what’s your business exit strategy? a road map to successful succession planning
DESCRIPTION
To listen to a replay of the webinar, visit: https://attendee.gotowebinar.com/recording/4958581190465573122 The most successful exits require considerable planning. However, 83% of business owners have no written transition plan and only 30% of all family-owned businesses survive into the second generation. This presentation covers: - Overview of the most common business exit strategies and the experts you'll want to involve - How to perpetuate your business for the next generation - Special considerations for family business, including points of conflict and governance systems - Opportunities and challenges of pursuing an ESOP - Financial best practices, including basic business valuation and financial reportingTRANSCRIPT
WHAT’S YOUR BUSINESS EXIT STRATEGY?
A Road Map to Successful Succession Planning
What We’ll Cover
Overview of the succession planning roadmap
First Stop: Transferring to long-term employees via ESOP
Second Stop: How to perpetuate your business for the next generation
Last Stop: Financial best practices
Today’s Presenters
Bob PedersenVP, Relationship Manger
American River Bank
Kurt GlassmanCo-Founder
Leadership One, The Capital Region Family
Business Center and the Family Business Association
Kevin LongAttorney at Law &
Taxation Law Specialist Chang Ruthenberg & Long
THE ROADMAPAn Overview
A Business Succession Plan provides both an exit strategy and an implementation plan for business owners and their families to ensure the survival of the company with a transition or sale. It plans for unanticipated events – the strategic and tactical options.
An Exit Plan helps secure and solely maximizes the financial future of the business owner, the spouse and family, when the owner chooses to exit the business, becomes disabled, or passes away. Timing is everything; and size matters.
Succession Planning vs. An Exit Plan
Why is it Important?
Ownership Will Transfer: Voluntary or Involuntary
Not “Necessarily” All About the Money Individuals Will Expire, Companies and
Families Can Live Forever. Living Plan Not An Estate Plan
Four Basic Options
Sale or Succession During LifeSell/Gift to Family
or HeirsSell to Employees, Key Management or ESOP
Sell to Outsider- Strategic Investor
Orderly Liquidation or Recap
Minimize Estate Taxes
Alternatives for Divesting Private Company Stock
There are specific benefits and drawbacks to each alternative
Understand your objectives and select the alternative that optimizes them – financial and non-financial – so as to avoid “Seller’s Remorse”
Many times business owners are unaware that an ESOP is even an option!
Benefits of Planning
Clarifies UncertaintyAntidote for AnxietyPromotes CommunicationBuilds TrustFamily Harmony
Obstacles To Planning
The Process
What are you really looking for in an exit?
Option A: $how me the money!
Option B: I want to get a good buyout price, but……I am not ready to retire yet…I want to keep my company independent and perpetuate a legacy…I want to sell only a portion of the company and maintain control…I’m tired of paying taxes!…I don’t want to be beholden to a new owner /investor…The other shareholders are not ready to sell…I want to protect my employees
Questions to Ask Yourself
What Do I Value?Where Am I Going?
What Do I Want To Change?
Challenges
AlignmentOwnership Transfer PlanGovernance StructureManagement Succession Plan
Changing Conditions Relationships Trust
Advisors
Attorney CPA Banker Family Business Advisor
WealthAdviso
r
Appraiser
1ST DESTINATIONIntelligent Succession and Liquidity Strategies for Closely Held Businesses
Background: A Brief History
Most Common Industries
Company Employees
144,000
55,000
18,000
9,200
9,000
8,400
7,000
1,500
400
200
Company Employees
11,500
7,000
4,000
3,000
2,600
2,400
1,500
1,500
600
200
Notable Employee Owned Companies
Myths And Misunderstandings
An ESOP is a giveaway I will lose control of my company You must disclose all financial data to employees My employees cannot pay me what my business is worth My employees are not interested in an ESOP ESOPs are for failing companies ESOPs are too expensive My CPA can advise me on this The ESOP must replace all retirement plans The ESOP's stock repurchase liability will kill the company
General Minimums for an ESOP
$5M in Revenues 20+ employees EBIDA greater than $1.5M/year last five years
• (adding back owners salaries)• Tax Burden is the Driver
Deferral of capital gains tax on sale to ESOP Can create a partial or 100% tax free ESOP company Retain participation or control during the sale Can do partial sales – whenever you are ready A known buyer – with controlled earn out Tax subsidy can cover more that 30% of the cost Doesn't impede a later strategic transaction
ESOP Appeal To The Owner/Seller
ESOP vs. Non-ESOP Transactions Seller’s Perspective
Asset Stock §1042Sale Sale Sale
Gross Sale Proceeds 20,000,000$ 20,000,000$ 20,000,000$ Corporate Taxes Due (6,000,000) - - Individual Taxes Due (4,620,000) (6,600,000) -
Net After Tax Sales Proceeds 9,380,000$ 13,400,000$ 20,000,000$
Note: Assumes $5,000,000 cost basis in corporate assets and no cost basis in stock.in stock. CA & Fed combined corporate tax rate = 40%. CA & federal combined capital gains rate = 33%.
