˘ˇˆ - tokyo university of foreign studies · 18 ahmet midhat efendi ÙÚ™^ ƒ’Ûb ......
TRANSCRIPT
�� 19�� ����
���������� ��� —�����������—
�� ���� ������ ����� 8502050
��� ��
1
���� ································································································ 2 ��� ��� ������ ···························································· 4 ��� � ������������� !" ··········································· 6 � ! "#�$%"&'()*+ ····························································7 �,! -.························································································ 10 �/! "#························································································ 14 �0! "#12 ·················································································· 15
�#� $%&'���··········································································18 ()�� ·······························································································19 *+,- ·······························································································21 ./�0 ·······························································································21
2
����
� 3456789:Belly Dance;<$=>? @�>A�B5CDEFGH>IFJKLIM
1NFO$P>QR�S5CTU6VWXNYZ[\(]^_`"Eab"#
`cbde1fg1hi=>jk1lm(nop+"Eaqjk1"#`cbdQR
e1�rst"#=uv1wx(yz+v{|}Ea>�S5C`~�1�P�$�
��N���Qtb�$r`xb"#�$���ab�������`���(��
`*bdQR`=>����78�61��(y#����Q1�M�` ¡Eaq
$¢oa+*bd � 3456789<=FH1"#`cb$*£¤S6 r�x*r>¥¦ §�(¨
Ea+*b3456789<=�©1ª«N�x¬}q�1`cbdQR? @�
T���=4567891FOI$P+¨Ea+®#>¯N°�tb?8±6²¤S
8�1 )$P+³´1µ¶(�z+*bd � PDP>e1"#N·¸`"z+*q1r¹º�(=»�r @¼6`czq�$>
e1"#1v{r~��1�N½¾(¿P+*q�$��1ÀÁrÂ95ÂÃÄ(®
*+"#$78�61ÃÄ�IÅNƬtbÇÁ$�zqd2QR�3456789<
=Ȭ12nɤ�ÊËÌTÍ9�Ë8`1¼Î6$*£hiN$z+®#>eaÏ
ÐÑÒÓÍ6789$¢oab�$�cbd�q>e1ª«$"#1ÔÕ$P+1Ö
×Ø�DE>¯1°���?8±6²¤S8�`cb(�ÙoEÚ>¥¦`����
T? @�1³´Û1Ü6ÂÝ6 (=456789NÞ¯1�ß�$tbàá��
}aâ¢ãtE×à�a+*�*d3�1äP*ÃÄ(cz+�>�1å1"#=æç
°(�èz+é1F$*£êEaq�M`·ë1ìí1F`ìxîz+xqd 19çïð>�1"#=çñ(ò¡+óô�a>e1õö÷�aq3456789<
$*£÷$$�(�S5CTø69�Ë5�>U6VWXù`��·ú1cb"#1
)$�zqdG�>¦û(®*+��üNýoÚþ��¬ò¡EabB�W��9
��1"#$P+e1·ú=��(]rz+®#>QR>�Nò¡$Pq�I`
� r�Da+*bd PDP>3456789<$ �(¢z+�>? @��>����>�ˤÓ�>
��6?¤ >�5¼Ò�>¤8�����Ôtb$Ñ5r�*���ë�å�1�
1r�Rtbd�1y£(3456789<1Çh=ea�a1�I(nzq�ßN
��qdeP+>IM(yz+�ë�v�N�)y£(�zqq¡>�ë1IM1
1����������� �������������������� !��"�#
$��%��&�'%�(�)���*+*�������(,��(,-�(#,�
%�.%/��-�*��+�0��1 23�45*��6+#78�9$*%�:;�
,��<&�$�#$��7=����%3�,>?@ABC�;DE#$��
