wood dust & western red cedar- ( 5/5/10)---l dust 6 9 2010.doc · web viewwood is often treated...

21
WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- (6/9/10)---L. Morse MD (with thanks to Bob Barish, Scott McAllister and Paul) SUMMARY: Wood dust exposure has been documented in dozens of reports from around the world as the cause of allergic lung disease , non allergic pulmonary disease, and sinonasal cancer. Less frequently, wood dust has been described as causing alveolitis, pulmonary fibrosis, dermatitis and other cancers. A summary document by ACGIH in 2005 proposed a TLV of 1 mg/M3 for wood dust in general, and 0.5 mg/M3 for Western Red Cedar, with a sensitizer designation. The conclusion ACGIH reached was based on it’s extensive review of the literature. (ACGIH released it’s “final” document in 2010 with the same conclusion but without updating the literature review.) ACGIH in the TLV designated oak and beech dusts with respect to carcinogenicity as 1A - Confirmed Carcinogens, and birch, mahogany, teak, and walnut as A2 Suspected Human Carcinogens. The ACGIH TLV designates all other wood dusts as A4 - Not Classifiable as Human Carcinogens. The U.S. National Toxicology Program (NTP) in its 11th Report on Carcinogens (11 th ROC, 2005) designates wood dust as being “Known to be a human carcinogen” based on sufficient evidence of carcinogenicity from studies in humans, while also noting there is inadequate evidence for the carcinogenicity of wood dust from studies in experimental animals. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) in its document last updated in 1997 similarly has classified wood dust as being Group 1 Carcinogenic to humans, stating there is sufficient evidence in humans for the carcinogenicity of wood dust, and inadequate evidence in experimental animals for the carcinogenicity of wood dust. Most recently, California’s OEEHA added wood dust to the Prop 65 list of carcinogens. An extensive review of the literature was performed for the development of this report for HEAC. Overall, there seems to have been a decline in exposure levels compared to older studies, with corresponding decrease in positive associations. In addition, recent research into mechanism of injury and pathophysiology has led to increased biological plausibility for wood dust causation of both cancer and non malignant lung disorders. Exposure monitoring and protection issues are complicated with wood dust, since there are over 12,000 species of trees worldwide, and a wide range of industrial applications. There are studies which show that biological contaminants, such as fungi and molds, and chemical contaminants, such as formaldehyde, can cause or contribute to the pathology. In addition it seems that different types of wood cause injury through different mechanisms on

Upload: buitruc

Post on 30-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- (6/9/10)---L. Morse MD (with thanks to Bob Barish, Scott McAllister and Paul)

SUMMARY: Wood dust exposure has been documented in dozens of reports from around the world as the cause of allergic lung disease , non allergic pulmonary disease, and sinonasal cancer. Less frequently, wood dust has been described as causing alveolitis, pulmonary fibrosis, dermatitis and other cancers. A summary document by ACGIH in 2005 proposed a TLV of 1 mg/M3 for wood dust in general, and 0.5 mg/M3 for Western Red Cedar, with a sensitizer designation. The conclusion ACGIH reached was based on it’s extensive review of the literature. (ACGIH released it’s “final” document in 2010 with the same conclusion but without updating the literature review.) ACGIH in the TLV designated oak and beech dusts with respect to carcinogenicity as 1A - Confirmed Carcinogens, and birch, mahogany, teak, and walnut as A2 Suspected Human Carcinogens. The ACGIH TLV designates all other wood dusts as A4 - Not Classifiable as Human Carcinogens. The U.S. National Toxicology Program (NTP) in its 11th Report on Carcinogens (11th ROC, 2005) designates wood dust as being “Known to be a human carcinogen” based on sufficient evidence of carcinogenicity from studies in humans, while also noting there is inadequate evidence for the carcinogenicity of wood dust from studies in experimental animals. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) in its document last updated in 1997 similarly has classified wood dust as being Group 1 Carcinogenic to humans, stating there is sufficient evidence in humans for the carcinogenicity of wood dust, and inadequate evidence in experimental animals for the carcinogenicity of wood dust. Most recently, California’s OEEHA added wood dust to the Prop 65 list of carcinogens.

An extensive review of the literature was performed for the development of this report for HEAC. Overall, there seems to have been a decline in exposure levels compared to older studies, with corresponding decrease in positive associations. In addition, recent research into mechanism of injury and pathophysiology has led to increased biological plausibility for wood dust causation of both cancer and non malignant lung disorders.

Exposure monitoring and protection issues are complicated with wood dust, since there are over 12,000 species of trees worldwide, and a wide range of industrial applications. There are studies which show that biological contaminants, such as fungi and molds, and chemical contaminants, such as formaldehyde, can cause or contribute to the pathology. In addition it seems that different types of wood cause injury through different mechanisms on molecular basis. (Whether that has any major relevance is unclear at this time.)

The US has 34 million asthmatics and 16 million with chronic bronchitis/ chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, with estimated 14 million with COPD undiagnosed. The etiology of these diseases includes genetic predisposition, tobacco smoking and environmental pollutants, in addition to occupational exposures to a wide range of chemicals and dusts. 47 million US citizens have Metabolic Syndrome, characterized by obesity, diabetes, abnormal lipids, and hypertension, and now 24% of the US workforce has Metabolic Syndrome. Obesity is now considered an independent risk factor for lung disease. These figures are all expected to rise over the next 20-30 years.

