will the air be clean enough to breathe?...this activity is part of a sequence of activities in the...

40
1 of 40 lesson Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe? What are the interactions of factors that affect a region's air quality? Content Created by Activity 1: Measuring Air Quality | 45 mins Directions 1. Activate students' prior knowledge about air quality. Show the Highland Park Optimist Club banquet in 1954 image. (Click on the link in the media carousel above and download using the arrow in the lower right corner of the window.) Tell students that bad air quality has a negative effect on human health. Air quality was poor in the United States before Clean Air Act regulations went into effect in 1970. Many areas around the world still experience very poor air quality. Ask: Why do you think air quality is better in the United States today than it was before 1970? (Air quality is better because the Clean Air Act set air quality standards that states and localities had to meet. They reduced their emissions to meet the standards, and the air quality improved.) What causes poor air quality events? (There are many causes of poor air quality events. Human actions [burning fuels and using volatile organic compounds] put pollutants into the air. Natural events [forest fires and volcanic eruptions] can also affect air quality.) Are human processes the only causes of air pollution? (Humans are not the only causes of air pollution. Forest fires and volcanic eruptions are two natural causes of poor air quality.) Tell students that air quality is measured by the air quality index. Show students the Air Quality Index , and then access the Air Now: Today’s AQI Forecast website and show the air quality forecast map for the United States. Ask: Where is the air quality forecast to be the worst in the United States today? (Answers will vary depending on the day.) What do you think is the cause for the poor air quality in the United States today? (Depending on the area of the country, the poor air quality could be due to fires, emissions from power plants

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jan-2021

5 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

1of40

lesson

WilltheAirBeCleanEnoughToBreathe?Whataretheinteractionsoffactorsthataffectaregion'sairquality?

ContentCreatedby

Activity1:MeasuringAirQuality|45minsDirections1.Activatestudents'priorknowledgeaboutairquality.

ShowtheHighlandParkOptimistClubbanquetin1954image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatbadairqualityhasanegativeeffectonhumanhealth.AirqualitywaspoorintheUnitedStatesbeforeCleanAirActregulationswentintoeffectin1970.Manyareasaroundtheworldstillexperienceverypoorairquality.Ask:

WhydoyouthinkairqualityisbetterintheUnitedStatestodaythanitwasbefore1970?(AirqualityisbetterbecausetheCleanAirActsetairqualitystandardsthatstatesandlocalitieshadtomeet.Theyreducedtheiremissionstomeetthestandards,andtheairqualityimproved.)

Whatcausespoorairqualityevents?(Therearemanycausesofpoorairqualityevents.Humanactions[burningfuelsandusingvolatileorganiccompounds]putpollutantsintotheair.Naturalevents[forestfiresandvolcaniceruptions]canalsoaffectairquality.)

Arehumanprocessestheonlycausesofairpollution?(Humansarenottheonlycausesofairpollution.Forestfiresandvolcaniceruptionsaretwonaturalcausesofpoorairquality.)

Tellstudentsthatairqualityismeasuredbytheairqualityindex.ShowstudentstheAirQualityIndex,andthenaccesstheAirNow:Today’sAQIForecastwebsiteandshowtheairqualityforecastmapfortheUnitedStates.Ask:

WhereistheairqualityforecasttobetheworstintheUnitedStatestoday?(Answerswillvarydependingontheday.)

WhatdoyouthinkisthecauseforthepoorairqualityintheUnitedStatestoday?(Dependingontheareaofthecountry,thepoorairqualitycouldbeduetofires,emissionsfrompowerplants

Page 2: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

2of40

andfactories,and/oremissionsfromvehicles.Stagnantweatherpatternscancontributetopoorairqualityevents.)

Howdoyouthinkscientistsforecastairquality?(Scientistsusedatafromreal-timemonitoringstationstomeasurethelevelofpollutantsinparticularareasandweatherforecaststopredictwherewindwillblowpollutants(orleavepollutantsoveraparticularlocation).)

2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.

Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Letstudentsknowthattheycanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyinforecastingairquality.ShowtheForecastofAirQualityonDecember10,2013imageandAirQualityonDecember10,2013image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatthesearesnapshotsoftheairqualityforecastandthereal-timeairqualityintheUnitedStatesonDecember10,2013.Ask:

Didtheforecastaccuratelypredictwhichareaswouldhavepoorqualityair?(Theforecastairqualityoverlapswithmanyofthepoorairqualityareas,butitdoesnotcoverallofthem.Theairqualityinsomeareas(NorthernCalifornia)ismuchworsethantheforecastpredicted.)

WhydoyouthinkscientistsdidnotaccuratelypredicttheairqualityformoreoftheUnitedStates?(Studentanswerswillvary.Theairqualityforecastisaffectedbyhumanactivitiesthatmaynotbeeasilypredicted.)

Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictions.Letstudentsknowtheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers,andencouragethemtodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.

3.HavestudentslaunchtheMeasuringAirQualityinteractive.

ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheMeasuringAirQualityinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentsthattheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofdatawithquestionsrelatedtothedata.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.

TellstudentsthatthisisActivity1oftheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.

4.Discusstheissues.

Page 3: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

3of40

Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:

Whatgroupsofpeoplearemostatriskfrompoorairquality?Peoplewhoworkoutdoorsaremostatrisk,followedbythosewithbreathingproblems,suchasasthma,emphysema,andCOPD(chronicobstructivepulmonarydisease).

Whatdoofficialssuggestpeopledowhenbadairqualityisforecast?(Whenbadairqualityisforecast,officialssuggestlimitingoutdooractivities.)

Whatmighthappentoairqualityifthepopulationcontinuestogrow?(Ifthepopulationcontinuestogrow,airqualitymightdecrease,especiallyinareasoftheworldwhereairqualityisalreadybadalotofthetime.)

Howmighthumansmitigatebadairqualityeventsinthefuture?(Humansmightbeabletomitigatebadairqualityeventsthroughtechnology.Technologycouldbedevelopedthatremovesmoreemissionsfromcars,factories,andpowerplants.Technologycouldalsochangesothatmanufacturingandtransportationmethodsdon'trequireburningoffuelsthatreleasepollutantsintotheair.)

TipTeacherTipIfyouwanttosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.

TipTeacherTipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesintheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.

ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.

InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingstudentsthefollowingquestions:

Whatfactorscontributetopoorairqualityevents?Whateffectscanairpollutionregulationshaveonairquality?

Page 4: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

4of40

Whatcanbedonetoreduceormanagepollutantemissions?

2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.

ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience

EarthscienceGeneralscience

LearningObjectivesStudentswill:

explainthelinkbetweenhumanandecosystemhealthandairpollutiondescribenaturalandanthropogenicsourcesofairpollution

TeachingApproachLearning-for-use

TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting

SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:

21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills

Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills

CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes

GlobalAwarenessCriticalThinkingSkills

AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding

NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices

Page 5: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

5of40

NationalScienceEducationStandards

•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardF-1:Personalhealth•(5-8)StandardF-4:Risksandbenefits•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardC-5:Matter,energy,andorganizationinlivingsystems•(9-12)StandardF-1:Personalandcommunityhealth•(9-12)StandardF-2:Populationgrowth•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality•(9-12)StandardF-5:Naturalandhuman-inducedhazards

CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy

•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3

ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)

Page 6: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

6of40

•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking

NextGenerationScienceStandards

•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation

PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationPoorairqualitycannegativelyaffecthumanandenvironmentalhealth.Airqualitycansufferduetobothnaturalandanthropogenic(human-caused)events.Anthropogenicemissionscanbecontrolled.AirqualityhasimprovedintheUnitedStatessincethepassageofthefirstCleanAirActin1970.

TheCleanAirActsetnationalambientairqualitystandardsforsixcommonpollutants:particulates,ozone,sulfurdioxide,nitrogenoxides,carbonmonoxide,andlead.Stateswererequiredtodevelopplanstoachievegoodairstandardsandtocontrolemissionsdriftingacrossstatelines.Pollutioncontroldevicesweredevelopedforstationary(powerplant,factory)andmobile(vehicle)pollutionsources.TheCleanAirActhasbeenupdatedseveraltimessincetheinitiallawwaspassedin1970.

Page 7: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

7of40

Asaresult,airqualityintheUnitedStatesisbettertodaythanithasbeeninthepast50years.Poorairqualityeventsarestillcommoninmanyothercountriesaroundtheworld.GlobalairmovementscanbringpollutantsfromothercountriestotheUnitedStates.Asystemoflocalairmeasurementstationsprovidesareal-timelookatairqualityaroundtheUnitedStates.Basedonthesemeasurementsandonweatherforecasts,scientistscanprovideairqualityforecasts.YoucanseethecurrentandforecastairqualityatAirNow.gov.Airqualityisdefinedintosixcategories:Good,Moderate,UnhealthyforSensitiveGroups(USG),Unhealthy,VeryUnhealthy,andHazardous.(SeetheAirQualityIndex(AQI)chartfromtheEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(EPA)intheresourcecarousel.)

PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities

None

VocabularyTerm Partof

Speech Definition

airquality noun measurementofpollutantsandotherharmfulmaterialsintheair.

atmosphere noun layersofgasessurroundingaplanetorothercelestialbody.

model,computationalnoun

amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.

particulate adjective,noun

microscopicsolidorliquidparticle,oftensuspendedintheatmosphereaspollution.

pollutant noun chemicalorothersubstancethatharmsanaturalresource.

smog nountypeofairpollutioncommoninmanufacturingareasorareaswithhightraffic.

system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.

Partner

Funder

Page 8: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

8of40

ThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder

GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.

Partner

Activity2:MovementofPollutants|45minsDirections1.Activatestudents'priorknowledgeaboutairmovementsintheatmosphere.

ShowtheAirPollutionFromaPowerPlantphotograph.Tellstudentsthatpollutantsemittedintotheatmospheredonotstayintheatmosphereorevendirectlyabovethepollutingsourceforever.Theymovethroughouttheatmosphereandaremovedandremovedbynaturalprocesses.Ask:

Whatnaturalprocesscausespollutantstomoveawayfromthepollutionsource?(Windwillcausepollutantstomoveawayfromthesource.)

Whatnaturalprocesswouldremovepollutantsfromtheatmosphere?(Precipitationwouldremovepollutantsfromtheatmosphere.)

2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.

Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Letstudentsknowthattheycanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyinforecastingairquality.TellstudentsthatairqualityismeasuredbytheAirQualityIndex.ShowstudentstheAirQualityIndex,whichincludesexplanationsoftherangesusedintheairqualityindex.ThenprojecttheForecastofAirQualityonDecember10,2013imageandAirQualityonDecember10,2013image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatthesearesnapshotsoftheairqualityforecastandthereal-timeairqualityintheUnitedStatesonDecember10,2013.Ask:

Didtheforecastaccuratelypredictwhichareaswouldhavepoorqualityair?(Theforecastairqualityoverlapswithmanyofthepoorairqualityareas,butitdoesnotcoverallofthem.Theairqualityinsomeareas[NorthernCalifornia]ismuchworsethantheforecastpredicted.)

WhydoyouthinkscientistsdidnotaccuratelypredicttheairqualityformoreoftheUnitedStates?(Studentanswerswillvary.Theairqualityforecastisaffectedbyhumanactivitiesthatmaynotbeeasilypredicted.)

Page 9: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

9of40

Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictions.Letstudentsknowthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers,andencouragethemtodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.

3.Introducetheconceptofstocksandflowsinasystem.

Tellstudentsthatmaterialsflowintoandoutofsystems.Theflowofthematerialsovertimecanchangeandcanbeinfluencedbymanydifferentfactorsandinteractingparts.Scientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofastockandflowinasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.

Thereisabathtubwithwaterflowinginfromthefaucetandwaterleavingthroughthedrain.Ask:

Whenthedrainisplugged,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwillincreasebecausetheoutflowofwaterisstopped,butwaterkeepscominginfromthefaucet.)

Whenthefaucetisturnedoff,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwilldecreasebecausetheinflowofwaterisstopped,butthewaterkeepsleavingthroughthedrain.)

Howcanthelevelofwaterinthebathtubbekeptatthesamelevel?(Thewaterinthebathtubcanbekeptatthesamelevelbymakingtheinflowequaltotheoutflow.Then,thewaterthatcomesinthroughthefaucetwillbeoffsetbythewaterthatleavesthroughthedrain.)

