wing beats volume 18 number 3wingbeats.floridamosquito.org › wingbeats › pdfs ›...
TRANSCRIPT
• GeoF/OW"' UNPRECEDENTED COMMAND OVER GROUND BASED MOSQUITO CONTROL Controlling mosquitoes is an unquestionably challenging endeavor. So why add to the challenge by limiting
your command over driver activity, chemical application and vehicle routing? ADAPco• created GeoFiow™
to make sure you won't have to. GeoFiow provides GPS-based mosquito application flow control, real -time/
post-event location and activity tracking, and revolutionary software-driven routing that ensures complete,
duplication-free coverage. Together, these functions deliver unprecedented mosquito control command, efficiency
and cost effectiveness. Contact us for a demonstration of everything GeoFlow can do to help you take command
of your ground-based mosquito control operation.
AoAPCo 800 367-0659 www.myadapco.com
2800 South Financial Coun I Sanford, Florida 32773-81181 407 330-4800 I Fax 866 330-9888
• WING M~~rUNPARALLELED AERIAL MOSQUITO CONTROL PRECISION, SAFETY AND EASE. To err is human. But when it comes to aerial mosquito control, it can also be costly, dangerous and time
consuming. Which is precisely why ADAPco • created Wingman™ GX, the world's most advanced aerial
precision guidance and recording system for mosquito control. With the capability to receive real -time
meteorology, process USDA Forest Service AGDISP spray fate model, and graphically display optimization
results in real-time, Wingman GX offers you greater precision, safety and security than any other product
of its kind. Contact us for a demonstration of everything Wingman GX can do to help take the err out of
your aerial mosquito control operation.
ADA~CO, 800 367-0659 www.myadapco.com
2800 South Financial Court I Sanford, Florida 32773-81181407 330-4800 I Fax 866 330-9888
Editm·-in-C hief Stephen L Sickennan 850.872-4250 e-mail: [email protected]
Managing Editor Jack Petersen 850-872-4370 e-mail: [email protected]
Director of Advertising Dennis Moore 727-376-4568 e-mail: [email protected]
Circulation Editm· Kellie Etherson 352-334-2287 email: [email protected]
Ass ociate Editors Dave Dame, Gainesville, FL Tom Wilmot, Sanford, Ml LCDR Eric Hoffman, Jacksonville, FL
Regional Editors Massachusetts- Tunothy D Deschamps, Northborough Michigan- Thomas R Wilmot, Sanford New Jersey -William C Reinert, Northfield Utah - Glenn Collett, Salt Lake City
Editorial Review Board Doug Carlson, Indian River, FL Frank Van Essen, Naples, FL Wayne Kramer, Baton Rouge, LA L Philip Lounibos, Vero Beach, FL Wtlliam Meredith, Dover, DE Bill Reynolds, Sanford, FL John J Smith, Norwood, MA Robert Cummings, Garden Grove, CA
Flosida Mosquito C ontrol A ssociation FMCA President: Bill Reynolds, Sanford, FL e-mail: [email protected]
Kellie Etherson, FMCA Executive Director Gainesville Mosquito Control 405 NW 39th Avenue Gainesville, FL 32609 email: [email protected]
Ameli can Mosquito C ontt-ol A ssociation AMCA President: Gene Payne, Chesapeake, VA e-mail: gpayn~ityofchesapeake.net
Sarah B Gazi, AMCA Executive Director 15000 Conunerce Parkway, Suite C Mount Laurel, NJ 08054 voice: 856-439-9222; fax: 856-439-0525 e-mail: [email protected]
www ftoridamosquito org www mosquito org
california Mosquito an~ Vector Control Districts an~ Universit~ of california Combine Forces to Battle Malaria in Africa ............ .... ............... ..... 6 b~ Katb Garve~
what is an Epi~emioloeical Week an~ wh~ ~o we use them? . ................ 2.2. b~ Joree R Arias
The Latest Buzz: Mosquito Control Goes Hieh Tech .... . .... . ....... ...... 2.5 b~ walter Monteomer~
MIR or MLE: That is the Question .................................... 32. b~ Joree R Arias
From where I Sit: Notes from the AMCA Technical A~visor ................. 36 b~ Joe Conlon
Florida Mosquito Control Association • PO Box 358630 • Gainesville, FL 32635-8630
~ &..t.s: An official publication of the American Mosquito Control Association, published quarterly by the Florida Mosquito Control Association This magazine is intended to keep all interested parties informed on matters as they relate to mosquito control All rights reserved Reproduction, in whole or part, for educational pwposes is permitted, without permission, with proper citation The FMCA and the AMCA have not tested any of the products advertised or referred to in this publication, nor have they verified any of the statements made in any of the advertisements or articles The FMCA and the AMCA do not warrant, expressly or implied, the fitness of any product advertised or the suitability of any advice or statements contained herein Opinions expressed in this publication are not necessarily the opinions or policies of the FMCA or the AMCA
Subscriptions:~ &..t.s is sent free of charge to anyone within the continental Uuited States Subscriptions are available for the cost of first class postage to any foreign address at the following rates: Europe, UK and Australia US$20; Canada, US$6; Sooth America US$! 0 Make checks and purchase orders payable to the Florida Mosquito Control Association
Correspondence: Address all correspondence regarding~ &..t.s to the Editor-in-Chief, Stephen Sickerman, 3920 Frankford Avenue, Panama City, FL 32405 Readers are invited to submit articles related to mosquito and biting fty biology and control, or letters to the Managing Editor, Jack Petersen There is no charge if your article or letter is printed Photogr.~phers and artists are invited to submit color transparencies, high quality original artwork or artwork in electrouic format for possible use in the magazine or on the cover; $100 \vill be paid for each cover photo Businesses are invited to place advertisements through the Director of Advertising, Dennis Moore
printed by Boyd Brother s, Inc, 425 East 15th Street, PO Box 18, Panama City, FL 32402-0018
March~ - 6, 2008
John Asbaaga's Nugget
Sparks, Nmula
March 2- 6, 2008
Ar l<:t.!t;r, "I" n: rr:nmrtmc. fr, ifr.(tfr:_:: :Tnl'f. 'A"·:OWI ~, ~crp 101
Frnx::nr pLl.J r nr.nlktr. Wr/t;r "" nJl •h: t:il~ttn ., ~rn:~c c~r
,mcctu )1: :lm.olnp. ::~pFIIr;lltl¥1 t:ut:lmqLcc. ft1· 111~ 1.:. .q ;~4"
t Jl:lrJI l!rd I!U' ·-o.:;r '\J' U'ul:!l ~ 1rm•l(.""'rU!'lu. ,,P.., IIJ+' II;IIllol lll. ,,l:~~~~:o:~u~u:ll~ · T•r:!- ~nJ -~1\, =w;tL"~ f'UI
liY ~'1r lll fl'tl:t:fi't:!lt~ t:'~ • • tve!J t •u-n ' ~ou·r~ ' !L t;b"o~ u.
