �4a?64.6 U H~4�7 {6<LB
=>?@ *AB(C DE= F0*GH D%9*I0C*6 J(*KL+1MN #
U3=<4qXY= A�6�7 QO=L`1 C4}qY=Z Q{@qILB= >.@d A@VL1 Q{�[6Z4fXi= {Y457 �R)%&&S <=ZD7=Z Q{1=L�N,�4�
A^�7 Q�4aAY=LE ZLvIU< 4B Z>�7 {B4Ic<=�I 8O=LI= HE3=Z<=U �4|4/1 wB41� �R)%*%S >@07 Q{`^_=LfY,$) ())'o\ Q""� Q�Z4fXi= 34/./01
Adam, A., M. Katsimi T. Moutos (2008); “Inequality and the Import Demand Function”,CESIFO Working Paper, 2196,
.//0122;;;-5<37=9$>89?0-4<2098/@A20@><2098/@A2B95C@3<DE9F/<F/2GH2GH$E)I7=9DG98J7F>DH@0<832;0$5<37=9$KLLM2;0$5<37=9$KLLM$L%25<37=9%D;0K%NO-04=
Ariz, A. C., & S. Nippani (2010); “Import Demand Behavior in Africa: Some NewEvidence”, The Quaterly Review of Economics and Finance, no.50, pp.254-263.
Bahmani-Oskooee, M., & G.G. Goswawi (2004); “Exchange Rate Sensitivity of JapaneseBilateral Flows”, Journal of Japan and the World Economy, no.16, pp.25-38.
Dilip, D. & A. Nasirulddin (2004); “An Aggregate Import Demand Function for India: ACointegration Analysis”, Applied Economices Letter, no.11(10), pp.607-613.
Galor, O. (2000); “Income Distribution and the Process of Development”, EuropeanEconomic Review, vol. 44, pp.706 -712.
Hye, Q. M. A. & M. Mashkoor (2010); “Import Demand Function for Bangladesh: A RollingWindow Analysis”, African Journal of Business Management, no.4(10), pp.21-56.
Katsimi, M. & T. Moutos (2006); “Inequality and the US Import Demand Function”,CESIFO Working Paper, 1827.
.//0122;;;-5<37=9$>89?0-4<2098/@A20@><2098/@A2B95C@3<DE9F/<F/2GH2GH$E)I7=9DG98J7F>DH@0<832;0$5<37=9$KLLO2;0$5<37=9$KLLO$%L25<37=9%D;0%MKP-04=
Katsimi, M. & T. Moutos (2011); “Inequality and the US Import Demand Function”,Journal of International Money and Finance, no.30, pp.492-506.
Tang, T. C. (2003); “An Empirical Analysis of China’s Aggregate Import DemandFunction”, China Economic Review, no.14, pp.142-163.