whimex doing high resolution x-ray spectroscopy right webster cash, chuck lillie and the whimex team...

16
WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited With Special Thanks to Northrop Grumman for Development and Proposal Support

Upload: godwin-murphy

Post on 18-Jan-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Designed for the WHIM Problem The WHIM is the highest profile science that we can address in an Explorer The hugely exciting science of AGN’s, stars etc comes free after WHIM problem is solved. IXO Requirement was R~3000, A~1000cm 2 (We fought for a decade to get IXO to raise R above 300) IXO is gone, and there’s nothing else on the high resolution horizon Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

WHIMEXDoing High Resolution

X-ray Spectroscopy Right

Webster Cash, Chuck Lillieand the WHIMEx Team

With Special Thanks toNorthrop Grumman forDevelopment and ProposalSupport

Page 2: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

The WHIMEx TeamRepresentative of the Community

W. Cash Colorado

N. Arav Virginia Tech

S. Barber Open U

M. Bautz MIT

J. Bregman Michigan

N. Brickhouse CFA

M. Elvis CFA

R. Heilman MIT

A. Holland Open U

A. Hornschemeier GSFC

D. Huenemoerder MIT

C. Lillie NGASR. McEntaffer IowaR. Mushotzky MarylandP. Nicastro CFAP. Oakley ColoradoS. O’Dell MSFCA. Ptak GSFCM. Schattenburg MITM. Shull ColoradoH. Tsunemi OsakaF. Walter Stony BrookL. Winter ColoradoS. Wolk SA/CfAW. Zhang GSFC

Page 3: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Designed for the WHIM Problem

• The WHIM is the highest profile science that we can addressin an Explorer

• The hugely exciting science of AGN’s, stars etc comes free after WHIMproblem is solved.

• IXO Requirement was R~3000, A~1000cm2

(We fought for a decade to get IXO to raise R above 300)

• IXO is gone, and there’s nothing else on the high resolution horizon

Page 4: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Origin of Concept• IXO Technology Studies and Older Suborbital Work

• Science from Decadal

• Will Zhang’s slumped glass Wolter optics (NUSTAR/IXO)

• MIT Flat Mirrors and Metrology

• Web Cash and Randy McEntaffer’s Off-plane Gratings

• CCD Arrays - Open U, Osaka U, MIT, GSFC

Reoptimized for an Explorer

Page 5: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Reduced Complexity• A Single Wolter Mandrel• A Single Grating Master• 15” Quality• 7m Focal Length with Deployable Bench

Page 6: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Page 7: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Page 8: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Payload

Page 9: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Figure of Merit

Page 10: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

OVII and OVIII Diagnostic of WHIM

10-03662_1025a_154

Model WHIM Mass Distributions0.016

0.014

0.012

0.010

0.008

Diffe

renti

al M

ass F

racti

on

765Log T (K)

OVIdetection range

OVII

OVIII

GalacticSuperwinds

No GalacticSuperwinds

Page 11: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Filament Column Densities

Page 12: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Simulated WHIMEx Spectrum

Page 13: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

WHIMExAGN Simulations

COS

WHIMex

Chandra

Page 14: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

High Resolution is Essential to Measuring the Basic Parameters(Slide courtesy of Schindhelm and Arav)

Shape of line is crucial to separating continuum from saturated line.Without E/E > 3000, can miss energy outflow by factor of 100!

Page 15: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited10-03662_1022_154

10

5

0

Coun

ts s-1

A-1

16.7 16.8 16.9 17.0 17.1Wavelength (A)

Fe XVIIFe XVII

AR Lac binary; (=0.25, v = 230 km/s)

Page 16: WHIMEX Doing High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy Right Webster Cash, Chuck Lillie and the WHIMEx Team Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

Conclusions• WHIMEx is Astronomy for and by the community

It is the IXO XGS channel repackaged• Can be implemented at the low end of the cost scale under

consideration.• Important Core Science and Exploration

that Cannot be Addressed Other Ways• Wide Open Guest Observing• Can Be Built Now, But Needs Prototype Demonstration• Also Needs a Community Statement of Why It is Relevant

to the Decadal. There is much mischief between competingdisciplines