Because of the history of lung disease findings at higher wood dust exposure levels, with recent lower wood dust dose studies showing no or little adverse effect, and because of the clear carcinogenicity of

Page 2: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

wood dust vis a vis sino-nasal cancer, and our workforce’s increasing pulmonary risk factors as described above, HEAC support of ACGIH’s position of lowering the PEL to 1 mg/M3 inhalable dust seems reasonable. NIOSH also proposes this level as a REL. A 5 fold reduction in exposure should also reduce the risk of sinonasal cancer to 1 case per million exposed. Many studies, including a recent large US one, show that exposure levels have already decreased well below the current California PEL of 5 mg/M3. .Western Red Cedar is a special case, because of the extensive conclusive scientific analysis of it’s pathophysiology, and should have a PEL of 0.5 mg/M3 and sensitizer designation.

BACKGROUND:

CAS-none

CHEMICAL FORMULA-None

SYNONYMS: n/a

CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES: Wood dust is defined as wood particles resulting from processing or handling of woods. Woods are divided into hardwood, from broad leafed deciduous trees which flower; and softwood, from conifers which do not shed their leaves in the winter. Tropical woods or “exotics”, (which are both ) are frequently a cause of allergic wood dust disease, but are rarely used in the United States.

Chemically, wood is composed of cellulose(a polysaccharide consisting of linear chains of glucose), hemi-celluloses (amorphous heteropolymers, ie matrix polysaccharides, such as arabinoyxlans) and lignin (polymeric phenylpropane), plus hundreds of high and low molecular weight compounds which protect the wood from attack by fungi, insects etc. These include terpenes, stibenes , tannins, flavinoids, quinines, and phenols. In addition, wood can be contaminated by fungi, molds, & insects, which can be irritants or allergenic in their own right. ACGIH notes that 5% to 30% of the wood mass can be composed of these other compounds, and a recent study from Tulane found even higher values for non wood solids.

Wood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate (CCA), ammoniacal copper arsenate (ACA), and formaldehyde and pentachlophenol as preservatives; lead based paint in the past; and epoxy and other glues in production of pulp/wood fiber products and plywood, etc.

Western red cedar is a softwood widely used in construction because of its resistance to molds, fungi and other causes of decay. California has only isolated strands of this wood along the coast from Humboldt County northward, and imports it from other states and Canada

FORMS, USES AND APPPLICATIONS: Rough cutting operations which “shatter” the wood, generate larger particles (20-30 um or more) which are much less likely to be inhaled into the lungs, but may impact the nasal and sinus mucosa. . Other processes such as sanding, generate smaller particles (1-2 um). Processes which produce smaller particles are also more likely to be indoors, increasing the risk. The type of operation being performed is the most important factor in exposure.

Page 3: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

CURRENT WORKPLACE LIMITS AND PUBLIC HEALTH LIMITS: (Usually measured as “inhalable” particulate mass because of effects on both upper and lower respiratory systems)

Cal OSHA : current—Wood dust 5 mg/m3

Carcinogenicity: Not designated by Cal OSHA, but OEEHA recently added it to Prop 65

Fed OSHA: Currently wood dust is regulated as Particulate NOS, ( “nuisance dust”) at 15 mg/M3 (CFR 29 1910 1000 Table TZ1

ACGIH 2005 & 2010: TLV-TWA 1 mg/M3 inhalable particulate mass –all species except WRC for which the proposed TLV –TWA is 0.5 mg/M3, and Sensitizer designation.

NIOSH REL The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) has established a recommended exposure limit (REL) for wood dust, all soft and hardwoods, except western red cedar of 1 mg/M3) as a TWA for up to a 10-hour workday and a 40-hour workweek [NIOSH 1992]. This was reviewed and reissued 7/09.

ACGIH Carcinogenicity: A1-Confirmed human carcinogen: oak, beech

A2-Suspected human carcinogen: birch, mahogany, teak, & walnut

A4: Not classifiable as a human carcinogen: all other wood dusts, including Western Red Cedar

International levels: European Union 5 mg/M3

Sweden OEL 2 mg/M3

MAJOR COMERCIAL USES: Construction, furniture and cabinet making, sawmills, carpentry. Outdoor construction projects involve more air moving and larger dust particles generated than indoor furniture making & cabinetry. Industry description: “Companies that cultivate and/or manufacture timber, mill lumber, wood, and/or wood products for construction.” Major changes in industry in recent decades due to increased environmental regulation include use of smaller trees and manufacturing of wood fiber boards instead of planed wood and plywood for construction. An industry document indicates over 90% of the timber in USA is on private land.

HEALTH ENDPOINTS:

ASTHMA/ALLERGIC UPPER AIRWAY DISEASE: The pathophysiologic mechanism linking wood dust to allergic asthma is unclear, although it has been identified quite elegantly for Western Red Cedar. Some studies have shown allergic effects of other woods, and these are equivocal for pine, but aside for WRC, most cases involve exotic tropical woods not native to US or widely used here.