(�F��Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, Eds. Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy, Mazda Publishers, Inc. 2005, p.2GHI�Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-YoungJ 2 Karin van Nieuwkerk, “A Trade Like Any Other” Female Singers and Dancers in Egypt, University of Texas Press, 1995, pp.3-4, pp.179-185 3 ����KLM����NOPQR��%3STPQRU*VW*�
3
!��À"(yz+�Ôßtb�$r`xbd¥¦>���13456789<=u
v�w#$ç!ß$1ª«DEçñ13456789<1F`�x�$%$�z+*
bd û�`=>ç!ß&¸1���1¹º(®*+��'À�(è)`�c#>3456
789<$*£*+r §�(,*Eaby£(�b-¸1ø9.8/¯)(0µP>
QR13456789<11%$�¢oab"#r�1y£(23Ea+*qD()
*+�3bde14>QR1¼Î65 �9$P+67Pq3456789<(��
G*$8oab>"#N9�$P+íwP+*q"#�$:õcEÏb éT;<`
"Ea+*q=>�1°�?$P+@A1BÍÂNC£�$(tbd
4
���� ��� ������
� ? @�>���>¤Ë8��NFO$PqIM(=QR13456789<1f
$�bDE�(FG1"#rczqdea=H)�×(®}bII�NJÐqKL`
1~MN1"#rO1�$*oa+*bd4
� e1"#1À"= @¼6(yz+]¡Eaqd]�zq�I`�ßN��>QR
1456789TBËS8�1f$�zq$PÐEa+*bdÑ59��T¤9Ë6
Â�rQRtb$>e1"#= @¼6r9�$P+"zqS> T(=éU1F`
23Ea+*qd � 456789$*£¢ãr §�(,*Eaby£(�zq1= 1893�1¼CV(®}bBW�&X`cb$PÐEa+*bd
5�¯�ßNóôtb�$Nµ�$Pq
�1BW�`"#rçñ(H¡+óô�a>YZNÈ�(wDt�DEBË89�` danse du ventre :YZ1"#;$÷[}EaqdeP+e1\]`cb bellydance $*£*+r,*Eaby£(�zqd � PDP>456789="#(®}bw#1v{Nst,�(t^�*d�1�r
_`tb^_=&a1b#`cbd 3cd%"
61?=eÐfa�*��cbr>�1"#(gEabhNit$
*£�$(=vj�_`rcbdcEÏb�klT¿m1nf`cbYZ=>"#1
�D`�$¬(op�a>½q`�[\('À�ZÔ$�abd�ar$¬(op�
ab$>�1y£�wxNrYZ%" belly dances$*t1`cbd�z$��1�$âr*)�u:��1`cb$=êE�*�$NàvP+�P*d rYZ%"s=ØD(w�#xzqQx`=�*dyz1hL{YZN9¤8|t
bwx=t`(�3qd¸z1hL=>h½}Ni~�pbwxDE�br>�aN
��z=r�Z%" posterior dances$DrhZ%"s$w¡+*bd�1"#1à�=�°�Ë91õ°DE�RP+®#>"#�=~�`czqdPâPâ>
�1"#=>�����N� 1µ�$tb�$rÈ*r>PDP>ûg1µ�=>
��`czqde1S1cEÏb���$�1y£(>��1wx=>ìö�$��
4XYX�Z�[\]^_�`ab� cd2-�efg�hZiijklmhnopqr��
�s�DV�tuvw�xyizB{m|}h�GAnthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, p.18J 5 Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, p.1 6 ~���}h���close dance�p���]��_���XY��#c2��������Zi���]����Yg�a�}hZi�����}H��������}����b��
��hZi������f�f��h�]�� ¡¢b�2l�£Y¤�¥��g#(�¦�h�Z}|���]#(�¦�hZig���§¨�©}hZig���ª�I«�¬�>
,&i�hZig�h�&DV]®X¯°±�}�²³b´|Y�µ}h�OOO¶\���
·�����i�iX�¸¹���º»��º¼��\�h�/(8s2-�½¾]�¿�À
Á�Â���¿YgÃ��°±�i}��,�#Ä�Å·i�h�Æ-%�OÇ2-#È�É
ÊËÌÍÎÏÐ��ÑÒÓÔÕÖ×�1972�pp.44-45GHI�-%�OÇ2-#J
5
$N�e£$tb�1`cbd<7
� �1y£(>456789=YZNoptb"#N_`P>¥¦���abFH>
cb*=A�B5C��`"Eab"#N�t¢ã`=�*d � QR §�(3456789<$*âab"#r�)v{=ûg1_`$=��z
+*bd � QR13456789<=h>�>�>�N��qpb:�8 �Í6¼Î8
undulation;>�opb:¼�6>�q=¼��>shimmy;>�i�pb:�6Ê�circle;>���(wDt:9X¤Ë� spiral;wx1À"`��a+®#8
>eaE1
w#N�>�>Y>h��q}1�ZÅ`ea�au��p+jë(wDt:�¤�
Í6¼Î8 isolation;�$rv{`cb9d
� û�`=>�à1wx1À"N�)"#N3456789<$*t�$(tbd � 3456789<=�aE1wx1À"NYZ�VW�DE ¡4Ñ9±8�`1
½+1�V789Nstd�E(3456789<$*£�r"#1¢£$�bw#
N_`tb�$DE>A�B5C>FH>F¤� �1"#$>e1w#$¥��a
q�S5C>�E(=çñF1¦>§>¨©>ªÃÄ1CBW>�8�6�19²
6 >����²�6«8±6>¤8±6�W���cEÏb2¬`"Eab¥�h
N�std10
� �1y£(¥¦13456789<=P+¹º�(®u1"#`czqo}`=
�¬>]M(]rzqw#$,�1¯nh`cbd � �ËÌT���>¤Ë8��1lm1hL$=°*>�1¯n1"#(=����
DE=�*$�a+*bP>e1"#N�Pst,�>�±²Ù>w#1³´ß�a
q*µ÷��*d � e1q¡¶33456789<$¢oa+*+�IM(yz+*µ÷r��z+®
#>�VW�`@V178�6= shikhat>? @�`1vw1"#(= raks sharqi>���`�3456789<1 å= çiftetelli$*âa+*bdwx19±¤��IM(yz+��z+¬bd � ]M(]rzq�V789(�ÙoEÚ>e1O1= §�(FH>A�B5CD
E����`1IFJKLIM`cb$¢oa+*bd � ea=>·�`¸¹qy£(�1"#reaE1IM1H)�×`1II�º»1
KL(¼gtb$¢oa+*bDE`cbd � e1n½=>�1IM16¾p¿(®}b �(�Lß�aqÀ6¡N$b~�r
ÁDa+*qÍ56BTÂÃ16g`cbdeaE16¾=Ä�¬$�ïf¸ 3000�(�V1jk789r�Rtb�$1Å×$�zqd � PDP>Æ4(=ea=®(�V789r�RP+*q�$NÅ×tb(t^Ú>
7Ø -%�OÇ2-#�p.46
8 Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, p.1 9 Najwa Adra, “Belly Dance : An Urban Folk Genre”, Eds. Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy, Mazda Publishers, Inc. 2005, p.31-32 10 Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, p.1
6
e�DE7891�1vw1wx�×ED(tb�$=`x�*dyz+>È�(]
rbÇÈ5?6¼Î81F`3456789<r*)ÉìPqD=ÊØ(¨b�$=
Ö=>`cb$*oa+*bd11
� 3456789<=e1~�1Ë}1P�TD�NoptbwxDE 18çï&Xø5?8±5¡Â1ª«N�x¬}qd � �©·=FHTBÍÂ(ÌtbÍ�NÎE�p>Ï>�NÐÑPqà¸T"#�T
ø759ÊN�Ò(PqeȬ1ÓÃNîPqd � e£*zq?V²�WÊ�¤S6 rw0tbF>20çïH��S5C·(yz+Ô�,1Õ¿�r *-.N##¿�aqdYZNÕ¿�p>Ö$hNopPqÑÒ
ÓÍ6×-.=�©·1FHØ1ÙaNÚQßPq�1`czqd � e1-.=FH>A�B5C��1FOIM(®*+�¼Î65 �91ÛÜp1
ÝÚ$P+,*Eaby£(�zqdeP+>Þë=¥¦1»�1456789¼Î
6`eaNgb�$r`xbd � �1y£(¥¦13456789<=�©·(y#Ï>�NÐÑ�aq�1`cbd
3456789<=QR�¼Î65 �91 ß$P+=�t�tà�`9�5W@
�(�z+x+*bdPDP>e1"#1����á(µNâ}>ÐÑ�aqÏ>�
ãx(tb$e1���=[\( *�1`cb$oDbd¥¦>çñ`~�qä1
å1·ú=e1���ræ¡Eaqçè`cb$¢Ðb�é£d � &�>� ê`=QR3456789<$ §�(*âa+*b"#1v{$wë
Nì®(¸¹+xqd�,ê`=>3456789<1%Níz+xq$*Ðb9��
"#�()*+>3456789<rì�ab-¸1ø9.8/¯)(êwP¸¹b�
$(tbd ���� � ������������� !"
� jk1"#1DE=î�$~�1�äE1�1`��¬>"#1hL(=cEÏb
·ërÙoz+*qd12�a=ø9.8ïða1õ°(�¢Ðbde1õ°= Çengi>
Köçek $*âabî~1"#�r/¯1?8±6²¤S8�1FñNíz+®#>�ë�ò*óTôõ1]2`e1"#NöÕP+*qd©¯·÷kzr���1"#
�()*+Á*qÁø=>:õ1"#rQ°14567891ù�(�úùP*�$
N×Ø(sP+*bd13î~1"#�1XBû6.89=�ú¶ ü�abde1î
~1"#�()*+�1ê`�3+*¬d 11 Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, pp.1-4 12 Anthony Shay, “The Male Dancer in the Middle East and Central Asia”, Eds. Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy, Mazda Publishers, Inc. 2005, p.67GHI�ShayJ 13 Shay, p.66
7
��#� ����$�%&� !"