~ ' Q'Pd!Lrii ''' ll c. 1 «'I •if\lbN~ :~ ·1 :.:.>11 I.J?•• ' rr .. ,. •1 e-"'' r rllO lf;TE, ~rm~!P~rr l (" II~ I:"~ ~I) II n \.YI'r;fl l/ 1 J f)il\~ 1i l ntt"lqr
pr rrr.Nm 1$,;; "'!lt~rt n:mtf ll'l (l.ir'! mr., ~ j. Jtl...: 41..(.~F,?
r.r "' . .., 1 Rot,rnrFrnr .r>1r iT rrmtiJilr.t(J,..
... . , ........ ~ . ... ,.... ._._... ttl! ._. • • i f6111 t 'l&~'il ,.. ... ii . . ... ~ o!Or!t:ab..... J MIK.t;l~ll
Fall 2007 5
6
California Mosquito ana Vector Control Districts ana Universit~ of California Combine Forces to Battle Malaria in Africa b~ I<atb~ I<eatle~ Garve~
A single statistic tells the story: malaria kills a child in Africa every 30 seconds.
In response to that tragic statistic, President Bush created the President's Malaria Initiative (PMI} in June 2005 to combat malaria in Africa, committing a $1 .2 billion increase in United States funding over five years.
PMI, partnering with US government agencies, including the US
Fall 2007
Agency for International Development, Centers for Disease Control, Department of State and the White House, seeks the involvement of private foundations and corporations to help implement malaria control programs in Africa. Many responded, including the American Red Cross, United Way and the Global Business Coalition. However, PMI did not tap one of the most potentially useful resources in the battle against malaria in Africa: the US
mosquito control community.
Enter the University of California Malaria Research and Control Group (MRCG}, based on the UC Davis campus.
MRCG is the brainchild of Greg Lanzaro, director of the statewide University of California Mosquito Research Program. "When President Bush first announced a renewed US commitment to provide assistance to African nations
in their struggle against malaria, I began thinking about what is needed and how the California vector biology community might contribute," he said. "The University of Califomia is home to a large cadre of the world's leading experts on the biology of mosquitoes and mosquito-borne diseases."
In the summer of 2005, Lanzaro contacted faculty members engaged in mosquito research and discussed the idea of assembling a group to focus on malaria in Africa. "The response was overwhelmingly positive," he said, "and we were able to form a group of 21 scientists from five of the ten UC campuses - Berkeley, Davis, Irvine, Los Angeles and Riverside."
"But research satisfies only one part of the need," he said. "What is sorely needed for malaria con-
trol in Africa is the establishment of modern mosquito abatement programs aimed at reducing malaria through mosquito control. California enjoys one of the most extensive and advanced systems of mosquito abatement programs in the world . These programs are home to a wealth of expert ise in the establishment and maintenance of contemporary mosquito and vector control districts, including technical, administrative and public education aspects."
In October of 2005, Lanzaro presented the concept at a meeting of the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California (MVCAC), which represents 61 districts in the state. A partnership between the University of California and MVCAC, he said, would "greatly provide assistance in efforts to control malaria in sub-
Saharan Africa." MVCAC members enthusiastically supported the concept and the MVCAC Board of Directors endorsed it on October 27, 2005.
The University of Ca lifornia Malaria Research and Control Group was born.
"The UC mosquito research community and MVCAC members have a long and effective history of collaboration in efforts aimed at the control of mosquitoes and mosquito-borne diseases in the state," Lanzaro said. "The partnership between research and application has been very successful in California. We are now committed to focusing our efforts to the challenge of malaria in Africa and are seeking partners and sponsors to make these goals a reality."
Fall 2007 7
8
Christopher Voight executive director of the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California, Sacramento, strongly supports the mission.
"California's mosquito control professionals are ready to provide their considerable experience in controlling the spread of mosquitoborne diseases to the African peoples," Voight said. "Efficient and effective methods of mosquito control honed over decades of use in California can be exported to Africa with immediate effects. Success will come with the team approach incorporating integrated pest management (IPM). The results will be dramatic reductions in the transmission of malaria in Africa, just as IPM has
Fall 2007
so effectively limited the spread of mosquito-borne illnesses in California."
MVCAC has greatly limited or eliminated the transmission of once-common mosquito-borne diseases, including malaria, in California. Its 61 districts serve more than 33 million residents within a 69,580 square mile area. They wage a three-pronged attack: suNeillance, public education and mosquito control.
To seek congressional support, Lanzaro met March 8, 2006 in Washington DC with the staffs of Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.}; Sen. Sam Brownback (D-Kansas); Rep. Barbara Lee (9th District}; Rep. Diane Watson (33rd District};
and Rep. Mike Thompson (1st District}.
MRCG scientists and Mosquito Abatement District representatives met for a daylong, organizational session on May 16, 2006 in Davis, CA. They hammered out plans encompassing academic research, education and public service.
The participants agreed to battle malaria on three unique fronts: mosquito abatement, applied research to improve existing mosquito control strategies, and basic research aimed at developing new and novel methods to control malaria vectors.
The 21-member research team
= - -- --
Fall 2007 9
of MRCG is comprised of: to participate in the MRCG. partnerships for malaria control and research.