Leveraged Buy-Out Seller Financing
3. Annual Contributions Deducted As Pension Expense
Seller Taxed On Installment Sale Basis
2. Cash And Note
1. Stock
4. Loan Repayment
SellingShareholder
SellingShareholder
Shares Allocated As Loan Is Paid
Pension Expense Matches Loan Amortization
Bank Financing
1. Loan
2. Loan
7. Loan Repayment (Principal & Interest)
6. AnnualContributions
QRP-Stocks &Bonds
QRP-Stocks &Bonds
3. Cash Purchase
4. Stock
5. Reinvest Cash
8. Loan Repayment(Principal & Interest)
Bank / Lender Bank / Lender
Company Company
ESOP TRUSTSuspense Account
Allocation
Participant Accounts
SellingShareholder
SellingShareholder
Tax Deferred "Rollover" ESOPs IRC §1042
Capital gain on sale to the ESOP is deferred Seller must reinvest proceeds within 12 months of
sale date in Qualified Replacement Property (QRP) Can do partial or complete deferral of sales proceeds ESOP must own at least 30% of company
Qualified Replacement Property
• Common Stock• Convertible Bonds• Corporate Fixed Rate
Bonds• Corporate Floating Rate
Notes (FRN)
Eligible1
• Municipal Bonds• U.S. Government Bonds• Mutual Funds• Foreign Securities• REITs• Bank CDs
Not Eligible1
1 Eligible issuer must have: More than 50% of its assets used in the active conduct of a trade or business No more than 25% of its gross income from passive sources
Congress' intention: Incentivize owners of private companies who sell to an ESOP to reinvest into corporate America
S Corp. ESOPs – Generally
S Corps. are pass-through entities ESOP is qualified trust, exempt from taxation Taxable income flows through to ESOP Percentage owned by ESOP is tax exempt ESOP may be minority or up to 100% owner Benefits paid in cash only – not stock
When Is Private Equity A Good Succession Alternative?
Business has solid and consistent cash flow
Business has solid growth prospects
Capable and experienced management team
Limited customer concentration or other business risks
Willingness to sell or recapitalize the business in 5 +- years
SAME
SAME
SAME or can develop over time
SAME
NO! No need to be hemmed in! ESOP allows later sale, but
does not dictate timing!
Private Equity ESOP Pros And Cons
Pros Many flexible structures
Partner with smart, experienced people
Can provide vehicle for immediate or staged liquidity
Can provide owner liquidity, while allowing existing management to maintain management control of the company
Cons More expensive than bank financing
Need to provide liquidity in 5+- years
May have senior class of securities (Preferred Stock) w/ certain rights
Same – over 20 different templates
Bring in outside talent, if you want it
Staged liquidity via financing
ESOP does not control the company –management does
Not as expensive as PE No requirement for a liquidity event – but
it does happen – you control it ESOP will never be superior to your
stock rights
ESOP v. Private Equity The Bottom Line
Private equity is real cash – not debt You are adding someone to your board – can you get
along? Can you replace them? You are selling control – now or in five years Unless you do an ESOP in five years
Description ESOP Company Private Equity Strategic Buyer
Maximize Sale Value
Appraised Fair Market Value
Negotiated Value Negotiated Value
Retain Control Yes Not if a 100% sale; temporary if a minority sale
No
Family Controlled Involvement
Short term Typically not
Legacy Yes No No
Employment Until negotiated to retire
Until company is sold
Short term contracts
Pass Business to Employees
Yes Management kept in place
Consolidation of workforce
Estate Liquidity
Over time Yes; in part or whole
Yes; for cash component of sale
Tax Impact Potential Cap gain deferral
Taxable Taxable (unless merger)
Impact On Shareholder's Goals, Objectives
2ND DESTINATIONPerpetuate your Business for the Next Generation
If What a Business Wants is… 79% of Senior-Generation Members Want Their
Families to Retain the Family Business. 70% of the Next Generation Share These Hopes.