Page 4: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

NON-ALLERGIC PULMONARY DISEASE: Chronic non allergic pulmonary disease is the most prevalent health effect, with numerous studies showing increased symptoms of chronic bronchitis or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and/or decrements in pulmonary function. There are numerous other criticisms of the studies, including small numbers, single industrial focus, exposure data obtained by old methods, soft end points and loss to follow-up, etc. Generally, an irritant effect is postulated, due to wood dust itself, and/or contaminants

CANCER END POINT: The mechanism of carcinogenicity unclear, but new research demonstrates specific mutations .The focus is on sinonasal cancer, both adeno and squamous. Laryngeal cancer and lung cancer are also of concern, but there is much less evidence for these.

OTHER LUNG DISORDERS: Alveolitis, hypersensitivity pneumonitis, and pulmonary fibrosis have all been reported associated with wood dust exposure, but may be actually due to fungi and molds involved in processing.

DERMATITIS: Wood dust can cause both Type I and Type IV hypersensitivity skin reactions as well as irritant dermatitis.

REVIEW: MECHANISM OF PATHPOPHYSIOLOGY FOR WOOD DUST RELATED DISORDERS

The basic primary mechanism for all wood dust related diseases is presumed to be an initial irritant effect of the wood dust on the tissue cells. In 2009,Pylkkanen et al in Finland used dust from dried pine, birch and oak, generating dusts with 90% less than 5 um, and exposed human bronchial epithelial cells from The American Type Culture Collection in 3 concentrations (10, 50, &500um/ml) and 5 duration periods from 0.5-24hr. All wood dusts caused cytotoxicity, dose dependant and statistically significant at 2 & 6 hrs compared with controls. Exposure to all three woods stimulated reactive oxygen species (ROS) and induced capase-3 protease activity. Maata et al studied wood dust particle induced pulmonary inflammation in mice to identify the mechanisms by which lung diseases develop. They used aged oak and birch, created fine dusts with 90 % 5um or less, and used titanium dioxide as a control dust. They instilled the dusts intranasally 2 xs week for 3 weeks. Airway hyper reactivity to methacholine was measured by body plethysmography. The mice were then killed and blood, bronchial alveolar lavage fluids, and tissue samples were taken. The results showed that repeated exposure to the oak and birch dusts caused influx of inflammatory cells into the lungs, and on a molecular level was associated with the increase in several cytokines, chemokines and chemokine receptors in the lung tissue.

Attempts at identifying an IgE mediated allergic mechanism have not been successful for woods used in the United States. Studies show elevated levels in some Pts with clear allergic asthma reactions to wood dust, but not others, and only in small numbers. The actual chemical agent responsible for Western Red Cedar related asthma has been identified as Plicatic acid, a component of both Western & Eastern cedars.

Page 5: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

Most of what we now know about carcinogenesis has been discovered since the 1970s. With the development of our ability to look at specific changes to parts of the genome. In the past 5 years, there has been major work looking at the mechanism of wood dust and carcinogenesis. In brief, it is believed that 5-10 sequential mutations are required to transform a normal cell into a cancer cell. (See attached diagram from the latest edition of Harrison’s internal medicine text).

Another significant mutation is inactivation of the tumor suppression gene P53 . Several studies have investigated this recently. Homila et al found a high prevalence of TP53 mutations in a large group of samples from 358 sinonasal cancers with data on occupational exposure , and found the mutation levels significantly elevated with duration of exposure 24 years (OR 3.5, 96%CI 1.2-10.7). In a further experiment, they reported the actual sequence change for 159 of the TP53 mutations, identifying C-T transitions, base changes in the coding region, G-T transversions and identified the actual codons most frequently affected .

REVIEW: NON-ALLERGIC PULMONARY DISEASE

Overwhelmingly studies looking at health effects of wood dust exposure describe non allergic pulmonary effects rather than immunologically mediated problems such as asthma or alveolitis. The mechanism by which these effects are produced is thought to be an irritant effect causing an inflammatory reaction which leads to chronic bronchitis (chronic cough and mucus production without PFT changes) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) which includes cough, mucus production and non reversible obstructive PFT changes.

The ACGIH TLV document critically reviewed studies of chronic non allergic pulmonary disease in development of its proposed TLV of 1 mg/M3, presented in 2005, and reissued in 2010 (although reissued without an updated literature review). Glindmeyer et al (2008) is clearly the most comprehensive analysis published to date, following a cohort of employees in ten different wood processing plants over a 5 year period, with exposure data and medical surveillance, including spirometry. The exposure data was presented in several formats, including the standard inhalable dust used in most studies previously, but also with respirable fraction broken out, because of their focus on pulmonary disorders. The authors also analyzed the exposure data by separating wood solids from the non wood fraction of the dusts (volatiles, water, fungi, etc). Spirometry was performed according to ATS standards and equipment was calibrated and maintained appropriately. Measurements were compared to a very large data base of Caucasian and African-American workers from the US who were non smokers and not exposed to pulmonary hazards on the job.