� ø9.8/¯1?8±6²¤S8�1FñNíz+*q"#�=î~ÙoEÚ��
��` Çengi$*âaqdÇengi=:õ1ýþ>~þ$»�DoE�*íwNP+*qd:õ=îr~1�N23q#>~��}`|�6@Nh�Pq#>��aaâ~
rî�Pq#PqdÇengi1÷= comicus>Spielmann>comediant>commediante>joueur de farce��1�ë��$¢oabr>�1*µ÷1�1=&a1 2�rG�`cb$PÐEabd
14
1> çenk$*âabm�d 2> ����` @¼6N_`tb çingened
� Çenk ="#(�*¼8Ó���$ �(2��abB6@`cbd"#$m�1Ù�NPÐaâ�1�1G��roDbdÇingene (ÙP+¢Ðâ>SBSW� 2çr 1453 �(�89±8�6@�N� Pqy>e1IM( @¼6r��Pò¡>"#�1�ZÔr @¼6`czq�$r�1�r�1`cb=>�=�Ôcbd
�äE�å°*`=�*1`cé£d � Çengi =î~��1"#�N�tr>õ(~1"#�N_`tb�$�cbd�E(>î1"#�Nst�=�1S( 2 )cbd15
)= köçek `c#>e1"#(�oablm= köçekçe$*âabd�£ )=>tavşan�P¬= tavşan oğlanı$*£÷`c#>tavşanca$*£lmN�£dKöçek$ tavşan1°*=-.`czq$¢oa+*bd � Köçek=����`��*$*£_`N�) küçük(¼gP+*bd16
e1¢ã1
b#>î1"#�1��r�¬>����DE"#Nò¡+*qdPDP>�ü(Ù
P+=>Anthony Shay1��F(&a1à¸rcbd � 3�E=PâPâ�¸rsty#Úz$�N$z+DE`�"z+*qP>��(
�z+�"b�1�*qd<17
� �1³�(yaâ>�©1ýþ$¶3y£(>���`í6�"#�1��rq}
���P�N��P+*qq¡>�¬gÐ+*qdPDP>~1"#�N köçek$*t�$�czqy£�d
18 � Tavşan= ��N_`tbd�a=�E1"#19±¤�DEg+*bdî1"# 14 Metin And, Culture, Performance and Communication in Turkey, Institute for The Study of Languages and Cultures of Asia & Africa, 1987, p.125GHI�And, 1987J 15 And, 1987, p.125 16 Shay, p.62 17 Shay, p.62 18 Ahmet Midhat Efendi�ÙÚ��^���ÛbÜ�Ý� çengii köçek�Þß�à�|}��h�
8
�="#1�F*)�PD¡¾NP+*+�=�x)z+®#>� �9²W@$
Ò8@NP+>�!�1"Ë$#N ��1y£(wDP+*qd�E1�1"#=
tavşan raksı$*âaqd19 � :õ"#�=�ë� kol $*âab$nT'}DEg+>³Û1¸`%mN23+*qd � "#�qä1 kol= 5)1$À�ø9.8ï1²Ù$Ùo#rczqd20 1> ��� 2> &'>¤W�W51Z( 3> )�çà 4> �±²Ù 5> @A � �aE1²Ù=�ë�ù�z1X�V81y£��1`c#>vj1õ("#�q
äN*À$PqdKol=e1$+c$$+å(,?Ë�Ñ6Nh�P+*qd�1 kol�ÞÔqä1X�V8²Ù1�$¶3*+N�z+*qd � Evliya Çelevi=Þq1÷kà1F`:õ1 kol()*+�×P+*bde�(=Ä�1"#�()*+¸¹Ea+*bd � 3¤9±8Ì�`9�±81ç-LT� (�£ò�> Ï1ç-L>./Lrc
b$x=*)`�0�>"#�>�ËÂ�z>Ýß>1�z��231Ä�qär&
�#> ¦F> 4F>�P¬=,¦T5¦å"z+®#>Ü9�DE64W@$
P+À7W�*z8*1Ê�¼�N�E£d9O(:xi#>;mN<¡b=$=�
(±8Ó58>À7W�(>Ê�¼����z+ç-L(?@tbd<21
� Evliya Çelevi1÷kà(= 121 kol()*+AP¬¸¹Ea+*bdÇ�r�(BE�Dzqq¡>Metin And, 1987 � Kemal Özdemil(�,>óô�a+*bZÔDE"#�()*+CaEa+*b�1Nóôtbd
22 � ,�µ1 Ahmed1 D= 300·1Ä�r*+ Balat(��`*qd�E="#��zqd � 5�µ1 Babanazlı1 D= 200·1Ä�1"#�r*qd�E1Ï>��wx=./1òN1EF1F`·&#N)¬z+*qd � G�µ1 Zümrüt 1 D= 300 ·1Ä�r*+>Yedikule>Narlıkapı>SulumanastırIHDEgq�5¼Ò·>��S��·�zqd"#�1F`�IxJ`c�}�*µNP+�*�)�1Ñø9¿q1�1r¤9±8Ì�NkK�p>È
