with consideration of future signal structures comparison ... · boc(2,2) bpsk(1) modulation scheme...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Comparison of Multipath Mitigation Techniques with Consideration of Future Signal Structures
M. Irsigler, B. EissfellerInstitute of Geodesy and Navigation
University FAF Munich Germany
![Page 2: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 2
Overview� Performance analysis for several multipath mitigation techniques
• Narrow CorrelatorTM
• Double Delta Correlator• Early/Late Slope Technique (ELS)• Early1/Early2 (E1/E2) Tracker
� Consideration of BPSK and BOC signals• BPSK(1) representing the current GPS C/A code• BOC(2,2) representing one Galileo signal option
� Background/Motivation:• Multipath is dominating error source for many GNSS applications• Different types of signals will be available in the future
>> how do they perform in a multipath environment?
![Page 3: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 3
IntroductionErrors caused by multipath depend on a variety of signal and receiver parameters:� Signal type/modulation scheme� Pre-correlation bandwidth� Pre-correlation filter characteristics� Chipping rate of code� Type of discriminator� Chip spacing d between correlators used for tracking� Carrier frequency� Multipath relative amplitude αααα� Actual number of multipath signals� Geometric path delay of multipath signal(s)
![Page 4: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 4
Signal and Receiver Parameters
2.046 MHz1.023 MHzChipping Rate
Galileo Signal Option
GPS C/A Code
SIGNAL PARAMETERS
146,53 m293,05 mChip Length
BOC(2,2)BPSK(1)Modulation Scheme
200 bit/s50 bit/sData Rate
1575.42 MHz1575.42 MHzCenter Frequency
E2-L1-E1L1Frequency Band
RECEIVER PARAMETERS
1-Chip Early minus LateDiscriminator
Ideal Band Pass FilterBand Limiting Filter
32 MHzPre-Corr. Bandwidth
� Multipath relative amplitude αααα=0.5� Direct signal always available� Static environment� One multipath signal
Further assumptions (multipath environment):
![Page 5: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 5
Wide (Standard) Correlator (d=1)
Multi
path
Per
form
ance
Code
Mul
tipat
hCa
rrier
Mul
tipat
h
Corre
latio
n Fu
nctio
n an
d Co
de D
iscrim
inat
or
E-L chip spacing: d=1
Results:•Maximum multipath error (nearly)identical for both signals
•BOC(2,2) less sensitive to medium-delay multipath
![Page 6: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 6
Narrow Correlation Technique� 2 Correlators with small spacing between early and late code (d < 1)� NovAtel‘s Narrow CorrelatorTM: d = 0.1
Discriminator Function Multipath Performance
� Results:• Maximum multipath error nearly identical for both signals• BOC(2,2) less sensitive to long-delay multipath
![Page 7: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 7
∆∆∆∆∆∆∆∆ Correlator� Basic concept:
• 5 Correlators (E1,E2,P,L1,L2)• Discriminator function: D = a(E1 - L1) - b(E2 - L2)
� Several discriminator functions can be set up (variation of a and b)• Strobe CorrelatorTM (Ashtech): D = 2*(E1 - L1) - (E2 - L2)• High Resolution Correlator (HRC): D = (E1 - L1) - 0.5*(E2 - L2)
� Strobe vs. HRC: • Different amplitudes • Same shape
>> Same multipath performance expected
![Page 8: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 8
∆∆∆∆∆∆∆∆ Correlator: Code Multipath� HRC discriminator function: D = (E1 - L1) - 0.5* (E2 - L2)
Multi
path
Per
form
ance
Disc
rimin
ator
Fun
ctio
n
� Results:• Maximum multipath error nearly identical for both signals• BOC(2,2) sensitive to medium-delay multipath• BPSK(1) not sensitive to medium-delay multipath• BOC(2,2) less sensitive to long-delay multipath
![Page 9: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 9
∆∆∆∆∆∆∆∆ Correlator: Carrier Multipath� HRC concept proposes synthesized
punctual correlator for carrier tracking� PHRC = 2*P - (E1 + L1)
Punc
tual
Corre
lator
Carri
er M
ultip
ath
Results:• Maximum multipath error
identical for both signals• BOC(2,2) sensitive to
medium-delay multipath• BPSK(1) not sensitive to
medium-delay multipath• BOC(2,2) less sensitive to
long-delay multipath
![Page 10: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 10
Early/Late Slope Technique (ELS)� Basic concept:
• 2 correlator pairs at both sides of the correlation function
• Determination of slopes a1 and a2
• Computation of pseudorange correction T by intersecting two first-order polynomials defined by (K1,K2) and (K3,K4)
� Introduced to GPS receivers by NovAtel as „Multipath Elimination Technology“ (MET) 21
2121 )(2aa
aasyyT
−−−−
++++++++−−−−====
![Page 11: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 11
Early/Late Slope Technique: Code Multipath
ττττ1=-0.1 ττττ2222 =-0.06 ττττ3= 0.06 ττττ4= 0.1
Multi
path
Per
form
ance
� Computation of code error envelopes by comparing the pseudorange correction T with the actual peak location
� Remarks:• Multipath performance strongly
depends on actual correlator configuration
• Slight changes of ττττ1,…,ττττ4 result in fairly different error envelopes
• impossible to make general statement whether the BPSK(1) or the BOC(2,2) performs betterMultipath error envelopes only valid for
given correlator configuration
![Page 12: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 12
12
AAR ====
Undi
stor
ted
ACF
Dist
orte
d AC
F
� 2 correlators (E1,E2) located on the early slope of the correlation function
� Amplitudes at E1,E2 are used to compute error function ∆∆∆∆R
Early1/Early2 (E1/E2) TrackingMu
ltipa
th P
erfo
rman
ce
1122 MM A
AAAR ⋅⋅⋅⋅−−−−====∆
� Issues:• Shape of undistorted correlation function must be known (R=A2/A1)• Degraded noise performance (reduced signal power at tracking point)
Results:• Multipath errors are zero for path delays
greater than (1+E2)• maximum ranging error of BOC(2,2)
much larger than that of BPSK(1) • BPSK(1) less sensitive to short-delay
multipath
![Page 13: with Consideration of Future Signal Structures Comparison ... · BOC(2,2) BPSK(1) Modulation Scheme 200 bit/s 50 bit/s Data Rate 1575.42 MHz 1575.42 MHz Center Frequency E2-L1-E1](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022011816/5e706e420684506d3f7ba351/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
ION GPS 2003, Portland, Oregon - 13
Summary
Results:• Double Delta shows the best overall code multipath performance• E1/E2 Tracker produces large maximum multipath errors (worst
multipath performance for short- and medium-delay multipath)• BOC(2,2) outperforms BPSK(1) for long-delay multipath (path delays
> 0.5 chips)
BPSK
(1)
BOC(
2,2)