UC Davis: Anthony Cornel, Bruce Six UC researchers, Cornel, James, Hammock, Sharon Lawler, Walter Lanzaro, Luckhart, Taylor and "We're hoping that what we do Leal, Shirley Luckhart, Sergey V. Van, already conduct field re- in Tanzania will be the template Nuzhdin, Wil liam Reisen and search in one or more countries for all of Africa," Lanzaro said. Thomas Scott in Africa, including Cameroon, "Malaria is the leading cause
Ghana, Kenya, Mali, South Africa of death in both children and UC Irvine: Timothy Bradley, and Tanzania. Their grants exis- adults in Tanzania. "More than l 0 Anthony James and Guiyun Van ted before the MRCG did. million cases of malaria occur in
Tanzania annually." UCLA: Charles Taylor Organizational plans are pro-
gressing steadily, Lanzaro said. The delegates met with malaria UC Riverside: Peter Atkinson, In October 2006, MRCG sent researchers at the lfakara Health Timothy Bradley, Ring T. Carde, a four-member delegation - Research and Development Brian A. Federici, Sarjeet S. Gill, entomologists Lanzaro and Comel Center (IHRDC) in lfakara, which Karine Le Roch, Alexander S. and MVCAC professionals Steve operates under a board of trust-Raikhel and William Walton Mulligan, manager of the Con- ees. Members include represen-
solidated Mosquito Abatement tatives from the Tanzanian Ministry UC Berkeley: Michael Levine District in Selma, and Major of Health, National Institute for
Dhillon, manager of the North- Medical Research, Commission In addition to the research team, west Mosquito and Vector Control of Science and Technology, mosquito abatement d istricts District in Corona -to the east Swiss Agency for Development throughout the state, coordinat- African nation of Tanzania to de- and Cooperation, Swiss Tropical ed through MVCAC, have agreed velop collaborations and build Institute, Hospital Clinic Barcelona,
10 Fall 2007 'U'i~<f '8eau
Adama Sacko, from the Malaria Research and Training Center in Bamako, Mali, (center) and UCLA researcher Charles Taylor (right) near Morigbedou, Mali. Photo by Mahamoudou Toure (Pele)
Fall 2007 11
Muhimbili University College of Health Sciences and the Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory.
Following several days of discussion at lfakara with the entomology group led by Gerry Ki lleen, the board agreed to pursue a collaborative effort between IHRDC and the MRCG. The first tangible step: provide a research fellowsh ip to Kija N'ghabi, a PhD student at IHRDC, to conduct research at the University of California in the
summer of 2007. N'ghabi worked in the Vector Genetics Lab at UC Davis. Mulligan and Dhillon were also invited to participate in a stakeholders' meeting of the Integrated Urban Malaria Control Program in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania's largest city, to exchange expertise and share ideas from the California mosquito control prospective. The two participated in a tour of the Dar program prior to the meeting . Deo Mtasiwa, city medical officer of health of Dar es Salaam City
Council, chaired the meeting, which included 15 presentations.
Most presentations, from the Dar Urban Mosquito Control Program personnel, described the operations program and discussed progress made and challenges faced by the program. The malaria program includes mapping of larval habitat, monitoring of larval and adult population, larviciding, and householder surveys. CORPS or communityowned resource persons work in
Medical entomologist Dr Raymon Kone (seated, fourth from left) of Kan Kan, speaks to the village chief and elders about gathering mosquitoes in the village of Morigbedou. "To collect Anopheles one typically must go into peoples' homes, where they have slept, and collect the resting female mosquitoes after they have fed," said Chuck Taylor (in white shirt). "We collect them from the walls, ceilings and hanging objects. To go into peoples' homes like this requires their permission. In this part of Africa the permissions are generally decided collectively, by the chief after consultation with other elders. In this photo we are describing what it is we wish to do to the chief and elders." The chief is seated at far left. To Kone's left is Dr Mahamoudou Toure, and to his left are a number of elders. They did give their permission. Photo by Adama Sacko
Fall 2007 13
14
ABOVE: UC Davis medical entomologist and MRCG director Gregory Lanzaro (second from right) addresses a meeting at the lfakara Health Research and Development Center; at far right is Anthony Cornel. Photo by Steve Mulligan
BELOW: Left to right: Anthony Cornel; Tunu Kingodi, IFAKAR secretary; Gregory Lanzaro; and Major Dhillon, manager of the Northwest Mosquito and Vector Control District, Corona, CA, standing outside the IFAKAR headquarters in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Photo by Steve Mulligan
Fall 2007
one of three areas: surveillance and monitoring, control, and data management. In addition, Uli Fillinger and Marcia de Castro discussed ongoing international research projects involving the Dar program.
In their presentation, Dhillon and Mulligan emphasized the similarities and differences between Dar es Salaam and California mosquito control programs, including program history, development, structure, operations and funding sources. "This presentation was very well received and generated much interest and discussion," Dhil lon and Mulligan said in a written report to MRCG.
"One difference from the typical control program in California is that in Dar es Salaam, no CORPS members who monitor the larval population are involved in the spray program, as the application treatments are made by a separate Control CORPS," the Dhillon-Mull igan report said. "All water sources are treated with only Bti, irrespective of any mosquito breeding. At present,
Bti is being donated by Valent Biosciences."
Every six months, a household survey group interviews approximately 10,000 people and draws blood samples to detect malaria. "The mapping group prepares very precise maps of all breeding sources within the 15-ward zone (15 of 73 wards are currently covered)," the report said. "These maps are so precise that when given to
new employees, they can locate every breeding source in their community, a virtual man-made GPS. The ultimate goal of the mapping is to prepare digitized maps. It is estimated that it takes one month of hard work to map 5 kilometers."
In the city of Dar es Salaam, 18 percent of malaria transmissions occur outside houses. Malaria incidence is lower in urban areas than in rural. The Entomological Inoculation Rate (EIR) in Tanzania varies from 200 to 1250, with an average of 400, "which translates to the fact that almost everybody has or has had malaria," the report said. EIR, a measurement of the intensity of malaria transmission, is the number of inoculations of malaria parasites received by one person in one year.
On December 14, 2006 Lanzaro, at the invitation of President and Mrs. Bush, participated in the White House Summit on Malaria, part of the President's Malaria Initiative, a five-year $1.2 billion
Fall 2007 15
16
ABOVE: Typical scene in a village in Cameroon. Photo by Tara Thiemann
BELOW: Gregory Lanzaro (left) leads an expedition collecting mosquitoes outside the village of Godola in Cameroon. The woman at far right joined the entourage to seek treatment for her child, who received antimalaria treatment and survived. Photo by Anthony Cornel
Fall 2007
(j CHEM/N OVA
FYFANON"ULV
P rotecting children from mosquitoes is a big job. But Fyfanon10 ULV. the most trusted mosquito adulticide in the world, makes that job a lot easier. At 96.5% active ingredient, it 's the purest brand of malathion commercially available. Fyfanon ULV is cost-effective, can be applied by
ground or air, used in rural and urban areas, has low mammalian toxicity and a short residual.
