0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

6

Click here to load reader

Upload: vuongtram

Post on 18-Jan-2019

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8 <1%

3 7 12 5 2 4 0 33 2%

1 1 19 2 17 38 19 97 5%

1 1 21 5 14 19 0 61 3%

3 0 24 8 12 17 0 64 3%

2 0 9 0 21 41 3 76 4%

0 2 3 1 21 24 0 51 3%

0 0 10 0 56 64 20 150 7%

0 0 0 1 40 60 39 140 7%

0 0 0 0 1 1 0 2

0 0 0 0 2 4 0 60 0 38 0 89 102 3 232 11%

0 0 0 0 0 0 7%8 0 40 8 63 145 85 349 17%

0 0 10 1 54 34 4 103 5%

1© 2018

BrownGreer PLC

SECTION 3: MONETARY AWARD

CLAIMS SUBMITTED: 2,039

Retired Player1,606 (79%)

Representative Claimant

433 (21%)

115

768

546

120

362

43

85

Unknown / Multiple

Level 1.5

Level 2

Parkinson’s …

Alzheimer’s …

ALS

Death with CTE

SECTION 4: QUALIFYING DIAGNOSIS

ASSERTED IN MONETARY AWARD

CLAIMS

NFL SNFL SNFL SNFL SETTLEMENTETTLEMENTETTLEMENTETTLEMENT PPPPROGRAMROGRAMROGRAMROGRAM SSSSUMMARYUMMARYUMMARYUMMARY RRRREPORTEPORTEPORTEPORT(AS(AS(AS(AS OF 10/8/18)OF 10/8/18)OF 10/8/18)OF 10/8/18)

BAP Eligible Not BAP Eligible Adverse NoticeIncomplete

Registration

TOTAL 12,818 6,535 1,157 3

Retired Player 12,723 2,434 801 0

Representative 95 862 301 3

Derivative 0 3,239 55 0

12,818

6,535

1,1573

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

SECTION 2: REGISTRATION NOTICES ISSUED BY TYPE

TOTAL: 20,513

SECTION 1: TIMELY REGISTRATIONS

TOTAL: 20,514

Retired Player

15,958 (78%)

Representative Claimant

1,259 (6%)

Derivative Claimant

3,287 (16%)

Page 2: 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

3 7 12 5 2 4 0 33 2%

1 1 19 2 17 38 19 97 5%

1 1 21 5 14 19 0 61 3%

3 0 24 8 12 17 0 64 3%

2 0 9 0 21 41 3 76 4%

0 2 3 1 21 24 0 51 3%

0 0 10 0 56 64 20 150 7%

0 0 0 1 40 60 39 140 7%0 0 0 0 1 1 0 2

0 0 0 0 2 4 0 6

0 0 38 0 89 102 3 232 11%

0 0 0 0 0 0 7%

8 0 40 8 63 145 85 349 17%

2

1 Section 6 counts all Monetary Award claims that have received a notice after claim processing. Claims receiving multiple notices are counted only

once based on the most recent notice issued. The number of appealed notices reflects only claims that have been appealed on the most recent

notice issued. For a cumulative total of all appeals, see Section 9.2 The results of the audit closed these claims and directed further alternatives for these Settlement Class Members.

1 The dollars and number of claims shown are the number of notices issued before holdbacks for potential Derivative Claimants, common benefit

fees, liens and any determinations on appeals.2The dollars reflected here include payments to third-party funders that have accepted rescission of prohibited assignments they had with Settlement

Class Members.

© 2018

BrownGreer

PLC

NFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORT

(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)

Payable DeniedDenied After

AuditWithdrawn

Request for

Additional

Documents

TOTAL 636 504 205 103 262

Not Appealed 534 404 205 103 262

Appealed 102 100

636

504

205103

262

SECTION 5: QUALIFYING DIAGNOSIS DATE ASSERTED

IN MONETARY AWARD CLAIMSPre-Effective Date: 1,552 Post-Effective Date: 350 No Date Asserted: 137

ALS Alzheimer’s

Parkinson’s DiseaseLevel 2 Level 1.5

Death with CTE

Monetary Awards

Issued1

Claims Funded by

the NFL Parties

Payments Made to

Retired Players

and Rep.

ClaimantsZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

ZZZZZZZZZ

Payments for

Liens

Dollars $563,537,808 $425,027,367 $348,307,380 $3,083,148

Claims 636 575 419 120

$563,537,808$425,027,367

$348,307,380

$3,083,148

636 575 4190

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

$0

$100,000,000

$200,000,000

$300,000,000

$400,000,000

$500,000,000

$600,000,000SECTION 7: PAYABLE CLAIMS SUMMARY

SECTION 6: NOTICES ISSUED ONMONETARY AWARD CLAIMS: 1,710

Claims with Monetary

Award Notices1

Denied AfterAudit2

Payments Made to Retired Players

and Rep.

Claimants2

Page 3: 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

CTECTECTECTE ALSALSALSALSAlzheimer’sAlzheimer’sAlzheimer’sAlzheimer’s

DiseaseDiseaseDiseaseDisease

Parkinson'sParkinson'sParkinson'sParkinson's

DiseaseDiseaseDiseaseDisease

LevelLevelLevelLevel

2222

LevelLevelLevelLevel

1.51.51.51.5

UnknownUnknownUnknownUnknown

Qualifying Qualifying Qualifying Qualifying

DiagnosisDiagnosisDiagnosisDiagnosis

TotalTotalTotalTotal %%%%

1.1.1.1. 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8 <1%

2.2.2.2. 0 1 5 3 6 11 1 27 1%

3.3.3.3. 3 7 12 5 2 4 0 33 2%

4.4.4.4. 1 1 19 2 17 38 19 97 5%

5.5.5.5. 1 1 21 5 14 19 0 61 3%

6.6.6.6. 3 0 24 8 12 17 0 64 3%

7.7.7.7. 2 0 9 0 21 41 3 76 4%

8.8.8.8. 0 2 3 1 21 24 0 51 3%

9.9.9.9. 0 0 10 0 56 64 20 150 7%

10.10.10.10. 0 0 0 1 40 60 39 140 7%

11.11.11.11. 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 2 <1%

12.12.12.12. 0 0 0 0 3 4 0 7 <1%

13.13.13.13. 0 0 38 0 89 102 3 232 11%

14.14.14.14. 0 0 0 0 74 69 0 143 7%

15.15.15.15. 8 0 40 8 63 145 85 349 17%

16.16.16.16. 0 0 10 1 54 34 4 103 5%

17.17.17.17. 1 1 13 6 7 9 0 37 2%

18.18.18.18. 1 0 7 4 12 16 0 40 2%

19.19.19.19. 66 30 149 77 34 63 0 419 21%

20.20.20.20. 86868686 43434343 362362362362 121121121121 527527527527 726726726726 174174174174 2,0392,0392,0392,039 100%100%100%100%

3

Withdrawn

Ready for Next Month's Payment

List

On this Month's Payment List

Needs Special Master Statute of

Limitations Review

SECTION 8LOCATION OF ALL MONETARY AWARD CLAIMSLOCATION OF ALL MONETARY AWARD CLAIMSLOCATION OF ALL MONETARY AWARD CLAIMSLOCATION OF ALL MONETARY AWARD CLAIMS

(STATUS BASED ON LAST NOTICE OR ACTION ON CLAIM)(STATUS BASED ON LAST NOTICE OR ACTION ON CLAIM)(STATUS BASED ON LAST NOTICE OR ACTION ON CLAIM)(STATUS BASED ON LAST NOTICE OR ACTION ON CLAIM)

In Review Process at Claims

Administrator

Notice Will Issue Tomorrow

Final Denial

Last Notice was for Incomplete

Claim Package1

Ready for Review by AAP

Last Notice was Award Notice2

Last Notice was Denial Notice3

On Appeal Now4

In Audit Investigation5

In Audit-Failure to Provide

Information

Adverse Audit Report with the

Parties for Review

Adverse Audit Report Awaiting

Response from Those Audited

Adverse Audit Report with the

Special Masters for Review

Denied After Audit6

Paid7

Total Claim Packages Total Claim Packages Total Claim Packages Total Claim Packages

SubmittedSubmittedSubmittedSubmitted

© 2018

BrownGreer PLC

NFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORT

(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)

1. The Program has issued notices to 1,374 incomplete claim packages, which is 72% of all Level 1.5 and Level 2 claims and 60% of all other

claims.

