www.mediationsupport.info restorative justice -overview, examples and matters of contention...
TRANSCRIPT
www.mediationsupport.info
Restorative Justice-overview, examples and matters of contention
(Presented by Paul Crosland)
“An enemy is one whose story we have not heard”
-Gene Knudsen-Hoffman
www.mediationsupport.info
The conflicts which have been criminalised
..to whom is this conflict valuable?
Nils Christie, 1977 -”Conflicts as Property”
www.mediationsupport.info
3 paradigms
“evil people” paradigm
“wrong behaviour” paradigm
“all actions are meaningful” -action planning paradigm
Focus of RJ:
RJ as offender
education/therapy and victim healing
Limited scope eg forced restitution
Understanding the meaning
behind behaviours and generating the resourcefulness for all in making future
choices
www.mediationsupport.info
6 Principles of RJ(through “wrong behaviour” & “meaningful behaviour”“meaningful behaviour” lenses)
➲ 1)➲ Victim support and healing is a priority➲ Generating understanding and
resourcefulness is prioritised
www.mediationsupport.info
6 Principles of RJ(through “wrong behaviour” & “meaningful behaviour”“meaningful behaviour” lenses)
➲ 2)➲ Offenders take responsibility for what they
have done➲ Taking responsibility for one's actions and
needs is key
www.mediationsupport.info
6 Principles of RJ(through “wrong behaviour” & “meaningful behaviour”“meaningful behaviour” lenses)
➲ 3)➲ There is dialogue to achieve understanding➲ There is dialogue to achieve understanding
(not necessarily with the actual other i.e. substitution to enable comprehension and action planning)
www.mediationsupport.info
6 Principles of RJ(through “wrong behaviour” & “meaningful behaviour”“meaningful behaviour” lenses)
➲ 4)➲ There is an attempt to put right the harm
done➲ Actions are taken to embody healing and
generate resourcefulness
www.mediationsupport.info
6 Principles of RJ(through “wrong behaviour” & “meaningful behaviour”“meaningful behaviour” lenses)
➲ 5)➲ Offenders look at how to avoid future
offending➲ Emphasis on how all can make choices
which are better able to meet all identified needs
www.mediationsupport.info
6 Principles of RJ(through “wrong behaviour” & “meaningful behaviour”“meaningful behaviour” lenses)
➲ 6)➲ The community helps to reintegrate both
victim and offender➲ Communities provide the context in which
choices are made and their engagement is key
www.mediationsupport.info
The dangers of a focus on: ➲ Restorative rehabilitation➲ Victim appeasement
www.mediationsupport.info
Retributive Culture/ Restorative Culture
➲ Identify who was wrong
➲ Forcibly re-educate
➲ Maintain control
➲ Identify unmet needs
➲ Restore harmony between those involved
➲ Re-establish balance
➲ Focus of evaluation->>>>>>>
➲ Focus of response->>>>>>>
➲ Social consequences->>>
(Dominic Barter, 2007 training)
www.mediationsupport.info
➲ Stages of criminal justice at which restorative justice occurs:
● Not prosecuted/Diversion● Reprimand/ Final Warning● Preparation of Pre-Sentence Report● Serving a community sentence● Serving a custodial sentence● Post custody (on licence)● Post sentence at request of victim or offender.
www.mediationsupport.info
Who gate-keeps which acts warrant RJ?
Author needs
Recipient needs
Community Needs
Domestic Violence cases?
www.mediationsupport.info
Styles of facilitation
➲ The one-party led process➲ The 'impartial' process➲ The 'multipartial' process
www.mediationsupport.info
Key aspects of restorative processes
➲ Mutual comprehension➲ Self Responsibility➲ Action Planning
www.mediationsupport.info
Areas of contention when collectively reviewing RJ principles
➲ 'Impartiality'➲ Voluntariness➲ Confidentiality
www.mediationsupport.info
RJ and the capacity to 'live your dreams'-George's story
www.mediationsupport.info
The F word in RJ
➲ Forgiveness (unhealthy without empathy)➲ Apology (meaningless without empathy)
Recommended website:ApologyPlus.org.uk
-more than sorry
www.mediationsupport.info
www.mediationsupport.info
www.mediationsupport.info
Case examples
➲ (Suspected) “Paedophile” beaten up by gang of youth on estate
➲ Hostage taking in relation to drug-dealing debts.
www.mediationsupport.info
How RJ works -account from victim (secondary)
of Fred (& Rosemary) West
➲ “If both people can talk about their lives, then the perpetrator usually expresses remorse. Consequently the victim feels more generous towards them.”