Tellstudentstheywillbefollowingtheflowofmaterials,inthiscasetheamountofairpollution,inthesystem.Letstudentsknowtheywillbeexploringsomeenvironmentalandhumanfactorsthatcontributetochangesintheamountofpollutionbeingaddedtoandremovedfromthemodeledsystem.

4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.

Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.ProjecttheNOAAWeatherForecastModel,whichprovidesagoodexampleofacomputationalmodel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusemodelstopredictfutureconditionsbasedoncurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphere.Scientistsuseatmosphericmodels,suchasthese,toforecastwhereandwhenairqualitymaybebad.

Page 10: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

10of40

5.HavestudentslaunchtheMovementofPollutantsinteractive.

ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheMovementofPollutantsinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofmodelswithquestionsrelatedtothemodels.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheinteractiveintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.

TellstudentsthatthisisActivity2oftheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.

6.Discusstheissues.

Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:

Whatconditionsallowforthebestairqualityoverthecityinthemodel(Model2:Cross-SectionofaCity:WithGraph)?(Inthecityinthemodel,thebestairqualityisachievedwhenthewindisblowingtowardthewaterorwhenitrainsfrequently.)

Howdidyougetpoorairqualityoverthecityinthemodel(Model2:Cross-SectionofaCity:WithGraph)?(Poorairqualitycanresultwhenthewindisblowingtowardsthemountains,whenthereisinfrequentrain,andwhenthereisinfrequentrainandintensesunlight.)

WheredidyouputfactoriesinModel3sothatallthecitieshadgoodairquality(Model3:SatelliteViewofaCity)?(Factoriesshouldbeplacedsouthofthenortheastern-mostmountainssothatthewindwon'tblowthepollutantstoCityA.Thewindfromthenortheastoreastwillnotblowpollutantsintoanycitywhenthefactoriesarelocateddirectlysouthofthenortheastern-mostmountains.)

HowcanpollutionfromAsiaaffectNorthAmerica?(ThewindblowsprimarilyfromtheWest.PollutedairoverAsiacanbeblownacrosstheoceantoaffectcitiesinNorthAmerica.)

Howcouldtallbuildingsaffectacity'sairquality?(Tallbuildingscouldformabarriertopollutants'escapefromthearea.Thisisdependentonthewinddirection.)

MexicoCity,Mexicoissurroundedbymountainsonallsides.Howdoesthisaffecttheregion'sairquality?(Theairqualitycouldbeaffectedbythemountainsbecausethepollutionmightnotbeabletoriseupoverthemountainsandblowaway.Thiscouldmaketheairqualityinthecityquitepoor.)

TipTeacherTip

Page 11: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

11of40

Ifyouwanttosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.

TipTeacherTipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesintheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.

ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.

InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingthemthefollowingquestions:

Whatnaturalprocessremovespollutantsfromtheatmosphere?Howcanairqualityoveranareabepooreveniftherearenolocalemissions?Howdogeographicalbarriersaffectthepollutionlevelincities?

2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.

ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience

EarthscienceGeneralscience

LearningObjectivesStudentswill:

identifyfactorsthataffectairqualityoveragivenareadescribehowpollutantsmovethroughtheatmosphereexplainhowairmovementsaffecttheairqualityoveragivenareaexplainhowprecipitationcanimproveairqualityoveranarea

TeachingApproachLearning-for-use

Page 12: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

12of40

TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting

SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:

21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills

Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills

CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes

GlobalAwarenessCriticalThinkingSkills

AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding

NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices

NationalScienceEducationStandards

•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardF-1:Personalhealth•(5-8)StandardF-4:Risksandbenefits•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardC-5:Matter,energy,andorganizationinlivingsystems•(9-12)StandardF-1:Personalandcommunityhealth•(9-12)StandardF-2:

Page 13: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

13of40

Populationgrowth•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality•(9-12)StandardF-5:Naturalandhuman-inducedhazards

CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy

•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3

ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)

•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking

NextGenerationScienceStandards

•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept4:Systemsandsystemmodels•CrosscuttingConcept5:

Page 14: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

14of40

Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice2:Developingandusingmodels•ScienceandEngineeringPractice3:Planningandcarryingoutinvestigations•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation

PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationAirqualityisaffectedbynaturalprocesses.Windcanmovepollutantsfromtheirsourcetofar-awaylocations.Precipitationcanremovepollutantsfromtheatmosphere.

Scientistsusecomputationalmodelstopredictthemovementofpollutantsfromtheirsourcesandtheformationofsecondarypollutants.Satellitescanmonitorthemovementsofvisiblepollutantsacrosslongdistances.Anetworkofairqualitymonitorsonthegroundmeasureslocalconcentrationsofpollutantstoprovidemoredetailedforecastsofairquality.

PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities

MeasuringAirQuality

VocabularyTerm Partof

Speech Definition

airquality noun measurementofpollutantsandotherharmfulmaterialsintheair.

atmosphere noun layersofgasessurroundingaplanetorothercelestialbody.

intensity noun measureofmagnitude.

Page 15: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

15of40

model,computationalnoun

amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.

particulate adjective,noun

microscopicsolidorliquidparticle,oftensuspendedintheatmosphereaspollution.

pollutant noun chemicalorothersubstancethatharmsanaturalresource.

precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.

smog nountypeofairpollutioncommoninmanufacturingareasorareaswithhightraffic.

solarradiation noun lightandheatfromthesun.

system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.

Term PartofSpeech Definition

Partner

FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder

GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.

Partner

Activity3:VisibleandInvisiblePollutants|45minsDirections1.Activatestudents'priorknowledgeabouttypesofpollutants.

Page 16: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

16of40

Showthe1980MountSt.HelensEruptionphotograph.Tellstudentsthattherearetwotypesofpollutants:visiblepollutantsandinvisiblepollutants.Ask:

Whatkindofpollutantscanyouseeinthispicture?(Youcanseeashemitted,rockfragments,andgasclouds.)

Tellstudentsthattherearemanydifferenttypesofinvisible,orgaseous,pollutants.Letstudentsknowthattheywillbeexploringthesourcesofvisibleandinvisiblepollutantsandtheireffectsonhumanandenvironmentalhealthinthisactivity.