2. For details on all claims receiving an Award Notice and the dollar values assigned, see Sections 7 and 11.

3. For details on all denied claims, including the denial reasons, see Section 10.

4. For details on all appeals filed by Settlement Class Members and the NFL parties, see Section 9.

5. The Program has audited 1,181, or 58%, of all claims, including 507 claims removed from audit and put back into the claims review process,

290 claims currently in Audit Investigation, 241 claims on Adverse Audit Reports with the Parties or Special Masters for Review or awaiting a

response from those audited and 143 claims denied after audit.

6. The results of the audit denied these claims and directed further alternatives for these Settlement Class Members.

7. For total dollars paid to or on behalf of these Settlement Class Members, see Part 5 of Section 11.

SSSSTATUSTATUSTATUSTATUS OOOOFFFF MMMMONETARYONETARYONETARYONETARY AAAAWARDWARDWARDWARD CCCCLAIMSLAIMSLAIMSLAIMS

(B(B(B(BASEDASEDASEDASED OOOONNNN LLLLASTASTASTAST NNNNOTICEOTICEOTICEOTICE OOOORRRR AAAACTIONCTIONCTIONCTION OOOONNNN CCCCLAIMLAIMLAIMLAIM))))

Page 4: 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8 <1%

A.A.A.A.

1.1.1.1.

2.2.2.2.

3.3.3.3.

4.4.4.4.

5.5.5.5.

6.6.6.6.

7.7.7.7.

8.8.8.8.

B.B.B.B.

1.1.1.1.

2.2.2.2.

3.3.3.3.

4.4.4.4.

5.5.5.5.

6.6.6.6.

7.7.7.7.

8.8.8.8.

C.C.C.C.

SECTION 9 STATUS OF ALL APPEALS ON MONETARY AWARD CLAIMS

StatusStatusStatusStatus1111 Appealed by Appealed by Appealed by Appealed by

Class MemberClass MemberClass MemberClass Member

Appealed by NFL Appealed by NFL Appealed by NFL Appealed by NFL

PartiesPartiesPartiesPartiesTotalTotalTotalTotal

Payable ClaimsPayable ClaimsPayable ClaimsPayable Claims 18181818 100100100100 118118118118

Appeal Filed and in Preliminary StepsAppeal Filed and in Preliminary StepsAppeal Filed and in Preliminary StepsAppeal Filed and in Preliminary Steps 1 1 2

Appellee's Opposition Memo Not ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Not ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Not ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Not Received 4 15 19

Appellee's Opposition Memo ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Received 1 19 20

Remanded to Claims AdministratorRemanded to Claims AdministratorRemanded to Claims AdministratorRemanded to Claims Administrator 2 1 3

With Special Masters for DecisionWith Special Masters for DecisionWith Special Masters for DecisionWith Special Masters for Decision 2 6 8

Result Upheld on AppealResult Upheld on AppealResult Upheld on AppealResult Upheld on Appeal 6 44 50

Result Overturned on AppealResult Overturned on AppealResult Overturned on AppealResult Overturned on Appeal 1 2 3

Closed or WithdrawnClosed or WithdrawnClosed or WithdrawnClosed or Withdrawn2222 1 12 13

Denied ClaimsDenied ClaimsDenied ClaimsDenied Claims 140140140140 0000 140140140140

Appeal Filed and in Preliminary StepsAppeal Filed and in Preliminary StepsAppeal Filed and in Preliminary StepsAppeal Filed and in Preliminary Steps 7 0 7

Appellee's Opposition Memo Not ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Not ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Not ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Not Received 19 0 19

Appellee's Opposition Memo ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo ReceivedAppellee's Opposition Memo Received 17 0 17

Remanded to Claims AdministratorRemanded to Claims AdministratorRemanded to Claims AdministratorRemanded to Claims Administrator 56 0 56

With Special Masters for DecisionWith Special Masters for DecisionWith Special Masters for DecisionWith Special Masters for Decision 8 0 8

Result Upheld on AppealResult Upheld on AppealResult Upheld on AppealResult Upheld on Appeal 28 0 28

TOTAL APPEALSTOTAL APPEALSTOTAL APPEALSTOTAL APPEALS 158158158158 100100100100 2582582582581 Co-Lead Class Counsel has filed statements in 22 of the Appeals across multiple statuses in the Appeals Process.