¬1LMz(�NNop>�ENäP*OP(Q*R��d 19 And, 1987, p.125 20 And, 1987, p.108 21 Kemal Özdemil, Trans. Dara Çolakoğlu, Oriental Belly Dance, Dönence Basım ve Yayın Hizmetleri, 2000, p.54GHI�ÖzdemilJ 22 And, 1987, pp.109-110, Özdemil, pp.54-56
9
� S�µ1 Çelebi 1 D= 200 ·`>e1F`���P*"#�= Can Memi>Zalim Shah>Hürrem Shah>Fitne Shah>Yusuf Shah�zqd��79·1Mirza Shah =�P�`=TNN�U*`*qd�aE1Ä�qä=¤9±8Ì�`G÷(�#>9�±8ÂË� 4ç1¸`�"zqd9�±8=�E(ÈV1WNXÐqd � Evliya Çelevi1"#�(Ùtbà¸(�ȬgEaby£(>î178�6= *Y>$Æ�N�z+*�}aâ�E�DzqP>�!=µZ�är[z+*b$D�
P*$Áø�a+*qd � �E(�1à¸DE>"#�r !�(= @¼6>\7]·>Ñ59��Äe
^1�_>�5¼Ò·>��S��·>Ñø9¿q1z`cb�$roDbd23
� "#�1Ȭ=)��(=¤9ËÂ�(`)P+®#>���÷N�ä>�$��
1z=ÞÔqä1uÞ1Y>N�1¡Dta+N�z+*qdeaE=Q°1�÷1
y£��1`>Altıntop:W1¶;>Kanarya:CÉ5];>Tazefidan:�*bc;>Tilki:Ñd�;>Kivicik:IxJ;��`czqd24 � î~(õbtbD=wD`=�*r>Metin And(yb$~1"#�Te�fg1 D=&a1Àh`i��a+*qd � Kolbami$*âabD�d � D�1jkd � b\ 12·12ùzd � sıracı$*âaq 4·1lméd � Sıracı=2ùz12ù(�£��Nl*qd ·=m�nm�>�£ ·r nakkare$*âabop>î#1,·r±8Ó58N2�Pqd
25 � Çengi= 20çï1H�DEqrPò¡qdea=ø9.8/¯1qÐ1õ)`�czqdst>uA>vwý�$*£x³���yr%m(�ª«NXÐqdvw��
ý�=�·eNzÐb çengi 1 D($z+�{|$�#> D=}��a>"#�2~3·$e÷1lmé1~(�zqd � î1"#�(ÙP+=Kemal Özdemir1��F(AP¬qr1õ)r¢��a+*qd�(yb$>î1"#�=>.BÂ6� 2 ç:1808-1839;1ða1õ°(�a+*zqdeP+>1856�1Mustafa Reşit Paşa1_gN£}q��`���aqdȬ1"#�=? @�(��Pqd
26
23 Metin And, “Dances of Anatolian Turkey.”, Dance Perspectives 3, New York, 1959, p.28-30GHI And, 1959J 24 And, 1959, p.30 25 And, 1987, p.110 26 Özdemir, p.59
10
��#� '(
� Çengi =b\�6�9C6�1�(�þP14�4W�149�N0+>���±B±+1�1]*9C6��*+*qd�19C6�(=W1��#r|*+®#>
W14��NP+-.r���abd�="bõ(=�,1 filer$*âab�eN�*�a1�DE0}+*qd
27e1�= 19 çïð1ø�(�gb�$r`xbd:�
1,2;
� 1
27 Özdemir, pp.39-41
11
� 2
� î1"#�=> §�(W`���aqÇW�4W�1¼ÒdN0+*qdeP+>
�E1¼�Ê19C6�(=4��(nopqB58 :���#;r|}Ea+*
qd�=�*IxJ`�¯×1��N|}>~�1y£(�z+*qd28
� 16 çï(ÁDaq@A1"#�1Ó(�¶�1v{Ngb�$r`xbd(� 3>4)Kemal Özdemir (yaâ� 3r köçek`c#>� 4r~1 çengi`cbd
28 Özdemir, p.58
12
� 3
� 4
� � !` köçek$ tavşan1°*=-.`czq¸¹qy£(>tavşan="#14(uv1-.N0+*qdÌV6��1�*Ó�6X8d:Ïzq#$Pq¼Î6�
X8d;$¼�Ê1¼Òd>�þP1 Ò7W�Nq(|}>�E(h(=��NI
13
*+*qdeaE1-.=*)�}�roDby£��1`czqd29
� ~�Ntbî1"#�r�RP+*qy£(>e1��czqd�1!`AP¬C
abr>~1 çengi= tavşan¶�1-.N0+�(����N�z+"b�$�czqd:� 5;
� 5
29 Özdemir, pp.57-58
14
�)#� ��
� "#�=î`cé£r~`cé£rb\¶3y£(23+*qde1"#1i�À