2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.

Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Letstudentsknowthattheycanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyinforecastingairquality.TellstudentsthatairqualityismeasuredbytheAirQualityIndex.ShowstudentstheAirQualityIndex,whichincludesexplanationsoftherangesusedintheairqualityindex.ThenprojecttheForecastofAirQualityonDecember10,2013imageandAirQualityonDecember10,2013image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatthesearesnapshotsoftheairqualityforecastandthereal-timeairqualityintheUnitedStatesonDecember10,2013.Ask:

Didtheforecastaccuratelypredictwhichareaswouldhavepoorqualityair?(Theforecastairqualityoverlapswithmanyofthepoorairqualityareas,butitdoesnotcoverallofthem.Theairqualityinsomeareas[NorthernCalifornia]ismuchworsethantheforecastpredicted.)

WhydoyouthinkscientistsdidnotaccuratelypredicttheairqualityformoreoftheUnitedStates?(Studentanswerswillvary.Theairqualityforecastisaffectedbyhumanactivitiesthatmaynotbeeasilypredicted.)

Tellstudentsthattheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictions.Letstudentsknowtheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers,andencouragethemtodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.

3.Introducetheconceptofstocksandflowsinasystem.

Tellstudentsthatmaterialsflowintoandoutofsystems.Theflowofthematerialsovertimecanchangeandcanbeinfluencedbymanydifferentfactorsandinteractingparts.Scientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofastockandflowinasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.

Page 17: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

17of40

Thereisabathtubwithwaterflowinginfromthefaucetandwaterleavingthroughthedrain.Ask:

Whenthedrainisplugged,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwillincreasebecausetheoutflowofwaterisstopped,butwaterkeepscominginfromthefaucet.)

Whenthefaucetisturnedoff,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwilldecreasebecausetheinflowofwaterisstopped,butthewaterkeepsleavingthroughthedrain.)

Howcanthelevelofwaterinthebathtubbekeptatthesamelevel?(Thewaterinthebathtubcanbekeptatthesamelevelbymakingtheinflowequaltotheoutflow.Then,thewaterthatcomesinthroughthefaucetwillbeoffsetbythewaterthatleavesthroughthedrain.)

Tellstudentstheywillbefollowingtheflowofmaterials,inthiscasetheamountofairpollution,inthesystem.Letstudentsknowtheywillbeexploringsomeenvironmentalandhumanfactorsthatcontributetochangesintheamountofpollutionbeingaddedtoandremovedfromthemodeledsystem.

4.HavestudentslaunchtheVisibleandInvisiblePollutantsinteractive.

ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheVisibleandInvisiblePollutantsinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentsthattheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofdatawithquestionsrelatedtothedata.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheinteractiveintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.

TellstudentsthatthisisActivity3oftheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.

5.Discusstheissues.

Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:

Whattypesofparticulatepollutantsareproducednaturally,andwhattypesareproducedthroughhumanactions?(Somenaturalparticulatesincludesandandsaltparticles,aswellasashandsootfromforestfires.Ashandsootarealsoproducedthroughhumanactionsasmaterialsareburnedforfuelintransportation,heating,andelectricityproduction.Humanscausesomeforestfires,makingthose“natural”sourcesreallyanthropogenicsources.)

Howdoinvisible(gaseous)pollutantsaffecttheenvironment?(InvisiblepollutantssuchasSO2

Page 18: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

18of40

andNO cancombinewithwatertoformacidicprecipitation.Theacidicprecipitationcanharmplantsandanimals.VOCsandCOareharmfultoanimals'healthaswellashumanhealth.)

Whyareparticulatepollutantshazardoustohumanhealth?(Particulatescanbeinhaleddeepintothelungsandcrossoverintothebloodstream.Thentheycantravelaroundthebody,causingeffectstomanyorgansystems.)

ShowtheNO Emissions,2008piechart(page6oftheinteractive).HowmanyoftheNOemissionsarefromhumansources?(AlmostalloftheNO emissionsareanthropogenic.Upto1%[miscellaneousandfires]couldbefromnaturalsources.)

Whattypesofmaterialscancauseindoorairpollution?(Carpets,perfumes,hairsprays,furniture,andpoorlyventilatedheating/cookingdevicescancauseindoorairpollution.)

Whyisindoorpollutionmorehazardoustohumanhealththanmostoutdoorpollution?(Indoorpollutioncannotbeblownawaybythewindorprecipitatedoutoftheairbyrainorsnow.Itcanbemoreconcentratedbecausethereislessdilutionwithcleanairthanispossibleoutdoors.)

Howcanincreasingfuelefficiencyreducetheemissionsofgaseouspollutants(SO ,NO ,CO)?(Increasingfuelefficiencycanreducetheemissionsofgaseouspollutantsbecauselessfuelneedstobeburnedtogothesamedistance[inavehicle]orproduceelectricity[inapowerplant].Iflessfuelisused,therewillbefeweremissions.)

TipTeacherTipIfyouwanttosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.

TipTeacherTipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesintheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.

ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.

InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingstudentsthefollowingquestions:

x

x x

x

2 x

Page 19: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

19of40

Whataresomecommonvisibleandinvisiblepollutants?Whatistheeffectofparticulateemissionsonhumanhealth?Howdoinvisible(gaseous)pollutantsaffecttheenvironment?

2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.

ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience

EarthscienceGeneralscience

LearningObjectivesStudentswill:

identifycommonsourcesofparticulateandgaseouspollutantsexplainhowparticulateemissionsaffecthumanhealthexplainhowgaseousemissionscanresultinacidrainexplainhowhumanhealthisaffectedbygaseouspollutantssuchasVOCsandcarbonmonoxide

TeachingApproachLearning-for-use

TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting

SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:

21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills

Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills

CriticalThinkingandProblemSolvingCriticalThinkingSkills

AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding

Page 20: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

20of40

NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices

NationalScienceEducationStandards

•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardF-1:Personalhealth•(5-8)StandardF-4:Risksandbenefits•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardC-5:Matter,energy,andorganizationinlivingsystems•(9-12)StandardF-1:Personalandcommunityhealth•(9-12)StandardF-2:Populationgrowth•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality•(9-12)StandardF-5:Naturalandhuman-inducedhazards

CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy

•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4

Page 21: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

21of40

•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3

ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)

•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking

NextGenerationScienceStandards

•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation

PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationAirpollutantemissionshaveaneffectonhumanandenvironmentalhealth.Particulateemissions(thevisiblepollutants)canbeinhaledintothenoseandlungs.Thesmallestparticlescancrossthealveolus-capillarybarrierandmaketheirwayintothebloodstream.