www.mediationsupport.info
Proposition -all behaviour is an attempt to meet (universal) needs
➲ Come up against our own limits to empathy
www.mediationsupport.info
Preparation for Face to Face meeting
● Coach the Victim and Perpetrator to giving and receiving empathy, before a face to face meeting.
www.mediationsupport.info
Face to Face -Step 1 of 6
●Victim receives empathy for their present pain from Perpetrator until they feel understood.
www.mediationsupport.info
Face to Face -Step 2 of 6
●Ask Perpetrator, “How do you feel as you hear victims pain”? ●Facilitator translates self hatred, guilt, shame and all thinking that they are bad, to feelings and unmet needs - this can help them then connect to their mourning.
www.mediationsupport.info
Step 3
●Victim empathises with Perpetrators mourning.➲At this point the Victim is usually ready to understand the Perpetrator.
www.mediationsupport.info
Step 4
➲ Facilitator asks the Perpetrator “What was going on in you at the time” when you did what they did.
www.mediationsupport.info
Step 5
● Facilitator helps Victim empathise with the Perpetrator.
www.mediationsupport.info
Step 6
➲ Parties make Request to each other to make life more wonderful, this could include reparations etc.
➲ (“Most wonderful thing” Marshall Rosenberg Workshop audio track “Forgiveness and Reconciliation”)
www.mediationsupport.info
All people are saying 'please' and 'thank you'
➲ What's alive?➲ What would make life more wonderful?
www.mediationsupport.info
The Skills of a Mediator / Restorative Justice Worker
➲ Empathy for all➲ Translating ways people say please and
thank you into clear observations, feelings, needs and requests
➲ Encouraging parties to express what each other is needing
www.mediationsupport.info
1) punishment, 2) rewards
3) guilt and shame4) obligation and duty
➲ If I'm trying to control someone else or myself I will use those 4 things -all disastrous
➲ All violent➲ Why do we want people to do things?➲ Do we want people to want to give?
www.mediationsupport.info
Domination Structures
➲ Teach blame -and self-blame
www.mediationsupport.info
Behaviour that is “a tragic expression of unmet needs”.
Doing the best?
➲ If people not doing the best they know how to meet their needs, what model is being suggested? That they are evil?
➲ How can a restorative worker work constructively with that?
www.mediationsupport.info
Reflect on a case of sexual offending with which
you are familiar-what are the unmet needs of
the victim(s)?
➲ (Use yellow post-its please)
www.mediationsupport.info
What do you speculate to be the needs that the offender in some way met in doing
what they did?
➲ (Use pink post-its please)
www.mediationsupport.info
What do you speculate to be the unmet needs of the
offender in doing what they did?
➲ (Use pink post-its please)
www.mediationsupport.info
What do I have to do to meet my needs at the expense of someone
else?
➲ I have to cut off from the other person's humanity /humaness
www.mediationsupport.info
The role of Role Play?
➲ Transforming enemy images by mediating between someone involved in the offence (victim or offender) and someone not involved with full needs consciousness. (Met and unmet needs of both)
www.mediationsupport.info
Working with enemy images➲ The emotional pain is a product of
projections (no one causes you to feel anything)
➲ (playground example -same physical pain -different responses)
➲ Think of something that someone did that brings up pain when you think about it
➲ How would you work on transforming the enemy image?
www.mediationsupport.info
Feelings literacy➲ Emotional intelligence -Daniel Goleman et
al➲ Self-awareness, self-management, social
awareness, relationship management➲ Intensity of feelings➲ Teaching feelings by initially engaging with
feelings that are more easily acknowledged -excitement etc
➲ Computers and emotional literacy➲ -the role of feelings -to indicate met or
unmet needs. Towards Needs Literacy
www.mediationsupport.info
Gender and feelings - needs
➲ Generalisation -males more likely to say 'yes' to a guessed need rather than a guessed feeling
➲ Women - more comfortable with an exploration of feelings first to get to the underlying needs
www.mediationsupport.info
Who is dangerous?
➲ The offender who says 'I'm dirt for doing what I did'
➲ The offender who will not look at their met and unmet needs?
www.mediationsupport.info
What ApologyPlus does?
➲ More than sorry➲ Encouraging people to take responsibility
and to be present with what is alive in the other person
➲ Enabling unmet needs to be clearly seen
www.mediationsupport.info
Thank you
www.mediationsupport.info
The definition of RJ
➲ “Restorative Justice works to resolve conflict and repair harm. It encourages those who have caused harm to acknowledge the impact of what they have done and gives them an opportunity to make reparation. It offers those who have suffered harm the opportunity to have their harm or loss aknowledged and amends made.”(Restorative Justice Consortium 2006)