(; CHEM/NOVA
FYFANON®ULV FYFANON ULV IS AVAILABLE IN 26o-GALLON MINI-BULK CONTAINERS, 55-GALLON DRUMS AND 5-GALLON PAILS.
1.800.548.6113 www.cheminova.us.com (!I CHEM/NOVA C2007 CHEMINOVA INC. Always read and follow label directions. FYFANON is a registered trademark of Cheminova. Inc.
For use only by Federal, state, tribal or local government offidals responsible for public health or vector control or by persons certified in the appropriate categol}' or otherwise authorized by the state or tribal lead pesticide regulatol}' agency to perform adult mosquito control applications, or by persons under their direct supervision. Not for application to people.
18
ABOVE: UC Davis medical entomologist Tom Scott (left) talks with Steve Mulligan, manager of the Consolidated Mosquito Abatement District, Selma, CA, at the organizational meeting of the UC Malaria Research and Control Group. Photo by Kathy Keatley Garvey
BELOW: Left to right: UC Davis medical entomologist Robert Washino; UC Davis medical entomologist William Reisen; Dave Brown, manager of the Sacramento-Yolo Mosquito and Vector Control District; and Christopher Voight, executive director of the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California. Photo by Kathy Keatley Garvey
F all 2007
program to cut malaria's mortality rate by 50 percent in the target countries. The PMI challenges the private sector to join the US government in combating malaria.
Lanzaro said it's tragic that many Americans are unaware of the severity of malaria in Africa.
To draw awareness to malaria in the UC Davis community, Lanzaro coordinated the first-ever UC Davis Malaria Awareness Day on April 25, 2007, which also is International Malaria Awareness Day. Five MRCG members Lanzaro, Cornel, Luckhart, Washino and Mulligan - spoke to the gathering.
In his introductory remarks, Chancellor Larry Vanderhoef described malaria as "a public health problem in more than 100 countries, or 40 percent of the global population."
"It is particularly devastating in Africa," Vanderhoef said. "Ninetypercent of the g lobal deaths occur in Africa. Most susceptible are children under five and pregnant women."
Vanderhoef praised UC Davis' involvement in the war against malaria and for "leading the way."
The United States has increased its commitment to assist in the war against malaria in Africa.
"The goal of defeating malaria is a challenging goaL yet it can be done. Irs not going to require a miracle, it just requires a smart sustained, focused effort. And that's what we're here to talk about.
Experts have identified tour key steps for combating malaria in
®
CURTIS DYNA-FD·G L1rl.
OVer 60 years of testing in all comers of th'e world have culmirmted in the ultimate high performance, super reliable aerosol applicator.
MINI-PROTM Model 2990 Outstanding features in a compact size
frame that is simple to operate and transport The perfect ULV applicator for small area applications or use on light duty vehicles.
MAXI-PRO"' 145 Model2748 Our large size, high output unit for major cities and open area spraying. Choice of 18 or 21 HP Briggs & Stratton or the new 20 HP Honda GX engines. Maxi-Pro's combination of a massive 400 CFM
blower and extra capacity fuel tank will handle any large scale operation.
,, ...
TYPHOON"' I Model 2984
Ideal for small communities and towns, choice of three pumping systems, single high output nozzle,
9 HP Briggs & Stratton engine, loaded with features and economically priced.
MAXI-PRO"' 2D/2G Model 2745 Unlike any other applicator on the market
today, the Maxi-Pro 2DI2G model features two high output MultiMist~ nozzles that are
directionally control via the remote control, 180° horizontal and 100° vertically.
li
TYPHOON"' II Model 2985 Medium sized ULV applicator featuring
Dyna-Fog's patented twin MultiMist~ nozzles, choice of pumping systems and our premium
11 HP Honda GX engine.
The most advanced electric ULV aerosol applicator in the world. Featuring a digitally controlled high-speed rotary atomizer that
produces the industry's most consistently-sized spray droplets. Remote controlled tilting spray head that allows for multi positioning of the spray and
stealthy, whisper quiet operation.
#Innovators of Spraying and Fogging Technology Since 1947"
* CURTIS DYNA-FOG• • www.dynafog.com • PHONE: 317.896.2561 • FAX: 317.896.3788 17335 US HWY 31 NORTH • P.O. BOX 297 WESTFIELD. INDIANA 46074 USA IIIIUI.
lil!i
C he m icals & Equipm e nt Co., Inc. TEL 800.345.9387 WEB www.bgchem.com
Sentinel GIS is your complete solution for recording and managing data cr it ical to controlling mosquitoes. Everything you need is included and easy to use. Applications are based on industry standard ESRI software and fu lly customizable.
GET THEM BEFORE THEY GET YOU!
In partn e r ship w it h: Electronic Data Solutions, Software and Support Juniper Systems, Inc., Archer Field PC ESRI, GIS Software Trimble, GPS Receivers
, Tbe Latest Buzz: Mosquito Control Goes Higb Tecb ~ b~ walter Montgowrer~
Controlling mosquitoes in Massachusetts is a serious job. With the increasing appearance of mosquito-borne diseases, such as Eastern Equine Encephalitis and West Nile virus, effective mosquito control has become essential to protect the quality of life for citizens of Massachusetts. The potential for an outbreak is real and if one does occur it may spread rapidly. That is why it is vitally important to know, in the b link of an eye, what locations have been t reated, with what chemicals, and on which dates, to prevent unwelcome conditions from spreading throughout the state.
In Massachusetts, the Northeast Massachusetts Mosquito Control and Wetlands Management
EMPLOYEE INFO
Employee 1"'-J a=--=ckc..:.....=.ca=r-=-d ____ .. _,]
lD
Truck
~m~ge ~IJ~o-=-oo=--=o __________ ~
NEXT EXIT
RKOrd Edit Optio.a D ~;; i~g 0.
Figure 1: This is the sign-in screen for employees to initialize their data acquisition tasks.