Invisiblepollutants(nitrogenoxides,sulfurdioxide,volatileorganiccompounds,carbonmonoxide)alsoposeathreattohealth.Carbonmonoxidedisplacesoxygeninredbloodcells,leadingquicklytodeathifthecarbonmonoxideconcentrationishigh.Nitrogenoxides,sulfurdioxide,andvolatileorganiccompoundsirritatethesensitivetissuesoftheairway;theyareparticularlyirritatingtopeople

Page 22: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

22of40

withpre-existinglungconditionssuchasasthmaoremphysema.

Inadditiontoposingathreattohumanhealth,nitrogenoxidesandsulfurdioxideareirritatingtoplants.Plants'leavescanbeburnedbydrydepositsofnitrogenoxidesandsulfurdioxide.Whenthesepollutantscombinewithwaterinclouds,theyformacidprecipitation.Theacidicprecipitationcancauseplantdamageanddestructionofaquatichabitatsasthewatersbecomemoreacidic.

PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities

MeasuringAirQualityMovementofPollutants

VocabularyTerm Partof

Speech Definition

airquality noun measurementofpollutantsandotherharmfulmaterialsintheair.

atmosphere noun layersofgasessurroundingaplanetorothercelestialbody.

carbonmonoxidenounCarbonmonoxideisacolorless,odorless,andtastelessgasthatisslightlylessdensethanair.Itcanbetoxictohumans.

emission noun dischargeorrelease.

intensity noun measureofmagnitude.

model,computational noun

amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.

nitrogenoxide nounoneofmanychemicalcompoundsmadeofdifferentcombinationsofnitrogenandoxygen.

particulate adjective,noun

microscopicsolidorliquidparticle,oftensuspendedintheatmosphereaspollution.

pollutant noun chemicalorothersubstancethatharmsanaturalresource.

precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.

smog nountypeofairpollutioncommoninmanufacturingareasorareaswithhightraffic.

solarradiationnoun

lightandheatfromthesun.

Page 23: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

23of40

sulfurdioxide noun greenhousegasthatcancauseacidrain.

system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.

volatileorganiccompound(VOC) noun

gasreleasedfromsomesolidsorliquidsthatmaycauseharmtopeopleandtheatmosphere.

Term PartofSpeech Definition

Partner

FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder

GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.

Activity4:PollutantsMakingMorePollutants|45minsDirections1.Activatestudents'priorknowledgeaboutsecondarypollutants.

Reviewwithstudentsthetermspollutants,particulatepollutants,andgaseouspollutants.Tellstudentsthatprimarygaseouspollutantscaninteractwithenvironmentalcomponentstomakesecondarypollutants.Tellstudentsthattwocommonsecondarypollutantsareozone,acomponentofsmog,andacidprecipitation.Askstudentstothinkaboutwhereandwhensmogandacidrainform.Ask:

Whatdoyouthinkishappeningintheenvironment(wind,precipitation,temperature)whentherearesmogevents?(Studentsmaymentionthatsmogeventsaremostcommonincitiesinthesummermonths.Studentsshouldstatethatsmogeventsarerarewhenthewindisblowing[barringgeographicbarriers]orwhenthereisregularprecipitation.)

Howdoyouthinkacidprecipitationformsintheatmosphere?(Studentsmaymentionthatpollutantscombinewithwaterinthecloudstomaketheprecipitationacidic.)

Page 24: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

24of40

Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Letstudentsknowthattheycanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyinforecastingairquality.TellstudentsthatairqualityismeasuredbytheAirQualityIndex.ShowstudentstheAirQualityIndex,whichincludesexplanationsoftherangesusedintheairqualityindex.ThenprojecttheForecastofAirQualityonDecember10,2013imageandAirQualityonDecember10,2013image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatthesearesnapshotsoftheairqualityforecastandthereal-timeairqualityintheUnitedStatesonDecember10,2013.Ask:

Didtheforecastaccuratelypredictwhichareaswouldhavepoorqualityair?(Theforecastairqualityoverlapswithmanyofthepoorairqualityareas,butitdoesnotcoverallofthem.Theairqualityinsomeareas[NorthernCalifornia]ismuchworsethantheforecastpredicted.)

WhydoyouthinkscientistsdidnotaccuratelypredicttheairqualityformoreoftheUnitedStates?(Studentanswerswillvary.Theairqualityforecastisaffectedbyhumanactivitiesthatmaynotbeeasilypredicted.)

Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictions.Letstudentsknowtheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers,andencouragethemtodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions

2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.

Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Letstudentsknowthattheycanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyinforecastingairquality.TellstudentsthatairqualityismeasuredbytheAirQualityIndex.ShowstudentstheAirQualityIndex,whichincludesexplanationsoftherangesusedintheairqualityindex.ThenprojecttheForecastofAirQualityonDecember10,2013imageandAirQualityonDecember10,2013image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatthesearesnapshotsoftheairqualityforecastandthereal-timeairqualityintheUnitedStatesonDecember10,2013.Ask:

Didtheforecastaccuratelypredictwhichareaswouldhavepoorqualityair?(Theforecastairqualityoverlapswithmanyofthepoorairqualityareas,butitdoesnotcoverallofthem.Theairqualityinsomeareas[NorthernCalifornia]ismuchworsethantheforecastpredicted.)

WhydoyouthinkscientistsdidnotaccuratelypredicttheairqualityformoreoftheUnitedStates?(Studentanswerswillvary.Theairqualityforecastisaffectedbyhumanactivitiesthatmaynotbeeasilypredicted.)

Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictions.Letstudentsknow

Page 25: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

25of40

thattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers,andencouragethemtodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.

3.Introducetheconceptofstocksandflowsinasystem.