"=½+¥¦13456789<(®*+�gb�$r`xbd � "#=&a1w#1À"`i��a+*qd � Ïz¬#$Pq:kd � ��cT� EP(yb¡õd � ¢*ú£zq9²W@d � �:yrP+>�q¤bw#d � ¥¦1µ)xd � §�tby£�q}1¬f#d � Ȭ1YZw#d � q}1�id � ¨1�Ø1Xa$�r©(|¬��1}ª1«#¬Pd � q}1f3#d � q}N(f3#®�tbwxd � �aE(@Ð+>õ(=¯°�aq±91�Q$$�(��Nq²#`�Qtb�
$tEczqy£�d30
� �E=��N$b4(�N EPq#>¢¬���³>zilli maşa>çegane T çarpara:�P¬= çalpara;$*âaq��c>c19@68>���W´�1B�8µ6¼8Ó�N,*qdB�8µ6¼8Ó�=¥¦13456789<`�y¬,
*EabÝÚ`cbd � �1y£�À"N�)"#1XBû6.89=�!¶�1·*õåDE¸×}�`
¹*+*qd � î1"#�()*+1à¸=g)DE�Dzqr>~1 çengi 1¼Î61 §�i�()*+= Kemal Özdemirr��F(�×�a+*q1`&a(�$¡qd31 � Çengi1¼Î6= 4ZDE�#�z+*qd 1>� D�$jk(yb “slow tempo”:�P¬= “slow dance”;d 2>� "#�qä(yb3456789<d 3>� "#�qä(yb“rabbit dance”d 4>� ºT»6Â��Ntb¼½��õåd � �Ú>ÛrZ¾(B#¿()*qy>lméqär"#rò�b�`1õåø6@
�8|1ºN0£de1õD�$jkrÄ21Û(ÀÁP+Âbd�1Ä2NÂbk
lr“slow tempo”$*âabd�1õÏz¬#q}NÞÃ(Ä}>�=�(Å�>�(�z+*b±8Ó58N EPqdeP+>Ä2N 4ÆÇb1`cbd � �(>"#�r�(¼8Ó�N0}+"bdeP+>�1õYN��qpq#hT
�N®�tb��3456789<vG1wxNPqd 30 And, 1987, p.125 31 Özdemir, p.36, pp.41-44
15
� 3 Z(�b$"#�=-.N�Ðbdî���Ó�6X8d$�þP1 Ò7W�N0+>h(¼Î6�NIx>�(����N�bd � ��`1"#= ��N8opby£�ȵÉfb²#|}rÈ*q¡>“rabbit dance”$÷|}Eaqd � �y1X6�`= çengi qä=�=T"E�*d�~qä=¥�=ÊË#TÔ·1y£�î1-.N0+¿+¬bdeP+Ì1ºN0zq#Pqd � �1y£(ø9.8/¯)1"#�=îr~1�ÍNPq$¶�(>~�î�NP
+î1y£(²b%zqd~1 çengi rî�NPq�$=î�Ûy#~�1³ÛNÎâpqd�1y£(¶�1úN�¬2¿NPq�$`>çengi =PâPâ¶�az`cb$¢��abdv(>î�Û1¸`"zq köçek T tavşan ()*+=�®�E`czqd�1y£("#�qä=çå1Ï_$ÐgN}+*qd §��"#�
(Ìtbg�=ear~12n=ÑÒ��C*N�aqP>î�12n=Ü�«Ê¼
Ò�$Ù�|}EaqdPDP>3e1«Ê¼Ò��íw= ÓB1q¡`czqDE>
�Er�1y£��âN�z+*y£re£pÔbNÐ�Dzqd<32eaÏÐ>*Ú
P�¶�a`czq$*£o}`=�*d � &�>"#�qä1"#()*+¸¹+xqd"#1i�À"Ngaâ>�Er"
z+*q"#r¥¦13456789<1w#([\(G*�1`c#>1%$�¢
Ðb�$roDbd � �1!`=>�Er�1y£�2`"z+*qD()*+¢�tbd �*#� ���+
� �E1XBû6.89=e1q¡(,_�aqvj�ÕeT2�2`�a+*qo
}`=�*d�E=ôõ1]2>¯é1)��1ò�>ç-LTN#>Ö1U>�6
,6B 9>×2>�·1�Ø��cEÏb$�é`"z+*qdPDP>~�r·
¸(¿+"b�$NÙzqÂ95ÂÃÄ(®*+>ò�1y£�2`"z+*q1=
~`=�¬î1"#�`czq$PÐEa+*bd33î1"#�rø9.8/¯1ò
�`"b�rÁDaqÓr�Rtbd:� 6>7; \(½+12ùz12ùrgEab2¬��RPqde£*zq21 )= 16çï
(= Tahtakale 1 �`czqde�(="#�1 DDEwe1p�g>�Úg>Û�g>=�Pé��c#$cEÏb·`ÜaDÐzqÝÞ$P+*qdWßà1
á1 @¼6§`cb Kağıthane1e1y£�21 )`czqd��= 17 çï$18çï(�E(·ú(�zqdæ>�1²8�r2ùz$³Û1��1q¡(�+Ea>âóTãeN¿t²8��czqd
34
32 Shay, p.63 33 Özdemir, p.46 34 And, 1987, p.108
16
� 6
� 7
17
� @A1BÍÂ(*âab çengi �*qdBÍÂ(*âaq"#�=>¢û�(«Ë6Â�Ê1���V8`cb,�8C6��BÈ9:äa1åæ ;$*£Z¾`
2ùNtb�$(�z+*qd9�±8=,�8C68�BÈ9(õëBÍÂ1z
qäNç*+mP��#>æD1èkNgq#Pqde1õ=BÍÂ1~�½hr?