District is the group responsible for controlling mosquitoes in Essex County. Our personnel recognize an important challenge which affects our success. We need a simple, yet accurate method for capturing mosquito control data. Our team had previous experience using handheld personal d ig ital assistants (PDAs), but this wasn't sufficient to support the ever increasing complexity of the mosquito control program. A proven approach was required that would reliably acquire data in the formats needed and be flexible enough to adapt to the way we work, instead of forcing us to adapt to the technology.
WORKING THE HOT SPOTS
As warmer months approach, fie ld personnel from our District spend their time eva luating wetlands, catch basins, and other mosquito habitats. They survey areas by foot or take an aerial view of larger tracts of land that are known to be popular homes for pesky insects. It's a large job. In any g iven city or town, there can be hundreds of catch basins to inspect, treat, and report. Ensuring accountability is their highest priority, because their efforts become highly vis ible when an outbreak occurs.
When it comes to treatment there are several methods that have specific reporting requirements to meet state reporting regulations. Some of these include:
Larvicidlng: a chemical method used to control the mosquito in its most vulnerable stage, when confined and localized, to prevent the insects from becoming adults. Many of the products designed to ki ll or prevent emergence are formulated with biological materials such as bacteria and insect growth regulators.
Catch Basin Management: targeted catch basins and storm drain larviciding to prevent adult emergence. Th is is especially important for controlling mosquitoes suspected of vectoring West Nile virus.
ACCOUNTABILITY IS CRITICAL, FAST ANSWERS REQUIRED
When performing treatment
CATCH BASIN
LARVICDE
Aerial Larvidde
BACKUP
RESTORE
EXIT
Racord Edit Option D l; ~
Figure 2: Large, easy co read menu items make selecting tasks on a PDA simple.
Fall 2007 25
26
services, precise time stamping and location data need to be recorded throughout the day by field personnel as they are applying chemicals. At the end of any given period, a county, city, or town that the District serves may call to request a treatment summary report. We want to know how much chemical was applied, what chemicals were used, when it was performed, and specific locations. To meet the data management challenge, field personnel traditionally recorded this information by paper and pencil.
The paperwork was massive, requiring notebook upon notebook of data to be entered into a computer. The District's employees would assume the large task of entering the data. The trouble with manual data entry is that it is time consuming and takes prec ious time to complete a season's worth of operations. In the event that a county or town requests a summary of treatment services, it would take days to prepare the report.
NORTHEAST DISTRICT TRIES PDAs
Over the past few years, we tried to use PDAs to faci litate automated data capture and manage the process more effectively. PDAs are more convenient than paper and provide an easy way to transfer the data back to the home office. They reduce the inaccuracies associated with manual data entry, reduce labor costs, and save an incredible amount of time when it comes to reporting. However, it is not that simple to change from manual data entry to automated methods. PDAs do not come fully equipped
Fall 2007
-I
,_,10 10
with the right software to capture data, and are not designed for such specific applications as recording field personnel activity for mosqutto control. An interface must be created that is simple to use, as field personnel have
!Pool -1 lvectobacG · I
.=_ __ -_.I I ~ .:.::•=--
'-"'-'=---'' I ACRE ... , ,, il/t~ I
rn ' l it!Y.if'l•'*-1~~~~ I CA~CH BASIN I I END I
Rec10nl Edit Option D .l; !ill Q
Figure 4: This screen shows the data captured for a larvicide treatment.
varying degrees of computer experience. In the case of the Northeast District, our first PDA experience ran into serious challenges with the application we were using. It was a standard application purchased off-theshelf, with some minor customization. But the standard product was not as flexible as we needed, and usability was a major challenge in the field. As a result, we returned to manual data collection and put a hold on the devices.
HANDHELDS GET ANOTHER TRY
Fast forward to 2006, and we were ready to use PDAs again. Jack Card, Operations Manager, and Robyn Januszewski, Staff Biologist recognized the enormous benefit of having the data captured electronically. Our District wanted to generate reports with different criteria and provide custom reports to their member communities on demand. This time we knew more about what we wanted from ou,r system. Requirements included:
• Customized data capture application to ensure the right data is recorded and not lost
• Simple user interface for field personnel
• Interface with the GIS/GPS system to record actual locations for each treatment.
Accord ing to Jack Card, "We were leery to get back into using PDAs." "The last time around didn't work out. We are a mobile organization and we wanted a solution that would keep our people p roductive and proactive. We didn't want them to keep leaving the field
DUAL ACTION MOSQUITO CONTROL! w/Unique Syphon Flow Technology
Ground ULV & storm Drain Fogging Has Never Been So Easy!!
No Pumps
To
Flush
or
Calibrate!
PH 10.2.0 Titan w /10 HP Kobler
l\f~ Public Health
Equipment & Supply
Co. Inc. Proteuional Mosquoto
Control Pro<lueto s .. ce 1947
in action!
1 (800) 284-0106 Mosquito Control Products· Since 1947
(21 0) 532-3846
Fax (210) 532-9703
web-site: www.phesco.com
e-mail: [email protected]
P.O. Box 10458, San Antonio, TX 78210
Ft. Worth Office (817) 233-8000
Fax (817) 568-6881
Truck Mounted ULV Fogging with Unique Syphon-Flow
Treat Storm Drains with Unique
New .. Tunnel Rat"
Stonn Drain Attachment w/36'' extension
Fits Titan, Blazer or HP91 0 Aerosol Generators
28
to report their progress at the office. We wanted to cut down on the amount of data entry we had to do on a daily basis and provide a better service to our cities and towns in the form of accurate, timely reports, and more productivity."
In searching for a solution, Card found an engineering consulting firm that specialized in interfacing GIS/GPS applications called True North Mapping (www.tnmapping. com). True North Mapping had previous experience in setting up GIS systems for mapping data from aerial larvicide and adulticide applications. After a few meetings and a proof of concept demonstration, True North was hired to create a custom solution for mosquito control data collection using Dell® PDAs.
The NIAID-sponsored Malaria Research and Reference Reagent Resource Center (MR4, www.mr4.org) is pleased to announce the availability of the new manual "Methods In Anopheles Research."
This 238-page compilation of laboratory methods and advice combines information previously presented on the web site and now with expanded and revised content. It is free for downloading, in part or whole, from the MR4 web site under the menu selection "Anopheles info," then "Training & Methods." The manual is designed to provide complete lists of materials and protocols for several common techniques used in the MR4 vector activities and elsewhere.
