woodrow wilson bridge project woodrow wilson bridge ... · woodrow wilson bridge project ... v6, v5...

39
Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project 1 Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project 1 Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Virginia Approach Spans David Tackoor, HNTB Formerly of URS Corp for Potomac Crossing Consultants Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Virginia Concrete Conference 2009

Upload: buidang

Post on 12-May-2018

251 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

1

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

1

Woodrow Wilson Bridge ProjectVirginia Approach Spans

David Tackoor, HNTB

Formerly of URS Corp for Potomac Crossing Consultants Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

Virginia Concrete Conference 2009

Page 2: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

2

Second Severn Crossing

Page 3: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

3

Medway Crossing (Channel Tunnel Rail Link)

Flared segments Tapered pier legs

Page 4: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

4

• Virginia approach Spans• Contractor: Granite/Corman joint venture • Construction Budget: $135M• Completed: August 2008

Page 5: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

5

Construction stages

February 2003Demolition of Hunting Towers

March 2003

October 2004

Page 6: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

Virginia Approach Spans

Page 7: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

7

Challenges

Segment shape - multi directional curvature

Schedule - Finite bridge opening dates. Fixed Construction cycle

Confinement - restricted site space and access, water bound two sides, two public trails across site

Access - difficult access to arches for grouting, stressing repair and finishing operations

Inspection - effective client/contractor team integration, common goals. Apply principles of trust and money, partnering

Mass concrete operations - Pier knuckle and pile caps

Coordination - with adjacent contractors for approach highway and bascule bridge

Continuous improvement – Flexible working methods, concrete

Page 8: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

8

Foundation and pedestal construction

Page 9: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

9

Detailed view of pedestal

Page 10: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

10

Construction

Page 11: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

11

Tie Beam

Knuckle

BearingPad

Pedestal andFoundation

Arch Rib

V-pier structure

Page 12: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

12

Pier knuckle

Page 13: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

13

Pier knuckle/tie beam assembly

Page 14: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

14

Epoxy resin adhesive

Normal and slow-set epoxiesMultiple temperature range formulations requiredSpecific requirements for

•Consistency•Gel Time•Contact Time•Compressive Yield Strength•Bond Strength•Heat Deflection

Special requirements for low temperature (20-40ºF) applications

Page 15: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

15

Placing upper knuckle and tie beams

Page 16: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

16

Upper knuckle construction

Page 17: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

17

Segmental Precast Pier Overview4 V-Piers at 6 Pier Locations >> 24 V-Piers >> 48 Arches

Two Separate but Similar Pier Geometries• One casting bed for 14’ Arches converted to cast 18’ Arches

™ 20 Arches 14’ Typical Width V7 OL, V6, V5

™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL

• One casting bed for 16’ Arches

™ 24 Arches 16’ Typical Width V4, V3, V2

Five Segment Types– Starter (length varies) – highest #– Typical (10’ long at top) - #5 to #9– Flared (inconsistent width) - #4 to #1– Knuckle (bearings) - #0– Tie Beams (span arch to arch)

Page 18: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

18

Segment placing

Temperature curing closure pour Placing segment

Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed

Page 19: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

19

Temporary stay system

Page 20: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

20

Post-tensioning

Page 21: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

21

Grouting operations

Page 22: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

22

Pre-casting operations

Page 23: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

23

Concrete placing sequence

121

3

5

3 33

4

Web

FlareWall

PourWindow

PourWindow

Page 24: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

24

Outline – two improvements

Overview of Precast Segmental Piers• Long Line vs. Short Line Casting

Project Innovations & Best Practices• Segment Casting Sequence (time & cost savings)

• Precast Segment PT Bar Joint Interface (quality)

Page 25: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

25

Linear Casting Sequence

Elevation

Plan

Knu

ckle

Segment ID

Casting Order

Page 26: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

26

Skip Casting Sequence

Casting Order

Segment ID

Knu

ckle

Plan

Elevation

Page 27: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

27

Post-Tensioning Bar Interface at Segment Joints

Page 28: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

28

Post-Tensioning Bar Interface at Segment Joints

Hole in PT Plate Washer is 1-7/8” for 1-3/8” PT BarDuct is I.D. is 3-5/8”A blockout almost doubles the size of the mandrel allowed to keep ducts

straightBlockout is 2-1/4” deepRebar cover is only 1-1/2”

Page 29: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

29

Original plate washer blockout

Page 30: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

30

Problems with original P/T plate washer blockout

Page 31: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

31

Modified Plate Washer Blockout

PT PLATE WASHER BLOCKOUT5"x9"x1-3/4" PLATE WASHER

SEGMENT JOINT

WETCAST SEGMENT MATCHCAST SEGMENT

3" P

E D

uct

4" P

E D

uct

3" P

E D

uct

CL 1-38" PT Bar

Page 32: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

32

Results of Modified Blockout

Page 33: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

33

Continual improvements

Page 34: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

34

Demolition of old bridgeTransparent noise wall

Transparent SoundwallApril 2008

Page 35: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

35

Steel superstructure

Lead core elastomeric bearing

Page 36: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

36

Deck construction

Page 37: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

37

Median and fascia barrier walls

Page 38: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

38

Value engineering

Sequence of pre-casting segments from linear to skip casting. This change resulted in significantly improving productivity

Decision to locate the precast yard on the job site

Separating the precast knuckle segment into three pieces to accommodate handling and placing

P/T duct connectors at segment bulkheads for improved alignment across joints. This cut a four-hour procedure down to 30 minutes

Mandrill use in pre-cast ducts reduced coring or open concrete repairs

Casting knuckle nose at ground level as opposed to in the air

Combining an inflatable bladder with the mandrill use in pre-cast ducts reduced coring or open concrete repairs

Needle beam formwork system for the large bridge deck overhangs to mitigate girder torsion issues

A slip-exit off the Capital Beltway was created to ease material deliveries and relieve in town congestion.

Daily improvements via RFC’s and RFI’s

Page 39: Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project Woodrow Wilson Bridge ... · Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project ... V6, V5 ™ 4 Arches 18’ Typical Width V7 IL ... Knuckle core Knuckle wing placed. Woodrow

Woodrow Wilson Bridge Project

39

Thank you!

David Tackoor, HNTB([email protected])

My gratitude to Mr. Bret Barton P.E. of Granite Construction. Bret provided several slides and made a significant contribution to building the team and partnering the project through to successful completion.