This study was initiated, according to the authors, because of criticisms of previous studies described above. The exposure assessment revealed geometric mean values of personal inhalable dust samples ranging from 0.82 to 2.51 mg/M3 across the ten plants, with geometric standard deviations ranging from 2.1-2.8 mg/M3. The respirable dust fraction was 0.10-0.23 mg/M3 with geometric standard deviation in the range of 2.0-3.5. Their conclusion was “Exposure response analysis showed no statistically significant adverse respiratory effects to any wood solids fraction”. However separating out the wood dust solids from other wood components such as terpenes, and possible contaminants such as

Page 6: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

fungi, may be removing the actual cause of disease in different wood processing operations. If fungi in sawmills or chemicals such as glues in plywood manufacturing operations are part of the etiology for lung diseases seen in those industries, calculating disease rates based on their removal is artificial unless one postulates new control mechanisms for that part of the hazard. In addition, the inhalable wood dust exposures were, for the most part, lower than the current PEL which is 5 mg/M3 This might support the concept that lowering the exposure decreases disease incidence. Finally a significant part of their original cohort was lost to medical follow-up, which also raises questions about the conclusions, and it does not appear that the PFT measurements were taken on the same shift as the personal dust sampling.

Mandryk et al (1999) in Australia studied the effects of wood dust exposure on cross shift PFTs and symptoms. Dust exposure was monitored by personal sampling for both inhalable and respirable dust. Geometric means for inhalable dust were in the range generally below 5 mg/M3. (At the time of the study the Australian OEL was 5 mg/M3 for softwoods and 1 mg/M3 for hardwood). PFT measurement equipment and methods were described and were academically appropriate, and lung function cross shift measurements and personal dust sampling were done on the same shift. The study also evaluated the effects of fungi/endotoxin levels) and found in sawmills the biologicals levels are higher as might be expected.

Andersen et al (1977) studied mucostasis in relation to exposure level because of elevation of woodworkers among those with nasal cancer in Denmark where the study was done. Whitehead summarizes Andersen as showing that “mucostasis drops to the background (control) level only in the lowest exposure group which had a mean exposure level of 2.2. mg/M3. Andersen appears to show a clear dose-response relationship between exposure level and mucostasis, which is postulated as a risk factor for sinonasal cancer. Andersen’s work was cited by Whitehead (1982) in a review article as being one of the two studies having “the soundest evidence” for his recommended TLV of 2 mg/M3 total dust at that time.

Chan-Yeung et al (1980) concludes that TLV of 5 mg/M3 is too high, but it’s less clear on suggesting a quantitative alternative level, partly because the overall exposure levels are fairly low since they were looking at pulp and paper mills in British Columbia rather than furniture making or other woodworking where dust exposure levels are generally higher.

Other studies more recent than those discussed in the ACGIH TLV document include Veneri’s study on upper and lower airway disorders in woodworkers published in 2007 (abstract only - Italian) which analyzed medical surveillance reports of 197 woodworkers with median dust exposure of 2.1mg/M3. Each had an examination and spirometry. They found decrease in FEF 25-75 correlated with no use of respiratory protection and weakly with length of service. A pathologic decrease in vital capacity correlated with wood dust exposure . They concluded that chronic irritation of the upper and lower respiratory tract are caused by exposure to wood dust below the European legal exposure limit of 5mg/M3 . Focusing on FEF 25-75 is not a useful endpoint however, since it is a highly variable measurement of small airway function. In 2008 Jacobsen et al published a study investigating the relationship between changes in lung function and cumulative exposure to wood dust in 1112

Page 7: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

woodworkers (927 male, 185 female) and 235 controls. This was a 6 year longitudinal study, involving a questionnaire, spirometry, personal dust sampling at baseline and passive dust monitoring on follow-up. The spirometry methods were described and appropriate. A significant decrease in exposure was identified from the initial period 1997-98 compared to 2003-04. At baseline it was 0.94 +/- 2.10 mg/yr/M3, and at follow-up it was 0.60+/- .60mg/yr/M3.The results showed a significant decrease in lung function among female woodworkers compared to controls, but not males. They note that the inhalable dust concentrations in their study were low.

Schlunssen et al (2002) evaluated respiratory symptoms and lung function among Danish woodworkers, with questionnaires (n=2033, plus 474 controls), spirometry pre and post shift, (n=2423) and personal dust sampling (n=1579). The arithmetic mean for inhalable dust was 1.19=/-.86 mg/M3 , which they noted was low. Again, the most significant finding was a dose response relationship seen in women smokers with high dust exposure , and a relationship between inhalable dust concentrations and asthma symptoms.

Fransman et al (2003) studied work exposure and respiratory symptoms in 112 New Zealand plywood workers , but again exposures were low (majority did not exceed 1mg/M3) , with only 57 dust samples, and symptoms were the outcome measure. “Asthma” symptoms were more common in the mill workers than the general population, were associated with duration of employment, and were reported to lessen or go away on weekends or vacations. They did look at endotoxin levels, abietic acid, terpenes and formaldehyde in a smaller number of samples each. Symptoms were more common in workers with high exposure to formaldehyde, but did not show a strong relationship to the other exposures. Aside from the reliance on self report symptoms, disease classification may be an issue in this study also.

Rusca et al (2008) looked at exposure to bioaerosols in 111 sawmill workers in Switzerland. They found that the airborne concentration of fungi exceeded the Swiss recommended limit and was associated with “bronchial syndrome” (cough and expectoration) but there was not an associated decline in lung function.