Tellstudentsthatmaterialsflowintoandoutofsystems.Theflowofthematerialsovertimecanchangeandcanbeinfluencedbymanydifferentfactorsandinteractingparts.Scientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofastockandflowinasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.

Thereisabathtubwithwaterflowinginfromthefaucetandwaterleavingthroughthedrain.Ask:

Whenthedrainisplugged,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwillincreasebecausetheoutflowofwaterisstopped,butwaterkeepscominginfromthefaucet.)

Whenthefaucetisturnedoff,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwilldecreasebecausetheinflowofwaterisstopped,butthewaterkeepsleavingthroughthedrain.)

Howcanthelevelofwaterinthebathtubbekeptatthesamelevel?(Thewaterinthebathtubcanbekeptatthesamelevelbymakingtheinflowequaltotheoutflow.Then,thewaterthatcomesinthroughthefaucetwillbeoffsetbythewaterthatleavesthroughthedrain.)

Tellstudentstheywillbefollowingtheflowofmaterials,inthiscasetheamountofairpollution,inthesystem.Letstudentsknowtheywillbeexploringsomeenvironmentalandhumanfactorsthatcontributetochangesintheamountofpollutionbeingaddedtoandremovedfromthemodeledsystem.

4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.

Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.ProjecttheNOAAWeatherForecastModel,whichprovidesagoodexampleofacomputationalmodel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusemodelstopredictfutureconditionsbasedoncurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphere.Scientistsuseatmosphericmodels,suchasthese,toforecastwhereandwhenairqualitymaybebad.

5.HavestudentslaunchthePollutantsMakingMorePollutantsinteractive.

Page 26: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

26of40

ProvidestudentswiththelinktothePollutantsMakingMorePollutantsinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofdatawithquestionsrelatedtothedata.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheinteractiveintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.

TellstudentsthatthisisActivity4oftheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.

6.Discusstheissues.

Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:

ShowtheAirPollutionModel2.Whatenvironmentalconditionsledtoahighconcentrationofsecondarypollutantsinthemodel?(Windblowingfromthewaterblowspollutantsagainstthemountainsotheyaretrappedoverthecity.Littlerainmeansthatthepollutantsarenotwashedoutoftheair.Intensesunlighthelpsprimarypollutantscreatesecondarypollutants.)

Whatconditionsarebestforformingasmogevent?(Lowwinds,orwindblowingtowardsageographicbarrier,lowprecipitation,andhighsunlightwillhelptheformationofsmog.)

Iftherearemorepeopleinacity,willtherebemoresmog?(Thatdependsonwhatthepeoplearedoinginthecity.IftheyarenotcreatingalotofNO orVOCs,therewillbelittleozoneformed.Whenthereislessozone,thereislessofachanceofsmog.)

Wouldrequiringeveryoneincitiestouseelectriccarspreventpoorairqualityevents?(Itmightpreventsmogeventsiftheelectricityisgeneratedfaroutsidethecityorifelectricitycomesonlyfromsolar,wind,nuclear,orhydroelectricplants.Ifthepowerplantsarelocatedinthecity[orthewindblowstowardsthecity],pollutantsfromburningcoal,naturalgas,orbiomasscouldblowintothecity.Withelectriccars,thepollutionisjustpushedtoanotherregion.)

Isthereawaytostopallacidrainevents?(No,butacidraineventscanbelimitedbylimitingtheamountsofSO emittedbypowerplants.SomeSO isemittednaturally,sotherewillalwaysbesomeacidrain,particularlydownwindfromvolcanoes.)

TipTeacherTipIfyouwanttosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.

x

2 2

Page 27: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

27of40

TipTeacherTipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesintheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.

ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents,orasawholeclassactivity.Ifusingasawholeclassactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.

InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingstudentsthefollowingquestions:

Whatenvironmentalcomponentaffectstheformationofsmog?Inwhatseasonissmogmostlikelytoform?Why?Howcanacidrainformthousandsofmilesfromapollutionsource?

2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.

ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience

EarthscienceGeneralscience

LearningObjectivesStudentswill:

describewhyintensesunlightcandecreaseairqualityinapollutioneventdescribetheeffectofsolarintensityontheformationofozoneexplaintheeffectofprecipitationontheconcentrationofpollutantsintheatmosphereexplainhowacidrainisformedfromprimarypollutants

TeachingApproachLearning-for-use

TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting

Page 28: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

28of40

SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:

21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills

Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills

CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes

GlobalAwarenessCriticalThinkingSkills

AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding

NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices

NationalScienceEducationStandards

•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardF-1:Personalhealth•(5-8)StandardF-4:Risksandbenefits•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardC-5:Matter,energy,andorganizationinlivingsystems•(9-12)StandardF-1:Personalandcommunityhealth•(9-12)StandardF-2:Populationgrowth•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality•(9-12)StandardF-5:Naturalandhuman-inducedhazards

CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy

Page 29: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

29of40

•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3

ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)

•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking

NextGenerationScienceStandards

•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept4:Systemsandsystemmodels•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice2:Developingandusingmodels•ScienceandEngineeringPractice3:

Page 30: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

30of40

Planningandcarryingoutinvestigations•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation

PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationPrimaryairpollutantscanbeconvertedintosecondarypollutants,suchasozoneandacidrain,byinteractingwithenvironmentalcomponents.Whennitrogenoxidesandsulfurdioxidecombinewithwaterinclouds,theyformacidprecipitation.Theacidicprecipitationcancauseplantdamageanddestructionofaquatichabitatsasthewatersbecomemoreacidic.

Whennitrogenoxidesandvolatileorganiccompoundsmixinthepresenceofsunlight,asecondarypollutant–ozone–canbeproduced.Ozoneisapowerfulirritanttothehumanrespiratorysystemandplants'leavesalike.Becauseozoneiscreatedasaresultofthechemicalreactionsbetweennitrogenoxidesandvolatileorganiccompoundsinthepresenceofsunlight,itiscalledaphotochemicalpollutant.Smogthatresultsfromsuchozoneiscalledphotochemicalsmog.

PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities

MeasuringAirQualityMovementofPollutantsVisibleandInvisiblePollutants

VocabularyTerm Partof

Speech Definition

acid nounchemicalcompoundthatreactswithabasetoformasalt.Acidscancorrodesomenaturalmaterials.AcidshavepHlevelslowerthan7.

airquality noun measurementofpollutantsandotherharmfulmaterialsintheair.

atmosphere noun layersofgasessurroundingaplanetorothercelestialbody.