éNê�a>&�zq·qä=lm>%">Ýß�z12ùNë¡+mP��$*£d
�1Z¾(*âaq"#�(ÙP+&a1à¸rcbd � 39�±81�]å`=>~mìrÓ���6`lmN�`>"#�qär9�±
81¸`"zqd"#�qä=í1Æ*�9581ÌË 9>4�4W�149�N
0+>Ïzq#$Pq9C6�N=*+*qd�x�9C6�=>�~qär"bq
µ(î�1y£(�x¬]rzqd�~qä>ïð·ï$16Â`2ùPqd6
Â=�ñ�$ïò·1"#�>ï·=gó*�zqd"#=¶D1(TôDEtE
a�+cb�õ¶("#�r�Nöât$�é`*)�÷ozqdea(Caq"#
�(>9�±8=ø�NXÐqd<35
� ·e(�eÈÄ1Úa=ì3+*br>-.1v{DE�~qär çengi `cb�$roDbd � BÍÂ(=î�`cbî1"#��e1"#NöÕtbq¡(çDaqdBÍÂ1
~�=�E1wx$"#Nnúo¬�fPy£$PqP>tavşan1uv�-.$¶��¡ù8N=*+mP��$*£d
36 � PDP>~�NP+456789N"z+*q Köçek`cbr>B6ÍÂ(*âaq4=>î�`cb$*£�¼DEÛ�gTýþ��$¶�(B6ÍÂ1~�qä$
1å(úf#rû}Ea+*qd37
� �E(>N.M.Ý8ü61��(=456789$*£¢ãr,*Ea+*bd � 3$¡��*ýþ$*�D*1�ãx$P+>�1å1èk=��Îâaq(är
*�*dõë>µ�N�Ð+>BÍÂ1©DEôæ178�6rçDaqr>e
a=��P`9��(���aqde·1�¸é(yb$>%"1��=����$
*£�1`�¬>456789e1S1*DroP*2ù`>earèk1�
ZÔN�¡+*qd<38
� N.M.Ý8ü61*£3456789e1S1*DroP*2ù<=��(ø5?8±5¡ÂNx{P+*bdø9.8ï)1�¸ér3456789<1Ï>
�NÐÑPq¤S6 N##¿P+*qd 35+áO&�%O-%*&�È�âãäÍÎå*+VØ á�*%�æ�}�ÏÐÒçèéê
ë×�1991�p.57 36 Shay, p.56, Özdemir, p.58 37 Shay, p.56 38 N.M.W�Ç*È�ìíîÍÎ��9�ïð�QiñÒòSKNèóR�1992�p.275 GHI�W�Ç*J
18
� �E(>�1à¸=:õ çengi qär�1y£(}�¡Ea+*qDN�P+*bdÇengi qä=ôõ12`"b�$NÙzq¤9Ë6Â�ß1F`·ë(��$� 1��1�±NzDpqd � Çengi 1"#=·ë1ìí(�¬+=�E�*�1`czqde£`czq(�ÙoEÚ>Ȭ1·ë=)��1�¼DE·¸`"b�$N�}qd � PDP>e1y£�ÃÄ`·ë=é1F`3456789<N"z+*qde1?
N�1ê`óôtbd �)�� ,-./���
� Q°13456789<1f(BÍÂ1�Rrczq$*£�$= §�(¢oa
b$�é`cbdPDPea=>Ȭ1·ër·¸`"b�$N�}qçè>)��
(����a+*�*é1�D`3456789<N"z+*q�$1���?(t
^�*1`=�*Dd � �1ê`=>e1y£�éUc1"#()*+¢�Pq*dPDP>e1y£�é
Uc`1"#(Ùtbº�=»�îz+*�*q¡>éUc`13456789<1
��oD#Tt*?$P+��`=BÍÂNC£dBÍÂ1"#(ÙP+=Ȭ1Ó
Tà¸rî�a+*bd$�éreaE1»�(�©·1FHØ1¤S6 TÍ�r
«��a+®#>Æ41"#r�1y£("Ea+*qD(ÙP+ÊØ(¨b�$=
�¡+�P*de1q¡>�1ê`=ȬN�b�$=`x�*r>~�qär&�
bBÍÂDE §ª 1ìíN�£�$=Ö=>`=�*�é£d � BÍÂ1~�qä1"#(ÙP+=>H¡+BÍÂNYZ«Ë65ø½}Ngq©
¯·$*oabBË891Æ�é Ò8ÊV6�BÍ6¼Òr�*q���()
*+1P��(1766)1F(gb�$r`xbd�r�65W@1N()*+�zqA��à¸1F(>~�qär9�±81q¡(PqcEÏb��rà�a+*bd � 3N=0�(k�oabd�£Pq²Ä1®N#F^=�~Er�z+*b
�¸Tù�Nt¹+�x¿P>���h``�mP�t�1NgpµEDty£�$>
æiD79Ë��µ=�(�z+¬aqd�·rÑ�6�W�T�8B1q¡(�
�Pq�£Pq���¼µ=>æDä�z$Pq0�NìZ�$�czqd�·rµ
�$£$P>ÈV1��N6 P>¶3y£(�Nse£$!z+*bdatbzN
"#ODED>$¬(ì�a�rE1ÏxODED`§�Py£$tb�*~�r>
¨$1%N���(&¬�`¾#a�b1N>oaoa=S¬`gD}q�$=�*d
þ'�%(>5¡Â(Ëzq)>*p(�Zlm>-.1þ��>²+cbÄæ>�
Î>,-�>̱{|¢taâ� 1.�$/ir0¿Pq�z$�16���1{
1t¹+r>9�±81µ1a1�1³mI` }$�z+s�a+*bd<39
39 W�Ç*�pp.407-410
19
� &�1à¸(=>~�qär9�±8(2âabq¡(ÞEN���(gpb�3
1 )$P+16��"#N"z+*q�$roDbdBÍÂ1~�qä=ÞÔqä
rgq çengi qä1"#N�ÍP>ÞÔqärmPZ�$$ÞÔqä1$·NÎâpb�$Nµ�(QR13456789<1ÇhN"z+*qd¶3�$= T1~�
qä1å`�¢ÐbdBÍÂ1~�qärêEaq2¬`êEaq·(â}+345
6789<N"z+*qy£(>·ë1å`�é1F$*£êEaq�M`%m1
ß$P+4P�a+*qdQR����1·ë="#N9�$P+*b@V78�6