REVIEW: ASTHMA

Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disorder of the airways characterized by reversible (fully or partially) bronchial tube spasm . Symptoms include wheezing or coughing , shortness of breath, with wheeze, cough and/or prolonged expiration on chest examination, and decreased FEV1 on spirometry. Common findings on histopathology include inflammatory cell infiltration, hypertrophy of smooth muscle, hyperplasia of goblet cells, airway edema, and denudation of airway epithelium. Identifiable predisposing factors include atopy and obesity. There are an estimated 22 million people with diagnosis of asthma in US, and over 40 million with allergic rhinitis. Internationally, about 9-15 % of adult onset asthma is considered to be occupational with rates varying by country and level of industrialization.

Asthma due to wood dust exposure has been reported for decades. Asthma due to a specific wood dust exposure is the subject of many individual case reports from around the world, usually due to exotic woods not used frequently in the US. (Algranti 2005, Bosomba 1991, Bush 1983, Eire 2006, Fernandez-Rivas 1997, Garces 1995, Gozalo 1988, Hinjosa 1986, Kospohl, Obata 2000, Reijuli 1994). The case

Page 8: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

reports describe symptoms related to a specific wood exposure, and are verified by IgE, prick and/or challenge testing. Best studied is Western Red Cedar, used widely in this country, where the specific allergen has been identified as plicatic acid, and the disease severity related to dose and duration of exposure. (Chan-Yeung 1992 & 1994, Cockcroft 1984, Coke 1990, Paggiori 1987, Vedal 1986 & 1988)). Eastern white cedar has also been found to be allergenic, with the same etiologic agent plicatiic acid (Cartier 1982, Malo 1994). In contrast, pine dust as an allergen was investigated by Skovsted et al (2003), evaluating 365 exposed and 116 non exposed workers . Some exposed and some non exposed were found to have IgE antibodies to pine, but only a small % each of the total. A study evaluated health effects of exposure to the tree which produces natural rubber latex, evaluating 103 workers and 76 unexposed, and found a dose dependent increase in wheeze, nasal symptoms ,asthma and reduced spirometric values. Exposure to oak and beech dust was found to cause sore throat and bronchial hyperresonsiveness but no decline in FEV1 with increasing dose/duration was noted.

Perez Rios et al published in Allergy in 2009 “A meta-analysis on wood dust exposure and risk of asthma”. A quality scale for selection was applied and nineteen studies were included, (3 cohort, 12 case control and 4 mortality studies). The pooled RR was 1.53 (95% CI 1.25-1.87). For studies of Caucasians alone the results were 1.59 (95% CI 1.26-2.00), and studies of Asian populations 1.15 (95%CI 0.92-1.44)

In addition to wood dust itself, other candidates for allergic asthma and rhinitis in the wood processing industries include molds, glues and other agents used in the processing or finishing of wood products, although not always: Winck et al did prick allergen tests with 3 common fungi in cork production and found negative results in all asthmatic and non asthmatic workers tested.

Williams did a “critical analysis of studies concerning reports of respiratory sensitization to certain wood dusts used in the US (oak, beech, pine, and western red cedar) and concluded that the effects seen in the studies were due to underlying bronchial hyperreactivity, not allergic sensitization.

REVIEW: CANCER:

Wood dust has been associated with cancer of the respiratory tract in a number of studies, and has been identified as a carcinogen by IARC, NTP and most recently, by California’s OEEHA. While there are studies suggesting a link between wood dust exposure and laryngeal and lung cancers, good documentation is available only for sinonasal cancer.

Cancer of the nose and paranasal sinuses (sinonasal cancer) is quite rare in the US, with incidence rates about 1/million. Multiple studies have been done showing an elevated risk of this cancer in wood workers from a variety of trades Most impressively, a recent analysis of cancer and occupation from the extensive registries in the Scandinavian countries revealed a high RR for sinonasal cancer and wood trades. Pukkala et al, from the Finnish Cancer Registry evaluated records of 15 million people aged 30-64 years and the 2.8 million incident cancers diagnosed in them through the personal identity code linkage system used in all the Nordic countries. The results are presented as “Standardized Incidence Ratio-SIR” -the number of cases observed divided by the expected number. Occupations were grouped into 53

Page 9: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

active and one group of economically inactive folks. “Wood workers “was one of the 53 codes. For nasal adenocarcinoma in male wood workers, the SIR was 5.50(4.60-6.56)

INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE ISSUES-

There is a body of literature looking specifically at measurements of exposure to wood dust. Most of the more recent studies show relatively lower exposure levels than in the past, which has been attributed to increased regulatory compliance, increased knowledge of the hazards, changes in production operations and changes in product development. Several of the studies noted above also had low SDs for dust exposure measured in personal sampling. The Feasibility Committee will need to review these papers, but reading them one could conclude that a significant number of wood dust exposed workers in the United States and Europe are already working in conditions where exposure levels are at or near the proposed 1mg/M3 level, offering substantial implications for the feasibility of lowering the current PEL. In contrast however, large geometric standard deviations in some studies indicate a substantial probability that, while some workers will be exposed considerably under the proposed PEL, others continue to be exposed well above it, thus arguing for a more protective PEL. These papers will be turned over to the Feasibility Committee.