2 These are appeals we are no longer processing because (1) the appealing party withdrew or (2) it was closed after being in audit.

Result Overturned on AppealResult Overturned on AppealResult Overturned on AppealResult Overturned on Appeal 0 0 0

Closed or WithdrawnClosed or WithdrawnClosed or WithdrawnClosed or Withdrawn2222 5 0 5

© 2018

BrownGreer PLC

NFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORT

(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)4

Page 5: 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8 <1%

1.1.1.1.

2.2.2.2.

3.3.3.3.

4.4.4.4.

5.5.5.5.

6.6.6.6.

7.7.7.7.

8.8.8.8.

9.9.9.9.

5

SECTION 10 REASONS IN NOTICES OF DENIAL ISSUED ON MONETARY AWARD CLAIMS

Reason Claim Denied NoticesNoticesNoticesNotices

Death with CTE ClaimsDeath with CTE ClaimsDeath with CTE ClaimsDeath with CTE Claims 9999

(a) Death Occurred After Final Approval 4

(b) Death Occurred Before 7/7/14 but Qualifying Diagnosis Was After Final Approval 2

(c) Death Between 7/7/14 & 4/22/15; Qualifying Diagnosis was greater than 270 Days From

Death1

(e) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Diagnosis Made by Inappropriate Physician 0

(f) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Not Death with CTE 0

(g) Complete Claim Package Never Provided by Class Member 0

ALS ClaimsALS ClaimsALS ClaimsALS Claims 1111

Complete Claim Package Never Provided by Class Member 1

Alzheimer’s Disease ClaimsAlzheimer’s Disease ClaimsAlzheimer’s Disease ClaimsAlzheimer’s Disease Claims 53535353

(a) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Diagnosis Made by Inappropriate Physician 8

(b) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Not Alzheimer's Disease 43

(c) Physician Not Qualified to Sign Diagnosis Physician Certification Form 1

(d) Complete Claim Package Never Provided by Class Member 0

Parkinson's Disease ClaimsParkinson's Disease ClaimsParkinson's Disease ClaimsParkinson's Disease Claims 8888

(a) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Diagnosis Made by Inappropriate Physician 3

(b) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Not Parkinson's Disease 6

(c) Complete Claim Package Never Provided by Class Member 0

Level 2 ClaimsLevel 2 ClaimsLevel 2 ClaimsLevel 2 Claims 114114114114

(a) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Diagnosis Made by Inappropriate Physician 7

(b) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Not Level 2 86

(c) Physician Not Qualified to Sign Diagnosis Physician Certification Form 17

(d) Complete Claim Package Never Provided by Class Member 10

Level 1.5 ClaimsLevel 1.5 ClaimsLevel 1.5 ClaimsLevel 1.5 Claims 195195195195

(a) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Diagnsosis Made by Inappropriate Physician 19

(b) Appeals Advisory Panel Denial - Not Level 1.5 140

(c) Physician Not Qualified to Sign Diagnosis Physician Certification Form 12

(d) Complete Claim Package Never Provided by Class Member 41

© 2018

BrownGreer PLC

NFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORT

(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)

Unconfirmed Qualifying Diagnosis - Complete Claim Package Not ProvidedUnconfirmed Qualifying Diagnosis - Complete Claim Package Not ProvidedUnconfirmed Qualifying Diagnosis - Complete Claim Package Not ProvidedUnconfirmed Qualifying Diagnosis - Complete Claim Package Not Provided 81818181

TOTAL DENIAL REASONS PROVIDED ON NOTICESTOTAL DENIAL REASONS PROVIDED ON NOTICESTOTAL DENIAL REASONS PROVIDED ON NOTICESTOTAL DENIAL REASONS PROVIDED ON NOTICES 461461461461

TOTAL NUMBER OF SETTLEMENT CLASS MEMBERS RECEIVING A DENIAL TOTAL NUMBER OF SETTLEMENT CLASS MEMBERS RECEIVING A DENIAL TOTAL NUMBER OF SETTLEMENT CLASS MEMBERS RECEIVING A DENIAL TOTAL NUMBER OF SETTLEMENT CLASS MEMBERS RECEIVING A DENIAL

NOTICENOTICENOTICENOTICE461461461461

Page 6: 0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8

0 0 2 0 1 5 0 8 <1%

1.1.1.1.