Fall 2007
ADDnnDNALTREA~ENT
I END II LARVICIDE I RKord Edit" Optioo D ~ !!~~ q
Figure 5: Treatments are carefully recorded to capture materials, location, and amount of chemical being used in each location.
VISUAL CE SELECTED AS THE APPLICATION PLATFORM
Suzanne Luinis, founder and president of True North Mapping explains, "They were doing a lot of paperwork and wanted a way to upload the recorded data of their activities into an Access database. After researching several PDA applications, we chose Visual CE, an application developed by SYWARE (www. syware.com). Visual CE was sophisticated enough to handle the customization we needed for our client, making it a user friendly application."
Visual CE is designed to bui ld mobile database applications for handheld devices including Windows® Mobile, Pocket PC, or Windows® CE, and can handle complex data acquisition inter-
It contains anopheline-specific information but does not contain molecular techniques of a generic nature. Subjects include dissect ion techniques, Insecticide-resistance assays, species identification by PCR and general anopheline culture.
The MR4 welcomes appropriate voluntary contributions and revisions to the manual. If you would like to add sections on techniques in which you have expertise, please contact Mark Benedict at the address below.
Mark Q Benedict, PhD CDC/NCID/DPD, Entomology
4770 Buford Hwy, MS F-42 Chamblee, GA 30341 USA
770-488-4987 [email protected]
faces like mosquito control. Mobile applications eliminate paperwork, improve data accuracy, and centralize the collection of data. The Visual CE development environment offers drag and drop controls to create custom electronic forms, like work orders. All data is collected and synchronized with a desktop PC or corporate server, and works seamlessly with the Microsoft Access database being used at District headquarters.
Visual CE was also able to interface with a GPS system to capture all location points. The GPS system is activated with the PDA using a Bluetooth receiver the size of a small keychain. The GPS logs periodic coordinates and uploads that information to the PDA of the field personnel. This dramatically improves the quality of the data collected, and supports the level of accountability needed to support their customer's reporting requirements.
"We are thrilled with the solution Suzanne's team provided for our group," states Card . "True North Mapping had a different approach attogether. The equipment was different and they provided an excellent presentation that helped us see the simplicity of the application. Our field personnel are able to quickly learn how to enter data without any extensive training or computer programming experience . And Suzanne's team provides outstanding technical support, which is a must in our industry."
MOVING FORWARD: PROTECTING THE DATA
As the project evolved, new requirements have emerged.
One need, in particular, is a way to protect the data captured in the field . PDA batteries can be a challenge and when they unexpectedly lose power, all the data collected that day can be lost. The True North Mapping team is now implementing a backup system to protect the data. This system will offer instant synchronization with the home office system using wireless protocols. This will ensure that field data captured is sent to the database immediately, preventing loss of information .
PDA'S CATCHING ON QUICKLY
With the success of our use of PDAs, other mosquito control teams in other states are catching on quickly. Who wouldn't want the benefits that the Northeast District has realized?
Those benefits include:
• Accurate data capture
• Save time and labor costs for data entry
• GPS position recording
• Instant synchronization with host database
• Clear picture of how much chemical was used during treatments, where they were used, and what type of treatments were performed
• Easy to integrate with databases, GIS systems, and office applications
• Produce custom reports instantly, on demand
As handheld applications are being successfully deployed in the field of mosquito control organizations, more regions and states are looking to adopt these mobile devices for their field personnel. Available solutions have increased in sophistication and now greatly improve the level and type of reporting possible. This is becoming even more important as new chemical treatments are introduced. These systems can help track how effective these treatments are in various environments, and help improve the overall effectiveness of mosquito control treatments regionally.
Now that is something the citizens of every state will appreciate.
Walter Montgomery Superintendent
Northeast Massachusetts Mosquito and Wetlands
Management District 261 Northern Plum Island Newburyport, MA 01950
978-463-6630 nemmc comcast.net
Fall 2007 29
30
Join us in historic
Plyznouth!!
At thi s meeting there will be:
• State reports on mosquito
activity from New England ,
New York & New Jersey
• Research projects in
mosquito biology and
control
• Updates on new techniques
and procedures in mosquito
control
• Much much more!!
December 3-5, 2007 For more information check our website at www.nmca.org
The 53rd Annual NMCA Meeting will be held at the Radisson Hotel at Plymouth Harbor in Plymouth, MA from December 3-5, 2007. Room cost for NMCA wi ll be $98 per night (single rate - plus 5.7% Mass tax and 4% local tax) - please specify the "Northeastern Mosquito Control Association Annual Meeting" when you book your room. This special rate is only effective unti l Nov. 19, 2007 please book soon!! For reservations call (508) 747-4900
The Radisson Hotel is within walking distance to the Mayflower II, Plymouth National Wax Museum, Plymouth Rock and other area attractions, and only minutes from car to Plimouth Plantation.
NORTHEASTERN MOSQUITO CONTROL ASSOCIATION, INC. mosquito control for health and comfort
PO Box 438 Barrington, Rl 02806
www.nmca.org
Fall 2007
Why do we do so much more than just sell vector control products and equipment?
Because our success depends on your success.
Fall 2007 31
32
Recently there have been conference presentations during which the terms MIR and MLE were used interchangeably, leading to some confusion. What exactly are they? What do they mean? What is the d ifference between the two? And when should we use them?
WHAT ARE THEY?
MIR stands for Minimum Infection Rate which is the minimum number of infected mosquitoes (per thousand) that are estimated to be in a given population sample.
MLE stands for Maximum Likelihood Estimation which is the most likely number of infected mosquitoes (per thousand) that are estimated to be in a g iven population sample.
WHAT DO THEY MEAN?
MIR means that there are at least a certain number of positive
mosquitoes in the population sample. It assumes that only one mosquito is infected in each positive pool, and when you calculate the number of positive mosquitoes per thousand, this is the minimum number of positive mosquitoes in the sample. This calculation is done in the following manner:
# Positive pools MIR = x 1,000
Total # mosquitoes tested
Conversely, MLE considers the number of positive mosquitoes that may be found in any given positive pool. When the number of positive mosquitoes per thousand is calculated, this number represents an estimation of the most likely number of positive mosquitoes in the population sample. The calculation of this number requires a much more complex formula (Gu et al., 2003), and fortunately there are several computer programs to make these calculations.