Page 31: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

31of40

carbonmonoxidenoun

Carbonmonoxideisacolorless,odorless,andtastelessgasthatisslightlylessdensethanair.Itcanbetoxictohumans.

intensity noun measureofmagnitude.

model,computational noun

amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.

nitrogenoxide nounoneofmanychemicalcompoundsmadeofdifferentcombinationsofnitrogenandoxygen.

ozone noun formofoxygenthatabsorbsultravioletradiation.

particulate adjective,noun

microscopicsolidorliquidparticle,oftensuspendedintheatmosphereaspollution.

pollutant noun chemicalorothersubstancethatharmsanaturalresource.

precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.

smog nountypeofairpollutioncommoninmanufacturingareasorareaswithhightraffic.

solarradiation noun lightandheatfromthesun.

sulfurdioxide noun greenhousegasthatcancauseacidrain.

system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.

volatileorganiccompound(VOC) noun

gasreleasedfromsomesolidsorliquidsthatmaycauseharmtopeopleandtheatmosphere.

Term PartofSpeech Definition

Partner

FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder

GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedin

Page 32: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

32of40

thismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.

Activity5:PreventingBadAirDays|45minsDirections1.Introducestudentstotheenvironmentalfactorsthataffectairquality.

Letstudentsknowthatenvironmentalfactorsaffecttheseverityanddurationofpollutionevents.ShowtheNewBridgeinBratislavaonClearDayphotographandtheNewBridgeinBratislavawithTemperatureInversionphotograph.(Downloadtheimagebyclickingonthedownarrowinthelowerrightcornerofthemediacarouselwindow.)Tellstudentsthatthetemperatureoftheatmosphereaffectsthemovementofpollutants.Ask:

Whathappenedtothetemperatureoftheairbetweenthefirstpictureandthesecondpicture?(Thereisatemperatureinversioninthesecondpicture.Theairiscooleratthesurfacethanitisabovethesurface.Normally,theaircoolswithincreasingelevation.)

Whathappenedtochangethetemperatureoftheatmosphere?(Atemperatureinversioncanbecausedbycoolairatthesurfacebecauseofsnow/iceonthesurfaceorbycoolerairblowinginoffacolderbodyofwater.)

2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.

Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Letstudentsknowthattheycanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyinforecastingairquality.

TellstudentsthatairqualityismeasuredbytheAirQualityIndex.ShowstudentstheAirQualityIndex,whichincludesexplanationsoftherangesusedintheairqualityindex.ThenprojecttheForecastofAirQualityonDecember10,2013imageandAirQualityonDecember10,2013image.(Clickonthelinkinthemediacarouselaboveanddownloadusingthearrowinthelowerrightcornerofthewindow.)Tellstudentsthatthesearesnapshotsoftheairqualityforecastandthereal-timeairqualityintheUnitedStatesonDecember10,2013.Ask:

Didtheforecastaccuratelypredictwhichareaswouldhavepoorqualityair?(Theforecastairqualityoverlapswithmanyofthepoorairqualityareas,butitdoesnotcoverallofthem.Theairqualityinsomeareas[NorthernCalifornia]ismuchworsethantheforecastpredicted.)

WhydoyouthinkscientistsdidnotaccuratelypredicttheairqualityformoreoftheUnitedStates?(Studentanswerswillvary.Theairqualityforecastisaffectedbyhumanactivitiesthatmaynotbeeasilypredicted.)

Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictions.Letstudentsknowthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeir

Page 33: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

33of40

answers,andencouragethemtodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.

3.Introducetheconceptofstocksandflowsinasystem.

Tellstudentsthatmaterialsflowintoandoutofsystems.Theflowofthematerialsovertimecanchangeandcanbeinfluencedbymanydifferentfactorsandinteractingparts.Scientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofastockandflowinasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.

Thereisabathtubwithwaterflowinginfromthefaucetandwaterleavingthroughthedrain.Ask:

Whenthedrainisplugged,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwillincreasebecausetheoutflowofwaterisstopped,butwaterkeepscominginfromthefaucet.)

Whenthefaucetisturnedoff,whathappenstothelevelofwaterinthebathtub?(Thewaterlevelwilldecreasebecausetheinflowofwaterisstopped,butthewaterkeepsleavingthroughthedrain.)

Howcanthelevelofwaterinthebathtubbekeptatthesamelevel?(Thewaterinthebathtubcanbekeptatthesamelevelbymakingtheinflowequaltotheoutflow.Then,thewaterthatcomesinthroughthefaucetwillbeoffsetbythewaterthatleavesthroughthedrain.)

Tellstudentstheywillbefollowingtheflowofmaterials,inthiscasetheamountofairpollution,inthesystem.Letstudentsknowtheywillbeexploringsomeenvironmentalandhumanfactorsthatcontributetochangesintheamountofpollutionbeingaddedtoandremovedfromthemodeledsystem.

4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.

Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.ProjecttheNOAAWeatherForecastModel,whichprovidesagoodexampleofacomputationalmodel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusemodelstopredictfutureconditionsbasedoncurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphere.Scientistsuseatmosphericmodels,suchasthese,toforecastwhereandwhenairqualitymaybebad.

Page 34: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

34of40

5.HavestudentslaunchthePreventingBadAirDaysinteractive.

ProvidestudentswiththelinktothePreventingBadAirDaysinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstobeabletoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofquestionsrelatedtothemodelsintheactivity.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.

TellstudentsthisisActivity5oftheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.

6.Discusstheissues.

Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthequestionsbelow.

NOTE:Theanswersprovidedarethecorrectanswers;however,studentsshouldbeencouragedtofindtheseanswersbyusingthemodelsintheactivity.

WhatconditionscreatedathermalinversioninModel4(Model4:Cross-SectionofaCity:WithThermalInversion)?(Thewindhastobecomingfromthewater.Thewateriscoolerthantheland.Thebreezecomingoffthewatercoolsthesurfaceofthelandsoitiscolderthanthelayerofairdirectlyaboveit.)