2.2.2.2.

3.3.3.3.

4.4.4.4.

5.5.5.5.

SECTION 11 MMMMONETARYONETARYONETARYONETARY A A A AWARDWARDWARDWARD P P P PAYMENTSAYMENTSAYMENTSAYMENTS

Status by Confirmed Qualifying Diagnosis NumberNumberNumberNumber Amount

Notices of Monetary Award (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)Notices of Monetary Award (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)Notices of Monetary Award (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)Notices of Monetary Award (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks) 636636636636 $563,537,808$563,537,808$563,537,808$563,537,808

(e) Level 2.0 Neurocognitive Impairment 101 $139,970,264

(c) Alzheimer’s Disease 199 $97,178,616

(a) Death with CTE 71 $88,954,779

(b) ALS 32 $86,811,938

(f) Level 1.5 Neurocognitive Impairment 138 $85,572,394

(d) Parkinson's Disease 95 $65,049,816

(b) ALS 1 $7,042,438

(c) Alzheimer’s Disease 31 $21,415,901

Not Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List; or a Not Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List; or a Not Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List; or a Not Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List; or a

Claim Hold is in Place (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)Claim Hold is in Place (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)Claim Hold is in Place (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)Claim Hold is in Place (Dollars Shown are Before Holdbacks)164164164164 $159,719,575$159,719,575$159,719,575$159,719,575

(a) Death with CTE 3 $7,861,247

(f) Level 1.5 Neurocognitive Impairment 62 $34,868,230

Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List (Dollars Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List (Dollars Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List (Dollars Ready to be Included on the Next Monthly Payment List (Dollars

Shown are Before Holdbacks)Shown are Before Holdbacks)Shown are Before Holdbacks)Shown are Before Holdbacks)37373737 $18,583,662$18,583,662$18,583,662$18,583,662

(d) Parkinson's Disease 8 $4,517,713

(e) Level 2.0 Neurocognitive Impairment 59 $84,014,046

(c) Alzheimer’s Disease 13 $5,093,089

(d) Parkinson's Disease 6 $2,645,655

(a) Death with CTE 1 $202,507

(b) ALS 1 $479,729

Claims in the Payment Process (Dollars Shown are After Claims in the Payment Process (Dollars Shown are After Claims in the Payment Process (Dollars Shown are After Claims in the Payment Process (Dollars Shown are After

Holdbacks)Holdbacks)Holdbacks)Holdbacks)16161616 $36,927,191$36,927,191$36,927,191$36,927,191

(a) Death with CTE 1 $17,250

(e) Level 2.0 Neurocognitive Impairment 7 $3,598,988

(f) Level 1.5 Neurocognitive Impairment 9 $6,563,693

(d) Parkinson's Disease 4 $3,254,569

(e) Level 2.0 Neurocognitive Impairment 1 $20,432,781

(b) ALS 0 $0

(c) Alzheimer’s Disease 6 $1,229,328

(a) Death with CTE 66 $80,873,775

(b) ALS 30 $79,289,772

(f) Level 1.5 Neurocognitive Impairment 4 $11,993,263

Paid Claims/Paid to or on Behalf of Class Members or to Lien Paid Claims/Paid to or on Behalf of Class Members or to Lien Paid Claims/Paid to or on Behalf of Class Members or to Lien Paid Claims/Paid to or on Behalf of Class Members or to Lien

HoldersHoldersHoldersHolders498498498498 $348,854,531$348,854,531$348,854,531$348,854,531

(e) Level 2.0 Neurocognitive Impairment 34 $31,924,449

(f) Level 1.5 Neurocognitive Impairment 63 $32,147,208

(c) Alzheimer’s Disease 149 $69,440,299

(d) Parkinson's Disease 77 $54,631,878

(g) Derivative Claimants 79 $547,151

© 2018

BrownGreer PLC

NFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORTNFL SETTLEMENT PROGRAM SUMMARY REPORT

(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)(As of 10/8/18)6