First is an Excel add-in called PooledlnfRate that is provided at no charge by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This add-in can be downloaded from the Web at http://www.cdc. gov/ncidod/dvbid/westnile/soft ware.htm (Biggerstaff, 2006). An alternative is the MLE-IR program, which is executable on PCs and is freely available upon request to the authors (Gu et al., 2003).
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO?
The difference between the two is that the MIR assumes there is only one positive mosquito in each pool while the MLE allows for the possibility that there may be more than one positive mosquito per pool. If the infection rates are low in a population, say in the order of five positive mosquitoes per thousand, the MIR and MLE values will be similar. However, as the infection rate increases so will the disparity between the MIR and MLE, with
SOUTHWEST ASSURANCE CORPORATION OF FLORIDA
~~-N 'r:• • •
THE PREFERRED INSURANCE PROGRAM
How Municipalities and Taxing Districts contain the High Cost of Insurance Protection
GENERI\L LIABILilY •!• PROFESSIONAL LIABILilY •!• AUTOMOBILE LIABILilY
AVIATION LIABILilY •!• AVIATION HULL •!• AVIATION CHEMICAL LIABILilY
SOUTHWEST ASSURANCE CORPORATION OF FLORIDA- Program Administrators 3101 West Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, 4th Floor, Tampa, FL 33607
phone: 800-527-4953 •:• fax: 813-222-4040 AMCA Sustaining Member
Fall 2007
I
re. ,~_
, ...,..
p ,. , ..,
..... ~
adulticides larvicides equipment pest products training
B&G Chemicals & Equipment Co., Inc. Calll-800-345-9387 or visit us online at www.bgchem.com
Helping professionals protect public health and environment since 1950.
the MLE always of a larger value MLE, as such a calculation over than the MIR. a long period of time is not truly
representative of viral activity in WHEN SHOULD WE USE THEM? the mosquito population, which
ftuctuates throughout the season. The best measure to use is the MLE. It will give you a better idea of the actual infection rate in the mosquito population, and as mentioned before, if the infection rate is low, there will be little if any difference between the two. The programs used to calculate MLE are able to accommodate pools of varying size, and they calculate confidence intervals that are essential for valid comparison of infection rates of different samples.
The infection rate calculations should be used on a weekly basis, and are best presented graphically as a line. A cu
Estimation of the mosquito infection rate can provide important epidemiological data, but it is a surveillance tool that requires thoughtful planning of specific surveillance goals and careful consideration of the proper interpretation of any data that may result (Shroyer, 2001 ).
This article is based on a news item first published in the July 2006 issue of "The Skeeter" Newsletter of the Virginia Mosquito Control Association. Vol. 66, No.2: 4.
REFERENCES
mulative infection rate for the Biggerstaff, B. 2006. http:Uwww. entire season should never be cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/westnile/ calculated, neither as a MIR or software.htm May 1, 2006
Gu, W., Lampman, R. & Novak, R. J. 2003. Problems in estimating mosquito infection rates using minimum infection rate. J. Med. Ent. 40(5): 595-596.
Shroyer, D. A. 2001 . The Collection and Processing of Mosquitoes for Arbovirus Assay: Some Fundamental Considerations. Wing Beats, Vol. 12, No. 2: 4,5,18,25.
Fall 2007 33
34 Fall 2007
36
FROM WHERE I SIT . . .
In 1928 Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis wrote, "The greatest dangers to liberty lurk in insidious encroachment by men of zeal, well-meaning but without understanding." Wise counsel, indeed, if only anti-pesticide activists would take heed. If the primary subject of many of my e-mails, telephone consults, and requests for assistance by mosquito abatement districts these days is any indicator, there appears to be a noticeable upsurge in attempts by activists to call the practices of our profession into question. All in support of the proliferation of "natural" mosquito control remedies such as garlic, rosemary oil, etc. For the past 7 years I've gamely attempted to rebut inaccuracies surrounding these products making their way to media sources that have been brought to my attention. I'll have to admit, though, that refuting the more egregious bilge is becoming increasingly tedious as a few of the more radicalized of the activist groups begin to eschew even the minimal trappings of rational thought. But it has to be done and done often. It's most assuredly frustrating dealing with the defiantly ignorant, but our responsibility to advocate sound science in the service of our constituencies should drive us to confront the inaccuracies published about our products and methodologies, lest the mythologies become ingrained as fact in the public's consciousness.
Fall 2007
Much of the more biased nonsense I've heard is the result of the public having minimal knowledge of the regulatory process and how it protects human health and the environment, coupled to a belief in the benign nature of "natural" products. Here's where the local public health and mosquito district education programs can make a difference. To be sure, the regulation of pesticides is an extremely complex process and
cannot be adequately de scribed or explained in this short article. Indeed, the longer I participate in the Pesticide Program Dialogue Committee (PPDC) at EPA, the more I appreciate some of the complex compromises necessitated through the interactions of various constituencies having widely divergent agendas. The open process by which the PPDC produces input and presents it to the EPA on these regulatory issues underscores the transparency
sought in the Agency fulfilling its FIFRA and FQPA responsibilities. This process is largely unknown to the public, but it contributes in a very real way to the level of safety built into the label.
The fact is, there are a great number of safeguards built into the products we use and the ways we use them. That is as it should be and we should not be shy about touting it. Furthermore, we should continually state that it is in no one's best interest to gratuitously poison the environment in which we and our families live and we won't do it. We have nothing to lose and everything to gain by confronting activist claims with science.
Interestingly, activists remained blithely unconcerned about potential human exposures to demonstrably toxic "natural" products - many of which they actively promote as mosquito control alternatives. For example, garlic oil, touted as an effective barrier treatment, contains allicin, a chemical with an LD
50 of 60, which is about 7 times as toxic as naled. When informed of this, activists with whom I've interacted seem intuitively to understand that poisoning by garlic is unlikely due to lack of historical data confirming such in addition to the minute amount which is ingested (exposure). This provides an excellent opportunity to make Paracelsus' point of "the dose makes the poison." In other words, the amount of a substance to which a person is
exposed is as important (or more so) as the intrinsic toxic ity of the chemical itself in establishing risk. For example, coumadin (warfarin) in therapeutic doses can prevent excessive blood clotting in individuals prone to emboli. If the therapeutic dose is exceeded it can lead to fatal internal bleeding. Don't be surprised if the point remains lost upon the true believer, though, because it conflicts with his or her confirmation bias.