&©�»�1·r"b�$N[\(Ï~>5réUc`=78�6`cb$*Ðbd
�1y£(3456789<=¥¦¨Ea+*bà��¼Î65 �9�À"�}`
�¬>·ë(]¬4P�aqéU1%m$P+16¾��z+*b1`cbd 01��
� û�`=>QR §�(¨Ea+*b3456789<1f$�zq"#()*+>
3456789<$*£,�r §�(,*Eaby£(�b-¸1ø9.8/¯)
(êwP+¸¹+xqde14>�Ú ê`¥¦13456789<r�)_`$v
{()*+¸¹>,ê`¼Î65 �9�À"ro*QR13456789<19±
¤�(��G*$8oab@V1"#�()*+>/ê`=3456789<réU
c`�Ȭ1·ë("Ea+*q�$)*+BÍÂN?($z+�×P+xqd � ¥i>3456789<$*£78�"#NCzq�$>�E(e1"#r9DE*
DroP*"#�$g��a+*q�$DEÊØ�à�rîz+*�*[\(�P*
²6.`czq$æ:P+*bd � &a>���1¹º�zMetin And1�S8�N�,tbd � 3"bÄ�>Ä~(ÙP+���1;�=ÄPPD±<N=_P+*�*d�>�
E(?1Ȭ1#é($z+"b�$=—$#o}@V1~�TÄ�r@ozq2n—ÖÝA`B�9À6d�$g��a+*qDE`cbd �>©¯1÷kz=ÞÔqä1��(®*+�1��WÊ()*+C*qrbr>�E="#1C*ÝA�$
DE�v{âD#NopP>ÞÔqär�aE1XBû6.89Ngqõ(z*q�
�)}F��1ÏGONÁø1F(Ht�$r`x�*d<40
� �1y£(456789=e1S1���1 ^%"$=°*ÊØ�9²W@Tw
#rà�aqº�r»��RP�*d�E(>"#�(Ùtbîz+*b�¸�Ȭ
rø5?8±5¡Â1ª«N�x¬}qÏ>�>���1op�aq�1`cbd � "#�&©r"z+*q=>�NY¡+�>Ȭ12n cTBÍÂ��·µ()
40 And, 1959, p.24
20
D�*$�é`"Ea+®#>e1Æi=Ö×I���`cbd � ¥i��N�¬(cqz+�fëÊØ�º�rÄ�*�( �;�r�(BE�D
zq�1�Ȭ>;�ÖJ=K¡�Dzq1rOî#`cbdPDP>3456789<
r�1y£(Ö×Ø�"#`cbDE�e>ÄP`�ÆiN×ED(tb�$(_`
rczq$8£d � 9²W@��1w#Nvwß`x�*3456789<(®*+>%"(�oab
lm()*+��Ú}���$(�¥i=CaEa�DzqdÄP`�e1ÆiN×
ED(tbq¡(>e£*zq:õ13456789<(®}bÚ}�À"1��N
¥y1��$Pq*d
21
2345
N.M.Ý8ü6�>LMN]��@C@@O1´$ª�PQ��¿RÛ>1992 �ÍÇ5��Ê�65?�>SÇT]�B6ÍÂ� ÇW6�(H�aqçñ�U
¿��VÃ>1991 W'�XY> Z[ ]��@C@@ONe\� B6ÍÂ1Õ]��@C@@ONe
\½&^kÄ>1980 Ê��üWÊ9�>�_'�]�çñ%"º�lm`aÃ>1972 Eds. Anthony Shay and Barbara Sellers-Young, Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy, Mazda Publishers, Inc. 2005
Anthony Shay, “The Male Dancer in the Middle East and Central Asia”, ibid. Najwa Adra, “Belly Dance : An Urban Folk Genre”, ibid. Kemal Özdemil, Trans. Dara Çolakoğlu, Oriental Belly Dance, Dönence Basım ve Yayın Hizmetleri, 2000
Metin And, Culture, Performance and Communication in Turkey, Institute for The Study of Languages and Cultures of Asia & Africa, 1987
Metin And, “Dances of Anatolian Turkey.”, Dance Perspectives 3, New York, 1959 Karin van Nieuwkerk, “A Trade Like Any Other” Female Singers and Dancers in Egypt, University of Texas Press, 1995
Ahmet Midhat Efendi, Eds. Erol Ülgen, Fatin Andı, Çengi, Kafkas ; Süleyman Musli, Türk Dil Kurum, Ankara, 2000
�������
���Qb³´Ûhttp://www.home.turkey.or.jp/ ? @��N\� ? @��³´Ûhttp://www.egypt.or.jp/ 67�8
� 1� 19çïð1 çengi� Özdemil, p.49 � 2� 19çïð1 çengi� Özdemil, p.48 � 3� Köçek� Özdemil, p.58 � 4� Çengi� Özdemil, p.45 � 5� 19çïð1 çengi� Özdemil, p.43 � 6� ø9.8ï1ò�`"b köçek D� Özdemil, p.56 � 7� ø9.8ï1ò�`"b köçek D� Özdemil, p.57