REFERENCES

Aguna EN et al: The prevalence of occupational asthma and rhinitis among wood workers in south-eastern Nigeria. 2007; 9(1)52-5

Ahman M et al: IgE-mediated allergy to wood dusts probably does not explain the high prevalence of respiratory symptoms among Swedish woodwork teachers. Allergy 1995; 50:559-62

Algranti E et al: Occupational asthma caused by Ipe (tabebuia spp) dust. J Investig Allergol Clin Immunol 2005; 15(1) 81-3

Andersen I, Solgaard J. Nasal cancers, symptoms and upper airway function in woodworkers. Br J Ind Med. 1977;34:201-207

Basomba A et al: Occupational Rhinitis and asthma caused by inhalation of Balfouradendron riedelianum (Pau Marfim) wood dust. Allergy 1991; 46(4) 316-8

Blot WJ et al: Wood dust and nasal cancer risk. A review of the evidence from North America. J Occup Environ Med 1997 39(2): 148-56

Page 10: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

Bornholt J et al: K-ras mutations in sinonasal cancer in relation to wood dust exposure BMC Cancer 2008;8:53

Boulet LP et al: New insights into occupational asthma. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol 2007;7(1)96-101

Brodkin CA & Rosenstock L: The relation between chronic respiratory symptoms and ventilator capacity in adults. Occup Med 1993 8(2) 363-74

Bush RK & Clayton D: Asthma due to Central American walnut (Juglans Olanchana dust). Clin Allergy 1983; 13(4) 389-94

Carson M et al: Occupational Exposure to wood dust. Health Effects and exposure limit values. Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique 2002; 50(2) 159-78 (ABSTRACT ONLY-ARTICLE IN FRENCH)

Cartier A et al: Occupational asthma caused by eastern white cedar (Thuja occidentalis) with demonstration that plicatic acid is present in this wood dust and is the causal agent. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1986; 77(4) 639-45

Chan-Yeung M : Mechanism of occupational asthma due to western red cedar (Thuja plicata). Am J ind Med 1994; 25 (1) 13-8

Chan-Yeung M & Desjardins A: Bronchial hyperresponsiveness and level of exposure in occupational asthma due to western red cedar (Thuja plicata). Serial observations before and after development of symptoms. Am Rev Resp Dis 1992 146(6) 1606-9

ChanYeung M, Wong R, MacLean L, Tan F, Dorken E, Schulzer M, Dennis R, Grzybowski S, Respiratory survey of workers in a pulp and paper mill in Powell River, British Colombia, Am Rev Respir Dis, 1980; 122 : 249-257

Cloutier Y et al: New methodology for specific inhalation challenges with occupational agents in powder form. Eur respire J 1989; 2(8) 769-77

Cockcroft DW et al: Recurrent nocturnal asthma after bronchoprovacation with Western Red Cedar sawdust: association with acute increase in non-allergic bronchial responsiveness. Clin Allergy 1984 14 (1)61-8

Cote J et al: Outcome of patients with cedar asthma with continuous exposure. Am Rev Resp Dis 1990; 141(12) 373-6

Dahlqvist M et al: Lung function and precipitating antibodies in low exposed wood trimmers in Sweden. Am J Ind Med 1992; 21(4) 549-59

Dement J: Cancer incidence among union carpenters in New Jersey. J Occ Envirn Med 2003 45(10)1059-67

Demers PA et al: Pooled reanalysis of cancer mortality among five cohorts of workers in wood related industries. Scan J Work, Environ Health 1995;21(3)179-190

Page 11: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

dErrico a et al: A case control study on occupational risk factors for sino- nasal cancer. Occup Environ Med 2009; 66:448-455

Eire MA et al: Occupational rhinitis and asthma due to Cedroarana (Cedrelinga catenaeformis Ducke) wood allergy. J Investig Allergol Clin Immunol 2006; 16(6)385-387

Estlander T et al: Occupational allergic contact dermatitis caused by wood dusts. Contact Dermatitis 2001:44(4): 213-7

Fernandez-Rivas M et al: Occupational asthma and rhinitis caused by ash (Fraxinus excelsior) wood dust. Allergy 1997; 52(20 196-9

Frew AJ et al: Lack of rome for mononuclear cel-derived histamine realeasing factors in occupational asthma due to western red cedar. Clin Exp Allergy 1993; 23(10) 861-7

Galea KS et al: Trends in wood dust inhalation exposure in the UK, 1985-2005. Annals of Occup Hyg 2009 53(7) 657-667

Garces SM et al: Occupational asthma and contact urticaria caused by mukali wood dust (Aningeria robusta). J Investig Allergol Clin Immunol 1995; 5(20113-4

Glindmeyer HW et al: Longitudinal respiratory health study of the wood processing industry. Am J Ind Med 2008; 51:595-609

Gozalo RF & Pelta FR: Occupational asthma due to exotic wood: Nesorgordonis papaverifera (danta or kotibe): Rev Mal Respir 1988; 5(1) 71-3 (ABSTRACT ONLY-ARTICLE IN FRENCH)

Hagstrom K et al: Variability and determinants of wood dust and resin acid exposure during wood pellet production: Measurement strategies and bias in assessing exposure response relationships. Annals of Occup Hyg 2008; 52 (8): 685-694

Halpin DM et al: Extrinsic allergi alveolits and asthma in a sawmill worker: case report and review of the literature. Occup Environ Med 1994 51(#) 160-4