The same goes for the extraordinary array of known nat ural carcinogens found in everyday vegetables, spices and essential oils. Nitrosamines in beets, celery, and lettuce; aflatoxin in peanuts, corn, and milk; sterigmatocystin in salami. ham, and wheat; hydrazines in mushrooms; allyl isothiocyanate in mustard, broccoli, and cabbage; safrole in pepper; tannins in coffee, tea, and wines; psoralens in celery and parsley; ethyl carbamate in b read, yogurt, beer, and wine; formaldehyde in fruits; benzene in eggs; methylene chloride in fats; coumarin in candy; d iacetyl in coffee and butter; and flavonoids in fruits and vegetables - all are known carc inogens.
Are there any groups advocating a ban on the food items containing these toxins? I think not. To paraphrase Dr. Bruce Ames, there are more natural carcinogens by weight in a single cup of coffee than potentially carcinogenic synthetic pesticide residues in the average American diet in a year. This doesn't mean that coffee is dangerous, but rather that worstcase risk assessments do not represent the true risks involved. This is also certainly not meant
to negate the perceived risk from the application of synthetic pesticides, but rather to place the exposure dynamic in its true perspective.
The use of comparative risk assessments by EPA's Office of Pesticide Programs remains under attack by those in favor of what amounts to the Precautionary Principle, that even if there is no scientific evidence of actual dangers of a product or activity, merely conjectural concerns should be a reason to prohibit them. This is not the same as mother's admonition "better safe than sorry," for proscription against effective mosquito control p ractices be
cause of imputed lack of sufficient 70 year chronic toxicity data in the face of impending disease transmission is not "safe". Indeed, the requirement for proof of absolute absence of importune effects from pesticides over the long term represents an unreachable standard. One could easily make the same case with regard to antib iotics that have demonstrably saved hundreds of m illions of lives at the cost of a few dozen fatal anaphylactic reactions.
A Precautionary Principle writ large would effectively preclude the development andJor use of all chemical substances and products, whether produced by industrial means or d iscovered in our rain forests. Mistakes are surely made, but all human endeavors would be eliminated if subject to a zero-defects criterion.
I'm aware that all of this is pretty dry reading. Believe me, I deal with it on a daily basis. However, risk management is the science upon which our profession bases its human health and environmental bona fides. It would be in the best interest of us all to become familiar, at some level, with its particulars in order to bring perspective to discussions with those whose agenda is inimical to ours. To this end, I intend on providing a primer on how EPA manages risk to humans and the environment in the upcoming issue of Wing Beats. In the meantime, it is incumbent upon a ll of us in mosquito control to confront fraudulent c laims made about the products we use and how we use them in as forthright and professional a manner as we can muster. To fail in this is to risk a society where ignorant hysteria drowns out scientific truth and where public health policies are driven by bullheaded nonsense, loudly shouted.
~ Joseph M Conlon
AMCA Technical Advisor l 500 Millbrook Court
Orange Park, FL 32003 904-215-3008
amcata Cilbellsouth,net .. -.... -~--~
Fall 2007 37
38
MOSQUITO CONTROL TEAM LEADERS: 2 posit ions ava ilab le $15.91 - 26.25 I hour $33,080 - 54,582 I year
GENERAL STATEMENT OF JOB
Performs specialized work involving the superv ision of mosquito contro l f ie ld opera t ions. Works under the d irection of the Manager and is expected to exerc ise consid erable independent judgment to accomplish work with a min imum of supervis ion. Work a lso includes performing the functions and duties o f a Mosquito Contro l Technician.
ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS
Assists in coordinating field evaluations o f pestic ides and appl icat ion equipment . Supervises field surveillance, larviciding and adultic id ing operations and evaluates the effectiveness of these operations. Conducts f ie ld inspections to detect the p resence of mosquitoes; sets and retrieves mosquito traps. Ensures a ll spray equip ment is calib rated accord ing to label specificat ions. Conducts qua li t y assurance eva luations and oversees the safety program. Assigns complaint investigations to the appropriate personnel. Eva luates work performance and abilities of subord inates. Applies natura l predators known to be effective against immature mosquitoes. Mainta ins records and completes reports. Maintains daily records o f areas sprayed, to included locat ion, time, volume of chemicals used and miles traveled. Establishes and maintains effective working re lationships w ith other employees and the genera l public. Maintains Sentinel Chicken Flocks and performs other duties of Mosquito-Borne Virus surveillance. Provides information to the public on the production and e lim ination of mosquitoes. Responds to c it izens' requests in a cou rteous and t imely manner. Conducts Out-Reach and Public Education programs as assigned by Manager. Participates in continuing education on Public Health Pest Control and federaL state and county laws and regulations governing pestic ides. Keeps abreast of advancements in the mosquito control fie ld through self-study and professional tra ining courses.
Fall 2007
MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS
High school d ip loma or GED and three (3) years of experience in a ll phases o f mosquito control to include three (1) year o f supervisory experience. Mosqu ito contro l supervisory experience preferred. Must be able to co lib ra te spray equipment for proper application rate. Knowledge of the geographic layout of Seminole County is a p lus.
SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS
Must possess a va lid Pub lic Hea lth Pest Contro l cert if ica t ion issued by the State o f Flo rida Department o f Agriculture and Consumer Services or obtain w ith in 90 days of appointment. Must possess and maintain a val id Florida Driver's License. Must be able to work evenings, weekends, holidays o r rotating sh ifts.
TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS
Know ledge o f the techn ica l aspects of mosquito control opera tions
WORKING CONDITIONS
Working extended outdoors in h igh tempera tures and humid it y.
HOW TO APPLY
Send resume by e -ma il o r mai l. Posit ion open unti l f i lled.
SEMINOLE COUNTY MOSQUITO CONTROL
177 Bush Loop
Sa nford, FL 32773
EdwardS. Horvath Mosquito Control Program Manager
407-665-5568
..... .,.~~-.............
Hfgh output OLV macblne .. Moll popular ll.V •fOIGI genantor
In the world.
hnprov111111111 tor 1he 11 .. 20
dan.perous and time
most advanced aerial
to receif real-time
II) displ'f optimization
th,m an ther P.roduct
he err MAG
'kliH9 C?eat¢ PO Box 358630 ~.FL3263~8630
PRESORTSTD US POSTAGE PAID
PERMIT //230 PANAMA CITY Fl