Whyaresmogeventslonger-lastingwhenthereisatemperatureinversion?(Smogeventsarelongerlastingwhenthereisatemperatureinversionbecausethetemperatureinversionpreventstheairfromrisingthroughtheatmosphereanddissipatingoveralargerarea.)

Canthermalinversionsbeprevented?(No,thermalinversionscannotbeeasilyprevented.Thermalinversionsarenaturalevents.Theyarecreatedwhenthesurfaceiscoolerthantheairabove.Thiscanhappenwhenthereissnowontheground,coolingtheground,whiletheSunwarmstheairaboveit.Theycanalsohappenwhencoolerairblowsoffalargebodyofwaterontothewarmerland.Theseabreeze[orlakebreeze]coolsthelowerlayerofairbelowthetemperatureoftheairabove.

Isitmoreimportanttolimitthepollutionfromcarsorfrompowerplantsandfactories(Model5:Cross-SectionofaCity:WithPollutionControl)?(Thedatafromthismodelindicatethatlimitingvehiclepollutionismoreimportanttoairqualitythanlimitingpowerplant/factorypollution.Thismayormaynotapplyintherealworld;themodel'spredictivepowerislimitedbecauseallcaremissionsaretreatedasthesame,justasallpowerplant/factoryemissionsaretreatedasthesame.Thedifferenttypesofpollutantsemittedbythedifferentpollutionsourcesarenotmodeledwiththismodel.Theeffectofweatherisnotmodeledwellenoughtomakelong-termpredictionsaboutwhichpollutiontypehasthebiggesteffectontheoverallcitypollutionlevel.

Page 35: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

35of40

Pollutantsfromotherpowerplants/factoriescouldblowintothisarea;onlyasmallportionoftheEarthismodeledinthismodel.)

Howcantechnologymakeadifferenceinairquality?(Technologycanbedevelopedthatcanlowertheemissionsofcars,powerplants,andfactories.Technologycanalsoincreasetheefficiencyofthepollutingsources,meaningthattherewouldbelesspollutionpermiletraveled/unitofelectricitygenerated/productmanufactured.Technologycanalsocreatemorepollutionasasideeffectofmoremanufacturingandmoredemandforproductsthatpollute.)

TipTeacherTipIfyouwanttosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.

TipTeacherTipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesintheWilltheAirBeCleanEnoughtoBreathe?lesson.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.

ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.

InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingstudentsthefollowingquestions:

Whatisathermalinversion?Whatconditionsleadtoathermalinversion?Howdopollutioncontroldeviceswork?

2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.

ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience

EarthscienceGeneralscience

Page 36: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

36of40

LearningObjectivesStudentswill:

describehowathermalinversionoccursandisdissipatedexplainhowpollutioncontroldevicesreduceemissionsofpollutantsfromvehiclesandsmokestackscomparemethodsoftransportationfortheirabilitytoprevent/reducethenumberofbadairqualitydays

TeachingApproachLearning-for-use

TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting

SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:

21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills

Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills

CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes

GlobalAwarenessCriticalThinkingSkills

AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding

NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices

NationalScienceEducationStandards

•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardF-1:

Page 37: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

37of40

Personalhealth•(5-8)StandardF-4:Risksandbenefits•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardC-5:Matter,energy,andorganizationinlivingsystems•(9-12)StandardF-1:Personalandcommunityhealth•(9-12)StandardF-2:Populationgrowth•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality

CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy

•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1

ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)

•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking

NextGenerationScienceStandards

Page 38: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

38of40

•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept4:Systemsandsystemmodels•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•HS.Earth'sSystems:HS-ESS3-4.Evaluateorrefineatechnologicalsolutionthatreducesimpactsofhumanactivitiesonnaturalsystems.•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice2:Developingandusingmodels•ScienceandEngineeringPractice3:Planningandcarryingoutinvestigations•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice5:Usingmathematicsandcomputationalthinking•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation

PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationThetemperatureprofileoftheatmosphereplaysanimportantroleinthelevelofpollutantsintheairaboveagivenlocation.Thermalinversionscantrappollutantsinanareaforalongperiodoftime,leadingtobadairquality.Theseeventscanbeforecastandpeoplecanchangetheiractionstopreventorreducethenumberofbadairqualitydays.Withtheseforecasts,peoplecanplantheiractivitiestominimizetheirexposuretopoorqualityair.

PriorKnowledge

Page 39: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

39of40

[]RecommendedPriorActivities

MeasuringAirQualityMovementofPollutantsPollutantsMakingMorePollutantsVisibleandInvisiblePollutants

VocabularyTerm Partof

Speech Definition

acid nounchemicalcompoundthatreactswithabasetoformasalt.Acidscancorrodesomenaturalmaterials.AcidshavepHlevelslowerthan7.

airquality noun measurementofpollutantsandotherharmfulmaterialsintheair.

atmosphere noun layersofgasessurroundingaplanetorothercelestialbody.

carbonmonoxidenounCarbonmonoxideisacolorless,odorless,andtastelessgasthatisslightlylessdensethanair.Itcanbetoxictohumans.

intensity noun measureofmagnitude.

inversion noun actorcircumstanceofbeingupside-down.

model,computational noun

amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.

nitrogenoxide nounoneofmanychemicalcompoundsmadeofdifferentcombinationsofnitrogenandoxygen.

particulate adjective,noun

microscopicsolidorliquidparticle,oftensuspendedintheatmosphereaspollution.

pollutant noun chemicalorothersubstancethatharmsanaturalresource.

precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.

scrubber noun deviceormethodusedtoremoveairpollutantsfromindustrialexhaust.

smog nountypeofairpollutioncommoninmanufacturingareasorareaswithhightraffic.

solarradiation noun lightandheatfromthesun.

sulfurdioxide noun greenhousegasthatcancauseacidrain.

Page 40: Will the Air Be Clean Enough To Breathe?...This activity is part of a sequence of activities in the Will the Air Be Clean Enough to Breathe? lesson. The activities work best if used

40of40

system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.

volatileorganiccompound(VOC) noun

gasreleasedfromsomesolidsorliquidsthatmaycauseharmtopeopleandtheatmosphere.

Term PartofSpeech Definition

Partner

FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder

GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.

FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder

GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.

Partner

©1996–2016NationalGeographicSociety.Allrightsreserved.