Hausen BM and Herrmann B: Bowmakers disease: an occupational disease in the manufacture of bows for string instruments 1990;115(5) 169-73 (ABSTRACT ONLY-ARTICLE IN GERMAN)

Hedenstierma G et al : Lung function and rhizopus antibodies in wood trimmers. A cross sectional and longitudinal study. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 1986; 58(3) 167-77

Heederick D et al: Occupational Exposure and 25-year incidence rate of non specific lung disease: The Zuphen Study. Int J Epidemiol 1990 19(40 945-52

Heikkila P et al: Asthma incidence in wood processing industries in Finland ina register based study.Scan J Work Environ Health 2008; 34(1) 66-72

Page 12: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

Herbert FA et al : Respiratory consequences of exposure to wood dust and formaldehyde of workers manufacturing oriented strand board. Arch Environ Health 1994; 49(60 465-70

Hessel PA et al : Lung health in sawmill workers exposed to pine and spruce. Chest 1995; 108(3) 642-6

Hinojosa M et al: Occupational asthma caused by African maple (Obeche) and Ramin: Evidence of cross-reactivity between these two woods. Clin Allergy 1986 16(2) 145-53

Homila R et al: Profile of TP53 gene mutations in sinonasal cancer. 2009 XXXXXXXXXXX

Holmila R et al; Cox-2 and p53 in human sinonasal cancer: COX2 expression is associated with adenocarcinoma histology and wood dust exposure. International J of Cancer 2008;9:2154-2159

Innocenti A: A technically attainable reference value for exposure to wood dust in light of Law 66/2000. Med Lav 2000; 91(6) 565-74 (abstract only—article in Italian)

Innocenti A et al: Asthma and systemic toxic reaction due to cabreuva (Myrocarpus fastgiatus Fr. All.) wood dust. Med Lav 1991 82(5) 446-50

Jacobsen G et al: Longitudinal lung function decline and wood dust exposure in the furniture industry. Eur Resp J 2008;31:334-342

Jacobson G et al: Increased incidence of respiratory symptoms among female woodworkers exposed to dry wood. Eur Respir J 2009;33(6) 1268-76

Jeebhay MF & Quirce S: Occupational asthma in the developing and industrialized world: a review. In J Tuberc Lung Dis 2007;11(2) 122-33

Kauffer E et al: Site comparison of selected aerosol samplers in the wood industry. Ann Occup Hyg 2009 advanced publication on line 12/31/09

Kauppinen T et al: Occupational exposure to inhalable wood dust in the member states of the European Union. Annals of Occup Hyg 2006; 50(6):549-561

Kennedy MT et al: Expression pattern of CK7, CKX2 and villin in intestinal-type sinonasal cancer . J Clin Pathol 2004; 57:932-937

Kespohl S et al: Identification of an obech (Triplochiton scleroxylon) wood allergen as a class I chitinase. Allergy 2005; 60 (6) 808-14

Kos PD: Wood dust exposure in wood industry and forestry Coll Anthropol 2005; 29(1)207-11

Larama MB et al: Exposure to wood dust and endotoxin in small-scale wood industries in Tanzania.

J of Exposure Analysis and Environ Epidem 200414;544-550

Lin FJ et al: New method for an occupational dust challenge test. OccupEnviron Med 1995; 52:54-56

Page 13: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

Liou SH et al: Respiratory symptoms and pulmonary function among wood dust exposed joss stick workers. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 1996 68(3) 154-60

Llorente JL et al: Genetic and clinical aspects of wood dust related intestinal-type sinonasal carcinoma: a review 2008. 1434

Long H et al: ROS mediated TNF a and MIP-2 gene expression in alveolar macrophages exposed to pine dust. Part Fiber Toxicol 2004;1:3

Maattan J et al: Immunolmodulatory effects of oak dust exposure to murine model of allergic asthma. Toxicol Sci 2007; 99(1);260-6

Maatta J et al: Mechanisms of particle induced pulmonary inflammation in a mouse model: exposure to wood dust. 2006 93 (1) 96-104

Malmberg PO et al: Increased bronchial responsiveness in workers sawing Scots pine. Am Rev Respir Crit Care Med 1996 153(3) 948-52

Malo JL et al: Occupational Asthma caused by oak wood dust. Chest 1995; 108:856-58

Malo JL et al: Prevalence of occupational asthma among woodworkers exposed to eastern white cedar. Am J Respir Crit care Med 1994 150(6 Pt 1) 1697-1701

Mandryk J et al: Work related symptoms and dose response relationships for personal exposure and pulmonary function among woodworkers. Am J Ind Med 1999; 35(5)481-490

Meo SA: Effects of duration of exposure to wood dust on peak expiratory flow rate among workers in small scale wood industries. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 2004: 17(4) 451-5

Moran CA et al: Primary adenocarcinomas of the nasal cavity and paranasal sinuses. Ear Nose Throat j 1991 70(12); 281-8

Noertjojo HK et al: Western red cedar dust exposure and lung function: a dose response relationship. Am j Respir Crit Care Med 1996;154(4 Pt 1) 968-73

Norrish AE et al: A study of New Zealand wood workers : exposure to wood dust, respiratory symptoms and suspected cases of occupational asthma. N Z Med J 1992 105(934) 185-7