Then Why… Do Only 30% of Family Businesses Make it to the
Second Generation? Do Only 10% of Family Businesses Make it to the
Third Generation?
Breakdown Factors
Traditional Assumptions:– Inadequate Planning– Poor Management
Performance– Estate Tax
Dynamics
Business Transition vs Succession Planning
Multi-dimensional approach that addresses the needs of the business owner
Systematic Approach to Help CEO’s Build “Stakeholder” Value
The Seven Critical Issues
Seven Critical Issues
1. Leadership2. Relationships3. Ownership Transfer4. Business Strategy and Execution5. Management Performance And
Succession6. Financial Performance7. Personal Financial Planning
1. Leadership
Effective Leaders AdaptLeadership is CulturalLeaders ExecuteLeaders Listen
2. Relationships
“How Do We Get Along”Need to Understand and Manage ConflictThe Conduit for Business
3. Ownership Transfer
Can We be Fair and Equitable to All Our Children?
Differences between Ownership and Management
Need to Align Ownership, Governance and Management Succession Plans
4. Business Strategy and Execution
Where Are We Going? (Vision)Why Do I Want To Go There? (Mission)How Do I Measure Success? (Goals)What Are We Going To Do? (Action Plan)
5. Management Performance & Succession
Do My People Know the Plays?Do I Have the Right People on the Bus?No Plan to Recruit, Retain, Reward and Retire
Key Employees
6. Financial Performance
Do You Know Your Key Performance Indicators (“KPI’S”)?
Do Your People Know Their Numbers?Are You Hitting Your Numbers?
7. Personal Financial Planning
Income Continuity All My Eggs Are In One BasketHow Do I Limit My Personal Guarantees?
3RD DESTINATIONFinancial Best Practices
Quality of Financial Reporting
Think like an airline pilot on instruments Treat family like a 3rd Party BuyerAccuracy of Information is Paramount!
– Full Disclosure of your business (w. bad)– Second (first) opinion of your trusted advisors –
CPA/Banker/Attorney– Confidentiality Agreements & Common $
Spreadsheets of Data is NOT boring Create value through ‘event planning’ Three years / year to date data All reports – AR, AP, Backlog, Debts Confidentiality /Sharing Data
– For outside buyers/employees – Share information ‘as needed’ – Use common sense / plan for the worst
Show Me the Money
Business Debt Capacity – A Short List
Liquidity (of company & owners) True Value of Assets Intangible Value – yes and no Leverage and Debt Load Management Quality & Track Record of New
Family Members/Owners is very important
What’s it Really Worth?
Valuation of companies for:– Internal purposes– Tax Purposes– Borrowing/Bank Purposes
The Highest Value is not necessarily the Best value Work with experts – business/equipment/real estate
Financing Options & Taxes
Private Financing – Good & Bad Commercial Bank Lending /Leverage
– ESOP Loans – yes/experience counts– Government Guaranty Programs
Separate Real Estate from the Business Assets– Sale/Leaseback of Property, etc. – Trusts and real estate income
Key Take-Aways
Ownership in your business will transfer: Voluntarily or Involuntarily Your business is the biggest asset and source of income you own – protect it
with “succession planning insurance” Having a written plan is key to successful transfer of control of your company Your family & employees want your legacy to succeed as much as you do ESOP’s and other ownership plans can provide tax advantaged strategies to
the owner/seller There are many options – explore them all with your advisors Most business owners are doer’s – it’s normal to avoid dealing with
succession planning/training There are seven critical issues to confront Others have done this successfully – there is a formula
Let’s Continue The Conversation
Kurt Glassman Kevin LongLeadershipOne Chang Ruthenberg & Long (916) 923-0245 (916) 294-3262 [email protected] [email protected]
Bob PedersenAmerican River Bank(916) [email protected]