Nylander LA & Dement JM: Carcinogenic effects of wood dust: review and discussion. Am J Ind Med 2007;24(5)619-647

Obata H et al: Occupational asthma due to exposure to African cherry (Makore) wood dust. Inter med 2000; 39(11) 947-9

Paggiaro PL & Yeung C M: Pattern of specific airway response in asthma due to western red cedar (Thuja plicata): relationship with length of exposure and lung function measurements. Clin Allergy 1987 17(4) 333-9

Page 14: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

Pisaniello DL et al: Wood dust exposure during furniture manufacture-results from an Austrailian study and considerations for threshold limit value development. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 1991; 52(11)485-92

Perez-Rios M et al: A meta analysis on wood dust exposure and risk of asthma. Allergy 2009; DOI;10.1111/J/1398-9995

***Post WK: Occupational estimated by a population specific exposure matrix and 25 years incidence rate of chronic nonspecific lung disease (CNSLD): the Zutphen Study

Pukkala E et al: Occupational and cancer-follow-up of 15 million people in five Nordic countries. Acta Oncol 2009;48(5):646-790

Puntaric D et al: Wood dust exposure in wood industry and forestry. Coll Anthropol 2005; 29(1) 207-11

Pylkkanen L et al: Wood dusts induce the production of reactive oxygen species and caspase 3 activity in human bronchial cells. Toxicology 2009 265-270

Reijula K et al: Sauna builder’s asthma caused by obeche (triplochiton scleroxylon) dust. Thorax 1994; 49:622-23

Robinson CF: Mortality of Carpenters’ Union members employed in the US construction or wood products industries, 1987-1990. Am J Ind Med 1997 30(6):674-94

Sandven EW & Levy F: Serum IgG antibodies to mold spores in two Norwegian sawmill populations: relationship to respiratory and other work related symptoms. Am J ind Med 1993 24(2) 207-22

Scarselli A et al: Occupational exposure levels to wood dust in Italy, 1996-2006; Occup Environ Med 2008; 65-567-574

Schlünssen V, et al: Respiratory symptoms and lung function among Danish woodworkers. J Occup Environ Med. 2002 Jan;44(1):82-98

Schlunssen V et al: Cross shift changes in FEV1 in relation to wood dust exposure: the implications of different exposure assessment methods. Occup Environ Med 2004 61(10); 824-30

Schlunssen V et al: Detreminants of wood dust exposure in the Danish Furniture industry—results from two cross sectional studies 6 years apart. Annals of Occup Hyg 2008 52(4) 227-238

Schmezer WJ et al: The role of combination effects on the etiology of malignant nasal tumors in the wood working industry. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl 1998; 535:1-16

Shamssain MH: Pulmonary function and symptoms exposed to wood dust. Thorax 1992;47;84-87

Siemiatcki J et al: Associations between several sites of cancer and nine organic dusts: results from a hypothesis- generating case-control study in Montreal, 1979-1983. Am J Epidemiology 1986. 123(2); 235-49

Page 15: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate

Skovsted TA et al: Only few workers exposed to wood dust are detected with specific IgE against pine. Allergy 2003; 58(8) 772-779

Stellman SD & Garfinkel L: Cancer mortality among woodworkers. Am J Ind Med 1984: 5(5) 343-57

Teschke, K et al: Exposures to wood dust in US industries and occupations 1979-1997. Am J Ind Med 1999; 35: 581-589

Toren K et al Health effects of working in pulp and paper mills: Malignant Diseases. Am J Ind Med 1996; 29-123-130

Tripodi D et al: Gene profiling in sinonasal adenocarcinoma. 2009; Brit Medical Genomics 2: 65

Vanderplas O: Increase in non-specific bronchial hyperresonsiveness as an early marker of bronchial response to occupational agents during specific inhalation challenges. Thorax 1996 51(%) 472-8

Vedal S et al : A longitudinal study of the occurrence of bronchial hyper-responsiveness in western red cedar workers. Am Rev Resp Dis 1988 137(3):651-5

Vedal S et al: Synptoms and pulmonary function in western red cedar workers related to duration of employment and dust exposure. Arch Environ Health1986;41(3)179-83

Veneri L: Study on prevalence of upper and lower airways disorders in woodworkers, using data from medical surveillance reports and exposure registers (Abstract only—article in Italian) G Ital Med Lav Ergon 2007; 29 (3 Suppl):833-5

Whitehead LW: Health effects of wood dust—relevance for an occupationa standard. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 1982 43(9) 674-8

Williams PB: Critical analysis of studies concerning reports of respiratory sensitization to certain wood dusts. Allergy Asthma Proc 2005; 26(40 262-7

Wu X et al: A case-control study of wood dust exposure, mutagen sensitivity, and lung cancer risk. Can Epi biomarkers and prev 1995; 4; 583-588

Zock JP: Occupation, chronic bronchitis and lung function in young adults. Am J of Respir Critical Care Med 2001, 163(7) 1572-1577

Page 16: WOOD DUST & WESTERN RED CEDAR- ( 5/5/10)---L dust 6 9 2010.doc · Web viewWood is often treated with a variety of toxic chemicals including copper, arsenic, chromate copper arsenate